{ "kind": "ainglish.may-modal.claim-items.v1", "seed": 2026082442, "items": [ { "id": "may-modal-001-active-permission", "english": "A tenant archive is queued for the overnight export. The export worker is permitted to transmit the tenant archive. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A tenant archive is queued for the overnight export. The export worker may-as-permission transmit the tenant archive. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-001", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-001-passive-possibility", "english": "A tenant archive is queued for the overnight export. The tenant archive might be transmitted by the export worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A tenant archive is queued for the overnight export. The tenant archive may-as-possibility be transmitted by the export worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-001", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-002-active-possibility", "english": "A compromised credential remains in the incident workspace. The incident bot might disable the compromised credential. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A compromised credential remains in the incident workspace. The incident bot may-as-possibility disable the compromised credential. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-002", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-002-passive-permission", "english": "A compromised credential remains in the incident workspace. The compromised credential is permitted to be disabled by the incident bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A compromised credential remains in the incident workspace. The compromised credential may-as-permission be disabled by the incident bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-002", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-003-active-permission", "english": "The sealed logs are listed in the quarterly review packet. The auditor is permitted to inspect the sealed logs. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The sealed logs are listed in the quarterly review packet. The auditor may-as-permission inspect the sealed logs. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-003", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-003-passive-possibility", "english": "The sealed logs are listed in the quarterly review packet. The sealed logs might be inspected by the auditor. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The sealed logs are listed in the quarterly review packet. The sealed logs may-as-possibility be inspected by the auditor. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-003", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-004-active-possibility", "english": "Emergency traffic is waiting at the regional gateway. The router might forward the emergency traffic. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "Emergency traffic is waiting at the regional gateway. The router may-as-possibility forward the emergency traffic. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-004", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-004-passive-permission", "english": "Emergency traffic is waiting at the regional gateway. The emergency traffic is permitted to be forwarded by the router. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "Emergency traffic is waiting at the regional gateway. The emergency traffic may-as-permission be forwarded by the router. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-004", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-005-active-permission", "english": "A recovery snapshot is mounted in the archive workspace. The recovery service is permitted to decrypt the recovery snapshot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A recovery snapshot is mounted in the archive workspace. The recovery service may-as-permission decrypt the recovery snapshot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-005", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-005-passive-possibility", "english": "A recovery snapshot is mounted in the archive workspace. The recovery snapshot might be decrypted by the recovery service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A recovery snapshot is mounted in the archive workspace. The recovery snapshot may-as-possibility be decrypted by the recovery service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-005", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-006-active-possibility", "english": "An incident summary is ready in the review folder. The analyst might disclose the incident summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "An incident summary is ready in the review folder. The analyst may-as-possibility disclose the incident summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-006", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-006-passive-permission", "english": "An incident summary is ready in the review folder. The incident summary is permitted to be disclosed by the analyst. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An incident summary is ready in the review folder. The incident summary may-as-permission be disclosed by the analyst. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-006", "strata": { "domain": "security", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-007-active-permission", "english": "A signed package is waiting in the release channel. The release bot is permitted to publish the signed package. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A signed package is waiting in the release channel. The release bot may-as-permission publish the signed package. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-007", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-007-passive-possibility", "english": "A signed package is waiting in the release channel. The signed package might be published by the release bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A signed package is waiting in the release channel. The signed package may-as-possibility be published by the release bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-007", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-008-active-possibility", "english": "The payment queue is stalled behind an old worker. The maintainer might restart the payment queue. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The payment queue is stalled behind an old worker. The maintainer may-as-possibility restart the payment queue. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-008", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-008-passive-permission", "english": "The payment queue is stalled behind an old worker. The payment queue is permitted to be restarted by the maintainer. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The payment queue is stalled behind an old worker. The payment queue may-as-permission be restarted by the maintainer. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-008", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-009-active-permission", "english": "A canary build has completed its smoke checks. The scheduler is permitted to promote the canary build. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A canary build has completed its smoke checks. The scheduler may-as-permission promote the canary build. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-009", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-009-passive-possibility", "english": "A canary build has completed its smoke checks. The canary build might be promoted by the scheduler. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A canary build has completed its smoke checks. The canary build may-as-possibility be promoted by the scheduler. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-009", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-010-active-possibility", "english": "A customer table is named in the migration plan. The migration worker might alter the customer table. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A customer table is named in the migration plan. The migration worker may-as-possibility alter the customer table. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-010", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-010-passive-permission", "english": "A customer table is named in the migration plan. The customer table is permitted to be altered by the migration worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A customer table is named in the migration plan. The customer table may-as-permission be altered by the migration worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-010", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-011-active-permission", "english": "A compromised release is still visible in the package index. The package agent is permitted to revoke the compromised release. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A compromised release is still visible in the package index. The package agent may-as-permission revoke the compromised release. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-011", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-011-passive-possibility", "english": "A compromised release is still visible in the package index. The compromised release might be revoked by the package agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A compromised release is still visible in the package index. The compromised release may-as-possibility be revoked by the package agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-011", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-012-active-possibility", "english": "The search index changed during the latest rollout. The operator might roll back the search index. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The search index changed during the latest rollout. The operator may-as-possibility roll back the search index. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-012", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-012-passive-permission", "english": "The search index changed during the latest rollout. The search index is permitted to be rolled back by the operator. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The search index changed during the latest rollout. The search index may-as-permission be rolled back by the operator. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-012", "strata": { "domain": "deployments", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-013-active-permission", "english": "Expired snapshots remain in the retention batch. The archive service is permitted to purge the expired snapshots. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "Expired snapshots remain in the retention batch. The archive service may-as-permission purge the expired snapshots. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-013", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-013-passive-possibility", "english": "Expired snapshots remain in the retention batch. The expired snapshots might be purged by the archive service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "Expired snapshots remain in the retention batch. The expired snapshots may-as-possibility be purged by the archive service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-013", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-014-active-possibility", "english": "Duplicate records appear in the import staging area. The import worker might delete the duplicate records. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "Duplicate records appear in the import staging area. The import worker may-as-possibility delete the duplicate records. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-014", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-014-passive-permission", "english": "Duplicate records appear in the import staging area. The duplicate records is permitted to be deleted by the import worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "Duplicate records appear in the import staging area. The duplicate records may-as-permission be deleted by the import worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-014", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-015-active-permission", "english": "The search catalog is listed in the maintenance window. The indexer is permitted to rebuild the search catalog. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The search catalog is listed in the maintenance window. The indexer may-as-permission rebuild the search catalog. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-015", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-015-passive-possibility", "english": "The search catalog is listed in the maintenance window. The search catalog might be rebuilt by the indexer. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The search catalog is listed in the maintenance window. The search catalog may-as-possibility be rebuilt by the indexer. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-015", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-016-active-possibility", "english": "A recovery archive is attached to the restoration case. The backup service might read the recovery archive. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A recovery archive is attached to the restoration case. The backup service may-as-possibility read the recovery archive. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-016", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-016-passive-permission", "english": "A recovery archive is attached to the restoration case. The recovery archive is permitted to be read by the backup service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A recovery archive is attached to the restoration case. The recovery archive may-as-permission be read by the backup service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-016", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-017-active-permission", "english": "A case file has reached the end of its active period. The retention bot is permitted to move the case file. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A case file has reached the end of its active period. The retention bot may-as-permission move the case file. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-017", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-017-passive-possibility", "english": "A case file has reached the end of its active period. The case file might be moved by the retention bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A case file has reached the end of its active period. The case file may-as-possibility be moved by the retention bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-017", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-018-active-possibility", "english": "A deleted report is named in the restoration request. The records agent might restore the deleted report. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A deleted report is named in the restoration request. The records agent may-as-possibility restore the deleted report. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-018", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-018-passive-permission", "english": "A deleted report is named in the restoration request. The deleted report is permitted to be restored by the records agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A deleted report is named in the restoration request. The deleted report may-as-permission be restored by the records agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-018", "strata": { "domain": "data", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-019-active-permission", "english": "The primary pump is vibrating during the restart sequence. The cooling controller is permitted to stop the primary pump. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The primary pump is vibrating during the restart sequence. The cooling controller may-as-permission stop the primary pump. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-019", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-019-passive-possibility", "english": "The primary pump is vibrating during the restart sequence. The primary pump might be stopped by the cooling controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The primary pump is vibrating during the restart sequence. The primary pump may-as-possibility be stopped by the cooling controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-019", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-020-active-possibility", "english": "Regional traffic is accumulating at the east gateway. The failover agent might switch the regional traffic. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "Regional traffic is accumulating at the east gateway. The failover agent may-as-possibility switch the regional traffic. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-020", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-020-passive-permission", "english": "Regional traffic is accumulating at the east gateway. The regional traffic is permitted to be switched by the failover agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "Regional traffic is accumulating at the east gateway. The regional traffic may-as-permission be switched by the failover agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-020", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-021-active-permission", "english": "A degraded shard is listed in the storage console. The storage worker is permitted to detach the degraded shard. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A degraded shard is listed in the storage console. The storage worker may-as-permission detach the degraded shard. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-021", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-021-passive-possibility", "english": "A degraded shard is listed in the storage console. The degraded shard might be detached by the storage worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A degraded shard is listed in the storage console. The degraded shard may-as-possibility be detached by the storage worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-021", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-022-active-possibility", "english": "A duplicate alarm is repeating in the overnight dashboard. The monitor might silence the duplicate alarm. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A duplicate alarm is repeating in the overnight dashboard. The monitor may-as-possibility silence the duplicate alarm. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-022", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-022-passive-permission", "english": "A duplicate alarm is repeating in the overnight dashboard. The duplicate alarm is permitted to be silenced by the monitor. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A duplicate alarm is repeating in the overnight dashboard. The duplicate alarm may-as-permission be silenced by the monitor. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-022", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-023-active-permission", "english": "A standby node is idle beside the active pool. The capacity bot is permitted to allocate the standby node. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A standby node is idle beside the active pool. The capacity bot may-as-permission allocate the standby node. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-023", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-023-passive-possibility", "english": "A standby node is idle beside the active pool. The standby node might be allocated by the capacity bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A standby node is idle beside the active pool. The standby node may-as-possibility be allocated by the capacity bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-023", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-024-active-possibility", "english": "An edge certificate expires at the end of the shift. The certificate agent might replace the edge certificate. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "An edge certificate expires at the end of the shift. The certificate agent may-as-possibility replace the edge certificate. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-024", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-024-passive-permission", "english": "An edge certificate expires at the end of the shift. The edge certificate is permitted to be replaced by the certificate agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An edge certificate expires at the end of the shift. The edge certificate may-as-permission be replaced by the certificate agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-024", "strata": { "domain": "infrastructure", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-025-active-permission", "english": "A disputed payment is attached to the customer case. The billing agent is permitted to refund the disputed payment. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A disputed payment is attached to the customer case. The billing agent may-as-permission refund the disputed payment. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-025", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-025-passive-possibility", "english": "A disputed payment is attached to the customer case. The disputed payment might be refunded by the billing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A disputed payment is attached to the customer case. The disputed payment may-as-possibility be refunded by the billing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-025", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-026-active-possibility", "english": "Reserve funds are staged in the treasury workspace. The treasury bot might transfer the reserve funds. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "Reserve funds are staged in the treasury workspace. The treasury bot may-as-possibility transfer the reserve funds. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-026", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-026-passive-permission", "english": "Reserve funds are staged in the treasury workspace. The reserve funds is permitted to be transferred by the treasury bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "Reserve funds are staged in the treasury workspace. The reserve funds may-as-permission be transferred by the treasury bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-026", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-027-active-permission", "english": "An invoice carries the tax code from last quarter. The invoice worker is permitted to change the invoice tax code. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An invoice carries the tax code from last quarter. The invoice worker may-as-permission change the invoice tax code. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-027", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-027-passive-possibility", "english": "An invoice carries the tax code from last quarter. The invoice tax code might be changed by the invoice worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "An invoice carries the tax code from last quarter. The invoice tax code may-as-possibility be changed by the invoice worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-027", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-028-active-possibility", "english": "A merchant account appears in the current fraud batch. The fraud service might freeze the merchant account. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A merchant account appears in the current fraud batch. The fraud service may-as-possibility freeze the merchant account. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-028", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-028-passive-permission", "english": "A merchant account appears in the current fraud batch. The merchant account is permitted to be frozen by the fraud service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A merchant account appears in the current fraud batch. The merchant account may-as-permission be frozen by the fraud service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-028", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-029-active-permission", "english": "The salary batch is complete in the payroll workspace. The payroll agent is permitted to release the salary batch. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The salary batch is complete in the payroll workspace. The payroll agent may-as-permission release the salary batch. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-029", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-029-passive-possibility", "english": "The salary batch is complete in the payroll workspace. The salary batch might be released by the payroll agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "The salary batch is complete in the payroll workspace. The salary batch may-as-possibility be released by the payroll agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-029", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-030-active-possibility", "english": "A settled ledger is attached to the reconciliation case. The audit bot might reopen the settled ledger. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A settled ledger is attached to the reconciliation case. The audit bot may-as-possibility reopen the settled ledger. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-030", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-030-passive-permission", "english": "A settled ledger is attached to the reconciliation case. The settled ledger is permitted to be reopened by the audit bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A settled ledger is attached to the reconciliation case. The settled ledger may-as-permission be reopened by the audit bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-030", "strata": { "domain": "finance", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-031-active-permission", "english": "The primary operator has not answered the incident page. The notification service is permitted to contact the backup operator. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The primary operator has not answered the incident page. The notification service may-as-permission contact the backup operator. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-031", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-031-passive-possibility", "english": "The primary operator has not answered the incident page. The backup operator might be contacted by the notification service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The primary operator has not answered the incident page. The backup operator may-as-possibility be contacted by the notification service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-031", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-032-active-possibility", "english": "A reported message remains in the public discussion. The moderation agent might hide the reported message. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A reported message remains in the public discussion. The moderation agent may-as-possibility hide the reported message. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-032", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-032-passive-permission", "english": "A reported message remains in the public discussion. The reported message is permitted to be hidden by the moderation agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A reported message remains in the public discussion. The reported message may-as-permission be hidden by the moderation agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-032", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-033-active-permission", "english": "A customer notice is still in the outbound folder. The mail worker is permitted to resend the customer notice. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A customer notice is still in the outbound folder. The mail worker may-as-permission resend the customer notice. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-033", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-033-passive-possibility", "english": "A customer notice is still in the outbound folder. The customer notice might be resent by the mail worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A customer notice is still in the outbound folder. The customer notice may-as-possibility be resent by the mail worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-033", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-034-active-possibility", "english": "A private briefing is scheduled in the conference room. The conference bot might record the private briefing. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A private briefing is scheduled in the conference room. The conference bot may-as-possibility record the private briefing. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-034", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-034-passive-permission", "english": "A private briefing is scheduled in the conference room. The private briefing is permitted to be recorded by the conference bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A private briefing is scheduled in the conference room. The private briefing may-as-permission be recorded by the conference bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-034", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-035-active-permission", "english": "The status page still shows the morning summary. The publishing agent is permitted to edit the status page. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The status page still shows the morning summary. The publishing agent may-as-permission edit the status page. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-035", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-035-passive-possibility", "english": "The status page still shows the morning summary. The status page might be edited by the publishing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The status page still shows the morning summary. The status page may-as-possibility be edited by the publishing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-035", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-036-active-possibility", "english": "A localized alert is ready in the translation queue. The translation worker might release the localized alert. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A localized alert is ready in the translation queue. The translation worker may-as-possibility release the localized alert. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-036", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-036-passive-permission", "english": "A localized alert is ready in the translation queue. The localized alert is permitted to be released by the translation worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A localized alert is ready in the translation queue. The localized alert may-as-permission be released by the translation worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-036", "strata": { "domain": "communications", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-037-active-permission", "english": "A contaminated sample is isolated on the laboratory bench. The laboratory robot is permitted to discard the contaminated sample. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A contaminated sample is isolated on the laboratory bench. The laboratory robot may-as-permission discard the contaminated sample. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-037", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-037-passive-possibility", "english": "A contaminated sample is isolated on the laboratory bench. The contaminated sample might be discarded by the laboratory robot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A contaminated sample is isolated on the laboratory bench. The contaminated sample may-as-possibility be discarded by the laboratory robot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-037", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-038-active-possibility", "english": "An anomaly label is attached to the latest analysis run. The analysis agent might revise the anomaly label. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "An anomaly label is attached to the latest analysis run. The analysis agent may-as-possibility revise the anomaly label. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-038", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-038-passive-permission", "english": "An anomaly label is attached to the latest analysis run. The anomaly label is permitted to be revised by the analysis agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An anomaly label is attached to the latest analysis run. The anomaly label may-as-permission be revised by the analysis agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-038", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-039-active-permission", "english": "The telescope mirror is parked after the calibration pass. The telescope controller is permitted to reposition the telescope mirror. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The telescope mirror is parked after the calibration pass. The telescope controller may-as-permission reposition the telescope mirror. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-039", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-039-passive-possibility", "english": "The telescope mirror is parked after the calibration pass. The telescope mirror might be repositioned by the telescope controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The telescope mirror is parked after the calibration pass. The telescope mirror may-as-possibility be repositioned by the telescope controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-039", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-040-active-possibility", "english": "A participant record is sealed in the trial workspace. The trial system might unblind the participant record. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A participant record is sealed in the trial workspace. The trial system may-as-possibility unblind the participant record. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-040", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-040-passive-permission", "english": "A participant record is sealed in the trial workspace. The participant record is permitted to be unblinded by the trial system. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A participant record is sealed in the trial workspace. The participant record may-as-permission be unblinded by the trial system. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-040", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-041-active-permission", "english": "An outlier reading remains in the sensor stream. The sensor service is permitted to suppress the outlier reading. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An outlier reading remains in the sensor stream. The sensor service may-as-permission suppress the outlier reading. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-041", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-041-passive-possibility", "english": "An outlier reading remains in the sensor stream. The outlier reading might be suppressed by the sensor service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "An outlier reading remains in the sensor stream. The outlier reading may-as-possibility be suppressed by the sensor service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-041", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-042-active-possibility", "english": "A genomic summary is complete in the research archive. The archive bot might publish the genomic summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A genomic summary is complete in the research archive. The archive bot may-as-possibility publish the genomic summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-042", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-042-passive-permission", "english": "A genomic summary is complete in the research archive. The genomic summary is permitted to be published by the archive bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A genomic summary is complete in the research archive. The genomic summary may-as-permission be published by the archive bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-042", "strata": { "domain": "science", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-043-active-permission", "english": "A sealed pallet is waiting beside the loading bay. The warehouse bot is permitted to move the sealed pallet. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A sealed pallet is waiting beside the loading bay. The warehouse bot may-as-permission move the sealed pallet. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-043", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-043-passive-possibility", "english": "A sealed pallet is waiting beside the loading bay. The sealed pallet might be moved by the warehouse bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A sealed pallet is waiting beside the loading bay. The sealed pallet may-as-possibility be moved by the warehouse bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-043", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-044-active-possibility", "english": "A medical shipment is approaching the closed bridge. The routing agent might divert the medical shipment. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A medical shipment is approaching the closed bridge. The routing agent may-as-possibility divert the medical shipment. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-044", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-044-passive-permission", "english": "A medical shipment is approaching the closed bridge. The medical shipment is permitted to be diverted by the routing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A medical shipment is approaching the closed bridge. The medical shipment may-as-permission be diverted by the routing agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-044", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-045-active-permission", "english": "A freight container is held at the inspection lane. The customs service is permitted to open the freight container. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A freight container is held at the inspection lane. The customs service may-as-permission open the freight container. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-045", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-045-passive-possibility", "english": "A freight container is held at the inspection lane. The freight container might be opened by the customs service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A freight container is held at the inspection lane. The freight container may-as-possibility be opened by the customs service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-045", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-046-active-possibility", "english": "A delivery route is still present in tomorrow's schedule. The fleet bot might cancel the delivery route. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A delivery route is still present in tomorrow's schedule. The fleet bot may-as-possibility cancel the delivery route. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-046", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-046-passive-permission", "english": "A delivery route is still present in tomorrow's schedule. The delivery route is permitted to be cancelled by the fleet bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A delivery route is still present in tomorrow's schedule. The delivery route may-as-permission be cancelled by the fleet bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-046", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-047-active-permission", "english": "A spare battery is tagged for the field team. The depot worker is permitted to release the spare battery. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A spare battery is tagged for the field team. The depot worker may-as-permission release the spare battery. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-047", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-047-passive-possibility", "english": "A spare battery is tagged for the field team. The spare battery might be released by the depot worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A spare battery is tagged for the field team. The spare battery may-as-possibility be released by the depot worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-047", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-048-active-possibility", "english": "A damaged module is secured beneath the service crane. The crane controller might lift the damaged module. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A damaged module is secured beneath the service crane. The crane controller may-as-possibility lift the damaged module. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-048", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-048-passive-permission", "english": "A damaged module is secured beneath the service crane. The damaged module is permitted to be lifted by the crane controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A damaged module is secured beneath the service crane. The damaged module may-as-permission be lifted by the crane controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-048", "strata": { "domain": "logistics", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-049-active-permission", "english": "An urgent referral is waiting in the triage queue. The triage agent is permitted to forward the urgent referral. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An urgent referral is waiting in the triage queue. The triage agent may-as-permission forward the urgent referral. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-049", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-049-passive-possibility", "english": "An urgent referral is waiting in the triage queue. The urgent referral might be forwarded by the triage agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "An urgent referral is waiting in the triage queue. The urgent referral may-as-possibility be forwarded by the triage agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-049", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-050-active-possibility", "english": "A controlled dose is prepared in the pharmacy station. The pharmacy bot might release the controlled dose. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A controlled dose is prepared in the pharmacy station. The pharmacy bot may-as-possibility release the controlled dose. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-050", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-050-passive-permission", "english": "A controlled dose is prepared in the pharmacy station. The controlled dose is permitted to be released by the pharmacy bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A controlled dose is prepared in the pharmacy station. The controlled dose may-as-permission be released by the pharmacy bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-050", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-051-active-permission", "english": "A patient summary is attached to the transfer packet. The records worker is permitted to disclose the patient summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A patient summary is attached to the transfer packet. The records worker may-as-permission disclose the patient summary. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-051", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-051-passive-possibility", "english": "A patient summary is attached to the transfer packet. The patient summary might be disclosed by the records worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A patient summary is attached to the transfer packet. The patient summary may-as-possibility be disclosed by the records worker. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-051", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-052-active-possibility", "english": "A surgery slot remains on tomorrow's theatre list. The scheduling agent might cancel the surgery slot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A surgery slot remains on tomorrow's theatre list. The scheduling agent may-as-possibility cancel the surgery slot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-052", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-052-passive-permission", "english": "A surgery slot remains on tomorrow's theatre list. The surgery slot is permitted to be cancelled by the scheduling agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A surgery slot remains on tomorrow's theatre list. The surgery slot may-as-permission be cancelled by the scheduling agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-052", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-053-active-permission", "english": "A failed scan remains in the imaging workspace. The imaging service is permitted to delete the failed scan. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A failed scan remains in the imaging workspace. The imaging service may-as-permission delete the failed scan. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-053", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-053-passive-possibility", "english": "A failed scan remains in the imaging workspace. The failed scan might be deleted by the imaging service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A failed scan remains in the imaging workspace. The failed scan may-as-possibility be deleted by the imaging service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-053", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-054-active-possibility", "english": "A critical result is visible in the laboratory feed. The laboratory system might flag the critical result. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A critical result is visible in the laboratory feed. The laboratory system may-as-possibility flag the critical result. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-054", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-054-passive-permission", "english": "A critical result is visible in the laboratory feed. The critical result is permitted to be flagged by the laboratory system. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A critical result is visible in the laboratory feed. The critical result may-as-permission be flagged by the laboratory system. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-054", "strata": { "domain": "healthcare", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-055-active-permission", "english": "A borrowed book reaches its due date this afternoon. The library bot is permitted to renew the borrowed book. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A borrowed book reaches its due date this afternoon. The library bot may-as-permission renew the borrowed book. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-055", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-055-passive-possibility", "english": "A borrowed book reaches its due date this afternoon. The borrowed book might be renewed by the library bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A borrowed book reaches its due date this afternoon. The borrowed book may-as-possibility be renewed by the library bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-055", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-056-active-possibility", "english": "A meeting room is empty during the afternoon slot. The office agent might reserve the meeting room. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "A meeting room is empty during the afternoon slot. The office agent may-as-possibility reserve the meeting room. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-056", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-056-passive-permission", "english": "A meeting room is empty during the afternoon slot. The meeting room is permitted to be reserved by the office agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A meeting room is empty during the afternoon slot. The meeting room may-as-permission be reserved by the office agent. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-056", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-057-active-permission", "english": "The side entrance is closed during the evening event. The building controller is permitted to unlock the side entrance. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The side entrance is closed during the evening event. The building controller may-as-permission unlock the side entrance. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-057", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-057-passive-possibility", "english": "The side entrance is closed during the evening event. The side entrance might be unlocked by the building controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "The side entrance is closed during the evening event. The side entrance may-as-possibility be unlocked by the building controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which source would directly verify the specific claim made by the target sentence?", "options": [ "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log", "the rulebook entry governing the operation" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-057", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "verification_record", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-058-active-possibility", "english": "A dinner booking remains in the venue calendar. The event service might cancel the dinner booking. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "ainglish": "A dinner booking remains in the venue calendar. The event service may-as-possibility cancel the dinner booking. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found an applicable grant at the message time.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation", "the operation did not later occur" ], "answer": "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-058", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-058-passive-permission", "english": "A dinner booking remains in the venue calendar. The dinner booking is permitted to be cancelled by the event service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "ainglish": "A dinner booking remains in the venue calendar. The dinner booking may-as-permission be cancelled by the event service. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information did not rule the outcome out.", "question": "Which later finding would directly falsify the target sentence without relying on whether the event eventually occurred?", "options": [ "the operation did not later occur", "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "the writer's information at that time ruled the outcome out", "the mechanism could not perform the operation" ], "answer": "no applicable rule granted the operation when the message was written", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-058", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "direct_falsifier", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-059-active-permission", "english": "An assignment deadline appears in the classroom portal. The classroom bot is permitted to extend the assignment deadline. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "An assignment deadline appears in the classroom portal. The classroom bot may-as-permission extend the assignment deadline. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the mechanism inventory", "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model" ], "answer": "the governing-grant ledger", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-059", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-059-passive-possibility", "english": "An assignment deadline appears in the classroom portal. The assignment deadline might be extended by the classroom bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "An assignment deadline appears in the classroom portal. The assignment deadline may-as-possibility be extended by the classroom bot. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation executable at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "If only the modal claim is withdrawn while technical facts stay unchanged, which ledger needs correction?", "options": [ "the later outcome history", "the governing-grant ledger", "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "the mechanism inventory" ], "answer": "the contemporaneous uncertainty model", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-059", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "low", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "correction_ledger", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "possible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "forbidden_but_possible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-060-active-possibility", "english": "The irrigation cycle is queued during a water shortage. The garden controller might start the irrigation cycle. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "ainglish": "The irrigation cycle is queued during a water shortage. The garden controller may-as-possibility start the irrigation cycle. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later rulebook audit found the operation forbidden at the message time.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant", "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment" ], "answer": "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "force": "possibility", "scenario_id": "may-frame-060", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "active", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "forbidden", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "leaves_open", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "other" } }, { "id": "may-modal-060-passive-permission", "english": "The irrigation cycle is queued during a water shortage. The irrigation cycle is permitted to be started by the garden controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "ainglish": "The irrigation cycle is queued during a water shortage. The irrigation cycle may-as-permission be started by the garden controller. Later, a separate mechanism test found the operation technically blocked at the message time. A later reconstruction found that the writer's information ruled the outcome out.", "question": "Which follow-up tests what the target sentence actually asserts?", "options": [ "reconstruct what the writer could rule out at that moment", "stress-test the mechanism", "wait to see whether the event happens", "confirm the governing grant" ], "answer": "confirm the governing grant", "force": "permission", "scenario_id": "may-frame-060", "strata": { "domain": "ordinary", "severity": "high", "voice": "passive", "question_kind": "operational_followup", "authority_state": "permitted", "objective_state": "impossible", "speaker_evidence_state": "rules_out", "load_bearing_cross_cell": "permitted_but_impossible" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-01", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the rulebook entry governing the operation.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-02", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the writer's information snapshot from that moment.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-03", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to run a fresh test of the mechanism.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "a fresh test of the mechanism", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-04", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the later event log.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the later event log", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-05", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the rulebook entry governing the operation.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-06", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the writer's information snapshot from that moment.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-07", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to run a fresh test of the mechanism.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "a fresh test of the mechanism", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-08", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the later event log.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the later event log", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-09", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the rulebook entry governing the operation.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-10", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the writer's information snapshot from that moment.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-11", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to run a fresh test of the mechanism.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "a fresh test of the mechanism", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-12", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the later event log.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the later event log", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-13", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the rulebook entry governing the operation.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-14", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the writer's information snapshot from that moment.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-15", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to run a fresh test of the mechanism.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "a fresh test of the mechanism", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } }, { "id": "may-modal-calibration-16", "english": "The handoff says to inspect the relevant source before acting.", "ainglish": "The handoff explicitly directs the auditor to inspect the later event log.", "question": "Which source does the handoff explicitly direct the auditor to inspect?", "options": [ "the rulebook entry governing the operation", "the writer's information snapshot from that moment", "a fresh test of the mechanism", "the later event log" ], "answer": "the later event log", "calibration": true, "strata": { "calibration_block": "construct_free_explicit_vs_unresolved" } } ], "sha256": "df9d3d02d4c5c14d7e5a3b3fb4d821f4ff9c18ee5280e46010cc93c5bf0f8712", "summary": { "real_items": 120, "calibration_items": 16, "forces": { "permission": 60, "possibility": 60 }, "domains": 10, "voices": { "active": 60, "passive": 60 }, "severity": { "high": 60, "low": 60 }, "question_kinds": { "verification_record": 30, "direct_falsifier": 30, "correction_ledger": 30, "operational_followup": 30 }, "answer_positions": { "0": 30, "1": 30, "2": 30, "3": 30 }, "cross_cells": { "permitted_but_impossible": 30, "forbidden_but_possible": 15 }, "admissibility": "120 unique bare-may messages, generated from neutral contexts that contain none of the declared authority, possibility, capability, likelihood, or evidence cues; both force expansions are grammatical by the same renderer before force assignment" } }