{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "release": "2026-09-24.2",
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "POP-01",
      "wording": "At s=0.25, Gaussian and reference-halo weighting in the tested slice have opposite T=10 responses; their T=20 suppression magnitudes differ by 4.735323.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#population-result",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "s": 0.25,
        "eta": 0.1,
        "times": [
          10,
          20
        ],
        "cutoff": 40
      },
      "observable": "noise-minus-smooth accumulated bar-mediated transfer",
      "units": "dimensionless integral(w K_B dx)",
      "reference_control": "Gaussian versus reference halo at the same density normalization, sweep, noise and endpoint",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "results/populations.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/0",
          "sha256": "ca646cb5bc56735b11e6c2906695e8b6d400338fa539b07eb4cb31c3d1808e16",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "POP-gaussian-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/populations.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/1",
          "sha256": "ca646cb5bc56735b11e6c2906695e8b6d400338fa539b07eb4cb31c3d1808e16",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "POP-halo-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/populations.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/3",
          "sha256": "ca646cb5bc56735b11e6c2906695e8b6d400338fa539b07eb4cb31c3d1808e16",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "POP-gaussian-T20"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/populations.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/4",
          "sha256": "ca646cb5bc56735b11e6c2906695e8b6d400338fa539b07eb4cb31c3d1808e16",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "POP-halo-T20"
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Eight independent seeded batches; population/time/window contractions share paths. Pointwise Student-t intervals where stated; paired numerical differences remain proxies.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-01",
        "LIM-02"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "results/populations.json",
      "comparison": "Gaussian versus reference halo at the same density normalization, sweep, noise and endpoint",
      "protocols": [
        "methods/validation-allocation-01.json"
      ],
      "physical_control": "Same prescribed dynamics and population without imposed action noise",
      "uncertainty_method": "Eight independent seeded batches; population/time/window contractions share paths. Pointwise Student-t intervals where stated; paired numerical differences remain proxies.",
      "protocol": "methods/validation-allocation-01.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "POP-02",
      "wording": "The slope-matched exponential closely follows the reference-halo point estimates; the point differences alone do not certify sub-0.1% accuracy.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#population-result",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "s": 0.25,
        "eta": 0.1,
        "times": [
          10,
          20
        ]
      },
      "observable": "noise-minus-smooth accumulated bar-mediated transfer",
      "units": "dimensionless integral(w K_B dx)",
      "reference_control": "Paired slope-matched exponential minus reference-halo response",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/exponential_halo/4",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "cutoff": 40
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/exponential_halo/5",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "cutoff": 64
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/exponential_halo/6",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "cutoff": 40
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/exponential_halo/7",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "cutoff": 64
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Eight paired seed batches; pointwise Student-t interval of exponential-minus-halo contraction, paired timestep/window intervals and independent numerical-refinement proxies; no certified sub-0.1% accuracy.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-01",
        "LIM-03"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
      "comparison": "Paired slope-matched exponential minus reference-halo response",
      "protocols": [
        "methods/validation-allocation-01.json",
        "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md"
      ],
      "physical_control": "Same prescribed dynamics and population without imposed action noise",
      "uncertainty_method": "Eight paired seed batches; pointwise Student-t interval of exponential-minus-halo contraction, paired timestep/window intervals and independent numerical-refinement proxies; no certified sub-0.1% accuracy.",
      "protocol": "methods/validation-allocation-01.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "PA-ACC-01",
      "wording": "Eight advance 5% qualifications are supported by independent numerical comparison at one new sweep rate, s=0.5.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#accuracy",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "s": 0.5,
        "eta": 0.1,
        "times": [
          10,
          20
        ],
        "cutoffs": [
          40,
          64
        ],
        "populations": [
          "exponential",
          "gaussian512"
        ]
      },
      "observable": "noise-minus-smooth accumulated bar-mediated transfer",
      "units": "dimensionless integral(w K_B dx)",
