const chartData = { "gpt-5.5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.6, 16.52, 16.91, 18.03, 18.12, 17.31, 16.13, 17.03, 15.6, 17.26, 16.63, 16.55, 17.53, 15.71, 17.17 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.11, 0.14, 0.1, 0.07, 0.09, 0.1, 0.15, 0.16, 0.22, 0.15, 0.11, 0.13, 0.12, 0.18, 0.1 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.55 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.27 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.54 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.36 } ] }, "gpt-5.4": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.5, 16.69, 16.94, 18.04, 18.12, 17.2, 15.89, 16.83, 14.98, 17.16, 16.58, 16.26, 17.46, 15.82, 16.96 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.07, 0.19, 0.12, 0.08, 0.1, 0.06, 0.07, 0.1, 0.0, 0.12, 0.1, 0.02, 0.11, 0.22, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.08 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.84 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.77 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.4 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.36 } ] }, "gpt-5-2025-08-07": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.43, 15.49, 16.58, 18.11, 17.9, 17.58, 15.97, 16.52, 15.8, 17.03, 16.54, 16.63, 17.33, 14.63, 17.23 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.05, -0.25, -0.02, 0.11, 0.01, 0.19, 0.1, -0.03, 0.28, 0.08, 0.1, 0.16, 0.06, -0.2, 0.14 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.53 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.37 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.79 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.28 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.26 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.17 } ] }, "openrouter/horizon-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.35, 15.46, 16.51, 18.06, 17.65, 17.48, 15.95, 16.81, 15.92, 16.83, 16.4, 16.57, 16.94, 14.67, 17.23 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.02, -0.26, -0.04, 0.1, -0.09, 0.16, 0.1, 0.09, 0.3, 0.0, 0.06, 0.15, -0.09, -0.17, 0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.36 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.32 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.3 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.66 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.25 } ] }, "moonshotai/Kimi-K2.6": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.36, 16.36, 16.46, 17.76, 17.84, 17.01, 15.67, 16.8, 15.06, 16.96, 16.22, 16.5, 17.19, 14.96, 16.97 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, 0.05, -0.07, -0.02, -0.01, -0.0, -0.0, 0.09, 0.08, 0.07, -0.01, 0.14, 0.02, -0.09, 0.06 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.57 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.44 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.37 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.32 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.34 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.29 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.27 } ] }, "openrouter/horizon-beta": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.25, 15.54, 16.57, 17.98, 17.71, 17.48, 15.96, 16.34, 15.57, 16.82, 16.36, 16.49, 17.23, 14.44, 17.12 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.02, -0.25, -0.01, 0.08, -0.07, 0.18, 0.12, -0.09, 0.25, 0.03, 0.07, 0.14, 0.04, -0.24, 0.13 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.61 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.41 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.32 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.97 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.37 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.31 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.19 } ] }, "gpt-5.2": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.45, 16.04, 16.64, 17.82, 17.98, 17.03, 15.51, 16.48, 14.9, 16.78, 16.29, 16.31, 17.38, 14.97, 16.95 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.06, -0.1, 0.03, 0.03, 0.05, 0.03, -0.05, -0.03, 0.04, 0.02, 0.05, 0.08, 0.11, -0.07, 0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.67 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.28 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.61 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.4 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.08 } ] }, "claude-opus-4-7": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.25, 16.67, 16.67, 17.71, 17.98, 16.56, 15.72, 16.65, 14.17, 16.63, 16.19, 15.88, 17.19, 15.69, 16.65 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.02, 0.14, 0.05, -0.02, 0.05, -0.15, 0.04, 0.05, -0.21, -0.04, 0.02, -0.08, 0.04, 0.21, -0.05 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.13 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.13 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.68 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.37 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.23 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "claude-opus-4-6": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.27, 16.54, 16.61, 17.62, 17.83, 16.7, 15.6, 16.66, 14.4, 16.79, 16.14, 15.78, 17.11, 15.67, 16.56 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, 0.09, 0.03, -0.04, -0.01, -0.1, -0.0, 0.06, -0.14, 0.04, -0.0, -0.11, 0.01, 0.2, -0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.13 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.69 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.51 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.28 } ] }, "gpt-5.4-mini": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.15, 16.03, 16.71, 17.8, 17.83, 16.95, 15.46, 16.54, 14.46, 16.67, 16.28, 16.05, 17.0, 15.15, 16.73 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.06, -0.12, 0.07, 0.04, -0.01, 0.02, -0.06, 0.02, -0.1, -0.01, 0.07, 0.0, -0.03, 0.0, 0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.96 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.25 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.44 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.21 } ] }, "claude-sonnet-4-6": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.06, 16.42, 16.76, 17.72, 17.91, 16.49, 15.39, 16.25, 14.12, 16.78, 16.28, 15.55, 17.18, 16.01, 16.61 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.09, 0.03, 0.09, 0.01, 0.03, -0.15, -0.08, -0.09, -0.2, 0.05, 0.08, -0.17, 0.05, 0.28, -0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.12 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.11 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.86 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.71 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.44 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.4 } ] }, "moonshotai/Kimi-K2-Thinking": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.34, 16.6, 16.48, 17.61, 17.71, 16.9, 15.58, 16.31, 14.69, 16.66, 16.07, 16.05, 16.9, 14.92, 16.64 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.04, 0.1, -0.01, -0.02, -0.05, 0.03, 0.03, -0.05, 0.06, 0.02, 0.0, 0.04, -0.05, -0.11, -0.0 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.36 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.34 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.27 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.47 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V4-Pro": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.09, 16.42, 16.35, 17.6, 17.83, 17.03, 15.53, 16.52, 15.01, 16.71, 15.85, 16.1, 17.0, 14.51, 16.67 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.06, 0.03, -0.05, -0.01, 0.01, 0.1, 0.02, 0.05, 0.19, 0.06, -0.07, 0.08, 0.01, -0.22, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.28 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.2 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.28 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.27 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.12 } ] }, "moonshotai/Kimi-K2-Instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.27, 16.25, 16.34, 17.6, 17.72, 17.18, 15.7, 16.64, 14.98, 16.57, 15.92, 15.88, 16.83, 14.54, 16.53 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, -0.06, -0.05, 0.0, -0.04, 0.16, 0.11, 0.1, 0.2, 0.03, -0.02, 0.0, -0.05, -0.21, -0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.76 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.45 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.1 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.22 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.21 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "claude-opus-4-5-20251101": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.19, 16.64, 16.66, 17.56, 17.86, 16.32, 15.06, 16.3, 13.54, 16.3, 