{ "cases": [ { "id": "INC-001", "title": "Distribution-return definition mismatch", "classification": "DELIBERATELY INJECTED TEST CASE", "severity": "BLOCK", "expected_status": "BLOCK", "observed_status": "BLOCK", "detected": true, "expected_domain_checks_any": [ "daily_gross_reconciliation", "daily_nav_reconstruction", "daily_net_reconciliation" ], "expected_domain_failure_observed": true, "injection": "Replaced total returns with ex-distribution returns in an in-memory copy of the full source panel.", "root_cause": "Data field mapping", "corrective_action": "Restore CRSP CIZ DlyRet and reconcile distributions without adding DLRET again.", "suggested_operational_owner": "Data engineering + portfolio analytics", "acceptance_criterion": "Independent return/NAV reconstruction must disagree with the saved total-return portfolio.", "failed_checks": [ { "id": "risk_shrinkage_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.0005296617782676316, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "risk_te_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.0008721221195768722, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "risk_te_budget", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 1440, "max_abs_error": 0.0007000897246580082, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" }, { "id": "risk_minimum_reference", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.0007753437586894875, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "Reconciles the saved Minimum risk solution; does not independently certify optimizer optimality." }, { "id": "risk_budget_definition", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.0007753437586894888, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "benchmark_nav_reconstruction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 3018, "max_abs_error": 511273.2271002892, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "benchmark_return_reconstruction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 3018, "max_abs_error": 0.003961570215387615, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "trade_preholdings_reconstruction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 314950.3415597589, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "trade_postholdings_reconstruction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 314950.3415597589, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "posttrade_decision_weights", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 0.052424734025188435, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" }, { "id": "posttrade_constraints", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.032551183327899746, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" }, { "id": "reconstructed_positive_nav", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 1.0, "tolerance": 0.0, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_cost_fraction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 1.3414037315357825e-05, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_traded_fraction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.026828074630549148, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_nav_reconstruction", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 564265.4505817401, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_gross_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.004914979967724416, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_net_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.0049149799677244595, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_benchmark_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.003961570215387615, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_gross_active_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.004271411088033077, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_net_active_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.004271411088033139, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "daily_drift_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 90540, "max_abs_error": 0.03265683714745236, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" } ], "aggregate_impact": { "returns_rows": 32192, "calendar_rows": 4024, "daily_rows": 90540, "decisions_rows": 4320, "trades_rows": 34560, "benchmark_rows": 3018, "paths": 30, "evaluation_dates": 3018, "execution_dates": 144, "source_dates": 4024, "assets": 8, "attribution_totals": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.044075543038562, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.007354074375617969, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.566519488050286, "IWM": 0.14033631960587395, "EFA": 0.1007664893405776, "EEM": 0.03173180979090884, "IEF": -0.02137949979673126, "TLT": -0.014938390890377674, "GLD": 0.24551404640093763, "SHY": -0.0018949943179083376 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.025037510931640528, "IWM": 0.006010426404720159, "EFA": -0.006968839667833848, "EEM": 0.0004915463718936676, "IEF": -0.002395886803290906, "TLT": -0.00016949238134270767, "GLD": 0.03822250303838273, "SHY": -0.00021894651026217174 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0025797251450238364, "active_linking_residual": -1.5406079190150024e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0440755429774695, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.007354074314525505, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5665194880220458, "IWM": 0.14033631960389512, "EFA": 0.1007664893657057, "EEM": 0.03173180977932361, "IEF": -0.02137950009342507, "TLT": -0.01493839067612722, "GLD": 0.24551404639265934, "SHY": -0.001894994271445907 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.025037510959880716, "IWM": 0.006010426402741326, "EFA": -0.00696883964270574, "EEM": 0.0004915463603084418, "IEF": -0.0023958870999847143, "TLT": -0.00016949216709225348, "GLD": 0.03822250303010444, "SHY": -0.00021894646379974126 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00257972514518495, "active_linking_residual": -1.9416759866608402e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0927091789645123, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.05598771030156824, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5970358828367511, "IWM": 0.13457036225142952, "EFA": 0.10212099580143252, "EEM": 0.033052754524045186, "IEF": -0.026132006017490064, "TLT": -0.010509448500745507, "GLD": 0.2658175244818071, "SHY": -0.0018287049782158681 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.0054788838548246455, "IWM": 0.0002444690502757252, "EFA": -0.005614333206978919, "EEM": 0.0018124911050300153, "IEF": -0.0071483930240497096, "TLT": 0.004259450008289459, "GLD": 0.058525981119252224, "SHY": -0.0001526571705697023 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0014181814345258653, "active_linking_residual": -2.0372592501871623e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 0.873683863431727, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.16303760523121702, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6239041085022123, "IWM": 0.15241743111969297, "EFA": 0.10738124957952402, "EEM": 0.0333677752637697, "IEF": -0.02401167305694712, "TLT": -0.016361135962789992, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": -0.002167103455533283 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.032347109520285855, "IWM": 0.01809153791853918, "EFA": -0.00035407942888741883, "EEM": 0.0021275118447545323, "IEF": -0.005028060063506767, "TLT": -0.0015922374537550264, "GLD": -0.2056725433625549, "SHY": -0.0004910556478871172 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002465788558221965, "active_linking_residual": -1.659783421814609e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 0.7464935342277106, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.2902279344352334, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5150164479582707, "IWM": 0.12358422536174295, "EFA": 0.10513597812299899, "EEM": 0.04168324716611464, "IEF": -0.019900164714108298, "TLT": -0.014499898801140472, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": -0.003135679294082044 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.07654055102365576, "IWM": -0.010741667839410843, "EFA": -0.002599350885412452, "EEM": 0.010442983747099472, "IEF": -0.0009165517206679435, "TLT": 0.0002689997078944937, "GLD": -0.2056725433625549, "SHY": -0.0014596314864358782 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0030096215721030915, "active_linking_residual": -1.3489209749195652e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 0.9007484973700313, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.13597297129291275, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6828874153091605, "IWM": 0.1275569240086687, "EFA": 0.0955367495270834, "EEM": 0.03821984900765726, "IEF": -0.02253951212643885, "TLT": -0.02077781853626072, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": -0.0004728794514787563 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.09133041632723404, "IWM": -0.006768969192485097, "EFA": -0.012198579481328048, "EEM": 0.006979585588642086, "IEF": -0.0035558991329984954, "TLT": -0.006008920027225754, "GLD": -0.2056725433625549, "SHY": 0.0012031683561674095 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012812303683814444, "active_linking_residual": -1.7430501486614958e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0802967743328011, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.04357530566985712, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6048687162262114, "IWM": 0.14965623770523648, "EFA": 0.10862251432862506, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.023043083275494793, "TLT": -0.016222636639581366, "GLD": 0.262965395039162, "SHY": -0.00201428838369349 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.013311717244284926, "IWM": 0.015330344504082688, "EFA": 0.0008871853202136182, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": -0.004059470282054438, "TLT": -0.0014537381305463996, "GLD": 0.0556738516766071, "SHY": -0.0003382405760473243 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026159806676856368, "active_linking_residual": -1.7756629500098597e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0893482026560055, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.0526267339930615, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5927566632291423, "IWM": 0.14407061447763317, "EFA": 0.12603850199301192, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.01934957486974752, "TLT": -0.016278450408987045, "GLD": 0.26929951304443545, "SHY": -0.0025472391493666347 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.001199664247215848, "IWM": 0.009744721276479379, "EFA": 0.018303172984600477, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": -0.0003659618763071637, "TLT": -0.0015095518999520795, "GLD": 0.06200796968188055, "SHY": -0.0008711913417204689 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002721725660132361, "active_linking_residual": -1.2490009027033011e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.241597915373799, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.20487644671085503, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7087053998468429, "IWM": 0.14519010968389753, "EFA": 0.11082022210586506, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.03483313171149589, "TLT": -0.00895215080748278, "GLD": 0.32538877901865815, "SHY": -0.0015100383988652442 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.1171484008649164, "IWM": 0.010864216482743744, "EFA": 0.00308489309745362, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": -0.01584951871805554, "TLT": 0.005816747701552187, "GLD": 0.11809723565610325, "SHY": 0.0001660094087809216 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012911743636358302, "active_linking_residual": -1.1435297153639112e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.1239869746128974, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.08726550594995341, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5994615546130009, "IWM": 0.14750554999633128, "EFA": 0.10742580314272143, "EEM": 0.03382687310325639, "IEF": -0.022358147664851093, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.26246778527825076, "SHY": -0.0019544781406627748 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.007904555631074395, "IWM": 0.013179656795177491, "EFA": -0.0003095258656900107, "EEM": 0.0025866096842412194, "IEF": -0.003374534671410738, "TLT": 0.014921048509034966, "GLD": 0.05517624191569587, "SHY": -0.00027843033301660895 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002540115715171641, "active_linking_residual": -1.8471335572201042e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0409508485374768, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.004229379874532757, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5569599881375098, "IWM": 0.14237210801828312, "EFA": 0.09968998830520769, "EEM": 0.031857820613248974, "IEF": -0.02619324514985401, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.24108968333001005, "SHY": -0.002241863938796902 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.03459701084441669, "IWM": 0.008046214817129332, "EFA": -0.008045340703203757, "EEM": 0.0006175571942338039, "IEF": -0.007209632156413657, "TLT": 0.014921048509034966, "GLD": 0.03379813996745515, "SHY": -0.0005658161311507361 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002735780778149484, "active_linking_residual": -1.3824011380059176e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.1324490197127566, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.09572755104981256, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6282921652329043, "IWM": 0.14631332132162703, "EFA": 0.0795633658189353, "EEM": 0.033159355895024084, "IEF": -0.03306866368600663, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.28025357071280177, "SHY": -0.0009430794988605611 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.036735166250977835, "IWM": 0.011987428120473237, "EFA": -0.028171963189476137, "EEM": 0.0019190924760089136, "IEF": -0.014085050692566277, "TLT": 0.014921048509034966, "GLD": 0.07296202735024687, "SHY": 0.0007329683087856047 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012731660836868784, "active_linking_residual": -1.4432899320127035e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 0.9679799884964246, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.06874148016651938, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5259692872771621, "IWM": 0.13079192115204477, "EFA": 0.0933695089215322, "EEM": 0.02937388213323148, "IEF": -0.018933128816909627, "TLT": -0.01322160111005688, "GLD": 0.22688228143650438, "SHY": -0.0036870436464118504 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.0655877117047644, "IWM": -0.0035339720491090187, "EFA": -0.014365820086879241, "EEM": -0.0018663812857836921, "IEF": 5.048417653072748e-05, "TLT": 0.0015472973989780862, "GLD": 0.019590738073949482, "SHY": -0.0020109958387656843 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002565118850661321, "active_linking_residual": 1.4307999229856705e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0253493496437733, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.011372119019170679, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5525968382130221, "IWM": 0.14098466942137033, "EFA": 0.10112589544758094, "EEM": 0.02957410846593155, "IEF": -0.01649913905822058, "TLT": -0.016612616293284182, "GLD": 0.24054871456373245, "SHY": -0.0037569847346605512 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.038960160768904406, "IWM": 0.006658776220216545, "EFA": -0.006609433560830505, "EEM": -0.001666154953083622, "IEF": 0.002484473935219774, "TLT": -0.0018437177842492158, "GLD": 0.03325717120117755, "SHY": -0.0020809369270143856 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002612136381724718, "active_linking_residual": -2.2305074454109786e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.1168811390302666, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.08015967036732263, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6171289042545334, "IWM": 0.13882532883514836, "EFA": 0.09166277788634267, "EEM": 0.030299458506126527, "IEF": -0.018793807197227543, "TLT": -0.01666613564063954, "GLD": 0.27966576205622523, "SHY": -0.003959150466744295 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.025571905272606887, "IWM": 0.004499435633994575, "EFA": -0.016072551122068776, "EEM": -0.0009408049128886431, "IEF": 0.00018980579621281218, "TLT": -0.001897237131604574, "GLD": 0.07237421869367033, "SHY": -0.002283102659098129 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012819992035222518, "active_linking_residual": -2.040034807748725e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 0.8230750144980674, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.2136464541648766, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.448751599362193, "IWM": 0.11243620715798458, "EFA": 0.0792867009810292, "EEM": 0.024871672410291906, "IEF": -0.01454813527988051, "TLT": -0.01014817030354049, "GLD": 0.1918434591505134, "SHY": -0.006906181851970765 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.1428053996197335, "IWM": -0.02188968604316921, "EFA": -0.02844862802738224, "EEM": -0.006368591008723265, "IEF": 0.004435477713559845, "TLT": 0.004620728205494477, "GLD": -0.015448084212041496, "SHY": -0.005230134044324599 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002512137128590076, "active_linking_residual": -3.347322419244847e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 0.9879410798138633, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.04878038884908076, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5251785119065912, "IWM": 0.142181316398316, "EFA": 0.10176047823232295, "EEM": 0.02534794412596662, "IEF": -0.007413992744063871, "TLT": -0.019634419677730264, "GLD": 0.23071952103774226, "SHY": -0.007313313369932009 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.06637848707533534, "IWM": 0.007855423197162203, "EFA": -0.005974850776088489, "EEM": -0.005892319293048551, "IEF": 0.011569620249376484, "TLT": -0.0048655211686952984, "GLD": 0.023427977675187367, "SHY": -0.005637265562285843 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002884966095369672, "active_linking_residual": -1.637578961322106e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0667874832611348, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.030066014598190804, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6137415074935103, "IWM": 0.14240329994559459, "EFA": 0.07339797564286328, "EEM": 0.026128478745526176, "IEF": -0.0007657336510468177, "TLT": -0.02845528451439855, "GLD": 0.24924731413797635, "SHY": -0.007526533776141176 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.022184508511583823, "IWM": 0.008077406744440796, "EFA": -0.03433735336554816, "EEM": -0.005111784673488995, "IEF": 0.018217879342393536, "TLT": -0.013686386005363583, "GLD": 0.04195577077542145, "SHY": -0.00585048596849501 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013835407627684278, "active_linking_residual": -1.536964999715451e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2288248928265455, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.1921034241636015, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7967017311536756, "IWM": 0.12486877069144016, "EFA": 0.09180099912154659, "EEM": 0.028534979137217573, "IEF": -0.020573588567438697, "TLT": -0.014747210456593399, "GLD": 0.22644509759095016, "SHY": -0.0017114993529192039 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.2051447321717491, "IWM": -0.00945712250971363, "EFA": -0.015934329886864856, "EEM": -0.002705284281797598, "IEF": -0.0015899755739983423, "TLT": 2.1688052441567324e-05, "GLD": 0.019153554228395264, "SHY": -3.545154527303802e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0024943864913779083, "active_linking_residual": -4.091171845743702e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2280516519734728, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.19133018331052876, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7987451580802144, "IWM": 0.08576405310008715, "EFA": 0.08167808031190434, "EEM": 0.028539864876696058, "IEF": -0.018550148071137317, "TLT": -0.024306295469690122, "GLD": 0.2812864661235022, "SHY": -0.0023739917711207517 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.20718815909828792, "IWM": -0.048561840101066636, "EFA": -0.026057248696507107, "EEM": -0.002700398542319113, "IEF": 0.0004334649223030375, "TLT": -0.009537396960655156, "GLD": 0.07399492276094732, "SHY": -0.0006979439634745858 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002731535206999618, "active_linking_residual": -1.2684298056342413e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2895171981524545, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.25279572948951046, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8280732644827736, "IWM": 0.09709045578735892, "EFA": 0.05312186617243711, "EEM": 0.028896828280062088, "IEF": -0.03254232738077865, "TLT": -0.011209002959434208, "GLD": 0.32823967730589176, "SHY": -0.0009337245027781563 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.23651626550084714, "IWM": -0.03723543741379487, "EFA": -0.05461346283597433, "EEM": -0.002343435138953083, "IEF": -0.013558714387338293, "TLT": 0.0035598955496007577, "GLD": 0.12094813394333687, "SHY": 0.0007423233048680096 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.001219839033098505, "active_linking_residual": -1.6764367671839864e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0821327430973464, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.045411274434402404, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5048796932353009, "IWM": 0.2785489811216482, "EFA": 0.0890499059281428, "EEM": 0.027351837304028653, "IEF": -0.019910838358451373, "TLT": -0.013786378135785152, "GLD": 0.220416603258753, "SHY": -0.0017294279215316205 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.08667730574662558, "IWM": 0.14422308792049443, "EFA": -0.018685423080268646, "EEM": -0.0038884261149865172, "IEF": -0.0009272253650110182, "TLT": 0.0009825203732498136, "GLD": 0.01312505989619811, "SHY": -5.3380113885454676e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00268763333478253, "active_linking_residual": -1.9796664307847323e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 0.9747521708273772, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.06196929783556682, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.40163594924879836, "IWM": 0.2722886635944038, "EFA": 0.0643671758944452, "EEM": 0.026954706875651834, "IEF": -0.022631011670069836, "TLT": -0.010337294065725294, "GLD": 