--- title: "Is This Why Science Advances One Funeral at a Time?" sha256: ca6080301a86396f276dea467943ff0a3b9b30a06807289f4081cf96ae5ac9c0 source: newsletter source_url: "https://nautil.us/is-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650" url: "https://nautil.us/is-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650" fetcher: jina review_value: 7 review_confidence: 8 review_recommendation: worth-reading review_stars: 3 ingested: 2026-05-14 created: 2026-05-14 updated: 2026-05-14 --- Published Time: 2026-05-11T21:00:00+00:00 Markdown Content: # Is This Why Science Advances One Funeral at a Time? [Skip to Content](https://nautil.us/is-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650#main) Menu [![Image 2: Nautilus home](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/sites/3/nautilus/cropped-nautilus-logo-print.png?w=2880)](https://nautil.us/) [![Image 3: Nautilus home](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/sites/3/nautilus/Nautilus-logo.png?w=2880)](https://nautil.us/) - [x] [Subscribe](https://nautil.us/products)[Log In](https://nautil.us/login?destination=%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650) Search Search * [Astronomy](https://nautil.us/category/astronomy) * [Environment](https://nautil.us/category/environment) * [Evolution](https://nautil.us/category/evolution) * [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) * [Philosophy](https://nautil.us/category/philosophy) * [Psychology](https://nautil.us/category/psychology) * [Zoology](https://nautil.us/category/zoology) * [FAQ](https://nautil.us/faq) * [Contact](https://nautil.us/contact) * [Awards and Press](https://nautil.us/awards-and-press) * [Privacy Policy](https://fragmnt.com/privacy-policy) * [Terms of Service](https://fragmnt.com/terms-of-use) * [RSS](https://nautil.us/feed) * [Jobs](https://nautil.us/jobs) * [Newsletter](https://nautil.us/newsletter) * [Ethics Policy](https://nautil.us/ethics-policy) [Log In](https://nautil.us/login?destination=%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650)[Subscribe](https://nautil.us/products) * [Nautilus Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/NautilusMag) * [Nautilus X (formerly Twitter)](https://x.com/nautilusmag) * [Nautilus TikTok](https://www.tiktok.com/@nautilusmagazine) * [Nautilus YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@NautilUsMag) * [Nautilus Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/nautil.us) * [Nautilus Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/nautilusmag/) * [Astronomy](https://nautil.us/category/astronomy) * [Environment](https://nautil.us/category/environment) * [Evolution](https://nautil.us/category/evolution) * [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) * [Philosophy](https://nautil.us/category/philosophy) * [Psychology](https://nautil.us/category/psychology) * [Zoology](https://nautil.us/category/zoology) [Subscribe to skip ads](https://nautil.us/products)Advertisement [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) As researchers age, they produce less disruptive work [BG](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) By [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) 4:00 PM CDT on May 11, 2026 * [Share on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on X (formerly Twitter)](https://x.com/intent/tweet?text=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F&url=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on Reddit](http://www.reddit.com/submit/?title=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F&url=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on Email](mailto:?body=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F&subject=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F) * [Share on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/intent/compose?text=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F%20-%20https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) ![Image 4](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/05/Einstein_HERO.png?w=2880) For centuries, science has been a top-heavy enterprise. A vanishingly small number of field-leading experts has the propensity to shape knowledge. They who win the Nobels. They who secure the multi-year, millions-of-dollars grants. They who rewrite the textbooks. Other workers in science are merely passing through, riding the coattails of these giants. [Subscribe to skip ads](https://nautil.us/products)Featured Video Powered By 10 86.4K 1 Are These Galaxies The Oldest Ever Discovered? Share Next Stay But how does a researcher’s capacity for invention, innovation, and insight change over the course of a career in science? Even the giants seem to have something of a use-by date. In one year of publishing—1905—Albert Einstein turned physics on its head and revolutionized humanity’s understanding of our universe with his concepts of special relativity, mass energy equivalence (_E_=_mc_ 2, anyone?), the photoelectric effect, and Brownian motion. He was 26 years old. The shockwaves of the ideas contained in four papers continue to ripple through the fabric of spacetime and shape the intellectual evolution of our species. But toward the tail end of Einstein’s life, he argued strenuously against the concepts undergirding the emerging field of quantum mechanics, the ideas that are shaking up physics yet again and may lay bare even more of our universe’s mysteries. **Read more: “**[**A Letter to Einstein from the Future**](https://nautil.us/a-letter-to-einstein-from-the-future-236791)**”** Historians of science have long debated both the typical shape of a scientist’s output curve and the reasons for its particular slopes, traced throughout the arc of a career in research. Creativity declines with age. Or not. Young