{ "skill_name": "rights-clearance-checklist", "status": "passed", "eval_score": 4.4, "test_cases": [ { "id": "tc-01", "description": "Feature documentary with complex mixed content", "input": { "title": "The Collector", "format": "Feature documentary", "content": "Talking heads, archive footage from film institute, advertising film clips on screen, original commissioned score, pop song on radio, archive photographs, historic building exterior, branded products visible", "distribution": "Theatrical + streaming (global), broadcast (European)", "obtained": "Talent releases for all interviewees" }, "scores": { "coherence": 5, "consistency": 5, "fluency": 4, "relevance": 5, "professionalism": 4, "actionability": 5, "editorial_naturalness": 4 }, "mean": 4.67, "notes": "All relevant clearance categories identified. High-risk items (advertising clips, pop song) correctly flagged. Sync vs master licence distinction made explicit. Legal referral items listed separately.", "editorial_naturalness_note": "EN backfill: zero lexical/structural/tonal tells detected in automated scan. Scored 4 (not 5) because full tell-by-tell examination not performed \u2014 EN=5 requires demonstrating zero tells, not just not finding any.", "case_mean": 4.57 }, { "id": "tc-02", "description": "Podcast with archival audio clips", "input": { "title": "Cold Front", "format": "Investigative podcast, 6 episodes", "content": "Original interview recordings, archive radio broadcast clips (1980s), government document reading aloud, ambient location sound, original theme music commissioned, episode published to Spotify/Apple Podcasts", "distribution": "All podcast platforms, global", "obtained": "Nothing yet" }, "scores": { "coherence": 4, "consistency": 4, "fluency": 4, "relevance": 4, "professionalism": 4, "actionability": 4, "editorial_naturalness": 4 }, "mean": 4.0, "notes": "Podcast-specific clearance requirements handled. Archive radio broadcast clearance correctly differentiated from archive film. Government documents correctly identified as typically public domain with caveat.", "editorial_naturalness_note": "EN backfill: zero lexical/structural/tonal tells detected in automated scan. Scored 4 (not 5) because full tell-by-tell examination not performed \u2014 EN=5 requires demonstrating zero tells, not just not finding any.", "case_mean": 4.0 }, { "id": "tc-03", "description": "Short drama with location filming and practical sets", "input": { "title": "Margins", "format": "Short drama film, 22 minutes", "content": "Professional actors (one known from TV), private residential location (owner permission verbal), caf\u00e9 exterior filming (public street), contemporary art prints visible on walls (bought at market), licensed music track from a production library", "distribution": "Festival circuit, then short film streaming platforms" }, "scores": { "coherence": 4, "consistency": 4, "fluency": 4, "relevance": 4, "professionalism": 4, "actionability": 5, "editorial_naturalness": 4 }, "mean": 4.17, "notes": "Drama format clears requirements differ from documentary \u2014 actor contracts vs release forms distinction made. Art prints on walls flagged for copyright check. Production library music correctly noted as pre-cleared but scope confirmation needed.", "editorial_naturalness_note": "EN backfill: zero lexical/structural/tonal tells detected in automated scan. Scored 4 (not 5) because full tell-by-tell examination not performed \u2014 EN=5 requires demonstrating zero tells, not just not finding any.", "case_mean": 4.14 } ], "overall_mean": 4.24, "passed": true, "editorial_naturalness_mean": 4.0 }