{ "surface_drift": null, "probes": [ { "probe_id": 1, "name": "issuer-identity", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 200, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"issuer\": \"https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/\"}", "body_sha256": "17c5c50b4f16c828e1a10443a511b9a3de17d2e00e498d77b6ca948574682c0c", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "issuer=https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/ base_url=https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/.well-known/oauth-authorization-server" }, { "probe_id": 2, "name": "resource-binding", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 200, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"resource\": \"https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp\"}", "body_sha256": "bbad3205ae680f10a9a6f7e601abd9a6b8cce1ec9ba6321423def8147d6c3774", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "resource=https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp mcp_url=https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp" }, { "probe_id": 12, "name": "resource-authservers", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 200, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"authorization_servers\": [\"https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/\"]}", "body_sha256": "305039c7c88c46fb25a92cb77488df7f4917e23ac5aac58043f1c83c91f1bfe4", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "authorization_servers=https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp" }, { "probe_id": 3, "name": "token-cache-control", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 401, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_client\", \"error_description\": \"Missing client_id\"}", "body_sha256": "c2d4d45161409253ed1a9e2914b5e229b3b7934c5ad1e1a5708fa6314d3233fa", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "Cache-Control: no-store", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/token" }, { "probe_id": 4, "name": "token-cors", "status": "NOT_OBSERVED", "http_status": 400, "headers_observed": { "content-type": "application/json", "connection": "close", "horizon-target-region": "us-east-1", "cache-control": "no-store", "pragma": "no-cache", "access-control-allow-origin": "*", "vary": "Origin", "horizon-request-id": "01a1fdd9-ab22-7440-82c8-711095597c53", "x-amz-cf-pop": "ATL59-P15", "x-amz-cf-id": "ekKsqfz9X5RxqRdEqAIxurUCkodJk7mKTcas2Bbng0BYkqTjPN2-xw==" }, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_request\", \"error_description\": \": Input tag 'client_credentials' found using 'grant_type' does not match any of the expected tags: 'authorization_code', 'refresh_token', 'urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:jwt-bearer'\"}", "body_sha256": "7b17db2832b16d8ea4e4a50580a79ce8a9400510de02bc381cef0a0099441a25", "prerequisites": [ "token_endpoint" ], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "HTTP 400; CORS not judged, only a 2xx token response is read", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/token" }, { "probe_id": 5, "name": "jwks-keys", "status": "EXCLUDED", "http_status": null, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "", "body_sha256": null, "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": "No JWKS endpoint", "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": null, "severity": null, "endpoint": null }, { "probe_id": 6, "name": "password-grant", "status": "NOT_OBSERVED", "http_status": 400, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_request\", \"error_description\": \": Input tag 'password' found using 'grant_type' does not match any of the expected tags: 'authorization_code', 'refresh_token', 'urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:jwt-bearer'\"}", "body_sha256": "83d902ca8323ba2b1908067d48193ec654bcd9634cdb2258b13896b2069dba18", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "Error invalid_request does not say the password grant is refused (only unsupported_grant_type does), so the grant type was never evaluated", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/token" }, { "probe_id": 7, "name": "pkce-s256", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 302, "headers_observed": { "location": "http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback?error=invalid_request&error_description=code_challenge_method%3A+Input+should+be+%27S256%27" }, "body_excerpt": "", "body_sha256": null, "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "PKCE required and S256 the only accepted method: A (no code_challenge): refused, HTTP 302, Location