15.97, 15.65, 16.78, 16.08, 16.34 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, 0.09, 0.09, 0.0, 0.02, -0.14, -0.13, -0.03, -0.26, -0.07, 0.02, -0.08, -0.08, 0.3, -0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.12 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.12 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.38 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.17 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "gemini-3-pro-preview": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.31, 16.61, 16.3, 17.48, 17.81, 16.75, 15.38, 16.06, 14.39, 16.2, 15.66, 15.89, 16.94, 14.58, 16.45 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.06, 0.07, -0.06, -0.03, 0.01, 0.04, 0.0, -0.11, 0.06, -0.1, -0.09, 0.05, 0.0, -0.21, -0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.85 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.75 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.58 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.48 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.23 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V4-Flash": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.17, 16.62, 16.3, 17.43, 17.78, 16.49, 15.34, 16.41, 13.94, 16.45, 15.69, 15.7, 16.99, 15.03, 16.39 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.0, 0.06, -0.05, -0.04, -0.01, -0.05, 0.01, 0.04, -0.09, 0.02, -0.06, -0.01, 0.03, -0.06, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.69 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.58 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.28 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.64 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.6 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.41 } ] }, "o3": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.26, 16.44, 16.29, 17.47, 17.86, 16.77, 15.54, 16.55, 14.36, 16.49, 15.79, 15.59, 16.66, 14.73, 16.46 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.05, -0.03, -0.04, -0.0, 0.03, 0.08, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.05, -0.0, -0.05, -0.1, -0.16, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.98 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.88 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.3 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.35 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.29 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V3.2": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.11, 16.73, 16.31, 17.34, 17.79, 16.59, 15.15, 16.09, 14.25, 16.33, 15.74, 15.69, 16.9, 15.01, 16.32 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, 0.09, -0.02, -0.05, 0.01, 0.02, -0.05, -0.07, 0.08, -0.0, -0.01, 0.01, 0.01, -0.06, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.83 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.29 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.23 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.19 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.65 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "openrouter/pony-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.1, 16.56, 16.46, 17.43, 17.74, 16.24, 15.23, 16.11, 13.82, 16.28, 15.82, 15.7, 16.65, 15.7, 16.3 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, 0.03, 0.05, -0.0, -0.01, -0.11, 0.0, -0.04, -0.08, -0.01, 0.04, 0.02, -0.08, 0.2, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.22 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.12 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.7 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.09 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-5.1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.17, 16.73, 16.32, 17.4, 17.72, 16.4, 15.27, 16.15, 13.98, 16.2, 15.71, 15.58, 16.89, 15.31, 16.29 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.02, 0.08, -0.0, -0.01, -0.02, -0.04, 0.03, -0.02, 0.0, -0.03, 0.01, -0.02, 0.02, 0.08, -0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.95 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.19 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.69 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.4 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.34 } ] }, "gpt-5.3-chat": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.15, 16.46, 16.5, 17.41, 17.85, 16.06, 14.95, 15.97, 13.1, 16.14, 15.81, 15.08, 16.84, 16.52, 16.07 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, -0.03, 0.09, 0.01, 0.05, -0.16, -0.1, -0.08, -0.29, -0.04, 0.07, -0.2, 0.01, 0.41, -0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.17 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.14 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.11 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.05 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.58 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.22 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "gemini-2.5-pro-preview-06-05": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.99, 16.47, 16.22, 17.31, 17.79, 16.64, 15.03, 16.25, 13.99, 16.1, 15.49, 15.69, 16.84, 14.6, 16.3 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.06, -0.02, -0.02, -0.03, 0.03, 0.07, -0.05, 0.05, 0.01, -0.04, -0.05, 0.04, 0.02, -0.14, 0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.75 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.64 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.51 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.38 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.27 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.14 } ] }, "hunter-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.04, 16.64, 16.28, 17.36, 17.76, 16.5, 15.1, 16.35, 13.96, 16.14, 15.53, 15.58, 16.7, 14.75, 16.2 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.03, 0.06, 0.02, 0.01, 0.02, 0.03, -0.02, 0.09, 0.02, -0.01, -0.02, 0.0, -0.04, -0.09, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.55 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.22 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.19 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.31 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.23 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.21 } ] }, "NousResearch/Hermes-4-405B": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.3, 16.24, 16.03, 17.36, 17.68, 16.51, 15.2, 16.3, 13.94, 16.01, 15.38, 15.77, 16.99, 14.26, 16.32 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.09, -0.11, -0.08, 0.02, -0.01, 0.05, 0.04, 0.09, 0.03, -0.04, -0.07, 0.09, 0.08, -0.24, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.92 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.9 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.85 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.24 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.34 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "claude-sonnet-4.5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.88, 16.6, 16.31, 17.26, 17.57, 15.99, 15.04, 16.2, 13.44, 16.14, 15.59, 15.29, 16.65, 16.04, 16.14 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.09, 0.06, 0.05, -0.02, -0.05, -0.16, -0.02, 0.06, -0.16, 0.02, 0.03, -0.1, -0.06, 0.34, -0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.14 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.11 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.98 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.53 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.25 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V3.1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.03, 16.53, 16.15, 17.34, 17.74, 16.46, 15.03, 15.93, 13.96, 16.12, 15.46, 15.54, 16.84, 14.55, 16.12 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.02, 0.03, -0.02, 0.02, 0.03, 0.03, -0.02, -0.06, 0.06, 0.02, -0.02, 0.01, 0.03, -0.14, -0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.41 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.32 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.32 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.24 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.2 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-4.6": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.1, 16.58, 16.04, 17.17, 17.76, 16.39, 15.03, 15.93, 13.64, 16.0, 15.31, 15.55, 16.92, 14.73, 16.16 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, 0.06, -0.06, -0.06, 0.05, -0.01, -0.01, -0.04, -0.08, -0.02, -0.08, 0.03, 0.07, -0.06, -0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.8 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.75 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.48 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.47 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.93 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.73 