0.2477196677354686, "SHY": -0.0022269562812121876 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.18992104973312812, "IWM": 0.13796277039325, "EFA": -0.043368153113966246, "EEM": -0.004285556543363336, "IEF": -0.0036473986766294812, "TLT": 0.004431604443309672, "GLD": 0.04042812437291371, "SHY": -0.0005509084735660218 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.003018730504402243, "active_linking_residual": -1.5251688800788088e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.1653369291062496, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.12861546044330563, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5398491584948256, "IWM": 0.2912230942065753, "EFA": 0.03905848553225896, "EEM": 0.025294696721197874, "IEF": -0.03470274558406887, "TLT": -0.007858840434274976, "GLD": 0.31406959333067996, "SHY": 0.00019632918758013325 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.051707840487100865, "IWM": 0.15689720100542148, "EFA": -0.06867684347615248, "EEM": -0.005945566697817296, "IEF": -0.015719132590628515, "TLT": 0.00691005807475999, "GLD": 0.10677804996812507, "SHY": 0.0018723769952262992 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00179284234854666, "active_linking_residual": -1.8596235662471372e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 0.9079634645419428, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.12875800412100125, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.35875117868300926, "IWM": 0.1624098090374842, "EFA": 0.11428338092207942, "EEM": 0.036463560246386265, "IEF": -0.019083191823648555, "TLT": -0.015670650786169846, "GLD": 0.2756232189103167, "SHY": -0.002159950335008387 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.23280582029891722, "IWM": 0.02808391583633041, "EFA": 0.006548051913667974, "EEM": 0.005223296827371094, "IEF": -9.957883020820027e-05, "TLT": -0.0009017522771348797, "GLD": 0.06833167554776182, "SHY": -0.000483902527362221 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026538903125349037, "active_linking_residual": -2.4868995751603507e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 0.8766580997517031, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.16006336891124096, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3565669647423358, "IWM": 0.1891963199599923, "EFA": 0.11677548835283152, "EEM": 0.03439920527401773, "IEF": -0.02083424311816266, "TLT": -0.008429667393433362, "GLD": 0.2137124187940069, "SHY": -0.001979026833590962 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.2349900342395907, "IWM": 0.05487042675883852, "EFA": 0.009040159344420082, "EEM": 0.0031589418550025568, "IEF": -0.0018506301247223043, "TLT": 0.006339231115601604, "GLD": 0.0064208754314520056, "SHY": -0.0003029790259447961 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002749360026310408, "active_linking_residual": -1.2490009027033011e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 0.955758982588852, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08096248607409207, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3546710775965652, "IWM": 0.2051870147808393, "EFA": 0.11017753592990907, "EEM": 0.035783577495404416, "IEF": -0.018545771406502636, "TLT": -0.006863858435119853, "GLD": 0.27950647396631134, "SHY": -0.00285656389299976 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.2368859213853613, "IWM": 0.07086112157968552, "EFA": 0.0024422069214976305, "EEM": 0.004543314076389245, "IEF": 0.0004378415869377185, "TLT": 0.007905040073915112, "GLD": 0.07221493060375644, "SHY": -0.0011805160853535941 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013005034455735955, "active_linking_residual": -1.4752088439706768e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.0418124386017147, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.005090969938770673, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6519717812083092, "IWM": 0.1634930215268142, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.02414967808859648, "TLT": -0.016912099009508304, "GLD": 0.2795661983673561, "SHY": -0.005753408231114103 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.060414782226382746, "IWM": 0.029167128325660402, "EFA": -0.10950152900841144, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": -0.005166065095156127, "TLT": -0.0021432005004733377, "GLD": 0.07227465500480118, "SHY": -0.004077360423467937 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002717077171568892, "active_linking_residual": -1.9251093774652617e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3955744866007724, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.3588530179378284, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8407776088313822, "IWM": 0.2296712960170872, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.029551385086893207, "TLT": -0.01744610662357547, "GLD": 0.38531643738215593, "SHY": -0.0063028491448829235 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.2492206098494557, "IWM": 0.0953454028159334, "EFA": -0.10950152900841144, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": -0.010567772093452853, "TLT": -0.0026772081145405024, "GLD": 0.17802489401960103, "SHY": -0.0046268013372367574 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0032042147745298885, "active_linking_residual": -2.4868995751603507e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3679657176088873, "benchmark_total_return": 1.036721468662944, "active_total_return_difference": 0.3312442489459433, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9299761198402965, "IWM": 0.1634606563823975, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": -0.0037792691718073, "TLT": -0.04560817457791432, "GLD": 0.33512944518057103, "SHY": -0.006366361344631264 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5915569989819265, "IWM": 0.1343258932011538, "EFA": 0.10773532900841144, "EEM": 0.03124026341901517, "IEF": -0.018983612993440355, "TLT": -0.014768898509034966, "GLD": 0.2072915433625549, "SHY": -0.0016760478076461658 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.33841912085837, "IWM": 0.029134763181243722, "EFA": -0.10950152900841144, "EEM": -0.03316036341901517, "IEF": 0.015204343821633055, "TLT": -0.030839276068879356, "GLD": 0.12783790181801613, "SHY": -0.004690313536985098 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0011603987000471925, "active_linking_residual": -1.8596235662471372e-14 } ], "path_metrics": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2044075.543038562, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.7251450238364, "net_cagr_pct": 6.151512358482725, "net_volatility_pct": 10.096774339014315, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.8335700766922, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.240082764740638, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6240082764740642, "gross_tracking_error": 0.003518494097706619, "net_tracking_error": 0.0035212871201349303, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2044075.5429774695, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.72514518495, "net_cagr_pct": 6.1515123582178255, "net_volatility_pct": 10.09677433858588, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.833570076469567, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.24008276562615, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6240082765626147, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0035184940988915742, "net_tracking_error": 0.0035212871213092856, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2092709.1789645124, "total_cost_dollars": 1418.1814345258654, "net_cagr_pct": 6.36013321690394, "net_volatility_pct": 10.108009396821089, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.761791472474123, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.827569691400525, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8827569691400526, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0049515327730889685, "net_tracking_error": 0.004951352096189157, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 1873683.863431727, "total_cost_dollars": 2465.788558221965, "net_cagr_pct": 5.38283345106767, "net_volatility_pct": 10.97741888831209, "max_drawdown_pct": -24.436244879234227, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.750669261079631, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5750669261079628, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0170614548518917, "net_tracking_error": 0.017066491080687387, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 1746493.5342277107, "total_cost_dollars": 3009.6215721030917, "net_cagr_pct": 4.766081914130682, "net_volatility_pct": 10.051611462358265, "max_drawdown_pct": -24.037663694373013, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 20.170013086678125, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 2.0170013086678127, "gross_tracking_error": 0.013998374833650686, "net_tracking_error": 0.014005799156846905, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 1900748.4973700312, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.2303683814444, "net_cagr_pct": 5.509103160823714, "net_volatility_pct": 10.228967460681897, "max_drawdown_pct": -24.707900346420786, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.040137680777343, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8040137680777343, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01638089270611976, "net_tracking_error": 0.016382871306944977, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2080296.7743328013, "total_cost_dollars": 2615.980667685637, "net_cagr_pct": 6.307314175391077, "net_volatility_pct": 9.80097871137247, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.274814477835502, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.32576389061774, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6325763890617737, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008587344118171443, "net_tracking_error": 0.008589482325920767, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2089348.2026560055, "total_cost_dollars": 2721.725660132361, "net_cagr_pct": 6.345859516146879, "net_volatility_pct": 10.121539887250327, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.565760741178707, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.003722869946746, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.7003722869946742, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006664832572009646, "net_tracking_error": 0.006667878730624818, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2241597.915373799, "total_cost_dollars": 1291.17436363583, "net_cagr_pct": 6.972272174837557, "net_volatility_pct": 10.209390797685504, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.644756471338546, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.695284097843934, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7695284097843934, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009433655277058393, "net_tracking_error": 0.009433024887286591, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2123986.9746128973, "total_cost_dollars": 2540.115715171641, "net_cagr_pct": 6.491968297055961, "net_volatility_pct": 10.61705407575123, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.25676700519973, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.982635209240414, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5982635209240412, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008264961901834032, "net_tracking_error": 0.008266352379079798, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2040950.848537477, "total_cost_dollars": 2735.780778149484, "net_cagr_pct": 6.137953518658734, "net_volatility_pct": 10.049179042319038, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.231231692048947, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.540532701839588, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.754053270183959, "gross_tracking_error": 0.004842579918194034, "net_tracking_error": 0.004846522706379029, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 62, "interim_drift_days": 59, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.000487446034335709 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2132449.0197127564, "total_cost_dollars": 1273.1660836868784, "net_cagr_pct": 6.527329745938459, "net_volatility_pct": 9.962191578353771, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.96014375282016, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.978604281369078, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7978604281369077, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007831095016714461, "net_tracking_error": 0.007830503783437295, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 1967979.9884964246, "total_cost_dollars": 2565.1188506613207, "net_cagr_pct": 5.815779205676641, "net_volatility_pct": 9.536667513104167, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.920626605215798, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.452575029505244, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6452575029505243, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008103443351565683, "net_tracking_error": 0.00810567658191297, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 152, "interim_drift_days": 152, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.00676556778353514 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2025349.3496437734, "total_cost_dollars": 2612.136381724718, "net_cagr_pct": 6.069968706544193, "net_volatility_pct": 9.986517542707839, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.31149617623247, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.530112482622027, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6530112482622026, "gross_tracking_error": 0.00401806837318153, "net_tracking_error": 0.004021130513629423, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 158, "interim_drift_days": 158, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.007192124781266004 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2116881.1390302666, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.9992035222517, "net_cagr_pct": 6.462174339848392, "net_volatility_pct": 10.002052104745225, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.329149114947246, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.939266831579538, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7939266831579537, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006313508616519674, "net_tracking_error": 0.006312411492768867, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 87, "interim_drift_days": 87, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0037649471763683967 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 1823075.0144980673, "total_cost_dollars": 2512.137128590076, "net_cagr_pct": 5.142166054492692, "net_volatility_pct": 8.431971853694751, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.093884730515697, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.718859615403414, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6718859615403419, "gross_tracking_error": 0.019001704102453134, "net_tracking_error": 0.019003580824884993, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 151, "interim_drift_days": 151, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.012048315214879951 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 1987941.0798138632, "total_cost_dollars": 2884.966095369672, "net_cagr_pct": 5.904983359698934, "net_volatility_pct": 9.773651838798772, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.283290701512392, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.580273430109735, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8580273430109735, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006619976989414559, "net_tracking_error": 0.006622731796256146, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 612, "interim_drift_days": 591, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.014624710829047927 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2066787.483261135, "total_cost_dollars": 1383.5407627684278, "net_cagr_pct": 6.249498239601836, "net_volatility_pct": 9.575238253253621, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.92653770325962, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.73985635996846, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8739856359968459, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01019345879084824, "net_tracking_error": 0.010193049381502438, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 135, "interim_drift_days": 135, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01479822796503441 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2228824.8928265455, "total_cost_dollars": 2494.3864913779084, "net_cagr_pct": 6.921242221199964, "net_volatility_pct": 10.942052126506713, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.924289507393702, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.929574020056819, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4929574020056822, "gross_tracking_error": 0.010320894154150023, "net_tracking_error": 0.010322749752828419, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2551, "interim_drift_days": 2414, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.056532615300620925 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2228051.651973473, "total_cost_dollars": 2731.5352069996184, "net_cagr_pct": 6.91814442247487, "net_volatility_pct": 10.230152164768358, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.43124069488278, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.30942930373628, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6309429303736283, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0073318215693701245, "net_tracking_error": 0.007332595132623775, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2491, "interim_drift_days": 2358, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.06357500174959524 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2289517.1981524546, "total_cost_dollars": 1219.839033098505, "net_cagr_pct": 7.161370421746449, "net_volatility_pct": 10.298360586663344, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.82667313396567, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.173659926127658, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7173659926127658, "gross_tracking_error": 0.010262997337880239, "net_tracking_error": 0.01026200161483776, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1271, "interim_drift_days": 1200, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.06737953641276478 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2082132.7430973463, "total_cost_dollars": 2687.63333478253, "net_cagr_pct": 6.315145024682178, "net_volatility_pct": 11.183145357615395, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.761958837902164, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.721657258855053, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6721657258855056, "gross_tracking_error": 0.014721698990556592, "net_tracking_error": 0.014723833023831035, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 652, "interim_drift_days": 652, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.033858733979578254 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 1974752.1708273771, "total_cost_dollars": 3018.730504402243, "net_cagr_pct": 5.846135993698676, "net_volatility_pct": 10.373019465599056, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.966631203971353, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 19.416076341643496, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.9416076341643491, "gross_tracking_error": 0.011975381274716387, "net_tracking_error": 0.011978674903574581, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 785, "interim_drift_days": 785, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.03699179411369782 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2165336.9291062495, "total_cost_dollars": 1792.84234854666, "net_cagr_pct": 6.663552556392616, "net_volatility_pct": 10.600806769663382, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.406132828388472, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 10.758492813328866, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.0758492813328868, "gross_tracking_error": 0.014428676755687632, "net_tracking_error": 0.014429482501939867, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 592, "interim_drift_days": 592, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.037883103970149296 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 1907963.4645419428, "total_cost_dollars": 2653.890312534904, "net_cagr_pct": 5.542486261936341, "net_volatility_pct": 9.640157699581165, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.96512906916538, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.51501524627308, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.7515015246273085, "gross_tracking_error": 0.012883072735254415, "net_tracking_error": 0.01288284873733464, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2165, "interim_drift_days": 2082, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.039634385184032145 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 1876658.099751703, "total_cost_dollars": 2749.360026310408, "net_cagr_pct": 5.396791175696802, "net_volatility_pct": 10.015649019662055, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.208569835839853, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.123371451493195, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8123371451493193, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008809022811904814, "net_tracking_error": 0.008811262986738764, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1689, "interim_drift_days": 1629, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.03859898187921612 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 1955758.982588852, "total_cost_dollars": 1300.5034455735956, "net_cagr_pct": 5.760754586706485, "net_volatility_pct": 10.019870532289001, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.491333414543114, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.576442355030595, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8576442355030597, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01190799498312196, "net_tracking_error": 0.011907897724663193, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 264, "interim_drift_days": 262, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01088659397529329 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2041812.4386017146, "total_cost_dollars": 2717.077171568892, "net_cagr_pct": 6.141694074572368, "net_volatility_pct": 8.160593989875517, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.26129763646077, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.878932025393016, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6878932025393023, "gross_tracking_error": 