---
title: "1-Click GitHub Token Stealing via a VSCode Bug"
source_url: https://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/
ingested: 2026-06-04
sha256: ae301641d61de6c19827a325dc0a8ff602ef5f502bd6a617dda15e1329f6e967
tags: [security, vscode, github, vulnerability, token-theft, postmessage]
source: rss
---

# 1-Click GitHub Token Stealing via a VSCode Bug

> 来源: <https://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/>


Published Time: Wed, 03 Jun 2026 13:24:19 GMT

Markdown Content:
Just by clicking a link, it’s possible for an attacker to steal a GitHub token that can read and **write** to your repos, including **private ones**.

### Table of Contents

*   [Background](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#background)
*   [VSCode Webview Security Model](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#vscode-webview-security-model)
    *   [The Bug](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#the-bug)

*   [PoC and Protecting Yourself](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#poc-and-protecting-yourself)
*   [What VSCode Did Well](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#what-vscode-did-well)
*   [Why Full Disclosure](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#why-full-disclosure)
*   [Timeline](http://blog.ammaraskar.com/github-token-stealing/#timeline)

## Background

Did you know GitHub has this really cool feature [called github.dev](https://docs.github.com/en/codespaces/the-githubdev-web-based-editor#about-the-githubdev-editor)?

On any repository you have access to, if you can change the url from `github.com` to `github.dev`_or_ you click this little menu item:

![Image 1: Dropdown option to use github.dev on github file viewer](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/github-dev-dropdown-option.webp)

You’ll be launched into a little light-weight version of VSCode that runs entirely in your browser (I guess that’s one advantage of having your app written with electron).

![Image 2: CPython file opened in github.dev, a VSCode web interface](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/github-dev-demo.png)

This browser instance of VSCode is pretty powerful, you can view all the files in the repo (even if it’s a private one), you can send out pull requests and even make commits.

This functionality is achieved by `github.com` POSTing over an OAuth token to `github.dev` that allows it to interact with GitHub on your behalf. The token is **not scoped to the particular repo you interacted with**, meaning it has full access to every other repo that you have access to.

The presence of this token and the fact that this web-app is running almost the entire brunt of VSCode’s million line Typescript codebase makes it a great target for anyone looking into VSCode bugs. That sort of bug is what we’ll explore here and show how an attacker can use it to exfiltrate your GitHub token.

## VSCode Webview Security Model

Being an electron app on the desktop, executing arbitrary Javascript inside of VSCode would be tantamount to full remote code execution. This is why VSCode implements some sandboxing approaches, the one we’ll focus on here is [VSCode’s webviews](https://code.visualstudio.com/api/extension-guides/webview).

Webviews use an `<iframe>` with a [different origin](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-origin_policy) to the main VSCode window to ensure that any JavaScript executed inside of them is fully isolated. These webviews are used for features such as Markdown previews or editing Jupyter notebooks:

![Image 3: HTML render inside an iframe in a Jupyter notebook](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/iframe-jupyter-notebook.png)

The output of the cell is rendered into an `<iframe>` from the origin `vscode-webview://...`, as opposed to the main electron window which has the origin `vscode-file://...`. This means that even if the Jupyter notebook uses the built-in features of [displaying HTML](https://stackoverflow.com/a/35760941) or [using Javascript for interactive widgets](https://ipywidgets.readthedocs.io/en/latest/), the actual core VScode application is protected from it. One cannot use Electron’s integration with Node.js APIs inside this iframe or call into VSCode’s APIs from this frame.

Great, that gives us the ability to render content, but just static content is boring. How do we implement features like having the Markdown preview show you which source line you currently have highlighted or updating the preview live as we edit it?

![Image 4: Markdown preview showing corresponding source line](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/markdown-preview-selection-marker.png)

The same cross-origin policy that gives us security also prevents our main editor window from interacting with the DOM in the `vscode-webview://...` frame. After all, you wouldn’t want someone who used an `<iframe src="google.com">` to be able to interact with the google page to steal your cookies or change that website’s behavior.

```
> document.getElementsByTagName('iframe')[0].contentWindow.findElementById('foo')
Uncaught SecurityError: Failed to read a named property 'findElementById' from 'Window': 
Blocked a frame with origin "vscode-file://vscode-app" from accessing a cross-origin frame.
```

