It occurred to me one day that Sparta, though among the most thinly
populated of states, was evidently the most powerful and most celebrated
city in Greece; and I fell to
wondering how this could have happened. But when I considered the
institutions of the Spartans, I wondered no longer.
Lycurgus, who gave them the laws that they
obey, and to which they owe their prosperity, I do regard with wonder; and I
think that he reached the utmost limit of wisdom. For it was not by
imitating other states, but by devising a system utterly different from that
of most others, that he made his country pre-eminently prosperous.
First, to begin at the beginning, I will take
the begetting of children.The prose
Constitution of the Lacedaemonians by Critias began
with the same point. See Introduction 3. In other states the
girls who are destined to become mothers and are brought up in the approved
fashion, live on the very plainest fare, with a most meagre allowance of
delicacies. Wine is either witheld altogether, or, if allowed them, is
diluted with water. The rest of the Greeks expect their girls to imitate the
sedentary life that is typical of handicraftsmen — to keep quiet and do
wool-work. How, then, is it to be expected that women so brought up will
bear fine children?
But Lycurgus thought the labour of slave women
sufficient to supply clothing. He believed motherhood to be the most
important function of freeborn woman. Therefore, in the first place, he
insisted on physical training for the female no less than for the male sex:
moreover, he instituted races and trials of strength for women competitors
as for men, believing that if both parents are strong they produce more
vigorous offspring.
He noticed, too, that, during the time
immediately succeeding marriage, it was usual elsewhere for the husband to
have unlimited intercourse with his wife. The rule that he adopted was the
opposite of this: for he laid it down that the husband should be ashamed to
be seen entering his wife’s room or leaving it. With this restriction on
intercourse the desire of the one for the other must necessarily be
increased, and their offspring was bound to be more vigorous than if they
were surfeited with one another.
In addition to this, he withdrew from men the right to take a wife whenever
they chose, and insisted on their marrying in the prime of their manhood,
believing that this too promoted the production of fine children.
It might happen, however, that an old man had a young wife; and he observed
that old men keep a very jealous watch over their young wives. To meet these
cases he instituted an entirely different system by requiring the elderly
husband to introduce into his house some man whose physical and moral
qualities he admired, in order to beget children.
On the other hand, in case a man did not want to cohabit with his wife and
nevertheless desired children of whom he could be proud, he made it lawful
for him to choose a woman who was the mother of a fine family and of high
birth, and if he obtained her husband’s consent, to make her the mother of
his children.
He gave his sanction to many similar
arrangements. For the wivesi.e., at
Sparta. want to
take charge of two households, and the husbands want to get brothers for
their sons, brothers who are members of the family and share in its
influence, but claim no part of the money.
Thus his regulations with regard to the
begetting of children were in sharp contrast with those of other states.
Whether he succeeded in populating Sparta with a race of men remarkable for their size and
strength anyone who chooses may judge for himself.
Having dealth with the subject of birth, I
wish next to explain the educational system of Lycurgus, and how it differs
from other systems.
In the other Greek states parents who profess
to give their sons the best education place their boys under the care and
control of a moral tutorI have adopted for
παιδαγωγός the term used at
Oxford for a person who has
charge of, but does not teach, an undergraduate. as soon as they
can understand what is said to them, and send them to a school to learn
letters, music and the exercises of the wrestling-ground. Moreover, they
soften the children’s feet by giving them sandals, and pamper their bodies
with changes of clothing; and it is customary to allow them as much food as
they can eat.
Lycurgus, on the contrary, instead of leaving
each father to appoint a slave to act as tutor, gave the duty of controlling
the boys to a member of the class from which the highest offices are filled,
in fact to the Warden
as he is called. He gave this person authority to
gather the boys together, to take charge of them and to punish them severely
in case of misconduct. He also assigned to him a staff of youths provided
with whips to chastise them when necessary; and the result is that modesty
and obedience are inseparable companions at Sparta.
Instead of softening the boys’ feet with sandals he required them to harden
their feet by going without shoes. He believed that if this habit were
cultivated it would enable them to climb hills more easily and descend steep
inclines with less danger, and that a youth who had accustomed himself to go
barefoot would leap and jump and run more nimbly than a boy in sandals.
And instead of letting them be pampered in the matter of clothing, he
introduced the custom of wearing one garment throughout the year, believing
that they would thus be better prepared to face changes of heat and cold.
