{"mechanical":{"counts":{"distinct_dead_targets":2152,"dead_citation_occurrences":5734,"documents_affected":4621,"dead_citations":5734,"corpus_gap_not_ingested":427,"lapsed_but_current":75,"rule_predates_statute_amendment":4603,"malformed_citations":50},"note":"Conflict candidates decidable BY CODE — no model involved. A hand-labelled taxonomy of the 137 frontier-pilot candidates found 29% of them were of these four deterministic types, and a regex finds far more of them than the models did: the pilot reported 21 dead citations in total, this scan finds 2,152 DISTINCT dead targets, cited 5,734 times across 4,621 documents. READ THE DISTINCT COUNT, NOT THE OCCURRENCES: they differ by ~2.7x because a single repealed section is cited by many rules — ORS 184.616 alone is cited by 727 of them. Occurrences are the blast radius; distinct targets are the number of things to actually resolve, and they are heavily concentrated, so the top handful clear thousands of documents. The magnitude is expected: Oregon has renumbered wholesale (ORS 181 to 181A in 2015, ORS 279 split into 279A/B/C in 2003, the 2015 higher-education restructuring), and every rule written before those still cites the old numbers. A decades-spanning corpus of 36,953 rules showing NO stale citations would be the surprising result. Verified against the live source: six sampled flagged sections were all genuinely absent, and a live control section was correctly not flagged. Everything here is a CANDIDATE, not a finding, and not legally reviewed. The model's budget belongs on the other 71% — what a rule omits, adds without authority, or redefines — which SYSTEM_V3 enumerates and which explicitly disqualifies these four types so the two passes do not overlap.","by_cause":{"chapter_absent":70,"oar_unclassified":1646,"renumbered_or_repealed":4018},"cause_meanings":{"renumbered_or_repealed":"the chapter is current, but this section has left its table of contents","chapter_absent":"no such ORS chapter page exists upstream","oar_unclassified":"an OAR-to-OAR citation that did not resolve"},"corpus_gap_note":"427 citations point at ORS sections that ARE catalogued upstream but have no document here. That is this corpus's ingestion gap, not a defect in the rule, and is counted separately so it is never reported as an agency's citation error.","most_cited":[{"cites":"ORS 184.616","cited_by_rules":727},{"cites":"ORS 192.410","cited_by_rules":158},{"cites":"ORS 181.534","cited_by_rules":102},{"cites":"ORS 480.110","cited_by_rules":84},{"cites":"ORS 192.440","cited_by_rules":56},{"cites":"ORS 342.950","cited_by_rules":41},{"cites":"ORS 192.430","cited_by_rules":40},{"cites":"ORS 79.0526","cited_by_rules":38},{"cites":"ORS 192.501","cited_by_rules":36},{"cites":"ORS 391.800","cited_by_rules":36}],"scanned_rules":36953},"retrieved":"2026-07-23","note":"CURATED, AI-ASSISTED, NOT mechanically derived and NOT legally reviewed. Produced by an exploratory pilot (2026-07-22, extended 2026-07-23): for each ORS chapter with 2+ agencies implementing it via OAR rules (the shared-authority set already computed in _meta/agency-graph.json), an LLM read the chapter's cited statute text plus every implementing rule's full text in one pass and was asked to identify CANDIDATE inconsistencies — never to assert that a conflict exists. Every candidate below carries the exact document IDs and quoted text it is based on; nothing here should be read as a legal finding. See git history for the retired BACKLOG.md \"Visualization\" section for the method note and docs/mcp.md-style disclaimers used elsewhere in this repo. This file is a snapshot of three runs over 60 distinct chapters (of 245 in the full shared-authority set), not an exhaustive or automatically-refreshed corpus scan — rerunning the pilot over the same or different chapters could surface different candidates. 13 chapters were re-analyzed a second time (batch 2, cheaper model) and a third time (batch 3, back to Sonnet) after a real model-quality gap surfaced between batches — see per-chapter notes.\nFOURTH RUN (2026-07-31, run_id haiku-scan-2026-07-31): a section-scoped screening pass, unlike the three chapter-scoped pilot batches above. 191 ORS sections across 72 chapters were screened, each by a separate Haiku agent reading one statute section plus only the rules that cite it as authority — not the whole chapter. Chapter entries from this run therefore carry a `sections_reviewed` list, and the chapter as a whole is NOT covered: a chapter appearing below may have hundreds of unscreened sections. This run was a partial sweep that stopped early at 191 of 1,850 queued units when the session hit its agent limit; units were ordered so that all 115 sections implemented by two or more different agencies were screened first, and that tier is complete. Every quote was mechanically checked against the cited document before merging: 109 candidates were proposed, 33 were DROPPED for quotes that do not appear in the document they cite (some fabricated outright, some real text with an edited tail), and 76 were kept. `type` was not elicited by this run's prompt and is null throughout; `confidence` and `severity` are the model's own graded self- assessment and are not a measure of correctness.\n","methodology":"Per chapter: pull every ORS section cited as authority by an implementing OAR rule in that chapter, plus the full text of every one of those rules (source: _meta/graph.json implements/implemented_by edges). Give the whole cluster to an LLM in one pass (not pairwise) and ask for candidate inconsistencies with quotes and citations, near-misses that looked like conflicts but resolved as non-issues on careful reading, and any citation-metadata artifacts noticed along the way. Batch 1 (2026-07-22, 12 chapters, Sonnet): 3 chosen for moderate agency count + high staleness lag (801, 819, 435 — zero candidates found), then 9 more chosen the same way (215, 408, 270, 646, 169, 283, 291, 820, 813 — ~15 candidates found). Batch 2 (2026-07-23, 20 chapters — the same 12 re-run plus 8 new: 163, 163A, 166, 167, 419A, 814, 244, 419C — Haiku, for cost control at high monthly token usage): re-running the original 12 after corpus data-quality fixes surfaced a real recall gap between models — the cheaper model found zero candidates on 813/820, where batch 1 had flagged some. Batch 3 (2026-07-23, 53 chapters — the same 13 chapters batch 2 touched, re-run a third time on Sonnet, plus 40 brand-new chapters — all Sonnet, after confirming the cheaper model materially undercounted): batch 3 supersedes batch 2 for all 13 overlapping chapters (those chapter entries below are the batch-3/Sonnet version; batch-2/Haiku findings for the same chapters are noted inline where the two runs disagreed rather than kept as separate entries). Batch 3 found dramatically more candidates than batch 2 on the same chapters (roughly 3x), confirming the recall gap was real and not chapter-specific. Selection for the 40 new chapters in batch 3: the 40 smallest-by-implementing-rule-count chapters remaining in the shared-authority set, to bound token cost while extending coverage — this biases the sample toward simpler/narrower regulatory domains, so treat the batch-3 \"clean chapter\" rate as not necessarily representative of larger chapters.\n","n_chapters":172,"n_clean_chapters":33,"n_candidates":1398,"n_artifacts":101,"n_docs_verified":2954,"n_quotes_grounded":2591,"n_quotes_absence_claim":34,"n_quotes_ungrounded":129,"n_candidates_citing_repealed":10,"schema_version":2,"triage_counts":{"unreviewed":1398,"confirmed":0,"dismissed":0},"severity_counts":{"ungraded":1325,"low":16,"medium":49,"high":8},"all_agencies":[{"slug":"board-of-chiropractic-examiners","name":"Board of Chiropractic Examiners","chapters":3},{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-engineering-and-land-surveying","name":"Board of Examiners for Engineering and Land Surveying","chapters":2},{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology","chapters":7},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners","chapters":8},{"slug":"board-of-licensed-social-workers","name":"Board of Licensed Social Workers","chapters":1},{"slug":"board-of-massage-therapists","name":"Board of Massage Therapists","chapters":3},{"slug":"board-of-medical-imaging","name":"Board of Medical Imaging","chapters":4},{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing","chapters":6},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry","chapters":8},{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision","chapters":7},{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy","chapters":5},{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries","chapters":12},{"slug":"chief-education-office","name":"Chief Education Office","chapters":1},{"slug":"citizens-initiative-review-commission","name":"Citizens' Initiative Review Commission","chapters":1},{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind","chapters":5},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board","chapters":15},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services","chapters":29},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office","chapters":6},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office","chapters":5},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-office-of-the-state-chief-information-officer","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Office of the State Chief Information Officer","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture","chapters":15},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-albacore-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Albacore Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-alfalfa-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Alfalfa Seed Commission","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Beef Council","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Blueberry Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-clover-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Clover Seed Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-dairy-products-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Dairy Products Commission","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-dungeness-crab-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Dungeness Crab Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-fine-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Fine Fescue Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hazelnut Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hop Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-invasive-species-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Invasive Species Council","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-mint-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Mint Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-potato-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Potato Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-processed-vegetable-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Processed Vegetable Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-ryegrass-growers-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Ryegrass Growers Seed Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-salmon-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Salmon Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sheep-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sheep Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Strawberry Commission","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sweet-cherry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sweet Cherry Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-tall-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Tall Fescue Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-trawl-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Trawl Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Wheat Commission","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division","chapters":14},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office","chapters":7},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation","chapters":7},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-health-insurance-marketplace","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Health Insurance Marketplace","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation","chapters":9},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-oregon-occupational-safety-and-health-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Board","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division","chapters":9},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections","chapters":24},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy","chapters":7},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council","chapters":5},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality","chapters":16},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife","chapters":9},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry","chapters":9},{"slug":"department-of-geology-and-mineral-industries","name":"Department of Geology and Mineral Industries","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services","chapters":13},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities","chapters":20},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs","chapters":17},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-home-care-commission","name":"Department of Human Services, Home Care Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs","chapters":20},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-vocational-rehabilitation-services","name":"Department of Human Services, Vocational Rehabilitation Services","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice","chapters":32},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training","chapters":6},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue","chapters":25},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands","chapters":6},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands-south-slough-national-estuarine-research-reserve","name":"Department of State Lands, South Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve","chapters":1},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police","chapters":12},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","name":"Department of State Police, Office of State Fire Marshal","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-oregon-state-athletic-commission","name":"Department of State Police, Oregon State Athletic Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation","chapters":13},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division","chapters":22},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division","chapters":12},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division","chapters":9},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-public-transit-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Public Transit Division","chapters":2},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-rail-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Rail Division","chapters":4},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division","chapters":6},{"slug":"department-of-veterans-affairs","name":"Department of Veterans' Affairs","chapters":4},{"slug":"eastern-oregon-border-economic-development-board","name":"Eastern Oregon Border Economic Development Board","chapters":1},{"slug":"economic-recovery-review-council","name":"Economic Recovery Review Council","chapters":1},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department","chapters":7},{"slug":"employment-relations-board","name":"Employment Relations Board","chapters":3},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission","chapters":11},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development","chapters":11},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Degree Authorization","chapters":3},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Student Access and Completion","chapters":4},{"slug":"judicial-department","name":"Judicial Department","chapters":2},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department","chapters":7},{"slug":"land-use-board-of-appeals","name":"Land Use Board of Appeals","chapters":1},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board","chapters":7},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board","chapters":8},{"slug":"legislative-administration-committee","name":"Legislative Administration Committee","chapters":1},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Licensed Professional Counselors and Therapists","chapters":4},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology","chapters":7},{"slug":"mortuary-and-cemetery-board","name":"Mortuary and Cemetery Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board","chapters":5},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety","chapters":9},{"slug":"oregon-529-savings-board","name":"Oregon 529 Savings Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-accountancy","name":"Oregon Board of Accountancy","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry","chapters":6},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-naturopathic-medicine","name":"Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-physical-therapy","name":"Oregon Board of Physical Therapy","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department","chapters":15},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission","chapters":13},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation","chapters":5},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education","chapters":14},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Early Learning Division","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-fair-dismissal-appeals-board","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Fair Dismissal Appeals Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division","chapters":5},{"slug":"oregon-facilities-authority","name":"Oregon Facilities Authority","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-film-and-video-office","name":"Oregon Film and Video Office","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-forest-resources-institute","name":"Oregon Forest Resources Institute","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-government-ethics-commission","name":"Oregon Government Ethics Commission","chapters":4},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority","chapters":13},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority Equity and Inclusion Division","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office","chapters":14},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-behavior-analysis-regulatory-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Behavior Analysis Regulatory Board","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Certified Advanced Estheticians","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-cosmetology","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Cosmetology","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-direct-entry-midwifery","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Direct Entry Midwifery","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-licensed-dietitians","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Licensed Dietitians","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-environmental-health-registration-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Environmental Health Registration Board","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-long-term-care-administrators-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Long Term Care Administrators Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics","chapters":7},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services","chapters":7},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services","chapters":13},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs","chapters":10},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-oregon-prescription-drug-program","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Oregon Prescription Drug Program","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board","chapters":5},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division","chapters":28},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department","chapters":18},{"slug":"oregon-liquor-control-commission","name":"Oregon Liquor Control Commission","chapters":4},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board","chapters":15},{"slug":"oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management","name":"Oregon Military Department, Office of Emergency Management","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-patient-safety-commission","name":"Oregon Patient Safety Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System","chapters":7},{"slug":"oregon-racing-commission","name":"Oregon Racing Commission","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-state-library","name":"Oregon State Library","chapters":3},{"slug":"oregon-state-lottery","name":"Oregon State Lottery","chapters":4},{"slug":"oregon-state-marine-board","name":"Oregon State Marine Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury","chapters":9},{"slug":"oregon-tourism-commission","name":"Oregon Tourism Commission","chapters":2},{"slug":"oregon-utility-notification-center","name":"Oregon Utility Notification Center","chapters":1},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority","chapters":10},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department","chapters":20},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board","chapters":9},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission","chapters":8},{"slug":"public-utility-commission-oregon-board-of-maritime-pilots","name":"Public Utility Commission, Oregon Board of Maritime Pilots","chapters":2},{"slug":"real-estate-agency","name":"Real Estate Agency","chapters":3},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-archives-division","name":"Secretary of State, Archives Division","chapters":3},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-audits-division","name":"Secretary of State, Audits Division","chapters":1},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-business-services-division","name":"Secretary of State, Business Services Division","chapters":3},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division","chapters":6},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division","chapters":6},{"slug":"state-board-of-architect-examiners","name":"State Board of Architect Examiners","chapters":1},{"slug":"teacher-standards-and-practices-commission","name":"Teacher Standards and Practices Commission","chapters":3},{"slug":"travel-information-council","name":"Travel Information Council","chapters":4},{"slug":"veterinary-medical-examining-board","name":"Veterinary Medical Examining Board","chapters":2},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department","chapters":9}],"chapters":[{"ors_chapter":"105","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[{"summary":"A state-parks rule categorically declares daily parking fees 'not a Charge' for recreational-immunity purposes regardless of amount, though the statute's exemption is capped at $15/day and a fee above that arguably should count as a Charge.","documents":[{"id":"ors-105.672","citation":"ORS 105.672(1)(c)","quote":"'Charge' ... does not include the fee for a winter recreation parking permit or any other parking fee of $15 or less per day.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-015-0030","citation":"OAR 736-015-0030(1) & (3)(a)","quote":"This charge is a parking fee and not a charge for recreational purposes under ORS 105.672... [fee schedule: Daily Motor Vehicle — $7-25, plus a 25% non-resident surcharge]","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Defensible counter-reading: the rule may assert a categorical (not amount-based) distinction between parking access and recreational-use fees.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"546746b0d92ba160","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]}],"artifacts":["ors-105.672 title truncated (\"Definitions for ORS 105.672 to\")."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"106","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[],"note":"No genuine statute-vs-rule content conflicts — the ORS 106 sections here are short and largely non-substantive as authority citations for unrelated APD/well-driller rules.","artifacts":["oar-411-049-0102 cites ORS 106.010 in statutes_implemented with no supporting textual link anywhere in its 105-entry AFH definitions text.","Same rule's legal_authority/statutes_implemented/relationships.implements three-way disagree on whether the target is ORS 441.111 or ORS 441.122."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"107","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":17,"candidates":[{"summary":"Two DOJ child-support rules implementing the same statute define 'substantial compliance' two contradictory ways — a pure time trigger vs. a pure dollar/percentage variance test.","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-055-3420","citation":"OAR 137-055-3420(3)","quote":"a child support order is not in substantial compliance with the guidelines if it has been more than 35 months since the order took effect.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-3430","citation":"OAR 137-055-3430(1)","quote":"'Substantial compliance' means that the difference between the existing support order and the amount calculated using current guidelines is not greater than $50 or 15% of the current guideline amount, whichever is less.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"An order reviewed at month 40 with only a $10 delta is non-compliant under one rule but compliant under the other.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ab8734525bced754","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"A rule narrows the statutory 'child attending school' definition by adding a military-service exclusion the statute's four-part test doesn't contain.","documents":[{"id":"ors-107.108","citation":"ORS 107.108(1)(a)","quote":"'Child attending school' means a child of the parties who: (A) Is unmarried; (B) Is 18 ... and under 21 ...; (C) Is making satisfactory academic progress...; and (D) Has a course load ...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-5110","citation":"OAR 137-055-5110(1)(c)","quote":"'Child attending school' has the meaning given in ORS 107.108, except a child attending school does not include an active member of the military.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"51123b719ea0b60d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The same rule collapses the statute's two distinct reinstatement pathways (non-IV-D vs. IV-D cases, with different recipients of confirmation) into one standard, and adds a case-closure precondition the statute doesn't authorize.","documents":[{"id":"ors-107.108","citation":"ORS 107.108(9)(a)-(b)","quote":"(a) If services are not being provided under ORS 25.080, effective on the date the parent receives written confirmation... (b) If services are being provided under ORS 25.080, effective on the date the department receives written confirmation...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-5110","citation":"OAR 137-055-5110(9)","quote":"reinstated when the program receives the following: ... (c) If the case has been closed pursuant to OAR 137-055-1120, an application for services...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"55bf405f774365a9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"artifacts":["Eight OYA rules (416-100-0000 through -0060) are status:current but each shows \"repeal filed 01/03/2022, effective 01/03/2022\" with no operative text, while still listed in ors-107.108's implemented_by."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"}]},{"ors_chapter":"113","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DHS rule attaches the statute's death-record-copy requirement only to ORS 114.456 notices, not to the parallel ORS 113.145 notices the statute itself requires it for.","documents":[{"id":"ors-113.145","citation":"ORS 113.145(6)","quote":"the personal representative must mail or deliver the information specified in subsection (1) of this section and a copy of the death record of the decedent to [DHS/OHA]...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-135-0834","citation":"OAR 461-135-0834(1)-(2)","quote":"(1) [113.145 notices — no death-record requirement stated] ... (2) A person required by ORS 114.456 ... must also include a copy of the decedent's long form death record...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6c3d8ff37f76427b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"A DHS rule (OAR 461-135-0838, single 1991 filing, never amended) cites ORS 113.145 as authority though the statute has been amended 9 times since, including 2017.","documents":[{"id":"ors-113.145","citation":"ORS 113.145, last_amended 2017","quote":"[... 2017 c.169 §50]","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-461-135-0838","citation":"OAR 461-135-0838, effective 1991-07-01","quote":"History: AFS 13-1991, f. & cert. ef. 7-1-91 (only entry)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a5c056efb61a0b66","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]}],"artifacts":["oar-461-135-0838's relationships.implements lists ors-113.145, but the rule's own \"Statutes/Other Implemented\" line omits it — 113.145 only appears in the rule's authority line."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"}]},{"ors_chapter":"125","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":8,"candidates":[{"summary":"An APD rule narrows the statute's list of qualifying causes for 'financially incapable.'","documents":[{"id":"ors-125.005","citation":"ORS 125.005(3)","quote":"'Financially incapable' means a condition ... for reasons including, but not limited to, mental illness, mental retardation, physical illness or disability, chronic use of drugs or controlled substances, chronic intoxication, confinement, detention by a foreign power or disappearance.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-026-0010","citation":"OAR 411-026-0010(10)","quote":"'Financially Incapable' means a condition ... for reasons including but not limited to physical disability or cognitive disability, such as acquired brain injury or dementia.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"159cb454bef7a229","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"The same rule redefines 'Visitor' by role/independence rather than the statute's appointment-mechanism definition.","documents":[{"id":"ors-125.005","citation":"ORS 125.005(11)","quote":"'Visitor' means a person appointed by the court under ORS 125.150 for the purpose of interviewing and evaluating a respondent or protected person.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-026-0010","citation":"OAR 411-026-0010(17)","quote":"'Visitor' means a person who is an officer, employee, or special appointee of the court, is not an interested party ... and has been trained or has the expertise...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e0c2fead4651b509","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the statutory 'Fiduciary' definition (dropping the catch-all clause) and adds an unsourced '30 days' duration detail.","documents":[{"id":"ors-125.005","citation":"ORS 125.005(2)","quote":"'Fiduciary' means a guardian or conservator appointed under the provisions of this chapter or any other person appointed by a court to assume duties with respect to a protected person...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-026-0010","citation":"OAR 411-026-0010(9)","quote":"'Fiduciary' means a guardian or conservator appointed under the provisions of ORS Chapter 125. A fiduciary may be: (a) Temporary in which the powers ... last generally 30 days...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f76e4d7429dd9c0e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"The rule inserts 'financial attention' into the statutory definition of 'meeting the essential requirements for physical health and safety,' blurring the statute's separation between physical- and financial-incapacity grounds.","documents":[{"id":"ors-125.005","citation":"ORS 125.005(5)","quote":"...those actions necessary to provide the health care, food, shelter, clothing, personal hygiene and other care without which serious physical injury or illness is likely to occur.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-026-0010","citation":"OAR 411-026-0010(11)","quote":"...health care, food, shelter, clothing, personal hygiene, financial attention, and other care...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0a9deffec2ed9f7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"A DHS guardianship-forms rule (amended 2023) doesn't incorporate the 'vulnerable youth' guardianship track added to ORS 125.300 in 2021.","documents":[{"id":"ors-125.300","citation":"ORS 125.300(1)(b), 2021 amendment","quote":"A guardian may be appointed for an adult person if there is clear and convincing evidence that the person is a vulnerable youth...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-091-0005","citation":"OAR 309-091-0005, effective 2023-07-11","quote":"(24-entry definitions list contains no \"vulnerable youth\" term anywhere)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"63e49bee0286a967","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]}],"artifacts":["oar-411-020-0030 legal_authority: \"ORS 124.055 124.065\" concatenated with no separator.","ors-125.330 title bleeds in a following subdivision heading (\"CONSERVATORS (Appointment)\")."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"}]},{"ors_chapter":"131","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":6,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 131.715's sole implementing rule is marked status:current though its own History line shows it was repealed effective the same date listed as its \"current\" effective_date.","documents":[{"id":"oar-461-135-0440","citation":"OAR 461-135-0440, status: current, effective_date 2023-07-01","quote":"History: SSP 19-2023, repeal filed 06/20/2023, effective 07/01/2023 ... (full text is empty)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2164c8a9f8cf4618","cites_repealed":["oar-461-135-0440"],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"An OYA rule's law-enforcement-interrogation procedure for youth in custody never engages ORS 131.040's central gating condition (no charging instrument/juvenile petition filed).","documents":[{"id":"ors-131.040","citation":"ORS 131.040","quote":"...(2) No accusatory instrument has been filed charging the person with the commission of an offense that is the subject of the investigation or communication, and no juvenile petition has been filed...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-416-150-0010","citation":"OAR 416-150-0010","quote":"...gates instead on warrant status and consent from supervisor/youth/guardian, with no reference to whether a petition has been filed.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"246154e64adf7b38","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-youth-authority"]}],"artifacts":["All five OAR 416-150 rules cite \"ORS 420.014\" in statutes_implemented but \"ors-420.081\" in relationships.implements — a systematic statute-number mismatch, identical across all five sibling rules."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"153","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":8,"candidates":[{"summary":"An aviation civil-penalty rule's dollar-amount definition cites ORS 153.012 as its source, but 153.012 contains no dollar figures — the actual $2,000/$4,000 figures are in ORS 153.018.","documents":[{"id":"oar-738-140-0010","citation":"OAR 738-140-0010(2)","quote":"'Class A Violation' ... incurs a maximum fine of $2,000 for an individual and $4,000 for a corporation in accordance with ORS 153.012.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-153.012","citation":"ORS 153.012","quote":"Violations are classified for the purpose of sentencing into the following categories: (1) Class A violations. ... (no dollar figures)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"560a85af4a6a1291","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-aviation"]},{"summary":"A Parks & Rec rule assigns two violation categories to Class A (the most severe), which — if the underlying default is Class B under ORS 153.015 — would exceed ORS 153.022's authorization to only lower, never raise, the statutory classification.","documents":[{"id":"ors-153.022","citation":"ORS 153.022","quote":"...as long as the class specified in the rule is lower than the statutory classification for the offense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-010-0022","citation":"OAR 736-010-0022(3)-(4)","quote":"Violations that disturb or damage park resources are Class A violations. ... constitute criminal trespass ... are Class A violations...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Unresolved without ORS 390.050/390.111 text, outside this cluster.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b41f46581456d3f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]}],"artifacts":["Systemic pattern: relationships.implements arrays for six rules merge \"Statutory/Other Authority\" citations with \"Statutes/Other Implemented\" citations, making ORS 153.022's implemented_by list overbroad relative to what those rules' own text supports."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"162","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[{"summary":"OYA rules use 'youth in custody' to mean youth physically detained in a facility — precisely the situation ORS 162.135(4) carves OUT of the statutory 'Custody' definition.","documents":[{"id":"ors-162.135","citation":"ORS 162.135(4)","quote":"'Custody' means the imposition of actual or constructive restraint by a peace officer or a parole and probation officer ... but does not include detention in a correctional facility, youth correction facility or a state hospital.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-416-410-0060","citation":"OAR 416-410-0060(1)","quote":"...ratio of population to staff assigned primarily or exclusively for supervision and control of youth in custody...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Caveat: 'youth in custody' may be a distinct term-of-art defined in ORS 420A.010, outside this cluster.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"257626a94b08c029","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-youth-authority"]},{"summary":"ORS 162.135 was amended in 2025; the four OYA rules implementing it (2023/2024 filings) show no review against the amendment.","documents":[{"id":"ors-162.135","citation":"ORS 162.135, last_amended 2025","quote":"2025 c.118 §1","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-416-410-0060","citation":"OAR 416-410-0060, effective 2024-03-22","quote":"(no later history entry)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"763654bcadeaf231","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-youth-authority"]}],"artifacts":["ors-162.135 title truncated (\"Definitions for ORS 162.135 to\") with duplicated \"Chapter 162 (Chapter 162)\" text.","oar-416-410-0060 relationships.implements lists ors-420a.025 where statutes_implemented/body text point to ORS 420A.081."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"163","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":21,"candidates":[{"summary":"A repealed rule (2022) is still presented as the current, sole implementer of ORS 163.575.","documents":[{"id":"oar-333-015-0210","citation":"OAR 333-015-0210, status: current","quote":"History: PH 16-2022, repeal filed 02/10/2022, effective 02/10/2022... Full text contains only the title/header, no operative text.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"ORS 163.575 (last amended 2017) lists this repealed rule as its sole implementer with no successor identified.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ab2dd498a71aed21","cites_repealed":["oar-333-015-0210"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"A Board of Parole rule states a stricter default voting threshold (full-board unanimity) than the statute's actual default (three-member panel unanimity).","documents":[{"id":"ors-163.105","citation":"ORS 163.105(3)","quote":"upon a unanimous vote of three board members or, if the chairperson requires all voting members to participate, a unanimous vote of all voting members, finds that the prisoner is capable of rehabilitation...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-032-0025","citation":"OAR 255-032-0025(6), amended 2025","quote":"the full Board, upon a unanimous vote of all members, or by such other vote as is specified in statute, finds that the AIC is capable of rehabilitation...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's three-member default is relegated to a vague trailing clause rather than stated directly.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3375e457753eba75","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"A CJC sentencing rule classifies ORS 163.445 (Sexual Misconduct, statutorily a Class C misdemeanor with no felony variant) as a felony in its 'person felonies' list.","documents":[{"id":"ors-163.445","citation":"ORS 163.445(2)","quote":"Sexual misconduct is a Class C misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-003-0001","citation":"OAR 213-003-0001(14)","quote":"...ORS 163.445 Sexual Misconduct (If person over 18) (Felony)...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat"},{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-ors163","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"97961ec1c9149d28","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]},{"summary":"The same rule cites the wrong statute number AND misclassifies 'Contributing to Sexual Delinquency of a Minor' as a felony.","documents":[{"id":"ors-163.435","citation":"ORS 163.435(2)","quote":"Contributing to the sexual delinquency of a minor is a Class A misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-003-0001","citation":"OAR 213-003-0001(14)","quote":"...ORS 167.435 Contributing to Sexual Delinquency of Minor (Felony)...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"\"ORS 167.435\" does not exist in this chapter — the rule's own statutes_implemented field correctly says \"ORS 163.435\"; only the body-text list entry is garbled.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e899c9e7c526a0bd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 213-005-0001 formally lists ORS 163.165(2) as an implemented statute but its operative text never engages assault classification at all.","documents":[{"id":"oar-213-005-0001","citation":"OAR 213-005-0001, statutes_implemented","quote":"...163.165(2)...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-163.165","citation":"ORS 163.165, last_amended 2021","quote":"(no corresponding reference found anywhere in oar-213-005-0001's operative text)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Rule (2012) predates the statute's 2021 substantive amendments; reads as a stale/orphaned citation.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"375a2244bfa95795","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule specifies a hearing within one year of sentencing, while the statute requires the hearing to occur only after completion of a minimum period of confinement.","type":null,"documents":[{"id":"ors-163.105","citation":"ORS 163.105(2)","quote":"At any time after completion of a minimum period of confinement pursuant to subsection (1)(c) of this section, the State Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision... shall hold a hearing","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-032-0005","citation":"OAR 255-032-0005(1)","quote":"An adult person convicted of Aggravated Murder under ORS 163.095 shall receive a hearing within one year of sentencing.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat","prompt_version":"conflict-v2-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-163.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-ors163","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"d3017c65ee8618f4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"The rule includes a twenty (20) year minimum for aggravated murder, whereas the statute only specifies a thirty (30) year minimum.","type":null,"documents":[{"id":"ors-163.105","citation":"ORS 163.105(1)(c)","quote":"the court shall order that the defendant shall be confined for a minimum of 30 years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-032-0005","citation":"OAR 255-032-0005(3)","quote":"Adult persons sentenced to life with a twenty (20) or thirty (30) year minimum for aggravated murder shall receive a prison term hearing","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat","prompt_version":"conflict-v2-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-163.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d36affb22c7309a5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"The rule cites ORS 163.105(2) as defining a minimum period of confinement, but that section of the statute actually defines the hearing process and burden of proof.","type":null,"documents":[{"id":"ors-163.105","citation":"ORS 163.105(2)","quote":"At any time after completion of a minimum period of confinement pursuant to subsection (1)(c) of this section, the State Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision... shall hold a hearing to determine if the prisoner is likely to be rehabilitated within a reasonable period of time.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-032-0010","citation":"OAR 255-032-0010(2)","quote":"The minimum period of confinement for an adult person convicted of Aggravated Murder as defined by ORS 163.105(2) prior to December 6, 1984, shall be twenty (20) years.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat","prompt_version":"conflict-v2-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-163.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"538788ceb07f67e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"The statute classifies ORS 163.435 as a Class A misdemeanor, but it is omitted from the rule's list of 'Person Class A misdemeanors.'","type":null,"documents":[{"id":"ors-163.435","citation":"ORS 163.435(2)","quote":"Contributing to the sexual delinquency of a minor is a Class A misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-003-0001","citation":"OAR 213-003-0001(15)","quoteret":"\"Person Class A misdemeanors\" are in numerical statutory order: ORS 162.315 Resisting Arrest; ORS 163.160 Assault IV; ORS 163.187 Strangulation; ORS 163.190 Menacing; ORS 163.195 Recklessly Endanger Another; ORS 163.200 Criminal Mistreatment II; ORS 163.212 Use of Stun Gun, Tear Gas, Mace II; ORS 163.415 Sexual Abuse III; ORS 163.454 Custodial Sexual Misconduct in the Second Degree; ORS 163.465 Public Indecency; ORS 163.467 Private Indecency; ORS 163.472 Unlawful Dissemination of Intimate Image; ORS 163.476 Unlawfully Being in a Location Where Children Regularly Congregate; ORS 163.545 Child Neglect II; ORS 163.575 Endanger Welfare of Minor; ORS 163.687 Encouraging Child Sex Abuse III; ORS 163.700 Invasion of Personal Privacy II; ORS 163.709 Unlawfully Directing a Laser Pointer; ORS 163.732(1) Stalking; ORS 163.750(1) Violating Court's Stalking Order; ORS 165.572 Interfering with Making a Police Report; ORS 165.815 Criminal Impersonation; ORS 166.065(4) Harassment/Offensive Sexual Contact; ORS 166.155 Bias Crime II; ORS 166.385(2) Misdemeanor Possession of a Hoax Destructive Device; ORS 167.054 Furnishing Sexually Explicit Material to a Child; ORS 475.910(4) Unlawful Administration of a Controlled Substance; ORS 609.990(3)(a) Maintaining Dangerous Dog; ORS 811.060 Vehicular Assault; ORS 813.010, Driving Under the Influence of Intoxicants (as provided in OAR 213-004-0009); ORS 837.374(2) and (3) Unlawful Interference with Aircraft (if aircraft manned at time of offense); and attempts or solicitations to commit any Class C person felonies as defined in section (14) of this rule.","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat","prompt_version":"conflict-v2-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-163.435","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-ors163","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"47bb9a4446494010","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule classifies violations as a Class D violation by default, whereas the statute defines public indecency as a Class A misdemeanor.","type":null,"documents":[{"id":"ors-163.465","citation":"ORS 163.465(2)(a)","quote":"(2)(a) Public indecency is a Class A misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-010-0040","citation":"oar-736-010-0040(1)","quote":"(1) Violations to this rule are a Class D violation, unless otherwise specified below or park resources are damaged resulting in a Class A violation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"gemma12b-163-validation","model":"gemma4:12b-it-qat","prompt_version":"conflict-v2-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-163.465","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-ors163","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","also_cited":["oar-736-010-0040#oar736010004011l"]}],"fingerprint":"be578cd69c7ce561","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]}],"artifacts":["oar-736-010-0040 legal_authority mislabels three ORS citations with an \"OAR\" prefix (\"OAR 390.124\", \"OAR 164.245\", \"OAR 164.805\").","oar-213-003-0001 statutes_implemented contains garbled entries (\"Sections 2\", \"ORS 3\") from a mis-split \"Sections 2 & 3\" citation."],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-ors163","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"163a","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":51,"candidates":[{"summary":"PSRB risk-assessment deadline is 60 days by rule vs. 90 days by statute for the same discharge/conditional-release trigger.","documents":[{"id":"ors-163a.105","citation":"ORS 163A.105(3)(a), last_amended 2025","quote":"...apply the results of the assessment ... no later than 90 days after the person is: (A) Placed on conditional release ... (B) Discharged ...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-859-400-0020","citation":"OAR 859-400-0020(1), effective 2016","quote":"this assessment will take place no later than 60 days of the registrant's discharge or conditional release.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3097e43d6c5ca06a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["psychiatric-security-review-board"]},{"summary":"A BOPPPS burglary-disqualification rule cites a narrower subparagraph range than the current statute.","documents":[{"id":"ors-163a.115","citation":"ORS 163A.115(2)(e), last_amended 2024","quote":"Burglary ... with the intent to commit any of the offenses listed in ORS 163A.005 (5)(a) to (y).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-087-0020","citation":"OAR 255-087-0020(3)(b)(A), 2018","quote":"...offenses listed in ORS 163A.005(5)(a) to (w)...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Rule (2018) predates the statute's current list and omits two disqualifying categories (x, y).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ddef56a40526c31","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"Two agencies set different reapplication waiting periods after a denied relief-from-reporting petition, though both implement the same statute, which is silent on the interval.","documents":[{"id":"oar-859-400-0220","citation":"OAR 859-400-0220(2), PSRB, 2018","quote":"beginning 24 months following the date of the final order.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-087-0090","citation":"OAR 255-087-0090(5), BOPPPS, 2018","quote":"after 36 months from the date of denial.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"310d223641cf5604","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","psychiatric-security-review-board"]},{"summary":"A DSP rule collapses the statute's four-category 'sex offender' definition into two and drops the explicit juvenile cross-reference.","documents":[{"id":"ors-163a.005","citation":"ORS 163A.005(6)","quote":"'Sex offender' means a person who: (a) Has been convicted of a sex crime; (b) Has been found guilty except for insanity of a sex crime; (c) ...(d) Is described in ORS 163A.025 (1).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-070-0015","citation":"OAR 257-070-0015(4), 2022","quote":"'Sex offender' means a person convicted, adjudicated or found guilty of a crime: (a) That would constitute a sex crime if convicted in this state; or (b) ...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fc1ac95c4cfdde46","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"'Category B sex crime' is anchored to a living, board-maintained website by one agency and to a static 2003 coding manual by the other, though both classify the same offender population's registration level.","documents":[{"id":"oar-255-085-0010","citation":"OAR 255-085-0010(4), BOPPPS, 2023","quote":"'Category B sex crime' means any type of criminal offense within the scope of 'Category B offenses' used to administer the Static-99R and listed on the Board's website...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-859-400-0005","citation":"OAR 859-400-0005(4), PSRB, 2018","quote":"'Category B sex crime' means any type of criminal offense within the scope of 'Category B offenses' listed in the Static-99 Coding Rules (Revised 2003).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6e2dd3a5e48f59c2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","psychiatric-security-review-board"]}],"artifacts":["Legislative-history fragments (\"Section 7\", \"Chapter 708\", \"Oregon Laws 2013\") atomized into separate statutes_implemented list items across most 255-085/255-087/859-400 rules.","ors-163a.110 title concatenates the section title with an editorial \"Note:\" caption."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"164","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":17,"candidates":[{"summary":"A Parks & Rec rule misattributes 'leaving materials near waterways' (statutorily a Class B misdemeanor under ORS 164.775) to ORS 164.805 (Class C, offensive littering generally).","documents":[{"id":"ors-164.775","citation":"ORS 164.775(6)","quote":"Violation of this section is a Class B misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-164.805","citation":"ORS 164.805(3)","quote":"Offensive littering is a Class C misdemeanor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-010-0040","citation":"OAR 736-010-0040(8)","quote":"Offensive littering or leaving materials near waterways will be cited as a Class C misdemeanor, ORS 164.805.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule's own statutes_implemented field doesn't even list ORS 164.775 — it's assigned in the corpus to a different rule (oar-736-021-0090).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eb83541740b912af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]}],"artifacts":["ors-164.814's last_amended (2019) appears to conflate an amendment to the adjacent, repealed ORS 164.815 with 164.814 itself, whose own bracket history shows no 2019 event.","ors-164.855 title truncated (missing \"164.825\")."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"165","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[{"summary":"An OLCC minor-decoy rule extends the statutory licensee-only immunity to third-party delivery facilitator permittees and their delivery persons, a class ORS 165.805(5) doesn't name.","documents":[{"id":"ors-165.805","citation":"ORS 165.805(5)","quote":"The prohibitions of this section do not apply to a person under the age of 21 years who is acting under the direction of a licensee for the purpose of investigating possible violations by employees of the licensee...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-845-009-0200","citation":"OAR 845-009-0200(6)","quote":"A licensee or third-party delivery facilitator permittees using a person under the age of 21 years for the purpose of investigating possible violations by employees of the licensee or delivery persons of the third-party delivery facilitator...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"12a006a5c4515413","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-liquor-control-commission"]}],"artifacts":["oar-845-009-0200 body text has a garbled/mangled authority footer (\"(1) & (5)\" fragment separated from its statute number)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"oregon-liquor-control-commission","name":"Oregon Liquor Control Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"166","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":19,"candidates":[{"summary":"OSP's firearm-transfer rules predate the 2023-enacted permit-to-purchase regime (now in force per the statute's own effective-date note) and describe only the older instant-check model.","documents":[{"id":"ors-166.412","citation":"ORS 166.412(2)(a), last_amended 2025","quote":"a gun dealer shall comply with the following before a firearm ... is delivered to a purchaser: (a) The purchaser shall present ... a valid permit issued under ORS 166.505.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-010-0055","citation":"OAR 257-010-0055, effective 2021","quote":"The purpose of the Firearm Instant Check System is to receive information ... to determine if the person purchasing the firearm is disqualified under Oregon (ORS 166.470) and Federal Law...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"None of the seven OSP rules in this cluster mention a permit-to-purchase, ORS 166.505, or 166.503/166.508 anywhere.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"256a00ea4d2af82f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"Three CJC sentencing-guidelines rules apply the mandatory Department-custody consequence in ORS 166.070(2) to the whole subsection, though the statute's mandatory-custody language is textually limited to (1)(a) convictions only.","documents":[{"id":"ors-166.070","citation":"ORS 166.070(2)","quote":"Aggravated harassment is a Class C felony. When a person is convicted of violating subsection (1)(a) of this section ... the court shall impose a term of incarceration in a state correctional facility.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-008-0005","citation":"OAR 213-008-0005(5)","quote":"terms of incarceration 12 months or less imposed pursuant to ORS 166.070(2) shall be served in the legal and physical custody of the Department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2bf6fff5fcece31","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]},{"summary":"Four CJC crime-category rules (division 213-017) carry near-identical statutes_implemented footers (ORS 164.889/166.642/166.643) regardless of which offense each rule actually classifies — a boilerplate-copy error, not a substantive conflict, but capable of misleading a reader about which rule governs a given offense.","documents":[{"id":"oar-213-017-0007","citation":"OAR 213-017-0007 (CC5), statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 166.643 — but body armor possession (166.643) is actually classified in OAR 213-017-0008 (CC4).","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"19f0bf84111f3b9b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission"]}],"artifacts":["\"OS 181A.230\" (missing R) in oar-257-010-0035 legal_authority."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"167","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":20,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DOJ bingo rule's 'raffle' definition drops the statute's charitable/fraternal/religious-operator requirement and substitutes a rebuttable 'consideration presumption' concept the statute doesn't contain.","documents":[{"id":"ors-167.117","citation":"ORS 167.117(19)","quote":"'Raffle' means a lottery operated by a charitable, fraternal or religious organization wherein the players pay something of value for chances...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-025-0020","citation":"OAR 137-025-0020(4)","quote":"'Raffle' means a form of a lottery in which each participant buys a ticket ... Consideration is presumed to be present unless it is clearly and conspicuously disclosed that tickets ... may be acquired without contributing something of economic value.","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Matters because 'raffle' status is a statutory exception to unlawful gambling — but only when operated by a charitable/fraternal/religious org.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f9ac65f888e4725c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 137-025 series mislabels bare session-law years as ORS citations (\"ORS 1997\", \"ORS 2003\") and cites a bare \"ORS 914\" (likely an OL chapter number, not a real ORS chapter).","OAR 213-003-0001/213-017-0006 statutes_implemented splits Oregon-Laws chapter numbers into individual pseudo-ORS citations (\"ORS 510\", \"ORS 635\", etc.)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-state-lottery","name":"Oregon State Lottery"}]},{"ors_chapter":"169","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":13,"candidates":[{"summary":"Two rule regimes from different agencies and eras both claim to implement the same juvenile extended-detention statute, naming different approving bodies with different renewal cadences, with no cross-reference or supersession between them.","documents":[{"id":"oar-213-050-0060","citation":"OAR 213-050-0060(1), Oregon Criminal Justice Commission, adopted 2003","quote":"A supervising authority ordered by the court to detain juveniles for an extended detention period pursuant to ORS 419C.453 must detain juveniles only in a detention facility which has an extended detention program plan approved by the JCPAC.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-423-150-0010","citation":"OAR 423-150-0010(2), Youth Development Division, adopted 2019","quote":"A supervising authority ordered by a court to detain a juvenile for a period of detention exceeding eight days pursuant to ORS 419C.453 must detain the juvenile in accordance with an extended detention program plan approved by the Youth Development Council.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-050-0065","citation":"OAR 213-050-0065(6)","quote":"The JCPAC may authorize the county to operate an extended detention program for a maximum of five years, subject to renewal of approval by JCPAC in the future.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-423-150-0010","citation":"OAR 423-150-0010(6)(a),(d)","quote":"An approved extended detention program plan must be renewed biennially ... [with] full Council reapproval every sixth year.","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Both rule sets carry status: current with no supersedes link and no cross-reference to each other. Plausibly the 2019 rule reflects a real reorganization (juvenile-justice functions moving to the Youth Development Council) that quietly displaced the 2003 rule without a formal repeal being reflected in this corpus — but that reading isn't confirmed against ORS 419C.453 itself, which is outside this pilot's cluster. Confirmed independently by both batch 1 and the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23) — high-confidence finding.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7066f25e0efaa3f7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission","oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division"]}],"artifacts":["ors-169.090's title field reads \"...juvenile detention facility operation TREATMENT OF PRISONERS\" — a later section heading bled into this section's title during chapter-snapshot slicing.","Multiple OAR rule titles truncated mid-phrase (\"Authority\", \"Modification,\", \"Suspension,\").","OAR 291-167-0005, -0010, -0015 all list statutes_implemented as a single sweeping range \"ORS 169.070 - 169.750\" rather than the specific sections actually referenced in the rules' own text (169.070, 169.076-078, 169.740, 419A.052, 419B.180) — noted again in the batch-2 re-check."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"171","agencies":6,"rules_reviewed":28,"candidates":[{"summary":"A board-compensation rule internally contradicts itself when implementing the legislative per diem: a 'no less than' floor pegged to the floating IRS-linked rate, immediately followed by a hard $250 daily cap.","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.072","citation":"ORS 171.072(9)","quote":"The per diem allowance ... shall be the amount fixed for per diem allowance that is authorized by the United States Internal Revenue Service to be excluded from gross income without itemization.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-003-0200","citation":"OAR 847-003-0200(1) & (3), effective 2026-07-02","quote":"(1) Members ... will receive no less than the current Oregon legislative per diem as specified in ORS 171.072... (3) The daily maximum Board member compensation is $250.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bdbb503d72750466","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"Two boards implementing the same statute structure per diem differently — one capped at $250/day, the other uncapped and tied directly to the legislative rate.","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-003-0200","citation":"OAR 847-003-0200(2)-(3), Oregon Medical Board","quote":"$250 compensation for each day of attendance ... The daily maximum Board member compensation is $250.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-858-010-0005","citation":"OAR 858-010-0005(2)(a), Board of Psychology","quote":"Board members shall receive compensation that is equal to the per diem paid to members of the Legislative Assembly under ORS 171.072(9) for each day...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b8fd4946a8f7b207","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"Several repealed rules are still carried as live implemented_by links with status: current.","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.752","citation":"ORS 171.752 relationships","quote":"implemented_by: [oar-199-010-0070, oar-199-010-0090, oar-199-010-0150]","quote_verified":"absence"},{"id":"oar-199-010-0090","citation":"OAR 199-010-0090, status: current","quote":"History: GEC 12-2021, repeal filed 12/07/2021, effective 12/30/2021 — no operative text.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Same pattern for oar-199-010-0085/-0100 (ORS 171.750) and oar-855-010-0016 (ORS 171.072).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"de5e3c45c248892a","cites_repealed":["oar-199-010-0090"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule requires reporting reimbursements for food and refreshment to lobbyists, which the statute says to exclude as 'living and travel expenses.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.750","citation":"ORS 171.750(1)(c)","quote":"The name of each registered lobbyist or entity comprised of more than one lobbyist to whom the person paid moneys for lobbying activities on the person's behalf, excluding living and travel expenses incurred for a lobbyist performing lobbying services, and the total amount of moneys paid to that lobbyist or entity.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-010-0095","citation":"OAR 199-010-0095(1)(b)","quote":"Report each registered lobbyist who is compensated to provide lobbying services and include the amount paid in compensation and the amount paid in reimbursement to the lobbyist for food, refreshment and entertainment (ORS 171.750(1)(c)).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.750","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2d10191f10f7d0e0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements only ORS 171.060(1) but the operative text applies to both ORS 171.060(1) and ORS 171.060(2).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-165-010-0060","citation":"OAR 165-010-0060, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 171.060(1)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-165-010-0060","citation":"OAR 165-010-0060, opening paragraph","quote":"These meeting procedures apply to appointments made under either ORS 171.060(1) (vacancy to be filled by nominee affiliated with a major political party) or ORS 171.060(2) (vacancy need not be filled by member of a particular major political party).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-171.060","citation":"ORS 171.060(1)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b14e7b59d669d3f6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-elections-division"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the client/employer authorization signature within 10 calendar days of filing, but the rule omits this deadline.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.740","citation":"ORS 171.740(2)(a)","quote":"Not later than 10 calendar days after a lobbyist files a registration statement under this section, the designation of official authorization to lobby shall be signed by an official of each person that employs the lobbyist or in whose interest the lobbyist appears or works.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-010-0035","citation":"OAR 199-010-0035(4)","quote":"A responsible representative of the client/employer must electronically sign to verify that the lobbyist has been authorized to lobby on behalf of the client/employer, and the lobbyist's registration is not complete without the client/employer's electronic confirmation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.740","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9d320645f18ee291","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The statute requires a lobbyist to revise registration within 30 days if information changes, but the rules do not address this requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.740","citation":"ORS 171.740(4)(a)","quote":"if any of the information submitted by a lobbyist in the statement required under subsection (1) of this section changes, the lobbyist shall revise the statement within 30 days of the change.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-010-0025","citation":"OAR 199-010-0025","quote":"The rules address registration, additional clients, and termination, but do not specify the 30-day requirement for updating other information that changes.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.740","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a9fb2d2991e45898","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-010-0080(3) makes the statutory requirement to submit estimates and exact amounts optional rather than mandatory.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.745","citation":"ORS 171.745(3)","quote":"an estimate of the expenditure shall be submitted in the statement and designated as an estimate. The exact amount expended for which a previous estimate was made shall be submitted in a subsequent report when the information is available.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-010-0080","citation":"OAR 199-010-0080(3)","quote":"If the amount of any expenditure required to be included in the report is not accurately known at the time of the report, an estimate thereof should be submitted timely and updated in a subsequent amended report when more accurate information is available.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.745","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c1ba97acc65a1ddc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-010-0075(1) narrows the statutory requirement to report all 'entertainment' by limiting reporting to only 'limited entertainment' subject to the $50 gift limit.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-171.745","citation":"ORS 171.745(1)(a)","quote":"The total amount of all moneys expended for food, refreshments and entertainment by the lobbyist for the purpose of lobbying.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-010-0075","citation":"OAR 199-010-0075(1)","quote":"A lobbyist must report the total amount of money spent during the reporting period for all lobbying activity expenditures that were made for food, refreshment and limited entertainment during the reporting period as required by ORS 171.745(1)(a).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.745","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"82ff4cd4c4374e3e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 847-003-0200 declares it implements ORS 171.072, but ORS 171.072 applies exclusively to members of the Legislative Assembly and does not address compensation for members of the Oregon Medical Board, excluding the rule's own subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-003-0200","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 292.495, ORS 677.235, ORS 171.072","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-171.072","citation":"ORS 171.072","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-171.072","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6158e83b578421fb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]}],"artifacts":["ors-171.992 title concatenates two unrelated statute-page fragments.","ors-171.725 title truncated (\"Definitions for ORS 171.725 to\")."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"oregon-government-ethics-commission","name":"Oregon Government Ethics Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"174","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":6,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidate inconsistencies. Every apparent divergence resolved to a legitimate statutory delegation or express override — including a WebFetch-verified check of ORS 187.010(1)(a) (\"Each Sunday\" is itself a legal holiday), which resolves the one lead that looked most promising (a computation-of-time rule naming \"Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday\" where the statute names only \"Saturday\" and \"any legal holiday\").","artifacts":["Lossy range-splitting: relationships.implements reduces statutory ranges like \"ORS 418.606-418.609\" and \"ORS 197.628 - 197.650\" to just the two endpoints, silently dropping interior sections, in oar-413-010-0000 and oar-660-025-0220.","ors-174.040 full text has a bled-in fragment from the following (repealed) ORS 174.050 stub."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"177","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":15,"candidates":[{"summary":"A Secretary of State Archives fee rule imposes flat, unconditional fees on legislative records with no exception mirroring the statute's mandatory no-fee-for-legislators/officers provision.","documents":[{"id":"ors-177.130","citation":"ORS 177.130(2)","quote":"No member of the legislature or state officer shall be charged any fee for any certificate or certified copy relative to the official duties of the member or officer.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-166-010-0016","citation":"OAR 166-010-0016(1)(b)(A)(i)","quote":"Duplication performed by Archives staff is $5.00 per record... (no legislator/officer exception stated)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c388884d715df54c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-archives-division"]},{"summary":"A Financial Transparency Policy rule cites ORS 177.050 (personnel/merit-system rulemaking authority) though its actual subject (spending-transparency disclosures) has nothing to do with personnel administration; the rule's own statutes_implemented field omits ORS 177.050 while legal_authority and relationships.implements both include it.","documents":[{"id":"ors-177.050","citation":"ORS 177.050(5)","quote":"The Secretary of State shall adopt rules ... to establish a system of personnel administration based on merit principles...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-167-060-0130","citation":"OAR 167-060-0130(1)-(2)","quote":"It is the policy of the Secretary of State to maintain full and timely transparency for all spending...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0acb0cc3540d0a09","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-business-services-division"]}],"artifacts":["oar-167-060-0130 legal_authority/statutes_implemented split a single \"Oregon Constitution, Article VI, Sections 2 and 5\" citation into duplicated fragments.","oar-160-050-0160 cites uncodified session-law provisions (\"2001 SB 171 Sec. 94.9-523\") rather than ORS sections."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"secretary-of-state-archives-division","name":"Secretary of State, Archives Division"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-business-services-division","name":"Secretary of State, Business Services Division"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"181a","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":431,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0060 adds a First Aid certification requirement for basic certification that the statute does not impose.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-008-0060","citation":"OAR 259-008-0060(4)(d)","quote":"Have valid certifications in adult and child cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and First Aid","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.440","citation":"ORS 181A.440(1)(d)","quote":"Certification in adult and child cardiopulmonary resuscitation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f0c1b36e3d06855a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0065 adds a First Aid certification maintenance requirement that the statute does not impose.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-008-0065","citation":"OAR 259-008-0065(7)(b)","quote":"Maintain a certification in First Aid","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.440","citation":"ORS 181A.440(2)(b)","quote":"Maintain a certification in adult and child cardiopulmonary resuscitation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1de4f533f695b24a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0085 cites ORS 181A.440(2) when implementing a basic certification requirement that is actually located in ORS 181A.440(1)(b).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-008-0085","citation":"OAR 259-008-0085(1)(b)(C)","quote":"Twenty-four hours of training in the recognition of mental illnesses as described in ORS 181A.440(2)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.440","citation":"ORS 181A.440(1)(b)","quote":"At least 24 hours of training in the recognition of mental illnesses utilizing a crisis intervention training model, at least one hour of which must include training on the appropriate use of the medical health database described in ORS 181A.285","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"7ac6ad3167b3f9a6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule redefines 'Subject individual' to mean someone employed or seeking employment by a qualified entity, contradicting the statute's definition which limits it to tribal gaming employees, certain tribal government employees, foster care providers, or household members of those providers.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.210","citation":"ORS 181A.210(4)(d)","quote":"\"Subject individual\" means an individual who is: (A) Applying for employment at a tribal gaming facility as a key employee, high security employee, low security employee or management employee; (B) Employed or applying for employment with a tribal government or agency responsible for child care, child welfare, law enforcement, education, health care, housing or social services; (C) Licensed, certified or registered, or applying to be licensed, certified or registered, by the government of a Native American tribe or an agency of a Native American tribe to provide foster care for children; or (D) Living in the home of an individual described in subparagraph (C) of this paragraph.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-010-0015","citation":"OAR 257-010-0015(16)","quote":"\"Subject individual\" means a person who is employed or seeks to be employed by a qualified entity or who is providing services or seeks to provide services to a qualified entity on a contractual or voluntary basis.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"14087698ec6cb371","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-257-010-0055 declares it implements ORS 181A.875 (about private security provider licenses) but the operative text concerns only firearm purchase checks by gun dealers, with no engagement of private security licensing.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-257-010-0055","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 166.291, ORS 166.412, ORS 181A.875","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.875","citation":"ORS 181A.875","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.875","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1ae48cc534e15ef8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-060-0020(2) requires applicants to have earned a high school diploma, GED, or college degree, but the statute only requires satisfactorily completed training—not educational credentials.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.855","citation":"ORS 181A.855(1)(b)","quote":"Must have satisfactorily completed training requirements approved by the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0020","citation":"OAR 259-060-0020(2)(a)","quote":"Applicants for certification or licensure must have earned one of the following: (A) A high school diploma; (B) A General Education Development (GED) certificate; or (C) A two-year or four-year, post-secondary degree issued by an accredited degree-granting college or university.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.855","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"808ffed1916a7d1e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-060-0020(1) establishes age requirements for 'alarm monitor,' 'event and entertainment private security professional,' 'supervisory manager,' 'executive manager,' and 'private security instructor'—categories of certification or licensure not mentioned in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.855","citation":"ORS 181A.855(1)(a)","quote":"Must be: (A) At least 18 years of age, if an applicant for certification as an unarmed private security professional; or (B) At least 21 years of age, if an applicant for certification as an armed private security professional","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0020","citation":"OAR 259-060-0020(1)","quote":"Private security providers must be: (a) At least 18 years of age to be certified as an alarm monitor, unarmed or event and entertainment private security professional or licensed as a supervisory manager; and (b) At least 21 years of age to be certified as an armed private security professional or private security instructor or licensed as an executive manager.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.855","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"29f4cafd519ae479","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0067(1) states regulatory specialist certifications lapse after 'greater than three months' of separation, but ORS 181A.550(4) states they lapse after 'three or more consecutive months'—different numeric thresholds for the same trigger.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.550","citation":"ORS 181A.550(4)","quote":"The certification of a regulatory specialist shall lapse after three or more consecutive months of not being employed as a regulatory specialist unless the regulatory specialist is on leave from the commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0067","citation":"OAR 259-008-0067(1)","quote":"Law enforcement officer certifications lapse after a law enforcement officer has been separated from their certifiable position for a consecutive period greater than three months.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.550","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b78c29d0b8bffc87","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0010(1)(d) requires that an exempted regulatory specialist 'continues full-time employment,' but ORS 181A.550(3) only requires that they 'continues to serve as a regulatory specialist'—the rule adds a full-time requirement the statute does not impose.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.550","citation":"ORS 181A.550(3)","quote":"The citizenship requirement in subsection (1) of this section does not apply to a person employed as a regulatory specialist on March 16, 2012, who continues to serve as a regulatory specialist without a lapse under subsection (4) of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0010","citation":"OAR 259-008-0010(1)(d)","quote":"The citizenship requirement found in (c) does not apply to a person employed as a regulatory specialist on March 16, 2012, who continues full-time employment as a regulatory specialist without a lapse.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.550","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f89da9e75bef5e13","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-060-0136 declares it implements ORS 181A.850 (Prohibited acts), but the operative text addresses only private security instructor responsibilities and training delivery requirements, with no engagement with any prohibited acts defined in ORS 181A.850.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-060-0136","citation":"259-060-0136","quote":"ORS 181A.870, ORS 181A.840 & ORS 181A.850","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.850","citation":"ORS 181A.850","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"27970aa269c4778d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0210(9) defines 'Qualified entity' but omits Native American tribes and tribal agencies that the statute explicitly includes in its definition.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-407-007-0210","citation":"OAR 407-007-0210(9)","quote":"'Qualified entity (QE)' means a community mental health or developmental disability program, local health department, or an individual, business, or organization, whether public, private, for-profit, nonprofit, or voluntary, that provides care, including a business or organization that licenses, certifies, or registers others to provide care (see ORS 181A.200).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.200","citation":"ORS 181A.200(1)(c)","quote":"'Qualified entity' means a community mental health program, a community developmental disabilities program, a local health department, the government of a Native American tribe or an agency of a Native American tribe responsible for child welfare or an individual or business or organization, whether public, private, for-profit, nonprofit or voluntary, that provides care, including a business or organization that licenses, certifies or registers others to provide care.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e01f55d599ab028c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"The rule limits the psychological screening requirement to officers hired on or after specific dates (January 1, 2020 for police/reserve officers; July 1, 2023 for other types), whereas the statute contains no such temporal limitation and appears to apply to all law enforcement officers going forward.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.485","citation":"ORS 181A.485(2)","quote":"A law enforcement agency may not employ a person as a law enforcement officer unless the person has completed a psychological screening to determine the person's fitness to serve as a law enforcement officer.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0010","citation":"OAR 259-008-0010(11)","quote":"This requirement applies to police officers and reserve officers hired on or after January 1, 2020, and corrections officers, parole and probation officers, and regulatory specialists hired on or after July 1, 2023.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.485","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e62c6b6f0594683","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"ORS 181A.170 requires use of electronic fingerprint capture technology for criminal records checks, but OAR 125-007-0220(3) permits traditional fingerprint cards from minors, which may not be electronic capture.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.170","citation":"ORS 181A.170(1)(a)","quote":"the Department of State Police and any other governmental agency authorized to report, receive or disseminate criminal offender information shall use electronic fingerprint capture technology to take and submit a person's fingerprints for purposes of conducting criminal records checks","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-007-0220","citation":"OAR 125-007-0220(3)","quote":"The authorized agency, district or qualified entity shall not request a fingerprint card from an SI under the age of eighteen (18) years unless the SI is emancipated pursuant to ORS 419B.550 et seq, or unless the authorized agency, district or qualified entity also requests the written consent of a parent or guardian.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.170","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ac4002727450393b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute allows suspension when charged with any crime; the rules limit suspension to charges of crimes that are grounds for denial or revocation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.885","citation":"ORS 181A.885(3)","quote":"The department may suspend the certificate or license of a private security provider charged with a crime pending disposition of the charge.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0300","citation":"OAR 259-060-0300(4)","quote":"The Department may suspend and may refuse to renew an alarm monitor private security professional's certification upon finding that the private security provider has been charged with a crime that is grounds for denial or revocation as defined in sections (2) and (3) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.885","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4034971ee75930fd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule allows $1,500 per violation per day, but statute caps penalty at $1,500 for each violation without reference to duration, effectively multiplying the statutory cap.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.655","citation":"ORS 181A.655(2)","quote":"Civil penalties imposed under subsection (1) of this section may not exceed $1,500 for each violation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0250","citation":"OAR 259-008-0250(3)(a)","quote":"An agency found in violation of any requirement listed in section (2) of this rule is subject to a civil penalty of not more than $1,500 per violation per day","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.655","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"caf65444974b9b7d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The statute explicitly covers both 'certified reserve officer' and 'reserve officer' as separate categories, but the rule only lists 'reserve officer' without distinguishing the certified variant.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.395","citation":"ORS 181A.395","quote":"may not employ as a police officer, corrections officer, parole and probation officer or regulatory specialist, or utilize as a certified reserve officer or reserve officer, any person who has not yet attained the age of 21 years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0010","citation":"OAR 259-008-0010(2)","quote":"No law enforcement unit in this state may employ or utilize any person under the age of 21 years as a police officer, corrections officer, parole and probation officer, regulatory specialist, or reserve officer.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.395","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1c41aa644e92ba28","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"ORS 181A.375 requires private security provider and investigator positions on the Private Security Policy Committee to be 'appointed by the chairperson of the board,' but the implementing rule assigns recommendation authority to the policy committee chair and vice-chair instead.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.375","citation":"ORS 181A.375(7)","quote":"The following, who may not be current board members, appointed by the chairperson of the board: ... (I) Two persons who are investigators licensed under ORS 703.430, one of whom is recommended by the Oregon State Bar and one of whom is in private practice","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-006-0005","citation":"259-006-0005(8)(b)","quote":"Appointment of a Private Security Provider or Private Investigator to the Private Security Policy Committee (PSIPC). Upon a vacancy, all interest forms and background information will be submitted to the PSIPC chair and vice-chair for consideration. The PSIPC chair and vice-chair will make a recommendation for appointment to the full Board for approval.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.375","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a1268a590da782cf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 259-013-0220 authorizes fingerprint requirements for private security providers, private investigators, fire service professionals, and polygraph applicants, which are not mentioned in ORS 181A.400(1)","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.400","citation":"ORS 181A.400(1)","quote":"the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training may require the fingerprints of a person who: (a) Is employed or applying for employment by the department; (b) Provides services or seeks to provide services to the department as a contractor, vendor or volunteer; or (c) Is applying to be certified as a public safety officer, is applying to be reissued certification as a public safety officer or is an applicant or public safety officer who is under investigation by the department","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-013-0220","citation":"OAR 259-013-0220","quote":"The Department may require the fingerprints of: (1) A fire service professional; (2) A public safety professional; (3) A private security provider; (4) A private investigator; (5) A polygraph intern or general license applicant; (6) A candidate for election to the office of Sheriff","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7cb6749b9bdf3d2f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0000(1)(c) omits fire service from the list of organizations for collaboration, but the statute explicitly includes it.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.365","citation":"ORS 181A.365(5)(c)","quote":"The board and department shall support collaboration among public and private security, law enforcement, fire service, telecommunications and corrections organizations, the related organizations with whom they work and the interests of the communities they serve.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0000","citation":"259-008-0000(1)(c)","quote":"The Board and Department will encourage participation among public and private security, law enforcement, telecommunications and corrections organizations, the related organizations with whom they work as well as the interests of the communities they serve.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a2664518af25c872","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-006-0010 allows members of Policy Committees who may not be board members to serve on the Applicant Review Committee, but ORS 181A.365(2) limits subcommittees to members appointed 'from among its members' of the board.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.365","citation":"ORS 181A.365(2)","quote":"The board may appoint from among its members such subcommittees as it deems necessary or useful.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-006-0010","citation":"259-006-0010(2) and (3)(b)","quote":"The Applicant Review Committee consists of: (a) Two representatives from the Corrections Policy Committee; (b) Two representatives from the Police Policy Committee; (c) Two representatives from the Telecommunications Policy Committee; and (d) One representative from the Board... To be eligible for nomination to the Applicant Review Committee, the nominee must be a current member on the Board or the Policy Committee making the nomination.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"20b523067bd7c07e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0010(1)(a) states only the citizenship requirement for corrections officer employment beyond one year, while the statute requires both citizenship AND certification (or exemption) as co-requisite conditions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.520","citation":"ORS 181A.520(1)","quote":"a person may not be employed as a corrections officer by a law enforcement unit for more than one year unless the person is a citizen of the United States or a nonimmigrant legally admitted to the United States under a Compact of Free Association, and: (a) The person has been certified as being qualified as a corrections officer under the provisions of ORS 181A.355 to 181A.689","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0010","citation":"OAR 259-008-0010(1)(a)","quote":"A person may not be employed as a corrections officer for more than one year unless the person is a citizen of the United States or a nonimmigrant legally admitted to the United States under a Compact of Free Association.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"656cf026590dbbb2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the scope of persons whose information must be reported by limiting coverage to those specifically prohibited under federal and state firearm laws, whereas the statute requires information on all eight enumerated categories of persons regardless of whether they meet firearm prohibition criteria.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.290","citation":"ORS 181A.290(1)","quote":"The Department of Human Services, the Oregon Health Authority, the Psychiatric Security Review Board and the Judicial Department shall provide the Department of State Police with the minimum information necessary to identify persons who: (a) Have been committed by a court to the Oregon Health Authority under ORS 426.130, based on a finding that the person is a danger to self or others; (b) Are subject to a court order under ORS 426.130 or 426.133 prohibiting the person from purchasing or possessing a firearm; (c) Have been committed by a court to the Department of Human Services under ORS 427.290, based on a finding that the person is a danger to self or others; (d) Have been found by a court to lack fitness to proceed under ORS 161.363 and 161.370; (e) Have been found guilty except for insanity of a crime under ORS 161.290 to 161.373; (f) Have been found responsible except for insanity for an act under ORS 419C.411; (g) Have been placed under the jurisdiction of the Psychiatric Security Review Board under ORS 161.315 to 161.351; or (h) Have been committed to a state hospital or facility under ORS 161.315 to 161.351 or 419C.529 to 419C.542.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-010-0060","citation":"OAR 257-010-0060(1)(b)","quote":"\"Minimum Information\" means only those data elements or identifying information that is minimally or nominally necessary to accurately identify a person listed under ORS 181A.290 and who is prohibited under either 18 U.S.C. §922(d)(4) and (g)(4) from purchasing, possessing, transporting or receiving a firearm, ORS 166.250 (1)(c)(D) or (E) from possessing a firearm, or ORS 166.470 (1)(e) or (f) from receiving a firearm.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.290","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6c834072776623c2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'Tutoring program' omits the statutory requirement that the program be 'based upon a specified activity that increases specific skills,' making the rule's definition broader than the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.235","citation":"ORS 181A.235(3)(f)","quote":"\"Tutoring program\" means a program that provides a committed, sustained, one-to-one relationship between a volunteer and a youth, dependent person or elderly person based upon a specified activity that increases specific skills of the youth, dependent person or elderly person. A sustained relationship typically lasts nine months or longer.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-010-0015","citation":"OAR 257-010-0015(18)","quote":"\"Tutoring program\" means a program that provides a committed, sustained, one-to-one relationship between a volunteer and a youth, dependent person or elderly person. A sustained relationship typically lasts nine months or longer.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3685636812c3cd07","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"OAR 259-060-0030 declares implementation of ORS 181A.870 but section (4) explicitly implements ORS 181A.850(2) regarding reciprocity for out-of-state private security professionals, which is not within the scope of the declared statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-060-0030","citation":"OAR 259-060-0030 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 181A.870","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.870","citation":"ORS 181A.870","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.870","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"05e083af437c869d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 181A.355, which explicitly excludes forest fire protection agency personnel from the definition of 'fire service professional,' but the rule contains no corresponding exclusion of forest fire personnel in its eligibility criteria.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.355","citation":"ORS 181A.355(11)","quote":"\"Fire service professional\" does not mean forest fire protection agency personnel.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-009-0059","citation":"OAR 259-009-0059(1)(a)","quote":"Be utilized or employed by an Oregon fire service agency","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4238add2419817bb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 413-208-0030(1)(a) cites ORS 181.555(3) for challenging procedures, but the statute it implements (ORS 181A.245(1)(b)(A)) specifies procedures adopted under ORS 181A.230(3), not 181.555(3).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.245","citation":"ORS 181A.245(1)(b)(A)","quote":"Notice to the individual of the manner in which the individual may become informed of the procedures adopted under ORS 181A.230(3) for challenging inaccurate criminal offender information","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-413-208-0030","citation":"OAR 413-208-0030(1)(a)","quote":"Has a right to inspect and challenge their Oregon criminal offender information through OSP procedures as adopted per ORS 181.555(3) and OAR 257-010-0035","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f8a075f5b0c3fea4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"The statute requires trauma-informed care, culturally specific services, and de-escalation training in both initial certification training AND any mandatory training to maintain certification; the rule specifies this requirement only for the initial Basic Parole and Probation Course, not for mandatory maintenance training.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.530","citation":"ORS 181A.530(3)","quote":"The initial training required for certification as a parole and probation officer, and any mandatory training to maintain certification, must include training in providing trauma-informed care, culturally specific services and de-escalation techniques.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0085","citation":"OAR 259-008-0085(3)(c)","quote":"The Basic Parole and Probation Course must include, at a minimum, training in providing trauma-informed care, culturally specific services, and de-escalation techniques.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.530","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb17c186cd75b513","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule implements the equity training requirement only for maintaining certification, but the statute requires equity training to be included in minimum training to both obtain and maintain basic certification.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.442","citation":"ORS 181A.442(2)","quote":"The department shall include the equity training described in subsection (1) of this section in the minimum training required to obtain and maintain basic certification as a police officer under ORS 181A.490.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0065","citation":"OAR 259-008-0065(7)(c)(E)","quote":"A minimum of three hours of Equity training completed within the three-year maintenance cycle.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.442","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"872fc6d115716314","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Multiple implementing rules specify different time periods (3 years vs 5 years) for when a nationwide criminal records check is triggered based on living outside Oregon for 60+ consecutive days, creating an inconsistency across rules implementing the same statute.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-007-0230","citation":"OAR 137-007-0230(3)(c)(A)","quote":"A subject individual has lived outside Oregon for 60 or more consecutive days during the previous five (5) years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-585-005-0030","citation":"OAR 585-005-0030(3)(c)(B)","quote":"A subject individual has lived outside Oregon for 60 or more consecutive days during the previous three (3) years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-635-600-0015","citation":"OAR 635-600-0015(3)(c)(B)","quote":"A subject individual has lived outside Oregon for 60 or more consecutive days during the previous three (3) years","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-736-002-0042","citation":"OAR 736-002-0042(3)(c)(B)","quote":"A subject individual has lived outside Oregon for 60 or more consecutive days during the previous three (3) years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-407-007-0250","citation":"OAR 407-007-0250(11)(a)(A)","quote":"The SI has been outside Oregon for 60 or more consecutive days during the previous five years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.195","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3a28e3b9676b93af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["commission-for-the-blind","department-of-fish-and-wildlife","department-of-human-services","department-of-justice","parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 181A.420, which governs public safety officers broadly, but the rule text exclusively addresses fire service professionals and fire service training, not the public safety officer categories or discretionary certification process described in the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.420","citation":"ORS 181A.420(2)","quote":"The Department of Public Safety Standards and Training may, upon application of an individual public safety officer, except a youth correction officer, at its discretion, certify the public safety officer as provided in ORS 181A.410 (1)(d) upon a finding that the public safety officer's professional experience, education or training meets the standards required for certification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-009-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 181A.420, ORS 181A.410","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-009-0020","citation":"259-009-0020(1)-(4)","quote":"fire service agency...fire service professional...fire service training","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e87e0458f42ec9c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 259-008-0060 fails to provide a certification scheme for fire service professionals, whom ORS 181A.570(1) explicitly authorizes the Department to certify as full-time DPSST employees.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.570","citation":"ORS 181A.570(1)","quote":"any full-time employee of the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training who possesses the requisite qualifications may be certified or recertified as a police officer, certified reserve officer, corrections officer, parole and probation officer, fire service professional, telecommunicator or emergency medical dispatcher","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0060","citation":"OAR 259-008-0060(1)","quote":"Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced Certificates are awarded by the Department to law enforcement officers and telecommunicators meeting prescribed standards of training, education, and experience. Emergency medical dispatchers may be awarded basic certification only.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.570","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6e7e4e79245e8f2d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rules do not address the statutory exception for honorably retired police officers whose certification may not lapse if they meet departmental requirements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.500","citation":"ORS 181A.500(1)(b)(B)","quote":"Is an honorably retired police officer who meets the requirements established by the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training under paragraph (c) of this subsection for maintaining certification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0067","citation":"OAR 259-008-0067(1)–(4)","quote":"Law enforcement officer certifications lapse after a law enforcement officer has been separated from their certifiable position for a consecutive period greater than three months...Public safety professional certifications do not lapse when the public safety professional is on leave from their employing agency...Public safety professional certifications expire after a public safety professional has been separated from their certifiable position for a consecutive period greater than five years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.500","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"44c227120cbb3b8a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule adds conviction for bias or hate crime as a mandatory ground for denial of public safety professional certifications, but the statute ORS 181A.640(2) does not list this as a separate mandatory ground for police officers.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-008-0300","citation":"OAR 259-008-0300(2)(d)","quote":"The public safety professional has a conviction in any jurisdiction for a bias or hate crime","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.640","citation":"ORS 181A.640(2)","quote":"(a) The officer has a conviction for any offense designated under the law of the jurisdiction where the conviction occurred as being punishable as a felony or as a crime for which a maximum term of imprisonment of more than one year may be imposed; (b) The officer has a conviction in any jurisdiction for any offense involving the unlawful use, possession, delivery or manufacture of a controlled substance, narcotic or dangerous drug, except for offenses involving the use or possession of marijuana; (c) The officer has a conviction in any jurisdiction for any offense involving domestic violence, as defined in ORS 135.230; (d) The officer has a conviction in any jurisdiction for any offense involving abuse, as defined in ORS 107.705, of a child who is under 18 years of age and is a natural child, adopted child, stepchild, a child under the guardianship of, or a child who regularly resides or formerly resided in the same household as, the officer; (e) The officer is a sex offender as defined in ORS 163A.005; or (f) The officer has been discharged for cause","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.640","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e6f19d887c217adb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule adds conviction for bias or hate crime as a mandatory ground for denial of fire service professional certifications, but the statute ORS 181A.640(3) and (4) limit mandatory grounds to crimes listed in ORS 137.700.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-009-0120","citation":"OAR 259-009-0120(2)(b)","quote":"The fire service professional has a conviction in any jurisdiction for any offense involving a bias or hate crime","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.640","citation":"ORS 181A.640(3)","quote":"The department shall deny, suspend or revoke the certification of a fire service professional, after written notice and hearing consistent with the provisions of ORS 181A.630, based upon a finding that the fire service professional has been convicted in this state of a crime listed in ORS 137.700 or in any other jurisdiction of a crime that, if committed in this state, would constitute a crime listed in ORS 137.700.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.640","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0685cbc03c03680","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-065-0200 declares it implements ORS 181A.225, but its operative text addresses victim services (safety planning, trauma-informed practices, qualifying programs) and never engages with the statute's actual subject matter: crime statistics reporting requirements, data collection, quarterly/annual reports, and disclosure rules.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.225","citation":"ORS 181A.225","quote":"All law enforcement agencies shall report to the Department of State Police statistics concerning crimes... The department shall prepare: (a) Quarterly and annual reports for the use of agencies reporting under subsection (1) of this section... (b) An annual public report of the statistics on the incidence of crime motivated by prejudice...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-065-0200","citation":"OAR 137-065-0200, frontmatter","quote":"ORS 166.155, ORS 137.678, ORS 181A.225","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-065-0200","citation":"OAR 137-065-0200(2)","quote":"\"Safety planning\" means assisting in the creation of a personalized, individual plan to: (a) Address specific safety concerns resulting from the hate or bias activity...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.225","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bf8b780b328f8b5f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-007-0220 specifies information required for criminal records checks without differentiating by category, contrary to the statute's requirement to specify information 'for each category'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.215","citation":"ORS 181A.215(2)(b)","quote":"Specifying the information, for each category, that may be required from a subject individual to permit a criminal records check.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-007-0220","citation":"OAR 125-007-0220(1)","quote":"An SI may be required to provide identification and information to have a criminal records check completed including, but not limited to; (a) Legal name and aliases; (b) Date of birth; (c) Address and recent residency information; (d) Driver license or identification card information; (e) Type of work or service being performed; (f) Disclosure of criminal history; all arrests, charges, convictions and offenses. (g) Social Security number, optional only, used solely for the purpose of positively identifying the SI during the criminal records check process.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0bcd41d8fd4ae17","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-007-0270 specifies types of crimes uniformly across all categories without differentiating by category, contrary to the statute's requirement to specify crimes 'for each category'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.215","citation":"ORS 181A.215(2)(c)","quote":"Specifying the types of crimes that may be considered in reviewing criminal offender information of a subject individual for each category.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-007-0270","citation":"OAR 125-007-0270(1)","quote":"A conviction of any of the following crimes or offenses is potentially disqualifying, unless otherwise provided by law. (a) All felonies. (b) All misdemeanors. (c) Any U.S. military crime or international crime.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aa42a637c647fafb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 259-003-0015 and OAR 259-005-0015 both declare they implement ORS 181A.880, but apply different procedures: 259-003-0015 to 'agency declaratory rulings' and 259-005-0015 to 'contested cases,' creating ambiguity about which procedure governs the hearing required by the statute for denials, suspensions, and revocations.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-003-0015","citation":"OAR 259-003-0015","quote":"Pursuant to the provisions of ORS 183.341, the Board and Department adopt the Attorney General's Model Rules of Procedure applicable to proceedings for agency declaratory rulings under the Administrative Procedures Act","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-005-0015","citation":"OAR 259-005-0015","quote":"Pursuant to the provisions of ORS 183.341, the Board and Department adopt the Attorney General's Model Rules of Procedure applicable to contested cases under the Administrative Procedures Act","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.880","citation":"ORS 181A.880(1)","quote":"If the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training or the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training denies a license or certificate or declines to renew a license or certificate or suspends or revokes a license or certificate, opportunity for a hearing consistent with the provisions of ORS 181A.630 shall be afforded as provided in ORS chapter 183.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.880","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7bf60c467e531959","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The statute requires training for 'all police officers and certified reserve officers,' but the rule specifies these training requirements only within the Basic Police Course curriculum without explicitly extending them to certified reserve officers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.470","citation":"ORS 181A.470","quote":"The Board on Public Safety Standards and Training shall ensure that all police officers and certified reserve officers are trained to: (1) Investigate, identify and report crimes: (a) Motivated by prejudice based on the perceived race, color, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, marital status, political affiliation or beliefs, membership or activity in or on behalf of a labor organization or against a labor organization, physical or mental disability, age, economic or social status or citizenship of the victim; and (b) That constitute abuse, as defined in ORS 419B.005, or domestic violence. (2) Understand the requirements of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations and identify situations in which the officers are required to inform a person of the person's rights under the convention.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0085","citation":"OAR 259-008-0085(1)(b)","quote":"Training will include, at a minimum: (E) The investigation, identification and reporting of crimes motivated by prejudice based on perceived race, color, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, marital status, political affiliation or beliefs, membership or activity in or on behalf of a labor organization or against a labor organization, physical or mental disability, age, economic or social status or citizenship of the victim; (F) Investigation, identification and reporting of crimes constituting abuse, as defined in ORS 419B.005, or domestic violence; (G) The requirements of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, including situations in which officers are required to inform a person of the person's rights under the convention","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.470","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eccf11f897e400e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule section (3)(a) excludes individuals controlling access to premises where minors are prohibited from the ORS 181A.845(1)(L) exemption, but the statute only limits this exemption during large-scale events outside ordinary business, not based on premises type or access control functions.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.845","citation":"ORS 181A.845(1)(L) and (3)","quote":"A person who has a valid service permit issued by the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission pursuant to ORS 471.360 and who is an employee of a licensee of the commission when the person is performing age verification and controlling access to premises of the licensee... The exemption provided by subsection (1)(L) of this section does not apply during an organized event that is on a scale substantially outside the ordinary course of the licensee's business.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0015","citation":"OAR 259-060-0015(3)(a)","quote":"The exemption found in ORS 181A.845(1)(L) does not apply to an individual who has the primary responsibility of controlling access to premises at an entry to the premises or any portion of the premises where minors are prohibited.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.845","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2ec48cdbad459274","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The rule creates mandatory minimum civil penalties ($250-$1,000 depending on professional type) that the statute does not require, narrowing the Board's discretion to impose penalties below those thresholds.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.995","citation":"ORS 181A.995(2)","quote":"the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training may impose a civil penalty not to exceed $1,500 for a violation of any provision of ORS 181A.840 to 181A.918 or any rule adopted by the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training or Department of Public Safety Standards and Training pursuant to ORS 181A.840 to 181A.918","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0450","citation":"OAR 259-060-0450(9)","quote":"Alarm monitor, unarmed and event and entertainment private security professionals will be charged a penalty of not less than $250 for the first violation and a maximum of $1,500 for each flagrant violation. (b) Armed private security professionals will be charged a penalty of not less than $500 for the first violation and a maximum of $1,500 for each flagrant violation. (c) Private security instructors will be charged a penalty of not less than $750 for the first violation and a maximum of $1,500 for each flagrant violation. (d) Private security managers, contract executive managers and employers who employ individuals to provide private security services will be charged a penalty of not less than $1,000 for the first violation and a maximum of $1,500 for each flagrant violation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.995","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5dd541d16ba4d35e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 181A.410 but the operative text is entirely procedural about rulemaking notice and never engages with ORS 181A.410's substantive authority over public safety standards and training.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-001-0005","citation":"OAR 259-001-0005","quote":"ORS 181A.410, ORS 181A.870, ORS 183.341, ORS 703.230, ORS 703.480","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.410","citation":"ORS 181A.410","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d4fdbc4a2ab227f3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 181A.410 but the operative text merely adopts procedural rules and never engages with ORS 181A.410's substantive authority over public safety standards and training.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-259-001-0015","citation":"OAR 259-001-0015","quote":"ORS 181A.410, ORS 181A.870, ORS 183.341, ORS 703.230, ORS 703.480","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-181a.410","citation":"ORS 181A.410","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2f6a6fb624657127","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The Executive Manager definition in the rule cites ORS 181A.840 to 181A.893 for compliance responsibility, but the statute cites ORS 181A.840 to 181A.918, narrowing the scope of statutes the manager must ensure compliance with.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.840","citation":"ORS 181A.840(2)(d)","quote":"Who has final responsibility for a company's or business's compliance with ORS 181A.840 to 181A.918","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0010","citation":"OAR 259-060-0010(20)(d)","quote":"Who has final responsibility for a company's or business's compliance with the ORS 181A.840 to 181A.893","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.840","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"37cedffbf2a6ef17","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The License definition in the rule specifies requirements must be 'listed in ORS 181A.855 and these rules' but the statute says requirements must be 'adopted by the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training as necessary to provide private security services,' giving the Board authority to determine necessity rather than fixing requirements in statute.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.840","citation":"ORS 181A.840(4)","quote":"\"License\" means recognition by the department that an executive manager or supervisory manager meets the requirements adopted by the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training as necessary to provide private security services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-060-0010","citation":"OAR 259-060-0010(26)","quote":"\"License\" or \"Licensed\" means recognition by the Department that an executive manager or supervisory manager meets the requirements listed in ORS 181A.855 and these rules.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.840","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"310e2ec19633685b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"The statute requires training in missing persons cases for both 'police officers and certified reserve officers,' but the rule implementing this statute only describes the Basic Police Course curriculum without explicitly ensuring certified reserve officers are required to receive the training.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.460","citation":"ORS 181A.460","quote":"the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training shall ensure that all police officers and certified reserve officers are trained to investigate and report cases of missing children and adults","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0085","citation":"OAR 259-008-0085(1)(b)(D)","quote":"The investigation and reporting of cases of missing children and adults","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f84973f13bc156a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 259-008-0010(1)(b) requires citizenship within 18 months but drops the certification requirement that the statute mandates.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.490","citation":"ORS 181A.490(1)","quote":"a person may not be employed as a police officer, or utilized as a certified reserve officer, by a law enforcement unit for more than 18 months unless the person: (a)(A) Is a citizen of the United States; or (B) Is a nonimmigrant legally admitted to the United States under a Compact of Free Association; and (b) Has been certified as being qualified as a police officer or certified reserve officer under the provisions of ORS 181A.355 to 181A.689","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0010","citation":"OAR 259-008-0010(1)(b)","quote":"A person may not be employed as a police officer or a parole and probation officer for more than 18 months unless the person is a citizen of the United States or a nonimmigrant legally admitted to the United States under a Compact of Free Association.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.490","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a85bfd269df3ee51","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 257-015-0080 contains duplicate subsection numbering, with two subsections labeled (2), making the rule internally inconsistent.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-257-015-0080","citation":"OAR 257-015-0080","quote":"(1) The agency is a criminal justice agency as defined in OAR 257-015-0030(7) and qualifies for access to NCIC/III via an ORI for the administration of criminal justice as defined in OAR 257-015-0030(9) and has been approved for access by the FBI CJIS Division; or(2) The agency is a public safety dispatching service agency which provides computer aided services, dispatching support, or other direct support service to one or more criminal justice agencies, and which has signed a management control agreement with a criminal justice agency; or\n\n(2) The agency is a non-criminal justice agency with a statutory requirement to access limited criminal justice information which may be available via LEDS, and use of the information will be for a criminal justice purpose as defined in OAR 257-015-0030(9); or\n\n(3) The agency is a non-criminal justice social services agency which performs child welfare protection duties under a state statute or federal law.\n\n(4) The agency is a non-criminal justice agency with statutory requirement to use Oregon criminal justice information","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ab8ce22ee34fee0f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"Rule requires Board review of proposed amendments to ALJ orders, but statute only requires policy committee to consider amendments","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-181a.630","citation":"ORS 181A.630(2)(d)(A)","quote":"For cases originally considered by a policy committee, if the department proposes to amend an administrative law judge's proposed order issued in response to a request for a hearing by an instructor or a public safety officer under subsection (1) of this section, the committee shall consider the proposed amendment before the department may issue a final order pursuant to ORS 181A.410.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-008-0340","citation":"OAR 259-008-0340(6)(b)","quote":"Department-proposed amendments to a Proposed Order issued by an Administrative Law Judge in a case that was originally reviewed by a Policy Committee and the Board must be considered by the Policy Committee and the Board before a Final Order can be issued.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.630","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"80d28c1f32dcb5d7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"OAR 413-208-0030 cites different statutes for the same right: ORS 181.555(3) in subsection (1)(a) and ORS 181A.230(3) in subsection (2)(a), both describing the right to inspect and challenge criminal offender information.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-413-208-0030","citation":"OAR 413-208-0030(1)(a) and (2)(a)","quote":"(1)(a) 'Has a right to inspect and challenge their Oregon criminal offender information through OSP procedures as adopted per ORS 181.555(3) and OAR 257-010-0035' and (2)(a) 'who was denied, of the right to inspect and challenge the subject individual's Oregon criminal offender information through OSP procedures as adopted per ORS 181A.230(3) and OAR 257-010-0035'","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-181a.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f70828561b224d3c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-oregon-state-athletic-commission","name":"Department of State Police, Oregon State Athletic Commission"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"real-estate-agency","name":"Real Estate Agency"}]},{"ors_chapter":"182","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":78,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 848-005-0030 claims to implement ORS 182.466(4), which authorizes setting and collecting fees, but the rule requires maintaining name, address, contact information, and employer information for applicants and licensees—not about fees.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-848-005-0030","citation":"ORS 182.466(4)","quote":"ORS 182.466(4), ORS 688.070(1)(2), ORS 688.080, ORS 688.100, ORS 688.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.466","citation":"ORS 182.466(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.466","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ab5693e9cf6577bb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-physical-therapy"]},{"summary":"Rule 2 (Purchasing) cites ORS 182.460(4) but that provision addresses contracting with state agencies for services; ORS 182.460(5) is the actual source requiring boards to adopt purchasing procedures.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-852-005-0010","citation":"ORS 182.460(4)","quote":"ORS 182.460(4)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.460","citation":"ORS 182.460(4)","quote":"In carrying out the duties, functions and powers of a board, the board may contract with any state agency for the performance of duties, functions and powers as the board considers appropriate.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.460","citation":"ORS 182.460(5)","quote":"A board shall adopt personnel policies and contracting and purchasing procedures.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0049a3494a7ddf6c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-optometry"]},{"summary":"OAR 334-001-0025 declares it implements ORS 182.472 (reporting requirements) but its operative text addresses only procurement exceptions, never engaging with reporting obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-334-001-0025","citation":"OAR 334-001-0025","quote":"ORS 182.456 - 182.472, ORS 687.011, ORS 687.051, ORS 687.057, ORS 687.061, ORS 687.086, ORS 687.121","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.472","citation":"ORS 182.472","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.472","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"494f806fccb603ea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"OAR 334-001-0028 declares it implements ORS 182.472 (reporting requirements) but its operative text addresses only procurement authority and contract approval procedures, never engaging with reporting obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-334-001-0028","citation":"OAR 334-001-0028","quote":"ORS 182.456 - 182.472, ORS 687.011, ORS 687.051, ORS 687.057, ORS 687.061, ORS 687.086, ORS 687.121","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.472","citation":"ORS 182.472","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.472","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d2c1871149ddd1f1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"OAR 334-001-0032 declares it implements ORS 182.472 (reporting requirements) but its operative text addresses only source selection methods for procurement, never engaging with reporting obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-334-001-0032","citation":"OAR 334-001-0032","quote":"ORS 182.456 - 182.472, ORS 687.011, ORS 687.051, ORS 687.057, ORS 687.061, ORS 687.086, ORS 687.121","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.472","citation":"ORS 182.472","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.472","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"408032d66e42aa48","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"OAR 334-001-0045 declares it implements ORS 182.472 (reporting requirements) but its operative text addresses only personnel policies, never engaging with reporting obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-334-001-0045","citation":"OAR 334-001-0045","quote":"ORS 182.456 - 182.472","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-182.472","citation":"ORS 182.472","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.472","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"efcfc12f3ff6ef4a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'Cost Effective' omits the statutory requirement that cost-effectiveness be 'as determined utilizing a cost-benefit analytical tool identified by the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.515","citation":"ORS 182.515(2)","quote":"\"Cost-effective\" means that benefits realized over a reasonable period of time are greater than costs, as determined utilizing a cost-benefit analytical tool identified by the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-291-031-0310","citation":"OAR 291-031-0310(1)","quote":"Cost Effective: Benefits realized over a reasonable period of time are greater than costs.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4c23feef3b89bed4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'Program' covers only programs intended to reduce crime likelihood, dropping the statutory definitions of programs intended to improve mental health or reduce youth antisocial behavior","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.515","citation":"ORS 182.515(4)(a)","quote":"\"Program\" means a treatment or intervention program or service that is intended to: (A) Reduce the propensity of a person to commit crimes; (B) Improve the mental health of a person with the result of reducing the likelihood that the person will commit a crime or need emergency mental health services; or (C) Reduce the propensity of a person who is less than 18 years of age to engage in antisocial behavior with the result of reducing the likelihood that the person will become a juvenile offender.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-291-031-0310","citation":"OAR 291-031-0310(3)","quote":"Program: A community-based treatment or intervention program or service that is intended to reduce the likelihood that an individual will commit a crime.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a7de79b29b893450","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"Rule for State Board of Massage Therapists declares it implements ORS 182.462 but omits the statutory requirement that this board specifically present its budget to the Governor, President of Senate, Speaker of House, and Legislative Fiscal Officer.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-334-001-0012","citation":"ORS 182.462(2)","quote":"the Oregon Board of Optometry, the State Board of Massage Therapists and the Oregon Board of Physical Therapy shall, on or before February 1 of each odd-numbered year, present the budget adopted by the board under this section to the Governor, the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the Legislative Fiscal Officer","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.462","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2d41f55595bf6d3d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"Rule for Oregon Board of Optometry declares it implements ORS 182.462(1) & (2) but operative text does not address the statutory requirement that this board present its budget to the Governor, President of Senate, Speaker of House, and Legislative Fiscal Officer.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-852-005-0005","citation":"ORS 182.462(2)","quote":"the Oregon Board of Optometry, the State Board of Massage Therapists and the Oregon Board of Physical Therapy shall, on or before February 1 of each odd-numbered year, present the budget adopted by the board under this section to the Governor, the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the Legislative Fiscal Officer","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.462","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f66232ac612dc901","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-optometry"]},{"summary":"The rules implement evaluation and compliance procedures but drop the core 75% spending requirement that is central to the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.525","citation":"ORS 182.525(1)","quote":"An agency shall spend at least 75 percent of state moneys that the agency receives for programs on evidence-based programs.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-291-031-0300","citation":"OAR 291-031-0300(1)-(3)","quote":"These rules establish a process by which the Department of Corrections determines if community-based programs, on which the agency expends state funds, meet the principles of evidence-based practices... These rules apply to community-based treatment or intervention programs or services that receive state funds and are intended to reduce the likelihood that an individual will commit a crime.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ba42838b5fac04ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"The rules restrict application to 'community-based treatment or intervention programs' narrowing the statute's broader scope to all 'programs' an agency receives moneys for.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.525","citation":"ORS 182.525(1)-(2)","quote":"An agency shall spend at least 75 percent of state moneys that the agency receives for programs on evidence-based programs. The agency shall submit a biennial report containing: (a) An assessment of each program on which the agency expends funds","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-291-031-0300","citation":"OAR 291-031-0300(3)","quote":"These rules apply to community-based treatment or intervention programs or services that receive state funds and are intended to reduce the likelihood that an individual will commit a crime.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"befdf291125ea701","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"Rule broadens the definition of \"Housing\" by allowing tenancy on other than monthly basis, while statute limits to monthly tenancy.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.415","citation":"ORS 182.415(2)","quote":"available on a monthly tenancy","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0000","citation":"OAR 125-060-0000(2)(b)","quote":"available for tenancy on a monthly or other basis","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"9c0a178c965f8626","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule narrows the definition of \"Dormitory\" by limiting it to Mental Health Division employees, while statute includes both Department of Human Services and Oregon Health Authority employees.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.415","citation":"ORS 182.415(3)","quote":"those facilities used primarily for sleeping purposes by the employees of the Department of Human Services or the Oregon Health Authority","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0000","citation":"OAR 125-060-0000(2)(c)","quote":"those facilities used primarily for sleeping purposes by the employees of the Mental Health Division","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eeb8f02720fe109e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule adds a date qualifier \"prior to September 9, 1971\" to the exclusion of Chancellor furniture from the \"Furnishings\" definition, which the statute does not contain, thereby narrowing the exclusion.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-182.415","citation":"ORS 182.415(1)","quote":"nor does it include any furniture purchased for the state-owned residence required in relation to the official duties of an institutional executive","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0000","citation":"OAR 125-060-0000(2)(a)","quote":"nor does it include any furniture purchased for the state-owned residence required in relation to the official duties of an institutional executive or the Chancellor of the Department of Higher Education prior to September 9, 1971","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-182.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"adb7b43e963b4502","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-massage-therapists","name":"Board of Massage Therapists"},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"citizens-initiative-review-commission","name":"Citizens' Initiative Review Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-naturopathic-medicine","name":"Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-physical-therapy","name":"Oregon Board of Physical Therapy"},{"slug":"oregon-patient-safety-commission","name":"Oregon Patient Safety Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"183","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":976,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 585-015-0035 declares implementation of ORS 183.411 to 183.497, but describes administrative complaint and hearing procedures before an administrative law judge, which fall outside ORS 183.497's scope that applies only to 'judicial review of a final order' and other specific judicial proceedings in circuit court against state agencies.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.497","citation":"ORS 183.497(2)","quote":"The provisions of subsection (1) of this section apply to an administrative or judicial proceeding brought by a petitioner against a state agency, as defined in ORS 291.002, for: (a) Judicial review of a final order as provided in ORS 183.480 to 183.484","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-585-015-0035","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 183.411 to 183.497, ORS 346.510 to 346.570","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-585-015-0035","citation":"OAR 585-015-0035(3)(d)","quote":"A full evidentiary hearing is conducted as a contested case hearing before an independent administrative law judge under the procedures set forth in ORS 183.411 to 183.497.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.497","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"17bac26eb0f1c659","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["commission-for-the-blind"]},{"summary":"Rule requires petitioner to affirmatively explain why granting stay will not result in substantial public harm; statute puts that determination on the agency, requiring the agency to determine whether substantial public harm will result after the petitioner shows irreparable injury and colorable claim of error.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0690","citation":"OAR 137-003-0690(3)(g)","quote":"A statement explaining why granting the stay will not result in substantial public harm","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.482","citation":"ORS 183.482(3)(a)-(b)","quote":"the agency may do so upon a showing of: (A) Irreparable injury to the petitioner; and (B) A colorable claim of error in the order... When a petitioner makes the showing required by paragraph (a) of this subsection, the agency shall grant the stay unless the agency determines that substantial public harm will result if the order is stayed.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.482","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e89de90f76150fff","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 309-114-0005(1) requires all authorized representatives to be supervised by an Oregon State Bar-licensed attorney, but ORS 183.458(3) allows relatives, friends, or any other person chosen by the claimant to represent someone in medical assistance cases without any supervision requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-309-114-0005","citation":"OAR 309-114-0005(1)","quote":"\"Authorized Representative\" or \"representative\" means an individual who represents a party in a contested case hearing; the representative must be supervised by an attorney that is licensed by the Oregon State Bar.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.458","citation":"ORS 183.458(3)","quote":"In any contested case hearing before a state agency involving an applicant for or recipient of medical assistance, the claimant may be represented by a relative, friend or any other person of the claimant's choosing.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.458","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b433ec76ba9a85fa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]},{"summary":"oar-340-011-0530 declares it implements ORS 183.464, which addresses proposed orders and their finalization, but the rule's operative text is entirely about requests for hearing and never engages with the proposed order statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-011-0530","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.464, 183.482, 183.745 & 183.484","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.464","citation":"ORS 183.464","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.464","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"49b97da3b8496f42","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(7) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0001","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.413, ORS 183.415(7), ORS 183.502, 2007 HB 2423","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(7)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4924b041c4a982c0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(4) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0005","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(4), ORS 183.450(3)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"facb11fdc3ee5a8b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(4) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0007","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 180.060, ORS 180.220, ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(4)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ab56ba2f27c5515","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule text references ORS 183.415(10) but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0025","citation":"ORS 183.415(10)","quote":"or unless excluding the evidence would violate the duty to conduct a full and fair inquiry under ORS 183.415(10)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(10)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4765231a3c76b233","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(9) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0035","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(9), ORS 183.462","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(9)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3161d3b12ab143e1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(9) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0040","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(9), ORS 183.462","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(9)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8697e7c9f80d0eab","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(9) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0055","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 173.341(1), ORS 183.415(9), ORS 183.462","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(9)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ec64947d2b8f2d2a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(6) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0075","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(6), ORS 183.470, 2007 HB 2423","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(6)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"927918e5ea977b4f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(4) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0535","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341, ORS 183.415(4), ORS 183.450(3), OL 1999 Ch. 849","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"98c673737c29d37b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(4) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0540","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 180.060, ORS 180.220, ORS 183.341, ORS 183.415(4), OL 1999 Ch. 849","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b63af2f51d9cddc6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(5) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0565","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.341, ORS 183.415(5), ORS 183.502","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(5)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6bf18b0422163d21","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 183.415(6) in declared statutes, but the statute provided only contains sections (1)-(3).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-438-085-0810","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.415(6), ORS 654.025, ORS 654.078","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.415","citation":"ORS 183.415(6)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"523955266fc6cdc9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board"]},{"summary":"Rule requires petitioner to include detailed comments on multiple factors when requesting amendment or repeal, while statute only requires agency to consider these factors when reviewing the petition and agency to invite public comment.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.390","citation":"ORS 183.390(2) and (3)","quote":"(2) If a petition requesting the amendment or repeal of a rule is submitted to an agency under this section, the agency shall invite public comment upon the rule, and shall specifically request public comment on whether options exist for achieving the rule's substantive goals in a way that reduces the negative economic impact on businesses. (3) In reviewing a petition subject to subsection (2) of this section, the agency shall consider: (a) The continued need for the rule; (b) The nature of complaints or comments received concerning the rule from the public; (c) The complexity of the rule; (d) The extent to which the rule overlaps, duplicates or conflicts with other state rules or federal regulations and, to the extent feasible, with local government regulations; (e) The degree to which technology, economic conditions or other factors have changed in the subject area affected by the rule; and (f) The statutory citation or legal basis for the rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-001-0070","citation":"OAR 137-001-0070(2)","quote":"(2) If the petitioner requests the amendment or repeal of an existing rule, the petition must also contain comments on: (a) Options for achieving the existing rule's substantive goals while reducing the negative economic impact on businesses; (b) The continued need for the existing rule; (c) The complexity of the existing rule; (d) The extent to which the existing rule overlaps, duplicates, or conflicts with other state or federal rules and with local government regulations; and (e) The degree to which technology, economic conditions, or other factors have changed in the subject area affected by the existing rule, since the agency adopted the rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.390","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8bbcb8b1d85c52b0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule makes declaratory rulings binding between intervenors and the agency, but the statute states rulings are binding only between the agency and the petitioner.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.410","citation":"ORS 183.410","quote":"A declaratory ruling is binding between the agency and the petitioner on the state of facts alleged","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-002-0025","citation":"OAR 137-002-0025(4)","quote":"the declaratory ruling, if any, issued by the agency shall be binding between the intervenor and the agency on the facts stated in the petition","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cce02745fa1d1e98","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-001-0750 declares implementation of ORS 183.411 but governs representation and legal argument in hearings, not delegation of authority to enter final orders.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.411","citation":"ORS 183.411","quote":"an agency may delegate authority to enter a final order in a proceeding or class of proceedings to an officer or employee of the agency, or to a class of officers or employees of the agency","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-001-0750","citation":"OAR 123-001-0750(1)","quote":"ORS 183.411, ORS 183.452","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-001-0750","citation":"OAR 123-001-0750(1)","quote":"Subject to the approval of the office of Attorney General of the State of Oregon under ORS chapter 180, the Director may authorize an officer or employee of the Department to appear on behalf of the Department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.411","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"336fcf77e7417417","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 170-060-0000 declares only ORS 183.355 as implemented, but the rule is entirely about notice of proposed rulemaking in the Secretary of State's Bulletin. ORS 183.355 addresses filing and effective dates of rules, not notice requirements (which are in ORS 183.335). The operative text references ORS 183.360 and never engages with ORS 183.355.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-170-060-0000","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.355","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2dce9ef37c43413c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"OAR 170-060-0001 declares only ORS 183.355 as implemented, but the rule provides definitions of terms (Counterparty, Swap policy, MDAC, OST) specific to State Treasurer regulations. These definitions are entirely unrelated to the subject matter of ORS 183.355 (filing and effective dates of rules). The operative text has no engagement with ORS 183.355.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-170-060-0001","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.355","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.355","citation":"ORS 183.355","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"06cfae4a4144fadc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"OAR 414-050-0005 declares ORS 183.355 as implemented, but the operative text is entirely about advance notice requirements (21 days, 28 days, 49 days, and media notification). ORS 183.355 addresses filing and effective dates of rules, not notice requirements. The rule references ORS 183.335(15) and ORS 183.360, not ORS 183.355, and never engages with ORS 183.355's content.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-414-050-0005","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 326.430 & ORS 183.355","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"31857fb770eb3c9f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division"]},{"summary":"Rule establishes procedures for contested case hearings, but ORS 183.484 explicitly applies only to orders 'other than contested cases'","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-011-0530","citation":"OAR 340-011-0530 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.415, ORS 183.464, ORS 183.482, ORS 183.745, ORS 183.484","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.484","citation":"ORS 183.484 heading and section (1)","quote":"Jurisdiction for review of orders other than contested cases; procedure; scope of court authority... Jurisdiction for judicial review of orders other than contested cases is conferred upon the Circuit Court","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.484","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b0ffafd0c2e07ca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule describes screening and investigating child abuse procedures, but ORS 183.484 establishes judicial review procedures for non-contested case orders, which the rule's operative text never engages","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-419-210-0100","citation":"OAR 419-210-0100 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.484, ORS 443.400 - 443.455, ORS 409.010, ORS 418.519-418.532, ORS 409.185, ORS 418.005, ORS 418.257 - 418.259, ORS 409.050, ORS 419B.005 - 419B.050","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-419-210-0100","citation":"OAR 419-210-0100(1) and (2)","quote":"The circumstances under which the Office of Training, Investigations and Safety (OTIS) is responsible to respond to a report of abuse of a child-in-care and The requirements for screening and investigating a report of abuse of a child-in-care that is the responsibility of OTIS","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.484","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5f79db8daa255d5b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["office-of-training-investigations-and-safety"]},{"summary":"Emergency Management adopts Attorney General Model Rules requiring 21 days notice (104-001-0005) but its own notice rule requires only 15 days notice (104-001-0000)","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-104-001-0005","citation":"OAR 104-001-0005","quote":"The Oregon Department of Emergency Management adopts by reference the Attorney General's Model Rules of Procedure for the adoption of rules and conduct of proceedings, effective July 31, 2014.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-104-001-0000","citation":"OAR 104-001-0000","quote":"In the Secretary of State's Bulletin referred to in ORS 183.360 at least 15 days before the effective date of the intended action","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.341","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2d0deb077d75561b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0250 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only what damages may or may not be awarded; it never engages with the statute's core requirement that proposed orders with findings be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0250","citation":"OAR 808-004-0250, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, ORS 183.460","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ed69ae103a667684","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0400 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only initial claim intake and processing; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0400","citation":"OAR 808-004-0400, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460 & 671.703","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"905940db6d888c16","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0480 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only mediation settlement agreements; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0480","citation":"OAR 808-004-0480, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460, ORS 671.703","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"11ea59fa119a445c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0500 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only claim closure procedures after settlement; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0500","citation":"OAR 808-004-0500, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460, ORS 671.703","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"140975c367baf084","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0520 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only suspension of processing when claims are transferred to courts or arbitrators; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0520","citation":"OAR 808-004-0520, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460, 671.703 & 671.575","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4b0c01efec380020","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-808-004-0540 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only how monetary damages are established and documented; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0540","citation":"OAR 808-004-0540, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460, 183.470, ORS 671.703","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f2e959527ce796f2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-812-001-0130 declares it implements ORS 183.460 but the operative text addresses only the disposal of large objects submitted as hearing exhibits after 90 days; it never engages with the statute's requirement that proposed orders be served and parties afforded opportunity to file exceptions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-001-0130","citation":"OAR 812-001-0130, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 183.415, 183.460 & 701.145","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.460","citation":"ORS 183.460","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fbeff1ef14e73232","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule adds a submission location for housing cost impact statements not specified in the statute","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.534","citation":"ORS 183.534(2)(a)","quote":"For an agency listed in ORS 183.530 shall be incorporated in: (A) Fiscal impact statement required by ORS 183.335 (2)(b)(E) for permanent rule adoption; or (B) Statements required by ORS 183.335 (5) for temporary rule adoption.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-813-025-0015","citation":"OAR 813-025-0015(2)","quote":"The Housing Cost Impact Statement shall be submitted with one of the following: (a) Fiscal impact statement as stated in ORS 183.325(2)(b)(E); (b) A notice of proposed permanent rulemaking action as stated in ORS 183.335(1); or (c) A temporary rule adoption as stated in ORS 183.335(5).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.534","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb6406268736b7b4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-housing-and-community-services-department"]},{"summary":"The statute requires attorney-issued subpoenas be 'subscribed by the signature of the attorney,' but the rule does not include this signature requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.445","citation":"ORS 183.445(1)","quote":"a subpoena may be issued by an attorney of record of the party, subscribed by the signature of the attorney","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0585","citation":"OAR 137-003-0585(1)(c)","quote":"By an attorney representing a party on behalf of that party","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cd5b5523ccf03c1c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 333-070-0210 declares implementation of ORS 183.540 (reduction of economic impact on small business) but the rule's operative text addresses only inspections, enforcement, civil penalties, and suspension/revocation of lead-based paint certifications—it never engages with small business impact mitigation requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-333-070-0210","citation":"OAR 333-070-0210, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.310-183.540, ORS 183.745, ORS 431A.355, ORS 431A.358, ORS 431A.363","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.540","citation":"ORS 183.540","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.540","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"798072baed11473c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-003-0075 permits final orders by default without explicitly requiring findings of fact and conclusions of law, contrary to the statute's mandate that all final orders be accompanied by these.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.470","citation":"ORS 183.470(2)","quote":"A final order shall be accompanied by findings of fact and conclusions of law.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0075","citation":"OAR 137-003-0075(3)","quote":"The agency may issue a final order that is adverse to a party by default only after making a prima facie case on the record.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.470","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"88d8668a9b848c7e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 438-085-0745(2) lists who can issue subpoenas but omits agencies issuing on their own motion, which ORS 183.440(1) explicitly permits.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.440","citation":"ORS 183.440(1)","quote":"An agency may issue subpoenas on its own motion in a contested case.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-438-085-0745","citation":"OAR 438-085-0745(2)","quote":"Subpoenas may be issued by the Presiding Administrative Law Judge, the Administrative Law Judge, or the representative of record of the party in whose behalf the witnesses are required to appear.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b939b58b700f56db","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-011-0550 declares implementation of ORS 183.440 but its operative text addresses only discovery procedures (depositions, interrogatories, site visits) and never engages with the subpoena provisions of that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-011-0550","citation":"OAR 340-011-0550 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.425, ORS 183.440, ORS 183.450","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.440","citation":"ORS 183.440","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6b7fea183ca38a62","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0330(5)(a) addresses only home care workers and personal support workers but omits family child care providers who are expressly covered by ORS 183.459(2) for representation in contested case hearings with the Department of Early Learning and Care.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.459","citation":"ORS 183.459(2)","quote":"Notwithstanding ORS 8.690, 9.160 and 9.320, a family child care provider, as defined in ORS 329A.430, who is a party in a contested case hearing conducted by the Department of Early Learning and Care may be represented in the hearing by a labor union representative.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-407-007-0330","citation":"OAR 407-007-0330(5)(a)","quote":"An SI who is appealing an adverse outcome regarding the position of homecare worker as defined in ORS 410.600 or personal support worker as defined in ORS 410.600 may be represented by a labor union representative pursuant to ORS 183.459.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b908258481f7b0da","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0200 declares it implements ORS 183.459 (which concerns labor union representation in contested case hearings), but the rule's operative text addresses only background checks and criminal records screening, never engaging with labor union representation at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-407-007-0200","citation":"OAR 407-007-0200 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 181A.195, ORS 181A.200, 183.459, ORS 409.025, ORS 409.027, ORS 411.060, ORS 411.122, ORS 413.036, ORS 409.010, ORS 443.004","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-183.459","citation":"ORS 183.459","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e34980dea72c4d3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0600 declares it implements ORS 183.459 (which concerns labor union representation in contested case hearings), but the rule's operative text addresses only background check registry procedures, never engaging with labor union representation.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-407-007-0600","citation":"OAR 407-007-0600 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 181A.195, ORS 181A.200, ORS 183.459, ORS 409.025, ORS 409.027, ORS 411.060, ORS 443.006, ORS 409.010, ORS 443.004","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.459","citation":"ORS 183.459","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"14095054004a82ef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0630 declares it implements ORS 183.459 (which concerns labor union representation in contested case hearings), but the rule's operative text addresses only reporting requirements for qualified entities regarding subject individuals, never engaging with labor union representation.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-407-007-0630","citation":"OAR 407-007-0630 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 181A.195, ORS 181A.200, ORS 183.459, ORS 409.025, ORS 409.027, ORS 411.060, ORS 443.004, ORS 443.725, ORS 443.735, ORS 409.010, ORS 443.006","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.459","citation":"ORS 183.459","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"401749798ceae8cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 407-007-0640 declares it implements ORS 183.459 (which concerns labor union representation in contested case hearings), but the rule's operative text addresses only access to and release of registry information, never engaging with labor union representation.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-407-007-0640","citation":"OAR 407-007-0640 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 181A.195, ORS 181A.200, ORS 183.459, ORS 409.010, ORS 409.025, ORS 409.027, ORS 411.060, ORS 443.004, ORS 443.006","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.459","citation":"ORS 183.459","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4cafbccfe2f2e5ee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-200-2200 declares it implements ORS 183.450(7)(b), but the statute contains only subsections (1) through (5).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-200-2200","citation":"OAR 123-200-2200, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.450(7)(b)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.450","citation":"ORS 183.450","quote":"183.450 Evidence in contested cases. In contested cases:\n\n(1) Irrelevant... (2) All evidence... (3) Every party... (4) The hearing officer and agency... (5) No sanction...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b9122728a074d436","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 345-001-0060 declares it implements ORS 183.450(8), but the statute contains only subsections (1) through (5).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-345-001-0060","citation":"OAR 345-001-0060, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.450(8), ORS 469","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.450","citation":"ORS 183.450","quote":"183.450 Evidence in contested cases. In contested cases:\n\n(1) Irrelevant... (2) All evidence... (3) Every party... (4) The hearing officer and agency... (5) No sanction...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af53b109cd9cbd7f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council"]},{"summary":"OAR 860-001-0450(1)(c) adds a balancing test for excluding evidence (probative value substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice) that is not stated in ORS 183.450(1), which provides that evidence commonly relied upon \"shall be admissible\" with only three specified exceptions: irrelevant, immaterial, or unduly repetitious.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.450","citation":"ORS 183.450(1)","quote":"Irrelevant, immaterial or unduly repetitious evidence shall be excluded but erroneous rulings on evidence shall not preclude agency action on the record unless shown to have substantially prejudiced the rights of a party. All other evidence of a type commonly relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in conduct of their serious affairs shall be admissible.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-001-0450","citation":"OAR 860-001-0450(1)","quote":"Relevant evidence: (a) Means evidence tending to make the existence of any fact at issue in the proceedings more or less probable than it would be without the evidence; (b) Is admissible if it is of a type commonly relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in the conduct of their serious affairs; and (c) May be excluded if the probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of the issues, or undue delay.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85fc0493846517c5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["public-utility-commission"]},{"summary":"The rules fail to implement ORS 183.630(4), which restricts ALJ authority to authorize agency-paid depositions. The discovery rules (OAR 137-003-0566, et seq.) list specific discovery methods (witness lists, documents, requests for admission, interrogatories) but do not mention depositions or the statutory prohibition on ALJ authorization of agency-paid depositions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.630","citation":"ORS 183.630(4)","quote":"an administrative law judge conducting a hearing for an agency under ORS 183.605 to 183.690 may not authorize a party to take a deposition that is to be paid for by the agency","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0566","citation":"OAR 137-003-0566(1)","quote":"Before the hearing, upon request by the agency or by a party, the agency and each party must provide: (a) The names, telephone numbers, and addresses of witnesses expected to testify at the hearing, except rebuttal witnesses; (b) Documents that the party or agency plans to offer as evidence; (c) Objects for inspection, if the party or agency plans to offer the objects as evidence: (d) Responses to no more than 20 requests for admission (each subpart to count as a separate request) unless otherwise authorized, limited, or prohibited by the administrative law judge; and, (e) Responses to no more than 20 written interrogatories (each subpart to count as a separate interrogatory), unless otherwise authorized, limited, or prohibited by the administrative law judge","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.630","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"72decac9cfce652d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-057-0510 reduces the deadline for requesting a hearing from 20 days (as stated in statute) to 10 days.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.745","citation":"ORS 183.745(3)","quote":"The person to whom the notice is addressed shall have 20 days from the date of service of the notice provided for in subsection (2) of this section in which to make written application for a hearing.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-057-0510","citation":"OAR 603-057-0510(4)(f)(B)","quote":"Any request for hearing must be received by the Department within ten (10) days of the date the Department mailed the notice","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.745","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d588c0603c6935c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-057-0502 changes the payment deadline from '10 days' (as stated in statute) to '10 business days'.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.745","citation":"ORS 183.745(2)","quote":"A civil penalty imposed under this section shall become due and payable 10 days after the order imposing the civil penalty becomes final by operation of law or on appeal.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-057-0502","citation":"OAR 603-057-0502(9)","quote":"Civil penalties shall be due and payable ten (10) business days after the order becomes final by operation of law or on appeal.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.745","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"baf241845bf08d9a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 177-010-0025 delegates authority to 'the Director' (a position/title) rather than to a named individual as required by the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.325","citation":"ORS 183.325","quote":"A delegation under this section may be made only to one or more named individuals. The delegation of authority shall reflect the name of the authorized individual or individuals","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-177-010-0025","citation":"OAR 177-010-0025(2)","quote":"The Commission delegates the authority to the Director to discipline, and/or terminate, with or without cause, any or all of the assistant directors","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e3cae92f3047a49d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-lottery"]},{"summary":"OAR 410-001-0005 declares it implements ORS 183.325 (delegation of authority to named individuals) but the operative text only directs compliance with chapter 943 rules on notices and does not address delegation to named individuals.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-410-001-0005","citation":"OAR 410-001-0005 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.325, ORS 183.330, ORS 183.335, ORS 183.341, ORS 414.025, ORS 414.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-410-001-0005","citation":"OAR 410-001-0005","quote":"Oregon Health Authority (Authority), Division of Medical Assistance Programs, chapter 410, will comply with Authority rules in chapter 943 for Notices of Rulemaking and adoption of Temporary rules","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.325","citation":"ORS 183.325","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f74253fb5d2eb100","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs"]},{"summary":"OAR 410-001-0020 declares it implements ORS 183.325 (delegation of authority to named individuals) but the operative text only directs compliance with chapter 943 rules and does not address delegation to named individuals.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-410-001-0020","citation":"OAR 410-001-0020 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.325, ORS 183.330, ORS 183.335, ORS 183.341, ORS 414.025, ORS 414.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-410-001-0020","citation":"OAR 410-001-0020","quote":"Oregon Health Authority (Authority), Division of Medical Assistance Programs, chapter 410, will comply with Authority rules in chapter 943 for Delegation of Rulemaking Authority","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.325","citation":"ORS 183.325","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cc64dfedaf6829d6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-001-0110 delegates authority to the 'Construction Contractors Board Administrator' (a position/title) rather than to a named individual as required by the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.325","citation":"ORS 183.325","quote":"A delegation under this section may be made only to one or more named individuals. The delegation of authority shall reflect the name of the authorized individual or individuals","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-001-0110","citation":"OAR 812-001-0110","quote":"The Construction Contractors Board Administrator may adopt, amend, or suspend a rule as provided in ORS 183.335","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd045688b933221f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute permits agencies to use arbitration to resolve disputes, but the rule restricts this to non-binding arbitration only.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.675","citation":"ORS 183.675","quote":"the ability of any agency to use alternative dispute resolution, including mediation or arbitration, to resolve disputes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0510","citation":"OAR 137-003-0510(2)","quote":"Such alternative methods of resolution may include arbitration or any collaborative method designed to encourage the agency and the parties to work together to develop a mutually agreeable solution, such as negotiation, mediation, use of a facilitator or a neutral fact-finder or settlement conferences, but may not include arbitration that is binding on the agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.675","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4aaaf9cee1014323","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-003-0625(2)(d) requires copies of written responses to 'any ex parte oral or written communication,' while ORS 183.685(1) specifies written responses in (c) without clarifying oral communications, and separately requires memoranda of oral responses only 'to an ex parte oral communication' in (1)(e), suggesting written response copying may be limited to written communications.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ORS 183.685(1)","citation":"ORS 183.685(1)(c) and (e)","quote":"(c) A copy of any written response to the communication made by the administrative law judge; and (e) A memorandum reflecting the substance of any oral response made by the administrative law judge to an ex parte oral communication.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"OAR 137-003-0625(2)(d)","citation":"OAR 137-003-0625(2)(d)","quote":"A copy of any written response made by the administrative law judge to any ex parte oral or written communication","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.685","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"270e976010211fdf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0572 requires petitioner to explain why no other means are adequate, but statute only requires showing materiality","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.425","citation":"ORS 183.425(1)","quote":"The petition shall set forth the name and address of the witness whose testimony is desired, a showing of the materiality of the testimony of the witness, and a request for an order that the testimony of such witness be taken before an officer named in the petition for that purpose.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0572","citation":"OAR 137-003-0572(2)","quote":"The petition shall include the name and address of the witness, explain why the witness's testimony is material to the proceedings and explain why no other means of obtaining the witness's testimony for the hearing is adequate.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.425","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"26f7234bbf58edca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0025 requires explanation of why deposition is necessary, but statute only requires showing of materiality and other specified items","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.425","citation":"ORS 183.425(1)","quote":"The petition shall set forth the name and address of the witness whose testimony is desired, a showing of the materiality of the testimony of the witness, and a request for an order that the testimony of such witness be taken before an officer named in the petition for that purpose.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0025","citation":"OAR 137-003-0025(3)(a)","quote":"The request must include the name and address of the witness, a showing of the materiality of the witness's testimony, an explanation of why a deposition rather than informal or other means of discovery is necessary, and a request that the witness's testimony be taken before an individual named in the request for the purpose of recording testimony.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.425","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"321814d7d164a5da","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 461-175-0340(2)(b) adds 'reliance on misinformation provided by the Department' as a ground to set aside a voluntary agreement, but ORS 183.417(3)(a) authorizes petitions to set aside informal dispositions only 'on the ground that the informal disposition was obtained by fraud or duress.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.417","citation":"ORS 183.417(3)(a)","quote":"A party may petition the agency to set aside a final order that incorporates the informal disposition on the ground that the informal disposition was obtained by fraud or duress.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-175-0340","citation":"OAR 461-175-0340(2)(b)","quote":"The individual may request a hearing to set aside this agreement on the grounds of fraud, duress, or reliance on misinformation provided by the Department, subject to the time limits for hearing requests in OAR 461-025-0310.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.417","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b47d1252ccd361d0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"Rule 410-200-0145(5) authorizes agency employee representation without requiring Attorney General consent, which ORS 183.452(2) mandates.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-410-200-0145","citation":"OAR 410-200-0145(5)","quote":"An officer or employee of the Authority or the Department of Human Services may appear on behalf of the Authority in medical assistance hearings described in this rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.452","citation":"ORS 183.452(2)(a)","quote":"an agency may be represented at contested case hearings by an officer or employee of the agency if: (a) The Attorney General has consented to the representation of the agency by an agency representative in the particular hearing or in the class of hearings that includes the particular hearing","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.452","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e476c3c62a28a9bf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-003-0015(2) and OAR 137-003-0565(2) contradict each other on who may establish a deadline for the collaborative dispute resolution process in contested cases.