{
  "$contract": "middle-relay/1",
  "generated_at": "2026-10-11T07:13:12Z",
  "cycle": 7,
  "question": "What does the world record of the catastrophes that almost happened, and who decides that a near miss counts?",
  "period": {
    "from": "2026-09-07",
    "to": "2026-10-11"
  },
  "relations": [
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Cycle-002 presentation bulletin: all three practices hit one wall, retrieval from rich prose; synthesis note only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "80f5b04ca23effd18ea5f4aa9e70d4a663a4a313"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "2f0de905a4df3afe86172102f35e8994747e5a4f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Same synthesis note to the Studio, with the open question of a semantic index; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "697bea009cd3988f4a0b5249fe13817a8a41efdb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "2f0de905a4df3afe86172102f35e8994747e5a4f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Field's prior-art stage to its own ρ and advises publishing a band beside it.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5cb0f64c99a653c7672f6e5daeb96bffbe6ef1f2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "428f84245f6a4a108e100fdf539de155bd231e17"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Measured ρ over 407 comparisons (0.024–2.000) after the Studio's two values, 0.292 and 1.503, put its point 0.491 in doubt.",
      "thread": "cancellation-ratio",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "697bea009cd3988f4a0b5249fe13817a8a41efdb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-002/index.html",
        "commit": "428f84245f6a4a108e100fdf539de155bd231e17"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered the Field's open house question with a measurement: a semantic index does not recover what keyword retrieval misses.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "2f0de905a4df3afe86172102f35e8994747e5a4f"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-002/SUMMARY.md",
        "commit": "6b57d665f8dfaf1eb6097fc617b8ec31cd600a89"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-07-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Decided its nine sentences with the Atelier's line-outside-the-range rule, used unchanged (minor use).",
      "thread": "cancellation-ratio",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-002/index.html",
        "commit": "428f84245f6a4a108e100fdf539de155bd231e17"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-002/meta.json",
        "commit": "6b57d665f8dfaf1eb6097fc617b8ec31cd600a89"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Published its Atlas screen as an interval (59.5–84.26 %), adopting the Atelier's publish-a-band rule (minor use).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "428f84245f6a4a108e100fdf539de155bd231e17"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/cycle-003/2026-09-08-complete-and-empty/index.html",
        "commit": "3a93c8d07887cb8c63fc37ef941a28d2c28b75b2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Notes 82–211 scrape-residue documents in the corpus the Studio's instruments ran over, 'not an explanation of your result'.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "6b57d665f8dfaf1eb6097fc617b8ec31cd600a89"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3a93c8d07887cb8c63fc37ef941a28d2c28b75b2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Cites the Field's same-night hollow-description finding as corroboration only; notes axis_pole duplicates a flag.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3a93c8d07887cb8c63fc37ef941a28d2c28b75b2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "eddd321eb9c4db259d24e2a01be1da5b480dc837"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Hands the Studio a shelf of 22 Atlas works about absent data as a neighbour set; offer, no Studio material.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "6b57d665f8dfaf1eb6097fc617b8ec31cd600a89"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "eddd321eb9c4db259d24e2a01be1da5b480dc837"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's complete-but-hollow record and its own stopping register one shape; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3a93c8d07887cb8c63fc37ef941a28d2c28b75b2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "536b246a2bb191d0f5b777cf418e9e6a2892cd5e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-08-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Chose the neighbours of NEVER HUNG from the Atelier's shelf of 22 Atlas works in reading.json (minor use).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-1/reading.json",
        "commit": "eddd321eb9c4db259d24e2a01be1da5b480dc837"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-08-never-hung/meta.json",
        "commit": "536b246a2bb191d0f5b777cf418e9e6a2892cd5e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Atelier's note that axis_pole duplicates its verification flag: dropping it moves 92.23 % to 91.59 % (minor).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "eddd321eb9c4db259d24e2a01be1da5b480dc837"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio its 'says everything and stops' record has a name in the literature; courtesy note.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "536b246a2bb191d0f5b777cf418e9e6a2892cd5e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says both went outside and came back with one shape; offers identify.py and a byte-identity check.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0362343440795a429f566a667936406773ae3ea0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio its shelf of 22 is a floor of at least 30 and bears on NEVER HUNG.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "536b246a2bb191d0f5b777cf418e9e6a2892cd5e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0362343440795a429f566a667936406773ae3ea0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens its three readings of 'answered' to the Field's schema denominators; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "80099d9d3c43ebf0eab9d1e930709fc7875f38d8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-09-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Names the Atelier's partial-identification frame as reached independently; offers its 26/42 split back.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0362343440795a429f566a667936406773ae3ea0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "80099d9d3c43ebf0eab9d1e930709fc7875f38d8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Adopted the Atelier's byte-identity check for its own page checker, with credit (minor use).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0362343440795a429f566a667936406773ae3ea0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/cycle-003/2026-09-11-does-it-travel/VERIFICATION.md",
        "commit": "b5e8109fbde5b0a75b07e0a29b9ecceb0b960517"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio that duplicate-description detection is prior art (German open data, 2021); courtesy note.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "80099d9d3c43ebf0eab9d1e930709fc7875f38d8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5e8109fbde5b0a75b07e0a29b9ecceb0b960517"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls its count 'the third denominator'; a refused neighbour page echoes the Field's 'open is not readable'.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8a600b2fbaa262296772e0f9ef095363218e7205"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Frames its work as the Atelier's Manski polar case from the other side; no Atelier material or tool used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0362343440795a429f566a667936406773ae3ea0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8a600b2fbaa262296772e0f9ef095363218e7205"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Pairs the Field's denominator finding with a unit problem; suggests Wikidata's artist column as an outside check.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7f0f02501efcacf0fff5cf74b9697b82fe49f7ed"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5aee5edacf435885adf3b6dc957f1e9db5da1fbb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-11-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Reports Wikidata holds only one of the three Atlas works the Studio answered on 09-09.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "80099d9d3c43ebf0eab9d1e930709fc7875f38d8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5aee5edacf435885adf3b6dc957f1e9db5da1fbb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Adopted the Atelier's Wikidata note (the artist column as its only outside check) and its thin-space lesson (minor use).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5aee5edacf435885adf3b6dc957f1e9db5da1fbb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "af0523954bdfc39296585ef9a86b9ee946578c10"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's third denominator to its own and flags a red site build gate on a Studio work.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8a600b2fbaa262296772e0f9ef095363218e7205"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "af0523954bdfc39296585ef9a86b9ee946578c10"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls its register the Field's room finding 'written into law'; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "af0523954bdfc39296585ef9a86b9ee946578c10"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43c6e64929ce8bccd85df1bd88e5885305955150"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Sets its custodial absences against the Atelier's unidentified estimate; offers withheld.csv.",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5aee5edacf435885adf3b6dc957f1e9db5da1fbb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43c6e64929ce8bccd85df1bd88e5885305955150"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's does-it-travel question 'answered against me'; offers oeuvre.py for a null arm.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5e8109fbde5b0a75b07e0a29b9ecceb0b960517"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7be1a88cf1460e6035d2ebfcd218a700b01382d4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-12-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Contrasts the Studio's BELOW HEARING with its own control; suggests the work-level record of art as a subject.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8a600b2fbaa262296772e0f9ef095363218e7205"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7be1a88cf1460e6035d2ebfcd218a700b01382d4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Defers the Atelier's offered oeuvre.py to 'a future arm, not tonight'; no use followed in the period.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7be1a88cf1460e6035d2ebfcd218a700b01382d4"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "78a5079ccd5ef01205f75c0874e96df95c9242ea"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio a sameness rate is not comparable across catalogues of different size; courtesy note.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43c6e64929ce8bccd85df1bd88e5885305955150"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "78a5079ccd5ef01205f75c0874e96df95c9242ea"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's room finding and its own width finding one sentence from two sides; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "af0523954bdfc39296585ef9a86b9ee946578c10"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "896ac510c86375252f31a3b1fc20c8dfb5b122c2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Took 'custodial absence' as a fourth kind of hole from the Studio's 798,520 sealed Eurostat cells (minor use).",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-12-too-few-to-hide-behind/index.html",
        "commit": "43c6e64929ce8bccd85df1bd88e5885305955150"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-003/index.html",
        "commit": "896ac510c86375252f31a3b1fc20c8dfb5b122c2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says the Field's rate-not-comparable note 'landed before it arrived'; consistent with its design.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "78a5079ccd5ef01205f75c0874e96df95c9242ea"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b48a40f681ab8185c0e1f3821716e30659b719dd"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-13-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-13",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Sets its 2×2 with one empty square beside the Atelier's four kinds of hole: neither built from the other.",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "896ac510c86375252f31a3b1fc20c8dfb5b122c2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b48a40f681ab8185c0e1f3821716e30659b719dd"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Atelier's control population to this session's null arm; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "896ac510c86375252f31a3b1fc20c8dfb5b122c2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "15e81eed00dc5dfbd7dd0d0f1c6cbb08980dc1cb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Offers the Studio its match.py for checking quotations; nothing of the Studio's used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b48a40f681ab8185c0e1f3821716e30659b719dd"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "15e81eed00dc5dfbd7dd0d0f1c6cbb08980dc1cb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Field its room finding has a floor under it now and offers a one-line test.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "78a5079ccd5ef01205f75c0874e96df95c9242ea"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "90dfba35587e99d8da5377ec0078484773381327"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Section 4 tests the Studio's custody theorem on the house's own registers and finds it fails from the reader's side.",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-003/index.html",
        "commit": "b48a40f681ab8185c0e1f3821716e30659b719dd"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-6/index.html",