http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback?error=invalid_request&error_description=code_challenge%3A+Field+required (error=invalid_request); B (S256): proceeded, HTTP 302, Location http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback?code=[redacted] (the redirect_uri sent); C (plain): refused, HTTP 302, Location http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback?error=invalid_request&error_description=code_challenge_method%3A+Input+should+be+%27S256%27 (error=invalid_request)", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/authorize" }, { "probe_id": 8, "name": "redirect-uri-exact", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 400, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_request\", \"error_description\": \"Redirect URI 'http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callbackx' not registered for client\"}", "body_sha256": "54a544f74b1cd34492ec7c24747d105e980e4b29475b749c634a72716694d5d5", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "Exact redirect_uri match enforced: P (registered redirect_uri): proceeded, HTTP 302, Location http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback?code=[redacted] (the redirect_uri sent); N (http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callbackx): refused, HTTP 400, error=invalid_request", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/authorize" }, { "probe_id": 9, "name": "client-auth", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 401, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_client\", \"error_description\": \"Missing client_id\"}", "body_sha256": "c2d4d45161409253ed1a9e2914b5e229b3b7934c5ad1e1a5708fa6314d3233fa", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "Error: invalid_client", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/token" }, { "probe_id": 11, "name": "token-audience", "status": "PASS", "http_status": 400, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "{\"error\": \"invalid_request\", \"error_description\": \": Input tag 'client_credentials' found using 'grant_type' does not match any of the expected tags: 'authorization_code', 'refresh_token', 'urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:jwt-bearer'\"}", "body_sha256": "7b17db2832b16d8ea4e4a50580a79ce8a9400510de02bc381cef0a0099441a25", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": null, "probe_class": "authserver", "detail": "Refused a token for a resource it does not serve (invalid_request)", "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/token" }, { "probe_id": 13, "name": "cross-origin read on the MCP endpoint", "status": "EXCLUDED", "http_status": 401, "headers_observed": { "connection": "close", "access-control-expose-headers": "horizon-request-id", "www-authenticate": "Bearer resource_metadata=\"https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/.well-known/oauth-protected-resource/mcp\"", "horizon-request-id": "01a1fdd9-a5aa-768b-9ddd-c832e7c2b936", "horizon-target-region": "us-east-1", "access-control-allow-origin": "*", "x-amz-cf-pop": "ATL59-P15", "x-amz-cf-id": "kZYQVrSiTSfUH5GYDkgdeWpI7kTyQ0zTjAryC49TdcfSWEM5hCfmvA==" }, "body_excerpt": "", "body_sha256": null, "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": "credential-free response needed; HTTP 401 requires one", "probe_class": null, "detail": null, "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp" }, { "probe_id": 14, "name": "rate limiting on the endpoint", "status": "EXCLUDED", "http_status": null, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "", "body_sha256": null, "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": true, "limitation": "no authorised request budget supplied, so no request was sent", "probe_class": null, "detail": null, "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp" }, { "probe_id": 15, "name": "alternate transport on the same host", "status": "EXCLUDED", "http_status": 404, "headers_observed": {}, "body_excerpt": "Not Found", "body_sha256": "0019dfc4b32d63c1392aa264aed2253c1e0c2fb09216f8e2cc269bbfb8bb49b5", "prerequisites": [], "prerequisite_met": false, "limitation": "sibling transport answered 404", "probe_class": null, "detail": null, "severity": null, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp" } ], "target": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp", "scan_mode": "LIVE_ENDPOINT_ASSESSMENT", "discovery_status": null, "probe_set_version": "2026.11.19.3", "severity_calibration_version": null, "owasp_mapping_version": "2026.11.02.1", "findings_count": 0, "findings": [], "authorization": { "authorized_by": "Lonnie Van