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0015","citation":"OAR 137-003-0015(2)","quote":"If the agency agrees to participate in a collaborative DR process, the agency may establish a deadline for the conclusion of the process.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0565","citation":"OAR 137-003-0565(2)","quote":"The agency, if participating in the contested case hearing, or the administrative law judge, if the agency is not participating in the contested case hearing, may establish a deadline for the conclusion of the collaborative DR process,","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.502","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a632b70de505baf6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0555(1)(b) expands the statutory definition of 'authorized representative' by adding 'or other authorized representatives recognized by state or federal law,' covering categories not enumerated in ORS 183.457(5).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.457","citation":"ORS 183.457(5)","quote":"For the purposes of this section, \"authorized representative\" means a member of a participating partnership, an authorized officer or regular employee of a participating corporation, association or organized group, or an authorized officer or employee of a participating governmental authority other than a state agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0555","citation":"OAR 137-003-0555(1)(b)","quote":"\"Authorized Representative\" means a member of a partnership, an authorized officer or regular employee of a corporation, association or organized group, an authorized officer or employee of a governmental authority other than a state agency or other authorized representatives recognized by state or federal law","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.457","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"94a10427c957676a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0035 addresses prehearing conferences and contains no substantive provisions about ex parte communications, yet declares it implements ORS 183.462 which requires placing ex parte communications on the record and notifying parties of rebuttal rights.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0035","citation":"OAR 137-003-0035","quote":"declared statutes_implemented: ORS 183.341(1), ORS 183.415(9), ORS 183.462","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-183.462","citation":"ORS 183.462","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.462","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d843f6fe902184c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0040(8) and rule 137-003-0055 apply ex parte communication requirements to communications 'during the contested case proceeding,' whereas ORS 183.462 limits the requirement to communications 'during its review of a contested case'—a post-hearing period.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0040","citation":"OAR 137-003-0040(8)","quote":"If the presiding officer or any decision maker receives any written or oral ex parte communication on a fact in issue during the contested case proceeding, that person shall notify all parties and otherwise comply with the requirements of OAR 137-003-0055.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.462","citation":"ORS 183.462","quote":"during its review of a contested case","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.462","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4c6b6ccd0b7e28c9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0055 applies ex parte communication requirements to communications 'during the contested case proceeding,' whereas ORS 183.462 limits the requirement to communications 'during its review of a contested case'—a post-hearing period.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0055","citation":"OAR 137-003-0055(1)","quote":"An ex parte communication is an oral or written communication to an agency decision maker or the presiding officer not made in the presence of all parties to the hearing, concerning a fact in issue in the proceeding","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.462","citation":"ORS 183.462","quote":"during its review of a contested case","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.462","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30770ee62ba6af3a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Nine rules declare implementing ORS 183.411-183.471, but their operative text addresses only contested case hearing procedures and does not engage with 183.471's provisions on digital order preservation, electronic copies, or fee structures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-410-120-1860","citation":"OAR 410-120-1860","quote":"ORS 183.411 - 183.471, ORS 411.408, ORS 414.025, ORS 414.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0000","citation":"OAR 411-318-0000","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0005","citation":"OAR 411-318-0005","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.007, ORS 427.101, ORS 427.104, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109, ORS 430.215, ORS 430.610, ORS 430.662","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0015","citation":"OAR 411-318-0015","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.007, ORS 427.101, ORS 427.104, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109, ORS 430.215, ORS 430.610, ORS 430.662","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0020","citation":"OAR 411-318-0020","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0025","citation":"OAR 411-318-0025","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.007, ORS 427.101, ORS 427.104, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109, ORS 430.215, ORS 430.610, ORS 430.662","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-318-0030","citation":"OAR 411-318-0030","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 409.010, ORS 427.007, ORS 427.101, ORS 427.104, ORS 427.107, ORS 427.109, ORS 430.215, ORS 430.610, ORS 430.662","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-419-050-0000","citation":"OAR 419-050-0000","quote":"ORS 183.411 -183.471, ORS 430.768, ORS 430.731, ORS 430.735-430.765, ORS 409.010","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-419-050-0010","citation":"OAR 419-050-0010","quote":"ORS 183.411-183.471, ORS 430.768, ORS 430.731, ORS 430.735-430.765, ORS 409.010","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.471","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"60de805e341dc04c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs"]},{"summary":"The rule removes a condition from the statute requiring modification notice only when the ALJ will not enter the final order, making the rule apply in more situations than the statute requires.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.650","citation":"ORS 183.650(2)","quote":"If the administrative law judge assigned from the office will not enter the final order in a contested case proceeding, and the agency modifies the form of order issued by the administrative law judge in any substantial manner, the agency must identify the modifications and provide an explanation to the parties to the hearing as to why the agency made the modifications.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0665","citation":"OAR 137-003-0665(3)","quote":"If the agency modifies the proposed order issued by the administrative law judge in any substantial manner, the agency must identify the modification and explain to the parties why the agency made the modification.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.650","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aeac1941afadb393","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 166-500-0047(3)(b) cites ORS 183.360(2) to justify agency authority to correct internal section numbering through statutory minor correction, but ORS 183.360(2) grants only the Secretary of State authority to renumber sections when preparing the compilation for publication, not agency authority.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-166-500-0047","citation":"OAR 166-500-0047(3)(b)","quote":"Correcting a rule's internal section numbering as allowed by ORS 183.360(2)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.360","citation":"ORS 183.360(2)","quote":"In preparing the compilation the Secretary of State may not alter the sense, meaning, effect or substance of any rule, but may renumber sections and parts of sections of the rules, change the wording of headnotes, rearrange sections, change reference numbers to agree with renumbered chapters, sections or other parts, substitute the proper subsection, section or chapter or other division numbers, change capitalization for the purpose of uniformity, and correct manifest clerical or typographical errors.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"536ecff040ea4a82","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-archives-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-001-0100(2) permits agencies to review amended rules despite the statute explicitly excluding amendments from the periodic review requirements.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.405","citation":"ORS 183.405(5)","quote":"The provisions of this section do not apply to the amendment or repeal of a rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-001-0100","citation":"OAR 137-001-0100(2)","quote":"Notwithstanding ORS 183.405(4) & (5), the agency may review any amended rule under the criteria set forth in ORS 183.405(1).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.405","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"87d0cd1ba4836b5a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-001-0725(2) requires notice to include only 6 specific items (receipt date, explanation of denial, statutory reference, right to hearing, file designation, instruction on requesting hearing), but ORS 183.413(2) requires 16 items including time and place of hearing, general description of hearing procedure including burdens of proof, identification of issues, discovery provisions, and many others.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.413","citation":"ORS 183.413(2)","quote":"the agency shall serve personally or by mail a written notice to each party to the hearing that includes the following: (a) The time and place of the hearing. (b) A statement of the authority and jurisdiction under which the hearing is to be held. (c) A statement that generally identifies the issues to be considered at the hearing... (f) A statement indicating whether discovery is permitted and, if so, how discovery may be requested. (g) A general description of the hearing procedure including the order of presentation of evidence, what kinds of evidence are admissible, whether objections may be made to the introduction of evidence and what kind of objections may be made and an explanation of the burdens of proof or burdens of going forward with the evidence. (h) Whether a record will be made of the proceedings","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-001-0725","citation":"OAR 123-001-0725(2)","quote":"The notice, on Department letterhead, shall include but is not limited to the following: (a) The date and other pertinent facts of the Department's receipt of the application; (b) Brief explanation of why the Department is unable to approve it; (c) Reference to the specifically relevant statutory subsection(s) or administrative rule section(s)... (d) Statement of the applicant's right to a contested case hearing on the matter before an administrative law judge and to be represented by legal counsel; (e) Designation of the Department's current file on the application as the record for purposes of proving a prima facie case upon default; and (f) Instruction on how the applicant must file a written request","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.413","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b40edbf88655bef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-003-0001(1) requires notice to include only 6 items (caption, statement, representation, right to hearing, authority/jurisdiction, and either time/place or procedure/time), but ORS 183.413(2) requires 16 items including identification of issues, discovery, hearing procedure description, recording, attorney for agency, presiding officer function, recess right if unrepresented, adjournment opportunity, opportunity to review findings, appeal process, and active duty servicemembers statement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.413","citation":"ORS 183.413(2)","quote":"the agency shall serve personally or by mail a written notice to each party to the hearing that includes the following: (a) The time and place of the hearing. (b) A statement of the authority and jurisdiction under which the hearing is to be held. (c) A statement that generally identifies the issues to be considered at the hearing. (d) A statement indicating that the party may be represented by counsel and that legal aid organizations may be able to assist a party with limited financial resources. (e) A statement that the party has the right to respond to all issues properly before the presiding officer and present evidence and witnesses on those issues. (f) A statement indicating whether discovery is permitted and, if so, how discovery may be requested. (g) A general description of the hearing procedure including the order of presentation of evidence, what kinds of evidence are admissible... (o) A description of the appeal process from the determination or order of the agency. (p) A statement that active duty servicemembers have a right to stay proceedings","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0001","citation":"OAR 137-003-0001(1)","quote":"The agency's contested case notice issued pursuant to ORS 183.415 shall include: (a) A caption with the name of the agency and the name of the person or agency to whom the notice is issued; (b) A short and plain statement of the matters asserted or charged and a reference to the particular sections of the statute and rules involved; (c) A statement of the party's right to be represented by counsel and that legal aid organizations may be able to assist a party with limited financial resources; (d) A statement of the party's right to a hearing; (e) A statement of the agency's authority and jurisdiction to hold a hearing on the matters asserted or charged; and (f) Either: (A) A statement of the procedure and time to request a hearing... or (B) A statement of the time and place of the hearing.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.413","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9fa446e95535982b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-003-0505(1) requires notice of proposed sanctions in subsection (i), but ORS 183.413(2) contains no requirement for notice of sanctions in the contested case hearing notice.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.413","citation":"ORS 183.413(2)","quote":"the agency shall serve personally or by mail a written notice to each party to the hearing that includes the following: (a) The time and place of the hearing. (b) A statement of the authority and jurisdiction under which the hearing is to be held. (c) A statement that generally identifies the issues to be considered at the hearing. (d) A statement indicating that the party may be represented by counsel and that legal aid organizations may be able to assist a party with limited financial resources. (e) A statement that the party has the right to respond to all issues properly before the presiding officer and present evidence and witnesses on those issues. (f) A statement indicating whether discovery is permitted and, if so, how discovery may be requested. (g) A general description of the hearing procedure","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0505","citation":"OAR 137-003-0505(1)(i)","quote":"If the agency proposes a sanction, the sanction that the agency proposes based on the facts alleged in the notice.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.413","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"243a521650234c51","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Multiple rules cite ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list procedures, but ORS 183.335(8) establishes the procedure for persons to request notice; subsection (7) concerns statutory minor corrections without notice.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-160-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Division mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-471-010-0010","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"By providing a copy of the notice to persons on the Employment Department's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-605-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Oregon Beef Council's mailing list, established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-611-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-635-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"persons on the Agency's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-643-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-668-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-670-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-837-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(7)","quote":"established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e30d8421637470e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","department-of-fish-and-wildlife","department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","employment-department","secretary-of-state-corporation-division"]},{"summary":"Multiple rules cite ORS 183.335(14) for notices to legislators, but ORS 183.335(15) specifies the legislators who must receive notice.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-255-001-0005","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"By providing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-605-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-611-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-643-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-668-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-670-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-837-001-0000","citation":"ORS 183.335(14)","quote":"to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ad9cfa02c118d63b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-001-0007(2) requires only a 'good faith effort' to ensure advisory committee membership represents affected interests, while ORS 183.333(1)(b) mandates that membership 'must represent' such interests.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.333","citation":"ORS 183.333(1)(b)","quote":"The membership of an advisory committee appointed under this subsection must represent the interests of persons and communities likely to be affected by the rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-001-0007","citation":"OAR 137-001-0007(2)","quote":"If the agency appoints an advisory committee, the agency shall make a good faith effort to ensure that the committee's members represent the interests of persons likely to be affected by the rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.333","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fe87dcb313df270f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-001-0007(3) requires seeking recommendations on fiscal impact and small business impact only if the committee indicates significant adverse impact, while ORS 183.333(3) requires seeking such recommendations unconditionally whenever an advisory committee is appointed.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.333","citation":"ORS 183.333(3)","quote":"If an agency appoints an advisory committee for consideration of a rule under subsection (1) of this section, the agency shall seek the committee's recommendations on whether the rule will have a fiscal impact, what the extent of that impact will be and whether the rule will have a significant adverse impact on small businesses.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-001-0007","citation":"OAR 137-001-0007(3)","quote":"If the advisory committee indicates that the rule will have a significant adverse impact on small businesses, the agency will seek the advisory committee's recommendations on compliance with ORS 183.540.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.333","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"34b52893f500d40f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-001-0087 does not include the 14-day deadline requirement for filing objections to fiscal impact statements that is specified in ORS 183.333(5).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.333","citation":"ORS 183.333(5)","quote":"An objection under this subsection must be made not later than 14 days after the notice required by ORS 183.335(1) is given.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-137-001-0087","citation":"OAR 137-001-0087(1)","quote":"An objection to a fiscal impact statement must be filed in writing and must: (a) Identify the fiscal impact statement to which objection is made; (b) Identify the persons likely to be affected by the proposed rule on whose behalf the objection is filed or, if filed by an association, assert the number of members of the association who are likely to be affected by the proposed rule; (c) Explain how the persons identified are likely to be affected by the proposed rule; (d) Explain the objection or objections to the fiscal impact statement; and (e) Be sent to the mailing address or electronic mail address identified in the notice of proposed rulemaking for the submission of written comments.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.333","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"38e2a69ae7a1f567","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Two rules both declare implementation of ORS 183.430 but contain contradictory provisions on whether combining emergency suspension hearings with related proceedings requires party agreement.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0010","citation":"OAR 137-003-0010(3)(b)","quote":"The agency may combine the hearing on the emergency suspension order with any underlying agency proceeding affecting the license.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-003-0560","citation":"OAR 137-003-0560(5)","quote":"The hearing on the emergency suspension order may be combined with any related agency proceeding affecting the license only with the agreement of the party.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.430","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c67d8496f4fbc3de","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 183.750 (which requires clear and simple language in public writings) but its operative text only adopts procedural rules without addressing the substantive requirement of plain language.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-001-0005","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.310 - 183.750","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.750","citation":"ORS 183.750","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.750","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ff841aaefad5480d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 183.370 (about distribution of published rules) but its operative text requires notice procedures for proposed rulemaking—a different subject that ORS 183.370 does not address.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-818-001-0000","citation":"frontmatter","quote":"ORS 183.370, ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.370","citation":"ORS 183.370","quote":"The bulletins and compilations may be distributed by the Secretary of State free of charge as provided for the distribution of legislative materials referred to in ORS 171.236. Other copies of the bulletins and compilations shall be distributed by the Secretary of State at a cost determined by the Secretary of State.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.370","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5daa6608fb62ac30","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-dentistry"]},{"summary":"OAR 582-020-0010(5) narrows the statutory definition of 'Final Order' by omitting the clause covering statements that do not preclude further agency consideration.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-183.310","citation":"ORS 183.310(6)(b)","quote":"\"Final order\" means final agency action expressed in writing. \"Final order\" does not include any tentative or preliminary agency declaration or statement that: (A) Precedes final agency action; or (B) Does not preclude further agency consideration of the subject matter of the statement or declaration.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-582-020-0010","citation":"OAR 582-020-0010(5)","quote":"\"Final Order\" means the written final Program action. Final order does not include any tentative or preliminary Program declaration or statement that precedes the final Program action.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c044a5bb1c1d71d8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-vocational-rehabilitation-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-003-0625(2)(e) requires recording of oral responses to any ex parte communication (oral or written), but statute ORS 183.685(1)(e) only requires recording oral responses to ex parte oral communications.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-003-0625","citation":"OAR 137-003-0625(2)(e)","quote":"A memorandum reflecting the substance of any oral response made by the administrative law judge to any ex parte oral or written communication.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.685","citation":"ORS 183.685(1)(e)","quote":"A memorandum reflecting the substance of any oral response made by the administrative law judge to an ex parte oral communication.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.685","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7b8117d86b99ddd2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-001-0040(4)(g) cites ORS 183.355(1) and (3) as authority for including a filing copy in the rulemaking record, but 183.355(1) addresses Secretary of State prescribing filing requirements, and 183.355(3) addresses when rules become effective—neither requires copies in the rulemaking record.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-001-0040","citation":"OAR 137-001-0040(4)(g)","quote":"A copy of the filing with the Secretary of State, required by ORS 183.355(1) or (3)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.355","citation":"ORS 183.355(1)","quote":"The Secretary of State shall by rule prescribe requirements for the manner and form for filing rules adopted, amended or repealed by agencies","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.355","citation":"ORS 183.355(3)","quote":"Each rule is effective upon filing as required by subsection (2) of this section, except that: (a) If a later effective date is required by statute or specified in the rule, the later date is the effective date","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"51fcc5e6ddd68fac","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 170-060-0000 declares it implements ORS 183.355, but its operative text addresses notice of proposed rulemaking, which is unrelated to ORS 183.355's subject of filing rules, effective dates, and fees.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-170-060-0000","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.355","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.355","citation":"ORS 183.355","quote":"Filing and taking effect of rules; filing of executive orders; copies; fees; rules. (1) The Secretary of State shall by rule prescribe requirements for the manner and form for filing rules adopted, amended or repealed by agencies.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ded46c0df9be8172","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"OAR 414-050-0005 declares it implements ORS 183.355, but its operative text addresses notice of proposed rulemaking procedures and does not engage ORS 183.355, instead citing ORS 183.360 (the bulletin) and ORS 183.335.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-414-050-0005","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 326.430, ORS 183.355","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.355","citation":"ORS 183.355","quote":"Filing and taking effect of rules; filing of executive orders; copies; fees; rules.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a5595142f2108b66","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 160-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-160-001-0000","citation":"OAR 160-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Division mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"368e1ac6baf49cb1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-corporation-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 255-001-0005 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-255-001-0005","citation":"OAR 255-001-0005(1)(b)","quote":"By providing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ad008c94ee4ef2c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"OAR 255-001-0005 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-255-001-0005","citation":"OAR 255-001-0005(1)(c)","quote":"By providing a copy of the notice at least 28 days prior to the effective date to persons on the Board mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7d0d5564a7e76e9d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"OAR 471-010-0010 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-471-010-0010","citation":"OAR 471-010-0010(2)","quote":"By providing a copy of the notice to persons on the Employment Department's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7) at least twenty-eight (28) days prior to the effective date.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0f060bd65c88d4d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["employment-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 605-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-605-001-0000","citation":"OAR 605-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Oregon Beef Council's mailing list, established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9706d28649748f4a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council"]},{"summary":"OAR 605-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-605-001-0000","citation":"OAR 605-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b87ded228f095e06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council"]},{"summary":"OAR 611-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-611-001-0000","citation":"OAR 611-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"80a31c6b7bdb3735","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 611-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-611-001-0000","citation":"OAR 611-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing or furnishing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0bffecfa00d19d8d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 635-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-635-001-0000","citation":"OAR 635-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Agency's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7) at least 28 days before the effective date of the rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"83c10d10047fa4f3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-fish-and-wildlife"]},{"summary":"OAR 643-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-643-001-0000","citation":"OAR 643-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on a list maintained by the Oregon Hop Commission, established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e814388643a7ae0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 643-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-643-001-0000","citation":"OAR 643-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"795edc8e0bd937d8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 668-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-668-001-0000","citation":"OAR 668-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Oregon Strawberry Commission's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7) at least 28 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b60361a0dda59a06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 668-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-668-001-0000","citation":"OAR 668-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f727107382b02275","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 670-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-670-001-0000","citation":"OAR 670-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the Oregon Blueberry Commission's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7) at least 28 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9d7810b8c8a897c4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 670-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-670-001-0000","citation":"OAR 670-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"630640d3c39d83c3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 837-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(7) for mailing list establishment, but the statute's mailing list procedure is in ORS 183.335(8).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-837-001-0000","citation":"OAR 837-001-0000(2)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to persons on the State Fire Marshal's mailing list established pursuant to ORS 183.335(7) at least 28 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(8)","quote":"(8)(a) Any person may request in writing that an agency send to the person copies of the agency's notices of intended action issued under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"362bf15a0c250ccf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal"]},{"summary":"OAR 837-001-0000 cites ORS 183.335(14) for legislators, but the statute's legislative notice requirement is in ORS 183.335(15).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-837-001-0000","citation":"OAR 837-001-0000(3)","quote":"By mailing a copy of the notice to the legislators specified in ORS 183.335(14) at least 49 days before the effective date of the rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-183.335","citation":"ORS 183.335(15)","quote":"(15) The notices required under subsections (1) and (3) of this section must be given by the agency to the following persons:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-183.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"39f7f7244c861bdd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-chiropractic-examiners","name":"Board of Chiropractic Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-medical-imaging","name":"Board of Medical Imaging"},{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"chief-education-office","name":"Chief Education Office"},{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-albacore-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Albacore Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-alfalfa-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Alfalfa Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Beef Council"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Blueberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-clover-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Clover Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hop Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-mint-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Mint Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-potato-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Potato Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-processed-vegetable-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Processed Vegetable Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-ryegrass-growers-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Ryegrass Growers Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-salmon-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Salmon Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sheep-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sheep Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Strawberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-trawl-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Trawl Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Wheat Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-health-insurance-marketplace","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Health Insurance Marketplace"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Board"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-home-care-commission","name":"Department of Human Services, Home Care Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-vocational-rehabilitation-services","name":"Department of Human Services, Vocational Rehabilitation Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","name":"Department of State Police, Office of State Fire Marshal"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-oregon-state-athletic-commission","name":"Department of State Police, Oregon State Athletic Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-rail-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Rail Division"},{"slug":"department-of-veterans-affairs","name":"Department of Veterans' Affairs"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"employment-relations-board","name":"Employment Relations Board"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Degree Authorization"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Student Access and Completion"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Licensed Professional Counselors and Therapists"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"mortuary-and-cemetery-board","name":"Mortuary and Cemetery Board"},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-529-savings-board","name":"Oregon 529 Savings Board"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-accountancy","name":"Oregon Board of Accountancy"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Early Learning Division"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-fair-dismissal-appeals-board","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Fair Dismissal Appeals Board"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division"},{"slug":"oregon-facilities-authority","name":"Oregon Facilities Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-forest-resources-institute","name":"Oregon Forest Resources Institute"},{"slug":"oregon-government-ethics-commission","name":"Oregon Government Ethics Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-liquor-control-commission","name":"Oregon Liquor Control Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management","name":"Oregon Military Department, Office of Emergency Management"},{"slug":"oregon-patient-safety-commission","name":"Oregon Patient Safety Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"},{"slug":"oregon-racing-commission","name":"Oregon Racing Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-state-library","name":"Oregon State Library"},{"slug":"oregon-state-lottery","name":"Oregon State Lottery"},{"slug":"oregon-state-marine-board","name":"Oregon State Marine Board"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"oregon-tourism-commission","name":"Oregon Tourism Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-utility-notification-center","name":"Oregon Utility Notification Center"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission-oregon-board-of-maritime-pilots","name":"Public Utility Commission, Oregon Board of Maritime Pilots"},{"slug":"real-estate-agency","name":"Real Estate Agency"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-archives-division","name":"Secretary of State, Archives Division"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"},{"slug":"teacher-standards-and-practices-commission","name":"Teacher Standards and Practices Commission"},{"slug":"travel-information-council","name":"Travel Information Council"},{"slug":"veterinary-medical-examining-board","name":"Veterinary Medical Examining Board"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"184","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":129,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 731-001-0009(1) prohibits appointees from having 'direct or indirect financial or fiduciary interest,' which is broader than the statute's restriction to 'actual conflict of interest, as defined in ORS 244.020.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.612","citation":"ORS 184.612(3)","quote":"At the time of appointment, a member or a relative or member of the household of a member, as those terms are defined in ORS 244.020, may not have an actual conflict of interest, as defined in ORS 244.020.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-001-0009","citation":"OAR 731-001-0009(1)","quote":"No appointee may have a direct or indirect financial or fiduciary interest at the time of appointment by the Governor.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd78ec79281b458c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 184.642, but the operative text entirely concerns the Statewide Transportation Improvement Fund (STIF) formula disbursements and never engages with the Department of Transportation Operating Fund that 184.642 establishes and governs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-732-042-0010","citation":"frontmatter","quote":"ORS 184.642, ORS 184.751-184.766, ORS 323.457","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.642","citation":"ORS 184.642","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.642","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b8961ff97eb412c5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-public-transit-division"]},{"summary":"ORS 184.751(3) requires that STIF moneys may not be used to supplant local and regional agency moneys unless approved by the department, but none of the implementing rules address this supplantation restriction or the department approval process.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.751","citation":"ORS 184.751(3)","quote":"Unless approved by the department, the moneys in the Statewide Transportation Improvement Fund may not be used to supplant local and regional agency moneys currently directed to public transportation service providers.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.751","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e803971aece942be","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 184.758(1)(a), which addresses distribution of moneys for 'Program administration,' but the operative text of the rule is entirely about administrative procedures for when a new mass transit district comes into existence as a Qualified Entity and assumes that role from a county—it never engages with the program administration distribution provision.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-732-040-0055","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.752(2)(a), ORS 184.758(1)(a)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.758","citation":"ORS 184.758(1)(a)","quote":"Program administration","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.758","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a98f0638524e074e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-public-transit-division"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 184.619, a general grant of rulemaking authority to the Transportation Commission, but the operative text never engages with or references that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0045","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.619, ORS 802.010, ORS 822.035, ORS 822.040, ORS 822.084","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.619","citation":"ORS 184.619","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.619","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"77de11dc06bfa630","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 737-025-0091(1)(b)(A) requires eligible projects to be within two miles of a 'public school,' but the statute does not limit projects to public schools—it refers only to 'a school that serves students in prekindergarten, kindergarten or grades 1 through 12' without specifying public versus private schools.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.742","citation":"ORS 184.742(4)","quote":"The commission shall prioritize the expenditure of funds as authorized under this section for projects that are located within a two-mile radius of a school that serves students in prekindergarten, kindergarten or grades 1 through 12, or any combination of those grade levels.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-025-0091","citation":"OAR 737-025-0091(1)(b)(A)","quote":"Be within a two - mile radius of a public school.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.742","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3daac4567b2b52da","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division"]},{"summary":"All three rules declare ORS 184.340 as a statute they implement, but their operative text never engages with or references ORS 184.340—a general authorization statute, not a substantive provision to be implemented.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-030-0021","citation":"OAR 125-030-0021 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 184.340, ORS 292.045, ORS 184.345","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-030-0041","citation":"OAR 125-030-0041 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 184.340, ORS 292.045, ORS 184.305","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-090-0175","citation":"OAR 125-090-0175 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"276.594, ORS 98.805, ORS 184.340","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.340","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"167f5ccfd0b6cf35","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"ORS 184.766(1)(c)(D) requires submission of quarterly reports within 30 days of audit results, but OAR 732-040-0025(3) implementing that provision omits quarterly reports and implements them separately in OAR 732-042-0035 with different timing (45-60 days from quarter end rather than 30 days from audit receipt).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.766","citation":"ORS 184.766(1)(c)(D)","quote":"Any quarterly reports that detail project progress, outcomes achieved and the expenditure of funds described under ORS 184.758 (2)(a)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-732-040-0025","citation":"OAR 732-040-0025(3)","quote":"The results of any relevant financial audits of the Qualified Entity or any Sub-Recipient located within the area of the Qualified Entity, as required by a local, state or federal oversight agency for the purposes of statewide reporting including, but not limited to: (a) The state financial report required under ORS 291.040; (b) The results of any comprehensive review completed by the Federal Transit Administration or the Agency; and (c) Any information submitted by the Qualified Entity as part of the requirements of a statewide audit in accordance with the federal Single Audit Act of 1984 (31 U.S.C. 7501 to 7507), as amended by the Single Audit Act Amendments of 1996 (P.L. 104-156)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.766","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2d4d5a6c43deb746","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-public-transit-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-700-0140(6) requires completed risk assessments and internal audits to be filed with the Secretary of State's Audits Division, but ORS 184.360(5) requires agencies to file reports with the Oregon Department of Administrative Services.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.360","citation":"ORS 184.360(5)","quote":"file a report with the Oregon Department of Administrative Services","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-700-0140","citation":"OAR 125-700-0140(6)","quote":"Completed risk assessments and internal audits need to be filed with the Audits Division of the Office of the Secretary of State.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b55da764cc81a30d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0211 declares it implements ORS 184.634 but establishes exemptions from reporting requirements, not procedures and criteria for disposition as the statute authorizes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0211","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 184.634, ORS 270.015, ORS 270.100, ORS 270.105, ORS 270.110, ORS 273.099","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.634","citation":"ORS 184.634","quote":"the Oregon Transportation Commission may establish by rule procedures and criteria for: (1) The advertisement for sale of real property by the Department of Transportation; (2) The disposition of real property by the department after an auction at which no satisfactory bids were received; and (3) The disposition by the department of real property that: (a) Has minimal value and is useful only to adjacent property owners; or (b) May not, because of local land use ordinances, be disposed of to anyone other than adjacent property owners.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.634","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"88ab3ed14d6fb0cd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0212 declares it implements ORS 184.634 but addresses exemptions from the Clearinghouse Process and PLAC review, not procedures and criteria for disposition as the statute authorizes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0212","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 184.634, ORS 270.015, ORS 270.100, ORS 270.105, ORS 270.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.634","citation":"ORS 184.634","quote":"the Oregon Transportation Commission may establish by rule procedures and criteria for: (1) The advertisement for sale of real property by the Department of Transportation; (2) The disposition of real property by the department after an auction at which no satisfactory bids were received; and (3) The disposition by the department of real property that: (a) Has minimal value and is useful only to adjacent property owners; or (b) May not, because of local land use ordinances, be disposed of to anyone other than adjacent property owners.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.634","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2e6e3f92efaf98c6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 184.345, which authorizes DAS to provide administrative services on a reimbursable basis to state agencies, but the rule's operative text establishes a Charitable Fund Drive Committee structure and functions unrelated to that authorization.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.345","citation":"ORS 184.345","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services may provide on a reimbursable basis administrative and other services, as agreed upon, to a state agency as defined in ORS 291.002.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-030-0021","citation":"OAR 125-030-0021, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.340, ORS 292.045, ORS 184.345","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"62b520dba8f72cc2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute limits eligibility in ORS 184.741(4) to cities, counties, or school districts applying for assistance with plans, but the rules extend eligible applicants to include additional entities not mentioned in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.741","citation":"ORS 184.741(4)","quote":"A city, county or school district that has developed or is preparing to develop a plan described in ORS 195.115 to reduce barriers and hazards to children walking or bicycling to and from school may apply to the department for assistance in developing or carrying out the plan.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-025-0030","citation":"OAR 737-025-0030(2)","quote":"A city, county, state, regional government body, transit district or other unit of local government as defined by ORS 190.003, in cooperation with a school district or a qualifying school.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-025-0091","citation":"OAR 737-025-0091(1)(a)","quote":"Eligible entities include: ODOT, cities, counties, transit district, tribes and any eligible road authority as defined under ORS 810.010.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.741","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ba981d38fa3e084c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division"]},{"summary":"The rules declare they implement ORS 184.670, but that statute is purely a purpose-setting provision for ORS 184.675 and 184.685-184.733, while the rules' operative text actually implements Chapter 746, OL 2007 (the Oregon Streetcar Project Fund) and never engages with the substantive content of ORS 184.670 itself.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-732-035-0010","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.670, ORS 184.685, Ch. 746, OL 2007","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-184.670","citation":"ORS 184.670","quote":"It is the purpose of ORS 184.675, 184.685 to 184.733 and this section: (1) To provide a means of state financial assistance and coordination to meet the state's most pressing mobility needs...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.670","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af5b4878c15ebff5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-public-transit-division"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 184.305, but that statute addresses only the Oregon Department of Administrative Services' general purposes (infrastructure services, rules, performance measurement, training, personnel systems, management information, and financial systems), not charitable organizations or charitable fund drive participation requirements that the rule regulates.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-184.305","citation":"ORS 184.305","quote":"The purpose of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services is to improve the efficient and effective use of state resources by providing: (1) Government infrastructure services... (2) Rules and associated performance reviews of agency compliance with statewide policies; (3) Leadership in implementing a statewide performance measurement program; (4) State employee workforce development and training; (5) Personnel systems... (6) Objective, credible management information... (7) Statewide financial administrative systems.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-030-0041","citation":"oar-125-030-0041, statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.340, ORS 292.045, ORS 184.305","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-184.305","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bcfc09dd735144b7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-public-transit-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Public Transit Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"190","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"A statute and its implementing OregonBuys-reporting rule cite different four-digit ORS sections (660.334 vs. 660.342) for the same category of intergovernmental agreement.","documents":[{"id":"ors-190.430","citation":"ORS 190.430","quote":"Every agreement made by an agency of this state under ORS 190.112, 190.420 or 660.334 shall be submitted to the Attorney General before taking effect.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0365","citation":"OAR 125-246-0365(1)","quote":"...an agreement under ORS 190.112 or under ORS 660.342, must submit a summary of the agreement through OregonBuys...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6e941b4f494557ab","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Systemic pattern: relationships.implements is built from legal_authority rather than statutes_implemented across nearly every rule in this cluster, producing internally contradictory frontmatter within single documents (e.g. OAR 125-090-0000 omits ORS 98.805 from implements despite it heading statutes_implemented).","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-090-0000","citation":"OAR 125-090-0000 frontmatter","quote":"statutes_implemented: [\"ORS 98.805\", \"ORS 190.240\", \"ORS 276.591\", \"ORS 283.110\"]; relationships.implements: [ors-184.340, ors-190.240, ors-276.591, ors-276.601, ors-283.100, ors-283.110] — omits ors-98.805 entirely.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"2ba4d5bcf16ed123","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts reporting requirements to 'state agency' but the statute allows any 'public body as defined in ORS 174.109' to enter into security function agreements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-190.112","citation":"ORS 190.112","quote":"A public body as defined in ORS 174.109 may enter into an agreement with the United States to perform security functions at a military installation or facility in the United States","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0365","citation":"OAR 125-246-0365(1)","quote":"A state agency that enters into an agreement under ORS 190.110, 190.420 or 190.485, or an agreement under ORS 190.112 or under ORS 660.342, must submit a summary of the agreement","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.112","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"96bd3cc5f9a9efcd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-045-0050 declares it implements ORS 190.490, but the operative text exempts 'Public Contracts' from 'legal sufficiency approval requirement under ORS 291.047' and never addresses intergovernmental agreements under ORS 190.485 or approval requirements under ORS 190.490.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-045-0050","citation":"OAR 137-045-0050","quote":"ORS 291.047, ORS 190.430, ORS 190.490","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-190.490","citation":"ORS 190.490","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.490","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","also_cited":["ors-190.430#"]}],"fingerprint":"c418ba0c2f52e17f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-090-0002 declares it implements ORS 190.240 (furnishing services to federal and local governmental units), but the rule's operative text addresses only regulation of parking facilities and transportation uses, never engaging with that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-090-0002","citation":"OAR 125-090-0002 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 98.805, ORS 190.240, ORS 276.591, ORS 283.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-190.240","citation":"ORS 190.240","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e255f93e688102bf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule authorizes agreements with entities in other countries ('International Agreements'), but the statute limits agreements to 'public agency in another state,' which means U.S. states, not foreign countries.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-190.420","citation":"ORS 190.420(1)","quote":"Any power or powers, privileges or authority exercised or capable of exercise by a public agency in this state may be exercised and enjoyed jointly with any public agency in another state to the extent that the laws of the other state permit such joint exercise or enjoyment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0365","citation":"OAR 125-246-0365(2)","quote":"Following ORS 190, each Agency may enter into Interstate and International Agreements through negotiation, direct award, direct appointment, or in any other manner that satisfies the legal requirements for such Agreements.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6746ca738fb3061f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 735-062-0080 declares implementation of ORS 190.485 (intergovernmental agreements) but contains no operative text engaging with that statute; the entire rule concerns driver licensing and drive test waivers.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-062-0080","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 190.485, ORS 807.070, ORS 807.072, ORS 807.080, ORS 807.170","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-190.485","citation":"ORS 190.485","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.485","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8fc05b766af7b6ca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0365 authorizes Interstate Agreements in section 2, but ORS 190.485 limits authority only to agreements with \"a nation or a public agency in any nation other than the United States,\" excluding interstate agreements.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0365","citation":"125-246-0365(2)","quote":"Interstate and International Agreements. Following ORS 190, each Agency may enter into Interstate and International Agreements through negotiation, direct award, direct appointment, or in any other manner that satisfies the legal requirements for such Agreements.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-190.485","citation":"ORS 190.485(1)","quote":"Any power or powers, privileges or authority exercised or capable of exercise by a state agency in this state may be exercised and enjoyed jointly with a nation or a public agency in any nation other than the United States, to the extent that the laws of the United States and of the other nation do not prohibit such joint exercise or enjoyment.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-190.485","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"557e2e8cc6182874","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"artifacts":["ORS 190.240's $500 unit-price threshold has no engaging rule text in either OAR 125-090-0000 or -0002 despite both citing it as authority."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"198","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidate inconsistencies. The one dollar-threshold overlap checked ($6,000 administrative retention, ORS 198.955 vs. OAR 150-198-0900) matches exactly.","artifacts":["ors-198.955's enacted/last_amended years (1969/2009) don't match the section's own bracket citation (...1991), likely corrupted by trailing renumbered-section stubs (198.973-198.990) bleeding into the sliced text."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"200","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":38,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 200.055(3) requires DBE denial/decertification appeals to go to USDOT, but oar-123-200-2000 applies contested case hearing procedures to \"All Programs\" including DBE, removing the statutorily-mandated USDOT appeal route.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.055","citation":"ORS 200.055(3)","quote":"If the Certification Office for Business Inclusion and Diversity denies a certification as, or decertifies, a disadvantaged business enterprise, an affected business enterprise may appeal directly to the United States Department of Transportation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-200-2000","citation":"OAR 123-200-2000 title and (9)-(11)","quote":"Complaints of Ineligibility for All Programs... The applicant or certified firm has 21 calendar days from the date of Notice of Intent to Deny or Notice of Intent to Decertify in which to submit a written appeal to the manager of the COBID... If the applicant or certified firm does not agree with the manager's decision, he or she may request a contested case hearing. The COBID will conduct a contested case hearing in accordance with ORS 183.310 to 183.550.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.055","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"361c4af81528a959","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0210(3) requires notice to the Advocate for Minority, Women and Emerging Small Business when contract price exceeds $5,000, but ORS 200.035 specifies the threshold is $10,000 or more.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.035","citation":"ORS 200.035(1)","quote":"A state contracting agency shall give timely notice and information to the Governor's Policy Advisor for Economic and Business Equity if the state contracting agency intends to advertise or solicit bids or proposals for a public contract with a contract price of $10,000 or more","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0210","citation":"OAR 137-049-0210(3)","quote":"State Contracting Agencies shall provide timely notice of all solicitations to the Advocate for Minority, Women and Emerging Small Business if the estimated Contract Price exceeds $5,000.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.035","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4de552b8ac03b454","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule redefines 'Disadvantaged Business Enterprise' as federally-defined USDOT standards, whereas the statute defines it by ownership percentage of socially and economically disadvantaged individuals.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.005","citation":"ORS 200.005(3)","quote":"Disadvantaged business enterprise\" means a small business concern: (a) At least 51 percent of which one or more socially and economically disadvantaged individuals own; or (b) At least 51 percent of the stock of which, if the small business concern is a corporation, is owned by one or more economically disadvantaged individuals who also control and manage the daily business operations of the small business concern.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-200-1100","citation":"OAR 123-200-1100(6)","quote":"Disadvantaged Business Enterprise\" or \"DBE\" means a business that meets the eligibility standards for participation in United States Department of Transportation (USDOT) federally funded projects as described in 49 CFR parts 23 and 26 (2013 Edition).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6bea397eea19bd34","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the statute's allowance for COBID to determine other disadvantaged groups by restricting it to only those designated by the SBA and 49 CFR Part 26, removing COBID's independent determination authority.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.005","citation":"ORS 200.005(6)(f)","quote":"Any other individual or member of another group that the Certification Office for Business Inclusion and Diversity determines is socially and economically disadvantaged.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-200-1100","citation":"OAR 123-200-1100(10)(f)","quote":"Any additional groups whose members are designated as socially disadvantaged by the Small Business Administration and/or as designated under 49 CFR Part 26 (2013 Edition).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"91f12ca8be52088e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0210(4)(b)(B) explicitly limits disqualification grounds to subsections (a)-(c) of ORS 200.075(1), but the statute lists four prohibited acts in subsections (a)-(d).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.075","citation":"ORS 200.075(1)","quote":"A bidder, proposer, contractor or subcontractor may not: (a) Enter into any agreement to represent that a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a veteran-owned business or an emerging small business certified under ORS 200.055 will perform work or supply materials under a public contract without the knowledge and consent of the disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, woman-owned business, veteran-owned business or emerging small business. (b) Exercise or permit another bidder, proposer, contractor or subcontractor to exercise management and decision making control over the internal operations of a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a veteran-owned business or an emerging small business, other than the bidder's, proposer's, contractor's or subcontractor's own enterprise or business. As used in this paragraph, \"internal operations\" does not include normal scheduling, coordination, execution or performance as a subcontractor on a public contract. (c) Use a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a veteran-owned business or an emerging small business to perform a public contract or subcontract or to supply material under a public contract to meet an established goal or requirement if the disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, woman-owned business, veteran-owned business or emerging small business does not perform a commercially useful function in carrying out responsibilities and obligations under the public contract. (d) Fail to perform a commercially useful function in performing a public contract or subcontract or in supplying material to a contractor or subcontractor that is performing a public contract or subcontract if the bidder, proposer, contractor or subcontractor is presented as a certified disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, woman-owned business, veteran-owned business or emerging small business to meet an established goal or requirement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0210","citation":"OAR 125-246-0210(4)(b)(B)","quote":"For a Disqualification under ORS 200.075, the Contracting Agency may suspend a Person upon finding that the Person engaged in any of the acts prohibited by ORS 200.075(a) through (c).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"57c9f178a8a51bdd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0370(1)(b)(B) enumerates three items (i)-(iii) corresponding to ORS 200.075(1)(a)-(c), but omits the fourth prohibited act listed in ORS 200.075(1)(d).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.075","citation":"ORS 200.075(1)(d)","quote":"Fail to perform a commercially useful function in performing a public contract or subcontract or in supplying material to a contractor or subcontractor that is performing a public contract or subcontract if the bidder, proposer, contractor or subcontractor is presented as a certified disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, woman-owned business, veteran-owned business or emerging small business to meet an established goal or requirement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0370","citation":"OAR 137-049-0370(1)(b)(B)","quote":"For a Disqualification under ORS 200.075, the Contracting Agency may disqualify a Person upon finding that: (i) The Person has entered into an agreement representing that a disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, women-owned business, emerging small business, or a Veteran-owned business, certified under ORS 200.055 (\"Certified Enterprise\"), will perform or supply materials under a Public Improvement Contract without the knowledge and consent of the Certified Enterprise; or (ii) The Person exercises management and decision-making control over the internal operations, as defined by ORS 200.075(1)(b), of any Certified Enterprise; or (iii) The Person uses a Certified Enterprise to perform Work under a Public Improvement Contract to meet an established Certified Enterprise goal, and such enterprise does not perform a commercially useful function, as defined by ORS 200.075(3), in performing its obligations under the contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2a2480baf59974d7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0710(1)(b)(B) enumerates three items (i)-(iii) corresponding to ORS 200.075(1)(a)-(c), but omits the fourth prohibited act listed in ORS 200.075(1)(d).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-200.075","citation":"ORS 200.075(1)(d)","quote":"Fail to perform a commercially useful function in performing a public contract or subcontract or in supplying material to a contractor or subcontractor that is performing a public contract or subcontract if the bidder, proposer, contractor or subcontractor is presented as a certified disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, woman-owned business, veteran-owned business or emerging small business to meet an established goal or requirement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0710","citation":"OAR 731-005-0710(1)(b)(B)","quote":"For a DBE Disqualification under ORS 200.075, ODOT may disqualify an Entity upon finding that: (i) The Entity has entered into an agreement representing that a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a business that a veteran owns, or an emerging small business pursuant to ORS 200.055 certified enterprise, will perform services or supply materials under a Contract without the knowledge and consent of the certified enterprise; (ii) The Entity exercises management and decision-making control over the internal operations, as defined by ORS 200.075(1)(b), of any certified enterprise; (iii) The Entity uses a disadvantaged business enterprise (\"DBE\"), a minority-owned business (\"MBE\"), a woman-owned business (\"WBE\"), a business that a veteran owns, or an emerging small business (\"ESB\") to perform services under a Contract or to provide supplies under a Contract to meet an established DBE/MBE/WBE/ESB goal, and such enterprise does not perform a commercially useful function, as defined by ORS 200.075(4), in performing its obligations under the Contract; or","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"661d13f35da248fc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"oar-123-200-2210 declares it implements ORS 200.065, but the operative text addresses only CUF (Commercially Useful Function) reviews and related investigations, which do not appear in the statute and relate to a different statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-200-2210","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 200.055, ORS 200.065 and ORS.075","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-200.065","citation":"ORS 200.065","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-200.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd248c13747c778c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"205","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 205.125's sole implementing rule was repealed effective the same date shown as its \"current\" retrieval snapshot.","documents":[{"id":"oar-813-001-0060","citation":"OAR 813-001-0060, status: current, effective_date 2026-07-06","quote":"History: OHCS 15-2026, repeal filed 07/02/2026, effective 07/06/2026 ... (full text has no operative subsections)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ad7a68e4a49d90fe","cites_repealed":["oar-813-001-0060"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-housing-and-community-services-department"]},{"summary":"A DOR rule cites the wrong ORS 205.323 subsection for the OLIS Fund's revenue source — (3)(a) is a mining-claim exemption, not the funding provision.","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-306-0130","citation":"OAR 150-306-0130","quote":"'Fund' means the Oregon Land Information System (OLIS) Fund. ... as provided by ORS 205.323(3)(a).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-205.323","citation":"ORS 205.323(4)(a)","quote":"The recording or filing fee ... must be deposited and credited to the Oregon Land Information System Fund established under ORS 306.132.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fbbad35407dab29a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A statute names ORS 411.694 for 'request for notice of transfer or encumbrance' recordation, but the rule that adopts the corresponding forms cites ORS 411.692 throughout.","documents":[{"id":"ors-205.246","citation":"ORS 205.246(1)(w)","quote":"Requests for notice of transfer or encumbrance ... presented for recordation under ORS 411.694;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-135-0847","citation":"OAR 461-135-0847 body and footer","quote":"...adopted in accordance with ORS 93.268, 205.246, and 411.692.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e74a9dac8ed75137","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]}],"artifacts":["oar-813-001-0060 bundles ORS 205.125 (county clerk lien records) with unrelated landlord-tenant and health statutes under a title about lay representation in contested cases."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"}]},{"ors_chapter":"21","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule in section 4 states funds provide services to victims of 'assault' while the statute limits them to victims of 'sexual assault,' broadening the scope beyond what the statute authorizes.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-21.007","citation":"ORS 21.007(4)","quote":"To the Higher Education Coordinating Commission to fund clinical legal education programs at accredited institutions of higher education that provide civil legal services to victims of domestic violence, stalking or sexual assault.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0060","citation":"OAR 715-013-0060(4)","quote":"Civil Legal Education Program funds are distributed in order to provide civil legal services to victims of stalking, domestic violence and assault.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-21.007","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0439a5b24e583102","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"215","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":37,"candidates":[{"summary":"[batch 1] The same OAR rule sets two different acreage caps for the identical trigger phrase, with no qualifying text distinguishing them.","documents":[{"id":"oar-660-033-0130","citation":"OAR 660-033-0130(17)","quote":"Permanent features of a power generation facility shall not use, occupy, or cover more than 12 acres unless an exception is taken pursuant to ORS 197.732 and OAR chapter 660, division 4.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-660-033-0130","citation":"OAR 660-033-0130(22)","quote":"Permanent features of a power generation facility shall not use, occupy or cover more than 20 acres unless an exception is taken pursuant to ORS 197.732 and OAR chapter 660, division 4.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Both subsections use identical language and the same escape valve; neither text explains why the cap differs. Possibly each routes from a different table entry not visible in the rule text alone — needs agency/legal confirmation. Not re-surfaced by the batch-2 (2026-07-23) re-check, which instead found a different candidate below — see chapter-level note.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e4aa2899a311b15f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["land-conservation-and-development-department"]},{"summary":"[batch 1] Rule text contains a self-declared 1995 sunset clause but the document is catalogued status: current with no note.","documents":[{"id":"oar-660-006-0004","citation":"OAR 660-006-0004(3)","quote":"The provisions of sections (1) and (2) of this rule are repealed on September 6, 1995.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"May be intentional legacy retention for numbering continuity (common in OAR), but as catalogued it presents as a currently-binding requirement that facially expired 30 years ago. Not re-surfaced by the batch-2 re-check.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a41ad67510e92406","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["land-conservation-and-development-department"]},{"summary":"[batch 2, 2026-07-23 re-check] Farm-dwelling gross-income threshold in the implementing rule is double the statute's, for counties not using the marginal-lands system.","documents":[{"id":"ors-215.213","citation":"ORS 215.213(2)(b)(A)","quote":"Has produced at least $20,000 in annual gross farm income in two consecutive calendar years...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-660-033-0135","citation":"OAR 660-033-0135(3)(a)(A)","quote":"the farm operator earned the lower of the following: (A) At least $40,000 in gross annual income from the sale of farm products...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"OAR 660-033-0135(6) explicitly preserves the statutory $20,000 threshold only 'in counties that have adopted marginal lands provisions under former ORS 197.247 (1991 Edition),' suggesting the doubled threshold outside that carve-out was an intentional LCDC policy choice, but the rule text doesn't on its face show statutory authority to raise the general-case number. Not surfaced by the batch-1 pass, which was looking at a different part of this same rule (the acreage caps above).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b024fb70fbdc9c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["land-conservation-and-development-department"]}],"note":"Batch 1 and batch 2 found *different* candidates in the same rule cluster rather than confirming or contradicting each other — read this chapter's candidates as a union of two partial passes over a large document set (37 implementing rules), not as agreement.","artifacts":["OAR 335-060-0060 statutes_implemented pulls in ORS 215.785 (a land-use statute) for a Social Security Number rule with no substantive land-use connection — likely a mis-cited section number, propagating a false implementer link into the ORS 215 authority graph.","OAR 603-080-0020 statutes_implemented lists \"ORS 215.70\" — truncated, almost certainly \"215.705\".","~10 OAR 660-006 rules carry \"Ch. 792\" / \"ORS 1993 OL\" fragments of a single Oregon Laws citation, not parseable as ORS section numbers."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"222","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"Two DOR phase-in tax rules (2016/2017) are silent on ORS 222.111's 2019-added 20-year duration option and 100%-ratio-reset-on-sale provision.","documents":[{"id":"ors-222.111","citation":"ORS 222.111(3)(e), 2019 amendment","quote":"during the term of fiscal years provided for pursuant to paragraph (b) ... the ratio shall be 100 percent for property that is sold or transferred to new ownership...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-222-0100","citation":"OAR 150-222-0100, effective 2016","quote":"operative text has no corresponding sale/transfer-reset provision.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"84d70e87488ed0d7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A Secretary of State rule sets a numeric cap on chief petitioners for a city-consolidation petition that appears nowhere in the statutes it implements.","documents":[{"id":"oar-165-004-0020","citation":"OAR 165-004-0020(1)","quote":"SEL 705, Prospective Petition to Create a City by Consolidation, which designates not more than three chief petitioners","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-222.230","citation":"ORS 222.230(2)","quote":"(petition-contents provision has no petitioner-count limit)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3498ecb534c1ea87","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-elections-division"]}],"artifacts":["oar-150-222-0100/-0110 relationships.implements includes ors-305.100 (a general rulemaking-authority statute) despite statutes_implemented listing only ORS 222.111."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"238","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":299,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 459-011-0050(7) adds a condition for purchasing credit under ORS 238.125 that the statute does not contain: requiring restoration of membership rights if the member previously withdrew.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.125","citation":"ORS 238.125","quote":"A member of the system who has a combined total of 10 years or more of creditable service in the system and prior service credit at the time of retirement, and who was required to complete one or more periods of six months or less in the service of an employer participating in the system before becoming a member of the system, shall receive retirement credit for those periods of six months or less if the member, within 90 days before the effective date of retirement of the member, applies in writing to the board for that retirement credit and pays to the board in a lump sum an amount determined by the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0050","citation":"OAR 459-011-0050(7)","quote":"Beginning with February 1, 2019 effective retirement dates, a member may not purchase retirement credit for the waiting period of employment completed prior to the effective date of withdrawal unless the membership rights and creditable service for the associated forfeited period of employment have been restored under ORS 238.105 or 238.115.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.125","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"429178dbf89d1bea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows when alternate payees may commence receiving payments by omitting the statute's alternative trigger for commencement upon member's death, disability, or termination of employment before retirement eligibility.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.465","citation":"ORS 238.465(2)(a)","quote":"That payments to the alternate payee may commence, at the election of the alternate payee, at any time after the earlier of: (A) The earliest date the member would be eligible to receive retirement benefits if the member separates from service; or (B) The date the member actually separates from service due to death, disability, retirement or termination of employment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-045-0010","citation":"OAR 459-045-0010(2)(e)","quote":"That an alternate payee may elect to receive the award at any time after the member's earliest retirement eligibility.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.465","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ed66380ca2503ff5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule establishes tiered administrative fees based on estimated costs as a percentage of a threshold, while the statute requires charging for actual and reasonable administrative expenses incurred, with only a maximum cap.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.465","citation":"ORS 238.465(9)(a)-(b)","quote":"the board shall charge and collect out of the benefits payable to the member and the alternate payee actual and reasonable administrative expenses and related costs incurred by the board in obtaining data and making calculations that are necessary by reason of the provisions of this section. (b) The board may not charge more than $1,300 for total administrative expenses and related costs incurred in obtaining data or making calculations that are necessary by reason of the provisions of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-045-0090","citation":"OAR 459-045-0090(3)","quote":"The fee to be assessed by the board shall be determined by the estimated administrative cost of implementing the court order based on a percentage of the fee threshold (rounded to the nearest dollar), as set forth below: (a) Low Administrative Cost Tier: Set at 50% of the maximum allowable administrative fee and is $685 for calendar year 2026. (b) Moderate Administrative Cost Tier: Set at 75% of the maximum allowable administrative fee and is $1,028 for calendar year 2026. (c) High Administrative Cost Tier: Set at 100% of the maximum allowable administrative fee and is $1,371 for calendar year 2026.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.465","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7edb8e5190eeb9ee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule definition of 'alternate payee' includes dissolution of registered domestic partnership, which is not explicitly stated in the statute's enumeration of qualifying judgments.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.465","citation":"ORS 238.465(1)","quote":"payments under this chapter or ORS chapter 238A of any pension, annuity, retirement allowance, disability benefit, death benefit, refund benefit or other benefit that would otherwise be made to a person entitled thereto under this chapter or ORS chapter 238A shall be paid, in whole or in part, by the Public Employees Retirement Board to an alternate payee if and to the extent expressly provided for in the terms of any judgment of annulment or dissolution of marriage or of separation, or the terms of any court order or court-approved property settlement agreement incident to any judgment of annulment or dissolution of marriage or of separation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-045-0001","citation":"OAR 459-045-0001(2)","quote":"Alternate payee\" means the recipient of an award of a portion or all of a PERS member's account(s) or benefits as provided for in the terms of any judgment of annulment, dissolution of marriage, dissolution of registered domestic partnership, or separation, or the terms of any court order or court-approved property settlement agreement incident to any judgment of annulment, dissolution of marriage, dissolution of registered domestic partnership, or separation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.465","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4052388daa7f195","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The statute establishes that eligible employees 'shall receive retirement credit' automatically upon meeting specified conditions and returning within required timeframes, but the implementing rule requires submission of an application and payment of a purchase cost as prerequisites to obtaining that credit.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.160","citation":"ORS 238.160","quote":"Any employee of an employer participating in the system shall receive retirement credit, subject to the limitations of this chapter, for the period of employment with the participating employer prior to July 1, 1946, and for employment in any branch or department of the United States Government, and for military service in the Armed Forces of the United States, as though the person had been an employee of the participating employer throughout such period of employment or service, if within 40 days from and after separation from such civilian employment with the United States Government, or within one year after being otherwise than dishonorably discharged from military service in the Armed Forces of the United States, the person returned to the employment of the participating employer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(2)","quote":"To make a purchase, a member must submit the application for restoration of creditable service or to obtain retirement credit and the full purchase cost, provided by PERS, within the time period established in the particular statute.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.160","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7ce62f917df9d042","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule applies the service retirement benefit comparison to all members eligible for service retirement, while the statute limits this comparison only to members who have passed earliest service retirement age.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.330","citation":"ORS 238.330(2)","quote":"Notwithstanding ORS 238.320, 238.325 and subsection (1) of this section, if an active or inactive member of the system has been found to be entitled to a disability retirement allowance as provided in ORS 238.320 after the member has passed earliest service retirement age, the amount of monthly disability retirement allowance shall not be less than the amount which the member would have received had the member retired for service and elected the same option.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-015-0055","citation":"OAR 459-015-0055(10)","quote":"A disability benefit will not be less than $100 per month under the non-refund Option 1 benefit or the amount the member would have received for service retirement, if eligible, whichever is higher.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4858ce9c79cb3b57","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the statutory requirement that interest only applies to underpayments of $10 or more per month, potentially broadening application to all underpayments.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.455","citation":"ORS 238.455(5)","quote":"If the estimated payment made to the member under subsection (1) of this section results in an underpayment to the member of $10 or more a month, the board shall pay interest on the balance of such underpayment at a rate established by rule of the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0015","citation":"OAR 459-007-0015","quote":"earnings credited to an underpayment of either Tier One or Tier Two estimated benefits shall be simple interest, prorated from date of underpayment to date of distribution","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.455","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"82d5beda38fa1d35","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-009-0350 declares implementation of ORS 238.705 but its operative text about allocating actuarial assets and liabilities in employee transfers and employer dissolutions never engages with 238.705's actual provisions regarding remitting contributions, charging interest on delinquent contributions, or penalties for delinquent reporting.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-009-0350","citation":"OAR 459-009-0350 (declared statutes)","quote":"ORS 238.225, ORS 238.605, ORS 238.670, ORS 238.705, 2005 OL, ORS 808, Sec. (12) & (13) & (14)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.705","citation":"ORS 238.705","quote":"All public employers that are members of the system shall promptly and regularly remit to the Public Employees Retirement Board all contributions required of them by law and furnish all reports required by the board. Any public employer delinquent in remitting contributions shall be charged interest on the total amount of contributions due from it at the rate of one percent per month or fraction thereof during which the public employer is delinquent.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.705","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5259e3dc067607c6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-035-0040(1)(a) restricts eligible retired state employees to 'Tier One or Tier Two' members, but ORS 238.415(1)(b)(A) defines the category as any 'retired member of the Public Employees Retirement System' meeting other criteria without any tier restriction.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.415","citation":"ORS 238.415(1)(b)(A)","quote":"A retired member of the Public Employees Retirement System who was a state employee at the time of retirement, is retired for service or disability, is receiving a retirement allowance or benefit under the system, had eight years or more of qualifying service in the system at the time of retirement or is receiving a disability retirement allowance including a pension computed as if the member had eight years or more of creditable service in the system at the time of retirement, and has attained earliest service retirement age but is not eligible for federal Medicare coverage","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-035-0040","citation":"OAR 459-035-0040(1)(a)","quote":"A Tier One or Tier Two member who is not eligible for Medicare, and whose PERS effective retirement date is the first of the month following termination of state employment","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f8829526b52b281","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule allows PERS to set a deadline for adjusted purchase costs, making the statutory 90-day requirement discretionary.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.148","citation":"ORS 238.148(2)","quote":"if the member within 90 days of the member's effective date of retirement: (a) Applies in writing to the Public Employees Retirement Board for such retirement credit","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(3)(a)","quote":"If the purchase cost is adjusted and requires an additional payment, PERS will notify the member of the balance due. To complete the purchase, the balance due must be received by PERS by the later of: (A) The date set by PERS; or (B) The member's effective retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.148","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ccce60d600be3826","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule permits termination for return-to-work violations and refusal to re-retire, circumstances not mentioned in the statute, which limits termination authority to situations where participation would cause loss of tax-qualified status.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.618","citation":"ORS 238.618","quote":"the Public Employees Retirement Board may deny or terminate participation by an employer in the Public Employees Retirement System, and may deny or terminate membership in the system for any employee, if the board determines that allowing participation by the employer or membership for the employee would cause the system or the Public Employees Retirement Fund to lose qualification as a qualified governmental retirement plan","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-010-0300","citation":"OAR 459-010-0300(2)(b) and (2)(c)","quote":"The Director is delegated the authority provided under ORS 238.618 to terminate a member's membership in the Public Employees Retirement System under the following circumstances: (a) The member retired and elected the total lump sum option under ORS 238.305(3); (b) The member exceeded the return to work limitations in ORS 238.078(2) and OAR 459-017-0060(5) in the six month period following the member's effective retirement date; and (c) The member refuses to re-retire in compliance with those return to work limitations.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.618","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"640547ee0e02c27b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rules limit application to judge members, but ORS 238.250 requires regular accounts for each active and inactive member who made contributions to the fund.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0400","citation":"ORS 238.250","quote":"The board shall provide for a regular account for each active and inactive member of the system who has made contributions to the fund.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-459-007-0400","citation":"459-007-0400","quote":"Upon withdrawal of a judge member account under ORS 238.545, earnings from the last judge member annual rate to the date of distribution will be credited as specified in this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"74c7704e3156003d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rules limit application to judge members, but ORS 238.250 requires regular accounts for each active and inactive member who made contributions to the fund.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0410","citation":"ORS 238.250","quote":"The board shall provide for a regular account for each active and inactive member of the system who has made contributions to the fund.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-459-007-0410","citation":"459-007-0410","quote":"Upon the death of a judge member, earnings will be credited to the judge member account as specified in this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0190698f46aa95c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rules limit application to judge members, but ORS 238.250 requires regular accounts for each active and inactive member who made contributions to the fund.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0420","citation":"ORS 238.250","quote":"The board shall provide for a regular account for each active and inactive member of the system who has made contributions to the fund.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-459-007-0420","citation":"459-007-0420","quote":"Upon retirement of a judge member for service or disability, earnings from the effective date of the last judge member annual rate to the effective date of retirement will be credited to the judge member account as specified in this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9ab0d6ebbc17f4e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-459-005-0055 declares it implements ORS 238.607, but the operative text contains no reference to or engagement with that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-005-0055","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.605, ORS 238.607, ORS 238.630)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.607","citation":"ORS 238.607","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.605","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"684a2d738be7d0fb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule imposes a specific 80% adequacy standard for substitute annuities, but the statute gives employers discretion to deem the annuity adequate without specifying a particular standard.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.015","citation":"ORS 238.015(7)(a)","quote":"if the employer deems the annuity adequate for the purposes of this chapter, it may enter into an agreement with the employee and the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-010-0045","citation":"OAR 459-010-0045(2)","quote":"The benefit adequacy of the substitute annuity shall be determined by the employer. In determining the adequacy of the benefits, the employer shall assure that the substitute annuity provides no less than 80 percent of the total actuarial present value of what the system would provide","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"965e2b1da90fbb48","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule allows officers to be deemed to have elected PERS membership through payment of contributions for more than one pay period, making the statute's requirement of written notice within 30 days optional.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.015","citation":"ORS 238.015(5)","quote":"may become a member of the system by giving the board written notice of desire to do so within 30 days after taking the office","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-010-0180","citation":"OAR 459-010-0180(2)","quote":"A member who is elected or appointed for a fixed term, or appointed as director of a department by the Governor, shall be deemed to have elected to participate in PERS for the term of office if the member and employer contributions are paid to PERS for more than one pay period after the member's term in office or appointment commences.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b840ec8dd3257799","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates that the board 'shall require medical examinations for all applicants,' but the rule states PERS is not obligated to request any examination.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.335","citation":"ORS 238.335","quote":"The board shall require medical examinations for all applicants for retirement for disability under such general rules as it prescribes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-015-0025","citation":"OAR 459-015-0025(1)(a)","quote":"PERS is not required or obligated to request any examination or evaluation. The burden of proof for eligibility for a disability retirement allowance is upon the applicant, whether or not PERS requests any examination or evaluation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"09dddd8da81615ae","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-007-0050 declares it implements ORS 238.435, which applies only to persons establishing membership on or after January 1, 1996 (Tier Two), but the rule itself applies exclusively to Tier One active or inactive members (pre-1996).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0050","citation":"OAR 459-007-0050 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 238.390, ORS 238.430, ORS 238.435","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0050","citation":"OAR 459-007-0050(1)","quote":"Upon the death of an active or inactive Tier One member","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.435","citation":"ORS 238.435 heading","quote":"Provisions applicable to persons establishing membership on or after January 1, 1996","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.435","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3dbbd28ba1898a26","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-007-0110 declares it implements ORS 238.435, which applies only to persons establishing membership on or after January 1, 1996 (Tier Two), but the rule itself applies exclusively to Tier One members.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0110","citation":"OAR 459-007-0110 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 238.095, ORS 238.435","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0110","citation":"OAR 459-007-0110","quote":"When a Tier One member's membership terminates under ORS 238.095(2)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.435","citation":"ORS 238.435 heading","quote":"Provisions applicable to persons establishing membership on or after January 1, 1996","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.435","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"083b960257aeb7a8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule requires submission of 'the full purchase cost' within the time period established in the statute, but ORS 238.165(4) establishes two separate time periods: one year to give written notice of election, and then five years from the date of election to complete payment.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.165","citation":"ORS 238.165(4)(a)-(b)","quote":"No later than one year after July 22, 1973, the employee shall give written notice to the board that the employee elects to pay to the fund the unpaid employee contributions attributable to legislative employment. (b) The employee shall then pay to the board the entire amount of the unpaid employee contributions without interest, in a lump sum or at the option of the employee in installments, within five years after the date of making the election but prior to reaching compulsory retirement age.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(2)","quote":"To make a purchase, a member must submit the application for restoration of creditable service or to obtain retirement credit and the full purchase cost, provided by PERS, within the time period established in the particular statute.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.165","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"43b0deaae1ecf739","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule restricts the conversion right under ORS 238.305(6) by requiring that beneficiaries must have been married on the member's effective retirement date, whereas the statute requires only that the beneficiary be the spouse at the time the marriage terminates (without specifying they must have been married at retirement).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.305","citation":"ORS 238.305(6)","quote":"if the beneficiary is the spouse of the member and the marriage relationship is terminated as provided by law after the expiration of the time within which the member could change the election of an option, the member may elect to receive, in lieu of the optional form of allowance previously elected, the allowance that the member would have received","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0060","citation":"OAR 459-013-0060(4)","quote":"To be eligible to convert their benefit pursuant to the termination of a marriage, the member and the beneficiary must have been married on the member's effective date of retirement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.305","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"202a7ee071b9b83e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule requires the 60-day window for changing beneficiary/option to run from 'the date of the first actual (not estimated) benefit payment,' but the statute triggers it from 'the date of the first benefit payment' without distinguishing between estimated and actual payments.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.325","citation":"ORS 238.325(2)","quote":"The designation of a beneficiary or the election of an option may be changed by a member within 60 days after the date of the first benefit payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-015-0055","citation":"OAR 459-015-0055(2)(b)","quote":"The beneficiary designation or benefit option may be changed up to 60 days after the date of the first actual (not estimated) benefit payment as provided in ORS 238.325(2).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c80dacd5cac54c6c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rules 459-013-0310 and 459-013-0320 make residency a determinative factor in the increased benefits provided under ORS 238.366, but the statute bases the increase solely on years of creditable service with no residency requirement or reference.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.366","citation":"ORS 238.366(4)","quote":"The percentage increases provided for in this section to the benefits payable to or on account of a member of the system who is serving as other than a police officer or firefighter at the time of death or retirement shall be: (A) For a member with a combined total of 10 or more years of creditable service in the system and prior service credit but less than a combined total of 20 years, one percent. (B) For a member with a combined total of 20 or more years of creditable service in the system and prior service credit but less than a combined total of 25 years, two percent. (C) For a member with a combined total of 25 or more years of creditable service in the system and prior service credit but less than a combined total of 30 years, three percent. (D) For a member with a combined total of 30 or more years of creditable service in the system and prior service credit, four percent.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0310","citation":"OAR 459-013-0310(1)(b)","quote":"The increased benefit percentage to be added to a benefit paid to a beneficiary under ORS 238.390, 238.395, 238.400, 238.405, or under an optional form of retirement allowance under ORS 238.305 or 238.325 will be determined based on: (A) The increased benefit percentage(s) for which the member is otherwise eligible under ORS 238.364, 238.366 and 238.368; and (B) The residency of the beneficiary.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0320","citation":"OAR 459-013-0320(3)","quote":"If the alternate payee is eligible for the increased benefit under section (2), payment of the increased benefit to the alternate payee under ORS 238.372 to 238.384 is determined by the residency of the alternate payee.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.366","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3e506ad758a8c44f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-005-0055(2) cites ORS 238.630(3)(g) for authority to require actuarial equivalency studies, but that subsection addresses federal tax qualification, not actuarial equivalency, which is governed by ORS 238.630(3)(f).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-005-0055","citation":"OAR 459-005-0055(2)","quote":"The Director shall take steps to assure, pursuant to ORS 238.630(3)(g), that the Board's consulting actuary shall present an Actuarial Equivalency Study to the Board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.630","citation":"ORS 238.630(3)(f)","quote":"Shall determine the actuarial equivalency of optional forms of retirement allowances and pensions and adopt for that purpose the necessary actuarial equivalency factor tables in the manner provided by ORS 238.607","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.630","citation":"ORS 238.630(3)(g)","quote":"Shall adopt rules and take all actions necessary to maintain qualification of the Public Employees Retirement System and the Public Employees Retirement Fund as a qualified governmental retirement plan and trust under the Internal Revenue Code and under regulations adopted pursuant to the Internal Revenue Code","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.630","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b2e392ed38a64dcd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule extends temporary exemption from hour limitations through calendar year 2035, but statute limits it through calendar year 2034.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.082","citation":"ORS 238.082, Note: Sec. 38 (1), chapter 355, Oregon Laws 2019","quote":"Section 35, chapter 355, Oregon Laws 2019, as amended by section 2, chapter 135, Oregon Laws 2021, and section 1 of this 2023 Act, is repealed on January 2, 2035.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-017-0060","citation":"OAR 459-017-0060(17)","quote":"For calendar years 2020 through 2035, the limitations on employment in section (2) of this rule do not apply to a retired member unless the member retired under the provisions of ORS 238.280(1), (2), or (3), and does not have a bona fide retirement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.082","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8e0c84eace24e270","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-040-0040(4) specifies that the five-year pro tem service period starts from 'the judge member's retirement date,' but the statute provides an alternative commencement date.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.535","citation":"ORS 238.535(1)(c)","quote":"The five-year period shall commence on the judge member's date of retirement or the date on which the judge member commences pro tem service under ORS 238.545 (4), whichever is earlier.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-040-0040","citation":"OAR 459-040-0040(4)","quote":"A judge member who retires under Plan B must serve as a pro-tem judge for 35 days per calendar year for five years following the judge member's retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.535","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eb0155a3d6d4b1f3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule defines 'bona fide retirement' using 'at least six full calendar months' as the threshold, while the statute requires 'more than six consecutive calendar months' for reemployment eligibility.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.078","citation":"ORS 238.078(1)(a)","quote":"A member who has been retired for service for more than six consecutive calendar months may be reemployed by a participating public employer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-017-0060","citation":"459-017-0060(1)(a)","quote":"'Bona fide retirement' means that the retired member has been absent from service with all participating employers and all employers in a controlled group with a participating employer for at least six full calendar months between the effective date of retirement and the date of hire.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.078","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e3a86adb70e8749c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-459-013-0320 declares it implements ORS 238.465, which is outside the scope of ORS 238.384's grant of authority to make rules for 'administration of ORS 238.372 to 238.384.'","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-013-0320","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.362, ORS 238.364, ORS 238.366, ORS 238.465, ORS 238.372 - 238.384","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.384","citation":"ORS 238.384","quote":"The Public Employees Retirement Board may establish rules for the administration of ORS 238.372 to 238.384.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.384","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4167a57b53881d2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule establishes a minimum threshold ($5) for retroactive payments, but ORS 238.601 is a legislative findings and intent section addressing fiduciary duties and system administration principles that never engages with the subject of retroactive payments or minimum payment amounts.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.601","citation":"ORS 238.601","quote":"Legislative findings and intent; administration of system. The Legislative Assembly finds that the maintenance of a solid, affordable public employees retirement plan is essential... It is the intent of the Legislative Assembly that the Public Employees Retirement Board, in performing its duties as trustee of the Public Employees Retirement Fund, recognize that the continued stability and viability of the Public Employees Retirement System depends on the ability of public employers and taxpayers to pay the costs of the system.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0615","citation":"OAR 459-005-0615 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.601","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.601","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2b36f12df6575571","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-007-0080 explicitly references receiving single payment benefits under ORS 238.315 but does not implement the statute's requirement that the member's 'total service retirement allowance... is less than $200 per month,' thereby dropping a condition that determines eligibility for 238.315 treatment.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.315","citation":"ORS 238.315","quote":"whose total service retirement allowance on the effective date of retirement, as computed by the board in accordance with the nonrefund plan, is less than $200 per month, shall receive, in lieu of any and all retirement allowance or other benefits under the system, a retirement benefit in the form of a lump sum amount","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0080","citation":"OAR 459-007-0080","quote":"when a Tier One member retires and elects to receive a single payment of benefits under ORS 238.305(2)(a) or (3), or receives a single payment of benefits under 238.315, earnings from the effective date of the last annual rate to the date of distribution shall be credited in the manner specified in this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.315","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1c84ce8175e09695","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-009-0090 declares it implements ORS 238.225-238.229, but those statutes address only lump-sum payments applied to existing liabilities (ORS 238.229(2): 'the account shall be used to offset contributions to the system that the public employer would otherwise be required to make for the liabilities against which the lump sum payment is applied'). OAR 459-009-0090 establishes an entirely different program for employers with NO existing unfunded actuarial liability to create actuarial surplus, which the statute's operative text never engages.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-009-0090","citation":"OAR 459-009-0090, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.225 - 238.229","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.229","citation":"ORS 238.229(2)","quote":"the account shall be used to offset contributions to the system that the public employer would otherwise be required to make for the liabilities against which the lump sum payment is applied","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.229","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dfe11349a3b341f0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a requirement that the employee must reenter 'in a qualifying position' when the statute only requires reentering 'the service of an employer participating in the system'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.105","citation":"ORS 238.105(1)","quote":"an employee who has withdrawn the amount credited to the member account of the member reenters the service of an employer participating in the system","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0050","citation":"OAR 459-011-0050(3)","quote":"any such person who reenters the service of a participating employer in a qualifying position within five years from the date of the last separation from employment in a qualifying position that preceded the member's withdrawal","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"868bb0a21d6809eb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 238.008(3) as the provision requiring allocation of retroactive payments, but ORS 238.008(2) specifies the allocation method while 238.008(3) only states that employees receive credit for periods to which payment is allocated.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"statute","citation":"ORS 238.008(2)","quote":"Retroactive payments described in this subsection shall be allocated to and deemed paid in the periods of the employee's active or inactive membership in which the work was done or in which the work would have been done.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"statute","citation":"ORS 238.008(3)","quote":"If retroactive payments are included in the salary of an employee under this section, the employee shall receive retirement credit for the periods to which the payment is allocated.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"rule","citation":"OAR 459-011-0050(3)(b)","quote":"A retroactive payment must be allocated pursuant to ORS 238.008(3).","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.008","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ccab576e4c0bc3af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"ORS 238.430(3) excludes judge members from ORS 238.435, but the rules declare they implement both ORS 238.430 and ORS 238.435 without explicitly excluding judge members from the earnings crediting procedures, potentially extending ORS 238.435 benefits to judge members contrary to the statute's limitation.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.430","citation":"ORS 238.430(3)","quote":"The provisions of ORS 238.435 do not apply to judge members of the system.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0050","citation":"459-007-0050 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.390, ORS 238.430, ORS 238.435","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.430","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4e309e2de8f308df","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rules 0400, 0410, and 0420 declare they implement ORS 238.255 but their operative text never engages with 238.255's core requirements regarding reserve accounts, assumed interest rate comparisons, or deficit rules—they only address judge member-specific earnings crediting procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0400","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.250, ORS 238.255, ORS 238.260, ORS 238.515, ORS 238.545, OL 2003 Ch. 625","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0410","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.250, ORS 238.255, ORS 238.260, ORS 238.515, ORS 238.565, OL 2003 Ch. 625","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-007-0420","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.250, ORS 238.255, ORS 238.260, ORS 238.515, ORS 238.565, OL 2003 Ch. 625","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.255","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"563c05425303ec06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts protection to only 'authorized paid leave' with a 600-hour threshold, while the statute protects all 'leave of absence, sabbatical leave, illness, accident or emergency' without such conditions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.025","citation":"ORS 238.025","quote":"no leave of absence, sabbatical leave, illness, accident or emergency preventing or interrupting service by an employee to an employer participating in the system shall be deemed to break the continuity of the employee's membership in the system","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-010-0011","citation":"OAR 459-010-0011(3)","quote":"For the purposes of ORS 238.005, a member is not \"inactive\" when: (a) The member is absent from service while on authorized paid leave; and (b) The member's employment position normally requires 600 or more hours of service to the public employer in a 12-month period.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"77b184fbcd405cd3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-016-0100(3)(a) allows lump-sum unit purchases for members retiring up to age 65 if prior contributions were made, but the statute limits lump-sum purchases to those retiring prior to age 60.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.440","citation":"ORS 238.440(2)","quote":"Notwithstanding subsection (1) of this section, a police officer or firefighter who retires prior to age 60 may apply for and receive an actuarially reduced unit income commencing at any date between the date of early retirement and age 60, with monthly benefits payable for at least 60 months or any other monthly formula in excess of 60 months but always terminating by age 65. Such a police officer or firefighter may elect to pay in a lump sum within the 90 days immediately preceding early retirement the contribution that the police officer or firefighter would have made to the account had the police officer or firefighter worked to age 60.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-016-0100","citation":"459-016-0100(3)(a)","quote":"If previous payroll contributions for unit benefits have been made, a lump-sum purchase of any remaining units, for a maximum of eight units, may be made within 90 days prior to the member's retirement date if the member is less than age 65.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1531f609d7d853e2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare they implement ORS 238.750, which is a short title provision containing no substantive requirements about transmission of documents, information, reports, or remittances that the rules actually address.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-005-0210","citation":"ORS 238.750","quote":"ORS 238.005–238.750, ORS 192.355, ORS 243.435, ORS 243.470","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0215","citation":"ORS 238.750","quote":"ORS 238.005 - 238.750","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.750","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ef69d802e68ba640","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule requires trustee-to-trustee transfers to be received by PERS within time periods established in underlying eligibility statutes, but the statute does not explicitly impose a deadline for receiving transfers—only that the member must be eligible.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.222","citation":"ORS 238.222(1)","quote":"a member of the Public Employees Retirement System who is eligible to obtain restoration of forfeited creditable service under ORS 238.115, or to purchase retirement credit under ORS 238.125, 238.135, 238.145, 238.148, 238.156, 238.157, 238.160, 238.162, 238.165, 238.175 or 526.052, and who participates in an eligible retirement plan described in subsection (3) of this section, may use moneys transferred by way of a trustee-to-trustee transfer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0580","citation":"459-005-0580(2)(a)","quote":"PERS must receive the trustee-to-trustee transfer within the time period established in the particular statute for restoration of creditable service or obtaining retirement credit included in ORS 238.222(1)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.222","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c117547dc782e744","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule allows additional trustee-to-trustee transfers when costs are adjusted upward, but the statute requires the member to pay any remaining amount needed.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.222","citation":"ORS 238.222(2)","quote":"If amounts transferred under this section are not sufficient to pay the full amount necessary to obtain restoration of the forfeited creditable service or to purchase the retirement credit, the member must pay the remaining amount that is needed to obtain restoration of the forfeited creditable service or to purchase the retirement credit","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0580","citation":"459-005-0580(2)(c)","quote":"If the cost of restoration of creditable service or obtaining retirement credit is adjusted and PERS determines that the amount required is greater than the amount originally received, a trustee-to-trustee transfer may be made to remit the additional amount required","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.222","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"52134f0cc2ac97ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule redefines 'delayed' benefit as occurring when valid request for distribution is received more than one year after death, whereas the statute defines 'delayed' as when the member's spouse elects to delay payment.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.395","citation":"ORS 238.395(2)(f)","quote":"The member's spouse may elect to delay payment of the death benefit provided under this subsection, which shall be actuarially adjusted for age and interest when payments commence, but payment must commence no later than December 31 of the calendar year in which the deceased member would have reached 72 years of age.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-014-0040","citation":"OAR 459-014-0040(4)","quote":"A benefit distribution will be considered \"delayed\" under ORS 238.395(2) and ORS 238A.230 when a valid request for distribution is received more than one year after the member's date of death.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.395","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aae6712a578e46d3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 459-005-0100 broadens the definition of 'member' beyond what the statute defines to include beneficiaries of PERS members and alternate payees, when the statute defines member only as persons who have established membership in the system.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.005","citation":"ORS 238.005(16)","quote":"\"Member\" means a person who has established membership in the system and whose membership has not been terminated as described in ORS 238.095. \"Member\" includes active, inactive and retired members.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0100","citation":"OAR 459-005-0100(2)","quote":"For the purposes of OAR 459-005-0100 to 459-005-0160, the term \"member\" means a PERS member as defined in ORS 238.005, the beneficiary of a PERS member, an alternate payee as defined in 238.465, or the beneficiary of an alternate payee.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0000302612cdb03","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule section (6) adds a new ground for ineligibility to restore credit under ORS 238.115 based on termination status under ORS 238.095(2), a condition not stated in the statute.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.115","citation":"ORS 238.115(1)(a)","quote":"A member of the Public Employees Retirement System who, after separation from all service entitling the employee to membership in the system and withdrawal of the amount credited to the member account of the member, reenters the service of an employer participating in the system and serves as an active member of the system for 10 years after that reentry, and who has not otherwise obtained restoration of creditable service forfeited by the withdrawal, shall obtain restoration of one full month of creditable service forfeited by the withdrawal for each three full months of service as an active member after that reentry if the member, within 90 days before the effective date of retirement of the member: (A) Applies in writing to the Public Employees Retirement Board for restoration of creditable service; and (B) Pays to the board in a lump sum for credit to the member account of the member the amount withdrawn and interest on the amount withdrawn compounded annually for each year or portion of a year after the date of the withdrawal and before the effective date of retirement of the member.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0050","citation":"OAR 459-011-0050(6)","quote":"Beginning with January 1, 2018 effective retirement dates, a person whose membership is terminated under ORS 238.095(2) may not restore forfeited credit under ORS 238.115.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.115","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"be80c9e16796a1c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Both rules are declared to implement ORS 238.364 but their operative text never engages with any of its substantive provisions (calculation formulas, service cutoffs, alternate payee division rules, etc.) and instead implement residency requirements entirely absent from ORS 238.364.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-013-0310","citation":"Declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 238.362, ORS 238.364, ORS 238.366, ORS 238.368, ORS 238.372 - 238.384","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0320","citation":"Declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 238.362, ORS 238.364, ORS 238.366, ORS 238.465, ORS 238.372 - 238.384","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.364","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","also_cited":["ors-238.362#1"]}],"fingerprint":"7ef6cdb1a9619ca3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts authorized investments to those \"enhancing the value of the PERF,\" but the statute only says it will not impair any law authorizing investment of moneys from the fund, without requiring such investments to enhance value.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.660","citation":"ORS 238.660(1)","quote":"except that this provision shall not be deemed to amend or impair the force or effect of any law of this state specifically authorizing the investment of moneys from the fund","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0010","citation":"OAR 459-005-0010(2)(b)","quote":"For any laws of the State of Oregon specifically authorizing the investment of moneys from the PERF for the purposes enhancing the value of the PERF","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.660","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8c8de1cffaaf7228","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule introduces residency as a determinative factor for calculating increased benefits, but ORS 238.368 contains no residency requirement and specifies increases based only on years of creditable service and job category at retirement.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.368","citation":"ORS 238.368(1)","quote":"the monthly retirement allowance payable to or on account of any person who has retired as a member of the Public Employees Retirement System shall be increased by the following percentages: (a) If the member was serving as other than a police officer or firefighter at the time of retirement, the percentage increase shall be: (A) For a member with a combined total of 10 or more years of creditable service in the system and prior service credit but less than a combined total of 20 years, one percent...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0310","citation":"OAR 459-013-0310(1)(b)","quote":"The increased benefit percentage to be added to a benefit paid to a beneficiary under ORS 238.390, 238.395, 238.400, 238.405, or under an optional form of retirement allowance under ORS 238.305 or 238.325 will be determined based on: (A) The increased benefit percentage(s) for which the member is otherwise eligible under ORS 238.364, 238.366 and 238.368; and (B) The residency of the beneficiary.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.368","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"008b55ddb03ab7a5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule adds an age requirement (under 72) for becoming a judge member that the statute's definition does not contain.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.500","citation":"ORS 238.500(3)","quote":"\"Judge member\" means a judge who is a member of the Public Employees Retirement System subject to ORS 238.500 to 238.585.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-040-0010","citation":"OAR 459-040-0010(1) and (8)","quote":"A person younger than age 72 becomes a judge member on the date that the person takes office as a judge... A person age 72 or older who becomes a judge is not eligible to become a judge member.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.500","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af6346fd8bb87ed8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rules extend eligibility to 'dependent domestic partner,' a category not mentioned in the statute's definition of eligible persons.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.410","citation":"ORS 238.410(1)(b)(A)","quote":"A member of the Public Employees Retirement System who is retired for service or disability and is receiving a retirement allowance or benefit under the system, and a spouse or dependent of that member","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-035-0020","citation":"OAR 459-035-0020(4)","quote":"A dependent domestic partner as defined in OAR 459-035-0001(2).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-035-0001","citation":"OAR 459-035-0001(2)","quote":"'Dependent Domestic Partner' means a person who has a relationship with a PERS retiree that has the characteristics described below. To qualify as a 'dependent domestic partner', the person and the PERS retiree must: (a) Share a close personal relationship and be responsible for each other's common welfare, including but not limited to having joint financial responsibilities; (b) Be each other's sole domestic partner; (c) Not be married to anyone, nor have had another domestic partner within the previous 12 months; (d) Not be related by blood so closely as to bar marriage in the State of Oregon; (e) Have jointly shared the same regular and permanent residence for at least 12 months immediately preceding the effective date of coverage with the intent to continue doing so indefinitely; and (f) Have the PERS retiree providing over one-half of the financial support for the person and qualify as a dependent of the PERS retiree as determined under section 105(b) of the Internal Revenue Code, 26 USC 105(b).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"25f304ed4e9fabe7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-013-0110 states that membership will not terminate under ORS 238.095(2) if a member reaches earliest retirement age, but ORS 238.095(2) establishes automatic termination based solely on inactive period and vesting status, with no exception for members reaching retirement age.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.095","citation":"ORS 238.095(2)","quote":"Except as provided in subsection (3) of this section, an inactive member ceases to be a member of the system if the member is not vested and is inactive for a period of five consecutive years.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0110","citation":"OAR 459-013-0110","quote":"After becoming eligible under that section, a member may not withdraw their account under ORS 238.265 nor will their membership terminate by operation of ORS 238.095(2).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.095","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e0a794883431054","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-007-0370 declares it implements ORS 238.265, but the operative text governs EPSA withdrawal under ORS 238A.375, not member account withdrawal under ORS 238.265; ORS 238.265 excludes the rule's own subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-007-0370","citation":"OAR 459-007-0370 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 238.265, ORS 238A.353","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.265","citation":"ORS 238.265","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.265","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30175c6b1e69b2ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-013-0110 describes members as 'becomes eligible for a service retirement benefit' whereas ORS 238.280 uses mandatory language stating they 'shall be retired upon written application,' potentially making a statutory requirement discretionary.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.280","citation":"ORS 238.280(1)","quote":"a member of the Public Employees Retirement System who attains the age of 55 shall be retired upon written application by the member to the Public Employees Retirement Board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-013-0110","citation":"OAR 459-013-0110","quote":"A member who reaches earliest retirement age under ORS 238.280 becomes eligible for a service retirement benefit that will be paid upon written application to the Board.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fc4676b95e6d4234","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-009-0098 exempts employers with fewer than 5 active members from the statutory requirement that contribution amounts be 'actuarially necessary to adequately fund the benefits' by allowing PERS to apply a system-wide average rate instead.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.225","citation":"ORS 238.225","quote":"A participating public employer shall, at intervals designated by the Public Employees Retirement Board, transmit to the board those amounts the board determines to be actuarially necessary to adequately fund the benefits to be provided by the contributions of the employer under this chapter","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-009-0098","citation":"OAR 459-009-0098","quote":"In determining the amounts to be paid to PERS by a public employer, if a current employer contribution rate does not exist for an employer and they employ fewer than five active members on their payroll, PERS will apply the system-wide average rate as the employer contribution rate.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.225","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"980be271af3b9938","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 105-020-0015(4) specifies contributions cease at an IRC 401(a)(17) salary limitation, contradicting the statute's requirement that contributions cease for all service performed on or after January 1, 2004.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.200","citation":"ORS 238.200(4)","quote":"a member of the system, or a participating employer acting on behalf of the member pursuant to ORS 238.205, is not permitted or required to make employee contributions to the fund for service performed on or after January 1, 2004","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-105-020-0015","citation":"OAR 105-020-0015(4)","quote":"A PERS participating member's employee contribution ceases when the participating member's salary reaches the salary limitation set forth in IRC § 401(a)(17) and ORS 238.005","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a3b008bf619eafb6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"The rule permits payment of balance due after the member's retirement date when PERS sets a later deadline, but the statute requires full payment 'on or before the effective date of retirement.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.145","citation":"ORS 238.145(3)(b)","quote":"Payment of the lump sum shall be made on or before the effective date of retirement for the member.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(3)(a)","quote":"To complete the purchase, the balance due must be received by PERS by the later of: (A) The date set by PERS; or (B) The member's effective retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc638c7b4a586665","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-011-0115(4)(a) allows payment 'within 90 days before or after the member's effective retirement date' for members at earliest retirement age, while the statute specifies payment 'within 90 days of the member's effective date of retirement,' which does not explicitly allow payment before retirement.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.157","citation":"ORS 238.157(2)","quote":"within 90 days of the member's effective date of retirement","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0115","citation":"OAR 459-011-0115(4)(a)","quote":"If the member has reached earliest retirement age, the purchase may be made within 90 days before or after the member's effective retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.157","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"058aa15fa0f581e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-011-0100(3)(f) defines 'uniformed services' but omits the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration commissioned corps, which the statute includes at ORS 238.156(5)(b)(D).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.156","citation":"ORS 238.156(5)(b)","quote":"\"Uniformed services\" means: (A) The Armed Forces; (B) The Army National Guard or the Air National Guard when the employee is engaged in active duty for training, inactive duty for training or full-time National Guard duty; (C) The commissioned corps of the United States Public Health Service; (D) The commissioned corps of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; and (E) Any other category of persons designated by the President of the United States in time of war or national emergency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0100","citation":"OAR 459-011-0100(3)(f)","quote":"\"Uniformed services\" means the following: (A) Armed Forces; (B) Army National Guard; (C) Air National Guard; (D) Commissioned corps of the Public Health Service; and (E) Any other category of individuals designated by the President in time of war or national emergency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.156","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"df7432d1eb51998d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-011-0100(3)(f) defines 'uniformed services' to include 'Army National Guard' and 'Air National Guard' without the statutory limitation that they must be 'when the employee is engaged in active duty for training, inactive duty for training or full-time National Guard duty,' whereas rule 459-011-0115(1)(d) correctly includes this limitation.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.156","citation":"ORS 238.156(5)(b)(B)","quote":"The Army National Guard or the Air National Guard when the employee is engaged in active duty for training, inactive duty for training or full-time National Guard duty","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0100","citation":"OAR 459-011-0100(3)(f)(B)-(C)","quote":"(B) Army National Guard; (C) Air National Guard","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0115","citation":"OAR 459-011-0115(1)(d)(B)","quote":"The Army National Guard or the Air National Guard when the employee is on duty as described in ORS 238.156(5)(b)(B)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.156","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0aa78333c47c724","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"ORS 238.300(1) requires that if a member dies before the first payment is due, the member account shall be treated as though death had occurred before retirement, but the rule instead provides that retirement benefit options selected pursuant to ORS 238.300 or 238.305 determine how benefits are paid.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.300","citation":"ORS 238.300(1)","quote":"If death of the member occurs before the first payment is due, the member account of the member shall be treated as though death had occurred before retirement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-014-0050","citation":"OAR 459-014-0050(4)(a)","quote":"Before the first payment is due, the benefit option selected pursuant to ORS 238.300 or 238.305 determines how benefits are paid to the designated beneficiary.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.300","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b559a8e9a2b3f38f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-045-0030 rule (5) extends dispute rights and deadlines to alternate payees, but the declared statute ORS 238.450 applies only to members who apply for retirement allowances.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.450","citation":"ORS 238.450(1), (2)","quote":"Upon receiving an application for a retirement allowance or benefit from a member of the Public Employees Retirement System... A member of the system may dispute the accuracy of the information used by the system in making the computation only by filing a written notice of dispute with the system not later than whichever of the following days occurs last: (a) The 240th day after the date on which the computation and information summary is provided to the member","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-045-0030","citation":"OAR 459-045-0030(5)(a)","quote":"An alternate payee may dispute the accuracy of the information used in making the calculation of the retirement allowance or benefit by filing a written notice by the later of: (A) The 30th day after the date on which the calculation and information is provided to the alternate payee; or (B) The 30th day after the issue date of the first actual, not estimated, payment of a retirement allowance or benefit to the alternate payee.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3a4c6162d35b99f6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule extends the deadline for payment beyond the 90-day window stated in the statute when PERS adjusts the purchase cost upward after the initial payment period.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.175","citation":"ORS 238.175(2)","quote":"within 90 days before the effective date of retirement of the member, applies in writing to the Public Employees Retirement Board for that retirement credit and pays to the board in a lump sum an amount determined by the board to represent the full cost to the system","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(3)(a)","quote":"If the purchase cost is adjusted and requires an additional payment, PERS will notify the member of the balance due. To complete the purchase, the balance due must be received by PERS by the later of: (A) The date set by PERS; or (B) The member's effective retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.175","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"13ecfd4272fe7d00","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-009-0020 declares it implements ORS 238.205 but its operative text never actually engages with any substantive provision of that statute; it only addresses the definition of 'public employer' from ORS 238.005.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-459-009-0020","citation":"oar-459-009-0020","quote":"ORS 238.005, ORS 238.205","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.205","citation":"ORS 238.205","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd4b6118f97e43c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule gives PERS discretion to set a deadline for additional payments that could extend beyond the 90-day requirement in the statute.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.162","citation":"ORS 238.162(2)","quote":"if the member within 90 days of the member's effective date of retirement: (a) Applies in writing to the Public Employees Retirement Board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0150","citation":"OAR 459-011-0150(3)(a)","quote":"If the purchase cost is adjusted and requires an additional payment, PERS will notify the member of the balance due. To complete the purchase, the balance due must be received by PERS by the later of: (A) The date set by PERS; or (B) The member's effective retirement date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.162","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5a122432d8de2b4d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-040-0060(3) adds a six-year service requirement not found in the statute for beneficiary payments when a judge member dies before retiring with no surviving spouse.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.565","citation":"ORS 238.565(2)(d)","quote":"If a judge member dies before retiring and has no surviving spouse, the beneficiary or beneficiaries shall receive a lump sum amount equal to the amount credited to the member account of the judge member in the fund on the date of death of the judge member.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-040-0060","citation":"OAR 459-040-0060(3)","quote":"If the judge member has six or more years of service as a judge and the judge member has no surviving spouse, the designated beneficiary or beneficiaries shall receive a lump sum payment equal to the amount credited to the judge member account in the Fund on the first of the month following the date of death.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.565","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"f6b8b792c8c9cad7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"ORS 238.585(3) allows restoration of forfeited rights if a person becomes a judge member within five years, but OAR 459-040-0010(8) makes it impossible for anyone age 72 or older to become a judge member, preventing those individuals from accessing the restoration mechanism.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.585","citation":"ORS 238.585(3)","quote":"A member of the system other than a judge member who separates from all service entitling the person to membership in the system and who withdraws the amount credited to the member account of the member in the fund may restore all rights forfeited by the withdrawal in the manner specified by ORS 238.105 if the person becomes a judge member within five years after the date that the person is separated from all service entitling the person to membership in the system.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-040-0010","citation":"OAR 459-040-0010(8)","quote":"A person age 72 or older who becomes a judge is not eligible to become a judge member.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.585","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2820bb1c37154fb5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The statute requires an eligible retired member to be 'eligible for federal Medicare coverage,' but the implementing rule requires enrollment in Parts A and B of Medicare, which is narrower.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.420","citation":"ORS 238.420(1)(a)","quote":"is eligible for federal Medicare coverage","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-035-0030","citation":"OAR 459-035-0030(1)(a)","quote":"who is enrolled in Parts A and B of Medicare","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-238.420","citation":"ORS 238.420(1)(b)","quote":"who is eligible for federal Medicare coverage","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-035-0030","citation":"OAR 459-035-0030(1)(b)","quote":"who is enrolled in Parts A and B of Medicare","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85cc4a0f987c32e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-015-0020(8)(b) specifies a 180-day deadline where ORS 238.320(5) states 'six months,' which are not numerically equivalent in calendar application.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.320","citation":"ORS 238.320(5)","quote":"within six months after the date of such separation from service if disability occurs after such separation date","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-015-0020","citation":"OAR 459-015-0020(8)(b)","quote":"the member must file an application for a disability retirement allowance within six months (180 days) after the date of separation from service","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a27ab2742f07a3aa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-015-0020(7) imposes a 90-day filing deadline for active members who become disabled but do not terminate employment, a party and situation not explicitly addressed in ORS 238.320.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.320","citation":"ORS 238.320(5)","quote":"An inactive member is not eligible for disability benefits referred to in subsection (1) or (3) of this section unless the member applies for such disability benefits within five calendar years after the date of separation from service with a participating public employer if the disability is continuous from such separation date or within six months after the date of such separation from service if disability occurs after such separation date.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-015-0020","citation":"OAR 459-015-0020(7)(a)","quote":"For a member who becomes totally disabled due to injury or disease but does not terminate employment, an application for disability retirement must be filed no later than 90 calendar days from the earlier of: (A) The date the member is medically released for work; or (B) The date the member returns to work.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ffc8deeda5abf900","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The statute ORS 238.088(3) excludes members who 'retire under the provisions of ORS 238.280(1), (2) or (3)' from the benefit of 238.088(2), but the rule OAR 459-017-0060(4)(g) narrows this exclusion to apply only to those who 'retired at a reduced benefit' under those provisions, thereby including persons the statute appears to exclude.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.088","citation":"ORS 238.088(3)","quote":"Subsection (2) of this section does not apply to any member who retires under the provisions of ORS 238.280 (1), (2) or (3).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-017-0060","citation":"OAR 459-017-0060(4)(g)","quote":"The retired member meets the requirements of ORS 238.088(2), and did not retire at a reduced benefit under the provisions of ORS 238.280(1), (2), or (3)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.088","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5030389d025a4f55","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"Rule 459-011-0500(4) adds a requirement that a member be 'in a covered group on or after the effective date' of an employer's election, but the statute only requires the employer's request to be in effect 'at the time of the member's separation.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.350","citation":"ORS 238.350(1)(c)","quote":"accumulated by an active member of the system while in the service of any public employer participating in the system that has the request described in paragraph (a) of this subsection in effect at the time of the member's separation from the service of the employer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-011-0500","citation":"OAR 459-011-0500(4)","quote":"To be eligible for the use of unused sick leave pursuant to ORS 238.350, a member must have been in the employ of a public employer and in a covered group on or after the effective date of an employer's election to extend the use of accumulated unused sick leave.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e6516a3629c080e2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-005-0250(1)(c) charges a flat $60 fee for retirement benefit estimates beyond 2 per calendar year without requiring the 'extraordinary costs' determination the statute mandates.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.610","citation":"ORS 238.610(1)(a)","quote":"The Public Employees Retirement Board by rule may establish procedures for recovering administrative costs from members for services provided in estimating retirement benefit amounts and processing payments if the board determines that the services requested by an individual member result in extraordinary costs to the system.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0250","citation":"OAR 459-005-0250(1)(c)","quote":"PERS shall charge a fee of $60 for each estimate that exceeds the limit specified in subsection (b) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"46d2e769e500fb6f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"The rule permits adjustments to verified amounts for USERRA compliance, judgments/settlements, and account divisions, which are not listed among the four post-verification adjustments authorized by the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-238.285","citation":"ORS 238.285(3)","quote":"the creditable service, retirement credit, final average salary, member account balances and accumulated unused sick leave used in calculating the member's retirement allowance or pension may not be less than the amounts provided in the verification, subject to adjustments for: (a) Creditable service or retirement credit accrued by the member after the date specified in the verification. (b) Salary attributable to periods of employment after the date specified in the verification. (c) Earnings and losses credited to the member's accounts from the end of the calendar year specified in the verification to the member's effective retirement date, in accordance with rules adopted by the board. (d) Sick leave used and accrued after the date specified in the verification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0040","citation":"459-005-0040(4)(b), (c)","quote":"(b) Amounts in a verification may be adjusted to comply with USERRA. (c) Amounts in a verification may be adjusted to implement a judgment, administrative order, arbitration award, conciliation agreement, or settlement agreement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-238.285","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"768c9ed1ae83c584","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"}]},{"ors_chapter":"240","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":14,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule cites ORS 240.240 as identifying employees and agencies exempt from ORS 240.240, but the statute does not identify exempt groups in that manner; it states unclassified and management service are not subject to the chapter except for leave and salary matters, and subsections (4) and (5) specify which entities establish arrangements for particular groups, not exemptions from the statute.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-105-020-0001","citation":"OAR 105-020-0001(2)","quote":"except those employees and agencies identified in ORS 240.240 as exempt from ORS 240.240","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-240.240","citation":"ORS 240.240(1)","quote":"The unclassified service or, except as provided in ORS 240.250, the management service shall not be subject to this chapter, except that employees and officers in the unclassified or management service shall be subject to the laws, rules and policies pertaining to any type of leave with pay except as otherwise provided in subsections (4) and (5) of this section, and shall be subject to the laws, rules and policies pertaining to salary plans except as otherwise provided in subsections (3) and (5) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e079d9356153dd0a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"The statute requires all hearings to be open to the public as a mandatory rule, but the rule makes this discretionary by allowing the board to close hearings when circumstances warrant.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-240.080","citation":"ORS 240.080","quote":"All hearings shall be open to the public.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-115-010-0020","citation":"OAR 115-010-0020","quote":"Ordinarily, contested case hearings shall be open to the public. When circumstances warrant, the Board may close contested case hearings.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.080","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"bf37d48c0334f3fc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["employment-relations-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 240.321, which addresses collective bargaining, collective bargaining agreements, and grievance procedures, but the rule's operative text establishes drug testing policies for applicants—a subject never addressed in ORS 240.321.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-105-050-0004","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 240.135 & 240.321","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-240.321","citation":"ORS 240.321(1)-(4)","quote":"All collective bargaining between the state and its agencies and any certified or recognized exclusive employee representative of classified employees shall be under the direction and supervision of the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services... Notwithstanding any of the provisions of ORS 240.235, 240.306, 240.316, 240.430 and 240.551, employees of state agencies who are in certified or recognized appropriate bargaining units shall have all aspects of their wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment determined by collective bargaining agreements... The provisions of rules adopted by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, the subjects of which are incorporated into collective bargaining agreements, shall not be applicable to employees within appropriate bargaining units covered by such agreements. The department shall ensure the speedy resolution of employee grievances by adopting a grievance procedure resulting in a final employer determination within 60 days of the filing of a written grievance...","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.321","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f20e4ffdc854721e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"The rule claims to implement ORS 240.245 but does not address the statute's requirement that exempt service positions without fixed salaries must maintain a salary plan equitably applied and in reasonable conformity with the state's salary structure; the rule instead addresses only unclassified and management service employees.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-240.245","citation":"ORS 240.245","quote":"except that, with regard to any position for which salaries are not fixed by law, the officer authorized by law to appoint or fill such position shall maintain a salary plan equitably applied to the exempt position and in reasonable conformity with the general salary structure of the state","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-105-020-0001","citation":"OAR 105-020-0001(2)","quote":"DAS shall use a neutral and objective method to determine the comparability of the value of work performed by State Executive Branch employees in unclassified and management service, except those employees and agencies identified in ORS 240.240 as exempt from ORS 240.240.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0d25e45b1b8059e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"The rule limits appeals only to duration violations of ORS 240.309, but the statute covers multiple substantive requirements including purpose of temporary employment, limitations on use, extensions, restrictions on permanent position assignment, and requirements for investigation of alleged misuse.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-240.309","citation":"ORS 240.309(1)-(11)","quote":"Temporary employment shall be used for the purpose of meeting emergency, nonrecurring or short-term workload needs of the state... A temporary employee may not be employed in a permanent, seasonal, intermittent or limited duration position except to replace an employee during an approved leave period... Employment of a temporary employee for the same workload need, other than for leave, may not exceed six calendar months... A temporary employee shall not be denied permanent work because of the temporary status... The Personnel Division of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall report the use of temporary employees, by agency, once every six months... If any interested party alleges misuse of temporary employees, the division shall investigate, report its findings and take appropriate action.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-115-045-0017","citation":"OAR 115-045-0017(1)","quote":"A complaint filed under ORS 240.307 that alleges a violation of ORS 240.309 (temporary appointment duration) must be in writing and must contain a detailed statement specifying: (a) The action being appealed; (b) The reason complainant believes that the action violates ORS 240.309","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.309","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb71b6e6963617e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["employment-relations-board"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the statute by implementing only the comparability determination aspect of the merit pay system (via the Hay Method), while omitting required consideration of individual performance, organizational accomplishment, living costs, maintenance or benefits, collective bargaining obligations, and the state's financial condition and policies.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-240.235","citation":"ORS 240.235(1)","quote":"The Personnel Division shall establish and implement a merit pay system which shall take into consideration individual performance and organizational accomplishment, prevailing rates of pay for the services performed and for comparable services in public and private employment, living costs, maintenance or other benefits received, obligations established by collective bargaining agreements, and the state's financial condition and policies.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-105-020-0001","citation":"oar-105-020-0001(1)","quote":"The Department of Administrative Services (DAS) shall use the Hay Method of job evaluation as the neutral and objective method to determine the comparability of the value of work performed by employees in the classified services within the State Executive Branch and the compensation and classification structure of the state system.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-240.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2dcd155369fb578","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office"},{"slug":"employment-relations-board","name":"Employment Relations Board"},{"slug":"judicial-department","name":"Judicial Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"244","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":47,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 244.040 lists a rule repealed in 2021 as its current implementer.","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-001-0040","citation":"OAR 199-001-0040, status: current","quote":"History: GEC 15-2021, repeal filed 12/07/2021, effective 12/30/2021 ... (full text is empty)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"094a90e95e97b026","cites_repealed":["oar-199-001-0040"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Three OAR 199-010 rules implementing ORS 244.290's lobbyist-reporting chain were repealed in 2021 but are still marked current and mixed into the statute's implemented_by list with no differentiation.","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-010-0085","citation":"OAR 199-010-0085 (\"Who Must File\"), status: current","quote":"History: GEC 15-2021, repeal filed 12/07/2021, effective 12/30/2021","quote_verified":"absence"},{"id":"oar-199-010-0090","citation":"OAR 199-010-0090 (\"When Must Reports Be Filed\"), status: current","quote":"History: GEC 15-2021, repeal filed 12/07/2021, effective 12/30/2021","quote_verified":"absence"},{"id":"oar-199-010-0100","citation":"OAR 199-010-0100 (\"Filing Deadlines\"), status: current","quote":"History: GEC 15-2021, repeal filed 12/07/2021, effective 12/30/2021","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5a92408178de43b6","cites_repealed":["oar-199-010-0085","oar-199-010-0090","oar-199-010-0100"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule requires calculating assessments for state government bodies based on Full Time Equivalent (FTE) employees, but the statute requires multiplying the rate by the number of public officials, which the statute defines to include both officers and employees.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.255","citation":"ORS 244.255(2)(a)","quote":"To determine the amount of the charge for each public body, the commission shall multiply the rate determined under this paragraph by the number of public officials serving the public body.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.255","citation":"ORS 244.255(6)(c)","quote":"\"Public official,\" notwithstanding ORS 244.020 (15), means any person who, on the date the commission charges the public body under this section, is serving the public body as an officer or employee.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0007","citation":"OAR 199-001-0007(1)(a)","quote":"Public bodies in state government are assessed one-half of the Commission's legislatively approved budget for the biennium, based upon their number of Full Time Equivalent (FTE) employees.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.255","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af952c5c706081be","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 1, section (5) exempts from honoraria valuation rules receptions that qualify as gift exceptions under ORS 244.020(7)(b)(L), but ORS 244.042 does not provide such an exception for honoraria—only exceptions for items of $50 or less and private professional services.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.042","citation":"ORS 244.042(3)","quote":"Except as provided in subsection (4) of this section, this section does not prohibit: (a) The solicitation or receipt of an honorarium or a certificate, plaque, commemorative token or other item with a value of $50 or less; or (b) The solicitation or receipt of an honorarium for services performed in relation to the private profession, occupation, avocation or expertise of the public official or candidate.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-005-0005","citation":"OAR 199-005-0005(5)","quote":"Attendance at receptions that qualify as an exception to the gift definition under ORS 244.020(7)(b)(L) is permitted without regard to the fair market value of the food and beverage provided.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.042","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"858ae2c7dd565fc6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule defines 'ministerial acts' under ORS 244.177 as requiring no financial impact on a relative or household member, but the statute does not impose any such financial impact requirement for acts to qualify as ministerial.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.177","citation":"ORS 244.177(1)(b)","quote":"As used in this paragraph, \"participate\" does not include serving as a reference, providing a recommendation or performing other ministerial acts that are part of the normal job functions of the public official.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-008-0005","citation":"OAR 199-008-0005(8)","quote":"\"Ministerial Acts\" as used in ORS 244.177 means any act that a public official may take in the ordinary course of performing their official duties that has no financial impact on a relative or household member who seeks employment with, is employed by, or who otherwise serves the same public body.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.177","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f6bd2ecf30b5100","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 199-008-0015 is declared to implement ORS 244.390 but does not explicitly require the Commission to consider 'any other penalty or sanction that has been or may be imposed on the public official as a result of the same conduct' before imposing sanctions, as mandated by ORS 244.390(2).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.390","citation":"ORS 244.390(2)","quote":"Before making a finding that there is cause to undertake an investigation under ORS 244.260 and before imposing a civil penalty under ORS 244.350 or 244.360, the commission shall consider the public interest and any other penalty or sanction that has been or may be imposed on the public official as a result of the same conduct that is the subject of action by the commission under ORS 244.260.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"OAR 199-008-0015(2)-(4)","quote":"The Commission will identify alleged violations of statutes or rules within the Commission's jurisdiction during the preliminary review phase or by preliminary finding of violations at the end of an investigative phase. This rule will standardize the method for setting sanctions to be imposed when a matter before the Commission is to be concluded by a stipulated final order, final order or a final order by default. (2) TABLE A lists the factors that the staff and Commission may consider as mitigating or aggravating any violation of Oregon Government Ethics law in ORS Chapter 244... (3) If there are aggravating or mitigating factors that are not listed in TABLE A, the director will prepare a summary of those factors for the Commission to consider. The Commission may exercise its discretion to deviate from the calculated sanctions from TABLE B and modify the civil penalty or the forfeiture.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.390","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d65529aa8860f535","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 244.320 but the operative text never engages with what ORS 244.320 requires—preparation, approval, publication, updating, and electronic availability of an ethics manual—addressing only a carve-out exception in subsection (5).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"ORS 244.290, ORS 244.390, ORS 244.370, ORS 244.350, ORS 244.280, ORS 244.282, ORS 244.320, ORS 244.360","quote":"ORS 244.290, ORS 244.390, ORS 244.370, ORS 244.350, ORS 244.280, ORS 244.282, ORS 244.320, ORS 244.360","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.320","citation":"ORS 244.320","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"51a2a9e542913b58","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule allows voice vote of a quorum for 'all other matters' in section (3)(d)(B), which could permit decisions with fewer than 5 affirmative votes, whereas the statute requires that 'a final decision may not be made without an affirmative vote of a majority of the members appointed to the commission.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.250","citation":"ORS 244.250(5)","quote":"A quorum consists of five members but a final decision may not be made without an affirmative vote of a majority of the members appointed to the commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0010","citation":"OAR 199-001-0010(3)(d)(B)","quote":"Voice vote of a quorum of Commissioners in all other matters","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"011d23058c5914b5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 244.350 but then states it does not apply in cases where the sanction is limited under ORS 244.350, creating a contradiction with its stated authority.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"OAR 199-008-0015(5)","quote":"This rule does not apply in cases where the sanction is limited under ORS 244.280, 244.282, 244.284, 244.320 or 244.350.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.290, ORS 244.390, ORS 244.370, ORS 244.350, ORS 244.280, ORS 244.282, ORS 244.320 & ORS 244.360","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"06228dd34002785a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The statute allows staff to issue advice on 'any actual or hypothetical circumstance,' but the rule restricts formal Advisory Opinions to 'real or hypothetical facts or circumstances but not upon actual events that have already occurred,' narrowing the scope of circumstances on which guidance can be issued.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.284","citation":"ORS 244.284(1)","quote":"Upon the written or oral request of any person, the executive director or other staff of the Oregon Government Ethics Commission may issue written or oral staff advice on the application of ORS 192.610 to 192.705 or any provision of this chapter to any proposed transaction or action or any actual or hypothetical circumstance.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0030","citation":"OAR 199-001-0030(2)","quote":"The Oregon Government Ethics Commission will issue an Advisory Opinion based on real or hypothetical facts or circumstances but not upon actual events that have already occurred.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.284","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d0e92b979f0bfc45","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'authorized by' in section (6) requires a 'significant role' in selection or execution, which narrows the statute's application to contracts 'authorized by...a board...of which the person was a member' by making authorization contingent on particular individuals having significant roles rather than treating board authorization as a status fact.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.047","citation":"ORS 244.047(3)(b)","quote":"A board, commission, council, bureau, committee or other governing body of a public body of which the person was a member when the contract was authorized.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-008-0005","citation":"oar-199-008-0005(6)","quote":"As used in ORS 244.047, a public contract is \"authorized by\" a public official if the public official performed a significant role in the selection of a contractor or the execution of the contract. A significant role can include recommending approval or signing of the contract, including serving on a selection committee or team, or having the final authorizing authority for the contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.047","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"024920e046721fd2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 736-146-0070 declares it implements ORS 244.400 but its operative text contains only general ethics policy language about safeguarding public trust in contracting, with no engagement with the statute's specific subject of attorney fees in contested cases.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-736-146-0070","citation":"Declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 244.010, ORS 244.400, ORS 279A.070, ORS 279A.140, ORS 279A.025(3)(k) & ORS 279A.065(6)(a)","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-244.400","citation":"ORS 244.400","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"68413483e3bd42fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 736-146-0080 declares it implements ORS 244.400 but its operative text addresses only ethics violations, gift prohibitions, and misuse of position or confidential information in contracting—with no engagement with the statute's specific subject of attorney fees in contested cases.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-736-146-0080","citation":"Declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 244.010 - 244.400, ORS 279A.065(5)(a), ORS 279A.070, ORS 279A.140","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.400","citation":"ORS 244.400","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ab74770d2a8034e5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-008-0035 declares it implements ORS 244.290(5)(d), but subsection (5) of the statute contains no subsections—it is a single paragraph about electronic filing. The actual provision governing prosecutorial discretion is ORS 244.290(2)(d).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-008-0035","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.290(5)(d)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.290","citation":"ORS 244.290(2)(d)","quote":"List criteria and establish a process for the commission to use prosecutorial discretion to decide whether to proceed with an inquiry or investigation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.290","citation":"ORS 244.290(5)","quote":"The commission shall adopt by rule an electronic filing system under which statements required to be filed under ORS 244.050 and 244.217 must be filed, without a fee, with the commission in an electronic format.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.290","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"92c7180858c67148","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 244.090, which requires reporting compensated lobbyist associations, but the rule's operative text addresses only administrative notification and registration of filers—never engaging with the substance of what ORS 244.090 requires to be reported.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-020-0005","citation":"oar-199-020-0005, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 244.050, ORS 244.060, ORS 244.070, ORS 244.090","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.090","citation":"ORS 244.090(1)","quote":"Each public official or candidate required to file a statement of economic interest under this chapter shall include on the statement the name of any compensated lobbyist who, during the preceding calendar year, was associated with a business with which the public official or candidate or a member of the household of the public official or candidate was also associated.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.090","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"507c2ea9255d041a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-001-0030 restricts advisory opinions to real or hypothetical future facts, excluding actual events that have already occurred, but the statute explicitly authorizes opinions on 'any actual or hypothetical circumstance.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.280","citation":"ORS 244.280(1)","quote":"any proposed transaction or action or any actual or hypothetical circumstance","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0030","citation":"OAR 199-001-0030(2)","quote":"The Oregon Government Ethics Commission will issue an Advisory Opinion based on real or hypothetical facts or circumstances but not upon actual events that have already occurred.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e52160dc6d5d1fd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-001-0030 extends advisory opinions to ORS 171.725 to 171.785 (lobbying regulation), but ORS 244.280(1) limits advisory opinions to 'the application of ORS 192.610 to 192.705 or any provision of this chapter' (Chapter 244), which does not include Chapter 171.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.280","citation":"ORS 244.280(1)","quote":"the application of ORS 192.610 to 192.705 or any provision of this chapter","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0030","citation":"OAR 199-001-0030(1)","quote":"The Oregon Government Ethics Commission may, upon the written request of any person, or upon its own motion, issue opinions on the requirements of ORS Chapter 244, and ORS 171.725 to 171.785.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4e8bf8aae684f35e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 199-001-0030 contains no provisions implementing the 60-day deadline and extension procedures required by the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.280","citation":"ORS 244.280(2)","quote":"Not later than 60 days after the date the commission receives the written request for a commission advisory opinion, the commission shall issue either the opinion or a written denial of the request... The commission, by vote of a majority of the members of the commission, may extend the 60-day deadline by one period not to exceed 60 days.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0657addd095239ae","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"The rule classifies the executive director's staff advisory opinions (which the statute protects from penalties) as 'informal written opinions' with no precedential effect and to which the Commission is not bound, thereby removing the statutory protection.