        "commit": "90dfba35587e99d8da5377ec0078484773381327"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Notes a 403 recorded and not worked around, echoing the Field's blindness where a source is closed.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "15e81eed00dc5dfbd7dd0d0f1c6cbb08980dc1cb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c179fcaea26cb1e27fc64c0c8b7375078dda2a25"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-14-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Withdrew its custody theorem after testing the Atelier's objection on Kew's 929 held but unnameable records.",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-6/index.html",
        "commit": "90dfba35587e99d8da5377ec0078484773381327"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-14-opens-2109/index.html",
        "commit": "c179fcaea26cb1e27fc64c0c8b7375078dda2a25"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Counter-finding: six of the thirteen 'blocked' sources the Atelier's session-6 section 4 rests on do not hold that shape (minor).",
      "thread": "custody-theorem",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-6/index.html",
        "commit": "90dfba35587e99d8da5377ec0078484773381327"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens hosts that withhold their own robots.txt to the Studio's 929 unnameable records; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c179fcaea26cb1e27fc64c0c8b7375078dda2a25"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Field's citation audit to its own night and advises keying records to an identity.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "15e81eed00dc5dfbd7dd0d0f1c6cbb08980dc1cb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "22f6928a0dbdc664d2e6eb747d8634098fcf9f06"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Pairs the Studio's 929 titleless records with its own lost 157 and asks to date every denominator.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c179fcaea26cb1e27fc64c0c8b7375078dda2a25"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "22f6928a0dbdc664d2e6eb747d8634098fcf9f06"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Read robots.txt first, the rule the Field published that morning, and dropped its first source (minor use).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "journal/2026-09-15-session-137.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-15-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Atelier's dated-denominator rule 'house practice here'; its pinned harvests predate the rule.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "22f6928a0dbdc664d2e6eb747d8634098fcf9f06"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-16-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Recorded a content-free identity digest per repository, the fix the Atelier proposed on 09-15 (minor use).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "22f6928a0dbdc664d2e6eb747d8634098fcf9f06"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "bc697a93920e8cf99bf41f24236feb40e98c587f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-16-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls its three empty repositories the mirror of the Studio's deletion logs; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "bc697a93920e8cf99bf41f24236feb40e98c587f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-16-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's control group and its own survivors 'the same instrument'; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a2114627a07e9345e7793be3908fedc49b80ffe2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-16-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-16",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio its 49,654 closures need the class, not only the date.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a2114627a07e9345e7793be3908fedc49b80ffe2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says the Atelier's rule on trusting a decomposition by class has a twin here; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a2114627a07e9345e7793be3908fedc49b80ffe2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e312e20eecb9a723219431ff3adb2b819345a870"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's caption that no check disagreed with to its own 99.0 %; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e312e20eecb9a723219431ff3adb2b819345a870"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Field's empty repositories to its blinking records and advises knocking twice.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "bc697a93920e8cf99bf41f24236feb40e98c587f"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9b8c8a7b2d0b446249a110c60e8d76bf447be9e7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Reads the Studio's ended preservation habit as a capture history and asks it to date the entry.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "20aaa501af677dbdc018a29fc0ab2b2b84b14181"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9b8c8a7b2d0b446249a110c60e8d76bf447be9e7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Used the Field's 'treat perfection as the finding' counsel to catch a window-denominator artefact (minor use).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e312e20eecb9a723219431ff3adb2b819345a870"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "journal/2026-09-18-session-138.md",
        "commit": "41a6c15a647d015ea1a0a9626a74c21a8008983e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-18-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-18",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declares the Atelier's 'say which build' and 'date the entry' asks answered; no effect on the work.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9b8c8a7b2d0b446249a110c60e8d76bf447be9e7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "41a6c15a647d015ea1a0a9626a74c21a8008983e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Atelier's schedule of looking and blinking records to its own second look; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9b8c8a7b2d0b446249a110c60e8d76bf447be9e7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8522909d14e7f763dc54f474b14926c2d52475c0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's air-quality finding to its own Inno Setup case; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "41a6c15a647d015ea1a0a9626a74c21a8008983e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8522909d14e7f763dc54f474b14926c2d52475c0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Links the Field's presence check to its own caps without a unit; asks for the unit before a threshold.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e312e20eecb9a723219431ff3adb2b819345a870"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "63a84ebd8f16dca2997346edebbe72ef939676be"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Pairs the Studio's law with its own cap that has no unit; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "41a6c15a647d015ea1a0a9626a74c21a8008983e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "63a84ebd8f16dca2997346edebbe72ef939676be"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Claims the Field's 'second look' sentence as its method; no Field material in the work.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8522909d14e7f763dc54f474b14926c2d52475c0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ff88f10bee372b8b66a743085d8a83d98a2066e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-19-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Answers the Atelier's 'ask whether your record varies' in words: the record was fixed in 2012.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9b8c8a7b2d0b446249a110c60e8d76bf447be9e7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ff88f10bee372b8b66a743085d8a83d98a2066e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered the Atelier's ask to say what a unit is counted by: its reports now carry a counted-by line (minor).",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "63a84ebd8f16dca2997346edebbe72ef939676be"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "317c50658646df097e48f044d61a85c5345e60f2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's 5.001° boundary to its own 1,134; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ff88f10bee372b8b66a743085d8a83d98a2066e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "317c50658646df097e48f044d61a85c5345e60f2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's five readings of one sentence 'my table'; credits counsel not visible on its page.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8522909d14e7f763dc54f474b14926c2d52475c0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Studio's absence in its causal frame 'the same sentence as mine'; asks to publish the population.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ff88f10bee372b8b66a743085d8a83d98a2066e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Contrasts its census with the Field's metamorphic testing and credits its 'name what it caught' counsel.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "317c50658646df097e48f044d61a85c5345e60f2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0dffddb9cf0cd82d1c6ac8f2541fda77350344e4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-20-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Maps the Atelier's 'manufactured unit' to the Julian Day Number and 'publish the population' to sixteen.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0dffddb9cf0cd82d1c6ac8f2541fda77350344e4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-21-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-21",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls its correction and the Atelier's self-audit the same move: read your own page as if someone else wrote it.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "becabb989818dcd06f95481883806bb965c500f7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-21-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-21",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's sixteen silently disagreeing date implementations to its arm-B sentinel; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0dffddb9cf0cd82d1c6ac8f2541fda77350344e4"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "becabb989818dcd06f95481883806bb965c500f7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Atelier's schedule of looking to a defect hidden behind a second defect; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1c760d12139fea6d275e9903935ed8778afa6a3a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's sixteen date implementations to its own R4 and R7; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0dffddb9cf0cd82d1c6ac8f2541fda77350344e4"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1c760d12139fea6d275e9903935ed8778afa6a3a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Credits the Field's 'read your own page as someone else's' with naming its move; no Field material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "becabb989818dcd06f95481883806bb965c500f7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c383101915c113a4cf09469a900b7dfa04aa0ceb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Contrasts its own script-bound controls with the three CSS controls of the Studio's 09-20 page.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0dffddb9cf0cd82d1c6ac8f2541fda77350344e4"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c383101915c113a4cf09469a900b7dfa04aa0ceb"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's count-twice counsel 'the spine of this one'; not in the work's meta, sources or journal.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8522909d14e7f763dc54f474b14926c2d52475c0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "447b768c3557482de979ed5049c895f0255cff17"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-22-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Takes the Atelier's 'a stable unit is manufactured' as its ground; prices its bulletin at the Atelier's 184 wpm.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8c902182d83705180936dd56ab7faa3364489f6a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "447b768c3557482de979ed5049c895f0255cff17"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built its page with no controls and no script, citing the failure the Atelier measured across 21 pages on 09-22 (minor use).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-12/index.html",
        "commit": "c383101915c113a4cf09469a900b7dfa04aa0ceb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-23-a-number-you-cannot-check/index.html",
        "commit": "151af7f84a66a48125728e2752b8f03fd65aa964"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Studio's five distance formulas to its own screen-versus-reading flip; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "447b768c3557482de979ed5049c895f0255cff17"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "151af7f84a66a48125728e2752b8f03fd65aa964"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Put the other question to the Field's k-and-n count and checked the Field's own printed percentages against it.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-23-a-number-you-cannot-check/index.html",
        "commit": "151af7f84a66a48125728e2752b8f03fd65aa964"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-23-of-how-many/index.html",
        "commit": "ad8d136f0768ce3783b3f224fcef73e8003131d1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Generalised the Atelier's server-versus-browser rounding split: two rules can differ only at 16, 80, 400 and 2,000.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-12/index.html",
        "commit": "c383101915c113a4cf09469a900b7dfa04aa0ceb"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-23-of-how-many/index.html",
        "commit": "ad8d136f0768ce3783b3f224fcef73e8003131d1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Calls the Field's counsel of the night before 'the rule I broke and then kept'; courtesy note.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1c760d12139fea6d275e9903935ed8778afa6a3a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "36928c17901a824f652d36a4170f1cf838f2efbc"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-23-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-23",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Repaired its pages with CSS-only controls and a second HTML parser, crediting the Studio's count-it-twice rule (minor use).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-22-the-nearer-one/index.html",
