{
  "schema": "halo-response-public-collective3-comparison-v1",
  "complete": true,
  "passed": true,
  "populations": [
    "F0",
    "A_full_plus"
  ],
  "numerical_versions": {
    "python": "3.11.14",
    "numpy": "1.26.4",
    "scipy": "1.17.1"
  },
  "portable_source_sha256": {
    "run.py": "e54fedbaa7d48f903217c4f7dae3a39b736df34c7a4d54dd36be92b9c5524eed",
    "bare_run.py": "abc1d554e8a642e4b2d0007f664a9b372c8d62c331966d37da517d3f66fdd9b1",
    "README.md": "7deb1b3f86031d3951120d7974e26e2488d3418dda4dbc0ce34b49968a51a36b",
    "METHOD.md": "f4fb9c15cf52bf793efacfb83397e279b12c649e1e6392a793c991a4a1bbc4fb",
    "requirements.txt": "7cfc262076b951f44468033354d1545562e74fed172bad23129fb28a885999d9"
  },
  "comparison": {
    "canonical_energy2_change": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.4399560103323106e-20,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11450,
      "maximum_at_time": 114.5
    },
    "canonical_orbit_energy2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.3552527156068805e-20,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11450,
      "maximum_at_time": 114.5
    },
    "projected_field_energy2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.2705494208814505e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11000,
      "maximum_at_time": 110.0
    },
    "included_field_energy2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.2705494208814505e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11000,
      "maximum_at_time": 110.0
    },
    "external_interaction_energy2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 3.3881317890172014e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 10550,
      "maximum_at_time": 105.5
    },
    "shape_work2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 6.352747104407253e-22,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 12000,
      "maximum_at_time": 120.0
    },
    "total_external_work2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 6.776263578034403e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11900,
      "maximum_at_time": 119.0
    },
    "discrete_external_flux2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 5.082197683525802e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 10450,
      "maximum_at_time": 104.5
    },
    "physical_energy_budget_residual": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.3552527156068805e-20,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11650,
      "maximum_at_time": 116.5
    },
    "discrete_energy_budget_residual": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.8634724839594607e-20,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11450,
      "maximum_at_time": 114.5
    },
    "canonical_impulse2_change": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.2197274440461925e-19,
      "tolerance": 2e-11,
      "maximum_at_step": 11600,
      "maximum_at_time": 116.0
    },
    "angular_impulse2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 2.710505431213761e-20,
      "tolerance": 2e-11,
      "maximum_at_step": 12000,
      "maximum_at_time": 120.0
    },
    "impulse_budget_residual": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.0842021724855044e-19,
      "tolerance": 2e-11,
      "maximum_at_step": 11700,
      "maximum_at_time": 117.0
    },
    "self_torque2": {
      "maximum_absolute": 4.530253848669667e-22,
      "tolerance": 2e-11,
      "maximum_at_step": 10650,
      "maximum_at_time": 106.5
    },
    "coefficients_real": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.3010426069826053e-18,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 10400,
      "maximum_at_time": 104.0
    },
    "coefficients_imag": {
      "maximum_absolute": 1.3010426069826053e-18,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 9800,
      "maximum_at_time": 98.0
    },
    "F0_l2_energy_bound_gap": {
      "maximum_absolute": 6.776263578034403e-21,
      "tolerance": 2e-12,
      "maximum_at_step": 11650,
      "maximum_at_time": 116.5