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.72 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.62 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.01, 16.36, 16.3, 17.28, 17.63, 16.12, 14.71, 15.76, 13.38, 16.03, 15.63, 15.53, 16.66, 15.53, 16.19 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, -0.03, 0.05, -0.0, 0.0, -0.1, -0.12, -0.1, -0.15, 0.01, 0.06, 0.03, -0.04, 0.22, 0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.2 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.12 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.09 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.81 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.63 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.63 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "claude-opus-4": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.05, 16.41, 16.25, 17.22, 17.56, 15.91, 14.97, 15.84, 13.42, 15.97, 15.44, 15.1, 16.73, 15.77, 15.98 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, -0.01, 0.03, -0.02, -0.02, -0.16, -0.02, -0.07, -0.11, -0.01, -0.01, -0.13, 0.0, 0.28, -0.06 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.12 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.07 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.05 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.03 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.65 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.27 } ] }, "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.14, 16.68, 16.21, 17.32, 17.86, 16.58, 15.0, 15.86, 13.62, 15.94, 15.42, 15.53, 16.63, 14.2, 16.15 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.05, 0.11, 0.03, 0.03, 0.11, 0.1, 0.01, -0.05, -0.03, -0.01, -0.0, 0.05, -0.04, -0.22, 0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.92 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.84 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.32 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.3 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.23 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.2 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.15 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.08 } ] }, "google/gemma-4-26B-A4B-it": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.02, 16.31, 15.97, 17.23, 17.55, 16.59, 15.07, 15.88, 14.36, 15.98, 15.31, 15.65, 16.83, 13.76, 16.19 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, -0.02, -0.06, -0.01, -0.01, 0.11, 0.05, -0.04, 0.24, 0.02, -0.04, 0.1, 0.04, -0.31, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.37 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.34 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.13 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.16 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.11 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.09 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.05 } ] }, "google/gemma-4-31B-it": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.11, 16.43, 16.06, 17.19, 17.47, 16.52, 14.86, 15.88, 14.2, 15.93, 15.31, 15.65, 16.56, 14.19, 16.16 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.05, 0.04, -0.01, -0.02, -0.04, 0.08, -0.03, -0.04, 0.19, 0.01, -0.02, 0.1, -0.07, -0.18, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.48 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.21 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.27 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.12 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.11 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.09 } ] }, "Qwen/Qwen3.5-397B-A17B": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.88, 16.31, 15.85, 17.06, 17.41, 16.31, 15.33, 16.16, 13.85, 15.84, 15.21, 15.37, 16.85, 14.7, 16.02 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.05, -0.01, -0.09, -0.06, -0.06, 0.02, 0.16, 0.1, 0.1, -0.01, -0.06, 0.0, 0.06, -0.01, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.6 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.58 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.39 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.57 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.55 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.45 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-4.7": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.98, 16.23, 15.98, 17.24, 17.42, 16.33, 14.95, 15.71, 14.05, 15.78, 15.29, 15.54, 16.74, 14.23, 16.09 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.0, -0.04, -0.03, 0.02, -0.04, 0.03, 0.02, -0.08, 0.18, -0.03, -0.01, 0.08, 0.03, -0.18, 0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.42 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.16 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.12 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.38 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.2 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.17 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "gemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.01, 15.9, 16.01, 17.23, 17.66, 16.32, 14.67, 15.79, 13.39, 15.78, 15.29, 15.34, 16.91, 14.62, 16.18 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, -0.16, -0.01, 0.02, 0.07, 0.04, -0.08, -0.03, -0.07, -0.01, -0.01, 0.02, 0.11, -0.04, 0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.69 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.64 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.26 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.48 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.17 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.14 } ] }, "mistral-medium-3.1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.03, 16.52, 16.23, 17.28, 17.52, 16.29, 15.01, 16.14, 13.41, 15.79, 15.41, 15.28, 16.32, 14.84, 15.95 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, 0.1, 0.09, 0.05, 0.02, 0.03, 0.08, 0.12, -0.05, 0.01, 0.06, -0.0, -0.12, 0.09, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.77 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.6 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.57 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.46 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.5 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.31 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.21 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.12 } ] }, "moonshotai/Kimi-K2.5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.45, 16.3, 16.21, 17.33, 17.04, 16.82, 15.15, 15.75, 14.01, 16.12, 15.65, 15.1, 16.63, 14.46, 16.04 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.18, 0.03, 0.09, 0.08, -0.15, 0.22, 0.14, -0.02, 0.2, 0.16, 0.15, -0.06, 0.02, -0.07, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.88 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.61 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.6 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.49 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.82 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "chatgpt-4o-latest-2025-03-27": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.99, 16.22, 16.12, 17.19, 17.45, 15.94, 14.68, 15.86, 13.22, 15.71, 15.29, 15.02, 16.5, 15.37, 15.81 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.02, 0.01, 0.07, 0.02, 0.02, -0.1, -0.04, 0.05, -0.1, 0.02, 0.04, -0.09, -0.03, 0.27, -0.06 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.18 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.09 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.06 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.02 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.95 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.87 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.44 } ] }, "optimus-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.04, 16.29, 16.15, 17.15, 17.57, 15.94, 14.77, 16.26, 12.96, 15.65, 15.28, 15.03, 16.46, 15.1, 15.93 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.04, 0.05, 0.09, 0.01, 0.07, -0.09, 0.02, 0.2, -0.17, 0.01, 0.05, -0.07, -0.03, 0.19, 0.0 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.99 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.36 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.15 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.52 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.24 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.08 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1-0528": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.1, 15.97, 15.74, 17.08, 17.54, 16.47, 14.77, 15.67, 13.65, 15.71, 15.14, 15.58, 16.81, 13.66, 16.11 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.07, -0.08, -0.07, -0.01, 0.07, 0.13, 0.03, -0.01, 0.11, 0.05, 0.0, 0.15, 0.13, -0.27, 