{ "sha256": "a45cfd1b5a6635f4df61ffe3119722ed12207654e2902e3dc2c0544e0a670c08", "design": "fresh different-manifest replication of 0ad586c99e429f93234d7ab45c25be06a578585e219ba56236409a3305c97cd2; endpoints-present detectability, writer intent additive, 16 clean / 8 relative-collision / 8 break-both", "items": [ { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-01-drone", "english": "Field bulletin: the drone inspection coverage rose by 7% during the comparison window, from 34% to 41%.", "ainglish": "Field bulletin: the drone inspection coverage rose by 7 percentage points during the comparison window, from 34% to 41%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 34, "delta_pp": 7, "final_stated": 41, "final_additive": 41, "final_relative": 36.38 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Field bulletin: the drone inspection coverage rose by 7 percentage points during the comparison window, from 34% to 41%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-02-archive", "english": "Verification memo: the archive checksum pass rate fell by 6% during the comparison window, from 88% to 82%.", "ainglish": "Verification memo: the archive checksum pass rate fell by 6 percentage points during the comparison window, from 88% to 82%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 88, "delta_pp": 6, "final_stated": 82, "final_additive": 82, "final_relative": 82.72 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Verification memo: the archive checksum pass rate fell by 6 percentage points during the comparison window, from 88% to 82%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-03-glossary", "english": "Monthly ledger: the translation glossary match rate rose by 9% during the comparison window, from 43% to 52%.", "ainglish": "Monthly ledger: the translation glossary match rate rose by 9 percentage points during the comparison window, from 43% to 52%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 43, "delta_pp": 9, "final_stated": 52, "final_additive": 52, "final_relative": 46.87 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Monthly ledger: the translation glossary match rate rose by 9 percentage points during the comparison window, from 43% to 52%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-04-cold-chain", "english": "Handoff note: the cold-chain alarm failure rate fell by 4% during the comparison window, from 17% to 13%.", "ainglish": "Handoff note: the cold-chain alarm failure rate fell by 4 percentage points during the comparison window, from 17% to 13%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 17, "delta_pp": 4, "final_stated": 13, "final_additive": 13, "final_relative": 16.32 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Handoff note: the cold-chain alarm failure rate fell by 4 percentage points during the comparison window, from 17% to 13%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-05-irrigation", "english": "Quality review: the irrigation sensor availability rose by 11% during the comparison window, from 62% to 73%.", "ainglish": "Quality review: the irrigation sensor availability rose by 11 percentage points during the comparison window, from 62% to 73%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 62, "delta_pp": 11, "final_stated": 73, "final_additive": 73, "final_relative": 68.82 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Quality review: the irrigation sensor availability rose by 11 percentage points during the comparison window, from 62% to 73%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-06-grants", "english": "Operations record: the grant application rejection rate fell by 5% during the comparison window, from 29% to 24%.", "ainglish": "Operations record: the grant application rejection rate fell by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 29% to 24%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 29, "delta_pp": 5, "final_stated": 24, "final_additive": 24, "final_relative": 27.55 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Operations record: the grant application rejection rate fell by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 29% to 24%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-07-seismic", "english": "Assessment update: the seismic classifier recall rose by 8% during the comparison window, from 55% to 63%.", "ainglish": "Assessment update: the seismic classifier recall rose by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 55% to 63%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 55, "delta_pp": 8, "final_stated": 63, "final_additive": 63, "final_relative": 59.4 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Assessment update: the seismic classifier recall rose by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 55% to 63%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-08-customs", "english": "Control summary: the customs document error rate fell by 3% during the comparison window, from 14% to 11%.", "ainglish": "Control summary: the customs document error rate fell by 3 percentage points during the comparison window, from 14% to 11%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 14, "delta_pp": 3, "final_stated": 11, "final_additive": 11, "final_relative": 13.58 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Control summary: the customs document error rate fell by 3 percentage points during the comparison window, from 14% to 11%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-09-downlink", "english": "Field bulletin: the satellite downlink completion rate rose by 12% during the comparison window, from 48% to 60%.", "ainglish": "Field bulletin: the satellite downlink completion rate rose by 12 percentage points during the comparison window, from 48% to 