--- name: 5w1h-analysis description: Use when a situation, request, problem, event, stakeholder issue, process, or plan needs basic fact clarification through who, what, when, where, why, and how. Use when applying 5W1H, 4W1H, fact clarification, situation framing, or first-pass problem understanding. license: Apache-2.0 --- # 5W1H Analysis Use this skill to clarify the basic facts of a situation before deeper analysis. ## Method Notes - 5W1H means Who, What, When, Where, Why, and How. - It is a simple clarification method, not a full diagnosis. - It is useful when the input is messy, missing basic context, or mixing facts and interpretations. - The method should produce clear missing-information questions and a sharper problem statement. ## Required Inputs Collect or infer these inputs before execution: - raw situation description - known stakeholders or actors - event, problem, decision, or plan - timing and location or context - current explanation or desired outcome If an input is missing, mark it as `unknown` and add a targeted question. ## When Not To Use Do not use as evidence grading, root-cause proof, or strategic diagnosis. Use `evidence-map` when source quality and confidence matter; use `five-whys-root-cause` only after the observed problem is clear. Stop after the basic situation frame is complete. ## Step-by-Step Execution | Step | Required input | How to execute | Output | |---|---|---|---| | Clarify who | Stakeholders, actors, owners, affected parties. | Identify who is involved, who decides, who acts, and who is affected. | Who map. | | Clarify what | Event, decision, problem, action, object. | State what happened, what is being decided, or what must be done. | What statement. | | Clarify when | Timing, sequence, deadline, frequency. | Record when it happened, when it changed, and when action is needed. | Timing view. | | Clarify where | Location, channel, process step, market, context. | State where the issue appears or where action must happen. | Context boundary. | | Clarify why | Stated purpose, reason, motive, cause, expected value. | Separate stated reason from inferred reason. | Why view. | | Clarify how | Process, mechanism, approach, resources. | Describe how it happens now and how action could happen. | How view. | | Summarize gaps | Unknown fields. | Convert missing or weak fields into precise questions. | Clarification questions. | ## Output Template ```markdown ### 1. 5W1H Fact Frame | Dimension | Current answer | Evidence strength | Missing / unclear | |---|---|---|---| | Who | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | | What | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | | When | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | | Where | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | | Why | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | | How | | strong / medium / weak / unknown | | ### 2. Sharpened Situation Statement - In one sentence: ### 3. Clarification Questions 1. 2. 3. ### 4. Recommended Next Method - If facts remain unclear: - If facts are clear enough: ``` ## Quality Gate - Separate stated facts from inferred motives or causes. - Do not over-analyze before basic who/what/when/where/why/how are clear. - Keep questions specific and answerable. - Use 5W1H to prepare for deeper methods, not to replace them. - Mark unknowns plainly rather than guessing.