scientists are more likely to crack open a field and explore uncharted territory. Older researchers acquire the necessary experience and knowledge necessary to shift paradigms and point inquiry in new directions. And so on. Now, researchers from the universities of Pittsburgh and Chicago have proposed a new model. The key lies in splitting creativity into two separate expressions—novelty through recombining existing insights into new connective ideas and disruptive innovation, the Einsteinian flashes of brilliance that rewrite a field’s trajectory. By analyzing the output of more than 12 million scientists over the course of six decades, from 1960 to 2020, they find that researchers across the world tend to increase their capacity for connective novelty as they age and decrease in their ability to disrupt. They published their [findings](https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ady8732) in _Science_ last week. The authors invoke Douglas Adam’s take on a life spent wandering through the intellectual wilds. “This life-cycle pattern accords with science-fiction author Douglas Adams’ observation about technological change,” they wrote. “What exists at one’s intellectual ‘birth’ feels normal, what appears during early career feels revolutionary, and what emerges after maturity feels suspect.” They contend that, as scientists age and their experience deepens, they become attached to the ideas upon which they built their career. This makes replacing this foundation harder as time wears on. But it also makes it more likely that they notice some connection between two or more established, familiar ideas. “Even the greatest minds, such as Einstein, transitioned from disruptor to gatekeeper when quantum mechanics threatened his nostalgic view of the universe,” they wrote. It was the Nobel laureate and quantum physicist Max Planck who wrote that “science advances one funeral at a time” (which is actually a somewhat artful [translation](https://campuspress.yale.edu/humanbrain/does-science-advance-one-funeral-at-a-time/) of his original statement, in German) about revered gatekeepers and their nostalgia for insights past that keep leaps in scientific understanding from happening. Turns out, he may have been right. ![Image 5](https://assets.nautil.us/sites/3/nautilus/nautilus-favicon-14.png?fm=png) _Lead image: Oren Jack Turner / Wikimedia_ [Subscribe to skip ads](https://nautil.us/products)Advertisement * [Share on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on X (formerly Twitter)](https://x.com/intent/tweet?text=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F&url=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on Reddit](http://www.reddit.com/submit/?title=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F&url=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) * [Share on Email](mailto:?body=https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F&subject=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F) * [Share on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/intent/compose?text=Is%20This%20Why%20Science%20Advances%20One%20Funeral%20at%20a%20Time%3F%20-%20https%3A%2F%2Fnautil.us%2Fis-this-why-science-advances-one-funeral-at-a-time-1280650%2F) [BG](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) Bob Grant is the deputy editor at Nautilus. ## Stay in touch Sign up for our free newsletter Email Sign up ## More from History [Explore History](https://nautil.us/category/history) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [Chernobyl, 40 Years Later](https://nautil.us/chernobyl-40-years-later-1280322) A lot has changed at the site of the world’s worst nuclear disaster [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) April 29, 2026 [![Image 6](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Grant_HERO_f5ad9e.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/chernobyl-40-years-later-1280322) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [Kon-Tiki Set Sail 79 Years Ago Today](https://nautil.us/kon-tiki-set-sail-79-years-ago-today-1280285) The most epic, pseudoscientific adventure ever [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) April 28, 2026 [![Image 7](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Grant_HERO_52ffe6.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/kon-tiki-set-sail-79-years-ago-today-1280285) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [Rome Was Built Today](https://nautil.us/rome-was-built-today-1280078) Celebrating the scientific and technical contributions of Rome on the mythical birthday of the eternal city [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) April 21, 2026 [![Image 8](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Grant_HERO_7c9871.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/rome-was-built-today-1280078) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [The Birth of Genius](https://nautil.us/the-birth-of-genius-1279907) Leonardo da Vinci, polymath and victim of the vagaries of science funding, was born on this day [Bob Grant](https://nautil.us/author/bobgrant) April 15, 2026 [![Image 9](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Grant_HERO_190927.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/the-birth-of-genius-1279907) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [The Bra-and-Girdle Maker That Fashioned the Impossible for NASA](https://nautil.us/the-bra-and-girdle-maker-that-fashioned-the-impossible-for-nasa-1279841) Crafting a spacesuit demanded perfection from seamstresses to gluers to engineers — every stitch could mean life or death [Nicholas de Monchaux](https://nautil.us/author/nicholas-de-monchaux) April 14, 2026 [![Image 10](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Monchaux_HERO.