      "reference_control": "Advance full allowance versus frozen 5% target; approximate kernel forecast versus independently evolved reference halo",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/1",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-exponential-T10-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/5",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian512-T10-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/7",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-exponential-T10-W64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/11",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian512-T10-W64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/13",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-exponential-T20-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/17",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian512-T20-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/19",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-exponential-T20-W64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/23",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian512-T20-W64"
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Eight kernel batches; simultaneous Student-t/Bonferroni envelope and paired refinement proxies. Independent deterministic evolution adds numerical proxies, not a new sampling interval.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-03",
        "LIM-04"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "results/accuracy.json",
      "comparison": "Advance full allowance versus frozen 5% target; approximate kernel forecast versus independently evolved reference halo",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md",
        "protocols/KERNEL_01.md",
        "protocols/INDEPENDENT_MATRIX_01.md"
      ],
      "physical_control": "Same prescribed dynamics and population without imposed action noise",
      "uncertainty_method": "Eight kernel batches; simultaneous Student-t/Bonferroni envelope and paired refinement proxies. Independent deterministic evolution adds numerical proxies, not a new sampling interval.",
      "protocol": "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "PA-ACC-02",
      "wording": "Four Gaussian-128 comparisons meet 5% in the independent assessment but are not qualified by the conservative absolute-gradient allowance.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#accuracy",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "s": 0.5,
        "eta": 0.1,
        "population": "gaussian128"
      },
      "observable": "noise-minus-smooth accumulated bar-mediated transfer",
      "units": "dimensionless integral(w K_B dx)",
      "reference_control": "Gaussian128 absolute-gradient allowance versus target and independently evolved intrinsic population error",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/4",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian128-T10-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/10",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian128-T10-W64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/16",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian128-T20-W40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/accuracy.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/22",
          "sha256": "971d9a3798d67f584f8d48e35cacce64f11bb7484d926832582b529b1ec91cfe",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "ACC-gaussian128-T20-W64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/conservatism-explanation.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/0",
          "sha256": "2f6afaef5f3b0dc1fb395c159fed728b033432d0b1ef9dc93a190a671da5f499",
          "expected_identity": {
            "tau": 10.0,
            "cutoff": 40
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/conservatism-explanation.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/1",
          "sha256": "2f6afaef5f3b0dc1fb395c159fed728b033432d0b1ef9dc93a190a671da5f499",
          "expected_identity": {
            "tau": 10.0,
            "cutoff": 64
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/conservatism-explanation.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/2",
          "sha256": "2f6afaef5f3b0dc1fb395c159fed728b033432d0b1ef9dc93a190a671da5f499",
          "expected_identity": {
            "tau": 20.0,
            "cutoff": 40
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/conservatism-explanation.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/3",
          "sha256": "2f6afaef5f3b0dc1fb395c159fed728b033432d0b1ef9dc93a190a671da5f499",
          "expected_identity": {
            "tau": 20.0,
            "cutoff": 64
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Shared eight-batch kernel; simultaneous nominal Student-t/Bonferroni envelope plus paired timestep/mesh proxies. Intrinsic errors use paired deterministic refinement changes, not a pointwise sampling CI.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-03",
        "LIM-04"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/conservatism-explanation.json",
      "comparison": "Gaussian128 absolute-gradient allowance versus target and independently evolved intrinsic population error",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md",
        "protocols/INDEPENDENT_MATRIX_01.md"
      ],
      "physical_control": "Same prescribed dynamics and population without imposed action noise",
      "uncertainty_method": "Shared eight-batch kernel; simultaneous nominal Student-t/Bonferroni envelope plus paired timestep/mesh proxies. Intrinsic errors use paired deterministic refinement changes, not a pointwise sampling CI.",
      "protocol": "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "EST-01",