The only way to allow this behavior is to have the two web pages in the different origins cooperate with each other using the [Window.postMessage() API](https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Window/postMessage). This method allows sending JavaScript objects across the different windows. So in that example of showing which rendered Markdown line corresponds to what editor line, the main editor window posts a little message like this:

```
{
    type: "onDidChangeTextEditorSelection",
    line: 31
}
```

and then the corresponding code running inside of the webview has a listener for this message [that adds the highlight](https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/blob/e4074382086b61bdfb0b6738e0853b2510660d57/extensions/markdown-language-features/preview-src/index.ts#L250):

```
window.addEventListener('message', async event => {
    const data = event.data as ToWebviewMessage.Type;
    switch (data.type) {
        ...
        case 'onDidChangeTextEditorSelection':
            marker.onDidChangeTextEditorSelection(data.line, documentVersion);
            return;
```

> **Note**: VSCode in the browser uses a similar sandboxing model. VSCode developer Matt Bierner has a [great blogpost about the challenges of porting it over from Electron worth checking out](https://blog.mattbierner.com/vscode-webview-web-learnings/).

## The Bug

So our security boundary for webviews roughly looks like this:

![Image 5: Webview security boundary](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/postmessage-boundary.png)

but in terms of UI, our webview sits right here in the window. People expect basic things like clicking links, drag and or pressing Ctrl+F to work inside of them:

![Image 6: Webviews as they appear in the layout of VSCode](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/webview-shown-in-ui.png)

Hence, VSCode implements a bunch of basic functionality through the message passing mechanism to enable these features. Speaking of keyboard shortcuts, the astute reader who has dealt with `<iframe>`s may have already picked up on the issue.

As with most things cross-origin, the browser offers a good amount of isolation between the two frames. If you had a page on `hackerman.com` and you iframed `google.com/login`, you would not want the hackerman page to be able to attach a keyboard listener onto the `iframe`. That would let them see all your keystrokes on `google.com`, allowing them snoop your password.

Okay given that information, try clicking inside a VSCode webview and then pressing Ctrl+Shift+P to bring up the command palette.

![Image 7: VSCode command palette](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/command-palette.png)

**Oh yay, that works. Wait. Oh. Oh no.** So, to avoid the terrible user experience of your keyboard shortcuts not working when you happen to be clicked inside of a webview, the default set of webview message handlers [have an event](https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/blob/e4074382086b61bdfb0b6738e0853b2510660d57/src/vs/workbench/contrib/webview/browser/webviewElement.ts#L249-L254) called `did-keydown`. When you load a webview, the following code runs inside the webview to register a handler for it:

```
contentWindow.addEventListener('keydown', handleInnerKeydown);

/**
 * @param {KeyboardEvent} e
 */
const handleInnerKeydown = (e) => {
    // ...
    hostMessaging.postMessage('did-keydown', {
        key: e.key,
        keyCode: e.keyCode,
        code: e.code,
        shiftKey: e.shiftKey,
        altKey: e.altKey,
        ctrlKey: e.ctrlKey,
        metaKey: e.metaKey,
        repeat: e.repeat
    });
};
```

How convenient, so webviews just bubble up `keydown` events so the main VSCode window can treat them seamlessly as user keyboard events.

But…there’s nothing preventing our script running in the untrusted web view from pretending like it’s the user and pressing a bunch of keys on their behalf.

We could, say, bring up the command palette and start running dangerous commands such as installing an attacker-controlled extension. All we’d need is a bit of javascript that emits the correct events to simulate the keystrokes…

*   Ctrl+Shift+P
*   `developer: install extension from location`
*   Enter
*   `<attacker controlled extension>`
*   Enter

In reality it’s not quite that simple. While we can certainly send the `keydown` events corresponding to that sequence, the browser will not treat it as if it’s the user typing it in. So VSCode will pop up the command palette but unless VScode is intercepting all `keydown` events to handle each character being typed manually, our events will not actually type text into the palette. Unfortunately, in this case here, it is not listening to `keydown` events, the command palette widget just uses an HTML `<input>` tag.

We can scroll up and down in the command palette if we emit up-arrow ↑, down-arrow ↓ presses and can press Enter to select commands but arbitrary keystrokes are off the table.

Luckily, VSCode comes with a massive set of default keyboard shortcuts, all of which listen directly on `keydown` that we can try to make use of. After a bunch of tinkering, the easiest way I found is to make use of the _“Notifications: Accept Notification Primary Action”_ action. This default keybind of Ctrl+Shift+A will hit the primary button on whatever notification popped up last in VSCode.