0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.69 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.51 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.31 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.3 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.15 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.15 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-4.5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.86, 16.0, 15.78, 17.04, 17.29, 16.29, 14.6, 15.98, 13.68, 15.61, 15.05, 15.42, 16.85, 13.92, 16.02 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.02, -0.06, -0.04, -0.01, -0.02, 0.09, -0.02, 0.13, 0.15, 0.03, -0.02, 0.13, 0.15, -0.22, 0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.98 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.87 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.83 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.59 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.18 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.12 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.04 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.04 } ] }, "gpt-4.1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.91, 16.12, 15.99, 17.08, 17.39, 15.94, 14.64, 15.6, 12.9, 15.56, 15.26, 14.92, 16.52, 15.21, 15.85 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.0, 0.02, 0.05, 0.01, 0.02, -0.04, 0.02, -0.01, -0.12, 0.03, 0.08, -0.06, 0.02, 0.23, 0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.06 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.04 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.51 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.15 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.11 } ] }, "claude-sonnet-4": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.86, 16.26, 16.02, 17.03, 17.51, 15.59, 14.44, 15.49, 12.79, 15.6, 15.08, 14.94, 16.53, 15.32, 15.77 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.01, 0.07, 0.07, -0.0, 0.08, -0.14, -0.05, -0.04, -0.12, 0.07, 0.02, -0.02, 0.04, 0.24, -0.01 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.24 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.23 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.3 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.22 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.13 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.86, 16.31, 15.81, 16.96, 17.19, 16.15, 14.89, 15.7, 13.27, 15.43, 15.02, 14.94, 16.2, 14.36, 15.72 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.0, 0.1, -0.01, -0.03, -0.05, 0.09, 0.16, 0.08, 0.09, 0.01, 0.0, -0.01, -0.08, -0.1, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.58 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.48 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.82 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.5 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.11 } ] }, "qwen/qwen3-235b-a22b:thinking": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.71, 16.17, 15.58, 17.0, 16.98, 16.12, 14.7, 15.79, 13.62, 15.38, 15.01, 15.06, 16.4, 14.19, 15.72 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.07, 0.06, -0.1, 0.0, -0.13, 0.1, 0.11, 0.12, 0.24, 0.01, 0.01, 0.06, 0.02, -0.15, 0.0 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.39 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.33 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.18 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.07 } ] }, "quasar-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.03, 15.7, 15.88, 16.96, 17.38, 15.69, 14.17, 15.38, 12.59, 15.18, 14.84, 15.02, 16.05, 14.54, 15.76 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.08, -0.12, 0.03, -0.01, 0.05, -0.07, -0.09, -0.02, -0.12, -0.05, -0.05, 0.06, -0.1, -0.01, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.78 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.66 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.49 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.49 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.96 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.78 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.45 } ] }, "mistralai/Mistral-Large-3-675B-Instruct-2512": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.75, 15.89, 15.79, 17.02, 17.08, 15.77, 14.35, 15.25, 12.45, 15.02, 14.78, 14.78, 16.27, 14.48, 15.53 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.04, -0.02, 0.02, 0.03, -0.07, -0.03, 0.02, -0.03, -0.16, -0.09, -0.05, -0.03, -0.01, 0.01, -0.06 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.95 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.8 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.71 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.41 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.4 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.23 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.16 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.12 } ] }, "grok-4.1-fast": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.18, 15.56, 14.93, 16.99, 17.09, 16.3, 14.36, 15.09, 13.79, 14.91, 14.55, 15.14, 16.49, 12.91, 15.88 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.13, -0.08, -0.25, 0.02, -0.05, 0.17, 0.05, -0.06, 0.3, -0.11, -0.12, 0.11, 0.1, -0.4, 0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.47 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.33 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.21 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.54 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.21 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.17 } ] }, "claude-3-7-sonnet-20250219": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.85, 16.1, 15.83, 16.77, 17.31, 15.23, 13.9, 14.94, 12.27, 15.23, 14.76, 14.49, 15.9, 15.93, 15.48 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, 0.14, 0.08, -0.06, 0.05, -0.2, -0.12, -0.1, -0.19, 0.05, -0.02, -0.12, -0.12, 0.43, -0.06 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.28 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.44 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.42 } ] }, "mistral-small-creative": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.8, 16.01, 15.73, 16.94, 17.15, 15.94, 14.32, 15.18, 12.84, 15.11, 14.89, 14.8, 15.86, 14.0, 15.51 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, 0.13, 0.06, 0.03, -0.01, 0.08, 0.08, 0.05, 0.05, 0.03, 0.05, 0.02, -0.12, -0.11, -0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.49 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.44 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.24 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.2 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.89 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.35 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.23 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.11 } ] }, "chatgpt-4o-latest-2025-01-29": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.76, 16.26, 15.86, 16.72, 17.26, 15.05, 13.99, 15.07, 11.79, 15.11, 14.81, 14.12, 16.26, 15.84, 15.29 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, 0.21, 0.12, -0.04, 0.06, -0.21, -0.02, 0.04, -0.27, 0.07, 0.05, -0.2, 0.07, 0.41, -0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.36 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.05 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.04 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.76 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.69 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.34 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.21 } ] }, "grok-3-beta": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.97, 15.36, 15.57, 16.91, 17.38, 15.73, 13.94, 15.35, 12.55, 14.84, 14.54, 14.78, 16.6, 13.7, 15.64 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.11, -0.09, 0.03, 0.05, 0.11, 0.06, 0.0, 0.18, 0.01, -0.01, -0.04, 0.08, 0.2, -0.22, 0.08 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.84 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.33 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.15 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.47 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.29 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.19 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V3-0324": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.57, 16.48, 15.79, 16.79, 17.23, 15.09, 14.0, 14.98, 11.83, 14.95, 14.7, 14.11, 16.19, 15.5, 15.11 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.0, 0.28, 0.14, 0.05, 0.09, -0.15, 0.03, 0.03, -0.22, 0.08, 0.07, -0.15, 0.07, 0.34, -0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.73 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.22 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.08 