      "wording": "The matched estimator has a large conditional cost-times-variance advantage for broad halo weights; the advantage disappears for the narrowest stress population.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#estimator",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "s": [
          0,
          0.25
        ],
        "times": [
          10,
          20
        ]
      },
      "observable": "Raw/remainder cost-times-variance ratio",
      "units": "dimensionless efficiency; CPU seconds reported separately",
      "reference_control": "Raw versus cumulative-remainder estimators on matched paths, weights and accounted workload",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/0",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-halo-s0.0-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/5",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-stress0.015625-s0.0-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/6",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-halo-s0.0-T20"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/11",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-stress0.015625-s0.0-T20"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/12",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-halo-s0.25-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/17",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-stress0.015625-s0.25-T10"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/18",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-halo-s0.25-T20"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "results/cost.json",
          "json_pointer": "/rows/23",
          "sha256": "fbe5aed978d23613ed8d130ea5ceedb6125239ad970da61f73d8c78e4fe71a04",
          "expected_identity": {
            "id": "COST-stress0.015625-s0.25-T20"
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Eight paired batches per sweep; whole-batch bootstrap intervals and distinct conditional/between-batch estimates; one pointwise consistency flag retained.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-06"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "results/cost.json",
      "comparison": "Raw versus cumulative-remainder estimators on matched paths, weights and accounted workload",
      "physical_control": "Each estimator targets the same noise-minus-smooth bar impulse; this is separate from the estimator comparison",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/ESTIMATOR_COST_02.md"
      ],
      "uncertainty_method": "Eight paired batches per sweep; whole-batch bootstrap intervals and distinct conditional/between-batch estimates; one pointwise consistency flag retained.",
      "protocol": "protocols/ESTIMATOR_COST_02.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "POP-MARG-01",
      "wording": "All 24 historical operational forecasts passed their original rule; two early Gaussian-12 window tests remain marginal under a later combined numerical-proxy assessment.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#limitations",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "old_allowance": "max(0.0002, 5% of forecast)"
      },
      "observable": "noise-minus-smooth accumulated bar-mediated transfer",
      "units": "dimensionless integral(w K_B dx)",
      "reference_control": "Historical operational intervals versus original allowance, then expanded intervals including numerical proxies versus that same allowance",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/0",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/1",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/2",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/3",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/4",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "quartic20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/5",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "quartic20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/6",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/7",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/8",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/9",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/10",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "quartic20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/11",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.0,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "quartic20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/12",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/13",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/14",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/15",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/16",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "quartic20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/17",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 10.0,
            "population": "quartic20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/18",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/19",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian12-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/20",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/21",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "gaussian20-64"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/22",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "quartic20-40"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
          "json_pointer": "/historical_forecast_assessment/23",
          "sha256": "97124a1ad6859382ce0c590baaba618dd70a713108fdde1e1efe618698929d11",
          "expected_identity": {
            "s": 0.25,
            "tau": 20.0,
            "population": "quartic20-64"
          }
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Historical paired pointwise prediction-discrepancy intervals and summed numerical-refinement proxies. Original absolute-floor decisions remain unchanged; expanded proxies are not rigorous bounds.",