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/the-bra-and-girdle-maker-that-fashioned-the-impossible-for-nasa-1279841) [History](https://nautil.us/category/history) ### [The Creator of the SAT Was an Infamous Eugenicist](https://nautil.us/the-creator-of-the-sat-was-an-infamous-eugenicist-1279568) The racist origin story of the most common college entrance exam [Jake Currie](https://nautil.us/author/jake-currie) April 6, 2026 [![Image 11](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2026/04/Currie_HERO-2.png?resize=2880%2C1920)](https://nautil.us/the-creator-of-the-sat-was-an-infamous-eugenicist-1279568) [![Image 12: Nautilus home](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/sites/3/nautilus/cropped-nautilus-logo-print.png?w=2880)](https://nautil.us/) [![Image 13: Nautilus home](https://lede-admin.nautil.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/sites/3/nautilus/Nautilus-logo.png?w=2880)](https://nautil.us/) ## Stay in touch Sign up for our free newsletter Email Sign up * [Nautilus Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/NautilusMag) * [Nautilus X (formerly Twitter)](https://x.com/nautilusmag) * [Nautilus TikTok](https://www.tiktok.com/@nautilusmagazine) * [Nautilus YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@NautilUsMag) * [Nautilus Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/nautil.us) * [Nautilus Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/nautilusmag/) * [FAQ](https://nautil.us/faq) * [Contact](https://nautil.us/contact) * [Awards and Press](https://nautil.us/awards-and-press) * [Privacy Policy](https://fragmnt.com/privacy-policy) * [Terms of Service](https://fragmnt.com/terms-of-use) * [RSS](https://nautil.us/feed) * [Jobs](https://nautil.us/jobs) * [Newsletter](https://nautil.us/newsletter) * [Ethics Policy](https://nautil.us/ethics-policy) © Copyright 2026 Made in partnership with [Lede](https://joinlede.com/) We value your privacy! This website uses essential cookies to ensure its proper operation and tracking cookies to understand how you interact with it. The latter will be set only after consent. These settings apply only to this site. Accept all Reject all Cookie usage 📢 Cookie usage 📢 We use cookies for basic functionality of the website and to enhance your online experience. You can choose to opt-in/out for each category whenever you want. Strictly necessary cookies- [x] Strictly necessary cookies These cookies are essential for the proper functioning of this website. Without these cookies, the website would not work properly Performance and Analytics cookies- [x] Performance and Analytics cookies These cookies allow the website to remember the choices you have made in the past | Name | Expiration | Description | | --- | --- | --- | | ^_ga | 2 years | Google Analytics tracking cookie. | | _gid | 24 hours | Google Analytics tracking cookie. | | ^uid | 1 year | Beacon Analytics tracking. | | ^sid | 30 minutes | Beacon Analytics tracking. | | ^seq | 30 minutes | Beacon Analytics tracking. | Advertisement and Targeting cookies- [x] Advertisement and Targeting cookies These cookies collect information about how you use the website, which pages you visited and which links you clicked on. All of the data is anonymized and cannot be used to identify you. | Name | Expiration | Description | | --- | --- | --- | | __gpi | 13 months | Google Ad Manager targeting cookie. | | __gads | 13 months | Google Ad Manager targeting cookie. | Accept all Reject all Save settings ![Image 14](https://ids4.ad.gt/api/v1/ip_match?id=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4)![Image 15](https://secure.adnxs.com/getuid?https://ids.ad.gt/api/v1/match?id=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&adnxs_id=$UID&gdpr=0)![Image 16](https://u.openx.net/w/1.0/cm?id=998eaf06-9905-4eae-9e26-9fac75960c53&r=https%3A%2F%2Fids.ad.gt%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Fopenx%3Fopenx_id%3D%7BOPENX_ID%7D%26id%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4%26auid%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&gdpr=0)![Image 17](https://image2.pubmatic.com/AdServer/UCookieSetPug?rd=https%3A%2F%2Fids.ad.gt%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Fpbm_match%3Fpbm%3D%23PM_USER_ID%26id%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&gdpr=0)![Image 18](https://token.rubiconproject.com/token?pid=50242&puid=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&gdpr=0)![Image 19](https://match.adsrvr.org/track/cmf/generic?ttd_pid=8gkxb6n&ttd_tpi=1&ttd_puid=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&gdpr=0)![Image 20](https://pixel.tapad.com/idsync/ex/receive?partner_id=3185&partner_device_id=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&partner_url=https://ids.ad.gt%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Ftapad_match%3Fid%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4%26tapad_id%3D%24%7BTA_DEVICE_ID%7D&gdpr=0)![Image 21](https://cm.g.doubleclick.net/pixel?google_cm&google_nid=audigent_dmp&google_hm=QVUxRC0wMTAwLTAwMTc3ODc2OTIyNS1KSEVXSTAyOC1EUkI0&id=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&gdpr=0)![Image 22](https://d.turn.com/r/dd/id/L2NzaWQvMS9jaWQvMTc0ODI0MTY1OC90LzA/url/https%3A%2F%2Fids.ad.gt%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Famo_match%3Fturn_id%3D%24!%7BTURN_UUID%7D%26id%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4)![Image 23](https://sync.go.sonobi.com/us?https://ids.ad.gt/api/v1/son_match?id=AU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4&uid=[UID]&gdpr=0)![Image 24](https://ad.360yield.com/ux?&publisher_dmp_id=15&r=https%3A%2F%2Fids.ad.gt%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Fimpr_match%3Fid%3DAU1D-0100-001778769225-JHEWI028-DRB4%26impr_uid%3D%7BPUB_USER_ID%7D&gdpr=0)