As to the food, he required the prefect to bring with himσυμβολεύειν is the
conjecture of F. Portus for συμβουλεύειν, and εἴρενα that of Schneider for ἄρρενα. The prefect took his meals with the class of
which he had charge. But Stobaeus’ text runs σῖτόν γε μὴν τοσοῦτον ἔχειν (for which read
ἐσθίειν) συνεβούλευεν ὡς, he recommended them
to eat so moderately that they; and this is probably right. such
a moderate amount of it that the boys would never suffer from repletion, and
would know what it was to go with their hunger unsatisfied; for he believed
that those who underwent this training would be better able to continue
working on an empty stomach, if necessary, and would be capable of carrying
on longer without extra food, if the word of command were given to do so:
they would want fewer delicacies and would accommodate themselves more
readily to anything put before them, and at the same time would enjoy better
health.
He also thought that a diet which made their bodies slim would do more to
increase their height than one that consisted of flesh-forming food.
On the other hand, lest they should feel too
much the pinch of hunger,Anabasis, 4.6.14. while not giving them the
opportunity of taking what they wanted without trouble he allowed them to
alleviate their hunger by stealing something.
It was not on account of a difficulty in providing for them that he
encouraged them to get their food by their own cunning. No one, I suppose,
can fail to see that. Obviously a man who intends to take to thieving must
spend sleepless nights and play the deceiver and lie in ambush by day, and
moreover, if he means to make a capture, he must have spies ready. There can
be no doubt then, that all this education was planned by him in order to
make the boys more resourceful in getting supplies, and better fighting
men.
Someone may ask:
But why, if he believed stealing to be a fine thing, did he have the boy who
was caught beaten with many stripes? I reply: Because in all cases men
punish a learner for not carrying out properly whatever he is taught to do.
So the Spartans chastise those who get caught for stealing badly.
He made it a point of honour to steal as many cheeses as possible from the
altar of Artemis Orthia,At this altar the
annual scourging of Spartan boys and youths took place, according to
Plutarch and Pausanias; but this custom seems to have no connexion with
that of punishing those who were caught thieving. It is not improbable
that the whole of this sentence is an interpolation; if not, the text is
corrupt beyond restoration. but appointed others to scourge the
thieves, meaning to show thereby that by enduring pain for a short time one
may win lasting fame and felicity. It is shown herein that where there is
need of swiftness, the slothful, as usual, gets little profit and many
troubles.
In order that the boys might never lack a
ruler even when the Warden was away, he gave authority to any citizen who
chanced to be present to require them to do anything that he thought right,
and to punish them for any misconduct. This had the effect of making the
boys more respectful; in fact boys and men alike respect their rulers above
everything.
And that a ruler might not be lacking to the boys even when no grown man
happened to be present, he selected the keenest of the prefects, and gave to
each the command of a division. And so at Sparta the boys are never without a ruler.
I think I ought to say something also about
intimacy with boys, since this matter also has a bearing on education. In
other Greek states, for instance among the Boeotians, man and boy live
together, like married people;Symposium, 8.34. elsewhere, among the
Eleians, for example, consent is won by means of favours. Some, on the other
hand, entirely forbid suitors to talk with boys.
The customs instituted by Lycurgus were
opposed to all of these. If someone, being himself an honest man, admired a
boy’s soul and tried to make of him an ideal friend without reproach and to
associate with him, he approved, and believed in the excellence of this kind
of training. But if it was clear that the attraction lay in the boy’s
outward beauty, he banned the connexion as an abomination; and thus he
caused lovers to abstain from boys no less than parents abstain from sexual
intercourse with their children and brothers and sisters with each other.
I am not surprised, however, that people
refuse to believe this. For in many states the laws are not opposed to the
indulgence of these appetites.
I have now dealt with the Spartan system of
education, and that of the other Greek states. Which system turns out men
more obedient, more respectful, and more strictly temperate, anyone who
chooses may once more judge for himself.
When a boy ceases to be a child, and begins to
be a lad, others release him from his moral tutor and his schoolmaster: he
is then no longer under a ruler and is allowed to go his own way. Here again
Lycurgus introduced a wholly different system.
For he observed that at this time of life self-will makes strong root in a
boy’s mind, a tendency to insolence manifests itself, and a keen appetite
for pleasure in different forms takes possession of him. At this stage,
therefore, he imposed on him a ceaseless round of work, and contrived a
constant round of occupation.
