{ "schema_version": "2.0.0", "summary": { "release": { "id": "deepseek-web-citation-audit-research-release-v2", "version": "2.0.0", "release_date": "2026-08-06", "language": "en-US", "status": "publication_ready_from_confirmed_current_results" }, "benchmark": { "id": "deepseek-web-citation-audit-v1", "version": "1.0.0", "frozen_design_date": "2026-07-26", "run_started_at": "2026-07-26T18:27:38.577Z", "run_completed_at": "2026-07-26T18:41:21.900Z", "surface": "DeepSeek consumer web chat", "visible_model_or_mode": "Instant", "search_state": "on", "deepthink_state": "off", "experimental_design": "Six fresh chats, four questions per chat, first completed response only." }, "result": { "overall": "FAIL", "final_macro_numeric_score": 61.3899, "questions_passed": { "numerator": 4, "denominator": 24, "percent": 16.6667 }, "batches_passed": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 6, "percent": 0 }, "weighted_factual_accuracy": { "numerator": 115.5, "denominator": 132, "percent": 87.5 }, "citation_url_validity": { "numerator": 76, "denominator": 96, "percent": 79.1667 }, "citation_support_precision": { "numerator": 118, "denominator": 169, "percent": 69.8225 }, "weighted_citation_completeness": { "numerator": 75, "denominator": 132, "percent": 56.8182 }, "weighted_authority_coverage": { "numerator": 67.5, "denominator": 132, "percent": 51.1364 }, "citation_placement_precision": { "numerator": 70, "denominator": 96, "percent": 72.9167 }, "preferred_source_hit_rate": { "numerator": 12, "denominator": 24, "percent": 50 }, "fabricated_url_count": 0, "invalid_or_unverifiable_citation_occurrences": 20, "citation_validity_labels": { "valid": 57, "valid_manual": 19, "invalid": 8, "unverifiable": 12 }, "unique_preserved_urls": 50 }, "protocol_deviation": [ { "batch_id": "B02", "event": "An identical prompt was accidentally submitted after an apparently empty snapshot.", "containment": "Only the untouched first completed response was frozen and scored. The duplicate remained excluded and did not contaminate any scored answer.", "contamination": false } ], "interpretation_guardrails": [ "This is one dated test of the signed-in DeepSeek consumer web chat with Search on, DeepThink off, and the visible mode labeled Instant.", "The result does not establish behavior for the DeepSeek API, open-weight models, other hosts, accounts, regions, or future versions.", "No fabricated URL was identified. Invalid and unverifiable citation occurrences are reported as separate states and are not automatically labeled fabricated.", "B01-B03 use source-specific claim-edge review. B04-B06 expand atomic edges while preserving the primary occurrence-level support labels; no source was upgraded." ], "canonical_sources": [ { "path": "../final-edge-reconciliation.json", "sha256": "cc7ae5e1e08b70ee42db2a8b5bebb30beb04d6a50fe3f4e2489f3cd80292f97c" }, { "path": "../citation-url-audit.json", "sha256": "3d956d5b905f8f67d40b30f8c431c53a190e8c80b26f64b547a64506e4accf61" }, { "path": "../primary-score.json", "sha256": "3a3577aabbe345017da210e523bf086362899d3ce53df44e1112ed9424ce2f99" }, { "path": "../live/run-metadata.json", "sha256": "3c4746555c139f9e4229d71258dca609f379a9eff86ab133560ecfc5dbd8cc1f" }, { "path": "../question-pack.json", "sha256": "16955c83a00f01a93a2a11647f2f640f5bbb8cf4c53dfb8dd9d7fb5cc2c8cd0e" }, { "path": "../gold-standard.json", "sha256": "a696ef4ecabc2215eb13ecb2fc7ea96a7f857615e2f1ace3a8df893a8e0d4d8b" }, { "path": "../scoring-rubric.json", "sha256": "aaa6e629d390ab822dee4719135ba3c12e7732bb7ef0efd767c5077c00e53a2a" } ] }, "questions": [ { "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "topic": "Health guidance", "category": "public_health", "prompt": "According to current CDC guidance for adults, what minimum weekly aerobic activity can be met with moderate activity, vigorous activity, or an equivalent combination? How many days of muscle-strengthening activity are recommended, and may the weekly activity be split into smaller chunks?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 3, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 80, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 5, "citation_url_validity_percent": 83.3333, "citation_claim_edges": 6, "citation_support_numerator": 4.5, "citation_support_denominator": 6, "citation_support_percent": 75, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 60, "authority_coverage_numerator": 2.25, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 45, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 5, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 83.3333, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 62, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "The activity totals and smaller-chunk advice were right, but a required strength qualifier was missing and one citation was unverifiable." }, { "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "topic": "Health guidance", "category": "food_safety", "prompt": "What daily caffeine amount does the FDA cite as not generally associated with negative effects for most adults, about how many 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee does that represent, and what two cautions does the FDA give about individual sensitivity and pregnancy or related conditions?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 3, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 60, "citation_occurrences": 7, "valid_citation_occurrences": 7, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 9, "citation_support_numerator": 5, "citation_support_denominator": 9, "citation_support_percent": 55.5556, "citation_completeness_numerator": 2, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 40, "authority_coverage_numerator": 1.5, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 30, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 6, "citation_placement_denominator": 7, "citation_placement_percent": 85.7143, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 38.6825, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_material_contradiction_of_a_required_claim" ], "key_finding": "The 400 mg framing was preserved, but the cup conversion and caution population were materially incomplete." }, { "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "topic": "Health guidance", "category": "nutrition", "prompt": "In the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements vitamin D guidance, what is the recommended daily amount for adults ages 19-70 and for adults age 71 or older? Give both micrograms and International Units, and state the listed amount for pregnant or breastfeeding teens and women.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 3, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 3, "valid_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 5, "citation_support_numerator": 4, "citation_support_denominator": 5, "citation_support_percent": 80, "citation_completeness_numerator": 5, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 5, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 3, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 96.3333, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "citation_support_precision_at_least_90" ], "key_finding": "All NIH intake values were accurate and complete; one redundant Mayo citation only partially entailed the combined age-band claim." }, { "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "topic": "Health guidance", "category": "sleep_health", "prompt": "What daily sleep duration does CDC list for adults ages 18-60, ages 61-64, and age 65 or older?", "expected_answer_length": "1-3 sentences", "required_claim_count": 3, "required_claim_weight": 3, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 3, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 3, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 2, "valid_citation_occurrences": 1, "citation_url_validity_percent": 50, "citation_claim_edges": 6, "citation_support_numerator": 3, "citation_support_denominator": 6, "citation_support_percent": 50, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 3, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0.75, "authority_coverage_denominator": 3, "authority_coverage_percent": 25, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 1, "citation_placement_denominator": 2, "citation_placement_percent": 50, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 73, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "The three sleep bands were correct, but one of two citations was unverifiable and the surviving source was a general secondary explainer." }, { "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "topic": "Earth, space, and climate science", "category": "space_science", "prompt": "When did NASA launch Voyager 1, which two planets were its primary flyby targets, and when did it enter interstellar space? Include the mission distinction NASA assigns to it.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 3, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 60, "citation_occurrences": 5, "valid_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_url_validity_percent": 80, "citation_claim_edges": 10, "citation_support_numerator": 6.5, "citation_support_denominator": 10, "citation_support_percent": 65, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 60, "authority_coverage_numerator": 3, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 60, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_placement_denominator": 5, "citation_placement_percent": 80, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 54, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "Launch, targets, and August 2012 were right, but the answer replaced the required NASA distinction with a phase name." }, { "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "topic": "Earth, space, and climate science", "category": "earth_science", "prompt": "According to the U.S. Geological Survey's global water estimate, what percentage of Earth's total water is in the oceans, and how is freshwater divided between ice and glaciers and groundwater? Also state approximately what fraction of all Earth's water is in fresh rivers and lakes.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 3, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 60, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_url_validity_percent": 50, "citation_claim_edges": 10, "citation_support_numerator": 4, "citation_support_denominator": 10, "citation_support_percent": 40, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 60, "authority_coverage_numerator": 3, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 60, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 50, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 44, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations", "zero_material_contradiction_of_a_required_claim" ], "key_finding": "The large reservoirs were accurate; the tiny rivers-and-lakes fraction was materially misstated and half the citation occurrences were broken." }, { "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "topic": "Earth, space, and climate science", "category": "atmospheric_science", "prompt": "What is ozone made of, what harmful radiation does the stratospheric ozone layer absorb, and what kinds of human-made chemicals drive depletion? Under continued current policies, around which years is recovery to 1980 values projected for most of the world, the Arctic, and the Antarctic?", "expected_answer_length": "3-5 sentences", "required_claim_count": 6, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 75, "citation_occurrences": 5, "valid_citation_occurrences": 5, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 5, "citation_support_numerator": 4, "citation_support_denominator": 5, "citation_support_percent": 80, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 50, "authority_coverage_numerator": 3, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 50, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_placement_denominator": 5, "citation_placement_percent": 80, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 53, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_material_contradiction_of_a_required_claim" ], "key_finding": "Ozone composition and depletion chemistry were good, but the regional recovery timetable did not match the frozen benchmark." }, { "question_id": "Q08", "batch_id": "B02", "topic": "Earth, space, and climate science", "category": "climate_science", "prompt": "What did the IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report conclude about the human cause of recent global warming, and how much warmer was the 2011-2020 global surface temperature than 1850-1900? Give the report's separate best estimates for warming over land and over the ocean.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 80, "citation_occurrences": 0, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": null, "citation_claim_edges": 0, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 0, "citation_support_percent": null, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 0, "citation_placement_percent": null, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 21, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "Most temperature values were right, but the central attribution wording was weakened and the answer contained no live citation at all." }, { "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "topic": "Public data and economics", "category": "demography", "prompt": "What U.S. resident population did the 2020 Census report as of April 1, 2020, and what was the percentage increase from 2010? Explain whether overseas military and federal civilian employees were part of that resident count or were added separately for congressional apportionment.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 7, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 7, "factual_accuracy_percent": 85.7143, "citation_occurrences": 3, "valid_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 6, "citation_support_numerator": 6, "citation_support_denominator": 6, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 5, "citation_completeness_denominator": 7, "citation_completeness_percent": 71.4286, "authority_coverage_numerator": 5, "authority_coverage_denominator": 7, "authority_coverage_percent": 71.4286, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 3, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 78.3333, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "The resident count, date, scope, and growth were correct; overseas home-state allocation was incomplete." }, { "question_id": "Q10", "batch_id": "B03", "topic": "Public data and economics", "category": "price_statistics", "prompt": "How does the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics define the Consumer Price Index, what are its eight major expenditure groups, and are sales and excise taxes tied directly to specific goods and services included?", "expected_answer_length": "2-5 sentences", "required_claim_count": 3, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 3, "valid_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 3, "citation_support_numerator": 3, "citation_support_denominator": 3, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 6, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 3, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 100, "result": "PASS", "failed_hard_gates": [], "key_finding": "The CPI basket, substitution distinction, and non-cost-of-living qualifier all matched the BLS benchmark with official citations." }, { "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "topic": "Public data and economics", "category": "monetary_policy", "prompt": "In the Federal Reserve's longer-run framework current after its 2025 review, what inflation rate does the FOMC judge consistent with its mandate, over what horizon, and which price index measures that rate?", "expected_answer_length": "1-3 sentences", "required_claim_count": 3, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 4, "valid_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 6, "citation_support_numerator": 6, "citation_support_denominator": 6, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 5, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 5, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_placement_denominator": 4, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 100, "result": "PASS", "failed_hard_gates": [], "key_finding": "The longer-run 2% PCE framing and measure distinction were accurate, complete, and supported by Federal Reserve sources." }, { "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "topic": "Public data and economics", "category": "tax_guidance", "prompt": "For calendar year 2024, what optional IRS standard mileage rates applied to business use, charitable service, and medical or qualifying military moving use? Include who could use the moving-expense rate during the statutory suspension.