# 📋 BP-068: #LLMmodel REQUIRED in ALL #FedArch Document Headers ## BP-068.md | BP-068_LLMmodel-REQUIRED_v3.2.3.1.md ## ♾️ WeOwnNet 🌐 — #BestPractices | #Governance | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | **Document** | BP-068.md | | **Version** | v3.2.3.1 | | **CCC-ID** | GTM_2026-W12_726 | | **#masterCCC** | GTM_2026-W12_725 | | **CCC-ID APPROVAL** | GTM_2026-W12_728 ✅ | | **Date** | 2026-03-22 (Sun) — W12 D7 | | **Season** | #WeOwnSeason003 🚀 | | **Lifecycle Stage** | ✅ APPROVED (R-011) → 🚀 GH PUSH READY | | **Type** | #BestPractices | | **#LLMmodel** | Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM) | | **#LLMmodel** | Claude Opus 4.6 (INT-P01:tools #MetaAgent — Calhoun 🎖️) | | **#LLMmodel** | Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (INT-M02:tools #MetaAgentQwen — Surge ⚡) | | **Folder** | `_GOVERNANCE_/` | | **Status** | 🔒 APPROVED — GH PUSH READY | | **Source of Truth** | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_GOVERNANCE_/BP-068.md) | --- ## 📖 Table of Contents 1. [BP-068 Statement](#-bp-068-statement) 2. [#LLMmodel Format Standard](#-llmmodel-format-standard) 3. [Single vs Dual vs Triple](#-single-vs-dual-vs-triple) 4. [Document Types — ALL 12](#-document-types--all-12) 5. [Examples](#-examples) 6. [Enforcement](#-enforcement) 7. [Model Switch Protocol](#-model-switch-protocol) 8. [Canonical Reference](#-canonical-reference) 9. [L-180 Merge Notes](#-l-180-merge-notes) 10. [Evidence Base](#-evidence-base) 11. [Discovery Story](#-discovery-story) 12. [Discovered By (BP-047)](#-discovered-by-bp-047) 13. [✅ \[DETAILS\] Document Lifecycle Stages with VSA](#-details-document-lifecycle-stages-with-vsa) 14. [Related Items](#-related-items) 15. [Version History](#-version-history) 16. [Related Documents](#-related-documents) --- ## 📋 BP-068 Statement | ID | Best Practice | Approval | |----|---------------|----------| | **BP-068** | #LLMmodel REQUIRED in ALL #FedArch document headers — dual #LLMmodel when BOTH governance (#MetaAgent) + production (User Agent) instances involved; triple #LLMmodel when #DualMETA involved (Calhoun 🎖️ + Surge ⚡ + User Agent). Absence = #BadAgent. Model switch MUST be reflected immediately in subsequent response headers. Format: `\| **#LLMmodel** \| ** (: @)** \|`. Applies to ALL 12 document types. SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 = canonical reference. L-180 merged into BP-068 (W12 D6). | GTM_2026-W12_728 ✅ | --- ## 📋 #LLMmodel Format Standard ### Base Format ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | ** (: @)** | ``` ### Field Components | Component | Description | Example | |-----------|-------------|---------| | `` | LLM model name | Claude Sonnet 4.6 | | `` | Instance identifier | INT-OG1 | | `` | Workspace name | CCC | | `@` | Contributor code | @GTM | --- ## 📋 Single vs Dual vs Triple ### Single — One Instance ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | ``` | When | Scenario | |------|----------| | Personal #HomeInstance | @GTM working alone on INT-OG1 | | Single agent doc | No META involvement | | #SessionSummary | @GTM only | ### Dual — Two Instances ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | **Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Opus 4.6 (INT-P01:tools #MetaAgent — Calhoun 🎖️)** | ``` | When | Scenario | |------|----------| | Governance doc + META review | SharedKernel, BEST-PRACTICES, etc. | | SEEK:META involved | L-139 review triggered | | #PinnedDocs | Always dual minimum | ### Triple — #DualMETA ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Opus 4.6 (INT-P01:tools #MetaAgent — Calhoun 