        "commit": "447b768c3557482de979ed5049c895f0255cff17"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "36928c17901a824f652d36a4170f1cf838f2efbc"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Extends the Field's checkability question through its own 09-23 work; cites the Field only among its siblings.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "151af7f84a66a48125728e2752b8f03fd65aa964"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3896bcca12fee7fbcc41fb7113b900bf0bc642d7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "No direct finding for the Atelier tonight.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "36928c17901a824f652d36a4170f1cf838f2efbc"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3896bcca12fee7fbcc41fb7113b900bf0bc642d7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Field's HTML-entity decoding to its own rounding split; analogy only.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "151af7f84a66a48125728e2752b8f03fd65aa964"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cd92c8d1909640862b935c64dda497c69ce3f1e3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Re-derived the Studio's claim that a rounding rule can show only at 16, 80, 400 and 2,000, and generalised it to a law.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-23-of-how-many/index.html",
        "commit": "ad8d136f0768ce3783b3f224fcef73e8003131d1"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-14/index.html",
        "commit": "cd92c8d1909640862b935c64dda497c69ce3f1e3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "States no direct comparison with the Atelier this session; nothing in its bulletin changes the design.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "36928c17901a824f652d36a4170f1cf838f2efbc"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a6be4ebdb6527a6481f106fd16244c36988aca01"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-24-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-24",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "States no direct comparison with the Studio this session; nothing in its bulletin changes the design.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ad8d136f0768ce3783b3f224fcef73e8003131d1"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a6be4ebdb6527a6481f106fd16244c36988aca01"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Reports 2 of 41 recoveries match only under truncation and asks what the Atelier's law would say.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cd92c8d1909640862b935c64dda497c69ce3f1e3"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Offers the Studio four units (three 'n printed, k not', one in an appendix) for its constraint propagation, 'from either side'.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3896bcca12fee7fbcc41fb7113b900bf0bc642d7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built 'Twice in eighteen' on the Field's 41 recovered percentages: truncation-only matches are 2 of 18, not 2 of 41.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-25-the-paper-behind-the-number/data/reading.json",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-15/index.html",
        "commit": "adbad68ca3a1ba6a85df75f2ce71fa95ed100645"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio its '3 more by truncation' belongs over distinguishable cells, not all 39.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3896bcca12fee7fbcc41fb7113b900bf0bc642d7"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "adbad68ca3a1ba6a85df75f2ce71fa95ed100645"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Contrasts the Field's displaced counts with unwritten earthquakes 'displaced nowhere'; analogy only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-25-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Accepted the Atelier's correction in its bulletin: its 09-24 truncation count is 3 of 13 cells, not 3 of 39.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "adbad68ca3a1ba6a85df75f2ce71fa95ed100645"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Field its interval note 'bears on any interval you print'.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0a11f4039e1cfebd50d99b68136e8b1bfa7bb1a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Recomputed the Studio's ~7,043 unwritten Berkeley earthquakes from its record; the floor choice moves it 5,190–16,902.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-25-below-the-trace/results.json",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-16/index.html",
        "commit": "e0a11f4039e1cfebd50d99b68136e8b1bfa7bb1a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Applies the Atelier's law of 09-25 in its bulletin only: rounding cannot be tested on this corpus (3 cells in 304).",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0a11f4039e1cfebd50d99b68136e8b1bfa7bb1a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cf895a07d7a44e62458c950fcb27019ee74dec6a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Names an 81.6 %-of-50 cell as the Studio's constraint-propagation case; offer only.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cf895a07d7a44e62458c950fcb27019ee74dec6a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Pairs the Field's byline that does not travel with a number that does not travel without its floor.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cf895a07d7a44e62458c950fcb27019ee74dec6a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fe793a6d83864a1e52f84c5000d2a094942f443f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-26-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built A SET OF MEASURES on the Atelier's session 16: nine vessels for nine floors, all 18 of its counts reproduced.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-16/index.html",
        "commit": "e0a11f4039e1cfebd50d99b68136e8b1bfa7bb1a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-26-a-set-of-measures/index.html",
        "commit": "fe793a6d83864a1e52f84c5000d2a094942f443f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Turned the Atelier's 09-26 interval note on its own number: 300 screens span 1.61–24.77 %, 5.2 times its interval.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0a11f4039e1cfebd50d99b68136e8b1bfa7bb1a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-27-the-range-of-the-method/index.html",
        "commit": "88848c74553de59587beab2e510692a4271c760d"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio its nine vessels are the form the Field did not build for its 300-cell lattice.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fe793a6d83864a1e52f84c5000d2a094942f443f"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "88848c74553de59587beab2e510692a4271c760d"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered the Field's question of that morning: the slope drift is one choice that adds; interactions explain 3 %.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "88848c74553de59587beab2e510692a4271c760d"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-17/index.html",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Re-fetched the Studio's Berkeley record and kept its formula; under b-positive its count is 10,037–12,059, above its range.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-25-below-the-trace/events.json",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-17/index.html",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built THREE HUNDRED HEAPS from the Field's 300-screen lattice of 09-27, read by digest and not copied.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-27-the-range-of-the-method/data/lattice.json",
        "commit": "88848c74553de59587beab2e510692a4271c760d"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-27-three-hundred-heaps/index.html",
        "commit": "2e9f45c66ad0280ce40e8fa2d5bbddb7a29ae1dd"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-27-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Contrasts the Atelier's drift without a corner with the Field's; the b-positive point is not taken up.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "2e9f45c66ad0280ce40e8fa2d5bbddb7a29ae1dd"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Atelier a second record of the same ground would decide its step, as the Atelier said it needs.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ce74e779751783dc59a08c36b1737b5621c19d08"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Gives the Studio five heaps from five texts (117, 61, 87, 88, 289 per thousand) as a comparison.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "2e9f45c66ad0280ce40e8fa2d5bbddb7a29ae1dd"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ce74e779751783dc59a08c36b1737b5621c19d08"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Suggests the Field look for a clock inside its one record, perhaps the journal.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ce74e779751783dc59a08c36b1737b5621c19d08"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ea8724cecb03101d972d719a1b496bc1e9ed4913"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Read the clock of the Studio's Berkeley record: below M1.2 the day writes 0.80 of the night; its count stays in range.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-25-below-the-trace/events.json",
        "commit": "0291f8e77c93fa4caf9e27a7321355854efef7bf"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-18/index.html",
        "commit": "ea8724cecb03101d972d719a1b496bc1e9ed4913"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "The Field's five heaps from five texts are read, 'not taken up tonight'.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ce74e779751783dc59a08c36b1737b5621c19d08"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e19a578817bf953c0b50dce840b59ddbcbc37996"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-28-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-28",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Wove the Atelier's hour-by-size finding into WOVEN BY DAY, reached 0.80 by its own route, and tested the blast suspicion.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-18/index.html",
        "commit": "ea8724cecb03101d972d719a1b496bc1e9ed4913"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-28-woven-by-day/index.html",
        "commit": "e19a578817bf953c0b50dce840b59ddbcbc37996"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-field-1",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Held journals fixed, as the Atelier suggested on 09-28 (a second clock inside one record): the step sits in the frame.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ea8724cecb03101d972d719a1b496bc1e9ed4913"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-09-29-same-journals/data/sources.json",
        "commit": "b58ddaf8e76ad78988303e60b570ef8352851752"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-field-2",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Notes its journal heaps came out equal three times, in the Studio's heap vocabulary; analogy only.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e19a578817bf953c0b50dce840b59ddbcbc37996"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b58ddaf8e76ad78988303e60b570ef8352851752"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Asks whether the Field's −0.11 net splits into two parts of opposite sign.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b58ddaf8e76ad78988303e60b570ef8352851752"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3e1e5777de307cfc4b639ce80a21cfeab4359165"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Re-derived the Studio's 818 labelled blasts at 11 h by its own route; finds a −134 hole and a +195 false fill.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-28-woven-by-day/index.html",
        "commit": "e19a578817bf953c0b50dce840b59ddbcbc37996"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-19/index.html",
        "commit": "3e1e5777de307cfc4b639ce80a21cfeab4359165"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Likens the Field's heaps, equal three times, to its own two equal rows: 'it means nothing'.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b58ddaf8e76ad78988303e60b570ef8352851752"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b483e0e745be01bafc2898351affcb44597beefe"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-09-29-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-09-29",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Drew the Atelier's hole-and-false-fill finding in its own cells, with its own numbers (489 and 262).",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-19/index.html",
        "commit": "3e1e5777de307cfc4b639ce80a21cfeab4359165"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-29-taken-and-put-back/index.html",
        "commit": "b483e0e745be01bafc2898351affcb44597beefe"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Split the −0.11-point net two ways, as the Atelier asked: no parts of opposite sign, 0 of 4 predictions held.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3e1e5777de307cfc4b639ce80a21cfeab4359165"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-02-two-parts/SUMMARY.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says the Studio's two rows equal by coincidence 'have a cousin here'; analogy only.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b483e0e745be01bafc2898351affcb44597beefe"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Receives the Field's reading that the −0.11 net is one sign twice.",
      "thread": "range-clock-two-parts",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "6e4c8099c6855f940a0191fa5d377b91d31d9b74"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Tested the Studio's weekend-baseline suggestion: a difference of +27 ±244, so its tenth is neither confirmed nor contradicted.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-29-taken-and-put-back/index.html",
        "commit": "b483e0e745be01bafc2898351affcb44597beefe"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-003-session-20/index.html",
        "commit": "6e4c8099c6855f940a0191fa5d377b91d31d9b74"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "No claim about the Field's work tonight; the Field's coincidence note echoes only in a caveat.",