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 80, "citation_occurrences": 4, "valid_citation_occurrences": 2, "citation_url_validity_percent": 50, "citation_claim_edges": 8, "citation_support_numerator": 3, "citation_support_denominator": 8, "citation_support_percent": 37.5, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 60, "authority_coverage_numerator": 3, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 60, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 1, "citation_placement_denominator": 4, "citation_placement_percent": 25, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 51.5, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "All three mileage rates were right, but two KPMG links were dead and the military PCS qualifier was incomplete." }, { "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "topic": "Law, regulation, and security policy", "category": "copyright_law", "prompt": "What four factors does Section 107 require courts to consider when evaluating fair use, and does U.S. law provide a fixed safe number of words or percentage of a work that may be used without permission?", "expected_answer_length": "3-5 sentences", "required_claim_count": 5, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 4, "valid_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 13, "citation_support_numerator": 13, "citation_support_denominator": 13, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 6, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_placement_denominator": 4, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 97, "result": "PASS", "failed_hard_gates": [], "key_finding": "All four statutory fair-use factors and the case-by-case rule were accurate and supported; only the requested sentence range was missed." }, { "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "topic": "Law, regulation, and security policy", "category": "commercial_email_law", "prompt": "Does the CAN-SPAM Act exempt business-to-business commercial email? Summarize the FTC's requirements for headers and subject lines, ad identification, a physical postal address, opt-out access, and the deadlines for keeping the mechanism available and honoring a request.", "expected_answer_length": "3-6 sentences", "required_claim_count": 6, "required_claim_weight": 8, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 7.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 8, "factual_accuracy_percent": 93.75, "citation_occurrences": 7, "valid_citation_occurrences": 7, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 11, "citation_support_numerator": 11, "citation_support_denominator": 11, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 7, "citation_completeness_denominator": 8, "citation_completeness_percent": 87.5, "authority_coverage_numerator": 7, "authority_coverage_denominator": 8, "authority_coverage_percent": 87.5, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 7, "citation_placement_denominator": 7, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 85, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "citation_completeness_equals_100" ], "key_finding": "CAN-SPAM duties and timing were largely correct, but the ad-identification exception was omitted." }, { "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "topic": "Law, regulation, and security policy", "category": "digital_identity", "prompt": "Under final NIST SP 800-63B-4, what minimum password length is required for single-factor use, what shorter minimum may be allowed when a password is used only as part of multi-factor authentication, and what does NIST require about composition rules and blocklist checks?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 5.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 91.6667, "citation_occurrences": 4, "valid_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 6, "citation_support_numerator": 2.5, "citation_support_denominator": 6, "citation_support_percent": 41.6667, "citation_completeness_numerator": 3, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 50, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0.75, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 12.5, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 4, "citation_placement_percent": 75, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 47.3333, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "Several password rules were directionally right, but citation support was weak and the named final-revision requirement was not met cleanly." }, { "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "topic": "Law, regulation, and security policy", "category": "data_protection_law", "prompt": "Under GDPR Article 17, give two grounds that can trigger erasure and list all five paragraph 3 categories in which the right does not apply to the extent processing is necessary.", "expected_answer_length": "3-6 sentences", "required_claim_count": 7, "required_claim_weight": 7, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 7, "factual_accuracy_percent": 92.8571, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 6, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 21, "citation_support_numerator": 18.5, "citation_support_denominator": 21, "citation_support_percent": 88.0952, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 7, "citation_completeness_percent": 85.7143, "authority_coverage_numerator": 6, "authority_coverage_denominator": 7, "authority_coverage_percent": 85.7143, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 6, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 78.2857, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100" ], "key_finding": "The two grounds and exception categories were mostly accurate, but one legally material necessity limit and the sentence range were missed." }, { "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "topic": "Web and software standards", "category": "web_accessibility", "prompt": "For WCAG 2.2 Success Criterion 1.4.3 at Level AA, what minimum contrast ratio applies to normal text and to large-scale text? Name the two content categories besides large text that the criterion exempts from a contrast requirement.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 4, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 4, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 6, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 15, "citation_support_numerator": 15, "citation_support_denominator": 15, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 4, "citation_completeness_denominator": 4, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 4, "authority_coverage_denominator": 4, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 6, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 100, "result": "PASS", "failed_hard_gates": [], "key_finding": "Contrast ratios, large-text thresholds, and exemptions were accurate, fully cited, and anchored by W3C material." }, { "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "topic": "Web and software standards", "category": "http", "prompt": "What condition does HTTP status code 429 represent under RFC 6585, what should the response representation explain, and what optional header may tell a client how long to wait? Does the RFC define how the server identifies a user or counts requests?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 5, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 5, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 5, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": 0, "citation_claim_edges": 7, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 7, "citation_support_percent": 0, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 5, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 5, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 5, "citation_placement_percent": 0, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 38, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "The 429 semantics were accurate, but every Stack Overflow revision citation remained unverifiable, so none could earn support or completeness credit." }, { "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "topic": "Web and software standards", "category": "web_crawling", "prompt": "Under RFC 9309, where must a robots.txt file be located and how must it be encoded and served? Explain whether its rules are access authorization and what security risk can come from listing paths in it.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": 0, "citation_claim_edges": 8, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 8, "citation_support_percent": 0, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 0, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 38, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "The robots.txt statements matched RFC 9309, but all six preserved citation occurrences were either unverifiable or broken." }, { "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "topic": "Web and software standards", "category": "python", "prompt": "According to the official Python tutorial, how do lists and tuples differ in mutability and typical use? Can a tuple contain a mutable object, and what syntax creates a one-item tuple?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 4, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 3, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 4, "factual_accuracy_percent": 75, "citation_occurrences": 4, "valid_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 5, "citation_support_numerator": 5, "citation_support_denominator": 5, "citation_support_percent": 100, "citation_completeness_numerator": 2, "citation_completeness_denominator": 4, "citation_completeness_percent": 50, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0.25, "authority_coverage_denominator": 4, "authority_coverage_percent": 6.25, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 4, "citation_placement_denominator": 4, "citation_placement_percent": 100, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 64, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "Mutability and singleton syntax were right, but typical access patterns were incomplete and the supporting sources had low authority." }, { "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "topic": "History and world heritage", "category": "colonial_history", "prompt": "On what date was Jamestown established, under whose corporate and royal authority, and what distinction does the Library of Congress give it? Include the Library's caution about the land's earlier inhabitants.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 5, "citation_url_validity_percent": 83.3333, "citation_claim_edges": 9, "citation_support_numerator": 4, "citation_support_denominator": 9, "citation_support_percent": 44.4444, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 100, "authority_coverage_numerator": 6, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 100, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 50, "preferred_source_hit": true, "final_numeric_score": 84.8889, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "zero_fabricated_or_unresolvable_citations" ], "key_finding": "All Jamestown facts were accurate and an official LOC source covered them, but two decorative/weak placements and one unverifiable news citation reduced precision." }, { "question_id": "Q22", "batch_id": "B06", "topic": "History and world heritage", "category": "constitutional_history", "prompt": "When did Congress pass, the states ratify, and the Secretary of State certify the 19th Amendment? Which state supplied the decisive ratification, and why does the National Archives caution that ratification did not immediately enfranchise every woman?", "expected_answer_length": "3-5 sentences", "required_claim_count": 5, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 6, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 100, "citation_occurrences": 0, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": null, "citation_claim_edges": 0, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 0, "citation_support_percent": null, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 0, "citation_placement_percent": null, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 38, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "All five 19th Amendment facts matched the benchmark, yet the answer supplied zero citations." }, { "question_id": "Q23", "batch_id": "B06", "topic": "History and world heritage", "category": "world_heritage", "prompt": "When was the Great Barrier Reef inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List, under which four criteria, and approximately how large is the listed ecosystem? State the approximate counts of individual reefs and islands described by UNESCO.", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 5, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 4.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 75, "citation_occurrences": 0, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": null, "citation_claim_edges": 0, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 0, "citation_support_percent": null, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 0, "citation_placement_percent": null, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 9, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80", "zero_material_contradiction_of_a_required_claim" ], "key_finding": "Year, criteria, and area were right, but reef and island counts were wrong or over-precise and no citation was supplied." }, { "question_id": "Q24", "batch_id": "B06", "topic": "History and world heritage", "category": "conservation_history", "prompt": "When and by whose signature was Yellowstone National Park established, what global distinction does the National Park Service give it, and what did the founding law do with the land? Did the park predate the National Park Service itself?", "expected_answer_length": "2-4 sentences", "required_claim_count": 4, "required_claim_weight": 6, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 6, "factual_accuracy_percent": 83.3333, "citation_occurrences": 0, "valid_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_url_validity_percent": null, "citation_claim_edges": 0, "citation_support_numerator": 0, "citation_support_denominator": 0, "citation_support_percent": null, "citation_completeness_numerator": 0, "citation_completeness_denominator": 6, "citation_completeness_percent": 0, "authority_coverage_numerator": 0, "authority_coverage_denominator": 6, "authority_coverage_percent": 0, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 0, "citation_placement_denominator": 0, "citation_placement_percent": null, "preferred_source_hit": false, "final_numeric_score": 22, "result": "FAIL", "failed_hard_gates": [ "final_numeric_score_at_least_85", "factual_accuracy_at_least_90", "citation_url_validity_equals_100", "citation_support_precision_at_least_90", "citation_completeness_equals_100", "authority_coverage_at_least_80" ], "key_finding": "The law, land withdrawal, and 1916 comparison were right; the NPS attribution was weakened and the entire answer was uncited." } ], "batches": [ { "batch_id": "B01", "topic": "Health guidance", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 0, "macro_numeric_score": 67.504, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 15, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 18, "factual_accuracy_percent": 83.3333, "citation_occurrences": 18, "valid_citation_occurrences": 16, "citation_url_validity_percent": 88.8889, "citation_claim_edges": 26, "citation_support_numerator": 16.5, "citation_support_percent": 63.4615, "citation_completeness_numerator": 13, "citation_completeness_denominator": 18, "citation_completeness_percent": 72.2222, "authority_coverage_numerator": 9.5, "authority_coverage_denominator": 18, "authority_coverage_percent": 52.7778, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 15, "citation_placement_denominator": 18, "citation_placement_percent": 83.3333, "result": "FAIL" }, { "batch_id": "B02", "topic": "Earth, space, and climate science", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 0, "macro_numeric_score": 43, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 14.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 21, "factual_accuracy_percent": 69.0476, "citation_occurrences": 16, "valid_citation_occurrences": 12, "citation_url_validity_percent": 75, "citation_claim_edges": 25, "citation_support_numerator": 14.5, "citation_support_percent": 58, "citation_completeness_numerator": 9, "citation_completeness_denominator": 21, "citation_completeness_percent": 42.8571, "authority_coverage_numerator": 9, "authority_coverage_denominator": 21, "authority_coverage_percent": 42.8571, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 11, "citation_placement_denominator": 16, "citation_placement_percent": 68.75, "result": "FAIL" }, { "batch_id": "B03", "topic": "Public data and economics", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 2, "macro_numeric_score": 82.4583, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 21, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 23, "factual_accuracy_percent": 91.3043, "citation_occurrences": 14, "valid_citation_occurrences": 12, "citation_url_validity_percent": 85.7143, "citation_claim_edges": 23, "citation_support_numerator": 18, "citation_support_percent": 78.2609, "citation_completeness_numerator": 19, "citation_completeness_denominator": 23, "citation_completeness_percent": 82.6087, "authority_coverage_numerator": 19, "authority_coverage_denominator": 23, "authority_coverage_percent": 82.6087, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 11, "citation_placement_denominator": 14, "citation_placement_percent": 78.5714, "result": "FAIL" }, { "batch_id": "B04", "topic": "Law, regulation, and security policy", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 1, "macro_numeric_score": 76.9048, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 25.