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.282","citation":"ORS 244.282(3)(a)","quote":"unless the staff advisory opinion is revised or revoked, the commission may only issue a written letter of reprimand, explanation or education for any good faith action a person takes in reliance on a staff advisory opinion issued under this section","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-001-0030","citation":"OAR 199-001-0030(8)","quote":"The informal written opinion of the Director shall have no precedential effect and the Oregon Government Ethics Commission shall not be bound by any informal written opinion of the Director.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.282","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e2c25aa19dcbb49","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-199-020-0005 declares it implements ORS 244.060 (form and contents of economic interest statements), but the operative text addresses only administrative procedures for updating jurisdictional contact information with the Commission and has no provisions about statement form or contents.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-020-0005","citation":"oar-199-020-0005 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.050, ORS 244.060, ORS 244.070, ORS 244.090","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.060","citation":"ORS 244.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5d6f298323c21e3c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-045-0200 declares it implements ORS 244.010 (a public ethics policy statute) but the operative text concerns only real property acquisition, disposition, and inventory procedures with no engagement with public ethics principles.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0200","citation":"OAR 125-045-0200","quote":"ORS 244.010, ORS 270.010","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.010","citation":"ORS 244.010(1)-(8)","quote":"The Legislative Assembly declares that service as a public official is a public trust and that, as one safeguard for that trust, the people require all public officials to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter... The Legislative Assembly recognizes that public officials should put loyalty to the highest ethical standards above loyalty to government, persons, political party or private enterprise.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7558d84534c35268","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-045-0205 declares it implements ORS 244.010 (public ethics policy) but the operative text contains only real property definitions with no connection to public ethics or trust principles.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205","quote":"ORS 244.010, ORS 270.005, ORS 270.010, ORS 270.100-270.135, ORS 271.330, ORS 271.335","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.010","citation":"ORS 244.010(1)","quote":"The Legislative Assembly declares that service as a public official is a public trust and that, as one safeguard for that trust, the people require all public officials to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4077258b3922f73b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule makes mandatory notification conditional on the public official requesting notice, whereas the statute mandates notification within 10 days regardless of request.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-244.100","citation":"ORS 244.100(1) and (2)","quote":"shall notify the public official in writing of the amount of the expense... The organization, unit, tribe or corporation shall provide the notice to the public official within 10 days after the date the expenses are incurred... shall notify the public official or candidate in writing of the value of the honorarium or other item. The person shall provide the notice to the public official or candidate within 10 days after the date of the event","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-005-0005","citation":"OAR 199-005-0005(4)","quote":"Upon request by the public official, the source shall give notice of the value of the merchandise, goods, or services received.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.100","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"58f8438fa2b7b4ee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 2 declares it implements ORS 750 but the operative text never mentions or engages with ORS 750—it only implements ORS 244.045(5)(a) by designating positions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-257-055-0001","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 750, OL 1997 (ORS 244.045)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.045","citation":"ORS 244.045(5)(a)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.045","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"235f09fa820046ec","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-812-001-0030 declares it implements ORS 244.040 but its operative text only states that the Construction Contractors Board adopts an external ethics policy, without containing any substantive provisions that engage with ORS 244.040.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-001-0030","citation":"oar-812-001-0030","quote":"ORS 244.040","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.040","citation":"ORS 244.040","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.040","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0e78bb173aca608","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 244.360, which requires a civil penalty equal to twice the amount of financial benefit from a violation, but the rule's operative text never addresses this specific calculation requirement and instead applies a general percentage-of-maximum-civil-penalty framework.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"OAR 199-008-0015(1), declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.290, ORS 244.390, ORS 244.370, ORS 244.350, ORS 244.280, ORS 244.282, ORS 244.320, ORS 244.360","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-199-008-0015","citation":"OAR 199-008-0015(2)(b)(A)","quote":"If the point total indicates a civil penalty, TABLE B will be used to determine the percentage of the maximum civil penalty that may be imposed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-244.360","citation":"ORS 244.360","quote":"the Oregon Government Ethics Commission may impose upon the public official a civil penalty in an amount equal to twice the amount the public official or other person realized as a result of the violation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-244.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a87dd46ba190aa4d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-government-ethics-commission"]}],"artifacts":["oar-199-005-0010(1) body text: \"ORS 244.020( 7 [6] )(b)(C)\" — stray bracketed fragment.","oar-199-005-0025 statutes_implemented: \"ORS 244.0020\" (extra zero).","Multiple 199-008 rules carry pre-2021-renumbering source_urls that don't match their current citation/id."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"oregon-government-ethics-commission","name":"Oregon Government Ethics Commission"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"255","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":12,"candidates":[{"summary":"Two district-elections rules hardcode a vacancy-notification trigger of the '101st day' before a regular election, though the statute cross-references a 105th-day deadline.","documents":[{"id":"ors-255.069","citation":"ORS 255.069(2)","quote":"Not later than the 105th day before a regular district election ... the district elections authority shall return to the elections officer the form for updating information on members of district boards.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-165-020-0021","citation":"OAR 165-020-0021(2)","quote":"If the vacancy occurs after the 101st day before the regular district election and on or before the 62nd day before the regular district election...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Same '101st day' figure repeated identically in oar-165-020-0035.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"03417dcbf94d3273","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-elections-division"]},{"summary":"A Secretary of State rule is silent on the website/mail notice alternative ORS 255.075(2) added in 2021, describing only newspaper publication.","documents":[{"id":"ors-255.075","citation":"ORS 255.075(2)(a), 2021 amendment","quote":"the elections officer may give notice by: (A) Publishing the notice on the county's website for a minimum of seven days; or (B) Mailing the notice to each elector of the district.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-165-020-0020","citation":"OAR 165-020-0020, effective 2009","quote":"(describes only newspaper-publication pathway; no mention of website or mail alternative)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"May not be a hard conflict since ORS 255.075(2) is arguably self-executing without rule implementation.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4a5fc0a737e39ea7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-elections-division"]},{"summary":"A signature-verification rule omits the statutory 4,500-signature threshold that gates when statistical sampling applies at all.","documents":[{"id":"ors-255.175","citation":"ORS 255.175(3)","quote":"For any petition requiring a number of signatures exceeding 4,500, the Secretary of State by rule shall designate a statistical sampling technique...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-165-014-0110","citation":"OAR 165-014-0110(4)","quote":"A random sample for any petition submittal, will only be selected if the Filing Officer determines the petition signature sheets accepted ... contain a number of unverified signatures equal to or greater than the required number...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"548c2e26f4318c67","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-elections-division"]}],"artifacts":["oar-581-024-0252 statutes_implemented cites \"ORS 335.690\" where legal_authority (and the rule's own body text) correctly says \"ORS 334.690\" — appears to be an error in the source OARD text itself."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"270","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":47,"candidates":[{"summary":"ODOT's public-notice rule requires less publication than the statute demands for the same value band, while DAS's rule implementing the same statute matches the statute exactly.","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.130","citation":"ORS 270.130","quote":"the state agency ... shall give the notice of the proposed sale not less than once a week for three successive weeks by publication in one or more newspapers...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0235","citation":"OAR 125-045-0235(3)","quote":"must publish notice ... not less than once a week for three successive weeks.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-734-035-0090","citation":"OAR 734-035-0090(3)(a)","quote":"For properties valued between $5,001 and $25,000 — Twice during the two-week period preceding the sale...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"For the $5,001-$25,000 band, ODOT's schedule is fewer/shorter publications than the statute's flat standard. ORS 270.130 contains no visible ODOT carve-out. Confirmed independently by both batch 1 and the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23) — high-confidence finding.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"9201b8500806cf75","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services","department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"[batch 1 only] A DAS rule defines two statutory cross-reference terms differently than the statute's own definitions section, while a third parallel term in the same rule matches exactly.","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.005","citation":"ORS 270.005(6)-(7)","quote":"'Urban growth boundary' has the meaning given that term in ORS 197.015 ... 'Urban reserve' means any land designated as an urban reserve under ORS 197A.245.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205(45)-(46)","quote":"'Urban growth boundary' has the meaning given that term in ORS 195.060 ... 'Urban reserve' means any land designated as an Urban reserve under ORS 195.145.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The third parallel term ('urban unincorporated community') is defined identically in both, citing ORS 197.015 — which makes these two divergences stand out. Whether ORS 195.060/195.145 carry equivalent definitions to 197.015/197A.245 is outside this corpus. Not re-surfaced by the batch-2 re-check.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"151f096ee065c4e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"[batch 1 only] A 1990 ODOT rule, unamended since, uses a one-year figure that doesn't map cleanly onto the statute's 2017-amended 18-month/12-month figures.","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.140","citation":"ORS 270.140 (amended 2017 c.205 §1)","quote":"18-month window before re-offering after notice; 12-month discontinuance trigger before the notice process must be repeated.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-734-035-0130","citation":"OAR 734-035-0130","quote":"At any time during a period of one year after the auction date from which no satisfactory bid was received, the Department may sell the property at a private negotiated sale.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Rule predates the 2017 statutory amendment by 27 years with no visible update. Flagged as a staleness candidate — the concept mapping between rule and statute isn't precise enough to call this a direct numeric contradiction. Not re-surfaced by the batch-2 re-check.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b788953b8ecbf7de","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0265(1) permits a \"hosting Agency\" to maintain the state land inventory in addition to or instead of DAS, while the statute requires only DAS to maintain it.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.180","citation":"ORS 270.180(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall maintain and keep current an inventory of all state-owned real property","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0265","citation":"125-045-0265(1)","quote":"The Division or hosting Agency, will keep current a State Land Inventory System of all State Real Property Interests","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.180","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c1c1e9664cc9860c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-045-0230(2) makes granting right of first refusal discretionary while ORS 270.010(2) establishes it as mandatory state policy.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.010","citation":"ORS 270.010(2)","quote":"the state policy shall be to give right of first refusal to purchase in the following order: (a) To the lessee of the land. (b) Where the intended activity or use is similar to that of adjacent properties within the region: (A) To adjacent landowners. (B) To residents within the region. (C) To persons outside the region.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0230","citation":"OAR 125-045-0230(2)","quote":"If no contractual Right of First Refusal exists, the Disposing Agency may, in its discretion, grant a Right of First Refusal to the parties described in ORS 270.010(2) via written agreement with the party or parties.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fd16cc1689ccae58","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0221(4)(f) and 125-045-0222(2) establish that Political Subdivisions' rights to negotiate for acquisition are subordinate to Nonprofit Organizations and Indian Tribes, but ORS 270.100(1)(b)(A) gives both groups equal 'first opportunity after other state agencies' status without establishing such a hierarchy.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0221","citation":"125-045-0221(4)(f)","quote":"If a disposition, notice that a Nonprofit Organization's or Indian Tribe's right to negotiate for Acquisition of the State Real Property Interest is subordinate to the right of Agencies to negotiate for Acquisition of the State Real Property Interest, and a Political Subdivision's right to negotiate for Acquisition of the State Real Property Interest is subordinate to the right of Nonprofit Organizations and Indian Tribes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0222","citation":"125-045-0222(2)","quote":"If no Agencies respond to a disposition notice, or if the Transacting Agency is not able to reach agreement with any Agency, the following entities may negotiate with the Transacting Agency in the following order: (a) Nonprofit Organizations and Indian Tribes in the order in which they were received; and (b) Political Subdivisions in the order in which they were received.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-270.100","citation":"ORS 270.100(1)(b)(A)","quote":"The department shall give the first opportunity after other state agencies to acquire, purchase, exchange or lease real property or an interest in real property that the State of Oregon disposes of or sells to: (i) The following entities, on the condition that the entities will develop housing on the real property that will be occupied by families and individuals with an income no greater than 80 percent of the median family income for the county in which the real property is located: (I) Nonprofit organizations; and (II) Indian tribes, as defined in ORS 97.740; and (ii) Political subdivisions, as defined in ORS 271.005.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.100","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4fdaea143b4da13f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-035-0060 omits the five-year timing requirement from ORS 270.110(1)(b)(C) when defining when property is surplus.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.110","citation":"ORS 270.110(1)(b)(C)","quote":"Is not needed for public use within five years of the last date the property was used for public purposes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-035-0060","citation":"OAR 734-035-0060","quote":"The following criteria may be used to determine real property is surplus: The property is no longer needed by the agency for public purposes.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ac4a5e2a036a069","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the statute's mandatory 'shall be made' language for reimbursement, replacing it with softer language 'are subject to,' which does not create an affirmative obligation to reimburse.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.155","citation":"ORS 270.155","quote":"Reimbursement of department costs shall be made subject to terms of the agreement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0265","citation":"125-045-0265(7)","quote":"Reimbursement of Department costs are subject to terms of the agreement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.155","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d35aad5b72255ada","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0205(45) defines 'Urban growth boundary' by reference to ORS 195.060, but the statute requires reference to ORS 197.015.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.005","citation":"ORS 270.005(6)","quote":"\"Urban growth boundary\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 197.015.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205(45)","quote":"\"Urban growth boundary\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 195.060.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1bf8dffd56792354","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-045-0205(46) defines 'Urban reserve' by reference to ORS 195.145, but the statute requires reference to ORS 197A.245.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.005","citation":"ORS 270.005(7)","quote":"\"Urban reserve\" means any land designated as an urban reserve under ORS 197A.245.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205(46)","quote":"\"Urban reserve\" means any land designated as an Urban reserve under ORS 195.145.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5f1ab05d29702586","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-045-0250 declares it implements ORS 270.190, but the rule text addresses only the Public Lands Advisory Committee structure, meetings, and member compensation—not the revenue transfer from the Operating Fund to the Capital Projects Fund that ORS 270.190 requires.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0250","citation":"ORS 270.190","quote":"ORS 171.072, ORS 270.005-270.015, ORS 270.100, ORS 270.120, ORS 270.190, ORS 292.495","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-270.190","citation":"ORS 270.190","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e3337dd1dcf6051c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-067-0130 and multiple subsequent land transaction rules (141-067-0150, 141-067-0155, et al.) declare they implement ORS 270.190, but their operative text addresses only procedures for sale, exchange, and purchase of state lands—not the biennium-end transfer of rental/lease revenue from the Operating Fund to the Capital Projects Fund that ORS 270.190 requires.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-067-0130","citation":"ORS 270.190","quote":"ORS 270.005 - 270.190, ORS 273.045, ORS 273.245 - 273.247, ORS 273.251 - 273.311, ORS 273.316 - 273.321, ORS 273.413 - 273.456, ORS 274.040, ORS 274.905 - 274.940, ORS 274.960 - 274.985","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-270.190","citation":"ORS 270.190","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ce2d783f1a392eb4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule 0214(7) triggers public notice obligation at \"$100,000 or more\" but statute requires it only if value is \"greater than $100,000\".","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.105","citation":"ORS 270.105(2)","quote":"If the value of the real property is greater than $100,000, invite public comment on and consider all the values of the property to the people of this state","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0214","citation":"OAR 125-045-0214(7)","quote":"If the Real Property Interest is valued at $100,000 or more, the Transacting Agency must provide public notice of the transaction and invite public comment on these values","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2e5556fdd52b677a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 0214(7) exempts compliance with the statutory requirement to consider values and invite public comment based on exemptions listed in 0211, but those exemptions in 0211(2) apply only to obtaining Department approval, a separate requirement.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0214","citation":"OAR 125-045-0214(7)","quote":"Transacting Agencies, unless exempted in 125-045-0211, must consider all values of the State Real Property Interest, including value of fish and wildlife habitat, mineral rights, wetlands, timber, Improvements, hazardous materials, Property Restriction(s), water rights and public access to other real property. If the Real Property Interest is valued at $100,000 or more, the Transacting Agency must provide public notice of the transaction and invite public comment on these values","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0211","citation":"OAR 125-045-0211(2)","quote":"Exempt Disposing Agencies are not required to obtain Department approval for certain Terminal Dispositions unless the selling price is below the Appraised Fair Market Value.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3d24f11c2c3ebe2a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 734-035-0120 omits the statute's explicit prohibition on court review, dropping the condition that the decision 'shall not be subject to review by any court'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.135","citation":"ORS 270.135","quote":"shall be final and conclusive, and shall not be subject to review by any court","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-035-0120","citation":"OAR 734-035-0120(1)","quote":"The decision of the Department on the question of the most advantageous bid shall be final and conclusive.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.135","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b4b748c66071f5b3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 0211 declares it implements ORS 273.099, but ORS 270.015(2) only authorizes rules for ORS 184.634, 270.005 to 270.015, 270.100 to 270.190, 273.416, 273.426 to 273.436 and 273.551 — ORS 273.099 is not included in that list.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0211","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 184.634, ORS 270.015, ORS 270.100, ORS 270.105, ORS 270.110, ORS 273.099","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-273.099","citation":"ORS 273.099","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"473d070a292b99b7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-035-0130 limits the timeline for private negotiated sale to one year from auction date, while ORS 270.140(1) permits such sales no later than 18 months after completing notice.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.140","citation":"ORS 270.140(1)","quote":"beginning at any time no later than 18 months after completing the process of giving notice under ORS 270.130, offer for sale the real property or equitable interest in any manner that the state agency considers appropriate","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-035-0130","citation":"OAR 734-035-0130(1)","quote":"At any time during a period of one year after the auction date from which no satisfactory bid was received, the Department may sell the property at a private negotiated sale.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4357356a45733f86","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-045-0260(3) gives the PLAC mandatory approval authority over appraisals and fair market value determinations, but ORS 270.120(6) limits the committee to an advisory role on property transactions.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-270.120","citation":"ORS 270.120(6)(a)","quote":"The advisory committee shall advise the department on the acquisition, exchange or disposal of real property valued at $100,000 or more.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0260","citation":"OAR 125-045-0260(3)(a)","quote":"The PLAC: (a) Must approve of the form and substance of any written Appraisal and final determination of Appraised Fair Market Value by the appraiser","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-270.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"31d05a21e431a6e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"note":"The publication-notice finding (first candidate) is corroborated across both batches. The other two batch-1 findings were not re-surfaced by the batch-2 (Haiku) re-check on 2026-07-23 — treat those two as lower-confidence pending a third look.","artifacts":["OAR 141-067-0215 statutes_implemented contains \"ORS 273.413 - RS 273.456\" — missing the \"O\" in \"ORS\".","OAR 141-067-0310 mixes an OAR self-reference into a statute-citation field, with a typo (\"141-167\" for \"141-067\")."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"271","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":8,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DAS rule redefines 'Governing Body' as a closed list of state-agency boards/commissions, incompatible with the statute's political-subdivision-legislative-body definition used by the same rule's own cited statute (ORS 271.335).","documents":[{"id":"ors-271.005","citation":"ORS 271.005(1)","quote":"'Governing body' means the board or body in which the general legislative power of a political subdivision is vested.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205(19)","quote":"'Governing Body' means a board or commission with constitutional or statutory governing authority ... includes but is not limited to: (a) The Oregon Board of Forestry; ... (f) The State Land Board.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"89c2297a99458719","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The same rule's restated 'Political Subdivision' definition adds a comma that splits 'dock commission' into two separate qualifying entity types ('dock' and 'commission').","documents":[{"id":"ors-271.005","citation":"ORS 271.005(3)","quote":"...including, but not limited to, a county, city, town, port, dock commission or district...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205(29)","quote":"...including but not limited to, a county, city, town, port, dock, commission or district...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b4af2b1033035c9a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The definitions rule declares it implements ORS 271.335 but contains no operative text that addresses the statutory requirements for waiving and relinquishing reversionary interests, the 20-year threshold, or the public interest determination.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"OAR 125-045-0205 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.010, ORS 270.005, ORS 270.010, ORS 270.100-270.135, ORS 271.330, ORS 271.335","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-271.335","citation":"ORS 271.335","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-271.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a26a4dfe16fc287e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 271.330 (a statute about political subdivisions relinquishing property) but the operative text is purely a definitions rule for state agency property management that never engages with the substantive provisions of ORS 271.330.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-045-0205","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 244.010, ORS 270.005, ORS 270.010, ORS 270.100-270.135, ORS 271.330, ORS 271.335","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-271.330","citation":"ORS 271.330","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-271.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bfceb6e268a3167a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"artifacts":["ors-271.005 title truncated (missing \"271.540\").","oar-741-040-0040 statutes_implemented is a bare \"ORS 271\" rather than the specific \"ORS 271.310\" used by all sibling rules."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-rail-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Rail Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"273","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":589,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule's definition of Asset Management Plan omits the statutory requirement that the plan provide a schedule for disposition of state lands.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-067-0150","citation":"OAR 141-067-0150(5)","quote":"\"Asset Management Plan\" or \"AMP\" is the plan adopted by the State Land Board that provides the policy direction and management principles to guide both the short and long term management by the Department of State Lands of its real estate assets.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-273.245","citation":"ORS 273.245","quote":"The asset management plan required by this section shall provide a schedule for disposition of state lands when the proper disposition, as determined, involves the sale, exchange or transfer of management responsibility from the Department of State Lands to other entities.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"32cbf4e5741812ae","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the program to include a recognition element to acknowledge participant efforts, but the implementing rules contain no provision implementing this requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.196","citation":"ORS 273.196(1)(c)","quote":"Include a recognition element to acknowledge the efforts of participants in the program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-130-0010","citation":"OAR 141-130-0010","quote":"The purpose of OAR chapter 141, division 130 is to establish procedures for volunteer associations to enter into agreements with the Department of State Lands to provide volunteer services. These services may include assistance with program implementation, maintenance or improvement of state lands administered by the department, and interpretative and educational programs.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-130-0030","citation":"OAR 141-130-0030","quote":"No provision addressing recognition elements for participants.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.196","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a23297bf9c4eeb6f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule 274-021-0015(1) explicitly adds sand and gravel to the definition of 'mineral,' but ORS 273.775 does not list or plainly include sand and gravel in its enumeration of what constitutes a mineral.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.775","citation":"ORS 273.775(1)","quote":"\"Mineral\" includes oil, gas, sulfur, coal, gold, silver, copper, lead, cinnabar, iron, manganese and other metallic ore, and any other solid, liquid or gaseous material or substance excavated or otherwise developed for commercial, industrial or construction use from natural deposits situated within or upon state lands, including mineral waters of all kinds.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-274-021-0015","citation":"OAR 274-021-0015(1)","quote":"As used in this rule \"mineral\" means oil, gas, sulfur, coal, gold, silver, copper, lead, cinnabar, iron, manganese and other metallic ore, and any other solid, liquid or gaseous material or substance excavated or otherwise developed for commercial, industrial or construction use from natural deposits, including mineral waters of all kinds. (This is the same definition as used in ORS 273.775.) As used in this rule \"mineral\" includes sand and gravel.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.775","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"caeb73de195814c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-veterans-affairs"]},{"summary":"The statute requires a hearing be held 'not earlier than the 30th day after the mailing of the notice,' but the rule requires the hearing be held 'at least 45 calendar days...after the written protest has been received by the Department,' changing both the minimum number of days (from 30 to 45) and the trigger event (from notice mailing to protest receipt).","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.321","citation":"ORS 273.321(2)","quote":"The hearing shall be held not earlier than the 30th day after the mailing of the notice described in subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0180","citation":"OAR 141-067-0180(7)","quote":"The hearing will be held at least 45 calendar days, but not more than 90 calendar days, after the written protest has been received by the Department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.321","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bfeacdf6d8134f2a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"The statute allows exchanges \"on the basis of value or acreage,\" but the implementing rule requires exchanges to be made \"on the basis of value\" only, eliminating acreage as a permissible basis for exchange.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.316","citation":"ORS 273.316(1)","quote":"The exchange may be made on the basis of value or acreage, and the department may pay or accept money as part of the consideration to the extent required for a fair transaction.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0170","citation":"OAR 141-067-0170(1)","quote":"Exchanges shall be made on the basis of value.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.316","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"16e4eccca6656b39","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule definition section (9) states Common School Grazing Lands are \"Trust Lands and Non-Trust Lands,\" but section (31) concludes \"Common School Grazing Lands are Trust Lands\" only.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-110-0005","citation":"OAR 141-110-0005(9) and (31)","quote":"(9) 'Common School Grazing Lands' as defined in ORS 273.805, are Trust Lands and Non-Trust Lands owned by the State of Oregon under the control of the Department of State Lands... (31) 'Trust Land' is state land granted to the state upon its admission into the Union... Common School Grazing Lands are Trust Lands.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.805","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"865dd8a5488d221b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule 141-073-0110(1)(b) states proceeds accrue to the Common School Fund 'Except as provided in ORS 273.785' but the statute states this exception applies to both 'ORS 273.785 and 273.787'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.780","citation":"ORS 273.780(1)","quote":"Except as provided in ORS 273.785 and 273.787, proceeds therefrom shall accrue to the Common School Fund","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-073-0110","citation":"OAR 141-073-0110(1)(b)(A)","quote":"Except as provided in ORS 273.785: (A) Proceeds from the mineral rights held by the state shall accrue to the Common School Fund","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.780","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a66abc39d4558b61","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-067-0130(4)(a) states the rules do not apply to the sale of submerged or submersible lands fronting the Pacific Ocean, but OAR 141-067-0215 provides procedures for sale of submerged and submersible lands without excluding Pacific Ocean fronting lands.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-067-0130","citation":"OAR 141-067-0130(4)(a)","quote":"Do not apply to: (a) The sale of submerged, submersible fronting upon the Pacific Ocean","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0215","citation":"OAR 141-067-0215","quote":"141-067-0215 Sale of Submerged and Submersible Lands","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.251","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ae5338305e347eb3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"The rules declare they implement ORS 273.456, which requires procedures for leasing space above or below streets and highways, but the operative text explicitly excludes leasing from the rules' scope.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-067-0130","citation":"OAR 141-067-0130(2)","quote":"Do not pertain to the leasing of lands or the granting of easements across lands managed by the State Land Board and the Department of State Lands, which are governed by other Department administrative rules.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0130","citation":"OAR 141-067-0130 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 270.005 - 270.190, ORS 273.045, ORS 273.245 - 273.247, ORS 273.251 - 273.311, ORS 273.316 - 273.321, ORS 273.413 - 273.456, ORS 274.040, ORS 274.905 - 274.940, ORS 274.960 - 274.985","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.456","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c53c9014cf86ccdc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule substitutes 'State Board of Higher Education' for the statute's specific reference to 'public universities listed in ORS 352.002' as a recipient of recommendations.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.573","citation":"ORS 273.573(2)(c)","quote":"Providing recommendations to the State Parks and Recreation Commission, State Land Board, State Board of Forestry, State Fish and Wildlife Commission, public universities listed in ORS 352.002 and Oregon Transportation Commission regarding areas under their respective jurisdictions that are appropriate for dedication","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-045-0100","citation":"OAR 736-045-0100(6)(c)","quote":"Providing recommendations to the commission, State Land Board, State Board of Forestry, State Fish and Wildlife Commission, State Board of Higher Education and Oregon Transportation Commission regarding areas under their respective jurisdictions which are appropriate for dedication","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.573","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a4cf5c438b3e5823","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-736-045-0405(1)(d) requires the commission to provide opportunity for adequate public notice and hearing before terminating a private dedication, but ORS 273.586(4)(b) does not require this for private terminations.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.586","citation":"ORS 273.586(4)(b)","quote":"The dedication of a state natural area by a private individual or organization may be terminated by the private individual or organization after the department is assured that there has been compliance with the procedures required by the terms of the dedication instrument.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-045-0405","citation":"oar-736-045-0405(1)(d)","quote":"Termination of dedication may occur upon written notification to the commission, including specific reasons for termination, and provision by the commission of opportunity for adequate public notice and hearing.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.586","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"63f95d1b04cd6312","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-736-045-0405(7)(b)(A) narrows 'imperative and unavoidable necessity' by listing three specific scenarios (natural disaster, declared war, extreme economic crisis), whereas ORS 273.586(4)(a) does not limit the term to those scenarios.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.586","citation":"ORS 273.586(4)(a)","quote":"The dedication of a state natural area by a public agency may be terminated following the providing of opportunity for adequate public notice and hearing and a finding by that agency of an imperative and unavoidable necessity","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-045-0405","citation":"oar-736-045-0405(7)(b)(A)","quote":"An imperative and unavoidable necessity due to natural disaster in the site, need of the natural resource during time of declared war, or the need of the natural resource because of extreme economic crisis of the state","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.586","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"19c773b8a9d5de37","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 273.775, but ORS 273.785(5) explicitly exempts the rule's subject matter—mineral and geothermal resource rights that the Department of Veterans' Affairs acquires—from the application of ORS 273.775 to 273.790.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.785","citation":"ORS 273.785(5)","quote":"Mineral or geothermal resource rights or the proceeds from mineral or geothermal resource rights that the Department of Veterans' Affairs acquires for the state after January 1, 1974, under ORS 88.720, 406.050 (2), 407.135 or 407.145","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-274-021-0015","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 88.720, ORS 273.775, ORS 273.785, ORS 407.135, ORS 407.145","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.785","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8158d736bbefb984","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-veterans-affairs"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-067-0230 provides general procedures for rangeland sales but omits the statutory requirement that the procedure be specifically tailored to 'isolated parcels' as defined in ORS 273.247(2) and that the procedure be 'efficient and cost-effective' as required in ORS 273.247(3).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.247","citation":"ORS 273.247(2) and (3)","quote":"'isolated parcel' means: (a) Land largely surrounded by land not owned by the board or not contiguous to other larger tracts of state land; or (b) Land determined by the board to be difficult or uneconomical to manage due to access, location, isolation, low production value or similar factors... the department or other agency acting on behalf of the board shall establish a sale procedure for isolated parcels of rangeland that is efficient and cost-effective.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0230","citation":"OAR 141-067-0230","quote":"Sale Procedures for Rangelands/Common School Grazing Lands... (1) After rangeland is determined to be 'available for sale' as described in OAR 141-067-0220, if a forage lessee of the land has not already done so, the forage lessee may apply, on a form prescribed by the Department, to purchase the lands.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.247","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1d27f15e5d22259a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"The statute grants the Commission discretion to adopt rules about fees, but the rules make adoption of a fee schedule mandatory every even-numbered year.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.554","citation":"ORS 273.554(2)","quote":"the commission may adopt rules necessary to: (a) Carry out the commission's responsibilities pursuant to ORS 273.553; and (b) Implement a system of fees to recover the costs of carrying out the management established in ORS 273.553, including fees for use of facilities at the reserve management area, fees for research activities conducted at the reserve management area, visitor activities fees and parking fees.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-142-015-0040","citation":"OAR 142-015-0040(2)","quote":"At the first regular Commission meeting of each even-numbered year, the Commission shall review the report and adopt a new fee schedule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.554","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f54260612fa6154b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands-south-slough-national-estuarine-research-reserve"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-005-0040 declares it implements ORS 273.035, but ORS 273.035 does not mention or authorize executive sessions, which are the rule's operative subject matter. The substantive requirement depends on ORS 192.660 instead.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-005-0040","citation":"OAR 141-005-0040","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 273.035","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-273.035","citation":"ORS 273.035","quote":"The Governor shall act as chairperson of the State Land Board. The board shall establish rules under ORS 183.325 to 183.410 for holding regular meetings and the means whereby timely notification of regular meetings may be given.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.035","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2cbf426b3dfa7341","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Statute grants 25-foot width on each side for water ditches; rules allow 15-foot minimum width for all easements without explicitly preserving the statute's specific 25-foot requirement for water ditches.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.761","citation":"ORS 273.761(1) and (2)","quote":"A right of way for construction of a water ditch to be used for irrigation, manufacturing or mining purposes, ditches or water pipes for conveying water to political subdivisions for domestic purposes, or for the extinguishment of fires, is granted for a distance of 25 feet on each side of such ditches or water pipes...A right of way for the construction and maintenance of domestic and industrial water supply mains, sanitary pressure mains and storm water outfalls is granted for a distance of 25 feet on each side of such mains and outfalls","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-122-0070","citation":"OAR 141-122-0070(1)","quote":"Unless otherwise authorized by the Director, the minimum width of an easement shall be no less than 15 feet.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-123-0070","citation":"OAR 141-123-0070(1)","quote":"Unless otherwise authorized by the Director, the minimum width of an easement shall be no less than 15 feet.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.761","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3f24cb21ed4449b6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"ORS 273.825 establishes a procedure for purchasing common school grazing lands by lessees and others, requiring rules to prescribe application procedures and payment terms, but these rules declare implementation of that statute while addressing only grazing leases, trailing permits, and related leasehold management—never engaging with purchase at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-110-0000","citation":"OAR 141-110-0000","quote":"ORS 273.805, ORS 273.815, ORS 273.825","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-273.825","citation":"ORS 273.825(2)","quote":"Application to purchase common school grazing land under subsection (1) of this section must be made in a manner prescribed by the rules of the department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.825","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4993ab9a601223cd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"The statute requires lease renewals to be for an additional term of 20 years, but the rule limits renewals to up to 10 calendar years.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.815","citation":"ORS 273.815(2)(a)","quote":"at the end of the initial term the lease shall be renewed by the department for an additional term of 20 years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-110-0085","citation":"OAR 141-110-0085(3)","quote":"Upon receipt of a completed lease renewal application form, the lease will be renewed for a term of up to 10 calendar years unless:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.815","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b59f78a0b08ac02a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-050-0500(18) redefines who determines special species: the rule says \"the Council\" but the statute says \"the State Parks and Recreation Department\"","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.563","citation":"ORS 273.563(12)","quote":"\"Special species\" means those species of plants and animals determined by the State Parks and Recreation Department to be significant in value in a state natural area and defined in the Oregon Natural Areas Plan.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-050-0500","citation":"OAR 141-050-0500(18)","quote":"\"Special Species\" means those species of plants and animals determined by the Council to be of significant value in a Natural Heritage Conservation Area and defined in the Plan.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6a73fbd314fdf1ee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-050-0500(14) redefines natural heritage resources to include \"plant community types\" where the statute specifies \"terrestrial ecosystem types\"","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.563","citation":"ORS 273.563(8)","quote":"\"Natural heritage resources\" means the terrestrial ecosystem types, aquatic ecosystem types and unique geologic types as defined in the Oregon Natural Areas Plan or a unit of land or water that contains a natural resource.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-050-0500","citation":"OAR 141-050-0500(14)","quote":"\"Natural Heritage Resources\" means the plant community types, aquatic types (or terrestrial ecosystems and aquatic ecosystems) and unique geologic types as defined in the Oregon Natural Heritage Plan; means a unit of land or water which contains a natural resource(s).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d96542e16f273648","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-050-0500(15) cites ORS 273.576 for the Plan, but ORS 273.563(9) cites ORS 273.578","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.563","citation":"ORS 273.563(9)","quote":"\"Plan\" means the Oregon Natural Areas Plan established under ORS 273.578, which governs the Natural Areas Program in selecting natural areas for conservation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-050-0500","citation":"OAR 141-050-0500(15)","quote":"\"Plan\" means the Natural Heritage Plan as established in ORS 273.576, which governs the Natural Heritage Program in the selection of areas for natural heritage conservation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3e2019a7aab4e808","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-050-0500 omits the definition of \"Commodity\" that appears in ORS 273.563(3)","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.563","citation":"ORS 273.563(3)","quote":"\"Commodity\" means timber, minerals, livestock, agricultural products or any other product of the land which is an important economic resource.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8f259f10614fe95f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"OAR 141-050-0500(5) adds a qualifier \"natural heritage\" to the definition of dedication not present in the statute","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.563","citation":"ORS 273.563(5)","quote":"\"Dedicate\" means the formal recognition and protection of a natural area for conservation purposes.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-050-0500","citation":"OAR 141-050-0500(5)","quote":"\"Dedicated\" means the formal recognition and protection of a natural area for natural heritage conservation purposes.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"09ed548debc760c6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-070-0050 and related oil and gas leasing rules authorize detailed leasing procedures (auctions, negotiated leases, minimum acreage, rental terms, etc.) that ORS 273.790 does not mention or address—the statute only requires establishing and maintaining a registry of rights.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.790","citation":"ORS 273.790","quote":"The Department of State Lands shall establish and maintain a registry of mineral and geothermal resource rights placed under the jurisdiction of the State Land Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-070-0050","citation":"OAR 141-070-0050","quote":"The Division of State Lands may conduct an auction of oil and gas rights upon receipt of applications nominating state-owned lands...State-owned oil and gas rights may be leased by oral bid auction or sealed bid auction, at the discretion of the Director...The Division will not auction oil and gas leases for tracts of land that contain less than 40 acres, except in the case of isolated parcels, or where the Division determines that the public interest will best be served by waiving the minimum acreage requirement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.790","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b4cb896e1aa1caf7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule 141-050-0525(3) states the State Land Board receives and credits funds, but the statute specifies the State Parks and Recreation Department receives them.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.591","citation":"ORS 273.591","quote":"All moneys received by the State Parks and Recreation Department for the purposes of ORS 273.563 to 273.591 shall be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the account.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-050-0525","citation":"OAR 141-050-0525(3)","quote":"All monies received by the Board shall be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the account of the Natural Heritage Program. Ref. ORS 273.591.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.591","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"095cb4296fe9e26b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"Rule 141-050-0925 requires the Register shall be reviewed every five years by the Council, but rule 736-045-0330 states the department may review it, creating conflicting mandatory vs. permissive standards and different responsible parties.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-050-0925","citation":"OAR 141-050-0925","quote":"The Register shall be reviewed and updated every five years by the Council.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-045-0330","citation":"OAR 736-045-0330","quote":"The department may review and update the Register every five years.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.591","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"73551604120e4812","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands","parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 736-045-0340 addresses only removal of natural areas from the register, while ORS 273.581(4) authorizes the commission to both place and remove natural areas.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.581","citation":"ORS 273.581(4)","quote":"After review and recommendation by the department, the State Parks and Recreation Commission may place natural areas onto the register or remove natural areas from the register.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-045-0340","citation":"OAR 736-045-0340","quote":"The commission may remove natural areas from the register. The commission will consider ORS 273.586(4) and the factors in OAR 736-045-0300, 736-045-0405(1)(d) and (7) in removing a state natural area or state natural area reserve from the register.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.581","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f1969495741c9530","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"ORS 273.413(6) requires the Department to obtain approval of the county governing body before selling or purchasing land, but the implementing rules only require notification of the county, not approval.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-273.413","citation":"ORS 273.413(6)","quote":"Before purchasing or selling land, the Department of State Lands shall obtain approval of the governing body of the county or counties in which such land is located.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-067-0180","citation":"OAR 141-067-0180(3)","quote":"The Department will notify, in writing, all adjacent landowners, and all affected school districts, city and county governments, including the county board of commissioners of a potential land sale or land exchange.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.413","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c00d18c21c3e407a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]},{"summary":"OAR 141-130-0020(5)(d) defines 'volunteer association' to include government agencies, but OAR 141-130-0030(3)(d) and (3)(f) require agreement provisions for volunteer injury coverage and fingerprinting of volunteer association members, which are incongruous with government agency employees.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-141-130-0020","citation":"OAR 141-130-0020(5)(d)","quote":"A state or federal agency other than the Department of State Lands","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-130-0030","citation":"OAR 141-130-0030(3)(d)","quote":"A requirement that the volunteer association or its members submit the appropriate information to receive volunteer injury coverage under ORS 278.125 for those members who will be participating in activities covered by an agreement","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-141-130-0030","citation":"OAR 141-130-0030(3)(f)","quote":"A requirement that any member of the volunteer association who is participating in an activity under an agreement will be fingerprinted if the member","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-273.199","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"623eab6713dc6759","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-lands"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands-south-slough-national-estuarine-research-reserve","name":"Department of State Lands, South Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve"},{"slug":"department-of-veterans-affairs","name":"Department of Veterans' Affairs"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"276","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":96,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 125-090-0138 excludes carpool participants from the Smart Commuter Program incentive while ORS 276.601(3)(b) and (4) contemplate incentive programs for employees participating in carpools and vanpools.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.601","citation":"ORS 276.601(3)(b)","quote":"For employees who have registered with and are participating in a carpool or vanpool","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-276.601","citation":"ORS 276.601(4)","quote":"Agencies are encouraged to use additional receipts obtained under this section to offer programs to incentivize employee carpooling, vanpooling, transit use or other alternative commuting to support the goals under ORS 276.591.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-090-0138","citation":"125-090-0138(2)(b)","quote":"State Employees who Lease Parking in a private, public lot or who are Participants in a Carpool or participate in a Carpool with assigned Parking in a City of Salem or City of Portland Carpool Area are not eligible for the Smart Commuter Program.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.601","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e202e4314722e10c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute requires comparison criteria to address 'The complexity of equipment options and any ancillary equipment,' but the rule does not establish complexity as a comparison criterion.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.910","citation":"ORS 276.910(2)(b)(C)","quote":"Criteria to be established under this subsection must address: ... (C) The complexity of equipment options and any ancillary equipment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-130-0500","citation":"OAR 330-130-0500(2)","quote":"The evaluation shall include, but not be limited to: (a) An evaluation of the emissions... (b) A comparison and documentation demonstrating that the agency considered the environmental impact... (c) A comparison of the life cycle costs... (d) An analysis of the ability of the systems to meet the design and stress needs of the application, the availability of fuel over the life cycle of the system and the availability of service support, maintenance and parts during system life cycle.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.910","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30ae66260186d88f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"The statute applies to 'major facility' but the rule applies only to 'Class 1 building,' which is narrower in scope.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.910","citation":"ORS 276.910(1)","quote":"Before constructing or renovating a major facility, an authorized state agency shall...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-130-0500","citation":"OAR 330-130-0500(2)","quote":"State agencies who are constructing or renovating a Class 1 building with an identified requirement for emergency backup power or with critical power application shall compare and evaluate...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.910","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ccd159bdd20c88f6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"The rule authorizes the Department to operate housing units as rental properties with specific management powers (setting rates, entering leases, charging for repairs, conducting inspections) that go beyond the statute's authorization to acquire and improve land.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.046","citation":"ORS 276.046(3)","quote":"The department may improve and develop the land acquired in a manner to accomplish the purpose and intent of ORS 276.054.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0005","citation":"OAR 125-060-0005(2), (3)","quote":"The Department may operate housing units acquired under section (1) of this rule as state office quarters, or as rental properties for any appropriate private commercial use. For each Mall housing unit used as a private commercial rental unit, the Department may: (a) Set rental rates, security deposits and fees at par with the prevailing comparable market rates... (b) Enter into a written rental agreement with tenants on a month-to-month tenancy basis or a longer term lease... (c) Conduct periodical inspections to ensure the tenant performance of the responsibilities under the rental agreement; (d) At any time during the tenancy the Department may order the tenant to repair or correct the conditions... and charge the tenant for the costs.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.046","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2862f889d3c1a4b2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule adds an exclusion for leased buildings to the definition of 'state building' that does not appear in the statute's list of exclusions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-475-0005","citation":"OAR 123-475-0005(9)","quote":"\"State Building\" does not include a building leased by a state agency, unless under a lease-purchase agreement or under any other agreement whereby ultimate state ownership is contemplated or expected.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-276.073","citation":"ORS 276.073(3)","quote":"\"State building\" does not include the following: (a) Any correctional facility. (b) Motor pools, heating plants, parking lots, maintenance sheds, highways, bridges, sewers, fishponds, fishways, service facilities at state parks and highway rest areas and similar nonarchitectural structures or improvements.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.073","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb9180417e55aae4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule excludes stand-alone storage and parking facilities from the definition of 'office quarters,' but the statute does not contain this exclusion.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.420","citation":"ORS 276.420(1)","quote":"office space, office buildings and related service, storage and parking facilities and may also include factory built, modular or portable units","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-120-0000","citation":"OAR 125-120-0000(7)","quote":"office space, office buildings and associated service, storage and parking facilities for state agencies, and may include factory-built, modular, or portable units, but excludes stand-alone storage and parking facilities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9037b1e6dd3881c4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule allows DAS to rescind or refuse parking authorization for any person meeting listed conditions, but fails to exempt statewide elective officers whom the statute mandates receive free parking.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.594","citation":"ORS 276.594(5)","quote":"the department shall furnish a space without charge to each statewide elective officer, except those with offices in the State Capitol","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-090-0175","citation":"OAR 125-090-0175(1)","quote":"DAS may rescind an existing Parking assignment, refuse to authorize Parking to, and may refuse to renew the authorization of, any person who: (a) Made a material misrepresentation or false statement in the application or certification for a Permit, (b) Made a material misrepresentation or false statement in the investigation of any Parking matter, (c) Failed to comply with a condition of a Permit, (d) Displayed a forged or altered Permit or a Permit reported lost or stolen, (e) Failed to pay the appropriate charges for Parking Facilities use, (f) Caused damage to Parking Facilities property, (g) Failed to comply with the recertification requirements of a Permit. (h) Violated the rules in this OAR, any policies, or procedures as published by DAS on the use of the Parking Facilities. (i) Through their communications or other actions have demonstrated that the State's best interests, as determined by DAS, are to deny them access to DAS controlled Parking Facilities. (j) Failed to supply valid written or certifiable electronic signatures on DAS required documents or provided forged signatures on DAS required documents.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.594","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8a2fa810fcaa7588","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 330-130-0090 mandates agencies use pre-qualified service providers for ESPC, while Rule 330-130-0100 permits but does not require agencies to use pre-qualified service providers for auditing, commissioning, and verification, despite both addressing similar pre-qualification requirements the statute does not distinguish between.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-330-130-0090","citation":"OAR 330-130-0090(3)(a)","quote":"Only select persons or firms that have been pre-qualified by the department to provide energy savings performance contracting services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-130-0100","citation":"OAR 330-130-0100(1)","quote":"Agencies may select persons or firms that have been pre-qualified by the department to perform auditing, commissioning, and performance verification services for energy systems.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.900","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a129d92734d81c13","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"The rule requires agencies to certify legislative funding availability for the current biennium and intent to fund the full lease term, but the statute imposes no such certification requirements on requesting agencies.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.429","citation":"ORS 276.429(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services may enter into, as appropriate, leases, including lease with option to purchase, installment purchases and rental agreements, as lessee, for office quarters for state agencies. In determining which method of acquiring office quarters is most appropriate under the circumstances, the department shall consider cost and the long-term best interests of the state.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-120-0110","citation":"OAR 125-120-0110(1)","quote":"Before Facilities Division approves an agency's request for office quarters, the head of the requesting agency, or designee, shall certify that legislatively approved funds are available to meet the obligations under the proposed lease for the current biennium and that the Agency intends to request funding to continue the lease for the full term of the lease.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.429","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d57a770109e6e007","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule allows annual rental rate adjustments based on market conditions, while the statute requires rate-setting on a biennial basis with modifications between sessions only after reporting to the Emergency Board.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.285","citation":"ORS 276.285(6)","quote":"The establishment by state agencies of rental rates for real property or facilities pursuant to this section shall be on a biennial basis as part of the budget development process, but modification of the rates may be made during the interim between legislative sessions after a report to the Emergency Board of the proposed rate modification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0005","citation":"OAR 125-060-0005(3)(a)","quote":"Set rental rates, security deposits and fees at par with the prevailing comparable market rates, and apply such rate schedule for the year with some adjustments allowed taking into consideration the prevailing market conditions or the condition of repairs of the rental unit","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.285","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9fa53f66a6c95e1c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 276.059, but the operative text (variance decision criteria) does not engage with 276.059's operative requirements (mandatory review process, 90-day deadline, written decision requirement, deemed approval).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-125-0524","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 276.058 & 276.059","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-276.059","citation":"ORS 276.059","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.059","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"197fa06fa2b29dfe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 581-001-0053(1) exempts OSSD employees from parking charges, but the statute requires agencies to impose equitable charges on users whether or not they are state employees.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.591","citation":"ORS 276.591(2)(a)","quote":"That each state agency that owns or controls parking facilities regulate their use and impose on users, whether or not state employees, equitable charges consistent with the state policy for such parking and with the policies as described in ORS 276.591 to 276.601.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-001-0053","citation":"OAR 581-001-0053(1)","quote":"There shall be no charge to employees of the Oregon State Schools for the Deaf for parking automobiles at the school or for using bicycle racks provided by the Department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.591","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"81de900341f80d2a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"Rule 330-130-0055 omits the statutory requirement that lease agreement guidelines allow 'reasonable time for the owner to implement the requirements'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.915","citation":"ORS 276.915(3)(e)","quote":"Establish guidelines for incorporating energy efficiency requirements into lease agreements of 10 or more years to be phased in as current lease agreements expire or as new lease agreements are entered into, allowing reasonable time for the owner to implement the requirements of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-130-0055","citation":"OAR 330-130-0055","quote":"The department, in consultation with the agencies, shall establish guidelines for incorporating energy efficiency requirements into lease agreements of 10 years or more to be phased in as current leases expire or as agencies enter into new agreements.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.915","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d779104d533822a0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"Rule 330-130-0090(1)(a) makes prequalification exempt for PE/RA discretionary rather than absolute as the statute requires","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.915","citation":"ORS 276.915(5)(a)","quote":"Direct an energy consumption analysis for an authorized state agency under subsection (2) of this section, unless the person is a professional engineer or a registered architect","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-130-0090","citation":"OAR 330-130-0090(1)(a)(B)","quote":"Agencies that wish to hire a person or firm that has not been previously prequalified by the department must request pre-approval from the department for exemption from this requirement. Only energy analysts that meet the qualifications as described in the SEED Program Guidelines will be considered eligible for exemption from prequalification.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.915","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b9a1f17b13d9529c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"Rule 1 states that State Capitol and Supreme Court Building are not subject to DAS space assignment, but the statute does not explicitly exclude these buildings and only requires conformity with DAS-managed buildings, leased quarters, or other agency space as provided by other statutes not included here.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-120-0020","citation":"oar-125-120-0020(2)","quote":"The State Capitol and the Supreme Court Building are not subject to space assignment by the Department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-276.410","citation":"ORS 276.410(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall assign state agencies office space in the buildings described in ORS 276.004 or in leased quarters as provided in ORS 276.420 to 276.440 or in available space in other buildings owned or controlled by other state agencies.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"63c75f4b83fb26b2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-475-0010(3) allows title to works of art to vest with either the Contracting Agency or the Resident Agency, but the statute limits title to the Contracting Agency only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.090","citation":"ORS 276.090(3)","quote":"Title to works of art acquired pursuant to ORS 276.073 to 276.090 vests with the contracting agency in the name of the state.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-475-0010","citation":"OAR 123-475-0010(3)","quote":"Title for all Works of Art acquired pursuant to ORS 276.073 to 276.090 shall be in the name of the state on behalf of the Contracting Agency or Resident Agency, as determined by the Department of Administrative Services and the Contracting Agency, if the Contracting Agency is an agency other than the Department of Administrative Services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.090","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b3d9a4e0925e2b35","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-125-0150(2) exempts additional entities (SAIF Corporation, Lottery, Secretary of State, Treasurer's Office, Legislative or Judicial branches) that ORS 276.227(7) does not mention.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.227","citation":"ORS 276.227(7)","quote":"The provisions of this section do not apply to public universities listed in ORS 352.002, the Oregon Health and Science University or a community college as defined in ORS 341.005.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-125-0150","citation":"OAR 125-125-0150(2)","quote":"The Statewide Facilities Planning Process applies to any State Agency that owns a Major Facility or meets the guidelines described in OAR 125-125-0150(5). The process does not apply to Oregon institutions of higher education (as defined in ORS 352.002 and ORS 341.005(4)(a)), Oregon Health Sciences University, SAIF Corporation, Lottery, Secretary of State, Treasurer's Office, or to the Legislative or Judicial branches.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.227","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e214a35be2ec818a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-060-0005 permits private commercial rental units in the Capitol area, but the statute declares its purpose is to permanently secure the areas from commercial encroachment.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.054","citation":"ORS 276.054","quote":"permanently to secure the areas from commercial and industrial encroachment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-060-0005","citation":"OAR 125-060-0005(2) and (3)","quote":"The Department may operate housing units acquired under section (1) of this rule as state office quarters, or as rental properties for any appropriate private commercial use. (3) For each Mall housing unit used as a private commercial rental unit, the Department may: (a) Set rental rates, security deposits and fees at par with the prevailing comparable market rates","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.054","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e5602f3a700ff634","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule limits project review to capital construction valued at $1,000,000 or greater, but the statute requires the Commission to review all proposals of state agencies to change state buildings.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-276.058","citation":"ORS 276.058(2)","quote":"Investigate, review and make recommendations on all proposals of state agencies to add to, reduce or otherwise change the use of a state building or grounds in the areas described by ORS 276.054","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-125-0350","citation":"OAR 125-125-0350(5)","quote":"For the purposes of the review required under this rule, a project means expenditures for capital construction valued at $1,000,000 or greater.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.058","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0dd4cc5501653f28","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-120-0150 requires public notice to local officials and community groups for significant leases, a requirement not stated in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-120-0150","citation":"OAR 125-120-0150(1)","quote":"When the geographic search area for siting office quarters for a significant lease has been established or when leasable properties have been identified, Division shall contact the community or communities which Division determines are likely to be affected by the requesting agency's proposed location. Agency and Division may also opt to give said notice to any lease siting situation at its discretion. Division will issue public notice at the agency's request for any leasing action to: (a) The mayor and/or city manager; (b) The chair of the county commissioners; (c) The chair of the planning commission; (d) The local state representative; (e) The local state senator; (f) Affected local business associations, as identified and determined by Division; and (g) Affected local neighborhood associations, as identified and determined by Division.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276.428","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"724b77ded1c43cb4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"}]},{"ors_chapter":"276a","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 128-020-0010(4)(c) automatically includes as covered vendors any corporate entity prohibited by federal agencies under the Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Act, which the statute does not authorize—only allowing the State Chief Information Officer to designate other covered vendors under ORS 276A.344.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-276a.340","citation":"ORS 276A.340(3)","quote":"\"Covered vendor\" means any of the following corporate entities, or any parent, subsidiary, affiliate or successor entity of the following corporate entities: (a) Ant Group Co., Limited. (b) ByteDance Limited. (c) Huawei Technologies Company Limited. (d) Kaspersky Lab. (e) Tencent Holdings Limited. (f) ZTE Corporation. (g) Any other corporate entity designated a covered vendor by the State Chief Information Officer under ORS 276A.344.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-128-020-0010","citation":"OAR 128-020-0010(4)(c)","quote":"Any corporate entity that has been prohibited or had its products or services prohibited from use by a federal agency pursuant to the Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Act of 2019, 47 USC 1601, et seq, including as amended.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-276a.340","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2241edd010e79442","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-office-of-the-state-chief-information-officer"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-office-of-the-state-chief-information-officer","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Office of the State Chief Information Officer"}]},{"ors_chapter":"279","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":24,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule omits the 75% direct labor requirement for fiscal years beginning on or before June 30, 2019 that the statute specifies, including only the 65% and 60% thresholds for subsequent periods.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279.835","citation":"ORS 279.835(6)(c)","quote":"That in the manufacture of products and in the provision of services, whether or not the products or services are procured under ORS 279.835 to 279.855, employs individuals with disabilities for not less than: (A) 75 percent of the work hours of direct labor required for the manufacture or provision of the products or services during a fiscal year that begins on or before June 30, 2019. (B) 65 percent of the work hours of direct labor required for the manufacture or provision of the products or services during a fiscal year that begins on or after July 1, 2019, and before June 30, 2021. (C) 60 percent of the work hours of direct labor required for the manufacture or provision of the products or services, or the federal ratio, whichever is lower, during a fiscal year that begins on or after July 1, 2021.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0005","citation":"OAR 125-055-0005(7)(c)","quote":"That employs Individuals with Disabilities in the manufacture of products or in the provision of services for external customers, whether or not the products or services are procured under ORS 279.835 to 279.855, for not less than: (A) 65 percent of the work hours of the OFC's direct labor during a fiscal year that begins on or after July 1, 2019, and before June 30, 2021. (B) 60 percent of the work hours of the OFC's direct labor or the direct labor ratio required by the federal program established by the Javits-Wagner O'Day Act or any successor federal program, whichever is lower, during a fiscal year that begins on or after July 1, 2021.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279.835","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8b6c05aa5e0301fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"}]},{"ors_chapter":"279a","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":458,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 279A.157, but its operative text contains only a cross-reference to another rule and requirements about conflict minerals from SB 471, never engaging with the substance of ORS 279A.157.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0135","citation":"OAR 125-246-0135, statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.157, ORS 279A.161, SB 471 (Chapter 294, ORS 2019)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.157","citation":"ORS 279A.157","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.157","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a32c3577277d63b0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0555 declares implementation of ORS 279A.159 but does not establish any substantive education and training standards that the statute requires; it only references that Contract Administration is 'subject to the requirements' of the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0555","citation":"frontmatter declaration","quote":"ORS 279A.050, ORS 279A.065(5), ORS 279A.070, ORS 279A.140, ORS 279A.159","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0555","citation":"125-246-0555(1)","quote":"The Authority for an Authorized Agency to conduct Contract Administration is found in OAR 125-246-0170, and is subject to the requirements of ORS 279A.159 and OAR 125-246-0140.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.159","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d0df3ef66b8c6339","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0320 declares it implements ORS 279A.145 but its operative text contains only definitions unrelated to the statute's requirement to include recycled product purchasing information in publications and training programs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0320","citation":"OAR 125-246-0320 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.125, ORS 279A.145, ORS 279A.150, ORS 279B.270, ORS 279B.280","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.145","citation":"ORS 279A.145","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall include recycled product purchasing information within publications and training programs provided to local governments requesting state government purchasing assistance.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fc8ee047715a84e3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 279A.161 (which requires director review and verification of advice, with a signed statement before executing contracts over $150,000, and allows delegation for agencies with 12+ contracts), but the rule's operative text never addresses any of these substantive requirements—it only references another rule and addresses conflict minerals compliance.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.161","citation":"ORS 279A.161(1)-(2)","quote":"Before a state contracting agency executes a public contract with a contract price that exceeds $150,000, the director or other head of the state contracting agency shall review, and shall verify that the person that will administer the public contract for the state contracting agency has read and understands, all advice and recommendations...The director or other head of the state contracting agency shall sign and retain in the state contracting agency's records a statement that acknowledges that the director or other head of the state contracting agency reviewed the advice and recommendations...The director or other head of a state contracting agency that enters into more than 12 public contracts during a calendar year may delegate to a qualified employee...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0135","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.157, ORS 279A.161, SB 471 (Chapter 294, 2019)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.161","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"41e9dbbb6bb1a91e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0322(1) limits the recycled materials preference to only Competitive Sealed Bidding or Competitive Sealed Proposals, but the statute applies the preference requirement to any procurement method without such limitation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.125","citation":"ORS 279A.125(1)","quote":"a contracting agency charged with the procurement of goods for any public use shall give preference to the procurement of goods manufactured from recycled materials","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0322","citation":"OAR 125-246-0322(1)","quote":"an Authorized Agency charged with the Procurement of Goods for any public use must give preference to the Procurement of Goods manufactured from Recycled Materials whenever the Authorized Agency uses Competitive Sealed Bidding or Competitive Sealed Proposals pursuant to ORS 279B.055 or 279B.060, respectively","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.125","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"74557379b946ae9b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule requires contractors to use recycled PETE products in contract performance, a mandate not stated in the statute which only requires providing guidelines and identifying suppliers.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.150","citation":"ORS 279A.150(1)-(2)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall provide guidelines to state agencies and contractors on the availability of necessary goods that contain recycled PETE, as well as other recycled plastic resin supplies and materials. The department shall identify suppliers able to provide necessary goods containing recycled PETE, as well as other recycled plastic resin supplies and materials.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-125-246-0321","citation":"OAR 125-246-0321(5)(a)","quote":"All Contracts must require Contractors to use, in the performance of the Contract Work, to the maximum extent economically feasible, recycled PETE products, as well as other recycled plastic resin products.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e283a11f0cce6a6d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule requires certification only for offerors with 50+ employees on contracts exceeding $500,000, but the statute contemplates a program for any person intending to submit a bid or proposal for a public contract without those thresholds.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0330","citation":"OAR 125-246-0330(6)","quote":"An Offeror in any State Contracting Agency procurements must demonstrate to the Agency that the Offeror possesses an unexpired certificate, issued by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services in accordance with ORS 279A.167, if the Offeror employs 50 or more full-time workers at the time of the Closing and the estimated Contract price exceeds $500,000.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.167","citation":"ORS 279A.167(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall establish a program to certify that a person that intends to submit a bid or proposal for a public contract understands the prohibition set forth in ORS 652.220 and in other laws or rules that prohibit discrimination in compensation or wage payments.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.167","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0c5c177fd9c461c9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the sources from which surplus property may be received by excluding not-for-profit organizations, other states, and private entities that the statute explicitly includes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.250","citation":"ORS 279A.250(5)","quote":"Surplus property means property received by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services or a state agency as surplus from federal government units, state agencies, local governments, special government bodies, not-for-profit organizations, other states and private entities.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-050-0100","citation":"OAR 125-050-0100(13)","quote":"Surplus Property means all personal property, vehicles and titled equipment property received by the Department as surplus from federal government units, state agencies, local governments, and special government bodies for sale to state agencies, political subdivisions of the State, and private not-for-profit organizations or the general public or any combination thereof.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"65e459aad9062504","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule broadens the definition of property included in surplus property by adding vehicles and titled equipment, which exceeds the statutory definition of 'Property' as personal property.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.250","citation":"ORS 279A.250(3)","quote":"Property means personal property.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-050-0100","citation":"OAR 125-050-0100(13)","quote":"Surplus Property means all personal property, vehicles and titled equipment property received by the Department as surplus from federal government units, state agencies, local governments, and special government bodies","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4bda2f0cdedf4637","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-055-0037 declares it implements ORS 279A.025(4), but that statute only exempts certain procurement methods from applying to qualified nonprofit agency contracts; the rule's operative text establishes affirmative substantive requirements about successor contractors, wages, and health benefits that are not found in the declared statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-055-0037","citation":"declared statutes (frontmatter)","quote":"ORS 279A.025(4), 279.835-279.855, SB494 (2019)","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-279a.025","citation":"ORS 279A.025(4)","quote":"ORS 279A.200 to 279A.225 and 279B.050 to 279B.085 do not apply to contracts made with qualified nonprofit agencies providing employment opportunities for individuals with disabilities under ORS 279.835 to 279.855.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6e5e45235d32f80e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0400(2)(c)(C) adds ORS 279B.085 as an alternative for source selection methods, but ORS 279A.215(1)(a) limits acceptable methods to only those 'specified in ORS 279B.055 or 279B.060'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.215","citation":"ORS 279A.215(1)(a)","quote":"The administering contracting agency's solicitation and award process for the original contract is an open and impartial competitive process and uses source selection methods substantially equivalent to those specified in ORS 279B.055 or 279B.060","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0400","citation":"OAR 125-246-0400(2)(c)(C)","quote":"For Permissive Cooperative Procurements, each Participant that participates after the Award of the Original Contract must determine, in Writing, whether the Solicitation and award process for the Original Contract arising out of a Cooperative Procurement is substantially equivalent to those identified in ORS 279B.055, 279B.060 or 279B.085","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"97eaa9f9f459e824","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-046-0130(3) addresses only local contracting agencies' designation of personal services contracts, omitting the statute's equal provision allowing state contracting agencies to designate personal services contracts.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.055","citation":"ORS 279A.055(2)","quote":"A state contracting agency with procurement authority under ORS 279A.050 or a local contract review board by ordinance, resolution, administrative rule or other regulation may designate certain service contracts or classes of service contracts as personal services contracts.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-046-0130","citation":"OAR 137-046-0130(3)","quote":"Contracts or classes of Contracts for Personal Services of a Local Contracting Agency designated as such by the Local Contracting Agency's Local Contract Review Board pursuant to ORS 279A.055, are not subject to these Model Rules, unless the Local Contracting Agency adopts OAR 137-047-0250 through 137-047-0290 as the procedures the Local Contracting Agency will use to screen and select persons to perform Contracts for Personal Services other than Architectural, Engineering and Surveying Services and Related Services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.055","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"baae5d25a3e7f86b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0400(2)(c)(C) permits source selection methods equivalent to ORS 279B.055, 279B.060 OR 279B.085, but the statute ORS 279A.220(1)(a) restricts them to 279B.055 or 279B.060 only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.220","citation":"ORS 279A.220(1)(a)","quote":"The administering contracting agency's solicitation and award process for the original contract is an open and impartial competitive process and uses source selection methods substantially equivalent to those specified in ORS 279B.055 or 279B.060","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0400","citation":"OAR 125-246-0400(2)(c)(C)","quote":"For Permissive Cooperative Procurements, each Participant that participates after the Award of the Original Contract must determine, in Writing, whether the Solicitation and award process for the Original Contract arising out of a Cooperative Procurement is substantially equivalent to those identified in ORS 279B.055, 279B.060 or 279B.085","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cff6e08347b3d622","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"DPSST rule allows DPSST to make the determination of which federal programs qualify, but statute limits this power to the Director of DAS or a local contract review board.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.180","citation":"ORS 279A.180(2)","quote":"other federal law that is, as determined by the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services or a local contract review board, similar to 10 U.S.C. 381 or section 211 of the Electronic Government Act of 2002","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-259-007-0150","citation":"OAR 259-007-0150(2)","quote":"DPSST hereby makes the determination according to ORS 279A.180 that the Local Preparedness Acquisition Act (Public Law 110-248), the GSA Order of 2000, and any subsequent revisions or updating of either of these programs describe other federal programs that, under federal law, are similar to 10 U.S.C. 381 or Section 211 of the Electronic Government Act of 2002","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.180","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d23e0a53cbe192ef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0110(102) defines 'Original Contract' to apply to any Department or Authorized Agency contract, but the statute ORS 279A.200(1)(f) limits the definition to contracts in cooperative procurements only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0110","citation":"OAR 125-246-0110(102)","quote":"'Original Contract' means the initial Contract or Price Agreement of the Department or an Authorized Agency. See OAR 125-246-0400 for the definition of 'Original Contract' that the Public Contracting Code and Rules use for Cooperative Procurements only.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.200","citation":"ORS 279A.200(1)(f)","quote":"'Original contract' means the initial contract or price agreement solicited and awarded during a cooperative procurement by an administering contracting agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"de868547abc7fad4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule exempts ODOT from mandatory use contracts for federal programs, but the statute states ODOT authority is subject to \"Except as otherwise provided in the Public Contracting Code,\" which would include mandatory use contract requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-147-0070","citation":"OAR 731-147-0070 declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 279A.050(3), ORS 279A.180","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.050","citation":"ORS 279A.050(3)","quote":"Except as otherwise provided in the Public Contracting Code, the Director of Transportation has all the authority available to: (a) Procure or supervise the procurement of all services and personal services to construct, acquire, plan, design, maintain and operate passenger terminal facilities and motor vehicle parking facilities in connection with any public transportation system in accordance with ORS 184.689 (5); (b) Procure or supervise the procurement of all goods, services, public improvements and personal services that relate to operating, maintaining or constructing highways, bridges and other transportation facilities that are subject to the authority of the Department of Transportation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.050","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7a5cda04b7de53ca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule drops the statutory prohibition on using records for evaluating proposals or invitations to bid.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.165","citation":"ORS 279A.165(2)","quote":"The state contracting agency shall maintain the records for the purposes described under this section and may not use the information for evaluating proposals or invitations to bid that the state contracting agency receives in response to a solicitation for a procurement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0287","citation":"OAR 125-247-0287(12)(b)","quote":"An Authorized Agency must maintain records about its Special Procurements that enable the Agency to determine and provide to the State Chief Procurement Officer at least the following information:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.165","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"492c99af6fbc4ea2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0220(9) uses a $100,000 threshold for Public Improvement Contracts with Emerging Small Businesses, while ORS 279A.100(3) limits the affirmative action preference to contracts estimated to cost $50,000 or less.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.100","citation":"ORS 279A.100(3)","quote":"In carrying out an affirmative action goal, policy or program, a contracting agency by appropriate ordinance, resolution or rule may limit competition for a public contract for goods and services, or for any other public contract estimated to cost $50,000 or less, to contracting entities owned or controlled by persons described in subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0220","citation":"OAR 125-246-0220(9)","quote":"When a Public Improvement Contract is less than $100,000 and the Offerors are being drawn exclusively from a list of certified Emerging Small Businesses maintained by the COBID, the Contracting Agency may Contract without formal competitive sourcing methods after a good faith effort to obtain a minimum of three competitive Quotes from Emerging Small Businesses.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.100","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f7e4d9eb210f35b3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0370 does not include the three-year statute of limitations on disqualification allegations in ORS 279A.110(3), allowing disqualifications beyond the temporal window the statute permits.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.110","citation":"ORS 279A.110(3)","quote":"A contracting agency may not allege an occurrence of discrimination in subcontracting as a basis for debarring or disqualifying a bidder or proposer under subsection (2) of this section more than three years after the alleged discriminatory conduct occurred or more than three years after the contracting agency, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, should have discovered the conduct, whichever is later.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0370","citation":"OAR 137-049-0370(1)(b)(C)","quote":"For a Disqualification under ORS 279A.110, a Contracting Agency may disqualify a Person if the Contracting Agency finds that the Person discriminated against a disadvantaged business enterprise, minority-owned business, women-owned business, emerging small business, or a Veteran-owned business in awarding a subcontract under a Contract with that Contracting Agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a968b01256872516","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0710 does not include the three-year statute of limitations on disqualification allegations in ORS 279A.110(3), allowing disqualifications beyond the temporal window the statute permits.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.110","citation":"ORS 279A.110(3)","quote":"A contracting agency may not allege an occurrence of discrimination in subcontracting as a basis for debarring or disqualifying a bidder or proposer under subsection (2) of this section more than three years after the alleged discriminatory conduct occurred or more than three years after the contracting agency, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, should have discovered the conduct, whichever is later.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0710","citation":"OAR 731-005-0710(1)(b)(C)","quote":"For a DBE Disqualification under ORS 279A.110, ODOT may disqualify an Entity if ODOT finds that the Entity discriminated against a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a business that a veteran owns, or an emerging small business in awarding a subcontract under a prior Contract with ODOT.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9bb82af5fbfb68d0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0670(3) narrows the protected class from 'veteran-owned business' to only 'a business enterprise that is owned or controlled by or that employs a disabled veteran,' dropping the broader veteran-owned business protection the statute requires.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.110","citation":"ORS 279A.110(1) and (4)","quote":"A bidder or proposer that competes for or is awarded a public contract may not discriminate against a subcontractor in awarding a subcontract because the subcontractor is a disadvantaged business enterprise, a minority-owned business, a woman-owned business, a veteran-owned business or an emerging small business that is certified under ORS 200.055.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0670","citation":"OAR 731-005-0670(3)","quote":"The Offeror shall certify and deliver to ODOT Written certification, as part of the Offer, that the Offeror has not discriminated against minority, women or emerging small business enterprises or against a business enterprise that is owned or controlled by or that employs a disabled veteran as defined in ORS 408.225 in obtaining any required subcontracts.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30b1d31e65fc058f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-046-0470(1) adds an exception for agencies not subject to the Code, making compliance with ORS 279B.400-279B.425 conditional, whereas the statute requires it absolutely.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.225","citation":"ORS 279A.225(1)","quote":"The protest must be in accordance with the provisions of ORS 279B.400 to 279B.425.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-046-0470","citation":"OAR 137-046-0470(1)","quote":"An Offeror or potential Offeror wishing to protest the procurement process, the contents of a solicitation document related to a Cooperative Procurement or the award or proposed award of an Original Contract shall make the protest in accordance with ORS 279B.400 through 279B.425 unless the Administering Contracting Agency is not subject to the Code. If the Administering Contracting Agency is not subject to the Code, then the Offeror or potential Offeror shall make the protest in accordance with the processes and procedures established by the Administering Contracting Agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.225","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bac1fae6872d8e36","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule makes the statutory mandate to punish violations discretionary by creating an optional administrative process that the statute does not authorize.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.990","citation":"ORS 279A.990(1)","quote":"Any violation of ORS 279A.140, 279A.280 or 279B.270 shall be punished as described in ORS 291.990.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0900","citation":"OAR 125-246-0900(2)","quote":"Upon notice to the Department of an alleged violation pursuant to ORS 279A.990(1), the Department, at its own discretion, may provide to an individual of an Agency or an Agency an optional administrative process with an opportunity for remedy prior or parallel to a legal process leading to conviction or a Department certification leading to other penalties provided by ORS 291.990.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.990","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9981504a79fef2f0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rules 125-055-0100 through 0130 declare they implement ORS 279A.140 (a general state procurement statute about DAS authority and contract procedures) but the operative text is entirely about HIPAA Business Associate requirements, Privacy Rule, Security Rule, and Protected Health Information—subjects that ORS 279A.140 does not address.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-055-0100","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0105","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 192.519; ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0115","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0120","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0125","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-055-0130","citation":"ORS 279A.140","quote":"ORS 279A.140, The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, 42 USC 1320d -1320d-8, PL 104-191, sec. 262, sec. 264","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d7c0801d0d96f1f9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-125-246-0800 declares it implements ORS 279A.010(x) (which defines 'Proposer') but the operative text never engages with proposers—it discusses selling and leasing activities and procurement methods.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-246-0800","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.010(x), ORS 279A.015, ORS 279A.050(1)(2), ORS 279A.065(5)(a), ORS 279A.070","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.010","citation":"ORS 279A.010(x)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a7aa08aa3c77be74","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-246-0400(2)(b)(F) defines 'Joint Cooperative Procurement' to require only identification of participants and contract requirements, omitting the statutory requirement for an open and impartial competitive process and the requirement for no material changes in terms, conditions or prices.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.210","citation":"ORS 279A.210(1)","quote":"A joint cooperative procurement is valid only if: (a) The administering contracting agency's solicitation and award process for the original contract is an open and impartial competitive process and uses source selection methods substantially equivalent to those specified in ORS 279B.055, 279B.060 or 279B.085 or uses a competitive bidding process substantially equivalent to the competitive bidding process in ORS chapter 279C; (b) The administering contracting agency's solicitation and the original contract or price agreement identifies the cooperative procurement group or each participating purchasing contracting agency and specifies the estimated contract requirements; and (c) No material change is made in the terms, conditions or prices of the contract between the contractor and the purchasing contracting agency from the terms, conditions and prices of the original contract between the contractor and the administering contracting agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0400","citation":"OAR 125-246-0400(2)(b)(F)","quote":"\"Joint Cooperative Procurement\" means a Cooperative Procurement that identifies: (i) The Participants or the Cooperative Procurement Group; and (ii) The contract requirements or estimated contract requirements for the Original Contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"06a14140af81ad41","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0400 requires delegation of authority for agencies to act as Administrators or Participants in cooperative procurements, a condition not stated in ORS 279A.205","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ORS 279A.205","citation":"ORS 279A.205(1)","quote":"A contracting agency may participate in, sponsor, conduct or administer a joint cooperative procurement for the procurement of any goods, services or public improvements.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"oar-125-246-0400","citation":"OAR 125-246-0400(2)(c)(A) and (B)","quote":"The State Chief Procurement Officer will enter into Cooperative Procurements on behalf of Agencies, unless an Authorized Agency receives a delegation of Authority according to OAR 125-246-0170 to act as an Administrator or Participant... Subject to a delegation of Authority described in subsection (2)(c)(A) of this Rule, an Administrator or Participant may participate in, sponsor, conduct or administer Joint Cooperative Procurements, Permissive Cooperative Procurements and Interstate Cooperative Procurements","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8a9f1367098836fd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the statutory requirement that a benefit company's majority workforce be located in the state 'at the time the benefit company submits the bid or proposal,' dropping a temporal qualifier.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.128","citation":"ORS 279A.128(2)(a)(A)(i)","quote":"has the majority of the benefit company's regular, full-time workforce located in this state at the time the benefit company submits the bid or proposal","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-046-0300","citation":"OAR 137-046-0300(5)(a)(A)","quote":"has the majority of the benefit company's regular, full-time workforce located in this state","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.128","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b65bb8ba785aa9f1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the statutory specification that an employee stock ownership plan must be 'as defined in 26 U.S.C. 4975(e)(7), as in effect on September 26, 2025,' replacing that specific definitional reference with a general IRS recognition standard.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.128","citation":"ORS 279A.128(2)(a)(A)(ii)","quote":"an employee stock ownership plan, as defined in 26 U.S.C. 4975(e)(7), as in effect on September 26, 2025, that the United States Internal Revenue Service recognizes as a qualified plan","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-046-0300","citation":"OAR 137-046-0300(5)(a)(B)","quote":"an employee stock ownership plan recognized by the Internal Revenue Service as a qualified stock ownership plan","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.128","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ce51b39d309b15d0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-249-0880 declares it implements ORS 279A.030 (federal law prevails) but the operative rule text contains only a cross-reference to another rule, never engaging with the federal law supremacy principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0880","citation":"OAR 125-249-0880","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 279A.030, 279C.375, 279C.380 & 279C.440","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-249-0880","citation":"OAR 125-249-0880","quote":"125-249-0880 Records Maintenance; Right to Audit Records See OAR 137-049-0880.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.030","citation":"ORS 279A.030","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2b72b376fdebc213","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0880 declares it implements ORS 279A.030 (federal law prevails) but the operative rule text addresses only records maintenance and audit procedures, never engaging with the federal law supremacy principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0880","citation":"OAR 137-049-0880","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 279A.030, 279C.375, 279C.380 & 279C.440","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0880","citation":"OAR 137-049-0880(1)","quote":"Records Maintenance; Access. Contractors and subcontractors shall maintain all fiscal records relating to Contracts in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0e4f1d81afd4a87","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 167-001-0007 declares it implements ORS 279A.030 (federal law prevails) but the operative rule text addresses only the applicability date of rules for Secretary of State contracts, never engaging with the federal law supremacy principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-167-001-0007","citation":"OAR 167-001-0007","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 279A.020, 279A.030 & 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-167-001-0007","citation":"OAR 167-001-0007","quote":"These OAR chapter 167, division 001 rules apply to public contracts of the Secretary of State first advertised, but if not advertised then entered into, on or after March 1, 2014.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.030","citation":"ORS 279A.030","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b88dc7e74ef06d5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-business-services-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-146-0010 declares it implements ORS 279A.030 (federal law prevails) but the operative rule text merely adopts other rules by reference and addresses internal rule hierarchy, never engaging with the federal law supremacy principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-146-0010","citation":"OAR 731-146-0010","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 279A.030 & 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-146-0010","citation":"OAR 731-146-0010(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) adopts OAR 137-046-0100 through 137-046-0480 in effect as of April 15, 2017.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0635cca3ee241db","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-010-0400 declares it implements ORS 279A.030 (federal law prevails) but the operative rule text addresses only records maintenance, retention periods, and audit rights, never engaging with the federal law supremacy principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-734-010-0400","citation":"OAR 734-010-0400","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 279A.030, 279C.375 & 279C.440","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-010-0400","citation":"OAR 734-010-0400(1)","quote":"Contractors; all subcontractors at all tiers; all material suppliers at all tiers of aggregates, asphalt cement concrete, Portland cement concrete, and the supply and fabrication of structural steel items; and all Related Entities as defined by this rule, (collectively referred to in this Rule as \"Record Keepers\") shall maintain all records, including fiscal records, regardless of when created, relating to their: (a) Performance of the Contract or a subcontract","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"da25592802686ffb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"Rules 137-049-0490 and 731-005-0750 apply the reporting requirement to 'Foreign Contractor' and 'Non-Resident Contractor' respectively, but the statute applies it only to 'nonresident bidder' as statutorily defined—a bidder who meets specific criteria about Oregon tax payments, business address, and bid disclosure.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.120","citation":"ORS 279A.120(1)(b) and (3)","quote":"'Nonresident bidder' means a bidder who is not a resident bidder. 'Resident bidder' means a bidder that has paid unemployment taxes or income taxes in this state during the 12 calendar months immediately preceding submission of the bid, has a business address in this state and has stated in the bid whether the bidder is a 'resident bidder'... When a public contract is awarded to a nonresident bidder and the contract price exceeds $10,000, the bidder shall promptly report to the Department of Revenue","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-137-049-0490","citation":"OAR 137-049-0490","quote":"If the Contract Price exceeds $10,000 and the Contractor is a Foreign Contractor, the Contractor shall promptly report to the Oregon Department of Revenue","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0750","citation":"OAR 731-005-0750","quote":"If the Contract Amount exceeds $10,000 and the Contractor is a Non-Resident Contractor, the Contractor shall promptly report to the Oregon Department of Revenue","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c3958d850c5159a4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 167-001-0020 references ORS 279A.065(4) when the statute provision that actually applies is ORS 279A.065(5), which addresses contracting agencies being subject to model rules by default.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"OAR 167-001-0020","citation":"ORS 279A.065(4)","quote":"It is the intent of the Secretary that these Model Rules will be accepted by default in accordance with the provisions of ORS 279A.065(4).","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"ORS 279A.065(5)","citation":"ORS 279A.065(5)","quote":"A contracting agency that has not adopted the contracting agency's own rules of procedure in accordance with subsection (6) of this section is subject to the model rules the Attorney General adopts under this section, including all modifications to the model rules that the Attorney General may adopt.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3418e914a36c92b6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"The rule's retaliation protection extends to employees who merely witness or report misconduct without requiring they also experience or witness it first, whereas the statute protects only those who (experience or witness) AND report.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.112","citation":"ORS 279A.112(2)(b)(E)","quote":"A prohibition against retaliating against an employee who experiences or witnesses, and reports, conduct that constitutes sexual harassment, sexual assault or discrimination against a member of a protected class.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0330","citation":"125-246-0330(8)(b)(E)","quote":"A prohibition against retaliating against an employee who experiences; witnesses, or reports, conduct that constitutes sexual harassment, sexual assault or discrimination against a member of a protected class;","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.112","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9012040bd68174b4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule defines 'Discrimination' as conduct showing animosity 'to others,' while the statute defines it as conduct that evinces animosity 'in others'—a grammatically and semantically distinct meaning.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-279a.112","citation":"ORS 279A.112(1)(a)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means conduct that has the purpose or effect of creating employment conditions for an individual that are intimidating, hostile or offensive or that evince animosity, resentment, anger, prejudice or ill will in others primarily because of the individual's identification with or membership in a protected class.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0330","citation":"125-246-0330(8)(g)(A)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means conduct that has the purpose or effect of creating employment conditions for an individual that are intimidating, hostile or offensive or that show animosity, resentment, anger, prejudice or ill will to others primarily because of the individual's identification with or membership in a protected class.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.112","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f8ed5449c26f5a94","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 167-001-0020 cites ORS 279A.065(4) to support the claim that Model Rules are accepted by default, but that statute addresses the Attorney General's process for reviewing legislation and updating model rules, not the default applicability of Model Rules to contracting agencies. ORS 279A.065(5) contains the provision establishing that agencies not adopting their own rules are subject to the Attorney General's model rules by default.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-167-001-0020","citation":"ORS 279A.065(4)","quote":"The Secretary intends that the Attorney General's Model Public Contracting Rules, Chapter 137, will govern all Secretary of State public contracting. It is the intent of the Secretary that these Model Rules will be accepted by default in accordance with the provisions of ORS 279A.065(4).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279a.065","citation":"ORS 279A.065(5)","quote":"A contracting agency that has not adopted the contracting agency's own rules of procedure in accordance with subsection (6) of this section is subject to the model rules the Attorney General adopts under this section, including all modifications to the model rules that the Attorney General may adopt.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279a.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"21d6532d6ec590b9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-business-services-division"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-home-care-commission","name":"Department of Human Services, Home Care Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-business-services-division","name":"Secretary of State, Business Services Division"},{"slug":"travel-information-council","name":"Travel Information Council"}]},{"ors_chapter":"279b","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":143,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 125-247-0165 declares it implements ORS 279B.270 but the operative text addresses electronic goods procurement, environmental impact, and sustainability considerations, not the recycled materials and recovered resources requirements of ORS 279B.270.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0165","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 279B.025, ORS 279B.270, ORS 279B.280","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.270","citation":"ORS 279B.270","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"961f46c6c6404be8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-247-0170 declares it implements ORS 279B.270 but the operative text establishes life cycle costing as an evaluation methodology for total cost of ownership, not the substantive requirement to use recycled materials and recovered resources stated in ORS 279B.270.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0170","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 279B.025, ORS 279B.270, ORS 279B.280","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.270","citation":"ORS 279B.270","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"012e53dd532dddeb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-047-0575(3) adds 'Imputed Knowledge' as a basis for debarment by attributing affiliate conduct to a prospective offeror, which is not listed among the specific enumerated grounds for debarment in ORS 279B.130(2).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.130","citation":"ORS 279B.130(2)","quote":"A prospective bidder or proposer may be debarred from consideration for award of a contracting agency's contracts if: (a) The prospective bidder or proposer has been convicted of a criminal offense... (b) The prospective bidder or proposer has been convicted under state or federal statutes of embezzlement, theft, forgery, bribery, falsification or destruction of records, receiving stolen property or any other offense... (c) The prospective bidder or proposer has been convicted under state or federal antitrust statutes. (d) The prospective bidder or proposer has committed a violation of a contract provision... (e) The prospective bidder or proposer does not carry workers' compensation or unemployment insurance as required by statute.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0575","citation":"OAR 137-047-0575(3)","quote":"A Contracting Agency may attribute improper conduct of a Person or its affiliate or affiliates having a contract with a prospective Offeror to the prospective Offeror for purposes of Debarment where the impropriety occurred in connection with the Person's duty for or on behalf of, or with the knowledge, approval, or acquiescence of, the prospective Offeror.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.130","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1dd70d8f4adc13c6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-047-0575(2) allows contracting agencies to circumvent the three-year debarment limit in ORS 279B.130(1)(b) by making responsibility determinations that exclude previously debarred offerors, effectively creating indefinite disqualification.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.130","citation":"ORS 279B.130(1)(b)","quote":"A contracting agency may not debar a prospective bidder or proposer under this section for more than three years.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0575","citation":"OAR 137-047-0575(2)","quote":"Notwithstanding the limitation on the term for Debarment in ORS 279B.130(1)(b), a Contracting Agency may determine that a previously Debarred Offeror is not Responsible prior to Contract Award.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.130","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"139d6ad46ad96881","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 170-002-0135 makes competitive procurement mandatory for all emergency goods and services, but the statute only mandates competition for construction services that are not public improvements, allowing non-competitive emergency procurement for general goods and services.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.080","citation":"ORS 279B.080(1) and (2)","quote":"The head of a contracting agency, or a person designated under ORS 279A.075, may make or authorize others to make emergency procurements of goods or services in an emergency. The contracting agency shall document the nature of the emergency and describe the method used for the selection of the particular contractor. (2) For an emergency procurement of construction services that are not public improvements, the contracting agency shall ensure competition for a contract for the emergency work that is reasonable and appropriate under the emergency circumstances.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-002-0135","citation":"OAR 170-002-0135","quote":"The Treasurer will competitively procure Goods and Services in an emergency using a process that is reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.080","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"468d178ec0419486","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"Rule 736-147-0030 establishes a $100,000 dollar threshold for certain emergency procurement requirements that the statute does not contain, narrowing the applicability of documented competition and reporting procedures to only contracts above that amount.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.080","citation":"ORS 279B.080","quote":"The head of a contracting agency, or a person designated under ORS 279A.075, may make or authorize others to make emergency procurements of goods or services in an emergency. The contracting agency shall document the nature of the emergency and describe the method used for the selection of the particular contractor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-147-0030","citation":"OAR 736-147-0030(3)","quote":"For contracts above $100,000, when entering into an emergency contract, the department must: (a) Encourage competition that is reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances; (b) Award contract within 60 days following the event triggering the need for an emergency contract unless an extension has been granted by the director or designee","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.080","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b261c351e6e6ece","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-247-0165 narrows the scope of ORS 279B.025 by applying only to electronic goods and only to the Department and Authorized Agencies, whereas the statute applies to all contracting agencies and all goods.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.025","citation":"ORS 279B.025","quote":"All contracting agencies shall establish procurement practices that ensure, to the maximum extent economically feasible, the procurement of goods that may be recycled or reused when discarded.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0165","citation":"OAR 125-247-0165(2)","quote":"The Department and Authorized Agencies must procure Electronic Goods in a manner that includes consideration of the impact of the electronic goods upon the environment and public health","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7b47e194f1cee40e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Both rules reference a 'prohibition against revocation' in ORS 279B.120(3) that does not exist; the statute allows revocation but only prohibits it after advertisement has been issued.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0550","citation":"ORS 279B.120(3)","quote":"Despite the prohibition against revocation of prequalification in ORS 279B.120(3), an Authorized Agency may determine that a prequalified Offeror is not Responsible before Contract Award.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0550","citation":"ORS 279B.120(3)","quote":"Notwithstanding the prohibition against revocation of prequalification in ORS 279B.120(3), a Contracting Agency may determine that a prequalified Offeror is not Responsible prior to Contract Award.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.120","citation":"ORS 279B.120(3)","quote":"If a contracting agency subsequently discovers that a prospective bidder or proposer that prequalified under subsections (1) and (2) of this section is no longer qualified, the agency may revoke the prequalification upon reasonable notice to the prospective bidder or proposer, except that a revocation is invalid as to any contract for which an advertisement for bids or proposals has already been issued.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb07b87ff1c28d56","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services","department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 731-146-0220 declares implementation of ORS 279C.110(9), but ORS 279B.015 provides that public contracting under Chapter 279B is not subject to Chapter 279C except as provided in ORS 279C.320—leaving no authorization for the rule to implement 279C.110(9).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.015","citation":"ORS 279B.015","quote":"Except as provided in ORS 279C.320, public contracting under this chapter is subject to ORS chapter 279A, but not ORS chapter 279C.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-146-0220","citation":"OAR 731-146-0220","quote":"ORS 279A.050(3), ORS 279B.015, ORS 279B.080, ORS 279C.110(9), ORS 279C.320","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"92b64c09f8b76121","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"Rule section (3) applies only to services contracts, but statute ORS 279B.210 applies to all public contracts and all solicitations for public contracts generally.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.210","citation":"ORS 279B.210","quote":"a contracting agency shall take reasonable measures to ensure that no person who prepares or assists in the preparation of solicitation documents, specifications, plans or scopes of work, and no business with which the person is associated, realizes a material competitive advantage in a procurement that arises from the agency's use of the solicitation documents, specifications, plans or scopes of work","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0690","citation":"OAR 125-247-0690(3) title and text","quote":"Contractor Advantage; Services Contract; Exception. An Authorized Agency must comply with ORS 279B.040, including but not limited to the following: (a) No Appearance of Contractor Advantage. If an Agency enters into a contract with a contractor to advise or assist the Agency in developing specifications...the Agency may not accept an Offer from that contractor or its affiliate","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d49a0c4ca65ff748","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule uses appearance-based standard (whether reasonable person would believe advantage exists), while statute focuses on actual material competitive advantage.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.210","citation":"ORS 279B.210","quote":"realizes a material competitive advantage","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0690","citation":"OAR 125-247-0690(3)(a)","quote":"if a reasonable person would believe that, by giving the advice or assistance, the contractor or affiliate would have or would appear to have an advantage in the Procurement","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"45a24865fc452f4f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-246-0321(2)(b) expands beyond recycled products already made from recycled materials to include virgin materials 'which may be recycled or reused when discarded,' and omits the statute's required condition that recycled products be 'functionally equal' to virgin products.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.280","citation":"ORS 279B.280","quote":"encourage the use of recycled products whenever economically feasible, if the quality of a recycled product is functionally equal to the same product manufactured with virgin resources","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0321","citation":"OAR 125-246-0321(2)(b)","quote":"Develop purchasing practices that, to the maximum extent economically feasible, assure purchase of materials which are recycled or which may be recycled or reused when discarded.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b56fe98ae0b86d74","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-006-0045 restricts sole-source procurements to six specific categories (advertising, bond counsel, event speakers, conferences, memberships, trade missions), while the statute allows sole-source procurements for any goods or services meeting the statutory findings of fact without limiting to specific categories.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.075","citation":"ORS 279B.075(1)","quote":"A contracting agency may award a contract for goods or services without competition if...determines in writing, in accordance with rules adopted under ORS 279A.065, that the goods or services, or class of goods or services, are available from only one source.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-006-0045","citation":"OAR 123-006-0045","quote":"The Department may procure goods or services for the following subjects without competition: (1) Advertising and Promotion....(2) Bond Counsel....(3) Event Speakers....(4) Conferences, Meetings, Events....(5) Organizational Memberships....(6) Foreign Trade Missions.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2b765ef0deb9c9c0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-247-0690 directs exceptions to the 'State Chief Procurement Officer' while Rule 137-047-0560 directs them to the 'Director of the Department of Administrative Services' (matching the statute's 'Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services'), creating conflicting guidance on where agencies must apply for exceptions under ORS 279B.040(2).","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0690","citation":"125-247-0690(3)(b)(A)","quote":"Before awarding a contract for the advice or assistance of a contractor described in subsection (3)(a), the Agency must request an exception from the State Chief Procurement Officer, if the Agency wishes to later accept an Offer from the Provider.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0560","citation":"137-047-0560(3)","quote":"the agency must apply to the Director of the Department of Administrative Services, as permitted by ORS 279B.040(2), for an exemption from the disqualification from the ability to submit a bid or proposal.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.040","citation":"ORS 279B.040(2)(a)","quote":"the state contracting agency, before awarding a contract for the advice or assistance, shall apply to the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services for an exception to the prohibition set forth in subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.040","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c7b743dca509c2e7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services","department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Two implementing rules establish conflicting deadlines for filing protests: one requires 7 days prior to Closing, the other requires 10 days prior to Closing.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0730","citation":"OAR 125-247-0730(2)","quote":"a prospective Offeror must deliver a Written protest to the Authorized Agency not less than seven (7) Days prior to Closing","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0730","citation":"OAR 137-047-0730(2)","quote":"a prospective Offeror must deliver a Written protest to the Contracting Agency not less than ten (10) Days prior to Closing","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.405","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4245c681db0b2eeb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services","department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule claims ORS 279B.120(3) contains 'the prohibition against revocation of prequalification,' but the statute text provided (ORS 279B.125(3)) explicitly permits revocation: 'the contracting agency may revoke or may revise and reissue the prequalification after reasonable notice.'","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.125","citation":"ORS 279B.125(3)","quote":"the contracting agency may revoke or may revise and reissue the prequalification after reasonable notice to the prequalified prospective bidder or proposer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0550","citation":"125-247-0550(1)","quote":"Despite the prohibition against revocation of prequalification in ORS 279B.120(3), an Authorized Agency may determine that a prequalified Offeror is not Responsible before Contract Award.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.125","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"be6c76ccdbcb5925","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule authorizes agencies to verify disclosure information and require contractors to maintain minimum worker levels over the contract term, which the statute does not authorize.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.112","citation":"ORS 279B.112(1)-(2)","quote":"A state contracting agency that receives a personnel deployment disclosure from a bidder or proposer under subsection (1) of this section may consider the personnel deployment disclosure in evaluating a bid or proposal if the contracting agency states in the solicitation documents for a procurement that the state contracting agency will consider a personnel deployment disclosure. The state contracting agency may give a preference to a bid or proposal that states that the bidder or proposer will employ more workers within this state than a competing bid or proposal if the bids or proposals otherwise suit the state contracting agency's specifications for the procurement equally well.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0318","citation":"OAR 125-246-0318(5)","quote":"The Agency may: (a) Verify the information stated in the Disclosure Form before awarding a public contract; and (b) Require that the contractor maintain a minimum number of workers and jobs over the term of the contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.112","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"abe3e001cfac1589","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 125-247-0296 declares it implements ORS 279B.140 (which addresses only price agreements) but the rule's operative text broadly applies mandatory use requirements to 'Department Price Agreements, service agreements, and sales agreements' — types of contracts beyond the statute's scope.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0296","citation":"125-247-0296(1)","quote":"Mandatory Use Contracts, for the purposes of this Rule and including Department Price Agreements, service agreements, and sales agreements, may be established...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0296","citation":"frontmatter","quote":"ORS 279B.140","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.140","citation":"ORS 279B.140 (title)","quote":"Price agreements","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e5e05d9a8c2d58fd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule expands the definition of 'Special Circumstances' beyond the statute's specific list by adding an independent, broader definition that would cover any circumstance making services 'incapable of being managed, utilized or dealt with successfully'—a standard more general and subjective than the statute's specific examples.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.036","citation":"ORS 279B.036(1)(b)","quote":"Special circumstances may include, but are not limited to, circumstances in which: (A) The terms under which the contracting agency receives a grant or other funds for use in a procurement require the contracting agency to obtain services through an independent contractor; (B) Other state or federal law requires the contracting agency to procure services through an independent contractor; (C) The procurement is for services that are incidental to a contract for purchasing or leasing real or personal property, including service and maintenance agreements for equipment that is leased or rented; (D) The contracting agency cannot accomplish policy, administrative or legal goals, including but not limited to avoiding conflicts of interest or ensuring independent or unbiased findings in cases when using the contracting agency's existing personnel or persons the contracting agency could hire through a regular or ordinary process would not be suitable; (E) The procurement is for services to which the provisions of ORS 279B.080 apply; (F) The procurement is for services, the need for which is so urgent, temporary or occasional that attempting to perform the services with the contracting agency's own personnel or resources would cause a delay that would frustrate the purpose for obtaining the services; or (G) The services that the contracting agency intends to procure will be completed within six months after the date on which the contract for the services is executed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0110","citation":"OAR 125-247-0110(3)(b)","quote":"Special Circumstances include any circumstances, conditions or occurrences that would make the Services, if performed by the Agency's employees, incapable of being managed, utilized or dealt with successfully in terms of the quality, timeliness of completion, success in obtaining desired results, or other reasonable needs of the Agency. Special Circumstances may include, but are not limited to, the follow circumstances: (A) Expertise. The DPO approves a determination that the Agency lacks the specialized capabilities, experience, or technical or other expertise necessary to perform the Services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.036","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ad5eae1f9b23ce34","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute makes rejection discretionary ('may be rejected'), but the rule makes certain rejections mandatory ('shall reject') based on specific criteria.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.100","citation":"ORS 279B.100(1)","quote":"Any solicitation or procurement described in a solicitation may be canceled, or any or all bids or proposals may be rejected in whole or in part, when the cancellation or rejection is in the best interest of the contracting agency as determined by the contracting agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0640","citation":"OAR 137-047-0640(1)(b)","quote":"The Contracting Agency shall reject an Offer upon the Contracting Agency's finding that the Offer: (A) Is contingent on the Contracting Agency's acceptance of terms and conditions (including Specifications) that differ from the Solicitation Document; (B) Takes exception to terms and conditions (including Specifications) set forth in the Solicitation Document; (C) Attempts to prevent public disclosure of matters in contravention of the terms and conditions of the Solicitation Document or in contravention of applicable law; (D) Offers Goods or Services that fail to meet the Specifications of the Solicitation Document; (E) Is late; (F) Is not in substantial compliance with the Solicitation Document; or (G) Is not in substantial compliance with all prescribed public Procurement procedures.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0640","citation":"OAR 137-047-0640(1)(c)","quote":"The Contracting Agency shall reject an Offer upon the Contracting Agency's finding that the Offeror: (A) Has not been prequalified under ORS 279B.120 and the Contracting Agency required mandatory prequalification; (B) Has been Debarred as set forth in ORS 279B.130 or has been disqualified under OAR 137-046-0210(3) (Disqualification); (C) Has not met the requirements of ORS 279A.105, if required by the Solicitation Document; (D) Has not submitted properly executed Bid or Proposal security as required by the Solicitation Document; (E) Has failed to provide the certification of non-discrimination required under ORS 279A.110(4); or (F) Is non-Responsible.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.100","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5827055cb1b20eeb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 170-002-0300 declares it implements ORS 279B.400 but its operative text applies to 'Exempt Procurements and Contracts, and Procurements and Contracts for Goods and Services' which are broader categories than the 'special procurements' that ORS 279B.400 governs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-170-002-0300","citation":"OAR 170-002-0300(1)","quote":"This rule applies to both Exempt Procurements and Contracts, and Procurements and Contracts for Goods and Services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-002-0300","citation":"OAR 170-002-0300 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279B.400, ORS 279B.405, ORS 279B.410, ORS 279B.415, ORS 279B.420, ORS 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.400","citation":"ORS 279B.400 (title and scope)","quote":"Protests and judicial review of approvals of special procurements","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f767b5b9049f6db4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"Rule 736-146-0012 declares it implements ORS 279B.005, but the operative text defines no terms from that statute (which defines 'Invitation to bid', 'Request for proposals', 'Responsible bidder', and 'Responsive bid') and instead defines procurement thresholds and methods ('Direct Award', 'Formal Procurement', 'Intermediate Procurement') not found in that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-736-146-0012","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.010, ORS 279A.025, ORS 279B.005, ORS 282.020 & ORS 279A.025(3)(k)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.005","citation":"ORS 279B.005","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a905c8219e5ab55","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]},{"summary":"The statute applies to all contracting agencies subject to specified exemptions, but the rule restricts application to state contracting agencies only, excluding local agencies not otherwise exempt.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.030","citation":"ORS 279B.030(1)","quote":"before conducting a procurement for services with an estimated contract price that exceeds $250,000, a contracting agency shall:","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0110","citation":"OAR 125-247-0110(2)(a)","quote":"Before conducting a Procurement for Services, a State Contracting Agency, as defined in ORS 279A.010, (for purposes of this Rule, Agency) must, in the absence of a Feasibility Determination under Section (3) of this Rule, conduct a Written Cost Analysis","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7602b93a92838570","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-247-0760 declares it implements ORS 279B.425 but its operative text refers to another rule (OAR 137-047-0745) and makes a statement about the State Chief Procurement Officer without engaging the statute's subject matter of review procedures for prequalification and debarment decisions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0760","citation":"OAR 125-247-0760","quote":"ORS 279B.425","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.425","citation":"ORS 279B.425","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.425","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"833bb8caa933b3dc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute establishes a narrow exception to the seven-day notice requirement when 'seven days is impractical,' but both rules broaden this to allow a shorter notice period whenever 'circumstances justify prompt execution of the Contract,' a much more permissive standard.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.135","citation":"ORS 279B.135","quote":"unless the contracting agency determines that seven days is impractical under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0610","citation":"OAR 125-247-0610(1)","quote":"unless the Authorized Agency determines that circumstances justify prompt execution of the Contract, in which case the Authorized Agency may provide a shorter notice period","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0610","citation":"OAR 137-047-0610(1)","quote":"unless the Contracting Agency determines that circumstances justify prompt execution of the Contract, in which case the Contracting Agency may provide a shorter notice period","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.135","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"75709d4cd932009a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services","department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-247-0265(3) states state agencies \"must comply with ORS 200.035\" but the statute requires them to document actions AND consider certified businesses, and only for contracts of $10,000 or more.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.065","citation":"ORS 279B.065(2)","quote":"A state contracting agency that awards a public contract with a contract price of $10,000 or more using a method permitted under this section shall document in the state contracting agency's procurement file the actions the state contracting agency takes to: (a) Comply with ORS 200.035; and (b) Consider for the procurement businesses or enterprises that the Certification Office for Business Inclusion and Diversity certifies under ORS 200.055.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0265","citation":"OAR 125-247-0265(3)","quote":"All State Contracting Agencies must comply with ORS 200.035 and applicable related Department statewide policy.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"721e7b1a5c07ac57","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 167-001-0630 adds a purpose requirement (\"in order to avoid competition\") not stated in the statute's fragmentation prohibition.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.065","citation":"ORS 279B.065(3)","quote":"A contracting agency may not artificially divide or fragment a procurement so as to constitute a small procurement under this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-167-001-0630","citation":"OAR 167-001-0630","quote":"A procurement may not be artificially divided or fragmented so as to constitute a small procurement, pursuant to ORS 279B.065, or an intermediate procurement, pursuant to 279B.070, in order to avoid competition.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"718d6c457037ee72","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-business-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule cites ORS 279B.060(6)(d) regarding addenda modifying evaluation criteria for tiers, but ORS 279B.060(6) only contains subsections (a), (b), and (c). The actual statute provision governing addenda that modify criteria before a tier begins is ORS 279B.060(10).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-047-0430","citation":"OAR 137-047-0430(3)(b)","quote":"an Addendum that modifies the evaluation criteria, selection process or procedure for any tier of competition under a multistep sealed Bid or a multi-tiered or multistep sealed Proposal issued in accordance with ORS 279B.060(6)(d) and OAR 137-047-0261","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.060","citation":"ORS 279B.060(10)","quote":"After opening proposals, a contracting agency may issue or electronically post an addendum to the request for proposals that modifies the criteria, rating process and procedure for any tier of competition before the start of the tier to which the addendum applies","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d038c5f966328d5a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule limits cost analysis requirements to state contracting agencies only, while the statute applies to all contracting agencies and explicitly contemplates both state and local agencies with different reporting requirements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.033","citation":"ORS 279B.033(2)(b)","quote":"If the contracting agency conducts a procurement under the conditions described in this paragraph, the contracting agency shall: (A) Keep a record of the cost analysis and findings that the contracting agency makes for each procurement the contracting agency conducts under this section, along with the basis for the contracting agency's decision to proceed with the procurement; and (B) Collect and provide copies of the records described in subparagraph (A) of this paragraph each calendar quarter to the local contract review board, if the contracting agency is a local contracting agency, or to the Emergency Board, if the contracting agency is a state contracting agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0110","citation":"OAR 125-247-0110(2)(a)","quote":"Before conducting a Procurement for Services, a State Contracting Agency, as defined in ORS 279A.010, (for purposes of this Rule, Agency) must, in the absence of a Feasibility Determination under Section (3) of this Rule, conduct a Written Cost Analysis","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.033","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a5447a4e29ab626","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a $250,000 contract value threshold that the statute does not mention, limiting the cost analysis requirement to larger procurements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.033","citation":"ORS 279B.033(1)","quote":"In the cost analysis required under ORS 279B.030, a contracting agency shall","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0110","citation":"OAR 125-247-0110(2)(c)","quote":"This Rule applies to a Procurement for Services that the Agency estimates will result in one or more Contracts with a value that exceeds $250,000 for the estimated term of the Contract(s)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.033","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"363af3082a717941","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the definition of 'Services' by excluding architects, engineers, and client services, categories the statute does not exclude.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.033","citation":"ORS 279B.033(1)(a)","quote":"In the cost analysis required under ORS 279B.030, a contracting agency shall: (a) Estimate the contracting agency's cost of performing the services","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0110","citation":"OAR 125-247-0110(2)(e)","quote":"\"Services\" has the meaning as defined in OAR 125-246-0110, except that for purposes of this Rule only: (A) \"Services\" does not include the services of an Architect, Engineer, Photogrammetrist, Transportation Planner, Land Surveyor or Provider of Related Services as defined in ORS 279C.100","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.033","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"59ce63232d05517e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule limits applicability to solicitations under specific statutes (279B.060, 279B.065, 279B.070, 279B.085, or 279A.200–279A.225), but ORS 279B.215 contains no such limitation and applies generally.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.215","citation":"ORS 279B.215(1)","quote":"A brand name or equal specification may be used when the use of a brand name or equal specification is advantageous to the contracting agency, because the brand name describes the standard of quality, performance, functionality and other characteristics of the product needed by the contracting agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0691","citation":"OAR 125-247-0691(1)","quote":"This Rule applies to Specifications for a Solicitation or class of Solicitations. For a Solicitation or class of Solicitations under ORS 279B.060, 279B.065, 279B.070, 279B.085, or 279A.200–279A.225, as provided in 279B.215","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f6383b1325111e15","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-247-0691 sections (4) and (5) impose monetary thresholds ($25,000 and $250,000) and multi-year periods (5 years) requiring additional procedural steps that do not appear in ORS 279B.215.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.215","citation":"ORS 279B.215(2)","quote":"A brand name specification may be prepared and used only if the contracting agency determines for a solicitation or a class of solicitations that only the identified brand name specification will meet the needs of the contracting agency based on one or more of the following written determinations","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0691","citation":"OAR 125-247-0691(4)","quote":"If the total purchase is $25,000 or more but does not exceed $250,000 and Supplies and Services are not available under an existing Mandatory Use Contract, the Authorized Agency must obtain informal, competitive Quotes, Bids, or Proposals","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0691","citation":"OAR 125-247-0691(5)","quote":"If an Authorized Agency intends to make several purchases of brand name-specified Supplies and Services from a particular manufacturer or seller for a period not to exceed five (5) years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2af0e4663537d4e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-247-0200(2) establishes a mandatory priority system requiring agencies to consider specific sources (Surplus Property, OFCs, Inmate Labor, OSBEs, Statewide Price Agreements) in priority order before using the methods in ORS 279B.050, but ORS 279B.050 makes no reference to these sources or requires any such priority ranking.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-247-0200","citation":"OAR 125-247-0200(2)","quote":"Agencies must make their Buy Decision in the priority order set forth in subsections (a) through (e) and in accordance with applicable law (Priority). If a higher Priority Source satisfies a Procurement and law requires the use of that Source, the Agency must procure through that higher Priority Source and may not elect to procure through a lower Priority Source. (a) Surplus Property... (b) Oregon Forward Contractors (OFCs)... (c) Inmate Labor... (d) Oregon Small Business Enterprises (OSBEs)... (e) Statewide Department Price Agreement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279b.050","citation":"ORS 279B.050(1)","quote":"a contracting agency shall award a public contract for goods or services by competitive sealed bidding under ORS 279B.055 or competitive sealed proposals under ORS 279B.060","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.050","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d4b20a1809cc4af7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-047-0600(3)(a) prohibits negotiation with any bidder, while OAR 170-002-0150(2) authorizes the Treasurer to negotiate contract terms with any offeror following closing; both rules claim to implement ORS 279B.055.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-047-0600","citation":"OAR 137-047-0600(3)(a)","quote":"A Contracting Agency shall not negotiate with any Bidder. After Award of the Contract the Contracting Agency and Contractor may only modify the Contract in accordance with OAR 137-047-0800.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-002-0150","citation":"OAR 170-002-0150(2)","quote":"Following the Closing, the Treasurer may negotiate any Contract terms or conditions with any Offeror if the Treasurer determines that negotiation is in the Treasurer's best interests.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.055","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b2b933680e3f72db","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-047-0270(3) prohibits contract amendments from exceeding $250,000 or 125% of original price, but ORS 279B.070(1) explicitly allows amendments to exceed $250,000 if done in accordance with rules.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.070","citation":"ORS 279B.070(1)","quote":"A contract awarded under this section may be amended to exceed $250,000 only in accordance with rules adopted under ORS 279A.065.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0270","citation":"OAR 137-047-0270(3)","quote":"but the cumulative amendments may not increase the total Contract Price to a sum that exceeds the higher dollar amount stated in ORS 279B.070 or one hundred twenty-five percent (125%) of the original Contract Price, whichever is greater.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.070","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f8f0fd58e09a12b6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 170-002-0125(3) prohibits contract amendments from exceeding $250,000 or 125% of original price, but ORS 279B.070(1) explicitly allows amendments to exceed $250,000 if done in accordance with rules.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.070","citation":"ORS 279B.070(1)","quote":"A contract awarded under this section may be amended to exceed $250,000 only in accordance with rules adopted under ORS 279A.065.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-002-0125","citation":"OAR 170-002-0125(3)","quote":"However, cumulative amendments to one Contract may not increase the total Contract price to a sum that exceeds the higher dollar amount stated in ORS 279B.070 or one hundred twenty-five percent (125%) of the original Contract price, whichever is greater.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.070","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"582641385a7efffd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-247-0270(2)(e) requires posting on OregonBuys with formal notice procedures, but ORS 279B.070(4) specifies seeking at least three informally solicited quotes, which indicates no formal notice requirement.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.070","citation":"ORS 279B.070(4)","quote":"a contracting agency shall seek at least three informally solicited competitive price quotes or competitive proposals","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-247-0270","citation":"OAR 125-247-0270(2)(e)","quote":"The Agency must post on OregonBuys or other Electronic Procurement System approved by the State Chief Procurement Officer a notice that it is seeking at least three Offers.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.070","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c5ed213bda18a579","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule adds requirement that bidders must comply with 'any rules and regulations that implement or enforce' tax laws, which the statute does not mention—it specifies only 'tax laws of the state or a political subdivision of the state, including ORS 305.620 and ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.110","citation":"ORS 279B.110(2)(e)","quote":"Complied with the tax laws of the state or a political subdivision of the state, including ORS 305.620 and ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0330","citation":"OAR 125-246-0330(2)(b)","quote":"the Bidder or Proposer has complied with the tax laws of this state or a political subdivision of this state, including ORS 305.620 and ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318, any tax provisions imposed by a political subdivision that apply to the Offeror or to the performance of the Contract, and any rules and regulations that implement or enforce those tax laws","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d5f6c0d6f02f7ce6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule adds requirement that bidders must comply with 'any rules and regulations that implement or enforce' tax laws, which the statute does not mention—it specifies only 'tax laws of the state or a political subdivision of the state, including ORS 305.620 and ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279b.110","citation":"ORS 279B.110(2)(e)","quote":"Complied with the tax laws of the state or a political subdivision of the state, including ORS 305.620 and ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-047-0640","citation":"OAR 137-047-0640(2)(b)","quote":"Tax laws include, but are not limited to, ORS 305.620, ORS chapters 316, 317 and 318, any tax provisions imposed by a political subdivision that apply to the Offeror or to the performance of the Contract, and any rules and regulations that implement or enforce those tax laws.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279b.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b9ce1a06d242b7ed","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-business-services-division","name":"Secretary of State, Business Services Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"279c","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":527,"candidates":[{"summary":"Both OAR 137-049-0810 and OAR 734-010-0420 omit the statutory protection for 'equitable adjustment' alongside damages, narrowing the scope of contractor rights protected from waiver.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.315","citation":"ORS 279C.315(1)","quote":"Any clause in a public improvement contract that purports to waive, release or extinguish the rights of a contractor to damages or an equitable adjustment arising out of unreasonable delay in performing the contract, if the delay is caused by acts or omissions of the contracting agency or persons acting therefor, is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0810","citation":"OAR 137-049-0810","quote":"Contracting Agencies shall not place any provision in a Public Improvement Contract purporting to waive, release, or extinguish the rights of a Contractor to damages resulting from a Contracting Agency's unreasonable delay in performing the Contract.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-010-0420","citation":"OAR 734-010-0420","quote":"Any clause in a Public Improvement Contract purporting to waive, release, or extinguish the rights of a Contractor to damages resulting from ODOT's unreasonable delay in performing the Contract is void and unenforceable, as against public policy.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.315","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f59475ae04ef9d19","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0290(1) requires bid security to be between 5% and 10%, but the statute allows up to 10% with no stated minimum.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.365","citation":"ORS 279C.365(5)","quote":"The security may not exceed 10 percent of the amount bid for the contract.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0290","citation":"OAR 137-049-0290(1)","quote":"If a Contracting Agency requires Bid or Proposal security, it shall be not more than 10% or less than 5% of the Offeror's Bid or Proposal","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cfa49d187fb5cad2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0550(1) requires bid security to be fixed at exactly 10%, but the statute allows discretion up to 10% with no mandatory fixed amount.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.365","citation":"ORS 279C.365(5)","quote":"The security may not exceed 10 percent of the amount bid for the contract.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0550","citation":"OAR 731-005-0550(1)","quote":"If ODOT requires Bid security, it shall be 10% of the Offeror's Bid.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f367bc4c62b0064","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule adds mandatory procedures (advertising requirements, protest provisions) for RFQs that the statute permits but does not require.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.405","citation":"ORS 279C.405(1)","quote":"A contracting agency may issue a request for information, a request for interest, a request for qualifications or other preliminary documents to obtain information useful in the preparation or distribution of a request for proposals.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0645","citation":"OAR 137-049-0645","quote":"When using an RFQ as the first step in a two-step solicitation process, in which distribution of the RFPs will be limited to the firms identified as most qualified through their submitted statements of qualification, Contracting Agencies shall first advertise and provide notice of the RFQ in the same manner in which RFPs are advertised, specifically stating that RFPs will be distributed only to the firms selected in the RFQ process. In such cases the Contracting Agencies shall also provide within the RFQ a protest provision substantially in the form of OAR 137-049-0450(5) regarding protests of the Competitive Range.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.405","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5da51417a7adc340","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rules require the disqualified person to notify the contracting agency of their appeal intent within three business days, but omit the statute's mandatory requirement that the contracting agency then notify the Director of DAS (for state agencies) or the local contract review board (for other agencies).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.445","citation":"ORS 279C.445","quote":"Immediately upon receipt of the notice of appeal: (1) A state contracting agency shall notify the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services. (2) All contracting agencies other than state contracting agencies shall notify the appropriate local contract review board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0370","citation":"OAR 137-049-0370(4)","quote":"For a Conduct Disqualification or a Disqualification under ORS 279A.110, the disqualified person must notify the Contracting Agency in Writing within three business Days after receipt of the Contracting Agency's notice of Disqualification if the Person intends to appeal the Contracting Agency's decision.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0710","citation":"OAR 731-005-0710(4)","quote":"For a Conduct Disqualification or a DBE Disqualification under ORS 279A.110, the disqualified Entity must notify ODOT in Writing within three business days after receipt of ODOT's notice of Disqualification if the Entity intends to appeal ODOT's decision.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f5cd73571b0d35d4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule sets a maximum fee of $12,500, while the statute sets it at $7,500.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.825","citation":"ORS 279C.825(1)(b)","quote":"However, in no event may a fee be charged and collected that is less than $250 or more than $7,500.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-025-0200","citation":"OAR 839-025-0200(2)","quote":"However, the fee must be no less than $250 nor more than $12,500 regardless of the contract price.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.825","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1fac9c175cd97779","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-048-0200(1)(c) and (d) require that the earlier contract be awarded under formal selection procedure, but the statute only requires that it be awarded under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065, which potentially encompasses other procedures.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.115","citation":"ORS 279C.115(2)","quote":"in an earlier contract with the consultant that was awarded under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-048-0200","citation":"OAR 137-048-0200(1)(c)","quote":"The Contracting Agency used either the formal selection procedure under OAR 137-048-0220 (Formal Selection Procedure) or the formal selection procedure applicable to selection of the Consultant at the time of original selection to select the Consultant for the earlier Contract","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-048-0200","citation":"OAR 137-048-0200(1)(d)","quote":"The Contracting Agency used either the formal selection procedure under OAR 137-048-0220 (Formal Selection Procedure) or the formal selection procedure applicable to selection of the Consultant at the time of original selection to select the Consultant for the earlier Contract","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.115","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"20a9e28eb45a5dee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-148-0200(1)(c) and (d) require that the earlier contract be awarded under formal selection procedure, but the statute only requires that it be awarded under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065, which potentially encompasses other procedures.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.115","citation":"ORS 279C.115(2)","quote":"in an earlier contract with the consultant that was awarded under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-148-0200","citation":"OAR 731-148-0200(1)(c)","quote":"ODOT used either the formal selection procedure under OAR 731-148-0220 (Formal Selection Procedure) or the formal selection procedure applicable to selection of the Consultant at the time of original selection to select the Consultant for the earlier Contract","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-148-0200","citation":"OAR 731-148-0200(1)(d)","quote":"ODOT used either the formal selection procedure under OAR 731-148-0220 (Formal Selection Procedure) or the formal selection procedure applicable to selection of the Consultant at the time of original selection to select the Consultant for the earlier Contract","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.115","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"281971e2a846b8fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-148-0205 authorizes direct contracts up to $250,000 through a Small Purchase Procedure without limitation to continuation of projects, which expands beyond ORS 279C.115(2)'s requirement that the contract be a continuation of a previously studied project.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.115","citation":"ORS 279C.115(2)","quote":"the new contract is a continuation of the project","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-148-0205","citation":"OAR 731-148-0205(1)","quote":"ODOT may use the Small Purchase Procedure described in this rule to award a Contract if the Estimated Fee does not exceed $250,000.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.115","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"da3d21a27950b73b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0370(1)(a)(D) narrows the disqualification ground by adding 'material' to 'failure to perform' when the statute requires no such materiality threshold.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.440","citation":"ORS 279C.440(2)(d)","quote":"A violation may include but is not limited to a failure to perform the terms of a contract or an unsatisfactory performance in accordance with the terms of the contract.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0370","citation":"OAR 137-049-0370(1)(a)(D)","quote":"A violation under this subsection (1)(a)(D) may include but is not limited to material failure to perform the terms of a contract or an unsatisfactory performance in accordance with the terms of the contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"06add678cd9377de","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0710(1)(a)(E) broadens the workers' compensation disqualification ground by requiring compliance with contractual requirements in addition to statutory requirements, while the statute specifies only statutory requirements.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.440","citation":"ORS 279C.440(2)(e)","quote":"The person does not carry workers' compensation or unemployment insurance as required by statute.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0710","citation":"OAR 731-005-0710(1)(a)(E)","quote":"The Entity does not carry workers' compensation or unemployment insurance in compliance with statutory and contractual requirements.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c579d9eaff4fdadb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0240 declares it implements ORS 279C.370 (subcontractor disclosure), but its operative text addresses only pre-offer conferences and never engages with disclosure requirements, subcontractor identification, thresholds, or any other requirement in ORS 279C.370.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0240","citation":"OAR 137-049-0240","quote":"ORS 279C.365 & 279C.370","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-279c.370","citation":"ORS 279C.370","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.370","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a3b67dcbcf002d39","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0470 declares it implements ORS 279C.370 (subcontractor disclosure), but its operative text addresses only substitute prime contractors under performance bonds and never engages with disclosure requirements, subcontractor identification, thresholds, or any other requirement in ORS 279C.370.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0470","citation":"OAR 137-049-0470","quote":"ORS 279C.365, 279C.370, 279C.375, 279C.380 & 279C.390","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.370","citation":"ORS 279C.370","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.370","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"25f473500f760bef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-025-0005(4) allows a 90-day pending period for outstanding information, which extends beyond the 60-day determination deadline specified in the statute.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.817","citation":"ORS 279C.817(3)","quote":"The commissioner shall make the determination within 60 days after receiving the request or 60 days after the requester has provided the commissioner with the information necessary to enable the commissioner to make the determination, whichever is later.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-025-0005","citation":"OAR 839-025-0005(4)","quote":"If the Bureau informs a requester that the Bureau has not received all the documents, records, or other information necessary to make a determination, the request will remain pending for 90 calendar days.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.817","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"db2ebef2937a9981","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule section (1) applies to suspensions of work, but the statute covers only 'termination of the contract'—suspension and termination are distinct concepts.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.665","citation":"ORS 279C.665","quote":"A contracting agency may provide in a public improvement contract detailed provisions under which the contractor shall be entitled, as a matter of right, to compensation upon termination of the contract on account of any reason considered to be in the public interest.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0900","citation":"OAR 137-049-0900(1)","quote":"In the event a Contracting Agency suspends performance of Work for any reason considered by the Contracting Agency to be in the public interest other than a labor dispute, the Contractor shall be entitled to a reasonable extension of Contract time, and to reasonable compensation for all costs, including a reasonable allowance for related overhead, incurred by the Contractor as a result of the suspension.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"57e8ed87736e32d9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0550 declares it implements ORS 279C.380 (Performance bond; payment bond), but the rule addresses bid security, which 279C.380 does not cover. The operative text never cites or engages with 279C.380, instead implementing 279C.365 and 279C.385 which govern bid security.