Which notification are we accepting?

![Image 8: Recommended extension notification in VSCode](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/notification-recommended-extension.png)

VSCode has this feature where your workspace can [recommend extensions](https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/configure/extensions/extension-marketplace#_recommended-extensions) by putting them in a file called `.vscode/extensions.json` that looks something like

```
{
  "recommendations": [
    "HackerMan.my-malicious-extension"
  ]
}
```

And then we can use Ctrl+Shift+A to accept that notification and install the malicious extension giving us full code execution? Shrimple as?

Again, not quite, VSCode as of 1.97 has this [new publisher trust system](https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/configure/extensions/extension-runtime-security#_extension-publisher-trust) whereby installing an extension from a new publisher for the first time gives you this dialog, even if we hit the _Install_ button in that notification:

![Image 9: Publisher trust dialog in VSCode](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/trusted-publisher-dialog.png)

While we can send Tab key presses to navigate the buttons here, pressing Enter on the _Trust Publisher & Install_ button is impossible as it listens for `keydown` events specifically on the button and not the entire window.

Instead, we can make use of another VSCode feature called **local workspace extensions**. As long as you are inside of a trusted workspace (which github.dev/web workspaces always are), then it’s possible to [install an extension directly present in `.vscode/extensions`](https://code.visualstudio.com/updates/v1_89#_local-workspace-extensions). Extensions installed in this way skip the trusted publisher check with the trusted workspace check acting as the trust check. So now we can just put our evil payload in `.vscode/extensions/extension.js` and execute our own code, right?

Well almost, doing this causes a Content Security Policy (CSP) error because the extension worker that loads extensions is expecting them to be from `vscode-cdn.net`. Local workspace extensions probably weren’t well tested with the web version of VSCode.

![Image 10: Content security policy violation in local extension](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/csp-error-local-ext.png)

This is just a small hiccup though, one of the things that extensions can do as part of their `package.json` is to contribute extra keybindings to VSCode. Since we can reliably trigger keybindings, we can just add a keybind for whatver VSCode command we want. Such as…installing an extension while skipping the trusted publisher check. So our `package.json` ends up looking like this to call into `workbench.extensions.installExtension` while skipping the publisher trust check.

```
"contributes": {
  "keybindings": [
    {
      "key": "ctrl+f1",
      "command": "runCommands",
      "args": {
        "commands": [
          {
            "command": "workbench.extensions.installExtension",
            "args": [
              "AmmarTest.hello-ammar-github",
              {
                "donotSync": true,
                "context": {
                  "skipPublisherTrust": true
                }
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  ]
}
```

To put it all together, what we need is a repo with a **Jupyter notebook** and a **local workspace extension**. The Jupyter notebook needs to execute a little bit of Javascript which we can do with a markdown cell containing the following:

```
<img src="data:foobar" onerror="javascript(); goes(); here();">
```

For our Javascript payload, we need to do the following:

1.   Wait a little bit for VSCode to pop-up asking us if we want to install the recommended extensions.
2.   Emit a `keydown` event for Ctrl+Shift+A to accept the notification.
3.   Wait a little bit for the extension to install and active, putting in our custom keybind.
4.   Emit a `keydown` event for Ctrl+F1 triggering the installation of our chosen extension.

This payload ends up looking like:

```
// Wait for VSCode to load and pop open the notification.
await sleep(10 * 1000);

// ctrl+shift+a, accept the primary notification asking if we want to install
// the recommended extension
window.dispatchEvent(
  new KeyboardEvent("keydown", {key: "a", code: "KeyA", keyCode: 65, 
                                ctrlKey: true, shiftKey: true})
);
// Wait a little for the extension to install...
await sleep(500);

// ctrl+f1, the custom keybind to install the chosen extension.
window.dispatchEvent(
  new KeyboardEvent("keydown", {key: "F1", code: "F1", keyCode: 112, ctrlKey: true})
);
```

## PoC and Protecting Yourself

Now that we’ve seen the details, let’s take a look at the proof-of-concept. For the bravest among you, go ahead and just directly click:

[https://github.dev/ammaraskar/github-dev-token-steal-poc/blob/main/README.ipynb](https://github.dev/ammaraskar/github-dev-token-steal-poc/blob/main/README.ipynb)

This will launch the github.dev editor directly to the notebook. You’ll see a little status message of what the Javascript payload is doing.