0.028768610615325478, "net_tracking_error": 0.028769904836573695, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 156, "interim_drift_days": 156, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01021662616465907 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2395574.4866007725, "total_cost_dollars": 3204.2147745298885, "net_cagr_pct": 7.567315686575737, "net_volatility_pct": 9.829059930701195, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.950919061333217, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.448809259588213, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8448809259588212, "gross_tracking_error": 0.018334221539078644, "net_tracking_error": 0.01833499107662315, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 204, "interim_drift_days": 204, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.013328389208623198 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2367965.7176088872, "total_cost_dollars": 1160.3987000471925, "net_cagr_pct": 7.463250961378409, "net_volatility_pct": 10.078478646119567, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.649303503687232, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.72499000978179, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.672499000978179, "gross_tracking_error": 0.019308359610275463, "net_tracking_error": 0.01930872036641529, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 55, "interim_drift_days": 55, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0030024134651664425 } ], "linking_method": "Initial-capital-scaled realized dollar P&L; sum asset gains/V0 plus negative costs/V0 equals cumulative portfolio return. Subtract analogous benchmark contributions for exact cumulative wealth-return difference. Not Brinson, factor attribution, or a separate cost-free portfolio." }, "blockers": [ "risk_shrinkage_reconciliation", "risk_te_reconciliation", "risk_te_budget", "risk_minimum_reference", "risk_budget_definition", "benchmark_nav_reconstruction", "benchmark_return_reconstruction", "trade_preholdings_reconstruction", "trade_postholdings_reconstruction", "posttrade_decision_weights", "posttrade_constraints", "reconstructed_positive_nav", "daily_cost_fraction", "daily_traded_fraction", "daily_nav_reconstruction", "daily_gross_reconciliation", "daily_net_reconciliation", "daily_benchmark_reconciliation", "daily_gross_active_reconciliation", "daily_net_active_reconciliation", "daily_drift_reconciliation" ], "corrected_retest": "PASS", "closure": "CLOSED_TEST_CASE" }, { "id": "INC-002", "title": "Duplicate trade record", "classification": "DELIBERATELY INJECTED TEST CASE", "severity": "BLOCK", "expected_status": "BLOCK", "observed_status": "BLOCK", "detected": true, "expected_domain_checks_any": [ "unique_keys_trades" ], "expected_domain_failure_observed": true, "injection": "Duplicated exactly one trade-key row in an in-memory copy.", "root_cause": "Join cardinality / ingestion", "corrective_action": "Reject duplicate natural keys before aggregation; identify upstream duplication and reload a unique snapshot.", "suggested_operational_owner": "Trade data operations", "acceptance_criterion": "One (date, client, method, ticker) key must identify one trade row.", "failed_checks": [ { "id": "unique_keys_trades", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34561, "max_abs_error": 1.0, "tolerance": 0.0, "detail": "" } ], "aggregate_impact": { "returns_rows": 32192, "calendar_rows": 4024, "daily_rows": 90540, "decisions_rows": 4320, "trades_rows": 34561, "benchmark_rows": 3018 }, "blockers": [ "unique_keys_trades" ], "corrected_retest": "PASS", "closure": "CLOSED_TEST_CASE" }, { "id": "INC-003", "title": "Same-day decision timestamp", "classification": "DELIBERATELY INJECTED TEST CASE", "severity": "BLOCK", "expected_status": "BLOCK", "observed_status": "BLOCK", "detected": true, "expected_domain_checks_any": [ "decision_chronology", "decision_risk_window" ], "expected_domain_failure_observed": true, "injection": "Changed one signal date to equal its execution date.", "root_cause": "Decision clock", "corrective_action": "Require the decision to reference the previous close and a strictly earlier complete risk window.", "suggested_operational_owner": "Quant research", "acceptance_criterion": "Signal date must be earlier than execution and match the declared previous-close clock.", "failed_checks": [ { "id": "decision_chronology", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 1.0, "tolerance": 0.0, "detail": "" }, { "id": "decision_risk_window", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 1.0, "tolerance": 0.0, "detail": "Exactly the declared trailing observations, ending strictly before execution." }, { "id": "trade_chronology", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 1.0, "tolerance": 0.0, "detail": "" } ], "aggregate_impact": { "returns_rows": 32192, "calendar_rows": 4024, "daily_rows": 90540, "decisions_rows": 4320, "trades_rows": 34560, "benchmark_rows": 3018, "paths": 30, "evaluation_dates": 3018, "execution_dates": 144, "source_dates": 4024, "assets": 8, "attribution_totals": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5345275118889457, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692457139111, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7641902269912244, "IWM": 0.17603068061438792, "EFA": 0.2138321129739271, "EEM": 0.05882650428732878, "IEF": 0.05784482574990592, "TLT": 0.005765120983103948, "GLD": 0.24551404640093763, "SHY": 0.015103719033138105 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.0026459779731509148, "IWM": -0.0009314152257186847, "EFA": 0.000363491383806841, "EEM": -0.0001463258383000779, "IEF": -0.0004900142349845843, "TLT": 1.485544749728774e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927024618911, "SHY": -3.578816881809853e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0025797251450238364, "active_linking_residual": -1.484836559262348e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.534527511788152, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692557932706, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.764190226933492, "IWM": 0.1760306806128757, "EFA": 0.21383211298696567, "EEM": 0.05882650428420453, "IEF": 0.0578448253366722, "TLT": 0.005765121235137153, "GLD": 0.24551404639265934, "SHY": 0.015103719151310474 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.002645978030883289, "IWM": -0.0009314152272309195, "EFA": 0.0003634913968454112, "EEM": -0.00014632584142432875, "IEF": -0.0004900146482183024, "TLT": 1.4855699530491942e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927107401858, "SHY": -3.578805064572907e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00257972514518495, "active_linking_residual": -1.9095836023552692e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5921669722544691, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.050579767908384365, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8144045603574873, "IWM": 0.16885394460746495, "EFA": 0.2106270468835373, "EEM": 0.05839846999577816, "IEF": 0.049535524876170065, "TLT": 0.012706955145351494, "GLD": 0.2658175244818071, "SHY": 0.013241127341377201 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.047568355393111994, "IWM": -0.008108151232641664, "EFA": -0.0028415747065829444, "EEM": -0.0005743601298506956, "IEF": -0.008799315108720437, "TLT": 0.006956689609744833, "GLD": 0.0196946853784076, "SHY": -0.0018983798605790025 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0014181814345258653, "active_linking_residual": -2.0546064849469303e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4215290136606908, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.12005819068539392, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8455829129898808, "IWM": 0.19233213384355213, "EFA": 0.23358805862626353, "EEM": 0.06361053583052598, "IEF": 0.06397713839265665, "TLT": 0.006613052376914119, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.016671970159102933 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.07874670802550543, "IWM": 0.015370038003445524, "EFA": 0.020119437036143273, "EEM": 0.004637705704897119, "IEF": 0.005642298407766144, "TLT": 0.0008627868413074585, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.00153246295714673 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002465788558221965, "active_linking_residual": -1.5890067039947553e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2572502943103285, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.28433691003575623, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6922020432422589, "IWM": 0.1581958559509042, "EFA": 0.22638093916140253, "EEM": 0.07670483082018123, "IEF": 0.08523305578520382, "TLT": 0.0029145542132029733, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.017009636709260274 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.07463416172211645, "IWM": -0.018766239889202396, "EFA": 0.012912317571282278, "EEM": 0.01773200069455237, "IEF": 0.02689821580031332, "TLT": -0.0028357113224036874, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.0018701295073040702 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0030096215721030915, "active_linking_residual": -1.687538997430238e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.460093160110683, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08149404423540174, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9425559611719156, "IWM": 0.15987030825541926, "EFA": 0.18582614979025203, "EEM": 0.06983484469301109, "IEF": 0.07103776971679376, "TLT": 0.010873237559768514, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.019757119291886848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.17571975620754032, "IWM": -0.01709178758468735, "EFA": -0.02764247179986823, "EEM": 0.010862014567382228, "IEF": 0.012702929731903262, "TLT": 0.005122972024161853, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.004617612089930645 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012812303683814444, "active_linking_residual": -1.650068970349139e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5732576341082627, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.03167042976217793, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8147891704055653, "IWM": 0.1876247735106619, "EFA": 0.2289653343326435, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.061446890895422296, "TLT": 0.005858322343224703, "GLD": 0.262965395039162, "SHY": 0.016143828249244083 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04795296544118999, "IWM": 0.010662677670555287, "EFA": 0.015496712742523233, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.003112050910531794, "TLT": 0.00010805680761804236, "GLD": 0.016842555935762477, "SHY": 0.0010043210472878792 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026159806676856368, "active_linking_residual": -2.373101715136272e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5961483736569573, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.054561169310872515, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8025305247508785, "IWM": 0.1810177905508809, "EFA": 0.2684612642706993, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.05867850934438678, "TLT": 0.0056456688906171525, "GLD": 0.26929951304443545, "SHY": 0.01515692846517483 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.03569431978650317, "IWM": 0.004055694710774299, "EFA": 0.05499264268057902, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.0003436693594962778, "TLT": -0.00010459664498950819, "GLD": 0.023176673941035925, "SHY": 1.7421263218625818e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002721725660132361, "active_linking_residual": -1.5931700403370996e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7642946875762084, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22270748323012368, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9707276302031296, "IWM": 0.18006394179100876, "EFA": 0.22436142087997057, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.03411989559731103, "TLT": 0.018993377312367825, "GLD": 0.32538877901865815, "SHY": 0.013850917137383114 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.20389142523875425, "IWM": 0.0031018459509021545, "EFA": 0.010892799289850319, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.02421494438757947, "TLT": 0.013243111776761164, "GLD": 0.07926593991525863, "SHY": -0.0012885900645730891 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012911743636358302, "active_linking_residual": -1.4405143744511406e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6198144763898967, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.07822727204381197, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8071597501926342, "IWM": 0.1851179504856676, "EFA": 0.22691833652562673, "EEM": 0.06250678535165581, "IEF": 0.06186075124276445, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.26246778527825076, "SHY": 0.016171083028446352 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04032354522825887, "IWM": 0.008155854645560984, "EFA": 0.01344971493550648, "EEM": 0.0035339552260269524, "IEF": 0.003525911257873951, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.016344946174851244, "SHY": 0.0010315758264901487 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002540115715171641, "active_linking_residual": -2.1635471192382738e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5275737409279389, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.01401346341814591, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7519888008157273, "IWM": 0.1778048890165744, "EFA": 0.2098754733023783, "EEM": 0.05921600491888479, "IEF": 0.09002486461360458, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.24108968333001005, "SHY": 0.00015765570889323 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.014847404148648047, "IWM": 0.0008427931764677932, "EFA": -0.0035931482877419596, "EEM": 0.00024317479325593194, "IEF": 0.03169002462871408, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": -0.005033155773389475, "SHY": -0.014981851493062973 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002735780778149484, "active_linking_residual": -1.4885662147356982e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6223508209242237, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.08076361657813891, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8582207668145045, "IWM": 0.180099158295092, "EFA": 0.16320323366715445, "EEM": 0.05965791666702852, "IEF": 0.0723531067579814, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.28025357071280177, "SHY": 0.009684084093325962 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.09138456185012922, "IWM": 0.0031370624549853787, "EFA": -0.05026538792296581, "EEM": 0.0006850865413996626, "IEF": 0.014018266773090898, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.03413073160940225, "SHY": -0.005455423108630241 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012731660836868784, "active_linking_residual": -2.1094237467877974e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.442025432038852, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.09956177230723284, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7106349597757761, "IWM": 0.16405568131499804, "EFA": 0.19847142102083895, "EEM": 0.054540103241492305, "IEF": 0.054528187961549554, "TLT": 0.005970550683095518, "GLD": 0.22688228143650438, "SHY": 0.02950736545526939 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05620124518859926, "IWM": -0.012906414525108573, "EFA": -0.014997200569281305, "EEM": -0.004432726884136554, "IEF": -0.003806652023340948, "TLT": 0.00022028514748885768, "GLD": -0.01924055766689514, "SHY": 0.014367858253313185 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002565118850661321, "active_linking_residual": 1.1782241848834474e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5076518336335982, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.033935370712486534, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7450451773971472, "IWM": 0.17662909494127293, "EFA": 0.21230173096995175, "EEM": 0.056574723493955745, "IEF": 0.03839157139379364, "TLT": 0.010784204879437964, "GLD": 0.24054871456373245, "SHY": 0.029988752376006997 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.02179102756722817, "IWM": -0.0003330008988336741, "EFA": -0.0011668906201685036, "EEM": -0.0023981066316731137, "IEF": -0.01994326859109686, "TLT": 0.005033939343831303, "GLD": -0.005574124539667075, "SHY": 0.014849245174050793 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002612136381724718, "active_linking_residual": -2.348121697082206e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6108853528134701, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.06929814846738536, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8436647701625559, "IWM": 0.17267578562303154, "EFA": 0.18762362915019892, "EEM": 0.05576522526655487, "IEF": 0.026215563064086827, "TLT": 0.014871316801049384, "GLD": 0.27966576205622523, "SHY": 0.031685299893263734 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.0768285651981806, "IWM": -0.004286310217075068, "EFA": -0.025844992439921333, "EEM": -0.0032076048590739883, "IEF": -0.03211927692080367, "TLT": 0.009121051265442723, "GLD": 0.03354292295282571, "SHY": 0.01654579269130753 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012819992035222518, "active_linking_residual": -2.5104918144336352e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2648491831478208, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.27673802119826396, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6083601226028378, "IWM": 0.14104327951495169, "EFA": 0.16921729015604525, "EEM": 0.04637007689905751, "IEF": 0.04799081215741253, "TLT": 0.006181416784615747, "GLD": 0.1918434591505134, "SHY": 0.05635486301093857 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.15847608236153754, "IWM": -0.03591881632515492, "EFA": -0.044251331434075, "EEM": -0.012602753226571346, "IEF": -0.010344027827477974, "TLT": 0.0004311512490090862, "GLD": -0.05427937995288612, "SHY": 0.04121535580898236 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002512137128590076, "active_linking_residual": -3.752553823233029e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4540849607486255, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08750224359745928, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7073098731086407, "IWM": 0.17771833303603254, "EFA": 0.20920782303736576, "EEM": 0.05216229941332555, "IEF": -0.00016132601981592266, "TLT": 0.020844346415195815, "GLD": 0.23071952103774226, "SHY": 0.059169056815488126 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05952633185573464, "IWM": 0.0007562371959259351, "EFA": -0.004260798552754491, "EEM": -0.006810530712303309, "IEF": -0.058496166004706425, "TLT": 0.015094080879589154, "GLD": -0.015403318065657257, "SHY": 0.04402954961353192 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002884966095369672, "active_linking_residual": -1.9498291869979312e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5344696850721204, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007117519273964312, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.831827835088315, "IWM": 0.1763464628132381, "EFA": 0.14585647219952236, "EEM": 0.05159592118694526, "IEF": 0.020649788310524976, "TLT": -0.0004223338339035706, "GLD": 0.24924731413797635, "SHY": 0.06075176593224909 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.06499163012393971, "IWM": -0.0006156330268685117, "EFA": -0.0676121493905979, "EEM": -0.007376908938683598, "IEF": -0.037685051674365526, "TLT": -0.006172599369510231, "GLD": 0.003124475034576829, "SHY": 0.045612258730292884 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013835407627684278, "active_linking_residual": -2.0441981440910695e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7665153742002495, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22492816985416475, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0698561212707327, "IWM": 0.1568045102225823, "EFA": 0.19357560398060453, "EEM": 0.05301087111920712, "IEF": 0.05140076066612208, "TLT": 0.00407307410058057, "GLD": 0.22644509759095016, "SHY": 0.013843721740802523 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3030199163063574, "IWM": -0.020157585617524315, "EFA": -0.01989301760951573, "EEM": -0.005961959006421741, "IEF": -0.006934079318768424, "TLT": -0.0016771914350260904, "GLD": -0.01967774151244936, "SHY": -0.0012957854611536802 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0024943864913779083, "active_linking_residual": -4.465872116554692e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7534256654281943, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.21183846108210957, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0719244394155991, "IWM": 0.10840884857731314, "EFA": 0.17104337388553428, "EEM": 0.05237883375672182, "IEF": 0.06504039075317218, "TLT": -0.0014515314923506488, "GLD": 0.2812864661235022, "SHY": 0.007526379615688228 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3050882344512238, "IWM": -0.06855324726279347, "EFA": -0.04242524770458597, "EEM": -0.006593996368907042, "IEF": 0.006705550768281679, "TLT": -0.0072017970279573094, "GLD": 0.0351636270201027, "SHY": -0.007613127586267975 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002731535206999618, "active_linking_residual": -1.27675647831893e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.806257778669182, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.26467057432309726, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.112300853184688, "IWM": 0.12672210731296324, "EFA": 0.12249471065011537, "EEM": 0.05201407116893994, "IEF": 0.030957970657757357, "TLT": 0.021501607194395936, "GLD": 0.32823967730589176, "SHY": 0.013246620227510546 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.34546464822031275, "IWM": -0.05023998852714337, "EFA": -0.09097391094000488, "EEM": -0.006958758956688918, "IEF": -0.027376869327133145, "TLT": 0.015751341658789275, "GLD": 0.08211683820249224, "SHY": -0.0018928869744456577 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.001219839033098505, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5619017921712257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.02031458782514095, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6818561945206191, "IWM": 0.350528489013525, "EFA": 0.19049071040048163, "EEM": 0.05168886861900644, "IEF": 0.05124459812103912, "TLT": 0.004809791766598669, "GLD": 0.220416603258753, "SHY": 0.01355416980596361 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.08498001044375625, "IWM": 