Zandt", "date": "2026-11-21", "basis": "written authorization 2026-11-11, publication permitted", "contact": "lhmisme2011@gmail.com", "assessed_by": "Leroy H. Mason" }, "counts": { "in_scope": 14, "attempted": 10, "PASS": 8, "FAIL": 0, "NOT_OBSERVED": 2, "EXCLUDED": 4, "NOT_IMPLEMENTED": 0 }, "coverage": 0.8, "completed": true, "not_implemented": [], "excluded": [ { "name": "jwks-keys", "reason": "No JWKS endpoint" }, { "name": "cross-origin read on the MCP endpoint", "reason": "credential-free response needed; HTTP 401 requires one" }, { "name": "rate limiting on the endpoint", "reason": "no authorised request budget supplied, so no request was sent" }, { "name": "alternate transport on the same host", "reason": "sibling transport answered 404" } ], "scope": "OAuth authorization server configuration for https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp", "not_tested": [ "MCP resource endpoint behavior (only OAuth server configuration assessed via RFC 9728 \u2192 RFC 8414 discovery)", "Source code review and design patterns", "Dependency vulnerabilities (CVE check)", "Secrets in repository history", "Comments and documentation", "Rate limiting (excluded): no authorised request budget supplied, so no request was sent" ], "content_observed": { "version": "2026.11.03.1", "inspected": {}, "reasons": [ "session not established: initialize returned HTTP 401" ] }, "exit_contract": "2026.11.02.4", "hash_scheme": "verdict-v3", "run_started_at": "2026-11-21T11:24:20+00:00", "exit_condition": "not_observed_present", "exit_code": 5, "fail_on": "high", "schema_version": 3, "status": "completed", "total_checks": 14, "severity_counts": { "CRITICAL": 0, "HIGH": 0, "MEDIUM": 0, "LOW": 0, "INFO": 0 }, "report_hash": "80e4cd495e464126a534004eb53cbb064764107bce8c7e47311ac5e2e8f92233", "hash_covers": [ "coverage", "findings", "findings_count", "probe_set_version", "severity_counts", "status", "target", "total_checks" ], "evidence": { "scheme": "evidence-binding-v3", "states": [ { "access_class": "anonymous", "state_id": "f91b3009b031cd660ff79f978b7b6c5ac0b85530ff93e55b2c173f9cdd743f52", "ledger": "tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app-0310e6c2fbb016a7/anonymous.jsonl", "ledger_head": "f91b3009b031cd660ff79f978b7b6c5ac0b85530ff93e55b2c173f9cdd743f52", "prior_row": { "access_class": "anonymous", "instructions_digest": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "previous_state_id": null, "prompts": [], "record": { "attestation": { "alg": "ed25519", "key_id": "9b79936f975f9770b3840dbd45f93d2bb23d1bd2cc3d7d81d092e5cd41926e9d", "value": "QT_fn9ZUzNtSO9FjnSUrwRlLNygVqEWE1bNgS0pq5QE6Ewd4avYZwffi11c1ZMwGD439uRZGKmGlxLXF5KpEBg" }, "observed_at": { "end": "2026-11-21T11:20:52Z", "start": "2026-11-21T11:20:43Z" }, "report_hash": "80e4cd495e464126a534004eb53cbb064764107bce8c7e47311ac5e2e8f92233" }, "resources": [], "state_id": "f91b3009b031cd660ff79f978b7b6c5ac0b85530ff93e55b2c173f9cdd743f52", "state_version": "1", "surface_digest": "e498b97c37656b596d8b93bc1fb01bfa568ae69f61435908d643dc6cb386a256", "tools": [] } } ] }, "provenance": { "tool_version": "1.1.34", "tool_manifest": "2728cc99fbf3b118b5e759dfcb99129c90a5468433137ccd50551963e4a4cba1" }, "sig_version": 3, "key_id": "9b79936f975f9770b3840dbd45f93d2bb23d1bd2cc3d7d81d092e5cd41926e9d", "signature": { "alg": "ed25519", "key_id": "9b79936f975f9770b3840dbd45f93d2bb23d1bd2cc3d7d81d092e5cd41926e9d", "value": "iYPluuOojUvG50ZCJ_rjnKHNwQ4qqcDRWswAC17nw6_vDNJJhWiqdQoH1qE-V42eCmZPcKsqCilqkR8FdVFrBA" }, "client_registration": [ { "authorization_server": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app", "client_registered": true, "registration": "HTTP 201, client_id 680dffa2-67ad-4111-b2a2-f0ec5e2bb795", "client_source": "registered", "client_id": "680dffa2-67ad-4111-b2a2-f0ec5e2bb795", "credential_grant_client_source": "registered", "redirect_uri": "http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback", "client_removal": "client removal is out of scope for this tool: client_id 680dffa2-67ad-4111-b2a2-f0ec5e2bb795 registered at https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app by this run was not removed", "client_deleted": false, "registered_client_id": "680dffa2-67ad-4111-b2a2-f0ec5e2bb795", "redirect_candidates_tried": [ { "redirect_uri": "http://localhost/mcp-authscan/callback", "result": "accepted, HTTP 201" } ], "token_revocation": null, "token_revocation_unconfirmed": null, "token_types_unconfirmed": [] } ], "tools_digest": { "captured": false, "endpoint": "https://tollbooth-authority.fastmcp.app/mcp", "phase": "initialize", "reason": "initialize returned HTTP 401", "http_status": 401 } }