    }
  },
  "nominal_record_count": 241,
  "shared_recorded_steps": [
    0,
    50,
    100,
    150,
    200,
    250,
    300,
    350,
    400,
    450,
    500,
    550,
    600,
    650,
    700,
    750,
    800,
    850,
    900,
    950,
    1000,
    1050,
    1100,
    1150,
    1200,
    1250,
    1300,
    1350,
    1400,
    1450,
    1500,
    1550,
    1600,
    1650,
    1700,
    1750,
    1800,
    1850,
    1900,
    1950,
    2000,
    2050,
    2100,
    2150,
    2200,
    2250,
    2300,
    2350,
    2400,
    2450,
    2500,
    2550,
    2600,
    2650,
    2700,
    2750,
    2800,
    2850,
    2900,
    2950,
    3000,
    3050,
    3100,
    3150,
    3200,
    3250,
    3300,
    3350,
    3400,
    3450,
    3500,
    3550,
    3600,
    3650,
    3700,
    3750,
    3800,
    3850,
    3900,
    3950,
    4000,
    4050,
    4100,
    4150,
    4200,
    4250,
    4300,
    4350,
    4400,
    4450,
    4500,
    4550,
    4600,
    4650,
    4700,
    4750,
    4800,
    4850,
    4900,
    4950,
    5000,
    5050,
    5100,
    5150,
    5200,
    5250,
    5300,
    5350,
    5400,
    5450,
    5500,
    5550,
    5600,
    5650,
    5700,
    5750,
    5800,
    5850,
    5900,
    5950,
    6000,
    6050,
    6100,
    6150,
    6200,
    6250,
    6300,
    6350,
    6400,
    6450,
    6500,
    6550,
    6600,
    6650,
    6700,
    6750,
    6800,
    6850,
    6900,
    6950,
    7000,
    7050,
    7100,
    7150,
    7200,
    7250,
    7300,
    7350,
    7400,
    7450,
    7500,
    7550,
    7600,
    7650,
    7700,
    7750,
    7800,
    7850,
    7900,
    7950,
    8000,
    8050,
    8100,
    8150,
    8200,
    8250,
    8300,
    8350,
    8400,
    8450,
    8500,
    8550,
    8600,
    8650,
    8700,
    8750,
    8800,
    8850,
    8900,
    8950,
    9000,
    9050,
    9100,
    9150,
    9200,
    9250,
    9300,
    9350,
    9400,
    9450,
    9500,
    9550,
    9600,
    9650,
    9700,
    9750,
    9800,
    9850,
    9900,
    9950,
    10000,
    10050,
    10100,
    10150,
    10200,
    10250,
    10300,
    10350,
    10400,
    10450,
    10500,
    10550,
    10600,
    10650,
    10700,
    10750,
    10800,
    10850,
    10900,
    10950,
    11000,
    11050,
    11100,
    11150,
    11200,
    11250,
    11300,
    11350,
    11400,
    11450,
    11500,
    11550,
    11600,
    11650,
    11700,
    11749,
    11750,
    11800,
    11850,
    11900,
    11950,
    12000
  ],
  "shared_recorded_times": [
    0.0,
    0.5,
    1.0,
    1.5,
    2.0,
    2.5,
    3.0,
    3.5,
    4.0,
    4.5,
    5.0,
    5.5,
    6.0,
    6.5,
    7.0,
    7.5,
    8.0,
    8.5,
    9.0,
    9.5,
    10.0,
    10.5,
    11.0,
    11.5,
    12.0,
    12.5,
    13.0,
    13.5,
    14.0,
    14.5,
    15.0,
    15.5,
    16.0,
    16.5,
    17.0,
    17.5,
    18.0,
    18.5,
    19.0,
    19.5,
    20.0,
    20.5,
    21.0,
    21.5,
    22.0,
    22.5,
    23.0,
    23.5,
    24.0,
    24.5,
    25.0,
    25.5,
    26.0,
    26.5,
    27.0,
    27.5,
    28.0,
    28.5,
    29.0,
    29.5,
    30.0,
    30.5,
    31.0,
    31.5,
    32.0,
    32.5,
    33.0,
    33.5,
    34.0,
    34.5,
    35.0,
    35.5,
    36.0,
    36.5,
    37.0,
    37.5,
    38.0,
    38.5,
    39.0,
    39.5,
    40.0,
    40.5,
    41.0,
    41.5,
    42.0,
    42.5,
    43.0,
    43.5,
    44.0,
    44.5,
    45.0,
    45.5,
    46.0,
    46.5,
    47.0,
    47.5,
    48.0,
    48.5,
    49.0,
    49.5,
    50.0,
    50.5,
    51.0,
    51.5,
    52.0,
    52.5,
    53.0,
    53.5,
    54.0,
    54.5,
    55.0,
    55.5,
    56.0,
    56.5,
    57.0,
    57.5,
    58.0,
    58.5,
    59.0,
    59.5,
    60.0,
    60.5,
    61.0,
    61.5,
    62.0,
    62.5,
    63.0,
    63.5,
    64.0,
    64.5,
    65.0,
    65.5,
    66.0,
    66.5,
    67.0,
    67.5,
    68.0,
    68.5,
    69.0,
    69.5,
    70.0,
    70.5,
    71.0,
    71.5,
    72.0,
    72.5,
    73.0,
    73.5,
    74.0,
    74.5,
    75.0,