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0550","citation":"OAR 731-005-0550","quote":"declared statutes_implemented (frontmatter, not operative text). If you quote this, quote ONLY the line below, not this heading:\nORS 279C.365, ORS 279C.380, ORS 279C.385, ORS 279C.390, ORS 279C.400","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-279c.380","citation":"ORS 279C.380","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.380","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c768bc2abaaceead","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0550 declares it implements ORS 279C.400 (competitive proposals), but the rule's operative text addresses only bid security for bids and never engages with the competitive proposal requirements or proposal security provisions of 279C.400.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0550","citation":"OAR 731-005-0550, Statutes/Other Implemented line","quote":"ORS 279C.365, 279C.380, 279C.385, 279C.390 & 279C.400","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.400","citation":"ORS 279C.400","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"331080f1688c950d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The statute requires delivery to one of three recipients (ODAS Director, local contract review board, or Director of Transportation depending on agency type), but the rule requires delivery only to the 'Contracting Agency's Contract Review Authority,' omitting the ODAS Director option.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.355","citation":"ORS 279C.355(1)","quote":"the contracting agency shall prepare and deliver to the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, the local contract review board or, for public improvement contracts described in ORS 279A.050 (3)(b), the Director of Transportation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0620","citation":"OAR 137-049-0620(3)","quote":"The evaluation must be delivered to the Contracting Agency's Contract Review Authority","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ef130a3e73fb4c6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The statute requires evaluations to be 'made available for public inspection,' but the rule does not address this public inspection requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.355","citation":"ORS 279C.355(3)(a)","quote":"Must be made available for public inspection","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0620","citation":"OAR 137-049-0620(3)","quote":"The evaluation must be delivered to the Contracting Agency's Contract Review Authority within 30 Days of the date the Contracting Agency \"accepts\" the Public Improvement project","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.355","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a0c07e9d64aceb56","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 279C.412 but contains only a cross-reference to another administrative rule without any operative text that actually engages with the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0160","citation":"OAR 125-249-0160","quote":"ORS 279C.412","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.412","citation":"ORS 279C.412","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.412","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"78fbc96ce70f32f7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0210 cites ORS 279C.340 for prequalification requirements, but ORS 279C.360(2)(c) specifies ORS 279C.430","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.360","citation":"ORS 279C.360(2)(c)","quote":"The date that prequalification applications must be filed under ORS 279C.430 and the class or classes of work for which bidders must be prequalified if prequalification is a requirement","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0210","citation":"OAR 137-049-0210(2)(d)(C)","quote":"The date that Persons must file applications for prequalification under ORS 279C.340, if prequalification is a requirement, and the class or classes of Work for which Persons must be prequalified","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"277ada42cb71e430","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-249-0320 declares it implements ORS 279C.360 but contains only rules about pre-closing modifications and withdrawals, which ORS 279C.360 does not address","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0320","citation":"OAR 125-249-0320 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279C.360, 279C.365, 279C.375 & 279C.395","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.360","citation":"ORS 279C.360","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f38c3b1fbe60e9be","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0320 declares it implements ORS 279C.360 but contains only rules about pre-closing modifications and withdrawals, which ORS 279C.360 does not address","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0320","citation":"OAR 137-049-0320 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279C.360, 279C.365, 279C.375 & 279C.395","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.360","citation":"ORS 279C.360","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5d27f4676f09f7e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0590 declares it implements ORS 279C.360 but contains only rules about pre-opening modifications and withdrawals, which ORS 279C.360 does not address","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0590","citation":"OAR 731-005-0590 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.065, ORS 279C.360, ORS 279C.365, ORS 279C.375 & ORS 279C.395","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-279c.360","citation":"ORS 279C.360","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.360","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2b002166665d491b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-048-0210(7) creates a $150,000 fee threshold not found in ORS 279C.110, requiring only 3 consultants to be contacted for informal selections under $150,000 versus 5 consultants for amounts from $150,000-$250,000, but the statute contains no such $150,000 breakpoint—only $100,000 and $250,000 thresholds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-048-0210","citation":"OAR 137-048-0210(7)","quote":"When the Estimated Fee in an informal selection procedure under this rule is expected not to exceed $150,000, the Contracting Agency is only required to provide the RFP under sections (2), (3) and (6) of this rule to three (3) prospective Consultants. If fewer than three (3) prospective Consultants are available, the Contracting Agency shall provide the RFP to all available prospective Consultants and shall maintain a written record of the Contracting Agency's efforts to locate available prospective Consultants for the RFP.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.110","citation":"ORS 279C.110(2) and (10)","quote":"ORS 279C.110(2): 'The contracting agency may adjust the procedures to accommodate the contracting agency's scope, schedule or objectives for a particular project if the estimated cost of the architectural, engineering, photogrammetric mapping, transportation planning or land surveying services for the project does not exceed $250,000.' ORS 279C.110(10): 'Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (1) of this section, a contracting agency may directly appoint a consultant if the estimated cost of the architectural, engineering, photogrammetric mapping, transportation planning or land surveying services for the project does not exceed $100,000.'","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f71bd29d0fa5ab7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 137-048-0270(2) imposes a mandatory minimum of three consultants for Price Agreements when the statute reserves the selection procedures to the contracting agency's sole discretion.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.120","citation":"ORS 279C.120(2)","quote":"the procedures that a contracting agency adopts for the screening and selection of consultants and the selection of a candidate under this section is within the sole discretion of the contracting agency","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-048-0270","citation":"OAR 137-048-0270(2)","quote":"A Contracting Agency shall select no fewer than three Consultants, when feasible.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"960b9cee8f9b28a5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule requires exhaustion of administrative remedies before court action, but statute permits immediate judicial action by adversely affected parties.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0450","citation":"OAR 137-049-0450(1)","quote":"An adversely affected or aggrieved Offeror must exhaust all avenues of administrative review and relief before seeking judicial review of the Contracting Agency's Contractor selection or Contract Award decision.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.460","citation":"ORS 279C.460(1)","quote":"Any bidder or proposer adversely affected or any trade association of construction contractors acting on behalf of a member of the association to protect interests common to construction contractor members may commence an action in the circuit court for the county where the principal offices of a contracting agency are located","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"201fea89248a3647","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule requires exhaustion of administrative remedies before court action, but statute permits immediate judicial action by adversely affected parties.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0690","citation":"OAR 731-005-0690(1)","quote":"An adversely affected Offeror must exhaust all avenues of administrative review and relief before seeking judicial review of ODOT's Contractor selection or Contract award decision.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.460","citation":"ORS 279C.460(1)","quote":"Any bidder or proposer adversely affected or any trade association of construction contractors acting on behalf of a member of the association to protect interests common to construction contractor members may commence an action in the circuit court","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dbcd109b14f00d22","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"Rule restricts 'adversely affected' status to the three apparent lowest bidders, but statute does not impose this numerical limitation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0690","citation":"OAR 731-005-0690(3)(c)","quote":"An Offeror is adversely affected only if the Offeror is one of the three apparent low Bidders.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.460","citation":"ORS 279C.460(1)","quote":"Any bidder or proposer adversely affected","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0853372a1d207f0a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule changes the statute's discretionary 'may' to a mandatory 'shall' for calculating compensation as a percentage of work completed when there is no unit or itemized pricing.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.660","citation":"ORS 279C.660(2)","quote":"May, with respect to any other work, be a percent of the contract price equal to the percentage of the work completed","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0900","citation":"OAR 137-049-0900(2)(b)","quote":"Unless the Work completed is subject to unit or itemized pricing under the Contract, payment shall be calculated based on percent of Contract completed","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.660","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2ec92d75186aa90d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule allows retention of unsuccessful bidders' security longer than the statute permits. The statute prohibits retention after the contract is 'duly signed,' but the rule requires return only after 'a Contract has been fully executed and all required bonds and insurance have been provided,' which could occur later.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.385","citation":"ORS 279C.385(3)","quote":"The contracting agency may return the bid security of unsuccessful bidders to them when the bids have been opened and the contract has been awarded, and may not retain the bid security after the contract has been duly signed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0290","citation":"OAR 137-049-0290(4)","quote":"A Contracting Agency shall return or release the Bid or Proposal security of all unsuccessful Offerors after a Contract has been fully executed and all required bonds and insurance have been provided, or after all Offers have been rejected.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.385","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7eea432904a6a2e3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 279C.555 (which requires withholding of retainage to be in accordance with ORS 701.420), but the rule's operative text only defines the term 'Subcontractor' and never engages with requirements for withholding retainage.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0720","citation":"OAR 812-002-0720","quote":"ORS 279C.555, ORS 701","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.555","citation":"ORS 279C.555","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.555","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c32e007ba8dd2725","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires adoption of procedures to screen and select persons for contracts involving 'architectural, engineering, photogrammetric mapping, transportation planning or land surveying services,' but the rule's licensing requirement in subsection (1)(b) applies only to architects, engineers, and land surveyors, omitting photogrammetric mapping and transportation planning professionals.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.105","citation":"ORS 279C.105(1)","quote":"shall adopt procedures to screen and select persons to perform architectural, engineering, photogrammetric mapping, transportation planning or land surveying services and related services","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0330","citation":"OAR 125-246-0330(1)(b)","quote":"for Contracts requiring the services of one or more architects, engineers, and land surveyors, these Consultants must be registered with the appropriate licensing boards","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"41357f794d11461c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-249-0800 declares it implements ORS 279C.545 but its operative text consists only of a cross-reference to another rule and does not engage with the statute's specific requirements for posting notices.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0800","citation":"OAR 125-249-0800","quote":"ORS 297C.505 - 279C.545, ORS 279C.800 - 279C.870","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.545","citation":"ORS 279C.545","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.545","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"841cabcbce9298af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0800 declares it implements ORS 279C.545 but its operative text requires only that 'all of the ORS Chapter 279C required Contract clauses' be included per a referenced checklist, without specifying what those clauses are or addressing the statute's specific requirements for posting notices with boldfaced 12-point type in a prominent place.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0800","citation":"OAR 137-049-0800","quote":"ORS 297C.505 - 279C.545, ORS 279C.800 - 279C.870","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.545","citation":"ORS 279C.545","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.545","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"827c377558366042","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule (1) omits the statute's exception for third-party judicial proceedings unrelated to labor disputes, narrowing when compensation is due.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.655","citation":"ORS 279C.655","quote":"other than a labor dispute or any third-party judicial proceeding relating to the work other than a suit or action filed in regards to a labor dispute","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0900","citation":"OAR 137-049-0900(1)","quote":"other than a labor dispute","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.655","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"24903faed88564ca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 137-049-0630(7) imposes a 7-calendar-day deadline for submitting written requests for a public hearing on exemptions, but ORS 279C.335(5) does not specify any such deadline.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ORS 279C.335","citation":"ORS 279C.335(5)(c)","quote":"The notice must state that in response to a written request, the contracting agency or state agency will hold a public hearing for the purpose of taking comments on the draft findings for an exemption from the competitive bidding requirement.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"oar-137-049-0630","citation":"OAR 137-049-0630(7)","quote":"Any written request for a public hearing must be submitted to the Contracting Agency or State Agency within seven (7) calendar days of the publication date of the original public notice.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"12da8f6c2134bb0f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-025-0320(2) treats payment by a surety or public agency as a violation, but ORS 279C.840(6)(d)(B) explicitly allows such payment as an exception to the prohibition in subsection (6)(a).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.840","citation":"ORS 279C.840(6)(d)(B)","quote":"This subsection does not prohibit: (A) Payments to a worker who is enrolled in any government-subsidized training or retraining program; or (B) A surety or public agency from paying the prevailing rate of wage.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-025-0320","citation":"839-025-0320(2)","quote":"A contractor or subcontractor violates ORS 279C.840(6)(a) and section (1) of this rule if another contractor, subcontractor, public agency, surety, or person pays the prevailing rate of wage or contributes any portion of the prevailing rate of wage that the contractor or subcontractor owes or pays to its workers for labor performed on a public works project.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.840","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"73ba9bfa86766411","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-025-0033(3) converts the statute's discretionary 'preferably shall be posted in the same place' requirement into a mandatory 'must be posted in the same location' requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.840","citation":"ORS 279C.840(5)","quote":"The notice preferably shall be posted in the same place as the notice required under subsection (4) of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-025-0033","citation":"839-025-0033(3)","quote":"The notice must be posted in the same location as the prevailing wage rate pursuant to section (1) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.840","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"79783caaa6ff7e0d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The administrative rules fail to explicitly carve out contractor violations from the compensation entitlements, contrary to the statutory exception in ORS 279C.670.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.670","citation":"ORS 279C.670","quote":"ORS 279C.650 to 279C.670 do not apply to suspension of the work or termination of the contract that occurs as a result of the contractor's violation of federal, state or local statutes, ordinances, rules or regulations in existence at the time the contract was executed or as a result of violations of the terms of the contract.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0900","citation":"OAR 137-049-0900(1)","quote":"In the event a Contracting Agency suspends performance of Work for any reason considered by the Contracting Agency to be in the public interest other than a labor dispute, the Contractor shall be entitled to a reasonable extension of Contract time, and to reasonable compensation for all costs, including a reasonable allowance for related overhead, incurred by the Contractor as a result of the suspension.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.670","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"492d0bef7fdda001","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0690 implements a 3 working day waiting period before ODOT's award becomes final, but ORS 279C.375(2) requires notice of intent to award be issued at least 7 days before awarding, and OAR 137-049-0395(3) requires the award not be final until 7 days after notice.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0690","citation":"OAR 731-005-0690(2)","quote":"ODOT's award shall not be final until the later of the following: (a) Three working days after the date of the notice","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.375","citation":"ORS 279C.375(2)","quote":"At least seven days before awarding a public improvement contract, unless the contracting agency determines that seven days is impractical under rules adopted under ORS 279A.065, the contracting agency shall issue to each bidder or post, electronically or otherwise, a notice of the contracting agency's intent to award a contract","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0395","citation":"OAR 137-049-0395(3)","quote":"The Contracting Agency's Award shall not be final until the later of the following: (a) Seven Days after the date of the notice","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.375","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d66a70055f9e4059","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The rule permits limited negotiation with the highest-ranked proposer on statement of work and contract price even when the RFP did not authorize negotiations, but the statute requires that negotiations be 'authorized by the request for proposals.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.410","citation":"ORS 279C.410(8)","quote":"the contracting agency shall award a public improvement contract to the responsible proposer whose proposal is determined in writing to be the most advantageous to the contracting agency based on the evaluation factors set forth in the request for proposals and, when applicable, the outcome of any negotiations authorized by the request for proposals","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0650","citation":"OAR 137-049-0650(3)(a)(B)","quote":"If the Contracting Agency did not permit negotiation in its RFP, the Contracting Agency may, nonetheless, negotiate with the highest-ranked Proposer, but may then only negotiate the: (i) Statement of Work; and (ii) Contract Price as it is affected by negotiating the statement of Work","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e19763bceadd23ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0820(2)(c) requires contractors to share interest earnings with subcontractors, while ORS 279C.560(5) only provides that earnings accrue to the contractor without imposing a sharing obligation.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0820","citation":"OAR 137-049-0820(2)(c)","quote":"When a Contractor on a Public Improvement Contract elects to have the Contracting Agency deposit the accumulated retainage in an interest-bearing account, the Contractor, within 30 days following payment of the final amount due for construction of the Public Improvement, shall pay to each subcontractor that performed work on the construction the subcontractor's proportional share of the interest earnings that accrued to the Contractor as a result of the election.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.560","citation":"ORS 279C.560(5)","quote":"Earnings on the account accrue to the contractor.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f21035dcf23fd163","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-010-0430(2) uses the standard 'extraordinary risk that is not typically associated' for rejecting alternatives, while ORS 279C.560(1)(c) requires 'good cause for the rejection that is based on unique project circumstances'—different and narrower grounds.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-734-010-0430","citation":"OAR 734-010-0430(2)","quote":"Unless a Contracting Agency that reserves an amount as retainage finds in writing that accepting a bond or instrument described in part (a) or (b) of this section poses an extraordinary risk that is not typically associated with the bond or instrument, the Contracting Agency, in lieu of withholding moneys from payment, shall accept from the Contractor:","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.560","citation":"ORS 279C.560(1)(c)","quote":"A contracting agency may reject bonds, securities or other instruments that a contractor submits under paragraph (a)(A) of this subsection or a surety bond that the contractor submits under paragraph (a)(B) of this subsection only if the contracting agency first finds in writing good cause for the rejection that is based on unique project circumstances.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb75aa1ae56f5a79","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-010-0430(4)(b) requires that 'the first $10,000 of retainage be held as cash, before the retainage bond takes effect,' a condition not found in ORS 279C.560, which permits surety bonds in lieu of retainage without such a cash floor requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-734-010-0430","citation":"OAR 734-010-0430(4)(b)","quote":"ODOT requires that the first $10,000 of retainage be held as cash, before the retainage bond takes effect.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.560","citation":"ORS 279C.560(7)","quote":"A contractor may deposit a surety bond for all or any portion of the amount of funds retained, or to be retained, by the contracting agency in substantially the form specified in ORS 701.435 (4).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4eac32ac0e3bbb4d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-025-0085(1) makes the commissioner's determination discretionary with 'may determine' language, while ORS 279C.860(1) mandates it with 'shall add' language, making an absolute statutory duty optional in the rule.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-025-0085","citation":"OAR 839-025-0085(1)","quote":"Under the following circumstances, the commissioner, in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act, may determine that a contractor or a subcontractor or a firm, limited liability company, corporation, partnership or association in which the contractor or subcontractor has a financial interest may not receive a contract or subcontract for a public works for a period of three years","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.860","citation":"ORS 279C.860(1)","quote":"The commissioner shall add a contractor's or subcontractor's name to the list after determining, in accordance with ORS chapter 183, that: (a) The contractor or subcontractor intentionally failed or refused to pay the prevailing rate of wage to workers employed upon public works; (b) The contractor failed to pay to the contractor's employees amounts required under ORS 279C.840 and a surety or another person paid the amounts on the contractor's behalf; (c) The subcontractor failed to pay to the subcontractor's employees amounts required under ORS 279C.840 and the contractor, a surety or another person paid the amounts on the subcontractor's behalf; (d) The contractor or subcontractor intentionally failed or refused to post the prevailing rates of wage as required under ORS 279C.840 (4); or (e) The contractor or subcontractor intentionally falsified information in the certified statements the contractor or subcontractor submitted under ORS 279C.845.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.860","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a9f49f5c6564d5e3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule extends the definition of 'Guaranteed Maximum Price' to alternative contracting methods beyond CM/GC services, while the statute defines GMP only for CM/GC.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.332","citation":"ORS 279C.332(4)","quote":"\"Guaranteed maximum price\" means the total price at which a construction manager/general contractor agrees to provide construction manager/general contractor services to a contracting agency in accordance with the terms and conditions and scope of work for a specific public improvement contract","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0610","citation":"OAR 137-049-0610(12)","quote":"For Alternative Contracting Methods other than the CM/GC Method, \"Guaranteed Maximum Price\" or \"GMP\" means the total maximum price provided to the Contracting Agency by the Contractor and accepted by the Contracting Agency that includes all reimbursable costs and fees for completion of the Contract Work and any particularly identified contingency amounts, as defined by the Public Improvement Contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.332","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fa4958120b2efaa7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 279C.306, but sections (2) and (3) addressing advance filing of planned public improvements and cost analyses do not engage with that statute, which covers only complaint procedures and administrative enforcement after violations are alleged.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-025-0008","citation":"OAR 839-025-0008, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279C.306","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.306","citation":"ORS 279C.306","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.306","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1b6f4b758235bf33","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"ORS 279C.835 requires notification whenever a contract subject to ORS 279C.800 to 279C.870 is awarded, but the implementing rule OAR 137-049-0360 only addresses disclosure and notification requirements for ITBs exceeding $100,000, potentially narrowing the scope of contracts subject to the notification requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.835","citation":"ORS 279C.835","quote":"Public agencies shall notify the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries in writing, on a form prescribed by the commissioner, whenever a contract subject to the provisions of ORS 279C.800 to 279C.870 has been awarded.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0360","citation":"OAR 137-049-0360(1)","quote":"Within two working hours after the Bid Closing on an ITB for a Public Improvement having a Contract Price anticipated by the Contracting Agency to exceed $100,000, all Bidders shall submit to the Contracting Agency a disclosure form","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.835","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"155bcca35bfda9c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-248-0130 declares implementation of ORS 279C.307 in its frontmatter, but the operative text (sections 1-2) addresses only selection procedures under ORS 279C.120 and never engages with the substance of ORS 279C.307 (restrictions on procuring oversight services from parties to the contract being overseen).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-248-0130","citation":"OAR 125-248-0130, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 279A.065, ORS 279C.100 - 279C.125, ORS 279C.307","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.307","citation":"ORS 279C.307","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.307","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5e797c64b6bd8e87","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of what \"public works\" does not include omits an entire statutory exclusion for private nonprofit entity renovations of publicly owned real property meeting specific conditions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.800","citation":"ORS 279C.800(6)(b)","quote":"\"Public works\" does not include: (A) Reconstructing or renovating privately owned property that a public agency leases; or (B) A private nonprofit entity's renovation of publicly owned real property that is more than 75 years old if: (i) The real property is leased to the private nonprofit entity for more than 25 years; (ii) Funds of a public agency used in the renovation do not exceed 15 percent of the total cost of the renovation; and (iii) Contracts for the renovation were advertised or, if not advertised, were entered into before July 1, 2003, but the renovation has not been completed on or before July 13, 2007.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-025-0004","citation":"OAR 839-025-0004(30)(b)","quote":"\"Public work,\" \"public works,\" or \"public works project\" does not include reconstructing or renovating privately owned property that a public agency leases.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.800","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e504de529d731ce","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0370 declares it implements ORS 279C.450 (the appeal procedure before the Director with 30-day decision deadline, de novo review, cost allocation, and judicial review limits), but the rule's operative text addresses only the disqualification decision at the contracting agency level and sets a 3-business-day appeal filing deadline—never engaging with any substantive requirement of ORS 279C.450.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0370","citation":"declared statutes","quote":"ORS 200.065, ORS 200.075, ORS 279A.110, ORS 279C.440, ORS 279C.445, ORS 279C.450, OL 2015 ch 565 (HB 3303)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.450","citation":"ORS 279C.450","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f342078beaba4c41","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 731-005-0710 declares it implements ORS 279C.450 (the appeal procedure before the Director with 30-day decision deadline, de novo review, cost allocation, and judicial review limits), but the rule's operative text addresses only the disqualification decision at ODOT's level and sets a 3-business-day appeal filing deadline—never engaging with any substantive requirement of ORS 279C.450.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-731-005-0710","citation":"declared statutes","quote":"ORS 200.065, ORS 200.075, ORS 279A.110, ORS 279C.440, ORS 279C.445, ORS 279C.450","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.450","citation":"ORS 279C.450","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6a6211cddea1bf05","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The statute allows a prequalified person to submit proof of prequalification in lieu of a prequalification application, but the implementing rule only addresses the rebuttable presumption and does not provide for or address this right to substitute proof.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.435","citation":"ORS 279C.435","quote":"the person may submit proof of the prequalification in lieu of a prequalification application as required by ORS 279C.430","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0220","citation":"OAR 137-049-0220(2)","quote":"If an Offeror is currently prequalified by either the Oregon Department of Transportation or the Oregon Department of Administrative Services to perform Contracts, the Offeror shall be rebuttably presumed qualified to perform similar Work for other Contracting Agencies.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.435","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0abb6593ae04a526","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 330-135-0020(2) applies the 50% threshold to 'insured value of the building,' while ORS 279C.527(1)(c) and (2)(a) reference 'value of the public building' without specifying insured value, potentially narrowing the scope of applicability.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.527","citation":"ORS 279C.527(2)(a)","quote":"if the cost of the reconstruction or major renovation exceeds 50 percent of the value of the public building","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-330-135-0020","citation":"OAR 330-135-0020(2)","quote":"major renovations for which the total contract price is $5,000,000 or more and at least 50 percent of the insured value of the building","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.527","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b4db4bf6a3d942c0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-energy"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0350(2)(c) and OAR 731-005-0620(2)(c) establish substantially different standards for permitting withdrawal of an offer based on errors, though both rules declare they implement the same statute.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0350","citation":"OAR 137-049-0350(2)(c)","quote":"A Contracting Agency may permit an Offeror to withdraw an Offer based on one or more clerical errors in the Offer only if the Offeror shows with objective proof and by clear and convincing evidence: (A) The nature of the error; (B) That the error is not a minor informality under this subsection or an error in judgment; (C) That the error cannot be corrected or waived under subsection (b) of this section; (D) That the Offeror acted in good faith in submitting an Offer that contained the claimed error and in claiming that the alleged error in the Offer exists; (E) That the Offeror acted without gross negligence in submitting an Offer that contained a claimed error; (F) That the Offeror will suffer substantial detriment if the Contracting Agency does not grant the Offeror permission to withdraw the Offer; (G) That the Contracting Agency's or the public's status has not changed so significantly that relief from the forfeiture will work a substantial hardship on the Contracting Agency or the public it represents; and (H) That the Offeror promptly gave notice of the claimed error to the Contracting Agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-005-0620","citation":"OAR 731-005-0620(2)(c)","quote":"ODOT may permit an Offeror to withdraw an Offer based on other errors only if the Offeror shows by clear and convincing evidence to the satisfaction of ODOT: (A) The nature of the error on the face of the Offer or documents submitted with the Offer, pursuant to the solicitation requirements; and (B) That the error is not a judgment error, minor informality or clerical error.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.395","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aee45f707df528af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"The statute requires that procurement documents for CM/GC services must state the contracting agency will conduct the procurement in accordance with model rules, but the implementing rule does not explicitly require or implement this statement requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.337","citation":"ORS 279C.337(2)(h)","quote":"State that the contracting agency will conduct the procurement in accordance with model rules the Attorney General adopts under ORS 279A.065 (3)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0690","citation":"OAR 137-049-0690(5)","quote":"The rule sections (5)(a) through (q) address various contract requirements but do not explicitly require that procurement documents include a statement that the procurement will be conducted in accordance with the model rules.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.337","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"60969d41fcb994ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0200's operative text references ORS 279C.375(3)(b), but that statute is not included in the rule's declared statutes to be implemented.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0200","citation":"OAR 137-049-0200(1)(b)(A)","quote":"A statement that the Contracting Agency may reject any Offer not in compliance with all prescribed Public Contracting procedures and requirements, including the requirement to demonstrate the Bidder's responsibility under ORS 279C.375(3)(b)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0200","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.110, ORS 279A.120, ORS 279C.365, ORS 279C.370, ORS 279C.390, ORS 279C.505 - 580, ORS 279C.605, ORS 305.385, ORS 468A.720, ORS 701.005 & ORS 701.055","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aff6fc5d456ba512","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0840(4) sets settlement/judgment interest at 'the discount rate' but the statute requires 'two times the discount rate, but not to exceed 30 percent'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.570","citation":"ORS 279C.570(9)(a)","quote":"the amount due plus interest at the rate of two times the discount rate, but not to exceed 30 percent, on 90-day commercial paper in effect at the Federal Reserve Bank in the Federal Reserve district that includes Oregon on the date of the settlement or judgment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0840","citation":"OAR 137-049-0840(4)","quote":"Such interest, at the discount rate on 90-day commercial paper in effect at the Federal Reserve Bank in the Federal Reserve District that includes Oregon, shall accrue from the later of the Progress Payment Due Date, or thirty Days after the Contractor submitted a claim for payment to the Contracting Agency in Writing or otherwise in accordance with the Contract requirements.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.570","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85f183ce8e986bc1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 731-007-0570(1) requires notice to inform applicant of right to hearing under only ORS 279C.450, but statute requires informing of right to hearing under both ORS 279C.445 and ORS 279C.450","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-279c.430","citation":"ORS 279C.430(3)","quote":"If the contracting agency finds the applicant is not qualified as to any contracts covered by the rule, resolution, ordinance or other regulation, the notice must specify the reasons found under ORS 279C.375 (3)(b) for not prequalifying the applicant and inform the applicant of the right to a hearing under ORS 279C.445 and 279C.450.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-731-007-0570","citation":"OAR 731-007-0570(1)","quote":"If ODOT finds the applicant is not qualified, ODOT will issue a notice specifying the reasons found under ORS 279C.375 (3)(b) for not prequalifying the applicant and informing the applicant of the right to a hearing under ORS 279C.450.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.430","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3ed9ea39fe50893f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0630(7) requires written requests for public hearings to be submitted within 7 calendar days of notice publication, and provides that if no timely request is received, the agency is not required to hold a hearing. The statute states the notice 'must state that in response to a written request, the contracting agency or state agency will hold a public hearing' but does not specify a deadline for making requests or provide that the hearing is optional if no timely request is received.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0630","citation":"OAR 137-049-0630(7)","quote":"Any written request for a public hearing must be submitted to the Contracting Agency or State Agency within seven (7) calendar days of the publication date of the original public notice. If the Contracting Agency or State Agency does not receive a written request from an interested party to hold a public hearing, the Contracting Agency or State Agency may hold a public hearing, but is not required to hold a public hearing.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-279c.335","citation":"ORS 279C.335(5)(c)","quote":"The notice must state that in response to a written request, the contracting agency or state agency will hold a public hearing for the purpose of taking comments on the draft findings for an exemption from the competitive bidding requirement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-279c.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a43a58ff0f2427c5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"280","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 280.518's only listed implementing rule was repealed in 2026 but is still presented as a live relationship.","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-042-0165","citation":"OAR 123-042-0165, status: current, effective_date 2026-06-18","quote":"History: OBDD 11-2026, repeal filed 06/18/2026, effective 06/18/2026 ... (full text has no operative subsections)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f5382cca6f0191cc","cites_repealed":["oar-123-042-0165"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]}],"artifacts":["The rule's frontmatter effective_date field is actually its repeal date, mislabeled as if it were a new-version effective date."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"}]},{"ors_chapter":"283","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":46,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule OAR 122-070-0150(3) cites the wrong statute subsection for infrastructure financing purposes, pointing to ORS 283.085(4)(a)(B) and (C) when the statute's infrastructure definitions are actually in ORS 283.085(3)(b) and (c).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-122-070-0150","citation":"OAR 122-070-0150(3)","quote":"The Department will not disburse to a local government or other public body the proceeds of any Financing Agreement(s) entered into for the purposes of infrastructure described in ORS 283.085(4)(a)(B) or (C)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.085","citation":"ORS 283.085(3)(b) and (c)","quote":"(b) To finance infrastructure, including but not limited to telecommunications systems, systems for water, sewage, electricity, steam or natural gas and other equipment or improvements that are necessary or appropriate to support a facility that is, or will be, owned or operated by the state; (c) To finance infrastructure components that are, or will be, owned or operated by a local government agency of this state","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.085","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e9885ce07287dfa2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"Rules assert that 'State law requires a narrow interpretation' of official state business, but the statute requires only that activities advance lawful policies without mandating narrow construction","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-155-0010","citation":"OAR 125-155-0010(20)","quote":"State law requires a narrow interpretation of this term.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0500","citation":"OAR 125-155-0500(1)","quote":"The law requires that 'official state business' be narrowly construed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.310","citation":"ORS 283.310(2)","quote":"the state agency on whose behalf a motor vehicle is used must state in writing in advance of such use that the particular activity for which the vehicle is to be used advances the lawful policies of the agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"69e7f7698e9dd2c2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule's operative text addresses selling CNG fuel to private entities and the general public, which does not engage with ORS 283.327's statutory requirements governing state agency light-duty vehicle procurement decisions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-156-0000","citation":"OAR 125-156-0000","quote":"ORS 283.327","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.327","citation":"ORS 283.327","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.327","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"efb512a7a34b748d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute permits operation by anyone 18 or older (by prohibiting only those under 18), but the rule requires drivers to be 'over the age of 18 years,' which literally means greater than 18 and would exclude 18-year-olds.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.340","citation":"ORS 283.340(3)","quote":"By rule, the department shall prohibit the operation of a state-owned motor vehicle by any person under 18 years of age.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0200","citation":"OAR 125-155-0200(1)(b)","quote":"Are over the age of 18 years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.340","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"27efd889f9c208ff","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-155-0500(1) states that 'personal use...may coincide' with state business use and 'certain allowable activities of a personal nature may occur,' but OAR 125-155-0500(3) states categorically that 'No one has authority to permit any personal or family use of a state vehicle.'","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-155-0500","citation":"OAR 125-155-0500(1) and (3)","quote":"(1) The law requires that 'official state business' be narrowly construed. However, necessary official state business use may coincide with a personal use. When these uses do coincide, certain allowable activities of a personal nature may occur... (3) No one has authority to permit any personal or family use of a state vehicle or any vehicle driven at state risk.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.395","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b8ed3444fa7c123","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule applies the mileage standard to 'light fleet vehicles' while the statute applies it specifically to 'standard passenger vehicle,' expanding the scope of regulated vehicles.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.312","citation":"ORS 283.312(1)","quote":"A state agency or institution shall provide a state-owned standard passenger vehicle to each authorized driver of the state agency or institution who is required to drive a standard passenger vehicle on official state business a number of miles per month averaged over a six-month period that equals or exceeds the mileage limit","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0900","citation":"OAR 125-155-0900(2)","quote":"DAS must establish and enforce a minimum mileage standard for light fleet vehicles.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.312","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7582bbb81cdb09af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute requires agencies to 'shall sell and not replace' non-compliant vehicles, but the rule states vehicles are 'subject to reassignment or sale,' making the requirement discretionary rather than mandatory.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.312","citation":"ORS 283.312(6)","quote":"If a state agency or institution is not in compliance with subsection (3) of this section, the state agency or institution shall sell and not replace a standard passenger vehicle for each vehicle that fails to comply","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0900","citation":"OAR 125-155-0900(2)(d)","quote":"Vehicles that do not meet the exemption criteria or are not approved for exemption are subject to reassignment or sale.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.312","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"57fd54a4ae512316","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule establishes an exemption approval process requiring Fleet Management Advisory Council review and approval, which is not mentioned in the statute's exemption framework.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.312","citation":"ORS 283.312(5)","quote":"Subsection (3) of this section does not apply to a standard passenger vehicle if the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services finds under rules adopted under ORS 283.313 that, notwithstanding the number of miles per month the vehicle is driven, use of a state-owned standard passenger vehicle is necessary","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0900","citation":"OAR 125-155-0900(2)(c)-(d)","quote":"The Fleet Management Advisory Council must develop and approve exemption criteria, with the DAS Director providing final approval. The DAS Director or designee approves exemption requests.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.312","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a1302708eab44abb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rules define 'private or personal vehicle' to include rented, borrowed, and leased vehicles, but the statute specifies only 'privately owned vehicles.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.345","citation":"ORS 283.345","quote":"rules for the use of privately owned vehicles for official state business","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0010","citation":"OAR 125-155-0010(25)","quote":"\"Private or personal vehicle\" means a motor vehicle owned, rented, borrowed, leased, or otherwise lawfully in the possession and control of any entity other than the state.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bced4b836ba63a32","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule limits application to 'light fleet vehicles' while the statute applies to any 'standard passenger vehicle owned or assigned to the state agency or institution,' narrowing the statutory scope.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-283.314","citation":"ORS 283.314","quote":"A standard passenger vehicle owned or assigned to the state agency or institution must be replaced after the number of miles the vehicle has been driven exceeds the replacement mileage standard","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-155-0900","citation":"125-155-0900(3)","quote":"DAS must establish vehicle replacement criteria for light fleet vehicles in collaboration with the Fleet Management Advisory Council.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.314","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8d72e165e82f0cde","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-090-0000 declares it implements ORS 283.110, but the operative text establishes definitions for parking facilities and related terms, which does not engage with ORS 283.110's provisions about state agencies furnishing services, facilities and materials to other agencies upon requisition and charging for those services.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-090-0000","citation":"OAR 125-090-0000","quote":"ORS 98.805, ORS 190.240, ORS 276.591, ORS 283.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.110","citation":"ORS 283.110(1)","quote":"Subject to rules prescribed by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, any state agency shall, as its own facilities permit, furnish to any other state agency such services (including labor), facilities and materials as are requisitioned by the head of another agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cca8cb7bea2ddc48","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-090-0002 declares it implements ORS 283.110, but the operative text establishes purpose and authority for parking facility regulation, which does not engage with ORS 283.110's provisions about state agencies furnishing services, facilities and materials to other agencies upon requisition and charging for those services.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-090-0002","citation":"OAR 125-090-0002","quote":"ORS 98.805, ORS 190.240, ORS 276.591, ORS 283.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.110","citation":"ORS 283.110(1)","quote":"Subject to rules prescribed by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, any state agency shall, as its own facilities permit, furnish to any other state agency such services (including labor), facilities and materials as are requisitioned by the head of another agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"71e4e7cc634c398d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 584-001-0010 declares it implements ORS 283.110, but the operative text establishes public access procedures for licensure files, which does not engage with ORS 283.110's provisions about state agencies furnishing services, facilities and materials to other agencies upon requisition.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-584-001-0010","citation":"OAR 584-001-0010","quote":"ORS 183, ORS 192.440, ORS 283.110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-283.110","citation":"ORS 283.110(1)","quote":"Subject to rules prescribed by the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, any state agency shall, as its own facilities permit, furnish to any other state agency such services (including labor), facilities and materials as are requisitioned by the head of another agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-283.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"99fddeb25978fb8a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["teacher-standards-and-practices-commission"]}],"note":"No candidate inconsistencies found in either batch 1 or the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23) — the cleanest chapter across both pilots. Main finding both times was a systematic rule-title truncation artifact (see artifacts), not a substantive issue.","artifacts":["Systematic title-field truncation across ~15 OAR rules and one statute in this cluster (e.g. \"Approval and\" for \"Approval and Execution of Financing Agreements\"; ors-283.140's title is literally \"and\").","OAR 125-156-0000 legal_authority: [\"2010 OL Ch. 30\", \"Sec. 13\", \"14\"] — one citation incorrectly split into three array entries, with a bare orphaned \"14\"."],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"teacher-standards-and-practices-commission","name":"Teacher Standards and Practices Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"284","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":10,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 715-013-0064 declares it implements ORS 284.720, but the statute makes no provision for Signature Research Centers, their allocation to specific universities, or distribution percentages to institutions, which are the operative subjects of the rule.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0064","citation":"OAR 715-013-0064 Statutes/Other Implemented","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), ORS 284.720 & ORS 284.701","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-284.720","citation":"ORS 284.720","quote":"There is created within the State Treasury, separate and distinct from the General Fund, the Oregon Innovation Fund... Moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the Oregon Innovation Council for the purposes of making grants, loans and equity investments under ORS 284.742 and, subject to the approval of the Oregon Business Development Department, entering into contracts and grant agreements to carry out the recommendations included in the state plan developed under ORS 284.715.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-284.720","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"845c43442600250e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"eastern-oregon-border-economic-development-board","name":"Eastern Oregon Border Economic Development Board"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-film-and-video-office","name":"Oregon Film and Video Office"},{"slug":"oregon-tourism-commission","name":"Oregon Tourism Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"285c","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":585,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule definition of 'Renewable energy resource' omits hydroelectric generating facilities and renewable energy storage devices that the statute explicitly includes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.540","citation":"ORS 285C.540(4)(a)-(b)","quote":"\"Renewable energy resource\" includes, but is not limited to: (A) Straw, forest slash, wood waste or other wastes from farm or forest land, nonpetroleum plant or animal based biomass, ocean wave energy, solar energy, wind power, water power or geothermal energy; (B) A hydroelectric generating facility that obtains all applicable permits and complies with all state and federal statutory requirements for the protection of fish and wildlife and that: (i) Does not exceed 10 megawatts of installed capacity; or (ii) Qualifies as a research, development or demonstration facility; or (C) A renewable energy storage device as defined by the director by rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-600-0105","citation":"OAR 123-600-0105(18)","quote":"\"Renewable energy resource\" means energy derived from sources including but not limited to: straw, forest slash, wood waste or other wastes from farm or forest land, nonpetroleum plant or animal based biomass, ocean wave energy, solar energy, wind power, water power or geothermal energy.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.540","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"66e2decf63bd9d86","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 123-623-1950(1)(e) permits distributing community service fees to local organizations or programs without taxing authority, but ORS 285C.623(6) limits the required parties to county, city/port, and local taxing districts listed in ORS 198.010 or 198.180.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.623","citation":"ORS 285C.623(6)(a)","quote":"An agreement described in this subsection is effective only if: (A) The county and the city or port, if any, in which the eligible project is located have entered into the agreement; and (B) Local taxing districts listed in ORS 198.010 or 198.180, other than ports, that constitute at least 75 percent of the property tax authority of all local taxing districts listed in ORS 198.010 or 198.180, other than ports, that are in the code area in which the eligible project is located have entered into the agreement.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1950","citation":"OAR 123-623-1950(1)(e)","quote":"Local organizations or programs that provide a relevant and significant community service, even without taxing authority.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.623","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc69b021f202418e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the exemption period to be 'as provided in the written agreement,' but the rules establish a 7-year default period when the agreement contains no express provision on the number of years.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.409","citation":"ORS 285C.409(1)(c)","quote":"For a period of at least seven consecutive tax years but not more than 15 consecutive tax years, as provided in the written agreement between the business firm and the rural enterprise zone sponsor","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-285-3400","citation":"OAR 150-285-3400(2)","quote":"If there is no express written agreement between the certified business firm and the zone sponsor on the number of tax years for which the facility is to be exempt, the period for the exemption will be seven consecutive tax years.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-2000","citation":"OAR 123-690-2000(1)(f)(A)","quote":"(A) Shall be not less than 7 and not more than 15 years (but it is only 7 years if nothing is said on the matter)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.409","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"960ac99457fc984c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue","oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-6885 declares it implements ORS 285C.230(2), but the rule's operative text never addresses that provision. ORS 285C.230(2) concerns what the assessor is not responsible for determining; the rule only addresses what zone sponsors may impose and how sponsors enforce such conditions—not the assessor's exemption from responsibility.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-6885","citation":"OAR 123-674-6885, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.105(1)(i), ORS 285C.203, ORS 285C.225(1), ORS 285C.230(2), ORS 285C.235(2), ORS 285C.240(1)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.230","citation":"ORS 285C.230(2)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.230","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"472ba3c57839d599","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-123-674-6200(5)(c)(A) makes disqualification automatic/mandatory after 60 days of non-response, but the statute ORS 285C.235(1) gives the assessor discretion ('may disqualify').","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.235","citation":"ORS 285C.235(1)","quote":"If, after 60 days' notice in writing by registered or certified mail, the owner or lessee fails to comply with this demand, the assessor may disqualify the property under ORS 285C.240","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-6200","citation":"OAR 123-674-6200(5)(c)(A)","quote":"Causes disqualification: (A) Automatically, if the firm does not satisfactorily respond within 60 days, but without extra penalty","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"521d9623f87e7ffe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-623-1900(3) establishes different fee caps based on determination date ($500K-$2.5M for older projects), while ORS 285C.609(4)(b) states the fee 'shall...not exceed $3 million in any year' without date-based distinctions, and ORS 285C.609(5) requires annual inflation adjustments to that $3 million cap.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.609","citation":"ORS 285C.609(4)(b)(B)","quote":"The fee shall be in an amount equal to 25 percent of the property taxes that would, but for the exemption, be due on the exempt property in each assessment year, but not exceeding $3 million in any year.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1900","citation":"OAR 123-623-1900(3)(a)-(c)","quote":"The annual maximum of the community service fee is: (a) $500,000, or $2 million with an Urban Project, for any Approved Project by determination of the Commission before October 6, 2017, or with an SIZ; (b) $2.5 million, if the determination occurred on or after October 6, 2017, and the agreement was entered into before September 24, 2023; or (c) Otherwise, under ORS 285C.609(5)...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.609","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"33446d7132e29334","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The statute requires a mandatory 21-day waiting period before an agreement becomes effective following public posting on the sponsor's website, but the rule does not address this timing requirement or how it should be implemented.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.407","citation":"ORS 285C.407(1)(a)","quote":"An agreement between a zone sponsor and a business firm seeking exemption within the rural enterprise zone of the sponsor, including, but not limited to, a written agreement entered into under ORS 285C.403, may not become effective before the day that is 21 days following the date on which the zone sponsor makes the terms of the agreement public by posting them on the zone sponsor's website.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-2000","citation":"OAR 123-690-2000 (entire rule)","quote":"The rule contains no section addressing the 21-day waiting period, posting requirement, or the timing of when an agreement becomes effective following public posting, despite claiming to implement ORS 285C.407.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.407","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b158e5b20733ee01","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-3100(4)(b)(A) restricts additional qualified property to being placed in service during only the first or second year of the initial exemption, but ORS 285C.225(3)(b) permits additional property schedules for property placed in service up to two years after the first year that qualified property was placed in service.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.225","citation":"ORS 285C.225(3)(b)","quote":"The firm may not file an additional property schedule to claim an exemption for additional qualified property placed in service more than two years after the first year that qualified property of the firm was placed in service and subsequently granted exemption under ORS 285C.175, except pursuant to another authorization application.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-3100","citation":"OAR 123-674-3100(4)(b)(A)","quote":"Additional qualified property covered by each subsequent exemption necessitates its being: (A) Placed in service during the first or second year of the initial exemption","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.225","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"25fb1b1682c93f31","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule extends the exemption from the 10-year redesignation restriction to ports, but the statute limits it to county governments only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.250","citation":"ORS 285C.250(1)(c)","quote":"Paragraph (b) of this subsection does not apply to a county government if the terminated zone was also jointly sponsored by one or more cities or ports.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-4900","citation":"OAR 123-650-4900(2)(c)","quote":"other than a county or port if a port/city also sponsored the terminated zone and none of the new enterprise zone area was inside that terminated zone.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a1a8fcec5cc9e727","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 3700 omits the 'more than two years' timing requirement that the statute specifies for when the first renewal statement must be submitted after approval.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.165","citation":"ORS 285C.165(1)(a)","quote":"After the January 1, but on or before the April 1, that first occurs more than two years after the application for authorization is approved, an authorized business firm shall submit a written statement","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-3700","citation":"OAR 123-674-3700(2)(b)","quote":"Submits a written statement between January 1 and April 1 (as presently received by both the local zone manager and the county assessor's office) that","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.165","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"718a41c651a1d33d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 123-656-1400(3) cross-references ORS 285C.306(2)(b) provisions that govern RENZs, not RPRZs, when describing what lands can compose an RPRZ.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-656-1400","citation":"OAR 123-656-1400(3)","quote":"The RPRZ shall consist of contiguous area inside the jurisdictional territory of its city, port or county cosponsor(s), and such area may also be (but does not need to be) land of the Tribe under ORS 285C.306(2)(b)(A) or (C) or both.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.306","citation":"ORS 285C.306(2)(b) and (3)(a)","quote":"Subsection (2)(b) states conditions for RENZ designation: 'the department shall designate a reservation enterprise zone if the land for which zone designation is sought is: (A) Land held in trust by the United States for the benefit of the tribe; (B) Land for which an application to transfer the land into trust has been filed with the federal government and is pending; or (C) Land that is located within the boundaries of the tribe's reservation.' Subsection (3)(a) addresses RPZs: 'A reservation partnership zone includes lands within the jurisdiction of a cosponsoring city, county or port and may include both lands held in trust by the federal government for the benefit of the tribe and lands within the boundaries of the tribe's reservation.'","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.306","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"18a092b0cfa7d364","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule disqualifies all hotel/motel/destination resort firms regardless of property use; statute only disqualifies property operated as such.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.170","citation":"ORS 285C.170(1)(g)","quote":"The property is not to be operated as all or a part of a hotel, motel or destination resort","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-6000","citation":"OAR 123-674-6000(5)(b)","quote":"The firm is a hotel, motel or destination resort, regardless of the zone","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.170","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1f24ec5213585534","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule limits implementation of the 21-day posting requirement to agreements entered into on or after September 24, 2023, while the statute contains no such date limitation and applies to all agreements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.163","citation":"ORS 285C.163(1)(a)","quote":"An agreement between a zone sponsor and a business firm seeking exemption within the enterprise zone of the sponsor, including, but not limited to, an agreement entered into under ORS 285C.160, may not become effective before the day that is 21 days following the date on which the zone sponsor makes the terms of the agreement public by posting them on the zone sponsor's website.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-0700","citation":"OAR 123-674-0700(6)(a)","quote":"For any agreement entered into on or after September 24, 2023, it: (a) Shall take effect only in accordance with OAR 123-668-3000.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.163","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ddb11b97afdedbb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule allows business firms to be eligible based on being in a 'priority industry sector' identified by zone sponsor resolution, but the statute limits eligibility to firms providing goods, products or services to businesses or other organizations.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.135","citation":"ORS 285C.135(1)","quote":"To be an eligible business firm, a business firm must be engaged, or proposing to engage, within the enterprise zone, in the business of providing goods, products or services to businesses or other organizations through activities including, but not limited to, manufacturing, assembly, fabrication, processing, shipping or storage.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-1100","citation":"OAR 123-674-1100(1)","quote":"The Firm/applicant (when qualified) must: (a) Be a business firm under ORS 285C.050 consistent with OAR 123-674-1000(3); and (b) Be engaged in or proposing to engage in business, within the enterprise zone, of providing goods, products or services to other businesses or other organizations, through eligible activities; or (c) Be engaged in or proposing to engage in an industry sector identified by resolution of the governing body of the zone sponsor as a priority industry under a local or regional economic development strategy","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.135","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"01c2b9b45dbc277c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates that state and municipal corporations 'shall make' real property available for lease or purchase, but the rule requires only 'reasonable efforts' to make it available, converting a mandatory obligation into a discretionary standard.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.110","citation":"ORS 285C.110","quote":"shall make that real property available for lease or purchase by authorized business firms","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-668-1400","citation":"OAR 123-668-1400(1)(b)","quote":"Undertake reasonable efforts to make the real estate identified in subsection (a) of this section available for lease or purchase by authorized or qualified business firms","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c917b58d4ca200f9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-662-2000 declares it implements ORS 285C.140, but the operative text addresses only eligibility criteria (ORS 285C.135) and never engages with any authorization-process requirement from ORS 285C.140 (application contents, filing fee, preauthorization conference, approval procedures, amendments, late filing).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-662-2000","citation":"frontmatter","quote":"ORS 285C.095, ORS 285C.100, ORS 285C.135, ORS 285C.140, ORS 285C.180, ORS 285C.185, ORS 285C.245","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.140","citation":"ORS 285C.140","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d7012d96b9e7c2dc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule applies the 24-month operations-commencement requirement only to firms that applied for preliminary certification on or after July 1, 2011, but the statute applies this requirement to all annual certification applications regardless of when preliminary certification was obtained.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.506","citation":"ORS 285C.506(5)(a)","quote":"The business operations of the firm at the facility commenced at least 24 months before the date of application for annual certification but within 10 years before the end of the tax year preceding the date of application for annual certification","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-635-0350","citation":"OAR 123-635-0350(2)","quote":"The first such filing may occur not less than 24 months after the date, on which operations commenced according to section (1) of this rule (if the firm applied for preliminary certification on or after July 1, 2011)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.506","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"230ed11c727a90ae","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 123-674-6100(5)(b) cites ORS 285C.220(10) for late filing authority, but subsection (10) addresses fee deposits; the operative late filing provision is ORS 285C.220(9).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-6100","citation":"OAR 123-674-6100(5)(b)","quote":"On or before April 1 (but after January 1) of the next year, the authorized business firm may file very late under ORS 285C.220(10) without a fee to receive the remainder of an exemption minus the first year, provided the firm was in compliance with all applicable requirements in order for the exemption to have been in effect during that first year.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.220","citation":"ORS 285C.220(9)","quote":"Notwithstanding subsection (1) of this section, a claim for qualified property required to be listed on a property schedule included with the claim form pursuant to ORS 285C.225 may be filed under this section after January 1 and on or before April 1 following the assessment year after the year in which the qualified property was placed in service, if the authorized business firm demonstrates that it was otherwise qualified by April 1 of the previous year but for the failure to file a timely claim.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.220","citation":"ORS 285C.220(10)","quote":"Any filing fee collected under this section shall be deposited to the county general fund.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ef4c2325faf90be","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule conditions the zone sponsor's annual reporting obligation on a request, whereas the statute mandates unconditional submission of an annual report.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.415","citation":"ORS 285C.415(4)","quote":"The zone sponsor shall submit an annual report to the county assessor, the Department of Revenue and the Oregon Business Development Department setting forth for each facility of a certified business firm located in the enterprise zone that is exempt under ORS 285C.409 (1)(c): (a) The number of new and existing full-time employees at the facility; (b) The average wage and compensation of all employees at the facility; and (c) The amount of any payment in cash made by a certified business firm as a result of any additional requirement included in the written agreement under ORS 285C.403 (4)(c).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-5200","citation":"OAR 123-690-5200(5)(c)","quote":"The sponsor shall share copies of returned worksheets and corroborating information with the Department, the county assessor or other relevant officials, as requested and in accordance with subsection (b) of this section","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.415","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0a1d22eec32b219","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule specifies different triggering events for when confidentiality ends than the statute requires, extending the confidentiality period.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.620","citation":"ORS 285C.620","quote":"shall be confidential, until the county governing body gives notice of its intent to take official action on the application","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-2000","citation":"OAR 123-623-2000(1)","quote":"The Department shall not release any information identifying or pertaining to an expected Applicant, or to discussions among it, local governments, or the Department and members of the Commission, before: (a) Finalization of local approval for the proposed investment based on its being inside an SIZ; or (b) The County governing body issues a public notice for the public hearing under ORS 285C.609(4), if not using an SIZ.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.620","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6ee4fc0064041c70","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 123-656-2100(2) restricts boundary changes to areas in the same or contiguous county, but the statute allows amendment to include the entire area of a federal enterprise zone without such geographic restriction.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.085","citation":"ORS 285C.085(3)","quote":"The boundary of an existing state enterprise zone may be amended by the director at the request of the sponsor to include the entire area of a federal enterprise zone without regard to ORS 285C.115 (2).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-656-2100","citation":"OAR 123-656-2100(2)","quote":"Such a boundary change may add an area to the existing zone, only if the area is located in a county, in which the zone is already located, or in a contiguous county.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.085","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6d6ec9ae3d50256d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-690-4400 requires a location to be 'effectively farther than 10.4 miles' from I-5 (meaning 10.5+ miles when rounded), while ORS 285C.412(3)(b) requires only '10 or more miles'—narrowing the statute by raising the effective threshold.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.412","citation":"ORS 285C.412(3)(b)","quote":"the location of the facility is 10 or more miles from Interstate Highway 5","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-4400","citation":"OAR 123-690-4400(3)","quote":"Round distances to the nearest whole number, such that an applicable location must be effectively farther than 10.4 miles from I-5.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.412","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"020cfe8d19154faa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-690-4600 limits the 130% compensation requirement for qualified rural counties to exemptions beginning in 2018 or later, while ORS 285C.412(1)(c) imposes no such year limitation—narrowing the statute by excluding rural-county facilities certified before 2018.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.412","citation":"ORS 285C.412(1)(c)","quote":"or, if the facility is located in a qualified rural county, determined as of the date on which the written agreement between the zone sponsor and the business firm was executed, the annual average compensation must be at least 130 percent of the average wage in the county in which the facility is located","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-4600","citation":"OAR 123-690-4600(4)(b)","quote":"1.3 times the Current County Wage, but only if: (A) The first year of the 7 to 15-year exemption under ORS 285C.409(1)(c) begins in or after 2018 (regardless of when the business firm applied or was certified)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.412","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a65d5b0855463326","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-650-4200(3) provides six alternative criteria for demonstrating zone designation eligibility (economic transition, vacant land, strategy alignment, emerging industries, performance metrics, community-defined indicators) that do not match and are broader than the three specific criteria the statute establishes in ORS 285C.090(1): income levels, unemployment rate, or OBDD's case-by-case economic hardship determination.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.090","citation":"ORS 285C.090(1)","quote":"An enterprise zone must be located in a local area in which: (a) Fifty percent or more of the households have incomes below 80 percent of the median income of this state, as defined by the most recent federal decennial census; (b) The unemployment rate is at least 2.0 percentage points greater than the comparable unemployment rate for this entire state, as defined by the most recently available data published or officially provided and verified by the United States Government, the Employment Department, the Portland State University Population Research Center or special studies conducted under a contract with a regional academic institution; or (c) The Oregon Business Development Department determines on a case-by-case basis using evidence provided by the cities, counties or ports designating the enterprise zone that there exists a level of economic hardship at least as severe as that described in paragraph (a) or (b) of this subsection.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-4200","citation":"OAR 123-650-4200(3)","quote":"The zone sponsor(s) demonstrates a need for economic development in the Local Area by providing satisfactory evidence of one or more of the economic development need conditions listed in 285C.090(1): (a) Economic transition or restructuring, including but not limited to significant job losses, industry contraction, supply chain realignment, automation impacts and shifts in regional economic specialization, and lack of high-wage jobs in the Local Area. (b) The presence of underutilized, vacant or redevelopment-ready industrial or employment land, including brownfields, legacy industrial sites and properties requiring modernization to support productive use. ... (c) Alignment with adopted local, regional or statewide economic development strategies, land-use plans, infrastructure plans, workforce strategies or climate and energy transition goals, where enterprise zone designation would materially advance implementation. (d) Demonstrated opportunity to: (A) Support emerging, traded sector or innovation-driven industries; (B) Retain, reinvest in or modernize existing industries or facilities; or (C) Make investments that improve productivity, competitiveness, supply chain resilience or workforce quality; or (e) Demonstrated a performance-based development approach, including measurable objectives related to capital investment, wages, workforce development, retention or modernization outcomes, productivity improvement, redevelopment outcomes or other economic performance indicators. ... (f) Community-defined indicators of economic need or development potential.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.090","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"faca9a4dd028d51f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rules 1400(6) and 1525(1) require completed local approval and a locally endorsed SIZ agreement before or with an application to the Department, but ORS 285C.626(1) only requires the firm to 'apply to the Oregon Business Development Department' with 'information required by the department,' without conditioning the application on prior local approval.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.626","citation":"ORS 285C.626(1)","quote":"A business firm seeking the exemption under ORS 307.123 for a project the firm intends to install or construct within a strategic investment zone shall apply to the Oregon Business Development Department. The application shall be in the form and shall contain the information required by the department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1400","citation":"OAR 123-623-1400(6)","quote":"Section (5) of this rule is not applicable to proposed investments using an SIZ. All local processing and approval of such a project must be completed before submission of an Application.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1525","citation":"OAR 123-623-1525(1)","quote":"A complete Application must also include a locally endorsed and fully executed copy of the SIZ's standardized agreement that unambiguously identifies the Applicant and the proposed investment.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.626","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e1d3fc299f562fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-4200 declares it implements ORS 285C.210 but its operative text engages only ORS 285C.200, and the rule's subject—preventing firm qualification based on job losses elsewhere—does not address ORS 285C.210's subject of defining substantial curtailment of operations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-4200","citation":"OAR 123-674-4200 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.200, ORS 285C.210, ORS 285C.240","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-4200","citation":"OAR 123-674-4200(1)","quote":"Under ORS 285C.200(1)(d) and (4) an authorized business firm seeking an exemption in any enterprise zone may not qualify or remain qualified, if the firm transfers operations into the zone involving the closure or curtailment of operations and a drop in employment (job losses) elsewhere in this state","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"065086f936b0cbf5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Two rules implementing the same statute specify different waiting periods before designation documentation can be submitted: 45 days for enterprise zones under rule 123-650-4000, but 31 days for electronic commerce zones under rule 123-662-1000, despite ORS 285C.078 applying the same process to both.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-650-4000","citation":"OAR 123-650-4000(3)","quote":"Not less than 45 days after advising the Department, the Sponsor Governments may submit the enterprise zone re-/designation electronically","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-662-1000","citation":"OAR 123-662-1000(4)(c)","quote":"Not less than 31 days after advising the Department, the sponsor may submit its E-commerce designation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.078","citation":"ORS 285C.078(2)(b)","quote":"After the consultation required under this subsection, the zone sponsor or the governing body of the city may submit to the department documentation of the designation, at the time and in the manner required under ORS 285C.074 or 285C.102, as applicable","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.078","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9347affac913f9cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"One rule states the preliminary certification application must include a $500 fee; another rule states the Department may excuse or reduce the fee.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-635-0200","citation":"OAR 123-635-0200(2)","quote":"The preliminary certification application must include a fee of $500 in the form of a check or money order payable to the Department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-635-0400","citation":"OAR 123-635-0400(1)","quote":"The Department may excuse the fee or reduce the required amount","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.503","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c82cded4c19400f8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 123-674-4300(3)(b)(B) requires firm to dedicate 'at least equal to 25 percent' of property tax savings, while statute ORS 285C.205(3) requires deposit of an amount 'equal to 25 percent' of estimated tax savings.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.205","citation":"ORS 285C.205(3)","quote":"the firm deposits into an account established by the sponsor an amount equal to 25 percent of the estimated tax savings arising from the exemption for that year","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-4300","citation":"OAR 123-674-4300(3)(b)(B)","quote":"Dedicate to employee or workforce training an amount at least equal to 25 percent of the property tax savings through deposits into an account","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4503400ed3509574","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-0700(3)(a) allows written agreements to specify abatement periods of up to ten consecutive years, exceeding the five-year statutory maximum (three base years plus two additional years) set by ORS 285C.175(2)(a)(B).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.175","citation":"ORS 285C.175(2)(a)(B)","quote":"The property may be exempt from property taxation under this section for up to two additional tax years consecutively following the tax years described in subparagraph (A) of this paragraph","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-0700","citation":"OAR 123-674-0700(3)(a)","quote":"The agreement shall specify whether: (a) The total period of abatement is four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, or ten consecutive years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.175","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dd7a58ec6d6ca7e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 123-656-1600(2)(a) applies a stricter standard for previously existing facilities on the Tribe's reservation by requiring operations be 'not in any way the continuation,' whereas ORS 285C.300(2)(c)(A) permits facilities as long as the enterprise is not 'the same or substantially identical'—the rule narrows the condition.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.300","citation":"ORS 285C.300(2)(c)(A)","quote":"A facility that is used in a revenue-producing enterprise that is the same or substantially identical to the revenue-producing enterprise in which the facility was previously used within the boundaries of the same Indian reservation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-656-1600","citation":"OAR 123-656-1600(2)(a)","quote":"If located on the Tribe's reservation, the business operations need to be significantly different from and not in any way the continuation of what was undertaken at the facility before its latest acquisition","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.300","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4cfb12a8c628754b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule for application reconsideration omits the statutory requirement that a denied application after reconsideration must be resubmitted in full with a new submission date.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ORS 285C.650","citation":"ORS 285C.650(2)","quote":"If the qualified community development entity fails to provide the information or complete its application within the 15-day period, the application remains denied and must be resubmitted in full with a new submission date.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"oar-123-630-0080","citation":"OAR 123-630-0080(5)","quote":"If the applicant fails to provide additional information within 15 days of receipt of the denial, the application remains denied.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.650","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2848b89a868493db","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule significantly expands the required contents of item (f) to include a detailed qualified low-income community investment certification form with specific information requirements and a mandatory 20-day prior notice, which the statute does not require.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ORS 285C.650","citation":"ORS 285C.650(1)(f)","quote":"Information regarding the proposed use of proceeds from the issuance of the qualified equity investment.","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"oar-123-630-0050","citation":"OAR 123-630-0050(1)(f)","quote":"Information regarding the proposed use of proceeds from the issuance of the qualified equity investment on a form provided by the department. If the information described in the previous sentence is not submitted with the application, the applicant shall, at least 20 days prior to the date of the applicant proposes to make a qualified low-income community investment, submit to the department for review and approval of the qualified low-income community investment, an updated qualified low-income community investment certification on a form provided by the department. The information will include but is not limited to the following for each proposed qualified low-income community investment: (A) Location; (B) Sources and uses of funds; (C) Impacts to communities; (D) Revenues; (E) Number of jobs created and/or retained; and (F) Economic impacts (G) Name and contact information for: the investor making the qualified equity investment(s), the investor making the qualified low-income community investment(s), and all qualified active low-income community business receiving the qualified low-income community investment(s).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.650","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"44b008fc9fc9cdff","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-0700(3)(a) allows written agreements specifying abatement periods of 'four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, or ten consecutive years,' which exceeds the two additional years maximum the statute specifies.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-0700","citation":"OAR 123-674-0700(3)(a)","quote":"The agreement shall specify whether: (a) The total period of abatement is four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, or ten consecutive years; and","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.160","citation":"ORS 285C.160(2)","quote":"The period for which the qualified property is to continue to be exempt must be set forth in the agreement and may not exceed two additional tax years for which a school support fee must be paid in accordance with ORS 285C.162.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.160","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"865a307d224f1d93","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare implementation of ORS 285C.200, but ORS 285C.125(1) limits rule-making authority to a specific list of statutes that excludes 285C.200.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-7210","citation":"OAR 123-674-7210, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.125, ORS 285C.200","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.125","citation":"ORS 285C.125(1)","quote":"Adopt any rules the Department of Revenue considers necessary to implement ORS 285C.125, 285C.130, 285C.140, 285C.145, 285C.165, 285C.175, 285C.180, 285C.185, 285C.190, 285C.220, 285C.225, 285C.230, 285C.235 and 285C.240.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.125","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a8075516b204bffc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare implementation of ORS 285C.200, but ORS 285C.125(1) limits rule-making authority to a specific list of statutes that excludes 285C.200.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-7220","citation":"OAR 123-674-7220, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.125, ORS 285C.200","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.125","citation":"ORS 285C.125(1)","quote":"Adopt any rules the Department of Revenue considers necessary to implement ORS 285C.125, 285C.130, 285C.140, 285C.145, 285C.165, 285C.175, 285C.180, 285C.185, 285C.190, 285C.220, 285C.225, 285C.230, 285C.235 and 285C.240.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.125","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e3cd09f7e44464a0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-668-1100(3) requires sponsors to submit a report within six months following termination, but ORS 285C.105(1)(k) limits reporting to situations where the county assessor or Department requests it.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-668-1100","citation":"OAR 123-668-1100(3)","quote":"Within six months following the termination of an enterprise zone unless re-designated in its entirety, the sponsor of the terminated zone and the county assessor shall jointly submit to the Department of Revenue, Department and contact agency, a complete list of","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.105","citation":"ORS 285C.105(1)(k)","quote":"Upon request of the county assessor or the Oregon Business Development Department, conduct, or assist in conducting, annual reporting of enterprise zone activity","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"558db3381c8bfe58","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-690-5000(6)(c) allows exemption from disqualification when employment falls below minimum due to 'unforeseen coincidence of vacant positions...quit,' but the statute limits the exception to decreases caused by 'circumstances beyond the control of the business firm,' and employee quits are generally within a firm's control.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.420","citation":"ORS 285C.420(2)(b)","quote":"This subsection does not apply if the decrease in hiring or in annual average compensation is caused by circumstances beyond the control of the business firm, including force majeure.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-5000","citation":"OAR 123-690-5000(6)(c)","quote":"Unforeseen coincidence of vacant positions at the Facility Site, such as the case in which employees die, quit or have been fired for cause","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"132bc83a91d13f2c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule requires consent from 'all existing cosponsors' but the statute requires consent only from 'the existing zone sponsor' (singular).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.068","citation":"ORS 285C.068(1)","quote":"subject to the consent of the existing zone sponsor","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-0500","citation":"OAR 123-650-0500(4)","quote":"by adopting a resolution with applicable elements of OAR 123-650-4800(2) and submitting an executed copy of it to the Department with consent resolutions from all existing cosponsors","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.068","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3e92a45f28214fcd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule imposes a specific numeric threshold (-1 or less) for negative net migration where the statute only requires that the county 'has experienced a negative net migration' without specifying a minimum magnitude.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.400","citation":"ORS 285C.400(3)(c)","quote":"The population of the county has experienced a negative net migration, irrespective of natural population change, since the most recent federal decennial census occurring three or more years prior to the current estimated population figure for the county, based on available population statistics.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-0500","citation":"OAR 123-690-0500(2)(c)(C)","quote":"The county's change in total population minus natural population change is equal to or less than negative one (-1), based on the most recent estimates available from the Portland State University Population Research Center, in comparison to the latest decennial U.S. Census count of not less than three years earlier.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bde0cc0860357f94","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 123-623-1300 states that applicants are 'encouraged' to consider local hiring, while Rule 123-623-1500 requires applicants to 'Address the exhortation' as a mandatory commitment in their application.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-623-1300","citation":"OAR 123-623-1300(1)","quote":"Prospective Applicants and County/local governments are encouraged to consider creative and cooperative means to promote gainful work","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1500","citation":"OAR 123-623-1500(2)(c)(A)","quote":"Address the exhortation under ORS 285C.603 consistent with OAR 123-623-1300","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.603","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5737e238566216b9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule treats violations outside the enterprise zone as potentially material for compliance purposes if they benefit zone operations or represent firm-wide activities influencing the zone, whereas the statute limits the compliance requirement to 'laws applicable to the firm's operations inside the enterprise zone.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-674-7230","citation":"OAR 123-674-7230(1)","quote":"It is related to or part of actual operations of and by the business firm within the enterprise zone boundary, including firm-wide activities that actually influence affairs in the zone, as well as elsewhere that the firm operates, such that: (a) The Illegal Act(s) might still occur outside the zone and be material if derivable from or directly beneficial to operations of the firm in the zone","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.200","citation":"ORS 285C.200(1)(f)","quote":"the firm complies in all material respects with local, Oregon and federal laws applicable to the firm's operations inside the enterprise zone since the application for authorization and throughout the period of exemption","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8113db4e29f022c9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"oar-123-650-4000(3) imposes a 45-day waiting period between advisory to the Department and submission of designation documentation, but ORS 285C.065(3) does not mention any such waiting period and only requires that designation be made by resolution and then approved by the Department","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oars-123-650-4000","citation":"oar-123-650-4000(3)","quote":"Not less than 45 days after advising the Department, the Sponsor Governments may submit the enterprise zone re-/designation","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"ors-285c.065","citation":"ORS 285C.065(3)","quote":"Designation of an enterprise zone under this section shall be made by resolution of the governing body of the city, county or port and is not final until a positive determination in favor of the zone has been made by the Oregon Business Development Department under ORS 285C.074","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.065","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e47346e83a95345","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"Rule 1000(3) states a revoked zone's enterprise zone designation is permanently ineligible for E-commerce status, but rule 1000(7) permits re-designation as E-commerce when that same enterprise zone is later re-designated, directly contradicting the permanent ineligibility established in (3).","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-662-1000","citation":"OAR 123-662-1000(3)","quote":"The sponsor of an enterprise zone may revoke its status as an E-commerce zone by resolution(s), at any time, pursuant to which the Department shall establish the effective date of revocation, but that enterprise zone designation is not eligible to be an E-commerce zone.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-662-1000","citation":"OAR 123-662-1000(7)","quote":"As otherwise permissible, the Department may allow a zone sponsor of an E-commerce zone to re-designate itself as an E-commerce zone at the time it re-designates the enterprise zone under ORS 285C.250, if the zone was designated for electronic commerce within one year of the enterprise zone's termination in OAR 123-650-9100(1)(a).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.095","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"528fe787de4bd1cd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare they implement ORS 285C.045, which is solely a short-title provision that does not govern or authorize any substantive subject matter that the rules address.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-650-0001","citation":"OAR 123-650-0001 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.045, ORS 285C.050 – 285C.250","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-0001","citation":"OAR 123-674-0001 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.045, ORS 285C.050 – 285C.250","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.045","citation":"ORS 285C.045","quote":"ORS 285C.050 to 285C.250 shall be known and may be cited as the Oregon Enterprise Zone Act.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.045","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e80b6db7357eb59c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"ORS 285C.120(2) requires the Director to 'shall grant' waivers if statutory conditions are met, but OAR 123-650-1100(4) states the Director 'may waive,' making mandatory statutory grant discretionary.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.120","citation":"ORS 285C.120(2)","quote":"The Director of the Oregon Business Development Department shall grant the waiver if the director determines that: (a) The designation or the boundary change satisfies all other applicable requirements; and (b) Consistent with rules adopted by the Oregon Business Development Department, designation of a separate enterprise zone is not a practical option under the particular circumstances, that the overall distances involved can be effectively administered and that the waiver will further the goals and purposes of ORS 285C.050 to 285C.250.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-1100","citation":"OAR 123-650-1100(4)","quote":"In accordance with ORS 285C.120(2), the Director may waive a limitation in section (2) or (3) of this rule to allow even greater distance as part of an applicable enterprise zone designation, re-designation or boundary change","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ff4bd0c7b21080cc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-630-0100 declares it implements ORS 285C.656, which specifies three independent recapture scenarios, but the rule only addresses one scenario (the 85% investment requirement), completely omitting the federal recapture scenario and the redemption/repayment scenario.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.656","citation":"ORS 285C.656(2)","quote":"The Department of Revenue may recapture any portion of a tax credit allowed under ORS 315.533 if: (a) Any amount of federal tax credit that might be available with respect to the qualified equity investment that generated the tax credit under ORS 315.533 is recaptured under section 45D of the Internal Revenue Code. The department's recapture shall be proportionate to the federal recapture with respect to the qualified equity investment. (b) The qualified community development entity redeems or makes a principal repayment with respect to the qualified equity investment that generated the tax credit prior to the final credit allowance date of the qualified equity investment. The department's recapture shall be proportionate to the amount of the redemption or repayment with respect to the qualified equity investment. (c) The qualified community development entity fails to invest at least 85 percent of the purchase price of the qualified equity investment in qualified low-income community investments within 12 months of the issuance of the qualified equity investment and maintain the same level of investment in qualified low-income community investments until the last credit allowance date for the qualified equity investment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-630-0100","citation":"OAR 123-630-0100(2)","quote":"The Department of Revenue may recapture any portion of a tax credit if the qualified community development entity applies for and receives qualified equity investment authority under ORS 285C.653(2) and OAR 123-630-0090(2) and fails to invest at least 85 percent of the cash purchase price of the QEI in qualified active low-income community businesses that satisfy the requirements of ORS 285C.653(2) and OAR 123-630-0090(2) within 12 months of the issuance of the qualified equity investment and maintain such level of investment in qualified active low-income community businesses satisfying such requirements until the last credit allowance date for such qualified equity investment.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.656","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb27f02b4dec723b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-668-0100(1) defines 'Sponsor' by reference only to designations 'under ORS 285C.065 or 285C.250' and boundary changes 'under ORS 285C.115,' omitting historical sponsors who 'received approval of an enterprise zone under ORS 284.150 and 284.160 (1987 Replacement Part), under ORS 285C.080 before October 5, 2015, or under ORS 285C.085' per the statute, and also omitting 'a port that joined the enterprise zone under ORS 285C.068' mentioned in ORS 285C.050(20)(d).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.050","citation":"ORS 285C.050(20)","quote":"\"Sponsor\" means: (a) The city, county or port, or any combination of cities, counties or ports, that received approval of an enterprise zone under ORS 284.150 and 284.160 (1987 Replacement Part), under ORS 285C.080 before October 5, 2015, or under ORS 285C.085 or 285C.250 or that designated an enterprise zone under ORS 285C.065 or 285C.250; (b) The tribal government, in the case of a reservation enterprise zone; (c) The tribal government and the cosponsoring city, county or port, in the case of a reservation partnership zone; or (d) A city, county or port that joined the enterprise zone through a boundary change under ORS 285C.115(6) or a port that joined the enterprise zone under ORS 285C.068.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-123-668-0100","citation":"OAR 123-668-0100(1)","quote":"(1) \"Sponsor\" or \"zone sponsor\" includes the single city, port or county, or the cities, ports or counties, or any combination of these, collectively, as described in OAR 123-650 that: (a) Most recently designated or re-designated the enterprise zone under ORS 285C.065 or 285C.250; or (b) Joined the zone with a change to the zone boundary under ORS 285C.115.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.050","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2378ccb3a5ec87e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-662-1000 declares it implements ORS 285C.102 but only addresses enterprise zone sponsors, not cities, even though the statute explicitly requires documentation submission from both 'the sponsor of an enterprise zone or the governing body of a city.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.102","citation":"ORS 285C.102(1)","quote":"the sponsor of an enterprise zone or the governing body of a city shall submit to the Oregon Business Development Department documentation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-662-1000","citation":"OAR 123-662-1000(4)(a)","quote":"To designate an E-commerce zone: (a) The process begins with a zone sponsor's sending a formal (email advisory) to the Department","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.102","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"14538ddc87ecabb8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-662-1000(4)(c) makes submission discretionary ('may submit') where the statute requires it mandatory ('shall submit').","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.102","citation":"ORS 285C.102(1)","quote":"the sponsor of an enterprise zone or the governing body of a city shall submit to the Oregon Business Development Department documentation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-662-1000","citation":"OAR 123-662-1000(4)(c)","quote":"Not less than 31 days after advising the Department, the sponsor may submit its E-commerce designation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.102","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"154a9c70d458627b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule allows the effective date of a boundary change to be set at the Department's receipt of a complete resubmission when the Department deems revisions significant, but the statute only allows the effective date to be either the date the latest resolution was adopted or the date an outstanding boundary change requirement is satisfied.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.117","citation":"ORS 285C.117(4)(c)","quote":"the boundary change shall take effect on the date on which the latest resolution of the sponsoring city, county or port was adopted, or the date on which any outstanding requirement for the boundary change is satisfied, as stipulated in the department's determination","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-4900","citation":"OAR 123-650-4900(1)(d)(A)","quote":"The date coinciding with the Department's receipt of a complete resubmission (in terms of all items needing to be revised, modified or redone), inasmuch as the Department deems the extent of necessary revisions or the amount of time that has elapsed to have been significant","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c9446d7b365dcd35","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates that the school support fee rate 'shall' be 'at least 15 percent and not more than 30 percent,' but the implementing rules require only evidence of 'establishment' of a rate without stating this numeric threshold.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.067","citation":"ORS 285C.067(1)(b)","quote":"The governing bodies of the zone sponsor and each school district as defined in ORS 332.002 with territory in the enterprise zone shall set a rate for the school support fee imposed pursuant to ORS 285C.162 and 285C.405 that is at least 15 percent and not more than 30 percent.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-123-650-4100","citation":"OAR 123-650-4100(5)","quote":"Evidence of the establishment of a school support fee rate with every school district that has territory inside the zone boundary consistent with OAR 123-650-5300","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.067","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4d914b77ebd13b4e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The statute requires consultation with 'all local taxing districts,' but the rule excludes notice to taxing districts that have 'the same board or governing body as a Sponsoring Government,' adding an exception the statute does not contain.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.067","citation":"ORS 285C.067(1)(a)","quote":"The governing body of the city, county or port seeking to designate the enterprise zone shall consult with all local taxing districts with territory in the zone.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-650-5000","citation":"OAR 123-650-5000(2)(c)","quote":"Need not be sent to the Department or to any taxing district that is a Sponsoring Government, subdivision thereof, or a service district, urban renewal district, or the like that effectively has the same board or governing body as a Sponsoring Government.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.067","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7c6c2c79dd983b16","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule narrows the definition of renewable energy by requiring electricity generation, when the statute explicitly includes liquid, gaseous, or solid fuel for commercial sale as renewable energy.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.350","citation":"ORS 285C.350(2)","quote":"\"Renewable energy\" means electricity that is generated through use of a renewable energy resource, as defined in ORS 469B.130, or a liquid, gaseous or solid fuel for commercial sale or distribution that is one of the following: (a) A biofuel, such as biodiesel or ethanol, as those terms are defined in ORS 646.905, that is derived from an organic source.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-680-0001","citation":"OAR 123-680-0001(4)(a)","quote":"The qualified property must generate electricity to a significant degree from the combustion, harnessing or utilization of a renewable energy resource, but it may also produce (even for the most part) other energy forms, including but not limited to steam, heat or mechanical power","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e094f2a0012aa16","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule describes the sponsor of a rural renewable energy development zone as potentially being 'multiple counties,' but the statute specifies that when two or more counties apply jointly, only the identified county serves as sponsor.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.353","citation":"ORS 285C.353(5)","quote":"If the application for designation was made by two or more counties, the application shall identify which county shall serve as the sponsor of the zone.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-668-0100","citation":"OAR 123-668-0100(2)(b)","quote":"The county, multiple counties or city that sought designation of a rural renewable energy development zone under ORS 285C.353","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.353","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"11f1127cced95074","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule excludes all self-propelled machinery from exemption regardless of use, but statute allows property used exclusively in tangible goods production to qualify with only a $1,000 minimum cost, without explicitly excluding self-propelled devices.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.185","citation":"ORS 285C.185(1)(b)(A)","quote":"$1,000 or more, in the case of an item of personal property that is used: (A) Exclusively in the production of tangible goods","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-5200","citation":"OAR 123-674-5200(6)(d)","quote":"Regardless of any other provision of this division of administrative rules, the following property does not qualify for the exemption: ... (d) Any machinery, equipment or device that can roam freely by its own motive power under the control of an operator/driver, including but not limited to forklifts.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.185","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d5325ab1c3d6d237","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-623-2000 declares implementation of ORS 285C.615, but the operative text addresses confidentiality of Applications and pre-approval communications, not annual reports and their disclosure as the statute requires.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-623-2000","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.615 & 285C.620","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-285c.615","citation":"ORS 285C.615(1)","quote":"On or before April 1 of each tax year that property is exempt under ORS 307.123, the business firm that owns or leases the property shall submit a report to the Oregon Business Development Department","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.615","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e720108dfa9e9f01","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule requires the agreement to stipulate a rate for the school support fee, but the statute specifies the amount shall equal the rate set under a different statute (ORS 285C.067), not a rate stipulated in the agreement.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.162","citation":"ORS 285C.162(2)(b)","quote":"The amount of the school support fee of each affected school district shall equal the respective rate set under ORS 285C.067 (1)(b) multiplied by the property taxes that would, but for the exemption, be due on the qualified property for each property tax year to which the agreement relates.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-0700","citation":"OAR 123-674-0700(6)(b)","quote":"Is not valid unless stipulating a rate for the school support fee under ORS 285C.160(2) in accordance with OAR 123-668-4000 and 123-668-4100.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.162","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"23dc09151bce3145","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-650-4600(1)(a) requires only 25% of land added in a boundary change to be 'usable land' with required infrastructure and zoning characteristics, whereas ORS 285C.115(2)(a) requires that added land shall be 'zoned for use by eligible business firms that has or will have infrastructure facilities, road access, on-site water, on-site sewage disposal and necessary utility services'—allowing the rule to permit up to 75% of additions to lack these statutory characteristics.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-650-4600","citation":"OAR 123-650-4600(1)(a)","quote":"Usable land described in section (2) of this rule must comprise: (a) At least 25 percent of what is added (except as specially allowed by the Department)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.115","citation":"ORS 285C.115(2)(a)","quote":"Add land zoned for use by eligible business firms that has or will have infrastructure facilities, road access, on-site water, on-site sewage disposal and necessary utility services","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.115","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"de16161d225bba06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Two rules specify conflicting end dates for the First Source Hiring Agreement required by ORS 285C.606(6)(a) for Strategic Investment Program projects: one rule requires the agreement to end when the property tax exemption period concludes on December 31, while another rule requires it to end no sooner than June 30 of the final tax year.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-070-1600","citation":"OAR 123-070-1600(2)(b)","quote":"Under tax incentive programs listed in OAR 123-070-1150(2), when the property tax exemption period concludes, which shall occur: (A) On December 31 of the final year of exemption","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1500","citation":"OAR 123-623-1500(1)","quote":"A copy of a First Source Hiring Agreement according to OAR 123-070 that takes effect beginning no later than when any hiring for the Approved Project commences and ending no sooner than June 30 of the final tax year of Abatement.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.606","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3cf37958e4615a32","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-7730(2) allows director waivers for late agreement execution based on grounds (such as mistaken communications or inability to obtain agreement through no fault of the firm) that are not within the two grounds specified in ORS 285C.215(3) for waiving requirements.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.215","citation":"ORS 285C.215(3)","quote":"The rules adopted by the department shall provide for a waiver under this subsection when the director finds that: (a) The business firm is unable to employ persons referred under the agreement; or (b) The waiver would further the goals and purposes of applicable state policies.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-7730","citation":"OAR 123-674-7730(2)","quote":"(a) The Firm/applicant was using first-source services in a timely fashion, without having a formal agreement; (b) Mistaken communications, an absence of local contacts or the like hampered the ability or understanding of the Firm/applicant as to the agreement or the need to enter into it; (c) The Firm/applicant made a good faith effort to obtain an agreement, but it was misled or otherwise unable to readily obtain it through no fault of its own; or (d) Similar circumstances.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5ba8bdd6c3614c17","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"ORS 285C.215(2)(a) requires that if a firm has not entered into an agreement 'as of April 1 preceding the first tax year,' the sponsor shall inform the county assessor; however, the implementing rules do not explicitly reference or implement this April 1 deadline.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.215","citation":"ORS 285C.215(2)(a)","quote":"If a firm has not entered into a first-source hiring agreement when qualified property of the firm is first placed in service, as of April 1 preceding the first tax year for which the authorized business firm claims an exemption for qualified property under ORS 285C.175, the sponsor shall inform the county assessor that an agreement under this section has not been executed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-7710","citation":"OAR 123-674-7710(5)(b)","quote":"Inform the county assessor under ORS 285C.215(2)(a) of any such firm that might have failed to enter into such an agreement","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"10df2e10b87eb8e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"ORS 285C.155(2) requires conditions be established 'at the time authorization is sought,' but oar-123-668-2400(4) states that for non-urban zones, a policy 'does not need to be prospectively adopted' and 'may reflect the cumulative effect of the sponsor's relevant past actions.'","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.155","citation":"ORS 285C.155(2)","quote":"The sponsor, at the time authorization is sought by a business firm under ORS 285C.140, may establish other reasonable conditions with which the firm must comply in order for qualified property of the firm to be exempt under ORS 285C.175.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-668-2400","citation":"OAR 123-668-2400(4)","quote":"Except for conditions imposed by an urban enterprise zone under ORS 285C.150, such a policy does not need to be prospectively adopted, nor does it need to be based on official standards or formal documentation, and it may reflect the cumulative effect of the sponsor's relevant past actions.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.155","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"04bcd6a6755b73d1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule requires the written agreement to stipulate a rate for the school support fee, but the statute specifies that the fee amount is calculated using a rate set under ORS 285C.067(1)(b) without requiring that rate to be stipulated in the agreement itself.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.405","citation":"ORS 285C.405(2)(b)","quote":"The amount of the school support fee of each affected school district shall equal the respective rate set under ORS 285C.067 (1)(b) multiplied by the property taxes that would, but for the exemption, be due on the facility for each property tax year after the fifth year of exemption.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-2000","citation":"OAR 123-690-2000(6)(b)","quote":"Is not valid unless stipulating a rate for the school support fee under ORS 285C.403(4)(b) in accordance with OAR 123-668-4000 and 123-668-4100.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.405","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6894a074b6099ce3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"The rule inverts the fee structure: statute establishes $10,000 as base with $5,000 for rural areas; rule establishes $5,000 as base with $10,000 for urban projects. Same inversion applies to both fees.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.612","citation":"ORS 285C.612(2)(a)","quote":"$10,000, or $5,000 if the project is located in a rural area, upon application to the commission","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1800","citation":"OAR 123-623-1800(1)","quote":"$5,000; or (b) $10,000 for a proposed Urban Project","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-285c.612","citation":"ORS 285C.612(2)(b)","quote":"$50,000, or $10,000 if the project is located in a rural area, when the eligible project is determined by the commission to be eligible for the tax exemption","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1800","citation":"OAR 123-623-1800(2)","quote":"$10,000; or (b) $50,000 for a proposed Urban Project","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d150e4a0f5aef18f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule 123-674-5300(5)(g) requires property be placed back into service \"no more than 12 months before the first exemption year,\" but the statute only requires the 18-month idleness period to precede the first assessment year without specifying when service resumes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.190","citation":"ORS 285C.190(1)(a)","quote":"The real property machinery or equipment is idle: (A) At the time of application for authorization; and (B) For a period of at least 18 consecutive months before or after the time of application for authorization but preceding the first assessment year of the exemption","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-5300","citation":"OAR 123-674-5300(5)(g)","quote":"It is placed back into service no more than 12 months before the first exemption year pursuant to modifications.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b1ba3e2e658eca27","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-180-1060(1) requires the department to distribute funds 'annually' but omits the statute's mandatory time window of 'not sooner than July 10 and not later than July 15.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.635","citation":"ORS 285C.635(3)(a)","quote":"Not sooner than July 10 and not later than July 15 of the fiscal year immediately following the fiscal year in which the certification under subsection (2) of this section is made, the Department of Revenue shall distribute to each county","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-180-1060","citation":"OAR 125-180-1060(1)","quote":"The department shall distribute moneys from the Shared Services Fund to the eligible county annually.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.635","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"35ef0659542e96ec","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule requires application before 'any physical work' on exempt property, while the statute specifies application must occur before 'commencement of construction or installation,' which is narrower.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.403","citation":"ORS 285C.403(1)(a)","quote":"before the commencement of construction or installation of property or improvements at a location in a rural enterprise zone and before the hiring of employees","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-690-2300","citation":"OAR 123-690-2300(1)(a)","quote":"before hiring new employees at the Facility Site and before commencing any physical work, as described in OAR 123-690-4000(1)(a), on property that would be subject to the exemption","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.403","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e92d6ee0f228ade0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule defines 'business firm' directly instead of deferring to ORS 285C.050 as the statute instructs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.500","citation":"ORS 285C.500(1)","quote":"\"Business firm\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 285C.050.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-635-0100","citation":"OAR 123-635-0100(1)","quote":"\"Business firm\" means a person operating or conducting one or more trades or businesses for profit, and does not include any governmental agency, municipal corporation or nonprofit corporation, other than a people's utility district or a joint operating agency under ORS 262.005.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-635-0100","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285C.500 – 285C.506","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.500","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1027e316c372f9ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule adds requirement that facility operations must directly benefit a traded sector industry, which does not appear in the statute's definition of 'qualified location.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.500","citation":"ORS 285C.500(5)","quote":"\"Qualified location\" means any area that is: (a) Zoned for industrial use or is within the urban growth boundary of a city that has 15,000 or fewer residents; and (b) Located in a county that, during either of the two years preceding the date an application for preliminary certification is filed under ORS 285C.503, had both: (A) A county unemployment rate that was in the top half of county unemployment rates in this state; and (B) A county per capita personal income that was in the bottom half of county per capita personal incomes in this state.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-635-0150","citation":"OAR 123-635-0150(2)(b)(C)","quote":"Such that the Facility's business operations must directly benefit a traded sector industry under ORS 285C.010, regardless of other uses permitted under the particular zoning code ordinance.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.500","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"bb961220af8fe175","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-623-1100(9) narrows the statutory definition of 'Strategic investment zone' by limiting it to 'three existing' zones established before a specific date, whereas the statute allows for any geographic area established under ORS 285C.623.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.600","citation":"ORS 285C.600(9)","quote":"\"Strategic investment zone\" means a geographic area established under ORS 285C.623, within which the property of eligible projects may be exempt from property taxation under ORS 307.123.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-623-1100","citation":"OAR 123-623-1100(9)","quote":"SIZ means any of three existing strategic investment zones designated by the Commission at the request of the County pursuant to an agreement by sponsoring governments under ORS 285C.623(4) before September 24, 2023.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.600","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b3a1e26220e9ad7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-180-1020(2) incorrectly cites ORS 285C.600(2) as the source of the 'Eligible Project' definition, but that statute section defines 'Business firm,' not 'Eligible project.' The correct citation should be ORS 285C.600(4).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.600","citation":"ORS 285C.600(2) and ORS 285C.600(4)","quote":"(2) \"Business firm\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 285C.050. ... (4) \"Eligible project\" means a project that meets criteria established by the Oregon Business Development Commission to be exempt from property taxation under ORS 307.123.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-180-1020","citation":"OAR 125-180-1020(2)","quote":"\"Eligible Project\" is a project described in ORS 285C.600(2) for which the Oregon Business Development Commission has reported new hires or retained employees.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.600","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7a7711d5422761f4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-674-6880(7)(b) applies the April 1 employment requirement deadline to all suspended firms, but the statute limits this deadline to firms that received at least one year of exemption before suspension began.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.203","citation":"ORS 285C.203(2)(d)(B)","quote":"which must also be met on or before April 1 preceding the first tax year after the period of suspension if the qualified business firm received at least one year of exemption under ORS 285C.175 before the period of suspension began","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-674-6880","citation":"OAR 123-674-6880(7)(b)","quote":"During the suspension period, or before April 1 of the first year of the resumed exemption period, employment of the firm does not meet the minimum level set by the resolution, or as otherwise required under ORS 285C.200(1)(c)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.203","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"46fe2b8ab19da899","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule restricts RENZ redesignation to specific timeframes, contradicting statute's \"at any time\" language","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.245","citation":"ORS 285C.245(4)","quote":"A reservation enterprise zone designated, or a reservation partnership zone cosponsored, under ORS 285C.306 shall terminate in accordance with subsection (1) of this section but may be redesignated at any time under ORS 285C.306.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-656-1200","citation":"OAR 123-656-1200(5)(b)","quote":"Re-designated: (A) Concurrent with or after the July-1 termination date under ORS 285C.245(1)(a) and (4); or (B) Any time more than a year after a requested early termination under ORS 285C.245(2).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"88e2079762b13140","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule requires new RPRZ agreement rather than redesignation, narrowing statute's \"may be redesignated at any time\" standard","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.245","citation":"ORS 285C.245(4)","quote":"A reservation enterprise zone designated, or a reservation partnership zone cosponsored, under ORS 285C.306 shall terminate in accordance with subsection (1) of this section but may be redesignated at any time under ORS 285C.306.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-656-1400","citation":"OAR 123-656-1400(7)(c)","quote":"The Tribe and city, port or county may create a new RPRZ pursuant to or in replacement of a terminated one, based on a newly executed co-sponsorship agreement consistent with this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f9427d7a2bef74a5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 123-656-1000(6)(B) restricts hotel, motel, and destination resort businesses from exemption eligibility for RENZs and RPRZs, a categorical exclusion not stated in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.320","citation":"ORS 285C.320(3)","quote":"Exemptions and tax credits available in connection with an enterprise zone are available in connection with a reservation enterprise zone or a reservation partnership zone. In order for property within a reservation enterprise zone or a reservation partnership zone to be exempt under ORS 285C.175, the business firm and property must meet the requirements applicable to business firms and property in an enterprise zone.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-656-1000","citation":"OAR 123-656-1000(6)(B)","quote":"Neither a RENZ (designated after 2003) nor an RPRZ sponsor may elect or allow a hotel, motel or destination resort business to be eligible for the standard exemption.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2e7d3bd9af6dfe3b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 123-630-0050(1)(f) allows the information about proposed use of proceeds to be submitted after the initial application (at least 20 days prior to making the investment), whereas the statute ORS 285C.650(1) requires this information to be included in the application that must be submitted.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-285c.650","citation":"ORS 285C.650(1)","quote":"The entity must submit an application on a form that the department provides that includes: (a) The entity's name, address, tax identification number and evidence of the entity's certification as a qualified community development entity. (b) A copy of an allocation agreement executed by the entity, or its controlling entity, and the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund that includes the State of Oregon in its service area. (c) A certificate executed by an executive officer of the entity attesting that the allocation agreement remains in effect and has not been revoked or canceled by the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund. (d) A description of the proposed purchase price, structure and purchaser of the equity investment or long-term debt security. (e) The name and tax identification number of any person eligible to claim a tax credit, under ORS 315.533, allowed as a result of the certification of the qualified equity investment. (f) Information regarding the proposed use of proceeds from the issuance of the qualified equity investment. (g) A nonrefundable application fee of $20,000.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-123-630-0050","citation":"OAR 123-630-0050(1)(f)","quote":"Information regarding the proposed use of proceeds from the issuance of the qualified equity investment on a form provided by the department. If the information described in the previous sentence is not submitted with the application, the applicant shall, at least 20 days prior to the date of the applicant proposes to make a qualified low-income community investment, submit to the department for review and approval of the qualified low-income community investment, an updated qualified low-income community investment certification on a form provided by the department.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-285c.650","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c56bef5527b72edb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"286a","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":45,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule imposes mandatory submission dates (July 1 and December 1) for Facility Assessments and Long-Range Facility Plans with automatic disqualification for missing these dates, whereas the statute only requires submission 'with the application for the grant' without specifying these particular dates.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.801","citation":"ORS 286A.801(2)","quote":"A school district that seeks a grant under this section must prepare and submit a facilities assessment and a long-range facilities plan to the department with the application for the grant.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-027-0023","citation":"OAR 581-027-0023(2)","quote":"Districts shall submit their Facility Assessment and Long-Range Facility Plan as follows: (a) On the July 1 that precedes the November Funding Cycles in a biennium; and (b) On the December 1 that precedes the May Funding Cycles in a biennium.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-027-0023","citation":"OAR 581-027-0023(1)","quote":"Failure to submit a Facility Assessment and Long-Range Facility Plan will disqualify the District from participation in the OSCIM Program application for that Funding Cycle.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.801","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a68863e037d9315c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates the State Treasurer 'shall select the underwriters' but the rule states the State Treasurer 'may select underwriters,' converting a mandatory duty into discretionary authority.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.025","citation":"ORS 286A.025(7)","quote":"the State Treasurer shall select the underwriters for the sale of the bonds requested by the related agency","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-061-0300","citation":"OAR 170-061-0300(1)","quote":"OST may select underwriters for the State's bond programs either through a direct appointment and negotiated process with a single firm or with multiple firms or through the issuance of requests for proposals for a single firm or multiple firms","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"87f95188fe724c06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The rule's section (1) addresses underwriter selection, but ORS 286A.130 only covers bond counsel services and financial advisory services and contains no reference to underwriters.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.130","citation":"ORS 286A.130","quote":"286A.130 Bond counsel services; financial advisory services; Public Contracting Code.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-061-0300","citation":"OAR 170-061-0300 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 286A.025, ORS 286A.130, ORS 286A.132","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-061-0300","citation":"OAR 170-061-0300(1)","quote":"(1) Underwriters. OST may select underwriters for the State's bond programs either through a direct appointment and negotiated process with a single firm or with multiple firms or through the issuance of requests for proposals for a single firm or multiple firms.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.130","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c5d68a6ef4c0637e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The rule addresses procedures for lost, stolen, or destroyed bonds (post-issuance claims) but is declared to implement a statute that authorizes only rules for 'procedural or administrative requirements for the issuance of obligations,' which refers to the bond issuance process itself.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.005","citation":"ORS 286A.005(6)","quote":"The State Treasurer may adopt rules providing for the procedural or administrative requirements for the issuance of obligations, as defined in ORS 286A.100.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-061-0400","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 286A.005","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"319ef6771f761b1d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 286A.095, which specifies detailed calculation methods for debt limit compliance (credit enhancement bonds, interest, zero coupon bonds, defeased bonds, deductions), but the operative text of the rule addresses only definitions, acronyms, and notice submission procedures with no substantive engagement with the statutory calculation requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-170-055-0001","citation":"OAR 170-055-0001, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 286A.095, ORS 287A.195, ORS 287A.360 - 287A.380","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-286a.095","citation":"ORS 286A.095","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.095","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1fb8eb8c2c0971d5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"Rule 122-075-0100 references ORS 327.700 to 327.711 in its operative text as authorizing lottery bonds, but the declared statutes_implemented line does not include those sections.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-122-075-0100","citation":"OAR 122-075-0100(1)","quote":"Lottery bond financings authorized by ORS 286A.560 to 286A.585 and 327.700 to 327.711, issued by the State Treasurer with the concurrence of the Director of the Department of Administrative Services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-075-0100","citation":"OAR 122-075-0100 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 286A.045 - 286A.050, ORS 286A.560 - 286A.585, ORS 286A.710 - 286A.792, ORS 353.550 - 353.563; 2001 OL ch. 921 & 2003 OL ch. 11","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.585","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1fa64d34bafb8953","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 286A.772, which mandates the Department of Administrative Services include bond-related costs in the Governor's budget, but the operative text never addresses this requirement and instead focuses entirely on Infrastructure Finance Authority grant programs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-123-051-0100","citation":"OAR 123-051-0100 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 285A.098, ORS 286A.760 – 286A.772, ORS 401.910, 2013 OL Ch. 782","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-286a.772","citation":"ORS 286A.772","quote":"For each biennium in which Article XI-M bonds will be outstanding, the Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall include in the Governor's budget an amount that, when added to the amount on deposit in the Article XI-M Bond Fund and the Article XI-M Bond Administration Fund, is sufficient to pay the bond-related costs that are scheduled to come due in the biennium.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.772","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ccc4ff78bca2da15","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-business-development-department"]},{"summary":"ORS 286A.792 specifically concerns Article XI-N bonds, but the implementing rules define 'Bonds' broadly to include any bonds administered by DAS, expanding the scope beyond what the statute addresses.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.792","citation":"ORS 286A.792","quote":"For each biennium in which Article XI-N bonds will be outstanding, the Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall include in the Governor's budget","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-075-0110","citation":"OAR 122-075-0110(2)","quote":"Bonds mean any contractual undertaking or instrument of the State of Oregon to repay borrowed moneys that are administered for another State Agency by the Department of Administrative Services or for which the Department of Administrative Services provides administrative assistance","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.792","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"72d104189fc1e6c0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"Rule section (6) states top-tier districts receive grants up to $12,000,000, but section (7)(a) states they receive $12 million under a different condition, creating a thousand-fold discrepancy.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-581-027-0015","citation":"OAR 581-027-0015(6) and (7)(a)","quote":"(6) The Districts shall be ranked from the lowest Assessed Value per ADMw as the top ranked district to the highest Assessed Value per ADMw as the lowest rank and receive a grant as follows: (a) Districts ranked 1 through 50 based on Assessed Value per ADMw shall receive a grant up to $12,000,000; ... (7) A District's maximum grant shall be modified as follows: (a) If a District passes a local general obligation bond that is greater than or equal to $360 million, then the district shall receive a State Matching grant of $12 million regardless of the District's eligibility based on its ranking per Assessed Value per ADMw","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.796","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c57e814096933bd1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"OAR 122-075-0100(1) requires State Treasurer issuance with DAS Director concurrence, but ORS 286A.585(3) requires issuance only at the request of the Director of the Oregon Business Development Department—the rule drops the statutory requirement for OBDB Director's request.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-286a.585","citation":"ORS 286A.585(3)","quote":"Lottery bonds issued pursuant to this section shall be issued only at the request of the Director of the Oregon Business Development Department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-075-0100","citation":"OAR 122-075-0100(1)","quote":"Lottery bond financings authorized by ORS 286A.560 to 286A.585 and 327.700 to 327.711, issued by the State Treasurer with the concurrence of the Director of the Department of Administrative Services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-286a.585","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fae2d2bec645fadc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"}]},{"ors_chapter":"291","agencies":9,"rules_reviewed":33,"candidates":[{"summary":"DOJ's contract-review dollar thresholds are roughly double the statute's, and collapse the statute's 3-way category split into 2 categories.","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.047","citation":"ORS 291.047(1)-(2)","quote":"The Attorney General shall approve for legal sufficiency all personal services contracts, all architectural and engineering services contracts and all information technology contracts calling for payment in excess of $75,000 ... all public contracts not subject to subsection (1) ... that provide for payment in excess of $100,000...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0030","citation":"OAR 137-045-0030(1)(a)-(b)","quote":"...Public Contract that is for or includes the acquisition of Information Technology that requests or provides for payment in excess of $150,000... Any Public Contract other than those described in subsection 1(a) above that requests or provides for payment in excess of $250,000...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"ORS 291.047(3) authorizes the AG to impose rules 'necessary to carry out the provisions of this section,' but the quoted text doesn't on its face authorize raising or restructuring the dollar triggers. Possible the AG has separate unquoted statutory authority for this; possible the rule (last touched 2011) never caught up with the statute. Batch 1 and batch 2 (re-check, 2026-07-23) both surfaced this same candidate independently — high-confidence finding.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"055df9e1517c53d9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Stale internal cross-reference to a rule number that doesn't exist in the corpus.","documents":[{"id":"oar-122-040-0060","citation":"OAR 122-040-0060","quote":"A state agency that fails to report a substantive program change in a timely manner as required under subsection (1) of 122-040-0020 above shall immediately report to the director.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"No OAR 122-040-0020 exists; division 040 in this corpus contains only -0040, -0050, -0060. The matching deadline text is actually in OAR 122-040-0050(1). Reads as an orphaned cross-reference from a prior renumbering. Confirmed again in the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"38ad2bb89b491c79","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"The rule adds 'exchange' as a type of transaction in the Public Contract definition, which the statute does not list.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.045","citation":"ORS 291.045(3)","quote":"\"Public contract\" means any acquisition, disposition, purchase, lease, sale or transfer of rights by a state agency of real or personal property, public improvements or services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0010","citation":"OAR 137-045-0010(22)","quote":"\"Public Contract\" means any contract, including any amendments, entered into by an Agency for the acquisition, disposition, purchase, exchange, lease, sale or transfer of rights of real or personal property, public improvements, or services, including any contract for repair or maintenance.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.045","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8a2645a9c9692584","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule adds the qualifier 'major' before 'renovation' in the Public Improvement Contract definition, narrowing it to only major renovations when the statute covers all renovations.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.045","citation":"ORS 291.045(4)","quote":"\"Public improvement\" means projects for construction, reconstruction or renovation on real property by or for a state agency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0010","citation":"OAR 137-045-0010(23)","quote":"\"Public Improvement Contract\" means any Public Contract for construction, reconstruction, or major renovation on real property by or for an Agency.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.045","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d87f78e3f9a8e74d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"ORS 291.047(1) requires AG approval for information technology contracts over $75,000, but OAR 137-045-0030(1)(a) requires approval only for IT contracts over $150,000.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.047","citation":"ORS 291.047(1)","quote":"all information technology contracts calling for payment in excess of $75,000","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0030","citation":"OAR 137-045-0030(1)(a)","quote":"Any Public Contract that is for or includes the acquisition of Information Technology that requests or provides for payment in excess of $150,000","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.047","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8b8fd0013a847c19","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"ORS 291.047(2) requires AG approval for public contracts not subject to subsection (1) over $100,000, but OAR 137-045-0030(1)(b) requires approval only for non-IT contracts over $250,000.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.047","citation":"ORS 291.047(2)","quote":"all public contracts not subject to subsection (1) of this section that are entered into by a state agency and that provide for payment in excess of $100,000","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0030","citation":"OAR 137-045-0030(1)(b)","quote":"Any Public Contract other than those described in subsection 1(a) above that requests or provides for payment in excess of $250,000","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.047","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"802a3089ba61f39e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"ORS 291.047(1) explicitly requires AG approval for personal services contracts and architectural and engineering services contracts over $75,000 as distinct categories, but OAR 137-045-0030 does not separately address these thresholds, treating them as 'other contracts' subject to a $250,000 threshold.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.047","citation":"ORS 291.047(1)","quote":"all personal services contracts, all architectural and engineering services contracts and all information technology contracts calling for payment in excess of $75,000","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-045-0030","citation":"OAR 137-045-0030(1)(a)-(b)","quote":"Any Public Contract that is for or includes the acquisition of Information Technology that requests or provides for payment in excess of $150,000; (b) Any Public Contract other than those described in subsection 1(a) above that requests or provides for payment in excess of $250,000","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.047","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fdfa4d42fecc90fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule allows only the director to determine whether changes affect essential aspects of a program, but the statute allows either the Legislative Fiscal Officer or the director to make that determination.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.373","citation":"ORS 291.373(3)(e)","quote":"Otherwise reorganizes or makes changes to the operation or financing of a program and the Legislative Fiscal Officer or the director determines that the changes affect one or more essential aspects of the program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-040-0040","citation":"122-040-0040(2)(d)","quote":"otherwise makes changes to the operation or financing of a Program that the director determines affects one or more essential aspects of that Program.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.373","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"882dbb31af99059d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"oar-461-120-0215 declares implementation of ORS 291.003, but the operative text (sections 1-5) never engages with 291.003's requirement that federal laws govern when federal funds are involved; instead, the rule prescribes Oregon-specific treatment of illegal activities without referencing or implementing the statutory principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-461-120-0215","citation":"OAR 461-120-0215","quote":"ORS 291.003, ORS 329A.500, ORS 409.010, ORS 409.040, ORS 411.060, ORS 411.070, ORS 411.404, ORS 411.816, ORS 412.014, ORS 412.049","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-291.003","citation":"ORS 291.003","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.003","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85f8292228ffe360","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"oar-461-190-0211 declares implementation of ORS 291.003, but the operative text (sections 1-7) never engages with 291.003's requirement that federal laws govern when federal funds are involved; instead, the rule details Oregon-specific support service payment standards without referencing or implementing the statutory principle.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-461-190-0211","citation":"OAR 461-190-0211","quote":"ORS 412.016, ORS 412.049, ORS 412.084, ORS 291.003, ORS 409.010, ORS 409.040, ORS 411.060, ORS 411.070, ORS 411.121, ORS 412.001, ORS 412.002, ORS 412.006, ORS 412.009, ORS 412.011, ORS 412.014, 45 CFR 260.20, 2 CFR 200.404, 45 CFR 260.31(b)(1)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-291.003","citation":"ORS 291.003","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.003","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d2cfcc7d08cafe27","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 291.200, which concerns budget policy and outcomes-based budgeting by the Governor, but the rule's operative text addresses only audit procedures, financial adjustments, and appeals for community colleges and contractors, never engaging with the statute's subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0800","citation":"OAR 589-002-0800 (frontmatter, declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 291.200, ORS 341.015, ORS 341.626","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-291.200","citation":"ORS 291.200","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"784b1150601e3404","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"All eight rules declare they implement ORS 291.055, but ORS 291.055(2)(k) explicitly exempts the fees these rules address from ORS 291.055's operative requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-813-003-0001","citation":"ORS 291.055(2)(k)","quote":"Fees charged by the Housing and Community Services Department for intellectual property pursuant to ORS 456.562.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-813-003-0001","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 291.055, ORS 456.562","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.055","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"988c3d8b52e8d525","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-housing-and-community-services-department"]},{"summary":"The rule requires the department to make percentage amounts publicly available no later than October 15 following the end of the biennium, but the statute requires DAS to determine and certify those amounts by November 1—creating a timeline conflict where the rule's deadline precedes the statute's certification deadline.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-291.349","citation":"ORS 291.349(5)(a)","quote":"on or before November 1, following the end of each biennium, the Oregon Department of Administrative Services shall determine and certify to the Department of Revenue the percentage amounts of credit","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-291-0300","citation":"150-291-0300(2)","quote":"No later than October 15 following the end of the biennium for which a surplus is determined, the department will make publicly available to taxpayers the applicable surplus percentage amounts and information giving guidance on the calculation of the surplus credit.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-291.349","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a21c0928ebbc8d7e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 137-045-0020 statutes_implemented includes \"OL 1997\" and \"Ch. 869\" — fragments of \"Oregon Laws 1997, chapter 869\" split into pseudo-citations.","OAR 461-190-0211 statutes_implemented includes federal CFR cites incorrectly prefixed \"ORS\" (e.g. \"ORS 45 CFR 260.20\").","OAR 813-003-0001 legal_authority includes a bare \"ORS 183\" (a whole chapter, not a section)."],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"292","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":45,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule oar-156-010-0000 requires the chosen methodology to include equal pay analysis, but ORS 292.956 only requires adoption of a neutral and objective method without specifying this analytical component.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-292.956","citation":"ORS 292.956","quote":"adopt a neutral and objective method of determining the comparability of the value of work","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-156-010-0000","citation":"OAR 156-010-0000(2)","quote":"The chosen methodology shall include an equal pay analysis which ensures the chosen method eliminates unlawful wage differentials required by equal pay laws.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.956","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4b1644eb06e919cc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["legislative-administration-committee"]},{"summary":"The rule presents prepaid cards as a standard payment option available to all employees, but the statute only permits bank-issued payroll cards when the department determines electronic payment is not practicable or efficient.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-292.026","citation":"ORS 292.026(2)(c)","quote":"If the department determines that the electronic payment of net salary and wages is not practicable or efficient, payment may be made by: (A) Paper check; or (B) A credit to a bank-issued payroll card if the employee consents to payment by a bank-issued payroll card that is made in accordance with 12 C.F.R. 1005.5","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-015-0200","citation":"OAR 125-015-0200(2)","quote":"All officers and employees paid under the state payroll system shall receive payment of net salary and wages one of three ways: (a) through electronic payment by direct deposit via Automated Clearing House (ACH) to a checking and/or savings account(s) that is located in a financial institution in the United States; or (b) through electronic payment by direct deposit via ACH to a reloadable state offered prepaid card; or a reloadable prepaid card provided by the officer or employee: or (c) payment of net salary and wages by paper check.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.026","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8ceb63b0c4e07616","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 101-002-0010 declares it implements ORS 292.051, but that statute addresses payroll deduction mechanics for benefits and contains no operative provisions addressing the conduct of Board meetings, which is the sole subject of the rule.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-002-0010","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.310 - 550, ORS 192.660, ORS 243.061 - 302, ORS 292.051","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.051","citation":"ORS 292.051","quote":"Deduction of cost of group insurance and other services; fee; payment of moneys deducted.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.051","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"284fa0e23461a8bd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"The rules require organizations to be approved and participate in the Annual Charitable Fund Drive before allowing payroll deductions, whereas the statute permits deductions upon individual written request to any foundation without requiring approval or program participation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-030-0006","citation":"OAR 125-030-0006(2)-(3)","quote":"No organized charitable solicitations of state employees in state offices, facilities or other places of employment shall be permitted without prior approval of the Director of the Department of Administrative Services... All solicitations by charitable organizations that are approved in accordance with this rule shall be made in one combined annual fund drive for cash contributions or payroll deductions","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.043","citation":"ORS 292.043(2)","quote":"Any state official authorized to disburse funds in payment of salaries or wages...is authorized, upon written request of the individual, to deduct each month from the salary or wages of the individual the amount of money designated by the individual for payment to a foundation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.043","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5b4019b53d19ee1e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The statute specifies a fixed two-year term for committee members, but the rule allows the Director to appoint members to terms ranging from one to three years.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-292.045","citation":"ORS 292.045(2)(a)","quote":"The term of office of a member is two years.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-030-0021","citation":"OAR 125-030-0021(3)","quote":"The Director will appoint members to serve a term of one to three years.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.045","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e095f481e4dfd410","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"oar-605-020-0010 states compensation is limited to $30 per day, but ORS 292.495(1) and (5) require compensation equal to the legislative per diem under ORS 171.072, not a fixed $30 cap.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-605-020-0010","citation":"OAR 605-020-0010(2)","quote":"The rate of compensation is limited to $30 per day, pursuant to ORS 292.495(1).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.495","citation":"ORS 292.495(5)","quote":"The compensation to be provided under subsections (1) and (4)(b)(A) of this section is equal to the per diem paid to members of the Legislative Assembly under ORS 171.072.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.495","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e951b76ad43e7cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council"]},{"summary":"oar-623-040-0005 states compensation is limited to $30 per day, but ORS 292.495(1) and (5) require compensation equal to the legislative per diem under ORS 171.072, not a fixed $30 cap.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"oar-623-040-0005","citation":"OAR 623-040-0005(2)","quote":"The rate of compensation is limited to $30 per day, pursuant to ORS 292.495(1).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.495","citation":"ORS 292.495(5)","quote":"The compensation to be provided under subsections (1) and (4)(b)(A) of this section is equal to the per diem paid to members of the Legislative Assembly under ORS 171.072.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.495","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ee923867f2d6ebb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission"]},{"summary":"oar-847-008-0003 declares it implements ORS 292.495 but the rule is entirely about delegation of licensure authority to the Executive Director and contains no provisions addressing compensation or expenses.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-008-0003","citation":"OAR 847-008-0003 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 292.495, ORS 677.235","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.495","citation":"ORS 292.495","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.495","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f3d3d8279d1a3e94","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"oar-847-003-0200 creates a compensation scheme tied to meeting duration (6+ hours yields $250 per day plus $250 for prep) and capped at $250, whereas ORS 292.495(1) and (5) require compensation equal to the legislative per diem without such duration conditions or daily caps.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-003-0200","citation":"OAR 847-003-0200(2)-(3)","quote":"If a Board or Committee meeting is scheduled for six (6) or more hours, Board members who attend the meeting will receive: (a) $250 compensation for each day of attendance at the meeting; and (b) $250 compensation for one day of preparation for the meeting. (3) The daily maximum Board member compensation is $250.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-292.495","citation":"ORS 292.495(1)","quote":"any member of a state board or commission, other than a member who is employed in full-time public service, who is authorized by law to receive compensation for time spent in performance of official duties, shall receive a payment, in the amount specified in subsection (5) of this section, for each day or portion thereof during which the member is actually engaged in the performance of official duties.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-292.495","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"60da8e21fe6a5d76","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Beef Council"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hazelnut Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Strawberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sweet-cherry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sweet Cherry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"judicial-department","name":"Judicial Department"},{"slug":"legislative-administration-committee","name":"Legislative Administration Committee"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-physical-therapy","name":"Oregon Board of Physical Therapy"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"293","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":74,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 293.450 (reporting outstanding checks), but the operative text addresses only restitution payments from incarcerated individuals, which has no connection to the statute's subject matter of outstanding check reporting.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-158-0071","citation":"statutes_implemented (declared)","quote":"ORS 423.020, ORS 423.030, ORS 30.643, ORS 34.365, ORS 34.370, ORS 138.590, ORS 144.335, ORS 179.040, ORS 293.450, ORS 421.125, ORS 423.075","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-293.450","citation":"ORS 293.450","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.450","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cd5c00a450896493","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"OAR 150-293-0040 requires payment by electronic funds transfer for Oregon estimated tax and payroll taxes, but ORS 293.525(3) explicitly prohibits the Department of Revenue from requiring electronic funds transfer as the primary method for payment of estimated tax.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.525","citation":"ORS 293.525(3)(a)","quote":"the Department of Revenue may not require electronic funds transfer as the primary method for payment of: (a) Estimated tax, as defined in ORS 316.557","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-293-0040","citation":"OAR 150-293-0040 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 293.525","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"66d499942f5da686","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-005-0225(2) requires all payments by PERS employers to be made by electronic funds transfer, but ORS 293.525(1)(a) permits agencies to require only payments 'above designated amounts' to be made by electronic funds transfer.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.525","citation":"ORS 293.525(1)(a)","quote":"Require that payments to the agency above designated amounts be made by electronic funds transfer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0225","citation":"OAR 459-005-0225(2)","quote":"Participating employers are required to make all payments to PERS by means of electronic funds transfer (EFT).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2222a8bae196d78e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-055-5035(2) and (4) require electronic funds transfer based on employer characteristics (employee count, number of income withholding orders, prior failures) without reference to payment amounts, whereas ORS 293.525(1)(a) permits agencies to require payments 'above designated amounts' to be made by electronic funds transfer.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.525","citation":"ORS 293.525(1)(a)","quote":"Require that payments to the agency above designated amounts be made by electronic funds transfer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-5035","citation":"OAR 137-055-5035(2)","quote":"An employer required to remit support payments to the Department of Justice (DOJ) must remit payments by EFT if: (a) An employer with five or more employees has received at least one income withholding order for an employee; (b) An employer with less than five employees has received an income withholding order for more than one employee; or (c) An employer is required by Treasury regulations to make federal corporation estimated tax payments or federal payroll tax payments by means of EFT.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0577d8079f311375","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rules narrow the statute's scope from all persons who have received state moneys to only contracted providers of child care and treatment services.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.260","citation":"ORS 293.260(1)","quote":"the Secretary of State shall require all persons who have received any moneys or property belonging to the state and who have not accounted therefor to settle their accounts and to return the moneys or property to the state","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0350","citation":"OAR 413-310-0350","quote":"These rules describe SOSCF's procedures for handling the collection of overpayments to contracted providers of child care and treatment services","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.260","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f6fed93918fc0baa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-018-0020 states that under ORS 293.250 the Department of Revenue may render assistance through wage garnishment of up to 25 percent of nonexempt disposable earnings, but the statute authorizes only offset against refunds and issuance of warrants, not wage garnishment.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-018-0020","citation":"OAR 150-018-0020(1)","quote":"Under ORS 293.250, the Department of Revenue may render assistance to recover delinquent debts owed to any entity listed in ORS 293.250(2) that is assigned by the entity to the department for collection, including actions to continuously garnish up to 25 percent of an individual's nonexempt disposable earnings.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-293.250","citation":"ORS 293.250(5)(b) and (6)","quote":"the department may offset any refunds or sums due to the debtor from the department or any other state agency against delinquent accounts assigned to the department for collection under this section... In providing assistance in the collection of any delinquent account under subsection (2) of this section, the Department of Revenue may issue a warrant for the collection of the delinquent account.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d9c38011d8b1fe06","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"All implementing rules declare they implement ORS 293.245 (collection of previously written-off debts), but none of the operative text addresses that statute—the rules address only initial erroneous payments, fraud investigation, and error prevention, not subsequent collection of debts that become collectible after write-off.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-413-310-0200","citation":"OAR 413-310-0200","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0210","citation":"OAR 413-310-0210","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245, 42 CFR 433","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0220","citation":"OAR 413-310-0220","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245, ORS 293.265","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0230","citation":"OAR 413-310-0230","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0240","citation":"OAR 413-310-0240","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.245","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a70805da0db2258a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 293.265, but its operative text about unintentional errors and establishing accounts receivable does not engage with any specific provision of ORS 293.265 (which addresses timing of deposits with State Treasurer, accord and satisfaction, and return of incomplete checks).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-413-310-0220","citation":"OAR 413-310-0220","quote":"ORS 293.235 - 293.245 & ORS 293.265","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-293.265","citation":"ORS 293.265","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.265","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f193580fa778abaf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"Rule 0235 declares implementation of only ORS 293.235, which is solely a definition statute stating that 'state agency' means what it means in ORS 293.226, but the rule's operative text addresses fraud investigation coordination procedures that the statute does not authorize.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-413-310-0235","citation":"OAR 413-310-0235 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 293.235","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-293.235","citation":"ORS 293.235","quote":"As used in ORS 293.240 and 293.245, \"state agency\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 293.226.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb2824991158007d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"The rule authorizes duplicate checks when the original was 'cashed because of forgery,' but the statute limits authorization to loss, destruction, or theft only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.475","citation":"ORS 293.475(1)","quote":"Upon satisfactory showing by the lawful owner of an instrument of the loss, destruction or theft of the instrument, the proper officer, board, department or commission that issued the original instrument, or the issuer's duly authorized legal successor, may issue a duplicate in lieu thereof","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-293-0030","citation":"150-293-0030(1)","quote":"The department may issue a duplicate check if the original check has been lost, stolen, destroyed, or cashed because of forgery.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.475","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"58a50d4f3792ac0d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule imposes a 15-month deadline for submitting forms in forgery cases, but the statute contains no such deadline.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.475","citation":"ORS 293.475(2)","quote":"Before a duplicate instrument is issued, the person making application for its issue shall furnish to the issuing officer a written statement","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-293-0030","citation":"150-293-0030(2)","quote":"All forms required in the case of a forged check must be completed and returned to the department within 15 months of the date the check was cashed for a duplicate check to be issued.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.475","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a3e681c89b724d38","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 413-310-0320 lists specific determinations for write-off but omits the requirement that criteria must include the right of offset, which the statute explicitly mandates.