      "status": "marginal",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-03"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/joint-error-assessment.json",
      "comparison": "Historical operational intervals versus original allowance, then expanded intervals including numerical proxies versus that same allowance",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/HELDOUT_POPULATIONS_01.md",
        "protocols/HELDOUT_MATRIX_01.md",
        "protocols/ACCURACY_PLAN.md"
      ],
      "physical_control": "Same prescribed dynamics and population without imposed action noise",
      "uncertainty_method": "Historical paired pointwise prediction-discrepancy intervals and summed numerical-refinement proxies. Original absolute-floor decisions remain unchanged; expanded proxies are not rigorous bounds.",
      "protocol": "protocols/HELDOUT_POPULATIONS_01.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "CART-01",
      "wording": "A reduced-model prediction has not yet achieved qualified transfer to prescribed-field three-dimensional orbits.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#limitations",
      "model_id": "CART-EXT",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "study": "halo-slice pilot"
      },
      "observable": "specified in source record",
      "units": "source-defined",
      "reference_control": "Predeclared reduced halo-slice forecast versus weighted prescribed-field Cartesian response",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-response/halo-pilot.json",
          "json_pointer": "/targets",
          "sha256": "c30b77afdd4468fc49792c83f982c06b14432742fa55676a92840957ca471ea1"
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-response/halo-pilot.json",
          "json_pointer": "/conditional_decision",
          "sha256": "c30b77afdd4468fc49792c83f982c06b14432742fa55676a92840957ca471ea1"
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-response/halo-pilot.json",
          "json_pointer": "/independent_3d_validation",
          "sha256": "c30b77afdd4468fc49792c83f982c06b14432742fa55676a92840957ca471ea1"
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-response/halo-pilot.json",
          "json_pointer": "/cost",
          "sha256": "c30b77afdd4468fc49792c83f982c06b14432742fa55676a92840957ca471ea1"
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Measured discrepancy precision exceeded the bounded cost allowance; unresolved agreement is not falsification.",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-05"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/population-response/halo-pilot.json",
      "comparison": "Predeclared reduced halo-slice forecast versus weighted prescribed-field Cartesian response",
      "physical_control": "Matched imposed-noise and smooth responses in each description",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/HALO_SLICE_PILOT_01.md"
      ],
      "uncertainty_method": "Measured discrepancy precision exceeded the bounded cost allowance; unresolved agreement is not falsification.",
      "protocol": "protocols/HALO_SLICE_PILOT_01.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "REP-01",
      "wording": "The project receipt documents exact reproduction of 162 saved arrays from the released numerical source. This publication campaign does not claim a new rerun.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#reproduction",
      "model_id": "RES-POS",
      "category": "software_reproduction",
      "conditions": {
        "public_numerical_revision": "66143ebdb7441e17f4b44c23d15c2b35eb66841a"
      },
      "observable": "Number of arrays reported exactly reproduced",
      "units": "array count",
      "reference_control": "Original versus reproduced arrays under the same inputs, seeds and numerical configuration",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/accuracy-reproduction.json",
          "json_pointer": "/saved_array_count",
          "sha256": "e835c5e0cbdcbe37263622a485bd0039bba49f9829c2e5675a698067addddd50"
        }
      ],
      "code_version": "cdb30b5b2f350d2f3de6831995b83f281fe2974e",
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Deterministic array equality reported by the project under identical seeds/configuration; no sampling interval or new independent physical sample.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-08"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/accuracy-reproduction.json",
      "comparison": "Original versus reproduced arrays under the same inputs, seeds and numerical configuration",
      "physical_control": null,
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/ACCURACY_REPRODUCTION.md"
      ],
      "uncertainty_method": "Deterministic array equality reported by the project under identical seeds/configuration; no sampling interval or new independent physical sample.",
      "protocol": "protocols/ACCURACY_REPRODUCTION.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "GAL-01",
      "wording": "Three of four matched force-opening comparisons fail the original endpoint criterion; this identifies numerical sensitivity, not the continuum solution.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#models",
      "model_id": "GAL-LIVE",
      "category": "numerical_result",
      "conditions": {
        "scope": "four paired force-opening comparisons"
      },
      "observable": "Endpoint bar-amplitude sensitivity between matched force-opening runs",
      "units": "Dimensionless Fourier amplitude and relative differences as defined in source",
      "reference_control": "Paired force-opening settings under the original endpoint sensitivity criterion",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json",