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 27, "factual_accuracy_percent": 94.4444, "citation_occurrences": 21, "valid_citation_occurrences": 21, "citation_url_validity_percent": 100, "citation_claim_edges": 51, "citation_support_numerator": 45, "citation_support_percent": 88.2353, "citation_completeness_numerator": 22, "citation_completeness_denominator": 27, "citation_completeness_percent": 81.4815, "authority_coverage_numerator": 19.75, "authority_coverage_denominator": 27, "authority_coverage_percent": 73.1481, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 20, "citation_placement_denominator": 21, "citation_placement_percent": 95.2381, "result": "FAIL" }, { "batch_id": "B05", "topic": "Web and software standards", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 1, "macro_numeric_score": 60, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 18, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 19, "factual_accuracy_percent": 94.7368, "citation_occurrences": 21, "valid_citation_occurrences": 10, "citation_url_validity_percent": 47.619, "citation_claim_edges": 35, "citation_support_numerator": 20, "citation_support_percent": 57.1429, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 19, "citation_completeness_percent": 31.5789, "authority_coverage_numerator": 4.25, "authority_coverage_denominator": 19, "authority_coverage_percent": 22.3684, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 10, "citation_placement_denominator": 21, "citation_placement_percent": 47.619, "result": "FAIL" }, { "batch_id": "B06", "topic": "History and world heritage", "question_count": 4, "questions_passed": 0, "macro_numeric_score": 38.4722, "factual_accuracy_numerator": 21.5, "factual_accuracy_denominator": 24, "factual_accuracy_percent": 89.5833, "citation_occurrences": 6, "valid_citation_occurrences": 5, "citation_url_validity_percent": 83.3333, "citation_claim_edges": 9, "citation_support_numerator": 4, "citation_support_percent": 44.4444, "citation_completeness_numerator": 6, "citation_completeness_denominator": 24, "citation_completeness_percent": 25, "authority_coverage_numerator": 6, "authority_coverage_denominator": 24, "authority_coverage_percent": 25, "well_placed_citation_occurrences": 3, "citation_placement_denominator": 6, "citation_placement_percent": 50, "result": "FAIL" } ], "citation_occurrences": [ { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT01", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-001", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "automated_final_host": "hipcuyahoga.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:55.041Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT02", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-002", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "automated_final_host": "www.hawaiipacifichealth.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.688Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT03", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-001", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "automated_final_host": "hipcuyahoga.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:55.041Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT04", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-002", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "automated_final_host": "www.hawaiipacifichealth.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.688Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT05", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-003", "displayed_label": "-\n5", "preserved_url": "https://www.emanatehealth.org/health-library/story/95082c33-0d56-4cfd-a179-15474d02777b", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.emanatehealth.org/health-library/story/95082c33-0d56-4cfd-a179-15474d02777b", "automated_final_host": "www.emanatehealth.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.011Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT06", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-001", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "automated_final_host": "hipcuyahoga.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:55.041Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT07", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 7, "url_id": "URL-004", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "automated_final_host": "www.health.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.709Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT08", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 8, "url_id": "URL-005", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "automated_final_host": "www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.122Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT09", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 9, "url_id": "URL-004", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "automated_final_host": "www.health.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.709Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT10", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 10, "url_id": "URL-005", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "automated_final_host": "www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.122Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT11", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 11, "url_id": "URL-006", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "automated_final_host": "www.mayoclinic.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.606Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT12", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 12, "url_id": "URL-006", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "automated_final_host": "www.mayoclinic.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.606Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT13", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_occurrence_number": 13, "url_id": "URL-005", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "automated_final_host": "www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.122Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT14", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_occurrence_number": 14, "url_id": "URL-007", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "automated_final_host": "ods.od.nih.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.137Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT15", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_occurrence_number": 15, "url_id": "URL-008", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/vitamin-d-deficiency/faq-20058397", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/vitamin-d-deficiency/faq-20058397", "automated_final_host": "www.mayoclinic.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:53.681Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT16", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_occurrence_number": 16, "url_id": "URL-007", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "automated_final_host": "ods.od.nih.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.137Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT17", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_occurrence_number": 17, "url_id": "URL-009", "displayed_label": "-\n4", "preserved_url": "https://www.dmuclinic.org/health-library/story/24a52a15-227d-448b-9364-fccb5fb925ec", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.dmuclinic.org/health-library/story/24a52a15-227d-448b-9364-fccb5fb925ec", "automated_final_host": "www.dmuclinic.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.229Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B01-CIT18", "batch_id": "B01", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_occurrence_number": 18, "url_id": "URL-010", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-many-hours-of-sleep-do-you-need-and-is-there-sweet-spot-us-still-fail-to-get", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-many-hours-of-sleep-do-you-need-and-is-there-sweet-spot-us-still-fail-to-get", "automated_final_host": "www.mindbodygreen.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:11:54.898Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT01", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-011", "displayed_label": "1", "preserved_url": "https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/webarchives/wayback/20110402101907/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_1", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 202, "automated_final_url": "https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/webarchives/wayback/20110402101907/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_1", "automated_final_host": "eresources.nlb.gov.sg", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.048Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT02", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-012", "displayed_label": "7", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "automated_final_host": "ssd.jpl.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.358Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT03", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-013", "displayed_label": "12", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "automated_final_host": "www.jpl.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.718Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT04", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-013", "displayed_label": "12", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "automated_final_host": "www.jpl.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.718Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT05", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-012", "displayed_label": "7", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "automated_final_host": "ssd.jpl.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.358Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT06", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-014", "displayed_label": "2", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "automated_final_host": "water.usgs.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.912Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT07", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 7, "url_id": "URL-015", "displayed_label": "10", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf", "automated_final_host": "ito.ocde.us", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.847Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT08", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 8, "url_id": "URL-014", "displayed_label": "2", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "automated_final_host": "water.usgs.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.912Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT09", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 9, "url_id": "URL-015", "displayed_label": "10", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf", "automated_final_host": "ito.ocde.us", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.847Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT10", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 10, "url_id": "URL-014", "displayed_label": "2", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "automated_final_host": "water.usgs.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.912Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT11", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_occurrence_number": 11, "url_id": "URL-015", "displayed_label": "10", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf", "automated_final_host": "ito.ocde.us", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.847Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT12", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_occurrence_number": 12, "url_id": "URL-016", "displayed_label": "9", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "science.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.074Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT13", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_occurrence_number": 13, "url_id": "URL-016", "displayed_label": "9", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "science.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.074Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT14", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_occurrence_number": 14, "url_id": "URL-016", "displayed_label": "9", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "science.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.074Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT15", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_occurrence_number": 15, "url_id": "URL-017", "displayed_label": "11", "preserved_url": "https://api.repository.cam.ac.uk/server/api/core/bitstreams/64468506-72a2-4589-b4e6-588a59d418a7/content#4#1", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://api.repository.cam.ac.uk/server/api/core/bitstreams/64468506-72a2-4589-b4e6-588a59d418a7/content#4#1", "automated_final_host": "api.repository.cam.ac.uk", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.944Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B02-CIT16", "batch_id": "B02", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_occurrence_number": 16, "url_id": "URL-016", "displayed_label": "9", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "science.nasa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.074Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT01", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-018", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/2020-census-apportionment-results.html?utm_id=28318&sfmc_id=711040", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/2020-census-apportionment-results.html?utm_id=28318&sfmc_id=711040", "automated_final_host": "www.census.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.389Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT02", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-019", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/decennial-census/decade/2020/planning-management/evaluate/eae/2020-operational-assessment-federally-affiliated-count-overseas.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/decennial-census/decade/2020/planning-management/evaluate/eae/2020-operational-assessment-federally-affiliated-count-overseas.html", "automated_final_host": "www.census.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.963Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT03", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-020", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-kits/2021/2020-census-apportionment-counts.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-kits/2021/2020-census-apportionment-counts.html", "automated_final_host": "www.census.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.955Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT04", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-021", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "automated_final_host": "www.bls.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.740Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT05", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-021", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "automated_final_host": "www.bls.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.740Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT06", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-021", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "automated_final_host": "www.bls.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.740Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT07", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_occurrence_number": 7, "url_id": "URL-022", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "automated_final_host": "www.federalreserve.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.821Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT08", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_occurrence_number": 8, "url_id": "URL-023", "displayed_label": "-\n12", "preserved_url": "http://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/09/the-federal-reserves-monetary-policy-framework-the-2025-review/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "http://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/09/the-federal-reserves-monetary-policy-framework-the-2025-review/", "automated_final_host": "bankingjournal.aba.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.139Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT09", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_occurrence_number": 9, "url_id": "URL-022", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "automated_final_host": "www.federalreserve.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.821Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT10", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_occurrence_number": 10, "url_id": "URL-024", "displayed_label": "-\n13", "preserved_url": "https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2026/jul/between-headline-core-inflation-excluding-energy-goods", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2026/jul/between-headline-core-inflation-excluding-energy-goods", "automated_final_host": "www.stlouisfed.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.157Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT11", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_occurrence_number": 11, "url_id": "URL-025", "displayed_label": "-\n15", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "assets.kpmg.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.091Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT12", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_occurrence_number": 12, "url_id": "URL-026", "displayed_label": "-\n8", "preserved_url": "https://apps.irs.gov/app/vita/lang/es/content/00/00_17_005.jsp?level=advanced", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://apps.irs.gov/app/vita/lang/es/content/00/00_17_005.jsp?level=advanced", "automated_final_host": "apps.irs.