// biome-ignore-all lint/suspicious/noTemplateCurlyInString: the fixtures below are SOURCE TEXT — a // `${…}` in one is the code under test, never an interpolation that went missing. // The floor under `x verify`'s errors step: the three shapes that shipped must be reported, a value // already routed through a total renderer must not be, and the mask must survive an escaped // delimiter — a template whose end is read wrong is a `${…}` nobody checks. A false positive here // is a rule an agent learns to skip; a miss is the bug that shipped three times. import { afterAll, beforeAll, describe, expect, test } from 'bun:test'; // why: Bun ships no `Bun.*` equivalent — `mkdtemp`/`rm` own a fixture root the scan reads. import { mkdtemp, rm } from 'node:fs/promises'; // why: Bun exposes no tmpdir(), so only node:os answers the platform temp root. import { tmpdir } from 'node:os'; // why: Bun exposes no path-join primitive. import { join } from 'node:path'; import { checkFile, errorRendering, maskToCode, mayRenderUnknown, topLevelSegments, unsafeRenderFindingFor, } from './error-render'; const scan = (source: string) => checkFile({ path: 'packages/x/src/errors.ts', source }); describe('checkErrorRendering catches the shape that shipped three times', () => { test('JSON.stringify of an unknown parameter in a cause', () => { // The real one: packages/ui/src/errors.ts, verbatim shape. const found = scan(` export function invalidValueError(kind: string, value: unknown, expected: string): UiError { return new UiError({ code: UI_ERROR_CODES.invalidValue, cause: \`<\${kind}> received \${JSON.stringify(value)}, which is not \${expected}\`, fix: 'pass a value the component can render', }); } `); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('stringify'); expect(found[0]?.binding).toBe('value'); expect(found[0]?.field).toBe('cause'); }); test('a bare unknown interpolated into a cause or a fix', () => { const found = scan(` export const flagExpiryInvalid = (key: string, given: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`\${key} has expiresAt \${given}, which is not a date\`, fix: \`set expiresAt to \${given} in defineFlag()\`, }); `); expect(found.map((one) => one.kind)).toEqual(['interpolation', 'interpolation']); expect(found.map((one) => one.field)).toEqual(['cause', 'fix']); }); test('a bare unknown under a cast, a non-null assertion, parentheses or a ??/|| fallback', () => { // Each renders the value itself: the cast and `!` are erased at runtime, the parentheses are // grouping, and a fallback renders its left operand whenever that is an object. for (const shape of [ 'given as string', 'given!', '(given)', '((given as string))', "given ?? 'none'", "given || 'none'", 'label ?? given', 'label as string || given', 'label as A | B || given', ]) { const found = scan(` export const bad = (label: string, given: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`got \${${shape}}\`, fix: 'x doctor' }); `); expect({ shape, kinds: found.map((one) => one.kind) }).toEqual({ shape, kinds: ['interpolation'], }); } }); test('a fallback, cast or group around a read OF the value is still not the value', () => { for (const shape of [ "(given as Error).message ?? 'none'", 'typeof given', "given instanceof Error ? given.message : 'other'", ]) { const found = scan(` export const fine = (given: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`got \${${shape}}\`, fix: 'x doctor' }); `); expect({ shape, found }).toEqual({ shape, found: [] }); } }); test('String() of an unknown, and a cause built by assignment rather than as a property', () => { const found = scan(` export function toUltimateError(value: unknown): UltimateError { const cause = \`non-error value thrown: \${String(value)}\`; return new InternalError({ cause, fix: 'fix the underlying failure' }); } `); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('conversion'); }); test('the finding names the file, the line and the call to paste', () => { const finding = unsafeRenderFindingFor({ file: 'packages/ui/src/errors.ts', line: 127, field: 'cause', binding: 'value', kind: 'stringify', }); expect(finding.code).toBe('X_ERROR_RENDER_UNSAFE'); expect(finding.at).toBe('packages/ui/src/errors.ts:127'); expect(finding.fix).toContain('renderCauseValue(value)'); expect(finding.cause).toContain('packages/ui/src/errors.ts:127'); }); }); describe('a value laundered through a file-local duck-type helper', () => { test('an arrow helper whose whole body is the duck-type is a render', () => { // The shape that shipped SIX times and the gate could not see, because it followed a