--- name: make-pythonic description: Audit and improve datafusion-python functions to accept native Python types (int, float, str, bool) instead of requiring explicit lit() or col() wrapping. Analyzes function signatures, checks upstream Rust implementations for type constraints, and applies the appropriate coercion pattern. argument-hint: [scope] (e.g., "string functions", "datetime functions", "array functions", "math functions", "all", or a specific function name like "split_part") --- # Make Python API Functions More Pythonic You are improving the datafusion-python API to feel more natural to Python users. The goal is to allow functions to accept native Python types (int, float, str, bool, etc.) for arguments that are contextually always or typically literal values, instead of requiring users to manually wrap them in `lit()`. **Core principle:** A Python user should be able to write `split_part(col("a"), ",", 2)` instead of `split_part(col("a"), lit(","), lit(2))` when the arguments are contextually obvious literals. ## Scope: `functions` vs `functions.spark` Both `python/datafusion/functions/__init__.py` and `python/datafusion/functions/spark.py` are in scope. We want both to feel pythonic — accept native Python types where the argument is contextually a literal — but `functions.spark` carries an additional constraint: **every signature must remain compatible with `pyspark.sql.functions`**. Compatibility rules for the spark namespace: - **Parameter names must match pyspark exactly.** Pyspark callers pass by keyword (`spark.shiftleft(col=..., numBits=...)`), so renames break them. Do NOT rename a parameter just because it would be more pythonic in the main namespace. - **Positional order must match pyspark exactly.** Reordering breaks positional pyspark calls. - **Type unions may widen the input set, never narrow it.** Pyspark accepts `Column` or `str` (column name) for most args; we accept `Expr` already, and widening to `Expr | int` / `Expr | str` for literal-friendly arguments is on-brand because the int/str case is exactly what a pyspark caller would also try. Just verify the widened set is a superset of what pyspark accepts for that arg. - **Extra keyword arguments are allowed** as long as they default to `None` and pyspark's positional/keyword form still works (e.g. the spark `avg`/`try_sum`/`collect_list`/`collect_set` retain DataFusion's `distinct`/`filter`/`order_by`/`null_treatment` kwargs). Practical effect: in `functions.spark`, apply Categories A and (where pyspark exposes the same arg as a non-`Expr`) B normally, but cross-check each proposed signature against `pyspark.sql.functions` before landing it. When pyspark's own type hint is `Column | str` for a "column name" arg, prefer leaving the spark wrapper at `Expr` — Category C ("`Expr | str` meaning column name") is unusual in `functions.py` and should remain so in `functions.spark`. ## How to Identify Candidates The user may specify a scope via `$ARGUMENTS`. If no scope is given or "all" is specified, audit all functions in `python/datafusion/functions/__init__.py` **and** `python/datafusion/functions/spark.py`. When updating a spark-namespace function, apply the compatibility rules from "Scope" above on top of the standard analysis. For each function, determine if any parameter can accept native Python types by evaluating **two complementary signals**: ### Signal 1: Contextual Understanding Some arguments are contextually always or almost always literal values based on what the function does: | Context | Typical Arguments | Examples | |---------|------------------|----------| | **String position/count** | Character counts, indices, repetition counts | `left(str, n)`, `right(str, n)`, `repeat(str, n)`, `lpad(str, count, ...)` | | **Delimiters/separators** | Fixed separator characters | `split_part(str, delim, idx)`, `concat_ws(sep, ...)