0.1735663931734184, "EFA": -0.022977911189638628, "EEM": -0.007283961506622416, "IEF": -0.007090241863851383, "TLT": -0.0009404737690079917, "GLD": -0.025706235844646513, "SHY": -0.0015853373959925938 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00268763333478253, "active_linking_residual": -2.085137618124122e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4147946780097134, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.1267925263363714, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5352437093500231, "IWM": 0.3421440984512125, "EFA": 0.1594561029675723, "EEM": 0.050618138944804325, "IEF": 0.055107409545375824, "TLT": 0.009554888144364235, "GLD": 0.2477196677354686, "SHY": 0.01796939337527965 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.23159249561435225, "IWM": 0.1651820026111059, "EFA": -0.05401251862254797, "EEM": -0.008354691180824533, "IEF": -0.003227430439514678, "TLT": 0.0038046226087575744, "GLD": 0.001596828632069086, "SHY": 0.002829886173323448 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.003018730504402243, "active_linking_residual": -1.4238610290817633e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6258732193304675, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.0842860149843827, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7331430653241838, "IWM": 0.36469442041694244, "EFA": 0.09994117445319692, "EEM": 0.04372906952164565, "IEF": 0.03639075038465191, "TLT": 0.01932943010570429, "GLD": 0.31406959333067996, "SHY": 0.016368558141986848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.033693139640191494, "IWM": 0.18773232457683584, "EFA": -0.11352744713692334, "EEM": -0.015243760603983206, "IEF": -0.021944089600238595, "TLT": 0.01357916457009763, "GLD": 0.06794675422728044, "SHY": 0.0012290509400306442 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00179284234854666, "active_linking_residual": -2.1468937738688965e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3551576995489225, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.18642950479716225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4861193321117492, "IWM": 0.2035602932023193, "EFA": 0.2439984794275416, "EEM": 0.06744930729539783, "IEF": 0.05609348177914334, "TLT": 0.007894828137706287, "GLD": 0.2756232189103167, "SHY": 0.017072648997255614 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.28071687285262614, "IWM": 0.026598197362212694, "EFA": 0.030529857837421348, "EEM": 0.008476477169768973, "IEF": -0.002241358205747161, "TLT": 0.0021445626020996263, "GLD": 0.029500379806917193, "SHY": 0.0019331417952994107 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026538903125349037, "active_linking_residual": -2.6728619317850644e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3327316929909525, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.20885551135513225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4837490516245933, "IWM": 0.23685338199297587, "EFA": 0.2510936537172181, "EEM": 0.0643991010258322, "IEF": 0.05300117426859076, "TLT": 0.010775725150410302, "GLD": 0.2137124187940069, "SHY": 0.02189654644361989 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.283087153339782, "IWM": 0.05989128615286926, "EFA": 0.037625032127097835, "EEM": 0.005426270900203339, "IEF": -0.005333665716299743, "TLT": 0.0050254596148036415, "GLD": -0.03241042030939262, "SHY": 0.006757039241663687 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002749360026310408, "active_linking_residual": -1.4765966227514582e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3971477411226063, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.14443946322347845, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48161496178994, "IWM": 0.261072142372408, "EFA": 0.2270395042779547, "EEM": 0.06988592082086303, "IEF": 0.03450083460267277, "TLT": 0.01822702333281722, "GLD": 0.27950647396631134, "SHY": 0.026601383405193146 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.2852212431744353, "IWM": 0.08411004653230139, "EFA": 0.013570882687834435, "EEM": 0.010913090695234176, "IEF": -0.023834005382217735, "TLT": 0.01247675779721056, "GLD": 0.03338363486291182, "SHY": 0.011461876203236942 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013005034455735955, "active_linking_residual": -1.887379141862766e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4736427513444257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.06794445300165908, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8782377521099625, "IWM": 0.20433129403518546, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.06593457657762311, "TLT": 0.006616170792757581, "GLD": 0.2795661983673561, "SHY": 0.0453601366330915 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.11140154714558714, "IWM": 0.027369198195078853, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.007599736592732609, "TLT": 0.0008659052571509205, "GLD": 0.03344335926395656, "SHY": 0.030220629431135293 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002717077171568892, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8864011382453598, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.34481393389927506, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.1526664820313828, "IWM": 0.2782339990169149, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.011414971378958515, "TLT": 0.015310350500598388, "GLD": 0.38531643738215593, "SHY": 0.05034941270985426 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.38583027706700745, "IWM": 0.10127190317680831, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.04691986860593199, "TLT": 0.009560084964991727, "GLD": 0.1391935982787564, "SHY": 0.03520990550789806 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0032042147745298885, "active_linking_residual": -2.403632848313464e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8552913075712572, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.3137041032251724, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.2481476443039528, "IWM": 0.2116089924038399, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.02687481813432769, "TLT": -0.013174583522867283, "GLD": 0.33512944518057103, "SHY": 0.051551689771457306 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48131143933957743, "IWM": 0.03464689656373329, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.03146002185056281, "TLT": -0.01892484905847394, "GLD": 0.08900660607717151, "SHY": 0.0364121825695011 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0011603987000471925, "active_linking_residual": -2.2093438190040615e-14 } ], "path_metrics": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2534527.5118889455, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.7251450238364, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937491648, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443398159633, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.91031816316077, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333293485576, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333293485575, "gross_tracking_error": 0.00029188046117938397, "net_tracking_error": 0.0003382763175867321, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2534527.511788152, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.72514518495, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937132758, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443397751147, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.910318163035914, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333294206085, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333294206085, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0002918804611750983, "net_tracking_error": 0.00033827631748173945, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2592166.972254469, "total_cost_dollars": 1418.1814345258654, "net_cagr_pct": 8.278055274888473, "net_volatility_pct": 10.264858474154753, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.876602669912316, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.018367322597046, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8018367322597045, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0026890174767739685, "net_tracking_error": 0.0026908769036650755, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2421529.0136606907, "total_cost_dollars": 2465.788558221965, "net_cagr_pct": 7.66414756994378, "net_volatility_pct": 11.053462182390206, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.206540599329273, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.154101348160564, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4154101348160564, "gross_tracking_error": 0.017483985426599607, "net_tracking_error": 0.017487934445408203, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2257250.2943103286, "total_cost_dollars": 3009.6215721030917, "net_cagr_pct": 7.0344434049465, "net_volatility_pct": 10.132089336625588, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.82845883787783, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.230981810244234, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8230981810244233, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01369081354202467, "net_tracking_error": 0.0136959883701921, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2460093.160110683, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.2303683814444, "net_cagr_pct": 7.806281417925365, "net_volatility_pct": 10.345465700937543, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.463680010108632, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.245279826304215, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7245279826304216, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01638991450996628, "net_tracking_error": 0.016391365221518187, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2573257.6341082626, "total_cost_dollars": 2615.980667685637, "net_cagr_pct": 8.211880687061246, "net_volatility_pct": 9.948335432185358, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.384058134449457, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.840482471257662, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.484048247125766, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006896540607515067, "net_tracking_error": 0.006899257312340247, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2596148.3736569574, "total_cost_dollars": 2721.725660132361, "net_cagr_pct": 8.291932072733822, "net_volatility_pct": 10.275986214436822, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.648477286948765, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.424441064683341, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5424441064683345, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005534356093023667, "net_tracking_error": 0.005538848615810009, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2764294.6875762083, "total_cost_dollars": 1291.17436363583, "net_cagr_pct": 8.860883173242584, "net_volatility_pct": 10.383790774240824, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.7641075295292, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.98526215985455, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6985262159854552, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008310308266614781, "net_tracking_error": 0.00831057071417959, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2619814.4763898966, "total_cost_dollars": 2540.115715171641, "net_cagr_pct": 8.37401771217805, "net_volatility_pct": 10.787777603851199, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.42023290327093, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.548727854344262, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4548727854344266, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009477283264071847, "net_tracking_error": 0.009480108068439075, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2527573.740927939, "total_cost_dollars": 2735.780778149484, "net_cagr_pct": 8.050148949645951, "net_volatility_pct": 10.191537674214475, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.30977437040036, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.984895350513536, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5984895350513537, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0031022215109469307, "net_tracking_error": 0.003110157762711688, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2622350.820924224, "total_cost_dollars": 1273.1660836868784, "net_cagr_pct": 8.382774636383239, "net_volatility_pct": 10.136833915287019, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.07614787143568, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.3016528964795295, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.730165289647953, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006147348356168236, "net_tracking_error": 0.006147780090621768, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2442025.432038852, "total_cost_dollars": 2565.1188506613207, "net_cagr_pct": 7.739946313529611, "net_volatility_pct": 9.701889541091797, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.078748407786343, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.969691486679517, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4969691486679517, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005451189619556276, "net_tracking_error": 0.005454124611702307, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010193711139916906 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2507651.8336335984, "total_cost_dollars": 2612.136381724718, "net_cagr_pct": 7.978780304514177, "net_volatility_pct": 10.143856033417427, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.487965466335034, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.02722662948243, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.502722662948243, "gross_tracking_error": 0.001713756094063691, "net_tracking_error": 0.0017234442626589167, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1758, "interim_drift_days": 1758, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010587574238425573 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2610885.35281347, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.9992035222517, "net_cagr_pct": 8.343127276735697, "net_volatility_pct": 10.179424635254527, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.5337999584294, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.231921636538252, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7231921636538252, "gross_tracking_error": 0.004554987872259147, "net_tracking_error": 0.004555103262737129, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1007, "interim_drift_days": 1007, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.004017115753815109 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2264849.1831478206, "total_cost_dollars": 2512.137128590076, "net_cagr_pct": 7.064483837520963, "net_volatility_pct": 8.632867745291346, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.402700329190825, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.298221861329726, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5298221861329724, "gross_tracking_error": 0.016292042534525698, "net_tracking_error": 0.016293271272996023, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.018329762362953278 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2454084.9607486255, "total_cost_dollars": 2884.966095369672, "net_cagr_pct": 7.784272196037412, "net_volatility_pct": 9.95832050282818, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.639016594008652, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.97997433376683, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6979974333766832, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005073109749382462, "net_tracking_error": 0.005077731436538761, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1759, "interim_drift_days": 1759, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020726017040199718 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2534469.6850721203, "total_cost_dollars": 1383.5407627684278, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074733043761562, "net_volatility_pct": 9.786474158072417, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.26758881878824, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.011177441127819, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8011177441127819, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008763502823565444, "net_tracking_error": 0.00876368150033827, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1429, "interim_drift_days": 1429, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020383408797257974 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2766515.3742002496, "total_cost_dollars": 2494.3864913779084, "net_cagr_pct": 8.868182726311469, "net_volatility_pct": 11.09114821546499, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.973579216855978, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 13.492952410652254, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.3492952410652255, "gross_tracking_error": 0.012355103418200453, "net_tracking_error": 0.012357530954334417, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1061, "interim_drift_days": 1061, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.047577931904168924 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2753425.665428194, "total_cost_dollars": 2731.5352069996184, "net_cagr_pct": 8.82507822311438, "net_volatility_pct": 10.393331716965967, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.645338468761565, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.749997684823562, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.474999768482356, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325890547288934, "net_tracking_error": 0.007327831704996808, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1080, "interim_drift_days": 1080, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05463820796388413 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2806257.778669182, "total_cost_dollars": 1219.839033098505, "net_cagr_pct": 8.997918890476608, "net_volatility_pct": 10.470418996664609, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.030126011111328, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.499750216974312, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6499750216974312, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009673029231131135, "net_tracking_error": 0.0096727673701935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 121, "interim_drift_days": 121, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05659163895288705 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2561901.792171226, "total_cost_dollars": 2687.63333478253, "net_cagr_pct": 8.171925591663353, "net_volatility_pct": 11.282622147723925, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.83797932831957, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.220630966173843, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5220630966173845, "gross_tracking_error": 0.015422547563953963, "net_tracking_error": 0.01542511523016283, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1369, "interim_drift_days": 1369, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.038709111864673074 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2414794.6780097135, "total_cost_dollars": 3018.730504402243, "net_cagr_pct": 7.63911464526299, "net_volatility_pct": 10.468382463722365, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.22038401558595, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.735984999923836, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.773598499992384, "gross_tracking_error": 0.011005791944861298, "net_tracking_error": 0.011009155480500807, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1350, "interim_drift_days": 1350, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0414325483934713 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2625873.2193304673, "total_cost_dollars": 1792.84234854666, "net_cagr_pct": 8.394923120198161, "net_volatility_pct": 10.712113052015038, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.651170591581817, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 9.792186561612723, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.9792186561612721, "gross_tracking_error": 0.013607185032656156, "net_tracking_error": 0.013608391748226742, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1095, "interim_drift_days": 1095, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04212962747898383 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2355157.6995489225, "total_cost_dollars": 2653.890312534904, "net_cagr_pct": 7.414596054728229, "net_volatility_pct": 9.766100371722036, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.084719289010902, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.98335943519397, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.598335943519397, "gross_tracking_error": 0.010151679973244638, "net_tracking_error": 0.010151771715024993, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2535, "interim_drift_days": 2535, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04213973834163309 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2332731.6929909526, "total_cost_dollars": 2749.360026310408, "net_cagr_pct": 7.32881743849314, "net_volatility_pct": 10.135137347566532, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.247207433551143, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.487839602504653, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6487839602504653, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325021777711064, "net_tracking_error": 0.0073277626421223135, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2336, "interim_drift_days": 2336, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.040852005830701005 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2397147.741122606, "total_cost_dollars": 1300.5034455735956, "net_cagr_pct": 7.573212539293883, "net_volatility_pct": 10.139199394542597, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.623771519109546, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.880926065371353, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7880926065371353, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009916912693656478, "net_tracking_error": 0.009917532235428891, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1292, "interim_drift_days": 1292, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.015184946330196819 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2473642.7513444256, "total_cost_dollars": 2717.077171568892, "net_cagr_pct": 7.855735978502798, "net_volatility_pct": 8.313609735955612, "max_drawdown_pct": -18.725081307824667, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.555569824404078, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5555569824404079, "gross_tracking_error": 