{ "kind": "dexagon.ainglish.snapshot-live-view-comprehension-carrier.v1", "proposal_revision": "send-snapshot-version-ref-to-recipient-grant-live-view", "sha256": "26ec5c7674b5c0a54e3543a1e415e46b534c7647213d060c3d68d388bfcbbfc3", "population": "144 fresh topology/consequence rows: 72 per form across six domains, four consequence events and three boundary probes, plus eight target-independent controls", "aggregation": "equal-weight mean of twelve load-bearing form-by-domain strata; forty-eight form-by-domain-by-consequence cells, both question components, and every boundary-probe cell remain in public sidecars", "reader_calls": 0, "items": [ { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-001", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-001", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v111 to v115. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v111. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v111 to v115. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v111, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-002", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-002", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v111 to v115. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v111 to v115. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v111.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v115 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-003", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-003", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v112 to v116. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v112. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v112 to v116. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v112, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-004", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-004", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v112 to v116. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v112 to v116. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-005", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-005", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v113 to v117. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v113. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v113 to v117. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v113, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-006", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-006", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v113 to v117. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is edited from v113 to v117. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-007", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-007", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v121. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v121, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-008", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-008", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-009", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-009", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v122. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v122, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-010", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-010", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-011", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-011", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v123. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v123, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-012", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-012", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, the canonical runbook is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-013", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-013", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v131. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v131, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-014", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-014", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-015", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-015", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v132. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v132, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-016", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-016", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-017", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-017", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v133. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v133, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-018", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-018", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. Later, access to the canonical runbook is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-019", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-019", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v145 rather than v141. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v141. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v145 rather than v141. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v141, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-020", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-020", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v145 rather than v141. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v145 rather than v141. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v141.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v145.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-021", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-021", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v146 rather than v142. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v142. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v146 rather than v142. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v142, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-022", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-022", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v146 rather than v142. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v146 rather than v142. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-023", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-023", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v147 rather than v143. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Nia an independent fixed representation of exactly runbook v143. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v147 rather than v143. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(runbook@v143, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-1", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-024", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-024", "english": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v147 rather than v143. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Nia a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object runbook. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named document is the canonical runbook. At a later read, the canonical runbook contains v147 rather than v143. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(runbook, to=Nia).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-1", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-1-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "document", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-025", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-025", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v211 to v215. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v211. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v211 to v215. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v211, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-026", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-026", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v211 to v215. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v211 to v215. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v211.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v215 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-027", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-027", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v212 to v216. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v212. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v212 to v216. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v212, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-028", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-028", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v212 to v216. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v212 to v216. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-029", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-029", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v213 to v217. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v213. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v213 to v217. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v213, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-030", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-030", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v213 to v217. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is edited from v213 to v217. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-031", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-031", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v221. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v221, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-032", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-032", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-033", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-033", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v222. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v222, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-034", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-034", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-035", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-035", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v223. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v223, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-036", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-036", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, the canonical capacity-sheet is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-037", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-037", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v231. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v231, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-038", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-038", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-039", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-039", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v232. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v232, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-040", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-040", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-041", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-041", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v233. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v233, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-042", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-042", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. Later, access to the canonical capacity-sheet is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-043", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-043", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v245 rather than v241. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v241. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v245 rather than v241. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v241, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-044", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-044", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v245 rather than v241. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v245 rather than v241. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v241.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v245.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-045", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-045", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v246 rather than v242. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v242. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v246 rather than v242. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v242, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-046", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-046", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v246 rather than v242. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v246 rather than v242. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-047", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-047", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v247 rather than v243. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Oren an independent fixed representation of exactly capacity-sheet v243. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v247 rather than v243. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(capacity-sheet@v243, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-2", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-048", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-048", "english": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v247 rather than v243. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Oren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object capacity-sheet. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named spreadsheet is the canonical capacity-sheet. At a later read, the canonical capacity-sheet contains v247 rather than v243. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(capacity-sheet, to=Oren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-2", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-2-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "spreadsheet", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-049", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-049", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v311 to v315. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v311. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v311 to v315. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v311, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-050", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-050", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v311 to v315. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v311 to v315. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v311.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v315 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-051", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-051", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v312 to v316. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v312. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v312 to v316. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v312, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-052", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-052", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v312 to v316. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v312 to v316. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-053", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-053", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v313 to v317. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v313. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v313 to v317. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v313, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-054", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-054", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v313 to v317. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is edited from v313 to v317. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-055", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-055", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v321. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v321, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-056", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-056", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-057", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-057", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v322. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v322, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-058", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-058", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-059", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-059", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v323. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v323, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-060", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-060", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, the canonical release-bundle is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-061", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-061", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v331. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v331, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-062", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-062", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-063", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-063", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v332. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v332, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-064", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-064", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-065", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-065", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v333. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v333, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-066", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-066", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. Later, access to the canonical release-bundle is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-067", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-067", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v345 rather than v341. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v341. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v345 rather than v341. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v341, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-068", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-068", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v345 rather than v341. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v345 rather than v341. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v341.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v345.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-069", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-069", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v346 rather than v342. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v342. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v346 rather than v342. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v342, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-070", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-070", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v346 rather than v342. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v346 rather than v342. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-071", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-071", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v347 rather than v343. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Pava an independent fixed representation of exactly release-bundle v343. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v347 rather than v343. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(release-bundle@v343, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-3", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-072", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-072", "english": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v347 rather than v343. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Pava a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object release-bundle. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named code artifact is the canonical release-bundle. At a later read, the canonical release-bundle contains v347 rather than v343. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(release-bundle, to=Pava).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-3", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-3-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "code artifact", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-073", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-073", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v411 to v415. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v411. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v411 to v415. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v411, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-074", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-074", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v411 to v415. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v411 to v415. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v411.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v415 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-075", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-075", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v412 to v416. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v412. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v412 to v416. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v412, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-076", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-076", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v412 to v416. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v412 to v416. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-077", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-077", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v413 to v417. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v413. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v413 to v417. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v413, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-078", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-078", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v413 to v417. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is edited from v413 to v417. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-079", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-079", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v421. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v421, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-080", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-080", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-081", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-081", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v422. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v422, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-082", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-082", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-083", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-083", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v423. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v423, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-084", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-084", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, the canonical incident-board is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-085", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-085", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v431. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v431, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-086", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-086", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-087", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-087", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v432. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v432, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-088", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-088", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-089", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-089", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v433. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v433, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-090", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-090", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. Later, access to the canonical incident-board is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-091", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-091", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v445 rather than v441. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v441. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v445 rather than v441. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v441, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-092", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-092", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v445 rather than v441. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v445 rather than v441. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v441.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v445.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-093", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-093", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v446 rather than v442. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v442. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v446 rather than v442. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v442, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-094", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-094", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v446 rather than v442. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v446 rather than v442. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-095", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-095", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v447 rather than v443. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Quin an independent fixed representation of exactly incident-board v443. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v447 rather than v443. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(incident-board@v443, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-4", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-096", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-096", "english": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v447 rather than v443. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Quin a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object incident-board. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named dashboard is the canonical incident-board. At a later read, the canonical incident-board contains v447 rather than v443. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(incident-board, to=Quin).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-4", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-4-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "dashboard", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-097", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-097", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v511 to v515. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v511. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v511 to v515. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v511, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-098", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-098", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v511 to v515. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v511 to v515. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v511.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v515 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-099", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-099", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v512 to v516. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v512. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v512 to v516. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v512, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-100", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-100", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v512 to v516. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v512 to v516. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-101", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-101", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v513 to v517. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v513. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v513 to v517. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v513, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-102", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-102", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v513 to v517. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is edited from v513 to v517. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-103", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-103", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v521. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v521, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-104", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-104", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-105", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-105", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v522. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v522, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-106", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-106", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-107", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-107", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v523. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v523, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-108", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-108", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, the canonical training-video is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-109", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-109", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v531. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v531, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-110", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-110", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-111", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-111", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v532. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v532, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-112", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-112", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-113", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-113", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v533. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v533, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-114", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-114", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. Later, access to the canonical training-video is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-115", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-115", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v545 rather than v541. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v541. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v545 rather than v541. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v541, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-116", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-116", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v545 rather than v541. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v545 rather than v541. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v541.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v545.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-117", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-117", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v546 rather than v542. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v542. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v546 rather than v542. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v542, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-118", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-118", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v546 rather than v542. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v546 rather than v542. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-119", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-119", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v547 rather than v543. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Rhea an independent fixed representation of exactly training-video v543. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v547 rather than v543. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(training-video@v543, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-5", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-120", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-120", "english": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v547 rather than v543. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Rhea a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object training-video. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named media file is the canonical training-video. At a later read, the canonical training-video contains v547 rather than v543. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(training-video, to=Rhea).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-5", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-5-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "media file", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-121", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-121", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v611 to v615. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v611. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v611 to v615. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v611, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-122", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-122", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v611 to v615. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v611 to v615. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the recipient-visible content stays at v611.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful later read shows the current v615 contents.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-123", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-123", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v612 to v616. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v612. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v612 to v616. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v612, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-124", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-124", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v612 to v616. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v612 to v616. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-125", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-125", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v613 to v617. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v613. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v613 to v617. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v613, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-126", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-126", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v613 to v617. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is edited from v613 to v617. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-edit", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-edit", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-127", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-127", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v621. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v621, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-128", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-128", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source deletion.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the source-backed permission cannot retrieve the deleted object.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-129", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-129", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v622. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v622, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-130", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-130", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-131", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-131", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v623. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v623, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-132", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-132", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, the canonical retention-policy is deleted from its source service. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-source-deletion", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "source-deletion", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-133", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-133", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v631. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v631, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-134", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-134", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the delivered and retained representation remains available after source access is revoked.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: future access through the revoked permission is denied.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-135", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-135", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v632. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v632, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-136", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-136", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-137", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-137", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v633. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v633, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-138", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-138", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. Later, access to the canonical retention-policy is revoked for the recipient. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-grant-revocation", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "grant-revocation", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-139", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-139", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v645 rather than v641. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v641. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v645 rather than v641. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v641, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-140", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-140", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v645 rather than v641. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v645 rather than v641. For a fixed transfer, delivery and retention succeed; for a live grant, no independent copy or alternative grant exists. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: opening the retained representation shows v641.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "snapshot", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: a successful read dereferences the canonical object and shows v645.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "live-view", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "core" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-141", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-141", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v646 rather than v642. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v642. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v646 rather than v642. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v642, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-142", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-142", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v646 rather than v642. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v646 rather than v642. The recipient already holds a separate copy under another authority; the instruction says nothing else about edit or redistribution rights. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: no edit or redistribution right follows, and a separately authorised copy is unaffected.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: edit and redistribution rights follow, and every separately authorised copy is erased.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "authority-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-143", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-143", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v647 rather than v643. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send Soren an independent fixed representation of exactly retention-policy v643. Do not grant continuing access to the source. Later source changes, deletion, or revocation cannot alter or withdraw a delivered and retained representation. Sending does not itself prove receipt.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v647 rather than v643. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: send-snapshot(retention-policy@v643, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability." ], "answer": "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "send-snapshot-6", "report_cell": "send-snapshot-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "send-snapshot", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-fresh-144", "scenario_id": "snapshot-live-scenario-144", "english": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v647 rather than v643. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant Soren a revocable read-only capability to the stable canonical object retention-policy. Each successful read shows its then-current contents. Do not intentionally transfer a durable independent copy. This grants no edit or redistribution right and does not prove that the object was opened.", "ainglish": "The named policy record is the canonical retention-policy. At a later read, the canonical retention-policy contains v647 rather than v643. No receipt, opening audit, or service-reachability observation is available. Instruction: grant-live-view(retention-policy, to=Soren).", "question": "Answer both questions by choosing the one option with both answers correct. (1) Which implementation satisfies the instruction? (2) What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?", "questions": [ "Which implementation satisfies the instruction?", "What later consequence or authority/evidence boundary follows?" ], "options": [ "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.", "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event." ], "answer": "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.", "option_components": { "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: transmit an independent representation of the named frozen version. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "snapshot", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": false, "consequence_correct": false }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction alone proves no later receipt, retention, opening, or service-reachability event.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "conservative", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": true }, "Implementation: grant revocable read-only access to the canonical object. Consequence or boundary: the instruction itself proves receipt, retention, opening, and service reachability.": { "implementation": "live-view", "consequence": "overclaim", "implementation_correct": true, "consequence_correct": false } }, "settlement_stratum": "grant-live-view-6", "report_cell": "grant-live-view-6-later-read", "strata": { "form": "grant-live-view", "domain": "policy record", "event": "later-read", "probe": "evidence-boundary" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-01", "english": "Either Ula or Venn owns the rollback.", "ainglish": "Ula, not Venn, owns the rollback.", "question": "Who owns the rollback?", "options": [ "Venn", "cannot tell", "Ula" ], "answer": "Ula", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "owner" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-02", "english": "The active mirror is in either Bern or Quito.", "ainglish": "The active mirror is in Quito, not Bern.", "question": "Where is the active mirror?", "options": [ "Bern", "Quito", "cannot tell" ], "answer": "Quito", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "region" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-03", "english": "The lease is either current or expired.", "ainglish": "The lease is expired, not current.", "question": "What is the lease state?", "options": [ "cannot tell", "expired", "current" ], "answer": "expired", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "state" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-04", "english": "Either a stale key or a full queue caused the fault.", "ainglish": "A stale key, not a full queue, caused the fault.", "question": "What caused the fault?", "options": [ "a full queue", "a stale key", "cannot tell" ], "answer": "a stale key", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "cause" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-05", "english": "The copper job ran either before or after the jade job.", "ainglish": "The copper job ran after, not before, the jade job.", "question": "When did the copper job run?", "options": [ "after", "cannot tell", "before" ], "answer": "after", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "order" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-06", "english": "The batch contains either six or eleven records.", "ainglish": "The batch contains six records, not eleven.", "question": "How many records are present?", "options": [ "eleven", "six", "cannot tell" ], "answer": "six", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "count" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-07", "english": "Either Wira or Xeno signed the receipt.", "ainglish": "Xeno, not Wira, signed the receipt.", "question": "Who signed the receipt?", "options": [ "cannot tell", "Wira", "Xeno" ], "answer": "Xeno", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "actor" } }, { "id": "snapshot-live-cal-08", "english": "The flag is either coral or indigo.", "ainglish": "The flag is coral, not indigo.", "question": "What colour is the flag?", "options": [ "coral", "indigo", "cannot tell" ], "answer": "coral", "calibration": true, "calibration_scope": "target-independent", "strata": { "control": "colour" } } ] }