          "json_pointer": "/force_pairs/0",
          "sha256": "44d25acd146dffbb900030378d94b50efcc07eafd92c2842cc5817df9ffe045d",
          "expected_identity": {}
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json",
          "json_pointer": "/force_pairs/1",
          "sha256": "44d25acd146dffbb900030378d94b50efcc07eafd92c2842cc5817df9ffe045d",
          "expected_identity": {}
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json",
          "json_pointer": "/force_pairs/2",
          "sha256": "44d25acd146dffbb900030378d94b50efcc07eafd92c2842cc5817df9ffe045d",
          "expected_identity": {}
        },
        {
          "path": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json",
          "json_pointer": "/force_pairs/3",
          "sha256": "44d25acd146dffbb900030378d94b50efcc07eafd92c2842cc5817df9ffe045d",
          "expected_identity": {}
        }
      ],
      "code_version": {
        "scope": "Historical galaxy/catalogue outputs; not reproduced by the reduced benchmark revision",
        "provenance": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json#/source_sha256"
      },
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Individual paired sensitivities; not independent Gaussian uncertainty.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "LIM-08"
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "diagnostics/followup/error-budget.json",
      "comparison": "Paired force-opening settings under the original endpoint sensitivity criterion",
      "physical_control": "Galaxy runs with matched initial conditions and other settings",
      "protocols": [
        "protocols/GALAXY_EXPERIMENT_PLAN.md"
      ],
      "uncertainty_method": "Individual paired sensitivities; not independent Gaussian uncertainty.",
      "protocol": "protocols/GALAXY_EXPERIMENT_PLAN.md"
    },
    {
      "id": "OBS-01",
      "wording": "The released selected observational amplitude sample contains 112 galaxies with median 0.4685. This publication campaign does not reprocess the catalogues.",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#models",
      "model_id": "GAL-LIVE",
      "category": "observational_benchmark",
      "conditions": {
        "source": "S4G; fixed mass selection"
      },
      "observable": "Selected amplitude sample count and median",
      "units": "galaxy count; dimensionless cosine amplitude",
      "reference_control": "Descriptive selected-catalogue amplitude distribution; no matched intervention",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/observational-summary.json",
          "json_pointer": "/s4g_mass_matched_A2",
          "sha256": "bb2f6e3e934e19db31f7b5342282398ac8a5fbff769678abba5e232d234f6bd9"
        }
      ],
      "code_version": {
        "scope": "Historical galaxy/catalogue outputs; not reproduced by the reduced benchmark revision",
        "provenance": "data/manifest.json"
      },
      "figure_version": "2026-09-24.2",
      "uncertainty": "Population spread is not an error bar on one model. Aperture and measurement differences remain.",
      "status": "supported_locally",
      "exclusions": [
        "No observational validation of the local resonance model."
      ],
      "release": "2026-09-24.2",
      "outcome": "data/observational-summary.json",
      "comparison": "Descriptive selected-catalogue amplitude distribution; no matched intervention",
      "physical_control": null,
      "protocols": [],
      "protocol_status": "Historical catalogue selection, not a frozen prospective experiment",
      "selection_record": "data/observational-summary.json#/selection",
      "uncertainty_method": "Population spread is not an error bar on one model. Aperture and measurement differences remain.",
      "protocol": null
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    {
      "id": "LIM-01",
      "text": "One isochrone fast-action slice and finite windows/times; no total halo torque or universal 4.7 correction."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-02",
      "text": "Imposed bar and population-independent additive noise; no collective halo response or calibrated SIDM operator."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-03",
      "text": "Approximate sampling coverage and numerical-refinement proxies; no rigorous operational 5% guarantee."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-04",
      "text": "Eight qualified comparisons share one new dynamical condition and correlated kernel; no eight independent physical regimes."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-05",
      "text": "Prescribed-field 3D transfer remains unresolved; even successful transfer would not validate a live halo."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-06",
      "text": "Cost-times-variance ratios project precision under a fixed workflow; no measured 6900-fold faster simulation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-07",
      "text": "Specific estimator priority and astrophysical generalization remain open; not externally reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "LIM-08",
      "text": "Software reproduction and deployment checks do not independently confirm physics."
    }
  ],
  "review_status": "not_externally_reviewed",
  "extends_historical_ledger": "diagnostics/population-accuracy/CLAIM_LEDGER.md",
  "identities": [
    {
      "id": "EQ-KER-01",
      "status": "exact_under_stated_assumptions",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#kernel"
    },
    {
      "id": "EQ-ERR-01",
      "status": "exact_under_stated_assumptions",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#accuracy"
    },
    {
      "id": "EQ-EST-01",
      "status": "exact_under_stated_assumptions",
      "article_anchor": "paper.html#estimator"
    }
  ]
}