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.240","citation":"ORS 293.240(2)","quote":"The criteria must include the right of offset and must be approved by the Attorney General.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-310-0320","citation":"OAR 413-310-0320","quote":"One of the following determinations of uncollectibility must apply to each debt submitted for write off: (1) The cost of collection is not economically feasible. (2) The debtor is dead and his/her estate has no assets from which money could be collected. [etc.]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c1a6cb8fcf2fb97f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"OAR 459-005-0620 lists nine criteria for uncollectible debt but omits the requirement that criteria must include the right of offset, which the statute explicitly mandates.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.240","citation":"ORS 293.240(2)","quote":"The criteria must include the right of offset and must be approved by the Attorney General.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-459-005-0620","citation":"OAR 459-005-0620","quote":"Any debt, including interest, penalties, or any portion of the debt, may be considered to be uncollectible when the debtor has no money or other thing of value owing or held by PERS that has not been credited to the debt, and it is reasonable to conclude, after all reasonable efforts to collect the debt have been made, that one or more of the following is true: [9 criteria listed with no mention of right of offset]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d173a15a455c7f2b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-public-employees-retirement-system"]},{"summary":"oar-436-001-0500 requires written request for refund of overpayments under $20 to be received within two years, but ORS 293.445(2) gives agencies three years from date money was paid to make refunds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.445","citation":"ORS 293.445(2)","quote":"the agency, within three years from the date the money was paid to the agency, shall refund the excess or erroneous payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-436-001-0500","citation":"oar-436-001-0500","quote":"the director will refund or credit the excess amount only if a written request for refund or credit is received within two years of the date that the excess amount was received by the director","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1ffa598de9d09602","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division"]},{"summary":"oar-436-070-0020 requires written request for refund of overpayments under $20 to be received within two years, but ORS 293.445(2) gives agencies three years from date money was paid to make refunds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.445","citation":"ORS 293.445(2)","quote":"the agency, within three years from the date the money was paid to the agency, shall refund the excess or erroneous payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-436-070-0020","citation":"oar-436-070-0020(8)","quote":"the director will refund or credit the excess amount only upon receipt of a written request from the employer or the employer's legal representative","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"109520b073f995de","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division"]},{"summary":"oar-818-001-0087 requires written request for refund of overpayments under $5.01 to be received within one year, but ORS 293.445(2) gives agencies three years from date money was paid to make refunds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.445","citation":"ORS 293.445(2)","quote":"the agency, within three years from the date the money was paid to the agency, shall refund the excess or erroneous payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-818-001-0087","citation":"oar-818-001-0087(3)","quote":"The Board shall not refund moneys under $5.01 received in excess of amounts due or to which the Board has no legal interest unless the person who made the payment or the person's legal representative requests a refund in writing within one year of payment to the Board","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2dd7038251ffdd8c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-dentistry"]},{"summary":"oar-845-004-0031 requires written request for refund of amounts of $25 or less to be filed within 18 months, but ORS 293.445(2) gives agencies three years from date money was paid to make refunds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.445","citation":"ORS 293.445(2)","quote":"the agency, within three years from the date the money was paid to the agency, shall refund the excess or erroneous payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-845-004-0031","citation":"oar-845-004-0031(2)","quote":"Refund requests must be filed within 18 months from the date of payment","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"06752b80166902dc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-liquor-control-commission"]},{"summary":"oar-863-001-0007 requires written request for refund of overpayments of $15 or less to be made within one year, but ORS 293.445(2) gives agencies three years from date money was paid to make refunds.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.445","citation":"ORS 293.445(2)","quote":"the agency, within three years from the date the money was paid to the agency, shall refund the excess or erroneous payment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-863-001-0007","citation":"oar-863-001-0007(1)","quote":"The Real Estate Agency shall not refund fees, civil penalties or other moneys overpaid by an amount of $15 or less unless such repayment is requested in writing by the payor within one year after the date of the overpayment","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.445","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"07af8168b74de975","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["real-estate-agency"]},{"summary":"The rule only addresses voluntary collection and explicitly excludes mandatory disclosures, but the statute directs rules to specify when the notice must state whether disclosure is voluntary or mandatory, contemplating coverage of both scenarios.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.226","citation":"ORS 293.226(2)(a)","quote":"Specifying the form of the notice, including provisions specifying when the notice must state whether the disclosure of a Social Security number is voluntary or mandatory","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0200","citation":"OAR 122-085-0200(2)","quote":"This rule does not apply to a Social Security number that is required to be provided under state or federal law.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.226","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e19ab68da47a38ed","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"The rule addresses sharing between state agencies but does not establish procedures for sharing between the Department of Revenue and private collection agencies, which the statute explicitly requires.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.226","citation":"ORS 293.226(2)(b)","quote":"Setting procedures for the sharing of Social Security numbers between state agencies, and between the Department of Revenue and private collection agencies, for the purpose of collecting debts owed state agencies.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0200","citation":"OAR 122-085-0200(3)(c)","quote":"any state agency may share Social Security numbers collected under section 3 of this rule as necessary for use in collecting debts owed to the state of Oregon","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.226","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"acf2fd027d0ba137","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"OAR 122-085-0130(1)(b) references 'Department of Justice Crime Victims Assistance Section' but the statute requires 'Department of Justice Crime Victim and Survivor Services Division'—different entities within DOJ.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.231","citation":"ORS 293.231(7)(b)","quote":"Is a court-ordered judgment that includes restitution or a payment to the Department of Justice Crime Victim and Survivor Services Division","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0130","citation":"OAR 122-085-0130(1)(b)","quote":"Is a court judgment that includes restitution or a payment to the Department of Justice Crime Victims Assistance Section","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.231","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"51bc2204adbb4496","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"OAR 122-085-0130(1)(i) broadens the exemption by adding 'loss of funding under a federal program' as an alternative to the statute's 'loss of federal funding if assigned'.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.231","citation":"ORS 293.231(7)(i)","quote":"Would result in loss of federal funding if assigned","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0130","citation":"OAR 122-085-0130(1)(i)","quote":"Would, if assigned, result in a loss of federal funding or a loss of funding under a federal program","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.231","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a518cd7977b53b1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"OAR 122-085-0130 declares it implements ORS 293.231(5) and ORS 293.231(6)(c), but its operative text at (1) implements the discretionary exemptions in ORS 293.231(7), which is not declared.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-122-085-0130","citation":"OAR 122-085-0130 declaration","quote":"ORS 293.231(5), ORS 293.231(6)(c), ORS 293.233(1), ORS 293.233(2)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-293.231","citation":"ORS 293.231(5)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.231","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"28122a358e5325dc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"The rule provides a definition of 'State agency' that omits the explicit exclusions required by the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.227","citation":"ORS 293.227(2)","quote":"\"State agency\" has the meaning given that term in ORS 293.226, except that it does not include the judicial department as defined in ORS 174.113, the legislative department as defined in ORS 174.114 or entities described in ORS 293.226 (7)(b).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0110","citation":"OAR 122-085-0110(14)","quote":"\"State agency\" means any officer, board, commission, department, division or institution in the executive or administrative branch of state government subject to ORS 293.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.227","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cee710c6d2e4f20c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"ORS 293.233(1) requires state agencies to 'shall provide documentation and justification' for exemptions, but OAR 122-085-0130(3) uses discretionary language ('should document') and explicitly states filing is not required.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-293.233","citation":"ORS 293.233(1)","quote":"The state agency shall provide documentation and justification for exempting liquidated and delinquent accounts from assignment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-085-0130","citation":"OAR 122-085-0130(3)","quote":"When a state agency determines an MCAT account may be exempted from assignment, the state agency should document their conclusions using the applicable form provided in the OAM (or equivalent). A state agency is not required to file this form with the DAS CFO, but the form is useful to explain the reasoning for exempting accounts in the event of an inquiry or in response to an audit of the state agency's liquidated and delinquent accounts.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-293.233","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a0a60d01f371f4e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-medical-imaging","name":"Board of Medical Imaging"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","name":"Department of State Police, Office of State Fire Marshal"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-liquor-control-commission","name":"Oregon Liquor Control Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"real-estate-agency","name":"Real Estate Agency"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-elections-division","name":"Secretary of State, Elections Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"30","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule restricts the source of disclosure prohibitions to only OAR 589-004-0150 through 589-004-0550, dropping the statute's alternative basis that prohibitions can also come from the governing board of a public university listed in ORS 352.002.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-30.864","citation":"ORS 30.864(1)","quote":"Any person claiming to be aggrieved by the reckless disclosure of personally identifiable information from a student's education records as prohibited by standards issued by the State Board of Education or the governing board of a public university listed in ORS 352.002 may file a civil action in circuit court","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-004-0700","citation":"OAR 589-004-0700","quote":"Any person claiming to be aggrieved by the reckless disclosure of personally identifiable information from a student's education records, as prohibited by OAR 589-004-0150 through 589-004-0550, may file a civil action in circuit court","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-30.864","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb922b1d5ad85a02","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"}]},{"ors_chapter":"305","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":94,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute mandates the penalty 'shall' be imposed if the condition is met, but the rule makes it discretionary by stating the department 'will not' impose the 100% penalty for returns already assessed a lower penalty, rather than applying the statutory cap to impose it up to the 100% total limit.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.992","citation":"ORS 305.992(1)","quote":"there shall be a penalty for each year of 100 percent of the tax liability determined after credits and prepayments for each such year","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0480","citation":"150-305-0480(2)","quote":"Under authority granted in ORS 305.229, the department will not impose the 100 percent penalty under ORS 305.992 for returns filed or a Notice of Assessment that have been assessed a lower failure-to-file penalty.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.992","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"88546041ba52daf5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The statute requires a procedure allowing institutions lacking technical ability to transmit account holder lists to the department, but the rule instead provides waivers from participation or alternative methods requiring departmental approval.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.094","citation":"ORS 305.094(2)(c)","quote":"A procedure by which financial institutions that lack the technical ability to participate in the data match system required by ORS 305.084 may transmit to the department a list of the names and Social Security numbers or other taxpayer identification numbers of all account holders.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0085","citation":"150-305-0085(3)(c)","quote":"A financial institution demonstrating, to the department's satisfaction, that it has a technological or financial hardship described in ORS 305.084(5)(b) or (c) that prevents it from providing the type of submissions described in section 3(a) or (b) of this rule may request a temporary waiver from complying with the data match system requirements. If the temporary waiver is approved by the department, the financial institution does not have to participate in the data match system for a time period specified by the department, not to exceed three years.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.094","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"191ac73de190c9a7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule allows tax matters partner designation whenever there is a notice of deficiency relating to partnership adjustments, but the statute permits designation only when the treatment of partnership items on the partner's return is consistent with treatment on the partnership return AND results in a notice of deficiency.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.242","citation":"ORS 305.242(1)(a)","quote":"When the treatment of partnership items on a partner's return is consistent with the treatment of that item on the partnership return and results in a notice of deficiency, the partners may designate a tax matters partner","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0180","citation":"OAR 150-305-0180(1)","quote":"A partner who elects to designate a tax matters partner as their authorized representative in proceedings before the Department of Revenue for issues relating to the partnership adjustments on a notice of deficiency shall make the designation as provided in this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.242","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4186f72c396b1509","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-320-0430 declares ORS 305.145 as implemented, but its operative text addresses preventing penalty imposition through alternative filing format, which operates under a different statutory authority (ORS 314.400, 320.445) than the waiver/reduction mechanism of ORS 305.145.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-320-0430","citation":"OAR 150-320-0430 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 305.145, ORS 305.229, ORS 314.385, ORS 320.455, ORS 320.480","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-320-0430","citation":"OAR 150-320-0430(2)","quote":"the department will not impose a late payment or late filing penalty added to the amount of tax by ORS 314.400, unless the return is filed or payment is made later than the due date prescribed in ORS 320.445","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"92730aa95021e4f7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 1 adds a 'signature petition' requirement that does not appear in ORS 305.725, which only addresses application contents.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-305-0380","citation":"ORS 305.725","quote":"ORS 305.725","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-305.725","citation":"ORS 305.725(1)","quote":"Each entity seeking to receive contributions by means of checkoff on a schedule of the Oregon individual income tax return shall make initial application to the Oregon Charitable Checkoff Commission not later than July 1 of the first tax year for which the entity seeks to be included on a schedule of the individual income tax return. The application shall contain or be accompanied by: (a) The name of the entity. (b) The address of the principal place of business of the entity and the name of the person, officer or employee to whom the moneys contributed by means of checkoff are to be remitted pursuant to ORS 305.747...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.725","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"507106c31909d2a8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 3 imposes a 10,000 voter signature gathering requirement that does not exist in ORS 305.725.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-305-0394","citation":"ORS 305.725","quote":"ORS 305.725","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-305.725","citation":"ORS 305.725(1)","quote":"Each entity seeking to receive contributions by means of checkoff on a schedule of the Oregon individual income tax return shall make initial application to the Oregon Charitable Checkoff Commission not later than July 1 of the first tax year for which the entity seeks to be included on a schedule of the individual income tax return. The application shall contain or be accompanied by...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.725","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3201cb0444e5c052","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule does not implement ORS 305.820(1)(c), which requires that a lost item be deemed filed on its original mailing date only if a duplicate is 'filed with the addressee... within 30 days after written notification is given by the addressee of its failure to receive such writing or remittance.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.820","citation":"ORS 305.820(1)(c)","quote":"Lost in transmission through the United States mail or private express carrier, shall be deemed filed and received on the date it was mailed or deposited for transmittal if the sender: (A) Can establish by competent evidence satisfactory to the addressee that the writing or remittance was deposited on or before the date due for filing in the United States mail, or with a private express carrier, and addressed correctly to the addressee; and (B) Files with the addressee a duplicate of the lost writing or remittance within 30 days after written notification is given by the addressee of its failure to receive such writing or remittance.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0470","citation":"OAR 150-305-0470(2)","quote":"Any writing or remittance received after the due date bearing a legible postmark dated on or before the due date will be considered timely filed if properly mailed and the postmark is that of the United States Postal Service. If the postmark is other than that of the United States Postal Service, the writing or remittance will be considered timely filed if it has been properly mailed and is received not later than the time a writing or remittance postmarked by the United States Postal Service at the same point of origin on the due date would ordinarily be received. If the writing or remittance is not received within the period of time, it must be shown by satisfactory proof to the Department that the writing or remittance was placed in the hands of the United States Postal Service or in the hands of a private express carrier on or before the due date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.820","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e92becf60dd9b50d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule limits who can be subpoenaed to persons who are Oregon residents/domiciliaries, earn income in Oregon, own property in Oregon, conduct business in Oregon, or have registered agents in Oregon, whereas the statute authorizes subpoenas to 'any person, company or corporation' without these geographic or business nexus limitations.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.190","citation":"ORS 305.190(1)","quote":"the Director of the Department of Revenue, in conformity to the resolutions or rules of the Department of Revenue, may subpoena and examine witnesses, administer oaths and order the production of any books or papers in the hands of any person, company or corporation, whenever necessary in the prosecution of any inquiries deemed necessary or proper.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0100","citation":"OAR 150-305-0100(2)(a)","quote":"A subpoena may be issued to any person who: is an Oregon resident or domiciliary; earns income in this state; owns or has an interest in any real or personal property in Oregon; conducts business in Oregon; or has a registered agent in Oregon.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30197ce6c0d1ba7d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule adds an explicit requirement that a person must 'represent to the department that they are authorized to receive the information,' but the statute only requires the person to 'reveal knowledge' of tax information meeting three criteria.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.193","citation":"ORS 305.193(1)","quote":"the department may consider a person designated by implication if the person reveals to the department knowledge of tax information that is: (a) Related to the tax matter that is the subject of the inquiry or communication; (b) Of a nature that is generally known only to the taxpayer; and (c) Of a nature that a taxpayer ordinarily would not share with another person except for the purpose of empowering that person to receive information regarding the tax matters of the taxpayer.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0120","citation":"OAR 150-305-0120(2)","quote":"Without evidence of the filing of written consent to disclose the taxpayer's information, the department may determine that a person is authorized to receive confidential information with respect to a particular tax matter by that person representing to the department that they are authorized to receive the information and revealing to the department knowledge of tax information that is: (a) Related to the tax matter that is the subject of the inquiry or communication; (b) Of a nature that is generally known only to the taxpayer; and (c) Of a nature that taxpayers ordinarily do not share with others except for the purpose of empowering the person to participate in the taxpayer's tax matters.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.193","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a774946afacc4cf5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0204 section (1) states that assessments for personal income tax, corporate excise tax, and corporate income tax \"generally cannot be appealed using the conference process,\" but section (2)(a) of the same rule explicitly lists these same tax chapters (316, 317, 318) as allowing conference requests.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-305-0204","citation":"150-305-0204(1) and (2)(a)","quote":"(1) A conference is a meeting with a department conference officer... Assessments related to personal income tax, corporate excise tax, or corporate income tax, including assessments issued under ORS 305.265(10) for failure to file a report or return, generally cannot be appealed using the conference process but must instead be appealed to the Oregon Tax Court... (2) A conference may be requested by a taxpayer in any of the following instances: (a) From a determination of tax deficiency, interest, or penalty arising under ORS Chapters 118, 119, 314, 316, 317, 318, or 321.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.265","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a8c7f0843447cfd2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule implements only one exception to the stay (jeopardized collection) and omits the second exception allowing collection when the taxpayer has taken a frivolous position in the appeal.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.565","citation":"ORS 305.565(2)","quote":"the department may proceed to collect any taxes, interest or penalties described in subsection (1) of this section if the department determines that collection will be jeopardized if collection is delayed or that the taxpayer has taken a frivolous position in the appeal","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0340","citation":"OAR 150-305-0340(1)","quote":"The department may continue to collect delinquent taxes during the pendency of an appeal if it becomes known the taxpayer is preparing to depart from the state or move assets out of the state to avoid paying taxes. In addition, the department may continue collection if the taxpayer does any other act tending to prejudice or to render wholly or partially ineffectual proceedings to collect tax.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.565","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e59f3cbff3fe8bb3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The statute requires both the Department of Revenue AND the property value appeals board to give notice of appeal rights, but the rule only addresses the Department of Revenue.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.525","citation":"ORS 305.525","quote":"the Department of Revenue or property value appeals board, as the case may be, shall in writing also notify the taxpayer of the right of the taxpayer to appeal to the tax court","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0330","citation":"OAR 150-305-0330(1)","quote":"The Department of Revenue shall give notice to the taxpayer to reflect that final department actions may only be appealed to the Magistrate Division of the Oregon Tax Court.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ebbcf9ab75ef0a3f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The statute specifies a 30-day period for the owner to seek a court order limiting disclosure, but the rule specifies a 33-day period (or more than 33 days in advance) before disclosure can occur.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.192","citation":"ORS 305.192(3)","quote":"The owner shall have 30 days to seek an order from the tax court prohibiting or limiting the department's disclosure of the information.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0110","citation":"OAR 150-305-0110(2)","quote":"The department must notify the provider of the \"books and papers\" of an intended disclosure more than 33 days in advance of the intended disclosure.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0110","citation":"OAR 150-305-0110(4)","quote":"The disclosure will not occur until: (a) Thirty-three days after the notice","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.192","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4af2c9505953c40c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0396 specifies a signature gathering period (July 1 to June 30) that the statute does not require, restricting when signatures for checkoff entity qualification may be collected.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.720","citation":"ORS 305.720(4)","quote":"Collects 10,000 or more signatures from electors of this state attesting that the electors support the entity qualifying for inclusion on a schedule of the Oregon individual income tax return.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0396","citation":"OAR 150-305-0396","quote":"The signature gathering period for any tax year for which an entity seeks to be included on a schedule of the individual tax return begins July 1 of the tax year two years prior to the year in which being included on a schedule is sought and extends through June 30 of the tax year being included on a schedule is sought.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.720","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d1a5e319f45dd523","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule requires the declaration to state that the document 'is made under penalties for false swearing and is true, complete, and correct,' but the statute only requires it to state that it is made 'under penalties for false swearing,' without explicitly requiring statements about truthfulness, completeness, or correctness.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.810","citation":"ORS 305.810(1)","quote":"Contain or be verified by a written declaration that it is made under penalties for false swearing","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0460","citation":"150-305-0460(1)","quote":"The declaration under ORS 305.810 that a return, statement, other document or report is made under penalties for false swearing and is true, complete, and correct must be verified by the taxpayer, an authorized agent, or declarant","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.810","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"87ec205088273f95","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 150-305-0090 creates an entire settlement offer program with detailed procedures, but ORS 305.155 does not authorize settlement offers—it only authorizes three mechanisms: cancellation after 7+ years of delinquency, suspension for low-income individuals, and cancellation when costs exceed recovery.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.155","citation":"ORS 305.155(1), (2), (3)","quote":"(1) The Department of Revenue shall cancel an unpaid tax imposed by laws of the State of Oregon that is collected by the department, including any penalty or interest applicable to the tax, if the department determines that: (a) The tax has been delinquent for seven or more years... (2) The department shall offer to suspend collection of an unpaid tax imposed by laws of the State of Oregon that is collected by the department... (3) The department may cancel any tax imposed by laws of the State of Oregon that is collected by the department or any portion of the tax assessed against a person, including any penalty and interest that has not been collected, if the department determines that the administration and collection costs involved would exceed the amount that can reasonably be expected to be recovered.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0090","citation":"OAR 150-305-0090(1)(e), (2)","quote":"(1)(e) 'Settlement offer' means an offer made by a taxpayer or an authorized representative to satisfy a tax liability for less than the full amount owed, for which appeal rights have expired and there is no pending appeal. (2) The department reviews all settlement offer applications and may accept or reject the offer based on the department's evaluation of the taxpayer's ability to pay and the anticipated costs of further collection work.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.155","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d44647018b0dc83d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 150-305-0094 authorizes cancellation of tax liabilities discharged in bankruptcy, but ORS 305.155 contains no provision addressing bankruptcy discharge and does not authorize cancellation outside of its three specified mechanisms.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.155","citation":"ORS 305.155","quote":"305.155 Cancellation of uncollectible tax; suspension of collection; filing order; releasing liens. (1) The Department of Revenue shall cancel an unpaid tax imposed by laws of the State of Oregon that is collected by the department, including any penalty or interest applicable to the tax, if the department determines that: (a) The tax has been delinquent for seven or more years; (b) All reasonable efforts have been made to effect collection; (c) The taxpayer cannot be located or is dead; and (d) The tax is wholly uncollectible.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0094","citation":"OAR 150-305-0094(1)","quote":"(1) Generally, all tax liabilities which are discharged in a bankruptcy proceeding under the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1978 shall be cancelled upon the Department's records.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.155","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0e2fbdf186424165","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the finality of closing agreements for taxable periods ending subsequent to the agreement date by making them subject to future law changes, an exception not in the statute.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.150","citation":"ORS 305.150(2)","quote":"Such agreement shall be final and conclusive on the date agreed to, and, except upon a showing of fraud or malfeasance or misrepresentation of a material fact, the question, issue or case shall not be reopened as to the matters agreed upon","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0080","citation":"OAR 150-305-0080","quote":"With respect to any taxable period ending subsequent to the date of the closing agreement, such agreement is subject to any change in or modification of the law enacted subsequent to the date of execution and applicable to such taxable period","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"61e667e03914eef7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the statutory authorization for offsetting state tax refunds or other state payments in payment of liquidated federal debt, covering only the reverse direction.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.612","citation":"ORS 305.612(1)","quote":"the offset of state tax refunds or other state payments in payment of liquidated federal debt","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0350","citation":"OAR 150-305-0350(2)","quote":"The department may submit liquidated state debt for offset against federal tax refunds through the \"Treasury Offset Program\" under 26 USC 6402(e) and 31 CFR 285.8 and federal payments under 31 USC 3716(h) and 31 CFR 285.6.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"ae0c908402c65864","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0052(1) makes discretionary (may) what the statute makes mandatory (shall) when there is no value in the lien.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.140","citation":"ORS 305.140(2)","quote":"If, upon a request under subsection (1) of this section, the department finds that a sale of such real property would not result in satisfaction in whole or in part of the taxes due, it shall execute a release of such cloud or lien upon such property","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0052","citation":"150-305-0052(1)","quote":"The department may issue a release of a lien against real property if the department determines there is no value in the lien or the full value of the lien is realized.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e5d4804b37f634c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"ORS 305.220(1) establishes a default rate of 10 percent per annum for deficiencies and delinquencies, but oar-150-305-0140(1) specifies 8 percent annually effective January 1, 2026.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.220","citation":"ORS 305.220(1)","quote":"every deficiency or delinquency arising under any law administered by the Department of Revenue shall bear simple interest at the rate of 10 percent per annum, to be computed on a daily basis","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0140","citation":"oar-150-305-0140(1)","quote":"For deficiencies and delinquencies owing on or after January 1, 2026, unless otherwise provided by law, every deficiency and delinquency arising under any law administered by the department will bear interest at the rate of eight percent annually","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"154fe44ec24d1e63","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"ORS 305.220(2) establishes a default rate of 10 percent per annum for refunds, but oar-150-305-0142(1) specifies 8 percent annually effective January 1, 2026.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.220","citation":"ORS 305.220(2)","quote":"every refund arising under any law administered by the department shall, subject to subsections (3) and (5) of this section and ORS 305.222, bear simple interest at the rate of 10 percent per annum, to be computed on a daily basis","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0142","citation":"oar-150-305-0142(1)","quote":"For refunds owing on or after January 1, 2026, unless specifically provided by statute or by rule, every refund arising under any law administered by the department will bear interest at the rate of eight percent annually","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"04afb3d810dc52fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 150-305-0304 allows satisfaction of the ORS 305.385(6) certification requirement by either a Department certificate or a written statement under penalty of perjury, making the statute's required form optional.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-305-0304","citation":"ORS 305.385(6)","quote":"No contract or other agreement for the purpose of providing goods, services or real estate space to any agency shall be entered into, renewed or extended with any person, unless the person certifies in writing, under penalty of perjury, that the person is, to the best of the person's knowledge, not in violation of any tax laws","quote_verified":"absence"},{"id":"oar-150-305-0304","citation":"OAR 150-305-0304(4)","quote":"A taxpayer required to attest or certify under ORS 279B.110(2)(e), ORS 305.385(6), or any other law that requires the taxpayer to provide a statement of compliance that is not issued by the Department, regarding the taxpayer's compliance with Oregon tax laws and local taxes administered by the department may request a certificate of tax compliance under section (1) of this rule as a method of certifying tax compliance in lieu of providing a written statement, signed under penalty of perjury","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.385","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f3646391883a469e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 331-030-0004 declares ORS 305.385 as an implemented statute but contains operative text solely about fingerprinting and criminal background checks for health licensing, which ORS 305.385 does not authorize.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-030-0004","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 25.785, ORS 305.385, 42 USC § 405(C)(2)(C)(i), 42 USC § 666(a)(13), ORS 670.280, ORS 676.303, ORS 676.565, ORS 676.575, ORS 676.615, ORS 681.700-681.730, ORS 181A.195","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-305.385","citation":"ORS 305.385","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.385","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ef4d9b157dfaa5d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0274 specifies interest accrues 45 days after deficiency paid or return filed, but the statute specifies it accrues from the date the taxpayer requests the refund.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.295","citation":"ORS 305.295(4)","quote":"Interest shall be paid at the rate established under ORS 305.220 for a period beginning on the date the taxpayer requests the refund.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0274","citation":"oar-150-305-0274","quote":"The interest starting date must be 45 days after the date the deficiency was paid or 45 days after the return was filed, whichever is later.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.295","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"14f09e7ade2c278f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0272 requires taxpayers to have submitted full payment of the tax amount determined correct (or entered an installment agreement), but the statute requires only compliance with reporting and filing requirements.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.295","citation":"ORS 305.295(1)(d)(C)","quote":"The taxpayer has complied with all applicable reporting and filing requirements for all tax years for which the department maintains records.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0272","citation":"oar-150-305-0272(3)(c)(B)","quote":"Has submitted full payment of the amount of tax, interest and penalty determined to be correct by the department, or has entered into and fulfilled an acceptable installment agreement for payment of such amounts.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.295","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"54a1e531e916a6d2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule requires financial statements and budget documents covering the most recent three years, while the statute specifies that information shall cover only the two years that ended during the 12-month period ending prior to July 1.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.730","citation":"ORS 305.730(4)","quote":"All information required by this section shall be as of the close of each fiscal or calendar year of the two years that ended during the 12-month period ending prior to July 1 of the year in which the financial report is filed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0410","citation":"oar-150-305-0410(1)(a)","quote":"The financial statements and budget documents must cover the most recent three years or the length of time the entity has been in existence.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.730","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f0dfc08d21092fd2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a 'two-year' lookback window for when the prior dishonored check must have been tendered, which the statute does not specify.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.228","citation":"ORS 305.228(1)","quote":"The Department of Revenue shall assess a penalty against any person who has previously tendered a dishonored check, draft, order or electronic funds transfer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0160","citation":"OAR 150-305-0160(2)","quote":"the penalty will be imposed on a dishonored check if a prior dishonored check has been tendered by any individual, firm, corporation, company, association, copartnership, estate, trust, trustee, receiver syndicate or any group or combination acting as a unit to the Department of Revenue within the immediately preceding two years","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.228","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7479fb333f277001","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule establishes a 60-day deadline for tax court appeals on decisions issued before October 6, 2001, while the statute specifies only a 90-day deadline.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.305","citation":"ORS 305.305(3)","quote":"If the person disagrees with the department's action, the person may file a complaint or petition with the tax court within 90 days after the date of the department's action","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0290","citation":"150-305-0290(6)","quote":"A taxpayer that disagrees with a decision issued before October 6, 2001, must file an appeal with the Magistrate Division of the Oregon Tax Court within 60 days of the department's decision. A taxpayer that disagrees with a decision issued on or after October 6, 2001, must file an appeal with the Magistrate Division of the Oregon Tax Court within 90 days of the department's decision.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.305","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"667b9193bee35e0e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule specifies that the six-month deadline runs from the 'mailing date' of the final determination, but the statute states the deadline is 'within six months of the final determination' without specifying when that determination is deemed made or mailed.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.285","citation":"ORS 305.285","quote":"within six months of the final determination, whichever is later","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0260","citation":"OAR 150-305-0260(2)","quote":"within six months of the mailing date of the final determination, whichever is later","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.285","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"accf6e16bb496404","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0230 states a claim for refund is not required to be submitted on a particular form and may be submitted as 'any other refund computation,' but the statute requires that claims 'shall be made on a form prescribed by the department' except for amended returns.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.270","citation":"ORS 305.270(2)","quote":"The claim shall be made on a form prescribed by the department, except that an amended report or return showing a refund due and filed within the time allowed by this subsection for the filing of a claim for refund, shall constitute a claim for refund.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0230","citation":"OAR 150-305-0230","quote":"A claim for refund is not required to be submitted on a particular form. A claim for refund may be submitted as an original return or report claiming a refund, an amended return or report claiming a refund, or any other refund computation setting forth a claim for refund.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f92a9290ed66222e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule section 3(c) cites ORS 305.084(5)(b) or (c) as describing 'technological or financial hardship' grounds for a waiver, but those statute sections address liability protections, not hardship or exemption criteria.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-305-0085","citation":"150-305-0085(3)(c)","quote":"A financial institution demonstrating, to the department's satisfaction, that it has a technological or financial hardship described in ORS 305.084(5)(b) or (c) that prevents it from providing the type of submissions described in section 3(a) or (b) of this rule may request a temporary waiver from complying with the data match system requirements.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-305.084","citation":"ORS 305.084(5)","quote":"Financial institutions, institution-affiliated parties as defined in the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813(u)) and institution-affiliated parties as defined in the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. 1786(r)) are not liable under state law to any person: (a) For any disclosure of information to the department under this section; (b) For encumbering or surrendering any assets held by the financial institution in response to a notice of lien or levy issued by the department; or (c) For any other action taken in good faith to comply with the requirements of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.084","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7494bab555a67ec2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a requirement to comply with ORS 315.650 that the statute does not mention or impose, narrowing what refund contributions are permitted.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.796","citation":"ORS 305.796(2)","quote":"The amount elected to be contributed by the taxpayer must be at least $25 and may be applied as a contribution only for the tax year in which the refund is issued.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0450","citation":"OAR 150-305-0450(2)","quote":"Must contribute at least $25 per account in accordance with ORS 315.650.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0450","citation":"OAR 150-305-0450(3)","quote":"May use contributions made under this section in calculating the credit under ORS 315.650 only for the tax year in which the refund is issued.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.796","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ddc845d306f6baac","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates that full opportunity for hearing shall be afforded to interested parties, but the rule makes hearing optional and requires a person to request it.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.105","citation":"ORS 305.105","quote":"Full opportunity for hearing shall be afforded to interested parties.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0030","citation":"OAR 150-305-0030(8)(a)","quote":"A person may request a department hearing on all issues to be addressed by a declaratory ruling.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"51498b5df8328baf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule substitutes a narrower standard ('circumstance beyond control') for the statute's broader 'reasonable cause' exception and omits the intent-to-evade element.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.217","citation":"ORS 305.217","quote":"unless it is shown that the failure to report is due to reasonable cause and not done with the intent to evade payment of the tax","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0130","citation":"OAR 150-305-0130(2)","quote":"the expense will be allowed if the individual or entity can show there was a circumstance beyond the individual or entity's control that caused the failure to file returns as required by law","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.217","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8f629222ee86efc4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"Rule 150-305-0152 applies the increased interest rate from 61 days after assessment in jurisdictional-only appeals, but ORS 305.222(3) conditions application of the increased rate on entry of a court order affirming the deficiency.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-305.222","citation":"ORS 305.222(3)","quote":"If the deficiency assessment is appealed to the Oregon Tax Court without prior payment of tax, then notwithstanding subsection (2) of this section, the increased rate of interest shall commence only for interest periods that begin 61 days after the date that the order of the Oregon Tax Court or the Oregon Supreme Court affirming the deficiency is entered.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-305-0152","citation":"150-305-0152","quote":"In an appeal where the court must first determine whether it has jurisdiction to consider the issues, the increased rate of interest will commence on the 61st day after the date of the assessment.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-305.222","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"900b314411f5c9e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"320","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":16,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DOR statewide-transit-tax rule cites the wrong ORS 320.550 subsection for the 'knowing failure to withhold' penalty — the rule's operative penalty provisions key to (10), a nonresident-wage-reporting subsection, where the actual $250/$25,000 penalty is in (9)(b).","documents":[{"id":"ors-320.550","citation":"ORS 320.550(9)(b)","quote":"...subject to a penalty of $250 per employee, up to a maximum penalty of $25,000, if the employer knowingly fails to deduct and withhold the tax.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-320-0510","citation":"OAR 150-320-0510(1) & (3)","quote":"the department must assess penalties, as described in ORS 320.550(10), when an employer knowingly fails to deduct and withhold statewide transit tax.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f83149e2f6de2032","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A rule broadens the statutory 'Employer' definition to include lenders/sureties, though the statute treats them as a separate, narrower liability category.","documents":[{"id":"ors-320.550","citation":"ORS 320.550(1)(a) & (6)","quote":"'Employer' has the meaning given that term in ORS 316.162. ... [lenders/sureties are liable only 'in a sum equal to the taxes'].)","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-150-316-0359","citation":"OAR 150-316-0359(1)(a)","quote":"'Employer' has the meaning given that term in ORS 316.162 and also includes lenders, sureties, and other persons subject to withholding and reporting requirements under ORS 316.169.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"16be43c38c85ccb2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A rule routes all amusement-device tax-penalty waivers to the general discretionary process, without acknowledging the statute's separate mandatory waiver ground.","documents":[{"id":"ors-320.075","citation":"ORS 320.075(3)","quote":"The penalty imposed in subsection (2) of this section shall be waived if the sole reason the tax was not paid is because of the failure of the Oregon State Lottery to act...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-320-0030","citation":"OAR 150-320-0030","quote":"The provisions of OAR 150-305-0068 shall be followed to determine when the department may waive a penalty...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4d8daa06f10162b1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]}],"artifacts":["ors-320.400 title truncated (missing \"320.490 and 803.203\").","oar-150-320-0430 statutes_implemented omits ORS 320.410 despite the rule's own body text describing that exact obligation."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"323","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DOJ tobacco-escrow rule imposes quarterly deposit deadlines (15 days after quarter-end) inside the statute's single annual April-15 deadline — tighter than, but not contradicting, the statutory outer limit; still a real discrepancy for a reader relying on the statute alone.","documents":[{"id":"ors-323.806","citation":"ORS 323.806(1)(b)(A)","quote":"place into a qualified escrow fund by April 15 of the year following the year in question...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-105-0020","citation":"OAR 137-105-0020(1)","quote":"escrow deposits ... in quarterly payments ... no later than 15 days after the end of each quarter.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"22248ef5d5e766d1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"A DOJ rule cross-references a subsection of ORS 323.806 for inflation-adjusted escrow amounts that doesn't exist — subsection (2) is about importer liability, not per-unit rate adjustment.","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-105-0020","citation":"OAR 137-105-0020(2)","quote":"...as adjusted for inflation pursuant to ORS 323.806(2)(a)(A)-(E).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-323.806","citation":"ORS 323.806(2)","quote":"(2) In the case of units sold that are cigarettes manufactured outside the United States and imported into the United States by an importer: (a) Importers shall be jointly and severally liable...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c5134263bce83fd7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"A rule and statute cite different closing section numbers (323.806 vs. 323.807) for the same Attorney General enforcement-monitoring authorization.","documents":[{"id":"ors-323.862","citation":"ORS 323.862","quote":"...monitor and enforce compliance by tobacco product manufacturers with ORS 323.800 to 323.807.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-105-0050","citation":"OAR 137-105-0050(1)","quote":"...to monitor and enforce compliance by tobacco product manufacturers with ORS 323.800 to 323.806.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a908c31fb5c7b539","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"artifacts":["oar-581-015-2390 (special-education hearings rule) cites \"ORS 323.055\" (cigarette tax exemption) as legal_authority — almost certainly a chapter transcription error for ORS 343.055, producing a bogus implemented_by cross-link on the cigarette-tax statute."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-public-transit-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Public Transit Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"328","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[{"summary":"A CPA-audit rule narrows the statute's three-statute audit-scope basis (ORS 327.011, 327.013, or 327.019) to just 327.013.","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.465","citation":"ORS 328.465(5)","quote":"The audit required by this section must include an audit of those factors that are used to compute the State School Fund distribution under ORS 327.011, 327.013 or 327.019.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-162-010-0315","citation":"OAR 162-010-0315","quote":"...compliance with legal requirements as stated in ORS 327.013 and as further defined by [ODE]...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"},{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"545e8324a8004df9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-audits-division"]},{"summary":"An OST rule conditions nonstandard-district bond approval on ORS 328.280(1)'s purposes list instead of the statute's own ORS 328.205(1) list.","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.205","citation":"ORS 328.205(2)","quote":"the school district may contract a bonded indebtedness only for the purposes enumerated in subsection (1) of this section that are approved by the Superintendent...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-023-0060","citation":"OAR 581-023-0060(1)","quote":"The purpose of the revenues is listed under ORS 328.280(1)...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"},{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"fb9cec542ec04c3c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"An OST bond-guaranty rule's ineligibility trigger omits the statute's cure/reinstatement mechanism.","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.331","citation":"ORS 328.331(5)","quote":"...is not eligible to issue any additional school bonds with the state guaranty until: (a) All payment obligations ... are satisfied; and (b) The State Treasurer certifies ... fiscally solvent.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-063-0000","citation":"OAR 170-063-0000(10)(b)","quote":"OST may deny ... or revoke a previously issued Certificate of Qualification ... if: ... (b) The State has ever paid ... any principal of or interest on any of the School District's bonds;","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"0177693b8107466d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"A rule adds a documentary 'letter to OST' requirement to the statutory 'paying agent' definition it restates.","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.321","citation":"ORS 328.321(3)","quote":"'Paying agent' means the corporate paying agent selected by the school district board ... who is: (a) Duly qualified; and (b) Acceptable to the State Treasurer.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-063-0000","citation":"OAR 170-063-0000(1)(j)","quote":"'Qualified Paying Agent' means a paying agent acceptable to OST who agrees ... and provides a letter to OST acknowledging as much.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"79101bd525aa6668","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The statute allows qualified districts to forgo the state guaranty by not referring to ORS 328.321 to 328.356 on bond faces, giving districts a choice, but the rule mandates that districts with a valid Certificate of Qualification and compliant with the rule must reference the guaranty on the face of their bonds, removing the option to forgo after following procedures.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.331","citation":"ORS 328.331(4)","quote":"Any qualified school district that chooses to forgo the benefits of the state guaranty for a particular issue of school bonds may do so by not referring to ORS 328.321 to 328.356 on the face of its school bonds.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-063-0000","citation":"OAR 170-063-0000(12)","quote":"School Districts with a valid Certificate of Qualification, and that have complied with section (6) and all other sections of this rule, shall evidence the State's guaranty of the School District's bonds by...  (b) Referencing the guaranty on the face of the School District's applicable bond(s)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v4-escape-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-328.331","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f850f2139e2d8e2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The rule implements a school bond guaranty program for school districts, but ORS 328.356 addresses only the State Treasurer's own bond issuances and is subject to ORS 291.445, not a guaranty program for school districts.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.356","citation":"ORS 328.356","quote":"If the State Treasurer issues state bonds, the treasurer shall be subject to the provisions of ORS 291.445 as an agency that is authorized to issue general obligation bonds that are ordinarily to be repaid from General Fund appropriations.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-063-0000","citation":"OAR 170-063-0000(1)(b)","quote":"The \"Act\" means the Oregon School Bond Guaranty Act set forth in ORS 328.321 to 328.356.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v4-escape-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-328.356","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9c12bfae2e9d8e81","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"The rule adds approval conditions (inclusion in corrective deficiency plan and non-impairment of standard district efforts) that the statute does not require for the Superintendent's approval.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.205","citation":"ORS 328.205(2)","quote":"the school district may contract a bonded indebtedness only for the purposes enumerated in subsection (1) of this section that are approved by the Superintendent of Public Instruction pursuant to rules of the State Board of Education","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-023-0060","citation":"OAR 581-023-0060(1) and (2)","quote":"when: (1) The purpose of the revenues is listed under ORS 328.280(1) and is included in the district's plan to correct the deficiencies causing the nonstandard or conditionally standard status. (2) The district demonstrates that in contracting for bonded indebtedness it will not impair or delay its efforts in becoming a standard district.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-328.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3120a309be44627c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 328.356, but the operative text never engages with that statute's requirement that the State Treasurer be subject to ORS 291.445 when issuing state bonds; the rule is entirely about school district bond guaranty program procedures and never addresses State Treasurer obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.356","citation":"ORS 328.356","quote":"If the State Treasurer issues state bonds, the treasurer shall be subject to the provisions of ORS 291.445 as an agency that is authorized to issue general obligation bonds that are ordinarily to be repaid from General Fund appropriations.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-063-0000","citation":"OAR 170-063-0000, declared statutes_implemented (frontmatter)","quote":"ORS 328.321 - 328.356, ORS 328.331","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-328.356","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30bb4e4eda067627","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"Rule 162-010-0316 applies audit requirements to public charter schools, which the statute does not mention or address.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-328.465","citation":"ORS 328.465(1)","quote":"All school district boards and education service district boards shall cause to have prepared an annual audit of the books and accounts of the school district or education service district","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-162-010-0316","citation":"OAR 162-010-0316","quote":"Public charter schools created under ORS Chapter 338 are subject to review and compliance with the following","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-328.465","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bf654f0ee9f949d1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-audits-division"]}],"artifacts":["ors-328.321 title is truncated (\"Definitions for ORS 328.321 to\")."],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-audits-division","name":"Secretary of State, Audits Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"332","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"A veterans-diploma rule drops the statute's 'physically present in' requirement for six named military operations, collapsing it into a general wartime-service standard.","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.114","citation":"ORS 332.114(4)(b)","quote":"Served in the Armed Forces of the United States and was physically present in: (A) Operation Urgent Fury (Grenada)... (F) Operation Iraqi Freedom (Iraq)...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2005","citation":"OAR 581-022-2005(1)(d)","quote":"The veteran served in Armed Forces of the United States during: ... (E) Operation Urgent Fury (Grenada) ... (J) Operation Iraqi Freedom (Iraq)...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"},{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"954c677b3fe8774c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The same rule adds a 'did not complete a high school diploma' requirement the statute doesn't contain.","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.114","citation":"ORS 332.114(3)(a)","quote":"Attended a high school before serving in the Armed Forces of the United States","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2005","citation":"OAR 581-022-2005(1)(b)","quote":"The veteran attended a high school, but did not complete a high school diploma, before serving...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"0e16dc49e84c19cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"A rule cites ORS 332.158 as authority for public-charter-school facility rules, though ORS 332.158(4) expressly excludes public charter schools from that section's scope.","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.158","citation":"ORS 332.158(4)","quote":"The provisions of this section do not apply to a public charter school.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-026-0600","citation":"OAR 581-026-0600, statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 332.158 & ORS 338 — rule text is entirely about \"Public Charter School Facility Location\".","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"},{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"833ac2b9e8c47154","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The rule requires the Oregon School for the Deaf (OSD) to develop, submit, test, and report HASS Plans, but the statute only requires this of school districts, education service districts, and public charter schools.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.331","citation":"ORS 332.331(1)","quote":"A school district, education service district or public charter school shall develop and adopt a plan, to be known as the Healthy and Safe Schools Plan","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2223","citation":"OAR 581-022-2223(1)(l)","quote":"\"OSD\" means the Oregon School for the Deaf","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2223","citation":"OAR 581-022-2223(4)","quote":"Districts, ESDs, OSD, and Charter Schools shall submit an electronic copy of a draft HASS Plan to the Department","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v4-escape-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-332.331","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9f8ab7f7edf44a15","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The rule allows electronic communications programs as an alternative method to fulfill the statutory requirement to send electronic mail to parents and staff, broadening the method beyond what the statute specifies.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.334","citation":"ORS 332.334(1)(b)(B)","quote":"By sending electronic mail to staff, students and parents of minor students for whom the district or school has electronic mail addresses on file.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2223","citation":"OAR 581-022-2223(12)(a)(B)","quote":"Final Test results shall be: (i) Emailed to staff, students, and parents of minor students by Districts, ESDs, OSD, and Charter Schools for those staff, students, or parents of minor students for which they have email addresses; or (ii) Delivered to staff, students, and parents of minor students, by an electronic communications program by those Districts, ESDs, OSD, or Charter Schools that use an electronic communications program in place of an email list.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v4-escape-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-332.334","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb8ae8ce76fd3875","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The rule limits reporting to 'Final Test results' for lead in water only, whereas the statute requires making available 'the results of any testing' conducted under the plan.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.334","citation":"ORS 332.334(1)(a)","quote":"A school district, education service district or public charter school shall make the results of any testing conducted under a plan described in ORS 332.331 available to the public no later than 10 business days after receiving the test results.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2223","citation":"OAR 581-022-2223(12)(a)(A)","quote":"Final Test results shall be made available on the District's, ESD's, OSD's, or Charter School's website","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v4-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v4-escape-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-332.334","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"e7888e8f55d98a9a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"The rule allows districts to restrict communication of test results to only 'affiliated' members, narrowing the statute's requirement to make results available to 'the public'.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-332.334","citation":"ORS 332.334(1)(a)","quote":"make the results of any testing conducted under a plan described in ORS 332.331 available to the public","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2223","citation":"OAR 581-022-2223(13)","quote":"Districts, ESDs, and Charter Schools may restrict communication of test results required under the HASS Plans to the staff, students, parents, and other community members affiliated with the building for which the test results are available.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-332.334","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3de47588fac13731","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]}],"artifacts":["oar-333-061-0400 cites ORS 332.334 substantively in its own text but omits it from statutes_implemented/relationships.implements."],"run_id":"haiku-v5-think-328332","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"339","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 589-007-0600 declares it implements ORS 339.505, but that statute addresses definitions for the student accounting system (graduate, school dropout, etc.) and does not provide operative authority for establishing, approving, or regulating the Adult High School Diploma Program that is the rule's actual subject.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-007-0600","citation":"OAR 589-007-0600, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 339.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-339.505","citation":"ORS 339.505","quote":"Definitions for ORS 339.505 to 339.520; rules. (1) For purposes of the student accounting system required by ORS 339.515, the following definitions shall be used: (a) \"Graduate\" means... (b) \"School dropout\" means... (c) \"School dropout\" does not include...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-339.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2fd7ee277767f998","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"}]},{"ors_chapter":"340","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[{"summary":"The entire OAR division (six rules) implementing ORS 340.320's Accelerated College Credit Instructor Grant Program was repealed in 2025, yet all six are still marked status: current.","documents":[{"id":"ors-340.320","citation":"ORS 340.320(1)","quote":"The Department of Education, in collaboration with the [HECC], shall administer the Accelerated College Credit Instructor Grant Program as provided by this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-017-0640","citation":"OAR 581-017-0640, status: current, effective_date 2025-04-02","quote":"History: ODE 18-2025, repeal filed 04/02/2025, effective 04/02/2025 ... (no operative text)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Identical pattern across all six oar-581-017-06xx rules.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b2ed86c0a94351f2","cites_repealed":["oar-581-017-0640"],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"A HECC dual-credit reporting rule drops 'school district' from the statutory list of obligated annual reporters.","documents":[{"id":"ors-340.310","citation":"ORS 340.310(3)","quote":"Each school district, community college and public university that provides a dual credit program shall submit an annual report...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-017-0005","citation":"OAR 715-017-0005(3)","quote":"Oregon community colleges and public universities shall submit an annual report...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"4ebb664c59645f33","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"artifacts":["oar-715-017-0005 legal_authority omits ORS 341.484, though statutes_implemented/relationships.implements both include it."],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"341","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":80,"candidates":[{"summary":"Section (5) contains a self-reference that appears to be a typo; it states 'The Commission may also include these projects on the prioritized list of projects referenced in section (5) of this rule' but is itself section (5), likely intending to reference section (4) which discusses prioritized lists.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-003-0100","citation":"589-003-0100(5)","quote":"The Commission may also include these projects on the prioritized list of projects referenced in section (5) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.937","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6516dd58ce332c24","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-004-0200(1)(b)(B) states colleges may not deny access to education records, but OAR 589-004-0250(8) permits colleges to deny inspection and review of certain records such as confidential recommendation letters.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-004-0200","citation":"OAR 589-004-0200(1)(b)(B)","quote":"With an understanding that it may not deny access to education records, a description of the circumstances in which the agency or institution believes it has a legitimate cause to deny a request for a copy of those records","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-004-0250","citation":"OAR 589-004-0250(8)","quote":"A college does not have to permit a student to inspect and review the following records: (a) Financial records of the student's parents; (b) Confidential letters and statements of recommendation if the student has waived his or her right to inspect the letters and statements under the procedure in 34 CFR, Section 99.12(b)(3).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.290","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f0fb263c4d95c42e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 589-002-0600 extensively implements procedures for nondistrict area contracts under ORS 341.022 but omits the statute's mandatory 300 FTE enrollment cap for annual state reimbursable enrollments.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.022","citation":"ORS 341.022","quote":"Annual state reimbursable enrollments under an agreement with a nondistrict area shall not exceed 300 full-time equivalent students.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0600","citation":"OAR 589-002-0600","quote":"The contract between the community college and the local contracting entity must include an annual budget setting forth both revenue and expenditures for services provided to the nondistrict area.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.022","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8f489310df116fdd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 589-002-0130 declares it implements ORS 341.492, but the operative text addresses only strategic fund management and never engages with ORS 341.492's subject matter of residency for state aid distribution.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0130","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.015, ORS 341.022, ORS 341.317, ORS 341.440, ORS 341.626, ORS 341.665, ORS 341.484, ORS 341.492","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.492","citation":"ORS 341.492(1)-(2)","quote":"The provisions of ORS 341.487 shall not apply to admissions arranged under ORS 350.750. For purposes of ORS 341.626, and notwithstanding ORS 341.487, students who are residents of Idaho, Washington, California and Nevada and students admitted pursuant to ORS 350.750 shall be considered as residents of Oregon.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.492","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a89582a555eee81","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 341.484 but the operative text never engages with contracts for reimbursement between college districts, reimbursement amounts, or the substance of that statute; instead it addresses only strategic fund allocation procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0130","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.015, ORS 341.022, ORS 341.317, ORS 341.440, ORS 341.626, ORS 341.665, ORS 341.484, ORS 341.492","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.484","citation":"ORS 341.484(1)-(3)","quote":"In the event of an agreement between two colleges to admit each other's students, if the student seeking admission to the community college resides within that college's district, no additional reimbursement shall be required from any college district. However, if the student does not reside within the district, a contract of reimbursement may be entered into between the district and any other district. The contract shall provide for reimbursement to the district for each student in an amount not to exceed the difference between the per student operating expense of the district and the amounts obtained from the student for tuition and fees and obtained from state and federal aid.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.484","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"50913680354c12cf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 341.481 (Admission of students), but the rule's operative text is explicitly about state reimbursement eligibility, a subject that the statute does not address.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0200","citation":"OAR 589-002-0200 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.290(7), ORS 341.626, ORS 341.481, ORS 341.496","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.481","citation":"ORS 341.481","quote":"Admission of students","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.481","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4b4d8a597c544e82","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-007-0180(2) allows contracts with local joint committees for educational services under ORS 341.440, but the statute limits contracts to enumerated parties (another community college district, common or union high school district, education service district, public university, OHSU, private educational institution with NW accreditation, or career school) and does not list local joint committees.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.440","citation":"ORS 341.440(1)","quote":"A community college district may contract with another community college district, a common or union high school district, an education service district, a public university listed in ORS 352.002, the Oregon Health and Science University, a private educational institution accredited by the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities or its successor or a career school as defined in ORS 345.010 to obtain educational services for students enrolled in the community college of the district.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0180","citation":"OAR 589-007-0180(2)","quote":"A community college may enter into contracts with local joint committees to obtain educational services for students enrolled in the community college as identified in ORS 341.440.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.440","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a555d9322bed8cdc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares implementation of ORS 341.185 (review of zone boundaries and appeals procedures) but the rule's operative text addresses only formation requirements for community college districts and never engages with zone boundary review or appeal procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-005-0100","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.025 - 341.185","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.185","citation":"ORS 341.185","quote":"Except as provided in ORS 255.400 to 255.424, any elector of a district aggrieved by the adjustment of or failure to adjust boundaries of a zone pursuant to ORS 341.175 on the basis that population is not as nearly equal as is feasible is entitled to appear before the board at a public hearing to present the case. If the board refuses to make the requested adjustment in the boundaries, the aggrieved elector may appeal from the decision of the board to the circuit court.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.185","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"53f7ac24a266a01d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The statute permits any of six categories of entities (school districts, education service districts, institutions of higher education, counties, municipalities, or private organizations) to contract with a community college, but the rule addresses only local joint committees and does not acknowledge the other five categories listed in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.315","citation":"ORS 341.315","quote":"Any school district, education service district, institution of higher education, county, municipality or private organization may contract with a community college district to provide services of an educational nature that are subject to the approval of the Higher Education Coordinating Commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0180","citation":"OAR 589-007-0180(1)","quote":"Local joint committees, as private organizations, may contract with a community college to provide services of an educational nature that are subject to the approval of the Commission as identified in ORS 341.315.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.315","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1f5a02ab007fca73","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The statute requires armed forces members to be treated as Oregon residents for admission and fee/tuition purposes, but the rule's definition of 'Oregon Resident' imposes a 90 continuous-day residency requirement and does not explicitly exempt armed forces members from it, despite the statute not imposing such a requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.496","citation":"ORS 341.496(2)","quote":"Community colleges in Oregon shall admit active members of the Armed Forces of the United States, active members of the commissioned corps of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and members of the Public Health Service of the United States Department of Health and Human Services detailed by proper authority for duty with the Army or Navy of the United States, and their spouses and dependent children, in the same manner as Oregon residents who are residents of the community college district and shall assess the same fees and tuition rates.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0200","citation":"OAR 589-002-0200(2)","quote":"\"Oregon Resident\" is defined as a person who currently maintains a permanent residence in the state and whose permanent residence has been maintained in Oregon for no less that ninety continuous days immediately preceding the person's first instructional day of the term (quarter) for which residency is in question.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.496","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c54764cabdbf5cf1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The statute requires audit statements to be filed by December 31 of the year the audit is conducted, but the rule requires submission by January 2 of the year following the year the audit is conducted—a different deadline.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.709","citation":"ORS 341.709(1)","quote":"The audit statements must be filed with the administrative office for the district on or before December 31 of the year in which the audit is conducted.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0900","citation":"OAR 589-002-0900(3)","quote":"Colleges are required to submit to the Office one copy of their final audits no later than January 2 of each year following the year for which the audits are conducted.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.709","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"681790128b0863ef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-002-0130(3) and (4) refer to 'the formula described in Section 6 of 589-002-0110,' but OAR 589-002-0110 is a definitions rule containing only numbered definitions (1)-(33) with no Section 6, and no formula is described there. The formula is described in Section 6 of OAR 589-002-0120.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0130","citation":"589-002-0130(3) and (4)","quote":"Strategic Funds allocated for either purpose will not be considered in the distribution of funds through the formula described in Section 6 of 589-002-0110","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0110","citation":"589-002-0110","quote":"589-002-0110 Definitions The following definitions apply to OAR 589-002-0100 through 589-002-0130. (1) \"Adult\" is any student...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.626","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b58b7b3acbf9cd97","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule expands the scope of who must be considered beyond the statute's definition of persons who served in the Armed Forces.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.506","citation":"ORS 341.506(1)","quote":"education and training obtained by a person while the person served in the Armed Forces of the United States, as defined in ORS 341.496","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0300","citation":"oar-589-007-0300","quote":"Each community college requesting approval for the training of veterans and other eligible persons will contact the State Approving Agency (SAA)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.506","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f445be25b1ff57c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 575-039-0040 eliminates eligibility for 'one-year curriculum for students who plan to transfer to another post-secondary institution of education' that the statute includes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.522","citation":"ORS 341.522(3)(a)(B)","quote":"Determined by the office, in accordance with rules adopted by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission, to be required for completion of: (i) A one-year curriculum for students who plan to transfer to another post-secondary institution of education; (ii) An associate degree; or (iii) A program in career and technical education","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-039-0040","citation":"OAR 575-039-0040(1)","quote":"Oregon Promise Grants may be awarded to students who are enrolled in courses at an Oregon community college that are required for completion of: (a) An associate degree; or (b) A program in career and technical education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.522","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"576570d9882d4e18","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Rule 575-039-0070(1)(c) drops the statute's requirement that students enroll for at least three terms in each consecutive academic year to maintain half-time enrollment eligibility.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.522","citation":"ORS 341.522(6)(a)(C)","quote":"Enrolls in courses described in subsection (3)(a) of this section for a sufficient number of credit hours to be considered at least a half-time student each term for at least three terms in each consecutive academic year.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-039-0070","citation":"OAR 575-039-0070(1)(c)","quote":"Enroll for a sufficient number of credits to be considered at least a half-time student, except that the Commission may waive the requirement that a student enroll for terms beginning or ending while a state or local declaration of emergency and related executive orders by the Governor restricting the operations of Oregon community colleges are in effect, as determined by the Commission.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.522","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bbbafc53bdb8e36d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Rule 575-039-0060(2)(a) changes the minimum grant calculation from the statute's 'greater of' ($2,000 adjusted or actual tuition) to 'whichever is less' ($2,000 or actual tuition), resulting in lower minimum awards when actual tuition exceeds $2,000.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.522","citation":"ORS 341.522(7)(a)(A)","quote":"not less than the greater of: (i) $2,000, adjusted for inflation based on the increase of the average cost of tuition at a community college operated under this chapter in a manner determined by the commission by rule; and (ii) The person's actual cost for tuition.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-039-0060","citation":"OAR 575-039-0060(2)(a)","quote":"No less than $2,000 or the actual cost of tuition, whichever is less","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.522","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fd6643dcb41644e7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The rule adds PDF email delivery as a permissible method for submitting petitions, but the statute only allows petitions to be received by the commission or mailed with a postmark date.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.565","citation":"ORS 341.565(2)(b)","quote":"Be either received by the commission, or mailed to the commission as evidenced by a postmark date, no later than 90 days after the date the first signature on the petition is recorded.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-005-0300","citation":"OAR 589-005-0300(8)","quote":"The delivery of a petition by PDF attachment to email to an address specified by the Commission on or prior to the expiry date of the petition, or by mail bearing a postmark date no later than 90 days after the date the first signature on the petition was recorded, shall also be evidence of timely submission.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.565","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d4767aef913ead0c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule changes the statutory requirement from considering 'programs' (plural) to 'program' (singular) when evaluating adverse effects on districts' ability to continue services.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.565","citation":"ORS 341.565(1)","quote":"The commission must find that the proposed change will have no substantially adverse effect upon the ability of the affected districts to provide and continue their programs","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-005-0300","citation":"OAR 589-005-0300(1)","quote":"The Commission must find that the proposed change will have no substantially adverse effect upon the ability of the affected districts to provide and continue their program","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.565","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ec5b7ea5bbd6ef02","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 589-005-0400(1) limits remonstrance petitions to 'annexation of territory' while the statute covers boundary changes that include both inclusion and exclusion of territory.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-005-0400","citation":"589-005-0400(1)","quote":"A petition submitted in remonstrance to the annexation of territory to a community college district pursuant to ORS 341.569 shall be submitted no later than 20 days from the date the Commission issues an order describing the revised boundaries of the district.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.569","citation":"341.569(1)(c)","quote":"The remonstrance is signed by at least five percent of the electors or at least 500 of the electors, whichever is less, in: (A) An area to be included in the district or excluded from the district by the proposed boundary change; or (B) The existing community college district","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.569","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fe443a3872047219","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 589-002-0700 limits services to 'DOC operated facilities' when the statute allows both state-operated and locally operated correctional facilities.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.317","citation":"ORS 341.317(1)","quote":"community colleges that deliver educational services to adults in custody confined to the state-operated correctional facilities and to locally operated correctional facilities","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0700","citation":"589-002-0700(1)","quote":"to provide Adult Basic Education (ABE) or Work Based Education (WBE) services at DOC operated facilities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.317","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"10a0ef1c8ea6a648","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule 589-002-0130 declares it implements ORS 341.317 but contains no operative text engaging with educational services to adults in custody at correctional institutions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-002-0130","citation":"589-002-0130 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.015, ORS 341.022, ORS 341.317, ORS 341.440, ORS 341.626, ORS 341.665, ORS 341.484, ORS 341.492","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.317","citation":"ORS 341.317","quote":"Educational services to adults in custody at correctional institutions; reimbursement","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.317","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"15566d8f6a088966","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule defines a CCSD characteristic as inability to incur bonded indebtedness but omits the statute's explicit exception for lease-purchase arrangements and other lawful forms of capital financing.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.039","citation":"ORS 341.039(2)(a)","quote":"community college service districts formed on or after July 1, 1997, may not incur bonded indebtedness for any purpose. This limitation shall not be construed to prohibit lease-purchase arrangements or other lawful forms of capital financing.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-005-0200","citation":"OAR 589-005-0200(1)(a)","quote":"May not incur bonded indebtedness for any purpose","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.039","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7097f6c20dcf465c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 341.665 (which addresses only funding conditions and FTE reimbursement restrictions) but the operative text never engages with any funding requirement—it merely provides apprenticeship-related definitions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-007-0100","citation":"589-007-0100 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 351.735, 341.665, 660.157, 660.160, 660.167, 660.190","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-341.665","citation":"ORS 341.665(1)–(2)","quote":"The receiving community college shall be awarded funds from the contracted out-of-district funds allocated to the Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development if the college operates the program under a contract with an apprenticeship training committee and the contract is approved by the office. A community college district may submit full-time equivalencies generated by apprenticeship programs to the office for reimbursement from the Community College Support Fund for purposes of ORS 341.626 but may not submit for reimbursement those full-time equivalencies generated through contracts under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0fa28e57f3339ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 341.665 (which addresses only funding conditions and FTE reimbursement restrictions) but the operative text addresses only apprenticeship-related training course requirements and never engages with any funding requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-007-0110","citation":"589-007-0110 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS, 341.665, 660.157, 660.160, 660.167, 660.190","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-341.665","citation":"ORS 341.665(1)–(2)","quote":"The receiving community college shall be awarded funds from the contracted out-of-district funds allocated to the Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development if the college operates the program under a contract with an apprenticeship training committee and the contract is approved by the office. A community college district may submit full-time equivalencies generated by apprenticeship programs to the office for reimbursement from the Community College Support Fund for purposes of ORS 341.626 but may not submit for reimbursement those full-time equivalencies generated through contracts under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0d4f9d55557c4388","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 341.665 (which addresses only funding conditions and FTE reimbursement restrictions) but the operative text addresses only apprenticeship instructor requirements and never engages with any funding requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-007-0130","citation":"589-007-0130 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 341.425, 341.665, 660.157, 660.160, 660.167, 660.190","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-341.665","citation":"ORS 341.665(1)–(2)","quote":"The receiving community college shall be awarded funds from the contracted out-of-district funds allocated to the Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development if the college operates the program under a contract with an apprenticeship training committee and the contract is approved by the office. A community college district may submit full-time equivalencies generated by apprenticeship programs to the office for reimbursement from the Community College Support Fund for purposes of ORS 341.626 but may not submit for reimbursement those full-time equivalencies generated through contracts under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b19ae4e03d0ada2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 341.665 (which addresses only funding conditions and FTE reimbursement restrictions) but the operative text addresses only core apprenticeship services and never engages with any funding requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-007-0160","citation":"589-007-0160 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 351.735, 341.665, 660.157, 660.160, 660.167, 660.190","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-341.665","citation":"ORS 341.665(1)–(2)","quote":"The receiving community college shall be awarded funds from the contracted out-of-district funds allocated to the Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development if the college operates the program under a contract with an apprenticeship training committee and the contract is approved by the office. A community college district may submit full-time equivalencies generated by apprenticeship programs to the office for reimbursement from the Community College Support Fund for purposes of ORS 341.626 but may not submit for reimbursement those full-time equivalencies generated through contracts under subsection (1) of this section.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4c9649145ffec835","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the Office and 'the interested residents of the nondistrict area' to jointly apply to the county for appointment of the local advisory committee, but the rule requires only the Office and a single designated 'chief petitioner' to make the joint application.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.019","citation":"ORS 341.019(5)","quote":"the office and the interested residents of the nondistrict area shall apply jointly to the governing body of the county for the appointment of a local advisory committee","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0600","citation":"OAR 589-002-0600(5)","quote":"Upon receipt of the petition, the Office and the chief petitioner shall jointly apply to the county governing body for the appointment of a local advisory committee","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.019","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"94f80cdbdd287328","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The statute restricts state reimbursement to the Community College Support Fund specifically, but the rule allows reimbursement from 'state funds' more broadly.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.021","citation":"ORS 341.021(3)(a)","quote":"Such reimbursement shall come from the Community College Support Fund established in ORS 341.620","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-341.021","citation":"ORS 341.021(4)","quote":"Agreements developed under this section shall be wholly supported by Community College Support Fund reimbursement, nondistrict student tuition and nondistrict resources.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-002-0600","citation":"OAR 589-002-0600(9)(a)","quote":"The budget must be wholly supported by state funds, nondistrict student tuition, and other nondistrict resources","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.021","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e6fb8f526a212863","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule allows community college instructors to teach at high school sites without specifying the statute's requirement that instruction be limited to academic, career and technical education, school-to-work, or other work-related programs under ORS chapter 329.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-341.535","citation":"ORS 341.535(2)","quote":"community college faculty who provide instruction in cooperation with a school district for academic, career and technical education, school-to-work or other work-related programs under ORS chapter 329 are not required to have teaching licenses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-008-0200","citation":"OAR 589-008-0200(1)","quote":"A school district may contract with a community college accredited by the Northwest Association of Schools and Colleges or a community college contracting for delivery of instructional and curriculum services with an accredited community college for instruction at a high school site by a faculty member who does not hold a current Teacher Standards and Practices Commission license","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-341.535","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"be129421c56c39d7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Student Access and Completion"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"}]},{"ors_chapter":"342","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute requires post-secondary institutions accredited by the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities, but the rule requires accreditation by the Northwest Association of Schools and Colleges—two different accrediting organizations.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-342.173","citation":"ORS 342.173(2)","quote":"The person is employed as a teacher by a post-secondary institution that is accredited by the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities, or its successor","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-008-0200","citation":"OAR 589-008-0200(1)(a)","quote":"The faculty member is employed by a community college accredited by the Northwest Association of Schools and Colleges","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-342.173","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2952bf0f02a06e00","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-fair-dismissal-appeals-board","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Fair Dismissal Appeals Board"},{"slug":"teacher-standards-and-practices-commission","name":"Teacher Standards and Practices Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"345","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":16,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute defines the career-school licensure scope as \"345.010 to 345.340\"; three OAR rules from two agencies consistently cite \"345.010 to 345.450\" instead.","documents":[{"id":"ors-345.010","citation":"ORS 345.010(3)","quote":"'License' means the authority the career school has been granted to operate under ORS 345.010 to 345.340.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0305","citation":"OAR 839-005-0305","quote":"'Career school' includes those required to be licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.450...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"95111c2626a97e65","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Two rules implementing the same anti-discrimination statute (ORS 345.240) define the protected-class list differently — one includes 'veterans' status,' the other doesn't.","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-011-0005","citation":"OAR 715-011-0005(3), HECC","quote":"...based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, disability, veterans' status, sexual orientation, or marital status.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0305","citation":"OAR 839-005-0305(3), BLI","quote":"'Discrimination' means any act ... based on age, disability, national origin, race, color, marital status, religion, sex or sexual orientation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f240c8dc3f5633c5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries","higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"A DOJ contested-case-hearing rule is broader than the statute in one clause and internally contradicts a sibling clause of the same rule.","documents":[{"id":"ors-345.120","citation":"ORS 345.120(4)(a)","quote":"When notice of suspension or revocation is issued, the licensee shall be notified and, upon request, shall be granted a contested case hearing...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-011-0070","citation":"OAR 715-011-0070(2)(b)","quote":"A school may also request a contested case hearing ... upon receipt of the results of an investigation made under this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"360397bf0a45fdfb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"Garbled/transposed statute numbers in sibling rules' statutes_implemented fields (354.120, 648.596) don't match the ORS 345.120/348.6xx pattern used consistently by their siblings.","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-011-0065","citation":"OAR 715-011-0065 statutes_implemented","quote":"\"ORS 354.120\" — no chapter 354 citation appears anywhere else in this cluster; sibling rules use \"ORS 345.120\" in the same slot.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a00ec0adb3078577","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0320(1) states that pursuant to ORS 345.120, the Superintendent of Public Instruction has authority to suspend or revoke licenses, but ORS 345.120(3) vests that authority in the Higher Education Coordinating Commission, not the Superintendent.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-345.120","citation":"ORS 345.120(3)","quote":"As a result of the investigation, and in addition to any penalty that may be imposed under ORS 345.992, the commission may issue a notice for corrective action or, subject to the procedures set forth in subsection (4) of this section, may suspend or revoke any license issued under ORS 345.010 to 345.340 when the licensee has...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0320","citation":"OAR 839-005-0320(1)","quote":"Pursuant to ORS 345.120, the Superintendent of Public Instruction of the State of Oregon has authority to suspend or revoke licenses of career schools violating ORS 345.010 to 345.450 or any applicable rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-345.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e84bc0d0f492dc1c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The statute limits ORS 345.240 to career schools licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.340, but multiple rules extend coverage to ORS 345.010 to 345.450","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-345.240","citation":"ORS 345.240(1)","quote":"No career school licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.340 shall refuse admission to or discriminate in admission against or discriminate in giving instruction to any person otherwise qualified.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0300","citation":"OAR 839-005-0300(1)","quote":"ORS 345.240 prohibits unlawful discrimination by career schools licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.450.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-345.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cc5ed3fc833539df","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The statute limits ORS 345.240 to career schools licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.340, but the rule definition extends coverage to ORS 345.010 to 345.450","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-345.240","citation":"ORS 345.240(1)","quote":"No career school licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.340 shall refuse admission to or discriminate in admission against or discriminate in giving instruction to any person otherwise qualified.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0305","citation":"OAR 839-005-0305(2)","quote":"\"Career school\" includes those required to be licensed under ORS 345.010 to 345.450, and excludes entities described in ORS 345.015.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-345.240","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"77e853f701d70323","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]}],"artifacts":["ors-345.120's sliced text has subsection-marker line breaks that split cross-references mid-citation."],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"348","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":213,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rules about Oregon Troops to Teachers Program declare they implement ORS 348.205, which only authorizes rules for the Oregon Opportunity Grant program, not Troops to Teachers.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-074-0000","citation":"OAR 575-074-0000","quote":"ORS 348.180, ORS 348.205, ORS 348.250, ORS 348.260","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.205","citation":"ORS 348.205(8)","quote":"The commission shall adopt rules that implement the Oregon Opportunity Grant program.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ee1173f16a01ea8b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"OAR 575-074-0000 declares it implements ORS 348.180, but the rule defines terms for the Oregon Troops to Teachers Program which does not appear in ORS 348.180 (which defines only cost of education, eligible post-secondary institution, and qualified student), while the rule's operative text references Ch. 831 as its actual authority for the Troops to Teachers Program.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-074-0000","citation":"OAR 575-074-0000 statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.180, ORS 348.205, ORS 348.250, ORS 348.260","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.180","citation":"ORS 348.180","quote":"As used in this section and ORS 348.205, 348.250, 348.260 and 348.263: (1) \"Cost of education\" includes but is not limited to, tuition, fees and living expenses. (2) \"Eligible post-secondary institution\" means: (a) A public university listed in ORS 352.002; (b) A community college operated under ORS chapter 341; (c) The Oregon Health and Science University; or (d) An Oregon-based, generally accredited, not-for-profit institution of higher education. (3) \"Enrollment level\" means the course load taken by a student as a proportion of the expected full-time course load. (4) \"Qualified student\" means any student who has been a resident of this state for not less than 12 months prior to enrolling at an eligible post-secondary institution and who...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.180","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9f44567cc8001b23","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The rule requires students to be Oregon residents, but the statute does not mention residency as an eligibility requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.290","citation":"ORS 348.290","quote":"provide financial aid, as defined in ORS 348.505, to students to study barbering, hairdressing, manicure and esthetics at eligible post-secondary schools","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-035-0005","citation":"OAR 575-035-0005","quote":"For a student to be eligible for a Barbers and Hairdressers (B & H) Grant, the student must be a resident of the State of Oregon","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.290","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eea77eb70625db66","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0005","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ad936afeff40349","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0010","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aec794b4ae841db2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0015","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a764db661a0f89f9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0020","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"16b859f052761889","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0025","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"79defd3014ef25c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0030","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290, ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e5ae7aa77cb05b07","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0040","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & 348.505","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f0291de84701fb53","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0045","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c11b7dfbe39a6a45","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0046","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6b843b36c7b80beb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0050","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b484e2c8a5cb644a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0051","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"add3b0939e2353cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"All 12 rules claim to implement ORS 348.505, which is purely a definition section stating what 'financial aid' includes, not a statute that establishes eligibility requirements, grant amounts, conditions of award, residency rules, institutional requirements, or any of the substantive provisions these rules implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-035-0055","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.290 & ORS 348.505","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.505","citation":"ORS 348.505","quote":"As used in ORS 348.500 to 348.621, \"financial aid\" includes loans, grants, scholarships, work opportunities and other forms of financial aid to assist students in completing their post-high-school education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"80888fb6094b9238","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The Oregon Troops to Teachers rules declare they implement ORS 348.250, which is titled and limited to 'Procedure for awarding grants under ORS 348.260' and never engages with the Troops to Teachers program, veterans, teaching requirements, or tuition assistance for teachers in its operative text.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-074-0010","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.180, 348.205, 348.250 & 348.260","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.250","citation":"ORS 348.250(1)","quote":"Grants established under ORS 348.260 shall be awarded by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission in the manner provided in this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dba14cea173bdf7d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The statute limits fees to schools or persons 'requesting information' from the Commission, but the rule extends fees to those requesting 'services or information.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.603","citation":"ORS 348.603(2)","quote":"The commission, by rule, may impose a fee on any school or person requesting information from the commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-583-001-0015","citation":"OAR 583-001-0015","quote":"A fee may be imposed on any school or person requesting services or information from the Commission pertaining to the administration of its functions under ORS 348.594 to 348.615.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.603","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3af4da3e992c3a4a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"Rule 583-050-0006(2)(d) adds religious exempt schools as valid sources for degrees without disclaimer, a category not mentioned in statute ORS 348.609(1).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-050-0006","citation":"OAR 583-050-0006(2)(d)","quote":"Is an Oregon school that has achieved exemption from state oversight on religious grounds","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.609","citation":"ORS 348.609(1)","quote":"A person may not claim or represent that the person possesses any academic degree unless the degree has been awarded to or conferred upon the person by a school that: (a) Has accreditation recognized by the United States Department of Education or the foreign equivalent of such accreditation; (b) Has been approved by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission to offer and confer degrees in Oregon; (c) Is described in ORS 348.597; or (d) Is located in the United States and has been found by the commission to meet standards of academic quality comparable to those of an institution located in the United States that has accreditation, recognized by the United States Department of Education, to offer degrees of the type and level claimed by the person.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.609","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2add6c8a42f44e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"The statute requires at least 20 days' written notice before a hearing, but the rule requires 21 days' written notice before a hearing for revocation or suspension.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.612","citation":"ORS 348.612(4)","quote":"At least 20 days before holding a hearing under this section, the school must have received written notice of the place, time and reason for the hearing.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-583-030-0045","citation":"OAR 583-030-0045(4)","quote":"A hearing to consider a proposed revocation or suspension shall be held only after the affected school has been given written notice of the time and place of such hearing 21 days in advance.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9c792294ca67b74e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"The rule definition of 'school' in OAR 583-030-0015(31) covers any entity engaging in educational activities including teaching and recognition of educational attainment, while the statute limits 'school' to those that confer or offer degrees or provide academic credit applicable to a degree.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.594","citation":"ORS 348.594(3)(a)","quote":"\"School\" means a person, organization, school or institution of learning that confers or offers to confer an academic degree upon a person or to provide academic credit applicable to a degree.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-583-030-0015","citation":"OAR 583-030-0015(31)","quote":"\"School\" means any person or persons and any organization or group of organizations, whether incorporated or not, engaging or appearing to engage in the activities of an educational entity or institution of learning, whether or not naming itself a school, college, university, institute, academy, seminary, conservatory, or similar term. The activities attributable to a school include but are not limited to teaching, measurement of achievement or proficiency, or recognition of educational attainment or comparable public distinction.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.594","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"04c87762d05a1fcb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"Rule 583-030-0049 states that offering a degree without authorization \"is a Class B misdemeanor,\" while rule 583-050-0026 states that violations \"may result in\" prosecution for a Class B misdemeanor, creating inconsistency about whether the offense automatically constitutes a misdemeanor or only potentially results in one.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0049","citation":"OAR 583-030-0049(1)","quote":"any offer of a degree or of services purporting to lead to a degree in whole or in part is a Class B misdemeanor under ORS 348.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-583-050-0026","citation":"OAR 583-050-0026(6)","quote":"Any violation of ORS 348.603 or 348.609 may result in any or all of the following sanctions: (a) Prosecution for a Class B misdemeanor under ORS 348.992","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.992","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e3101d520733780","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"Rule 583-030-0063 declares it implements ORS 348.597, but the operative text never engages with that statute. The rule creates temporary emergency authorization for non-Oregon schools when their home state declares an emergency—a mechanism outside the normal authorization/exemption framework that ORS 348.597 addresses.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0063","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.606, ORS 350.075, ORS 348.597, ORS 348.603","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.597","citation":"ORS 348.597","quote":"Except as provided in subsection (2) of this section, ORS 348.594 to 348.615 apply to all schools that operate in this state.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.597","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fefdd8f9cd7eaaee","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"OAR 575-074-0010 and related Troops to Teachers rules (575-074-0000 through 575-074-0030) declare they implement ORS 348.260, but that statute is exclusively about Oregon Opportunity Grants and contains no authorization for, mention of, or engagement with the Oregon Troops to Teachers Program that is the sole subject of these rules.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-074-0010","citation":"OAR 575-074-0010 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.180, ORS 348.205, ORS 348.250, ORS 348.260","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.260","citation":"ORS 348.260(1)","quote":"In addition to any other form of student financial aid authorized by law, the Higher Education Coordinating Commission may award Oregon Opportunity Grants to qualified students.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.260","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e0339489860d284b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Section (2)(g) allows the Commission to assess a fee not to exceed $1,000 for exemption applications under ORS 348.604, but section (4)(c) provides a different, more restrictive limit stating the fee may not exceed the lesser of actual costs or $1,000.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0046","citation":"OAR 583-030-0046(2)(g)","quote":"The Commission may assess a fee not to exceed $1,000 on a school that applies for an exemption under ORS 348.604.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-583-030-0046","citation":"OAR 583-030-0046(4)(c)","quote":"The fee for religious-exempt schools may not exceed the actual cost to the Commission of determining the school's compliance with the requirements for an exemption under ORS 348.604, or may not exceed $1,000, whichever is the lesser amount.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.604","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"862f74b42814f235","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"Rule defines good standing to include satisfactory academic progress, in addition to or instead of the statutory 2.0 GPA requirement.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.268","citation":"ORS 348.268(1)(b)","quote":"\"Good standing\" means the qualified student has a cumulative grade point average of 2.0 or higher at Oregon Health and Science University or the community college, public university listed in ORS 352.002 or qualifying private institution at which the student is enrolled.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-067-0002","citation":"OAR 575-067-0002(2)","quote":"\"Good standing\" means the qualified student has a cumulative grade point average of 2.0 or higher or is maintaining satisfactory academic progress as defined by the institution in accordance with federal Title IV regulations and guidelines.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.268","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7bb7e53b985d4d6d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Rule requires completion of any military basic training in the United States Armed Forces, while statute requires basic training with Oregon National Guard or National Guard of another state or territory.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.268","citation":"ORS 348.268(1)(c)(D)","quote":"Has completed basic training with the Oregon National Guard or a National Guard of any other state or territory","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-067-0006","citation":"OAR 575-067-0006(1)(d)","quote":"Have completed any military basic training in the United States Armed Forces","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.268","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2131b3450d3be597","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Rule calculates grant amount based on resident tuition only, while statute requires grant amount to equal the sum of resident tuition charges, average fees, and book allowance.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.268","citation":"ORS 348.268(2)","quote":"A qualified student shall receive a grant under this section in an amount that equals the sum of the following, minus the amount of federal military tuition assistance received by the qualified student: (a)(A) The resident tuition charges at the community college at which the qualified student is enrolled; (B) The resident tuition charges at the public university listed in ORS 352.002 at which the qualified student is enrolled; (C) The average resident tuition charges to attend a public university listed in ORS 352.002 if the qualified student is enrolled at a qualifying private institution; or (D) The resident tuition charges at Oregon Health and Science University if the qualified student is enrolled at Oregon Health and Science University; (b) The average amount of fees charged by the type of institution at which the qualified student is enrolled, as determined by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission; and (c) An allowance for books required for coursework, as determined by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-067-0016","citation":"OAR 575-067-0016(1)","quote":"An eligible student shall receive an award in an amount that equals the resident tuition charges at Oregon public universities, the Oregon Health and Science University, and community colleges that the student is attending.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.268","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e0c7a4cc6770a73","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"OAR 583-030-0015(23) redefines 'practicum' to include 'internship,' which the statute does not mention, broadening the fee categories covered by ORS 348.606(4).","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0015","citation":"OAR 583-030-0015(23)","quote":"\"Practicum\" means that portion of a degree program that involves a supervised field placement in a professional or workplace environment. For purposes of these rules, also includes \"internship.\"","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.606","citation":"ORS 348.606(6)","quote":"As used in this section, \"practicum\" means a portion of a degree program that involves a supervised field placement in a professional or workplace environment.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.606","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cacd8dfa4b497efa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"The Eligibility Criteria rule omits the FAFSA requirement that the statute includes as part of the eligibility criteria in ORS 348.270(3)(a)(D).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.270","citation":"ORS 348.270(3)(a)(D)","quote":"Complete and submit the Free Application for Federal Student Aid for each academic year and accept all state and federal aid grants available to the person, if eligible to file the application","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-037-0051","citation":"575-037-0051(1)-(6)","quote":"To be eligible for a Deceased or Disabled Public Safety Officers scholarship, a student must: (1) Be a child of a public safety officer who has suffered a qualifying death or disability. (2) Be enrolled or have applied for enrollment at an eligible institution of higher education in this state. (3) Be under 25 years of age at the time of submitting the application. (4) Not have achieved a baccalaureate or higher degree from any post-secondary institution. (5) A student who is awarded a scholarship, in addition to satisfying all other eligibility criteria, must maintain satisfactory academic progress (SAP) as defined by the institution of higher education. (6) A student is eligible to receive a scholarship for a maximum of the equivalent of four academic years.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bc37f5b49c83008b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 348.605, which imposes restrictions and duties on schools obtaining exemptions under ORS 348.604, but the rule's operative text never engages with schools under ORS 348.604—it only exempts schools under ORS 348.597 and entities in ORS 348.594(3)(b) from the standards.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0010","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 348.604, ORS 348.597, ORS 348.605, ORS 348.594","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.605","citation":"ORS 348.605","quote":"A school that obtains an exemption under ORS 348.604 or that, on July 14, 2005, met the criteria and followed procedures to obtain a religious exemption adopted by rule by the Oregon Student Access Commission and that offered only degrees leading to occupations in theology or religious occupations may not","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.605","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d7977ff8b6083af2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"OAR 575-095-0045(5) creates an exception allowing students to remain eligible for awards despite failing to meet renewal requirements during emergencies, but ORS 348.520(4) states the Commission 'shall Withhold any financial aid if the recipient thereof fails to maintain the standards established for receipt of that aid' without carving out emergency exceptions, making the statutory mandate to withhold discretionary.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-095-0045","citation":"OAR 575-095-0045(5)","quote":"An awardee who fails to meet the requirements of subsections (1) and (3) may remain eligible to receive an award in the following term if the student is unable to meet the requirement during a period where there exists an active declaration of emergency or executive order restricting the operations of institutions of higher education, or due to the temporary closure of the awardees usual child care facility related to the issuance of the same or similar declarations or orders.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.520","citation":"ORS 348.520(4)","quote":"Withhold any financial aid if the recipient thereof fails to maintain the standards established for receipt of that aid.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9faf9f846ba456c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the commission to provide a recommendation on whether community colleges should be allowed to offer applied baccalaureate degrees, treating this as an open question. The implementing rule presupposes an affirmative answer by exempting applied baccalaureate degree programs from the two-year limitation normally binding on community colleges.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.910","citation":"ORS 348.910(3)(f)","quote":"A recommendation as to whether community colleges should be allowed to offer applied baccalaureate degrees.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-001-0300","citation":"OAR 589-001-0300(6)(b)(B)","quote":"The two-year limitation described in paragraph (a) of this subsection does not apply to: ... (B) Applied baccalaureate degree programs.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.910","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9d85d5092da14fdd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the statutory definition of 'teacher candidate' by specifying only four particular school professional roles instead of the statute's broader 'teacher or other school professional' language, and adds a requirement for 'preliminary licensure' not in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-348.295","citation":"ORS 348.295(4)(b)","quote":"\"Teacher candidate\" means an individual who is preparing to be a teacher or other school professional licensed, registered or certified by the Teacher Standards and Practices Commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-575-066-0002","citation":"OAR 575-066-0002(11)","quote":"\"Teacher candidate\" means an individual who is pursuing their preliminary licensure for teaching, school counseling, school social work or school psychology in a program registered or certified by the Teacher Standards and Practices Commission.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.295","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e4860ffdc4316f2c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"ORS 348.530(7) grants the Commission discretionary power to 'deny financial aid' to certain students, but OAR 575-001-0010(1) makes denial mandatory by stating such students 'shall not be eligible to participate in any student assistance program.'","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-001-0010","citation":"OAR 575-001-0010(1)","quote":"Any student or parent in default on any Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) loan (formerly Guaranteed Student Loan/GSL) or any loan made or insured by the Higher Education Coordinating Commission and any student owing a refund on any State grant, or owing a refund or in default on any Title IV federal aid program shall not be eligible to participate in any student assistance program administered by the Commission.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.530","citation":"ORS 348.530(7)","quote":"Deny financial aid to any student owing a refund or in default on financial aid previously made available to that student.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.530","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e5380dc945c6484c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"ORS 348.530(7) grants the Commission discretionary power to 'deny financial aid' to certain students, but OAR 575-060-0030(2) makes denial mandatory by stating 'No award shall be made' to students in this situation.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-060-0030","citation":"OAR 575-060-0030(2)","quote":"No award shall be made to a student in default on any federal Title IV loan or owing a refund on federal Title IV funds previously disbursed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.530","citation":"ORS 348.530(7)","quote":"Deny financial aid to any student owing a refund or in default on financial aid previously made available to that student.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.530","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"77ca8dc71010208d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"ORS 348.530(7) grants the Commission discretionary power to 'deny financial aid' to certain students, but OAR 575-095-0020(4) makes ineligibility based on default status a mandatory eligibility criterion.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-095-0020","citation":"OAR 575-095-0020(4)","quote":"Not be in default on any federal Title IV loan or owing a refund on federal Title IV funds previously disbursed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-348.530","citation":"ORS 348.530(7)","quote":"Deny financial aid to any student owing a refund or in default on financial aid previously made available to that student.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-348.530","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"21d764ef0c04e31d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Degree Authorization"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Student Access and Completion"}]},{"ors_chapter":"350","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":22,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 715-013-0060 claims to implement ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), but the statute's section (3) uses alphabetic subsections (a)-(n), not Roman numerals; (3)(iii)(f) does not exist in the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0060","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), ORS 21.007","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-350.075","citation":"ORS 350.075(3)","quote":"(3) The Higher Education Coordinating Commission shall: (a) Develop state goals... (b) Determine strategic investments... (c) Coordinate the post-secondary elements... (d) Adopt a strategic plan... (e)(A) Each biennium... (f) Adopt rules governing... (g) Approve or disapprove... (h) For public universities... (i) Authorize degrees... (j) Oversee the licensing... (k) Have the authority... (L) Administer a statewide... (m) In coordination... (n) Establish a direct...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"698771c501426b13","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 715-013-0062 claims to implement ORS 350.075(3)(iiI)(f), but the statute's section (3) uses alphabetic subsections (a)-(n), not Roman numerals; (3)(iii)(f) does not exist.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0062","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iiI)(f) & 2015 Oregon Laws Chapter 682","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-350.075","citation":"ORS 350.075(3)","quote":"(3) The Higher Education Coordinating Commission shall: (a) Develop state goals... (b) Determine strategic investments... (c) Coordinate the post-secondary elements... (d) Adopt a strategic plan... (e)(A) Each biennium... (f) Adopt rules governing... (g) Approve or disapprove... (h) For public universities... (i) Authorize degrees... (j) Oversee the licensing... (k) Have the authority... (L) Administer a statewide... (m) In coordination... (n) Establish a direct...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"011d74d73bd45843","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 715-013-0064 claims to implement ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), but the statute's section (3) uses alphabetic subsections (a)-(n), not Roman numerals; (3)(iii)(f) does not exist.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0064","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), ORS 284.720 & ORS 284.701","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-350.075","citation":"ORS 350.075(3)","quote":"(3) The Higher Education Coordinating Commission shall: (a) Develop state goals... (b) Determine strategic investments... (c) Coordinate the post-secondary elements... (d) Adopt a strategic plan... (e)(A) Each biennium... (f) Adopt rules governing... (g) Approve or disapprove... (h) For public universities... (i) Authorize degrees... (j) Oversee the licensing... (k) Have the authority... (L) Administer a statewide... (m) In coordination... (n) Establish a direct...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0878e290e39917b6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 715-013-0066 claims to implement ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), but the statute's section (3) uses alphabetic subsections (a)-(n), not Roman numerals; (3)(iii)(f) does not exist.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0066","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), ORS 36.105 & ORS 36.145","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-350.075","citation":"ORS 350.075(3)","quote":"(3) The Higher Education Coordinating Commission shall: (a) Develop state goals... (b) Determine strategic investments... (c) Coordinate the post-secondary elements... (d) Adopt a strategic plan... (e)(A) Each biennium... (f) Adopt rules governing... (g) Approve or disapprove... (h) For public universities... (i) Authorize degrees... (j) Oversee the licensing... (k) Have the authority... (L) Administer a statewide... (m) In coordination... (n) Establish a direct...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.075","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d6a980e973d5db26","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts the transcript-withholding prohibition to schools offering degree programs, while the statute applies it to all post-secondary institutions of education.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-583-030-0035","citation":"OAR 583-030-0035(13)(c)","quote":"A school based in this state may not: (A) Refuse to provide a transcript for a current or former student because the student owes a debt to the institution","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-350.210","citation":"ORS 350.210(1)","quote":"A post-secondary institution of education that is based in this state may not: (a) Refuse to provide a transcript for a current or former student because the student owes a debt to the institution","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bff8443bce5b35db","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization"]},{"summary":"The statute explicitly permits the commission to waive the fee 'in case of hardship,' but neither implementing rule provides for such hardship waivers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-350.175","citation":"ORS 350.175(3)","quote":"The fee may be waived by the commission in case of hardship.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0500","citation":"OAR 589-007-0500(1)","quote":"The Commission authorizes the Office to charge a fee of $38 per test at the time testing begins (this includes the $8.00 state administration fee).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.175","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a5423b7864ef0743","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule extends allotment authority to Oregon Health Sciences University, but the statute authorizes allocation only to public universities listed in ORS 352.002.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-350.095","citation":"ORS 350.095(1)(b)","quote":"Allocate moneys, from funds appropriated to the commission and other available moneys, to public universities listed in ORS 352.002","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0005","citation":"OAR 715-013-0005(1) and (2)","quote":"authority in all areas of fiscal and administrative responsibility necessary for the execution of Commission policy relating to the allotment of funds to public universities and Oregon Health Sciences University","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-350.095","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af06aaf0a7dec748","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-degree-authorization","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Degree Authorization"}]},{"ors_chapter":"352","agencies":6,"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"A HECC rule expands ORS 352.089's academic-program-review criteria to cover 'community colleges,' a class the statute never mentions.","documents":[{"id":"ors-352.089","citation":"ORS 352.089(2)","quote":"...(b) Do not unnecessarily duplicate academic programs offered by Oregon's other public universities; ...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0020","citation":"OAR 715-013-0020(3)","quote":"...(b) Do not unnecessarily duplicate academic programs offered by Oregon's other community colleges or public universities; ...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ff3a3d0e4389a4e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The same rule omits ORS 352.089(2)(e)'s mandatory fifth criterion specific to WOU/SOU/EOU program approvals.","documents":[{"id":"ors-352.089","citation":"ORS 352.089(2)(e)","quote":"Submitted by Western Oregon University, Southern Oregon University or Eastern Oregon University comply with ORS 352.011.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0020","citation":"OAR 715-013-0020(3)","quote":"(enumerates only criteria (a) through (d); no analog to (e) anywhere in the rule)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"df73f5bdf54ba3f0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 715-013-0040(10) excludes COFA students who meet ORS 352.287 requirements from Eastern Oregon University's PUSF funding calculation, contradicting the statute's establishment that these students 'shall qualify' for tuition exemptions at public universities including Eastern Oregon University.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0040","citation":"OAR 715-013-0040, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(f), ORS 352.287, ORS 350.075(3)(f)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-352.287","citation":"ORS 352.287(4)","quote":"A student who is a COFA islander and who has not previously established residence in any state or territory of the United States or the District of Columbia other than Oregon shall qualify for exemption from nonresident tuition and fees for enrollment as an undergraduate student and a graduate student in a degree program at a public university listed in ORS 352.002.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-352.287","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f298ccd80ead3bc8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 352.113, but the operative text never engages with any substantive provision of that statute. ORS 352.113 addresses legal title, custody, conveyances, and restrictions on disposal of university property. The rule instead distributes CIR funding based on building square footage and density calculations, without implementing any requirement in ORS 352.113.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0070","citation":"OAR 715-013-0070","quote":"ORS 350.075, ORS 352.113","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-352.113","citation":"ORS 352.113","quote":"Legal title to all real property acquired by a public university listed in ORS 352.002 must be taken and held in the name of the State of Oregon, acting by and through the governing board of the public university.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-352.113","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"058971754bcfaf5e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule broadens criterion (b) by adding 'community colleges' as a comparison point, whereas the statute only mentions 'public universities'.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-352.089","citation":"ORS 352.089(2)(b)","quote":"Do not unnecessarily duplicate academic programs offered by Oregon's other public universities","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0020","citation":"OAR 715-013-0020(3)(b)","quote":"Do not unnecessarily duplicate academic programs offered by Oregon's other community colleges or public universities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-352.089","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c7c78d8e595faea9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule broadens criterion (c) by adding 'community colleges' as a comparison point, whereas the statute only mentions 'public universities'.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-352.089","citation":"ORS 352.089(2)(c)","quote":"Are not located in a geographic area that will cause undue hardship to Oregon's other public universities","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0020","citation":"OAR 715-013-0020(3)(c)","quote":"Are not located in a geographic area that will cause undue hardship to Oregon's other community colleges or public universities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-352.089","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd00c0380ba6688d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule broadens criterion (d) by adding 'community colleges', whereas the statute allocates programs only 'among Oregon's public universities'.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-352.089","citation":"ORS 352.089(2)(d)","quote":"Are allocated among Oregon's public universities to maximize the achievement of statewide needs and requirements","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0020","citation":"OAR 715-013-0020(3)(d)","quote":"Are allocated among Oregon's community colleges and public universities to maximize the achievement of statewide needs and requirements","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-352.089","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0a7823ab68d0e447","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"artifacts":["oar-715-013-0040 statutes_implemented duplicates \"ORS 350.075(3)(f)\".","ors-352.089/ors-352.274 titles truncated mid-word."],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"353","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"Five DAS bond-administration rules cite a broader statutory range (\"353.550 to 353.563\") for the Oregon Opportunity bond program than the statute's own self-declared definitions range (\"353.550 to 353.559\").","documents":[{"id":"ors-353.550","citation":"ORS 353.550","quote":"Definitions for ORS 353.550 to 353.559 and sections 10, 12, 14, 16 and 18, chapter 921, Oregon Laws 2001...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-122-075-0100","citation":"OAR 122-075-0100(3)","quote":"General obligation bonds issued ... for the Oregon Opportunity Program under ORS 353.550 to 353.563 and chapter 921 of Oregon Laws 2001.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Low-confidence: the statute's range describes only the definitions section's own scope, not necessarily the full bond-program statutory range; 353.560-353.563 aren't in this corpus to verify.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"72fde36f0cc8c4d8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]},{"summary":"oar-122-075-0110 declares it implements ORS 353.550, which defines specific terms (Bond-related costs, Capital costs, Indirect financing, Master Settlement Agreement, Noncapital costs, Oregon Opportunity program), but the rule's operative text defines entirely different terms (Benefiting Agency, Bonds, Department, Director, Finance Manager, State Agency, Tax-advantaged) and never engages with the statutory definitions at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-122-075-0110","citation":"oar-122-075-0110","quote":"ORS 286A.045 - 286A.050, ORS 286A.560 - 286A.585, ORS 286A.710 - 286A.792, ORS 353.550 - 353.563; 2001 OL ch. 921, 2003 OL ch. 11","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-353.550","citation":"ORS 353.550","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-353.550","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0495afd7c38a6c73","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office"]}],"artifacts":["ors-353.550 title truncated (\"Definitions for ORS 353.550 to\").","oar-459-005-0350 statutes_implemented lists \"ORS 238.015\" twice."],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-financial-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Financial Office"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"}]},{"ors_chapter":"36","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":193,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule oar-603-075-0050 authorizes the Department to charge fees for general agriculture mediation under ORS 36.256, but that statute does not authorize or mention fees, whereas the related ORS 36.280 (farming practices mediation) specifically addresses fees with a $2,500 cap.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.256","citation":"ORS 36.256(1)-(4)","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture may accept a request for mediation under ORS 36.252 to 36.268 of a dispute directly related to activities of the department or agricultural issues under the jurisdiction of the department from: (a) A person engaged in the production of livestock, poultry, field crops, fruit, dairy, fur-bearing animals, Christmas trees, vermiculture products, food fish or other animal and vegetable matter; or (b) Any other person at the discretion of the department. A person may request mediation by submitting the request to the department on a form provided by the department.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-603-075-0050","citation":"oar-603-075-0050(1)(a)-(d)","quote":"The Department may charge reasonable fees necessary to cover the cost of mediation services. Such fees shall be calculated by determining the costs, including administrative overhead, for providing mediation service. At the option of the Department, fees may be established at an amount reasonably necessary to cover the cost of administration of the mediation program. The fees to be charged per party shall be reviewed at the beginning of each biennium by the coordinator to determine the appropriateness of such fees and whether the fees should be increased or decreased based upon the overall financial status of the program. Individuals may apply for a fee waiver.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.256","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d5106147c218971a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-005-0052 section (p) narrows ORS 36.232(4) by only explicitly allowing confidential mediation communications for research, training, or educational purposes, while the statute also allows disclosure of the disposition of matters referred for mediation and the terms of mediation agreements for these purposes.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-005-0052","citation":"OAR 137-005-0052(9)(p) and ORS 36.232(4)","quote":"Rule: 'The agency conducting the mediation or making the mediation available or the mediator may use or disclose confidential mediation communications for research, training or educational purposes, subject to the provisions of ORS 36.232.' Statute: 'ORS 36.220 to 36.238 do not limit the ability of a mediator or mediation program to use or disclose confidential mediation communications, the disposition of matters referred for mediation and the terms of mediation agreements to another person for use in research, training or educational purposes, subject to the following:'","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.232","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4995fb1854becf0f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The statute provides that ORS 36.220-36.238 apply to 'All mediations, whether conducted by a publicly funded program or by a private mediation provider,' but the rules limit application only to mediations where the agency is a party or has regulatory authority, narrowing the scope.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.238","citation":"ORS 36.238","quote":"The provisions of ORS 36.210 and 36.220 to 36.238 apply to: (1) All mediations, whether conducted by a publicly funded program or by a private mediation provider","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-801-001-0050","citation":"OAR 801-001-0050(3)","quote":"This rule applies only to mediations in which the agency is a party or is mediating a dispute as to which the agency has regulatory authority.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-809-001-0035","citation":"OAR 809-001-0035(3)","quote":"This rule applies only to mediations in which the agency is a party or is mediating a dispute as to which the agency has regulatory authority.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.238","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d0b0332262c06c3f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-geologist-examiners","oregon-board-of-accountancy"]},{"summary":"The rule makes mediation work products and memoranda confidential by default, while the statute conditions confidentiality on written agreement by the parties.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.283","citation":"ORS 36.283(2)","quote":"if the parties to a mediation described in ORS 36.280 have agreed in writing that all or part of the mediation communications or all or part of the terms of a mediation agreement are confidential, a cause of action exists against a party that discloses the confidential communications or terms","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-075-0035","citation":"oar-603-075-0035(1)","quote":"all memoranda, work products, and other materials contained in the case files of a mediator, a mediation service provider, or the Department, that are created for, or used in a mediation are confidential and not subject to disclosure","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.283","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9226d4775a62ab50","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"The statute ORS 36.230(2) specifies that provisions exempt from disclosure under ORS 192.311 to 192.478 are confidential, but several rules implementing ORS 36.230 cite ORS 192.410 to 192.505 instead, pointing at different statute sections.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-008-0100","citation":"OAR 137-008-0100 section 2","quote":"Whether or not they are confidential under this or other rules of the agency, mediation communications are exempt from disclosure under the Public Records Law to the extent provided in ORS 192.410 to 192.505.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.230","citation":"ORS 36.230(2)","quote":"If a public body is a party to a mediation agreement, any provisions of the agreement that are exempt from disclosure as a public record under ORS 192.311 to 192.478 are confidential.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.230","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"92116753397a2301","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the definition of 'Mediator' by omitting the statutory provision that judges conducting case settlement conferences are included as mediators.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.110","citation":"ORS 36.110(9)","quote":"Mediator\" means a third party who performs mediation. \"Mediator\" includes agents and employees of the mediator or mediation program and any judge conducting a case settlement conference.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-005-0050","citation":"OAR 137-005-0050(1)(e)","quote":"\"Mediator\" means a third party who performs mediation. Mediator includes agents and employees of the mediator or mediation program.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ffee7166a9818e37","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 339-001-0018 declares it implements only ORS 36.224(4), but the rule's operative text establishes substantive confidentiality and inadmissibility requirements that derive from ORS 36.224(1)-(3), not from subsection (4) alone, which merely addresses procedural adoption authority.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-339-001-0018","citation":"ORS 36.224(4)","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 36.224(4)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.224","citation":"ORS 36.224(4)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.224","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8461c88e70cf566b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["occupational-therapy-licensing-board"]},{"summary":"ORS 36.228(2) uses 'private person' but some implementing rules use 'private entity' instead, which could be narrower","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-005-0052","citation":"OAR 137-005-0052(5)(d)","quote":"Mediation in which two or more public bodies and a private entity are parties if the laws, rule or policies governing mediation confidentiality for at least one of the public bodies provide that mediation communications in the mediation are not confidential","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.228","citation":"ORS 36.228(2)","quote":"if two or more public bodies are parties to a mediation in which a private person is also a party, mediation communications in the mediation are not confidential if the laws, rules or policies governing confidentiality of mediation communications for at least one of the public bodies provide that mediation communications in the mediation are not confidential","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.228","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f76a517463ecf997","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Different rules use different terminology ('entity' vs 'party') for the same party type in ORS 36.228 scenario","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-005-0052","citation":"OAR 137-005-0052(5)(d)","quote":"Mediation in which two or more public bodies and a private entity are parties","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-170-001-0020","citation":"OAR 170-001-0020(5)(d)","quote":"Mediation involving two or more public bodies and a private party if the laws, rule or policies governing mediation confidentiality for at least one of the public bodies provide that mediation communications in the mediation are not confidential","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.228","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"59af14cbaf401303","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice","oregon-state-treasury"]},{"summary":"Rule section (2) states the rule allocates funds to 'Public Universities' (defined in section 1(f) to include seven institutions), but the statute limits appropriation to only two specific institutions.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.145","citation":"ORS 36.145","quote":"all moneys in the account are continuously appropriated to the University of Oregon or Portland State University","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-013-0066","citation":"OAR 715-013-0066(1)(f) and (2)","quote":"A 'Public University' is any institution as defined in ORS 352.002, including; Eastern Oregon University (EOU), Oregon Institute of Technology (OIT), Oregon State University (OSU), Portland State University (PSU), Southern Oregon University (SOU), University of Oregon (UO) and Western Oregon University (WOU)... This rule allocates Dispute Resolution Program funds to Public Universities.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"215f152079964a6b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 36.105, which is solely a statement of legislative purposes and does not authorize the fund allocation mechanics that comprise the rule's operative provisions (49% first year/remainder second year allocation timing, 65/35 split between universities).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0066","citation":"OAR 715-013-0066 frontmatter (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 350.075(3)(iii)(f), ORS 36.105, ORS 36.145","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.105","citation":"ORS 36.105","quote":"The Legislative Assembly declares that it is the purpose of ORS 36.100 to 36.238 to: (1) Foster the development of community-based programs... [seven enumerated purposes]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"3c8cd0cf3bd8d236","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"oar-603-075-0005 declares implementation of ORS 36.210 (liability and immunity of mediators), but the operative text addresses only agricultural mediation program administration, eligibility, fees, and advertising—never engaging with liability.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-075-0005","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 36.210, ORS 36.252-268","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.210","citation":"ORS 36.210(1)-(2)","quote":"Mediators, mediation programs and dispute resolution programs are not civilly liable for any act or omission done or made while engaged in efforts to assist or facilitate a mediation or in providing other dispute resolution services, unless the act or omission was made or done in bad faith, with malicious intent or in a manner exhibiting a willful, wanton disregard of the rights, safety or property of another.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"759258e081fc8db4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"oar-603-075-0025 declares implementation of ORS 36.210 (liability and immunity of mediators), but the operative text addresses only advertising methods for mediation services—never engaging with liability.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-075-0025","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 36.210","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.210","citation":"ORS 36.210(1)-(2)","quote":"Mediators, mediation programs and dispute resolution programs are not civilly liable for any act or omission done or made while engaged in efforts to assist or facilitate a mediation or in providing other dispute resolution services, unless the act or omission was made or done in bad faith, with malicious intent or in a manner exhibiting a willful, wanton disregard of the rights, safety or property of another.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c810ebb91b3b79e2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"oar-603-075-0050 declares implementation of ORS 36.210 (liability and immunity of mediators), but the operative text addresses only agricultural mediation program administration, fees, and coordinator review processes—never engaging with liability.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-075-0050","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"36.252, 36.256, 36.268, ORS 36.210","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.210","citation":"ORS 36.210(1)-(2)","quote":"Mediators, mediation programs and dispute resolution programs are not civilly liable for any act or omission done or made while engaged in efforts to assist or facilitate a mediation or in providing other dispute resolution services, unless the act or omission was made or done in bad faith, with malicious intent or in a manner exhibiting a willful, wanton disregard of the rights, safety or property of another.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.210","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a926b9d46cefc36a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rules oar-801-001-0050, oar-809-001-0035, oar-811-001-0070, and oar-847-006-0000 lack the specific confidentiality exceptions for child abuse and elder abuse that ORS 36.220(5) mandates, instead providing only a broader 'licensed professional conduct' exception.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-36.220","citation":"ORS 36.220(5)","quote":"Any mediation communication relating to child abuse that is made to a person who is required to report child abuse under the provisions of ORS 419B.010 is not confidential to the extent that the person is required to report the communication under the provisions of ORS 419B.010. Any mediation communication relating to elder abuse that is made to a person who is required to report elder abuse under the provisions of ORS 124.050 to 124.095 is not confidential to the extent that the person is required to report the communication under the provisions of ORS 124.050 to 124.095.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-801-001-0050","citation":"OAR 801-001-0050(9)(d)","quote":"Any mediation communication related to the conduct of a licensed professional that is made to or in the presence of a person who, as a condition of his or her professional license, is obligated to report such communication by law or court rule is not confidential and may be disclosed to the extent necessary to make such a report.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-809-001-0035","citation":"OAR 809-001-0035(9)(d)","quote":"Any mediation communication related to the conduct of a licensed professional that is made to or in the presence of a person who, as a condition of his or her professional license, is obligated to report such communication by law or court rule is not confidential and may be disclosed to the extent necessary to make such a report.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-811-001-0070","citation":"OAR 811-001-0070(9)(d)","quote":"Any mediation communication related to the conduct of a licensed professional that is made to or in the presence of a person who, as a condition of their professional license, is obligated to report such communication by law or court rule is not confidential and may be disclosed to the extent necessary to make such a report.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-847-006-0000","citation":"OAR 847-006-0000(9)(d)","quote":"Any mediation communication related to the conduct of a licensed professional that is made to or in the presence of a person who, as a condition of his or her professional license, is obligated to report such communication by law or court rule is not confidential and may be disclosed to the extent necessary to make such a report.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"58cd006f94243d78","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-chiropractic-examiners","board-of-geologist-examiners","oregon-board-of-accountancy","oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-075-0045 declares implementation of only ORS 36.252, but its operative text implements ORS 36.280 (farming practices mediation), which is a distinct program from the general agricultural mediation services in ORS 36.252.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-075-0045","citation":"OAR 603-075-0045 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"36.252","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-603-075-0045","citation":"OAR 603-075-0045(1)","quote":"This program is intended for farmer to farmer disputes wherein a person engaged in a farming practice has a reasonable belief that the planting, growing, or harvesting of an agricultural or horticultural commodity on nearby land might interfere with or is interfering with the farming practice, and the person responsible for the planting, growing, or harvesting disputes that it might interfere with or is interfering with the farming practice.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.252","citation":"ORS 36.252(1)","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture shall coordinate agricultural mediation services for disputes directly related to activities of the department and agricultural issues under the jurisdiction of the department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-36.280","citation":"ORS 36.280(1)","quote":"If a person that is engaged in a farming practice, as defined in ORS 30.930, has a reasonable belief that the planting, growing or harvesting of an agricultural or horticultural commodity on nearby land might interfere with or is interfering with the farming practice, and the person responsible for the planting, growing or harvesting disputes that it might interfere with or is interfering with the farming practice, the State Department of Agriculture shall, if requested by either party to the dispute: (a) Provide mediation program services under ORS 36.252 to assist the parties in attempting to reach a voluntary resolution of the dispute","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.252","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"de0b41b9dc58b71d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 603-075-0010 declares implementation of ORS 36.252-36.268 but its operative definition of 'Mediation program' includes ORS 36.280-36.283, which are outside the declared scope.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-075-0010","citation":"OAR 603-075-0010(8) and declared statutes_implemented","quote":"Declared: 'ORS 36.252 - 36.268'; Operative text: '\"Mediation program\" means a program through which mediation is made available and includes as provided in ORS 36.252 – 268 or ORS 36.280 – 283.'","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-36.252","citation":"ORS 36.252","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.268","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"423f5a707687cc16","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule section (2) states the rule 'allocates Dispute Resolution Program funds to Public Universities,' but section (6) specifies allocation only to University of Oregon and Portland State University, contradicting the broader statement in (2).","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-013-0066","citation":"OAR 715-013-0066(2) and (6)","quote":"(2) This rule allocates Dispute Resolution Program funds to Public Universities. (6) The University of Oregon shall receive 65% of Dispute Resolution Program funds each biennium and Portland State University shall receive 35% of Dispute Resolution Program funds.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-36.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"403f2f96be9f8eaf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-chiropractic-examiners","name":"Board of Chiropractic Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-veterans-affairs","name":"Department of Veterans' Affairs"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board"},{"slug":"oregon-529-savings-board","name":"Oregon 529 Savings Board"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-accountancy","name":"Oregon Board of Accountancy"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-liquor-control-commission","name":"Oregon Liquor Control Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"},{"slug":"oregon-state-library","name":"Oregon State Library"},{"slug":"oregon-state-lottery","name":"Oregon State Lottery"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"},{"slug":"travel-information-council","name":"Travel Information Council"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"403","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":17,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DOR 9-1-1 tax rule writes its own broader 'Provider' definition (with an added reseller/subscriber carve-out) instead of deferring to the statutory definition, unlike a sibling OEM rule that correctly defers.","documents":[{"id":"ors-403.105","citation":"ORS 403.105(19)","quote":"'Provider' means a utility, or other vendor or supplier, that offers communications service or equipment that provides access to the emergency communications system.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-403-0010","citation":"OAR 150-403-0010(5)","quote":"'Provider' means any corporation, individual, group of individuals, or other person or entity providing telecommunication access... A carrier that has access ... and does not resell the access is not considered to be a provider...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"37332b8c392b1542","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A rule substitutes an open-ended plan-review process for the statute's mandatory 90-day approve/reject deadline.","documents":[{"id":"ors-403.120","citation":"ORS 403.130(4)(b)","quote":"the department shall review the revised plan and either approve or reject the revised plan within 90 days after the date the department receives the revised plan.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-104-080-0150","citation":"OAR 104-080-0150(3)(c)","quote":"if the revised 9-1-1 Jurisdiction Plan is unacceptable, the Department will work with the 9-1-1 jurisdiction to complete an acceptable plan.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"313932eb2c01ae76","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management"]},{"summary":"A rule requires advance (before-the-fact) notice for PSAP consolidations/relocations where the statute requires only after-the-fact notice within 30 days for any change.","documents":[{"id":"ors-403.120","citation":"ORS 403.130(5)","quote":"Each 9-1-1 jurisdiction shall submit to the department in writing within 30 days any change to a public safety answering point that alters the approved 9-1-1 jurisdiction plan...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-104-080-0150","citation":"OAR 104-080-0150(4)(b)","quote":"...30 days prior to any consolidation, co-location, or physical move and within 30 days of any other change...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ad3d72057e544d0b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management"]}],"artifacts":["Fifteen OAR 104-080-01xx rules mix a bill number (\"2015 HB 2426\") and a bare chapter citation (\"ORS 403\") into legal_authority/statutes_implemented, inconsistent with the section-level precision used elsewhere in the same corpus."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management","name":"Oregon Military Department, Office of Emergency Management"}]},{"ors_chapter":"408","agencies":9,"rules_reviewed":54,"candidates":[{"summary":"A rule restates the statute's 'immediate family' definition but drops one of its four listed categories, for the same veterans' emergency-assistance program.","documents":[{"id":"ors-408.500","citation":"ORS 408.500(4)(a)","quote":"'Immediate family' means a spouse, unremarried surviving spouse, child or stepchild.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-274-012-0001","citation":"OAR 274-012-0001(5)","quote":"'Immediate family' means a spouse, child or stepchild.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule (2013) postdates the statute's last amendment (2007), so this isn't explained by the rule predating a later statutory change. The same rule section correctly defers 'veteran' to the statute by reference but chose to restate 'immediate family' independently, narrowing it. Confirmed again by the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23).","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"caf3ea21f5613827","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-veterans-affairs"]},{"summary":"A rule's grant cap is double the statute's, citing a 2026 bill the corpus's statute snapshot may not yet reflect.","documents":[{"id":"ors-408.115","citation":"ORS 408.115(2)(a), 2025 Edition","quote":"Grants under the program: (a) May not exceed $5,000 per veteran...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-274-036-0250","citation":"OAR 274-036-0250(1), citing HB 4132 (2026)","quote":"total disbursement amounts will not exceed $10,000 per veteran, per lifetime.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"If HB 4132 (2026) amended ORS 408.115(2)(a), this is a corpus-freshness artifact (statute snapshot lagging a newer law), not a live conflict. If it didn't, this is a rule exceeding its enabling statute's cap. Not resolved in-corpus; needs the bill text. Confirmed again by the batch-2 re-check (2026-07-23), still unresolved.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"35ccab4e6faa14bb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-veterans-affairs"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 274-010-0100 and OAR 274-012-0001 use \"ORS 2013 HB 2633\" / \"2013 HB 2633\" as if it were an ORS section number — it's a bill number.","OAR 274-035-0005 legal_authority cites \"ORS 408.510\" and \"ORS 408.530\" — this cluster's own ors-408.518 text notes 408.530 was renumbered to 408.395 in 1999; 408.510 doesn't appear to exist in the retrieved chapter at all.","Many OAR rule titles are truncated to single dangling words (\"Who\", \"Lost,\", \"Additional\")."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-veterans-affairs","name":"Department of Veterans' Affairs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"419a","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":31,"candidates":[{"summary":"The entire OAR division (five rules) implementing ORS 419A.260/419A.262 (both substantively re-amended in 2025) was repealed in 2021 with no replacement captured in the corpus, yet all five rules and both statutes still show a live implements/implemented_by relationship.","documents":[{"id":"ors-419a.260","citation":"ORS 419A.260, last_amended 2025","quote":"2025 c.487 §2","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-413-350-0130","citation":"OAR 413-350-0130, status: current","quote":"History: CWP 25-2021, repeal filed 11/01/2021, effective 11/01/2021 ... (full text is empty — title only)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Same pattern identically across oar-413-350-0100/-0110/-0120/-0130/-0140.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"667fa3bba4c5e2dd","cites_repealed":["oar-413-350-0130"],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]}],"artifacts":["oar-413-010-0035 cites \"ORS 419A.263\", which doesn't appear among this cluster's 9 statutes.","oar-413-010-0035 legal_authority: \"ORS 409.050 & ORS 418.005. 418.340\" (period instead of separator)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"419c","agencies":8,"rules_reviewed":91,"candidates":[{"summary":"Two rule regimes from different agencies/eras (2003 CJC vs. 2019 OYA) both claim to implement the same juvenile extended-detention statute, naming different approving bodies (JCPAC vs. Youth Development Council) with different renewal cadences (5-year vs. biennial), with no supersession link.","documents":[{"id":"ors-419c.453","citation":"ORS 419C.453(1)","quote":"...unless a program plan that is in conformance with standards established by the Youth Development Council has been filed with and approved by the council...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-213-050-0060","citation":"OAR 213-050-0060(1), 2003","quote":"must detain juveniles only in a detention facility which has an extended detention program plan approved by the JCPAC.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-423-150-0010","citation":"OAR 423-150-0010(2), 2019","quote":"must detain the juvenile in accordance with an extended detention program plan approved by the Youth Development Council.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d38d26157ef41bd9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-criminal-justice-commission","oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division"]},{"summary":"Two agencies (OHA and PSRB) define 'Qualifying Mental Disorder' in materially different terms for overlapping statutory concepts under ORS 419C.520.","documents":[{"id":"oar-309-090-0005","citation":"OAR 309-090-0005(25), OHA, 2024","quote":"A developmental or intellectual disability, traumatic brain injury, brain damage or other biological dysfunction ... as defined in the current [DSM 5-TR]...","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-859-510-0005","citation":"OAR 859-510-0005(15)-(16), PSRB, 2023","quote":"manifested by developmental delay or disability if a mental deficiency exists concurrently with qualitative deficits in activities of daily living and is not otherwise attributable to mental illness or substance abuse...