# Model Documentation Evaluation Template

# Metadata
model_name: "Muse Spark"
model_link: "https://dev.meta.ai/docs/getting-started/overview"
organization: "Meta"
org_link: "https://www.meta.com/"
evaluation_date: "2026-07-21"
public_summary_link: "https://transparency.meta.com/reports/regulatory-transparency-reports/"
public_summary_date: "2026-07-08"
public_summary_location: "https://transparency.meta.com/reports/regulatory-transparency-reports/"
model_publication_date: "2026-04-08"
category: "New model" # New model, fine-tuned model
archive_file_name: "Muse_Spark_2026_08_18.pdf"

# Requirement assessments
# Each requirement should be assessed once with a score from 0-10
# Leave blank for N/A, and assign a max score of 0
S1: # Document-level requirements
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 5.5
    max_score: 11
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 4
    max_score: 4
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 7
    max_score: 7
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 3
    max_score: 5
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 4.5
    max_score: 13
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 6
    max_score: 9
    notes: ""

S2: # General information
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 19
    max_score: 31
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 46
    max_score: 74
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 8
    max_score: 8
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 13.5
    max_score: 15
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 0
    max_score: 0
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 10
    max_score: 11
    notes: ""

S3: # Public datasets
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 32
    max_score: 92
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 12
    max_score: 92
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 3
    max_score: 3
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 20
    max_score: 20
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 0
    max_score: 20
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 16
    max_score: 16
    notes: ""

S4: # Private datasets
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 32
    max_score: 32
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 48
    max_score: 88
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 3
    max_score: 3
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 24
    max_score: 24
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 0
    max_score: 0
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 16
    max_score: 16
    notes: ""

S5: # Scraped/crawled data
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 62
    max_score: 129
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 81
    max_score: 158
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 3
    max_score: 3
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 68
    max_score: 93
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 0
    max_score: 25
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 20
    max_score: 58
    notes: ""

S6: # User data
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 15
    max_score: 15
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 18.5
    max_score: 26
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 3
    max_score: 3
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 11
    max_score: 11
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 15
    max_score: 15
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 15
    max_score: 15
    notes: ""

S7: # Synthetic & other
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 0
    max_score: 48
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 6
    max_score: 30
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 6
    max_score: 6
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 6
    max_score: 30
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 0
    max_score: 0
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 0
    max_score: 12
    notes: ""

S8: # Data processing
  D1: # Clarity
    score: 0
    max_score: 18
    notes: ""

  D2: # Completeness
    score: 10.5
    max_score: 18
    notes: ""

  D3: # Consistency
    score: 3
    max_score: 3
    notes: ""

  D4: # Correctness
    score: 36
    max_score: 36
    notes: ""

  D5: # Accessibility
    score: 7.5
    max_score: 15
    notes: ""

  D6: # Comprehension
    score: 33
    max_score: 69
    notes: ""


general_notes: "The public summary for MAI Image 2 can be found <a href=\"https://transparency.meta.com/reports/regulatory-transparency-reports/\" target=\"_blank\"> on Meta's transparency reports page</a>. The summary matches the structure of the template. A previous version of the template is missing, despite being implied. The summary links to external pages to provide some key information, resulting in loss of points. We assessed the summary's score to be <span class=\"openness partial\">53.61%</span> with Grade <strong>C</strong> for <strong><i>transparency</i></strong>, and <span class=\"openness closed\">48.64%</span> with Grade <strong>D+</strong> for <strong><i>usefulness</i></strong>."