` | | **Search/replace patterns** | Literal search strings, replacements | `replace(str, from, to)`, `regexp_replace(str, pattern, replacement, flags)` | | **Date/time parts** | Part names from a fixed set | `date_part(part, date)`, `date_trunc(part, date)` | | **Rounding precision** | Decimal place counts | `round(val, places)`, `trunc(val, places)` | | **Fill characters** | Padding characters | `lpad(str, count, fill)`, `rpad(str, count, fill)` | ### Signal 2: Upstream Rust Implementation Check the Rust binding in `crates/core/src/functions.rs` and the upstream DataFusion function implementation to determine type constraints. The upstream source is cached locally at: ``` ~/.cargo/registry/src/index.crates.io-*/datafusion-functions-/src/ ``` Check the DataFusion version in `crates/core/Cargo.toml` to find the right directory. Key subdirectories: `string/`, `datetime/`, `math/`, `regex/`. For **aggregate functions**, the upstream source is in a separate crate: ``` ~/.cargo/registry/src/index.crates.io-*/datafusion-functions-aggregate-/src/ ``` There are five concrete techniques to check, in order of signal strength: #### Technique 1: Check `invoke_with_args()` for literal-only enforcement (strongest signal) Some functions pattern-match on `ColumnarValue::Scalar` in their `invoke_with_args()` method and **return an error** if the argument is a column/array. This means the argument **must** be a literal — passing a column expression will fail at runtime. Example from `date_trunc.rs`: ```rust let granularity_str = if let ColumnarValue::Scalar(ScalarValue::Utf8(Some(v))) = granularity { v.to_lowercase() } else { return exec_err!("Granularity of `date_trunc` must be non-null scalar Utf8"); }; ``` **If you find this pattern:** The argument is **Category B** — accept only the corresponding native Python type (e.g., `str`), not `Expr`. The function will error at runtime with a column expression anyway. #### Technique 1a: Check `accumulator()` for literal-only enforcement (aggregate functions) Technique 1 applies to scalar UDFs. Aggregate functions do not have `invoke_with_args()` — instead, they enforce literal-only arguments in their `accumulator()` (or `create_accumulator()`) method, which runs at planning time before any data is processed. Look for these patterns inside `accumulator()`: - `get_scalar_value(expr)` — evaluates the expression against an empty batch and errors if it's not a scalar - `validate_percentile_expr(expr)` — specific helper used by percentile functions - `downcast_ref::()` — checks that the physical expression is a literal constant Example from `approx_percentile_cont.rs`: ```rust fn accumulator(&self, args: AccumulatorArgs) -> Result { let percentile = validate_percentile_expr(&args.exprs[1], "APPROX_PERCENTILE_CONT")?; // ... } ``` Where `validate_percentile_expr` calls `get_scalar_value` and errors with `"must be a literal"`. Example from `string_agg.rs`: ```rust fn accumulator(&self, acc_args: AccumulatorArgs) -> Result> { let Some(lit) = acc_args.exprs[1].as_any().downcast_ref::() else { return not_impl_err!( "The second argument of the string_agg function must be a string literal" ); }; // ... } ``` **If you find this pattern:** The argument is **Category B** — accept only the corresponding native Python type, not `Expr`. The function will error at planning time with a non-literal expression. To discover which aggregate functions have literal-only arguments, search the upstream aggregate crate for `get_scalar_value`, `validate_percentile_expr`, and `downcast_ref::()` inside `accumulator()` methods. For example, you should expect to find `approx_percentile_cont` (percentile) and `string_agg` (delimiter) among the results. #### Technique 1b: Check `partition_evaluator()` for literal-only enforcement (window functions) Window functions do not have `invoke_with_args()` or `accumulator()`. Instead, they enforce literal-only arguments in their `partition_evaluator()` method, which constructs the evaluator that processes each partition. The upstream source is in a separate crate: ``` ~/.cargo/registry/src/index.crates.io-*/datafusion-functions-window-/src/ ``` Look for `get_scalar_value_from_args()` calls inside `partition_evaluator()`. This helper (defined in the window crate's `utils.rs`) calls `downcast_ref::()` and errors with `"There is only support Literal types for field at idx: {index} in Window Function"`. Example from `ntile.rs`: ```rust fn partition_evaluator( &self, partition_evaluator_args: PartitionEvaluatorArgs, ) -> Result> { let scalar_n = get_scalar_value_from_args(partition_evaluator_args.input_exprs(), 0)? .ok_or_else(|| { exec_datafusion_err!