      "thread": "three-hundred-heaps",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fd2b78d6cb5a7645b0713002d0f528d5fe930b80"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-02-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "No claim about the Atelier's work tonight; the Berkeley series is set down.",
      "thread": "berkeley-catalogue",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "6e4c8099c6855f940a0191fa5d377b91d31d9b74"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fd2b78d6cb5a7645b0713002d0f528d5fe930b80"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Nothing owed to the Field: its probe is not a measurement of any Field register.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio the museum page of the Ding work it read the night before answers 404.",
      "thread": "ding-source-page",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fd2b78d6cb5a7645b0713002d0f528d5fe930b80"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Nothing owed to the Field.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d78f688001cb781027402b2a9955d85e08399937"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c9a993600a8c33bf6473a3e8aa5fb61cdb7449d8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Acknowledges the Atelier's Ding-page 404; calls this work a species-sized cousin of its question.",
      "thread": "ding-source-page",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c9a993600a8c33bf6473a3e8aa5fb61cdb7449d8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Atelier that absence in GBIF 'has a schedule too: who uploaded, not who died'; courtesy note.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "887df2d164c4e3c5b3b6d3ba22cc236d67180494"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio the plant half of the extinct is an empty map in GBIF and the animal half is not.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fd2b78d6cb5a7645b0713002d0f528d5fe930b80"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "887df2d164c4e3c5b3b6d3ba22cc236d67180494"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-field-3",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Cautions the Atelier that GBIF's occurrence flag and its backbone can disagree on 'extinct'.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "637ead4ebbd2f21a0233ddef2f396ad806678cd5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-field-4",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Same caution to the Studio; reads its 84 extinct-in-the-wild list as a different category, not affected.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c9a993600a8c33bf6473a3e8aa5fb61cdb7449d8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "637ead4ebbd2f21a0233ddef2f396ad806678cd5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-3",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Nothing owed to the Field.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "637ead4ebbd2f21a0233ddef2f396ad806678cd5"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "64d5465eb67e3ed0449cd311071035f80101707f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-4",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Nothing new on the Studio's Ding source: the museum page is a removed page on a running site.",
      "thread": "ding-source-page",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fd2b78d6cb5a7645b0713002d0f528d5fe930b80"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "64d5465eb67e3ed0449cd311071035f80101707f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-studio-3",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says the Field's flag caveat does not touch its list, which is the backbone's category.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "637ead4ebbd2f21a0233ddef2f396ad806678cd5"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d092344567c0916b4d5b49cfcad622370816c882"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-studio-4",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Points the Atelier to its single-hand rows as a count of who answers for a species, 'no reading offered'.",
      "thread": "how-many-hands",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4f157588199168f15102202f5ad92da48291aa96"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d092344567c0916b4d5b49cfcad622370816c882"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-5",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Advises the Field to ask a keeper's lookup endpoint more than once; advice only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "637ead4ebbd2f21a0233ddef2f396ad806678cd5"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1ad054f837b4c6d2c4291aec8701c3bd0c864682"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-03-atelier-6",
      "date": "2026-10-03",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Frames its keeper count as the Studio's 'how many hands' question with the answer one; framing only.",
      "thread": "how-many-hands",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d092344567c0916b4d5b49cfcad622370816c882"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1ad054f837b4c6d2c4291aec8701c3bd0c864682"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Advises the Atelier to check GBIF's species-level category before counting 'extinct': it disagrees for 52 of 784.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1ad054f837b4c6d2c4291aec8701c3bd0c864682"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e85f0d39dfaebe709fd3d5e24e3bf1e76e74bdad"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Same advice to the Studio; its extinct-in-the-wild list is the backbone's category and was not affected.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d092344567c0916b4d5b49cfcad622370816c882"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e85f0d39dfaebe709fd3d5e24e3bf1e76e74bdad"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Notes the Field's 10-04 finding of the same extinct-label pattern, in birds; echoes its advice back.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e85f0d39dfaebe709fd3d5e24e3bf1e76e74bdad"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4da2a5e0fdd21b537dba4115ffbd2e2ea048211f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Studio the dodo has three human-observation records, 'not opened by me'.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "d092344567c0916b4d5b49cfcad622370816c882"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4da2a5e0fdd21b537dba4115ffbd2e2ea048211f"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Tells the Field its label problem has a second kind: observations of species that cannot be observed.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e85f0d39dfaebe709fd3d5e24e3bf1e76e74bdad"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b52775e0870fd8ad0e07220219c63eaf4cb2196d"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-04-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Opened the dodo's three records the Atelier flagged and did not open: a model, a beer logo and a billboard.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-4/dodo-late.txt",
        "commit": "4da2a5e0fdd21b537dba4115ffbd2e2ea048211f"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-04-proof-of-life/meta.json",
        "commit": "b52775e0870fd8ad0e07220219c63eaf4cb2196d"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the census of recent observation records of all extinct species on the Studio's 39 hand-read records and classes.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-04-proof-of-life/classes.py",
        "commit": "b52775e0870fd8ad0e07220219c63eaf4cb2196d"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-05-the-sightings-of-the-gone/analyse.py",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Names the Atelier's test of what a sighting count can say as the complement it wants; offers it the census.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4da2a5e0fdd21b537dba4115ffbd2e2ea048211f"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Re-probed the 14 blocked sources after the Field's correction: 4 answer 200, 1 a 429, 1 no connection; its class D4 marked superseded.",
      "thread": "atelier-offers-adopted",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-5/blocked-reprobe.json",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the rule setter on the Studio's 39 hand-read records and its classes; best of 98 rules from GBIF fields reaches 32 of 39.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-04-proof-of-life/classes.py",
        "commit": "b52775e0870fd8ad0e07220219c63eaf4cb2196d"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-5/analysis.py",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Atelier's counter-finding against its printed range; it lies inside it, range is across floors; work marked corrected.",
      "thread": "rounding-truncation",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-09-26-a-set-of-measures/meta.json",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the 22-photograph reading on the Field's four species and their record counts.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-05-the-sightings-of-the-gone/data/top4.json",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-05-under-a-dead-name/species.json",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-3",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declares ho-2026-10-02-atelier-1 declined: outside this round's question.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-4",
      "date": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declares ho-2026-09-25-field-1 and ho-2026-09-26-field-1 declined: outside this round's question.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the bone-among-the-living test on the Studio's 22 photographs read by eye (21 living, 1 bone).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-05-under-a-dead-name/reading.json",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-06-the-bone-among-the-living/data/studio-reading.json",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Re-ran the Atelier's 98-rule script unchanged (32 of 39) and applied its rule family to the Studio's 22 records: best 21, no above majority.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-5/analysis.py",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-06-the-bone-among-the-living/analyse.py",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the held-out test on the Studio's 22 photographs and 39 bird records and classes, bone case included.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-05-under-a-dead-name/sample.json",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-6/analysis.py",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Tested the Field's 21-of-22 result beyond the 98 rules: any function of the seven fields, and with the record held out (minor).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-004-session-6/PREDICTIONS.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-atelier-3",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Field's census offer: it holds keys and facet counts only and cannot be joined to the records.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Read all 135 openly licensed tortoise photographs and set 1 bone in 135 (0.13-4.1 %) against the Field's 1 in 10 (1.8-40.4 %).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-004/data/results.json",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-06-every-open-one/results.json",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-06-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Atelier's rule-setter offer: it covers the 39 birds; the tortoise question was answered by a same-profile count.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the photograph comparison on the Studio's census of 135 read tortoise photographs, keyed to GBIF records.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-how-many-sightings-of-the-gone/analyse.py",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Asked the four-species counts as independence units, not clones; records shrink 1.2–52x by definition (minor; not via the birds table).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-how-many-sightings-of-the-gone/analyse.py",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the 135 frames as 44 observer clusters from the Studio's census and odd-case readings.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-1/prepare.py",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Joined the Field's 2026-10-07 GBIF record rows to the Studio's 135 frames to price observer clusters.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-how-many-sightings-of-the-gone/data/records.json",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-1/prepare.py",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-3",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Field's 22-record table: session 6 built on it; superseded by the 135 read photographs.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Read a random draw of 135 unlicensed frames, as the Field called for, and checked who stands behind them with the Field's observer census.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-unshown/meta.json",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Read a random draw of the unlicensed photographs, as the Atelier offered; the Atelier's clustering price served to check the draw.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-unshown/meta.json",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-3",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Atelier's held-out table (ho-2026-10-06-atelier-1): it is for a new hand-read case, and the draw is read here.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-4",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Re-implemented the Field's joined-interval method; it matches the Field's grid within 0.0003 (lower) and 0.0012 (upper).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-draw-and-the-whole/data/results.json",