direct // interpolation and not a value handed to a local name first. const found = scan(` const describe = (error: unknown): string => error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error); export function prerenderFailed(file: string, error: unknown): RenderError { return new RenderError({ code: 'X_PRERENDER_FAILED', cause: \`\${file} threw while rendering: \${describe(error)}\`, fix: 'run bun test against the component', }); } `); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('conversion'); expect(found[0]?.binding).toBe('error'); }); test('a function-declaration helper of the same shape counts too', () => { const found = scan(` function describe(error: unknown) { return error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error); } export function loadFailed(error: unknown): RenderError { return new RenderError({ code: 'X_ROUTE_LOAD_FAILED', cause: \`load threw: \${describe(error)}\`, fix: 'return a value from load()', }); } `); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('conversion'); }); test('a helper whose `instanceof` and `Error` sit on two lines is still found', () => { // The scan returns early from a file with no `instanceof` in it — 16% of the step's CPU was // this one regex. The early return may not be narrower than the regex: `\s+` spans a newline. const found = scan(` const describe = (error: unknown): string => error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error); export function loadFailed(error: unknown): RenderError { return new RenderError({ code: 'X_ROUTE_LOAD_FAILED', cause: \`load threw: \${describe(error)}\`, fix: 'return a value from load()', }); } `); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('conversion'); }); test('a helper that does real work is NOT a duck-type and is left alone', () => { // Deliberately narrow: a false finding here is a rule an agent learns to skip, which is the // failure this file's header names. const found = scan(` const summarise = (error: unknown): string => renderThrowable(error).slice(0, 80); export function loadFailed(error: unknown): RenderError { return new RenderError({ code: 'X_ROUTE_LOAD_FAILED', cause: \`load threw: \${summarise(error)}\`, fix: 'return a value from load()', }); } `); expect(found).toEqual([]); }); }); describe('what it deliberately lets through', () => { test('a value already routed through a total renderer', () => { expect( scan(` export const tenancyMismatch = (given: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`the row named \${renderCauseValue(given)}\`, fix: \`scope the call to \${renderFixLiteral(given, '')}\`, }); `), ).toEqual([]); }); test('a property of an unknown, which TypeScript has already typed', () => { // `error.message` is a string or the file does not compile. Reporting it would report // every narrowed `unknown` in the framework, and a check like that gets ignored. expect( scan(` export const finalizeFailed = (stage: string, error: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`the "\${stage}" stage threw: \${error instanceof Error ? error.message : 'unknown'}\`, fix: 'return a Response built here', }); `), ).toEqual([]); }); test('a binding of the same name declared as a type field, not a parameter', () => { // `@ultimat3/ai`'s describeFailure: the cast declares `cause?: unknown`, the const that // reaches the message is a narrowed string. expect( scan(` function describeFailure(error: unknown): string { const e = error as { code?: unknown; cause?: unknown }; const cause = typeof e.cause === 'string' ? e.cause : 'unknown'; return \`\${e.code}: \${cause}\`; } `), ).toEqual([]); }); test('the word cause inside a string literal is not a declaration', () => { expect( scan(` export const bad = (version: unknown): E => new E({ fix: 'set a semver "version" in package.json, then: bun run verify' }); `), ).toEqual([]); }); test('a cause in a doc comment', () => { expect( scan(` /** Renders \`cause: \${value}\` for the reader. */ export const doc = (value: unknown): string => 'x'; `), ).toEqual([]); }); }); describe('the mask and the scope', () => { test('a template substitution stays code while the text around it does not', () => { const { code, substitutions } = maskToCode(`const a = \`left \${value} right\`;`); expect(code).toContain('value'); expect(code).not.toContain('left'); expect(substitutions).toHaveLength(1); }); test('a parameter list does not close a segment, so a factory keeps its parameters', () => { const source = `export const f = (value: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`\${value}\` });`; // The whole factory is