("NTILE requires a positive integer") })?; // ... } ``` **If you find this pattern:** The argument is **Category B** — accept only the corresponding native Python type, not `Expr`. The function will error at planning time with a non-literal expression. To discover which window functions have literal-only arguments, search the upstream window crate for `get_scalar_value_from_args` inside `partition_evaluator()` methods. For example, you should expect to find `ntile` (n) and `lead`/`lag` (offset, default_value) among the results. #### Technique 2: Check the `Signature` for data type constraints Each function defines a `Signature::coercible(...)` that specifies what data types each argument accepts, using `Coercion` entries. This tells you the expected **data type** even if it doesn't enforce literal-only. Example from `repeat.rs`: ```rust signature: Signature::coercible( vec![ Coercion::new_exact(TypeSignatureClass::Native(logical_string())), Coercion::new_implicit( TypeSignatureClass::Native(logical_int64()), vec![TypeSignatureClass::Integer], NativeType::Int64, ), ], Volatility::Immutable, ), ``` This tells you arg 2 (`n`) must be an integer type coerced to Int64. Use this to choose the correct Python type (e.g., `int` not `str` or `float`). Common mappings: | Rust Type Constraint | Python Type | |---------------------|-------------| | `logical_int64()` / `TypeSignatureClass::Integer` | `int` | | `logical_float64()` / `TypeSignatureClass::Numeric` | `int \| float` | | `logical_string()` / `TypeSignatureClass::String` | `str` | | `LogicalType::Boolean` | `bool` | **Important:** In Python's type system (PEP 484), `float` already accepts `int` values, so `int | float` is redundant and will fail the `ruff` linter (rule PYI041). Use `float` alone when the Rust side accepts a float/numeric type — Python users can still pass integer literals like `log(10, col("a"))` or `power(col("a"), 3)` without issue. Only use `int` when the Rust side strictly requires an integer (e.g., `logical_int64()`). #### Technique 3: Check `return_field_from_args()` for `scalar_arguments` usage Functions that inspect literal values at query planning time use `args.scalar_arguments.get(n)` in their `return_field_from_args()` method. This indicates the argument is **expected to be a literal** for optimal behavior (e.g., to determine output type precision), but may still work as a column. Example from `round.rs`: ```rust let decimal_places: Option = match args.scalar_arguments.get(1) { None => Some(0), Some(None) => None, // argument is not a literal (column) Some(Some(scalar)) if scalar.is_null() => Some(0), Some(Some(scalar)) => Some(decimal_places_from_scalar(scalar)?), }; ``` **If you find this pattern:** The argument is **Category A** — accept native types AND `Expr`. It works as a column but is primarily used as a literal. #### Decision flow ``` What kind of function is this? Scalar UDF: Is argument rejected at runtime if not a literal? (check invoke_with_args for ColumnarValue::Scalar-only match + exec_err!) → YES: Category B — accept only native type, no Expr → NO: continue below Aggregate: Is argument rejected at planning time if not a literal? (check accumulator() for get_scalar_value / validate_percentile_expr / downcast_ref::() + error) → YES: Category B — accept only native type, no Expr → NO: continue below Window: Is argument rejected at planning time if not a literal? (check partition_evaluator() for get_scalar_value_from_args / downcast_ref::() + error) → YES: Category B — accept only native type, no Expr → NO: continue below Does the Signature constrain it to a specific data type? → YES: Category A — accept Expr | → NO: Leave as Expr only ``` ## Coercion Categories When making a function more pythonic, apply the correct coercion pattern based on **what the argument represents**: ### Category A: Arguments That Should Accept Native Types AND Expr These are arguments that are *typically* literals but *could* be column references in advanced use cases. For these, accept a union type and coerce native types to `Expr.literal()`. **Type hint pattern:** `Expr | int`, `Expr | str`, `Expr | int | str`, etc. **When to use:** When the argument could plausibly come