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.062Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT13", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_occurrence_number": 13, "url_id": "URL-025", "displayed_label": "-\n15", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "assets.kpmg.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.091Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B03-CIT14", "batch_id": "B03", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_occurrence_number": 14, "url_id": "URL-027", "displayed_label": "-\n14", "preserved_url": "https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/ARC24_PurpleBook_08_MiscRecs_61.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/ARC24_PurpleBook_08_MiscRecs_61.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.451Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT01", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-028", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "automated_final_host": "www.copyright.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.663Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 4, "canonical_support_points": 4, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT02", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-029", "displayed_label": "-\n5", "preserved_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "automated_final_host": "fedsoc.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.496Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 4, "canonical_support_points": 4, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT03", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-030", "displayed_label": "-\n8", "preserved_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "automated_final_host": "copyright.princeton.edu", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.887Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 4, "canonical_support_points": 4, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT04", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-028", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "automated_final_host": "www.copyright.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:03.663Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT05", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-031", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "automated_final_host": "www.ftc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.626Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT06", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-032", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "automated_final_host": "gdprlocal.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.979Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT07", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 7, "url_id": "URL-031", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "automated_final_host": "www.ftc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.626Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT08", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 8, "url_id": "URL-031", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "automated_final_host": "www.ftc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.626Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT09", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 9, "url_id": "URL-032", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "automated_final_host": "gdprlocal.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.979Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT10", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 10, "url_id": "URL-031", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "automated_final_host": "www.ftc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.626Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT11", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_occurrence_number": 11, "url_id": "URL-032", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "automated_final_host": "gdprlocal.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.979Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT12", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_occurrence_number": 12, "url_id": "URL-033", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "automated_final_host": "securityboulevard.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.014Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT13", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_occurrence_number": 13, "url_id": "URL-034", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "automated_final_host": "www.linkedin.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.663Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT14", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_occurrence_number": 14, "url_id": "URL-033", "displayed_label": "-\n3", "preserved_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "automated_final_host": "securityboulevard.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.014Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT15", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_occurrence_number": 15, "url_id": "URL-034", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "automated_final_host": "www.linkedin.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.663Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT16", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 16, "url_id": "URL-035", "displayed_label": "-\n4", "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "automated_final_host": "ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.252Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT17", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 17, "url_id": "URL-036", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "www.dataprotection.ie", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.145Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT18", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 18, "url_id": "URL-037", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "automated_final_host": "www.activemind.legal", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.902Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT19", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 19, "url_id": "URL-035", "displayed_label": "-\n4", "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "automated_final_host": "ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.252Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 5, "canonical_support_points": 5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT20", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 20, "url_id": "URL-036", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": null, "automated_final_url": null, "automated_final_host": "www.dataprotection.ie", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.145Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 5, "canonical_support_points": 5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B04-CIT21", "batch_id": "B04", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_occurrence_number": 21, "url_id": "URL-037", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "automated_final_host": "www.activemind.legal", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.902Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 5, "canonical_support_points": 2.5, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT01", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-038", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.marywood.edu/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.marywood.edu", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.083Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT02", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-039", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "automated_final_host": "w3c.github.io", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.398Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT03", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-040", "displayed_label": "-\n5", "preserved_url": "https://testparty.ai/blog/wcag-contrast-ratio-guide-2025", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://testparty.ai/blog/wcag-contrast-ratio-guide-2025", "automated_final_host": "testparty.ai", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.806Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 3, "canonical_support_points": 3, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT04", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-038", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.marywood.edu/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.marywood.edu", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.083Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT05", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-039", "displayed_label": "-\n9", "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "automated_final_host": "w3c.github.io", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.398Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT06", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-041", "displayed_label": "-\n12", "preserved_url": "https://apps.des.wa.gov/contracting/08213b.pdf#14#10", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://apps.des.wa.gov/contracting/08213b.pdf#14#10", "automated_final_host": "apps.des.wa.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:06.525Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT07", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_occurrence_number": 7, "url_id": "URL-042", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "automated_final_host": "stackoverflow.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.477Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT08", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_occurrence_number": 8, "url_id": "URL-043", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "automated_final_host": "stackoverflow.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.376Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT09", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_occurrence_number": 9, "url_id": "URL-042", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "automated_final_host": "stackoverflow.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.477Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT10", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_occurrence_number": 10, "url_id": "URL-043", "displayed_label": "-\n6", "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "automated_final_host": "stackoverflow.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.376Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT11", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_occurrence_number": 11, "url_id": "URL-042", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "automated_final_host": "stackoverflow.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.477Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT12", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 12, "url_id": "URL-044", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "automated_final_host": "dt-main.dev.ietf.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.523Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT13", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 13, "url_id": "URL-045", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.potaroo.net", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.419Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT14", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 14, "url_id": "URL-044", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "automated_final_host": "dt-main.dev.ietf.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.523Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT15", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 15, "url_id": "URL-045", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.potaroo.net", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.419Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT16", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 16, "url_id": "URL-044", "displayed_label": "-\n7", "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "automated_final_host": "dt-main.dev.ietf.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.523Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT17", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_occurrence_number": 17, "url_id": "URL-045", "displayed_label": "-\n10", "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 404, "automated_final_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "automated_final_host": "www.potaroo.net", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.419Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT18", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_occurrence_number": 18, "url_id": "URL-046", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "automated_final_host": "bugs.python.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.134Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT19", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_occurrence_number": 19, "url_id": "URL-046", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "automated_final_host": "bugs.python.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.134Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT20", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_occurrence_number": 20, "url_id": "URL-046", "displayed_label": "-\n11", "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "automated_final_host": "bugs.python.org", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:05.134Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B05-CIT21", "batch_id": "B05", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_occurrence_number": 21, "url_id": "URL-047", "displayed_label": "-\n8", "preserved_url": "https://codegym.cc/quests/lectures/en.codegym.python.core.lecture.level05.lecture09", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://codegym.cc/quests/lectures/en.codegym.python.core.lecture.level05.lecture09", "automated_final_host": "codegym.cc", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:06.422Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT01", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 1, "url_id": "URL-048", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "automated_final_host": "www.loc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.561Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 2, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT02", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 2, "url_id": "URL-049", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "automated_final_host": "www.loc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.888Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT03", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 3, "url_id": "URL-050", "displayed_label": "-\n13", "preserved_url": "https://www.politico.com/story/2012/05/jamestown-settlement-founded-076223", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.politico.com/story/2012/05/jamestown-settlement-founded-076223", "automated_final_host": "www.politico.com", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.808Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 2, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT04", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 4, "url_id": "URL-048", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "automated_final_host": "www.loc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.561Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT05", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 5, "url_id": "URL-049", "displayed_label": "-\n1", "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 200, "automated_final_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "automated_final_host": "www.loc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.888Z", "manual_verification_used": false, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 0, "placement_credit": false }, { "occurrence_id": "B06-CIT06", "batch_id": "B06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_occurrence_number": 6, "url_id": "URL-048", "displayed_label": "-\n2", "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "automated_final_status": 403, "automated_final_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "automated_final_host": "www.loc.gov", "automated_checked_at": "2026-07-26T19:12:04.561Z", "manual_verification_used": true, "canonical_edge_count": 1, "canonical_support_points": 1, "placement_credit": true } ], "citation_claim_edges": [ { "edge_id": "EDGE-0001", "citation_id": "B01-CIT01", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-001", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "response_claim": "The weekly aerobic minimum is 150 minutes moderate, 75 minutes vigorous, or an equivalent combination.", "gold_claim": "The weekly aerobic minimum is 150 minutes moderate, 75 minutes vigorous, or an equivalent combination.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "HIP-Cuyahoga directly states the 150-minute moderate, 75-minute vigorous, or equivalent weekly alternatives." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0002", "citation_id": "B01-CIT02", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-002", "preserved_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "response_claim": "The weekly aerobic minimum is 150 minutes moderate, 75 minutes vigorous, or an equivalent combination.", "gold_claim": "The weekly aerobic minimum is 150 minutes moderate, 75 minutes vigorous, or an equivalent combination.