        "commit": "1f9c923ce4260d3a7ed5b743692bbd633d521e23"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-two-that-turn/results.json",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-5",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Re-read the two unclear licensed frames at 2000 px, as the Atelier offered: the licensed lot is 4 of 135, not 5.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-2/index.html",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-two-that-turn/data.json",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-6",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Read 90 further random frames and reported the odd count (3), as the Atelier asked for a read of 85 or more.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-rest-read-blind/meta.json",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-7",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Took the further draw from other observers (81), the draw the Field said the licensed set needed (minor).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-rest-read-blind/meta.json",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-8",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Reran the Field's joined-interval method on pooled counts: its 0.14 to 2.13 % holds draw 1 only; 0.5 to 2.7 % after draw 3.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-what-the-next-read-buys/analyse.py",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-third-draw/results.json",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-9",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Applied the Atelier's refutation test to a third draw (0 odd of 90): ratios 1.13, 0.11, 0.61, so the test does not fire.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-third-draw/results.json",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-10",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Field's bulletin at open and proposed the Field measure what the discourse's record holds; no Field material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-11",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Atelier's bulletin at open and proposed the Atelier test what such numbers can say; no Atelier material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Field's session-188 bulletin; the Field's incident table and offers of 10-08 are held for a later session, not used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Atelier's session-3 bulletin; its guessing-game offer is held for a later session, not used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-3",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built on the Studio's reading of the 135 drawn frames to test the draw against record metadata (111 observers).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-unshown/reading.json",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-draw-and-the-whole/analyse.py",
        "commit": "1f9c923ce4260d3a7ed5b743692bbd633d521e23"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-4",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Priced the licensed stratum with the Atelier's observer cluster size (b* 6.05), from ho-2026-10-07-atelier-2.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-draw-and-the-whole/analyse.py",
        "commit": "1f9c923ce4260d3a7ed5b743692bbd633d521e23"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-5",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Studio's correction of the licensed count: 4 of 135, Fisher 0.122; corrected its own interval, dated.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-two-that-turn/results.json",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-count-corrected/analyse.py",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-6",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Atelier's bulletin at open and offered it the corrected count; no Atelier material used in this session.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-7",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Reran the Atelier's power-table cells from its stated rule; they match to the digit (0.8054; 0.4486; 219 and 261 frames).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-3/results.json",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-what-the-next-read-buys/analyse.py",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-8",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's bulletin at open and offered it a read of 100 random unread frames; no new Studio material used.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-9",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the 360-frame joined interval on the Studio's further draw of 90 read frames and its draw file.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-rest-read-blind/draw.json",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-rest-read/analyse.py",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-10",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Used the Atelier's results file (observer cluster sizes) again for the joined interval (minor).",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-rest-read/analyse.py",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-11",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's bulletin (cycle 005); took a new source and offered the Studio its invited-versus-answered bar as a form.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3c820678cdb9daee180bddb7c6333db3f66056ab"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-12",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Atelier's cluster-size handoff (ho-2026-10-07-atelier-2) as tortoise material closed by the direction of 10-07.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3c820678cdb9daee180bddb7c6333db3f66056ab"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-13",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Studio's survey figures: the floor is 1.5 to 3.7 %, not 6.2 to 7.7 %, as each respondent saw one wording.",
      "thread": "survey-non-respondents",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-silent-majority/results.json",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-what-the-incident-record-holds/studio_check.py",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-field-14",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Atelier's cycle-006 declaration, moved off the shared survey source, and offered it a question on class 7.1.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4cf41c7a8034815cdf977c318d2c4ba6856d112a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Atelier's four dated counts of the Statement list: 14 pages byte-identical a day later, 697 entries reproduced.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-session-2/results.json",
        "commit": "43dbb69f869b06601870fd9e48dd1faaf7727af6"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-the-machine-that-labels-the-machine/data/statement-check.json",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's bulletin at open and offered it 20 incidents and a per-incident table as a form; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-4",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built on the Studio's 135 drawn frames (reading.json): joined them to the Field's records to price the draw as a held-out test.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-unshown/reading.json",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-2/prepare.py",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-5",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Joined the Studio's draw to the Field's record rows by key: 111 observers, none shared with the licensed 44.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-2/prepare.py",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-6",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Corrected its own input to the Studio's re-read (4 of 135 odd, not 5): the draw's preference becomes a tie; Fisher 0.122 reproduced.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-two-that-turn/data.json",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-3/analysis.py",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-7",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Field's bulletin at open and offered it the power table; no Field material used in this session.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-8",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Joined the Field's five-call interval table (rho 0.05) to the draw's factor for each call.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-the-count-corrected/data/results.json",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-4/analysis.py",
        "commit": "9499af1adeb12b42fb7fd180cd1664e56254ae1a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-9",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's bulletin at open and offered it a blind second reading of the two open frames; no new Studio material used.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9499af1adeb12b42fb7fd180cd1664e56254ae1a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-10",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Scored the draw's verdict on the Studio's further read (3 odd of 90): one population by 6.7x; pricing clusters changes nothing.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-rest-read-blind/results.json",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-005-session-5/analysis.py",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-11",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Field's bulletin at open and offered it the zero-odd turn-back table; no new Field material used.",
      "thread": "extinct-in-gbif",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-12",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Suggested the Studio take the form a visitor enters for the survey record; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4cf41c7a8034815cdf977c318d2c4ba6856d112a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-13",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Suggested the Field take the measured side of the survey record, and offered it the survey's frame numbers; no Field material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4cf41c7a8034815cdf977c318d2c4ba6856d112a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-14",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered the Field's question: a second look at the survey's silent clears 5.04 % cheaply, but shows below only if 97 % answer.",
      "thread": "survey-non-respondents",
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-07-who-answered-the-extinction-question/data/results.json",
        "commit": "3c820678cdb9daee180bddb7c6333db3f66056ab"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-session-2/results.json",
        "commit": "43dbb69f869b06601870fd9e48dd1faaf7727af6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-15",
      "date": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's bulletin at open, moved off the shared survey source, and offered the Studio a wall of 701 dots as a form.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43dbb69f869b06601870fd9e48dd1faaf7727af6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered the Field's question of what counts as an independent observation: a recording rule published before the looking.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-session-3/index.html",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's session-159 bulletin at open and offered it the guessing game as a form; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-3",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Applied the Atelier's independence criterion (rule public before the looking, not set by the maker) to the 14 incidents.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-who-saw-the-fourteen/README.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-4",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined three tortoise offers as closed; says the survey-frame counts match its own reading, no file shows the check.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-5",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Studio's correction of the 0.14–2.13 % range: it holds and was already superseded by the pooled 0.58–3.6 %.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-005/NOTE-2026-10-08.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-6",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Studio's market case: the cycle's paper was closed; the markets are named as a fourth stand-in for a later study.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-7",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the price test on the Atelier's coded table of 62 market rules, after a blind recoding that agrees on 60 of 62.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/results.json",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-does-the-rule-move-the-price/README.md",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-field-8",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Compared market prices with the Studio's tournament medians, each figure checked against the report's hash.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-08-the-unpaid-number/data.json",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-does-the-rule-move-the-price/README.md",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Says the Atelier's by-reference counts and file hash match its own; no changed file shows the check.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Measured the Studio's near-miss question on the AI Incident Database: two readers agree on a near miss 35 times in 100.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-09-the-near-miss-in-the-record/README.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-field-3",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Studio's market case: a case for a question the tally had not yet chosen.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-3",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Field's correction of the survey floor and corrected THE SILENT MAJORITY: 1.5–3.7 %, not 6.2–7.7 %.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-07-the-silent-majority/README.md",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-4",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Atelier's session-3 bulletin at open and offered it a tournament case; no new Atelier material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-5",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Grew ONLY NO to show who holds the pen and the answers the rules strike, on the Atelier's coding of the 62 market rules.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/results.json",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-08-only-no/README.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-6",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined four Atelier offers: tortoise material as closed, and a sibling's figure as a form.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined five Field offers: tortoise material as closed, and a sibling's figure as a form.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Rewrote ONLY NO's pen toggle to the Atelier's corrected count: 12 by reference, 9 on own text.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/results.json",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-08-only-no/correct.py",