60%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 48, "delta_pp": 12, "final_stated": 60, "final_additive": 60, "final_relative": 53.76 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Field bulletin: the satellite downlink completion rate rose by 12 percentage points during the comparison window, from 48% to 60%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-10-inventory", "english": "Verification memo: the library inventory mismatch rate fell by 7% during the comparison window, from 21% to 14%.", "ainglish": "Verification memo: the library inventory mismatch rate fell by 7 percentage points during the comparison window, from 21% to 14%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 21, "delta_pp": 7, "final_stated": 14, "final_additive": 14, "final_relative": 19.53 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Verification memo: the library inventory mismatch rate fell by 7 percentage points during the comparison window, from 21% to 14%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-11-fisheries", "english": "Monthly ledger: the fisheries sample traceability rate rose by 6% during the comparison window, from 71% to 77%.", "ainglish": "Monthly ledger: the fisheries sample traceability rate rose by 6 percentage points during the comparison window, from 71% to 77%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 71, "delta_pp": 6, "final_stated": 77, "final_additive": 77, "final_relative": 75.26 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Monthly ledger: the fisheries sample traceability rate rose by 6 percentage points during the comparison window, from 71% to 77%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-12-legal-intake", "english": "Handoff note: the legal intake abandonment rate fell by 9% during the comparison window, from 33% to 24%.", "ainglish": "Handoff note: the legal intake abandonment rate fell by 9 percentage points during the comparison window, from 33% to 24%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 33, "delta_pp": 9, "final_stated": 24, "final_additive": 24, "final_relative": 30.03 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Handoff note: the legal intake abandonment rate fell by 9 percentage points during the comparison window, from 33% to 24%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-13-museum", "english": "Quality review: the museum image tagging accuracy rose by 5% during the comparison window, from 79% to 84%.", "ainglish": "Quality review: the museum image tagging accuracy rose by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 79% to 84%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 79, "delta_pp": 5, "final_stated": 84, "final_additive": 84, "final_relative": 82.95 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Quality review: the museum image tagging accuracy rose by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 79% to 84%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-14-transit", "english": "Operations record: the transit missed-connection rate fell by 8% during the comparison window, from 26% to 18%.", "ainglish": "Operations record: the transit missed-connection rate fell by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 26% to 18%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 26, "delta_pp": 8, "final_stated": 18, "final_additive": 18, "final_relative": 23.92 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Operations record: the transit missed-connection rate fell by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 26% to 18%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-15-weather", "english": "Assessment update: the weather station reporting rate rose by 10% during the comparison window, from 37% to 47%.", "ainglish": "Assessment update: the weather station reporting rate rose by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 37% to 47%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 37, "delta_pp": 10, "final_stated": 47, "final_additive": 47, "final_relative": 40.7 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Assessment update: the weather station reporting rate rose by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 37% to 47%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-16-escrow", "english": "Control summary: the escrow reconciliation exception rate fell by 4% during the comparison window, from 12% to 8%.", "ainglish": "Control summary: the escrow reconciliation exception rate fell by 4 percentage points during the comparison window, from 12% to 8%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "consistent", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "clean", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 12, "delta_pp": 4, "final_stated": 8, "final_additive": 8, "final_relative": 11.52 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Control summary: the escrow reconciliation exception rate fell by 4 percentage points during the comparison window, from 12% to 8%.", "mutable_field": null }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-17-triage", "english": "Field bulletin: the case triage completion rate rose by 25% during the comparison window, from 40% to 50%.", "ainglish": "Field bulletin: the case triage completion rate rose by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 40% to 50%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 40, "delta_pp": 25, "final_stated": 50, "final_additive": 65, "final_relative": 50.