0.02682463660801744, "net_tracking_error": 0.026825133926513825, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1790, "interim_drift_days": 1790, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01430184990891703 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2886401.13824536, "total_cost_dollars": 3204.2147745298885, "net_cagr_pct": 9.254497969836661, "net_volatility_pct": 10.039978981292881, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.446739380149726, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.96507706803343, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6965077068033436, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01730102880761127, "net_tracking_error": 0.017302151848603935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1799, "interim_drift_days": 1799, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.017031460688173655 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2855291.307571257, "total_cost_dollars": 1160.3987000471925, "net_cagr_pct": 9.155684504757811, "net_volatility_pct": 10.28890859578624, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.11036359163676, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.185531783434095, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6185531783434094, "gross_tracking_error": 0.019221518589753548, "net_tracking_error": 0.01922204994098753, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 957, "interim_drift_days": 957, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.005629091773254852 } ], "linking_method": "Initial-capital-scaled realized dollar P&L; sum asset gains/V0 plus negative costs/V0 equals cumulative portfolio return. Subtract analogous benchmark contributions for exact cumulative wealth-return difference. Not Brinson, factor attribution, or a separate cost-free portfolio." }, "blockers": [ "decision_chronology", "decision_risk_window", "trade_chronology" ], "corrected_retest": "PASS", "closure": "CLOSED_TEST_CASE" }, { "id": "INC-004", "title": "Prohibited asset allocation", "classification": "DELIBERATELY INJECTED TEST CASE", "severity": "BLOCK", "expected_status": "BLOCK", "observed_status": "BLOCK", "detected": true, "expected_domain_checks_any": [ "decision_constraint_bounds" ], "expected_domain_failure_observed": true, "injection": "Moved one percentage point from SPY to prohibited GLD in one No gold proposal; weights still sum to one.", "root_cause": "Mandate / trade construction", "corrective_action": "Reject the proposal and re-solve under the separately declared client bounds.", "suggested_operational_owner": "Portfolio management", "acceptance_criterion": "A normalized portfolio can still violate its mandate; prohibited asset weights must be zero within tolerance.", "failed_checks": [ { "id": "decision_constraint_bounds", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.01, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" }, { "id": "risk_te_reconciliation", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 0.002361789154921183, "tolerance": 1e-10, "detail": "" }, { "id": "posttrade_decision_weights", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 0.010000000000000064, "tolerance": 2e-06, "detail": "" } ], "aggregate_impact": { "returns_rows": 32192, "calendar_rows": 4024, "daily_rows": 90540, "decisions_rows": 4320, "trades_rows": 34560, "benchmark_rows": 3018, "paths": 30, "evaluation_dates": 3018, "execution_dates": 144, "source_dates": 4024, "assets": 8, "attribution_totals": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5345275118889457, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692457139111, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7641902269912244, "IWM": 0.17603068061438792, "EFA": 0.2138321129739271, "EEM": 0.05882650428732878, "IEF": 0.05784482574990592, "TLT": 0.005765120983103948, "GLD": 0.24551404640093763, "SHY": 0.015103719033138105 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.0026459779731509148, "IWM": -0.0009314152257186847, "EFA": 0.000363491383806841, "EEM": -0.0001463258383000779, "IEF": -0.0004900142349845843, "TLT": 1.485544749728774e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927024618911, "SHY": -3.578816881809853e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0025797251450238364, "active_linking_residual": -1.484836559262348e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.534527511788152, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692557932706, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.764190226933492, "IWM": 0.1760306806128757, "EFA": 0.21383211298696567, "EEM": 0.05882650428420453, "IEF": 0.0578448253366722, "TLT": 0.005765121235137153, "GLD": 0.24551404639265934, "SHY": 0.015103719151310474 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.002645978030883289, "IWM": -0.0009314152272309195, "EFA": 0.0003634913968454112, "EEM": -0.00014632584142432875, "IEF": -0.0004900146482183024, "TLT": 1.4855699530491942e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927107401858, "SHY": -3.578805064572907e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00257972514518495, "active_linking_residual": -1.9095836023552692e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5921669722544691, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.050579767908384365, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8144045603574873, "IWM": 0.16885394460746495, "EFA": 0.2106270468835373, "EEM": 0.05839846999577816, "IEF": 0.049535524876170065, "TLT": 0.012706955145351494, "GLD": 0.2658175244818071, "SHY": 0.013241127341377201 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.047568355393111994, "IWM": -0.008108151232641664, "EFA": -0.0028415747065829444, "EEM": -0.0005743601298506956, "IEF": -0.008799315108720437, "TLT": 0.006956689609744833, "GLD": 0.0196946853784076, "SHY": -0.0018983798605790025 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0014181814345258653, "active_linking_residual": -2.0546064849469303e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4215290136606908, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.12005819068539392, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8455829129898808, "IWM": 0.19233213384355213, "EFA": 0.23358805862626353, "EEM": 0.06361053583052598, "IEF": 0.06397713839265665, "TLT": 0.006613052376914119, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.016671970159102933 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.07874670802550543, "IWM": 0.015370038003445524, "EFA": 0.020119437036143273, "EEM": 0.004637705704897119, "IEF": 0.005642298407766144, "TLT": 0.0008627868413074585, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.00153246295714673 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002465788558221965, "active_linking_residual": -1.5890067039947553e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2572502943103285, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.28433691003575623, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6922020432422589, "IWM": 0.1581958559509042, "EFA": 0.22638093916140253, "EEM": 0.07670483082018123, "IEF": 0.08523305578520382, "TLT": 0.0029145542132029733, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.017009636709260274 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.07463416172211645, "IWM": -0.018766239889202396, "EFA": 0.012912317571282278, "EEM": 0.01773200069455237, "IEF": 0.02689821580031332, "TLT": -0.0028357113224036874, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.0018701295073040702 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0030096215721030915, "active_linking_residual": -1.687538997430238e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.460093160110683, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08149404423540174, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9425559611719156, "IWM": 0.15987030825541926, "EFA": 0.18582614979025203, "EEM": 0.06983484469301109, "IEF": 0.07103776971679376, "TLT": 0.010873237559768514, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.019757119291886848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.17571975620754032, "IWM": -0.01709178758468735, "EFA": -0.02764247179986823, "EEM": 0.010862014567382228, "IEF": 0.012702929731903262, "TLT": 0.005122972024161853, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.004617612089930645 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012812303683814444, "active_linking_residual": -1.650068970349139e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5732576341082627, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.03167042976217793, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8147891704055653, "IWM": 0.1876247735106619, "EFA": 0.2289653343326435, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.061446890895422296, "TLT": 0.005858322343224703, "GLD": 0.262965395039162, "SHY": 0.016143828249244083 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04795296544118999, "IWM": 0.010662677670555287, "EFA": 0.015496712742523233, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.003112050910531794, "TLT": 0.00010805680761804236, "GLD": 0.016842555935762477, "SHY": 0.0010043210472878792 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026159806676856368, "active_linking_residual": -2.373101715136272e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5961483736569573, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.054561169310872515, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8025305247508785, "IWM": 0.1810177905508809, "EFA": 0.2684612642706993, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.05867850934438678, "TLT": 0.0056456688906171525, "GLD": 0.26929951304443545, "SHY": 0.01515692846517483 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.03569431978650317, "IWM": 0.004055694710774299, "EFA": 0.05499264268057902, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.0003436693594962778, "TLT": -0.00010459664498950819, "GLD": 0.023176673941035925, "SHY": 1.7421263218625818e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002721725660132361, "active_linking_residual": -1.5931700403370996e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7642946875762084, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22270748323012368, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9707276302031296, "IWM": 0.18006394179100876, "EFA": 0.22436142087997057, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.03411989559731103, "TLT": 0.018993377312367825, "GLD": 0.32538877901865815, "SHY": 0.013850917137383114 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.20389142523875425, "IWM": 0.0031018459509021545, "EFA": 0.010892799289850319, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.02421494438757947, "TLT": 0.013243111776761164, "GLD": 0.07926593991525863, "SHY": -0.0012885900645730891 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012911743636358302, "active_linking_residual": -1.4405143744511406e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6198144763898967, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.07822727204381197, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8071597501926342, "IWM": 0.1851179504856676, "EFA": 0.22691833652562673, "EEM": 0.06250678535165581, "IEF": 0.06186075124276445, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.26246778527825076, "SHY": 0.016171083028446352 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04032354522825887, "IWM": 0.008155854645560984, "EFA": 0.01344971493550648, "EEM": 0.0035339552260269524, "IEF": 0.003525911257873951, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.016344946174851244, "SHY": 0.0010315758264901487 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002540115715171641, "active_linking_residual": -2.1635471192382738e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5275737409279389, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.01401346341814591, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7519888008157273, "IWM": 0.1778048890165744, "EFA": 0.2098754733023783, "EEM": 0.05921600491888479, "IEF": 0.09002486461360458, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.24108968333001005, "SHY": 0.00015765570889323 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.014847404148648047, "IWM": 0.0008427931764677932, "EFA": -0.0035931482877419596, "EEM": 0.00024317479325593194, "IEF": 0.03169002462871408, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": -0.005033155773389475, "SHY": -0.014981851493062973 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002735780778149484, "active_linking_residual": -1.4885662147356982e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6223508209242237, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.08076361657813891, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8582207668145045, "IWM": 0.180099158295092, "EFA": 0.16320323366715445, "EEM": 0.05965791666702852, "IEF": 0.0723531067579814, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.28025357071280177, "SHY": 0.009684084093325962 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.09138456185012922, "IWM": 0.0031370624549853787, "EFA": -0.05026538792296581, "EEM": 0.0006850865413996626, "IEF": 0.014018266773090898, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.03413073160940225, "SHY": -0.005455423108630241 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012731660836868784, "active_linking_residual": -2.1094237467877974e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.442025432038852, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.09956177230723284, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7106349597757761, "IWM": 0.16405568131499804, "EFA": 0.19847142102083895, "EEM": 0.054540103241492305, "IEF": 0.054528187961549554, "TLT": 0.005970550683095518, "GLD": 0.22688228143650438, "SHY": 0.02950736545526939 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05620124518859926, "IWM": -0.012906414525108573, "EFA": -0.014997200569281305, "EEM": -0.004432726884136554, "IEF": -0.003806652023340948, "TLT": 0.00022028514748885768, "GLD": -0.01924055766689514, "SHY": 0.014367858253313185 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002565118850661321, "active_linking_residual": 1.1782241848834474e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5076518336335982, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.033935370712486534, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7450451773971472, "IWM": 0.17662909494127293, "EFA": 0.21230173096995175, "EEM": 0.056574723493955745, "IEF": 0.03839157139379364, "TLT": 0.010784204879437964, "GLD": 0.24054871456373245, "SHY": 0.029988752376006997 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.02179102756722817, "IWM": -0.0003330008988336741, "EFA": -0.0011668906201685036, "EEM": -0.0023981066316731137, "IEF": -0.01994326859109686, "TLT": 0.005033939343831303, "GLD": -0.005574124539667075, "SHY": 0.014849245174050793 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002612136381724718, "active_linking_residual": -2.348121697082206e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6108853528134701, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.06929814846738536, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8436647701625559, "IWM": 0.17267578562303154, "EFA": 0.18762362915019892, "EEM": 0.05576522526655487, "IEF": 0.026215563064086827, "TLT": 0.014871316801049384, "GLD": 0.27966576205622523, "SHY": 0.031685299893263734 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.0768285651981806, "IWM": -0.004286310217075068, "EFA": -0.025844992439921333, "EEM": -0.0032076048590739883, "IEF": -0.03211927692080367, "TLT": 0.009121051265442723, "GLD": 0.03354292295282571, "SHY": 0.01654579269130753 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012819992035222518, "active_linking_residual": -2.5104918144336352e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2648491831478208, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.27673802119826396, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6083601226028378, "IWM": 0.14104327951495169, "EFA": 0.16921729015604525, "EEM": 0.04637007689905751, "IEF": 0.04799081215741253, "TLT": 0.006181416784615747, "GLD": 0.1918434591505134, "SHY": 0.05635486301093857 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.15847608236153754, "IWM": -0.03591881632515492, "EFA": -0.044251331434075, "EEM": -0.012602753226571346, "IEF": -0.010344027827477974, "TLT": 0.0004311512490090862, "GLD": -0.05427937995288612, "SHY": 0.04121535580898236 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002512137128590076, "active_linking_residual": -3.752553823233029e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4540849607486255, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08750224359745928, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7073098731086407, "IWM": 0.17771833303603254, "EFA": 0.20920782303736576, "EEM": 0.05216229941332555, "IEF": -0.00016132601981592266, "TLT": 0.020844346415195815, "GLD": 0.23071952103774226, "SHY": 0.059169056815488126 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05952633185573464, "IWM": 0.0007562371959259351, "EFA": -0.004260798552754491, "EEM": -0.006810530712303309, "IEF": -0.058496166004706425, "TLT": 0.015094080879589154, "GLD": -0.015403318065657257, "SHY": 0.04402954961353192 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002884966095369672, "active_linking_residual": -1.9498291869979312e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5344696850721204, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007117519273964312, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.831827835088315, "IWM": 0.1763464628132381, "EFA": 0.14585647219952236, "EEM": 0.05159592118694526, "IEF": 0.020649788310524976, "TLT": -0.0004223338339035706, "GLD": 0.24924731413797635, "SHY": 0.06075176593224909 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.06499163012393971, "IWM": -0.0006156330268685117, "EFA": -0.0676121493905979, "EEM": -0.007376908938683598, "IEF": -0.037685051674365526, "TLT": -0.006172599369510231, "GLD": 0.003124475034576829, "SHY": 0.045612258730292884 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013835407627684278, "active_linking_residual": -2.0441981440910695e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7665153742002495, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22492816985416475, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0698561212707327, "IWM": 0.1568045102225823, "EFA": 0.19357560398060453, "EEM": 0.05301087111920712, "IEF": 0.05140076066612208, "TLT": 0.00407307410058057, "GLD": 0.22644509759095016, "SHY": 0.013843721740802523 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3030199163063574, "IWM": -0.020157585617524315, "EFA": -0.01989301760951573, "EEM": -0.005961959006421741, "IEF": -0.006934079318768424, "TLT": -0.0016771914350260904, "GLD": -0.01967774151244936, "SHY": -0.0012957854611536802 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0024943864913779083, "active_linking_residual": -4.465872116554692e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7534256654281943, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.21183846108210957, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0719244394155991, "IWM": 0.10840884857731314, "EFA": 0.17104337388553428, "EEM": 0.05237883375672182, "IEF": 0.06504039075317218, "TLT": -0.0014515314923506488, "GLD": 0.2812864661235022, "SHY": 0.007526379615688228 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3050882344512238, "IWM": -0.06855324726279347, "EFA": -0.04242524770458597, "EEM": -0.006593996368907042, "IEF": 0.006705550768281679, "TLT": -0.0072017970279573094, "GLD": 0.0351636270201027, "SHY": -0.007613127586267975 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002731535206999618, "active_linking_residual": -1.27675647831893e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.806257778669182, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.26467057432309726, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.112300853184688, "IWM": 0.12672210731296324, "EFA": 0.12249471065011537, "EEM": 0.05201407116893994, "IEF": 0.030957970657757357, "TLT": 0.021501607194395936, "GLD": 0.32823967730589176, "SHY": 0.013246620227510546 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.34546464822031275, "IWM": -0.05023998852714337, "EFA": -0.09097391094000488, "EEM": -0.006958758956688918, "IEF": -0.027376869327133145, "TLT": 0.015751341658789275, "GLD": 0.08211683820249224, "SHY": -0.0018928869744456577 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.001219839033098505, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5619017921712257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.02031458782514095, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6818561945206191, "IWM": 0.350528489013525, "EFA": 0.19049071040048163, "EEM": 0.05168886861900644, "IEF": 0.05124459812103912, "TLT": 0.004809791766598669, "GLD": 0.220416603258753, "SHY": 0.01355416980596361 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.08498001044375625, "IWM": 0.1735663931734184, "EFA": -0.022977911189638628, "EEM": -0.007283961506622416, "IEF": -0.007090241863851383, "TLT": -0.0009404737690079917, "GLD": -0.025706235844646513, "SHY": -0.0015853373959925938 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00268763333478253, "active_linking_residual": -2.085137618124122e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4147946780097134, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.1267925263363714, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5352437093500231, "IWM": 0.3421440984512125, "EFA": 0.1594561029675723, "EEM": 0.050618138944804325, "IEF": 0.055107409545375824, "TLT": 0.009554888144364235, "GLD": 0.2477196677354686, "SHY": 0.01796939337527965 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.23159249561435225, "IWM": 0.1651820026111059, "EFA": -0.05401251862254797, "EEM": -0.008354691180824533, "IEF": -0.003227430439514678, "TLT": 0.0038046226087575744, "GLD": 0.001596828632069086, "SHY": 0.002829886173323448 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.003018730504402243, "active_linking_residual": -1.4238610290817633e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6258732193304675, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.0842860149843827, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7331430653241838, "IWM": 0.36469442041694244, "EFA": 0.09994117445319692, "EEM": 0.04372906952164565, "IEF": 0.03639075038465191, "TLT": 0.01932943010570429, "GLD": 0.31406959333067996, "SHY": 0.016368558141986848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.033693139640191494, "IWM": 