generated: '2026-08-19' method: probed source: >- Live probes on 2026-08-19 of s-space.snu.ac.kr/oai/*, kossda.snu.ac.kr/oai/*, s-space.snu.ac.kr/open-search/*, and the eduGAIN aggregate metadata at https://mds.edugain.org/edugain-v2.xml (10,566 entities; one carries the snu.ac.kr scope). Scored against the Kin Score `education` regime standards[]. REWARD-ONLY — every `conforms: true` below points at a specific artifact or response captured in this repository. Standards SNU does not implement are recorded as false with the negative probe that established it, so the absence is evidence, not silence. regime: education regime_id: education standards: - id: oai-pmh conforms: true evidence: >- Two independent OAI-PMH 2.0 data providers on SNU's own hosts. S-Space: https://s-space.snu.ac.kr/oai/request?verb=Identify returns protocolVersion 2.0, repositoryName "SNU Open Repository and Archive", repositoryIdentifier s-space.snu.ac.kr, adminEmail s-space@snu.ac.kr, earliestDatestamp 2008-07-31T15:00:00Z, granularity YYYY-MM-DDThh:mm:ssZ, twelve metadata formats (oai_dc, qdc, mods, mets, marc, rdf, didl, ore, uketd_dc, xoai, dim, etdms) and over 100 sets, across three contexts (/oai/request, /oai/driver, /oai/openaire). KOSSDA: https://kossda.snu.ac.kr/oai/request?verb=Identify returns repositoryName "한국사회과학자료원 (KOSSDA)", adminEmail kossda@snu.ac.kr, earliestDatestamp 2017-04-09T11:10:50Z, same twelve formats. Captured responses: examples/snu-s-space-oai-identify-example.xml, examples/snu-s-space-oai-listmetadataformats-example.xml, examples/snu-kossda-oai-identify-example.xml. artifacts: - openapi/snu-s-space-oai-pmh-openapi.yml - openapi/snu-kossda-oai-pmh-openapi.yml - id: saml conforms: true evidence: >- SNU operates a SAML 2.0 Identity Provider, entityID https://kafegw.snu.ac.kr/idp/simplesamlphp, published in the eduGAIN interfederation aggregate. IDPSSODescriptor declares protocolSupportEnumeration urn:oasis:names:tc:SAML:2.0:protocol with SingleSignOnService and SingleLogoutService over HTTP-Redirect and HTTP-POST bindings, transient NameID format, and separate signing and encryption X.509 keys issued to CN=kafegw.snu.ac.kr, O=SNU, OU=Information Systems and Technology (valid to 2028-06-03). Host kafegw.snu.ac.kr resolves to 147.46.10.201, SNU's own block, and answers 200. Artifact: authentication/snu-kafe-saml-idp-metadata.xml. artifacts: - authentication/snu-kafe-saml-idp-metadata.xml - id: shibboleth conforms: true evidence: >- The IdP's metadata carries the Shibboleth metadata extension urn:mace:shibboleth:metadata:1.0 with snu.ac.kr, the scoped-affiliation assertion the Shibboleth ecosystem relies on. Recorded honestly: the implementation is SimpleSAMLphp, not the Shibboleth IdP software — the conformance is to the Shibboleth metadata profile, not to the product. artifacts: - authentication/snu-kafe-saml-idp-metadata.xml - id: opensearch conforms: true evidence: >- https://s-space.snu.ac.kr/open-search/description.xml returns application/opensearchdescription+xml with an OpenSearch 1.1 OpenSearchDescription (LongName "SNU Open Repository and Archive"); /open-search/ answers in Atom and RSS 2.0 with opensearch: namespace annotations. Conditional: reachable only after replaying the site's js-challenge cookie — see coverage. Not an `education` regime standard; recorded because it is a real machine-readable contract. artifacts: - openapi/snu-s-space-opensearch-openapi.yml - id: scim conforms: false evidence: >- No SCIM 2.0 service provider found. https://api.snu.ac.kr/ answers 403 at the root and 404 on /v1, /api, /scim-adjacent paths; no /ServiceProviderConfig anywhere on snu.ac.kr surfaces probed. - id: lti conforms: false evidence: >- SNU's LMS is eTL (https://etl.snu.ac.kr, CNAME to Naver Cloud Platform gov LB). It is not Moodle and not Canvas — zero "moodle" strings in the served HTML, and /mod/lti/auth.php, /mod/lti/token.php, /mod/lti/certs.php and /.well-known/lti-configuration all return 404. No LTI 1.3 platform or tool registration is publicly discoverable. - id: oneroster conforms: false evidence: No IMS OneRoster endpoint found on any snu.ac.kr host probed. - id: ed-fi conforms: false evidence: Ed-Fi is a US K-12 data standard; not applicable to a Korean university and not found. - id: caliper conforms: false evidence: No IMS Caliper Analytics event store or sensor endpoint found on etl.snu.ac.kr or elsewhere. - id: qti conforms: false evidence: No QTI assessment interchange surface found. - id: orcid conforms: false evidence: >- Negative probe against real data, not a guess: a full ListRecords page of oai_dc records from S-Space (228 KB, harvested 2026-08-19) contains zero occurrences of "orcid". Creator fields carry names only. No ORCID member API integration is publicly visible. - id: datacite conforms: false evidence: >- https://api.datacite.org/providers?query=Seoul%20National%20University returns {"data":[],"meta":{"total":0}} — SNU is not a DataCite provider or client. S-Space identifiers are Handle System handles under prefix 10371 (https://hdl.handle.net/10371/702); KOSSDA uses prefix 20.500.12236. Handles, not DOIs. - id: crossref conforms: false evidence: >- Same ListRecords sample contains zero occurrences of "doi.org". No Crossref deposit surface or DOI minting is visible from the repository metadata. notes: >- The two conformances that matter here are the two nobody had catalogued: an OAI-PMH data provider SNU actually runs (two of them), and a SAML identity provider that is registered in eduGAIN and therefore machine-readable by definition. Neither is a vendor contract wearing SNU's name — the OAI endpoints answer from SNU's own address block with SNU's own admin contacts, and the IdP's certificates are issued to SNU's own Information Systems and Technology office.