--- name: craft-explore description: Use when asked for options, alternatives, variations, directions or "a few ideas" for a screen, flow or element, when the person rejects a design or says they don't like it, or says "rethink this", "try something else" or "design both so I can pick". --- # Three proposals ## Overview When someone asks for options, they want to **choose**, not to be handed a winner. Give them three directions that solve the problem in genuinely different ways, side by side, at the same fidelity, next to what exists today, **with your recommendation first**. Then wait for the pick. ## When to use - "Give me options", "3 variations", "other directions", "what else could this be?" - "I don't like this", "rethink it", "try something different". - "Design both so I can choose": that means two. ## When NOT to use - A specific change ("change the title to Preferences", "make it blue"): make it. - One clear fix the person already described. ## Before you start 0. Read `DESIGN.md` at the project root if it exists: it is the project's design brief. 1. Read the project's design system and the screen in question. All options use the system's pieces and tokens: options differ in **design**, not in brand. 2. Pick your tool's adapter in `references/adapters/` (`paper.md`, `pen.md`, `figma.md`, `html.md`). If no adapter matches your tool, do the same verbs in your tool and say which you mapped by hand. With no design tool at all, build in HTML (`html.md`). If an image is all you have, say that values read from it are estimates. ## Steps 1. **Restate the problem** in one or two sentences: what's wrong today, and what a good result must do. If the request was only "make it better", name the problem you see. **Stop and confirm it with the person before designing.** If they already named the problem, go on. 2. **Choose the directions on different axes** ([divergence axes](references/divergence-axes.md)): structure or placement, interaction model, density, emphasis, or what gets removed. Write each direction as one line: the idea and its trade-off. Directions must differ: a different axis, or clearly different values on one axis when the person names the axis ("too dense" → three density answers). A change of colour, theme or font is never an axis. 3. **Build the comparison board in a temporary area** ([comparison board](references/comparison-board.md)): - a legend card (each option's idea, what it's good at, what it costs, and the recommendation with its reason); - **"Current"**, a copy of today's design, when one exists; - options **A, B, C**, the same size and with the same realistic data. **Never edit the real screens.** 4. **Draw every option with final-screen care**, including the states that its difference affects. If B moves an action into a menu, show the menu open. 5. **Present the recommendation first**, then one line per option. **Stop. The person picks, combines ("B with A's header"), or rejects all of them.** 6. **After the answer:** - **Pick or combination:** apply it to the real screens and the design system (and its propagation to every screen that uses a changed piece), then clear the temporary area. - **All rejected:** go back to step 1 with their reason as the new problem statement. Allow changes to the surrounding parts. Never answer a rejection with small tweaks of the same options. ## Rules | Rule | Why | |---|---| | Three by default; two for "both" (when they named both options, skip the bolder-option rule); exactly the number they ask for otherwise | The count is theirs; three is enough to compare without fatigue | | Different axes, not different paint | Three layouts in three colour schemes is one idea with three skins | | Always recommend, and say why | They asked an expert; "tell me which you like" hands the work back | | "Current" sits on the board | People judge change against what they know | | Same data, same size, same fidelity | A polished option next to sketches is a vote, not a choice | | No straw men: every option is one you'd defend | Fake options waste the person's attention and trust | | One option is deliberately bolder | Otherwise the set only covers safe variations | | Real screens stay untouched until the pick | Options that leak into the product are decisions nobody made | ## Done when The board shows the legend, Current and every option at equal fidelity; the recommendation is stated first; you have stopped for the pick. After the pick: applied to the real screens and the system, and the temporary area cleared. ## Common mistakes | Thought | Reality | |---|---| | "Option C: the same page in a dark theme" | Theme is paint, not a direction. Change structure, interaction, density, emphasis or what's removed. | | "I'll let them choose without biasing them" | Not recommending isn't neutral, it's unhelpful. Recommend first, with the reason. | | "The original file is unchanged, so they can compare" | Put Current *on the board*, next to the options. | | "They rejected all three, I'll adjust the closest one" | A rejection is new information about the problem. Restate it and diverge again. | | "They asked for 5, but 3 is the method" | Give 5. The divergence rule still applies to all of them. | | "Options share the same fixes, so they look alike" | Shared fixes are fine. Say so once in the legend and make the main axis differ. |