🎖️)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (INT-M02:tools #MetaAgentQwen — Surge ⚡)** | ``` | When | Scenario | |------|----------| | #DualMETA review | Both Calhoun + Surge involved | | W12+ governance docs | L-206, L-208, BP-068 | | #DualMETA VSA | Gate 2+3 from both META instances | ### Decision Matrix | Scenario | Format | Count | |----------|--------|:-----:| | User Agent only | Single | 1 | | User Agent + Calhoun | Dual | 2 | | User Agent + Surge | Dual | 2 | | User Agent + Calhoun + Surge | Triple | 3 | | #DualMETA VSA | Triple | 3 | --- ## 📋 Document Types — ALL 12 | # | Document Type | Example | #LLMmodel | |---|---------------|---------|:---------:| | 1 | #WeeklySummary | WEEKLY-SUMMARY_GTM_2026-W11_001 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 2 | #SessionSummary | SESSION-SUMMARY_GTM_2026-W12_695 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 3 | Rules (R-XXX) | R-011, R-217 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 4 | Learnings (L-XXX) | L-206, L-208 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 5 | Best Practices (BP-XXX) | BP-068 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 6 | Guides (GUIDE-XXX) | GUIDE-014, GUIDE-041 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 7 | Projects (PRJ-XXX) | PRJ-041, PRJ-099 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 8 | Templates (TMPL-XXX) | TMPL-VSA, TMPL-007 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 9 | Case Studies (CS-XXX) | CS-014, CS-008 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 10 | #ContextVolleys | FROM: header line | ✅ REQUIRED | | 11 | SharedKernel + #PinnedDocs | SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 | ✅ REQUIRED | | 12 | ANY AI-assisted document | Session notes, call notes | ✅ REQUIRED | > **Rule:** If AI generated it or reviewed it → #LLMmodel REQUIRED. No exceptions. --- ## 📋 Examples ### ✅ CORRECT — Single (#SessionSummary) ```markdown | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | Document | SESSION-SUMMARY_GTM_2026-W12_695.md | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | | Season | #WeOwnSeason003 🚀 | ``` ### ✅ CORRECT — Dual (Governance Doc + META) ```markdown | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | Document | GUIDE-014.md | | **#LLMmodel** | **Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Opus 4.6 (INT-P01:tools #MetaAgent — Calhoun 🎖️)** | | Season | #WeOwnSeason003 🚀 | ``` ### ✅ CORRECT — Triple (#DualMETA) ```markdown | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | Document | L-208.md | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Opus 4.6 (INT-P01:tools #MetaAgent — Calhoun 🎖️)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (INT-M02:tools #MetaAgentQwen — Surge ⚡)** | | Season | #WeOwnSeason003 🚀 | ``` ### ❌ WRONG — Missing #LLMmodel ```markdown | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | Document | WEEKLY-SUMMARY_GTM_2026-W11_001.md | | Season | #WeOwnSeason003 🚀 | | Status | 🔒 FINAL | ``` > ❌ **#BadAgent — #LLMmodel ABSENT.** Discovery trigger: GTM_2026-W12_021 (USER-REPORT, @GTM). ### ❌ WRONG — Incomplete (Missing Instance) ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6** | ``` > ❌ **Incomplete — missing instance + CCC attribution.