from a column in some use case (e.g., the repeat count might come from a column in a data-driven scenario). ```python def repeat(string: Expr, n: Expr | int) -> Expr: """Repeats the ``string`` to ``n`` times. Examples: >>> ctx = dfn.SessionContext() >>> df = ctx.from_pydict({"a": ["ha"]}) >>> result = df.select( ... dfn.functions.repeat(dfn.col("a"), 3).alias("r")) >>> result.collect_column("r")[0].as_py() 'hahaha' """ if not isinstance(n, Expr): n = Expr.literal(n) return Expr(f.repeat(string.expr, n.expr)) ``` ### Category B: Arguments That Should ONLY Accept Specific Native Types These are arguments where an `Expr` never makes sense because the value must be a fixed literal known at query-planning time (not a per-row value). For these, accept only the native type(s) and wrap internally. **Type hint pattern:** `str`, `int`, `list[str]`, etc. (no `Expr` in the union) **When to use:** When the argument is from a fixed enumeration or is always a compile-time constant, **AND** the parameter was not previously typed as `Expr`: - Separator in `concat_ws` (already typed as `str` in the Rust binding) - Index in `array_position` (already typed as `int` in the Rust binding) - Values that the Rust implementation already accepts as native types **Backward compatibility rule:** If a parameter was previously typed as `Expr`, you **must** keep `Expr` in the union even if the Rust side requires a literal. Removing `Expr` would break existing user code like `date_part(lit("year"), col("a"))`. Use **Category A** instead — accept `Expr | str` — and let users who pass column expressions discover the runtime error from the Rust side. Never silently break backward compatibility. ```python def concat_ws(separator: str, *args: Expr) -> Expr: """Concatenates the list ``args`` with the separator. ``separator`` is already typed as ``str`` in the Rust binding, so there is no backward-compatibility concern. Examples: >>> ctx = dfn.SessionContext() >>> df = ctx.from_pydict({"a": ["hello"], "b": ["world"]}) >>> result = df.select( ... dfn.functions.concat_ws("-", dfn.col("a"), dfn.col("b")).alias("c")) >>> result.collect_column("c")[0].as_py() 'hello-world' """ args = [arg.expr for arg in args] return Expr(f.concat_ws(separator, args)) ``` ### Category C: Arguments That Should Accept str as Column Name In some contexts a string argument naturally refers to a column name rather than a literal. This is the pattern used by DataFrame methods. **Type hint pattern:** `Expr | str` **When to use:** Only when the string contextually means a column name (rare in `functions.py`, more common in DataFrame methods). ```python # Use _to_raw_expr() from expr.py for this pattern from datafusion.expr import _to_raw_expr def some_function(column: Expr | str) -> Expr: raw = _to_raw_expr(column) # str -> col(str) return Expr(f.some_function(raw)) ``` **IMPORTANT:** In `functions.py`, string arguments almost never mean column names. Functions operate on expressions, and column references should use `col()`. Category C applies mainly to DataFrame methods and context APIs, not to scalar/aggregate/window functions. Do NOT convert string arguments to column expressions in `functions.py` unless there is a very clear reason to do so. ## Implementation Steps For each function being updated: ### Step 1: Analyze the Function 1. Read the current Python function signature in `python/datafusion/functions/__init__.py` 2. Read the Rust binding in `crates/core/src/functions.rs` 3. Optionally check the upstream DataFusion docs for the function 4. Determine which category (A, B, or C) applies to each parameter ### Step 2: Update the Python Function 1. **Change the type hints** to accept native types (e.g., `Expr` -> `Expr | int`) 2. **Add coercion logic** at the top of the function body 3. **Update the docstring** examples to use the simpler calling convention 4. **Preserve backward compatibility** — existing code using `Expr` must still work ### Step 3: Update Alias Type Hints After updating a primary function, find all alias functions that delegate to it (e.g., `instr` and `position` delegate to `strpos`). Update each alias's **parameter type hints** to match the primary function's new signature. Do not add coercion logic to aliases — the