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e07415c361bce5b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","psychiatric-security-review-board"]},{"summary":"Several PSRB rules still cite ORS 419C.544 as live authority though it was repealed by the 2025 legislative session.","documents":[{"id":"ors-419c.542","citation":"ORS 419C.542 provenance note","quote":"419C.544 [2005 c.843 §19; repealed by 2025 c.56 §11]","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-859-530-0010","citation":"OAR 859-530-0010, effective 2024, status: current","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ... 419C.540, 419C.544","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Same pattern in oar-859-550-0015 and oar-859-560-0050.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c03f8d8648629ea0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["psychiatric-security-review-board"]}],"artifacts":["oar-309-090-0010 statutes_implemented: \"ORS 161-392\" (hyphen instead of period)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"433","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule adds medical and religious exemptions that make the immunization requirement optional, while the statute establishes it as an absolute requirement for students born on or after January 1, 1957 in the specified programs.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-433.283","citation":"ORS 433.283(1)","quote":"The Oregon Health Authority may require each community college to require that students involved in clinical experiences in allied health programs, practicum experiences in education and child care programs and membership on intercollegiate sports teams have current immunizations for measles prior to each student's participation. The requirement shall apply only to those students born on or after January 1, 1957.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-009-0100","citation":"OAR 589-009-0100(4)","quote":"Each community college shall include a medical exemption and religious exemption.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-433.283","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"524b524f0c15cde3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"435","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":10,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 435.254(3) directs complaint-response toward ORS 435.256 (the civil-penalty section, which imposes no hospital-facing duty); the implementing rule silently substitutes a different scope.","documents":[{"id":"ors-435.254","citation":"ORS 435.254(3)","quote":"The authority shall respond to complaints of violations of ORS 435.256 in accordance with ORS 441.044.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-505-0120","citation":"OAR 333-505-0120(6)","quote":"The Authority shall investigate complaints of violations of sections (1) or (2) of this rule in accordance with ORS 441.044.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Either the statute has a citation error (likely meant 435.254), or the rule has silently redefined the complaint-response scope.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0742ba0da8a3e8c5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"A rule narrows the statute's unqualified emergency-contraception provision to victims 'of any child bearing age,' a term the statute never uses.","documents":[{"id":"ors-435.254","citation":"ORS 435.254(1)(c)","quote":"provide the victim with emergency contraception immediately at the hospital","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-505-0120","citation":"OAR 333-505-0120(1)(c)","quote":"provide the victim of any child bearing age with emergency contraception immediately at the hospital","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Undefined term could exclude prepubescent assault victims from the immediate-provision requirement.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb223b3797377749","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"A rule (oar-461-135-0010, DHS Medicaid eligibility) is graph-linked as implementing ORS 435.120 (contraceptive-license-fee disposition) but its own text cites only the unrelated federal reg 42 CFR 435.120.","documents":[{"id":"oar-461-135-0010","citation":"OAR 461-135-0010 frontmatter","quote":"relationships.implements: [..., ors-435.120]; body text cites only \"42 CFR 435.926\" / \"42 CFR 435.120\", never \"ORS 435.120\".","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Appears to be a mechanical conflation of \"42 CFR 435.120\" with \"ORS 435.120\" — the likely reason this Medicaid rule was pulled into an ORS-435 cluster at all.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"306aae432c7d549a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]}],"artifacts":["Systematic ORS/CFR conflation across the OAR 410-200 series (\"ORS 435.1200\", \"ORS 435.3\" etc. are almost certainly unlabeled 42 CFR Part 435 citations).","\"ORS 89 FR 39392\" — a Federal Register citation mislabeled with an ORS prefix.","Truncated statute titles (ors-435.190, ors-435.235, ors-435.254)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"442","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":10,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 442.470, but the operative text never applies or engages with any of the definitions that statute provides.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-071-0040","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 442.470, ORS 442.550 - 442.570","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-442.470","citation":"ORS 442.470","quote":"Definitions for ORS 442.470 to 442.507. As used in ORS 442.470 to 442.507: (1) \"Acute inpatient care facility\" means... (2) \"Council\" means... (3) \"Office\" means... (4) \"Primary care physician\" means... (5) \"Rural critical access hospital\" means... (6) \"Rural hospital\" means...","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-442.470","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c97b38509a5b4264","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-575-071-0070 establishes the 'Rural Health Services Fund' while the declared statute ORS 442.570 specifically establishes the 'Primary Care Services Fund'—these are two different funds with different names.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-575-071-0070","citation":"oar-575-071-0070","quote":"ORS 442.550 - 442.570","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-442.570","citation":"ORS 442.570(1)","quote":"There is established in the State Treasury a fund, separate and distinct from the General Fund, to be known as the Primary Care Services Fund.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-442.570","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fb653631b1e765b3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-student-access-and-completion","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Student Access and Completion"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"457","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":14,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DOR urban-renewal rule states a categorically different (six-years-earlier) certified-statement grandfather cutoff date than the 1997-amended statute.","documents":[{"id":"ors-457.430","citation":"ORS 457.430(6)(a), amended 1997","quote":"all certified statements and amendments thereto filed under this section before July 14, 1997, shall continue to remain in effect.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-457-0400","citation":"OAR 150-457-0400(2)","quote":"All certified statements and amendments filed under ORS 457.430 before September 29, 1991, continue to remain in effect...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f5fa5e95da8e0f3d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule's 'Standard rate plan' definition omits the 'permanent rate plan' carve-out the statute added in 2019.","documents":[{"id":"ors-457.010","citation":"ORS 457.010(15)","quote":"'Standard rate plan' means an urban renewal plan that is not a permanent rate plan or reduced rate plan.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-457-0420","citation":"OAR 150-457-0420(1)(m)","quote":"'Standard rate plan' means an urban renewal plan that is not a reduced rate plan.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"39de7e4a109d8b97","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"The rule's 'reduced rate plan' clauses have no end-date, unlike the statute's 2019-added September 29, 2019 sunset for that category.","documents":[{"id":"ors-457.010","citation":"ORS 457.010(14)(b)-(c)","quote":"...on or after October 6, 2001, and before September 29, 2019...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-457-0420","citation":"OAR 150-457-0420(1)(k)(B)-(C)","quote":"...substantially amended ... on or after October 6, 2001... [no end date]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fe8becba4976e737","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A rule's cross-reference for the reduced-rate-plan election cites ORS 457.445(4), but the current statute's election provision is at subsection (5).","documents":[{"id":"ors-457.445","citation":"ORS 457.445(5)(a)","quote":"The governing body of a municipality that adopted a standard rate plan ... may, by ordinance or resolution, irrevocably elect to become a reduced rate plan.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-457-0420","citation":"OAR 150-457-0420(1)(k)(D)","quote":"...irrevocably elects to change the plan ... pursuant to ORS 457.445(4)...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"71e8046777edca8f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"A rule's 'Existing plan' cross-reference cites a narrower statutory range (457.420 to 457.460) than the statute's own range (457.420 to 457.470) for the same defined term.","documents":[{"id":"ors-457.010","citation":"ORS 457.010(4)(a)","quote":"'Existing urban renewal plan' means an urban renewal plan ... as described under ORS 457.420 to 457.470...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-457-0420","citation":"OAR 150-457-0420(1)(d)","quote":"'Existing plan' means an urban renewal plan ... as described under ORS 457.420 to 457.460...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c4b02d942a5ea2bc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 410-200 series mislabels several 42 CFR §435 provisions with an \"ORS 435.xxx\" prefix, while a sibling rule (oar-410-200-0315) correctly labels the equivalent entries \"42 CFR\".","\"ORS 457.80\" (truncated, likely 457.800) appears alongside the correct \"ORS 457.805\" in three rules."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"}]},{"ors_chapter":"468a","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":1346,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule OAR 340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.495 (prohibition on installation of used solid fuel burning devices) but the rule's operative text is entirely devoted to air quality definitions and never engages with solid fuel burning devices, certifications, or any subject matter of the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.495","citation":"ORS 468A.495","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.495","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e4d306333e6fd10f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'friable asbestos material' adds alternative criteria beyond hand pressure that the statute does not include.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.700","citation":"ORS 468A.700(8)","quote":"\"Friable asbestos material\" means any asbestos-containing material that hand pressure can crumble, pulverize or reduce to powder when dry.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0010","citation":"OAR 340-248-0010(21)","quote":"\"Friable asbestos material\" means asbestos-containing material that when dry can be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure or by the forces expected to act upon the material in the course of demolition, renovation, transportation, or disposal.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.700","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bcb497cb0fb44be8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-255-0040(2)(a)(B) provides up to 25% reimbursement for non-government school bus purchases, but ORS 468A.805(2)(b)(A) requires 30 percent for school bus purchases awarded under the mandatory 450-school-bus grant program.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.805","citation":"ORS 468A.805(2)(b)(A)","quote":"The grant amount per school bus awarded under subsection (1)(a) of this section shall be for: (A) $50,000 or 30 percent of the cost to purchase a school bus that meets minimum standards adopted by the State Board of Education under ORS 820.100 for the applicable class or type of school bus, whichever is less","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-255-0040","citation":"OAR 340-255-0040(2)(a)(B)","quote":"For non-government owned eligible buses that are not privately owned school buses under contract with a public school district, approved applications may receive a maximum reimbursement in the amount of: ... (B) Up to 25% of the cost of a new diesel or alternate fueled (for example, CNG, propane, hybrid) vehicle.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.805","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c775bb369cdefab1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute lists specific exempt fuel uses (farm vehicles, tractors, implements of husbandry, log trucks, off-highway construction vehicles, watercraft, and locomotives), but the rule adds three additional exempt categories not mentioned in the statute: aircraft, racing activity vehicles, and military tactical vehicles and equipment.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.277","citation":"ORS 468A.277(2)","quote":"The provisions of ORS 468A.265 to 468A.277 do not apply to fuel that is demonstrated to have been used in any of the following: (a) Motor vehicles registered as farm vehicles under the provisions of ORS 805.300. (b) Farm tractors, as defined in ORS 801.265. (c) Implements of husbandry, as defined in ORS 801.310. (d) Motor trucks, as defined in ORS 801.355, used primarily to transport logs. (e) Motor vehicles that are not designed primarily to transport persons or property, that are operated on highways only incidentally and that are used primarily for construction work. (f) Watercraft. (g) Railroad locomotives.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-253-0250","citation":"OAR 340-253-0250(2)(a)","quote":"Transportation fuels supplied for use in any of the following motor vehicles are exempt from regulation, subject to subsections (b) and (c): (A) Aircraft; (B) Racing activity vehicles defined in ORS 801.404; (C) Military tactical vehicles and tactical support equipment; (D) Locomotives; (E) Watercraft; (F) Motor vehicles registered as farm vehicles as provided in ORS 805.300; (G) Farm tractors defined in ORS 801.265; (H) Implements of husbandry defined in ORS 801.310; (I) Motor trucks defined in ORS 801.355 if used primarily to transport logs; and (J) Motor vehicles that meet all of the following conditions...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.277","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"209d5976c2573383","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule cites ORS 468A.205(1)(c) as its statutory basis for incorporating federal requirements and standards, but ORS 468A.205(3) explicitly states that the section creates no regulatory authority for executive department agencies.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.205","citation":"ORS 468A.205(3)","quote":"This section does not create any additional regulatory authority for an agency of the executive department as defined in ORS 174.112.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-813-205-0007","citation":"OAR 813-205-0007, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"10 CFR 440, ORS 458.505, ORS 757.612, ORS 468A.205(1)(c), 2 CFR 200","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.205","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ce6fee5c3e688f9b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-housing-and-community-services-department"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-214-0110 requires all stationary sources to provide information DEQ reasonably requires, but ORS 468A.050(1) authorizes the commission only to optionally classify specific classes of sources and require registration or reporting for those particular classes.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.050","citation":"ORS 468A.050(1)","quote":"By rule the Environmental Quality Commission may classify air contamination sources according to levels and types of emissions and other characteristics which cause or tend to cause or contribute to air pollution and may require registration or reporting or both for any such class or classes.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-214-0110","citation":"OAR 340-214-0110","quote":"All owners or operators of stationary sources must provide any and all information and analysis, including an air quality analysis of the source, that DEQ reasonably requires for the purpose of regulating stationary sources.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.050","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"269babd323299dce","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute requires ODA to furnish calculations to each gas station in the state; the rule makes furnishing conditional on written request from gas station owners/operators who wish to post the material.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.271","citation":"ORS 468A.271(4)(c)","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture shall furnish the formula and results of the calculations required by this subsection to each gas station in this state to facilitate compliance by gas station owners or operators with ORS 646.932.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-111-0030","citation":"OAR 603-111-0030(4)","quote":"ODA shall furnish the formula, the cost per gallon of the CFP, and the total greenhouse gas reduction attributable to the CFP to gas station owners or operators who wish to post this material at their respective gas stations, upon written request from such owners or operators.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.271","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"68475766d4e91b63","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"The rule defines 'Approved Retrofit Technology' as solely 'on-road Diesel Particulate Matter pollution control system,' but the statute directs the commission to consider California regulations for 'reducing diesel engine emissions' and to consider the broader 'list of technologies approved as qualifying retrofits included in the standards established by the commission under ORS 468A.799,' suggesting the statute contemplates multiple types of retrofit technologies beyond just DPM systems.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0010","citation":"OAR 340-256-0010(2)","quote":"'Approved Retrofit Technology' means on-road Diesel Particulate Matter pollution control system that meets the criteria established in OAR 340-256-0510.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.810","citation":"ORS 468A.810(1)","quote":"In determining the criteria and approved retrofit technologies, the commission shall consider: (a) Regulations adopted by the State of California for reducing diesel engine emissions from in-use medium-duty trucks and heavy-duty trucks; and (b) The list of technologies approved as qualifying retrofits included in the standards established by the commission under ORS 468A.799.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.810","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8005f464feeeff32","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rules 340-246-0010, 340-246-0030, 340-246-0050, 340-246-0090, 340-246-0110, 340-246-0130, 340-246-0150, and 340-246-0170 declare they implement ORS 468A.135, but their operative text addresses only the Toxic Air Contaminant Program, which is not enumerated among the functions that ORS 468A.135(1) authorizes regional authorities to exercise.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-246-0010","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468.035","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0030","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.135","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0050","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.025","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0090","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.025","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0110","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.025","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0130","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.025","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0150","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.135","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-246-0170","citation":"ORS 468A.135","quote":"ORS 468.035, ORS 468A.010(1), ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.135","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.135","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fd0cf6c2f2b6a68d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 468A.635, but the operative text contains only general air quality definitions and never engages with the substance of that statute, which restricts sales of certain CFC-containing products and requires CFC recovery in automobile air conditioners.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020 declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.635","citation":"ORS 468A.635","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.635","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3bc23f38babd979a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute makes the exemption from CFC recovery requirements conditional upon \"one year after the Environmental Quality Commission determines that equipment...is affordable and available,\" but the rule converts this conditional trigger into a fixed calendar date of August 10, 1992.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.635","citation":"ORS 468A.635(2)(b)","quote":"Until one year after the operative date of paragraph (a) of this subsection, the provisions of paragraph (a) of this subsection shall not apply to: (A) Any automobile repair shop that has fewer than four employees; or (B) Any automobile repair shop that has fewer than three covered bays.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-260-0030","citation":"OAR 340-260-0030(2)","quote":"Any automobile repair shop that has: (a) Fewer than four employees; or (b) Fewer than three covered bays shall comply with the provisions of section (1) of this rule after August 10, 1992.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.635","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d98141073c78a70a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-253-0040(18) narrows the statutory definition of biodiesel by adding requirements for B100 designation and ASTM D6751 compliance not stated in ORS 468A.265(1).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.265","citation":"ORS 468A.265(1)","quote":"Biodiesel means a motor vehicle fuel consisting of mono-alkyl esters of long chain fatty acids derived from vegetable oils, animal fats or other nonpetroleum resources, not including palm oil.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-253-0040","citation":"OAR 340-253-0040(18)","quote":"Biodiesel means a motor vehicle fuel consisting of mono-alkyl esters of long chain fatty acids derived from vegetable oils, animal fats, or other nonpetroleum resources, not including palm oil, designated as B100 and complying with ASTM D6751.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.265","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"62f2212d262d30f5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-272-0010 declares implementation of ORS 468A.010, but the operative text about establishing verification body requirements never engages with the statute's general policy statement about air pollution control programs undertaken through cooperation and conciliation.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-272-0010","citation":"ORS 468A.010","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 468A.010, ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.265 through 468A.277, ORS 468A.280","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-468a.010","citation":"ORS 468A.010","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"17175b3007ff6148","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 468A.775, which requires establishment of voluntary accreditation and certification programs, but the operative text of the rule contains only definitions and never engages with the statutory requirement to establish such programs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.775","citation":"ORS 468A.775","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.775","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1fcf175362d27ec9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.612, which requires rules for field burning prohibitions in critical nonburn areas, but the rule contains only general air quality definitions with no substantive content addressing field burning, critical nonburn areas, crop residues, or the field burning prohibition requirement of that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.612","citation":"ORS 468A.612","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3682e0a510e82054","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0200 declares it implements ORS 468A.720, but its operative text addresses only public contracting solicitation procedures and mentions the asbestos licensing statute only once in passing without implementing any of the statute's actual provisions regarding licensing qualifications, employee certification requirements, grounds for refusal, or application procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0200","citation":"OAR 137-049-0200, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 279A.110, ORS 279A.120, ORS 279C.365, ORS 279C.370, ORS 279C.390, ORS 279C.505 - 580, ORS 279C.605, ORS 305.385, ORS 468A.720, ORS 701.005 & ORS 701.055","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.720","citation":"ORS 468A.720","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.720","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a6189cf78ee0ec39","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0100 declares it implements ORS 468A.310, but the rule implements Section 128 FCAA requirements about public interest representation and conflicts of interest, which ORS 468A.310 does not address. ORS 468A.310 concerns only the federal operating permit program, streamlined procedures, delays, and permit changes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0100","citation":"OAR 340-200-0100","quote":"ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.310","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.310","citation":"ORS 468A.310","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4c3b50b8fb89bd5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0110 declares it implements ORS 468A.310, but requires public interest representation by EQC members, a requirement of Section 128 FCAA that ORS 468A.310 does not address. ORS 468A.310 is limited to the federal operating permit program.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0110","citation":"OAR 340-200-0110","quote":"468A.035, 468A.310","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.310","citation":"ORS 468A.310","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"820a2d52b505c6f1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0120 declares it implements ORS 468A.310, but requires disclosure of conflicts of interest by EQC members, a requirement ORS 468A.310 does not state. ORS 468A.310 addresses only the federal operating permit program.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0120","citation":"OAR 340-200-0120","quote":"ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.310","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.310","citation":"ORS 468A.310","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1250e4a8d09aceb8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rules implementing greenhouse gas emissions verification declare ORS 468A.015 as authority, but that statute addresses only 'air pollution laws' and contains no reference to greenhouse gas emissions or fuel pathways.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-272-0010","citation":"ORS 468A.010, ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.265 through 468A.277, ORS 468A.280","quote":"ORS 468A.010, ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.265 through 468A.277, ORS 468A.280","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.015","citation":"ORS 468A.015","quote":"It is the purpose of the air pollution laws contained in ORS 448.305, 454.010 to 454.040, 454.205 to 454.255, 454.505 to 454.535, 454.605 to 454.755 and ORS chapters 468, 468A and 468B to safeguard the air resources of the state by controlling, abating and preventing air pollution","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7a7a31695d4b0800","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule is declared to implement ORS 468A.799, which requires standards for qualifying replacements, repowers, and retrofits, but the rule's operative text contains only general air quality definitions unrelated to those substantive requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820 & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-468a.799","citation":"ORS 468A.799","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.799","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"48e61754175345c4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute specifically addresses 'residential open burning of vegetative debris from residential yard cleanup,' but the implementing rules for specific areas regulate 'open burning of domestic waste,' which is broader than vegetative debris alone.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.085","citation":"ORS 468A.085(1)","quote":"the Environmental Quality Commission shall establish by rule periods during which open burning of vegetative debris from residential yard cleanup shall be allowed or disallowed","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-240-0250","citation":"OAR 340-240-0250","quote":"Open burning of domestic waste is prohibited on any day or at any time when DEQ advises fire permit issuing agencies that open burning is not allowed","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-240-0440","citation":"OAR 340-240-0440","quote":"No open burning of domestic waste is allowed to be initiated on any day or at any time when the local air stagnation advisory forecasts adverse meteorological or air quality conditions","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.085","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6d725ceda54c93b3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 918-500-0580(6) cites ORS 468A.460 to 468A.480 in operative text but declared statutes_implemented lists only ORS 468A.460.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-918-500-0580","citation":"OAR 918-500-0580(6)","quote":"Solid fuel burning devices must be certified as required by the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality pursuant to ORS 468A.460 to 468A.480.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-500-0580","citation":"OAR 918-500-0580 frontmatter (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 446.003, ORS 446.155, ORS 446.180, ORS 446.225, ORS 446.245, ORS 468A.460","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.460","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8a5a6163d0dee08a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.797 but contains no substantive content addressing the statute's requirement to establish standards related to certified cost, incremental cost of labor and hardware, or cost-effectiveness threshold—instead providing only general air quality definitions unrelated to these statutory requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.797","citation":"ORS 468A.797","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.797","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"15d82daaeac661e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"This definitions rule declares it implements ORS 468A.505, but its operative text never engages with that statute's substantive requirements regarding removal and destruction of solid fuel burning devices in residential real estate transactions, written confirmation procedures, or any related terms.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"frontmatter","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.505","citation":"ORS 468A.505","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e628f07d844d372","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.600, but the rule's operative text is a general definitions provision that does not establish standards of practice and performance for open field burning, propane flaming, stack/pile burning, or certified alternative methods, which is the statutory requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.600","citation":"ORS 468A.600","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.600","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b92e010d55c916a2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 340-256-0200 declares it implements ORS 468A.390, which is specifically about 'motor vehicle pollution control system inspection program' and boundaries for 'certificate of compliance' requirements, but the rule instead designates counties where vehicles 'must be equipped with a motor vehicle pollution control system' — a requirement about having the system itself, not about inspection or certification.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.390","citation":"ORS 468A.390(1)","quote":"If the need for a motor vehicle pollution control system inspection program is identified for an area in the State of Oregon Clean Air Act Implementation Plan, then the Environmental Quality Commission, by rule, shall designate boundaries, in addition to the areas specified in ORS 815.300 (2)(a) and (b), within which motor vehicles are subject to the requirement under ORS 815.300 to have a certificate of compliance issued under ORS 468A.380 to be registered or have the registration of the vehicle renewed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-256-0200","citation":"OAR 340-256-0200","quote":"ORS 468A.390","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-256-0200","citation":"OAR 340-256-0200","quote":"Clackamas, Columbia, Jackson, Marion, Multnomah, Washington and Yamhill counties are hereby designated by the Environmental Quality Commission as counties in which all motor vehicles registered therein, unless otherwise exempted by statute or by rules subsequently adopted by the Commission, must be equipped with a motor vehicle pollution control system and must comply with motor vehicle emission standards adopted by the Commission.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.390","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"549bf8f56a6514a4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the smoke management program to pertain to 'open field burning, propane flaming and stack or pile burning,' but the rule only specifies 'open field burning, propane flaming, and stack burning,' omitting separate reference to pile burning.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.590","citation":"ORS 468A.590(1)(a)","quote":"Conduct the smoke management program established by rule by the Environmental Quality Commission as it pertains to open field burning, propane flaming and stack or pile burning.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-266-0070","citation":"OAR 340-266-0070","quote":"As part of the Smoke Management Program provided for in ORS 468A.590, the Department shall set forth the types and extent of open field burning, propane flaming, and stack burning to be allowed each day","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.590","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d2047c8efacf796b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute requires notice for modifications that 'significantly affect' emissions, but the rule requires notice for ANY modification causing an increase in emissions, regardless of significance.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.055","citation":"ORS 468A.055(7)","quote":"Addition to or enlargement or replacement of an air contamination source, or any major alteration or modification therein that significantly affects the emission of air contaminants shall be considered as construction of a new air contamination source","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-210-0205","citation":"OAR 340-210-0205(1)(b)(A)","quote":"Construction or modification that will cause an increase, on an hourly basis at full production, in any regulated air pollutant emissions","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.055","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d3122ebfc05c2752","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.780 (fee schedule for accreditation programs), but the rule's operative text contains only general air quality definitions and never establishes any fee schedule or addresses the voluntary accreditation or certification programs.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"oar-340-200-0020","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820 & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-468a.780","citation":"ORS 468A.780","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.780","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6537e92c6015aae9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.105 (Formation of regional air quality control authorities) but the operative text contains only general air quality definitions and never engages with any substantive provision of the statute regarding regional authority formation, population thresholds, territory requirements, or approval procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.105","citation":"ORS 468A.105","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.105","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d1bfd6e30ee6da1a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 468A.820 (which requires establishment of community emission reduction credit banks with specific rules for credit validity and discounting), but the rule's operative text is purely definitional and never engages with any of those substantive requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.820","citation":"ORS 468A.820","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.820","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2c5da49c27462a0f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-266-0110 limits emergency cessation orders to only open field burning, omitting propane flaming and stack or pile burning that the statute expressly authorizes for emergency cessation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-266-0110","citation":"OAR 340-266-0110","quote":"the Commission may order temporary emergency cessation of all open field burning in any area of the Willamette Valley","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.610","citation":"ORS 468A.610(10)","quote":"the commission may order temporary emergency cessation of all open field burning, propane flaming and stack or pile burning in any area of the counties listed in ORS 468A.560","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"21f2995ad46e36c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"ORS 468A.707(1)(b) requires the commission to establish 'the date after which a contractor must be licensed...and a worker must hold a certificate' but oar-340-248-0110 and oar-340-248-0120 impose licensing and certification requirements without establishing when these requirements became effective.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.707","citation":"ORS 468A.707(1)(b)","quote":"Establish the date after which a contractor must be licensed under ORS 468A.720 and a worker must hold a certificate under ORS 468A.730.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0110","citation":"OAR 340-248-0110(1)","quote":"a person performing an asbestos abatement project must be a certified supervisor or worker under OAR 340-248-0130","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0120","citation":"OAR 340-248-0120(1)","quote":"A contractor must submit an application for a license","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.707","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b497e17d3ee35aeb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0020 declares implementation of ORS 468A.707 but its operative text consists entirely of definitions of air quality terms and does not address the substantive program requirements of ORS 468A.707 (establishing asbestos abatement programs, contractor licensing criteria, worker certification criteria, etc.).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"oar-340-200-0020 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.707","citation":"ORS 468A.707(1)-(3)","quote":"The Environmental Quality Commission by rule shall: (a) Establish an asbestos abatement program that assures the proper and safe abatement of asbestos hazards through contractor licensing and worker training. (b) Establish the date after which a contractor must be licensed under ORS 468A.720 and a worker must hold a certificate under ORS 468A.730. (c) Establish criteria and provisions for granting an extension of time for contractor licensing and worker certification...The program established under subsection (1) of this section shall include at least: (a) Criteria for contractor licensing and training; (b) Criteria for worker certification and training; (c) Standardized training courses; and (d) A procedure for inspecting asbestos abatement projects.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.707","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"180ce70ff7d95cc8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0030(1)(d) narrows the exception to the exemption by limiting it to 'woodstoves' instead of the statute's broader 'solid fuel burning devices, as defined in ORS 468A.485', thereby broadening the exemption to include some devices the statute requires to be regulated.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.020","citation":"ORS 468A.020(1)(d)","quote":"Heating equipment in or used in connection with residences used exclusively as dwellings for not more than four families, except solid fuel burning devices, as defined in ORS 468A.485, that are subject to regulation under this section and ORS 468A.140 and 468A.460 to 468A.515.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-200-0030","citation":"OAR 340-200-0030(1)(d)","quote":"Heating equipment in or used in connection with residences used exclusively as dwellings for not more than four families, except woodstoves which shall be subject to regulation under OAR 340 divisions 240 and 262, and as provided in ORS 468A.020(1)(d).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.020","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"03f786a92e4e3db7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 468A.060, which establishes that compliance with one requirement does not relieve a person of other applicable laws and standards. However, the operative text of the rule addresses only the classification of violations into magnitude categories (Major, Moderate, Minor) and never engages with the statutory principle about relief from requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.060","citation":"ORS 468A.060","quote":"Any person who complies with the provisions of ORS 468A.055 and receives notification that construction may proceed in accordance therewith is not thereby relieved from complying with any other applicable law, rule or standard.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-012-0135","citation":"OAR 340-012-0135, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468.090 - 468.140, ORS 468A.060","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8c05f7ede65fc17a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 340-200-0020 is declared to implement ORS 468A.500 but contains only general air quality definitions; the operative text never engages with ORS 468A.500's prohibition on sale of noncertified solid fuel burning devices, instead providing general definitional provisions unrelated to that statute's substance.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.500","citation":"ORS 468A.500","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.500","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b31fe07eacebaf9c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-256-0300 declares implementation of ORS 468A.400, which is entirely about establishing, collecting, and managing fees, but the rule's operative text addresses only inspection scope and testing requirements without any engagement with fee-related provisions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0300","citation":"OAR 340-256-0300","quote":"ORS 468A.350 - 468A.400, ORS 803.350, ORS 815.295, ORS 803.415 & 815.300","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-468a.400","citation":"ORS 468A.400","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a99727b0fc1a82bc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-256-0010 declares implementation of ORS 468A.400, which is entirely about fees and licensing administration, but the rule contains only definitions with no operative provisions addressing fees, licensing, certificate issuance, or other substantive requirements of that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0010","citation":"OAR 340-256-0010","quote":"ORS 468A.350 - 468A.400, ORS 468A.810","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.400","citation":"ORS 468A.400","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2da5f6c0e653d16d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-256-0330 declares implementation of ORS 468A.350-468A.400, which is entirely about fees and licensing, but the rule's operative text addresses only DOD personnel exemptions for catalytic converters and O2 sensors without any engagement with fee-related provisions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0330","citation":"OAR 340-256-0330","quote":"ORS 468A.350 - 468A.400","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0251326dc8ef580","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule does not restrict experimental burning to the specific crop types (perennial grass seed crops, annual grass seed crops, and grain crops) that the statute specifies, making the rule broader in scope.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.620","citation":"ORS 468A.620(1)","quote":"for up to 1,000 acres of perennial grass seed crops, annual grass seed crops and grain crops","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-266-0100","citation":"OAR 340-266-0100(1)","quote":"Acreage experimentally open field burned, propane flamed, or stack burned shall not exceed 1,000 acres annually.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.620","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5a706bf38ae47e3a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule fails to include the statutory requirement that the commission must find the burning can reduce air quality/health harms and is necessary to obtain information before allowing open burning, instead allowing burning without these conditional findings.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.620","citation":"ORS 468A.620(2)","quote":"The commission may allow open burning under this section of acreage for which permits have not been issued under ORS 468A.575 if the commission finds that the experimental burning: (a) Can, in theory, reduce the adverse effects on air quality or public health from open field burning; and (b) Is necessary in order to obtain information on air quality, public health or the agronomic effects of an experimental form of field sanitization.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-266-0100","citation":"OAR 340-266-0100(1)","quote":"Acreage experimentally open field burned, propane flamed, or stack burned shall not exceed 1,000 acres annually.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.620","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"693bf037ca6d1d54","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-216-8030 declares it implements ORS 468A.315, but the rule's operative text requires Cleaner Air Oregon specific activity fees from CAO sources, which ORS 468A.315 does not address or authorize.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-216-8030","citation":"OAR 340-216-8030","quote":"ORS 468.020, ORS 468.065, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.315","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.315","citation":"ORS 468A.315","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.315","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9cbb8535aff3e9ca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-245-0005 declares it implements ORS 468A.345 (Fees), but the operative text is an overview of the Cleaner Air Oregon program's purpose, applicability, and goals with no engagement whatsoever with the statutory fee schedule, fee increase, or fee-related provisions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-245-0005","citation":"OAR 340-245-0005","quote":"ORS 468.065, ORS 468A.010, ORS 468A.015, ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.155, Or Laws 2018, ch. 102, § 7, ch 468A.337, ch 468A.345, ch 468A.335, ch 468A.343","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.345","citation":"ORS 468A.345","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"41194d6074ff4a33","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 340-256-0010(45) defines 'Motor vehicle' without the statutory exclusions for special interest vehicles and racing activity vehicles that ORS 468A.350(3) explicitly prohibits.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350(3)","quote":"\"Motor vehicle\" includes any self-propelled vehicle used for transporting persons or commodities on public roads and highways but does not include a vehicle of special interest as that term is defined in ORS 801.605, if the vehicle is maintained as a collector's item and used for exhibitions, parades, club activities and similar uses but not used primarily for the transportation of persons or property, or a racing activity vehicle as defined in ORS 801.404.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-256-0010","citation":"OAR 340-256-0010(45)","quote":"\"Motor vehicle\" or \"vehicle\" means any self-propelled vehicle used for transporting persons or commodities on public roads.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f41d2d316fb5a6fa","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 340-256-0010(46) defines 'Motor vehicle pollution control system' to include 'a system or device that inhibits the introduction of fuels that can adversely affect the overall motor vehicle pollution control system,' which ORS 468A.350(4) does not include.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350(4)","quote":"\"Motor vehicle pollution control system\" means equipment designed for installation on a motor vehicle for the purpose of reducing the pollutants emitted from the vehicle, or a system or engine adjustment or modification which causes a reduction of pollutants emitted from the vehicle.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-256-0010","citation":"OAR 340-256-0010(46)","quote":"\"Motor vehicle pollution control system\" means equipment designed for installation on a motor vehicle for the purpose of reducing the pollutants emitted from the vehicle, or a system or engine adjustment or modification that causes a reduction of pollutants emitted from the vehicle, or a system or device that inhibits the introduction of fuels that can adversely affect the overall motor vehicle pollution control system.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e95f0f69da1ef6dd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 340-256-0010(25) defines 'Factory-installed motor vehicle pollution control system' by reference only to CFR Parts 85 and 86, omitting the statute's requirement to meet federal criteria as of September 9, 1971, or ORS 468A.365(1) criteria, whichever is stricter.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350(2)","quote":"\"Factory-installed system\" means a motor vehicle pollution control system installed by the manufacturer which meets criteria for emission of pollutants in effect under federal laws and regulations applicable on September 9, 1971, or which meets criteria adopted pursuant to ORS 468A.365 (1), whichever criteria are stricter.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-256-0010","citation":"OAR 340-256-0010(25)","quote":"\"Factory-installed motor vehicle pollution control system\" means a motor vehicle pollution control system installed by the vehicle or engine manufacturer to comply with United States motor vehicle emission control laws and regulations published in the Code of Federal Regulations, 40 C.F.R. Parts 85 and 86.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.350","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc5e18e1b236412a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.750 (fee schedule; waiver; disposition) but contains only general air quality definitions with no provisions relating to fees, waivers, fee schedules, or disposition of collected fees.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.750","citation":"ORS 468A.750","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.750","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fc48bee65b91c44d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-245-0220(2) restricts presumptive TBACT to major source NESHAPs adopted before April 10, 2018, whereas ORS 468A.337(6)(d) states presumptive TBACT applies to major source NESHAPs adopted 'after 1993' with no upper date limit.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-245-0220","citation":"OAR 340-245-0220(2)","quote":"For an existing TEU, compliance with emission control requirements, work practices or limitations established by a major source NESHAP adopted by the EPA after 1993 and before April 10, 2018 is deemed to be TBACT","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.337","citation":"ORS 468A.337(6)(d)","quote":"compliance with emission control requirements, work practices or limitations established by a major source National Emission Standard for Hazardous Air Pollutants adopted by the United States Environmental Protection Agency after 1993 is deemed to be toxics best available control technology","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.337","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"92ec2d44346fc701","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule allows delegation of permit 'issuance and/or enforcement,' but the statute limits delegation to the narrower duty of 'delivering' permits to burn acreage after registration and payment requirements are met.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.575","citation":"ORS 468A.575(2)","quote":"By rule the Environmental Quality Commission may delegate to any county court, board of county commissioners, fire chief of a rural fire protection district or other responsible person the duty to deliver permits to burn acreage if the acreage has been registered under ORS 468A.615 and fees have been paid as required in ORS 468A.615.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-264-0075","citation":"OAR 340-264-0075","quote":"Whenever DEQ finds that any city, county, fire protection district, forest protection district or state agency is capable of effectively administering the issuance and/or enforcement of permits under any or all of the open burning authority outlined within this division and is desirous of doing so, DEQ may delegate powers necessary for the issuance and/or enforcement of open burning permits to that entity.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.575","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"98bf7146050300b0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-260 (Chlorofluorocarbons from automobile air conditioners) declares ORS 468A.025 as its statutory basis, but ORS 468A.025 is about local air purity standards and controlling emissions to maintain air quality in defined areas of the state, whereas the CFCs rule addresses stratospheric ozone depletion, which is a global environmental issue unrelated to local air pollution standards.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.025","citation":"ORS 468A.025(1)","quote":"By rule the Environmental Quality Commission may establish areas of the state and prescribe the degree of air pollution or air contamination that may be permitted therein, as air purity standards for such areas.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-260-0010","citation":"OAR 340-260-0010","quote":"The purpose of OAR 340-260-0010 through 340-260-0030 is to reduce the use of stratospheric ozone depleting chemicals, to recycle those chemicals already in use, and to encourage the use of less dangerous chemicals.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-260-0010-declared","citation":"OAR 340-260-0010 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"partial":true,"note":"Found in part 2 of 3 for ors-468a.025: this section's implementing rules exceeded one context window, so rules were compared within a subset only.","fingerprint":"6d131e6a7ad04630","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The definitions rule declares it implements ORS 468A.385, which specifically requires the Environmental Quality Commission to establish procedures and programs for determining whether motor vehicles meet certification requirements. However, the rule's operative text provides only general air quality definitions (such as \"emissions unit,\" \"major source,\" \"regulated pollutant\") that are not specific to motor vehicle testing or the statutory requirement to establish motor vehicle certification procedures.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.385","citation":"ORS 468A.385","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.385","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3f4dba993f87b776","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute describes the program as addressing both 'reduce use of and recycle compounds,' but the rule implements only recycling requirements, not requirements to reduce use.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.640","citation":"ORS 468A.640","quote":"Department program to reduce use of and recycle compounds. Subject to available funding, the Department of Environmental Quality may establish a program to carry out the purposes of ORS 468A.625 to 468A.645, including enforcement of the provisions of ORS 468A.635.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-260-0030","citation":"OAR 340-260-0030(1)","quote":"no person shall engage in the business of installing, servicing, repairing, disposing of, or otherwise treating automobile air conditioners without recovering and recycling CFC.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.640","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7d15ff146b773692","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"Rule 340-266-0050 sets the permit fee for open field burning at $16 per acre without any county distinction, but Rule 340-266-0140 sets it at $8 per acre for counties outside the Willamette Valley, directly contradicting each other on the applicable fee amount.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-266-0050","citation":"OAR 340-266-0050(2)(f)(A)","quote":"$16 per acre sanitized by open field burning","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-266-0140","citation":"OAR 340-266-0140","quote":"each person open field burning perennial or annual grass seed crops in counties outside the Willamette Valley, shall pay the Department $8.00 for each acre burned","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.615","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"afafafba507ab8f5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-258-0010(23) defines oxygenated gasoline to include fuel with 2.0% oxygen under an averaging method, but ORS 468A.420(3) requires oxygenated fuel to contain 2.7 percent or more oxygen by weight.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-258-0010","citation":"OAR 340-258-0010(23)","quote":"Oxygenated Gasoline means any gasoline which when supplied on a per gallon basis contains at least 2.7 percent oxygen by weight, except where otherwise required by OAR 340-258-0310, or which when supplied using the averaging method contains at least 2.0 percent oxygen by weight","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.420","citation":"ORS 468A.420(3)","quote":"An oxygenated fuel shall contain 2.7 percent or more oxygen by weight.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f6ec751064624433","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-256-0357 declares it implements ORS 468A.350 - 468A.420, but its operative text is entirely about emission control testing methods and never engages with ORS 468A.420, which concerns oxygenated motor vehicle fuels.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0357","citation":"oar-340-256-0357 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.350 - 468A.420","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8d04342bca59e4f9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-256-0358 declares it implements ORS 468A.350 - 468A.420, but its operative text is entirely about emission control testing methods and never engages with ORS 468A.420, which concerns oxygenated motor vehicle fuels.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-256-0358","citation":"oar-340-256-0358 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.350 - 468A.420","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.350","citation":"ORS 468A.350","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"45006a83f3df77e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-262-0400 declares it implements ORS 468A.100 - 468A.180, but the operative text addresses only solid fuel burning device regulation and never engages with ORS 468A.180's court cost exemption for regional authorities.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-262-0400","citation":"OAR 340-262-0400 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.460 - 468A.515, ORS 468A.100 - 468A.180","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.100","citation":"ORS 468A.100","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.180","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1d4764b34628da46","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-264-0160 declares it implements ORS 468A.100 - 468A.180, but the operative text addresses only open burning requirements in Lane County and never engages with ORS 468A.180's court cost exemption for regional authorities.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-264-0160","citation":"OAR 340-264-0160 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.100 - 468A.180, ORS 468A.555 - 468A.620, ORS 477.515, ORS 477.520","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.100","citation":"ORS 468A.100","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.180","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3811cf34fde7b0eb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 468A.740 (accreditation of asbestos abatement training courses), but the operative text is a definitions rule that never engages with accreditation, course content, provider qualifications, or any substantive requirement from the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.740","citation":"ORS 468A.740","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.740","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a7c0aafa0f7588cf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR-340-200-0020 declares it implements ORS 468A.380, but the operative text is a general definitions rule containing no requirements or criteria relating to motor vehicle inspection, inspector qualification, examination procedures, equipment criteria for inspection, licensing of persons or equipment, or certificates of compliance—the core subjects of ORS 468A.380.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.380","citation":"ORS 468A.380(1) and (2)","quote":"The Environmental Quality Commission by rule may: (a) Establish criteria and examinations for the qualification of persons eligible to inspect motor vehicles and motor vehicle pollution control systems... (b) Establish criteria and examinations for the qualification of equipment, apparatus and methods used by persons to inspect motor vehicles and motor vehicle pollution control systems. (c) Establish criteria and examinations for the testing of motor vehicles. Subject to rules of the commission, the Department of Environmental Quality shall: (a) Issue licenses to any person, type of equipment, apparatus or method qualified... (b) Revoke, suspend or modify licenses issued... (c) Issue certificates of compliance for motor vehicles...","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.380","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a6888d8eda13754f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The rules declare they implement ORS 468A.700 - 468A.760, but none of the operative text engages with ORS 468A.760, which requires public agencies to determine whether projects need a licensed contractor and include that requirement in bid advertisements. Instead, all rules address asbestos abatement technical standards, licensing procedures, and emissions control, never addressing the public agency bidding requirement the statute mandates.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-248-0005","citation":"OAR 340-248-0005","quote":"ORS 468A.700 - 468A.760","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0010","citation":"OAR 340-248-0010","quote":"ORS 468A.700 - ORS 468A.760","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0100","citation":"OAR 340-248-0100","quote":"ORS 468A.700 - ORS 468A.760","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0205","citation":"OAR 340-248-0205","quote":"ORS 468A.700 - 468A.760","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-248-0275","citation":"OAR 340-248-0275","quote":"ORS 468A.700 - 468A.760","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.760","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"31f69cbebfb1facb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"oar-340-200-0020 declares ORS 468A.803 as an implemented statute, but the rule contains only general air quality definitions with no connection to the statute's subject matter of diesel engine grants, loans, retrofits, repowers, replacements, or scrapping.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.803","citation":"ORS 468A.803","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.803","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"338befb20b6bf461","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-200-0020 declares implementation of ORS 468A.280 (statute authorizing registration and reporting requirements for electricity and fossil fuels), but the rule's operative text contains only general air quality definitions with no provisions addressing registration and reporting of electricity or fossil fuels.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-200-0020","citation":"OAR 340-200-0020","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.035, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.050, ORS 468A.055, ORS 468A.070, ORS 468A.075, ORS 468A.085, ORS 468A.105, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.140, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.280, ORS 468A.310, ORS 468A.315, ORS 468A.360, ORS 468A.363, ORS 468A.380, ORS 468A.385, ORS 468A.420, ORS 468A.495, ORS 468A.500, ORS 468A.505, ORS 468A.515, ORS 468A.575, ORS 468A.595, ORS 468A.600, ORS 468A.610, ORS 468A.612, ORS 468A.620, ORS 468A.635, ORS 468A.707, ORS 468A.740, ORS 468A.745, ORS 468A.750, ORS 468A.775, ORS 468A.780, ORS 468A.797, ORS 468A.799, ORS 468A.803, ORS 468A.820, & Or. Laws 2009, chapter 754","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.280","citation":"ORS 468A.280","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.280","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ff22a94078e71294","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"The statute contemplates masonry fireplaces being certified and curtailed only at the more severe stage if certified, but the rules exclude fireplaces from the definition of 'solid fuel burning device' and provide no mechanism for certifying masonry fireplaces.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-468a.515","citation":"ORS 468A.515(2)","quote":"The programs shall provide that use of a solid fuel burning device, masonry fireplace or other solid fuel burning device identified in rules adopted by the commission be curtailed only at the more severe stage of projected air quality if the solid fuel burning device, masonry fireplace or other solid fuel burning device identified in rules adopted by the commission was certified for sale as new","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-262-0450","citation":"OAR 340-262-0450(24)","quote":"Solid fuel burning device or \"device\" means a woodstove or any other device that burns wood, coal or other nongaseous or non-liquid fuels for aesthetic, space-heating or water-heating purposes in or for a private residential structure or a commercial establishment and that has a heat output of less than one million British thermal units per hour. Solid fuel burning device does not include: (a) Fireplaces","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-262-0500","citation":"OAR 340-262-0500(1)-(4)","quote":"By order, the department may certify solid fuel burning devices that have been certified by the United States Environmental Protection Agency...By order, the department may certify solid fuel burning devices that have not been certified by the United States Environmental Protection Agency...By order, the department may certify any hydronic heater that has been accepted by EPA...By order, the department may certify solid fuel burning devices that have been tested using a test method...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"71adc54d1e2c49cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-268-0030 claims to implement ORS 468A.025, but the operative text of ORS 468A.025 addresses only air purity standards, air quality standards, and treatment/control of emissions, not emission reduction credits which is the entire subject of the rule.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-268-0030","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 468A.025, ORS 468A.040, ORS 468A.135, ORS 468A.155, ORS 468A.310","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-468a.025","citation":"ORS 468A.025(1)","quote":"By rule the Environmental Quality Commission may establish areas of the state and prescribe the degree of air pollution or air contamination that may be permitted therein, as air purity standards for such areas.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"partial":true,"note":"Found in part 3 of 3 for ors-468a.025: this section's implementing rules exceeded one context window, so rules were compared within a subset only.","fingerprint":"52b7239c074f41e4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"OAR 340-240-0100 states rule 0180 applies only in Medford-Ashland AQMA, but OAR 340-240-0360 requires La Grande area sources to comply with rule 0180.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-240-0100","citation":"OAR 340-240-0100","quote":"OAR 340-240-0100 through 340-240-0250 apply in the Medford-Ashland Air Quality Maintenance Area (AQMA) and the Grants Pass Urban Growth Area (Area), except that OAR 340-240-0130, 340-240-0180, and 340-240-0190 apply only in the Medford-Ashland AQMA.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-240-0360","citation":"OAR 340-240-0360","quote":"The owner or operator of any sawmill, plywood mill or veneer manufacturing plant, particleboard plant, or hardboard plant that is located in the La Grande Urban Growth Area must comply with OAR 340-240-0180.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-468a.025","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"partial":true,"note":"Found in part 2 of 3 for ors-468a.025: this section's implementing rules exceeded one context window, so rules were compared within a subset only.","fingerprint":"0db84c66e03e4e1a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"475a","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"A BCU psilocybin-permit rule's clause (A) ('any felony conviction,' undated) is capable of overriding the statute's mandatory 2-year non-consideration window for felonies that are also ORS 475A.210-.722 offenses.","documents":[{"id":"ors-475a.483","citation":"ORS 475A.483(4)(a)","quote":"Is convicted of a felony ... except that the authority may not consider a conviction for an offense under ORS 475A.210 to 475A.722 if the date of the conviction is two or more years before the date of the application...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-407-007-0281","citation":"OAR 407-007-0281(2)(b)","quote":"BCU may only consider the following ... (A) Any felony conviction; or (B) Any felony or misdemeanor conviction under [ORS 475A.210 to 475A.722] if the date of the conviction is less than two years before...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Drafting-ambiguity conflict, not unambiguous — clauses (A) and (B) aren't drafted as mutually exclusive.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"42ca2c9de340ddf9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services"]}],"artifacts":["oar-333-064-0060 statutes_implemented drops the \"ORS \" prefix used by every sibling rule.","oar-407-007-0210 mixes a session-law citation (\"Or. Law 2026 ch. 59 (2026 HB 4115)\") into otherwise ORS/OAR-only citation fields."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"543","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":22,"candidates":[{"summary":"A WRD rule converts the statute's absolute 'no injury to other water rights' standard into a mitigable standard subject to Department discretion.","documents":[{"id":"ors-543.092","citation":"ORS 543.092(2)(c)","quote":"Any amendments under subsection (1) of this section shall: ... (c) Cause no injury to other water rights...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-690-053-0020","citation":"OAR 690-053-0020(3)","quote":"...causes no injury to other water rights that cannot be adequately mitigated as determined by the Water Resources Department...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"37c4f6f0df8716d9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["water-resources-department"]},{"summary":"Two rule sets both frontmatter-tagged as implementing ORS 543.092 impose wildly different deadlines (120 vs. 30 days) for the identical post-protest final-order-or-hearing decision step.","documents":[{"id":"oar-690-052-0110","citation":"OAR 690-052-0110(6)","quote":"Within 120 days after the close of the period for receiving protests, the director shall: (a) Issue a final order... or (b) Schedule a contested case hearing...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-690-053-0045","citation":"OAR 690-053-0045(1)","quote":"Within 30 days after the close of the period for receiving protests, the Director shall determine whether to issue a final order or schedule a contested case hearing.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Likely an artifact of Division 052 (decommissioning, ORS 543A.300) being mistagged as implementing ORS 543.092 — see artifacts.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a67010570de4182e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["water-resources-department"]},{"summary":"The same two rule sets also diverge on the proposed/final-order deadline after comments close (90 vs. 120 days).","documents":[{"id":"oar-690-052-0110","citation":"OAR 690-052-0110(1)","quote":"Within 90 days of the close of the comment period ... a proposed final order ... shall be prepared by the Director.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-690-053-0035","citation":"OAR 690-053-0035","quote":"...the Department shall issue a proposed order within 120 days.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b39a56866dc30024","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["water-resources-department"]}],"artifacts":["Entire Division 052 (decommissioning) rule set carries statutes_implemented: [\"ORS 543.092\", \"ORS 543\", \"ORS 543A\"] though its subject matter is decommissioning under ORS 543A.300 — likely the root cause of candidates 2 and 3 above.","Session-law citation \"OL 1999 Ch. 873\" mechanically split into two array entries (\"OL 1999 Ch. 873\" and a dangling \"Sec. 26\") across seven Division 052 rules."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"543a","agencies":5,"rules_reviewed":21,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DEQ rule grants discretionary deadline flexibility (department-and-applicant-agreed alternative date) that the statute's one-year-before deadline doesn't authorize.","documents":[{"id":"ors-543a.095","citation":"ORS 543A.095(1)","quote":"the applicant shall file with the Hydroelectric Application Review Team: (a) A draft application for a water right ... [no flexibility clause]","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-340-048-0020","citation":"OAR 340-048-0020(5)","quote":"...no later than one year before the applicant files a final application ... unless the department and the applicant agree to a different time for submission...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"22750eaa45abc27c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"A rule substantively applies ORS 543A.025's standards but neither the rule's nor the statute's frontmatter records that relationship.","documents":[{"id":"oar-340-048-0020","citation":"OAR 340-048-0020(2)(l)(B)","quote":"Identifies applicable standards under ORS 543A.025(2) through (4), rules adopted by the Water Resources Commission implementing such standards...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-543a.025","citation":"ORS 543A.025 relationships","quote":"implemented_by: [oar-340-048-0042, oar-340-048-0045] — omits oar-340-048-0020","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3c9b948b1ff7cc70","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-environmental-quality"]},{"summary":"A WRD decommissioning rule implements only one of the statute's two alternative decommissioning triggers (ORS 543A.030), omitting the ORS 543A.075 branch.","documents":[{"id":"ors-543a.300","citation":"ORS 543A.300(1)","quote":"If any person operating a hydroelectric project fails to advise the Water Resources Department within 60 days of the time established in ORS 543A.030 or 543A.075, the Water Resources Commission may order the decommissioning of the project.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-690-052-0020","citation":"OAR 690-052-0020(1)","quote":"If an operator does not submit a notice of intent to reauthorize under ORS 543A.030, the Department shall ... request ... information regarding the decommissioning...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8854c3ba2779d765","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["water-resources-department"]}],"artifacts":["oar-690-052-0020 statutes_implemented: \"ORs 543A\" (malformed capitalization)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"}]},{"ors_chapter":"578","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":8,"candidates":[{"summary":"Three Oregon Wheat Commission per-diem/expense rules — which ORS 578.060(3)'s 'shall adopt' mandate depends on — were repealed in 2022 but remain status: current with no operative replacement text.","documents":[{"id":"ors-578.060","citation":"ORS 578.060(3)","quote":"the commission shall adopt uniform and reasonable rules governing the incurring and paying of such expenses.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-678-030-0000","citation":"OAR 678-030-0000, status: current","quote":"History: WHEAT 1-2022, repeal filed 03/04/2022, effective 03/04/2022 ... (no operative text)","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Same pattern across oar-678-030-0010 and oar-678-030-0020.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"342b31965bde56ba","cites_repealed":["oar-678-030-0000"],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission"]}],"artifacts":["oar-678-001-0000 cites \"ORS 578.090(2)(n)\" though the cluster's ORS 578.090(2) text only runs (a) through (i)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Wheat Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"622","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":22,"candidates":[{"summary":"Sibling shellfish-sanitation rules cite different, non-updated NSSP Guide revisions (2023 vs. 2009) though all implement the same statute and one was refreshed as recently as late 2024.","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-100-0010","citation":"OAR 603-100-0010, effective 2024-12-31","quote":"...the National Shellfish Sanitation Program, Guide for the Control of Molluscan Shellfish, 2023 Revision, is hereby adopted...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-100-0920","citation":"OAR 603-100-0920(9), effective 2013","quote":"Violation of any requirement ... found in the National Shellfish Sanitation Program, Guide for the Control of Molluscan Shellfish, 2009 Revision.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0c0a45f4c712125d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"A plat-application rule is metadata-tagged to ORS 622.230 ($25 conversion fee) though its own body text is entirely about new plats and cites ORS 622.250's $250 fee — and ORS 622.250's own implemented_by list omits this rule.","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-082-0030","citation":"OAR 603-082-0030(1)(c)","quote":"Applicants for new oyster, clam or mussel plats shall complete and submit an application form ... including ... An application fee as established by ORS 622.250(1).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-622.250","citation":"ORS 622.250 relationships","quote":"implemented_by: [oar-603-082-0040, oar-603-082-0050, oar-603-082-0060] — omits oar-603-082-0030","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eaae1f2f587730d1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"A rule cites the wrong ORS 622.290 subsection for the shellfish use-tax rate — subsection (1) is the quarterly-payment rule; the rates are in (2) and (3).","documents":[{"id":"ors-622.290","citation":"ORS 622.290(2)-(3)","quote":"Use taxes shall be in the amount of 10 cents per gallon of oysters... [and] one-half cent per pound of clams or mussels sold.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-082-0080","citation":"OAR 603-082-0080(1)","quote":"Use taxes shall be in the amount established by ORS 622.290(1).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"75d2c0cef1b17308","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]}],"artifacts":["\"ORS 622.210 - 662.360\" (digit transposition, 622→662) in two sibling rules.","OAR 603-100-0930 cites \"ORS 621.995\" (nonexistent in this context; should be 622.996) and \"OAR 603-024-0910\" (should likely be 603-100-0920)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"}]},{"ors_chapter":"646","agencies":7,"rules_reviewed":54,"candidates":[{"summary":"[batch 1] A civil-penalty escalation rule shows no sign of the statute's 2-year reset window between violations.","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.963","citation":"ORS 646.963(2)","quote":"The director may impose civil penalties ... (b) Not more than $2,500 for a second violation within two years from the date of the first violation. (c) Not more than $10,000 for a third violation within two years from the date of the first violation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-027-0490","citation":"OAR 603-027-0490(3)","quote":"Violations occurring after the time prescribed for the elimination of the violation shall be considered repeat violations.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule's dollar amounts never exceed the statute's caps (not in tension on the numbers), but its escalation-by-count logic carries no visible two-year reset. A second violation 3 years after the first should, per the statute, still be capped at the first-violation ceiling. Needs confirmation whether the reset is applied in unwritten agency practice. Not re-surfaced by the batch-2 re-check, which found a different candidate below.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"668d1940f9cf8802","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"[batch 2, 2026-07-23 re-check] A telephonic-seller disclosure rule drops the statute's '12 months' qualifier, leaving the reporting period undefined.","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.557","citation":"ORS 646.557(1)(c)","quote":"The total number of individuals who have actually received from the telephonic seller, during the preceding 12 months or if the seller has not been in business that long, during the period the telephonic seller has been in business, the item having the greatest value and the item with the smallest odds of being received.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-020-0203","citation":"OAR 137-020-0203(1)(c)","quote":"The total number of individuals who have actually received from the telephonic seller, during the preceding months (or if the seller has not been in business that long, during the period the telephonic seller has been in business), the item having the greatest value and the item with the smallest odds of being received.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule omits the '12' qualifier present in the statute. Creates ambiguity about whether the disclosure period is 12 months or unspecified. Requires human/legal review to determine if this is stale rule text or a transcription artifact. Not surfaced by the batch-1 pass.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"c5ef04f6d356674c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule changes 'usually changed' to 'usually charged' in section (4), altering the statutory language.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.557","citation":"ORS 646.557(4)","quote":"are offered at prices which are below those usually changed for these items","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-020-0203","citation":"OAR 137-020-0203(4)","quote":"are offered at prices which are below those usually charged for these items","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.557","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"53766c89cba330ea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"The rule's description of the department's active supervision duties omits the statutory requirement that the Director must approve proposed prices before they take effect.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.738","citation":"ORS 646.738(2)(c)","quote":"The director must approve the proposed prices and any adjustments to previously approved prices before the prices may be implemented.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0016","citation":"OAR 603-076-0016(2)","quote":"As part of active supervision, the department shall: (a) Organize and attend all meetings of the Bargaining Council and the Planning Committee; (b) Create and maintain minutes of all meetings of the Bargaining Council and the Planning Committee... (d) Monitor and facilitate the negotiations regarding the process to create an established price","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.738","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"60ce10435ed487cf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"The rule expands violations of anti-trust laws to include monopolization attempts, which are not mentioned in ORS 646.725, which addresses only restraints of trade.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.725","citation":"ORS 646.725","quote":"Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce is declared to be illegal.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0621","citation":"OAR 125-246-0621(1)","quote":"Violations of anti-trust laws include but are not limited to the attempt of any Person(s) to monopolize or to conspire with any other Person(s) to monopolize any trade of commerce.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.725","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"359571d90e3a7890","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-027-0490 declares it implements ORS 646.990 (which establishes criminal penalties: Class B misdemeanor, Class B felony, Class D violation, Class C misdemeanor) but the operative text never engages with those criminal penalties. Instead, it creates an entirely separate civil penalty system with its own monetary penalty schedule (up to $10,000 per violation based on gravity levels). The operative text only addresses penalties for violations of ORS 646.947, 646.949, 646.953, and rules under 646.957—not ORS 646.990.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0490","citation":"OAR 603-027-0490 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 646.905 - 646.990, ORS 183","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.990","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"12923ec5a1215ddb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-020-0030 is declared as implementing ORS 646.608(1)(s), which addresses representations about offering price or cost, but the rule requires disclosure of the year of manufacture of a motor vehicle—a matter of condition/quality unrelated to price or cost representations.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.608","citation":"ORS 646.608(1)(s)","quote":"Makes false or misleading representations of fact concerning the offering price of, or the person's cost for real estate, goods or services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.608","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a23e35e65ee9e28f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"OAR 137-020-0550 is declared as implementing ORS 646.608(1)(yy), which prohibits operating as a vehicle dealer without a certificate under ORS 822.005, but the rule establishes purchase agreement requirements for manufactured dwelling dealers, a different category of dealer entirely.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-020-0550","citation":"declared statutes_implemented, first line","quote":"ORS 646.400 - 646.404, ORS 646.608(1)(yy)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.608","citation":"ORS 646.608(1)(yy)","quote":"Commits the offense of acting as a vehicle dealer without a certificate under ORS 822.005.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.608","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fa32bf0797738579","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-076-0051 declares implementation of ORS 646.535 but its operative text never mentions or engages with 646.535—it contains only definitions related to the seafood regulatory program with no substantive engagement with the prohibited unfair trade practices or exception in 646.535","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-076-0051","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 62.845, ORS 646.515, ORS 646.535, ORS 646.740","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.535","citation":"ORS 646.535","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.535","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5e1f12f42732e18a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-076-0052 declares implementation of ORS 646.535 but its operative text never mentions or engages with 646.535—the procedural rules for seafood price negotiations never reference or apply 646.535's prohibition on unfair trade practices or its exception","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-076-0052","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 62.845, ORS 646.515, ORS 646.535, ORS 646.740","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.535","citation":"ORS 646.535","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.535","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"574888aece7bbf33","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 603-111-0030(4) adds a 'written request' requirement to obtain information from ODA, which the statute does not require.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.932","citation":"ORS 646.932(4)","quote":"The owner or operator of a gas station may disclose to customers the cost, per gallon of gasoline and diesel, of the low carbon fuel standards adopted by rule under ORS 468A.266 after viewing on the Department of Environmental Quality's website or receiving from the State Department of Agriculture the annual calculations described in ORS 468A.271.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-111-0030","citation":"OAR 603-111-0030(4)","quote":"ODA shall furnish the formula, the cost per gallon of the CFP, and the total greenhouse gas reduction attributable to the CFP to gas station owners or operators who wish to post this material at their respective gas stations, upon written request from such owners or operators.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.932","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ebe00664eb61483a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"The rule omits 'combine' from the types of prohibited conduct enumerated in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.730","citation":"ORS 646.730","quote":"Every person who shall monopolize, or attempt to monopolize, or combine or conspire with any other person or persons, to monopolize any part of trade or commerce","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-246-0621","citation":"OAR 125-246-0621(1)","quote":"Violations of anti-trust laws include but are not limited to the attempt of any Person(s) to monopolize or to conspire with any other Person(s) to monopolize any trade of commerce.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.730","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8af09511c44fc543","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"All three rules require notification of ORS 646.561 and 646.563, which the statute does not mention as required provisions for notification.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.578","citation":"ORS 646.578","quote":"The Public Utility Commission shall by rule require that telecommunications companies inform parties of the provisions of ORS 646.567 to 646.578 and 646.608.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-021-0610","citation":"860-021-0610","quote":"Each large telecommunications utility shall notify its residential customers of the provisions of ORS 646.561, 646.563, 646.567 through 646.578, and 646.608.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-034-0280","citation":"860-034-0280","quote":"Each small telecommunications utility shall notify its residential customers of the provisions of ORS 646.561, 646.563, 646.567 through 646.578, and 646.608.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-034-0725","citation":"860-034-0725","quote":"Each telecommunications cooperative shall notify its residential customers of the provisions of ORS 646.561, 646.563, 646.567 through 646.578, and 646.608.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.578","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"86189c329789b124","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["public-utility-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule narrows the statutory definition of 'Telephonic Seller' by limiting it only to those required to register with the Department of Justice, whereas the statute defines it as any person who causes or attempts a telephone solicitation regardless of registration status.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.551","citation":"ORS 646.551(3)(a)","quote":"\"Telephonic seller\" means a person who, on the person's own behalf, or on behalf of another person, causes or attempts a telephone solicitation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-020-0200","citation":"OAR 137-020-0200(1)","quote":"\"Telephonic Seller\" applies to all persons required to register with the Oregon Department of Justice pursuant to ORS 646.551 through 646.565.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.551","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6d5ec52761c81f89","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-076-0005(6) narrows the purpose for which a dealer purchases commodities by omitting 'packing' from the statute's list of purposes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.515","citation":"ORS 646.515(3)(a)","quote":"for the purpose of packing, processing or marketing such commodity","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0005","citation":"OAR 603-076-0005(6)","quote":"for the purpose of processing or marketing such seed","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"843d9c23f52381ec","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-076-0005(4) adds a requirement not found in the statute by defining cooperative bargaining association as requiring compliance with the federal Capper-Volstead Act in addition to ORS chapter 62.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.515","citation":"ORS 646.515(2)(a)","quote":"An association of producers formed or operated pursuant to ORS chapter 62","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0005","citation":"OAR 603-076-0005(4)","quote":"any cooperative formed or operated pursuant to ORS chapter 62 and the federal Capper-Volstead Act (7 U.S.C. §§ 291-292)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ea859387ee485011","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-076-0051(1) narrows the definition of dealer for seafood by adding a requirement that the dealer must have bought product in the prior year, which is not stated in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.515","citation":"ORS 646.515(3)(a)","quote":"any person or agent of the person who purchases or contracts to purchase an agricultural commodity or Oregon seafood commodity from a producer or agent of the producer","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0051","citation":"OAR 603-076-0051(1)","quote":"has the same meaning provided under ORS 646.515(3), and who has bought product in the prior year respective to the specific seafood species under price negotiations","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6177119b74edf755","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"The statute applies to cooperatives marketing 'agricultural, seafood and other products derived from natural resources or labor resources,' but the rules restrict all definitions and the regulatory program exclusively to three specific grass seed kinds (annual ryegrass, perennial ryegrass, and tall fescue).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.736","citation":"ORS 646.736(1)","quote":"It is the public policy of the State of Oregon to encourage the efficient production and distribution of agricultural, seafood and other products derived from natural resources or labor resources of this state.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0005","citation":"OAR 603-076-0005(6)","quote":"\"Dealer\" or \"seed dealer\" means any person or agent of the person who purchases or contracts to purchase perennial ryegrass seed, annual ryegrass seed, or tall fescue seed kinds from a grower or agent of the grower for the purpose of processing or marketing such seed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0005","citation":"OAR 603-076-0005(22)","quote":"\"Regulatory program\" means the state regulatory program described in ORS 646.738(2) that is actively supervised by the Director and that authorizes parties to engage in certain collective bargaining and negotiations to establish the price of perennial ryegrass seed to be produced and sold to perennial ryegrass seed dealers in the future, annual ryegrass seed to be produced and sold to annual ryegrass seed dealers in the future or tall fescue seed kinds to be produced and sold to tall fescue seed dealers in the future.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0016","citation":"OAR 603-076-0016(1)","quote":"It is the intent of the grass seed price negotiations to displace competition in the annual ryegrass seed, perennial ryegrass seed, and tall fescue seed industries to a limited degree as allowed by these rules.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.736","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e73036d1e7fe3d81","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rules 603-076-0101 and 603-076-0106 declare they implement ORS 646.740, but that statute only permits negotiating activities of dealers in agricultural commodities if they are 'carried out and supervised under ORS 646.737 or 646.738'—not under ORS 62.845 or 62.848 that the blackberry rules actually implement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-076-0101","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 62.015, ORS 62.845, ORS 62.848, ORS 646.535, ORS 646.740","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-076-0106","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 62.015, ORS 62.845, ORS 646.535, ORS 646.740","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.740","citation":"ORS 646.740(11)","quote":"The negotiating activities of a dealer in agricultural commodities that are carried out and supervised under ORS 646.737 or 646.738.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.740","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eded88295d0079c4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 3 defines 'Alcohol' as only a chemical compound without the statute's required conditions that it be used for gasoline blending, commonly known as alcohol, or include only ethanol and methanol.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.905","citation":"ORS 646.905(1)","quote":"\"Alcohol\" means a volatile flammable liquid having the general formula C n H(2n+1)OH used or sold for the purpose of blending or mixing with gasoline for use in propelling motor vehicles, and commonly or commercially known or sold as an alcohol, and includes ethanol or methanol.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-027-0410","citation":"OAR 603-027-0410(3)","quote":"\"Alcohol\" means a volatile flammable liquid having the general formula CnH(2n+1)OH.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.905","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"983c815123847a09","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 11 defines 'Biodiesel' without the statute's requirement that it be designated as B100 and comply with ASTM D 6751, thereby covering non-B100 biodiesel the statute does not cover.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.905","citation":"ORS 646.905(2)","quote":"\"Biodiesel\" means a motor vehicle fuel consisting of mono-alkyl esters of long chain fatty acids derived from vegetable oils, animal fats or other nonpetroleum resources, not including palm oil, designated as B100 and complying with ASTM D 6751.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-027-0410","citation":"OAR 603-027-0410(11)","quote":"\"Biodiesel\" means a motor vehicle fuel consisting of mono-alkyl esters of long chain fatty acids derived from vegetable oils, animal fats, or other nonpetroleum resources other than palm oil.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.905","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e7b5187ea8b3aaf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-027-0460 is entirely about test methods for premium diesel and never addresses ORS 646.920's requirement for wholesale dealers to declare oxygenate content in gasoline","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0460","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 646.905, ORS 646.915, ORS 646.920","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.920","citation":"ORS 646.920","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.920","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0a6569e1d251bffe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 646.605, but the statute contains no definition or discussion of structures, and the rule's operative text only references ORS 701.005.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0700","citation":"OAR 812-002-0700","quote":"ORS 87.058, ORS 279C.460, ORS 646.605, ORS 701","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.605","citation":"ORS 646.605","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.605","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d278eadb0c466326","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the Department's document to be posted at the telephonic seller's principal business location, but the rule requires it to be posted at each business location.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-646.553","citation":"ORS 646.553(3)","quote":"The Department of Justice shall send to each registrant a certificate or other appropriate document demonstrating registration compliance, which shall be posted at the telephonic seller's principal business location.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-020-0201","citation":"OAR 137-020-0201(5)","quote":"If the seller has more than one business location, the written confirmation shall be sent to the principal business location identified in the seller's filing in sufficient number so that the seller has one for each business location. The seller shall post the confirmation of receipt of filing, within ten days of receipt thereof, in a conspicuous place at each of the seller's business locations","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.553","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"452fa9d6bdb2408c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule 603-027-0450 declares it implements ORS 646.915 but addresses sampling procedures and inspections, not the statute's requirement for display of oxygenate names and concentrations on fuel dispensing devices.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0450","citation":"OAR 603-027-0450 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 646.905, ORS 646.915, ORS 646.920","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.915","citation":"ORS 646.915","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture may adopt rules that require a retail dealer or nonretail dealer to display on fuel dispensing devices through which the retail dealer or nonretail dealer sells gasoline the names of the oxygenates and the relative concentrations of the oxygenates present in the gasoline","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.915","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"79e03e3d4e80985f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 603-027-0460 declares it implements ORS 646.915 but addresses test methods and reproducibility limits, not the statute's requirement for display of oxygenate names and concentrations on fuel dispensing devices.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0460","citation":"OAR 603-027-0460 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 646.905, ORS 646.915, ORS 646.920","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.915","citation":"ORS 646.915","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture may adopt rules that require a retail dealer or nonretail dealer to display on fuel dispensing devices through which the retail dealer or nonretail dealer sells gasoline the names of the oxygenates and the relative concentrations of the oxygenates present in the gasoline","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.915","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cd57f1213ce2c151","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule 603-027-0480 declares it implements ORS 646.915 but provides only enforcement definitions, not the statute's requirement for display of oxygenate names and concentrations on fuel dispensing devices.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0480","citation":"OAR 603-027-0480 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 646.905, ORS 646.915, ORS 646.920","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.915","citation":"ORS 646.915","quote":"The State Department of Agriculture may adopt rules that require a retail dealer or nonretail dealer to display on fuel dispensing devices through which the retail dealer or nonretail dealer sells gasoline the names of the oxygenates and the relative concentrations of the oxygenates present in the gasoline","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.915","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5f8ba9908a0d75b2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"OAR 603-027-0490 declares it implements ORS 646.990 (which prescribes criminal penalties), but the rule's operative text addresses only civil penalties for violations of other statutes (ORS 646.947, 646.949, 646.953) and never engages with ORS 646.990.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-603-027-0490","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 646.905 - 646.990, ORS 183","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-646.990","citation":"ORS 646.990","quote":"Violation of ORS 646.910 is a Class D violation. (4) Violation of a rule that the State Department of Agriculture adopts under ORS 646.915 is a Class D violation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-646.990","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c1e23eeb1e9353bd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]}],"note":"Batch 1 and batch 2 surfaced different candidates in this 54-rule cluster rather than confirming each other — read as a union of two partial passes, not agreement.","artifacts":["Several OAR 137-020 rules have a standalone \"(4)\" or \"(1)(yy)\" entry in legal_authority/statutes_implemented — a citation like \"ORS 646.608(1)(u) & (4)\" split across array entries, leaving a bare fragment as its own item.","OAR 603-111-0020 statutes_implemented: \"ORS 646932\" — missing the period."],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"646a","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":20,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DCBS rule defines 'harm' (the standard for excusing breach notification) as 'limited to monetary loss' though the statute never defines the term and covers sensitive-data breaches generally.","documents":[{"id":"ors-646a.604","citation":"ORS 646A.604(8)","quote":"...reasonably determines that the consumers whose personal information was subject to the breach of security are unlikely to suffer harm.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-441-646-0010","citation":"OAR 441-646-0010(2)","quote":"'Harm,' for purposes of the notification requirement, is limited to monetary loss.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1b366e4911c55ac6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation"]},{"summary":"A drug-price-transparency rule hardcodes two dollar thresholds pegged to specific past CMS Call Letters (2018/2024), where the statute ties the trigger to CMS's current, annually-revised Part D specialty-tier benchmark.","documents":[{"id":"ors-646a.689","citation":"ORS 646A.689(6)","quote":"...at a price that exceeds the threshold established by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services for specialty drugs in the Medicare Part D program...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-836-200-0520","citation":"OAR 836-200-0520(2)-(3)","quote":"(2) For new prescription drugs introduced on or after January 1, 2025, the threshold is $950 ... (3) ... prior to January 1, 2025, the threshold is $670...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b29d3547147606ac","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation"]},{"summary":"The same rule omits the statute's 30-day new-drug-notification deadline entirely, deferring to a rule (OAR 836-200-0531) not present anywhere in the corpus.","documents":[{"id":"ors-646a.689","citation":"ORS 646A.689(6)","quote":"No later than 30 days after a manufacturer introduces a new prescription drug ... the manufacturer shall notify the department...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-836-200-0520","citation":"OAR 836-200-0520(1)","quote":"...the manufacturer must report to the department the information described in OAR 836-200-0531. [no deadline stated]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"89dcea922f27869c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation"]}],"artifacts":["\"OAR 826-200-0515 to 826-200-0535\" (chapter typo for 836) in oar-836-200-0505(12).","Multiple rules cite OAR 836-200-0531/0532/0553, none of which exist anywhere in the corpus's document set."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"648","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"An assumed-business-name amendment rule drops the statute's 'member-managed' qualifier for LLC member signatures, reading as if any manager or member of any LLC may sign.","documents":[{"id":"ors-648.025","citation":"ORS 648.025(2)","quote":"...by a manager of a foreign or domestic limited liability company, or by a member of a foreign or domestic member-managed limited liability company...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-160-010-0030","citation":"OAR 160-010-0030","quote":"...by a manager or member of a foreign or domestic limited liability company...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5e5bd62cdfc774af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-corporation-division"]},{"summary":"The same rule cites a nonexistent subsection (\"648.125(2)\") for the signature obligation actually stated in ORS 648.025(2) — ORS 648.125 has no subsection (2).","documents":[{"id":"oar-160-010-0030","citation":"OAR 160-010-0030 body text","quote":"In addition to the signatures required by 648.125(2)...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-648.125","citation":"ORS 648.125, full text","quote":"References in the Bank Act to federal statutes... [single-sentence rulemaking-authority section, no subsection (2)]","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8f87c6218cf2938b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-corporation-division"]},{"summary":"A rule (OAR 160-010-0020) substantively implements ORS 648.025(5) (replacement-representative designation) but is instead tagged as implementing ORS 648.010, and ORS 648.025's own implemented_by list omits it.","documents":[{"id":"oar-160-010-0020","citation":"OAR 160-010-0020 full text","quote":"If the authorized representative of an assumed business name registration withdraws and the registrants fail ... the new authorized representative shall be the first listed registrant...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-648.025","citation":"ORS 648.025(5)","quote":"The Secretary of State may designate a new authorized representative by rule if the authorized representative withdraws...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f7aadc4b2364b3bd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["secretary-of-state-corporation-division"]}],"artifacts":["Four sibling rules (160-010-0011/-0012/-0013/-0014) collapse \"ORS 128.580\" and \"ORS 554.005\" into one semicolon-joined citation string."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"},{"slug":"travel-information-council","name":"Travel Information Council"}]},{"ors_chapter":"655","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":44,"candidates":[{"summary":"The rule defines 'Department' as a specific division of ODAS rather than the whole department as the statute states.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-655.505","citation":"ORS 655.505(4)","quote":"\"Department\" means the Oregon Department of Administrative Services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-160-0010","citation":"OAR 125-160-0010(13)","quote":"\"Department\" means Risk Management of the Enterprise Goods and Services Division of the Department of Administrative Services.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-655.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"973f2d8b6b02a493","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule limits authorized work assignments to facilities within Oregon operated by Corrections, while the statute does not include these geographic or operational restrictions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-655.505","citation":"ORS 655.505(3)","quote":"\"Authorized work or occupational training assignment\" means the work assignment of an adult in custody: (a) As authorized by ORS 421.305 and 421.312; (b) As authorized by ORS 421.450 to 421.480; (c) As authorized by ORS 144.410 to 144.525; (d) As authorized by ORS 420.011; (e) As authorized by ORS 420.240 to 420.265; or (f) In any other adult in custody activity or program, including, but not limited to, on-the-job training established by the Department of Corrections","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-160-0010","citation":"OAR 125-160-0010(2)","quote":"\"Authorized work or training assignment\" is the duties of, and travel to and from, work or occupational training assigned to the claimant by Corrections. It applies only to assignments during confinement in a facility or institution located within Oregon and operated by Corrections.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-655.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9ac64483f8ab0b96","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule imposes a 6-month time limit on medical services following release, but the statute provides services 'for a period that the nature of the injury or the process of recovery requires' with no specific time limit.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-655.505","citation":"ORS 655.505(6)","quote":"\"Medical services\" means reasonable and necessary services prescribed by an attending practitioner for conditions resulting from injury for a period that the nature of the injury or the process of recovery requires.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-160-0100","citation":"OAR 125-160-0100(2)","quote":"After the release date, any medical services shall be payable for no more than the 6 months immediately following release.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-655.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fa82473c60d9745c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"The rule applicability is limited to DOC only, but the statute's definition of 'attending practitioner' includes both Department of Corrections and Oregon Youth Authority medical staff, suggesting coverage was intended for both.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-655.505","citation":"ORS 655.505(2)","quote":"\"Attending practitioner\" means Department of Corrections or Oregon Youth Authority medical staff, or specialists assisting Department of Corrections or Oregon Youth Authority medical staff, while the adult in custody is committed to the physical and legal custody of the Department of Corrections.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-160-0000","citation":"OAR 125-160-0000(2)","quote":"These rules apply to injuries to inmates in authorized work or training assignments of the Oregon Department of Corrections.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-655.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"abd4c9888240eba4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"}]},{"ors_chapter":"657","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":11,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 589-004-0550 applies the penalty provision from ORS 657.665(6) to officers and employees of community colleges and other state agencies, and to student records not maintained by the Employment Department, whereas ORS 657.665(6) explicitly limits penalties to 'Any officer appointed by or any employee of the Director of the Employment Department'.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-657.665","citation":"ORS 657.665(6)","quote":"Any officer appointed by or any employee of the Director of the Employment Department who discloses confidential information, except with the authority of the director, pursuant to rules or as otherwise required by law, may be disqualified from holding any appointment or employment with the Employment Department.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-004-0550","citation":"OAR 589-004-0550","quote":"Any officer or employee of OCCURS or of the Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development or of any other state agency who has access to personally identifiable student records maintained and/or provided by a community college who, without proper authority, shall disclose such information may be disqualified from holding any appointment or employment with the State of Oregon, in accordance with ORS 657.665(6).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-657.665","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0ad8f897a0b7a1cd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"659","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":30,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 715-011-0060 restricts the retaliation prohibition to only career schools, post-secondary education programs, and private colleges/universities, while ORS 659.852 defines 'education program' to include school districts, charter schools, education service districts, long-term care/treatment facilities, Youth Corrections Education Program, Oregon School for the Deaf, approved recovery schools, community colleges, public universities, career schools, private schools, and private colleges/universities.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659.852","citation":"ORS 659.852(1)(a)","quote":"\"Education program\" means an education program provided by: (A) A school district; (B) A public charter school; (C) An education service district; (D) A long term care or treatment facility, as described in ORS 343.961; (E) The Youth Corrections Education Program; (F) The Oregon School for the Deaf; (G) An approved recovery school, as defined in ORS 336.680; (H) A community college operated under ORS chapter 341; (I) A public university listed in ORS 352.002; (J) A career school; (K) A private school; or (L) A private college or university.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-011-0060","citation":"OAR 715-011-0060","quote":"A student of a career school, a post-secondary education program or a private college or university may not be subjected to retaliation for the reason that the student has in good faith reported information that the student believes is evidence of a violation of a state or federal law, rule or regulation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659.852","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0896cb9b00601ae3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"Rule 715-011-0010 declares implementation of ORS 659.860 (an enforcement/procedures statute) but its operative text provides only a general discrimination prohibition with no engagement whatsoever with any enforcement mechanism, filing requirement, deadline, damage provision, or other operative element of ORS 659.860.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-715-011-0010","citation":"OAR 715-011-0010, statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659.850, ORS 659.860","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659.860","citation":"ORS 659.860","quote":"Any person claiming to be aggrieved by unlawful discrimination as prohibited by ORS 659.850 may file a civil action in circuit court... The action authorized by this section shall be filed within one year of the filing of a grievance... An action may not be filed unless, within 180 days of the alleged discrimination, a grievance has been filed...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659.860","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"28d94825b499d4f9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 715-011-0005(3) and (7) define prohibited discrimination to include 'veterans' status,' which is not listed as a protected class in ORS 659.850(1).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659.850","citation":"ORS 659.850(1)(a)(A)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment, intended or unintended, or any act that is fair in form but discriminatory in operation, either of which is based on race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, age or disability.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-715-011-0005","citation":"OAR 715-011-0005(3)","quote":"Discrimination or discriminate is defined as any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment, intended or unintended, or any act that is fair in form but discriminatory in operation, either of which is based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, disability, veterans' status, sexual orientation, or marital status.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"16e1f2584c52e89a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0305(3) defines discrimination based on protected classes but omits 'gender identity,' which ORS 659.850(1) lists as a separate protected class.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659.850","citation":"ORS 659.850(1)(a)(A)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment, intended or unintended, or any act that is fair in form but discriminatory in operation, either of which is based on race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, age or disability.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0305","citation":"OAR 839-005-0305(3)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment, intended or unintended, or any act that is fair in form but discriminatory in operation, either of which is based on age, disability, national origin, race, color, marital status, religion, sex or sexual orientation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fdd959446220b5ef","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 581-022-2312(2)(a) and (4) define 'bias incidents' covered by the discrimination prohibition to include only perceived race, color, religion, gender identity, sexual orientation, disability, or national origin—omitting sex, marital status, and age, which ORS 659.850(1) protects.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659.850","citation":"ORS 659.850(1)(a)(A)","quote":"\"Discrimination\" means any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment, intended or unintended, or any act that is fair in form but discriminatory in operation, either of which is based on race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, age or disability.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-022-2312","citation":"OAR 581-022-2312(2)(a)","quote":"\"Bias Incident\" means a person's hostile expression of animus toward another person, relating to the other person's perceived race, color, religion, gender identity, sexual orientation, disability or national origin, of which criminal investigation or prosecution is impossible or inappropriate.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"efebf6899a30f110","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"}]},{"ors_chapter":"659a","run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","rules_reviewed":419,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 839-050-0030(6) excludes intervening aggrieved persons in housing cases from the definition of 'party' for service purposes, directly conflicting with OAR 839-050-0170(3) which states aggrieved persons 'may intervene and be joined as a party' in the same proceedings.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-050-0030","citation":"OAR 839-050-0030(6)","quote":"For the purpose of this rule, the term 'participant' or 'party' does not include an aggrieved person intervening in a proceeding involving a complaint alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-839-050-0170","citation":"OAR 839-050-0170(3)","quote":"An aggrieved person may intervene and be joined as a party in a proceeding in which the Agency has issued Formal Charges alleging violations of ORS 659A.145, 659A.421, or federal housing law.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.850","citation":"ORS 659A.850(1)(b)","quote":"An aggrieved person may intervene as a party in the proceeding.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6b4e807e9df67969","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 659A.049, which establishes that reinstatement rights cannot be forfeited if a worker refuses to return without physician or nurse practitioner release, but the operative text of the rule never addresses medical clearance, physician release, or the conditions under which reinstatement rights are forfeited.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-006-0115","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.100, ORS 659A.040, ORS 659A.043 - 659A.046, ORS 659A.049","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.049","citation":"ORS 659A.049","quote":"The rights of reinstatement afforded by ORS 659A.043 and 659A.046 shall not be forfeited if the worker refuses to return to the worker's regular or other offered employment without release to such employment by the worker's attending physician or a nurse practitioner authorized to provide compensable medical services under ORS 656.245.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.049","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6748b291854ca95e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare they implement ORS 659A.800-659A.890, but their operative text does not address ORS 659A.865 violations, which is the specific subject matter of ORS 659A.890.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-003-0020","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.800- 659A.890","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0235","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.800 - 659A.890","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.890","citation":"ORS 659A.890(1)","quote":"Any person aggrieved by a violation of ORS 659A.865 may bring a civil action in the manner provided by ORS 659A.885(3)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.890","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"56fa8d0cdb8c2e08","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-014-0600 defines 'reasonable access' as requiring a telephone to be located at the housing or within one-tenth of one mile, while OAR 839-014-0620 requires 'reasonable access' to be within a two-mile radius, creating conflicting distance thresholds for the same term in the same regulatory scheme.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-014-0600","citation":"OAR 839-014-0600(6)","quote":"\"Reasonable access\" means access to a telephone at any time the employee indicates that an emergency exists and that a telephone is needed to communicate with any person for the purpose of dealing with the emergency. A reasonably accessible telephone must be located at the housing or within one tenth of one mile from the housing.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-014-0620","citation":"OAR 839-014-0620(1)","quote":"When employees occupy housing that is owned or controlled by the employer, the employer shall ensure that employees occupying the housing have reasonable access to an operating telephone for the private use of the employees. The telephone must be located within a two mile radius of the farm worker housing as measured by the most direct route by road or foot path from the housing to the place where the telephone is located.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5123b64d2bddf74a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-020-0002 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses general PEBB plan effective dates and employee eligibility continuation for all employees, not specifically the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-020-0002","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060-069, ORS 743.600 - 602, ORS 743.707","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5429322d5d43f429","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-020-0020 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses newborn and adopted child enrollment for all PEBB-eligible employees, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation addressed by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-020-0020","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060-069, ORS 743.600-602, ORS 743.707","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"77c62eaa86d13533","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-020-0025 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses removal of ineligible individuals from PEBB benefit plans in general, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-020-0025","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060-069, ORS 743.600-602, ORS 743.707","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dd29d2b53dcb165c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-020-0040 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses late enrollment for all employees and family members, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-020-0040","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060-069, ORS 743.600-602, ORS 743.707","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"21c729cc935b8fea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-020-0050 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses midyear benefit plan changes for qualified status changes and cost or coverage changes in general, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-020-0050","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061 - 302, ORS 659A.060 - 069, ORS 743.600 - 602, ORS 743.707","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8b9e57cd79def7a9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-030-0005 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses COBRA continuation of coverage for employees losing employer group health coverage, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-030-0005","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060 - 069, ORS 743.600 - 602","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5ec82e7491f07a0e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-050-0005 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses retiree health plan eligibility, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-050-0005","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061 - 302, ORS 659A.060 - 659A.069","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"4e6634ef82a1387e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-101-050-0020 declares it implements ORS 659A.060-069, but its operative text addresses retiree survivor medical and dental insurance coverage, not the injured worker group health benefits continuation required by ORS 659A.060-069.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-101-050-0020","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 243.061-302, ORS 659A.060 - 659A.069","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.060","citation":"ORS 659A.060","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.060","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"367cf967dd21239b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board"]},{"summary":"The rule fails to implement the statutory requirement that employers post notices and provide written copies of employment protections to employees within specified timeframes and circumstances.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.147","citation":"ORS 659A.147(2)","quote":"An employer shall post signs that provide notice informing employees of the employment protections under this section, including the right to be free from discrimination because of pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions, and the right to reasonable accommodation under this section. The employer shall post the signs in a conspicuous and accessible location in or about the premises where employees work. In addition to posting the signs, the employer shall provide a written copy of the notice to: (A) A new employee, at the time of hire; (B) Existing employees, within 180 days after January 1, 2020; and (C) An employee who informs the employer of the employee's pregnancy, within 10 days after the employer receives the information.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.147","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a1b5436295c2782b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"The rule adds an exemption from deductions for serious health conditions that the statute does not explicitly provide.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.171","citation":"ORS 659A.171(6)","quote":"unless the employee fails to return to work because of circumstances beyond the control of the employee","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-001-0250","citation":"OAR 839-001-0250(2)","quote":"no deduction may be made if the employee fails to return to work for the following reasons: (a) The employee's absence from work is caused by a continuation, recurrence or onset of a serious health condition that would entitle the employee to family leave as provided for under OFLA or to benefits under ORS chapter 657B; or (b) The employee's absence from work is caused by circumstances beyond the control of the employee","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.171","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ecc351c84b71b7f4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-010-0010(5) drops nonprofit organization employees and board members from the definition of 'Employee' that ORS 659A.200(2) explicitly includes.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.200","citation":"ORS 659A.200(2)","quote":"\"Employee\" means a person: (a) Employed by or under contract with the state or any agency of or political subdivision in the state; (b) Employed by or under contract with any person authorized to act on behalf of the state, or agency of the state or subdivision in the state, with respect to control, management or supervision of any employee; (c) Employed by the public corporation created under ORS 656.751; (d) Employed by a contractor who performs services for the state, agency or subdivision, other than employees of a contractor under contract to construct a public improvement; (e) Employed by or under contract with any person authorized by contract to act on behalf of the state, agency or subdivision; (f) Employed by a nonprofit organization; or (g) Serving as a member of a board of directors of a nonprofit organization who is not otherwise considered an employee.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0010","citation":"OAR 839-010-0010(5)","quote":"\"Employee\" means a person: (a) Employed by or under contract with the state or any agency of or political subdivision in the state; (b) Employed by or under contract with any person authorized to act on behalf of the state, or agency of the state or subdivision in the state, with respect to control, management or supervision of any employee; (c) Employed by the public corporation created under ORS 656.751; (d) Employed by the public corporation established under ORS 741.001; (e) Employed by a contractor who performs services for the state, agency or subdivision, other than employees of a contractor under contract to construct a public improvement; and (f) Employed by or under contract with any person authorized by contract to act on behalf of the state, agency or subdivision.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"081138878d9aa8b8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-010-0010(3) removes 'discrimination' from the explicit examples of disciplinary action listed in ORS 659A.200(1).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.200","citation":"ORS 659A.200(1)","quote":"\"Disciplinary action\" includes but is not limited to any discrimination, dismissal, demotion, transfer, reassignment, supervisory reprimand, warning of possible dismissal or withholding of work, whether or not the action affects or will affect employee compensation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0010","citation":"OAR 839-010-0010(3)","quote":"\"Disciplinary action\" means any adverse action including dismissal, demotion, transfer, reassignment, supervisory reprimand, warning of possible dismissal, or withholding of work, whether or not the action affects or will affect employee compensation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"67432129b275ef81","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule (7) adds cease and desist orders as a remedy, but the statute ORS 659A.550(4) specifies only civil penalties under ORS 659A.855.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.550","citation":"ORS 659A.550(4)","quote":"An employer or employment agency that is found to have violated subsection (1) of this section by the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries shall be assessed a civil penalty as provided under ORS 659A.855.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0036","citation":"OAR 839-005-0036(7)","quote":"The commissioner may issue a cease and desist order under the provisions of ORS 659.885(3).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.550","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f7355bec941c863","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule declares a substantive guarantee of rights to employment, housing, public accommodation, and private schools, while the statute only states purposes and legislative intent to create education programs, remedies, and administrative machinery.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.003","citation":"ORS 659A.003","quote":"The purpose of this chapter is to encourage the fullest utilization of the available workforce by removing arbitrary standards...and to ensure the human dignity of all people...To accomplish this purpose, the Legislative Assembly intends by this chapter to provide: (1) A program of public education...  (2) An adequate remedy for persons aggrieved...  (3) An adequate administrative machinery...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0000","citation":"OAR 839-003-0000(1)","quote":"The policy of the State of Oregon guarantees all citizens of the state the right to employment, housing, access to places of public accommodation and private vocational, professional or trade schools without unlawful discrimination.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.003","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c2082df4ef6abc87","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-050-0080(3) cross-references ORS 659A.870(4)(b) for the election to have a matter heard in circuit court, but that provision is about back pay calculation; the election provision is at ORS 659A.870(5)(b).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-050-0080","citation":"OAR 839-050-0080(3)","quote":"unless an aggrieved person or respondent named in a complaint alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law elects to have the matter heard in circuit court under 659A.885 (see 659A.870(4)(b))","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-659a.870","citation":"ORS 659A.870(5)(b)","quote":"A respondent or complainant named in a complaint filed under ORS 659A.820 or ORS 659A.825 alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law may elect to have the matter heard in circuit court under ORS 659A.885.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.870","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a1a419c1d452035b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule omits statutory factors required to be considered when determining whether an accommodation imposes undue hardship, specifically the reference to school district obligations and the special undue hardship rules for school districts.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.033","citation":"ORS 659A.033(4)(f)","quote":"The degree to which an accommodation may constrain the obligation of a school district, education service district or public charter school to maintain a religiously neutral work environment.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.033","citation":"ORS 659A.033(5)","quote":"A reasonable accommodation imposes an undue hardship on the operation of the business of the employer for the purposes of this section if the accommodation would constrain the legal obligation of a school district, education service district or public charter school to: (a) Maintain religious neutrality in the school environment; or (b) Refrain from endorsing religion.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0140","citation":"OAR 839-005-0140(2)(a)","quote":"A reasonable accommodation imposes an undue hardship on the operation of the business of the employer for the purposes of this section if the accommodation requires significant difficulty or expense. For the purpose of determining whether an accommodation requires significant difficulty or expense, the following factors shall be considered: (A) The nature and the cost of the accommodation needed. (B) The overall financial resources of the facility or facilities involved in the provision of the accommodation, the number of persons employed at the facility and the effect on expenses and resources or other impacts on the operation of the facility caused by the accommodation. (C) The overall financial resources of the employer, the overall size of the business of the employer with respect to the number of persons employed by the employer and the number, type and location of the employer's facilities. (D) The type of business operations conducted by the employer, including the composition, structure and functions of the workforce of the employer and the geographic separateness and administrative or fiscal relationship of the facility or facilities of the employer. (E) The safety and health requirements in a facility, including requirements for the safety of other employees and any other person whose safety may be adversely impacted by the requested accommodation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.033","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"49c6d10b37f28e77","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule drops the phrase 'in accordance with the employee's sincerely held religious beliefs' from the statutory requirement that an occupational requirement restricts the ability to wear religious clothing.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.033","citation":"ORS 659A.033(3)(a)","quote":"The employer imposes an occupational requirement that restricts the ability of an employee to wear religious clothing in accordance with the employee's sincerely held religious beliefs, to take time off for a holy day or to take time off to participate in a religious observance or practice","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0140","citation":"OAR 839-005-0140(3)","quote":"An employer violates ORS 659A.030 if the employer imposes an occupational requirement that restricts the ability of an employee to wear religious clothing, to take time off for a holy day or to take time off to participate in a religious observance or practice when","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.033","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e36475b7453b48e1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rules 2 and 3 declare they implement ORS 659A.233, which applies to all employers, but the rules limit application only to public employers and public employees.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.233","citation":"ORS 659A.233","quote":"It is an unlawful employment practice for an employer to discharge, demote, suspend or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee with regard to promotion, compensation or other terms, conditions or privileges of employment for the reason that the employee has in good faith reported possible violations of ORS chapter 441 or of ORS 443.400 to 443.455 or has testified in good faith at an unemployment compensation hearing or other hearing conducted pursuant to ORS chapter 657.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0010","citation":"OAR 839-010-0010, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 659A.233, ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224, 2014 OL Ch. 78, Sec. 2","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0010","citation":"OAR 839-010-0010(2), (8)","quote":"\"Agency\" for the purposes of OAR 839-010-0010 to 839-010-0060 refers to the state or any agency of or political subdivision in the state... \"Public employer\" means: (a) The state or any agency of or political subdivision in the state","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0020","citation":"OAR 839-010-0020, declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 659A.233, ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0020","citation":"OAR 839-010-0020(1)","quote":"Oregon public employee whistleblower statutes prohibit public employers from taking action against or prohibiting employees from","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.233","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d6d7b68d03650082","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule explicitly includes public bodies as employers with extensive specification, while the statute uses only the general term 'any person' without such enumeration.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.001","citation":"ORS 659A.001(4)(a)","quote":"\"Employer\" means any person who in this state, directly or through an agent, engages or uses the personal service of one or more employees, reserving the right to control the means by which such service is or will be performed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0003","citation":"OAR 839-005-0003(5)","quote":"Employer also includes any public body that, directly or through an agent, engages or utilizes the personal service of one or more employees, reserving the right to control the means by which such service is or will be performed, including all officers, agencies, departments, divisions, bureaus, boards and commissions of the legislative, judicial and administrative branches of the state, all county and city governing bodies, school districts, special districts, municipal corporations and all other political subdivisions of the state.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.001","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc58ed025680d979","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a conditional age exception (26 years or older) to the statutory exclusion of those employed by parents in domestic service, narrowing which individuals are excluded from the definition of employee.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.001","citation":"ORS 659A.001(3)","quote":"\"Employee\" does not include any individual employed by the individual's parents, spouse or child or in the domestic service of any person.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0003","citation":"OAR 839-005-0003(4)(b)","quote":"Any individual employed by that individual's parents, unless the individual is in the domestic service of their parent and is 26 years or older.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.001","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"abcb16edcf34c33b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-006-0136 adds two grounds for losing reemployment rights—discharge for bona fide non-injury-related reasons and abandonment—that ORS 659A.046(3) does not enumerate.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.046","citation":"ORS 659A.046(3)","quote":"Notwithstanding subsection (1) of this section, the right to reemployment under this section terminates when whichever of the following events first occurs: (a) The worker cannot return to reemployment at any position with the employer either by determination of the attending physician or a nurse practitioner authorized to provide compensable medical services under ORS 656.245 or upon appeal of that determination, by determination of a medical arbiter or panel of medical arbiters pursuant to ORS chapter 656. (b) The worker is eligible and participates in vocational assistance under ORS 656.340. (c) The worker accepts suitable employment with another employer after becoming medically stationary. (d) The worker refuses a bona fide offer from the employer of light duty or modified employment that is suitable prior to becoming medically stationary. (e) Seven days elapse from the date that the worker is notified by the insurer or self-insured employer by certified mail that the worker's attending physician or a nurse practitioner authorized to provide compensable medical services under ORS 656.245 has released the worker for reemployment unless the worker requests reemployment within that time period. (f) Three years elapse from the date of injury.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0136","citation":"OAR 839-006-0136(7)–(8)","quote":"(7) The worker is discharged for bona fide reasons not connected with the injury and for which others are or would be discharged; or (8) The worker clearly and unequivocally abandons employment with the employer.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.046","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"273e1d630036bec1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rules omit 'bias' from the definition of covered employer and eligible employee, even though the statute explicitly includes 'bias' alongside domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, and stalking.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.270","citation":"ORS 659A.270(1)","quote":"\"Covered employer\" means an employer who employs six or more individuals in the State of Oregon for each working day during each of 20 or more calendar workweeks in the year in which an eligible employee takes leave to address domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0340","citation":"OAR 839-009-0340(1)","quote":"\"Covered employer\" means an employer who employs 6 or more individuals in the state of Oregon for each working day during each of 20 or more calendar workweeks in the year in which an eligible employee takes leave under ORS 659A.270 to 659A.285 for victims of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.270","citation":"ORS 659A.270(2)","quote":"\"Eligible employee\" means an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking or is the parent or guardian of a minor child or dependent who is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0340","citation":"OAR 839-009-0340(2)","quote":"\"Eligible employee\" means an employee who is employed in the state of Oregon on the date leave begins under ORS 659A.270 to 659A.285 for victims of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking and is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"34a65c8984486b53","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-009-0362(4) cites to OAR 839-009-0340(14), (15), (16) and (17) for victim type definitions, but those subsection numbers do not contain victim type definitions; the actual victim type definitions are in subsections (8), (9), (11) and (12).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-009-0362","citation":"OAR 839-009-0362(4)","quote":"The covered employer may require the eligible employee to provide certification that: (a) The eligible employee or the eligible employee's minor child or dependent is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking as defined in OAR 839-009-0340(14), (15), (16) and (17)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0340","citation":"OAR 839-009-0340(13)-(14)","quote":"\"Victim\" includes any other person who has suffered financial, social, psychological or physical harm as a result of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking committed against a victim as defined in subsections (8), (9), (11), and (12), including a member of the victim's immediate family as defined in this rule. In no event will an alleged perpetrator of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, or stalking be considered a victim for the purposes of these rules.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.270","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"93d293f6e680285f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-010-0100(2) extends protection to situations where the employer merely believes the employee engaged in protected activity, adding language not present in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-010-0100","citation":"OAR 839-010-0100(2)","quote":"ORS 659A.230 prohibits any employer with one or more employees in Oregon from discriminating or retaliating against an employee because the employee has in good faith, or the employer believes the employee has: (a) Reported to any person...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.230","citation":"ORS 659A.230(1)","quote":"It is an unlawful employment practice for an employer to discharge, demote, suspend or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee with regard to promotion, compensation or other terms, conditions or privileges of employment for the reason that the employee has in good faith reported criminal activity by any person...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.230","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb5590e729ec5786","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-010-0100(2)(b) protects reporting of activities the employee believed to be criminal, whereas the statute protects only reporting of actual criminal activity.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-010-0100","citation":"OAR 839-010-0100(2)(b)","quote":"Reported to any person, orally or in writing, any activity the employee believed to be criminal","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.230","citation":"ORS 659A.230(1)","quote":"the employee has in good faith reported criminal activity by any person","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.230","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fdcd975dc8649183","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-010-0140(3) extends protection based on the employer's belief that the employee engaged in protected civil proceedings activity, not limited to actual engagement as the statute requires.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-010-0140","citation":"OAR 839-010-0140(3)","quote":"The employer believes that the employee has engaged in the civil proceedings acts described above.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.230","citation":"ORS 659A.230(1)","quote":"has in good faith brought a civil proceeding against an employer or has testified in good faith at a civil proceeding or criminal trial","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.230","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f53d394acdc23b47","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-839-006-0280 declares it implements ORS 659A.104, but its operative text never engages with ORS 659A.104 at all—the rule defines state government, executive department, judicial department, and legislative department, while the statute defines disability, major life activities, substantially limits, and related terms.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-006-0280","citation":"oar-839-006-0280, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.103, ORS 659A.104, ORS 659A.106, ORS 659A.109, ORS 659A.139, ORS 659A.142","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.104","citation":"ORS 659A.104","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.104","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8c7f603796b62e7f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule at subsection (9) contains a cross-reference error: it references subsections (5) and (7), but based on the rule's renumbering of the statute, it should reference subsections (8) and (10) to maintain consistency with the statute's intent.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.143","citation":"ORS 659A.143(7)","quote":"For purposes of this subsection, except as provided in subsections (6) and (8) of this section, in addition to any other applicable accommodation requirement, allowing the presence of the assistance animal is a reasonable modification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0345","citation":"OAR 839-006-0345(9)","quote":"For purposes of this subsection, except as provided in subsections (5) and (7) of this section, in addition to any other applicable accommodation requirement, allowing the presence of the assistance animal is a reasonable modification.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.143","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1fd5be974fb2ba3a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule applies the lift system requirement to all transient lodging facilities with 175+ rooms, but the statute limits it only to those facilities that are newly constructed or altered in a manner affecting usability.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.144","citation":"ORS 659A.144(5)(a)","quote":"The requirements of this section apply only to transient lodging facilities that: (A) Consist of 175 or more rooms or suites of rooms; and (B) Are newly constructed or that are altered in a manner that affects or could affect the usability of the facility in a manner that requires the facility to be in compliance with the accessibility standards established by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0350","citation":"OAR 839-006-0350(1)","quote":"A transient lodging provider shall ensure that in transient lodging facilities of 175 or more rooms or suite of rooms that at least one room or suite of rooms has a lift system or multiple lift systems that enable an individual with a disability to access a bed, a toilet, and a shower or bathtub in the room or suite of rooms occupied by the individual with a disability.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.144","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4da0e94922b123ff","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-009-0220(2) allows employers discretion to apply whichever OFLA or FMLA provision is 'more beneficial,' whereas the statute mandates that when leave qualifies under both, it must be taken concurrently and not in addition.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.186","citation":"ORS 659A.186(2)","quote":"If family leave taken under ORS 659A.150 to 659A.186 qualifies as protected leave pursuant to the federal Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (P.L. 103-3), family leave taken under ORS 659A.150 to 659A.186 must be taken concurrently with, and not in addition to, any leave taken under the federal Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (P.L. 103-3).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0220","citation":"OAR 839-009-0220(2)","quote":"employers subject to both OFLA and FMLA must apply in a given leave situation the provision that is more beneficial to the employee's circumstances","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.186","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"08a8ddaf8f30e0a1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0075(3)(b) omits several entities from the statutory list of employers from which peace officers can be commissioned.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.320","citation":"ORS 659A.320(2)(c)(B)","quote":"Employed as a peace officer commissioned by a city, port, school district, mass transit district, county, university under ORS 352.121 or 353.125, Indian reservation, the Superintendent of State Police under ORS 181A.340, the Criminal Justice Division of the Department of Justice, the Oregon State Lottery Commission or the Governor or employed as a regulatory specialist by the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0075","citation":"OAR 839-005-0075(3)(b)","quote":"A peace officer commissioned by a city, port, school district, mass transit district, county, Indian reservation, or the Criminal Justice Division of the Department of Justice, the Oregon State Lottery Commission, the Governor","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"94dd2cc67838f5f1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0070(2) adds an adverse impact discrimination standard that does not appear in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.320","citation":"ORS 659A.320(1)","quote":"it is an unlawful employment practice for an employer to obtain or use for employment purposes information contained in the credit history of an applicant for employment or an employee, or to refuse to hire, discharge, demote, suspend, retaliate or otherwise discriminate against an applicant or an employee with regard to promotion, compensation or the terms, conditions or privileges of employment based on information in the credit history","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0070","citation":"OAR 839-005-0070(2)","quote":"Obtainment or use of credit history information may not be conducted in a manner that results in adverse impact discrimination as prohibited by 42 U.S.C. §2000e-2, ORS 659A.030 and OAR 839-005-0010. A finding of adverse impact discrimination does not require establishment of intentional discrimination.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.320","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4d151ab36062700f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The statute authorizes the Attorney General and Commissioner to file housing discrimination complaints under 659A.825(1)(c), but the rule states 'This section does not apply to housing discrimination complaints,' excluding them from its scope while declaring to implement that statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.825","citation":"ORS 659A.825(1)(c)","quote":"If the Attorney General or the commissioner has reason to believe that an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law has occurred or is about to occur, the Attorney General or the commissioner may file a complaint in the same manner as a person filing a complaint under ORS 659A.820.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-839-003-0010","citation":"OAR 839-003-0010(1)","quote":"This section does not apply to housing discrimination complaints under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or the federal Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601 – 3614a). Complaints of housing discrimination must be filed in accordance with OAR 839-003-0200.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.825","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"40c6bfeacc5c2010","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule fails to implement the statutory requirement that state agencies include information concerning awards of construction, service, and personal service contracts to minority businesses in their affirmative action reports.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.015","citation":"ORS 659A.015","quote":"every state agency shall include in its affirmative action reports under ORS 659A.012 information concerning its awards of construction, service and personal service contracts awarded to minority businesses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-105-040-0001","citation":"OAR 105-040-0001(1)(b)(B)","quote":"Produce periodic reports showing Oregon State Government's progress toward achieving established affirmative action objectives identified by the Chief Human Resources Office at DAS and the Governor's Office of Diversity and Inclusion","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.015","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b6560826c59e1efe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"The rule fails to explicitly require that evaluation of management personnel include effectiveness in achieving affirmative action objectives as a key consideration, as mandated by the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.012","citation":"ORS 659A.012(1)","quote":"every state agency shall be required to include in the evaluation of all management personnel the manager's or supervisor's effectiveness in achieving affirmative action objectives as a key consideration of the manager's or supervisor's performance","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-105-040-0001","citation":"OAR 105-040-0001(2)","quote":"Employment related decisions include, but are not limited to: (a) Hiring, (b) Promotion, (c) Demotion, (d) Transfer, (e) Termination, (f) Layoff, (g) Training, (h) Compensation, (i) Benefits, and (j) Performance evaluations","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.012","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a415901ec9060d45","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office"]},{"summary":"Rules extend statutory protection for testimony to include workers 'about to give testimony' and those 'perceived as having testified,' beyond the statute's protection for those who have 'given testimony'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.040","citation":"ORS 659A.040(3)","quote":"Given testimony under the provisions of ORS chapter 656","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0100","citation":"OAR 839-006-0100(2)","quote":"An employer may not discriminate against workers who have testified, are about to give testimony, or who are perceived as having testified in connection with Oregon Workers' Compensation procedures","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0115","citation":"OAR 839-006-0115(1)","quote":"the worker has applied for benefits or invoked or utilized the procedures provided for in ORS Chapter 656 or 659A.040 to 659A.052 or has given testimony, is about to give testimony or is perceived as having testified under the provisions of such sections","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0117","citation":"OAR 839-006-0117(1)(b)","quote":"Discriminating against a person who has testified, is about to give testimony, or who is perceived as having testified in connection with Oregon Worker's Compensation procedures or civil procedures","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.040","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9144e33a821e2da9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule states as a general principle that an unlawful compensation practice occurs each time remuneration is paid, but the statute limits this principle specifically to time limitation purposes.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.875","citation":"ORS 659A.875(7)","quote":"For the purpose of time limitations, a compensation practice that is unlawful under ORS 652.220 occurs each time compensation is paid under a discriminatory compensation decision or other practice.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-008-0035","citation":"839-008-0035","quote":"An employer commits an unlawful compensation practice each time an employee is remunerated in violation of ORS 652.220.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.875","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d84a7ae1c11c8a8f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-009-0240(6)(c) allows employers to reduce OFLA leave after an employee refuses a suitable offer under ORS 659A.043(3)(a)(D), but the statute mandates automatic commencement of family leave upon such refusal without reduction.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.043","citation":"ORS 659A.043(4)","quote":"a worker who refuses an offer of employment under subsection (3)(a)(D) of this section and who otherwise is entitled to family leave under ORS 659A.150 to 659A.186: (a) Automatically commences a period of family leave under ORS 659A.150 to 659A.186 upon refusing the offer of employment","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0240","citation":"OAR 839-009-0240(6)(c)","quote":"Notwithstanding this rule, the employer may reduce the amount of OFLA leave available to an eligible employee under this section by any period the employee is unable to work because of a disabling compensable injury as defined in ORS 656.005 after the employee has refused a suitable offer of light duty or modified employment under ORS 659A.043 (3)(a)(D) or 659A.046(3)(d).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.043","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b5b592ef1823cf58","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rules cite ORS 192.410 to 192.505 for confidentiality of settlement discussions when implementing a statute that cites ORS 192.311 to 192.478 for the same prohibition.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.840","citation":"ORS 659A.840(6)","quote":"Nothing said or done in the course of settlement discussions concerning a complaint alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law may be disclosed in any manner, including but not limited to disclosure under ORS 192.311 to 192.478","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0225","citation":"OAR 839-003-0225(2)","quote":"Nothing said or done in the course of settlement discussions concerning a complaint alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or 659A.421 or discrimination under the federal Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601 – 3614a) may be disclosed under ORS 192.410 to 192.505 (the Oregon Public Records Act)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-051-0010","citation":"OAR 839-051-0010(11)","quote":"Nothing said or done in the course of settlement discussions concerning a complaint alleging an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or 659A.421 or discrimination under federal housing law may be disclosed in any manner, including but not limited to disclosure under 192.410 to 192.505","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.840","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f1e58be97c847ab","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-005-0125 declares implementation of ORS 659A.030(1)(f), which concerns age disclosure in employment applications, but the rule's operative text addresses retaliation for protected activity, which is the subject of ORS 659A.030(1)(g).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-005-0125","citation":"OAR 839-005-0125(1)","quote":"This rule interprets ORS 659A.030(1)(f).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0125","citation":"OAR 839-005-0125, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.001(9), ORS 659A.030(1)(f)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.030","citation":"ORS 659A.030(1)(f)","quote":"For an employer, prospective employer or employment agency, prior to completing an initial interview, or if there is no initial interview, prior to making a conditional offer of employment, to request or require disclosure of the applicant's age or date of birth or when the applicant attended or graduated from any educational institution, except when such information is required to: (A) Affirm that the applicant meets bona fide occupational qualifications; or (B) Comply with any provision of federal, state or local law, rule or regulation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.030","citation":"ORS 659A.030(1)(g)","quote":"For any person to discharge, expel or otherwise discriminate against any other person because that other person has opposed any unlawful practice, or because that other person has filed a complaint, testified or assisted in any proceeding under this chapter or has attempted to do so.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.030","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"37b4a380fbfeeb8d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-003-0245(1) allows the commissioner to file a complaint based on \"reason to believe,\" but ORS 659A.885(9) requires \"reasonable cause to believe\" and explicitly requires proof of \"a pattern or practice of resistance\" or that \"a group of persons has been denied\" (past/present), not future potential denial.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.885","citation":"ORS 659A.885(9)","quote":"When the commissioner or the Attorney General has reasonable cause to believe that a person or group of persons is engaged in a pattern or practice of resistance to the rights protected by ORS 659A.145 or 659A.421 or federal housing law, or that a group of persons has been denied any of the rights protected by ORS 659A.145 or 659A.421 or federal housing law, the commissioner or the Attorney General may file a civil action on behalf of the aggrieved persons","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0245","citation":"OAR 839-003-0245(1)","quote":"The commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries may make, sign and file a complaint whenever the commissioner has reason to believe that any person or group of persons has been denied rights or is about to be denied rights due to an unlawful practice under ORS 659A.145 or ORS 659A.421 or the federal Fair Housing Act","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.885","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aa2b634a010c9ba8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-006-0280 declares it implements ORS 659A.139 (a statute about constructing disability discrimination provisions in favor of broad coverage and consistency with federal ADA) but its operative text defines state government, executive department, judicial department, and legislative department—subjects that do not engage with ORS 659A.139's construction principle at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-006-0280","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 659A.103, ORS 659A.104, ORS 659A.106, ORS 659A.109, ORS 659A.139, ORS 659A.142","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.139","citation":"ORS 659A.139(1) and (2)","quote":"ORS 659A.103 to 659A.144 shall be construed to the extent possible in a manner that is consistent with any similar provisions of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990... The determination of whether an individual has a disability as provided in ORS 659A.104(1) shall be construed in favor of broad coverage of individuals under ORS 659A.103 to 659A.145","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.139","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b62522acfcd7c661","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-014-0620 establishes a commissioner-based dispute resolution process for telephone access terms, while ORS 659A.262 establishes only a judicial process (magistrate/court) for disputes about access to housing.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-014-0620","citation":"OAR 839-014-0620(3)-(4)","quote":"If a dispute arises regarding the terms of access established by the employer, the or the court if a private action has been filed, shall determine whether the terms of access to the telephone are reasonable. In making a determination, the commissioner will consider: (a) Any circumstances presented by the employer in support of the employer's position; (b) Any circumstances presented by the employee in support of the employee's position; (c) The number of employees occupying the housing; (d) The location of the housing; (e) Any other relevant information.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-659a.262","citation":"ORS 659A.262(6)-(8)","quote":"Any person subject to an order referred to in subsections (1) to (5) of this section may request that the order be vacated or modified by filing a written motion with the court which issued the order. Upon receipt of a motion to modify or vacate the order, the court shall schedule a hearing. If after the hearing, the court determines that the applicant is not entitled to access, the court shall vacate or modify the order.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.262","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e2a8daf2ed742877","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule adds age limits for children in certain leave contexts that the statute's family member definition does not contain.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.150","citation":"ORS 659A.150(4)(b)","quote":"A child of an eligible employee or the child's spouse or domestic partner","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0210","citation":"OAR 839-009-0210(3)","quote":"For purposes of child placement leave and sick child leave only, the child must be: (a) Under the age of 18; or (b) An adult dependent child substantially limited by a physical or mental impairment","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f7709ae1aa308ea2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule's catch-all for family members by affinity does not include blood-related individuals meeting the statute's equivalent-family-relationship test.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.150","citation":"ORS 659A.150(4)(h)","quote":"Any individual related by blood or affinity whose close association with an eligible employee is the equivalent of a family relationship","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0210","citation":"OAR 839-009-0210(8)","quote":"\"Family member\" means an individual related to an eligible employee by affinity or an individual who is an eligible employee's: (a) Spouse or domestic partner; (b) Child or the child's spouse or domestic partner; (c) Parent or the parent's spouse or domestic partner; (d) Sibling or stepsibling or the sibling's or stepsibling's spouse or domestic partner; (e) Grandparent or the grandparent's spouse or domestic partner; or (f) Grandchild or the grandchild's spouse or domestic partner","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e4183293a7a02386","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule adds an exception allowing compensable injury leave to count as OFLA leave under certain circumstances, contradicting the statute's absolute exclusion.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.150","citation":"ORS 659A.150(3)","quote":"\"Family leave\" does not include leave taken by an eligible employee who is unable to work because of a disabling compensable injury, as defined in ORS 656.005, under ORS chapter 656","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0210","citation":"OAR 839-009-0210(19)(b)","quote":"\"OFLA leave\" does not include leave taken by an eligible employee who is unable to work because of a disabling compensable injury, as defined in ORS 656.005, unless the leave qualifies as OFLA leave to which the employee is otherwise entitled and the employee refuses a bona fide offer from the employer of light duty or modified employment that is suitable prior to becoming medically stationary under ORS 659A.043 or 659A.046","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e594f67c6b18eab5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-014-0610 omits the statutory requirement for a telephone located within two miles for employee private use, implementing only the emergency access requirement.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.253","citation":"ORS 659A.253(3)(a)","quote":"The employer shall ensure to the employees residing in housing owned or controlled by an employer and occupied by employees the availability of: (A) A reasonably accessible operating telephone, whether pay or private, available 24 hours a day for emergency use; and (B) An operating telephone, whether pay or private, located within two miles of the housing, accessible and available so as to provide reasonable opportunity for private use by employees.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-014-0610","citation":"OAR 839-014-0610(1)","quote":"When employees occupy farmworker housing that is owned or controlled by the employer, the employer shall ensure that employees occupying the housing have reasonable access to an operating telephone at any time for emergency use.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.253","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6b8e0b6ee8051768","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-005-0026(2) conditions the prohibition on pregnancy benefits discrimination to situations 'when employee and dependent spouse or domestic partner benefits exist for other medical conditions,' but the statute requires equal treatment without this conditional limitation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.029","citation":"ORS 659A.029","quote":"An individual affected by the individual's pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions or occurrences shall be treated the same for all employment-related purposes, including receipt of benefits under fringe benefit programs, as any other person not so affected but similar in ability or inability to work by reason of physical condition","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0026","citation":"OAR 839-005-0026(2)","quote":"ORS 659A prohibits discrimination regarding employee and dependent spouse or domestic partner benefits for pregnancy when employee and dependent spouse or domestic partner benefits exist for other medical conditions.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.029","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d50a00413fe5cb3e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rules declare implementation of ORS 659A.200 - ORS 659A.224, but the operative text of each rule never engages with ORS 659A.224 itself, which is only a short title provision stating the range 'shall be known as the Whistleblower Law.' The rules cite and implement only other statutes within that range (e.g., ORS 659A.203, 659A.206, 659A.212).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-010-0010","citation":"oar-839-010-0010","quote":"ORS 659A.233, ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224, 2014 OL Ch. 78, Sec. 2","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0020","citation":"oar-839-010-0020","quote":"ORS 659A.233, ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0040","citation":"oar-839-010-0040","quote":"ORS 659A.200 - ORS 659A.224","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0050","citation":"oar-839-010-0050","quote":"ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-010-0060","citation":"oar-839-010-0060","quote":"ORS 659A.200 - 659A.224","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.224","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6f8fa50375d44bcc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-003-0010(4) authorizes the commissioner and attorney general to file complaints on their own initiative, but ORS 659A.820(2) limits filing to 'any person claiming to be aggrieved' and does not authorize enforcement-initiated complaints.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-003-0010","citation":"OAR 839-003-0010(4)","quote":"The commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries or attorney general of the State of Oregon may file a complaint whenever there is reason to believe that a person has committed unlawful practices.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.820","citation":"ORS 659A.820(2)","quote":"Any person claiming to be aggrieved by an unlawful practice may file with the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries a verified written complaint that states the name and address of the person alleged to have committed the unlawful practice.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.820","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aa0dc3f265839527","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-003-0040(3) prohibits adding new facts when amending employment complaints, but OAR 839-003-0205(1) explicitly allows adding new factual allegations when amending housing discrimination complaints, with both rules claiming to implement ORS 659A.820.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-003-0040","citation":"OAR 839-003-0040(3)","quote":"A complaint may be amended to add a protected class only if the addition is supported by facts already alleged. New facts may not be added.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0205","citation":"OAR 839-003-0205(1)","quote":"The division may amend a complaint to correct technical defects, to add additional persons as respondents and to add additional information found during the investigation of a complaint, including new factual allegations.