The penalty for shirking the duties was exclusion from all future honours. He
thus caused not only the public authorities, but their relations also to
take pains that the lads did not incur the contempt of their fellow citizens
by flinching from their tasks.
Moreover, wishing modesty to be firmly rooted
in them, he required them to keep their hands under their cloaks, to walk in
silence, not to look about them, but to fix their eyes on the ground. The
effect of this rule has been to prove that even in the matter of decorum the
male is stronger than the female sex.
At any rate you would expect a stone image to utter a sound sooner than those
lads; you would sooner attract the attention of a bronze figure; you might
think them more modest even than a young bride in the bridal chamber.Longinus and Stobaeus quote this with
ὀφθαλμοῖς, eyes, in place of
θαλάμοις, bridal chambers;
and the former censures the use of παρθένων for κορῶν,
meaning pupils of the eye. When they have taken their place at
a public meal, you must be content if you can get an answer to a
question.
Such was the care that he bestowed on the
growing lads.
For those who had reached the prime of life he
showed by far the deepest solicitude. For he believed that if these were of
the right stamp they must exercise a powerful influence for good on the
state.
He saw that where the spirit of rivalryCyropaedia, 2.1.22. is strongest among the
people, there the choruses are most worth hearing and the athletic contests
afford the finest spectacle. He believed, therefore, that if he could match
the young men together in a strife of valour, they too would reach a high
level of manly excellence.Cyropaedia, 7.2.26. I will proceed to
explain, therefore, how he instituted matches between the young men.
The Ephors, then, pick out three of the very
best among them. These three are called Commanders of the Guard. Each of
them enrols a hundred others, stating his reasons for preferring one and
rejecting another.
The result is that those who fail to win the honour are at war both with
those who sent them away and with their successful rivals; and they are on
the watch for any lapse from the code of honour.
Here then you find that kind of strife that is
dearest to the gods, and in the highest sense political — the strife that
sets the standard of a brave man’s conduct; and in which either party exerts
itself to the end that it may never fall below its best, and that, when the
time comes, every member of it may support the state with all his
might.Horsemanship,
2.1.
And they are bound, too, to keep themselves fit, for one effect of the strife
is that they spar whenever they meet; but anyone present has a right to part
the combatants. If anyone refuses to obey the mediator the Warden takes him
to the Ephors; and they fine him heavily, in order to make him realize that
he must never yield to a sudden impulse to disobey the laws.
To come to those who have passed the time of
youth, and are now eligible to hold the great offices of state. While
absolving these from the duty of bestowing further attention on their bodily
strength, the other Greeks require them to continue serving in the army. But
Lycurgus established the principle that for citizens of that age, hunting
was the noblest occupation, except when some public duty prevented, in order
that they might be able to stand the fatigues of soldiering as well as the
younger men.
I have given a fairly complete account of the
institutions of Lycurgus so far as they apply to the successive stages of
life. I will now try to describe the system that he established for all
alike.
Lycurgus found the Spartans boarding at home
like the other Greeks, and came to the conclusion that the custom was
responsible for a great deal of misconduct. He therefore established the
public messes outside in the open,Lit.
moved the Syskania out into the open. See Introduction 3.
thinking that this would reduce disregard of orders to a minimum.
The amount of food he allowed was just enough to prevent them from getting
either too much or too little to eat. But many extras are supplied from the
spoils of the chase; and for these rich men sometimes substitute wheaten
bread. Consequently the board is never bare until the company breaks up, and
never extravagantly furnished.
Another of his reforms was the abolition of compulsory drinking,At the public meals each had his own cup:
there was no passing of cups along as at Athens and elsewhere. Critias in
Athenacus, 10.432 D and 11.463 E. which is the
undoing alike of body of mind. But he allowed everyone to drink when he was
thirsty, believing that drink is then most harmless and most welcome.
Now what opportunity did these public messes
give a man to ruin himself or his estate by gluttony or wine-bibbing?
Note that in other states the company usually consists of men of the same
age, where modesty is apt to be conspicuous by its absence from the board.
But Lycurgus introduced mixed companiesSomething appears to be lost after ἀνέμιξε . Schneider suggested ἀνέμιξε τὰς ἡλικίας ὥστε, mixed the ages, so
that. at Sparta, so
that the experience of the elders might contribute largely to the education
of the juniors.
In point of fact, by the custom of the country the conversation at the public
meals turns on the great deeds wrought in the state, and so there is little
room for insolence or drunken uproar, for unseemly conduct or indecent talk.