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Hawaii Pacific Health confirms the 150-minute weekly recommendation but does not fully preserve the displayed vigorous-or-equivalent alternative." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0003", "citation_id": "B01-CIT03", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-001", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "response_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activities are recommended on at least two days per week.", "gold_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activity is recommended on at least two days each week and should work all major muscle groups.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "HIP-Cuyahoga directly supports muscle-strengthening activity on at least two days per week; claim accuracy separately records the omitted all-major-groups qualifier." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0004", "citation_id": "B01-CIT04", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-002", "preserved_url": "https://www.hawaiipacifichealth.org/healthier-hawaii/health-and-well-being/youre-never-too-young-to-create-healthy-exercise-habits/", "response_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activities are recommended on at least two days per week.", "gold_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activity is recommended on at least two days each week and should work all major muscle groups.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Hawaii Pacific Health supports the displayed two-days-per-week strengthening recommendation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0005", "citation_id": "B01-CIT05", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-003", "preserved_url": "https://www.emanatehealth.org/health-library/story/95082c33-0d56-4cfd-a179-15474d02777b", "response_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activities are recommended on at least two days per week.", "gold_claim": "Muscle-strengthening activity is recommended on at least two days each week and should work all major muscle groups.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The page was unverifiable, so no entailment credit is inferred." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0006", "citation_id": "B01-CIT06", "question_id": "Q01", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q01-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q01-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-001", "preserved_url": "https://hipcuyahoga.org/active-living/", "response_claim": "The activity may be spread through the week and broken into smaller chunks.", "gold_claim": "The activity may be spread through the week and broken into smaller chunks.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "HIP-Cuyahoga supports spreading the weekly activity and using smaller chunks." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0007", "citation_id": "B01-CIT07", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-004", "preserved_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "response_claim": "For most adults, 400 mg per day is not generally associated with negative effects; it is not stated as a universal safe ceiling.", "gold_claim": "For most adults, 400 mg per day is not generally associated with negative effects; it is not stated as a universal safe ceiling.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Health.com reports the FDA's 400 mg framing for most adults without turning it into an individualized guarantee." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0008", "citation_id": "B01-CIT08", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-005", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "response_claim": "For most adults, 400 mg per day is not generally associated with negative effects; it is not stated as a universal safe ceiling.", "gold_claim": "For most adults, 400 mg per day is not generally associated with negative effects; it is not stated as a universal safe ceiling.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan directly supports the 400 mg most-adults framing." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0009", "citation_id": "B01-CIT09", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-004", "preserved_url": "https://www.health.com/coffee-and-blood-pressure-11886910?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=shareurlbuttons", "response_claim": "Four hundred milligrams represents about three to four 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "gold_claim": "The FDA equates that amount to about two to three 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Health.com supports roughly three cups, not the entire displayed three-to-four 12-ounce range." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0010", "citation_id": "B01-CIT10", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-005", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "response_claim": "Four hundred milligrams represents about three to four 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "gold_claim": "The FDA equates that amount to about two to three 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Blue Cross explainer gives an approximate four-cup equivalence and therefore supports only part of the displayed range." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0011", "citation_id": "B01-CIT11", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-006", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "response_claim": "Four hundred milligrams represents about three to four 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "gold_claim": "The FDA equates that amount to about two to three 12-fluid-ounce cups of coffee.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The preserved Mayo hydration page does not establish the displayed three-to-four 12-ounce cup conversion." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0012", "citation_id": "B01-CIT12", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-006", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "response_claim": "Individual sensitivity to caffeine varies.", "gold_claim": "People vary widely in caffeine sensitivity and how quickly they eliminate it.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The inspected Mayo page did not establish the adjacent sensitivity statement." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0013", "citation_id": "B01-CIT12", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-006", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/caffeinated-drinks/faq-20057965?srch_tag=ygo7rjkqugqjgtcjcvjywxml7xvrtegk", "response_claim": "Pregnant or breastfeeding women should consult a healthcare provider about caffeine intake.", "gold_claim": "The FDA advises consulting a healthcare professional about limits for pregnancy, trying to become pregnant, breastfeeding, relevant medications, or health conditions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Mayo page supports pregnancy-related professional guidance but not the entire displayed pregnancy-or-breastfeeding formulation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0014", "citation_id": "B01-CIT13", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-005", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "response_claim": "Individual sensitivity to caffeine varies.", "gold_claim": "People vary widely in caffeine sensitivity and how quickly they eliminate it.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Blue Cross page directly notes variation in individual caffeine sensitivity." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0015", "citation_id": "B01-CIT13", "question_id": "Q02", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q02-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q02-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-005", "preserved_url": "https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/does-caffeine-raise-blood-pressure", "response_claim": "Pregnant or breastfeeding women should consult a healthcare provider about caffeine intake.", "gold_claim": "The FDA advises consulting a healthcare professional about limits for pregnancy, trying to become pregnant, breastfeeding, relevant medications, or health conditions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "It supports pregnancy-related consultation but does not fully establish every displayed category." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0016", "citation_id": "B01-CIT14", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q03-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q03-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-007", "preserved_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "response_claim": "Adults ages 19-70: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "gold_claim": "Adults ages 19-70: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements table directly supports 15 mcg (600 IU) for ages 19-70." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0017", "citation_id": "B01-CIT14", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q03-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q03-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-007", "preserved_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "response_claim": "Adults age 71 or older: 20 mcg (800 IU) per day.", "gold_claim": "Adults age 71 or older: 20 mcg (800 IU) per day.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The NIH table directly supports 20 mcg (800 IU) for age 71 or older." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0018", "citation_id": "B01-CIT15", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q03-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q03-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-008", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/vitamin-d-deficiency/faq-20058397", "response_claim": "Adults ages 19-70: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "gold_claim": "Adults ages 19-70: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Mayo page supports the adult 600 IU recommendation but does not fully preserve the exact age-and-unit formulation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0019", "citation_id": "B01-CIT15", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q03-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q03-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-008", "preserved_url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/zh-hans/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/vitamin-d-deficiency/faq-20058397", "response_claim": "Adults age 71 or older: 20 mcg (800 IU) per day.", "gold_claim": "Adults age 71 or older: 20 mcg (800 IU) per day.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Mayo page supports the older-adult 800 IU recommendation but does not fully preserve the exact age-and-unit formulation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0020", "citation_id": "B01-CIT16", "question_id": "Q03", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q03-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q03-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-007", "preserved_url": "https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-Consumer/?ref=popsugar.com&=___psv__p_40242376__t_w__r_www.popsugar.com%2Ffitness%2FFoods-High-Vitamin-D-40242376_", "response_claim": "Pregnant and breastfeeding teens and women: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "gold_claim": "Pregnant and breastfeeding teens and women: 15 mcg (600 IU) per day.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The NIH table directly supports 15 mcg (600 IU) for pregnant and breastfeeding teens and women." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0021", "citation_id": "B01-CIT17", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-009", "preserved_url": "https://www.dmuclinic.org/health-library/story/24a52a15-227d-448b-9364-fccb5fb925ec", "response_claim": "Ages 18-60: seven or more hours.", "gold_claim": "Ages 18-60: seven or more hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The page was unverifiable, so no support is inferred for the first age band." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0022", "citation_id": "B01-CIT17", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-009", "preserved_url": "https://www.dmuclinic.org/health-library/story/24a52a15-227d-448b-9364-fccb5fb925ec", "response_claim": "Ages 61-64: seven to nine hours.", "gold_claim": "Ages 61-64: seven to nine hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The page was unverifiable, so no support is inferred for the second age band." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0023", "citation_id": "B01-CIT17", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-009", "preserved_url": "https://www.dmuclinic.org/health-library/story/24a52a15-227d-448b-9364-fccb5fb925ec", "response_claim": "Age 65 or older: seven to eight hours.", "gold_claim": "Age 65 or older: seven to eight hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The page was unverifiable, so no support is inferred for the third age band." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0024", "citation_id": "B01-CIT18", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-010", "preserved_url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-many-hours-of-sleep-do-you-need-and-is-there-sweet-spot-us-still-fail-to-get", "response_claim": "Ages 18-60: seven or more hours.", "gold_claim": "Ages 18-60: seven or more hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The accessible sleep table supports seven or more hours for ages 18-60." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0025", "citation_id": "B01-CIT18", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-010", "preserved_url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-many-hours-of-sleep-do-you-need-and-is-there-sweet-spot-us-still-fail-to-get", "response_claim": "Ages 61-64: seven to nine hours.", "gold_claim": "Ages 61-64: seven to nine hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The accessible sleep table supports seven to nine hours for ages 61-64." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0026", "citation_id": "B01-CIT18", "question_id": "Q04", "batch_id": "B01", "response_claim_id": "Q04-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q04-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-010", "preserved_url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-many-hours-of-sleep-do-you-need-and-is-there-sweet-spot-us-still-fail-to-get", "response_claim": "Age 65 or older: seven to eight hours.", "gold_claim": "Age 65 or older: seven to eight hours.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The accessible sleep table supports seven to eight hours for age 65 or older." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0027", "citation_id": "B02-CIT01", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-011", "preserved_url": "https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/webarchives/wayback/20110402101907/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_1", "response_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "gold_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The archived Wikipedia target was unverifiable." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0028", "citation_id": "B02-CIT01", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": "URL-011", "preserved_url": "https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/webarchives/wayback/20110402101907/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_1", "response_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "gold_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The archived Wikipedia target was unverifiable." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0029", "citation_id": "B02-CIT02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-012", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "response_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "gold_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Horizons records the launch instant as September 6 UTC while its trajectory begins September 5; it does not cleanly entail the displayed calendar date." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0030", "citation_id": "B02-CIT02", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-012", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "response_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "gold_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Horizons timeline directly records the Jupiter and Saturn encounters." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0031", "citation_id": "B02-CIT03", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-013", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "response_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "gold_claim": "Voyager 1 launched on September 5, 1977.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The JPL mission record gives the September 5, 1977 launch date." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0032", "citation_id": "B02-CIT03", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-013", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "response_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "gold_claim": "Its primary planetary flyby targets were Jupiter and Saturn.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The JPL mission record identifies Jupiter and Saturn as the planetary encounters." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0033", "citation_id": "B02-CIT04", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-013", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "response_claim": "Voyager 1 entered interstellar space in August 2012.", "gold_claim": "It crossed into interstellar space in August 2012.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The JPL mission record supports entry into interstellar space in August 2012." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0034", "citation_id": "B02-CIT04", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-X01", "gold_claim_id": null, "claim_type": "extra", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-013", "preserved_url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/voyager-1/", "response_claim": "NASA designates the current phase as the Voyager Interstellar Mission.", "gold_claim": null, "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The same JPL record identifies the Voyager Interstellar Mission phase." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0035", "citation_id": "B02-CIT05", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q05-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-012", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "response_claim": "Voyager 1 entered interstellar space in August 2012.", "gold_claim": "It crossed into interstellar space in August 2012.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Horizons records the August 25, 2012 heliopause crossing." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0036", "citation_id": "B02-CIT05", "question_id": "Q05", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q05-X01", "gold_claim_id": null, "claim_type": "extra", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-012", "preserved_url": "https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&MAKE_EPHEM=NO&COMMAND=-31", "response_claim": "NASA designates the current phase as the Voyager Interstellar Mission.", "gold_claim": null, "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "Horizons says the interstellar mission began in 1990 and does not entail NASA's displayed current-phase designation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0037", "citation_id": "B02-CIT06", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-014", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "response_claim": "About 96.5% of Earth's total water is in oceans.", "gold_claim": "About 96.5% of Earth's total water is in oceans.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The USGS distribution table gives 96.5% of total water in oceans." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0038", "citation_id": "B02-CIT07", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-015", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "About 96.5% of Earth's total water is in oceans.", "gold_claim": "About 96.5% of Earth's total water is in oceans.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The cited OECD-hosted PDF returned 404 and cannot support the claim." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0039", "citation_id": "B02-CIT08", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-014", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "response_claim": "About 68.7% of freshwater is in ice caps and glaciers.", "gold_claim": "More than 68% of freshwater is locked in ice and glaciers.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The USGS table gives about 68.7% of freshwater in ice caps, glaciers, and permanent snow." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0040", "citation_id": "B02-CIT08", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-014", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "response_claim": "About 30.1% of freshwater is in groundwater.", "gold_claim": "About 30% of freshwater is in the ground.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The USGS table gives about 30.1% of freshwater as groundwater." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0041", "citation_id": "B02-CIT09", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-015", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "About 68.7% of freshwater is in ice caps and glaciers.", "gold_claim": "More than 68% of freshwater is locked in ice and glaciers.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The cited PDF returned 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0042", "citation_id": "B02-CIT09", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-015", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "About 30.1% of freshwater is in groundwater.", "gold_claim": "About 30% of freshwater is in the ground.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The cited PDF returned 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0043", "citation_id": "B02-CIT10", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C04a", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C04", "claim_type": "required_response_subclaim", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-014", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "response_claim": "Fresh rivers contain approximately 0.006% of all Earth water.", "gold_claim": "Fresh rivers and lakes are about 1/150th of 1% of total global water.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "USGS gives rivers as about 0.0002% of total water, contradicting the displayed 0.006% river value." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0044", "citation_id": "B02-CIT10", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C04b", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C04", "claim_type": "required_response_subclaim", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-014", "preserved_url": "https://water.usgs.gov/edu/gallery/watercyclekids/earth-water-distribution.html", "response_claim": "Fresh lakes contain approximately 0.007% of all Earth water.", "gold_claim": "Fresh rivers and lakes are about 1/150th of 1% of total global water.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "USGS gives freshwater lakes as approximately 0.007% of total water." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0045", "citation_id": "B02-CIT11", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C04a", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C04", "claim_type": "required_response_subclaim", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-015", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "Fresh rivers contain approximately 0.006% of all Earth water.", "gold_claim": "Fresh rivers and lakes are about 1/150th of 1% of total global water.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The cited PDF returned 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0046", "citation_id": "B02-CIT11", "question_id": "Q06", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q06-C04b", "gold_claim_id": "Q06-C04", "claim_type": "required_response_subclaim", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-015", "preserved_url": "http://ito.ocde.us/Resources/Documents/Workshop%20Resources/WaterDistributionChart.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "Fresh lakes contain approximately 0.007% of all Earth water.", "gold_claim": "Fresh rivers and lakes are about 1/150th of 1% of total global water.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The cited PDF returned 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0047", "citation_id": "B02-CIT12", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q07-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q07-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-016", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "response_claim": "Ozone is made of three oxygen atoms.", "gold_claim": "Ozone is made of three oxygen atoms.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "NASA directly describes ozone as three oxygen atoms." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0048", "citation_id": "B02-CIT13", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q07-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q07-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-016", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "response_claim": "Stratospheric ozone absorbs harmful UV-B radiation.", "gold_claim": "Stratospheric ozone absorbs harmful UV-B radiation.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "NASA directly explains that stratospheric ozone absorbs harmful ultraviolet radiation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0049", "citation_id": "B02-CIT14", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q07-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q07-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-016", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "response_claim": "Certain human-made chemicals containing chlorine and bromine drive ozone depletion.", "gold_claim": "Certain human-made chemicals containing chlorine and bromine drive ozone depletion.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "NASA explains ozone depletion by chlorine- and bromine-releasing human-made chemicals." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0050", "citation_id": "B02-CIT15", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q07-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q07-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-017", "preserved_url": "https://api.repository.cam.ac.uk/server/api/core/bitstreams/64468506-72a2-4589-b4e6-588a59d418a7/content#4#1", "response_claim": "Under continued current policies, near-global total-column ozone is projected to return to 1980 levels around 2040.", "gold_claim": "Near-global 60Â degrees N-60Â degrees S recovery to 1980 values is projected around 2040.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Cambridge paper discusses signal de-emergence timing; it does not establish return to 1980 near-global total-column values under continued policy." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0051", "citation_id": "B02-CIT16", "question_id": "Q07", "batch_id": "B02", "response_claim_id": "Q07-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q07-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-016", "preserved_url": "https://science.nasa.gov/earth/explore/nasa-knows-the-ozone-hole/", "response_claim": "The Antarctic ozone hole could be restored by about 2070.", "gold_claim": "Antarctic recovery to 1980 values is projected around 2066.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "NASA supports the adjacent approximate 2070 Antarctic recovery statement, even though claim accuracy separately records its mismatch with the frozen 2066 benchmark." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0052", "citation_id": "B03-CIT01", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-018", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/2020-census-apportionment-results.html?utm_id=28318&sfmc_id=711040", "response_claim": "The U.S. resident population was 331,449,281 as of April 1, 2020.", "gold_claim": "The resident population was 331,449,281 as of April 1, 2020, for the 50 states and District of Columbia.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Census release supports the stated resident-population number and April 1, 2020 date." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0053", "citation_id": "B03-CIT01", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-018", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/2020-census-apportionment-results.html?utm_id=28318&sfmc_id=711040", "response_claim": "That was a 7.4% increase from the 2010 Census.", "gold_claim": "That was a 7.4% increase from the 2010 Census.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The same Census release supports the 7.4% increase from 2010." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0054", "citation_id": "B03-CIT02", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-019", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/decennial-census/decade/2020/planning-management/evaluate/eae/2020-operational-assessment-federally-affiliated-count-overseas.html", "response_claim": "Eligible U.S. military and federal civilian employees overseas and dependents living with them were not part of the resident-population count.", "gold_claim": "Eligible U.S. military and federal civilian employees overseas and dependents living with them were not part of the resident-population count.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The operational assessment distinguishes the overseas federally affiliated count from the resident-population count." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0055", "citation_id": "B03-CIT02", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-019", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/decennial-census/decade/2020/planning-management/evaluate/eae/2020-operational-assessment-federally-affiliated-count-overseas.html", "response_claim": "Eligible overseas counts were added separately for congressional apportionment.", "gold_claim": "Those eligible overseas counts were allocated to a home state and included separately in apportionment counts.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "It explains the separate apportionment treatment and home-state allocation." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0056", "citation_id": "B03-CIT03", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-020", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-kits/2021/2020-census-apportionment-counts.html", "response_claim": "Eligible U.S. military and federal civilian employees overseas and dependents living with them were not part of the resident-population count.", "gold_claim": "Eligible U.S. military and federal civilian employees overseas and dependents living with them were not part of the resident-population count.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Census press kit defines apportionment population as resident population plus eligible overseas people." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0057", "citation_id": "B03-CIT03", "question_id": "Q09", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q09-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q09-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-020", "preserved_url": "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-kits/2021/2020-census-apportionment-counts.html", "response_claim": "Eligible overseas counts were added separately for congressional apportionment.", "gold_claim": "Those eligible overseas counts were allocated to a home state and included separately in apportionment counts.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The press kit states that eligible overseas people could be allocated to home states and added for apportionment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0058", "citation_id": "B03-CIT04", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q10-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q10-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-021", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "response_claim": "CPI measures the average change over time in prices paid by consumers for a representative basket of consumer goods and services.", "gold_claim": "CPI measures the average change over time in prices paid by consumers for a representative basket of consumer goods and services.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The BLS FAQ directly defines CPI as average price change for a representative consumer basket." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0059", "citation_id": "B03-CIT05", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q10-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q10-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-021", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "response_claim": "The eight groups are food and beverages; housing; apparel; transportation; medical care; recreation; education and communication; and other goods and services.", "gold_claim": "The eight groups are food and beverages; housing; apparel; transportation; medical care; recreation; education and communication; and other goods and services.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The BLS FAQ lists all eight displayed expenditure groups." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0060", "citation_id": "B03-CIT06", "question_id": "Q10", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q10-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q10-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-021", "preserved_url": "https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm?utm_term=The%20Node", "response_claim": "Directly associated sales and excise taxes are included.", "gold_claim": "Directly associated sales and excise taxes are included.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The BLS FAQ states that directly associated sales and excise taxes are included." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0061", "citation_id": "B03-CIT07", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-022", "preserved_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "response_claim": "The inflation objective is 2%.", "gold_claim": "The inflation objective is 2%.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Federal Reserve page supports the 2% objective." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0062", "citation_id": "B03-CIT07", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-022", "preserved_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "response_claim": "The horizon is the longer run.", "gold_claim": "The horizon is the longer run.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Federal Reserve page states the longer-run horizon." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0063", "citation_id": "B03-CIT08", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-023", "preserved_url": "http://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/09/the-federal-reserves-monetary-policy-framework-the-2025-review/", "response_claim": "The inflation objective is 2%.", "gold_claim": "The inflation objective is 2%.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The ABA review article reports retention of the 2% objective after the 2025 review." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0064", "citation_id": "B03-CIT08", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": "URL-023", "preserved_url": "http://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/09/the-federal-reserves-monetary-policy-framework-the-2025-review/", "response_claim": "The horizon is the longer run.", "gold_claim": "The horizon is the longer run.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "It also preserves the longer-run horizon." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0065", "citation_id": "B03-CIT09", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-022", "preserved_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14419.htm?mibextid=onnTyB&fs=e&s=cl", "response_claim": "It is measured by the annual change in the personal consumption expenditures price index.", "gold_claim": "It is measured by the annual change in the personal consumption expenditures price index.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Federal Reserve page identifies annual PCE price-index change as the measure." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0066", "citation_id": "B03-CIT10", "question_id": "Q11", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q11-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q11-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-024", "preserved_url": "https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2026/jul/between-headline-core-inflation-excluding-energy-goods", "response_claim": "It is measured by the annual change in the personal consumption expenditures price index.", "gold_claim": "It is measured by the annual change in the personal consumption expenditures price index.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis article directly describes inflation using annual PCE price-index change." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0067", "citation_id": "B03-CIT11", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-025", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The 2024 business rate was 67 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 business rate was 67 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The KPMG PDF URL is a 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0068", "citation_id": "B03-CIT11", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-025", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The 2024 charitable-service rate was 14 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 charitable-service rate was 14 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The KPMG PDF URL is a 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0069", "citation_id": "B03-CIT11", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-025", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The 2024 medical or qualifying military moving rate was 21 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 medical or qualifying military moving rate was 21 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The KPMG PDF URL is a 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0070", "citation_id": "B03-CIT12", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-026", "preserved_url": "https://apps.irs.gov/app/vita/lang/es/content/00/00_17_005.jsp?level=advanced", "response_claim": "The 2024 business rate was 67 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 business rate was 67 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The IRS courseware gives the 67-cent 2024 business rate." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0071", "citation_id": "B03-CIT12", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-026", "preserved_url": "https://apps.irs.gov/app/vita/lang/es/content/00/00_17_005.jsp?level=advanced", "response_claim": "The 2024 charitable-service rate was 14 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 charitable-service rate was 14 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The IRS courseware gives the 14-cent charitable rate." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0072", "citation_id": "B03-CIT12", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-026", "preserved_url": "https://apps.irs.gov/app/vita/lang/es/content/00/00_17_005.jsp?level=advanced", "response_claim": "The 2024 medical or qualifying military moving rate was 21 cents per mile.", "gold_claim": "The 2024 medical or qualifying military moving rate was 21 cents per mile.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The IRS courseware gives the 21-cent medical or military-moving rate." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0073", "citation_id": "B03-CIT13", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": "URL-025", "preserved_url": "https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/us/pdf/2023/12/23443.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The moving-expense rate can be used only by qualified active-duty Armed Forces members because the deduction is suspended for other taxpayers.", "gold_claim": "The moving rate applied to qualifying active-duty Armed Forces members moving under orders incident to a permanent change of station.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The KPMG PDF URL is a 404." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0074", "citation_id": "B03-CIT14", "question_id": "Q12", "batch_id": "B03", "response_claim_id": "Q12-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q12-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "source_specific", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": "URL-027", "preserved_url": "https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/ARC24_PurpleBook_08_MiscRecs_61.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The moving-expense rate can be used only by qualified active-duty Armed Forces members because the deduction is suspended for other taxpayers.", "gold_claim": "The moving rate applied to qualifying active-duty Armed Forces members moving under orders incident to a permanent change of station.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs immediately after the sentence or clause containing this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The Taxpayer Advocate document lists the 21-cent medical and military-moving rate but does not establish the active-duty, military-orders, permanent-change-of-station scope." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0075", "citation_id": "B04-CIT01", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "response_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "gold_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0076", "citation_id": "B04-CIT01", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "response_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0077", "citation_id": "B04-CIT01", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "response_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "gold_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0078", "citation_id": "B04-CIT01", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "response_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0079", "citation_id": "B04-CIT02", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "gold_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0080", "citation_id": "B04-CIT02", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0081", "citation_id": "B04-CIT02", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "gold_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0082", "citation_id": "B04-CIT02", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/putting-fair-back-in-fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0083", "citation_id": "B04-CIT03", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "gold_claim": "Factor one is the purpose and character of the use, including commercial versus nonprofit educational use.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0084", "citation_id": "B04-CIT03", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor two is the nature of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0085", "citation_id": "B04-CIT03", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "gold_claim": "Factor three is the amount and substantiality used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0086", "citation_id": "B04-CIT03", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://copyright.princeton.edu/basics/fair-use", "response_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "gold_claim": "Factor four is the effect on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0087", "citation_id": "B04-CIT04", "question_id": "Q13", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q13-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q13-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html", "response_claim": "There is no predetermined safe number of words, lines, pages, copies, or percentage; fair use is case-specific.", "gold_claim": "There is no predetermined safe number of words, lines, pages, copies, or percentage; fair use is case-specific.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0088", "citation_id": "B04-CIT05", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "Commercial business-to-business email is not exempt.", "gold_claim": "Commercial business-to-business email is not exempt.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0089", "citation_id": "B04-CIT06", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "response_claim": "Commercial business-to-business email is not exempt.", "gold_claim": "Commercial business-to-business email is not exempt.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0090", "citation_id": "B04-CIT07", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "Headers and routing information must be accurate, and subject lines must not be deceptive.", "gold_claim": "Headers and routing information must be accurate, and subject lines must not be deceptive.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0091", "citation_id": "B04-CIT07", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "The message must be identified clearly and conspicuously as an advertisement unless a stated exception applies.", "gold_claim": "The message must be identified clearly and conspicuously as an advertisement unless a stated exception applies.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0092", "citation_id": "B04-CIT07", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "The message must include a valid physical postal address.", "gold_claim": "The message must include a valid physical postal address.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0093", "citation_id": "B04-CIT08", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "The message must provide a clear, conspicuous, easy opt-out method.", "gold_claim": "The message must provide a clear, conspicuous, easy opt-out method.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0094", "citation_id": "B04-CIT08", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "gold_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0095", "citation_id": "B04-CIT09", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "response_claim": "The message must provide a clear, conspicuous, easy opt-out method.", "gold_claim": "The message must provide a clear, conspicuous, easy opt-out method.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0096", "citation_id": "B04-CIT09", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "response_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "gold_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0097", "citation_id": "B04-CIT10", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business?kuid=efecb97c-ca68-4573-b772-63b305941255-1783007072&kref=https%3A%2F%2Faselfguru.com%2Femail-marketing-vs-social-media%2F", "response_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "gold_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0098", "citation_id": "B04-CIT11", "question_id": "Q14", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q14-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://gdprlocal.com/usa-e-mail-marketing-rules/", "response_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "gold_claim": "The mechanism must process requests for at least 30 days after sending, and requests must be honored within 10 business days.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0099", "citation_id": "B04-CIT12", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "response_claim": "Single-factor passwords must be at least 15 characters.", "gold_claim": "Single-factor passwords must be at least 15 characters.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0100", "citation_id": "B04-CIT13", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "response_claim": "Passwords used only as part of MFA may be shorter but must be at least eight characters.", "gold_claim": "Passwords used only as part of MFA may be shorter but must be at least eight characters.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0101", "citation_id": "B04-CIT14", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "response_claim": "Verifiers and CSPs must not impose other composition rules such as required character-type mixtures.", "gold_claim": "Verifiers and CSPs must not impose other composition rules such as required character-type mixtures.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0102", "citation_id": "B04-CIT14", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://securityboulevard.com/2025/09/nist-sp-800-63b-rev-4-password-updates/", "response_claim": "Prospective passwords must be checked against a blocklist of commonly used, expected, or compromised passwords.", "gold_claim": "Prospective passwords must be checked against a blocklist of commonly used, expected, or compromised passwords.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0103", "citation_id": "B04-CIT15", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "response_claim": "Verifiers and CSPs must not impose other composition rules such as required character-type mixtures.", "gold_claim": "Verifiers and CSPs must not impose other composition rules such as required character-type mixtures.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0104", "citation_id": "B04-CIT15", "question_id": "Q15", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q15-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q15-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/justinricher_nist-proposes-barring-some-of-the-most-nonsensical-activity-7245071368067723268-090j", "response_claim": "Prospective passwords must be checked against a blocklist of commonly used, expected, or compromised passwords.", "gold_claim": "Prospective passwords must be checked against a blocklist of commonly used, expected, or compromised passwords.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0105", "citation_id": "B04-CIT16", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0106", "citation_id": "B04-CIT16", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0107", "citation_id": "B04-CIT17", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0108", "citation_id": "B04-CIT17", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0109", "citation_id": "B04-CIT18", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when personal data are no longer necessary for the purposes for which they were collected or processed.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0110", "citation_id": "B04-CIT18", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "gold_claim": "A ground exists when consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal ground for processing.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0111", "citation_id": "B04-CIT19", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "gold_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0112", "citation_id": "B04-CIT19", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "gold_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0113", "citation_id": "B04-CIT19", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "gold_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0114", "citation_id": "B04-CIT19", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "gold_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0115", "citation_id": "B04-CIT19", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://ukgdpr.fieldfisher.com/chapter-3/article-17-gdpr/", "response_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "gold_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0116", "citation_id": "B04-CIT20", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "gold_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0117", "citation_id": "B04-CIT20", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "gold_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0118", "citation_id": "B04-CIT20", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "gold_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0119", "citation_id": "B04-CIT20", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "gold_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0120", "citation_id": "B04-CIT20", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.dataprotection.ie/en/individuals/know-your-rights/right-erasure-articles-17-19-gdpr?utm_source=prn1&utm_medium=media&utm_campaign=gold%20partnership&utm_content=google%20consent&utm_term=news&irpid=irpid", "response_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "gold_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0121", "citation_id": "B04-CIT21", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "gold_claim": "Exception: exercising freedom of expression and information.