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Field bulletin: the case triage completion rate rose by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 40% to 65%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-18-water", "english": "Verification memo: the water-quality sample rejection rate fell by 15% during the comparison window, from 80% to 68%.", "ainglish": "Verification memo: the water-quality sample rejection rate fell by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 80% to 68%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 80, "delta_pp": 15, "final_stated": 68, "final_additive": 65, "final_relative": 68.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Verification memo: the water-quality sample rejection rate fell by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 80% to 65%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-19-catalogue", "english": "Monthly ledger: the catalogue record enrichment rate rose by 10% during the comparison window, from 60% to 66%.", "ainglish": "Monthly ledger: the catalogue record enrichment rate rose by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 60% to 66%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 60, "delta_pp": 10, "final_stated": 66, "final_additive": 70, "final_relative": 66.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Monthly ledger: the catalogue record enrichment rate rose by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 60% to 70%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-20-permits", "english": "Handoff note: the permit review escalation rate fell by 20% during the comparison window, from 50% to 40%.", "ainglish": "Handoff note: the permit review escalation rate fell by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 50% to 40%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 50, "delta_pp": 20, "final_stated": 40, "final_additive": 30, "final_relative": 40.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Handoff note: the permit review escalation rate fell by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 50% to 30%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-21-habitat", "english": "Quality review: the habitat survey completion rate rose by 25% during the comparison window, from 32% to 40%.", "ainglish": "Quality review: the habitat survey completion rate rose by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 32% to 40%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 32, "delta_pp": 25, "final_stated": 40, "final_additive": 57, "final_relative": 40.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Quality review: the habitat survey completion rate rose by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 32% to 57%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-22-settlement", "english": "Operations record: the trade settlement exception rate fell by 25% during the comparison window, from 72% to 54%.", "ainglish": "Operations record: the trade settlement exception rate fell by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 72% to 54%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 72, "delta_pp": 25, "final_stated": 54, "final_additive": 47, "final_relative": 54.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Operations record: the trade settlement exception rate fell by 25 percentage points during the comparison window, from 72% to 47%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-23-caption", "english": "Assessment update: the lecture caption approval rate rose by 20% during the comparison window, from 45% to 54%.", "ainglish": "Assessment update: the lecture caption approval rate rose by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 45% to 54%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 45, "delta_pp": 20, "final_stated": 54, "final_additive": 65, "final_relative": 54.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Assessment update: the lecture caption approval rate rose by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 45% to 65%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-24-dispatch", "english": "Control summary: the emergency dispatch transfer rate fell by 10% during the comparison window, from 90% to 81%.", "ainglish": "Control summary: the emergency dispatch transfer rate fell by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 90% to 81%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "collision", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 90, "delta_pp": 10, "final_stated": 81, "final_additive": 80, "final_relative": 81.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Control summary: the emergency dispatch transfer rate fell by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 90% to 80%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-25-orchard", "english": "Field bulletin: the orchard disease detection rate rose by 20% during the comparison window, from 25% to 37%.", "ainglish": "Field bulletin: the orchard disease detection rate rose by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 25% to 37%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 25, "delta_pp": 20, "final_stated": 37, "final_additive": 45, "final_relative": 30.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Field bulletin: the orchard disease detection rate rose by 20 percentage points during the comparison window, from 25% to 45%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-26-appeal", "english": "Verification memo: the benefit appeal reversal rate fell by 10% during the comparison window, from 70% to 55%.", "ainglish": "Verification memo: the benefit appeal reversal rate fell by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 70% to 55%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 70, "delta_pp": 10, "final_stated": 55, "final_additive": 60, "final_relative": 63.0 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Verification memo: the benefit appeal reversal rate fell by 10 percentage points during the comparison window, from 70% to 60%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-27-coral", "english": "Monthly