And the system of feeding in the open has other good results. They must needs
walk home after the meal, and, of course, must take good care not to stumble
under the influence of drink (for they know that they will not stay on at
the table); and they must do in the dark what they do in the day. Indeed,
those who are still in the army are not even allowed a torch to guide them.
Lycurgus had also observed the effects of the
same rations on the hard worker and the idler; that the former has a fresh
colour, firm flesh and plenty of vigour, while the latter looks puffy, ugly
and weak. He saw the importance of this; and reflecting that even a man who
works hard of his own will because it is his duty to do so, looks in pretty
good condition, he required the senior for the time being in every gymnasium
to take care that the tasks set should be not too small for the rations
allowed.
And I think that in this matter too he succeeded. So it would not be easy to
find healthier or handier men than the Spartans. For their exercises train
the legs, arms and neck equally.
In the following respects, again, his
institutions differ from the ordinary type. In most states every man has
control of his own children, servants and goods. Lycurgus wanted to secure
that the citizens should get some advantage from one another without doing
any harm. He therefore gave every father authority over other men’s children
as well as over his own.
When a man knows that fathers have this power, he is bound to rule the
children over whom he exercises authority as he would wish his own to be
ruled.The text of this sentence is
open to suspicion. οὗτοι πατέρες
can hardly be sound. If a boy tells his own father when he has
been whipped by another father, it is a disgrace if the parent does not give
his son another whipping. So completely do they trust one another not to
give any improper orders to the children.
He also gave the power of using other men’s
servants in case of necessity; and made sporting dogs common property to
this extent, that any who want them invite their master, and if he is
engaged himself he is glad to send the hounds. A similar plan of borrowing
is applied to horses also; thus a man who falls ill or wants a carriage or
wishes to get to some place quickly, if he sees a horse anywhere, takes and
uses it carefully and duly restores it.
There is yet another among the customs
instituted by him which is not found in other communities. It was intended
to meet the needs of parties belated in the hunting-field with nothing ready
to eat. He made a rule that those who had plenty should leave behind the
prepared food,i.e., so much of it as
remained over. and that those who needed food should break the
seals, take as much as they wanted, seal up the rest and leave it behind.
The result of this method of going shares with one another is that even those
who have but little receive a share of all that the country yields whenever
they want anything.
Nor does this exhaust the list of the customs
established by Lycurgus at Sparta that are contrary to those of the other Greeks. In
other states, I suppose, all men make as much money as they can. One is a
farmer, another a ship-owner, another a merchant, and others live by
different handicrafts.
But at Sparta Lycurgus forbade
freeborn citizens to have anything to do with business affairs. He insisted
on their regarding as their own concern only those activities that make for
civic freedom.
Indeed, how should wealth be a serious object there, when he insisted on
equal contributions to the food supply and on the same standard of living
for all, and thus cut off the attraction of money for indulgence’ sake? Why,
there is not even any need of money to spend on cloaks: for their adornment
is due not to the price of their clothes, but to the excellent condition of
their bodies.
Nor yet is there any reason for amassing money in order to spend it on one’s
messmates; for he made it more respectable to help one’s fellows by toiling
with the body than by spending money,Agesilaus, 9.6. pointing out that toil is an
employment of the soul, spending an employment of wealth.
By other enactments he rendered it impossible
to make money in unfair ways. In the first place the system of coinage that
he established was of such a kind that even a sum of ten minaeSome 40 pounds about the year 1925;. could not be brought into a house
without the master and the servants being aware of it: the money would fill
a large space and need a wagon to draw it.
Moreover, there is a right of search for gold and silver, and, in the event
of discovery, the possessor is fined. Why, then, should money-making be a
preoccupation in a state where the pains of its possession are more than the
pleasures of its enjoyment?
To continue: we all know that obedience to the
magistrates and the laws is found in the highest degree in Sparta. For my part, however, I think
that Lycurgus did not so much as attempt to introduce this habit of
discipline until he had secured agreement among the most important men in
the state.
I base my inference on the following facts. In other states the most powerful
citizens do not even wish it to be thought that they fear the magistrates:
they believe such fear to be a badge of slavery. But at Sparta the most
important men show the utmost deference to the magistrates: they pride
themselves on their humility, on running instead of walking to answer any
call, in the belief that, if they lead, the rest will follow along the path
of eager obedience. And so it has proved.