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0122", "citation_id": "B04-CIT21", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "gold_claim": "Exception: compliance with a legal obligation or performance of a public-interest task or official authority.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0123", "citation_id": "B04-CIT21", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C05", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "gold_claim": "Exception: reasons of public interest in public health under the cited GDPR provisions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0124", "citation_id": "B04-CIT21", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C06", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "gold_claim": "Exception: protected public-interest archiving, scientific or historical research, or statistics where erasure would make objectives impossible or seriously impair them.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0125", "citation_id": "B04-CIT21", "question_id": "Q16", "batch_id": "B04", "response_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "gold_claim_id": "Q16-C07", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "partial", "support_score": 0.5, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.activemind.legal/legislation/gdpr/article-17/", "response_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "gold_claim": "Exception: establishment, exercise, or defence of legal claims.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0126", "citation_id": "B05-CIT01", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu:443/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "response_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0127", "citation_id": "B05-CIT01", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu:443/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "response_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0128", "citation_id": "B05-CIT01", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-X01", "gold_claim_id": null, "claim_type": "extra", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu:443/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "response_claim": "Large-scale text means 18 point, or 14 point bold, and larger.", "gold_claim": null, "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0129", "citation_id": "B05-CIT02", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "response_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0130", "citation_id": "B05-CIT02", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "response_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0131", "citation_id": "B05-CIT02", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-X01", "gold_claim_id": null, "claim_type": "extra", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "response_claim": "Large-scale text means 18 point, or 14 point bold, and larger.", "gold_claim": null, "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0132", "citation_id": "B05-CIT03", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://testparty.ai/blog/wcag-contrast-ratio-guide-2025", "response_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Normal text requires at least 4.5:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0133", "citation_id": "B05-CIT03", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://testparty.ai/blog/wcag-contrast-ratio-guide-2025", "response_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "gold_claim": "Large-scale text requires at least 3:1 contrast.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0134", "citation_id": "B05-CIT03", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-X01", "gold_claim_id": null, "claim_type": "extra", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://testparty.ai/blog/wcag-contrast-ratio-guide-2025", "response_claim": "Large-scale text means 18 point, or 14 point bold, and larger.", "gold_claim": null, "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0135", "citation_id": "B05-CIT04", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu:443/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "response_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "gold_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0136", "citation_id": "B05-CIT04", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "B", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.marywood.edu:443/x/super-user/docs/WCAG-1.4.3-text-images.pdf?language_id=1#1#1", "response_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "gold_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0137", "citation_id": "B05-CIT05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "response_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "gold_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0138", "citation_id": "B05-CIT05", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://w3c.github.io/wcag21/understanding/contrast-minimum", "response_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "gold_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0139", "citation_id": "B05-CIT06", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://apps.des.wa.gov/contracting/08213b.pdf#14#10", "response_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "gold_claim": "Incidental text or images of text are exempt under the criterion's stated conditions.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0140", "citation_id": "B05-CIT06", "question_id": "Q17", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q17-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://apps.des.wa.gov/contracting/08213b.pdf#14#10", "response_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "gold_claim": "Logotypes are exempt.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0141", "citation_id": "B05-CIT07", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "response_claim": "429 means too many requests in a given amount of time, or rate limiting.", "gold_claim": "429 means too many requests in a given amount of time, or rate limiting.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0142", "citation_id": "B05-CIT08", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "response_claim": "429 means too many requests in a given amount of time, or rate limiting.", "gold_claim": "429 means too many requests in a given amount of time, or rate limiting.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0143", "citation_id": "B05-CIT09", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "response_claim": "The response representation should include details explaining the condition.", "gold_claim": "The response representation should include details explaining the condition.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0144", "citation_id": "B05-CIT09", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "response_claim": "The response may include Retry-After to indicate how long to wait.", "gold_claim": "The response may include Retry-After to indicate how long to wait.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0145", "citation_id": "B05-CIT10", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "response_claim": "The response representation should include details explaining the condition.", "gold_claim": "The response representation should include details explaining the condition.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0146", "citation_id": "B05-CIT10", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/f37d0206-1da5-4cc7-913f-3cd33201f4bf/view-source", "response_claim": "The response may include Retry-After to indicate how long to wait.", "gold_claim": "The response may include Retry-After to indicate how long to wait.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0147", "citation_id": "B05-CIT11", "question_id": "Q18", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q18-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q18-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/571027dc-58ff-4b48-ac92-a532f1387fc0/view-source", "response_claim": "The RFC does not define how the origin server identifies the user or counts requests.", "gold_claim": "The RFC does not define how the origin server identifies the user or counts requests.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0148", "citation_id": "B05-CIT12", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "response_claim": "The file is `/robots.txt`, all lowercase, at the top-level path of the service.", "gold_claim": "The file is `/robots.txt`, all lowercase, at the top-level path of the service.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0149", "citation_id": "B05-CIT12", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "response_claim": "It must be UTF-8 encoded and served as `text/plain`.", "gold_claim": "It must be UTF-8 encoded and served as `text/plain`.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0150", "citation_id": "B05-CIT13", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "The file is `/robots.txt`, all lowercase, at the top-level path of the service.", "gold_claim": "The file is `/robots.txt`, all lowercase, at the top-level path of the service.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0151", "citation_id": "B05-CIT13", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "It must be UTF-8 encoded and served as `text/plain`.", "gold_claim": "It must be UTF-8 encoded and served as `text/plain`.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0152", "citation_id": "B05-CIT14", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "response_claim": "Robots exclusion rules are not access authorization or a substitute for security controls.", "gold_claim": "Robots exclusion rules are not access authorization or a substitute for security controls.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0153", "citation_id": "B05-CIT15", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "Robots exclusion rules are not access authorization or a substitute for security controls.", "gold_claim": "Robots exclusion rules are not access authorization or a substitute for security controls.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0154", "citation_id": "B05-CIT16", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://dt-main.dev.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9309.html", "response_claim": "Listing URI paths exposes them publicly and makes them discoverable.", "gold_claim": "Listing URI paths exposes them publicly and makes them discoverable.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0155", "citation_id": "B05-CIT17", "question_id": "Q19", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q19-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q19-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "invalid", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.potaroo.net/ietf/rfc-pdf/rfc9309.pdf#1#1", "response_claim": "Listing URI paths exposes them publicly and makes them discoverable.", "gold_claim": "Listing URI paths exposes them publicly and makes them discoverable.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0156", "citation_id": "B05-CIT18", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q20-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q20-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "response_claim": "Lists are mutable and usually contain homogeneous elements accessed by iteration.", "gold_claim": "Lists are mutable and usually contain homogeneous elements accessed by iteration.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0157", "citation_id": "B05-CIT18", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q20-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q20-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "response_claim": "Tuples are immutable and often contain heterogeneous elements accessed by unpacking or indexing.", "gold_claim": "Tuples are immutable and often contain heterogeneous elements accessed by unpacking or indexing.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0158", "citation_id": "B05-CIT19", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q20-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q20-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "response_claim": "A tuple may contain a mutable object such as a list.", "gold_claim": "A tuple may contain a mutable object such as a list.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0159", "citation_id": "B05-CIT20", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q20-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q20-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "D", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://bugs.python.org/file25633/tuple", "response_claim": "A one-item tuple is created with a trailing comma; parentheses alone are insufficient.", "gold_claim": "A one-item tuple is created with a trailing comma; parentheses alone are insufficient.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0160", "citation_id": "B05-CIT21", "question_id": "Q20", "batch_id": "B05", "response_claim_id": "Q20-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q20-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://codegym.cc/quests/lectures/en.codegym.python.core.lecture.level05.lecture09", "response_claim": "A one-item tuple is created with a trailing comma; parentheses alone are insufficient.", "gold_claim": "A one-item tuple is created with a trailing comma; parentheses alone are insufficient.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0161", "citation_id": "B06-CIT01", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "response_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "gold_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0162", "citation_id": "B06-CIT01", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "response_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "gold_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0163", "citation_id": "B06-CIT02", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "response_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "gold_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0164", "citation_id": "B06-CIT02", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "response_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "gold_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0165", "citation_id": "B06-CIT03", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C01", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.politico.com/story/2012/05/jamestown-settlement-founded-076223", "response_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "gold_claim": "Jamestown was established on May 14, 1607.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0166", "citation_id": "B06-CIT03", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C02", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "unverifiable", "validity_score": 0, "authority_tier": "C", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.politico.com/story/2012/05/jamestown-settlement-founded-076223", "response_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "gold_claim": "The settlers acted under the Virginia Company of London, chartered by King James I.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0167", "citation_id": "B06-CIT04", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "response_claim": "The Library of Congress describes it as the first permanent English settlement in North America.", "gold_claim": "The Library of Congress describes it as the first permanent English settlement in North America.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0168", "citation_id": "B06-CIT05", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C03", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C03", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "none", "support_score": 0, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/jamestown/", "response_claim": "The Library of Congress describes it as the first permanent English settlement in North America.", "gold_claim": "The Library of Congress describes it as the first permanent English settlement in North America.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." }, { "edge_id": "EDGE-0169", "citation_id": "B06-CIT06", "question_id": "Q21", "batch_id": "B06", "response_claim_id": "Q21-C04", "gold_claim_id": "Q21-C04", "claim_type": "required", "support_label": "full", "support_score": 1, "support_adjudication": "primary_occurrence_label_propagated_to_expanded_edge", "validity_label": "valid_manual", "validity_score": 1, "authority_tier": "A", "source_url_id": null, "preserved_url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-14?loclr=eatod", "response_claim": "The land was already inhabited by Native peoples and had been for about 15,000 years.", "gold_claim": "The land was already inhabited by Native peoples and had been for about 15,000 years.", "association_basis": "The citation occurs in the same rendered citation cluster as this atomic claim.", "evidence_note": "The primary occurrence-level support label is applied to every atomic claim reasonably associated with that same rendered citation position. This fixes the denominator while preserving the primary source-support judgment." } ] }