    75.5,
    76.0,
    76.5,
    77.0,
    77.5,
    78.0,
    78.5,
    79.0,
    79.5,
    80.0,
    80.5,
    81.0,
    81.5,
    82.0,
    82.5,
    83.0,
    83.5,
    84.0,
    84.5,
    85.0,
    85.5,
    86.0,
    86.5,
    87.0,
    87.5,
    88.0,
    88.5,
    89.0,
    89.5,
    90.0,
    90.5,
    91.0,
    91.5,
    92.0,
    92.5,
    93.0,
    93.5,
    94.0,
    94.5,
    95.0,
    95.5,
    96.0,
    96.5,
    97.0,
    97.5,
    98.0,
    98.5,
    99.0,
    99.5,
    100.0,
    100.5,
    101.0,
    101.5,
    102.0,
    102.5,
    103.0,
    103.5,
    104.0,
    104.5,
    105.0,
    105.5,
    106.0,
    106.5,
    107.0,
    107.5,
    108.0,
    108.5,
    109.0,
    109.5,
    110.0,
    110.5,
    111.0,
    111.5,
    112.0,
    112.5,
    113.0,
    113.5,
    114.0,
    114.5,
    115.0,
    115.5,
    116.0,
    116.5,
    117.0,
    117.49000000000001,
    117.5,
    118.0,
    118.5,
    119.0,
    119.5,
    120.0
  ],
  "public_only_checkpoint_steps": [
    119,
    238,
    357,
    477,
    596,
    729,
    865,
    1020,
    1176,
    1305,
    1434,
    1558,
    1669,
    1776,
    1885,
    1995,
    2105,
    2217,
    2340,
    2464,
    2582,
    2687,
    2793,
    2915,
    3040,
    3165,
    3276,
    3382,
    3488,
    3594,
    3805,
    3911,
    4016,
    4122,
    4228,
    4334,
    4440,
    4543,
    4645,
    4747,
    4952,
    5054,
    5156,
    5254,
    5352,
    5548,
    5646,
    5744,
    5842,
    5940,
    6036,
    6134,
    6232,
    6330,
    6427,
    6525,
    6622,
    6720,
    6817,
    6915,
    7012,
    7110,
    7225,
    7347,
    7449,
    7551,
    7653,
    7755,
    7857,
    7959,
    8061,
    8164,
    8266,
    8368,
    8471,
    8573,
    8706,
    8862,
    9019,
    9176,
    9332,
    9487,
    9632,
    9782,
    9930,
    10170,
    10289,
    10408,
    10527,
    10646,
    10764,
    10883,
    11005,
    11154,
    11303,
    11452,
    11898
  ],
  "private_only_checkpoint_steps": [
    302,
    455,
    625,
    797,
    968,
    1140,
    1312,
    1484,
    1655,
    1826,
    1994,
    2148,
    2315,
    2483,
    2633,
    2787,
    2919,
    3053,
    3203,
    3342,
    3476,
    3609,
    3742,
    3877,
    4047,
    4215,
    4381,
    4540,
    4681,
    4821,
    4962,
    5103,
    5244,
    5399,
    5552,
    5717,
    5876,
    6009,
    6142,
    6268,
    6381,
    6491,
    6603,
    6716,
    6828,
    6943,
    7068,
    7195,
    7316,
    7423,
    7532,
    7657,
    7785,
    7912,
    8025,
    8133,
    8241,
    8349,
    8457,
    8564,
    8672,
    8780,
    8888,
    8997,
    9105,
    9214,
    9320,
    9424,
    9529,
    9634,
    9739,
    9844,
    9948,
    10048,
    10148,
    10248,
    10348,
    10448,
    10548,
    10648,
    10749,
    10848,
    10948,
    11049,
    11149,
    11249,
    11349,
    11449,
    11549,
    11649,
    11849,
    11949
  ],
  "final_public_W2": [
    1.9496906077037958e-05,
    -6.0241050093021344e-06
  ],
  "final_private_W2": [
    1.949690607703796e-05,
    -6.024105009302132e-06
  ],
  "final_public_J2": [
    0.00017089385026078857,
    -6.201194792478192e-05
  ],
  "final_private_J2": [
    0.0001708938502607886,
    -6.20119479247819e-05
  ],
  "independent_algorithm": false,
  "new_physical_samples": false,
  "continuum_response_qualified": false,
  "stability_qualified": false,
  "unmatched_rows_interpolated": false,
  "physical_configuration": {
    "ne": 128,
    "neta": 128,
    "nmax": 6,
    "radial_modes": 64,
    "orbit_order": 64,
    "maximum_orbit_order": 2048,
    "orbit_tolerance": 3e-08,
    "duration": 120.0,
    "rise": 12.0,
    "fall": 12.0,
    "dt": 0.01,
    "omega": 0.12,
    "theta0": 0.0,
    "shape": 0.8,
    "self_gravity": 1,
    "record_every": 50,
    "chunk_actions": 64,
    "populations": [
      "F0",
      "A_full_plus"
    ]
  },
  "scope": "Same-equation full-history comparison; no independent physical samples or universal accessibility claim"
}