It is probable also that these same citizens
helped to set up the office of Ephor, having come to the conclusion that
obedience is a very great blessing whether in a state or an army or a
household. For they thought that the greater the power of these magistrates
the more they would impress the minds of the citizens.τοῦ ὑπακούειν is
omitted in the translation. It can hardly be right; Schneider removed
it, and Cobet proposed εἰς τὸ ὑπακούειν,
so as to make them obedient.
Accordingly, the Ephors are competent to fine whom they choose, and have
authority to enact immediate payment: they have authority also to deprive
the magistrates of office, and even to imprison and prefer a capital charge
against them. Possessing such wide power they do not, like other states,
leave persons elected to office to rule as they like throughout the year,
but in common with despots and the presidents of the games, they no sooner
see anyone breaking the law than they punish the offender.
Among many excellent plans contrived by
Lycurgus for encouraging willing obedience to the laws among the citizens, I
think one of the most excellent was this: before delivering his laws to the
people he paid a visit to Delphi,Herodotus
1.65. accompanied by the most important citizens, and inquired of
the god whether it was desirable and better for Sparta that she should obey the laws
that he himself had framed. Only when the god answered that it was better in
every way did he deliver them, after enacting that to refuse obedience to
laws given by the Pythian god was not only unlawful, but wicked.
The following achievement of Lycurgus, again,
deserves admiration. He caused his people to choose an honourable death in
preference to a disgraceful life. And, in fact, one would find on
consideration that they actually lose a smaller proportion of their men than
those who prefer to retire from the danger zone.
To tell the truth, escape from premature death more generally goes with
valour than with cowardice: for valour is actually easier and pleasanter and
more resourceful and mightier.The
sentiment is taken from Tyrtaeus. And obviously glory adheres to
the side of valour, for all men want to ally themselves somehow with the
brave.
However, it is proper not to pass over the
means by which he contrived to bring about this result. Clearly, what he did
was to ensure that the brave should have happiness, and the coward misery.
For in other states whn a man proves a coward, the only consequence is that
he is called a coward. He goes to the same market as the brave man, sits
beside him, attends the same gymnasium, if he chooses. But in Lacedaemon everyone would be ashamed to
have a coward with him at the mess or to be matched with him in a wrestling
bout.
Often when sides are picked for a game of ball he is the odd man left out: in
the chorus he is banished to the ignominious place; in the streets he is
bound to make way; when he occupies a seat he must needs give it up, even to
a junior; he must support his spinster relatives at home and must explain to
them why they are old maids: he must make the best of a fireside without a
wife, and yet pay forfeit for that: he may not stroll about with a cheerful
countenance, nor behave as though he were a man of unsullied fame, or else
he must submit to be beaten by his betters.
Small wonder, I think, that where such a load of dishonour is laid on the
coward, death seems preferable to a life so dishonoured, so ignominious.
The law by which Lycurgus encouraged the
practice of virtue up to old age is another excellent measure in my opinion.
By requiring men to face the ordeal of election to the Council of Elders
near the end of life, he prevented neglect of high principles even in old
age.
Worthy of admiration also is the protection that he afforded to the old age
of good men. For the enactment by which he made the Elders judges in trials
on the capital charge caused old age to be held in greater honour than the
full vigour of manhood.
And surely it is natural that of all contests in the world this should excite
the greatest zeal. For noble as are the contests in the Games, they are
merely tests of bodily powers. But the contest for the Council judges souls
whether they be good. As much then, as the soul surpasses the body, so much
more worthy are the contests of the soul to kindle zeal than those of the
body.
Again, the following surely entitles the work
of Lycurgus to high admiration. He observed that where the cult of virtue is
left to voluntary effort, the virtuous are not strong enough to increase the
fame of their fatherland. So he compelled all men at Sparta to practise all the virtues in
public life. And therefore, just as private individuals differ from one
another in virtue according as they practise or neglect it, so Sparta, as a matter of course,
surpasses all other states in virtue, because she alone makes a public duty
of gentlemanly conduct.
For was not this too a noble rule of his, that whereas other states punish
only for wrong done to one’s neighbour, he inflicted penalties no less
severe on any who openly neglected to live as good a life as possible?
For he believed, it seems, that enslavement, fraud, robbery, are crimes that
injure only the victims of them; but the wicked man and the coward are
traitors to the whole body politic. And so he had good reason, I think, for
visiting their offences with the heaviest penalties.
