I totally agree with Atonal that the "twinked" enchanter shouldn't get the
robe, or even get to roll for the robe. Two people playing 4 characters is
a little ridiculous to me, especially on any serious raid. For one of those
people to be the guild leader makes me shudder.
I would have made the same decision had I been in your shoes Brilinnia. I
hope your guildleader hopefully has learned a lesson from this incident and
that your guild can continue to travel the breadth of Norrath in camaraderie.
---Windleaf
At 10:10 AM 2/12/01 -0500, you wrote:
>Looks pretty simple to me.
>
>Chanter #1 is being played, and died doing his job.
>
>Chanter #2 is there only because someone has multiple computers with
>multiple accounts, and is doing nothing, and continued to do nothing despite
>the fact that your group was being overrun, and was even gated out safe and
>sound.
>
>I'm a bit surprised that the leader of a guild that attracts people such as
>yourself would be the center of such a disagreement. Granted, I don't know
>your guild leader, but I do know you, and I supposed I've always assumed
>that your conduct is representative of Excalibur. :) I'm sure this has
>caused strife internally, as threats to walk should not be taken lightly. A
>momentary lapse of reason, perhaps?
>
>Atonal
>
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Rebecca Small [mailto:rsmall@...]
>Sent: Monday, February 12, 2001 9:12 AM
>To: 'eqbards@yahoogroups.com'
>Subject: [eqbards] Loot Rights Question
>
>
>Hail bards and bardettes,
>
> We had a loot rights discussion this weekend. We had 2 groups together in
>Howling Stones North Tower. One group had a L44 chanter, a 50s shaman, a 50s
>warrior, 50s cleric all played by 2 people plus a 50s wiz. The chanter
>really didn't function as a chanter and we'd asked them not to bring her
>along as we had a real working chanter in our group. We got to the last
>corner before the Crypt keeper's room and when the monk pulled it, the whole
>room came. We killed the Crypt Keeper but had alot of mobs on us. Our
>chanter was doing his best to pause/mez what he could. Then the hallway
>started to respawn and we had 8 -10 mobs. Our chanter died, I was doing what
>I could but out numbered by live awake mobs. We called for gates and the
>other groups wiz got them out. We all died. The necro in our group looted
>the chanter robe (Siren's?) off the keeper before he died and I got the key
>before I died rather than have it poof. The aftermath was they wanted to
>lotto the robe between the chanter twink and the chanter who died doing CC.
>We felt this would be very wrong yet they didn't see it. We felt the twink,
>while there when the robe dropped, was not being played, else we probably
>would not have been wiped out. We also all know that char is a twink, not a
>primary. I think that robe on a twink would hurt our guild's credibility
>somewhat as the twink belongs to the head of the guild. It's also our
>opinion you can't function as a good chanter unless the person is giving the
>character their whole attention. I'd like to hear the opinion of others on
>this. Were we out of line?
>The result was I said we'd walk on the guild if they insisted on lottoing
>it. They agreed to give the robe to the other chanter.
>
>Brilinnia Ban'Sidhe
>Excalibur, Xegony
>
>
>Please send submissions for the eqbards newsletter to lol@...
>with the subject submissions.
>
>
>Please send submissions for the eqbards newsletter to lol@...
>with the subject submissions.