0.18773232457683584, "EFA": -0.11352744713692334, "EEM": -0.015243760603983206, "IEF": -0.021944089600238595, "TLT": 0.01357916457009763, "GLD": 0.06794675422728044, "SHY": 0.0012290509400306442 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00179284234854666, "active_linking_residual": -2.1468937738688965e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3551576995489225, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.18642950479716225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4861193321117492, "IWM": 0.2035602932023193, "EFA": 0.2439984794275416, "EEM": 0.06744930729539783, "IEF": 0.05609348177914334, "TLT": 0.007894828137706287, "GLD": 0.2756232189103167, "SHY": 0.017072648997255614 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.28071687285262614, "IWM": 0.026598197362212694, "EFA": 0.030529857837421348, "EEM": 0.008476477169768973, "IEF": -0.002241358205747161, "TLT": 0.0021445626020996263, "GLD": 0.029500379806917193, "SHY": 0.0019331417952994107 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026538903125349037, "active_linking_residual": -2.6728619317850644e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3327316929909525, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.20885551135513225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4837490516245933, "IWM": 0.23685338199297587, "EFA": 0.2510936537172181, "EEM": 0.0643991010258322, "IEF": 0.05300117426859076, "TLT": 0.010775725150410302, "GLD": 0.2137124187940069, "SHY": 0.02189654644361989 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.283087153339782, "IWM": 0.05989128615286926, "EFA": 0.037625032127097835, "EEM": 0.005426270900203339, "IEF": -0.005333665716299743, "TLT": 0.0050254596148036415, "GLD": -0.03241042030939262, "SHY": 0.006757039241663687 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002749360026310408, "active_linking_residual": -1.4765966227514582e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3971477411226063, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.14443946322347845, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48161496178994, "IWM": 0.261072142372408, "EFA": 0.2270395042779547, "EEM": 0.06988592082086303, "IEF": 0.03450083460267277, "TLT": 0.01822702333281722, "GLD": 0.27950647396631134, "SHY": 0.026601383405193146 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.2852212431744353, "IWM": 0.08411004653230139, "EFA": 0.013570882687834435, "EEM": 0.010913090695234176, "IEF": -0.023834005382217735, "TLT": 0.01247675779721056, "GLD": 0.03338363486291182, "SHY": 0.011461876203236942 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013005034455735955, "active_linking_residual": -1.887379141862766e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4736427513444257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.06794445300165908, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8782377521099625, "IWM": 0.20433129403518546, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.06593457657762311, "TLT": 0.006616170792757581, "GLD": 0.2795661983673561, "SHY": 0.0453601366330915 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.11140154714558714, "IWM": 0.027369198195078853, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.007599736592732609, "TLT": 0.0008659052571509205, "GLD": 0.03344335926395656, "SHY": 0.030220629431135293 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002717077171568892, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8864011382453598, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.34481393389927506, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.1526664820313828, "IWM": 0.2782339990169149, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.011414971378958515, "TLT": 0.015310350500598388, "GLD": 0.38531643738215593, "SHY": 0.05034941270985426 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.38583027706700745, "IWM": 0.10127190317680831, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.04691986860593199, "TLT": 0.009560084964991727, "GLD": 0.1391935982787564, "SHY": 0.03520990550789806 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0032042147745298885, "active_linking_residual": -2.403632848313464e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8552913075712572, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.3137041032251724, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.2481476443039528, "IWM": 0.2116089924038399, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.02687481813432769, "TLT": -0.013174583522867283, "GLD": 0.33512944518057103, "SHY": 0.051551689771457306 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48131143933957743, "IWM": 0.03464689656373329, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.03146002185056281, "TLT": -0.01892484905847394, "GLD": 0.08900660607717151, "SHY": 0.0364121825695011 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0011603987000471925, "active_linking_residual": -2.2093438190040615e-14 } ], "path_metrics": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2534527.5118889455, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.7251450238364, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937491648, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443398159633, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.91031816316077, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333293485576, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333293485575, "gross_tracking_error": 0.00029188046117938397, "net_tracking_error": 0.0003382763175867321, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2534527.511788152, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.72514518495, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937132758, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443397751147, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.910318163035914, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333294206085, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333294206085, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0002918804611750983, "net_tracking_error": 0.00033827631748173945, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2592166.972254469, "total_cost_dollars": 1418.1814345258654, "net_cagr_pct": 8.278055274888473, "net_volatility_pct": 10.264858474154753, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.876602669912316, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.018367322597046, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8018367322597045, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0026890174767739685, "net_tracking_error": 0.0026908769036650755, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2421529.0136606907, "total_cost_dollars": 2465.788558221965, "net_cagr_pct": 7.66414756994378, "net_volatility_pct": 11.053462182390206, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.206540599329273, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.154101348160564, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4154101348160564, "gross_tracking_error": 0.017483985426599607, "net_tracking_error": 0.017487934445408203, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2257250.2943103286, "total_cost_dollars": 3009.6215721030917, "net_cagr_pct": 7.0344434049465, "net_volatility_pct": 10.132089336625588, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.82845883787783, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.230981810244234, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8230981810244233, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01369081354202467, "net_tracking_error": 0.0136959883701921, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2460093.160110683, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.2303683814444, "net_cagr_pct": 7.806281417925365, "net_volatility_pct": 10.345465700937543, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.463680010108632, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.245279826304215, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7245279826304216, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01638991450996628, "net_tracking_error": 0.016391365221518187, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2573257.6341082626, "total_cost_dollars": 2615.980667685637, "net_cagr_pct": 8.211880687061246, "net_volatility_pct": 9.948335432185358, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.384058134449457, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.840482471257662, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.484048247125766, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006896540607515067, "net_tracking_error": 0.006899257312340247, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2596148.3736569574, "total_cost_dollars": 2721.725660132361, "net_cagr_pct": 8.291932072733822, "net_volatility_pct": 10.275986214436822, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.648477286948765, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.424441064683341, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5424441064683345, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005534356093023667, "net_tracking_error": 0.005538848615810009, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2764294.6875762083, "total_cost_dollars": 1291.17436363583, "net_cagr_pct": 8.860883173242584, "net_volatility_pct": 10.383790774240824, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.7641075295292, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.98526215985455, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6985262159854552, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008310308266614781, "net_tracking_error": 0.00831057071417959, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2619814.4763898966, "total_cost_dollars": 2540.115715171641, "net_cagr_pct": 8.37401771217805, "net_volatility_pct": 10.787777603851199, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.42023290327093, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.548727854344262, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4548727854344266, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009477283264071847, "net_tracking_error": 0.009480108068439075, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2527573.740927939, "total_cost_dollars": 2735.780778149484, "net_cagr_pct": 8.050148949645951, "net_volatility_pct": 10.191537674214475, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.30977437040036, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.984895350513536, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5984895350513537, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0031022215109469307, "net_tracking_error": 0.003110157762711688, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2622350.820924224, "total_cost_dollars": 1273.1660836868784, "net_cagr_pct": 8.382774636383239, "net_volatility_pct": 10.136833915287019, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.07614787143568, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.3016528964795295, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.730165289647953, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006147348356168236, "net_tracking_error": 0.006147780090621768, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2442025.432038852, "total_cost_dollars": 2565.1188506613207, "net_cagr_pct": 7.739946313529611, "net_volatility_pct": 9.701889541091797, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.078748407786343, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.969691486679517, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4969691486679517, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005451189619556276, "net_tracking_error": 0.005454124611702307, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010193711139916906 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2507651.8336335984, "total_cost_dollars": 2612.136381724718, "net_cagr_pct": 7.978780304514177, "net_volatility_pct": 10.143856033417427, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.487965466335034, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.02722662948243, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.502722662948243, "gross_tracking_error": 0.001713756094063691, "net_tracking_error": 0.0017234442626589167, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1758, "interim_drift_days": 1758, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010587574238425573 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2610885.35281347, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.9992035222517, "net_cagr_pct": 8.343127276735697, "net_volatility_pct": 10.179424635254527, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.5337999584294, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.231921636538252, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7231921636538252, "gross_tracking_error": 0.004554987872259147, "net_tracking_error": 0.004555103262737129, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1007, "interim_drift_days": 1007, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.004017115753815109 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2264849.1831478206, "total_cost_dollars": 2512.137128590076, "net_cagr_pct": 7.064483837520963, "net_volatility_pct": 8.632867745291346, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.402700329190825, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.298221861329726, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5298221861329724, "gross_tracking_error": 0.016292042534525698, "net_tracking_error": 0.016293271272996023, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.018329762362953278 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2454084.9607486255, "total_cost_dollars": 2884.966095369672, "net_cagr_pct": 7.784272196037412, "net_volatility_pct": 9.95832050282818, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.639016594008652, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.97997433376683, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6979974333766832, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005073109749382462, "net_tracking_error": 0.005077731436538761, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1759, "interim_drift_days": 1759, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020726017040199718 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2534469.6850721203, "total_cost_dollars": 1383.5407627684278, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074733043761562, "net_volatility_pct": 9.786474158072417, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.26758881878824, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.011177441127819, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8011177441127819, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008763502823565444, "net_tracking_error": 0.00876368150033827, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1429, "interim_drift_days": 1429, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020383408797257974 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2766515.3742002496, "total_cost_dollars": 2494.3864913779084, "net_cagr_pct": 8.868182726311469, "net_volatility_pct": 11.09114821546499, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.973579216855978, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 13.492952410652254, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.3492952410652255, "gross_tracking_error": 0.012355103418200453, "net_tracking_error": 0.012357530954334417, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1061, "interim_drift_days": 1061, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.047577931904168924 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2753425.665428194, "total_cost_dollars": 2731.5352069996184, "net_cagr_pct": 8.82507822311438, "net_volatility_pct": 10.393331716965967, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.645338468761565, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.749997684823562, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.474999768482356, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325890547288934, "net_tracking_error": 0.007327831704996808, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1080, "interim_drift_days": 1080, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05463820796388413 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2806257.778669182, "total_cost_dollars": 1219.839033098505, "net_cagr_pct": 8.997918890476608, "net_volatility_pct": 10.470418996664609, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.030126011111328, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.499750216974312, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6499750216974312, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009673029231131135, "net_tracking_error": 0.0096727673701935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 121, "interim_drift_days": 121, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05659163895288705 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2561901.792171226, "total_cost_dollars": 2687.63333478253, "net_cagr_pct": 8.171925591663353, "net_volatility_pct": 11.282622147723925, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.83797932831957, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.220630966173843, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5220630966173845, "gross_tracking_error": 0.015422547563953963, "net_tracking_error": 0.01542511523016283, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1369, "interim_drift_days": 1369, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.038709111864673074 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2414794.6780097135, "total_cost_dollars": 3018.730504402243, "net_cagr_pct": 7.63911464526299, "net_volatility_pct": 10.468382463722365, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.22038401558595, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.735984999923836, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.773598499992384, "gross_tracking_error": 0.011005791944861298, "net_tracking_error": 0.011009155480500807, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1350, "interim_drift_days": 1350, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0414325483934713 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2625873.2193304673, "total_cost_dollars": 1792.84234854666, "net_cagr_pct": 8.394923120198161, "net_volatility_pct": 10.712113052015038, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.651170591581817, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 9.792186561612723, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.9792186561612721, "gross_tracking_error": 0.013607185032656156, "net_tracking_error": 0.013608391748226742, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1095, "interim_drift_days": 1095, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04212962747898383 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2355157.6995489225, "total_cost_dollars": 2653.890312534904, "net_cagr_pct": 7.414596054728229, "net_volatility_pct": 9.766100371722036, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.084719289010902, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.98335943519397, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.598335943519397, "gross_tracking_error": 0.010151679973244638, "net_tracking_error": 0.010151771715024993, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2535, "interim_drift_days": 2535, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04213973834163309 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2332731.6929909526, "total_cost_dollars": 2749.360026310408, "net_cagr_pct": 7.32881743849314, "net_volatility_pct": 10.135137347566532, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.247207433551143, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.487839602504653, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6487839602504653, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325021777711064, "net_tracking_error": 0.0073277626421223135, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2336, "interim_drift_days": 2336, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.040852005830701005 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2397147.741122606, "total_cost_dollars": 1300.5034455735956, "net_cagr_pct": 7.573212539293883, "net_volatility_pct": 10.139199394542597, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.623771519109546, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.880926065371353, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7880926065371353, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009916912693656478, "net_tracking_error": 0.009917532235428891, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1292, "interim_drift_days": 1292, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.015184946330196819 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2473642.7513444256, "total_cost_dollars": 2717.077171568892, "net_cagr_pct": 7.855735978502798, "net_volatility_pct": 8.313609735955612, "max_drawdown_pct": -18.725081307824667, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.555569824404078, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5555569824404079, "gross_tracking_error": 0.02682463660801744, "net_tracking_error": 0.026825133926513825, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1790, "interim_drift_days": 1790, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01430184990891703 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2886401.13824536, "total_cost_dollars": 3204.2147745298885, "net_cagr_pct": 9.254497969836661, "net_volatility_pct": 10.039978981292881, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.446739380149726, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.96507706803343, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6965077068033436, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01730102880761127, "net_tracking_error": 0.017302151848603935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1799, "interim_drift_days": 1799, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.017031460688173655 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2855291.307571257, "total_cost_dollars": 1160.3987000471925, "net_cagr_pct": 9.155684504757811, "net_volatility_pct": 10.28890859578624, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.11036359163676, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.185531783434095, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6185531783434094, "gross_tracking_error": 0.019221518589753548, "net_tracking_error": 0.01922204994098753, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 957, "interim_drift_days": 957, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.005629091773254852 } ], "linking_method": "Initial-capital-scaled realized dollar P&L; sum asset gains/V0 plus negative costs/V0 equals cumulative portfolio return. Subtract analogous benchmark contributions for exact cumulative wealth-return difference. Not Brinson, factor attribution, or a separate cost-free portfolio." }, "blockers": [ "decision_constraint_bounds", "risk_te_reconciliation", "posttrade_decision_weights" ], "corrected_retest": "PASS", "closure": "CLOSED_TEST_CASE" }, { "id": "INC-005", "title": "Trade-fee reconciliation error", "classification": "DELIBERATELY INJECTED TEST CASE", "severity": "BLOCK", "expected_status": "BLOCK", "observed_status": "BLOCK", "detected": true, "expected_domain_checks_any": [ "sql_fee_error", "sql_funding_error", "trade_cost_formula" ], "expected_domain_failure_observed": true, "injection": "Added $100 to one recorded trade fee without changing holdings or actual trade notional.", "root_cause": "Cost accounting", "corrective_action": "Recompute each fee from absolute notional and rate; reconcile fees and funded NAV.", "suggested_operational_owner": "Portfolio accounting", "acceptance_criterion": "Independent SQL cost and cash-funding identities must flag the discrepancy.", "failed_checks": [ { "id": "sql_funding_error", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 100.0000000000515, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "sql_signed_trade_error", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 100.00000000007333, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "sql_fee_error", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 100.0, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "sql_daily_fee_error", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 4320, "max_abs_error": 99.99999999999997, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" }, { "id": "trade_cost_formula", "status": "BLOCK", "count": 34560, "max_abs_error": 100.0, "tolerance": 0.0001, "detail": "" } ], "aggregate_impact": { "returns_rows": 32192, "calendar_rows": 4024, "daily_rows": 90540, "decisions_rows": 4320, "trades_rows": 34560, "benchmark_rows": 3018, "paths": 30, "evaluation_dates": 3018, "execution_dates": 144, "source_dates": 4024, "assets": 8, "attribution_totals": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5345275118889457, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692457139111, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7641902269912244, "IWM": 0.17603068061438792, "EFA": 0.2138321129739271, "EEM": 0.05882650428732878, "IEF": 0.05784482574990592, "TLT": 0.005765120983103948, "GLD": 0.24551404640093763, "SHY": 0.015103719033138105 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.0026459779731509148, "IWM": -0.0009314152257186847, "EFA": 0.000363491383806841, "EEM": -0.0001463258383000779, "IEF": -0.0004900142349845843, "TLT": 1.485544749728774e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927024618911, "SHY": -3.578816881809853e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0025797251450238364, "active_linking_residual": -1.484836559262348e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.534527511788152, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007059692557932706, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.764190226933492, "IWM": 0.1760306806128757, "EFA": 0.21383211298696567, "EEM": 0.05882650428420453, "IEF": 0.0578448253366722, "TLT": 0.005765121235137153, "GLD": 0.24551404639265934, "SHY": 0.015103719151310474 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.002645978030883289, "IWM": -0.0009314152272309195, "EFA": 0.0003634913968454112, "EEM": -0.00014632584142432875, "IEF": -0.0004900146482183024, "TLT": 1.4855699530491942e-05, "GLD": -0.0006087927107401858, "SHY": -3.578805064572907e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00257972514518495, "active_linking_residual": -1.9095836023552692e-14 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5921669722544691, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.050579767908384365, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8144045603574873, "IWM": 0.16885394460746495, "EFA": 0.2106270468835373, "EEM": 0.05839846999577816, "IEF": 0.049535524876170065, "TLT": 0.012706955145351494, "GLD": 0.2658175244818071, "SHY": 0.013241127341377201 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.047568355393111994, "IWM": -0.008108151232641664, "EFA": -0.0028415747065829444, "EEM": -0.0005743601298506956, "IEF": -0.008799315108720437, "TLT": 0.006956689609744833, "GLD": 0.0196946853784076, "SHY": -0.0018983798605790025 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0014181814345258653, "active_linking_residual": -2.0546064849469303e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4215290136606908, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.12005819068539392, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8455829129898808, "IWM": 0.19233213384355213, "EFA": 0.23358805862626353, "EEM": 0.06361053583052598, "IEF": 0.06397713839265665, "TLT": 0.006613052376914119, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.016671970159102933 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.07874670802550543, "IWM": 0.015370038003445524, "EFA": 0.020119437036143273, "EEM": 0.004637705704897119, "IEF": 0.005642298407766144, "TLT": 0.0008627868413074585, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.00153246295714673 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002465788558221965, "active_linking_residual": -1.5890067039947553e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2572502943103285, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.28433691003575623, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6922020432422589, "IWM": 0.1581958559509042, "EFA": 0.22638093916140253, "EEM": 0.07670483082018123, "IEF": 0.08523305578520382, "TLT": 0.0029145542132029733, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.017009636709260274 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.07463416172211645, "IWM": -0.018766239889202396, "EFA": 0.012912317571282278, "EEM": 0.01773200069455237, "IEF": 0.02689821580031332, "TLT": -0.0028357113224036874, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.0018701295073040702 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0030096215721030915, "active_linking_residual": -1.687538997430238e-14 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.460093160110683, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08149404423540174, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9425559611719156, "IWM": 0.15987030825541926, "EFA": 0.18582614979025203, "EEM": 0.06983484469301109, "IEF": 0.07103776971679376, "TLT": 0.010873237559768514, "GLD": 0.001619, "SHY": 0.019757119291886848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.17571975620754032, "IWM": -0.01709178758468735, "EFA": -0.02764247179986823, "EEM": 0.010862014567382228, "IEF": 0.012702929731903262, "TLT": 0.005122972024161853, "GLD": -0.2445038391033995, "SHY": 0.004617612089930645 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012812303683814444, "active_linking_residual": -1.650068970349139e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5732576341082627, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.03167042976217793, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8147891704055653, "IWM": 0.1876247735106619, "EFA": 0.2289653343326435, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.061446890895422296, "TLT": 0.005858322343224703, "GLD": 0.262965395039162, "SHY": 0.016143828249244083 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04795296544118999, "IWM": 0.010662677670555287, "EFA": 0.015496712742523233, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.003112050910531794, "TLT": 0.00010805680761804236, "GLD": 0.016842555935762477, "SHY": 0.0010043210472878792 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026159806676856368, "active_linking_residual": -2.373101715136272e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5961483736569573, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.054561169310872515, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8025305247508785, "IWM": 0.1810177905508809, "EFA": 0.2684612642706993, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.05867850934438678, "TLT": 0.0056456688906171525, "GLD": 0.26929951304443545, "SHY": 0.01515692846517483 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.03569431978650317, "IWM": 0.004055694710774299, "EFA": 0.05499264268057902, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.0003436693594962778, "TLT": -0.00010459664498950819, "GLD": 0.023176673941035925, "SHY": 1.7421263218625818e-05 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002721725660132361, "active_linking_residual": -1.5931700403370996e-14 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7642946875762084, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22270748323012368, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.9707276302031296, "IWM": 0.18006394179100876, "EFA": 0.22436142087997057, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.03411989559731103, "TLT": 0.018993377312367825, "GLD": 0.32538877901865815, "SHY": 0.013850917137383114 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.20389142523875425, "IWM": 0.0031018459509021545, "EFA": 0.010892799289850319, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.02421494438757947, "TLT": 0.013243111776761164, "GLD": 0.07926593991525863, "SHY": -0.0012885900645730891 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012911743636358302, "active_linking_residual": -1.4405143744511406e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6198144763898967, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.07822727204381197, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8071597501926342, "IWM": 0.1851179504856676, "EFA": 0.22691833652562673, "EEM": 0.06250678535165581, "IEF": 0.06186075124276445, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.26246778527825076, "SHY": 0.016171083028446352 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.04032354522825887, "IWM": 0.008155854645560984, "EFA": 0.01344971493550648, "EEM": 0.0035339552260269524, "IEF": 0.003525911257873951, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.016344946174851244, "SHY": 0.0010315758264901487 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002540115715171641, "active_linking_residual": -2.1635471192382738e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5275737409279389, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.01401346341814591, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7519888008157273, "IWM": 0.1778048890165744, "EFA": 0.2098754733023783, "EEM": 0.05921600491888479, "IEF": 0.09002486461360458, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.24108968333001005, "SHY": 0.00015765570889323 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.014847404148648047, "IWM": 0.0008427931764677932, "EFA": -0.0035931482877419596, "EEM": 0.00024317479325593194, "IEF": 0.03169002462871408, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": -0.005033155773389475, "SHY": -0.014981851493062973 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002735780778149484, "active_linking_residual": -1.4885662147356982e-14 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6223508209242237, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.08076361657813891, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8582207668145045, "IWM": 0.180099158295092, "EFA": 0.16320323366715445, "EEM": 0.05965791666702852, "IEF": 0.0723531067579814, "TLT": 0.00015215, "GLD": 0.28025357071280177, "SHY": 0.009684084093325962 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.09138456185012922, "IWM": 0.0031370624549853787, "EFA": -0.05026538792296581, "EEM": 0.0006850865413996626, "IEF": 0.014018266773090898, "TLT": -0.0055981155356066604, "GLD": 0.03413073160940225, "SHY": -0.005455423108630241 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012731660836868784, "active_linking_residual": -2.1094237467877974e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.442025432038852, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.09956177230723284, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7106349597757761, "IWM": 0.16405568131499804, "EFA": 0.19847142102083895, "EEM": 0.054540103241492305, "IEF": 0.054528187961549554, "TLT": 0.005970550683095518, "GLD": 0.22688228143650438, "SHY": 0.02950736545526939 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05620124518859926, "IWM": -0.012906414525108573, "EFA": -0.014997200569281305, "EEM": -0.004432726884136554, "IEF": -0.003806652023340948, "TLT": 0.00022028514748885768, "GLD": -0.01924055766689514, "SHY": 0.014367858253313185 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002565118850661321, "active_linking_residual": 1.1782241848834474e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5076518336335982, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.033935370712486534, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7450451773971472, "IWM": 0.17662909494127293, "EFA": 0.21230173096995175, "EEM": 0.056574723493955745, "IEF": 0.03839157139379364, "TLT": 0.010784204879437964, "GLD": 0.24054871456373245, "SHY": 0.029988752376006997 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.02179102756722817, "IWM": -0.0003330008988336741, "EFA": -0.0011668906201685036, "EEM": -0.0023981066316731137, "IEF": -0.01994326859109686, "TLT": 0.005033939343831303, "GLD": -0.005574124539667075, "SHY": 0.014849245174050793 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002612136381724718, "active_linking_residual": -2.348121697082206e-14 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6108853528134701, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.06929814846738536, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8436647701625559, "IWM": 0.17267578562303154, "EFA": 0.18762362915019892, "EEM": 0.05576522526655487, "IEF": 0.026215563064086827, "TLT": 0.014871316801049384, "GLD": 0.27966576205622523, "SHY": 0.031685299893263734 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.0768285651981806, "IWM": -0.004286310217075068, "EFA": -0.025844992439921333, "EEM": -0.0032076048590739883, "IEF": -0.03211927692080367, "TLT": 0.009121051265442723, "GLD": 0.03354292295282571, "SHY": 0.01654579269130753 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0012819992035222518, "active_linking_residual": -2.5104918144336352e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.2648491831478208, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.27673802119826396, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6083601226028378, "IWM": 0.14104327951495169, "EFA": 0.16921729015604525, "EEM": 0.04637007689905751, "IEF": 0.04799081215741253, "TLT": 0.006181416784615747, "GLD": 0.1918434591505134, "SHY": 0.05635486301093857 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.15847608236153754, "IWM": -0.03591881632515492, "EFA": -0.044251331434075, "EEM": -0.012602753226571346, "IEF": -0.010344027827477974, "TLT": 0.0004311512490090862, "GLD": -0.05427937995288612, "SHY": 0.04121535580898236 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002512137128590076, "active_linking_residual": -3.752553823233029e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4540849607486255, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.08750224359745928, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7073098731086407, "IWM": 0.17771833303603254, "EFA": 0.20920782303736576, "EEM": 0.05216229941332555, "IEF": -0.00016132601981592266, "TLT": 0.020844346415195815, "GLD": 0.23071952103774226, "SHY": 0.059169056815488126 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.05952633185573464, "IWM": 0.0007562371959259351, "EFA": -0.004260798552754491, "EEM": -0.006810530712303309, "IEF": -0.058496166004706425, "TLT": 0.015094080879589154, "GLD": -0.015403318065657257, "SHY": 0.04402954961353192 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002884966095369672, "active_linking_residual": -1.9498291869979312e-14 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5344696850721204, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.007117519273964312, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.831827835088315, "IWM": 0.1763464628132381, "EFA": 0.14585647219952236, "EEM": 0.05159592118694526, "IEF": 0.020649788310524976, "TLT": -0.0004223338339035706, "GLD": 0.24924731413797635, "SHY": 0.06075176593224909 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.06499163012393971, "IWM": -0.0006156330268685117, "EFA": -0.0676121493905979, "EEM": -0.007376908938683598, "IEF": -0.037685051674365526, "TLT": -0.006172599369510231, "GLD": 0.003124475034576829, "SHY": 0.045612258730292884 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013835407627684278, "active_linking_residual": -2.0441981440910695e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7665153742002495, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.22492816985416475, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0698561212707327, "IWM": 0.1568045102225823, "EFA": 0.19357560398060453, "EEM": 0.05301087111920712, "IEF": 0.05140076066612208, "TLT": 0.00407307410058057, "GLD": 0.22644509759095016, "SHY": 0.013843721740802523 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3030199163063574, "IWM": -0.020157585617524315, "EFA": -0.01989301760951573, "EEM": -0.005961959006421741, "IEF": -0.006934079318768424, "TLT": -0.0016771914350260904, "GLD": -0.01967774151244936, "SHY": -0.0012957854611536802 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0024943864913779083, "active_linking_residual": -4.465872116554692e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.7534256654281943, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.21183846108210957, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.0719244394155991, "IWM": 0.10840884857731314, "EFA": 0.17104337388553428, "EEM": 0.05237883375672182, "IEF": 0.06504039075317218, "TLT": -0.0014515314923506488, "GLD": 0.2812864661235022, "SHY": 0.007526379615688228 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.3050882344512238, "IWM": -0.06855324726279347, "EFA": -0.04242524770458597, "EEM": -0.006593996368907042, "IEF": 0.006705550768281679, "TLT": -0.0072017970279573094, "GLD": 0.0351636270201027, "SHY": -0.007613127586267975 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002731535206999618, "active_linking_residual": -1.27675647831893e-14 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.806257778669182, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.26467057432309726, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.112300853184688, "IWM": 0.12672210731296324, "EFA": 0.12249471065011537, "EEM": 0.05201407116893994, "IEF": 0.030957970657757357, "TLT": 0.021501607194395936, "GLD": 0.32823967730589176, "SHY": 0.013246620227510546 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.34546464822031275, "IWM": -0.05023998852714337, "EFA": -0.09097391094000488, "EEM": -0.006958758956688918, "IEF": -0.027376869327133145, "TLT": 0.015751341658789275, "GLD": 0.08211683820249224, "SHY": -0.0018928869744456577 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.001219839033098505, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.5619017921712257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.02031458782514095, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.6818561945206191, "IWM": 0.350528489013525, "EFA": 0.19049071040048163, "EEM": 0.05168886861900644, "IEF": 0.05124459812103912, "TLT": 0.004809791766598669, "GLD": 0.220416603258753, "SHY": 0.01355416980596361 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.08498001044375625, "IWM": 0.1735663931734184, "EFA": -0.022977911189638628, "EEM": -0.007283961506622416, "IEF": -0.007090241863851383, "TLT": -0.0009404737690079917, "GLD": -0.025706235844646513, "SHY": -0.0015853373959925938 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00268763333478253, "active_linking_residual": -2.085137618124122e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4147946780097134, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.1267925263363714, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.5352437093500231, "IWM": 0.3421440984512125, "EFA": 0.1594561029675723, "EEM": 0.050618138944804325, "IEF": 0.055107409545375824, "TLT": 0.009554888144364235, "GLD": 0.2477196677354686, "SHY": 0.01796939337527965 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.23159249561435225, "IWM": 0.1651820026111059, "EFA": -0.05401251862254797, "EEM": -0.008354691180824533, "IEF": -0.003227430439514678, "TLT": 0.0038046226087575744, "GLD": 0.001596828632069086, "SHY": 0.002829886173323448 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.003018730504402243, "active_linking_residual": -1.4238610290817633e-14 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.6258732193304675, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.0842860149843827, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7331430653241838, "IWM": 0.36469442041694244, "EFA": 0.09994117445319692, "EEM": 0.04372906952164565, "IEF": 0.03639075038465191, "TLT": 0.01932943010570429, "GLD": 0.31406959333067996, "SHY": 0.016368558141986848 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.033693139640191494, "IWM": 0.18773232457683584, "EFA": -0.11352744713692334, "EEM": -0.015243760603983206, "IEF": -0.021944089600238595, "TLT": 0.01357916457009763, "GLD": 0.06794675422728044, "SHY": 0.0012290509400306442 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.00179284234854666, "active_linking_residual": -2.1468937738688965e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3551576995489225, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.18642950479716225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4861193321117492, "IWM": 0.2035602932023193, "EFA": 0.2439984794275416, "EEM": 0.06744930729539783, "IEF": 0.05609348177914334, "TLT": 0.007894828137706287, "GLD": 0.2756232189103167, "SHY": 0.017072648997255614 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.28071687285262614, "IWM": 0.026598197362212694, "EFA": 0.030529857837421348, "EEM": 0.008476477169768973, "IEF": -0.002241358205747161, "TLT": 0.0021445626020996263, "GLD": 0.029500379806917193, "SHY": 0.0019331417952994107 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0026538903125349037, "active_linking_residual": -2.6728619317850644e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3327316929909525, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.20885551135513225, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.4837490516245933, "IWM": 0.23685338199297587, "EFA": 0.2510936537172181, "EEM": 0.0643991010258322, "IEF": 