ledger: the coral image classification accuracy rose by 15% during the comparison window, from 52% to 73%.", "ainglish": "Monthly ledger: the coral image classification accuracy rose by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 52% to 73%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 52, "delta_pp": 15, "final_stated": 73, "final_additive": 67, "final_relative": 59.8 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Monthly ledger: the coral image classification accuracy rose by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 52% to 67%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-28-freight", "english": "Handoff note: the freight manifest correction rate fell by 5% during the comparison window, from 44% to 35%.", "ainglish": "Handoff note: the freight manifest correction rate fell by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 44% to 35%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 44, "delta_pp": 5, "final_stated": 35, "final_additive": 39, "final_relative": 41.8 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Handoff note: the freight manifest correction rate fell by 5 percentage points during the comparison window, from 44% to 39%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-29-manuscript", "english": "Quality review: the manuscript metadata recovery rate rose by 30% during the comparison window, from 18% to 40%.", "ainglish": "Quality review: the manuscript metadata recovery rate rose by 30 percentage points during the comparison window, from 18% to 40%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 18, "delta_pp": 30, "final_stated": 40, "final_additive": 48, "final_relative": 23.4 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Quality review: the manuscript metadata recovery rate rose by 30 percentage points during the comparison window, from 18% to 48%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-30-vaccination", "english": "Operations record: the vaccination reminder failure rate fell by 12% during the comparison window, from 96% to 76%.", "ainglish": "Operations record: the vaccination reminder failure rate fell by 12 percentage points during the comparison window, from 96% to 76%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 96, "delta_pp": 12, "final_stated": 76, "final_additive": 84, "final_relative": 84.48 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Operations record: the vaccination reminder failure rate fell by 12 percentage points during the comparison window, from 96% to 84%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-31-turbine", "english": "Assessment update: the wind-turbine inspection completion rate rose by 8% during the comparison window, from 67% to 82%.", "ainglish": "Assessment update: the wind-turbine inspection completion rate rose by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 67% to 82%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 67, "delta_pp": 8, "final_stated": 82, "final_additive": 75, "final_relative": 72.36 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Assessment update: the wind-turbine inspection completion rate rose by 8 percentage points during the comparison window, from 67% to 75%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-32-licence", "english": "Control summary: the professional licence renewal lapse rate fell by 15% during the comparison window, from 38% to 19%.", "ainglish": "Control summary: the professional licence renewal lapse rate fell by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 38% to 19%.", "question": "Considering only the numeric claims in this report, are they mutually consistent?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "contradictory", "cell": "endpoints_present", "condition": "break_both", "writer_intent": "additive percentage-point change", "numbers": { "base": 38, "delta_pp": 15, "final_stated": 19, "final_additive": 23, "final_relative": 32.3 }, "clean_twin_marked_arm": "Control summary: the professional licence renewal lapse rate fell by 15 percentage points during the comparison window, from 38% to 23%.", "mutable_field": "final value" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-cal-01", "calibration": true, "english": "The reconciliation note was checked.", "ainglish": "The reconciliation note was checked; its numeric claims were explicitly verified as consistent.", "question": "What verdict about the numeric claims does the note explicitly state?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "consistent" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-cal-02", "calibration": true, "english": "The sampling note was checked.", "ainglish": "The sampling note was checked; its numeric claims were explicitly found contradictory.", "question": "What verdict about the numeric claims does the note explicitly state?", "options": [ "consistent", "contradictory", "cannot be determined" ], "answer": "contradictory" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-cal-03", "calibration": true, "english": "The allocation note was checked.", "ainglish": "The allocation note was checked; its numeric claims were explicitly verified as consistent.", "question": "What verdict about the numeric claims does the note explicitly state?", "options": [ "contradictory", "cannot be determined", "consistent" ], "answer": "consistent" }, { "id": "dex-pp-det-rep-cal-04", "calibration": true, "english": "The retention note was checked.", "ainglish": "The retention note was checked; its numeric claims were explicitly found contradictory.", "question": "What verdict about the numeric claims does the note explicitly state?", "options": [ "cannot be determined", "consistent", "contradictory" ], "answer": "contradictory" } ] }