{
  "kind": "dexagon.by_withheld.comprehension_replication_items.v1",
  "seed": 2026082404,
  "sha256": "1f8607906baa30a1a6f2f9ef472c57d8c146dcd22e4d9c92787f0c86d51dc849",
  "design": "24 fresh scored scenarios across six domains and four lossless careful-English glosses, plus eight both-arm calibration rows.",
  "items": [
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-incident-01",
      "english": "The emergency override was approved. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The emergency override was approved by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "incident",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-incident-02",
      "english": "The audit record was deleted. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The audit record was deleted by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "incident",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-incident-03",
      "english": "The service was restarted. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The service was restarted by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "incident",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-incident-04",
      "english": "The recovery key was rotated. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The recovery key was rotated by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "incident",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-finance-05",
      "english": "The transfer was authorized. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The transfer was authorized by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "finance",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-finance-06",
      "english": "The refund was issued. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The refund was issued by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "finance",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-finance-07",
      "english": "The invoice was adjusted. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The invoice was adjusted by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "finance",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-finance-08",
      "english": "The credit limit was raised. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The credit limit was raised by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "finance",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-research-09",
      "english": "The sample was relabelled. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The sample was relabelled by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "research",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-research-10",
      "english": "The measurement was excluded. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The measurement was excluded by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "research",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-research-11",
      "english": "The dataset was amended. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The dataset was amended by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "research",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-research-12",
      "english": "The result was corrected. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The result was corrected by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "research",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-operations-13",
      "english": "The deployment was cancelled. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The deployment was cancelled by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "operations",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-operations-14",
      "english": "The reservation was moved. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The reservation was moved by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "operations",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-operations-15",
      "english": "The shipment was rerouted. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The shipment was rerouted by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "operations",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-operations-16",
      "english": "The maintenance window was extended. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The maintenance window was extended by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "operations",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-moderation-17",
      "english": "The comment was removed. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The comment was removed by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "moderation",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-moderation-18",
      "english": "The account was suspended. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The account was suspended by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "moderation",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-moderation-19",
      "english": "The appeal was denied. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The appeal was denied by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "moderation",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-moderation-20",
      "english": "The warning was issued. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The warning was issued by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "moderation",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-governance-21",
      "english": "The ballot was invalidated. The report's writer knows who did this and intentionally omits that identity.",
      "ainglish": "The ballot was invalidated by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "governance",
      "gloss_variant": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-governance-22",
      "english": "The proposal was edited. The author could name the actor but has chosen not to disclose them.",
      "ainglish": "The proposal was edited by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "governance",
      "gloss_variant": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-governance-23",
      "english": "The delegation was revoked. The actor's identity is known to the writer and withheld from this message.",
      "ainglish": "The delegation was revoked by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "governance",
      "gloss_variant": 3
    },
    {
      "id": "dex-withheld-governance-24",
      "english": "The threshold was changed. The writer has the actor's identity but does not reveal it here.",
      "ainglish": "The threshold was changed by-withheld.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "domain": "governance",
      "gloss_variant": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-quarantine",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The package was quarantined.",
      "ainglish": "The package was quarantined. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-rollout",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The rollout was paused.",
      "ainglish": "The rollout was paused. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-contract",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The contract was approved.",
      "ainglish": "The contract was approved. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-docket",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The docket entry was withdrawn.",
      "ainglish": "The docket entry was withdrawn. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-certificate",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The certificate was revoked.",
      "ainglish": "The certificate was revoked. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-backup",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The backup was restored.",
      "ainglish": "The backup was restored. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-claim",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The claim was rejected.",
      "ainglish": "The claim was rejected. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    },
    {
      "id": "cal-endpoint",
      "calibration": true,
      "english": "The endpoint was disabled.",
      "ainglish": "The endpoint was disabled. The report's author knows who did it and can be asked for disclosure or authorization.",
      "question": "If the responder needs the actor's identity, which first route does this sentence support?",
      "options": [
        "search independent records because the author does not know",
        "neither route is supported by this sentence",
        "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization"
      ],
      "answer": "ask the report's author for disclosure or authorization",
      "marker": "by-withheld",
      "set": "heldout_explicit-author-route_positive_control"
    }
  ]
}