the first segment: cutting at the `)` that ends the parameter list // would put `value: unknown` in a different scope from the `cause:` that renders it. Asserting // a count instead would assert nothing — a trailing segment is pushed for every input. expect(topLevelSegments(maskToCode(source).code)[0]).toEqual({ start: 0, end: source.length }); expect(scan(source)).toHaveLength(1); }); test('an escaped backtick does not close a template, so a later substitution is still read', () => { const source = ` export const f = (value: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`a \\\` tick, then \${value}\`, fix: 'x' }); `; const found = scan(source); expect(found).toHaveLength(1); expect(found[0]?.kind).toBe('interpolation'); expect(found[0]?.binding).toBe('value'); }); test('a backtick inside a substitution string does not close the template around it', () => { const found = scan(` export const f = (value: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`\${tick('\\\`')} then \${value}\`, fix: 'x' }); `); expect(found.map((one) => one.kind)).toEqual(['interpolation']); }); test('an escaped quote inside a substitution does not swallow the substitutions after it', () => { const found = scan(` export const f = (value: unknown): E => new E({ cause: \`\${label('a\\'b')} then \${value}\`, fix: 'x' }); `); expect(found.map((one) => one.binding)).toEqual(['value']); }); test('a later declaration does not leak into an earlier segment', () => { // @ultimat3/query shipped exactly this: an interface below the class that uses the name. expect( scan(` export class QueryInputInvalidError extends UltimateError { constructor(name: string, detail: string) { super({ cause: \`input for "\${name}" failed: \${detail}\`, fix: 'x queries show' }); } } interface Shape { readonly detail?: unknown } `), ).toEqual([]); }); }); describe('the entry point sees a catch binding', () => { let root = ''; beforeAll(async () => { root = await mkdtemp(join(tmpdir(), 'ultimate-error-render-')); }); afterAll(async () => { await rm(root, { recursive: true, force: true }); }); const write = async (source: string): Promise => { await Bun.write(join(root, 'packages/x/src/thing.ts'), source); }; // The catch half of the rule, through the entry point the command and the gate step both call. // `error-render.ts` reads PARAMETERS typed `unknown`, and a catch binding is neither — so the // half that sees one is `catch-render.ts`, and this is the composition of the two. test('a catch binding rendered into a cause is reported', async () => { await write( [ 'export function readPayload(raw: string): string {', ' try {', ' return JSON.parse(raw) as string;', ' } catch (error) {', ' throw new Error({', ' cause: `unreadable payload: ${error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error)}`,', ' });', ' }', '}', '', ].join('\n'), ); const findings = await errorRendering(root); expect(findings.map((one) => one.code)).toContain('X_CATCH_RENDER_UNSAFE'); }); test('the same value routed through renderThrowable is not', async () => { await write( [ 'export function readPayload(raw: string): string {', ' try {', ' return JSON.parse(raw) as string;', ' } catch (error) {', ' throw new Error({', ' cause: `unreadable payload: ${renderThrowable(error)}`,', ' });', ' }', '}', '', ].join('\n'), ); const findings = await errorRendering(root); expect(findings.map((one) => one.code)).not.toContain('X_CATCH_RENDER_UNSAFE'); }); }); // The pre-filter that skips the mask on most files: it must still see an annotation with a comment // between its `:` and the type, and it must answer in linear time on any text a file can hold. describe('the pre-filter: an `unknown` annotation and a `cause`/`fix` key', () => { test('a block or line comment between the `:` and the type is still an annotation', () => { for (const annotation of [ ': unknown', ':/* x */unknown', ': /** a ** b */ any', ':// c\n unknown', ]) expect(mayRenderUnknown(`(e${annotation}) => ({ cause: e })`), annotation).toBe(true); expect(mayRenderUnknown('(e: unknownish) => ({ cause: e })')).toBe(false); expect(mayRenderUnknown('(e: unknown) => ({ reason: e })')).toBe(false); // A comment ends at its first `*/`: what follows it is code, not more comment. expect(mayRenderUnknown('(e:/* a */ x /* b */unknown) => ({ cause: e })')).toBe(false); }); test('linear on `:/*` and many `*//*`, where a lazy comment body backtracks exponentially', () => { const started = performance.now(); expect(mayRenderUnknown(`cause:/*${'*//*'.repeat(40)}`)).toBe(false); expect(performance.now() - started).toBeLessThan(1_000); }); });