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.05 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.68 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.67 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.46 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "google/gemma-3-27b-it": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.64, 15.59, 15.66, 16.81, 17.06, 15.52, 13.68, 14.6, 12.74, 14.92, 14.76, 14.85, 15.83, 14.37, 15.55 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.04, 0.04, 0.12, 0.08, 0.04, 0.04, -0.07, -0.07, 0.13, 0.11, 0.12, 0.15, -0.05, 0.05, 0.1 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.76 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.69 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.63 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.55 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.82 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.1 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.06 } ] }, "gpt-4.5-preview": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.79, 15.71, 15.61, 16.7, 17.22, 15.17, 13.61, 15.15, 11.81, 14.6, 14.5, 14.47, 15.89, 14.29, 15.3 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.12, 0.11, 0.12, 0.05, 0.12, -0.08, -0.05, 0.17, -0.18, 0.02, 0.05, 0.04, -0.01, 0.01, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.57 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.53 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.53 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.46 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.47 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.36 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.19 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.11 } ] }, "minimax/minimax-m2.5": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.52, 15.34, 15.5, 16.79, 16.88, 15.73, 13.87, 14.35, 12.59, 14.9, 14.71, 14.51, 15.77, 14.06, 15.34 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.03, -0.01, 0.09, 0.11, -0.01, 0.17, 0.1, -0.08, 0.15, 0.17, 0.15, 0.08, -0.03, -0.07, 0.08 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.99 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.77 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.76 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.23 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.68 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.57 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.56 } ] }, "openrouter/sherlock-dash-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 18.16, 15.06, 14.9, 16.88, 17.04, 16.3, 13.91, 14.43, 13.1, 14.48, 14.28, 14.8, 16.16, 12.4, 15.47 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.25, -0.1, -0.13, 0.15, 0.07, 0.33, 0.15, -0.0, 0.31, 0.06, 0.01, 0.2, 0.14, -0.46, 0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.87 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.52 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.02 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.28 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.18 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.26, 12.56, 14.82, 16.94, 16.42, 16.76, 13.7, 13.84, 13.7, 14.69, 14.92, 15.48, 15.8, 11.81, 16.08 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.05, -0.58, -0.13, 0.19, -0.15, 0.42, 0.1, -0.18, 0.43, 0.17, 0.25, 0.37, 0.03, -0.53, 0.32 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.98 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.77 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.59 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.36 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.87 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.22 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.2 } ] }, "claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.09, 16.06, 15.45, 16.34, 16.92, 14.67, 13.67, 14.65, 11.65, 14.43, 14.22, 13.69, 15.42, 15.54, 14.81 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.09, 0.3, 0.12, -0.01, 0.07, -0.17, 0.13, 0.17, -0.13, 0.12, 0.04, -0.16, -0.09, 0.41, -0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.16 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.55 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.53 } ] }, "gemini-2.5-flash-preview": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.49, 14.8, 15.23, 16.47, 17.06, 15.24, 13.09, 14.01, 11.79, 14.18, 14.12, 14.09, 15.82, 13.71, 15.08 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.12, -0.08, 0.07, 0.07, 0.15, 0.05, -0.06, -0.02, -0.06, 0.07, 0.02, 0.01, 0.1, -0.06, 0.08 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.64 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.26 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.21 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.88 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.87 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.84 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.51 } ] }, "deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V3.2-Speciale": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.27, 15.5, 14.96, 16.09, 16.9, 14.6, 12.85, 13.64, 11.29, 13.79, 13.72, 13.6, 15.37, 14.95, 14.65 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.06, 0.21, -0.02, -0.07, 0.11, -0.17, -0.11, -0.11, -0.19, -0.04, -0.11, -0.14, -0.06, 0.34, -0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.59 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.22 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.09 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.79 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.53 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.29 } ] }, "google/gemma-3-12b-it": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.29, 14.62, 14.89, 16.24, 16.65, 14.75, 12.56, 13.71, 11.76, 13.83, 13.83, 13.96, 15.59, 13.79, 14.84 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.09, -0.07, -0.01, 0.03, 0.05, -0.12, -0.18, -0.04, -0.03, 0.03, -0.03, 0.02, 0.08, 0.07, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.89 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.66 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.31 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.66 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "grok-4.20-beta": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 15.12, 16.31, 14.32, 14.61, 15.61, 13.7, 14.72, 16.43, 11.62, 13.52, 13.08, 13.02, 16.08, 15.7, 13.57 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.47, 0.42, -0.19, -0.41, -0.28, -0.36, 0.46, 0.6, -0.04, -0.06, -0.25, -0.26, 0.26, 0.5, -0.33 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.78 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.63 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.4 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.55 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.25 } ] }, "allura-org/Gemma-3-Glitter-12B": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.22, 13.96, 14.59, 16.07, 16.45, 14.66, 12.23, 12.9, 11.64, 13.2, 13.51, 14.02, 15.12, 13.32, 14.78 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.11, -0.21, -0.04, 0.01, 0.02, -0.12, -0.2, -0.21, -0.03, -0.12, -0.09, 0.1, -0.03, -0.01, 0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.92 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.3 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.97 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.89 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.4 } ] }, "mistralai/Mistral-Small-3.2-24B-Instruct-2506": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.73, 15.24, 14.91, 16.04, 16.43, 14.26, 12.72, 13.59, 10.89, 13.3, 13.55, 13.09, 15.19, 14.42, 14.1 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.05, 0.3, 0.13, 0.03, 0.06, -0.24, 0.03, 0.1, -0.25, 0.01, -0.02, -0.21, 0.03, 0.38, -0.16 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.71 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.21 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.15 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.05 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.97 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.84 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.62 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "gemini-2.0-flash-001": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.93, 14.57, 14.62, 15.97, 16.52, 14.5, 12.42, 13.04, 11.12, 13.0, 13.39, 13.6, 15.03, 13.52, 14.49 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.09, 0.2, 0.07, 0.05, 0.14, -0.15, -0.02, -0.03, -0.15, -0.03, -0.03, 0.01, 0.03, 0.22, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.93 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.52 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.29 