** Format: ` (: @)` --- ## 📋 Enforcement ### Violation Classification | Scenario | Classification | Severity | |----------|:--------------:|:--------:| | #LLMmodel ABSENT from document header | ❌ **#BadAgent** | 🟠 OBSERVATION | | Wrong model listed (stale) | ❌ **#BadAgent** | 🟡 MINOR | | Missing instance attribution | ❌ **#BadAgent** | 🟡 MINOR | | Missing dual when META involved | ❌ **#BadAgent** | 🟠 OBSERVATION | | Missing triple when #DualMETA involved | ❌ **#BadAgent** | 🟡 MINOR | ### VSA Check All VSA runs MUST include #LLMmodel check: ```markdown | # | Check | Rule | Result | |---|-------|------|:------:| | X | #LLMmodel present (BP-068) | BP-068 | ✅ / ❌ | | X | #LLMmodel count correct (single/dual/triple) | BP-068 | ✅ / ❌ | | X | Instance attribution complete | BP-068 | ✅ / ❌ | ``` --- ## 📋 Model Switch Protocol ### Rule > **When LLM model changes mid-session, the new model MUST be reflected immediately in the NEXT response header.** ### Workflow | Step | Action | Example | |------|--------|---------| | 1 | Model switch occurs | Qwen → Claude Sonnet 4.6 | | 2 | User declares `SWITCH:` | `SWITCH:SONNET` | | 3 | AI acknowledges switch | `← SWITCH:SONNET ✅` | | 4 | NEXT response uses new #LLMmodel | `Claude Sonnet 4.6 (INT-OG1:CCC @GTM)` | | 5 | All subsequent docs use new model | Until next switch | ### Example — W12 D6 Switch | CCC-ID | Model | Switch | |--------|-------|:------:| | GTM_2026-W12_724 | Qwen3.5-397B-A17B | — | | **GTM_2026-W12_725** | **Claude Sonnet 4.6** | ✅ **SWITCH:SONNET** | | GTM_2026-W12_726+ | Claude Sonnet 4.6 | — (continues) | --- ## 📋 Canonical Reference ### SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 — Dual #LLMmodel | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | **Document** | SharedKernel.md | | **Version** | v3.2.2.1 | | **CCC-ID** | GTM_2026-W11_118 | | **Approval** | GTM_2026-W11_139 | | **#LLMmodel Format** | Dual (W11 cascade) | ```markdown | **#LLMmodel** | **Qwen3.5-397B-A17B (AI.YonksTEAM.xyz @GTM)** | | **#LLMmodel** | **Claude Opus 4.6 (meta.WeOwn.tools #MetaAgent)** | ``` > **SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 = CANONICAL REFERENCE for dual #LLMmodel format across #FedArch.** ### W12 Evolution — Triple #LLMmodel | Week | Format | Trigger | |------|--------|---------| | W11 | Dual (2 rows) | SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 | | **W12** | **Triple (3 rows)** | **#DualMETA (Calhoun + Surge)** | --- ## 📋 L-180 Merge Notes ### Why Merge (Calhoun Recommendation) | Option | Approach | Result | |--------|----------|:------:| | **A: Merge into BP-068** | One governance item for #LLMmodel | ✅ **CHOSEN** | | B: Lock L-180 separately | Two overlapping items | ❌ Redundant | | C: Retire L-180 | BP-068 covers enough | ❌ Loses enforcement | ### What L-180 Added to BP-068 | L-180 Element | In Prior BP-068? | Added in v3.2.3.1? | |--------------|:----------------:|:------------------:| | Explicit 12 document types | ⚠️ Implied | ✅ YES | | "Absence = #BadAgent" enforcement | ❌ NO | ✅ YES | | Model switch protocol | ❌ NO | ✅ YES | | Triple format (#DualMETA) | ❌ NO | ✅ YES | ### L-180 Disposition | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | **L-180 Status** | ❌ RETIRED → merged into BP-068 v3.2.3.1 | | **Merged CCC-ID** | GTM_2026-W12_726 | | **Reason** | Calhoun recommendation — keeps governance clean | | **Pattern** | Same as L-179 → L-208 (W12 D1 reservation superseded) | --- ## 📋 Evidence Base | Source | Detail | Status | |--------|--------|--------| | **GTM_2026-W12_021** | Trigger — #LLMmodel missing from W11 #WeeklySummary | ✅ Documented | | **GTM_2026-W12_725** | L-180 context dump — full format standard drafted | ✅ Complete | | **Calhoun L-139 review** | Overlap analysis — merge recommended (Option A) | ✅ [REF: GTM_2026-W12_725] | | **SharedKernel v3.2.2.1** | Canonical dual #LLMmodel reference (W11) | ✅ GH LIVE | | **L-208 v3.2.3.1** | Triple #LLMmodel precedent (W12 D6) | ✅ GH