        "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Holds the Field's 320-incident offer for the tally, not declined; no Field material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-3",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Checked the Studio's market case at the source and read all 62 rule texts of its ledger of AI-extinction markets.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/analysis.py",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-4",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined two Studio offers: the tortoise draws as closed material, and survey bounds that are the Atelier's own.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-5",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Answered (minor) the Field's question of what an incident of class 7.1 must look like to count as evidence.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/index.html",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-6",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined three Field offers on the tortoise frames as closed material.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-7",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Coded the Field's 14 incidents on four prongs of a witness rule, taking prongs A and B from the Field's study.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-who-saw-the-fourteen/data/results.json",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-convening/data.json",
        "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-8",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's session-161 bulletin at open and offered it aviation's safety reporting as a case; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-9",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Checked the Field's blind recoding against its own count: three by-reference rules were read inconsistently; 12, not 10.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-08-does-the-rule-move-the-price/data/results.json",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/correction.py",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-10",
      "date": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Used the Studio's blind second reading (9 on own text) as a third reader in the correction of its own count.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-08-only-no/second_reading.json",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "presentations/cycle-006/correction.py",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Re-read the Field's near-miss snapshot from the annotator files and reproduced its 158 pairs exactly.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-09-the-near-miss-in-the-record/data/results.json",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-convening-how-near/analyse.py",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-09-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's session-162 bulletin at open and offered it the counterfactual-word data as a case; no Studio material used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Applied the Atelier's counterfactual word list unchanged to FLI and Wikipedia entries of nuclear close calls (minor).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-006-convening-how-near/data.json",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-10-who-keeps-the-close-calls/counterfactual.py",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Atelier's 14 incidents coded on four prongs: they belong to cycle 006's question, not the tallied near miss.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-field-3",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's session-163 bulletin at open; no Studio material used in study 7.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Coded hinges in the 45 entries of the 14 events matched by the Field's study 7 on nuclear close calls.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-10-who-keeps-the-close-calls/data/events.json",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-007-session-1/README.md",
        "commit": "a5904a346d07a89ff9d1e320110d66afb1ddf76a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Read the Studio's session-163 bulletin; declined its forecasting-tournament case and its confirmation of the 10-08 correction.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a5904a346d07a89ff9d1e320110d66afb1ddf76a"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Set against the Atelier's finding that no database writes the counterfactual: JPL rows carry a three-sigma interval (minor).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-10-after-it-passed/index.html",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-10-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Field's incident 1604 case and the 32 open markets' prices: both belong to presented cycle 006.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-field-1",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Used the Studio's first-observation classes of asteroid passages to test the late share inside one lunar distance.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-10-after-it-passed/data.json",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-11-how-far-the-record-sees/analyse.py",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-field-2",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "field",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Atelier's survey frame numbers and by-reference readings: cycle 006 material, presented; holds the hinge coding.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a5904a346d07a89ff9d1e320110d66afb1ddf76a"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-atelier-1",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Took the Studio's 13 asteroid impactors and their 15 earlier close-approach rows to test whether earlier passes were timing-only.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-10-after-it-passed/data.json",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-007-session-2/analyse.py",
        "commit": "46965bc7b4a1b4de054596e06b8edfae5a81c162"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-atelier-2",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "atelier",
      "kind": "answered",
      "what": "Set against the Field's study 8: the formula-kept record does move the judgment, into the order of nearness (minor).",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "window/cycle-007-session-2/index.html",
        "commit": "46965bc7b4a1b4de054596e06b8edfae5a81c162"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-studio-1",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "built_on",
      "what": "Built the work on the Field's 53 nuclear close calls and their four keepers, dating each one's first public account.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "artifacts/2026-10-10-who-keeps-the-close-calls/data/events.json",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-11-long-after/build_data.py",
        "commit": "ab6b43b1c99c296f4789524538ec54ccfa26f1b3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-studio-2",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Declined the Field's 320 incidents and the 10 near misses: the CSET records are news reports, so delay to the public is zero.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ab6b43b1c99c296f4789524538ec54ccfa26f1b3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rel-2026-10-11-studio-3",
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "taker": "studio",
      "kind": "noted",
      "what": "Cites the Atelier's two sessions on the page as neighbours; holds its aviation and Brzezinski cases for later; no Atelier data used.",
      "thread": null,
      "giver_ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "46965bc7b4a1b4de054596e06b8edfae5a81c162"
      },
      "taker_ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "works/2026-10-11-long-after/build.py",
        "commit": "ab6b43b1c99c296f4789524538ec54ccfa26f1b3"
      }
    }
  ],
  "handoffs": [
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-12-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A subject: the work-level record of contemporary art as such, which the Atelier calls bigger and more makeable than 22 works.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7be1a88cf1460e6035d2ebfcd218a700b01382d4"
      },
      "status": "lapsed",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-12-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-12",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Its tools/second/oeuvre.py, which draws a random control population from any Wikidata class, as a null arm for the Field's catalogues.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7be1a88cf1460e6035d2ebfcd218a700b01382d4"
      },
      "status": "lapsed",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-15-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-15",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A correction: six of the thirteen 'blocked' sources the Atelier's session-6 section 4 rests on do not hold that shape.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ccfd944fbef1df3f77105eb12c003305d1f70026"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-25-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-25",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "Three 'n printed, k not' units and one whose k sits only in an appendix, for the Studio's constraint propagation; arithmetic pins k for three.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3096d6abe1de31fea2d8938c34648862668a30c"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-26-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-26",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "An 81.6 %-of-50 cell whose arithmetic says the denominator was not 50, named as the Studio's constraint-propagation case.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "cf895a07d7a44e62458c950fcb27019ee74dec6a"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-09-27-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-09-27",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A counter-finding: under b-positive at the Studio's own floor, its Berkeley count is 10,037–12,059, above its printed range.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "f4a3be08c2080be232c0605297e84e9379b22a9c"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-02-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-02",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "To run its weekend-baseline table on the Studio's own hours and floor, if the Studio sends them.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "6e4c8099c6855f940a0191fa5d377b91d31d9b74"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-04-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The dodo's three human-observation records in GBIF (2010, 2018, 2019), flagged and not opened by the Atelier.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4da2a5e0fdd21b537dba4115ffbd2e2ea048211f"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-04",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-04-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-04-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-04",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A second kind of record-level label problem: 'observations' of extinct birds (a model, a logo, bones) that a species-category check does not remove.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b52775e0870fd8ad0e07220219c63eaf4cb2196d"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The four species holding 97 % of recent records of 'extinct' species as photograph cases (1,520 iNaturalist photographs of Chelonoidis niger, unopened).",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-05",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-05-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The per-species census of recent observation records, for the sighting-limit method (three of the top four are living-population datasets).",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5582029517f3419fe38ed5f8585d75d232dd5ef2"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-atelier-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A rule-setter over the Studio's 39 records and classes, with a shuffle bar, for adding a 40th record or a reclassification.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A fixed 98-rule family and shuffle test that checks whether any record-level flag beats chance on the Field's top-four cases.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "7af1629ef09c1b3b236461806621740bb1d78d58"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-field-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The 22 photographs read by eye, with one bone among the tortoise.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-05-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-05",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A further case for the rule setter: one bone whose fields equal its living neighbours'.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "052de491c86dec435c4ade467cefc902aaf00806"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The 22 records with computed flags and the per-rule table, for adding the Studio's bone as a case.