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.820","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e2700ac6c6c6ea7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-020-0051 section (4) requires all employers to provide reasonable accommodation for expression of milk limitations, but ORS 659A.148 limits the requirements of ORS 659A.147 to employers with six or more employees.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.148","citation":"ORS 659A.148","quote":"The requirements of ORS 659A.147 apply only to employers who employ six or more persons.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-020-0051","citation":"OAR 839-020-0051(4)","quote":"An employer is required provide a reasonable accommodation to an employee's or applicant's limitations related to the expression of milk in accordance with ORS 659A.146 to ORS 659A.148.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.148","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"885be59838e93c29","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-006-0345 applies its rules to 'a place of public accommodation or of access to state government services, programs or activities,' but ORS 659A.400 defines only 'place of public accommodation' (which includes public body services to the public, but not all state government access).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.400","citation":"ORS 659A.400(1)","quote":"A place of public accommodation, subject to the exclusions in subsection (2) of this section, means: (a) Any place or service offering to the public accommodations, advantages, facilities or privileges whether in the nature of goods, services, lodgings, amusements, transportation or otherwise. (b) Any place that is open to the public and owned or maintained by a public body, as defined in ORS 174.109, regardless of whether the place is commercial in nature. (c) Any service to the public that is provided by a public body, as defined in ORS 174.109, regardless of whether the service is commercial in nature.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0345","citation":"OAR 839-006-0345(4)","quote":"A place of public accommodation or of access to state government services, programs or activities may not:","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0345","citation":"OAR 839-006-0345(8)","quote":"a place of public accommodation or of access to state government services, programs or activities may not deny a person with a disability or an assistance animal trainer the right to be accompanied by an assistance animal or assistance animal trainee","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.400","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"666512e90037d16e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule 839-009-0363(2) conditions the right to use accrued paid leave on taking leave pursuant to an agreement, CBA, or employer policy, whereas the statute allows any eligible employee taking leave to use accrued paid leave without such a condition.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.285","citation":"ORS 659A.285(2)","quote":"An eligible employee who takes leave pursuant to ORS 659A.272 may use any paid accrued vacation leave, any accrued sick leave or personal business leave, or any other paid leave that is offered by the covered employer in lieu of vacation leave during the period of leave.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-009-0363","citation":"OAR 839-009-0363(2)","quote":"An eligible employee taking leave pursuant to an agreement between the eligible employee and the covered employer, a collective bargaining agreement or a covered employer policy may use any paid accrued vacation leave or may use any other paid leave that is offered by the covered employer in lieu of vacation leave during the period of leave.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.285","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5042812ed8fed33c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Both rules declare they implement ORS 659A.106, but their operative text never engages with ORS 659A.106's actual subject matter: the six-or-more-employee threshold and the Oregon National Guard exception.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-006-0275","citation":"OAR 839-006-0275","quote":"ORS 659A.103, 659A.104, 659A.106, 659A.109, 659A.139 & 659A.142","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0280","citation":"OAR 839-006-0280","quote":"ORS 659A.103, 659A.104, 659A.106, 659A.109, 659A.139 & 659A.142","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.106","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"848142d9c0ea5ed8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The statute imposes a mandatory duty on employees to report (\"shall promptly and without delay\"), but the rule makes the Department's provision of information discretionary (\"may provide\" and \"may give\") rather than mandatory.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.212","citation":"ORS 659A.212(2)","quote":"the employee shall promptly and without delay report to the employee's immediate supervisor or a person designated by the agency by rule to receive such report.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-005-0015","citation":"OAR 411-005-0015(1)","quote":"The Department may provide client information only to a law enforcement officer in any of the following situations:","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-005-0015","citation":"OAR 411-005-0015(2)","quote":"The Department may give a client's current address, Social Security number, and photo to a law enforcement officer...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.212","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"64831f8ebb4673fe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"The rules omit 'bias' as a protected category from the unlawful employment practices that the statute explicitly includes in ORS 659A.290(2)(a), (b), and (c), and from the certification requirements in OAR 839-005-0170(4).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.290","citation":"ORS 659A.290(2)(a)","quote":"Refuse to hire an otherwise qualified individual because the individual is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.290","citation":"ORS 659A.290(2)(b)","quote":"Discharge, threaten to discharge, demote, suspend or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an individual with regard to promotion, compensation or other terms, conditions or privileges of employment because the individual is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.290","citation":"ORS 659A.290(2)(c)","quote":"Refuse to make a reasonable safety accommodation requested by an individual who is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, bias or stalking","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0160","citation":"OAR 839-005-0160(1)","quote":"ORS 659A.290 provides that it is an unlawful practice for an employer, because an individual is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking to: (a) Refuse to hire an otherwise qualified individual; (b) Discharge, threaten to discharge, demote, suspend or in any way discriminate or retaliate against an individual with respect to promotion, compensation or any other terms, conditions or privileges of employment; or to (c) Refuse to make a reasonable safety accommodation requested by an individual who is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault or stalking","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0170","citation":"OAR 839-005-0170(4)","quote":"Prior to making a reasonable safety accommodation, an employer may require an individual to provide certification that the individual is a victim of domestic violence, harassment, sexual assault, or stalking","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.290","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b159ed01140781bc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule section (1)(e) omits subsection (A) from the statute's list of protected refusals, removing protection against penalization for refusing to establish or maintain a personal social media account.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.330","citation":"ORS 659A.330(1)(e)","quote":"Take, or threaten to take, any action to discharge, discipline or otherwise penalize an employee for the employee's refusal to: (A) Establish or maintain a personal social media account; (B) Disclose, or provide access through, the employee's user name and password, password or other means of authentication that is associated with a personal social media account; (C) Add the employer to the employee's list of contacts associated with a social media website; or (D) Access a personal social media account as described in paragraph (d) of this subsection","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0400","citation":"OAR 839-005-0400(1)(e)","quote":"Take, or threaten to take, any action to discharge, discipline or otherwise penalize an employee for the employee's refusal to disclose, or to provide access through, the employee's user name and password, password or other means of authentication that is associated with a personal social media account, to add the employer to the employee's list of contacts associated with a social media website or to access a personal social media account as described in subsection (7)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"889530308f15cd31","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule section (1)(f) omits subsection (A) from the statute's list of protected refusals, removing protection against hiring decisions based on refusal to establish or maintain a personal social media account.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.330","citation":"ORS 659A.330(1)(f)","quote":"Fail or refuse to hire an applicant for employment because the applicant refused to: (A) Establish or maintain a personal social media account; (B) Disclose, or provide access through, the applicant's user name and password, password or other means of authentication that is associated with a personal social media account; (C) Add the employer to the applicant's list of contacts associated with a social media website; or (D) Access a personal social media account as described in paragraph (d) of this subsection","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0400","citation":"OAR 839-005-0400(1)(f)","quote":"Fail or refuse to hire an applicant for employment because the applicant refused to disclose, or to provide access through, the applicant's user name and password, password or other means of authentication that is associated with a personal social media account, to add the employer to the applicant's list of contacts associated with a social media website or to access a personal social media account as described in subsection (7)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f7ebddcdfc41d2d2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"Rule omits the law enforcement unit exception found in the statute.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.330","citation":"ORS 659A.330(7)","quote":"This section does not apply to an employer that is a law enforcement unit as defined in ORS 181A.355","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a889748cce928a1d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"The rule cites 'ORS 408.240 to 408.240' where the statute requires 'ORS 408.240 to 408.280 and 408.290', removing the range up to 408.280.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.082","citation":"ORS 659A.082(2)(a)","quote":"If the employer is a public body, denying a public officer or public employee the status or rights provided by ORS 408.240 to 408.280 and 408.290","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-006-0480","citation":"OAR 839-006-0480(2)(a)","quote":"Denying a public officer or public employee the status or rights provided by ORS 408.240 to 408.240 and 408.290, if the employer is a public body","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.082","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"da033bfdd23ac46c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"The rule does not implement ORS 659A.082(5), which provides specific exclusions from durational limits for voluntary service overseas and voluntary service within the United States during or in response to an emergency or disaster.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.082","citation":"ORS 659A.082(5)","quote":"the cumulative period of time for which an employee is absent from a position of employment with an employer for purposes of any of the following types of service in the uniformed service shall be excluded from the calculation of any durational limit on the eligibility for reemployment rights: (a) Voluntary service overseas; and (b) Voluntary service within the United States during or in response to an emergency or disaster declared by local, state or federal government","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.082","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a85311c2691fbe7e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0220(7) narrows the statute's protection by specifying only HIV/AIDS instead of the broader category of blood-borne infections.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.145","citation":"ORS 659A.145(10)","quote":"In the sale, lease or rental of real property, a person may not disclose to any person that an occupant or owner of the real property has or died from a blood-borne infection.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0220","citation":"OAR 839-005-0220(7)","quote":"In the sale, lease or rental of real estate, a person may not disclose to any person that an occupant or owner of real property has or died from human immunodeficiency virus or acquired immune deficiency syndrome.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2d0d03f444bbe09b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-006-0206 declares it implements ORS 659A.145, which addresses housing discrimination in real property transactions, but the operative text of the rule covers only employment-based reasonable accommodations and never engages with housing at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-839-006-0206","citation":"OAR 839-006-0206, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 659A.103 - 659A.145","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-659a.145","citation":"ORS 659A.145","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb325a78d4b4bb5a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-003-0215(5) bars issuing a finding of substantial evidence after a civil action trial commences, but ORS 659A.835(4) requires issuing a finding whenever substantial evidence is disclosed, without any exception for civil actions.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.835","citation":"ORS 659A.835(4)","quote":"If an investigation under this section discloses any substantial evidence supporting the allegations of a complaint, the commissioner shall issue a finding of substantial evidence.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-003-0215","citation":"OAR 839-003-0215(5)","quote":"The division cannot issue a finding of substantial evidence of discrimination after an aggrieved person has filed a civil action alleging the same matters as provided in OAR 839-003-0235, and the trial for the civil action has commenced.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.835","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a66a4d20af4d229e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]},{"summary":"OAR 839-005-0210(2) omits 'gender identity' from the exception's protective scope, even though ORS 659A.421(8) explicitly includes it.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-659a.421","citation":"ORS 659A.421(8)","quote":"The provisions of subsection (2)(a) to (d) and (f) of this section that prohibit actions based upon sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or familial status do not apply to the renting of space within a single-family residence","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-005-0210","citation":"OAR 839-005-0210(2)","quote":"The provisions of OAR 839-005-0205(1)(a) to (d) and (f) that prohibit actions based upon sex, sexual orientation or familial status do not apply to the renting of space within a single-family residence","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-659a.421","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fa194d4da656b613","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services-chief-human-resources-office","name":"Department of Administrative Services, Chief Human Resources Office"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"660","run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","rules_reviewed":37,"candidates":[{"summary":"ORS 660.190 requires community colleges to appoint at least one employee member and one training agent member of a local joint committee to an advisory committee for training programs, but none of the rules implementing this statute contain any operative provisions addressing advisory committee appointments.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-660.190","citation":"ORS 660.190","quote":"Each community college operating a preemployment or trade extension training program in an apprenticeable occupation shall appoint at least one employee member and one training agent member of an appropriate local joint committee to the advisory committee for that training program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0110","citation":"OAR 589-007-0110(1)-(18)","quote":"Community colleges will cooperate with the State Apprenticeship and Training Council, the Office, and the local joint committees in providing the necessary related training courses... Community colleges will collaborate with local joint committees to develop and implement apprenticeship related training courses... Community colleges will transcript the credit for all apprenticeship related training courses completed by apprentices...","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d339107c06cc6d3e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"ORS 660.167 requires the State Apprenticeship and Training Council to adopt policies regarding evaluation procedures for apprenticeship credit and procedures for demonstrating achievement levels in related instruction. OAR 589-007-0150(6) states that evaluation procedures for apprenticeship credit 'will follow policies adopted by the State Apprenticeship and Training Council' but the rules themselves do not articulate what those Council-adopted policies are; instead, the rules focus on what community colleges will do rather than addressing the Council's required policy adoption.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-660.167","citation":"ORS 660.167","quote":"The State Apprenticeship and Training Council, in cooperation with the Higher Education Coordinating Commission, shall adopt policies regarding: (1) Evaluation procedures relating to the determination of apprenticeship credit for work experience, education and training. (2) Procedures for demonstrating the level of achievement required in any area of related instruction, including but not limited to taking a qualifying examination of the course content.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0150","citation":"OAR 589-007-0150(6)","quote":"Evaluation procedures to establish apprenticeship credit for community college work toward apprenticeship requirements will follow policies adopted by the State Apprenticeship and Training Council in cooperation with the Office.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.167","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1b189dd30762f85b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts program eligibility to citizens or authorized workers, dropping the statute's broader category of simply being a resident of Oregon.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-660.343","citation":"ORS 660.343(2)","quote":"Program services may be offered through public high schools, community colleges, local and regional career centers and any other institutions determined to be appropriate by the commission to residents of Oregon and to employees of businesses located in Oregon.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0700","citation":"589-007-0700(2)(h)(A)","quote":"Must be a citizen or national of the United States, lawfully admitted permanent resident noncitizen, refugee, asylee, or parolee, or other immigrant authorized by the Attorney General to work in the United States","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.343","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fd4dcad2619c6beb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-007-0110 substitutes community colleges for the district school boards the statute requires to cooperate and provide related instruction.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-660.160","citation":"ORS 660.160","quote":"All district school boards shall cooperate with the State Apprenticeship and Training Council, the Department of Education, and the local joint committees or trade committees in providing the necessary related instruction classes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-589-007-0110","citation":"OAR 589-007-0110(1)","quote":"Community colleges will cooperate with the State Apprenticeship and Training Council, the Office, and the local joint committees in providing the necessary related training courses","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.160","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"151e72da6b25739e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"The rule's operative text addresses complaint procedures against HECC, but ORS 660.318 addresses only HECC's substantive duties under WIOA and contains no provision engaging with complaint procedures or their resolution.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-020-0300","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 660.318","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-660.318","citation":"ORS 660.318","quote":"To implement and oversee state implementation of the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, the Higher Education Coordinating Commission may: (a) Receive federal youth activities funds... (b) Receive federal adult employment and training activities funds... (c) Receive federal dislocated worker funds... (d) Establish a procedure for use by local workforce development boards to identify eligible providers... (e) Receive the comprehensive strategic plan... (f) Approve the plans... (g) Carry out the required and allowable activities... (h) Pursuant to ORS 660.339, establish procedures to maintain the confidentiality... (i) Establish a method to set performance standards... (j) Perform planning functions...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.318","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2783151889eae74a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-020-0330(5)(d) authorizes release to federal, state, or local staff to determine nondiscrimination compliance, which is not listed among the statutory circumstances in ORS 660.339(4)(a)-(e).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-020-0330","citation":"OAR 589-020-0330(5)(d)","quote":"To authorized federal, state, or local staff, or designee, to determine compliance with nondiscrimination and equal employment opportunity requirements under 29 CFR Section § 38","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-660.339","citation":"ORS 660.339(4)","quote":"The commission may adopt policies and rules to provide the circumstances under which participant names or records may be made available for inspection when: (a) Ordered by a court of competent jurisdiction. (b) Necessary to protect the health or safety of a participant or another. (c) Necessary to provide information to state and local agencies administering ORS 412.001 to 412.161 and 412.991 and ORS chapters 418 and 657, other programs under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act and other mandatory programs under this state's one-stop service delivery system. (d) Necessary for program staff work or studies of a statistical or demographic nature. (e) Necessary to carry out the planning and coordinating functions between state and local agencies under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, other applicable state laws or those functions assigned by the Education and Workforce Policy Advisor.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.339","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d57dce1dd01b3a3a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]},{"summary":"OAR 589-020-0330(5)(f) authorizes release to private auditing firms for program monitoring, which is not listed among the statutory circumstances in ORS 660.339(4)(a)-(e).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-589-020-0330","citation":"OAR 589-020-0330(5)(f)","quote":"To private auditing firms employed by the subrecipient to carry out monitoring of its programs for internal purposes only with a properly executed release of information form","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-660.339","citation":"ORS 660.339(4)","quote":"The commission may adopt policies and rules to provide the circumstances under which participant names or records may be made available for inspection when: (a) Ordered by a court of competent jurisdiction. (b) Necessary to protect the health or safety of a participant or another. (c) Necessary to provide information to state and local agencies administering ORS 412.001 to 412.161 and 412.991 and ORS chapters 418 and 657, other programs under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act and other mandatory programs under this state's one-stop service delivery system. (d) Necessary for program staff work or studies of a statistical or demographic nature. (e) Necessary to carry out the planning and coordinating functions between state and local agencies under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, other applicable state laws or those functions assigned by the Education and Workforce Policy Advisor.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"hecc-v6-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-660.339","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d8b01baa73907f22","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"higher-education-coordinating-commission-office-of-community-colleges-and-workforce-development","name":"Higher Education Coordinating Commission, Office of Community Colleges and Workforce Development"}]},{"ors_chapter":"671","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":419,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute requires the board to establish fees for practical skills testing, but the rule delegates fee-setting authority to the third-party exam provider NALP.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.561","citation":"ORS 671.561(5)","quote":"The board shall establish fees for applicants described in this section in amounts reasonably calculated to offset the full program cost of conducting the practical skills test and business practices class described in this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0710","citation":"OAR 808-003-0710(3)","quote":"Practical skills exam fee: Exterior Technician Exam taken through the National Association of Landscape Professionals (NALP) is paid directly to NALP. The fee amount is determined by NALP.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.561","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"327f6ea1abe004a2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-002-0760 declares it implements ORS 671.710, which concerns priority of claim payments from surety bonds, but the rule's operative text addresses only what work qualifies as contractor work and never engages with claims, bonds, payment priority, or any other provision of ORS 671.710.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0760","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 448.115, ORS 448.279, ORS 671.510-671.710, ORS 701.005, ORS 701.021, ORS 701.026","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.710","citation":"ORS 671.710","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.710","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c7a251685048c28f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule requires documentation only for judgments 'issued on or after January 1, 2008' and 'in any state,' while statute requires notice of any unpaid judgment 'in any jurisdiction' without temporal restriction.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.563","citation":"ORS 671.563","quote":"notice of any unpaid court judgment, arbitration award or administrative agency final order entered or issued in any jurisdiction that requires the applicant to pay damages arising out of the performance of, or a contract for, landscaping work","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0015","citation":"OAR 808-003-0015(2)(f)","quote":"Documentation of any unpaid court judgment, arbitration award or administrative agency final order entered or issued in any state that requires the applicant to pay damages arising out of the performance of, or a contract for, landscaping work issued on or after January 1, 2008, along with the status of any appeal or exceptions","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0015","citation":"OAR 808-003-0015(3)(d)","quote":"Documentation of any unpaid court judgment, arbitration award or administrative agency final order entered or issued in any state that requires the applicant to pay damages arising out of the performance of, or a contract for, landscaping work issued on or after January 1, 2008, along with the status of any appeal or exceptions","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0015","citation":"OAR 808-003-0015(4)(c)","quote":"Documentation of any unpaid court judgment, arbitration award or administrative agency final order entered or issued in any state that requires the applicant to pay damages arising out of the performance of, or a contract for, landscaping work issued on or after January 1, 2008, along with the status of any appeal or exceptions","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.563","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ebf60b47ce0659eb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule redefines 'owner or officer' to include employees, which differs from the statute's requirement that the registered landscape architect be an owner or officer.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-035-0010","citation":"OAR 804-035-0010(3)(a)","quote":"For purposes of ORS 671.318 and Division 35, an \"owner or officer\" of the business means an individual owning, operating, or employed by the business and having full authority, accountability, and responsibility on behalf of the business to enter into contracts for provision of landscape architectural services in Oregon, to directly provide such services, and to otherwise make decisions regarding the execution and outcome of such services.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.318","citation":"ORS 671.318","quote":"A business may not provide landscape architecture services unless the work is under the full authority and responsible charge of a registered landscape architect who is also an owner or officer of the business.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.318","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"50e1901f06137efd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"The rule requires notification of changes to the Registered Landscape Architect in responsible charge, which the statute does not mention.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-035-0010","citation":"OAR 804-035-0010(4)(d)","quote":"Registered Landscape Architect designated as being in responsible charge of the landscape architectural services provided in Oregon by the business or business office.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.318","citation":"ORS 671.318","quote":"The business shall notify the board in writing no later than 30 days after a change of registered owners or officers or a change of business name or address.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.318","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"523a45e1f003b127","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 804-027-0005 declares it implements ORS 671.365 (a statute entirely about establishing fee amounts) but the rule's operative text contains no fee provisions whatsoever and addresses only LAIT professional conduct, functions, and supervisory powers.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-027-0005","citation":"oar-804-027-0005 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 671.315, ORS 671.316, ORS 671.335, ORS 671345, ORS 671.365, ORS 671.425, ORS 671.393","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.365","citation":"ORS 671.365","quote":"The State Landscape Architect Board may establish by rule the amounts for fees to be charged and collected under ORS 671.310 to 671.459.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"14485e0d0eee38b1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 804-022-0015 declares it implements ORS 671.365 (a statute about establishing fee amounts) but the rule's operative text never establishes any fee amounts; it only addresses renewal dates, lapsed registrations, and reinstatement procedures without setting fees.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-022-0015","citation":"oar-804-022-0015 declared statutes","quote":"ORS 671.325, ORS 671.345, ORS 671.365, ORS 671.376","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.365","citation":"ORS 671.365","quote":"The State Landscape Architect Board may establish by rule the amounts for fees to be charged and collected under ORS 671.310 to 671.459.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.365","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"faec9cfd31fd9eeb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 804-030-0000(8) and OAR 804-030-0003(4) establish 'disciplinary action or civil penalty' as consequences for improper use, but ORS 671.995 provides only for civil penalties and does not authorize or mention disciplinary action.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.995","citation":"ORS 671.995(1)","quote":"The State Landscape Architect Board may impose a civil penalty against any person who violates any provision of ORS 671.310 to 671.459 or any rule adopted thereunder.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-030-0000","citation":"OAR 804-030-0000(8)","quote":"Improper use of the stamp, whether authorized or not by the Registered Landscape Architect, shall be grounds for disciplinary action or civil penalty by the Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-030-0003","citation":"OAR 804-030-0003(4)","quote":"Improper use, whether authorized or not by the Registered Landscape Architect, of a digital signature shall be grounds for disciplinary action or civil penalty by the Board.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.995","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e0d400e58474519b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-040-0050(3) automatically approves university/college credit courses without requiring the pre-approval process the statute contemplates, effectively broadening the category of approved programs beyond what the statute's approval framework requires.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.676","citation":"ORS 671.676(2) and (3)","quote":"The board may approve programs for purposes of continuing education for landscape construction professionals and determine the number of hours to be credited to the programs...Programs approved by the board for continuing education purposes must be designed to directly contribute to the professional competency of landscape construction professionals. Approved programs may include, but need not be limited to: (a) Professional development programs and technical meetings of professional associations for landscape contracting businesses or for related industries such as pesticide application or irrigation auditing; (b) University or college courses related to landscaping or horticulture","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-040-0050","citation":"OAR 808-040-0050(3)","quote":"Credit courses taken by an accredit college or university do not need to be approved prior to or after taking the course as stated in subsections (1) or (2) of this rule. Credit is granted as stated in OAR 808-040-0030(1).","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.676","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f0af46db2a7b00a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the stamp to bear the landscape architect's 'registration date,' but the rule specifies 'initial date of registration,' which are different concepts—initial registration date is narrower than what 'registration date' in the statute could mean.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.379","citation":"ORS 671.379(1)","quote":"The stamp must bear the name, registration date and registration certificate number of the landscape architect and the legend \"registered landscape architect.\"","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-030-0000","citation":"OAR 804-030-0000(4)(b)(C)","quote":"Third, the initial date of registration below the word OREGON, as required by the Board.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.379","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b76101b24ca6a8f2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the landscape architect to 'stamp and sign all final drafts of professional documents' issued for specified purposes, but the rule establishes exceptions allowing certain documents (including those without landscape architecture work and unmodified manufacturer cut sheets) to not be stamped.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.379","citation":"ORS 671.379(2)","quote":"A registered landscape architect shall stamp and sign all final drafts of professional documents that the landscape architect issues for obtaining permits, obtaining approvals by agencies other than the board or fulfilling contractual obligations, including maps, plans, designs, contract documents and reports.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-030-0000","citation":"OAR 804-030-0000(7)","quote":"A Registered Landscape Architect is not required to stamp or sign the following types of documents: (a) Documents that do not contain landscape architecture work, which could include but are not necessarily limited to project checklists, cost estimates, construction schedules, payment verifications, general correspondence, or advertising; (b) Documents that reflect the installed, fabricated, constructed or commissioned condition of a product as provided by another party (i.e. manufacturer cut sheets) and that have not been modified by the Registered Landscape Architect prior to submittal to a client or government agency","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.379","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"01be8c6f78a5ce6b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0613(1) sets the required bond amount at $2,000, but ORS 671.690(1) states it must be $20,000.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.690","citation":"ORS 671.690(1)","quote":"The amount of the bond or letter of credit must be $20,000.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0613","citation":"OAR 808-003-0613(1)","quote":"Except as provided in subsection (2) of this rule, a surety bond, letter of credit or cash deposit required under ORS 671.690 must be in the amount of $2,000.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.690","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5af5bc41e885bec9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0126 declares implementation of ORS 671.595 but contains no operative text addressing coursework requirements, examinations, or notice of duty changes—the statutory subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-003-0126","citation":"OAR 808-003-0126 frontmatter","quote":"ORS 671.310, ORS 671.595","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.595","citation":"ORS 671.595","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.595","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"994f79cca5961e9b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Conflicting notification deadlines: OAR 808-003-0125(5)(a) requires the business to notify within 10 days when a managing employee ceases to act in that role, but OAR 808-030-0015(2) and 808-030-0018(6) require the managing employee and managing owner respectively to notify within 30 days of the same change.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-003-0125","citation":"OAR 808-003-0125(5)(a)","quote":"Within ten (10) calendar days of the date a managing owner or managing employee ceases to act in the roles as defined in OAR 808-002-0625 or 808-002-0734(2) notify the agency in writing","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-030-0015","citation":"OAR 808-030-0015(2)","quote":"In the event a designated managing employee no longer is employed by or fulfills the role of managing employee for a landscape contracting business the managing employee must notify the board within 30 days of the change in employment or role.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-030-0018","citation":"OAR 808-030-0018(6)","quote":"In the event a designated managing owner no longer fulfills the role of managing owner for a landscape contracting business the managing owner must notify the board within 30 days of the change in role.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.595","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e539c772dd053d18","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule adds a 5-year discipline disqualification for registrant board members that the statute does not mention.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.459","citation":"ORS 671.459(1)","quote":"Four of the members shall be registered landscape architects","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-001-0014","citation":"oar-804-001-0014(2)(b)","quote":"A registrant is not qualified for nomination to board membership if the registrant, within the previous 5 years, has been disciplined by the Board for a violation of ORS Chapter 671 or the rules adopted by the Board.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.459","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0266947c1e50e523","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"The rule defines 'Court, arbitrator or other entity' to include arbitrators and other dispute resolution entities, while ORS 671.578 explicitly limits suits to 'a court of competent jurisdiction' only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.578","citation":"ORS 671.578","quote":"that person may bring suit in a court of competent jurisdiction to recover damages","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-002-0260","citation":"OAR 808-002-0260","quote":"\"Court, arbitrator or other entity\" means a court of competent jurisdiction or an arbitrator or other entity authorized by law or the parties to a dispute to effect a resolution to the dispute","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.578","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"06b8ccdbd68410ba","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-002-0800 declares ORS 671.600 as a statute it implements, but the operative text—a definition of \"Renew License\"—does not engage with ORS 671.600's substantive requirements regarding ownership changes requiring a new license and notification of address changes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0800","citation":"declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 671.600, ORS 671.610, ORS 671.660","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.600","citation":"ORS 671.600(1)–(2)","quote":"A new landscape contracting business license shall be required whenever there is a change in ownership, irrespective of whether the business name is changed... If a licensee moves to another location, relicensing is not required but the licensee must notify the State Landscape Contractors Board promptly of the new address.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.600","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d0fb2ff1adaf748d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule's definition of 'Employee' excludes leased or temporary employees, but the statute requires submission of 'all employees' who are licensed landscape construction professionals during license renewal.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.660","citation":"ORS 671.660(4)","quote":"When a landscape contracting business renews its license, the business must submit the names of all employees who are licensed landscape construction professionals.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-002-0360","citation":"OAR 808-002-0360","quote":"Employee does not include either a subcontractor that is an independent contractor, or a leased or temporary employee.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.660","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3e95aa29e07d609e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule mandates penalty fees as part of reinstatement amounts, but the statute grants the board discretion to 'require' a penalty fee, making it optional.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.660","citation":"ORS 671.660(2)","quote":"The board may require the person to also pay a penalty fee.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0130","citation":"OAR 808-003-0130(11)","quote":"If a landscape construction professional license expires, the amount to be paid for reinstatement to active or inactive status equals the required fee for each year of expiration (up to two years) plus a late penalty fee for each year.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.660","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"112f0ae35be763cf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 804-022-0000(2) allows LAIT registration for candidates who have 'successfully completed two or more sections' of the LARE examination, but statute 671.316(3) requires that a person must 'pass a board approved examination' to be registered as a landscape architect in training.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.316","citation":"ORS 671.316(3)","quote":"the board may register a person as a landscape architect in training if the person meets the education and experience standards established by board rule and passes a board approved examination","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0000","citation":"OAR 804-022-0000(2)","quote":"An examination candidate who has successfully completed two or more sections of the Landscape Architect Registration Examination (LARE) and is working toward registration as a Landscape Architect is qualified to register with the Board as a LAIT.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.316","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ddb4d5af0affa98e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.520 but defines \"Employee,\" a term that does not appear in that statute and is not engaged with in the operative text.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0360","citation":"OAR 808-002-0360","quote":"ORS 305, ORS 314, ORS 316, ORS 317, ORS 318, ORS 656, ORS 657, ORS 671.525, ORS 671.520, ORS 671.565, ORS 671.660, ORS 447.060","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.520","citation":"ORS 671.520","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a7af134e562b6107","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.520 but defines \"Casual, Minor, or Inconsequential,\" a term that appears in ORS 671.540(1)(c)(C), not in ORS 671.520, and the operative text never engages with ORS 671.520.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0200","citation":"OAR 808-002-0200","quote":"ORS 671.520, ORS 671.540","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.520","citation":"ORS 671.520","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0971a63e1f349bca","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.520 but defines \"Piping\" as used in ORS 671.540(1)(m), (n) & (o), not in ORS 671.520, and the operative text never engages with ORS 671.520.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0775","citation":"OAR 808-002-0775","quote":"ORS 671.520, ORS 671.540","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.520","citation":"ORS 671.520","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dbda0fda978e29df","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.520 but defines \"Negligent\" as used in ORS 671.690(2)(c), 671.695(1)(a) and (3)(a), not in ORS 671.520, and the operative text never engages with ORS 671.520.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0685","citation":"OAR 808-002-0685","quote":"ORS 671.695, ORS 671.520","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.520","citation":"ORS 671.520","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"9fdd9f0465d9635e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute allows registration 'without examination' for applicants with equivalent out-of-state licensure, but the implementing rule requires passage of the LARE examination in all registration pathways.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.345","citation":"ORS 671.345(1)(a)","quote":"The State Landscape Architect Board may register as a landscape architect, without examination, any individual who applies for such registration under ORS 671.325, and: (a) On the date of making application is a landscape architect licensed or registered under the laws of any other state or territory of the United States, if the requirements for the licensing or registration of landscape architects in the state or territory in which the applicant is licensed or registered on the date of licensing or registration in such state or territory were substantially equal to the requirements for the registration of landscape architects in this state on the date of the application","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0010","citation":"OAR 804-022-0010(4)(a)","quote":"Examination: Passage of the Landscape Architect Registration Examination (LARE) or the equivalent from previous versions of the national examination is required.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0010","citation":"OAR 804-022-0010(5)(a)","quote":"Examination: Passage of the Landscape Architect Registration Examination (LARE) or the equivalent from previous versions of the national examination is required.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0010","citation":"OAR 804-022-0010(6)(a)","quote":"Examination: Passage of the Landscape Architect Registration Examination (LARE) or the equivalent from previous versions of the national examination is required.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"670b93f0814c723b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule changes the statutory deadline from 15 days to 15 business days for application submission","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.325","citation":"ORS 671.325(1)","quote":"shall make application to the State Landscape Architect Board 15 days prior to any meeting of the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0005","citation":"oar-804-022-0005(3)","quote":"must be submitted no later than 15 business days prior to the Board meeting at which the applicant wants to complete the oral examination","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"646dcdf67ec595d4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 804-022-0020(5)(b) and 804-025-0015(3) require lapsed RLA registrants to pass a continuing education audit and provide proof of continuing education compliance as part of reinstatement, but ORS 671.376(3) only requires 'passing examinations required by the board and by paying any required examination fees, renewal fees and late fees' without mentioning continuing education.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.376","citation":"ORS 671.376(3)","quote":"A person who fails to pay the renewal fee and, if applicable, the late fee for a period of 60 days after the renewal date may renew the registration only upon passing examinations required by the board and by paying any required examination fees, renewal fees and late fees.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-022-0020","citation":"OAR 804-022-0020(5)(b)","quote":"For a Registered Landscape Architect registration, submit documentation of continuing education completion as required in OAR 804-025-0015(3) and pass a continuing education audit; and","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-025-0015","citation":"OAR 804-025-0015(3)","quote":"Lapsed registrants seeking reinstatement must provide proof of compliance with the requirements of OAR 804 Division 025 for the equivalent of each year the registration has been lapsed up to a maximum of the PDH required over 3 renewal periods.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.376","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9467d60dfef15cfd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-002-0260 declares it implements ORS 671.707, but the rule is merely a definition of 'court, arbitrator or other entity' that does not appear in or relate to ORS 671.707, which concerns surety notification, recording of orders with county clerks, and lien effects.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0260","citation":"OAR 808-002-0260","quote":"ORS 671.545, ORS 671.578, ORS 671.610, ORS 671.625, ORS 671.703, ORS 671.707, ORS 671.710","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.707","citation":"ORS 671.707","quote":"If a final order of the State Landscape Contractors Board is not paid by the landscape contracting business, the board shall notify the surety on the business's bond. An order of the board that determines a claim under ORS 671.703 that becomes final by operation of law or on appeal and remains unpaid for 20 days after the order becomes final is an order in favor of the claimant against the landscape contracting business and may be recorded with the county clerk in any county of this state. Upon receipt, the clerk shall record the order in the County Clerk Lien Record.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.707","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fd1db9007dc95186","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-004-0590(3) triggers the 30-day deadline for filing court complaints when either an arbitration or contested case hearing is scheduled, but ORS 671.703(5)(c) specifies the deadline is triggered only when an arbitration hearing is scheduled.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.703","citation":"ORS 671.703(5)(c)","quote":"A party that is subject to paragraph (a) or (b) of this subsection must deliver a request or complaint to the board as described in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this subsection no later than the 30th day after the board sends notice that an arbitration hearing has been scheduled.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-004-0590","citation":"OAR 808-004-0590(3)","quote":"A copy of a complaint filed under section (2) of this rule must be received by the agency or the Office of Administrative Hearings no later than 30 days after the Office of Administrative Hearings sends the first notice that an arbitration or contested case hearing is scheduled.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.703","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6d5532c77224b17d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-004-0590 contains an internal inconsistency: subsection (3) applies the 30-day deadline when 'an arbitration or contested case hearing is scheduled' but subsection (4)(a) applies it only when 'an arbitration is scheduled'.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0590","citation":"OAR 808-004-0590(3) vs (4)(a)","quote":"(3) A copy of a complaint filed under section (2) of this rule must be received by the agency or the Office of Administrative Hearings no later than 30 days after the Office of Administrative Hearings sends the first notice that an arbitration or contested case hearing is scheduled. ... (4)(a) The request by a party or the agency must be in writing and received by the agency or the Office of Administrative Hearings no later than 30 days after the Office of Administrative Hearings sends the first notice that an arbitration is scheduled.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.703","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7be02d3a0323f8da","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-004-0450(2)(d) requires that 'the individual landscape construction professional whose phase of license is the basis for the landscape contracting business license and who supervised the project must attend the meeting,' but ORS 671.703 does not specify any requirement for a particular professional to attend on-site meetings.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.703","citation":"ORS 671.703(10)","quote":"The board may dismiss or close a claim as established by rule of the board if: (a) The claimant does not permit the person against whom the claim is filed to be present at any on-site investigation made by the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-004-0450","citation":"OAR 808-004-0450(2)(d)","quote":"The individual landscape construction professional whose phase of license is the basis for the landscape contracting business license and who supervised the project must attend the meeting as required by OAR 808-003-0018.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.703","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b3aea31102f5c67a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-008-0040 narrows ORS 671.703(3) by limiting voluntary arbitration to disputes that do not meet jurisdictional requirements and requiring written agreement, whereas the statute simply permits the board to use arbitration for disputes where parties 'agree to follow the rules.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.703","citation":"ORS 671.703(3)","quote":"The board may use arbitration, mediation or other forms of dispute resolution to resolve a landscaping dispute between any parties who agree to follow the rules of the board, including parties to a dispute that is not a claim described in ORS 671.695.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-008-0040","citation":"OAR 808-008-0040","quote":"A dispute involving a landscaping contractor that does not meet timeliness filing or other jurisdictional requirements under this chapter or ORS 671.690 to 671.710 may be arbitrated by the agency only if both parties agree in writing to submit the dispute to the Landscape Contractors Board for binding arbitration.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.703","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc2b4f142b99e540","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 806-010-0037 declares it implements ORS 671.010-671.220, but its operative text addresses architect title restrictions while ORS 671.220 addresses board injunctions, standing to bring actions, and representation of professional organization membership—the rule's content never engages with 671.220's actual subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-806-010-0037","citation":"OAR 806-010-0037 declared statutes_implemented line","quote":"ORS 671.010 – 671.220","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.010","citation":"ORS 671.010","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.220","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ebacd67293e06bea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["state-board-of-architect-examiners"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 671.510-671.990, but the operative text limits applicability to ORS 671.510-671.710 and 671.955, excluding ORS 671.990 from its actual scope.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0100","citation":"OAR 808-002-0100 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 671.510 - 671.990","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-002-0100","citation":"OAR 808-002-0100 (operative text)","quote":"the definitions in this division govern the interpretation of ORS 671.510 to 671.710, 671.955 and OAR chapter 808","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.510","citation":"ORS 671.510","added_by":"mechanical-declaration-clause-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.990","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c0ae3c0e5e4f9526","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rules make any 'improper use' of the stamp or signature grounds for discipline, broader than ORS 671.404(4) which specifies only signing documents not prepared by you or permitting your name's use to help someone evade the law.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-030-0000","citation":"OAR 804-030-0000(8)","quote":"Improper use of the stamp, whether authorized or not by the Registered Landscape Architect, shall be grounds for disciplinary action or civil penalty by the Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-030-0003","citation":"OAR 804-030-0003(4)","quote":"Improper use, whether authorized or not by the Registered Landscape Architect, of a digital signature shall be grounds for disciplinary action or civil penalty by the Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.404","citation":"ORS 671.404(4)","quote":"Has affixed the person's signature to plans, reports or other professional documents that have not been prepared by the person or under the person's immediate and responsible direction or has permitted the use of the person's name for the purpose of assisting any individual, not a registered landscape architect, to evade the provisions of ORS 671.310 to 671.459, 671.992 and 671.995.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.404","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"181feab457a76446","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementation of ORS 671.575 (license requirement to obtain judicial remedy) but the operative text never addresses the licensing requirement—instead addressing only procedural matters of claim processing when transferred to courts.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"ars-808-004-0520","citation":"OAR 808-004-0520 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 183.415, ORS 183.460, ORS 671.703, ORS 671.575","not_found":true,"quote_verified":null},{"id":"ors-671.575","citation":"ORS 671.575(1)","quote":"A landscape contracting business may not file a lien, file a claim with the State Landscape Contractors Board or bring or maintain in any court of this state a suit or action for compensation for the performance of any work or for the breach of any contract for work that is subject to ORS 671.510 to 671.760 and 671.997, unless the landscape contracting business was: (a) Licensed under ORS 671.510 to 671.760 at the time the landscape contracting business bid or entered into the contract for performance of the work; and (b) Licensed continuously while performing the work for which compensation is sought.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.575","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"575a39e8afeb58cd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"Rule 808-004-0360 allows new claim items to be added through mediation or on-site meetings that occur well beyond the one-year deadline the statute imposes for filing claims.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.700","citation":"ORS 671.700(3)","quote":"The board may not accept a claim against a landscape contracting business for processing if the claim is not filed with the board within one year after the business substantially completed work.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-004-0360","citation":"OAR 808-004-0360","quote":"Effective January 1, 2017, if the agency conducts mediation or holds an on-site meeting, the claimant may add new claim items up to and through the mediation process or initial on-site meeting, whichever is latest. Agency staff will determine the completion date of the mediation process. New items added to a timely filed claim under this rule are considered timely filed.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.700","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e4ed596a6169d4c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule mandates acceptance of CLARB's grading procedures, but statute allows the board discretion to either determine its own basis or adopt CLARB's recommendations.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.335","citation":"ORS 671.335(1)","quote":"examinations shall be written or oral or both written and oral and shall cover such subjects and be graded on such basis as the board shall determine by rule. The board may adopt the examination and the recommended grading procedures of the Council of Landscape Architectural Registration Boards","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-020-0040","citation":"OAR 804-020-0040","quote":"The Board shall accept the recommended grading procedures and minimum passing scores for all sections of the Landscape Architect Registration Examination (LARE) as established by the Council of Landscape Architectural Registration Boards (CLARB).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c1a253f78687ab65","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.530 but its entire operative text is just a cross-reference to another rule, with no engagement with the statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0230","citation":"OAR 125-249-0230","quote":"ORS 279C.365, ORS 671.530, ORS 701.026","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.530","citation":"ORS 671.530","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.530","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cb539e8d102d9c9e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0230(3)-(4) creates an 'inactive military' status that can be renewed/maintained across multiple licensing periods, whereas ORS 671.574(4) prohibits a landscape construction professional license from being 'placed or maintained in inactive status more than once during a licensing period.'","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.574","citation":"ORS 671.574(4)","quote":"A landscape construction professional license may not be placed or maintained in inactive status more than once during a licensing period.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0230","citation":"OAR 808-003-0230(3)-(4)","quote":"If a landscape construction professional is on active military duty, that servicemember may place a license on 'inactive military' status, and may renew the license to 'inactive military' status without paying the renewal fee... To convert an inactive military status license to active or inactive status upon an honorable discharge, the servicemember must submit a written request within 60 days from the date of discharge.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.574","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2c6d4025dde35d44","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0255(3) and (4) contain internal citations to 'OAR 812-003-0130' while the rest of the regulation and other rules consistently cite 'OAR 808-003-0130', creating an internal inconsistency.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-003-0255","citation":"OAR 808-003-0255(3)-(4)","quote":"If a licensee requests conversion from an inactive to active status at the time of renewal, the licensee must submit all fees required under OAR 812-003-0130. (4) If a licensee requests conversion from inactive to active status other than at the time of renewal, the licensee must be current to date upon all fees due and owing under OAR 812-003-0130.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.574","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c66aff4cf5d4a56a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0126 declares it implements ORS 671.310 (a definitions section), but the rule's operative text addresses permits and requirements for landscape contracting business work and does not engage with any definitions from that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-003-0126","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 671.310, ORS 671.595","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.310","citation":"ORS 671.310","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.310","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d3158f20ed826ee7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 671.617, which requires examination procedures and bilingual examination materials for backflow assembly installer licenses, but the operative text of the rule provides only a definition of 'backflow assembly' and never engages with ORS 671.617's examination requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0150","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 671.615, ORS 671.617","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.617","citation":"ORS 671.617","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.617","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"1f0d00893a6c07e2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule for probationary professional license applications omits the examination fee and landscape construction professional license fee that the statute explicitly requires applicants to pay.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.571","citation":"ORS 671.571(1)","quote":"To obtain a probationary landscape construction professional license, the person must: (a) Pay a nonrefundable application fee; (b) Pay an examination fee; (c) Pay to the board the landscape construction professional license fee required by ORS 671.650; and (d) Pass all sections of the examination described in ORS 671.570 within 12 months after first taking the examination.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0015","citation":"OAR 808-003-0015(4)","quote":"Application for a probationary landscape construction professional license shall be on forms provided by the agency and shall be accompanied by: (a) A non-refundable application fee, (b) If applicable the name of the employing licensed landscape contracting business or businesses. (c) Documentation of any unpaid court judgment, arbitration award or administrative agency final order entered or issued in any state that requires the applicant to pay damages arising out of the performance of, or a contract for, landscaping work issued on or after January 1, 2008, along with the status of any appeal or exceptions. For purposes of this rule and ORS 671.563, \"applicant\" means the person applying for the individual probationary landscape construction professional license; (d) Complete questions to Licensing and Litigation History and Criminal Background sections; (e) Social security number of the applicant. Effective January 1, 2020, in lieu of a social security number, a federal individual taxpayer identification number or other federally-issued identification number; (f) Mailing and physical address of the applicant; and (g) Signature of applicant.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.571","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4bf75e0855d86052","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-002-0734(1)(c) refers to 'stockholders' in a limited partnership, but limited partnerships do not have stockholders—they have partners.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0734","citation":"OAR 808-002-0734(1)(c)","quote":"A majority stockholder in a limited partnership","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.607","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"889120ece5839ee7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-002-0320 requires at least 3 prior final orders/awards to establish defective work, but the statute allows sanctions for simply performing defective work without any threshold.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0320","citation":"OAR 808-002-0320(3)-(4)","quote":"If there have been at least 3 such final administrative orders, arbitration awards, or court orders issued against a landscape contracting business; and, No more than 5 years elapsed between the date the oldest final administrative order, arbitration award, or court order being considered was issued, and the date the most recent final administrative order, arbitration award, or court order being considered was issued.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-671.610","citation":"ORS 671.610(1)(c)","quote":"Performs defective work.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"834097d277cfcbbe","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-002-0338 is declared to implement ORS 671.610(1)(o), which addresses failure to pay claims to claimants, but the rule text defines landscape drainage systems which are not mentioned in that statute section.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0338","citation":"OAR 808-002-0338, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 671.610(1)(o)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.610","citation":"ORS 671.610(1)(o)","quote":"Fails to pay in full any amount owed to a claimant under a final order of the board or an arbitration award, or under a judgment rendered in this or any other state.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6599ee9fb7f9d4e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-002-0340 is declared to implement ORS 671.610(1)(o) (failure to pay claims), but the rule text defines 'Employ' in relation to 671.610(2)(f) (operation without at least one licensed professional), which does not involve payment obligations.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0340","citation":"OAR 808-002-0340, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 671.610(1)(o)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.610","citation":"ORS 671.610(1)(o)","quote":"Fails to pay in full any amount owed to a claimant under a final order of the board or an arbitration award, or under a judgment rendered in this or any other state.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1b1ee1429032672d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-003-0440 requires notification of conviction of a crime listed in ORS 671.610(1)(q), but subsection (1)(q) addresses dishonest or fraudulent conduct, not criminal convictions. Criminal convictions are addressed in subsection (1)(s).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-003-0440","citation":"OAR 808-003-0440","quote":"convicted of a crime listed in ORS 671.610(1)(q)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.610","citation":"ORS 671.610(1)(q)","quote":"Engages in conduct as a landscape construction professional or landscape contracting business that is dishonest or fraudulent or that the board finds injurious to the welfare of the public.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.610","citation":"ORS 671.610(1)(s)","quote":"Is convicted of a crime under ORS 163.107, 163.115, 163.185, 163.225, 163.235, 163.355, 163.365, 163.375, 163.385, 163.395, 163.405, 163.408, 163.411, 163.415, 163.425, 163.427, 164.055, 164.075, 164.325 or 164.415","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.610","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7785643d83f37293","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 808-004-0211(2) allows email as a delivery method for non-initial communications in contested cases, but the statute specifies only regular mail deposit for such communications","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.603","citation":"ORS 671.603(2)","quote":"Any other communication directed by the board to the last-known address of record for a landscape construction professional or landscape contracting business is considered delivered to the professional or business when deposited in the United States mail, regular mail.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-004-0211","citation":"OAR 808-004-0211(2)","quote":"All other communication directed to the last known email address of record or mailing address of record of a party to a claim shall be considered delivered when sent by email or deposited in the United States mail and sent by regular mail.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.603","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a9595965588e91e9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires notification 'immediately' upon a change in partners or ownership, but the rule allows 10 calendar days.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.605","citation":"ORS 671.605","quote":"A partnership or corporation licensed as a landscape contracting business shall notify the State Landscape Contractors Board immediately upon any change in partners or corporate owners or in the percentage of an ownership interest","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0125","citation":"OAR 808-003-0125(6)","quote":"Within ten (10) calendar days following a change in partners or owners or a change in percentage of an ownership interest, the landscape contracting business shall submit written notification of the change to the agency as required by ORS 671.605.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.605","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"2e6f2ffa48aabfe7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 808-003-0090 includes joint ventures, limited liability partnerships, limited partnerships, and trusts as entities subject to classification, but ORS 671.525(2) limits the enumeration to sole proprietorships, partnerships, corporations and limited liability companies.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.525","citation":"ORS 671.525(2)","quote":"The board shall establish two classes of independent contractor licensees: (a) The nonexempt class is composed of the following entities: (A) Sole proprietorships, partnerships, corporations and limited liability companies with one or more employees; and (B) Partnerships, corporations and limited liability companies with more than two partners, corporate officers or members if any of the partners, officers or members are not part of the same family","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0090","citation":"OAR 808-003-0090(1)","quote":"The nonexempt class is composed of the following entities: (a) Sole proprietorships with one or more employees; (b) Partnerships or limited liability partnerships with one or more employees; (c) Partnerships or limited liability partnerships with more than two partners if any of the partners are not family members as defined in OAR 808-002-0390; (d) Joint ventures with one or more employees; (e) Joint ventures with more than two joint venturers if any of the joint venturers are not family members as defined in OAR 808-002-0390; (f) Limited partnerships with one or more employees; (g) Limited partnerships with more than two general partners if any of the general partners are not family members as defined in OAR 808-002-0390; (h) Corporations with one or more employees; (i) Corporations with more than two corporate officers if any of the corporate officers are not family members; (j) Trusts with one or more employees; (k) Trusts with more than two trustees if any of the trustees are not family members as defined in OAR 808-002-0390; (l) Limited liability companies with one or more employees; or (m) Limited liability companies with more than two members if any of the members are not family members as defined in OAR 808-002-0390.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.525","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b87ec22525945c04","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule authorizes five additional probationary conditions (contracts, invoices, permits, customer contact authorization, and site visit logs) that the statute does not explicitly permit, expanding the board's authority beyond the education course requirements stated in ORS 671.614(3) and (4).","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.614","citation":"ORS 671.614(3) and (4)","quote":"The board may require as a condition of probation imposed under this section that the landscape construction professional take a board-approved education course in one or more subjects relating to landscape operations... The board may require as a condition of probation imposed under this section that the owner or officer of the landscape contracting business take a board-approved education course in one or more subjects relating to landscape contracting business or general business practices.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0225","citation":"oar-808-003-0225","quote":"the board may, in addition to imposing conditions outlined in 671.614(3) & (4), require that the landscaping contracting business, landscaping contracting business owner or landscape construction professional: (1) Submit to the board copies of all written contracts entered into during the period of probation; (2) Submit to the board copies of all billing invoices (or those that the board specifies) issued during the period of probation; (3) Submit copies to the board of all permits required for landscaping work during the period of probation; (4) Authorize the board to contact the customers of the landscaping contracting business and supply to the board the names, addresses and phone numbers of such customers; and (5) Maintain a log of site visits and customer contacts during the period of probation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.614","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"86455c817185e53a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.540(15) & (16), but the statute has only 2 subsections; the rule actually implements subsections (1)(q) and (1)(r).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0328","citation":"ORS 671.540(15) & (16)","quote":"ORS 671.540(15) & (16)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.540","citation":"ORS 671.540(15)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.540","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"22edb5e496a3c7a2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 671.540(5), but the statute has only 2 subsections; the rule actually implements subsection (1)(e).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-002-0875","citation":"ORS 671.540(5)","quote":"ORS 671.540(5)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.540","citation":"ORS 671.540(5)","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.540","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"80b867cf64f60d23","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute sets the landscaping value threshold at $2,500 per residential dwelling, but the rule shows $3,000 for the first time period (2003-2008), a $500 numeric difference.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.540","citation":"ORS 671.540(1)(h)","quote":"if the total value of the landscaping is less than $2,500 per residential dwelling","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-003-0210","citation":"OAR 808-003-0210(1)","quote":"$3,000 if the landscaping work was completed September 1, 2003 and before September 1, 2008","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.540","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f82e19c6e8939de5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"For violations of ORS 671.610(5), the rule establishes penalties only through the fourth offense (3-year revocation) but the statute explicitly authorizes permanent revocation for fifth or subsequent offenses.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-671.997","citation":"ORS 671.997(4)(c)(C)","quote":"For a fifth or subsequent offense may provide for permanent revocation of the license","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-808-005-0020","citation":"OAR 808-005-0020(22)","quote":"(a) $1,000 for the first offense; (b) $2,000 for the second offense; (c) Six months suspension of the license for the third offense; and (d) Three-year revocation of license for a fourth offense.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.997","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"934a6c1143e3e63a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 804-027-0005 declares it implements ORS 671.425, but the operative text addresses only the qualifications, duties, and authority of Landscape Architects in Training, not reinstatement after revocation of registered landscape architects.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-804-027-0005","citation":"statutes_implemented declaration","quote":"ORS 671.315, ORS 671.316, ORS 671.335, ORS 671345, ORS 671.365, ORS 671.425, ORS 671.393","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.425","citation":"ORS 671.425","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.425","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7c48fc9da6d4c357","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 671.575, which requires landscape contractors to be licensed in order to file claims or bring suits, but the rule's operative text never addresses licensing requirements and only addresses procedural matters for processing claims transferred to courts.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-808-004-0520","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 183.415, ORS 183.460, ORS 671.703, ORS 671.575","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-671.575","citation":"ORS 671.575(1)","quote":"A landscape contracting business may not file a lien, file a claim with the State Landscape Contractors Board or bring or maintain in any court of this state a suit or action for compensation for the performance of any work or for the breach of any contract for work that is subject to ORS 671.510 to 671.760 and 671.997, unless the landscape contracting business was: (a) Licensed under ORS 671.510 to 671.760 at the time the landscape contracting business bid or entered into the contract for performance of the work; and (b) Licensed continuously while performing the work for which compensation is sought.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-671.575","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"091eddb59b4254c8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-contractors-board"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"state-board-of-architect-examiners","name":"State Board of Architect Examiners"}]},{"ors_chapter":"676","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":658,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 819-005-0005(4) defines the modality for hair procedures as 'Light energy hair removal,' but ORS 676.630(1)(f) lists 'Hair removal or reduction' as a modality without limiting it to light energy devices, despite the statute allowing procedures using 'a laser, intense pulsed light or other device.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.630","citation":"ORS 676.630(1)","quote":"a procedure that uses a laser, intense pulsed light or other device for nonablative procedures performed on the skin or hair, including, but not limited to, procedures performed in conjunction with one of the following modalities: ... (f) Hair removal or reduction","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-819-005-0005","citation":"OAR 819-005-0005(4)","quote":"Modality\" defined under ORS 676.630 means: (a) Light energy hair removal","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.630","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"607c6d035d2a95ad","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians"]},{"summary":"The rule is declared to implement ORS 676.616, which concerns delegation of authority to enter final orders in contested cases, but the rule's operative text addresses only disclosure requirements for traditional midwives and never engages with the statute's subject matter.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-332-025-0125","citation":"OAR 332-025-0125, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.615, ORS 676.616, ORS 687.410, ORS 687.145, ORS 687.420, ORS 687.425, ORS 687.445, ORS 687.480, ORS 687.493","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.616","citation":"ORS 676.616","quote":"The Health Licensing Office shall delegate the authority to enter a final order for all contested cases related to the practice of direct entry midwifery, as defined in ORS 687.405, to the State Board of Direct Entry Midwifery.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.616","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c8a2cf359710fd2e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-direct-entry-midwifery"]},{"summary":"OAR 125-300-0200(2) excludes Oregon Health Authority from the boards covered by the rule, but ORS 676.160(18) defines health professional regulatory board to include Oregon Health Authority to the extent it licenses emergency medical services providers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.160","citation":"ORS 676.160(18)","quote":"Oregon Health Authority, to the extent that the authority licenses emergency medical services providers","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-300-0200","citation":"OAR 125-300-0200(2)","quote":"Health Professional Regulatory Boards listed in ORS 676.160, other than the Oregon Health Authority with regard to certification of emergency technicians","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.160","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0c79ab0a168879d9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule 833-130-0080 declares implementation of ORS 676.150 but its operative text on discipline review for supervisors never engages with ORS 676.150's reporting requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-833-130-0080","citation":"ORS 675.705 - 675.835, ORS 676.150 - 676.405","quote":"ORS 675.705 - 675.835, ORS 676.150 - 676.405","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.150","citation":"ORS 676.150","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a2b1f276787d7c89","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists"]},{"summary":"Rule 850-050-0120 declares implementation of ORS 676.150 but its operative text addresses only general discipline framework without engaging ORS 676.150's reporting duties or Class A violation standard.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-850-050-0120","citation":"ORS 685.220, ORS 685.110 & 676.150","quote":"ORS 685.220, ORS 685.110 & 676.150","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-676.150","citation":"ORS 676.150","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"843341589deec5d2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-naturopathic-medicine"]},{"summary":"For self-referred licensees, the statute mandates enrollment upon attestation alone, but the rule conditions enrollment on additional requirements beyond attestation, making a mandatory provision conditional.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.190","citation":"ORS 676.190(6)(b)","quote":"The program shall enroll the licensee on the date on which the licensee attests that the licensee, to the best of the licensee's knowledge, is not under investigation by the licensee's health professional licensing board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0035","citation":"OAR 847-065-0035(1)","quote":"To be provisionally enrolled in the program, a self-referred licensee must: (a) Sign a written consent allowing disclosure and exchange of information among the contractor, the contractor's investigator, the licensee's employer, independent clinical evaluators and treatment providers; (b) Sign a written consent allowing disclosure and exchange of information among the contractor, the Board, the licensee's employer, independent clinical evaluators and treatment providers in the event the contractor determines the licensee to be in substantial non-compliance with their monitoring agreement as defined in OAR 847-065-0065; (c) Attest that the licensee is not, to the best of the licensee's knowledge, under investigation by the Board; and (d) Agree to and sign a provisional enrollment agreement","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.190","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cc04495eaa17979f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"The implementing rules declare they implement ORS 676.830 (credentialing for applied behavior analysis providers by health benefit plans), but none of the rules' operative text addresses health benefit plan credentialing requirements or engages substantively with that statute at all.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-824-010-0005","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-020-0040","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-030-0010","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-030-0020","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-030-0040","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992, House Bill 2048 (2023)","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992, House Bill 2048 (2023)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-036-0001","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-040-0010","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-050-0010","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-060-0010","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-070-0005","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-824-070-0010","citation":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote":"ORS 676.802-676.830, ORS 676.990, ORS 676.992","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.830","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"58fde8bca4e45870","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-behavior-analysis-regulatory-board"]},{"summary":"Multiple fee rules declare ORS 676.560 as the statute they implement, but ORS 676.560 addresses only the purpose and mission of the Health Licensing Office, not fee-setting authority. The fee rules actually cite ORS 676.576, ORS 676.592, or general authority as their statutory basis.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-300-0020","citation":"ORS 676.560, ORS 676.565 & ORS 681.700-681.730","quote":"Statutory/Other Implemented: ORS 676.560, ORS 676.565 & ORS 681.700-681.730","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-331-300-0020","citation":"ORS 676.576","quote":"Fees established by the Health Licensing Office pursuant to ORS 676.576 are as follows","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ece9ab2bf29ea070","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Multiple fee rules across different licensing schemes declare ORS 676.560 as implemented, but ORS 676.560 only establishes the office's mission and coordination role, not fee-setting authority.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-475-0010","citation":"ORS 676.560, ORS 676.565 & ORS 676.665-676.689","quote":"Statutory/Other Implemented: ORS 676.560, ORS 676.565 & ORS 676.665-676.689","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-331-475-0010","citation":"ORS 676.576","quote":"Fees established by the Office pursuant to ORS 676.576 are as follows","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.560","citation":"ORS 676.560","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85a91b50ddef4bda","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Body art licensing fee rules declare ORS 676.560 as a statute they implement for fee-setting, but ORS 676.560 does not authorize fees.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-940-0000","citation":"676.560","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: 676.560","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-331-940-0000","citation":"ORS 676.560","quote":"Fees established by the Office are as follows: (a) Application: (A) Standard Body Piercing — $50","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.560","citation":"ORS 676.560","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.560","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"897e08e19d513d21","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Rule 819-020-0150 declares it implements ORS 676.640 and ORS 676.655, but its operative text never cites or engages with ORS 676.640, only ORS 676.655, and the provided ORS 676.640 statute contains no provisions about examination retakes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-819-020-0150","citation":"OAR 819-020-0150 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.640, ORS 676.655","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-819-020-0150","citation":"OAR 819-020-0150(1)","quote":"Pursuant to ORS 676.655(1)(a) in order for an applicant to retake a written examination:","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.640","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6a717b43523e8cfb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians"]},{"summary":"The statute requires clinical assessments to follow the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5-TR), but rules define DSM as DSM-5 without the Text Revision specification.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.200","citation":"ORS 676.200(2)(a)(A)","quote":"Provides a comprehensive clinical assessment of the licensee including both a mental health disorder assessment and an alcohol or substance use disorder assessment, according to guidelines established by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5-TR)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-415-065-0010","citation":"OAR 415-065-0010(10)","quote":"\"DSM\" means the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-5, published by the American Psychiatric Association on May 18, 2013.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.200","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"466ec18289ac476a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 830-011-0010 declares it implements ORS 676.300, but its operative text addresses only Board organization, employees, meetings, and officer elections—topics entirely unrelated to the statute's subject of health care providers' authority to notify law enforcement about intoxicated drivers.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-830-011-0010","citation":"OAR 830-011-0010, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.300, ORS 676.306, ORS 692.300, ORS 692.310, ORS 692.320","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.300","citation":"ORS 676.300","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.300","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4f4847058f83b74c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mortuary-and-cemetery-board"]},{"summary":"The statute mandates the board 'shall assign' investigators when a complaint is received, but the rule makes investigation discretionary by stating the Authority 'may conduct' an investigation.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.165","citation":"ORS 676.165(1)","quote":"the board shall assign one or more persons to act as investigator of the complaint","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-265-0085","citation":"OAR 333-265-0085(3)","quote":"Upon receipt of a report or complaint about an EMS provider or applicant, the Authority may conduct an investigation as described under ORS 676.165 and 682.220","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.165","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"57991994eeb079c9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the investigator to make the report within 120 days of receiving the complaint (with extensions possible), but this rule implementing ORS 676.165 does not mention any reporting deadline.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.165","citation":"ORS 676.165(4)","quote":"The investigator shall make the report to the board not later than 120 days after the board receives the complaint","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-265-0085","citation":"OAR 333-265-0085","quote":"declared statutes_implemented: ORS 676.165, ORS 676.175, ORS 682.017, ORS 682.220, ORS 682.224","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.165","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eceab335d1e248c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"The statute authorizes malpractice insurance premium subsidies for providers in 'rural or medically underserved areas,' but the rule restricts the insurance subsidy to rural areas only.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.454","citation":"ORS 676.454(1)(c)(C)","quote":"Medical malpractice insurance premium subsidies","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.454","citation":"ORS 676.454 opening","quote":"qualified health care providers who commit to serving medical assistance and Medicare enrollees in rural or medically underserved areas of this state","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-409-036-0050","citation":"OAR 409-036-0050(2)(a)","quote":"Provide health services in rural Oregon","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.454","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e0bccd4b0629dd46","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics"]},{"summary":"The statute lists 'Stipends' as a type of incentive that may be provided, but the implementing rules do not explicitly address or provide for stipends in any rule section.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.454","citation":"ORS 676.454(1)(c)(B)","quote":"Stipends","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-409-036-0020","citation":"OAR 409-036-0020","quote":"The types of incentives that may be provided under the Program include: (1) Loan Repayment subsidies... (2) Primary Care Loan Forgiveness Payments... (3) Incentive opportunity for scholarships... (4) Incentive opportunities specific to Health Care Workforce Scholarships... (5) Rural medical practitioner insurance subsidies... (6) Community Workforce Assistance Grants... (7) Other Incentives Opportunities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.454","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a831fd42e7faf472","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics"]},{"summary":"The statute lists 'Paying the moving expenses of providers not located in rural or medically underserved areas who commit to relocate to such areas' as a specific type of incentive, but the implementing rules do not explicitly provide for moving expenses as a designated incentive type.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.454","citation":"ORS 676.454(1)(c)(F)","quote":"Paying the moving expenses of providers not located in rural or medically underserved areas who commit to relocate to such areas","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-409-036-0020","citation":"OAR 409-036-0020","quote":"The types of incentives that may be provided under the Program include: (1) Loan Repayment subsidies... (2) Primary Care Loan Forgiveness Payments... (3) Incentive opportunity for scholarships... (4) Incentive opportunities specific to Health Care Workforce Scholarships... (5) Rural medical practitioner insurance subsidies... (6) Community Workforce Assistance Grants... (7) Other Incentives Opportunities","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.454","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c38045b9e8974864","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics"]},{"summary":"The statute limits scholarships at non-OHSU institutions to specific provider types (doctor of osteopathic medicine, dentistry, nurse practitioner, physician associate, certified registered nurse anesthetist), but OAR 409-036-0040 allows scholarships for eligible students in any health professional Training Program as defined broadly by the Authority.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.454","citation":"ORS 676.454(1)(c)(E)","quote":"Scholarships for students at institutions of higher education based in this state who are enrolled in health professional training programs leading to a doctor of osteopathic medicine or doctor of dentistry or a license as a nurse practitioner, physician associate or certified registered nurse anesthetist","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-409-036-0040","citation":"OAR 409-036-0040(4)(a)","quote":"Be an institution that provides health care related training serving students located in Oregon","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.454","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3b5d308547edebd6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics"]},{"summary":"OAR 851-062-0071 requires cultural competency continuing education (2 hours) for reinstatement of a lapsed certification, but the statute limits the requirement to 'renewal' only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.850","citation":"ORS 676.850(2)(a)","quote":"Completion of the continuing education described in this subsection shall be a condition of renewal of an authorization to practice the profession regulated by the board every other time that the person's authorization is subject to renewal.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-851-062-0071","citation":"OAR 851-062-0071(1)(d)","quote":"Completion of two hours of cultural competency continuing education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.850","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a60630068979effc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-nursing"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the licensing requirement from ORS 676.110(1)(b), which mandates that an individual must be licensed by a health professional regulatory board (or be working under an approved residency contract) in order to use the title 'doctor.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.110","citation":"ORS 676.110(1)(b)","quote":"Is licensed by a health professional regulatory board to practice the particular health care profession in which the individual's doctoral degree was earned; or (B) Is working under a board-approved residency contract and is practicing under the license of a supervisor who is licensed by the health professional regulatory board to practice the particular health care profession in which the individual's doctoral degree was earned.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-070-0020","citation":"OAR 847-070-0020(5)","quote":"As provided in ORS 676.110, an acupuncturist who has earned a doctoral degree in acupuncture may use the title \"doctor\" in connection with the practice of acupuncture if: (a) The doctoral degree program holds federally recognized accreditation, and (b) The specific doctoral degree is designated in all professional communications as required by ORS 676.110(2).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.110","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0372680737216cc6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 817-007-0350(5) requires posting of temporary and demonstration authorizations, but statute 676.572(9) explicitly exempts these types from the section's requirements.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.572","citation":"ORS 676.572(9)","quote":"This section does not apply to temporary authorizations or authorizations related to demonstration permits.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-817-007-0350","citation":"OAR 817-007-0350(5)","quote":"Demonstration and temporary authorizations must be posted in public view.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.572","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a4dacbb8ab4928c4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-cosmetology"]},{"summary":"Rules declare they implement ORS 676.194, but their operative text never engages with that statute, which concerns the establishment and governance of an Impaired Health Professional Program Work Group, while the rules address only the substantive HPSP program requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-065-0010","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 677.200, ORS 676.194, OL 2025 chapter 499, section 2-3","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0015","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 676.200, ORS 676.194, OL 2025 chapter 499, section 2-3","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0020","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 676.200, ORS 676.194","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0025","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 676.200, ORS 676.194, OL 2025 chapter 499, sections 2-3","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0055","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 676.200, ORS 676.194, OL 2025 chapter 499, sections 2-3","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-065-0065","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.190, ORS 676.185, ORS 676.200, ORS 676.194, OL 2025 chapter 499, sections 2-3","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.194","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e2dea8709938803c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"The rule adds requirements for CPR, first aid, blood borne pathogens training, collaborative agreement, and proof of active esthetic certificate that the statute does not require.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.645","citation":"ORS 676.645(1)","quote":"To renew a certificate under this section, a certified advanced esthetician must submit to the Health Licensing Office: (a) A renewal application; (b) Proof that the certified advanced esthetician has completed any continuing education requirements established by the Board of Certified Advanced Estheticians by rule; and (c) The applicable renewal fee established under ORS 676.576.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-819-025-0010","citation":"OAR 819-025-0010(3)","quote":"To avoid delinquency penalties, a certification holder must renew prior to the certification entering inactive status. The certification holder must submit the following: (a) Renewal application form; (b) Payment of required renewal fees pursuant to OAR 819-040-0005; (c) Attestation of having obtained required annual continuing education under OAR 819-025-0020 and 819-020-0030, on a form prescribed by the Office, whether certification is current or inactive; (d) Attestation of current certification in cardiopulmonary resuscitation from an Office-approved provider; (e) Attestation of current first aid training by an Office-approved provider; (f) Attestation of current certification in blood borne pathogens training from an Office-approved provider; (g) Attestation of having a collaborative agreement with a health-care provider pursuant to OAR 819-030-0020; and (h) Provide proof of having an active esthetic certificate through the Board of Cosmetology pursuant to ORS 690.046 and be in good standing with no current or pending disciplinary action.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.645","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4528f1f78c28ce3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians"]},{"summary":"Multiple rules declare implementation of ORS 676.608 (about investigative authority) but their operative text never engages with investigative authority at all - they address tattoo licensing, curriculum, examinations, and continuing education requirements instead.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-915-0005","citation":"OAR 331-915-0005, declared statutes (frontmatter)","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-331-920-0000","citation":"OAR 331-920-0000, declared statutes (frontmatter)","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.608","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"93b5c4f70c25bc25","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Rule oar-331-718-0010 is declared to implement ORS 676.576 (Fees), but the rule text addresses only pharmacological agent administration, monitoring requirements, and policies—not fees, fee collection, or any matter within the scope of ORS 676.576.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-718-0010","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 676.615, ORS 688.830, ORS 688.800, ORS 676.576","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.576","citation":"ORS 676.576","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.576","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"af627f1ab087c130","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"The rule restricts liability protection to optometric services provided 'to defined charitable organizations,' but ORS 676.340 contains no such organizational limitation and only requires services be provided 'without compensation' to any patient.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.340","citation":"ORS 676.340(1)","quote":"a health practitioner described in subsection (7) of this section who has registered under ORS 676.345 and who provides health care services without compensation is not liable for any injury, death or other loss arising out of the provision of those services","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-852-050-0022","citation":"OAR 852-050-0022(1)","quote":"An active status licensee may register with the Board at no additional charge to qualify for the provisions of ORS 676.340, which provides registrants with specific exemptions from liability for the provision of optometric services to defined charitable organizations without compensation under the terms of the law.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.340","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f5474e9753050619","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-optometry"]},{"summary":"Rule 337-021-0073 declares it implements ORS 676.410(7), but that provision addresses database creation/maintenance, not the surcharge or questionnaire requirement that the rule's operative text establishes.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-337-021-0073","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 688.425, ORS 676.410(7)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.410","citation":"ORS 676.410(7)","quote":"Using information collected under subsection (2) of this section, the authority shall create and maintain a health care workforce database.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d70636f28abd2df4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-medical-imaging"]},{"summary":"Rule 409-026-0130 allows fees to cover costs of 'compiling, maintaining, and analyzing' health care workforce information, but the statute limits fees to reimburse 'the actual cost of obtaining or reporting information.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-409-026-0130","citation":"OAR 409-026-0130(1)","quote":"The fee shall be calculated by adding the costs necessary to compile, maintain, and analyze the health care workforce information and dividing that cost by the approximate number of individuals licensed in Oregon.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.410","citation":"ORS 676.410(6)","quote":"The amount of fees established under this subsection must be reasonably calculated to reimburse the actual cost of obtaining or reporting information as required by subsection (2) of this section.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.410","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e9a3f3c44fbbe153","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics"]},{"summary":"OAR 335-005-0026 applies ORS 676.175 (which addresses investigations of licensee or applicant conduct) to criminal background checks for fitness determination, which the statute does not contemplate.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-335-005-0026","citation":"OAR 335-005-0026(8)","quote":"Criminal offender information is confidential. Dissemination of information received under this rule is part of the investigation of an applicant or licensee and as such is confidential pursuant to ORS 676.175.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.175","citation":"ORS 676.175(1)","quote":"A health professional regulatory board shall keep confidential and not disclose to the public any information obtained by the board as part of an investigation of a licensee or applicant, including complaints concerning licensee or applicant conduct","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.175","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"47e2c7e8187e9b6b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology"]},{"summary":"The statute requires certified advanced estheticians to 'maintain client disclosure forms' but does not explicitly require providing them to clients; the rule requires both maintaining and providing them to each client.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.655","citation":"ORS 676.655(2)(b)","quote":"Requiring a certified advanced esthetician to maintain client disclosure forms that include, at a minimum, disclosure of the existence of professional liability insurance","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-819-030-0010","citation":"OAR 819-030-0010","quote":"A certified advanced esthetician must maintain and provide to each client a 'client disclosure form' pursuant to ORS 676.655, which includes at minimum the existence of professional liability insurance.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.655","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"42c2d48f129b3d97","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians"]},{"summary":"The rule allows suicide risk assessment CME to count toward general CME hours but fails to implement the statute's core requirement that licensees report completion of such education to the board upon reauthorization.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.860","citation":"ORS 676.860(2)","quote":"In collaboration with the Oregon Health Authority, a board shall adopt rules to require a licensee regulated by the board to report to the board, upon reauthorization to practice, the licensee's completion of any continuing education regarding suicide risk assessment, treatment and management.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-008-0070","citation":"OAR 847-008-0070(6)(b)","quote":"CME in suicide risk assessment, treatment and management is considered relevant CME for the current practice of all licensees and may be used toward satisfying the required CME hours.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.860","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"61a94f6b016310e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"The rule's operative text addresses discipline review procedures and supervisor registry placement, but never engages with ORS 676.405's subject matter of releasing personal contact information (email, home address, phone number).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-833-130-0080","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 675.705 - 675.835, ORS 676.150 - 676.405","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.405","citation":"ORS 676.405","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.405","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b5df7fbcc368ad17","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists"]},{"summary":"Rule for physician assistants uses wrong profession in section (6), stating applicants may obtain temporary authorization to practice medicine when the rule is about physician assistants","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-050-0022","citation":"OAR 847-050-0022(6)","quote":"A military spouse or domestic partner may obtain a temporary authorization for a license to practice medicine after satisfying sections (2) through (5) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.308","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bc9044d9784fe755","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"Rule for acupuncturists uses wrong profession in section (5), stating applicants may obtain temporary authorization to practice medicine when the rule is about acupuncturists","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-070-0024","citation":"OAR 847-070-0024(5)","quote":"A military spouse or domestic partner may obtain a temporary authorization for a license to practice medicine after satisfying sections (2) through (4) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.308","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"90232d815543c84a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"Rule for podiatrists uses wrong profession in section (6), stating applicants may obtain temporary authorization to practice medicine when the rule is about podiatrists","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-847-080-0016","citation":"OAR 847-080-0016(6)","quote":"A military spouse or domestic partner may obtain a temporary authorization for a license to practice medicine after satisfying sections (2) through (5) of this rule.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.308","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fa6116afcca059ce","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"The ASC rule requires a circulating nurse only when general anesthesia is used, while the hospital rule requires one for anesthesia or conscious sedation, creating an inconsistent standard between the two facility types.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-333-076-0137","citation":"OAR 333-076-0137(5)","quote":"In all cases requiring general anesthesia, a circulating nurse shall be assigned to, and present in, an operating room for the duration of the surgical procedure","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-520-0050","citation":"OAR 333-520-0050(5)","quote":"In all cases requiring anesthesia or conscious sedation, a circulating nurse shall be assigned to, and present in, an operating room for the duration of the surgical procedure","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.870","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"6cdc831c3ea07993","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 819-005-0015 makes election of chairperson and vice chairperson optional (may) when the statute mandates it (shall).","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.650","citation":"ORS 676.650(5)","quote":"The voting members of the board shall select one of the voting members as chairperson and another voting member as vice chairperson.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-819-005-0015","citation":"oar-819-005-0015","quote":"The chairperson and vice chairperson may be elected at the request of the Board.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.650","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e6243cfd76c2d46b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians"]},{"summary":"Two rules directly contradict each other on minimum meeting frequency: one requires six times per year, the other only once per year.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-830-011-0010","citation":"OAR 830-011-0010(2)","quote":"The Board shall meet at least six times per year, at a date, time, and place determined by the Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-852-010-0005","citation":"OAR 852-010-0005(1)","quote":"The Board must hold regular meetings at least once each year at such time and place as the Board may designate.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.306","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"85a8489c8f44a188","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-optometry","mortuary-and-cemetery-board"]},{"summary":"Rule narrows executive director supervision from the statutory requirement of supervision by the appointing board to supervision by only the board president.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.306","citation":"ORS 676.306(2)","quote":"The executive director shall serve at the pleasure of the Governor under the direct supervision of the appointing board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-830-011-0010","citation":"OAR 830-011-0010(4)","quote":"The executive director shall act under instruction of the president of the Board, and in his/her absence the vice-president and shall be responsible for supervising and monitoring the activities of the Board's office and staff.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.306","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c83c2a9b757cce8a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mortuary-and-cemetery-board"]},{"summary":"331-920-0000 declares it implements ORS 676.625 but its operative text is purely a prohibition statement that contains no provisions addressing the Health Licensing Office Account, fees, records, appropriations, or any substantive element of ORS 676.625.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-920-0000","citation":"OAR 331-920-0000","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.625","citation":"ORS 676.625","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.625","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c3103ede55756b6e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"331-920-0005 declares it implements ORS 676.625 but its operative text is purely a prohibition statement that contains no provisions addressing the Health Licensing Office Account, fees, records, appropriations, or any substantive element of ORS 676.625.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-920-0005","citation":"OAR 331-920-0005","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.625","citation":"ORS 676.625","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.625","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"db99b61c8815eddf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"OAR 339-010-0012 limits fingerprinting requirement to applicants for license, reinstatement applicants, and licensees renewing, but omits the statute's authority to require fingerprints of board employees or volunteers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.303","citation":"ORS 676.303(3)","quote":"a health professional regulatory board may require the fingerprints of a licensee seeking renewal of a license, an applicant for a license, a board employee or volunteer or an applicant for employment with the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-339-010-0012","citation":"OAR 339-010-0012","quote":"The Board may require Oregon or National criminal history checks, including fingerprints or other background checks such as the Law Enforcement Data System (LEDS), from any applicants for a license as an occupational therapist or occupational therapy assistant, a limited permit, or an applicant to reinstate a lapsed license. ... The Board may conduct a criminal record check on licensees applying to renew a license","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.303","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1ff964cc34e72e4b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["occupational-therapy-licensing-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 847-008-0068 limits fingerprinting requirement to applicants and licensees, but omits the statute's authority to require fingerprints of board employees or volunteers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.303","citation":"ORS 676.303(3)","quote":"a health professional regulatory board may require the fingerprints of a licensee seeking renewal of a license, an applicant for a license, a board employee or volunteer or an applicant for employment with the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-847-008-0068","citation":"OAR 847-008-0068(2)","quote":"The Board may require legible fingerprints for the purpose of a criminal records check and fitness determination of all applicants and licensees, including: (a) Applicants for a license; (b) Licensees applying to reactivate a license; (c) Licensees renewing a license; and (d) Licensees under investigation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.303","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bbc7154f114e5509","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-medical-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 852-050-0025 limits fingerprinting requirement to applicants and licensees, but omits the statute's authority to require fingerprints of board employees or volunteers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.303","citation":"ORS 676.303(3)","quote":"a health professional regulatory board may require the fingerprints of a licensee seeking renewal of a license, an applicant for a license, a board employee or volunteer or an applicant for employment with the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-852-050-0025","citation":"OAR 852-050-0025(2)","quote":"The Board may require legible fingerprints for the purpose of a criminal records check and fitness determination of all applicants and licensees including: (a) Applicants for a license; (b) Licensees applying to reactivate a license; (c) Licensees applying to reinstate a license, (d) Licenses applying to renew a license (e) Licensees renewing a license; and (f) Licensees under investigation","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.303","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a5f0319c3fe3f435","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-optometry"]},{"summary":"OAR 858-010-0034 limits fingerprinting requirement to applicants for licensure and licensees under investigation, but omits the statute's authority to require fingerprints of board employees or volunteers.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.303","citation":"ORS 676.303(3)","quote":"a health professional regulatory board may require the fingerprints of a licensee seeking renewal of a license, an applicant for a license, a board employee or volunteer or an applicant for employment with the board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-858-010-0034","citation":"OAR 858-010-0034(2)","quote":"The following persons (\"subject individuals\") must take the steps necessary to complete a nationwide criminal records check under ORS 181A.195: (a) All applicants for licensure; and (b) Licensees under investigation by the Board, when the Board has a rational reason to determine if the licensee has a history of criminal behavior","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.303","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e424afcb843c1cf3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology"]},{"summary":"oar-331-910-0060 declares it implements ORS 676.618, but the rule's operative text is entirely about continuing education audits and documentation, which ORS 676.618 does not address; that statute concerns facility inspections for safety, infection control, and sterilization compliance.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-910-0060","citation":"oar-331-910-0060, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"676.618, 690.350, 690.390, 690.405","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.618","citation":"ORS 676.618(1)","quote":"Upon its own motion or upon any complaint, the Health Licensing Office may conduct an inspection to determine whether a facility or a part of the facility that is the subject of the inspection complies with the authorization, safety, infection control and sterilization requirements imposed by statute or rule of the office or the boards and councils administered by the office.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.618","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"002eb0f2c9889c16","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Rule 331-920-0000 declares it implements ORS 676.612, but the rule's operative text only addresses prohibition of dermal implanting services. ORS 676.612 governs only disciplinary authority and fingerprint requirements for existing authorization holders, not service prohibitions.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-920-0000","citation":"OAR 331-920-0000","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-676.612","citation":"ORS 676.612","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc7ab8085ac7f65e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"Rules 331-915-0005 through 331-915-0060 declare they implement ORS 676.612, but these rules' operative texts address tattoo licensure requirements, education standards, examination procedures, and continuing education—subjects never addressed in ORS 676.612, which is purely about disciplinary authority and fingerprint requirements.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-915-0005","citation":"OAR 331-915-0005","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-331-915-0015","citation":"OAR 331-915-0015","quote":"ORS 676.607, ORS 676.608, ORS 676.612, ORS 676.615, ORS 676.625, ORS 690.350, ORS 690.360, ORS 690.365, ORS 690.370, ORS 690.380, ORS 390.385, ORS 690.390, ORS 690.405, ORS 690.407, ORS 690.410, ORS 690.415, 2011 OL Ch. 346 § 22, ORS 35","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.612","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"52c0b7393f7ad437","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]},{"summary":"OAR 818-021-0088(1)(f) requires dentists and dental hygienists registering for liability limitation to volunteer a minimum of 80 hours per renewal cycle, but ORS 676.345 imposes no such hour requirement for registration.","type":"other","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.345","citation":"ORS 676.345(2)","quote":"All health practitioners registering under the program must provide the health professional regulatory boards with: (a) A statement that the health practitioner will provide health care services to patients without compensation, except for reimbursement for laboratory fees, testing services and other out-of-pocket expenses; (b) A statement that the health practitioner will provide the notice required by ORS 676.340(2) in the manner provided by ORS 676.340(2) before providing the services; and (c) A statement that the health practitioner will only provide health care services without compensation that are within the scope of the health practitioner's license.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-818-021-0088","citation":"OAR 818-021-0088(1)(f)","quote":"Licensee must agree to volunteer for a minimum of 80 hours in Oregon per renewal cycle.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c6c91843df3886f0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-dentistry"]},{"summary":"OAR 415-065-0010(21) adds items (i) and (j) to the definition of 'Substantial Non-Compliance' that are not enumerated in ORS 676.185(4), expanding the scope beyond the statute's explicit list.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-676.185","citation":"ORS 676.185(4)","quote":"\"Substantial noncompliance\" includes the following: (a) Criminal behavior; (b) Conduct that causes injury, death or harm to the public, or a patient, including sexual impropriety with a patient; (c) Impairment in a health care setting in the course of employment; (d) A positive toxicology test result as determined by federal regulations pertaining to drug testing; (e) Violation of a restriction on a licensee's practice imposed by the impaired health professional program established under ORS 676.190 or the licensee's health professional licensing board; (f) Civil commitment for mental illness; (g) Failure to participate in the program after entering into a monitoring agreement under ORS 676.190; or (h) Failure to enroll in the program after being referred to the program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-415-065-0010","citation":"OAR 415-065-0010(21)","quote":"\"Substantial Non-Compliance\" means but is not limited to the following when they occur after a licensee entered into a monitoring agreement. (a) Criminal behavior; (b) Conduct that causes injury, death or harm to the public, or a patient, including sexual impropriety with a patient; (c) Impairment in a health care setting in the course of employment; (d) A positive toxicology test result as determined by federal regulations pertaining to drug testing; (e) Violation of a restriction on a licensee's practice imposed by the program or the licensee's health profession licensing board (f) Civil commitment for mental illness; (g) Failure to participate in the program after entering into a monitoring agreement under ORS 676.190; (h) Failure to enroll in the program after being referred to the program; (i) Violation of a provision of a licensee's monitoring agreement that gives rise to concerns about the licensee's ability or willingness to participate in the program; or (j) Violation of a Board's rules establishing additional requirements for licensees referred to the program in accordance with ORS 676.200(1)(c).","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-676.185","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0826d053f84532a9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"board-of-medical-imaging","name":"Board of Medical Imaging"},{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Licensed Professional Counselors and Therapists"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"mortuary-and-cemetery-board","name":"Mortuary and Cemetery Board"},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-naturopathic-medicine","name":"Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority Equity and Inclusion Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-behavior-analysis-regulatory-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Behavior Analysis Regulatory Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-certified-advanced-estheticians","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Certified Advanced Estheticians"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-cosmetology","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Cosmetology"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-direct-entry-midwifery","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Direct Entry Midwifery"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-licensed-dietitians","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Licensed Dietitians"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-environmental-health-registration-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Environmental Health Registration Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-long-term-care-administrators-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Long Term Care Administrators Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"693","agencies":2,"rules_reviewed":12,"candidates":[{"summary":"A plumbing-licensure rule narrows the statute's owner-work exemption from 'any building or premises' to 'residential building' only.","documents":[{"id":"ors-693.020","citation":"ORS 693.020(1)(a)","quote":"this chapter does not apply to: (a) A person working on a building or premises owned by the person...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-695-0020","citation":"OAR 918-695-0020(1)(a)","quote":"A license is not required for: (a) A person to do the person's own work on the person's own residential building on the person's own premises...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cba0b92e6beb9974","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]},{"summary":"The commercial/industrial carve-back is statute-scoped to exemptions (1)(a)-(d), but the rule restates it as a freestanding universal licensure requirement.","documents":[{"id":"ors-693.020","citation":"ORS 693.020(2)","quote":"Subsection (1)(a) to (d) of this section does not allow a person other than a journeyman plumber or apprentice plumber to install, remodel or alter plumbing in a commercial or industrial building...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-695-0020","citation":"OAR 918-695-0020(2)","quote":"All plumbing installations, alterations or remodeling in a commercial or industrial building ... shall be made by a licensed Oregon journeyman plumber...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b6527e4f12e804d1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]},{"summary":"A journeyman renewal fee ($180 flat) may exceed the statutory per-year cap ($50 base + $25 CE = up to $150 for a 2-year term) depending on an unstated renewal-cycle length.","documents":[{"id":"ors-693.135","citation":"ORS 693.135(2) & (7)","quote":"(2) For a journeyman plumber license renewal, $50 per year. ... (7) For continuing education for renewing a license, $25 per year.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-780-0030","citation":"OAR 918-780-0030(3)","quote":"Journeyman plumber: ... Renewal fee — $180, including $30 fee to track continuing education.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Unresolved without the renewal-cycle-length rule, not in this cluster.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2152e793b22201a2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]},{"summary":"A statute-side implemented_by claim (ORS 693.030 → OAR 918-695-0040) contradicts the rule's own self-declared 'Statutes/Other Implemented' line, which lists 693.030 as authority only.","documents":[{"id":"ors-693.030","citation":"ORS 693.030 relationships","quote":"implemented_by: [oar-918-695-0040]","quote_verified":"absence"},{"id":"oar-918-695-0040","citation":"OAR 918-695-0040 own verbatim text","quote":"Statutory/Other Authority: ORS 455.117, 693.030 & 693.120 Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 455.117 & 693.120","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Same authority/implements-conflation pattern repeats for OAR 918-780-0030 and ORS 693.135.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"87e11a9f6327a233","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]}],"artifacts":["ORS 693.103's sliced text contains a stray disconnected \"(12)\" fragment near a cross-reference to ORS 479.630."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"701","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":518,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute defines 'specialized education program' broadly to include programs from accredited colleges with 2-4 year degrees and apprenticeships, but the rules restrict implementation to only lead-based paint and lead safe work practices training.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.120","citation":"ORS 701.120(1)","quote":"a 'specialized education program' means one or more of the following: (a) A structured program that is approved or certified by an appropriate state or federal agency, or by an organization recognized by the Construction Contractors Board as representing construction contractors, and is designed to educate contractors to deal with one or more specific consumer health or safety issues. (b) A board-approved program from an accredited college or university that grants a two-year or four-year degree upon successful completion of the program. (c) An apprenticeship program that is approved by the board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-011-0000","citation":"OAR 812-011-0000(2)","quote":"The purpose of these rules is to provide needed information to the public about contractors who have successfully completed accredited abatement training or training in approved lead safe work practices.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.120","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"da2ebbc5ff6a77af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule extends notification requirement to individuals and persons who are not contractors, when statute requires only \"contractors\" to notify the board.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-007-0032","citation":"OAR 812-007-0032(1)","quote":"Individuals licensed to engage in LBP activities, contractors licensed to engage in LBP activities and certified LBP renovation contractors shall notify the board of any change in mailing or e-mail addresses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.117","citation":"ORS 701.117(1)","quote":"A contractor shall notify the Construction Contractors Board of","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"45c5e3a55a3bb146","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule extends notification requirement to certified home inspectors when statute requires only \"contractors\" to notify the board.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-008-0065","citation":"OAR 812-008-0065(1)","quote":"Certified home inspectors shall notify the board of any change in mailing or e-mail addresses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.117","citation":"ORS 701.117(1)","quote":"A contractor shall notify the Construction Contractors Board of","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2866b7401ec0e71d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule extends notification requirement to certified locksmiths when statute requires only \"contractors\" to notify the board.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-030-0235","citation":"OAR 812-030-0235(1)","quote":"Certified locksmiths shall notify the board of any change in mailing or e-mail addresses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.117","citation":"ORS 701.117(1)","quote":"A contractor shall notify the Construction Contractors Board of","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2f4789128db78b47","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule adds requirement that parties notify the board of email address changes and attorney changes, which the statute does not require.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-004-1210","citation":"OAR 812-004-1210(2)","quote":"A party must notify the agency in writing within 10 days of any change in the party's address, e-mail address, withdrawal or change of the party's attorney or change of address of the party's attorney","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.117","citation":"ORS 701.117(1)","quote":"A contractor shall notify the Construction Contractors Board of: (a) Any change of address","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4b5f0a07cc3ca472","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule adds timing condition that forwarding addresses are not effective until entered into agency records or 7 calendar days pass, a requirement not stated in the statute.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0440","citation":"OAR 812-002-0440(2)","quote":"A forwarding address is not effective as a \"last known address of record\" until the address is entered into agency records or seven calendar days after the agency receives notice of the forwarding address, whichever occurs first.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.117","citation":"ORS 701.117(1)","quote":"A contractor shall notify the Construction Contractors Board of: (a) Any change of address while licensed and for one year following the date the contractor's license expires or otherwise becomes inactive","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.117","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd9666c5de039df6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule applies the 701.227 disqualification list to violations of ORS 279C.590 (subcontractor disclosure requirements), but the statute 701.227 limits placement on the list to two scenarios: contractors who failed to pay suppliers within 60 days, or persons who supplied false/bad faith information about non-payment.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800(33)(c)-(d)","quote":"Placement of the contractor on a list of contractors not eligible to bid on public contracts established to ORS 701.227(4), for a period of up to six months for a second offense if the offense occurs within three years of the first offense. (d) Placement of the contractor on a list of contractors not eligible to bid on public contracts established to ORS 701.227(4), for a period of up to one year for a third or subsequent offense if the offense occurs within three years of the first offense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.227","citation":"ORS 701.227(1)-(3)","quote":"The Construction Contractors Board shall begin an action to determine whether a contractor or a subcontractor shall be considered not qualified to hold or participate in a public contract for a public improvement upon receipt of information from a public contracting agency or from any person who supplied labor or materials in connection with a public contract for a public improvement indicating that the contractor or subcontractor has not made payment to persons who supplied labor or materials within 60 days after the date when the payment was received by the contractor or subcontractor... If the board determines that the information supplied to the board against a contractor or subcontractor was supplied in bad faith or was false, the person who supplied the information in bad faith or supplied false information shall be placed on the list","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.227","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dbce082ba9b9ac19","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-030-0240(1) states a certified locksmith must either work for a licensed contractor or 'be otherwise exempt under ORS 701.490,' but ORS 701.490 provides exemptions from certification itself, making it logically impossible for a person to be simultaneously certified and exempt from the requirement to be certified.","type":"internal","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-030-0240","citation":"OAR 812-030-0240(1)","quote":"In order to work as a locksmith, a certified locksmith must: (a) Be an owner or employee of a licensed construction contractor, including, but not limited to, a residential locksmith services contractor; or (b) Be otherwise exempt under ORS 701.490.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.490","citation":"ORS 701.490","quote":"ORS 701.480 and 701.485 do not apply to: (1) A person offering key duplication services at a fixed location or ancillary to other business activities, if the person does not undertake, offer to undertake or submit a bid to undertake other locksmith services [and 10 other exempted categories]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.490","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b95e0296aabddc0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule requires documentation of key employee experience only for licenses obtained pursuant to Oregon Laws 2018, but the statute requires certification of key employee experience for all commercial general contractors and commercial specialty contractors upon license application or renewal.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.050","citation":"ORS 701.050(1)","quote":"A commercial general contractor or commercial specialty contractor shall certify upon license application or renewal that the contractor has one or more key employees with the combined total amount of experience required under ORS 701.084.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0260","citation":"OAR 812-003-0260(1)(r)","quote":"For licenses obtained pursuant to Oregon Laws 2018, chapter 46, sections 1 and 2, and OAR 812-006-0162, forms prescribed by the agency that document and verify qualifying work experience.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.050","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a3445f49a8df2724","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-022-0028(7)-(9) deems certain courses automatically approved without the board considering course content, which the statute requires the board to do for all courses.","type":"narrowing","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.267","citation":"ORS 701.267(3)","quote":"In determining whether to approve a course as continuing education described in ORS 701.082 (1)(c), the board shall consider the course content.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-022-0028","citation":"OAR 812-022-0028(7)-(9)","quote":"Courses offered by the State of Oregon, the United States government or any other state or local governmental agencies are deemed approved. Courses offered by accredited universities, colleges or community colleges are deemed approved. Courses offered through the Oregon Small Business Development Center Network are deemed approved.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.267","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b9e2c269bbdf3e55","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-005-0800(16) penalizes failure to comply with ORS chapters 316, 656, or 657, but ORS 701.106(1)(b) includes violations of both 'ORS chapter 316 or 317' among the sanctionable offenses, leaving chapter 317 unaddressed by the rule.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.106","citation":"ORS 701.106(1)(b)","quote":"ORS chapter 316 or 317","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800(16)","quote":"Failure to comply with any part of ORS chapters 316, 656, or 657 or with ORS 701.035, 701.046 or 701.091, $1,000 and suspension of the license until the contractor provides the agency with proof of compliance with the statute.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.106","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7b4ce5e17381b80a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-001-0100 declares ORS 701.235 as implemented but its operative text about notice procedures for rulemaking does not engage with any substantive requirement of ORS 701.235 (which mandates rules about bonds, complaint processing, direct contractual relationships, and forms).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-001-0100","citation":"OAR 812-001-0100","quote":"ORS 183.335, ORS 183.341, ORS 670.310, ORS 701.235","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.235","citation":"ORS 701.235","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"40d2fd5dfe2d913a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-001-0110 declares ORS 701.235 as implemented but its operative text about temporary rule procedures does not engage with any substantive requirement of ORS 701.235 (which mandates rules about bonds, complaint processing, direct contractual relationships, and forms).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-001-0110","citation":"OAR 812-001-0110","quote":"ORS 183.325, ORS 701.235","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.235","citation":"ORS 701.235","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"022a91c601791105","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-001-0160 declares ORS 701.235 as implemented but its operative text about charges for records and certifications does not engage with any requirement of ORS 701.235 (which mandates rules about bonds, complaint processing, direct contractual relationships, and forms).","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-001-0160","citation":"OAR 812-001-0160","quote":"ORS 192.430, ORS 293.445, ORS 701.235, ORS 701.250","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.235","citation":"ORS 701.235","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.235","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b0544ec201ad9408","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-002-0540 expands the definition of 'owner of a structure' to include persons who lease or rent structures, but ORS 701.225(3) requires notice be served on 'the owner of each structure' without mentioning lessees or renters as recipients.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.225","citation":"ORS 701.225(3)","quote":"The notice of noncompliance shall be served upon the person and shall be served upon or delivered to the owner of each structure upon which the person is then performing work under contract","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-002-0540","citation":"OAR 812-002-0540(1)(c)","quote":"Owns, leases, or rents a structure on which alterations or repairs are being or have been made.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.225","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"12b03f90e34c7e44","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-030-0110 is a rule about locksmith certification fitness standards, but it declares it implements ORS 701.102, which is a statute exclusively about construction contractor licensing and sanctions, not locksmith licensing.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-030-0110","citation":"OAR 812-030-0110","quote":"ORS 670.280, ORS 701.098, ORS 701.102, ORS 701.485","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.102","citation":"ORS 701.102(2)","quote":"The Construction Contractors Board may revoke, suspend or refuse to issue a license required under this chapter","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.102","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"570947e5eee50991","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rules implementing renewal requirements omit the education completion evidence that the statute requires.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.063","citation":"ORS 701.063(2)","quote":"A person may renew a license by submitting an application for renewal on the prescribed form, providing any additional information required, including evidence of completion of any required education and an affirmation of the person's status as exempt under ORS 701.035 (2)(b), if the person continues to qualify as exempt, and submitting the appropriate application fee, as provided by Construction Contractors Board rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0280","citation":"OAR 812-003-0280","quote":"Each entity must complete a form prescribed by the agency. Notwithstanding OAR 812-003-0300(4), a license may be renewed or reissued upon: (1) The applicant's completion of the renewal form or application form prescribed by the agency including, but not limited to, the information provided in OAR 812-003-0260; (2) Payment of the fee or fees, (3) Receipt of the required certification of insurance coverage or other evidence of insurance, and (4) Receipt of a commercial and/or residential bond, letter of credit or cash deposit. If it appears to the agency that the required letter of credit or cash deposit has terminated or expired, the applicant must submit a new bond, letter of credit or cash deposit. (5) Receipt of a signed statement or declaration affirming the contractor's status as exempt or non-exempt under ORS 701.035(2)(b). (6) Receipt of a signed acknowledgement that the contractor understands that if there is a change of status from nonexempt to exempt, or from exempt to nonexempt, the contractor must notify the board within 10 days.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0290","citation":"OAR 812-003-0290(2)","quote":"In order to obtain a renewed or reissued license, a contractor must provide the following: (a) A completed application form; (b) Proof of insurance; (c) A commercial or residential bond, or both (as indicated by the contractor's endorsement(s)); (d) Where authorized by ORS 701.088, a letter of credit or cash deposit in lieu of the bond; and (e) An application fee. (f) A signed statement or declaration affirming the contractor's status as exempt or non-exempt. (g) A signed acknowledgement that the contractor understands that if there is a change of status from nonexempt to exempt, or from exempt to nonexempt, the contractor must notify the board within 10 days.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.063","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"30c1535e2f0c6f97","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-002-0040 declares it implements ORS 701.325, but its operative text only defines a term ('Appurtenance') that appears once in that statute, without engaging the statute's substantive requirements about licensing, permits, information notices, or business licenses.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0040","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 656.027, ORS 701.005, ORS 701.139, ORS 701.145, ORS 701.146, ORS 701.325","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.325","citation":"ORS 701.325","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.325","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"978ca0548bf52df8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-025-0020(6) requires contractors to pay 180% of state minimum wage for all EEAST program projects, extending wage requirements to non-commercial structures, while the statute only mandates prevailing wage for commercial structures and leaves non-commercial structure wage standards to discretionary consultation with BOLI.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.108","citation":"ORS 701.108(1)","quote":"If a project financed under the energy efficiency and sustainable technology loan program is to be constructed for a commercial structure, the State Department of Energy shall require that the certified contractor pay the employees used for the project at the prevailing wage rate determined by the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries for each trade or occupation employed. If a project is not to be constructed for a commercial structure, but the department is uncertain whether prevailing wage requirements apply to the project, the department shall consult with the Bureau of Labor and Industries.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-025-0020","citation":"OAR 812-025-0020(6)","quote":"It pays wages to employees used for the EEAST program at a rate equal to at least 180 percent of the state minimum wage.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.108","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"755420aa6840c038","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the appeal committee to hear appeals on three types of matters (proposed orders, petitions for reconsideration and rehearing, and motions for stays), but the implementing rules only address exceptions to proposed orders from enforcement hearings, omitting procedures for the other two types of appeals the statute mandates.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.260","citation":"ORS 701.260(2)","quote":"An appeal committee shall hear appeals on proposed orders and on petitions for reconsideration and rehearing and motions for stays that were originally appealed to the board as proposed orders.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-009-0420","citation":"OAR 812-009-0420(1)","quote":"After a contested case enforcement hearing, the respondent may file written exceptions if the respondent does not believe the proposed order is supported by the evidence received at the hearing.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.260","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4fa5bcaa63dce102","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule OAR 812-003-0250 expands the nonexempt class to include joint ventures and trusts, which are not listed in ORS 701.035(2)(a) as entities that must be classified as nonexempt.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.035","citation":"ORS 701.035(2)(a)","quote":"The nonexempt class is composed of the following entities: (A) Sole proprietorships, partnerships, corporations and limited liability companies: (i) With one or more employees; or (ii) That utilize one or more workers supplied by a worker leasing company. (B) Partnerships, corporations and limited liability companies with more than two partners, corporate officers or members, if any of the partners, corporate officers or members are not part of the same family and related as parents, spouses, sisters, brothers, daughters or sons, daughters-in-law or sons-in-law or grandchildren.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0250","citation":"OAR 812-003-0250(1)(d), (1)(e), (1)(j), (1)(k)","quote":"(d) Joint ventures with one or more employees or that utilize one or more workers supplied by a worker leasing company; (e) Joint ventures with more than two joint venturers if any of the joint venturers are not family members; (j) Trusts with one or more employees or that utilize one or more workers supplied by a worker leasing company; (k) Trusts with more than two trustees if any of the trustees are not family members.","quote_verified":"absence"}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.035","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"04f6dda659811225","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule applies a $150 minimum threshold to complaints by contractors and subcontractors, but the statute only authorizes the board to set a minimum for material/equipment supplier complaints.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-004-1320","citation":"OAR 812-004-1320(10)","quote":"Complaints by a contractor or by persons furnishing material, or renting or supplying equipment to a contractor will not be processed unless they are at least $150 in amount, not including the processing fee required by 812-004-1110.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.140","citation":"ORS 701.140(5)","quote":"A complaint, as limited by rule of the board, by a person furnishing material or renting or supplying equipment to a contractor. The minimum limit set by the board may not exceed $150.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.140","citation":"ORS 701.140(3)","quote":"A complaint against a licensed subcontractor by a licensed contractor for the following: (a) Negligent work. (b) Improper work. (c) Breach of contract.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-701.140","citation":"ORS 701.140(6)","quote":"A complaint by a subcontractor against a contractor for unpaid labor or materials arising out of a contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.140","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"793946ce0059f424","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-025-0035 implements ORS 701.119(2) but omits the mandatory hearing requirement before revoking certification.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.119","citation":"ORS 701.119(2)","quote":"If the board receives information that the contractor has failed to comply with the certification standards established by the department or has violated a wage and hours standard described in ORS 701.108, the board shall hold a hearing and may revoke the certification.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-025-0035","citation":"OAR 812-025-0035","quote":"The board may deny, refuse to renew, suspend or revoke a certification authorized under these rules on the following grounds: (1) Obtaining a certification through invalid documentation; (2) Permitting the duplication or use of the certification by another; (3) Failing to comply with any of the certification standards in OAR 812-025-0015 and 812-025-0020. (4) If a project is constructed for a commercial structure, failing to pay employees used for the project at the prevailing wage rated, as determined by the Commissioner of BOLI for each trade or occupation employed.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.119","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c5ba03abe8da19ad","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0820(4)(a) requires 1.5% monthly interest on final payment, but ORS 701.420(2) requires 1% per month.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.420","citation":"ORS 701.420(2)","quote":"The owner, contractor or subcontractor shall pay interest at the rate of one percent per month on the final payment due the contractor or subcontractor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-049-0820","citation":"OAR 137-049-0820(4)(a)","quote":"Additionally, the Contracting Agency shall pay interest at the rate of 1.5 percent per month on the final payment due the Contractor","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d772e8ea18bcc207","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 734-010-0430 claims to implement ORS 701.420 but omits the mandatory interest requirement on final payment stated in ORS 701.420(2).","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.420","citation":"ORS 701.420(2)","quote":"The owner, contractor or subcontractor shall pay interest at the rate of one percent per month on the final payment due the contractor or subcontractor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-010-0430","citation":"OAR 734-010-0430","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: 701.420, ORS 279C.560 & ORS 279C.570","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.420","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fedf7feb51e0732d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"ORS 701.330(4) requires rules specifying both 'time and manner' of delivery of consumer notices, but OAR 812-012-0130 specifies only the time (on or before contract date), omitting the required 'manner' specification.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.330","citation":"ORS 701.330(4)","quote":"The board shall adopt rules specifying the time and manner for a contractor to deliver a consumer notice form and notice of procedure form.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-012-0130","citation":"OAR 812-012-0130(1)","quote":"If a contractor is required to have a written contract under ORS 701.305, the consumer notices described in OAR 812-001-0200(1), (2) and (4) shall be delivered on or before the date the contract is entered into.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.330","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"61e3d52c935d6067","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-004-1250 declares in its statutes_implemented line that it implements ORS 701.146, but OAR 812-004-1001(2) specifies which rules apply to ORS 701.146 complaints and does not list OAR 812-004-1250 among them (it lists 1001-1240, then 1260-1320, leaving 1250 out).","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-004-1250","citation":"OAR 812-004-1250, declared statutes","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: OAR 701.068, 701.088, 701.133, 701.145 & 701.146","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1001","citation":"OAR 812-004-1001(2)","quote":"The following rules apply to complaints filed under ORS 701.146: (a) OAR 812-004-1001 through 812-004-1240; (b) OAR 812-004-1260 through 812-004-1320; (c) OAR 812-004-1340, except 812-004-1340(2)(c), (2)(i) and (8); (c) OAR 812-004-1420; (d) OAR 812-004-1520; and (e) OAR 812-004-1600.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.146","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5997c86e9523dae3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-002-0260 claims to address ORS 701.098(4)(a)(D), but that provision covers worker leasing company usage, not dishonest/fraudulent conduct; the correct provision is (4)(a)(E).","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0260","citation":"OAR 812-002-0260","quote":"\"Dishonest or fraudulent conduct\", as used in ORS 701.098(1)(o) and (4)(a)(D) includes","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.098","citation":"ORS 701.098(4)(a)(D) and (E)","quote":"(D) Using one or more workers supplied by a worker leasing company while classed as exempt under ORS 701.035; (E) Conduct as a construction contractor that is dishonest or fraudulent;","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.098","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"23805a3997cc5e1e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rules 812-007-0031, 812-008-0077, 812-025-0032, and 812-030-0223 declare they implement ORS 701.238 and set fees ($10 for replacement cards), but ORS 701.238 authorizes only fees for 'applications under ORS 701.056 for the issuance or renewal of contractor licenses,' not replacement fees.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.238","citation":"ORS 701.238(1)","quote":"the Construction Contractors Board shall determine the amounts of the fees to be charged for applications under ORS 701.056 for the issuance or renewal of contractor licenses","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0031","citation":"OAR 812-007-0031(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a license and pocket card","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-008-0077","citation":"OAR 812-008-0077(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a certification and pocket card","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-025-0032","citation":"OAR 812-025-0032(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a certification and pocket card","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-030-0223","citation":"OAR 812-030-0223(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a certificate and pocket card","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.238","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9e9da1ea77959d97","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-002-0160 declares it implements ORS 701.238 but its operative text only defines the term 'construction management' and makes no reference to application fees, the subject of ORS 701.238.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0160","citation":"OAR 812-002-0160, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 701.005, ORS 701.021, ORS 701.026, ORS 701.238","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.238","citation":"ORS 701.238","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.238","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c35e0a2185ece401","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-032-0123(5) authorizes a $10 fee to replace a certificate and pocket card, but the statute lists only three permissible fees (application, issuance, and renewal) and does not authorize a replacement fee.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.532","citation":"ORS 701.532(3)(c)","quote":"Establishing fees necessary for the administration of ORS 701.527 to 701.536 that do not exceed the following amounts: (A) $100 for application for a home energy assessor certificate; (B) $100 for issuance of an initial one-year home energy assessor certificate; and (C) $100 for renewal of a one-year home energy assessor certificate.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-032-0123","citation":"OAR 812-032-0123(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a certificate and pocket card.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.532","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4519f17790e2bf7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-030-0250 declares it implements ORS 701.480, but the operative text (which sets application, testing, and certification renewal fees) never engages ORS 701.480 at all—the rule only addresses fee-setting related to certification.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-030-0250","citation":"OAR 812-030-0250","quote":"ORS 701.480, ORS 701.485","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.480","citation":"ORS 701.480","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.480","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9a3f28982eb7fbce","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule omits the requirement to report changes in responsible managing individuals, which the statute explicitly requires to be reported.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.114","citation":"ORS 701.114(1)","quote":"a contractor licensed under this chapter shall immediately notify the Construction Contractors Board of any change in the identity, name or address of a person who holds a position with the contractor that is described in ORS 701.046 (1)(h), (i) or (j) or of a responsible managing individual for the contractor as defined in ORS 701.091","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0325","citation":"OAR 812-003-0325 opening paragraph","quote":"When a contractor notifies the agency of any change in the identity of a person who holds a position with the contractor that is described in ORS 701.046(1)(h), (E), (F), (G), or (I), or 701.046(1)(i) (D), (E), or (F)","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.114","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"corroborated_by":[{"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001"}],"fingerprint":"85e7fb8d2df57fab","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"ORS 701.131(1) requires continuous licensing while performing work, but OAR 812-004-1320(3)(a) accepts complaints against respondents licensed only 'during all or part of the work period'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.131","citation":"ORS 701.131(1)","quote":"a contractor may not perfect a construction lien, file a complaint with the Construction Contractors Board or commence an arbitration or a claim in a court of this state for compensation for the performance of any work or for the breach of any contract for work that is subject to this chapter, unless the contractor had a valid license issued by the board and properly endorsed for the work performed: (a) At the time the contractor bid or entered into the contract for performance of the work; and (b) Continuously while performing the work for which compensation is sought.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1320","citation":"OAR 812-004-1320(3)(a)","quote":"For an owner, primary contractor or subcontractor complaint, the respondent will be considered licensed if the respondent was licensed during all or part of the work period.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.131","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a00676fe8446b5a0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0420 changes the deadline for delivering the subcontractor list from 'within 72 hours after a board request' under the statute to 'on the same date that the initial Payroll and Certified Statement form (WH-38) is due' for Davis Bacon projects.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.345","citation":"ORS 701.345(2)","quote":"The contractor must deliver the list referred to in subsection (1) of this section to the Construction Contractors Board within 72 hours after a board request made during reasonable working hours.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0420","citation":"OAR 812-003-0420(2)","quote":"The initial list of subcontractors will be submitted to the contracting public agency and to the Wage and Hour Division of the Bureau of Labor and Industries on the same date that the initial Payroll and Certified Statement form (WH-38) is due.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.345","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"954c46d7a12139f0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute allows moneys to be used for 'lead poisoning prevention, including consumer and industry outreach, public education and other activities,' but the rule specifies only 'lead poisoning prevention, including consumer and industry outreach, public education, and enforcement activities,' replacing the broader 'other activities' with the specific 'enforcement activities.'","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.520","citation":"ORS 701.520","quote":"Moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the Construction Contractors Board for the purposes of lead poisoning prevention, including consumer and industry outreach, public education and other activities.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0025","citation":"OAR 812-007-0025(2)","quote":"The board will use the monies in the Construction Contractors Board LBP Activities Fund for lead poisoning prevention, including consumer and industry outreach, public education, and enforcement activities.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.520","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3e0b4bbcea2f7676","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-006-0100(2) requires all contractor applicants to designate an RMI, but ORS 701.091(2) explicitly exempts businesses licensed solely with residential or commercial developer endorsements from the RMI requirement, and the rule does not acknowledge this exemption.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-006-0100","citation":"OAR 812-006-0100(2)","quote":"Upon initial application, an applicant for a contractor's license shall designate at least one individual as the applicant's RMI","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.091","citation":"ORS 701.091(2)","quote":"Subsection (1) of this section does not apply to a business licensed with endorsement solely as a residential or commercial developer.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.091","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6a0efaccc8f58cf0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"oar-812-022-0022 declares it implements ORS 701.265, but the statute specifically requires rules establishing minimum standards for approved providers and approved courses, while the rule's operative text addresses only exemptions from CE requirements based on experience—a subject ORS 701.265 does not mention.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-022-0022","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 701.082 & 701.265","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-701.265","citation":"ORS 701.265(1)","quote":"The rules shall include, but need not be limited to, minimum standards to be met: (a) By approved providers of continuing education; and (b) By courses that the board approves as continuing education.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.265","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e925f5d27b6d3ee2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule establishes a $10 fee for replacement certificate and pocket cards, a fee type not mentioned or capped in the statute's specific enumeration of application, testing, issuance, and renewal fees.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-030-0223","citation":"OAR 812-030-0223(5)","quote":"There is a $10 fee to replace a certificate and pocket card","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.485","citation":"ORS 701.485(3)(d)","quote":"Establishing fees necessary for the administration of ORS 701.475 to 701.490 that do not exceed the following amounts: (A) $100 for application. (B) $100 for testing. (C) $300 for issuance of an initial two-year certificate. (D) $300 for renewal of a two-year certificate.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.485","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"cdb45bb4d9513931","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-003-0200(1) requires certification of insurance for applicants seeking 'licensure, renewal, reinstatement or reissuance,' but ORS 701.073(2) specifies the requirement applies only 'at the time of licensure and renewal,' not reinstatement or reissuance.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.073","citation":"ORS 701.073(2)","quote":"The contractor shall provide satisfactory evidence to the Construction Contractors Board at the time of licensure and renewal that the insurance required by subsection (1) of this section has been procured and is in effect.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0200","citation":"OAR 812-003-0200(1)","quote":"An applicant seeking licensure, renewal, reinstatement or reissuance shall certify that the applicant: (a) Has procured insurance from a risk retention group or an insurer transacting insurance in compliance with Oregon Revised Statutes and Oregon Administrative Rules","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.073","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a4076d48a038681f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule lists specific items that certification 'will include' but omits the professional credentials that the statute requires shall be included in status information.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.250","citation":"ORS 701.250(1)","quote":"Status information provided by the board shall include any professional credentials earned by the contractor as described in ORS 701.120.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-001-0160","citation":"OAR 812-001-0160(1)","quote":"This certification will include the following information: (a) License numbers. (b) Name of licensed entity and any assumed business names on file with the agency. (c) Type of business entity. (d) Category of license. (e) Class of independent contractor license status. (f) Personal names of owner, partners, joint venturers, members, corporate officers, or trustees. (g) The dates in the license history and the action that took place on those dates.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.250","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"94b2613ce4a48116","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-004-1600(4)(a) determines bond payment eligibility by checking only if the bond was cancelled more than 14 months before complaint receipt, but the statute requires checking the earlier of two dates: the license expiration/cancellation date OR the bond cancellation date.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.150","citation":"ORS 701.150(3)","quote":"a bond is not subject to payment for a complaint that is filed more than 14 months after the earlier of: (a) The expiration or cancellation date of the license that was in force when the work that is the subject of the complaint was completed or abandoned; or (b) The date that the surety canceled the bond.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1600","citation":"OAR 812-004-1600(4)(a)","quote":"If a surety bond, letter of credit or cash deposit was in effect when the work period began and that bond, letter of credit or cash deposit was not cancelled more than 14 months before the agency received the complaint, payment must be made from that surety bond, letter of credit or cash deposit.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.150","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"455c5b74802ed201","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule allows courses in 'Energy' but the statute specifies 'Energy efficiency,' broadening the acceptable subject matter.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.082","citation":"ORS 701.082(1)(c)","quote":"Five of the hours required under paragraph (a) of this subsection must be education from approved providers and be courses the board has approved as continuing education regarding one or more of the following: ... (I) Energy efficiency.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-022-0015","citation":"OAR 812-022-0015(2)(b)","quote":"Five hours of education, approved by the agency and offered by approved providers, in one or more of the following subjects: ... (I) Energy;","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.082","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c6ebcb497b830aea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Statute mandates board shall attempt to conduct mediation meetings; rule makes meeting scheduling discretionary.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.145","citation":"ORS 701.145(4)","quote":"The board shall attempt to conduct one or more meetings on-site or by telephone to mediate a dispute.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1450","citation":"OAR 812-004-1450(1)","quote":"The agency may schedule one or more on-site meetings or telephone mediations among the parties for the purpose of discussing a settlement of a complaint under ORS 701.145.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.145","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"974c9a6a6ae1976f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Two rules establish overlapping penalties for contract violations: section (12) penalizes 'failing to use a written contract as required by ORS 701.305' at $500/$1,000/$5,000, while section (37) penalizes 'failing to provide a written contract with the contractual terms provided by ORS 701.305 or OAR 812-012-0110' at $200/$500/$1,000. Both appear to address the same statutory violation (lack of a properly formed contract under ORS 701.305), but with different penalties and unclear scope overlap.","type":"rule_vs_rule","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800(12)","quote":"Failing to use a written contract as required by ORS 701.305: $500 for the first offense; $1,000 for the second offense; and $5,000 for subsequent offenses.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800(37)","quote":"Failing to provide a written contract with the contractual terms provided by ORS 701.305 or OAR 812-012-0110: $200 for the first offense; $500 for the second offense; and $1,000 for subsequent offenses.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.305","citation":"ORS 701.305(1)-(2)","quote":"A contractor may not perform work to construct, improve or repair a residential structure or zero-lot-line dwelling for a property owner without a written contract if the aggregate contract price exceeds $2,000... The Construction Contractors Board shall adopt rules that require a contractor to use standard contractual terms in a construction contract for which subsection (1) of this section requires a written contract.