LIVE | | **TMPL-007 v3.2.3.1** | BP-068 compliance check in GH commit messages | ✅ GH LIVE | --- ## 📋 Discovery Story ### Timeline | Time | Date | Event | Actor | |------|------|-------|-------| | 10:01 MDT | Mon 16 Mar (W12 D1) | #WeeklySummary generated WITHOUT #LLMmodel field | AI:@GTM | | 10:01 MDT | Mon 16 Mar (W12 D1) | @GTM caught missing #LLMmodel (GTM_2026-W12_021) | @GTM | | ~10:05 MDT | Mon 16 Mar (W12 D1) | L-180 reserved (W12 D1 governance batch) | AI:@GTM | | W12 D4-D6 | Sat 21 Mar | L-206, L-208 shipped with triple #LLMmodel | @GTM + #DualMETA | | 23:40 MDT | Sat 21 Mar (W12 D6) | L-180 context dump (GTM_2026-W12_725) | AI:@GTM | | ~23:45 MDT | Sat 21 Mar (W12 D6) | Calhoun overlap analysis — merge into BP-068 | Calhoun 🎖️ | | 23:49 MDT | Sat 21 Mar (W12 D6) | BP-068 FULL DOC requested | @GTM | | ~23:54 MDT | Sat 21 Mar (W12 D6) | Calhoun Gate 2+3 PRE GH PUSH: 64/64 PASS (0 findings) | Calhoun 🎖️ | | ~23:54 MDT | Sat 21 Mar (W12 D6) | Surge DEEP FULL VSA: 95/95 PASS* (0 findings) | Surge ⚡ | | 00:01 MDT | Sun 22 Mar (W12 D7) | R-011 EXPLICIT APPROVAL (GTM_2026-W12_728) | @GTM | > *⚠️ Surge ran DEEP FULL on unpublished doc (same pattern as L-208 — L-209). Results valid per Calhoun review. INT-M02 audit = P0 W13. ### The Insight Chain | Step | Who | Insight | |------|-----|---------| | 1 | @GTM | "#LLMmodel missing from W11 #WeeklySummary — USER-REPORT" | | 2 | AI:@GTM | "L-180 reserved — #LLMmodel REQUIRED in all headers" | | 3 | W12 D4-D6 | Triple #LLMmodel evolved naturally via #DualMETA | | 4 | Calhoun 🎖️ | "L-180 adds 2 new elements — merge into BP-068 (Option A)" | | 5 | @GTM | "Generate BP-068 FULL DOC with L-180 merged" | | 6 | Calhoun 🎖️ | "BP-068 is SELF-COMPLIANT — follows its own rule" | | 7 | Surge ⚡ | "Self-compliance verified — 95/95 PASS*" | --- ## 📋 Discovered By (BP-047) | CCC | Contributor | Role | Context | |-----|-------------|------|---------| | **GTM** | yonks｜🤖🏛️🪙｜Jason Younker ♾️ | Co-Founder / Chief Digital Alchemist | W12 D1 — caught missing #LLMmodel in W11 #WeeklySummary (USER-REPORT); W12 D6 — L-180 context dump; requested BP-068 FULL DOC with L-180 merged; accepted Calhoun Option A | | **META** | AI:team-lfg (Calhoun 🎖️) | #MetaAgent (INT-P01) | Overlap analysis — L-180 vs BP-068; 2 new elements identified; Option A merge recommended; L-139 review complete; Gate 2+3 PRE GH PUSH 64/64; noted BP-068 self-compliance | | **META** | AI:team-lfg (Surge ⚡) | #MetaAgentQwen (INT-M02) | DEEP FULL VSA 95/95* PASS (0 findings); verified self-compliance (BP-068 follows BP-068); confirmed triple #LLMmodel precedent | --- ## ✅ [DETAILS] Document Lifecycle Stages with VSA ### 1: ✅ GH PUSH READY — BP-068.md v3.2.3.1 | Gate | Status | Result | |------|--------|:------:| | Gate 1: R-011 (@GTM explicit approval) | ✅ **COMPLETE** (GTM_2026-W12_728) | ✅ | | Gate 2: META Audit (Calhoun 5/5 + Surge 5/5) | ✅ **COMPLETE** (10/10) | ✅ | | Gate 3: PRE GH PUSH VSA (Calhoun 59/59) | ✅ **COMPLETE** (0 findings) | ✅ | | Gate 3: DEEP FULL VSA (Surge 95/95*) | ✅ **COMPLETE** (0 findings) | ✅ | | **GH Push** | ✅ **READY** | @GTM:ADMIN | > *⚠️ Surge ran DEEP FULL (wrong type — L-209). Results valid per Calhoun. Same pattern as L-208. INT-M02 audit = P0 W13. ### 2: ✅ EXPLICIT APPROVAL ACK — BP-068.md v3.2.3.1 | Field | Value | |-------|-------| | **Approval CCC-ID** | **GTM_2026-W12_728** | | **Approver** | @GTM (u-gtm_user) | | **Rule** | R-011 🔒 (#OnlyHumanApproves) | | **#DualMETA VSA** | Calhoun 64/64 + Surge 95/95 = **159/159 PASS** | | **Self-Compliance** | ✅ BP-068 follows BP-068 (triple #LLMmodel) | | **Timestamp** | Su 22 Mar 2026 \| 00:01 MDT | > ✅ **R-011 SATISFIED — @GTM explicitly approved BP-068.md v3.2.3.1** --- ## 📋 Related Items ### Rules | ID | Rule | Relationship | |----|------|-------------| | R-011 | #OnlyHumanApproves | BP-068 approval: GTM_2026-W12_728 ✅ | | R-197 | Governance docs = #MetaAgent | BP-068 update routes through META | ### Learnings | ID | Learning | Relationship | |----|----------|-------------| | L-180 | #LLMmodel REQUIRED in all headers | **MERGED INTO BP-068 v3.2.3.1 — RETIRED** | | L-208 | #BadAgent SELF vs USER tracking | Triple #LLMmodel example (W12 D6) | | L-209 | PRE GH PUSH ≠ DEEP FULL VSA | Surge wrong type (same pattern as L-208) | ### Best Practices | ID | Best Practice | Relationship | |----|---------------|-------------| | BP-045 | Document Reference Standard | Version History + Related Docs format | | BP-047 | Case Study Attribution | Discovered By section | ### Documents | ID | Document | Relationship | |----|----------|-------------| | SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 | Canonical dual #LLMmodel reference | ✅ GH LIVE | | L-206.md | Triple #LLMmodel example | ✅ GH LIVE | | L-208.md | Triple #LLMmodel example | ✅ GH LIVE | | TMPL-007 v3.2.3.1 | BP-068 compliance in GH commits | ✅ GH LIVE | --- ## 📋 Related Documents | Document | Version | #masterCCC | Approval | URL | |----------|---------|------------|----------|-----| | SharedKernel | v3.2.2.1 | GTM_2026-W11_118 | GTM_2026-W11_139 | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_SYS_/SharedKernel.md) | | BEST-PRACTICES | v3.1.3.1 | GTM_2026-W08_069 | GTM_2026-W08_071 | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_SYS_/BEST-PRACTICES.md) | | PROTOCOLS | v3.1.3.1 | GTM_2026-W08_069 | GTM_2026-W08_071 | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_SYS_/PROTOCOLS.md) | | L-206 | v3.2.3.1 | GTM_2026-W12_702 | GTM_2026-W12_708 ✅ | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_GOVERNANCE_/L-206.md) | | L-208 | v3.2.3.1 | GTM_2026-W12_715 | GTM_2026-W12_722 ✅ | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_GOVERNANCE_/L-208.md) | | TMPL-007 | v3.2.3.1 | GTM_2026-W12_643 | GTM_2026-W12_644 ✅ | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_TEMPLATES_/TMPL-007_GH-Commit-Message.md) | | BP-068 | v3.2.3.1 | GTM_2026-W12_725 | GTM_2026-W12_728 ✅ | [GitHub](https://github.com/CCCbotNet/fedarch/blob/main/_GOVERNANCE_/BP-068.md) | --- ## 📋 Version History | Version | Date | #masterCCC | Approval | Changes | |---------|------|------------|----------|---------| | v3.2.3.1 | 2026-W12 | GTM_2026-W12_725 | GTM_2026-W12_728 ✅ | L-180 MERGED — +explicit 12 document types; +absence = #BadAgent enforcement; +model switch protocol (5-step); +triple #LLMmodel (#DualMETA); +decision matrix (5 scenarios); +enforcement table (5 violations); +VSA check format; +canonical reference (SharedKernel v3.2.2.1); +L-180 merge notes (Option A); +[DETAILS] section per PRJ-041; +Surge to BP-047; TOC: 16 sections; #DualMETA VSA: Calhoun 64/64 (PRE GH PUSH) + Surge 95/95* (DEEP FULL — wrong type, L-209) = 159/159 PASS; R-011 ✅ GTM_2026-W12_728; L-180 RETIRED; Folder: `_GOVERNANCE_/`; BP-068 SELF-COMPLIANT (triple #LLMmodel) | | v3.2.2.1 | 2026-W11 | GTM_2026-W11_118 | GTM_2026-W11_139 | Initial BP-068 — dual #LLMmodel header required for governance docs; SharedKernel v3.2.2.1 canonical reference; both models listed | --- #FlowsBros #FedArch #WeOwnSeason003 #BP068 #LLMmodel #Governance #L180Merged #DualMETA #TripleLLMmodel #SelfCompliant #FELG ♾️ WeOwnNet 🌐 ● 🏡 Real Estate and 🤝 cooperative ownership for everyone ● An 🤗 inclusive community, by 👥 invitation only.