And he laid on the people the duty of
practising the whole virtue of a citizen as a necessity irresistible. For to
all who satisfied the requirements of his code he gave equal rights of
citizenship, without regard to bodily infirmity or want of money. But the
coward who shrank from the task of observing the rules of his code he caused
to be no more reckoned among the peers.
Now that these laws are of high antiquity
there can be no doubt: for Lycurgus is said to have lived in the days of the
Heracleidae. Nevertheless, in spite of their antiquity, they are wholly
strange to others even at this day. Indeed, it is most astonishing that all
men praise such institutions, but no state chooses to imitate them.
The blessings that I have enumerated so far
were shared by all alike in peace and in war. But if anyone wishes to
discover in what respect Lycurgus’ organisation of the army on active
service was better than other systems, here is the information that he
seeks.
The Ephors issue a proclamation stating the
age-limit fixed for the levy, first for the cavalry and infantry, and then
for the handicraftsmen. Thus the Lacedaemonians are well supplied in the
field with all things that are found useful in civil life. All the
implements that an army may require in common are ordered to be assembled,
some in carts, some on baggage animals; thus anything missing is not at all
likely to be overlooked.
In the equipment that he devised for the
troops in battle he included a red cloak, because he believed this garment
to have least resemblance to women’s clothing and to be most suitable for
war, and a brass shield, because it is very soon polished and tarnishes very
slowly.The words καὶ χαλκῆν ἀσπίδα should probably
come before καὶ γὰρ τάχιστα.
There is also a suspicion that some words referring to other details of
the equipment have dropped out. He also permitted men who were
past their first youth to wear long hair, believing that it would make them
look taller, more dignified and more terrifying.
The men so equipped were divided into six
regiments of cavalry and infantry. The officers of each citizenOr, reading ὁπλιτικῶν with Stobaeus, regiment of heavy
infantry. regiment comprise one colonel, fourOn account of Hellenica 7.4.20 and 5.10
it is thought that δύο, two,
should be read for τέτταρας
(δʹ). captains, eight first lieutenants and sixteen
second lieutenants. These regiments at the word of command form
sectionsA number, ἕνα, in single file, or δύο, two, must have fallen out before
ἐνωμοτίας. sometimes
(two), sometimes three, and sometimes six abreast.
The prevalent opinion that the Laconian
infantry formation is very complicated is the very reverse of the truth. In
the Laconian formation the front rank men are all officers, and each file
has all that it requires to make it efficient.The exact meaning is not clear and the text is possibly
corrupt. Weiske suggested πάντα παρέχει,
acts exactly as it should.
The formation is so easy to understand that no one who knows man from man can
possibly go wrong. For some have the privilege of leading; and the rest are
under orders to follow. Orders to wheel from column into line of battle are
given verbally by the second lieutenant acting as a herald, and the line is
formed either thin or deep, by wheeling. Nothing whatever in these movements
is difficult to understand.
To be sure, the secret of carrying on in a battle with any troops at hand
when the line gets into confusion is not so easy to grasp, except for
soldiers trained under the laws of Lycurgus.
The Lacedaemonians also carry out with perfect
ease manoeuvres that instructors in tactics think very difficult. Thus, when
they march in column, every section of course follows in the rear of the
section in front of it. Suppose that at such a time an enemy in order of
battle suddenly makes his appearance in front: the word is passed to the
second lieutenant to deploy into line to the left, and so throughout the
column until the battle-line stands facing the enemy. Or again, if the enemy
appears in the rear while they are in this formation, each file
counter-marches, in order that the best men may always be face to face with
the enemy.
True, the leader is then on the left, but instead of thinking this a
disadvantage, they regard it as a positive advantage at times. For should
the enemy attempt a flanking movement he would try to encircle them, not on
the exposed but on the protected side.i.e., this was the regular plan, because each of two battle lines
advancing to meet one another always tended to converge to the right.
See Thucydides, 5.71. If, however, it seems better for any reason
that the leader should be on the right wing, the left wing wheels, and the
army counter-marches by ranks until the leader is on the right, and the rear
of the column on the left.
If, on the other hand, an enemy force appears on the right when they are
marching in column, all that they have to do is to order each company to
wheel to the right so as to front the enemy like a man-of-war, and thus
again the company at the rear of the column is on the right. If again an
enemy approaches on the left, they do not allow that either, but either push
him backThis can only mean that if the
Lacedaemonians are in battle-order the whole phalanx turns to the left
to meet the attack: wheeling by companies to the left would only be
necessary when the army marching in column was threatened on the left.