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.2 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.99 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.32 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.28 } ] }, "CohereForAI/c4ai-command-a-03-2025": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.32, 14.25, 14.83, 16.09, 16.55, 14.7, 12.11, 12.89, 11.15, 13.03, 13.58, 13.61, 14.81, 13.41, 14.43 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.25, 0.15, 0.19, 0.14, 0.17, -0.01, -0.05, -0.0, -0.08, 0.08, 0.11, 0.09, 0.02, 0.21, 0.08 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.71 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.56 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.47 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.36 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.83 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.56 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.53 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.41 } ] }, "qwen/qwq-32b": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 17.06, 14.44, 14.3, 15.84, 15.83, 15.0, 12.83, 13.18, 11.95, 12.92, 13.44, 13.71, 15.07, 12.55, 14.31 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.22, 0.26, 0.04, 0.11, -0.07, 0.17, 0.27, 0.19, 0.27, 0.12, 0.11, 0.18, 0.19, -0.09, 0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.98 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.85 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.51 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.15 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.94 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.56 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.36 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.29 } ] }, "google/gemma-3-4b-it": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.49, 13.18, 14.55, 15.86, 15.99, 15.19, 11.65, 11.91, 11.3, 12.83, 13.56, 13.58, 14.7, 12.33, 14.38 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.07, -0.16, 0.16, 0.16, 0.02, 0.28, -0.06, -0.2, 0.16, 0.17, 0.21, 0.2, 0.14, -0.16, 0.18 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.39 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.35 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.12 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.11 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.86 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.86 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.58 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.38 } ] }, "zai-org/GLM-4.7-Flash": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 15.53, 13.39, 14.19, 15.46, 15.21, 15.29, 12.24, 12.2, 11.57, 12.69, 13.34, 13.28, 14.66, 11.7, 14.09 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.18, -0.02, 0.07, 0.07, -0.21, 0.34, 0.23, 0.02, 0.27, 0.19, 0.19, 0.18, 0.18, -0.29, 0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.6 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.38 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.18 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.75 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.68 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.27 } ] }, "gpt-4.1-mini": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.78, 14.1, 14.27, 15.52, 16.28, 14.25, 11.84, 12.19, 10.56, 12.48, 13.03, 12.7, 14.16, 13.27, 13.76 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.29, 0.29, 0.15, 0.14, 0.21, 0.1, 0.19, 0.12, -0.0, 0.2, 0.15, 0.03, 0.09, 0.26, 0.09 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.96 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.76 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.42 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.34 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.79 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.38 } ] }, "RekaAI/reka-flash-3": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.35, 14.19, 13.97, 15.32, 15.47, 15.01, 12.34, 12.53, 11.69, 12.44, 13.07, 13.21, 13.92, 11.83, 13.78 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.23, 0.35, 0.1, 0.13, -0.04, 0.35, 0.36, 0.28, 0.37, 0.26, 0.21, 0.26, 0.06, -0.19, 0.16 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.96 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.86 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.84 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.33 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.64 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.46 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.36 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.3 } ] }, "anthropic/claude-3.5-haiku-20241022": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 15.93, 14.17, 14.48, 15.55, 16.08, 13.61, 11.0, 12.09, 10.33, 12.56, 13.23, 12.16, 14.39, 14.0, 13.58 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.15, 0.41, 0.3, 0.24, 0.24, -0.07, 0.03, 0.23, 0.01, 0.34, 0.29, -0.05, 0.27, 0.48, 0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.34 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.17 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.96 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.73 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.38 } ] }, "ifable/gemma-2-Ifable-9B": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 16.98, 12.51, 12.4, 15.42, 15.96, 15.54, 11.3, 12.31, 11.73, 11.52, 12.2, 13.86, 14.08, 9.12, 14.59 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.41, 0.05, -0.31, 0.23, 0.23, 0.47, 0.25, 0.37, 0.43, 0.14, 0.02, 0.45, 0.25, -0.59, 0.41 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.88 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.75 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.68 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.68 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.5 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.2 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.18 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.11 } ] }, "sam-paech/Darkest-muse-v1": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 15.25, 9.89, 13.23, 15.22, 14.74, 15.23, 11.12, 11.05, 10.58, 10.46, 12.11, 13.06, 14.37, 8.98, 13.73 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.0, -0.54, -0.01, 0.23, -0.16, 0.46, 0.26, 0.12, 0.22, -0.17, 0.06, 0.35, 0.36, -0.59, 0.29 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.64 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.6 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.33 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.86 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.24 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.1 } ] }, "THUDM/GLM-4-32B-0414": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 14.93, 9.82, 12.99, 14.27, 14.58, 13.61, 9.61, 10.2, 9.81, 10.39, 11.8, 11.95, 12.68, 10.61, 12.71 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.03, -0.52, -0.04, -0.04, -0.17, 0.15, -0.17, -0.11, 0.03, -0.11, 0.01, 0.12, -0.08, -0.32, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.82 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.37 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.33 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.25 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.43 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.17 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.16 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.08 } ] }, "mistralai/mistral-large-2411": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 14.99, 12.19, 12.86, 13.92, 15.16, 12.09, 9.12, 9.88, 8.89, 9.97, 11.28, 10.94, 11.52, 12.37, 11.9 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.09, 0.12, -0.03, -0.11, 0.1, -0.3, -0.24, -0.12, -0.24, -0.17, -0.12, -0.18, -0.33, 0.28, -0.19 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.52 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.47 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.45 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.2 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.48 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.48 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.26 } ] }, "gpt-4o-mini": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 14.72, 11.31, 12.69, 13.94, 15.27, 12.61, 9.07, 9.62, 8.78, 9.61, 11.19, 11.11, 11.76, 11.05, 12.22 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.06, -0.08, 0.0, -0.03, 0.21, -0.14, -0.19, -0.12, -0.24, -0.19, -0.08, -0.08, -0.23, -0.02, -0.02 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.43 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.18 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.17 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.89 