{ "kind": "dexagon.ainglish.overnight-comprehension-carrier.v1", "proposal_revision": "cause-question-event-ref-justification-question-action-ref", "construct": "cause-question / justification-question", "comparison": "registered compact form versus the committed comparator named per item", "reader_calls": 0, "items": [ { "id": "why-cause-question-001", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-200@evt-10? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-200@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-200@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-002", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-201@evt-11?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-201@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-201@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-003", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-202@evt-12? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-202@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-202@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-004", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-203@evt-13?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-203@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-203@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-005", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-204@evt-14? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-204@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-204@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-006", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-205@evt-15?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-205@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-205@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-007", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-206@evt-16? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-206@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-206@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-008", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-207@evt-17?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-207@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-207@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-009", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-208@evt-18? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-208@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-208@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-010", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-209@evt-19?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-209@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-209@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-011", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-210@evt-20? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-210@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-210@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-012", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-211@evt-21?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-211@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-211@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-013", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-212@evt-22? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-212@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-212@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-014", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-213@evt-23?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-213@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-213@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-015", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-214@evt-24? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-214@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-214@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-016", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-215@evt-25?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-215@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-215@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-017", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-216@evt-26? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-216@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-216@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-018", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-217@evt-10?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-217@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-217@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-019", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-218@evt-11? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-218@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-218@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-020", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-219@evt-12?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-219@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-219@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-021", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-220@evt-13? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-220@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-220@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-022", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-221@evt-14?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-221@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-221@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-023", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-222@evt-15? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-222@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-222@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-024", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-223@evt-16?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-223@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-223@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-025", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-224@evt-17? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-224@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-224@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-026", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-225@evt-18?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-225@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-225@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-027", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-226@evt-19? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-226@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-226@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-028", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-227@evt-20?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-227@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-227@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-029", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-228@evt-21? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-228@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-228@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-030", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-229@evt-22?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-229@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-229@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-031", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-230@evt-23? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-230@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-230@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-032", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-231@evt-24?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-231@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-231@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-033", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-232@evt-25? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-232@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-232@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-034", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-233@evt-26?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-233@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-233@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-035", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-234@evt-10? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-234@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-234@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-036", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-235@evt-11?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-235@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-235@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-037", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-236@evt-12? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-236@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-236@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-038", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-237@evt-13?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-237@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-237@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-039", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-238@evt-14? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-238@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-238@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-040", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-239@evt-15?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-239@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-239@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-041", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-240@evt-16? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-240@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-240@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-042", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-241@evt-17?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-241@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-241@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-043", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-242@evt-18? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-242@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-242@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-044", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-243@evt-19?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-243@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-243@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-045", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-244@evt-20? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-244@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-244@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-046", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-245@evt-21?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-245@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-245@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-047", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-246@evt-22? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-246@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-246@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-048", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-247@evt-23?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-247@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-247@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-049", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-248@evt-24? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-248@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-248@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-050", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-249@evt-25?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-249@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-249@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-051", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-250@evt-26? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-250@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-250@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-052", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-251@evt-10?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-251@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-251@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-053", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-252@evt-11? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-252@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-252@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-054", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-253@evt-12?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-253@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-253@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-055", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-254@evt-13? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-254@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-254@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-056", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-255@evt-14?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-255@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-255@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-057", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-256@evt-15? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-256@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-256@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-058", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-257@evt-16?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-257@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-257@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-059", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-258@evt-17? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-258@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-258@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-060", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-259@evt-18?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-259@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-259@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-061", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-260@evt-19? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-260@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-260@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-062", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-261@evt-20?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-261@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-261@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-063", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-262@evt-21? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-262@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-262@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-064", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-263@evt-22?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-263@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-263@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-065", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-264@evt-23? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-264@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-264@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-066", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-265@evt-24?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-265@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-265@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-067", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-266@evt-25? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-266@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-266@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-068", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-267@evt-26?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-267@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-267@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-069", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-268@evt-10? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-268@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-268@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-070", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-269@evt-11?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-269@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-269@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-071", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-270@evt-12? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-270@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-270@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-072", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-271@evt-13?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-271@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-271@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-073", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact service restart event restart-272@evt-14? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(restart-272@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-272@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-074", "english": "Why did Bela perform file deletion delete-273@evt-15?", "ainglish": "cause-question(delete-273@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-273@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-075", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact deployment rollback event rollback-274@evt-16? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(rollback-274@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-274@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-076", "english": "Why did Dina perform account suspension suspend-275@evt-17?", "ainglish": "cause-question(suspend-275@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-275@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-077", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact payment refund event refund-276@evt-18? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(refund-276@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-276@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-078", "english": "Why did Faye perform meeting cancellation cancel-277@evt-19?", "ainglish": "cause-question(cancel-277@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-277@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-079", "english": "What triggers, inputs, state transitions, decisions, or faults produced exact credential revocation event revoke-278@evt-20? This asks for mechanism, not whether the event was warranted.", "ainglish": "cause-question(revoke-278@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-278@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-cause-question-080", "english": "Why did Hana perform emergency shutdown shutdown-279@evt-21?", "ainglish": "cause-question(shutdown-279@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the triggers, inputs, state transitions, or process that produced the event", "form": "cause-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "cause-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-279@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-001", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-200@evt-10 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-200@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-200@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-002", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-201@evt-11?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-201@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-201@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-003", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-202@evt-12 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-202@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-202@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-004", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-203@evt-13?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-203@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-203@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-005", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-204@evt-14 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-204@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-204@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-006", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-205@evt-15?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-205@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-205@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-007", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-206@evt-16 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-206@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-206@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-008", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-207@evt-17?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-207@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-207@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-009", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-208@evt-18 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-208@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-208@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-010", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-209@evt-19?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-209@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-209@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-011", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-210@evt-20 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-210@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-210@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-012", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-211@evt-21?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-211@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-211@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-013", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-212@evt-22 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-212@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-212@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-014", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-213@evt-23?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-213@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-213@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-015", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-214@evt-24 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-214@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-214@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-016", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-215@evt-25?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-215@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-215@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-017", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-216@evt-26 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-216@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-216@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-018", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-217@evt-10?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-217@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-217@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-019", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-218@evt-11 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-218@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-218@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-020", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-219@evt-12?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-219@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-219@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-021", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-220@evt-13 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-220@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-220@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-022", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-221@evt-14?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-221@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-221@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-023", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-222@evt-15 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-222@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-222@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-024", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-223@evt-16?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-223@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-223@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-025", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-224@evt-17 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-224@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-224@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-026", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-225@evt-18?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-225@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-225@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-027", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-226@evt-19 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-226@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-226@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-028", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-227@evt-20?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-227@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-227@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-029", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-228@evt-21 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-228@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-228@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-030", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-229@evt-22?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-229@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-229@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-031", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-230@evt-23 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-230@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-230@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-032", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-231@evt-24?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-231@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-231@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-033", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-232@evt-25 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-232@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-232@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-034", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-233@evt-26?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-233@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-233@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-035", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-234@evt-10 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-234@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-234@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-036", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-235@evt-11?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-235@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-235@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-037", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-236@evt-12 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-236@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-236@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-038", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-237@evt-13?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-237@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-237@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-039", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-238@evt-14 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-238@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-238@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-040", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-239@evt-15?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-239@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-239@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-041", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-240@evt-16 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-240@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-240@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-042", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-241@evt-17?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-241@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-241@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-043", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-242@evt-18 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-242@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-242@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-044", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-243@evt-19?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-243@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-243@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-045", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-244@evt-20 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-244@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-244@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-046", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-245@evt-21?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-245@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-245@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-047", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-246@evt-22 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-246@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-246@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-048", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-247@evt-23?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-247@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-247@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-049", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-248@evt-24 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-248@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-248@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-050", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-249@evt-25?