But ἀλλὰ προθέουσιν found in C
(but either run forward) is almost certainly the right reading.
or wheel their companies to the left to face him, and thus the rear of the
column finds itself on the left.
I will now explain the method of encampment
approved by Lycurgus.
Seeing that the angles of a square are
useless, he introduced the circular form of camp, except where there was a
secure hill or wall, or a river afforded protection in the rear.
He caused sentries to be posted by day facing inwards along the place where
the arms were kept, for the object of these is to keep an eye not on the
enemy but on their friends. The enemy is watched by cavalry from positions
that command the widest outlook.
To meet the case of a hostile approach at night, he assigned the duty of
acting as sentries outside the lines to the Sciritae. In these days the duty
is shared by foreigners, if any happen to be present in the camp.
The rule that patrols invariably carry their spears, has the same purpose,
undoubtedly, as the exclusion of slaves from the place of arms. Nor is it
surprising that sentries who withdraw for necessary purposes only go so far
away from one another and from the arms as not to cause inconvenience.
Safety is the first object of this rule also.
The camp is frequently shifted with the double
object of annoying their enemies and of helping their friends.
Moreover the law requires all Lacedaemonians
to practise gymnastics regularly throughout the campaign; and the result is
that they take more pride in themselves and have a more dignified appearance
than other men. Neither walk nor race-course may exceed in length the space
covered by the regiment, so that no one may get far away from his own arms.
After the exercises the senior colonel gives the order by herald to sit down
— this is their method of inspection — and next to take breakfast and to
relieve the outposts quickly. After this there are amusements and
recreations until the evening exercises.
These being finished, the herald gives the order to take the evening meal,
and, as soon as they have sung to the praise of the gods to whom they have
sacrificed with good omens, to rest by the arms.
Let not the length to which I run occasion
surprise, for it is almost impossible to find any detail in military matters
requiring attention that is overlooked by the Lacedaemonians.
I will also give an account of the power and
honour that Lycurgus conferred on the King in the field. In the first place,
while on military service the King and his staff are maintained by the
state. The colonels mess with the King, in order that constant intercourse
may give better opportunities for taking counsel together in case of need.
Three of the peers also attend the King’s mess. These three take entire
charge of the commissariat for the King and his staff, so that these may
devote all their time to affairs of war.
But I will go back to the beginning, and
explain how the King sets out with an army. First he offers up sacrifice at
home to Zeus the Leader and to the gods associated with him.Or, if we read οἱ σὺν αὐτῷ
with Haase, he and his staff. By the
associated gods
we should understand Castor and Pollux, the Dioscuri.
In the Oxford text I gave
τοῖν σιοῖν, the twin
gods. If the sacrifice appears propitious, the Fire-bearer takes
fire from the altar and leads the way to the borders of the land. There the
King offers sacrifice again to Zeus and Athena.
Only when the sacrifice proves acceptable to both these deities does he cross
the borders of the land. And the fire from these sacrifices leads the way
and is never quenched, and animals for sacrifice of every sort follow. At
all times when he offers sacrifice, the King begins the work before dawn of
day, wishing to forestall the goodwill of the god.
And at the sacrifice are assembled colonels, captains, lieutenants,
commandants of foreign contingents, commanders of the baggage train, and, in
addition, any general from the states who chooses to be present.
There are also present two of the Ephors, who interfere in nothing except by
the King’s request, but keep an eye on the proceedings, and see that all
behave with a decorum suitable to the occasion. When the sacrifices are
ended, the King summons all and delivers the orders of the day. And so,
could you watch the scene, you would think all other men mere improvisors in
soldiering and the Lacedaemonians the only artists in warfare.
When the King leads, provided that no enemy
appears, no one precedes him except the Sciritae and the mounted vedettes.
But if ever they think there will be fighting, he takes the lead of the
first regiment and wheels to the right, until he is between two regiments
and two colonels.
The troops that are to support these are marshalled by the senior member of
the King’s staff. The staff consists of all peers who are members of the
royal mess, seers, doctors, fluteplayers, commanding officers and any
volunteers who happen to be present. Thus nothing that has to be done causes
any difficulty, for everything is duly provided for.