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.67 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.65 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.35 } ] }, "mistralai/Pixtral-Large-Instruct-2411": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 15.23, 11.05, 12.64, 13.82, 15.01, 12.28, 8.99, 9.66, 8.4, 9.46, 11.1, 10.93, 11.49, 11.49, 12.11 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.29, -0.08, 0.05, -0.0, 0.17, -0.18, -0.13, 0.0, -0.28, -0.16, -0.03, -0.07, -0.22, 0.18, 0.03 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.58 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.55 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.19 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.14 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.7 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.53 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.44 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.3 } ] }, "gpt-4.1-nano": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 13.97, 10.14, 12.17, 13.7, 14.56, 12.06, 8.05, 8.48, 8.16, 8.92, 10.81, 10.28, 11.26, 10.82, 11.51 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, -0.25, -0.01, 0.11, 0.11, -0.11, -0.25, -0.25, -0.23, -0.16, 0.02, -0.14, -0.12, 0.0, -0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.98 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.53 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.49 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.99 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.84 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.32 } ] }, "meta-llama/llama-3.1-405b-instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 13.3, 11.16, 11.83, 12.93, 14.3, 10.72, 7.98, 8.67, 8.1, 8.71, 10.1, 9.54, 11.78, 12.14, 10.93 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.15, 0.19, -0.08, -0.12, 0.09, -0.4, -0.21, -0.12, -0.21, -0.15, -0.18, -0.29, 0.18, 0.43, -0.17 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.46 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.44 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.31 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.1 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.49 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.19 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.18 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.08 } ] }, "openai/gpt-oss-120b": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 14.78, 8.34, 10.91, 12.73, 12.73, 13.57, 9.03, 8.84, 9.73, 8.8, 10.13, 10.94, 11.11, 7.72, 11.61 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.37, -0.49, -0.3, -0.12, -0.35, 0.43, 0.25, 0.05, 0.37, -0.01, -0.1, 0.24, 0.02, -0.59, 0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.79 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.77 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.45 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.42 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.73 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.35 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.12 } ] }, "meta-llama/Llama-4-Maverick-17B-128E-Instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 13.38, 9.94, 11.7, 12.8, 14.31, 11.2, 7.41, 7.68, 7.79, 8.05, 10.02, 9.48, 10.92, 11.12, 10.88 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, -0.01, 0.06, 0.02, 0.24, -0.23, -0.24, -0.27, -0.23, -0.18, -0.04, -0.23, 0.02, 0.34, -0.07 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.68 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.21 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.13 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.12 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.87 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.8 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.79 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.78 } ] }, "meta-llama/llama-3.1-70b-instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 12.57, 10.79, 11.4, 12.18, 13.86, 10.04, 7.15, 7.61, 7.58, 8.03, 9.59, 8.83, 10.85, 11.61, 9.95 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.18, 0.31, -0.02, -0.14, 0.17, -0.42, -0.25, -0.21, -0.22, -0.11, -0.14, -0.32, 0.08, 0.42, -0.27 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.72 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.42 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.3 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.17 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.56 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.38 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.31 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.22 } ] }, "anthropic/claude-3-haiku": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.36, 11.36, 11.54, 12.02, 13.35, 9.91, 7.2, 7.71, 6.94, 7.66, 9.53, 8.54, 10.16, 11.71, 9.83 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.41, 0.45, 0.11, -0.12, 0.05, -0.39, -0.16, -0.11, -0.32, -0.16, -0.09, -0.32, -0.08, 0.43, -0.24 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.96 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.29 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.21 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.05 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.63 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.63 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.32 } ] }, "openai/gpt-4-0314": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 12.28, 10.86, 11.43, 12.21, 14.05, 10.41, 7.02, 7.05, 7.45, 7.77, 9.54, 9.05, 9.53, 10.74, 9.85 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.12, 0.35, 0.12, 0.03, 0.29, -0.22, -0.16, -0.25, -0.14, -0.05, -0.01, -0.12, -0.2, 0.23, -0.16 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.83 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.65 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.41 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.25 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.74 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.6 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.27 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.23 } ] }, "gpt-5-nano-2025-08-07": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 13.13, 6.06, 9.44, 12.4, 11.82, 13.6, 7.47, 7.62, 9.26, 7.55, 8.85, 10.95, 10.33, 4.98, 11.4 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.26, -0.66, -0.41, 0.17, -0.33, 0.59, 0.09, -0.0, 0.42, -0.07, -0.2, 0.46, 0.14, -0.79, 0.37 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.62 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.55 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.44 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.23 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.7 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.25 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": -0.14 } ] }, "ToastyPigeon/Gemma-3-Starshine-12B": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.92, 9.35, 11.05, 11.93, 12.86, 10.8, 6.84, 7.09, 7.31, 7.38, 9.49, 9.2, 9.03, 10.63, 9.7 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.09, 0.02, 0.1, 0.07, 0.07, 0.04, -0.11, -0.15, -0.1, -0.06, 0.11, 0.09, -0.26, 0.25, -0.08 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.33 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.32 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.25 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.18 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.52 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.38 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.35 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.32 } ] }, "mistralai/Mistral-Nemo-Instruct-2407": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 12.46, 9.08, 10.96, 11.74, 12.89, 11.27, 6.83, 7.53, 7.53, 7.38, 9.48, 9.24, 8.71, 8.81, 9.99 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.19, 0.01, 0.14, 0.07, 0.17, 0.22, -0.06, 0.09, 0.02, 0.02, 0.16, 0.16, -0.3, -0.29, 0.11 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.71 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.56 }, { "criterion": "Elegant Prose", "relativeScore": 0.49 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.45 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.95 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.31 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.18 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.16 } ] }, "openrouter/cypher-alpha": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.41, 9.96, 10.84, 10.98, 12.51, 9.6, 6.55, 7.99, 6.36, 6.82, 8.78, 7.92, 8.81, 11.19, 8.97 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.11, 0.36, 0.19, -0.12, 0.17, -0.27, -0.1, 0.26, -0.31, -0.1, -0.01, -0.24, -0.23, 0.44, -0.19 