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-249@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-249@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-051", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-250@evt-26 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-250@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-250@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-052", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-251@evt-10?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-251@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-251@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-053", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-252@evt-11 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-252@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-252@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-054", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-253@evt-12?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-253@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-253@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-055", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-254@evt-13 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-254@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-254@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-056", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-255@evt-14?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-255@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-255@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-057", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-256@evt-15 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-256@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-256@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-058", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-257@evt-16?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-257@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-257@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-059", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-258@evt-17 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-258@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-258@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-060", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-259@evt-18?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-259@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-259@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-061", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-260@evt-19 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-260@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-260@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-062", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-261@evt-20?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-261@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-261@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-063", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-262@evt-21 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-262@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-262@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-064", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-263@evt-22?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-263@evt-22)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-263@evt-22" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-065", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-264@evt-23 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-264@evt-23)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-264@evt-23" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-066", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-265@evt-24?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-265@evt-24)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-265@evt-24" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-067", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-266@evt-25 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-266@evt-25)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-266@evt-25" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-068", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-267@evt-26?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-267@evt-26)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-267@evt-26" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-069", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-268@evt-10 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-268@evt-10)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-268@evt-10" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-070", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-269@evt-11?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-269@evt-11)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-269@evt-11" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-071", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-270@evt-12 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-270@evt-12)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-270@evt-12" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-072", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-271@evt-13?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-271@evt-13)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-271@evt-13" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-073", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Cato's exact service restart action restart-272@evt-14 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(restart-272@evt-14)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "incident response", "intentionality": "known cause; no valid warrant", "reference": "restart-272@evt-14" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-074", "english": "Why did Dina perform file deletion delete-273@evt-15?", "ainglish": "justification-question(delete-273@evt-15)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "file operation", "intentionality": "valid warrant; proximate cause unknown", "reference": "delete-273@evt-15" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-075", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Eli's exact deployment rollback action rollback-274@evt-16 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(rollback-274@evt-16)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "deployment", "intentionality": "one fact may be both cause and warrant", "reference": "rollback-274@evt-16" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-076", "english": "Why did Faye perform account suspension suspend-275@evt-17?", "ainglish": "justification-question(suspend-275@evt-17)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "moderation", "intentionality": "accidental event; no attributable choice", "reference": "suspend-275@evt-17" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-077", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Gus's exact payment refund action refund-276@evt-18 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(refund-276@evt-18)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "payments", "intentionality": "coercion", "reference": "refund-276@evt-18" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-078", "english": "Why did Hana perform meeting cancellation cancel-277@evt-19?", "ainglish": "justification-question(cancel-277@evt-19)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "scheduling", "intentionality": "automation executing a policy", "reference": "cancel-277@evt-19" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-079", "english": "What rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off, if any, made Ari's exact credential revocation action revoke-278@evt-20 warranted? 'No valid basis' is a responsive answer; mechanism is not requested.", "ainglish": "justification-question(revoke-278@evt-20)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "careful", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-careful", "strata": { "domain": "access control", "intentionality": "authorized act produced by a bug", "reference": "revoke-278@evt-20" } }, { "id": "why-justification-question-080", "english": "Why did Bela perform emergency shutdown shutdown-279@evt-21?", "ainglish": "justification-question(shutdown-279@evt-21)?", "question": "Which kind of answer directly satisfies this question without adding a relation it did not request?", "options": [ "the identity of whoever should be blamed", "a promise that the event will be reversed", "both mechanism and valid warrant are presupposed by the question", "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did" ], "answer": "the rule, authority, obligation, goal, value, or trade-off that warranted the action, including that none did", "form": "justification-question", "comparator": "bare", "settlement_stratum": "justification-question-bare", "strata": { "domain": "safety", "intentionality": "unjustified act with a complete trace", "reference": "shutdown-279@evt-21" } }, { "id": "why-cal-01", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the amber token, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the amber token is in locker 17.", "question": "Where does the note state that the amber token is?", "options": [ "locker 17", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated" ], "answer": "locker 17", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-02", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the blue key, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the blue key is in drawer 22.", "question": "Where does the note state that the blue key is?", "options": [ "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "drawer 22" ], "answer": "drawer 22", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-03", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the cedar card, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the cedar card is in cabinet 14.", "question": "Where does the note state that the cedar card is?", "options": [ "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "cabinet 14", "the dispatch desk" ], "answer": "cabinet 14", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-04", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the dune badge, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the dune badge is in vault 19.", "question": "Where does the note state that the dune badge is?", "options": [ "the location is not stated", "vault 19", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room" ], "answer": "vault 19", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-05", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the elm seal, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the elm seal is in locker 23.", "question": "Where does the note state that the elm seal is?", "options": [ "locker 23", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated" ], "answer": "locker 23", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-06", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the flint pass, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the flint pass is in drawer 25.", "question": "Where does the note state that the flint pass is?", "options": [ "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "drawer 25" ], "answer": "drawer 25", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-07", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the granite tag, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the granite tag is in cabinet 18.", "question": "Where does the note state that the granite tag is?", "options": [ "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "cabinet 18", "the dispatch desk" ], "answer": "cabinet 18", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-08", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the hazel chip, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the hazel chip is in vault 12.", "question": "Where does the note state that the hazel chip is?", "options": [ "the location is not stated", "vault 12", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room" ], "answer": "vault 12", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-09", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the indigo note, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the indigo note is in locker 21.", "question": "Where does the note state that the indigo note is?", "options": [ "locker 21", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated" ], "answer": "locker 21", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-10", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the jade disk, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the jade disk is in drawer 15.", "question": "Where does the note state that the jade disk is?", "options": [ "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "drawer 15" ], "answer": "drawer 15", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-11", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the kelp token, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the kelp token is in cabinet 24.", "question": "Where does the note state that the kelp token is?", "options": [ "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "cabinet 24", "the dispatch desk" ], "answer": "cabinet 24", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-12", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the linen key, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the linen key is in vault 16.", "question": "Where does the note state that the linen key is?", "options": [ "the location is not stated", "vault 16", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room" ], "answer": "vault 16", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-13", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the maple card, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the maple card is in locker 13.", "question": "Where does the note state that the maple card is?", "options": [ "locker 13", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated" ], "answer": "locker 13", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-14", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the nickel badge, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the nickel badge is in drawer 20.", "question": "Where does the note state that the nickel badge is?", "options": [ "the dispatch desk", "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "drawer 20" ], "answer": "drawer 20", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-15", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the ochre seal, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the ochre seal is in cabinet 11.", "question": "Where does the note state that the ochre seal is?", "options": [ "the archive room", "the location is not stated", "cabinet 11", "the dispatch desk" ], "answer": "cabinet 11", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" }, { "id": "why-cal-16", "calibration": true, "english": "A sealed inventory note mentions the pearl pass, but gives no location.", "ainglish": "A sealed inventory note states that the pearl pass is in vault 26.", "question": "Where does the note state that the pearl pass is?", "options": [ "the location is not stated", "vault 26", "the dispatch desk", "the archive room" ], "answer": "vault 26", "probe": "construct-free explicit-location planted effect" } ] }