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.305","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e3304a0d3890a9c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 701.026 but operative text is only a cross-reference that never engages with the statute's requirements about contractor licensing","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0200","citation":"OAR 125-249-0200","quote":"ORS 279A.110, ORS 279A.120, ORS 279C.365, ORS 279C.370, ORS 279C.375, ORS 279C.390, ORS 279C.505-580, ORS 279C.605, ORS 305.385, ORS 468A.720, ORS 701.005, ORS 701.026","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.026","citation":"ORS 701.026","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.026","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"eb61511c392b6717","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"Rule declares it implements ORS 701.026 but operative text is only a cross-reference that never engages with the statute's requirements about contractor licensing","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-125-249-0230","citation":"OAR 125-249-0230","quote":"ORS 279C.365, ORS 671.530, ORS 701.026","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.026","citation":"ORS 701.026","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.026","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4ad35db43097f2b8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 137-049-0200(1)(c)(U) cites ORS 701.005(2) as describing \"construction Work,\" but ORS 701.005(2) defines \"Commercial contractor\" (a specific license endorsement type), not construction work generally.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-137-049-0200","citation":"OAR 137-049-0200(1)(c)(U)","quote":"Contractor's certification that all subcontractors performing Work described in ORS 701.005(2) (i.e., construction Work)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.005","citation":"ORS 701.005(2)","quote":"\"Commercial contractor\" means a licensed contractor that holds an endorsement as a: (a) Commercial general contractor level 1; (b) Commercial specialty contractor level 1; (c) Commercial general contractor level 2; (d) Commercial specialty contractor level 2; or (e) Commercial developer.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.005","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ee77fa1c1d38be53","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-007-0205 requires that lead abatement and inspection contractors have at least one owner or employee who is a licensed lead supervisor or inspector, but ORS 701.510 contains no such requirement for \"a lead-based paint activities contractor.\"","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.510","citation":"ORS 701.510(1)","quote":"A contractor may not perform lead-based paint activities in this state unless the contractor is a lead-based paint activities contractor.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0205","citation":"OAR 812-007-0205(1)-(2)","quote":"A lead abatement contractor must, at all times, have at least one owner or employee who is a licensed lead supervisor. A lead inspection contractor must, at all times, have at least one owner or employee who is a licensed lead inspector or a licensed lead risk assessor.","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.510","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a976f7c1a7c6ff1d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule's operative text only defines 'small commercial structure' by reference to ORS 701.005, but does not address any of the substantive provisions in ORS 701.153 regarding recording orders as liens, surety bond payment priorities, payment caps, or complaint procedures that the statute establishes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0675","citation":"statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 701.005, 701.021, 701.139, 701.145, 701.146, 701.150 & 701.153","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.153","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f2c291037d8891ed","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0240(7) cites the wrong subsection for the independent contractor certification requirement.","type":"wrong_pointer","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-003-0240","citation":"OAR 812-003-0240(7)","quote":"An applicant must use this form to meet the requirements of ORS 701.046(1)(k).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.046","citation":"ORS 701.046(1)(L)","quote":"The basis on which the applicant meets the standards for independent contractor status under ORS 670.600.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.046","citation":"ORS 701.046(1)(k)","quote":"For each person described in paragraphs (h), (i) and (j) of this subsection, information as required by board rule regarding the following if related to construction activities: (A) A final judgment against the person by a court in any state entered within five years preceding the application date that requires the person to pay money to another person or to a public body if the judgment remains unsatisfied on the application date. (B) A final order against the person by an administrative agency in any state issued within five years preceding the application date that requires the person to pay money to another person or to a public body if the order remains unsatisfied on the application date. (C) A court action against the person in any state pending on the application date that alleges the person owes money to another person or to a public body. (D) An action by an administrative agency in any state pending on the application date that seeks an order that the person pay money to another person or to a public body. (E) A conviction for a crime listed in ORS 701.098 (1)(L) entered within five years preceding the application date. (F) An indictment for a crime listed in ORS 701.098 (1)(L) filed within five years preceding the application date.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.046","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5ceef562e6782989","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0410 restricts the Social Security number requirement to sole proprietorships, but the statute requires it for all entity types including partnerships, LLCs, and corporations.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-003-0410","citation":"OAR 812-003-0410(1)","quote":"The agency will not issue or renew a license issued to a sole proprietorship unless the owner provides his or her social security number on the application or renewal form.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.046","citation":"ORS 701.046(1)(c)","quote":"For each person described in paragraphs (h), (i) and (j) of this subsection, a Social Security number.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.046","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"855d5222ff27bdfc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 701.083, which concerns specialized education programs as substitutes for continuing education, but the rule's operative text addresses only exemptions from continuing education and never mentions or implements the specialized education program provisions of ORS 701.083.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-022-0021","citation":"oar-812-022-0021, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 701.082, ORS 701.083","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.083","citation":"ORS 701.083","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.083","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"aa5ff64d5a258415","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule applies quorum and voting requirements to advisory committees, but the statute only specifies these requirements for the Board itself.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.215","citation":"ORS 701.215(2)","quote":"A majority of the members of the board constitutes a quorum for the transaction of business.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-001-0051","citation":"oar-812-001-0051(2)","quote":"A quorum must be present for the Board or Committee meeting to be called to order and to make decisions. A majority of affirmative votes among the members present are required for any official action or decision.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.215","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a255c47e775afd15","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule broadens 'Accredited training program' to include EPA and EPA-authorized programs; statute limits to Oregon Health Authority only.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.505","citation":"ORS 701.505(2)","quote":"\"Accredited training program\" means a training program that has been accredited by the Oregon Health Authority to provide training for individuals engaged in lead-based paint activities.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0020","citation":"OAR 812-007-0020(2)","quote":"\"Accredited training program\" means a training program provisionally accredited or accredited by the OHA, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) or an EPA-authorized state or tribal program.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"78a8d2cda2ab152c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule narrows 'Abatement' by dropping reference to P.L. 102-550, section 1004 and omitting requirement that term be further defined pursuant to ORS 431A.350.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.505","citation":"ORS 701.505(1)","quote":"\"Abatement\" has the meaning given that term in P.L. 102-550, section 1004, 40 C.F.R. 745.223 and as further defined pursuant to the authorities described in ORS 431A.350.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0020","citation":"OAR 812-007-0020(1)","quote":"\"Abatement\" 40 CFR 745.223.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.505","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a877b141c14c7bd0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires the maintenance schedule be provided at the time of warranty offer; the rule allows up to 60 days after substantial completion or occupancy.","type":"numeric","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.335","citation":"ORS 701.335(1)","quote":"shall provide a recommended maintenance schedule to the property owner or original purchaser of the proposed structure or dwelling at the time that the contractor makes a written offer of warranty under ORS 701.320","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-012-0120","citation":"OAR 812-012-0120(8)","quote":"The contractor that constructs a new residential structure or zero-lot-line dwelling shall provide a copy of its maintenance schedule to the first purchaser or owner no later than 60 days after substantial completion of the structure or dwelling, or occupancy of the structure or dwelling, whichever occurs later","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.335","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f000102a1fad1491","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-005-0800 does not provide the mandatory escalating penalties that ORS 701.992(4) explicitly requires for violations of ORS 701.098(1)(k)","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.992","citation":"ORS 701.992(4)","quote":"The board shall impose sanctions for a violation of ORS 701.098 (1)(k) on the person to whom a contract is awarded and the person who awards the contract, and sanctions on a contractor for a violation of ORS 701.117 (2), as follows: (a) A penalty not less than $500 nor more than $1,000 for the first offense; (b) A penalty not less than $1,000 nor more than $2,000 for the second offense; (c) Suspension of the person's license for six months for a third offense; (d) Suspension of the person's license for three years for a fourth offense; and (e) Revocation of the person's license for a fifth offense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800 (entire rule)","quote":"Rule 812-005-0800 provides detailed penalty schedules addressing violations of ORS 701.098(1)(f), 701.098(1)(h), and 701.098(1)(o) at sections (36), (23), and (20) respectively, but contains no section addressing the mandatory penalties for violations of ORS 701.098(1)(k) as required by ORS 701.992(4)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.992","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4e93fa5e245b0edd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-012-0170 uses 'order awarding arbitration' instead of the statute's defined term 'court order that confirms an arbitration award,' referring to different concepts.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.109","citation":"ORS 701.109(1)(b)","quote":"A court order that confirms an arbitration award","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-012-0170","citation":"OAR 812-012-0170(1)","quote":"A contractor against whom a court enters a judgment or order awarding arbitration must report that judgment or order","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.109","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"409b04825c891f92","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 812-007-0025 declares implementation of ORS 701.995 but omits the statutory requirement that the board report all penalties to three state agencies.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.995","citation":"ORS 701.995(4)","quote":"The board shall report all civil penalties or sanctions imposed under this section to each of the following state agencies: (a) The Oregon Health Authority; (b) The Occupational Safety and Health Division of the Department of Consumer and Business Services; and (c) The Department of Environmental Quality.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.995","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ce5bc9501e77139d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":[]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0280 allows letter of credit or cash deposit as alternatives to satisfy renewal requirements, but ORS 701.068(1) requires applicants for renewal to file 'a surety bond' specifically, with no mention of alternatives; ORS 701.088 (not declared as implemented by this rule) provides for such alternatives.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-003-0280","citation":"OAR 812-003-0280(4)","quote":"Receipt of a commercial and/or residential bond, letter of credit or cash deposit.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.068","citation":"ORS 701.068(1)","quote":"An applicant for issuance or renewal of a contractor license shall file with the Construction Contractors Board a surety bond with one or more corporate sureties authorized to do business in this state in the amount set forth in ORS 701.081 or 701.084.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0280","citation":"OAR 812-003-0280 frontmatter","quote":"Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 701.063, 701.068, 701.073 & 701.081","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.068","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"daa85b5b99af661f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule provides definitions for 'Certificate,' 'Conviction,' 'False statement,' and 'License' that do not appear in the statute's definitions section ORS 701.475, which only defines 'Key,' 'Lock,' and 'Locksmith.'","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.475","citation":"ORS 701.475","quote":"As used in ORS 701.475 to 701.490: (1) \"Key\" means a mechanical, electromechanical, electronic, electromagnetic or other device for operating a lock. (2) \"Lock\" means a mechanical, electromechanical, electronic, electromagnetic or other device that is designed to control access from one area to another or control the use of a device in a structure or vehicle. (3) \"Locksmith\" means a person who services, installs, repairs, rebuilds, rekeys, repins or adjusts locks, hardware peripheral to locks, safes, vaults, safe deposit boxes or mechanical or electronic security systems.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-030-0000","citation":"OAR 812-030-0000","quote":"The following definitions apply to OAR 812-030-0000 to 812-030-0300: (1) \"Certificate\" means the authorization issued by the board to an individual locksmith. (2) \"Conviction\" means a final judgment on a verdict or finding of guilty, a plea of guilty, a plea of nolo contendere (no contest), or any other determination of guilt entered by a court against an individual in a criminal case unless the final judgment has been reversed or set aside by a subsequent court decision. (3) \"False statement\" means a statement whereby an individual applying for a locksmith certificate: (a) Provides the board with materially false information; or (b) Fails to provide the board with information material to determining his or her qualifications. (4) \"License\" means the construction contractor license issued by the board under ORS 701.046 to a business offering to or providing locksmith services, including, but not limited to, a residential locksmith services contractor.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.475","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bb6680e12a9be4fb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0131(5) requires 'at least one owner or employee' to be a certified locksmith, but statute 701.081(5)(c) specifically requires the 'responsible managing individual for the business' to be certified.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.081","citation":"ORS 701.081(5)(c)","quote":"Have a responsible managing individual for the business who is certified as a locksmith under ORS 701.485.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0131","citation":"OAR 812-003-0131(5)","quote":"The licensee must have at least one owner or employee who is a certified locksmith.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.081","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b510adffbf0126af","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-003-0131(6) requires 'at least one owner or employee' to be a certified home inspector, but statute 701.081(6)(c) specifically requires the 'responsible managing individual for the business' to be certified.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.081","citation":"ORS 701.081(6)(c)","quote":"Have a responsible managing individual for the business who is certified as a home inspector under ORS 701.445.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0131","citation":"OAR 812-003-0131(6)","quote":"The licensee must have at least one owner or employee who is a certified home inspector.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.081","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"074e75b736797644","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires that if the board adopts fee rules under ORS 701.133(3), the rules must provide that a prevailing complainant recover processing fees, but oar-812-004-1110 does not provide for recovery by prevailing complainants.","type":"discretion","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.133","citation":"ORS 701.133(4)(a)","quote":"If the board adopts rules under subsection (3) of this section, the rules: (a) Except as provided in paragraphs (b) and (c) of this subsection, must provide that a prevailing complainant recover processing fees.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1110","citation":"OAR 812-004-1110(1)-(6)","quote":"The complaint processing fee authorized under ORS 701.133 is $50 for a complaint filed under ORS 701.145. There is no complaint processing fee for a complaint filed under ORS 701.146. [Rule then addresses waiver procedures and false information penalties but does not address prevailing complainant recovery of fees]","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.133","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d53b7a6d7c798df0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The statute requires pre-complaint notice be sent by certified mail, but the rule allows either certified or registered mail receipt as proof of compliance.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.133","citation":"ORS 701.133(1)","quote":"The notice must be mailed by certified mail to the last known address of the contractor as shown in board records.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-004-1340","citation":"OAR 812-004-1340(9)(a)","quote":"A copy of the pre-complaint notice required under ORS 701.133 and of the certified or registered mail receipt for the pre-complaint notice","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.133","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"673ac5b1f5701593","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-002-0120 narrows the exemption for casual, minor, inconsequential work by adding requirements not in the statute: that work not require a permit and not be done as a subcontractor.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.010","citation":"ORS 701.010(4)","quote":"A person working on one structure or project, under one or more contracts, when the aggregate price of all of that person's contracts for labor, materials and all other items is less than $1,000 and such work is of a casual, minor or inconsequential nature.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-002-0120","citation":"OAR 812-002-0120(1)","quote":"\"Casual, minor or inconsequential\" as used in ORS 701.010(4) means work: (a) That does not require a permit; (b) That does not affect the health or safety of the owner or occupant of the structure; (c) For which the aggregate contract price for all work on one structure or project is less than $1,000; and (d) That does not include work done as a subcontractor to a licensee.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.010","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3edde66ed5ecdccd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule (34) narrows the statutory violation by restricting it to preclusion (complete prevention) rather than any limitation, and to homeowners rather than any person.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.315","citation":"ORS 701.315","quote":"A contract that is for the performance of work on a residential structure and that is subject to this chapter may not contain a provision that limits the right of a person to file a complaint described in ORS 701.140 with the Construction Contractors Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-005-0800","citation":"OAR 812-005-0800(34)","quote":"Violation of ORS 701.315, inclusion of provisions in a contract that preclude a homeowner from filing a breach of contract complaint with the Board","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.315","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0a9b9dea90207116","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule excludes 40 CFR §745.226 from adoption, but the statute requires the licensing system to include the requirements described in that regulation.","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.515","citation":"ORS 701.515(1)","quote":"The licensing system must include the requirements described in 40 C.F.R. 745.226.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0015","citation":"OAR 812-007-0015(2)(d)","quote":"The board does not adopt the following regulations: (d) 40 CFR §745.226 (Certification of individuals and firms engaged in lead-based paint activities: target housing and child-occupied facilities)","quote_verified":false}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bf7f57d923c523e6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule allows the requirement to be satisfied by someone who owns the licensee, but the statute specifies the requirement must be met by an employee of the applicant.","type":"broadens","documents":[{"id":"ors-701.515","citation":"ORS 701.515(1)(c)","quote":"Requiring an applicant for a certified lead-based paint renovation contractor license to show that an employee of the applicant has completed an accredited training program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-007-0310","citation":"OAR 812-007-0310(4)","quote":"Proof that the licensee is owned by or employs at least one individual who has a current and valid course completion certificate evidencing that the individual is a certified renovator as provided in 40 CFR 745.83.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.515","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f4a3ab92b23f0fc4","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"The rule's operative text defines 'small commercial structure' by reference to ORS 701.005 only and does not engage at all with ORS 701.153, yet declares it implements that statute.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-002-0675","citation":"OAR 812-002-0675, statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 701.005, ORS 701.021, ORS 701.139, ORS 701.145, ORS 701.146, ORS 701.150 & ORS 701.153","quote_verified":false},{"id":"ors-701.153","citation":"ORS 701.153","quote":"Recording of order as lien; satisfaction of order against residential contractor","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.153","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bf2e60a336bd4800","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]},{"summary":"Rule 812-032-0000 declares implementation of ORS 701.527–701.536 (the statute that defines 'Home energy assessor' and 'Home energy performance score'), but the operative text defines 'Certificate' and 'License' instead, which do not appear in the statute and are not defined or required by ORS 701.527.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-812-032-0000","citation":"OAR 812-032-0000","quote":"ORS 701.527–701.536","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-701.527","citation":"ORS 701.527","quote":"(1) \"Home energy assessor\" means a person who assigns residential buildings a home energy performance score. (2) \"Home energy performance score\" means a score assigned to a residential building using the home energy performance score system adopted by the State Department of Energy under ORS 469.703.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-701.527","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"fc03d26495099e28","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"706","agencies":1,"rules_reviewed":23,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DCBS rule fixes the Bank Act's federal-reference date at June 30, 2007, though the statute's own 2015-amended default baseline (January 1, 2015) is now later, and the statute only authorizes moving the date forward, not backward.","documents":[{"id":"ors-706.015","citation":"ORS 706.015, last_amended 2015","quote":"...are to the statutes or regulations as the statutes or regulations are in effect on January 1, 2015. The Director ... may by rule construe ... as references to the statutes and regulations as ... in effect on a later date.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-441-505-1110","citation":"OAR 441-505-1110, effective 2007-10-22","quote":"...references ... shall be construed to refer to statutes or regulations in effect on June 30, 2007...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6c7a48b2fdf9ccd5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation"]}],"artifacts":["oar-441-505-2005 statutes_implemented cites \"ORS 706.610\" (examiner insolvency-reporting statute), topically unconnected to the rule's actual subject (remote stockholder meetings, ORS 707.621)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"}]},{"ors_chapter":"801","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":29,"candidates":[{"summary":"Field-sobriety-test rules still name a superseded consultation-body ('Board on Public Safety Standards and Training') and a narrower impairment scope than the 2023-amended statute.","documents":[{"id":"ors-801.272","citation":"ORS 801.272","quote":"approved by the Department of State Police by rule after consultation with the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training, that enables a police officer or trier of fact to screen for or detect probable impairment from an intoxicant or a combination of intoxicants.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-025-0012","citation":"OAR 257-025-0012(1), effective 1997","quote":"approved by the Department of State Police, after consultation with the Board on Public Safety Standards and Training (BPSST), for use by sworn police officers...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Rule cluster (OAR 257-025-0000 to -0025) unamended since 1996-97; statute amended 2017/2021/2023.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"07ef5be049f6b853","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]},{"summary":"A DMV rule cites a subsection lettering of ORS 801.375 that no longer exists in the current statute text.","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-154-0060","citation":"OAR 735-154-0060, effective 1991","quote":"Notwithstanding ORS 801.375(1)(b) and 803.050, the lessee shall appear as owner...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-801.375","citation":"ORS 801.375(2)(b)","quote":"The lessor or lessee of a vehicle, as designated by the lessor on the application for title, if the lessee is entitled to possession and use...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The lessor/lessee provision now sits at (2)(b), not (1)(b); subsection (1) has no lettered subparts. Rule (1991) predates the 1993 statutory amendment that likely renumbered this.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"615ef8cb71a48b6c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Three DMV registration-fee rules (last touched 1999-2018) predate ORS 801.040/.041/.042's 2025 amendment.","documents":[{"id":"ors-801.041","citation":"ORS 801.041 provenance note","quote":"801.041 is amended by Enrolled House Bill 3991 (2025 special session)... subject to potential referendum petitions.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-735-030-0055","citation":"OAR 735-030-0055, effective 2018-01-01","quote":"statutes_implemented: ORS 801.040, ORS 801.041, ORS 801.042","quote_verified":"absence"}],"note":"Caveat: the 2025 amendment's own effect is contingent on a referendum outcome, so this is a watch-list staleness flag, not a confirmed live conflict.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2e1891dc33f43d85","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"ORS 801.465, last amended 2025 (adding a cross-reference to ORS 71.2010(2)(jj) for 'security interest'), is implemented by a rule dated 2004 that doesn't engage the new cross-reference.","documents":[{"id":"ors-801.465","citation":"ORS 801.465, last_amended 2025","quote":"...2025 c.33 §106] — defines 'Security interest' by reference to ORS 71.2010(2)(jj).","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-735-020-0020","citation":"OAR 735-020-0020, effective 2004-05-24","quote":"uses 'security interest' without restating or updating for the 2025 definitional cross-reference.","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Not a textual contradiction (no restated definition to conflict with) — a staleness flag only.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"857c4b410c0e1f9f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 735-010-0170 statutes_implemented embeds a subsection reference directly in the citation string (\"ORS 801.040(6) & (7)\"), inconsistent with the bare-citation format used elsewhere in the cluster.","Several rules mix Oregon-Laws-chapter citations (\"Ch. 233\", \"OL 1993\") and one federal-CFR citation (\"6 CFR §37.3\") into otherwise ORS-only legal_authority lists."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"813","agencies":8,"rules_reviewed":87,"candidates":[],"note":"Sonnet re-check (2026-07-23) found ZERO candidates on a full, careful read of all 40 statute sections and 87 rules — every apparent numeric overlap (BAC thresholds, hardship-permit windows, calibration intervals) resolved to a different trigger, party, or statute-authorized carve-out. This matches the batch-2 Haiku re-check's result (also 0), and neither reproduces the original batch-1 pilot's 2 candidates (undefined '6-month no-negative-certificate' track; two OAR sections with matching numbers but no supersession link). Read as: two independent re-checks now disagree with the original pilot — the batch-1 findings should be treated as likely stale/resolved rather than live.","artifacts":["OAR 812-002-0190 (Construction Contractors Board arbitration rule) lists ORS 813.460 (DUII suspension) in statutes_implemented with zero substantive connection — likely a mis-extraction.","OAR 415-012-0057 legal_authority/statutes_implemented includes \"ORS 430.01030\" (invalid) and cites \"ORS 813.500\", which does not appear to exist in ORS chapter 813.","Inconsistent bare-vs-ORS-prefixed citation style across several statutes_implemented/legal_authority fields (e.g. oar-291-208-0030 lists \"813.011\" with no prefix)."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"814","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":12,"candidates":[{"summary":"A DMV rule imports subsection (2)'s three-wheel/under-15-mph limitation into subsection (1)'s general 'enclosed cab' helmet exemption, which the statute's text does not itself confine to three-wheeled vehicles.","documents":[{"id":"ors-814.290","citation":"ORS 814.290","quote":"A person is not in violation ... if the person is any of the following: (1) Within an enclosed cab. (2) Operating or riding a vehicle designed to travel with three wheels ... at speeds of less than 15 miles per hour.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-010-0005","citation":"OAR 737-010-0005","quote":"'Enclosed Cab' for the purposes of ORS 814.290(1), is a three-wheeled vehicle, such as a motorcycle or moped...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5a7e2ad8b7bbe1cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division"]},{"summary":"The entire OAR 734-058 division (8 rules) implementing ORS 814.070 has a single 2008 filing date, while the statute has been amended three times since (2009, 2011, 2013).","documents":[{"id":"ors-814.070","citation":"ORS 814.070, last_amended 2013","quote":"[... 2009 c.547 §§2,3; 2011 c.507 §3; 2013 c.474 §1]","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-734-058-0010","citation":"OAR 734-058-0010, effective 2008-08-26","quote":"identical single filing date across all eight sibling rules in the division.","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Facial staleness signal; substantive divergence not confirmable from this cluster alone.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"00e2ec534a97e234","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]}],"artifacts":["oar-735-108-0090 legal_authority garbling: \"ORS 816.050.Stats. Imp.: ORS 814.320\" (metadata label spliced into a citation string).","ors-814.600 title has a trailing \"PEDESTRIANS (Traffic Control Devices)\" fragment bled in from the source page."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"819","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":22,"candidates":[{"summary":"An ODOT rule sets different rush-hour hazard windows for oversize freeway-shoulder vehicles than the statute it implements, and silently extends the criterion to 'expressway.'","documents":[{"id":"ors-819.120","citation":"ORS 819.120(2)(b)(B)","quote":"freeway within city limits ... during the hours of 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. if the vehicle has a gross vehicle weight of more than 26,000 pounds","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-734-020-0147","citation":"OAR 734-020-0147(2)(c)(A), 2008","quote":"freeway or expressway within city limits ... during the hours of 5 a.m. to 9 a.m. and 2:30 p.m. to 7 p.m. local time if the vehicle has a gross vehicle weight of more than 26,000 pounds","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Statute gives OTC authority for 'additional criteria,' but restating the same criterion with different numbers isn't obviously 'additional.'","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"02db514642271f50","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"A currently-effective DMV rule cites a repealed ORS section (819.020, repealed 1991) as authority for a 'totaled' vehicle brand designation.","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-024-0025","citation":"OAR 735-024-0025(5)(f), amended 2020","quote":"a vehicle issued an Oregon title with a 'replica' brand that is later reported to DMV as 'totaled' under ORS 819.020 or 819.014...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The substantively parallel provision is ORS 819.012, used correctly elsewhere in the same rule (subsection 5(e)) — reads as an uncorrected typo surviving a 2020 amendment.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"044830de07b58e90","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]}],"artifacts":["OAR 735-024-0120's relationships.implements/legal_authority omit ORS 819.012 despite the rule's own operative text hinging on it twice.","Three rules (oar-735-020-0012, -735-150-0250, -735-150-0260) still cite the stale \"ORS 819.230\" instead of its 2007 renumbering to ORS 819.480.","\"ORS 819. 018\" (stray space) in oar-735-024-0130."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"820","agencies":4,"rules_reviewed":92,"candidates":[{"summary":"A rule's SPAB (School Pupil Activity Bus) definition uses a stricter GVWR comparator than the 'motor coach' definition it's built on, leaving vehicles at exactly 26,000 lbs GVWR classified as a motor coach but not a SPAB.","documents":[{"id":"oar-581-053-0003","citation":"OAR 581-053-0003(23)","quote":"'Motor coach' means an over-the-road bus, having a gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) of 26,000 lbs or more...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-053-0003","citation":"OAR 581-053-0003(33)(d)","quote":"'School pupil activity bus (SPAB)' means a motor coach with a gross vehicle weight rating of more than 26,000 pounds...","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Same-rule internal definitional gap rather than statute-vs-rule; flagged because SPAB is defined as a subtype of motor coach yet a boundary vehicle qualifies as one but not the other.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4aa19cb838e7c7ea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]},{"summary":"A graph-completeness bug: ORS 820.100's implemented_by list omits OAR 581-053-0120, though that rule's own frontmatter cites ORS 820.100 as both legal_authority and statutes_implemented — traced to a missing space in the rule's own citation string.","documents":[{"id":"oar-581-053-0120","citation":"OAR 581-053-0120 legal_authority/statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS820.100, ORS 820.105, ORS 820.110, ORS 820.120","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Companion statutes 820.105/820.110/820.120 DO list oar-581-053-0120 correctly, confirming this is an isolated citation-formatting bug, not a deliberate omission.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c7420f75afce7e36","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]}],"artifacts":["\"ORS820.100\" (missing space) in oar-581-053-0120 legal_authority/statutes_implemented — root cause of the missing graph edge above."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"826","agencies":3,"rules_reviewed":16,"candidates":[{"summary":"A currently-effective ODOT fee-credit rule defines 'registration period' as a calendar year, where the statute defines it as a carrier-selected floating four-quarter window.","documents":[{"id":"ors-826.009","citation":"ORS 826.009(3)","quote":"The registration period for proportionally registered vehicles is a period of four consecutive quarters ... Each carrier may select the calendar quarter in which the registration will begin...","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-740-200-0030","citation":"OAR 740-200-0030(1)(b), effective 2026-03-20","quote":"Registration periods are based on a calendar year. When a registrant elects to pay Oregon registration fees for calendar quarters...","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"96dd329f58906cb0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division"]},{"summary":"A rule tagged as implementing ORS 826.035 sets a $10 biennial 'identification device' fee where the statute (via its cross-reference to ORS 826.023) sets $3.","documents":[{"id":"ors-826.035","citation":"ORS 826.035(1)","quote":"The fees for such stickers or plates are as provided in ORS 826.023.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-826.023","citation":"ORS 826.023(4)","quote":"The fee for issuance of replacement registration stickers is $3.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-740-045-0030","citation":"OAR 740-045-0030(3)","quote":"...a biennial fee of $10.","quote_verified":false}],"note":"Rule's own text ties the $10 fee to ORS 825.454 (not in this cluster) — may resolve if that statute independently authorizes a $10 fee for a non-overlapping vehicle population.","run_id":"pilot-2026-07","model":null,"prompt_version":null,"model_note":"pilot batches 1-3 did not record per-candidate model attribution; see methodology","confidence":null,"severity":null,"triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"56d3b7cec0762b3d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division"]}],"artifacts":["oar-735-016-0030 statutes_implemented: \"ORS 807.040 807.045\" concatenated with no separator, mirrored in the rule's own body text."],"run_id":"pilot-2026-07","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"98","run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","rules_reviewed":26,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 125-090-0000(20) redefines 'Parking Facility' more narrowly than ORS 98.805(3) by limiting it to facilities owned, managed, controlled or administered by DAS, whereas the statute defines parking facility as any property used for vehicle parking without such limitation.","type":"redefines","documents":[{"id":"ors-98.805","citation":"ORS 98.805(3)","quote":"(3) \"Parking facility\" means any property used for vehicle parking.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-125-090-0000","citation":"OAR 125-090-0000(20)","quote":"(20) \" Parking Facility \" means any lot, grounds, parking structure, or facility owned, managed, controlled or administered by DAS and used or available for the parking of Motor Vehicles and Bicycles and other transportation uses","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.805","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ea195a29972df531","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services"]},{"summary":"OAR 735-150-0250 declares it implements ORS 98.810, 98.812, 98.818, and 98.830, but its operative text concerning lien claimant records and notification of sales does not engage with any of these parking/towing statutes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0250","citation":"OAR 735-150-0250 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 87.166, ORS 87.172, ORS 87.176 - 206, ORS 90.425, ORS 90.675, ORS 98.805, ORS 98.810, ORS 98.812, ORS 98.818, ORS 98.830, ORS 803.097, ORS 809.720, ORS 811.555, ORS 811.570, ORS 819.110, ORS 819.120, ORS 819.160, ORS 819.230, ORS 822.035, ORS 822.042, ORS 822.045, ORS 822.093, ORS 87.152, ORS 87.162","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.810","citation":"ORS 98.810","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.810","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e49e7b60ede9e4bd","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"OAR 735-150-0260 declares it implements ORS 98.810, 98.812, 98.818, and 98.830, but its operative text concerning civil penalties for lien claimant record violations does not engage with any of these parking/towing statutes.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0260","citation":"OAR 735-150-0260 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 87.152, ORS 87.162, ORS 87.166, ORS 87.172, ORS 87.176 - 206, ORS 90.425, ORS 90.675, ORS 98.805, ORS 98.810, ORS 98.812, ORS 98.818, ORS 98.830, ORS 803.097, ORS 809.720, ORS 811.555, ORS 811.570, ORS 819.110, ORS 819.120, ORS 819.160, ORS 819.230, ORS 822.035, ORS 822.042, ORS 822.045, ORS 822.093","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.810","citation":"ORS 98.810","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.810","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"35ff336890b0fa42","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"The rules implement only the deposit portion of ORS 98.316 but not the court-ordered refund provision in ORS 98.316(2)","type":"narrows","documents":[{"id":"ors-98.316","citation":"ORS 98.316(2)","quote":"A sum received for utility services which a utility has been ordered to refund, together with any interest thereon and less any lawful deductions","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-036-1260","citation":"oar-860-036-1260 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 98.316","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-860-037-0050","citation":"oar-860-037-0050 (declared statutes_implemented)","quote":"ORS 98.316","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.316","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"068c0c039913bd1d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["public-utility-commission"]},{"summary":"The rule declares it implements ORS 98.436, which is only a short title provision, and the rule's operative text never engages with that section—it references ORS 98.302 et seq. instead.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-158-0015","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 30.643, ORS 34.365, ORS 34.370, ORS 98.302 - 98.436, ORS 138.590, ORS 144.335, ORS 179.040, ORS 423.020, ORS 423.030, ORS 423.075, ORS 423.105","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.436","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b4e96bd10b71fb40","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]},{"summary":"OAR 735-150-0260 declares it implements ORS 98.812, but the operative text never mentions or engages with ORS 98.812—it only enforces violations of ORS 822.093 or OAR 735-150-0250.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0260","citation":"OAR 735-150-0260, declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 87.152, 87.162, 87.166, 87.172, 87.176 - 206, 90.425, 90.675, 98.805, 98.810, 98.812, 98.818, 98.830, 803.097, 809.720, 811.555, 811.570, 819.110, 819.120, 819.160, 819.230, 822.035, 822.042, 822.045 & 822.093","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-150-0260","citation":"OAR 735-150-0260(1)","quote":"In addition to any other penalty or sanction provided by law, a lien claimant who violates any provision of ORS 822.093 or OAR 735-150-0250 relating to lien claimant records may incur a civil penalty in an amount not to exceed $1,000 for each violation.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.812","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"34adf9fa9c2dfde2","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 735-020-0012 declares it implements ORS 98.818, which establishes that a lien shall have preference over other liens, but the rule's operative text addresses only forms and procedures for title applications and never engages with the lien preference requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-020-0012","citation":"735-020-0012 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 87.152, ORS 87.162, ORS 87.166, ORS 87.172, ORS 87.176 — 87.206, ORS 90.425, ORS 90.675, ORS 98.805, ORS 98.812, ORS 98.818, ORS 98.830, ORS 803.045, ORS 803.094, ORS 803.097, ORS 803.205, ORS 809.720, ORS 811.555, ORS 811.570, ORS 819.110, ORS 819.120, ORS 819.160, ORS 819.230","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.818","citation":"ORS 98.818","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.818","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7ac6fefaa29fab72","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 735-150-0250 declares it implements ORS 98.818, which establishes that a lien shall have preference over other liens, but the rule's operative text addresses only record-keeping and sale notification and never engages with the lien preference requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0250","citation":"735-150-0250 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 87.166, ORS 87.172, ORS 87.176 - 206, ORS 90.425, ORS 90.675, ORS 98.805, ORS 98.810, ORS 98.812, ORS 98.818, ORS 98.830, ORS 803.097, ORS 809.720, ORS 811.555, ORS 811.570, ORS 819.110, ORS 819.120, ORS 819.160, ORS 819.230, ORS 822.035, ORS 822.042, ORS 822.045, ORS 822.093, ORS 87.152, ORS 87.162","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.818","citation":"ORS 98.818","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.818","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"55a2c2be879a2a61","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Rule 735-150-0260 declares it implements ORS 98.818, which establishes that a lien shall have preference over other liens, but the rule's operative text addresses only civil penalties for record-keeping violations and never engages with the lien preference requirement.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-735-150-0260","citation":"735-150-0260 declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 87.152, ORS 87.162, ORS 87.166, ORS 87.172, ORS 87.176 - 206, ORS 90.425, ORS 90.675, ORS 98.805, ORS 98.810, ORS 98.812, ORS 98.818, ORS 98.830, ORS 803.097, ORS 809.720, ORS 811.555, ORS 811.570, ORS 819.110, ORS 819.120, ORS 819.160, ORS 819.230, ORS 822.035, ORS 822.042, ORS 822.045, ORS 822.093","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.818","citation":"ORS 98.818","added_by":"mechanical-statute-extraction-2026-07-29","quote_verified":null}],"run_id":"das-v5-think-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v5-authority-2026-07b","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.818","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1d7ff17895f3e442","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"The rule declares implementing ORS 98.436, which is only a short title provision stating how the Uniform Disposition of Unclaimed Property Act \"may be cited,\" but the rule's operative text about unclaimed property (section 12) references the substantive Act itself (\"ORS 98.302, et seq.\"), not the short title provision.","type":"wrong_authority","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-158-0015","citation":"declared statutes_implemented","quote":"ORS 30.643, ORS 34.365, ORS 34.370, ORS 98.302 - 98.436, ORS 138.590, ORS 144.335, ORS 179.040, ORS 423.020, ORS 423.030, ORS 423.075, ORS 423.105","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-98.436","citation":"ORS 98.436","quote":"This Act may be cited as the Uniform Disposition of Unclaimed Property Act.","quote_verified":true}],"run_id":"das-v6-edgecases-2026-07","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-v6-both-sides-2026-07","confidence":null,"severity":null,"section":"ors-98.436","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d90b72fb0eda832a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections"]}],"agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-administrative-services","name":"Department of Administrative Services"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"25","sections_reviewed":["ors-25.080","ors-25.750","ors-25.785"],"rules_reviewed":17,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule prohibits initiating establishment of parentage or support after age 18, but statute does not restrict by age and contemplates support for school-attending children who may exceed 18.","documents":[{"id":"ors-25.080","citation":"ORS 25.080(2)","quote":"The provisions of this section apply to child support services for any order or judgment that is or could be entered under ORS 25.501 to 25.556 or 419B.400 or ORS chapter 107, 108, 109 or 110.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-25.080","citation":"ORS 25.080(4)(a)–(b)","quote":"Shall establish and enforce any child support obligation; (b) Shall establish genetic parentage","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-3485","citation":"OAR 137-055-3485(2)","quote":"The administrator may not initiate the establishment of parentage or support for a child after the child turns 18 years old.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute imposes mandatory duties to 'establish and enforce any child support obligation' and to 'establish genetic parentage' without age restriction, and explicitly references support for children attending school (ORS 107.108), which the statute recognizes can extend beyond 18. A reader might reasonably interpret the statute as authorizing establishment of support for a school-attending adult never previously in the system. The rule's flat prohibition on post-18 initiation narrows this authority. However, this can be read as reasonable implementation: the sequence envisioned is initiate before 18, modify after for school status.","type":null,"section":"ors-25.080","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"493d4c4482824dbf","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule omits agreement compliance as a contestable basis for subpoena-based license suspension, though statute requires it.","documents":[{"id":"ors-25.750","citation":"ORS 25.759(5)(d)","quote":"That the person subject to the suspension is in compliance with a previous agreement as provided for by ORS 25.750 to 25.783.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-3640","citation":"OAR 137-055-3640(4)(d)","quote":"The only bases for contesting the suspension are: (A) There is a mistake in identity of the party; (B) The party has complied with the subpoena; or (C) The subpoena was not properly served upon the party pursuant to OAR 137-055-3620.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute lists four bases for contesting suspension, including agreement compliance. The rule lists only three bases, omitting agreement compliance. Applicable because statute 25.750(1)(b) conditions subpoena-based suspension on either lack of agreement or non-compliance with an agreement. If an obligor has a valid compliance agreement, the statute appears to allow contesting on that basis, but the rule does not explicitly permit it.","type":null,"section":"ors-25.750","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a35f1703cd65c3ec","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule condition requires that obligor has not paid sufficiently during past three months, which is not stated in the statute's grounds for suspension.","documents":[{"id":"ors-25.750","citation":"ORS 25.750(1)(a)-(b)","quote":"All licenses... are subject to suspension... upon certification... that one or both of the following conditions apply: (a) That the party holding the license, certificate, permit or registration is in arrears under any child support judgment or order, in an amount equal to the greater of three months of support or $2,500, and: (A) Has not entered into an agreement with the administrator with respect to the child support obligation; or (B) Is not in compliance with an agreement entered into with the administrator; or (b) That the party holding the license, certificate, permit or registration has failed, after receiving appropriate notice, to comply with a subpoena or other procedural order","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-055-4420","citation":"OAR 137-055-4420(2)(e)","quote":"The obligor has not made voluntary payments or payments by income withholding every month for the last three months greater than the current support amount, or if there is no longer an order or judgment for current support equal to the amount of the most recent order for current support. This criterion does not apply to payments resulting from garnishment, tax offset, or any other enforcement action other than income withholding","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute establishes two grounds for suspension: arrears at threshold plus agreement status, OR subpoena non-compliance plus agreement status. Statute does not condition suspension on recent payment history. Rule adds as a requirement that obligor must not have made sufficient payments in the past three months. This appears to be an additional requirement beyond what the statute requires. However, this may be a reasonable regulatory implementation of the discretion authorized by statute 25.750(2) allowing DOJ to specify conditions and terms of agreements, depending on whether past payment history could be deemed a 'condition' of determining whether an obligation exists.","type":null,"section":"ors-25.750","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e96b1820edf3c517","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"HLO rule's suspension language omits the $2,500 or three-month arrears threshold explicitly required by statute. Additionally: HLO rule does not explicitly require the agreement status check that statute makes prerequisite to suspension.","documents":[{"id":"ors-25.750","citation":"ORS 25.750(1)(a)","quote":"in arrears under any child support judgment or order, in an amount equal to the greater of three months of support or $2,500","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-331-020-0080","citation":"OAR 331-020-0080(2)","quote":"The Office will suspend the authorization if the Oregon Child Support Program or the district attorney identifies the authorization holder as being in arrears with respect to any judgment or order requiring the payment of child support and that the case is being enforced under the provisions of ORS 25.080.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-25.750","citation":"ORS 25.750(1)(a)","quote":"in an amount equal to the greater of three months of support or $2,500, and: (A) Has not entered into an agreement with the administrator with respect to the child support obligation; or (B) Is not in compliance with an agreement entered into with the administrator","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute requires suspension only when arrears equal or exceed the greater of three months of support or $2,500. Rule requires suspension when DOJ identifies someone 'as being in arrears' without specifying the threshold amount. Rule section (1) references 'according to ORS 25.750(a) or (b)' which might incorporate statutory thresholds, but section (2) suspension language does not. The rule may rely on DOJ to apply the threshold before identifying persons for suspension, but does not explicitly require the $2,500/three-month test in its own language. Statute makes suspension conditional on either (A) no agreement or (B) non-compliance with an agreement. Rule requires only that DOJ 'identifies' someone 'as being in arrears' and case is 'being enforced.' The rule does not state that the DOJ's identification must include verification that no agreement exists or that an existing agreement is not being complied with. The rule may assume DOJ's identification process includes this check, but does not explicitly require it in the HLO's decision to suspend.","type":null,"section":"ors-25.750","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e106734b1f778183","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Early Learning Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"84","sections_reviewed":["ors-84.013","ors-84.022","ors-84.025","ors-84.049","ors-84.052","ors-84.055"],"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute allows agencies discretion to specify electronic signature requirements; rule mandates compliance with specific federal E-authentication policy.","documents":[{"id":"ors-84.052","citation":"ORS 84.052(2)","quote":"the governmental agency, giving due consideration to security, may specify: (a) The manner and format in which the electronic records must be created, generated, sent, communicated, received and stored and the systems established for those purposes; (b) If electronic records must be signed by electronic means, the type of electronic signature required, the manner and format in which the electronic signature must be affixed to the electronic record","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-128-050-0005","citation":"OAR 128-050-0005(3)","quote":"Agencies shall follow the Information Resources Management Division policy which adopts the federal E-authentication process. The IRMD policy requires that agencies using electronic signatures: (a) Determine the level of assurance the agency needs that the party signing an electronic transaction is authentic. (b) Use only those tools and software applications approved by NIST and the Department of Administrative Services, Information Resources Management Services Division to mitigate the risks identified and provide the level of authentication needed.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule could be read as a valid specification made by the agency under the statute's delegation authority in section 2. Additionally, the rule provides an exemption mechanism (128-050-0005(4)) allowing agencies to request relief from these requirements, which partially preserves agency discretion.","type":null,"section":"ors-84.052","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ff9252a6e4b6c14c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-administrative-services-office-of-the-state-chief-information-officer"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"}]},{"ors_chapter":"87","sections_reviewed":["ors-87.226"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"90","sections_reviewed":["ors-90.650","ors-90.736"],"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 150-090-0600 requires landlords to provide notice of a personal income tax credit, but ORS 90.650 only authorizes notice of the right to appeal property tax assessments and does not mention any tax credit.","documents":[{"id":"ors-90.650","citation":"ORS 90.650(1)","quote":"the landlord shall provide notice to the tenant that the closure may allow the taxpayer to appeal the property tax assessment on the manufactured dwelling.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-90.650","citation":"ORS 90.650(2)","quote":"The Department of Revenue, in consultation with the Housing and Community Services Department, shall adopt rules establishing a sample form and explanation for the property tax assessment appeal.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-090-0600","citation":"OAR 150-090-0600(1)","quote":"A landlord must provide notice regarding the tax credit available to tenants of a closing manufactured dwelling park.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-150-090-0600","citation":"OAR 150-090-0600(2)","quote":"The notice to tenants of a closing park must include: (a) The qualifications for the personal income tax credit (b) Information on how to apply for the personal income tax credit, and (c) Instructions regarding how to appeal the property tax assessment.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"ORS 90.650(2) specifically authorizes the Department of Revenue to establish rules for 'a sample form and explanation for the property tax assessment appeal' only. The statute does not authorize rules requiring notice of a personal income tax credit; ORS 90.650(1) requires notice of only the property tax appeal right and does not mention any tax credit. The rule expands the required notice content beyond what the statute explicitly authorizes.","type":null,"section":"ors-90.650","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"70e6670d55b4fe8a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-revenue"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"137","sections_reviewed":["ors-137.120","ors-137.123"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"144","sections_reviewed":["ors-144.104","ors-144.106","ors-144.120","ors-144.123","ors-144.185","ors-144.260","ors-144.335","ors-144.350","ors-144.635","ors-144.637","ors-144.644","ors-144.787"],"rules_reviewed":95,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 255-030-0010(1)(c) states the one-year timing requirement for initial prison term hearings for inmates sentenced to life or 15+ years without explicitly excluding aggravated murder and murder sentences, but ORS 144.120(1) contains an explicit exception for these offenders.","documents":[{"id":"ors-144.120","citation":"ORS 144.120(1)","quote":"For those prisoners sentenced to a term of imprisonment for life or for 15 years or more, with the exception of those sentenced for aggravated murder or murder, the board shall conduct the parole hearing, and shall set the initial release date, within one year following admission of the prisoner to the institution.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-030-0010","citation":"OAR 255-030-0010(1)(c)","quote":"Twelve months of admission to a Department of Corrections facility for those sentenced to life or fifteen years or more.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"While OAR 255-032-0005 addresses aggravated murder and murder separately (providing for review dates rather than parole release dates), the language in OAR 255-030-0010(1)(c) does not explicitly state the statutory exception and could be read to apply the one-year timing to all life/15+ sentences. A reasonable reading might reconcile these if 255-030-0010 is interpreted as applying only to those not covered by 255-032-0005, but the statute's explicit exception is not reflected in 255-030-0010's text.","type":null,"section":"ors-144.120","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4b1573afd6e0c510","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"Statute lists physical examinations as records the board may consider, but Board Review Packet rules require only psychiatric/psychological evaluations.","documents":[{"id":"ors-144.185","citation":"ORS 144.185(3)","quote":"The reports of any physical, mental and psychiatric examinations of the prisoner;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-060-0030","citation":"OAR 255-060-0030, Exit Interview Board Review Packet","quote":"(3) Psychiatric and/or psychological evaluations (previous 6 months);","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's reference to 'physical, mental and psychiatric examinations' as a distinct category suggests examinations by medical doctors (physical exams) are contemplated. The rule specifies only psychiatric and/or psychological evaluations, which cover psychiatric and psychological aspects but not medical/physical examinations. The rule does not explicitly prohibit physical exams, and the statute uses permissive language ('may cause to be brought before'), but the rule's omission of physical exams from a mandatory packet could create an implementation gap. A similar omission appears in OAR 255-030-0035 which lists only 'Current psychological/psychiatric evaluations' without mentioning physical examinations.","type":null,"section":"ors-144.185","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"87f5b154ac97a3be","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision"]},{"summary":"Two implementing rules cite same statute but define sex offender scope differently: Board rule applies to predatory sex offenders (ORS 181.765), DOC rule applies to level three sex offenders (ORS 163A.105).","documents":[{"id":"ors-144.644","citation":"ORS 144.644(1)","quote":"The State Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision, in consultation with the Department of Corrections and community corrections agencies, shall adopt rules establishing criteria to be considered: (a) In reviewing the proposed residence of a sex offender in a release plan under ORS 144.096 or a parole plan under ORS 144.125; and (b) In determining the residence of a sex offender in a release plan under ORS 144.096, as a condition of post-prison supervision under ORS 144.102 or as a condition of parole under ORS 144.270.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-255-060-0009","citation":"OAR 255-060-0009(1)","quote":"A sex offender classified as a sexually violent dangerous offender (ORS 137.765) or a predatory sex offender (ORS 181.765) may not reside near locations where children are the primary occupants or users.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-291-202-0040","citation":"OAR 291-202-0040(1)","quote":"For purposes of this rule , a sex offender is defined as a person classified as a sexually violent dangerous offender (ORS 137.765) or a level three sex offender (ORS 163A.105).","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Could be defensible if ORS 181.765 and ORS 163A.105 populations are mutually exclusive or if different agencies are appropriately specialized by their respective offender populations. However, statute does not indicate such differentiation, and requires Board consultation with DOC, suggesting coordinated regulation of a single regime.","type":null,"section":"ors-144.644","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f0ccb91776d0cea","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","department-of-corrections"]}],"note":"6 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"147","sections_reviewed":["ors-147.125"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Board"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"161","sections_reviewed":["ors-161.327","ors-161.370"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"The State Police rule assumes PSRB authority to grant firearms relief for people under ORS 161.327, but the statute does not explicitly authorize this.","documents":[{"id":"ors-161.327","citation":"ORS 161.327(1)(a)","quote":"the court shall place the person under the jurisdiction of the Psychiatric Security Review Board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-257-010-0060","citation":"OAR 257-010-0060(6)(a)","quote":"When the PSRB grants relief from the prohibitions under 18 U.S.C. §922(d)(4) and (g)(4) for the purchase, possession, transportation or receipt of a firearm, or grants additional or alternative relief from either the prohibition on possessing a firearm under ORS 166.250 (1)(c)(D) or (E), or the prohibition on receiving a firearm under ORS 166.470 (1)(e) or (f), the PSRB shall send the minimum information of the person for whom relief is granted electronically to OSP.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute places people under PSRB 'jurisdiction,' which could reasonably be interpreted to include authority over various restrictions including firearms. The rule cites multiple statutes as legal authority and may derive firearms relief authority from provisions other than 161.327.","type":null,"section":"ors-161.327","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8e02b92dd47d07f5","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-state-police"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"178","sections_reviewed":["ors-178.205","ors-178.215","ors-178.225"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-state-treasury","name":"Oregon State Treasury"}]},{"ors_chapter":"179","sections_reviewed":["ors-179.505","ors-179.770"],"rules_reviewed":38,"candidates":[{"summary":"Warrant issuance blocked by filed appeal: DOC bars warrant if appeal has been exercised; OHA bars warrant only if appeal is still pending.","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-203-0100","citation":"OAR 291-203-0100(2)(c)","quote":"The adult in custody has exercised the right to appeal the Ability to Pay Order pursuant to OAR 291-203-0090","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-012-0035","citation":"OAR 309-012-0035(4)(c)","quote":"The person has exercised the right to appeal the Reimbursement Order pursuant to OAR 309-012-0025(6) and that appeal is still pending","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute authorizes rulemaking but does not specify the conditions for warrant issuance. DOC's reading prevents warrant issuance whenever an appeal is filed, while OHA's reading allows warrant issuance once a pending appeal is resolved. Both interpretations are reasonable given the statutory silence on this detail, but they create different procedures.","type":null,"section":"ors-179.770","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"29233e36652dab15","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]},{"summary":"Bond execution requirements: DOC requires surety company only; OHA permits surety company or individual sureties.","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-203-0100","citation":"OAR 291-203-0100(3)(b)(A)","quote":"The bond must be executed by a surety company that is registered with, and under the supervision of, the insurance commissioner of the State of Oregon.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-012-0035","citation":"OAR 309-012-0035(5)(b)(A)","quote":"The bond must be executed by: (i) A surety company which is registered with, and under the supervision of, the Insurance Commissioner of the State of Oregon; or (ii) By two or more individual sureties, each of whom shall be a resident and homeowner or holder of an interest in land within the state and each of whom shall be worth sums specified in the under-taking, exclusive of property exempt from execution and over and above all valid debts and liability.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute does not specify bonding requirements. OHA's rule explicitly provides an alternative method not available under DOC's rule. This difference may reflect deliberate policy choice or differential interpretation of bonding authority.","type":null,"section":"ors-179.770","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"6db410cf9dc4d23c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"180","sections_reviewed":["ors-180.267","ors-180.415"],"rules_reviewed":15,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule expands personal information categories triggering fingerprinting by adding medical information and substituting criminal history for criminal background information","documents":[{"id":"ors-180.267","citation":"ORS 180.267(2)(c)","quote":"Has access to personal information about employees or members of the public including Social Security numbers, dates of birth, driver license numbers, personal financial information or criminal background information","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-007-0220","citation":"OAR 137-007-0220(2)(c)","quote":"Has access to personal information about employees or members of the public including Social Security numbers, dates of birth, driver license numbers, medical information, personal financial information or criminal history information","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute uses 'including' to introduce its list, which could indicate an illustrative rather than exhaustive enumeration. Under a broad reading, medical information could fall within 'personal information about employees or members of the public.' However, the explicit enumeration of specific categories—with medical information notably absent—may suggest the statute did not contemplate that category as triggering the fingerprinting requirement.","type":null,"section":"ors-180.267","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b95ce456ed152639","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]},{"summary":"Rule applies to 'tobacco product manufacturers' while statute specifies 'nonparticipating manufacturers'","documents":[{"id":"ors-180.415","citation":"ORS 180.415(2)(b)","quote":"A nonparticipating manufacturer that executes the model escrow agreement is deemed to have satisfied the requirement that it use a form of escrow agreement that has been reviewed and approved by the Attorney General.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-137-105-0025","citation":"OAR 137-105-0025(1)","quote":"A tobacco product manufacturer that executes the model escrow agreement set forth in OAR 137-105-0025(2) is deemed to have satisfied the requirement of ORS 180.415(2)(b) that it use a form of escrow agreement that has been reviewed and approved by the Attorney General.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute applies the model agreement provision to 'nonparticipating manufacturers'; the rule applies it to 'tobacco product manufacturers.' These terms may be equivalent or one may encompass the other, but the terminology is inconsistent with the statutory language. Since the rule implements a provision specifically limited to nonparticipating manufacturers, the rule should use matching terminology unless the broader term is intentional.","type":null,"section":"ors-180.415","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"945d0f0defc93c70","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-justice"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"}]},{"ors_chapter":"192","sections_reviewed":["ors-192.001","ors-192.311","ors-192.345","ors-192.355","ors-192.610","ors-192.690"],"rules_reviewed":34,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule makes exam test data permanently confidential without the statute's temporal limitation (before examination is given; if exam is to be used again).","documents":[{"id":"ors-192.345","citation":"ORS 192.345(4)","quote":"Test questions, scoring keys, and other data used to administer a licensing examination, employment, academic or other examination or testing procedure before the examination is given and if the examination is to be used again.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-809-040-0020","citation":"OAR 809-040-0020","quote":"Test questions, scoring keys, and other data used to administer the national examination and the engineering geologist examination are confidential and may not be disclosed to candidates unless otherwise required by law.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule's language 'are confidential' (present, unconditional) does not track the statute's temporal condition ('before the examination is given') or the reuse condition ('if the examination is to be used again'). However, the rule includes 'unless otherwise required by law,' which could be read to incorporate statutory constraints. Additionally, if the national and engineering geologist exams are recurring, they may continuously satisfy the statute's 'to be used again' condition.","type":null,"section":"ors-192.345","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3596ffb228ecbf25","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-geologist-examiners"]}],"note":"2 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"board-of-parole-and-post-prison-supervision","name":"Board of Parole and Post-Prison Supervision"},{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-albacore-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Albacore Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Blueberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-clover-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Clover Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-dungeness-crab-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Dungeness Crab Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-fine-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Fine Fescue Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hazelnut Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-mint-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Mint Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-potato-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Potato Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-processed-vegetable-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Processed Vegetable Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-ryegrass-growers-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Ryegrass Growers Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-salmon-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Salmon Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Strawberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-tall-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Tall Fescue Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-trawl-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Trawl Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Wheat Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"employment-relations-board","name":"Employment Relations Board"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation"},{"slug":"oregon-government-ethics-commission","name":"Oregon Government Ethics Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-employees-benefit-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Employees' Benefit Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"oregon-public-employees-retirement-system","name":"Oregon Public Employees Retirement System"},{"slug":"oregon-state-library","name":"Oregon State Library"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-archives-division","name":"Secretary of State, Archives Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"194","sections_reviewed":["ors-194.240"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-state-marine-board","name":"Oregon State Marine Board"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"197","sections_reviewed":["ors-197.180"],"rules_reviewed":18,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation","name":"Department of Transportation"},{"slug":"economic-recovery-review-council","name":"Economic Recovery Review Council"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"},{"slug":"land-use-board-of-appeals","name":"Land Use Board of Appeals"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"307","sections_reviewed":["ors-307.459"],"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 603-025-0151 bases ODA's certification authority on ORS 307.453–307.457 (a range including 307.453 and 307.456), but ORS 307.459 authorizes rules only to implement 307.455, 307.457, and 307.458—omitting 307.453 and 307.456 from the statutory scope.","documents":[{"id":"ors-307.459","citation":"ORS 307.459","quote":"The Department of Revenue and the State Department of Agriculture may adopt rules to implement the provisions of ORS 307.455, 307.457 and 307.458.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-025-0151","citation":"OAR 603-025-0151(1)","quote":"The Oregon Department of Agriculture is authorized to certify qualified machinery and equipment for the purposes of ORS 307.453–307.457.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"A reasonable counter-reading is that OAR 603-025-0151(1) merely identifies the full statutory framework governing qualified machinery and equipment as context, while the rule itself is adopted pursuant to ORS 307.459's specific authorization (307.455, 307.457) and possibly independent authority from ORS 307.453 or 307.456. The rule's substantive certification processes may implement only the sections within 307.459's scope.","type":null,"section":"ors-307.459","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"3f5582a483297c8d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"315","sections_reviewed":["ors-315.141"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-oregon-occupational-safety-and-health-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-rail-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Rail Division"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-film-and-video-office","name":"Oregon Film and Video Office"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"316","sections_reviewed":["ors-316.856"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-state-lottery","name":"Oregon State Lottery"}]},{"ors_chapter":"317","sections_reviewed":["ors-317.097"],"rules_reviewed":27,"candidates":[{"summary":"Manufactured dwelling park occupancy requirement added by rule but not stated in statute","documents":[{"id":"ors-317.097","citation":"ORS 317.097(5)(c)","quote":"Subject to subsection (14) of this section, a qualified borrower who: (A) Uses the loan proceeds to finance construction, development, acquisition or rehabilitation of housing consisting of a manufactured dwelling park; and (B) Provides a written certification executed by the Housing and Community Services Department that the housing will continue to be operated as a manufactured dwelling park during the period for which the tax credit is allowed","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-813-110-0013","citation":"OAR 813-110-0013(2)(b)","quote":"The housing created by the loan is or will be occupied by a significant number of households, defined as 60% or more of all households at initial tenant qualification, earning 80 percent or less of the area median income","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute specifies criteria for qualified loans to finance manufactured dwelling parks but does not require that residents earn 80% or less of area median income. Contrast with ORS 317.097(5)(b), (d), (e), and (f), which explicitly state occupancy requirements for other qualified loan categories. The rule imposes an income-based occupancy requirement (60% of households at 80% AMI) that does not appear in the statute's text for MDPs. This could be viewed as implementing the general affordable housing purpose, but the statute does not explicitly authorize this requirement for this specific category.","type":null,"section":"ors-317.097","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"13ef392d42dc3698","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-housing-and-community-services-department"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"346","sections_reviewed":["ors-346.010"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"commission-for-the-blind","name":"Commission for the Blind"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"}]},{"ors_chapter":"390","sections_reviewed":["ors-390.565","ors-390.635","ors-390.805"],"rules_reviewed":29,"candidates":[{"summary":"The statute limits the Parks and Recreation Department's jurisdiction to land acquired under specified statutes, but the rule applies to ocean beaches without verifying or stating they meet this acquisition requirement.","documents":[{"id":"ors-390.635","citation":"ORS 390.635","quote":"the State Parks and Recreation Department has jurisdiction over the land and interests in land acquired under ORS 390.610, 390.615, 390.620 or 390.630","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-736-030-0095","citation":"OAR 736-030-0095","quote":"Camping on the ocean shore between the Necanicum River and the South Jetty of the Columbia River is prohibited.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule cites ORS 390.660 as additional legal authority, which may provide separate jurisdictional grounds for regulating these beaches independent of the acquisition requirement in ORS 390.635. The apparent inconsistency may be resolved if the referenced beaches were acquired under the specified statutes or if ORS 390.660 provides broader authority.","type":null,"section":"ors-390.635","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"bd4beed0ab81787d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["parks-and-recreation-department"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-state-lands","name":"Department of State Lands"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"land-conservation-and-development-department","name":"Land Conservation and Development Department"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"401","sections_reviewed":["ors-401.168"],"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"oregon-military-department-office-of-emergency-management","name":"Oregon Military Department, Office of Emergency Management"}]},{"ors_chapter":"409","sections_reviewed":["ors-409.025","ors-409.040"],"rules_reviewed":8,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"}]},{"ors_chapter":"411","sections_reviewed":["ors-411.085","ors-411.095","ors-411.122","ors-411.300","ors-411.408"],"rules_reviewed":31,"candidates":[{"summary":"Notice requirement for GA housing assistance reductions appears to conflict with statutory mandate for advance notice","documents":[{"id":"ors-411.095","citation":"ORS 411.095(1)(a)","quote":"when the Department of Human Services or the Oregon Health Authority changes a benefit standard that results in the reduction, suspension or closure of a grant of public assistance or a grant of medical assistance, the department or the authority shall mail a notice of intended action to each recipient affected by the change at least 30 days before the effective date of the action","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-175-0224","citation":"OAR 461-175-0224","quote":"In the GA program, no decision notice (see OAR 461-001-0000) is required under the following circumstances: (1) The Department reduces housing assistance payments because a change in housing arrangements results in decreased rent. (2) The Department ends housing assistance payments due to a loss of housing.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute requires advance notice when DHS action results in reduction or closure of public assistance. The rule explicitly provides that no decision notice is required for GA housing assistance reductions/closures in two specific circumstances. This could be consistent if 'changes a benefit standard' is interpreted narrowly to mean only changes to department policies, not applications of existing policies to changed client circumstances (e.g., lower rent). If housing assistance reduction due to lower rent is application of existing standards rather than a department benefit standard change, the rule may be correct. However, a plain reading of the statute could require notice whenever department action results in reduction.","type":null,"section":"ors-411.095","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0b88b5f71ff23c2a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]},{"summary":"DHS defines 'reasonable promptness' for claim action as 45 days from application, while OHA's rule establishes a 90-day timeline only after a hearing request, leaving initial 'reasonable promptness' undefined.","documents":[{"id":"ors-411.408","citation":"ORS 411.408","quote":"if the Oregon Health Authority or the Department of Human Services denies a claim for medical assistance or fails to act with reasonable promptness on a claim for medical assistance, the person making the claim may request a contested case hearing","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-025-0310","citation":"OAR 461-025-0310(1)(a)","quote":"Except as provided in subsection (o) of this section, the Department has not approved or denied a request or application for public assistance or medical assistance within 45 days of the application","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-410-200-0146","citation":"OAR 410-200-0146(5)(a)","quote":"A final order shall be issued or the case otherwise shall be resolved no later than: (a) Ninety days following the date of the hearing request","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's 'reasonable promptness' language addresses failure to act on the initial claim. OAR 461-025-0310 defines this as 45 days for DHS. OAR 410-200-0146(5) addresses only the final-order timeline post-hearing request, not the initial-action standard that triggers the right to request a hearing. If OAR 410-200-0145 or other OHA rules define an initial timeline, the inconsistency may not exist; however, within the provided texts, the two agencies appear to implement different standards.","type":null,"section":"ors-411.408","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7e82adf4f44d97b6","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"412","sections_reviewed":["ors-412.024"],"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute appears to limit application to TANF/Title IV-A, but implementing rule extends assignment requirement to Title IV-E programs.","documents":[{"id":"ors-412.024","citation":"ORS 412.024(3)","quote":"This section shall apply to recipients of aid pursuant to the temporary assistance for needy families program as long as the aid is funded in whole or in part with federal grants under Title IV-A of the Social Security Act.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-461-120-0310","citation":"OAR 461-120-0310(2)","quote":"To be eligible for any program funded in whole or in part with federal grants under Title IV-E of the Social Security Act, the filing group must assign to the state its right to receive, from any other person, child support that has accrued or that accrues during any time period that the group receives assistance, not to exceed the total amount of assistance paid.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's sections (1) and (2) use the broad term 'aid' without specifying program. Section (3) may limit the entire section to TANF, or may simply clarify that TANF is included when federally funded. If sections (1) and (2) apply broadly to all aid recipients, Title IV-E programs (also federally funded) could reasonably fall within the statute's scope, supporting the rule's consistency with statutory intent.","type":null,"section":"ors-412.024","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9c9f9018d3edf4ed","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"}]},{"ors_chapter":"413","sections_reviewed":["ors-413.014","ors-413.033","ors-413.036","ors-413.161","ors-413.558"],"rules_reviewed":59,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule narrows advisory committee composition to REALD-affected individuals but excludes those affected by SOGI data collection, while statute contemplates committee representing all persons affected by adopted standards including SOGI.","documents":[{"id":"ors-413.161","citation":"ORS 413.161(1)","quote":"The Oregon Health Authority, in collaboration with the Department of Human Services, shall adopt by rule uniform standards, based on local, statewide and national best practices, for the collection of data on race, ethnicity, preferred spoken and written languages, disability status, sexual orientation and gender identity.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-413.161","citation":"ORS 413.161(2)","quote":"The authority shall appoint an advisory committee in accordance with ORS 183.333 composed of individuals likely to be affected by the standards and advocates for individuals likely to be affected by the standards.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-950-038-0010","citation":"OAR 950-038-0010(2)","quote":"The Authority, in collaboration with the Department, shall appoint a permanent standing advisory committee composed of individuals or advocates of individuals likely to be affected by the inequities addressed in the collection of race, ethnicity, preferred spoken, signed and written language, and disability status data.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule's enumeration of specific data types (REALD) while omitting SOGI could be read as non-exhaustive, and section (3) directs the committee to advise on 'these rules' generally (which include SOGI collection), suggesting the committee's full scope may implicitly cover SOGI despite the compositional language in (2). However, the statute's reference to 'the standards' (which explicitly include SOGI) suggests committee representation should encompass all affected populations.","type":null,"section":"ors-413.161","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"913cf9d8738ab355","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division"]},{"summary":"ASL qualified interpreter training requirement exemption","documents":[{"id":"ors-413.558","citation":"ORS 413.558(4)","quote":"Has had at least 60 hours of health care interpreter training that includes anatomy and physiology and concepts of health care interpretation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-950-050-0040","citation":"OAR 950-050-0040(3)(b)","quote":"Provide written verification of certification in American Sign Language interpreting from the Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf (RID) or other Oregon Health Authority-approved signed language certification and testing bodies","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute requires all qualified health care interpreters to have 'at least 60 hours of health care interpreter training that includes anatomy and physiology and concepts of health care interpretation,' with no stated exception for signed language interpreters. However, the rule allows ASL qualified interpreters to substitute RID certification without explicit requirement for the 60-hour health care-specific training or documented evidence that RID certification includes the required content (anatomy, physiology, health care interpretation concepts). The statute makes no distinction between interpreter types regarding this training requirement.","type":null,"section":"ors-413.558","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"109d798de362a2e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division"]}],"note":"2 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-naturopathic-medicine","name":"Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority Equity and Inclusion Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"414","sections_reviewed":["ors-414.312"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-equity-and-inclusion-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority Equity and Inclusion Division"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-oregon-prescription-drug-program","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Oregon Prescription Drug Program"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"417","sections_reviewed":["ors-417.782","ors-417.859"],"rules_reviewed":11,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rehabilitation Act citation year differs between statute and rule (1973 vs. 1978).","documents":[{"id":"ors-417.859","citation":"ORS 417.859(6)(c)(E)","quote":"How the school district or other entity will provide special education and related services for eligible youths with disabilities who have an individualized education program or will provide necessary accommodations and plans for eligible youths who qualify under section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. 794)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-581-017-0655","citation":"OAR 581-017-0655(2)(e)","quote":"How the reengagement program will provide special education and related services for eligible youths with disabilities who have an individualized education program, or will provide necessary accommodations and plans for eligible youths who qualify under section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1978 (29 U.S.C. 794)","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The Rehabilitation Act was enacted in 1973, making the statute's citation correct. This appears to be a factual error in the rule. The functional requirement (29 U.S.C. 794) is identical, but the year citation is inconsistent.","type":null,"section":"ors-417.859","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2a60a152d4e0bd8a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-department-of-education"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-early-learning-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Early Learning Division"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education-youth-development-division","name":"Oregon Department of Education, Youth Development Division"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"418","sections_reviewed":["ors-418.016","ors-418.205","ors-418.255","ors-418.280"],"rules_reviewed":39,"candidates":[{"summary":"Proctor foster home definition cites different ORS section range","documents":[{"id":"ors-418.205","citation":"ORS 418.205(10)","quote":"not subject to ORS 418.625 to 418.645","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-015-0115","citation":"OAR 413-015-0115(57)","quote":"not subject to ORS 418.625 to 418.470","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute specifies exemption from ORS 418.625 to 418.645, while the implementing rule narrows this to ORS 418.625 to 418.470. This effectively changes which ORS sections apply to proctor foster homes, potentially expanding regulatory requirements if sections 418.471-418.645 are relevant to child welfare licensing.","type":null,"section":"ors-418.205","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5a9d4c1ba21f6bb1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"Secure transportation provider definition differs on medical and nonemergency qualifiers","documents":[{"id":"ors-418.205","citation":"ORS 418.205(2)(b)(E)","quote":"A secure nonemergency medical transportation provider, as defined in ORS 418.241","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-413-015-0115","citation":"OAR 413-015-0115(8)(b)(E)","quote":"A secure transportation services provider that transports or provides escort services for children on the highways of this state, along a route that begins or ends in this state as described in ORS 418.205","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute specifically includes 'secure nonemergency medical transportation provider' as a defined category with specific attributes. Rule generalizes this to 'secure transportation services provider' and relocates the route requirements (begins or ends in state) from ORS 418.241 definition to this rule. Rule text does not preserve the 'nonemergency medical' specification, potentially expanding scope beyond what statute contemplates.","type":null,"section":"ors-418.205","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"566e0bc144bec047","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs"]},{"summary":"Statute requires financial statements reviewed by independent CPA for $1M-or-less agencies upon request; rules specify only internal financial statements without explicit independent review requirement.","documents":[{"id":"ors-418.255","citation":"ORS 418.255(3)(b)","quote":"a child-caring agency subject to ORS 418.205 to 418.327, 418.470, 418.475 or 418.950 to 418.970 that has annual revenues of $1 million or less shall provide the Department of Human Services, upon request or at such times as the department specifies by rule, with financial statements that have been reviewed by an independent certified public accountant and a tax compliance certificate issued by the Department of Revenue.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-419-400-0050","citation":"OAR 419-400-0050(3)(a)","quote":"A child-caring agency must maintain complete and accurate accounts, books, and records following generally accepted principles of accounting. A child-caring agency must provide to the Department current internal financial statements, general ledgers, bank statements, and any other financial records as required in OAR 419-400-0210 and upon request.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-419-400-0210","citation":"OAR 419-400-0210(4)(h)(A)","quote":"Except as provided in paragraph (B) of this subsection, a child-caring agency that has annual revenues in excess of $1 million must provide an audit completed by an independent certified public accountant for the most recent fiscal year.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute requires $1M-or-less agencies to provide 'financial statements that have been reviewed by an independent certified public accountant' upon request (or at specified times). OAR 419-400-0210(4) explicitly addresses audited statements for >$1M agencies at renewal but is silent on $1M-or-less agencies. OAR 419-400-0050(3)(a) requires 'current internal financial statements' upon request, but does not specify that they must be reviewed by an independent CPA as the statute requires. The gap is particularly clear because the rule explicitly differentiates requirements by revenue threshold in 419-400-0210(4)(h), yet provides no parallel requirement for reviewed statements for smaller agencies.","type":null,"section":"ors-418.255","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d7b7e1d661a15e41","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["office-of-training-investigations-and-safety"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-child-welfare-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Child Welfare Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"420","sections_reviewed":["ors-420.500","ors-420.505"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule applies to 'offenders' in OYA close custody; statute specifies 'adjudicated youth' as the subject population. Additionally: Rule permits transfer to 'facility designated by the Addictions and Mental Health Division' but statute limits transfer to 'institution for persons with mental illness or mental retardation'","documents":[{"id":"ors-420.500","citation":"ORS 420.500","quote":"An adjudicated youth in a youth correction facility may not be transferred","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-120-0070","citation":"OAR 309-120-0070","quote":"offenders in Oregon Youth Authority (OYA) close custody facilities may be transferred","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-420.500","citation":"ORS 420.500","quote":"transferred to an institution for persons with mental illness or mental retardation","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-120-0070","citation":"OAR 309-120-0070","quote":"transferred to a state mental hospital or a facility designated by the Addictions and Mental Health Division","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Terminology difference: 'adjudicated youth' is a defined legal status; 'offenders' may be broader. If OYA close custody houses non-adjudicated offenders, the rule's scope could exceed statute. Addictions treatment facilities may not be 'institutions for mental illness or mental retardation' — these address different service categories. Unclear if the Addictions and Mental Health Division designation includes only mental illness/retardation facilities or extends to substance abuse treatment. [severity recorded by the model as 'medium-high'; normalized to 'high'.]","type":null,"section":"ors-420.500","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e6badf1a92f056c7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-youth-authority","name":"Oregon Youth Authority"}]},{"ors_chapter":"421","sections_reviewed":["ors-421.512"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"426","sections_reviewed":["ors-426.110","ors-426.237","ors-426.385"],"rules_reviewed":27,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute permits mechanical restraints if medically needed; rule restricts seclusion/restraint to behavioral management (violent or self-destructive behavior).","documents":[{"id":"ors-426.385","citation":"ORS 426.385(4)","quote":"Mechanical restraints may not be applied to a person admitted to a facility unless it is determined by the chief medical officer of the facility or designee to be required by the medical needs of the person.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-309-033-0700","citation":"OAR 309-033-0700(2)","quote":"Seclusion or restraint may be used only for the management of violent or self-destructive behavior that jeopardizes the immediate physical safety of the patient, a staff member, or other individuals.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"In behavioral health settings, terminology may distinguish between 'mechanical restraints' (statute, possibly medical procedures or restraint devices) and 'seclusion or restraint' (rule, behavioral management). If these terms are synonymous or substantially overlap, the rule's restriction to behavioral management narrows the statute's 'medical needs' standard. A reasonable counter-reading is that the statute and rule address distinct types of restraint use, one medical and one behavioral.","type":null,"section":"ors-426.385","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"54b7807ebdfcf765","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"psychiatric-security-review-board","name":"Psychiatric Security Review Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"430","sections_reviewed":["ors-430.010","ors-430.610","ors-430.705","ors-430.735"],"rules_reviewed":23,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"}]},{"ors_chapter":"432","sections_reviewed":["ors-432.143"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule omits statutory five-day submission deadline for non-institutional fetal deaths","documents":[{"id":"ors-432.143","citation":"ORS 432.143(4)","quote":"the physician in attendance at or immediately after the delivery of the fetus shall prepare and submit the report of fetal death within five calendar days of the delivery in a format adopted by the state registrar by rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-432.143","citation":"ORS 432.143(5)","quote":"the medical examiner in the jurisdiction where the fetal death occurred shall prepare and submit the report of fetal death within five calendar days of the delivery in a format adopted by the state registrar by rule","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-011-0285","citation":"OAR 333-011-0285","quote":"When a fetal death occurs outside a licensed medical facility, the report of fetal death must be submitted by the Medical Examiner or physician who attended at or immediately after the delivery through the electronic reporting system","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute mandates submission within five calendar days for both physician-attended and medical-examiner-submitted deaths outside institutions. The rule addresses who must submit but contains no timeframe requirement. The rule may be incomplete, or the five-day requirement may be incorporated through other rules or administrative procedures not shown here.","type":null,"section":"ors-432.143","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"536dc8b158e66cdc","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"441","sections_reviewed":["ors-441.037","ors-441.044","ors-441.056","ors-441.223","ors-441.820"],"rules_reviewed":23,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-chiropractic-examiners","name":"Board of Chiropractic Examiners"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"443","sections_reviewed":["ors-443.373","ors-443.400","ors-443.886"],"rules_reviewed":35,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute requires applicant to identify individual responsible for application; rule does not list this as required application component","documents":[{"id":"ors-443.373","citation":"ORS 443.373(4)(a)","quote":"The department shall require an applicant to: (a) Identify an individual responsible for the application","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-058-0020","citation":"OAR 411-058-0020(1)(a)","quote":"Application for registration must be made to the Department and must include: (A) The registration fee as described in section (2) of this rule; (B) The disclosure statement as described in OAR 411-058-0030; (C) General Liability Insurance requirements, as described in OAR 411-058-0070; and (D) Background Check Requirements, as described in OAR 411-058-0080.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute explicitly requires the applicant to identify an individual responsible for the application. The rule lists four required components (fee, disclosure, insurance, background check requirements) but does not include identification of an individual responsible. This requirement does not appear elsewhere in the rules examined. Possible mitigation: this requirement could be satisfied through application forms or data entry rather than rule text, or the disclosure statement's requirement for agent name in OAR 411-058-0030(2)(b) might be intended to address this, though that rule specifically requires the referral agent's name rather than an individual responsible for the application.","type":null,"section":"ors-443.373","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"39734d88d7ae87a0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]},{"summary":"Fee schedule does not differentiate by type of facility despite statute requiring consideration of facility type","documents":[{"id":"ors-443.886","citation":"ORS 443.886(3)","quote":"The department shall adopt a fee schedule for memory care endorsement, taking into account the type of facility and the number of residents.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-411-057-0120","citation":"OAR 411-057-0120(3)","quote":"Fees shall be as follows: (a) $50 for each facility with a total memory care community endorsed capacity of 16 or fewer residents; (b) $75 for each facility with a total memory care community endorsed capacity of 17 to 50; or (c) $100 for each facility with a total memory care community endorsed capacity of 51 or more.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute mandates taking into account both facility type (nursing facility, assisted living facility, residential care facility) and number of residents. Rule establishes single fee schedule based only on resident capacity, without differentiation by type of facility. DHS could defend this as having considered facility type but determined other factors are dispositive, but the statute language suggests facility type should be a differentiating factor.","type":null,"section":"ors-443.886","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ba22486f0601da64","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities"]}],"note":"2 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services","name":"Department of Human Services"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"office-of-training-investigations-and-safety","name":"Office of Training, Investigations and Safety"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-policy-and-analytics","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Policy and Analytics"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-addiction-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Addiction Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-behavioral-health-services","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Behavioral Health Services"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"446","sections_reviewed":["ors-446.062","ors-446.095","ors-446.100","ors-446.641"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule requires buyer's notice to be 'division approved', but statute does not explicitly specify this requirement for buyer-submitted notices","documents":[{"id":"ors-446.641","citation":"ORS 446.641(8)","quote":"a buyer may submit a notice of sale to the assessor if the notice is accompanied by proof of sale acceptable to the department as provided by rule.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-550-0120","citation":"OAR 918-550-0120","quote":"If a purchaser submits a division approved notice of sale under ORS 446.641(8), the purchaser must include one or more of the following as acceptable proof of sale:","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute requires seller's notice to be on approved form (446.641(2)) but does not explicitly state this for buyer notices (446.641(8)). Rule adds 'division approved' requirement for buyer-submitted notices. Reasonable reading: statute delegates proof-of-sale definition to rule under subsection (8), which the rule appropriately provides; however, the 'division approved' requirement for the notice itself is not explicitly delegated, only the proof standards.","type":null,"section":"ors-446.641","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d3324f6eeccf0285","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"447","sections_reviewed":["ors-447.154"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"oregon-business-development-department","name":"Oregon Business Development Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"453","sections_reviewed":["ors-453.752","ors-453.780","ors-453.790","ors-453.864"],"rules_reviewed":23,"candidates":[],"note":"1 candidate(s) were proposed here and ALL were dropped by quote verification. This chapter is NOT clean — it is unresolved.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","name":"Department of State Police, Office of State Fire Marshal"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"455","sections_reviewed":["ors-455.044","ors-455.560"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule does not specify geographic limitation to three counties required by statute","documents":[{"id":"ors-455.044","citation":"ORS 455.044","quote":"Fees adopted and imposed under this section shall be in addition to the total building permit fees otherwise imposed in Clackamas, Multnomah and Washington Counties.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-050-0800","citation":"OAR 918-050-0800","quote":"(1) A one-percent surcharge will be assessed upon the total permit fees collected pursuant to ORS 455.210(4)(c).\n\n(2) Effective January 1, 2008, a four percent surcharge will be assessed upon the total permit fees collected pursuant to ORS 455.210(4)(d).","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute explicitly limits application to Clackamas, Multnomah, and Washington Counties. Rule may rely on incorporation by reference or another implementing mechanism, but the geographic scope is not stated in the rule text itself.","type":null,"section":"ors-455.044","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"19c3e0a5c8a1f194","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-geology-and-mineral-industries","name":"Department of Geology and Mineral Industries"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"458","sections_reviewed":["ors-458.480"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"466","sections_reviewed":["ors-466.330"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"Subject matter mismatch: statute concerns PCB disposal and condemnation; rule regulates recreation parksite design and health hazards from soil/groundwater/drainage.","documents":[{"id":"ors-466.330","citation":"ORS 466.330","quote":"The Environmental Quality Commission may acquire real property for the disposal of PCB by instituting condemnation proceedings therefor to be conducted in accordance with ORS chapter 35.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-333-031-0060","citation":"OAR 333-031-0060","quote":"Condition of soil, groundwater level, drainage, and topography shall be considered in the design of the park and in the selection of the type and location of water supply and sewage disposal systems so that a health hazard is not created.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule cites ORS 466.330 as legal authority but the statute is entirely about environmental waste (PCB) and condemnation procedures. The rule addresses recreation parksite design and health hazards—subjects unrelated to the statute. The rule's own frontmatter lists different statutes (ORS 446.330, 446.340, 446.345) as the ones it implements, suggesting possible misattribution in legal authority.","type":null,"section":"ors-466.330","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2e6a6cacb06f51a3","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-public-health-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"secretary-of-state-corporation-division","name":"Secretary of State, Corporation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"469","sections_reviewed":["ors-469.740"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule describes 'Voluntary' standards while statute mandates Director 'shall adopt rules establishing energy conservation standards'. Additionally: Rule limits standards to pre-1978 buildings while statute requires standards for 'public buildings' without temporal qualification","documents":[{"id":"ors-469.740","citation":"ORS 469.740","quote":"the Director of the Department of Consumer and Business Services shall adopt rules establishing energy conservation standards for public buildings","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-918-440-0020","citation":"OAR 918-440-0020","quote":"Voluntary energy conservation standards for public buildings constructed prior to January 1, 1978, have been adopted by the Building Codes Division pursuant to ORS 469.740","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute mandates adoption of standards but does not specify whether standards must be mandatory or may be voluntary. Potential conflict: whether 'voluntary' standards satisfy the statutory obligation to establish energy conservation standards. The statute does not explicitly authorize limiting standards to buildings of a particular age. Potential conflict: whether the rule's restriction to pre-1978 construction exceeds delegated authority. However, delegation doctrine typically allows differentiation by building characteristics.","type":null,"section":"ors-469.740","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"001ffc895f5bf8ec","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"department-of-energy-energy-facility-siting-council","name":"Department of Energy, Energy Facility Siting Council"},{"slug":"oregon-housing-and-community-services-department","name":"Oregon Housing and Community Services Department"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"475","sections_reviewed":["ors-475.005","ors-475.125","ors-475.190","ors-475.425"],"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy"},{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police","name":"Department of State Police"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"veterinary-medical-examining-board","name":"Veterinary Medical Examining Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"477","sections_reviewed":["ors-477.001"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-forestry","name":"Department of Forestry"}]},{"ors_chapter":"480","sections_reviewed":["ors-480.390","ors-480.570","ors-480.660"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-state-police-office-of-state-fire-marshal","name":"Department of State Police, Office of State Fire Marshal"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-aviation","name":"Oregon Department of Aviation"}]},{"ors_chapter":"498","sections_reviewed":["ors-498.152","ors-498.158"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule grants Department authority to trap without showing statutory prerequisites (ordinance/resolution authorization and Commission determination after notice and hearing)","documents":[{"id":"ors-498.158","citation":"ORS 498.158(2)","quote":"No hunting or trapping shall be allowed on any lands within the boundaries of any city, public park or on any school lands unless: (a) The governing body or other agency that administers the affairs of the city, public park or school, after notice and hearing, authorizes such hunting or trapping by ordinance or resolution; and (b) The State Fish and Wildlife Commission, after notice and hearing, determines that such hunting or trapping would not adversely affect public safety or unreasonably interfere with other authorized uses of such lands.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-635-043-0056","citation":"OAR 635-043-0056","quote":"For the purpose of alleviating a public nuisance or preventing property damage, the Department may trap and relocate wild turkeys found within the Roseburg city limits.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Rule may be read as presuming the statutory prerequisites have been satisfied elsewhere, but the rule text does not reference or confirm compliance with mandatory statutory procedures (ordinance/resolution and Commission determination).","type":null,"section":"ors-498.158","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e065262c90369ce0","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-fish-and-wildlife"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"517","sections_reviewed":["ors-517.831"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-geology-and-mineral-industries","name":"Department of Geology and Mineral Industries"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"537","sections_reviewed":["ors-537.332","ors-537.797"],"rules_reviewed":18,"candidates":[],"note":"2 candidate(s) were proposed here and ALL were dropped by quote verification. This chapter is NOT clean — it is unresolved.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-fish-and-wildlife","name":"Department of Fish and Wildlife"},{"slug":"parks-and-recreation-department","name":"Parks and Recreation Department"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"570","sections_reviewed":["ors-570.800"],"rules_reviewed":6,"candidates":[],"note":"1 candidate(s) were proposed here and ALL were dropped by quote verification. This chapter is NOT clean — it is unresolved.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-invasive-species-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Invasive Species Council"}]},{"ors_chapter":"576","sections_reviewed":["ors-576.051","ors-576.066","ors-576.206","ors-576.265","ors-576.311","ors-576.325","ors-576.416","ors-576.440"],"rules_reviewed":45,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule extends the scope of statutes for measuring plan consistency beyond what the statute specifies.","documents":[{"id":"ors-576.066","citation":"ORS 576.066(2)(c)","quote":"Consistent with the purposes of ORS 576.051 to 576.455","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-042-0015","citation":"OAR 603-042-0015(1)(c)","quote":"Consistent with the purposes of ORS 576.051 to 576.584, 577, and 578","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule explicitly implements three different statutes (ORS 576.066, 577.125, 578.025) and applies to multiple commodity commissions. The broader criteria range may be a defensible necessity to apply uniform review standards across commissions operating under different statutory authorities, each with potentially different purposes. However, ORS 576.066(2)(c) is specific about the reference range that should apply to its review standard.","type":null,"section":"ors-576.066","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"90afbd78b2dba745","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Different deadlines for submitting compensation claims across commodity commissions (Beef 15th day vs Hazelnut/Sweet Cherry 10th day vs Raspberry/Blackberry/Strawberry 10th of second month)","documents":[{"id":"oar-605-020-0010","citation":"OAR 605-020-0010(3)","quote":"In order to receive compensation, a member must submit to the Oregon Beef Council a written claim for compensation by the 15th day of the calendar month following the month for which the member seeks compensation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-611-040-0010","citation":"OAR 611-040-0010(3)","quote":"In order to receive compensation, a member must submit to the Commission a written claim for compensation by the 10th day of the second calendar month following the month for which the member seeks compensation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-623-040-0005","citation":"OAR 623-040-0005(3)","quote":"In order to receive compensation, a member must submit to the Oregon Hazelnut Commission a written claim for compensation by the 10th day of the calendar month following the month for which the member seeks compensation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-668-040-0010","citation":"OAR 668-040-0010(3)","quote":"In order to receive compensation, a member must submit to the Commission a written claim for compensation by the 10th day of the second calendar month following the month for which the member seeks compensation.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-669-030-0050","citation":"OAR 669-030-0050(3)","quote":"In order to receive compensation, a member must submit to the Oregon Sweet Cherry Commission a written claim for compensation by the 10th day of the calendar month following the month for which the member seeks compensation.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute delegates compensation procedures to commission rules without specifying claim deadlines. Divergent readings may reflect legitimate commission discretion, but the variation across five commissions (15th, 10th, and 10th-of-second-month) warrants review to determine if this degree of variation was contemplated by statute.","type":null,"section":"ors-576.206","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"d2462d3ef4f4ea7c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-sweet-cherry-commission"]},{"summary":"Different expense authorization thresholds across commodity commissions, ranging from $200 to $1,000","documents":[{"id":"oar-623-040-0010","citation":"OAR 623-040-0010(3)","quote":"An expense that exceeds $200 dollars must be authorized by the Oregon Hazelnut Commission before a member incurs the expense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-668-040-0020","citation":"OAR 668-040-0020(3)","quote":"An expense that exceeds $300 dollars must be authorized by the Commission before a member incurs the expense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-605-020-0020","citation":"OAR 605-020-0020(3)","quote":"An expense that exceeds $500.00 dollars must be authorized by the Oregon Beef Council before a member incurs the expense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-669-030-0060","citation":"OAR 669-030-0060(3)","quote":"An expense that exceeds $500 dollars must be authorized by the Oregon Sweet Cherry Commission before a member incurs the expense.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-611-040-0020","citation":"OAR 611-040-0020(3)","quote":"An expense that exceeds $1,000 dollars must be authorized by the Commission before a member incurs the expense.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Statute does not specify expense authorization thresholds, delegating details to commission rules. Thresholds vary fivefold ($200-$1,000) across commissions. Divergent readings may reflect legitimate discretion unless statute intended uniform standards across commodity commissions.","type":null,"section":"ors-576.206","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"df2dcba396c740c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","department-of-agriculture-oregon-sweet-cherry-commission"]}],"note":"3 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Beef Council"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-blueberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Blueberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-dairy-products-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Dairy Products Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-dungeness-crab-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Dungeness Crab Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-fine-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Fine Fescue Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hazelnut-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hazelnut Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-hop-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Hop Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-mint-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Mint Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-potato-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Potato Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-processed-vegetable-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Processed Vegetable Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-raspberry-and-blackberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Raspberry and Blackberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-ryegrass-growers-seed-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Ryegrass Growers Seed Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-salmon-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Salmon Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sheep-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sheep Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-strawberry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Strawberry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-sweet-cherry-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Sweet Cherry Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-tall-fescue-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Tall Fescue Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-trawl-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Trawl Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-wheat-commission","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Wheat Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"577","sections_reviewed":["ors-577.125"],"rules_reviewed":6,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule uses 'other commodities' for disparagement criterion where statute specifies 'agricultural commodities'","documents":[{"id":"ors-577.125","citation":"ORS 577.125(2)(b)","quote":"Not disparaging to agricultural commodities","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-042-0015","citation":"OAR 603-042-0015(1)(b)","quote":"Not disparaging to other commodities","quote_verified":true}],"note":"In context of beef promotion, both likely mean the same thing: beef materials should not disparage other agricultural commodities. However, statute uses broader term 'agricultural commodities' while rule uses 'other commodities,' which could potentially have different meanings or scope.","type":null,"section":"ors-577.125","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"4d05ac7e146545c1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]},{"summary":"Rule requires consistency with multiple chapters while statute specifies single chapter","documents":[{"id":"ors-577.125","citation":"ORS 577.125(2)(c)","quote":"Consistent with the purposes of this chapter","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-603-042-0015","citation":"OAR 603-042-0015(1)(c)","quote":"Consistent with the purposes of ORS 576.051 to 576.584, 577, and 578","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule applies uniformly to commodity commissions under three different statutes (576.066, 577.125, 578.025), so requiring consistency with all three chapters is a reasonable and practical unified approach. However, statute 577.125 specifically requires 'this chapter' (577) alone, and the rule extends the scope to Chapters 576, 577, and 578, potentially raising review standards beyond what the statute contemplates.","type":null,"section":"ors-577.125","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"afbeb17416182d5c","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-agriculture"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-agriculture","name":"Department of Agriculture"},{"slug":"department-of-agriculture-oregon-beef-council","name":"Department of Agriculture, Oregon Beef Council"}]},{"ors_chapter":"656","sections_reviewed":["ors-656.307","ors-656.612","ors-656.725"],"rules_reviewed":36,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute authorizes additional assessment only from self-insured employer groups, but rule also assesses individual self-insured employers","documents":[{"id":"ors-656.612","citation":"ORS 656.612(3)","quote":"The director may impose and collect an additional assessment from self-insured employer groups in an amount sufficient to pay the additional expenses involved in administering the group self-insured program.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-440-045-0025","citation":"OAR 440-045-0025","quote":"In addition to the assessments established in OAR 440-045-0020, self-insured employers for the Calendar Year 2026 shall be assessed an additional 0.1 percent to fund the Self-Insured Employer Adjustment Reserve. Public self-insured employer groups for the Calendar Year 2026 shall be assessed an additional 0.1 percent to fund the Self-Insured Employer Group Adjustment Reserve. Private self-insured employer groups for the Calendar Year 2026 shall be assessed an additional 0.5 percent to fund the Self-Insured Employer Group Adjustment Reserve.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-436-085-0005","citation":"OAR 436-085-0005(8)-(9)","quote":"(8) \"Self-Insured employer\" means an employer that has been certified under ORS 656.430 as having met the qualifications of a self-insured employer set out by ORS 656.407. (9) \"Self-Insured employer group\" means five or more employers certified under ORS 656.430 as having met the qualifications of a self-insured employer set out by ORS 656.407 and OAR 436-050-0260 through 436-050-0340.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute distinguishes between 'self-insured employers' (individual entities) and 'self-insured employer groups' (five or more entities) as separate categories throughout 656.612(1). Subsection (3) limits the additional assessment authority to 'self-insured employer groups,' not individual 'self-insured employers.' However, OAR 440-045-0025 imposes an additional 0.1% assessment on individual 'self-insured employers' as well as on groups. A reasonable counter-reading might note that OAR 436-085-0030(1) states that for purposes of that rule, 'self-insured employers' includes groups, but 440-045-0025 does not contain such a definitional provision and appears to treat them as separate categories.","type":null,"section":"ors-656.612","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"19530f7087ffd7cb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-oregon-occupational-safety-and-health-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-board","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Board"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-home-care-commission","name":"Department of Human Services, Home Care Commission"},{"slug":"department-of-justice","name":"Department of Justice"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"658","sections_reviewed":["ors-658.078","ors-658.405","ors-658.705"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule specifies contract logging format but does not address statutory requirement to maintain receipts of moneys received","documents":[{"id":"ors-658.078","citation":"ORS 658.078(2)","quote":"keep accurate and current records of all contracts and receipts of moneys received from applicants","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-839-017-0032","citation":"OAR 839-017-0032","quote":"All contracts shall be in numerical order and registered in a log. The log will contain the contract number, the date, and the name of the applicant as it appears in some uniform place in the contract.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute explicitly requires recording of 'receipts of moneys received from applicants' as a distinct record-keeping obligation when charges are collected. The rule implements logging requirements for contracts but contains no specification for how receipts or amounts received should be recorded. This could represent incomplete implementation of the statutory requirement, or receipts could be addressed elsewhere in the regulatory framework. [confidence recorded by the model as 'moderate'; normalized to 'medium'.] [severity recorded by the model as 'moderate'; normalized to 'medium'.]","type":null,"section":"ors-658.078","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1e1c6c946899a26e","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["bureau-of-labor-and-industries"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"bureau-of-labor-and-industries","name":"Bureau of Labor and Industries"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-oregon-occupational-safety-and-health-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"670","sections_reviewed":["ors-670.280","ors-670.306","ors-670.350","ors-670.400","ors-670.415","ors-670.605"],"rules_reviewed":26,"candidates":[{"summary":"Scope of 'good standing' requirement differs. Mental Health boards require no restrictions in 'any jurisdiction where applicant has been licensed'; statute specifies 'issuing out-of-state professional licensing board' only.","documents":[{"id":"ors-670.400","citation":"ORS 670.400(2)(c)","quote":"Provides to the professional licensing board, in a manner determined by the professional licensing board, sufficient proof that the person is in good standing with the issuing out-of-state professional licensing board","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-833-020-0200","citation":"OAR 833-020-0200(1)(c)","quote":"To qualify for Temporary Practice Authorization, an applicant must be in good standing, with no restrictions or limitations upon, actions taken against, or investigation or disciplinary action pending against his or her license in any jurisdiction where the applicant is or has been licensed.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-858-010-0056","citation":"OAR 858-010-0056(1)(b)","quote":"To qualify for Temporary Practice Authorization, an applicant must be in good standing, with no restrictions or limitations upon, actions taken against, or investigation or disciplinary action pending against his or her license in any jurisdiction where the applicant is or has been licensed.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute conditions eligibility on good standing with 'the issuing out-of-state professional licensing board' (the state where the person currently holds a license). The Mental Health boards' rules extend this to require good standing in 'any jurisdiction where the applicant is or has been licensed' — retroactively checking all past jurisdictions. This is broader/more restrictive than the statute specifies. Reasonable reading: statute allows someone with past regulatory issues in another state to qualify if they are in good standing with their current licensing state; rules would exclude them based on history anywhere.","type":null,"section":"ors-670.400","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"c09d4607803883e8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology"]},{"summary":"Rule claims statutory authority under ORS 670.415 but lists ORS 671.415 as the statute it implements; rule text does not address specific provisions of ORS 670.415","documents":[{"id":"ors-670.415","citation":"ORS 670.415(3)","quote":"A professional licensing board may adopt rules to carry out the provisions of this section.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-804-001-0005","citation":"OAR 804-001-0005","quote":"Statutory/Other Authority: ORS 183.341 & ORS 670.415 Statutes/Other Implemented: ORS 671.415","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule's authority line cites ORS 670.415 but its implementation line cites ORS 671.415. The rule text adopts model rules of procedure and does not directly address the specific provisions of ORS 670.415 (staff culturally responsive training and guidance publication for internationally educated individuals). This may indicate the wrong statute is cited as authority, or there is a transcription error in the rule's statutory citations.","type":null,"section":"ors-670.415","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f3000a96ab2cfd0b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["landscape-architect-board"]},{"summary":"OAR 150-316-0241 and OAR 812-003-0240 list different organizational names for the same entity in their cooperation clauses","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-316-0241","citation":"OAR 150-316-0241(2)","quote":"The Construction Contractors Board, Employment Department, Landscape Contractors Board, Department of Consumer and Business Services, and Department of Revenue of the State of Oregon, under the authority of ORS 670.605, will cooperate as necessary in their compliance and enforcement activities to ensure among the agencies the consistent interpretation and application of ORS 670.600.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0240","citation":"OAR 812-003-0240(6)","quote":"The Construction Contractors Board, Employment Department, Landscape Contractors Board, Workers Compensation Division, and Department of Revenue of the State of Oregon, under authority of ORS 670.605, will cooperate as necessary in their compliance and enforcement activities to ensure among the agencies the consistent interpretation and application of 670.600.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"DCBS (Department of Consumer and Business Services) is the parent agency of the Workers Compensation Division. Both rules refer to the same entity but at different organizational levels. The statute ORS 670.605(2) mandates consistent interpretation and application, but does not specify whether cooperation requirements should be framed at the parent-agency or division level.","type":null,"section":"ors-670.605","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f1b6ee65de6130a1","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board","department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 150-670-0010 and OAR 436-170-0300 use 'licensed' while OAR 812-003-0240 uses 'registered' to describe the same professional category under ORS 671.010-671.220","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-670-0010","citation":"OAR 150-670-0010(4)(a)","quote":"(A) Architects licensed under ORS 671.010 to 671.220;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-436-170-0300","citation":"OAR 436-170-0300(1)(a)","quote":"(a) Architects licensed under ORS 671.010 to 671.220;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0240","citation":"OAR 812-003-0240(4)(a)","quote":"(A) Architects registered under ORS 671.010 to 671.220;","quote_verified":true}],"note":"ORS 670.605 mandates joint rulemaking by multiple agencies to ensure consistent interpretation. Two agencies (DOR and DCBS/WCD) use 'licensed' while the Construction Contractors Board uses 'registered' when defining the scope of covered professionals. 'Licensed' and 'registered' could be synonymous under ORS 671.010-671.220, in which case this difference would not indicate actual conflict. However, the terms could also denote different professional statuses or requirements.","type":null,"section":"ors-670.605","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b998927f556de236","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board","department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","department-of-revenue"]},{"summary":"OAR 150-670-0010 and OAR 436-170-0300 refer to 'Landscaping businesses' while OAR 812-003-0240 refers to 'Landscape contracting businesses' for the same statutory provision","documents":[{"id":"oar-150-670-0010","citation":"OAR 150-670-0010(4)(a)","quote":"(C) Landscaping businesses licensed under ORS 671.510 to 671.710;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-436-170-0300","citation":"OAR 436-170-0300(1)(c)","quote":"(c) Landscaping businesses licensed under ORS 671.510 to 671.710;","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-812-003-0240","citation":"OAR 812-003-0240(4)(a)","quote":"(C) Landscape contracting businesses licensed under ORS 671.510 to 671.710;","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Both terms likely refer to the same regulatory category under ORS 671.510-671.710, but 'landscape contracting businesses' is more specific than 'landscaping businesses,' which could theoretically include non-contracting landscaping work. The difference could be a matter of terminology or could indicate scope ambiguity.","type":null,"section":"ors-670.605","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"dc52ed1fd2a4c222","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["construction-contractors-board","department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","department-of-revenue"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-engineering-and-land-surveying","name":"Board of Examiners for Engineering and Land Surveying"},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"board-of-massage-therapists","name":"Board of Massage Therapists"},{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"construction-contractors-board","name":"Construction Contractors Board"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-building-codes-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Building Codes Division"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-public-safety-standards-and-training","name":"Department of Public Safety Standards and Training"},{"slug":"department-of-revenue","name":"Department of Revenue"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"},{"slug":"landscape-architect-board","name":"Landscape Architect Board"},{"slug":"landscape-contractors-board","name":"Landscape Contractors Board"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Licensed Professional Counselors and Therapists"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-dentistry","name":"Oregon Board of Dentistry"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority","name":"Oregon Health Authority"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission-oregon-board-of-maritime-pilots","name":"Public Utility Commission, Oregon Board of Maritime Pilots"},{"slug":"water-resources-department","name":"Water Resources Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"672","sections_reviewed":["ors-672.045","ors-672.240","ors-672.325","ors-672.505"],"rules_reviewed":4,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule defines unprofessional conduct for engineers, land surveyors, and photogrammetrists only; statute covers ORS 672.002-672.325 which appear to include geologists based on statute title and chapter scope, creating potential scope mismatch","documents":[{"id":"ors-672.325","citation":"ORS 672.325(1)","quote":"any person who violates any provision of ORS 672.002 to 672.325 or any rule adopted thereunder shall forfeit and pay to the State Board of Examiners for Engineering and Land Surveying a civil penalty","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-820-020-0055","citation":"OAR 820-020-0055","quote":"Incompetence, negligence or gross negligence in the practice engineering, land surveying, or photogrammetric mapping is unprofessional conduct.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Rule explicitly limits unprofessional conduct definition to three professions while implementing statutes governing a broader professional scope. Geologists may be governed by separate rules or statute provisions, but rule's scope here does not align with statute's apparent multi-profession coverage.","type":null,"section":"ors-672.325","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"a8ffd89d1535d87b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-examiners-for-engineering-and-land-surveying"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-engineering-and-land-surveying","name":"Board of Examiners for Engineering and Land Surveying"},{"slug":"board-of-geologist-examiners","name":"Board of Geologist Examiners"},{"slug":"employment-department","name":"Employment Department"}]},{"ors_chapter":"675","sections_reviewed":["ors-675.070","ors-675.300","ors-675.310","ors-675.320","ors-675.600","ors-675.745"],"rules_reviewed":43,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule 858-020-0045 treats non-compliance with Board orders as a violation of ORS 675.070(2)(h), but the statute limits that ground to violations of statutes or the code of professional conduct, not Board orders per se.","documents":[{"id":"ors-675.070","citation":"ORS 675.070(2)(h)","quote":"Has violated a provision of ORS 675.010 to 675.150 or 675.850 or a provision of the code of professional conduct formulated under ORS 675.110 (13)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-858-020-0045","citation":"OAR 858-020-0045(8)(a)","quote":"Failure to comply with one or more terms of a Board order or agreement constitutes a violation of ORS 675.070(2)(h) and is grounds for disciplinary action.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule could be consistent if Board orders enforce specific provisions of the code of professional conduct formulated under ORS 675.110(13), or if one of the statutes from 675.010 to 675.150 requires compliance with Board orders. However, the statute does not explicitly authorize Board orders as independent grounds for sanction.","type":null,"section":"ors-675.070","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"b1286ada67dd45f8","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology"]},{"summary":"Rule cites a non-existent subsection as legal authority.","documents":[{"id":"ors-675.600","citation":"ORS 675.600(1)","quote":"Pursuant to ORS chapter 183, adopt rules necessary to carry out the provisions of ORS 675.510 to 675.600.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-877-022-0005","citation":"OAR 877-022-0005, Statutory/Other Authority line","quote":"Statutory/Other Authority: ORS 675.510(3), 675.530(1)(3), 675.535(1), 675.537(1)(3), 675.560 (2), 675.571(4), 675.595(3) & 675.600(1)(a)","quote_verified":true}],"note":"ORS 675.600 contains only four main subsections numbered (1) through (4). Subsection (1) contains no lettered subparagraphs. The citation should reference 'ORS 675.600(1)' without the '(a)'. No defensible reading accommodates the citation as written.","type":null,"section":"ors-675.600","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"1b62def5a18bb846","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-licensed-social-workers"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-licensed-social-workers","name":"Board of Licensed Social Workers"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-licensed-professional-counselors-and-therapists","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Licensed Professional Counselors and Therapists"},{"slug":"mental-health-regulatory-agency-oregon-board-of-psychology","name":"Mental Health Regulatory Agency, Oregon Board of Psychology"},{"slug":"occupational-therapy-licensing-board","name":"Occupational Therapy Licensing Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"}]},{"ors_chapter":"678","sections_reviewed":["ors-678.111","ors-678.140","ors-678.153","ors-678.390","ors-678.442"],"rules_reviewed":42,"candidates":[{"summary":"Initial certification via enrollment without completion requirement","documents":[{"id":"ors-678.442","citation":"ORS 678.442(1)(b)","quote":"(b)(A) Shows completion of an approved training program for nursing assistants; (B) Has military training or experience that the board determines is substantially equivalent to the training required by subparagraph (A) of this paragraph; or (C) Has other health care education, training or experience that the board determines is sufficient; and (c) Passes a board approved examination.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-851-062-0050","citation":"OAR 851-062-0050(1)(e)","quote":"(e) One of the following: (A) Proof of completion, including date of completion of a nursing assistant training program approved by the Board or, for non-Oregon programs, by the appropriate agency in that state or U.S. territory; (B) A Joint Services transcript and DD214 form; (C) Proof of an active RN, PN or Vocational Nurse (VN) license in good standing; or (D) Proof of current enrollment in a nursing education program approved by the Board or, for non-Oregon programs, by the appropriate agency in that state or U.S. territory.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute explicitly requires applicants to show 'completion' of an approved training program as one path (subsection A), or alternatively 'has' military training equivalent or 'has' other health care education that the board determines sufficient. The statute's language—particularly 'completion' in (A) and 'has' in (C)—refers to education/training already completed or possessed. OAR 851-062-0050(1)(e)(D) allows 'current enrollment' as a separate alternative path. Enrollment indicates training in progress, not yet completed. The rule presents enrollment as a distinct fourth pathway alongside completion, suggesting they are alternatives rather than equivalent. However, enrollment could arguably satisfy statute section (b)(C) if the board has determined that enrollment in an approved program constitutes 'other health care education...that the board determines is sufficient,' though the rule does not explicitly make this determination or explain the reasoning.","type":null,"section":"ors-678.442","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"22f233ad7d5f592f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-nursing"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-nursing","name":"Board of Nursing"},{"slug":"department-of-human-services-aging-and-people-with-disabilities-and-developmental-disabilities","name":"Department of Human Services, Aging and People with Disabilities and Developmental Disabilities"},{"slug":"oregon-department-of-education","name":"Oregon Department of Education"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-long-term-care-administrators-board","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Long Term Care Administrators Board"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"681","sections_reviewed":["ors-681.350","ors-681.410"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule sets compensation amount without explicitly establishing that the amount is greater than the ORS 292.495 baseline as required by statute.","documents":[{"id":"ors-681.410","citation":"ORS 681.410","quote":"The board may provide by rule for compensation to board members for the performance of official duties at a rate that is greater than the rate provided in ORS 292.495.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-335-001-0012","citation":"OAR 335-001-0012","quote":"Compensation is set at $50.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule cites ORS 292.495 as legal authority, suggesting intent to comply with the statutory constraint. The statute allows rule-based compensation only if greater than the ORS 292.495 rate, but the rule text does not verify or state this relationship. Defensible counter-reading: the board is exercising delegated authority within statutory limits without needing to restate the limitation in rule text.","type":null,"section":"ors-681.410","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ccfd4860b02c838f","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-examiners-for-speech-language-pathology-and-audiology","name":"Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"}]},{"ors_chapter":"687","sections_reviewed":["ors-687.051","ors-687.081"],"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute specifies 12-hour minimum for renewal continuing education; rule requires 25 hours","documents":[{"id":"ors-687.051","citation":"ORS 687.051(5)","quote":"To be eligible for biennial renewal, a renewal applicant shall submit evidence to the board, as determined by the board by rule, that the applicant has completed a minimum of 12 hours of board-approved continuing education.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-334-010-0015","citation":"OAR 334-010-0015(7)","quote":"Applicants for the renewal of an active license must sign a statement verifying completion of a minimum of 25 hours of continuing education.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's phrase 'as determined by the board by rule' is ambiguous. It could mean the board determines procedural compliance mechanisms (keeping the 12-hour floor) or determines the substantive requirement itself (allowing 25 hours). Standard regulatory interpretation suggests a specific statutory floor ('minimum of 12 hours') cannot be exceeded by delegation, but this reading is defensible.","type":null,"section":"ors-687.051","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"5b9b0b4bba812599","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"Statute limits criminal conviction basis to crimes with demonstrable relationship to massage practice; rule permits discipline for any conviction without relationship requirement.","documents":[{"id":"ors-687.081","citation":"ORS 687.081(1)(f)","quote":"Has been convicted of a crime that bears a demonstrable relationship to the practice of massage or operation of a massage facility.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-334-040-0010","citation":"OAR 334-040-0010(6)","quote":"Conviction of a crime in any state or jurisdiction;","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's requirement that a crime 'bears a demonstrable relationship' to massage practice is an essential limiting principle. The rule's broader language (any crime, any jurisdiction) appears to remove this limiting requirement, potentially allowing discipline based on unrelated criminal conduct.","type":null,"section":"ors-687.081","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"7f3865c30ab2ea3d","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"Statute limits disciplinary action basis to actions against massage therapists or facility operators; rule extends to any licensed healthcare professional.","documents":[{"id":"ors-687.081","citation":"ORS 687.081(1)(k)","quote":"Has been the subject of disciplinary action as a massage therapist or operator of a massage facility by another state or territory of the United States or by a foreign country and the board determines that the cause of the disciplinary action would be a violation under ORS 687.011 to 687.250, 687.895 or 687.991 or the rules of the board if the cause of the disciplinary action had occurred in this state.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-334-040-0010","citation":"OAR 334-040-0010(3)","quote":"Has been the subject of disciplinary action as a licensed healthcare professional by this or any other state or territory of the United States or by a foreign country and the Board determines that the cause of the disciplinary action would be a violation under ORS 687.011 to 687.250, 687.895 and 687.991 or OAR Chapter 334;","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute expressly limits this ground to disciplinary action 'as a massage therapist or operator of a massage facility.' The rule's extension to 'any licensed healthcare professional' appears to broaden the scope beyond what the statute authorizes, potentially allowing discipline based on disciplinary action in unrelated healthcare professions (e.g., nursing, dentistry).","type":null,"section":"ors-687.081","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"f0e1783ae6624325","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]},{"summary":"Statute requires false statements to board be made 'in order to induce or prevent action'; rule omits this purpose element.","documents":[{"id":"ors-687.081","citation":"ORS 687.081(1)(b)","quote":"Has made a false representation or statement to the board in order to induce or prevent action by the board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-334-040-0010","citation":"OAR 334-040-0010(2)","quote":"Knowingly or recklessly making any false statement to the Board;","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute condition requires a specific purpose ('in order to induce or prevent action by the board'), which is a material element of the violation. The rule requires 'knowingly or recklessly' making a false statement but does not include the statutory purpose requirement. These are distinct mental states and purposes: the statute requires purposeful inducement/prevention, while the rule only requires knowing or reckless falsity.","type":null,"section":"ors-687.081","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"81c0bdf45fadf39b","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["board-of-massage-therapists"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-massage-therapists","name":"Board of Massage Therapists"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-direct-entry-midwifery","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Direct Entry Midwifery"}]},{"ors_chapter":"688","sections_reviewed":["ors-688.140"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule narrows statute's negligence standard to gross negligence or multiple acts, excluding single negligent acts.","documents":[{"id":"ors-688.140","citation":"ORS 688.140(2)(d)","quote":"Provides substandard care as a physical therapist through a deliberate or negligent act or failure to act, regardless of whether injury to the patient occurs.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-848-045-0020","citation":"OAR 848-045-0020(2)(f)","quote":"Commits gross negligence or multiple acts of negligence in practice. The Board may take into account relevant factors and practices, including but not limited to the standard of practice generally and currently followed and accepted by persons licensed to practice physical therapy in this state, the current teachings at accredited physical therapy schools and relevant technical reports published in recognized physical therapy journals in determining the definition of gross negligence","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute includes 'negligent act' (singular) which could encompass simple negligence, but the rule limits discipline grounds to 'gross negligence or multiple acts of negligence.' A single negligent act that does not rise to gross negligence would not be grounds under the rule but appears contemplated by the statute.","type":null,"section":"ors-688.140","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"141c7bc9cf615904","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-physical-therapy"]},{"summary":"Rule requires reporting of any conduct by any licensed medical provider, while statute limits reporting to violations of physical therapy statutes and rules.","documents":[{"id":"ors-688.140","citation":"ORS 688.140(2)(p)","quote":"Fails to report to the board, when the person has direct knowledge of an unprofessional, incompetent or illegal act that reasonably appears to be in violation of ORS 688.010 to 688.201 or any rules of the board.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-848-045-0020","citation":"OAR 848-045-0020(2)(z)","quote":"Fails to notify the appropriate licensing board of any conduct by another licensed medical provider when the licensee has reasonable cause to believe that the medical provider has engaged in prohibited or unprofessional conduct. Notice must occur without undue delay, but in no event later than 10 days after the reporting licensee learns of the conduct.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute requires reporting only violations of ORS 688.010 to 688.201 (physical therapy statutes) and board rules to the physical therapy board. Rule 848-045-0020(2)(z) adds a new ground for discipline: failure to report any conduct by any medical provider to their respective board. This appears to expand the reporting requirement beyond the scope of violations defined in the statute.","type":null,"section":"ors-688.140","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"772f6ca8b254c527","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-board-of-physical-therapy"]}],"note":"1 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-medical-imaging","name":"Board of Medical Imaging"},{"slug":"oregon-board-of-physical-therapy","name":"Oregon Board of Physical Therapy"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-systems-division-medical-assistance-programs","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Systems Division: Medical Assistance Programs"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"689","sections_reviewed":["ors-689.115","ors-689.285","ors-689.645","ors-689.689"],"rules_reviewed":7,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"board-of-optometry","name":"Board of Optometry"},{"slug":"board-of-pharmacy","name":"Board of Pharmacy"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-public-health-division","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Public Health Division"},{"slug":"oregon-medical-board","name":"Oregon Medical Board"}]},{"ors_chapter":"690","sections_reviewed":["ors-690.005","ors-690.015"],"rules_reviewed":9,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule cites non-existent subsection citation format for student prohibition.","documents":[{"id":"oar-817-090-0035","citation":"OAR 817-090-0035(4)","quote":"Performing in a field of practice by a student when not on the premises of an educational institution, or while not pursuing the prescribed curriculum in which he or she is enrolled, is a violation of ORS 690.015(a)","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-690.015","citation":"ORS 690.015","quote":"690.015 Prohibited acts. (1) This section establishes prohibitions relating to the practice of hair design, barbering, esthetics, nail technology and natural hair care. [...] (2) A person may not: (a) Perform or attempt to perform services in a field of practice without an active authorization.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute structure does not include a bare subsection (a) under 690.015; subsections are (2)(a) through (2)(k). The correct citation should be ORS 690.015(2)(a) or another subsection of (2). The statute contains no specific prohibition against student practice outside educational institutions; this prohibition appears to exceed or mischaracterize the statute.","type":null,"section":"ors-690.015","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ade4cb83356d9282","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-cosmetology"]},{"summary":"Rule imposes blanket prohibition on alteration; statute prohibits only fraudulent alteration.","documents":[{"id":"oar-331-030-0020","citation":"OAR 331-030-0020(5)","quote":"Authorizations may not be altered; displayed authorizations may have the address covered by a removable sticker.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"ors-690.015","citation":"ORS 690.015(2)(j)","quote":"Materially alter with fraudulent intent a document evidencing an authorization.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute (2)(j) prohibits alteration only when done 'with fraudulent intent.' The rule states an absolute prohibition without the fraudulent-intent element. However, the rule may be justified as a prophylactic measure independent of the statute; if defended, the agency would need to cite independent rulemaking authority.","type":null,"section":"ors-690.015","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"39fbeb4ff2fad90a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office"]}],"note":"2 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office"},{"slug":"oregon-health-authority-health-licensing-office-board-of-cosmetology","name":"Oregon Health Authority, Health Licensing Office, Board of Cosmetology"}]},{"ors_chapter":"697","sections_reviewed":["ors-697.031","ors-697.692"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-finance-and-securities-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Finance and Securities Regulation"}]},{"ors_chapter":"731","sections_reviewed":["ors-731.008","ors-731.016","ors-731.264","ors-731.804"],"rules_reviewed":16,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule excludes only workers' compensation from property-casualty line but does not mention statutory exclusion of wet marine and transportation insurance.","documents":[{"id":"ors-731.804","citation":"ORS 731.804(6)","quote":"Wet marine and transportation insurance policies.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-836-009-0011","citation":"OAR 836-009-0011(1)","quote":"For purposes of this rule, this line includes title insurance but does not include workers' compensation insurance.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"A reasonable reading is that the rule's language 'subject to assessment under 731.804' incorporates all statutory exclusions by reference, including wet marine. However, the rule explicitly calls out workers' compensation but omits wet marine, creating ambiguity about whether wet marine premiums would be included in the property and casualty assessment base despite the statute's explicit exclusion.","type":null,"section":"ors-731.804","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9012cc64126297ff","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-director-s-office","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Director's Office"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-workers-compensation-division","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"746","sections_reviewed":["ors-746.135"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-consumer-and-business-services-insurance-regulation","name":"Department of Consumer and Business Services, Insurance Regulation"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"756","sections_reviewed":["ors-756.036"],"rules_reviewed":1,"candidates":[],"note":"No candidates proposed for the sections listed.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-energy","name":"Department of Energy"},{"slug":"public-utility-commission","name":"Public Utility Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"802","sections_reviewed":["ors-802.020","ors-802.050","ors-802.087","ors-802.179"],"rules_reviewed":19,"candidates":[{"summary":"Maximum photograph age differs between DOC and DMV implementations of the same program","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-207-0100","citation":"OAR 291-207-0100(3)","quote":"The photograph on file must not be older than nine years and two months.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-001-0062","citation":"OAR 735-001-0062(3)","quote":"The photograph on file must not be older than nine years.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"Both rules implement the same statutory program, but establish different photograph age standards. The statute does not specify a photograph age limit.","type":null,"section":"ors-802.087","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"e8e42373bdf12bc7","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"License expiration threshold for renewal eligibility differs between DOC and DMV rules","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-207-0100","citation":"OAR 291-207-0100(3)(b)","quote":"A renewal driver license to an inmate whose driving privileges are valid or are reinstated at the time of issuance and whose driver license is within the allotted time for early renewal as described in OAR 735-062-0090(4) or has been expired for less than one year","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-001-0062","citation":"OAR 735-001-0062(3)(b)","quote":"A renewal driver license to an adult in custody whose driving privileges are valid or are reinstated at the time of issuance and whose driver license is within the allotted time for early renewal as described in OAR 735-062-0090(8) or has been expired for less than two years","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rules establish different eligibility windows for renewal: DOC permits if expired less than one year, DMV permits if expired less than two years. This affects who can participate in the program.","type":null,"section":"ors-802.087","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"ef5dca1e15b872bb","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"License expiration threshold for identification card eligibility differs between DOC and DMV rules","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-207-0100","citation":"OAR 291-207-0100(3)(c)(B)","quote":"Whose previous driver license has been expired for more than one year","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-001-0062","citation":"OAR 735-001-0062(3)(c)(B)","quote":"Whose previous driver license has been expired for more than two years","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The two rules establish different thresholds for when a person becomes eligible for an identification card instead of a driver license: DOC at one year, DMV at two years.","type":null,"section":"ors-802.087","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"high","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"8d999800ff954496","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Age threshold for vision examination requirement differs between DOC and DMV rules","documents":[{"id":"oar-291-207-0100","citation":"OAR 291-207-0100(8)","quote":"An inmate who is eligible to renew his or her driving privileges, and is or will be 50 years of age or older at the time his or her driving privileges expire, must meet the requirements of OAR 735-062-0060.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-001-0062","citation":"OAR 735-001-0062(7)","quote":"An adult in custody who is eligible to renew their driving privileges, and is or will be 65 years of age or older at the time their driving privileges expire, must meet the requirements of OAR 735-062-0060.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rules differ on the age at which a vision examination becomes mandatory: DOC requires it at 50 or older, DMV at 65 or older. This is a fifteen-year difference in when the requirement applies.","type":null,"section":"ors-802.087","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"0000fe43a4dfe5ad","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-corrections","department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]},{"summary":"Statute requires disseminator contract include two-day delay method for non-subscribers; not addressed in implementing rules","documents":[{"id":"ors-802.179","citation":"ORS 802.179(13)(b)(C)","quote":"That the disseminator will have a method of ensuring that the disseminator can delay for a period of up to two days the giving of personal information to a requester who is not a subscriber.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-010-0215","citation":"OAR 735-010-0215(1)","quote":"In order for DMV to determine if a person is in the business of disseminating information, the person must provide the following: (a) Sufficient evidence that the person is a legitimate business as set forth in OAR 735-010-0210(1); (b) A description of the business; (c) A description of the method used to ensure that personal information will be resold or redisclosed only to qualified persons or entities who are authorized by DMV to receive personal information; (d) A copy of or reference to a current business advertisement, including but not limited to the yellow pages, newspaper, television, internet or other media of general circulation. If from a reference DMV is unable to verify the advertisement, documentation of the advertisement may be required; and (e) Names and phone numbers of customers who may be contacted for verification.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute mandates that disseminator contracts contain a provision allowing disseminators to delay information to non-subscribers for up to two days. The rule lists required submissions from disseminators but does not mention or require verification of this two-day delay capability. The rule addresses contract provision (B) (authorized recipients only) in section (1)(c) but omits provision (C) (two-day delay).","type":null,"section":"ors-802.179","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"high","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"59aab96fd406d171","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division"]}],"note":"3 further candidate(s) proposed here were dropped by quote verification and are not recorded.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-corrections","name":"Department of Corrections"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"811","sections_reviewed":["ors-811.595"],"rules_reviewed":3,"candidates":[{"summary":"OAR 735-080-0000 lists four permit types but OAR 734-020-0070, which is the source of fee information, specifies only three permit types with fees, leaving the Interim Annual permit without a specified fee.","documents":[{"id":"ors-811.595","citation":"ORS 811.595(2)(a)","quote":"The type of permit.","quote_verified":false},{"id":"oar-734-020-0070","citation":"OAR 734-020-0070(1)","quote":"(1) The fee for parking permits in winter recreation parking areas (Sno-Parks) shall be as follows: (a) One day — $4; (b) Three consecutive days — $9; (c) Annual, beginning each November — $25.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-080-0000","citation":"OAR 735-080-0000(1)","quote":"(1) There are four types of Sno-Park permits: Annual, Interim Annual, Three-day, and Daily.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-735-080-0000","citation":"OAR 735-080-0000(7)","quote":"(7) Sno-Park permit fees are established by the Oregon Transportation Commission under OAR 734-020-0070.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The Interim Annual permit is described in OAR 735-080-0000(4)-(5) as a temporary certificate issued automatically when an Annual permit is purchased via DMV's website, valid for two weeks or until the full Annual permit arrives. It may not require a separate fee since no additional charge is implied when purchasing the Annual permit. However, the statute ORS 811.595(2)(a) requires that permit types be specified in the rules, and OAR 735-080-0000 explicitly enumerates Interim Annual as a type, yet no corresponding fee appears in the fee-setting rule to which OAR 735-080-0000(7) directs readers.","type":null,"section":"ors-811.595","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"684411ae6c1c761a","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","department-of-transportation-highway-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"oregon-criminal-justice-commission","name":"Oregon Criminal Justice Commission"}]},{"ors_chapter":"815","sections_reviewed":["ors-815.010","ors-815.030"],"rules_reviewed":17,"candidates":[{"summary":"Statute allows SAE/ANSI/NIST standards as alternative compliance pathways, but vehicle safety rules specify only FMVSS without acknowledging these alternatives.","documents":[{"id":"ors-815.010","citation":"ORS 815.010(1)","quote":"Testing requirements for equipment standards adopted under the vehicle code shall be met by the manufacturer submitting a report from a laboratory approved by the Department of Transportation showing compliance with the current federal regulations or the standards of the Society of Automotive Engineers, the American National Standards Institute or the National Institute of Standards and Technology.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-010-0010","citation":"OAR 737-010-0010(1)","quote":"As the minimum vehicle safety standards for low-speed vehicles, TSO adopts the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FMVSS) applicable to low-speed vehicles as set forth in 49 CFR, Part 571.500 (October 1, 2008).","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-737-010-0020","citation":"OAR 737-010-0020","quote":"As the minimum vehicle safety standards for medium-speed electric vehicles, Transportation Safety adopts the standards and requirements set forth below.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute's 'or' language suggests SAE/ANSI/NIST are acceptable standalone alternatives to federal regulations. However, rules 737-010-0010 and 737-010-0020 adopt only FMVSS with no explicit acknowledgment of alternatives, whereas OAR 735-110-0020(1) for sirens explicitly references 'ANS and SAE items,' suggesting that when alternative standards are intended to be acceptable, agencies specify them. The rules' use of 'minimum' standards and allowance for 'more stringent' testing does not clarify whether SAE/ANSI/NIST can substitute for FMVSS compliance or only supplement it. This could be reconciled if 'minimum standards adopted' means federal regulations are the floor but alternatives are still permitted per the statute.","type":null,"section":"ors-815.010","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"9b38b4af483d84b9","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-environmental-quality","name":"Department of Environmental Quality"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-transportation-safety-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Transportation Safety Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"818","sections_reviewed":["ors-818.070","ors-818.140","ors-818.150","ors-818.160","ors-818.170","ors-818.270"],"rules_reviewed":5,"candidates":[{"summary":"Rule extends exemption to private contractors leasing state vehicles; statute restricts exemption to enumerated government entities.","documents":[{"id":"ors-818.070","citation":"ORS 818.070 (section 3)","quote":"Any vehicle, combination of vehicles, article, machine or other equipment while being used by the federal government, the State of Oregon or any county or incorporated city in the construction, maintenance or repair of public highways and at the immediate location or site of such construction, maintenance or repair.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-070-0017","citation":"OAR 734-070-0017","quote":"The exemptions from maximum weight limitations in ORS 818.030(3), 818.070(3) and 818.140(3) apply to any department-owned vehicle, combination of vehicles, article, machine or other equipment leased from the department to a private contractor, when used under contract with the department.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The statute lists specific eligible entities and does not name private contractors. However, a contractor operating a state vehicle under a state contract could arguably constitute use 'by the State of Oregon' in functional terms. Ambiguous—worth legal review to determine whether contractor-operator status falls within statutory scope.","type":null,"section":"ors-818.070","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"medium","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"124ab1b78ad47049","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]},{"summary":"Rule may extend exemption to leased equipment under any departmental contract without explicitly requiring the construction/maintenance/repair and immediate-location limitations specified in statute","documents":[{"id":"ors-818.140","citation":"ORS 818.140(3)","quote":"Posted use limits do not apply to any vehicle, combination of vehicles, article, machine or other equipment while being used by the federal government, the State of Oregon or any county or incorporated city in the construction, maintenance or repair of public highways and at the immediate location or site of such construction, maintenance or repair.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-734-070-0017","citation":"OAR 734-070-0017","quote":"The exemptions from maximum weight limitations in ORS 818.030(3), 818.070(3) and 818.140(3) apply to any department-owned vehicle, combination of vehicles, article, machine or other equipment leased from the department to a private contractor, when used under contract with the department.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"The rule may reasonably incorporate the statutory conditions implicitly since it cites the statute section. However, the rule does not explicitly require 'construction, maintenance or repair' or 'immediate location or site' conditions. A reader could potentially interpret 'when used under contract' as permitting exemptions for any departmental contract, not solely construction/maintenance/repair work at specified locations. [severity recorded by the model as 'moderate'; normalized to 'medium'.]","type":null,"section":"ors-818.140","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"medium","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"2740dd5f35291e03","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-highway-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-highway-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Highway Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"823","sections_reviewed":["ors-823.061"],"rules_reviewed":10,"candidates":[],"note":"1 candidate(s) were proposed here and ALL were dropped by quote verification. This chapter is NOT clean — it is unresolved.","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-rail-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Rail Division"}]},{"ors_chapter":"825","sections_reviewed":["ors-825.212","ors-825.470"],"rules_reviewed":2,"candidates":[{"summary":"Fee basis differs: statute specifies 'for each motor vehicle' while rule specifies 'for each pass issued'","documents":[{"id":"ors-825.470","citation":"ORS 825.470(1)","quote":"For this pass a fee of $9 for each motor vehicle shall be paid.","quote_verified":true},{"id":"oar-740-055-0025","citation":"OAR 740-055-0025","quote":"A pass fee of $9 will be collected for each pass issued.","quote_verified":true}],"note":"While likely equivalent in practice (one pass per vehicle), the different reference points could theoretically allow multiple passes per vehicle under the rule's language, which would diverge from the statute's per-vehicle structure.","type":null,"section":"ors-825.470","run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","prompt_version":"conflict-haiku-section-scan-2026-07-31","confidence":"low","severity":"low","triage":{"status":"unreviewed","note":null,"by":null,"date":null},"fingerprint":"06b92b11ddf3de63","cites_repealed":[],"agency_slugs":["department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division"]}],"run_id":"haiku-scan-2026-07-31","agency_list":[{"slug":"department-of-human-services-self-sufficiency-programs","name":"Department of Human Services, Self-Sufficiency Programs"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-driver-and-motor-vehicle-services-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Driver and Motor Vehicle Services Division"},{"slug":"department-of-transportation-motor-carrier-transportation-division","name":"Department of Transportation, Motor Carrier Transportation Division"}]}]}