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.76 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.4 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.37 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.79 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.63 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.58 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.38 } ] }, "liquid/lfm-7b": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.72, 8.84, 10.55, 11.22, 12.41, 11.17, 6.66, 6.81, 7.55, 7.33, 8.99, 8.85, 8.73, 7.92, 9.49 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.06, 0.07, 0.13, 0.02, 0.18, 0.27, -0.03, -0.13, 0.1, 0.14, 0.11, 0.12, -0.23, -0.42, 0.04 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.49 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.31 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.27 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.23 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.49 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.29 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.14 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.06 } ] }, "meta-llama/Llama-4-Scout-17B-16E-Instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.84, 7.61, 10.36, 11.24, 12.18, 10.0, 6.35, 7.01, 6.9, 6.7, 8.82, 8.53, 9.03, 9.7, 9.75 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.14, -0.3, 0.1, 0.07, 0.15, -0.13, -0.12, -0.02, -0.14, -0.07, 0.08, 0.02, -0.1, 0.15, 0.16 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.86 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.86 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.8 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.49 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.38 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.36 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.28 } ] }, "Nanbeige/Nanbeige4-3B-Thinking-2511": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 13.0, 6.53, 8.27, 10.1, 8.96, 12.18, 7.84, 7.27, 9.88, 6.69, 7.93, 10.28, 10.19, 4.66, 10.09 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.45, -0.5, -0.47, -0.28, -0.6, 0.5, 0.38, 0.12, 0.59, -0.04, -0.22, 0.48, 0.32, -0.78, 0.29 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.66 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.57 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.41 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.61 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -0.46 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.23 } ] }, "meta-llama/llama-3.1-8b-instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.21, 8.7, 9.95, 10.75, 12.4, 9.23, 5.95, 6.32, 6.61, 6.56, 8.39, 7.75, 9.47, 10.3, 8.7 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.01, 0.09, -0.02, -0.05, 0.27, -0.28, -0.2, -0.21, -0.18, -0.06, -0.04, -0.2, 0.15, 0.31, -0.15 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.83 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.47 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.3 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.13 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": -0.65 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.56 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.56 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.48 } ] }, "mistralai/mistral-small-3.1-24b-instruct-2503": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 11.04, 7.36, 9.62, 10.79, 10.86, 9.78, 6.05, 6.54, 6.18, 5.94, 8.07, 7.69, 8.45, 9.47, 8.78 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.02, -0.31, -0.11, 0.0, -0.21, -0.12, -0.15, -0.13, -0.29, -0.23, -0.13, -0.2, -0.18, 0.13, -0.1 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.52 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.44 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": 0.13 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.09 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.85 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.53 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.39 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.35 } ] }, "openai/gpt-3.5-turbo-0613": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 9.16, 10.62, 10.26, 10.46, 12.46, 8.02, 5.43, 6.27, 5.82, 6.15, 7.99, 6.99, 7.27, 10.6, 7.75 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.48, 0.56, 0.18, -0.1, 0.35, -0.51, -0.31, -0.2, -0.37, -0.15, -0.13, -0.37, -0.43, 0.44, -0.36 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 0.71 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": 0.56 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.34 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": 0.1 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.89 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": -0.69 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.45 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.45 } ] }, "meta-llama/llama-3.2-3b-instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 9.59, 7.62, 9.21, 9.95, 10.65, 8.78, 5.6, 6.18, 6.44, 6.0, 7.59, 7.23, 8.89, 9.52, 7.96 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.4, -0.13, -0.18, -0.23, -0.18, -0.38, -0.26, -0.22, -0.22, -0.17, -0.23, -0.31, 0.03, 0.23, -0.31 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.54 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.24 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": 0.14 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": 0.12 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.87 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.42 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.41 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": -0.15 } ] }, "mistralai/Mistral-Small-24B-Instruct-2501": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 10.64, 7.72, 9.23, 9.92, 10.62, 8.97, 5.84, 6.51, 6.01, 5.59, 7.66, 7.08, 8.27, 10.06, 8.24 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.08, -0.15, -0.18, -0.2, -0.17, -0.28, -0.16, -0.1, -0.28, -0.26, -0.2, -0.29, -0.17, 0.3, -0.18 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.2 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.17 }, { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": 0.07 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.04 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": -0.92 }, { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": -0.9 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "relativeScore": -0.73 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.19 } ] }, "openai/gpt-oss-20b": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 10.95, 5.94, 8.5, 9.64, 9.28, 10.55, 6.01, 6.05, 6.98, 5.68, 7.42, 7.52, 8.17, 7.04, 8.2 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 0.09, -0.51, -0.34, -0.25, -0.45, 0.28, -0.09, -0.24, 0.07, -0.22, -0.23, -0.14, -0.19, -0.5, -0.17 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Descriptive Imagery", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": 0.57 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.53 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.28 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": 0.18 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Pacing", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": -0.97 }, { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -0.72 }, { "criterion": "Sentence Flow", "relativeScore": -0.33 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.07 } ] }, "meta-llama/llama-3.2-1b-instruct": { "absoluteRadar": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ 5.8, 5.76, 7.23, 7.28, 5.92, 7.17, 5.41, 6.07, 5.65, 4.55, 5.78, 5.23, 8.15, 9.23, 5.79 ] }, "relativeRadarLog": { "labels": [ "Instruction Following", "Pacing", "Sentence Flow", "Consistent Voice & Tone", "Coherent", "Descriptive Imagery", "Show-Don't-Tell", "Strong Dialogue", "Creativity", "Avoids Amateurish Prose", "Elegant Prose", "Emotional Depth", "Avoids Positivity Bias", "Avoids Purple Prose", "Believable Characters" ], "values": [ -0.8, -0.52, -0.54, -0.63, -0.8, -0.56, -0.26, -0.21, -0.35, -0.45, -0.53, -0.57, -0.2, 0.07, -0.6 ] }, "strengths": [ { "criterion": "Avoids Purple Prose", "relativeScore": 1.0 }, { "criterion": "Avoids Positivity Bias", "relativeScore": 0.7 }, { "criterion": "Strong Dialogue", "relativeScore": 0.69 }, { "criterion": "Show-Don't-Tell", "relativeScore": 0.61 }, { "criterion": "Creativity", "relativeScore": 0.45 } ], "weaknesses": [ { "criterion": "Coherent", "relativeScore": -1.0 }, { "criterion": "Instruction Following", "relativeScore": -0.98 }, { "criterion": "Consistent Voice & Tone", "relativeScore": -0.29 }, { "criterion": "Believable Characters", "relativeScore": -0.21 }, { "criterion": "Emotional Depth", "relativeScore": -0.13 } ] } };