0.05300117426859076, "TLT": 0.010775725150410302, "GLD": 0.2137124187940069, "SHY": 0.02189654644361989 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.283087153339782, "IWM": 0.05989128615286926, "EFA": 0.037625032127097835, "EEM": 0.005426270900203339, "IEF": -0.005333665716299743, "TLT": 0.0050254596148036415, "GLD": -0.03241042030939262, "SHY": 0.006757039241663687 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002749360026310408, "active_linking_residual": -1.4765966227514582e-14 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.3971477411226063, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.14443946322347845, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48161496178994, "IWM": 0.261072142372408, "EFA": 0.2270395042779547, "EEM": 0.06988592082086303, "IEF": 0.03450083460267277, "TLT": 0.01822702333281722, "GLD": 0.27950647396631134, "SHY": 0.026601383405193146 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": -0.2852212431744353, "IWM": 0.08411004653230139, "EFA": 0.013570882687834435, "EEM": 0.010913090695234176, "IEF": -0.023834005382217735, "TLT": 0.01247675779721056, "GLD": 0.03338363486291182, "SHY": 0.011461876203236942 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0013005034455735955, "active_linking_residual": -1.887379141862766e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "portfolio_total_return": 1.4736427513444257, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": -0.06794445300165908, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.8782377521099625, "IWM": 0.20433129403518546, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.06593457657762311, "TLT": 0.006616170792757581, "GLD": 0.2795661983673561, "SHY": 0.0453601366330915 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.11140154714558714, "IWM": 0.027369198195078853, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": 0.007599736592732609, "TLT": 0.0008659052571509205, "GLD": 0.03344335926395656, "SHY": 0.030220629431135293 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.002717077171568892, "active_linking_residual": -1.7541523789077473e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8864011382453598, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.34481393389927506, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.1526664820313828, "IWM": 0.2782339990169149, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.011414971378958515, "TLT": 0.015310350500598388, "GLD": 0.38531643738215593, "SHY": 0.05034941270985426 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.38583027706700745, "IWM": 0.10127190317680831, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.04691986860593199, "TLT": 0.009560084964991727, "GLD": 0.1391935982787564, "SHY": 0.03520990550789806 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0032042147745298885, "active_linking_residual": -2.403632848313464e-14 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "portfolio_total_return": 1.8552913075712572, "benchmark_total_return": 1.5415872043460848, "active_total_return_difference": 0.3137041032251724, "linked_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 1.2481476443039528, "IWM": 0.2116089924038399, "EFA": -0.0017662, "EEM": -0.0019200999999999999, "IEF": 0.02687481813432769, "TLT": -0.013174583522867283, "GLD": 0.33512944518057103, "SHY": 0.051551689771457306 }, "linked_benchmark_pnl": { "SPY": 0.7668362049643753, "IWM": 0.1769620958401066, "EFA": 0.21346862159012026, "EEM": 0.05897283012562886, "IEF": 0.0583348399848905, "TLT": 0.005750265535606661, "GLD": 0.24612283910339952, "SHY": 0.015139507201956203 }, "linked_active_asset_pnl": { "SPY": 0.48131143933957743, "IWM": 0.03464689656373329, "EFA": -0.21523482159012025, "EEM": -0.06089293012562886, "IEF": -0.03146002185056281, "TLT": -0.01892484905847394, "GLD": 0.08900660607717151, "SHY": 0.0364121825695011 }, "linked_cost_contribution": -0.0011603987000471925, "active_linking_residual": -2.2093438190040615e-14 } ], "path_metrics": [ { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2534527.5118889455, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.7251450238364, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937491648, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443398159633, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.91031816316077, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333293485576, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333293485575, "gross_tracking_error": 0.00029188046117938397, "net_tracking_error": 0.0003382763175867321, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2534527.511788152, "total_cost_dollars": 2579.72514518495, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074938937132758, "net_volatility_pct": 10.239443397751147, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.910318163035914, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.736333294206085, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4736333294206085, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0002918804611750983, "net_tracking_error": 0.00033827631748173945, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "Unrestricted", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2592166.972254469, "total_cost_dollars": 1418.1814345258654, "net_cagr_pct": 8.278055274888473, "net_volatility_pct": 10.264858474154753, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.876602669912316, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.018367322597046, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8018367322597045, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0026890174767739685, "net_tracking_error": 0.0026908769036650755, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2421529.0136606907, "total_cost_dollars": 2465.788558221965, "net_cagr_pct": 7.66414756994378, "net_volatility_pct": 11.053462182390206, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.206540599329273, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.154101348160564, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4154101348160564, "gross_tracking_error": 0.017483985426599607, "net_tracking_error": 0.017487934445408203, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2257250.2943103286, "total_cost_dollars": 3009.6215721030917, "net_cagr_pct": 7.0344434049465, "net_volatility_pct": 10.132089336625588, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.82845883787783, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 18.230981810244234, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.8230981810244233, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01369081354202467, "net_tracking_error": 0.0136959883701921, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No gold", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2460093.160110683, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.2303683814444, "net_cagr_pct": 7.806281417925365, "net_volatility_pct": 10.345465700937543, "max_drawdown_pct": -23.463680010108632, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.245279826304215, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7245279826304216, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01638991450996628, "net_tracking_error": 0.016391365221518187, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2573257.6341082626, "total_cost_dollars": 2615.980667685637, "net_cagr_pct": 8.211880687061246, "net_volatility_pct": 9.948335432185358, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.384058134449457, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.840482471257662, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.484048247125766, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006896540607515067, "net_tracking_error": 0.006899257312340247, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2596148.3736569574, "total_cost_dollars": 2721.725660132361, "net_cagr_pct": 8.291932072733822, "net_volatility_pct": 10.275986214436822, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.648477286948765, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.424441064683341, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5424441064683345, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005534356093023667, "net_tracking_error": 0.005538848615810009, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No emerging markets", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2764294.6875762083, "total_cost_dollars": 1291.17436363583, "net_cagr_pct": 8.860883173242584, "net_volatility_pct": 10.383790774240824, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.7641075295292, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.98526215985455, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6985262159854552, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008310308266614781, "net_tracking_error": 0.00831057071417959, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2619814.4763898966, "total_cost_dollars": 2540.115715171641, "net_cagr_pct": 8.37401771217805, "net_volatility_pct": 10.787777603851199, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.42023290327093, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.548727854344262, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4548727854344266, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009477283264071847, "net_tracking_error": 0.009480108068439075, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2527573.740927939, "total_cost_dollars": 2735.780778149484, "net_cagr_pct": 8.050148949645951, "net_volatility_pct": 10.191537674214475, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.30977437040036, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.984895350513536, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5984895350513537, "gross_tracking_error": 0.0031022215109469307, "net_tracking_error": 0.003110157762711688, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "No long Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2622350.820924224, "total_cost_dollars": 1273.1660836868784, "net_cagr_pct": 8.382774636383239, "net_volatility_pct": 10.136833915287019, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.07614787143568, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.3016528964795295, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.730165289647953, "gross_tracking_error": 0.006147348356168236, "net_tracking_error": 0.006147780090621768, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 0, "interim_drift_days": 0, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2442025.432038852, "total_cost_dollars": 2565.1188506613207, "net_cagr_pct": 7.739946313529611, "net_volatility_pct": 9.701889541091797, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.078748407786343, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.969691486679517, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.4969691486679517, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005451189619556276, "net_tracking_error": 0.005454124611702307, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010193711139916906 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2507651.8336335984, "total_cost_dollars": 2612.136381724718, "net_cagr_pct": 7.978780304514177, "net_volatility_pct": 10.143856033417427, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.487965466335034, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.02722662948243, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.502722662948243, "gross_tracking_error": 0.001713756094063691, "net_tracking_error": 0.0017234442626589167, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1758, "interim_drift_days": 1758, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.010587574238425573 }, { "client": "10% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2610885.35281347, "total_cost_dollars": 1281.9992035222517, "net_cagr_pct": 8.343127276735697, "net_volatility_pct": 10.179424635254527, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.5337999584294, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.231921636538252, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7231921636538252, "gross_tracking_error": 0.004554987872259147, "net_tracking_error": 0.004555103262737129, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1007, "interim_drift_days": 1007, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.004017115753815109 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2264849.1831478206, "total_cost_dollars": 2512.137128590076, "net_cagr_pct": 7.064483837520963, "net_volatility_pct": 8.632867745291346, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.402700329190825, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.298221861329726, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5298221861329724, "gross_tracking_error": 0.016292042534525698, "net_tracking_error": 0.016293271272996023, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1754, "interim_drift_days": 1754, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.018329762362953278 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2454084.9607486255, "total_cost_dollars": 2884.966095369672, "net_cagr_pct": 7.784272196037412, "net_volatility_pct": 9.95832050282818, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.639016594008652, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.97997433376683, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6979974333766832, "gross_tracking_error": 0.005073109749382462, "net_tracking_error": 0.005077731436538761, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1759, "interim_drift_days": 1759, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020726017040199718 }, { "client": "20% short Treasuries", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2534469.6850721203, "total_cost_dollars": 1383.5407627684278, "net_cagr_pct": 8.074733043761562, "net_volatility_pct": 9.786474158072417, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.26758881878824, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 8.011177441127819, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.8011177441127819, "gross_tracking_error": 0.008763502823565444, "net_tracking_error": 0.00876368150033827, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1429, "interim_drift_days": 1429, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.020383408797257974 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2766515.3742002496, "total_cost_dollars": 2494.3864913779084, "net_cagr_pct": 8.868182726311469, "net_volatility_pct": 11.09114821546499, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.973579216855978, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 13.492952410652254, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.3492952410652255, "gross_tracking_error": 0.012355103418200453, "net_tracking_error": 0.012357530954334417, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1061, "interim_drift_days": 1061, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.047577931904168924 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2753425.665428194, "total_cost_dollars": 2731.5352069996184, "net_cagr_pct": 8.82507822311438, "net_volatility_pct": 10.393331716965967, "max_drawdown_pct": -21.645338468761565, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 14.749997684823562, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.474999768482356, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325890547288934, "net_tracking_error": 0.007327831704996808, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1080, "interim_drift_days": 1080, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05463820796388413 }, { "client": "Retain 40% US large cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2806257.778669182, "total_cost_dollars": 1219.839033098505, "net_cagr_pct": 8.997918890476608, "net_volatility_pct": 10.470418996664609, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.030126011111328, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.499750216974312, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6499750216974312, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009673029231131135, "net_tracking_error": 0.0096727673701935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 121, "interim_drift_days": 121, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.05659163895288705 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2561901.792171226, "total_cost_dollars": 2687.63333478253, "net_cagr_pct": 8.171925591663353, "net_volatility_pct": 11.282622147723925, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.83797932831957, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.220630966173843, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5220630966173845, "gross_tracking_error": 0.015422547563953963, "net_tracking_error": 0.01542511523016283, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1369, "interim_drift_days": 1369, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.038709111864673074 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2414794.6780097135, "total_cost_dollars": 3018.730504402243, "net_cagr_pct": 7.63911464526299, "net_volatility_pct": 10.468382463722365, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.22038401558595, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 17.735984999923836, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.773598499992384, "gross_tracking_error": 0.011005791944861298, "net_tracking_error": 0.011009155480500807, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1350, "interim_drift_days": 1350, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.0414325483934713 }, { "client": "20% US small-cap floor", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2625873.2193304673, "total_cost_dollars": 1792.84234854666, "net_cagr_pct": 8.394923120198161, "net_volatility_pct": 10.712113052015038, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.651170591581817, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 9.792186561612723, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.9792186561612721, "gross_tracking_error": 0.013607185032656156, "net_tracking_error": 0.013608391748226742, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1095, "interim_drift_days": 1095, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04212962747898383 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2355157.6995489225, "total_cost_dollars": 2653.890312534904, "net_cagr_pct": 7.414596054728229, "net_volatility_pct": 9.766100371722036, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.084719289010902, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.98335943519397, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.598335943519397, "gross_tracking_error": 0.010151679973244638, "net_tracking_error": 0.010151771715024993, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2535, "interim_drift_days": 2535, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.04213973834163309 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2332731.6929909526, "total_cost_dollars": 2749.360026310408, "net_cagr_pct": 7.32881743849314, "net_volatility_pct": 10.135137347566532, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.247207433551143, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.487839602504653, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6487839602504653, "gross_tracking_error": 0.007325021777711064, "net_tracking_error": 0.0073277626421223135, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 2336, "interim_drift_days": 2336, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.040852005830701005 }, { "client": "20% position cap", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2397147.741122606, "total_cost_dollars": 1300.5034455735956, "net_cagr_pct": 7.573212539293883, "net_volatility_pct": 10.139199394542597, "max_drawdown_pct": -22.623771519109546, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 7.880926065371353, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.7880926065371353, "gross_tracking_error": 0.009916912693656478, "net_tracking_error": 0.009917532235428891, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1292, "interim_drift_days": 1292, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.015184946330196819 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Proportional", "terminal_nav": 2473642.7513444256, "total_cost_dollars": 2717.077171568892, "net_cagr_pct": 7.855735978502798, "net_volatility_pct": 8.313609735955612, "max_drawdown_pct": -18.725081307824667, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 15.555569824404078, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.5555569824404079, "gross_tracking_error": 0.02682463660801744, "net_tracking_error": 0.026825133926513825, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1790, "interim_drift_days": 1790, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.01430184990891703 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Minimum risk", "terminal_nav": 2886401.13824536, "total_cost_dollars": 3204.2147745298885, "net_cagr_pct": 9.254497969836661, "net_volatility_pct": 10.039978981292881, "max_drawdown_pct": -19.446739380149726, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 16.96507706803343, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 1.6965077068033436, "gross_tracking_error": 0.01730102880761127, "net_tracking_error": 0.017302151848603935, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 1799, "interim_drift_days": 1799, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.017031460688173655 }, { "client": "Domestic and liquid", "method": "Lower turnover", "terminal_nav": 2855291.307571257, "total_cost_dollars": 1160.3987000471925, "net_cagr_pct": 9.155684504757811, "net_volatility_pct": 10.28890859578624, "max_drawdown_pct": -20.11036359163676, "annual_one_way_turnover_pct": 6.185531783434095, "annual_incurred_cost_bps": 0.6185531783434094, "gross_tracking_error": 0.019221518589753548, "net_tracking_error": 0.01922204994098753, "all_days_weight_limits_drifted": 957, "interim_drift_days": 957, "maximum_interim_bound_drift": 0.005629091773254852 } ], "linking_method": "Initial-capital-scaled realized dollar P&L; sum asset gains/V0 plus negative costs/V0 equals cumulative portfolio return. Subtract analogous benchmark contributions for exact cumulative wealth-return difference. Not Brinson, factor attribution, or a separate cost-free portfolio." }, "blockers": [ "sql_funding_error", "sql_signed_trade_error", "sql_fee_error", "sql_daily_fee_error", "trade_cost_formula" ], "corrected_retest": "PASS", "closure": "CLOSED_TEST_CASE" } ], "injected_case_count": 5, "detected_case_count": 5, "corrected_retest_status": "PASS", "original_inputs_unchanged": true, "scope": "Controlled fault-injection experiments, not real production incidents. Original files never modified." }