![Image 11: Proof-of-concept initial page](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/poc-status-page.png)

Once the payload runs, the newly installed extension will grab your GitHub API token and then query `https://api.github.com/user/repos` to get private repos you have access to. It then prints them out and your token in a little information box.

![Image 12: Private repos printed by proof-of-concept](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/poc-info-box.png)

The code for both the repos used is here:

*   **Installed extension**: [https://github.com/ammaraskar/vscode-github-token-grab-extension/blob/main/src/extension.ts](https://github.com/ammaraskar/vscode-github-token-grab-extension/blob/main/src/extension.ts)
*   **Notebook JS**: [https://github.com/ammaraskar/github-dev-token-steal-poc/blame/main/README.ipynb](https://github.com/ammaraskar/github-dev-token-steal-poc/blame/main/README.ipynb)

If you run the PoC, remember to either clear your github.dev data (see below) or at the very least uninstall the proof-of-concept extension otherwise it will follow you on all github.dev pages.

This vulnerability also exists in the desktop version of VSCode, though it’s a bit harder to exploit since you would need to convince the victim to clone your repo and open the notebook with the webview script payload. Of course, if you had some other XSS in a webview that you can get a victim to open, you get effectively full RCE on their computer.

## Protecting Yourself

By a stroke of luck, if you have never used github.dev in the past, there is one dialog to click through when landing on the website. This didn’t used to happen before but some changing of VSCode’s GitHub plugins has caused this.

![Image 13: Initial sign in dialog](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/initial-sign-in-dialog.png)

This means that if you clear your cookies and local site data for github.dev, you can take action and navigate away from the page if someone tries to use this attack on you. I strongly recommend you clear site data for github.dev, in Chrome this can be done by clicking the little icon in the URL bar, clicking **Cookies and site data**>**Manage on-device site data**.

![Image 14: Manage site data in Chrome](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/manage-site-data.png)

and then deleting data for all the domains with the trash can icons:

![Image 15: Delete site data in Chrome](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/delete-site-data.png)

Unfortunately, if you’ve ever been past that dialog on github.dev and haven’t cleared your browser’s local storage, you’re completely screwed. There are no CSRF tokens or anything for github.dev so any link on the internet can redirect you to this attack.

## What VSCode Did Well

VSCode’s approach of not just solely relying on the `<iframe>` but using defense-in-depth security measures like a strict [Content Security Policy](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Security_Policy) and using [DOMPurify](https://github.com/cure53/dompurify) for rendered markdown pays dividends here. If there was a way to execute arbitrary Javascript inside the Markdown preview shown on an extension’s page, you can imagine how this vulnerability could have even more impact (1-click RCE on desktop by linking someone your extension). However, by using `script-src 'none'` this is effectively nipped in the bud.

![Image 16: Content security policy in extension view](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/images/vscode/extension-page-script-src-csp.png)

## Why Full Disclosure?

To summarize the last time I interacted with [MSRC regarding reporting a VSCode bug](https://blog.ammaraskar.com/vscode-rce/#microsoft-security-and-vscode), it was a horrible experience where they silently fixed the bug I pointed out without any credit. They also marked it as not having any security impact. As I mentioned in that post, going forward I would be doing full public disclosure for any security bugs I found in VSCode. Taking a look at a [recent report by Starlabs on a VSCode XSS bug](https://starlabs.sg/blog/2025/05-breaking-out-of-restricted-mode-xss-to-rce-in-visual-studio-code/) marked as ineligible and low severity, it doesn’t look like MSRC has gotten any better about VSCode bugs.

I’m sure the VSCode team would have appreciated a longer heads up on this to come up with solutions. There is legitimately a UI/UX balance here that needs to be struck with the security concerns. To those folks, I am sorry, but this is one of the few levers I have to try to influence MSRC and the security posture of VSCode. Finding and fully developing security bugs into proof-of-concepts like this takes time and effort on the part of security researchers that should not be disrespected or taken for granted.

## Timeline

*   **Jun 2, 2026** - An hour before posting I gave a heads up to an old contact at GitHub security that I would be disclosing this bug.
*   **Jun 2, 2026** - I disclosed the bug here and on the [VSCode issue tracker](https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues/319593).
*   **Jun 3, 2026** - Microsoft [applies a stopgap fix](https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/pull/319705) by adding a confirmation when opening notebooks in web VSCode and not allowing trusted publisher to be skipped by commands.