primary function handles that. ### Step 4: Update Docstring Examples (primary functions only) Per the project's CLAUDE.md rules: - Every function must have doctest-style examples - Optional parameters need examples both without and with the optional args, using keyword argument syntax - Reuse the same input data across examples where possible **Update examples to demonstrate the pythonic calling convention:** ```python # BEFORE (old style - still works but verbose) dfn.functions.left(dfn.col("a"), dfn.lit(3)) # AFTER (new style - shown in examples) dfn.functions.left(dfn.col("a"), 3) ``` ### Step 5: Run Tests After making changes, run the doctests to verify: ```bash python -m pytest --doctest-modules python/datafusion/functions/__init__.py -v ``` ## Coercion Helper Pattern Use the coercion helpers from `datafusion.expr` to convert native Python values to `Expr`. These are the complement of `ensure_expr()` — where `ensure_expr` *rejects* non-`Expr` values, the coercion helpers *wrap* them via `Expr.literal()`. **For required parameters** use `coerce_to_expr`: ```python from datafusion.expr import coerce_to_expr def left(string: Expr, n: Expr | int) -> Expr: n = coerce_to_expr(n) return Expr(f.left(string.expr, n.expr)) ``` **For optional nullable parameters** use `coerce_to_expr_or_none`: ```python from datafusion.expr import coerce_to_expr, coerce_to_expr_or_none def regexp_count( string: Expr, pattern: Expr | str, start: Expr | int | None = None, flags: Expr | str | None = None, ) -> Expr: pattern = coerce_to_expr(pattern) start = coerce_to_expr_or_none(start) flags = coerce_to_expr_or_none(flags) return Expr( f.regexp_count( string.expr, pattern.expr, start.expr if start is not None else None, flags.expr if flags is not None else None, ) ) ``` Both helpers are defined in `python/datafusion/expr.py` alongside `ensure_expr`. Import them in `functions.py` via: ```python from datafusion.expr import coerce_to_expr, coerce_to_expr_or_none ``` ## What NOT to Change - **Do not change arguments that represent data columns.** If an argument is the primary data being operated on (e.g., the `string` in `left(string, n)` or the `array` in `array_sort(array)`), it should remain `Expr` only. Users should use `col()` for column references. - **Do not change variadic `*args: Expr` parameters.** These represent multiple expressions and should stay as `Expr`. - **Do not change arguments where the coercion is ambiguous.** If it is unclear whether a string should be a column name or a literal, leave it as `Expr` and let the user be explicit. - **Do not add coercion logic to simple aliases.** If a function is just `return other_function(...)`, the primary function handles coercion. However, you **must update the alias's type hints** to match the primary function's signature so that type checkers and documentation accurately reflect what the alias accepts. - **Do not change the Rust bindings.** All coercion happens in the Python layer. The Rust functions continue to accept `PyExpr`. ## Priority Order When auditing functions, process them in this order: 1. **Date/time functions** — `date_part`, `date_trunc`, `date_bin` — these have the clearest literal arguments 2. **String functions** — `left`, `right`, `repeat`, `lpad`, `rpad`, `split_part`, `substring`, `replace`, `regexp_replace`, `regexp_match`, `regexp_count` — common and verbose without coercion 3. **Math functions** — `round`, `trunc`, `power` — numeric literal arguments 4. **Array functions** — `array_slice`, `array_position`, `array_remove_n`, `array_replace_n`, `array_resize`, `array_element` — index and count arguments 5. **Other functions** — any remaining functions with literal arguments ## Output Format For each function analyzed, report: ``` ## [Function Name] **Current signature:** `function(arg1: Expr, arg2: Expr) -> Expr` **Proposed signature:** `function(arg1: Expr, arg2: Expr | int) -> Expr` **Category:** A (accepts native + Expr) **Arguments changed:** - `arg2`: Expr -> Expr | int (always a literal count) **Rust binding:** Takes PyExpr, wraps to literal internally **Status:** [Changed / Skipped / Needs Discussion] ``` If asked to implement (not just audit), make the changes directly and show a summary of what was updated.