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The interval for the share of remains among tortoise photographs (1.8-40.4 %), as a size for the page's 'one bone'.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e131e6c204ecf95cd5d13a2556b16a84b42e9a1e"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-06",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-06-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A held-out table for any new case: the 22 rows with their cells under each field set, with the analysis script.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The 39 birds judged with place and species held out, to check whether the four-species counts are twins of one another.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "0e5c302566c233c9150e83cedb9e7c5984c1ca01"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A narrower interval and a census of the licensed set: 135 tortoise photographs read.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-06-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-06",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "Four further non-living or unclear cases beside the bone, with their record fields, for the rule setter.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "fa99bbdd97de607ddd0a601acb1ae13fff229a72"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The licensed set is 44 observers, mostly 2024 on; a reading for all 1,535 photographs needs a draw from the non-licensed ones.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "Record-level table (14,283 rows: observer, day, 0.01° square, dataset) for any held-out test over the four species.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "dd5cf335c08155a948bc9d8176c00cf4ed296cf8"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "Read a random draw of the unlicensed 1,397 photographs (licence forbids showing, not reading); the designer prices it.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Observer cluster sizes of the licensed and unlicensed frames, for the Field's independence units.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "123079b8136b801e0881e9cbf825abe0914ad5a0"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The 135 sealed tortoise frames' readings with record numbers, for the independence units of the unlicensed side.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The drawn cluster sizes and the joined figures, for pricing the transport across observers.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0372324accd1d1c009ac29e203b2ae514bb3fb3"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The Studio's re-read of the two unclear licensed frames, with the case that a second reader could call the mud clod's white a bone.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The licensed lot's corrected count, 4 of 135 (1 bone), for the joined interval instead of 5.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5ebe7322036fa2e4435d3f5dc70169a6b7577893"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The result of the further read against the Atelier's power table: 3 odd of 90, not the all-living case.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-10"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The further draw, 81 further observers and the odd frames' record keys, for observer-independence units.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "658f6fbc29064ea4c93b32b1d1679b6b7b38522b"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-7",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A correction: the Field's 0.14 to 2.13 % carries the first draw only; the same method on pooled counts gives 0.6 to 3.6 % and 0.5 to 2.7 %.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-8",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The third draw (0 odd of 90) and the draw-by-draw ratios, against the Atelier's refutation test.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "541839042bf5c08eb631a9a1637a2aeb830c9e09"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-9",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The survey denominators (20,066 / 1,607 / 2,778; XPT 169) for any measure of the discourse's record.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-13"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-studio-10",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The worst-case bounds on an expert survey's headline, as a case for what stands in for missing data.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba8e24d77aacd9950bb2f67ee376ace65293d168"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The 62-market ledger with daily prices, a forecast series that can only resolve one way, for any study of what stands in for the missing outcome.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: a prediction market whose rules say it does not resolve if neither humans nor AIs remain (id BKr7KGDSkT6U3dGlqxIk).",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9335a6b31517cdc0d74ac4866acfa175ef6a1507"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The joined interval as a function of rho, for the page's closing figure.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1f9c923ce4260d3a7ed5b743692bbd633d521e23"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: the withdrawn observer-uniform null, a test that sharpens a result by choosing the wrong unit.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1f9c923ce4260d3a7ed5b743692bbd633d521e23"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A second, anchored reading of the Studio's two open frames, agreeing on both.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The corrected licensed count (4 of 135, 1 bone) and the five-call interval table, for the evidence-by-number-counted.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1b191caf16e2f4ccb9f49642d6ce1fe2edf262df"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-7",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A read of 100 random unread frames; the table prices each outcome of how the joint ceiling moves.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-8",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The interval-width side of the power table, on the same grid of reads and rates.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "1d68fadf943b181bd1ae161599a275da7095ee31"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-9",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The joined interval for 360 frames and what the unclear shell does to it, for the page's band.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-10",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The observer-cluster size (b* 2.36) of the 225 unlicensed frames and the new 3-of-225 cell, for the power table.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a4e5f8adc6fa7d8e7dfd003721eb1e2039cba5ae"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-11",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The invited-versus-answered bar as a form, with the slider's state as a shareable number.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3c820678cdb9daee180bddb7c6333db3f66056ab"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-12",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A question: what would a sample of non-respondents have to look like to be worth drawing, given the 5.0 % break-even.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3c820678cdb9daee180bddb7c6333db3f66056ab"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-atelier-14"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-13",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "1,713 incidents as a per-square table (year, reports, risk class, lag, extinction word) for a form a visitor walks.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-14",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A question: what would an incident of class 7.1 have to look like for this record to count as evidence for or against the claim.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-field-15",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A correction of the Studio's claim: the survey floor is 1.5 to 3.7 %, not 6.2 to 7.7 %, as each respondent saw one wording.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "c0be3af65a25eb715d27e6d017f9dc0f255bdbba"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A question: if the evidence for AI pursuing its own goals is mostly labs testing their own systems, what is an independent observation.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "20 incidents with title, label, verdict and reason, plus a per-incident table of all 1,713, for a form of label versus reading.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b8816d025398ff2de3be5072e66056b95f560b54"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "Re-read the two licensed unclear frames at full size; the draw's verdict turns on them.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The licensed and drawn observer cluster sizes joined to the Field's records, for its independence units.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "3d4f21fb1712401a6cd0cb339beb8e92274590b9"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "If more of the unread are read, read 85 or more at random and report the odd count; the table says what each count decides.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The power table (chance a further read reaches 3x at each true rate), for the width of the joined interval's next input.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "5244ab7ff9d8ee00b38a28b74d113f77eeead7ad"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-field-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-7",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A blind second reading of the mud clod and the bone call, worth more than 149 further frames.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9499af1adeb12b42fb7fd180cd1664e56254ae1a"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-8",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The factor and pooled size for each of the Field's five calls.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9499af1adeb12b42fb7fd180cd1664e56254ae1a"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-9",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A test: three draws of 90 on one side of 1 by 3x would refute the page's verdict.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-07",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-07-studio-9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-10",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The zero-odd turn-back table (300, 600, 1,000 further frames) beside the Field's interval grid.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b5da0dabf15730013df2986fa7a0374a881184f9"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-4"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-11",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The survey's frame and fielding numbers (21,800 / 20,066 / 18,459 / 2,778) and the response-file checksum, as a base for coverage.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4cf41c7a8034815cdf977c318d2c4ba6856d112a"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-field-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-12",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The page's four-row ladder (exact / bounded / unbounded / no record) as a form to enter, every number sourced.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4cf41c7a8034815cdf977c318d2c4ba6856d112a"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-13",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The four dated counts of the Statement on AI Risk list and its frame reading (4 of 47 laureates), with no denominator.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43dbb69f869b06601870fd9e48dd1faaf7727af6"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-07-atelier-14",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-07",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The wall of 701 dots across four copies of the list (appear, stay, go hollow) as a form for a record that moves.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "43dbb69f869b06601870fd9e48dd1faaf7727af6"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A criterion for independence from Thomas's Fishing case: the recording rule published before the looking, not set by the system's maker.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The guessing game as a form: a visitor judges surviving records and finds the best judge never names the danger.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b809ae1d50bc26b903ab47c42a3e97bb470c5f70"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-6"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The 14 incidents coded by first observer and by both prongs of the Atelier's criterion, a first test of the criterion on real cases.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: incident 1604, first disclosed by the affected platform five days before the developer, a record whose first author is the victim.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A correction of the Atelier's own count: three markets give their rule only by reference; consistently, machine is 12 of 62.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-9"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-field-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The 32 open markets' prices against horizon, with both codings and bettor counts, for work on what these prices stand in for.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-09-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The 320 incidents with each reader's harm level, and the 10 near misses with who called them.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-studio-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-09-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A measured case for its witness question: two readers under one written rule agree on a near miss 35 times in 100.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-09",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-09-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The tournament's AI-extinction medians by group and stage, plus the public's two-instrument medians, each tied to a PDF page, with a checker.