The following arrangementsThis paragraph is an afterthought, supplementing
11.3-4. made by Lycurgus with a view to the actual fighting are
also, in my opinion, very useful. When a goat is sacrificed, the enemy being
near enough to see, custom ordains that all the fluteplayers present are to
play and every Lacedaemonian is to wear a wreath. An order is also given to
polish arms. It is also the privilege of the young warrior to comb his
hair(?) before entering battle, to look cheerful and earn a good report.
Moreover, the men shout words of encouragement to the subaltern, for it is
impossible for each subaltern to make his voice travel along the whole of
his section to the far end.When two or
more sections are abreast (c. xi. 4), the men take up and repeat the
exhortations of the subaltern posted at the end of the line, and pass
them along to the next subaltern, and so on. These detached notes are
not clearly expressed. The colonel is responsible for seeing that
all is done properly.
When the time for encamping seems to have
arrived, the decision rests with the King, who also indicates the proper
place. On the other hand the dispatch of embassies whether to friends or
enemies is not the King’s affair. All who have any business to transact deal
in the first instance with the King.
Suitors for justice are remitted by the King to the Court of Hellanodicae,
applications for money to the treasurers; and if anyone brings booty, he is
sent to the auctioneers. With this routine the only duties left to the King
on active service are to act as priest in matters of religion and as general
in his dealings with the men.
Should anyone ask me whether I think that the
laws of Lycurgus still remain unchanged at this day, I certainly could not
say that with any confidence whatever.οὐκ .. ἔτι probably does not
correspond to no longer here. On this chapter see Introduction.
For I know that formerly the Lacedaemonians preferred to live together at
home with moderate fortunes rather than expose themselves to the corrupting
influences of flattery as governors of dependent states.
And I know too that in former days they were afraid to be found in possession
of gold; whereas nowadays there are some who even boast of their
possessions.
There were alien acts in former days, and to live abroad was illegal; and I
have no doubt that the purpose of these regulations was to keep the citizens
from being demoralized by contact with foreigners; and now I have no doubt
that the fixed ambition of those who are thought to be first among them is
to live to their dying day as governors in a foreign land.
There was a time when they would fain be worthy of leadership; but now they
strive far more earnestly to exercise rule than to be worthy of it.
Therefore in times past the Greeks would come to Lacedaemon and beg her to lead them against reputed
wrongdoers; but now many are calling on one another to prevent a revival of
Lacedaemonian supremacy.
Yet we need not wonder if these reproaches are levelled at them, since it is
manifest that they obey neither their god nor the laws of Lycurgus.
I wish also to give an account of the compact
made by Lycurgus between King and state. For this is the only government
that continues exactly as it was originally established, whereas other
constitutions will be found to have undergone and still to be undergoing
modifications.
He ordained that the King shall offer all the
public sacrifices on behalf of the state, in virtue of his divine descent,
and that, whatever may be the destination to which the state sends out an
army, he shall be its leader.
He also gave him the right to receive certain parts of the beasts sacrificed,
and assigned to him enough choice land in many of the outlanders’ cities to
ensure him a reasonable competence without excessive riches.
In order that even the kings should mess in public, he assigned to them a
public mess tent; he also honoured them with a double portion at the meal,
not that they might eat enough for two, but that they might have the
wherewithal to honour anyone whom they chose.
He also allowed each King to choose two messmates, who are called Pythii.
Further, he granted them to take of every litter of pigs a porker, that a
King may never want victims, in case he wishes to seek counsel of the gods.
A lake near the house supplies abundance of
water; and how useful that is for many purposes none know so well as those
who are without it. Further, all rise from their seats when the King
appears; only the Ephors do not rise from their official chairs.
And they exchange oaths monthly, the Ephors on behalf of the state, the King
for himself. And this is the King’s oath:
I will reign according to the
established laws of the state.
And this the oath of the state:
While you
abide by your oath, we will keep the kingship unshaken.
These then are the honours that are bestowed on the King at
home during his lifetime; and they do not greatly exceed those of
private persons. For it was not the wish of Lycurgus to put into the
King’s hearts despotic pride, nor to implant in the mind of the citizens
envy of their power.
As for the honours assigned to the King at his death, the intention of the
laws of Lycurgus herein is to show that they have preferred the Kings of the
Lacedaemonians in honour not as mere men, but as demigods.Herodotus (6.58) gives details of these honours. The
elaborate funeral obsequies were attended by a great concourse of men
and women from all parts of Laconia. A man and a woman in every family were
compelled to go into mourning. If a king died on foreign service his
body was embalmed and brought home if possible; if not, an image of him,
as in the case of Agesilaus, was buried.