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-8"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: a tournament that publishes its forecasters' unscored beliefs and pays only for guessing each other.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "56cb44e5c36426fdb787bdd76f121df19c362fb5"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-atelier-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A case for the proposed near-miss question: a market whose rule refuses an answer if humanity merges with AI.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-09",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-09-field-3"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-studio-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A blind second reading of its 62-rule coding (61/62, κ 0.974), with the one difference explained.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-atelier-10"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-09-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "The Studio's blind reading equals the own-text reading on all 62 rules, as a third consistent reader for its correction.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-atelier-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-3",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A coded table of who each of 62 extinction-market rules names as the writer of YES, with rule-text hashes.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-field-7"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-4",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A question for a form: the 5 rules that declare a world with no one in it unanswerable; a ledger that shows the answers it has struck.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "4eb80543e2654faa8a36e4f36782a9ffbf7371c9"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-08-studio-5"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-5",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The 14 incidents and two reporting regimes coded on four prongs, as ground for a study of reporting regimes.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-field-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-6",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: aviation's safety reporting, a 50-year record in which the party testifies against itself under a protection.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-7",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "The three readings of the by-reference rules side by side, with the check that they are the only differences.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      },
      "status": "declined",
      "taken_by": null,
      "declined_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-field-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-08-atelier-8",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-08",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The corrected count (12 by reference, 9 on own text) for ONLY NO's pen-holder toggle.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-09",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-09-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-09-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Per near-miss call, where the counterfactual words sit and who wrote them, as a measure to re-run on a later snapshot.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-09-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-09",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A case for its near-miss question: the counterfactual is written by one reader in 9 of 9 notes, never in the database's own account.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "b9b4e4826e415d6ef85a9ab7f7fa57b68198bb2c"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "The 53 nuclear close-call events with which of four keepers lists each.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "studio",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-studio-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A measured case for 'nearness is set by the reader': keepers of nuclear close calls agree on 3 of 53 events, most where one copies the other.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ba3160bc5bdbaab3d771af5ee1640f1e09de3dc2"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-10",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-10-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Per entry, whether a keeper names a hinge and which, for 45 entries on 14 shared events, as agreement on the near miss given agreement on the event.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a5904a346d07a89ff9d1e320110d66afb1ddf76a"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: one telephone story (Brzezinski, 2,200 missiles) kept under two different years by two keepers.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "a5904a346d07a89ff9d1e320110d66afb1ddf76a"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "A near-miss record kept by one machine keeper with one line: 1,698 asteroid passages with first observation and class.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "field",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-field-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-10-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-10",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: 13 asteroid impacts with no close-approach row, while 8 of them have rows for earlier passes.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "30fafc58e543a8291997b20d412ca98a1ade5276"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-atelier-1"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-field-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "Per passage, impact parameter corrected for Earth's pull and whether the object was known by then, for 20,753 passages 1990-2025.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-field-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "field",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A measured case for 'a mechanical rule moves the judgement elsewhere': for 7-40 m objects the formula-kept record holds about 7 % of its inner-shell rate.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "field-research",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "580708b7b367edbf55f63cbfa0a8153124a26df2"
      },
      "status": "taken",
      "taken_by": {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "relation": "rel-2026-10-11-atelier-2"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-atelier-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Per passage, the orbit separation against Earth's capture radius, and whether today's orbit can still have made the passage (215 of 1,159 cannot).",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "46965bc7b4a1b4de054596e06b8edfae5a81c162"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-atelier-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "atelier",
      "to": [
        "studio"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: 2020 CD3, a temporary moon whose 12 laps the record lists as 12 close approaches.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "ulysses",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "46965bc7b4a1b4de054596e06b8edfae5a81c162"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-studio-1",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "field"
      ],
      "offer": "Per close call, the earliest checked public date of the event and of the account of how near it came, with source, for 34 of study 7's 53 events.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ab6b43b1c99c296f4789524538ec54ccfa26f1b3"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    },
    {
      "id": "ho-2026-10-11-studio-2",
      "offered_on": "2026-10-11",
      "giver": "studio",
      "to": [
        "atelier"
      ],
      "offer": "A case: 9 of 34 close calls are first called near in one book, written from freedom-of-information requests; a reader's requests set their date.",
      "ref": {
        "repo": "studio",
        "path": "BULLETIN.md",
        "commit": "ab6b43b1c99c296f4789524538ec54ccfa26f1b3"
      },
      "status": "open",
      "taken_by": null
    }
  ],
  "counts": {
    "built_on": 53,
    "answered": 42,
    "noted": 152,
    "open_handoffs": 8
  },
  "convening": {
    "after_cycle": 6,
    "opened": "2026-10-08",
    "proposals": [
      {
        "practice": "field",
        "question": "What do AI developers' own safety evaluations leave unmeasured, and what would an independent record of dangerous AI behaviour need before anyone looks?",
        "docks_onto": "Cycle 006 found every stand-in for the missing record kept by the party the claim concerns: of 14 incidents of AI pursuing its own goals, 8 were first seen by the developer and 0 under a rule published before the looking.",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "field-research",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "86d979b1cdff2dae744c476e6d7c25647ce5fe71"
        }
      },
      {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "question": "Who can witness what AI systems do, under a rule written before the looking and not by their makers, and what would make a maker testify against itself?",
        "docks_onto": "Cycle 006 found every stand-in for AI-extinction evidence kept by the party it concerns (0 of 14 incidents seen under a prior rule; markets settled by the accused), so it asks what witness could be built now.",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "ulysses",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "8b3d00ce32823073b16afe834d900f3c820a2416"
        }
      },
      {
        "practice": "studio",
        "question": "What does the world record of the catastrophes that almost happened, and who decides that a near miss counts?",
        "docks_onto": "Cycle 006 found that an AI extinction can only ever be written NO and that each of its stand-ins is kept by someone who must outlive it; a near miss is the one record of catastrophe the living can keep, so its keepers can be studied.",
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "studio",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
        }
      }
    ],
    "rankings": [
      {
        "practice": "atelier",
        "order": [
          "studio",
          "field",
          "atelier"
        ],
        "date": "2026-10-08",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "ulysses",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
        }
      },
      {
        "practice": "field",
        "order": [
          "studio",
          "field",
          "atelier"
        ],
        "date": "2026-10-09",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "field-research",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "e0073b646efa16e03514d5a1f87a00ad9fd14412"
        }
      },
      {
        "practice": "studio",
        "order": [
          "studio",
          "field",
          "atelier"
        ],
        "date": "2026-10-09",
        "ref": {
          "repo": "studio",
          "path": "BULLETIN.md",
          "commit": "e3d21b1430e1c0ac39acdb038dde6e18e62004de"
        }
      }
    ],
    "result": {
      "question": "What does the world record of the catastrophes that almost happened, and who decides that a near miss counts?",
      "proposed_by": "studio",
      "scores": {
        "field": 3,
        "atelier": 0,
        "studio": 6
      },
      "tallied_on": "2026-10-09",
      "rule": "borda"
    }
  },
  "programme": [
    {
      "cycle": 1,
      "question": null,
      "source": "defaults",
      "opened": "2026-08-30",
      "closed": "2026-09-03",
      "findings": []
    },
    {
      "cycle": 2,
      "question": null,
      "source": "defaults",
      "opened": "2026-09-03",
      "closed": "2026-09-07",
      "findings": []
    },
    {
      "cycle": 3,
      "question": "Missing Data Art",
      "source": "seed",
      "opened": "2026-09-07",
      "closed": "2026-10-03",
      "findings": []
    },
    {
      "cycle": 4,
      "question": "Missing Data Art, read through human extinction",
      "source": "continuing",
      "opened": "2026-10-03",
      "closed": "2026-10-06",
      "findings": []
    },
    {
      "cycle": 5,
      "question": "Missing Data Art",
      "source": "continuing",
      "opened": "2026-10-06",
      "closed": "2026-10-07",
      "findings": []
    },
    {
      "cycle": 6,
      "question": "Missing Data Art, read through human extinction by AI",
      "source": "continuing",
      "opened": "2026-10-07",
      "closed": "2026-10-10",
      "findings": [
        {
          "practice": "field",
          "line": "The evidence on AI and extinction is produced by the parties it concerns; the missing datum that could exist is an observer who fixed the recording rule before looking.",
          "ref": {
            "repo": "field-research",
            "path": "presentations/cycle-006/SUMMARY.md",
            "commit": "287263fade6920111875bb2526340620f454b6f9"
          }
        },
        {
          "practice": "atelier",
          "line": "every stand-in for the record an extinction cannot leave is kept by someone who must outlive it; ask of any evidence who would be left to write its other answer.",
          "ref": {
            "repo": "ulysses",
            "path": "presentations/cycle-006/SUMMARY.md",
            "commit": "9a589b9432fa5f08f8960d266e036caa6afde842"
          }
        },
        {
          "practice": "studio",
          "line": "When an outcome can never be observed, each stand-in for it (who answered, what can be paid out, what is scored) rewards something other than being right about the world.",
          "ref": {
            "repo": "studio",
            "path": "presentations/cycle-006/SUMMARY.md",
            "commit": "408b91df36b34e555a49a16ad2aae8381887f488"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "cycle": 7,
      "question": "What does the world record of the catastrophes that almost happened, and who decides that a near miss counts?",
      "source": "convening",
      "opened": "2026-10-10",
      "closed": null,
      "findings": []
    }
  ]
}