Digitized copy served via HathiTrust.
Buckley's prose, page breaks, speaker turns, stage directions, Greek and Latin quotations, and footnotes are preserved. Speaker turns point explicitly to the Smyth/Perseus Greek edition. Each Smyth card was aligned by direct comparison of its Greek wording with Buckley's literal English; exact turn starts were used where available. Passages absent from Buckley are represented by explicit gaps rather than false English alignments.
This pointer pattern extracts a speaker turn.
The return of Agamemnon from Troy, in company with Cassandra, and the murder of both by Clytemnestra.
Let morning become, as the adage runs, a herald of gladness from its mother night. And learn thou a joy greater than thy hope to hear; for the Argives have taken the city of Priam.
I say that Troy is in the power of the Argives—speak I clearly?
Joy is stealing over me, that calls forth a tear.
Ay, for thy countenance proves thy loyalty.
Why, what sure proof hast thou of these things?
I have a proof—why not?—unless the deity hath deluded me.
Art thou, then, reverencing the vision of dreams, that win easy credence?
I would not take the opinion of my soul when sunk in slumber.
But did some wingless rumour gladden thy mind?
Thou sharply mockest my sense as that of a young girl.
And at what time hath the city been sacked?
I say in the night that hath now brought forth this day.
And what messenger could come with such speed?
To the gods, my queen! I will make prayer hereafter; but I could wish to hear and to admire once more, at length, these tidings as thou tellest them.
My queen, thou speakest sensibly like a prudent man; and I, having heard thy sure tokens, prepare myself to make fitting addresses to the gods; since no inglorious reward of our toils hath been achieved.
Whosoever, in this matter, prays otherwise for this our city, may he himself reap the fruit of his soul’s trespass.
O! father-land of the soil1 of Argos, in this the light of the tenth year am I arrived, mastering one only hope, with many broken down. For never dared I think that, dying, I should share a burial dearest to me in this Argive land. Now hail to thee, country mine, and hail to thee light of the sun, and to thee O Jove, supreme god of the realm, and to the Pythian king, that no longer with thy bow dost launch thy shafts against us. Enough unfavouring comest2 thou by Scamander; but now in turn be thou our saviour, and freer from our contests3 and I address both all the gods of battle and my patron Mercury, beloved herald, herald's glory, and the heroes that sent us forth, that they may kindly welcome back again the residue of the host that has escaped the spear. O halls of our kings, dear roofs! and awful judgment-seat, and ye divinities that face the sun, if ever in the olden times ye did with these your bright eyes receive with honourable greeting our sovereign after his long absence; for king Agamemnon is come, bringing a light in darkness common to you and to all
I feel joy; and no longer do I refuse the gods to die.
Did love of this thy father-land train thee?
Aye, so that mine eyes swim with tears of joy.
Ye were then smitten with this pleasant malady.
How? learning [from thee] I shall master this speech3.
As being smitten with love for them who loved thee in turn.
Say'st thou that this country longed for the army which longed for it?
Yes, so that full oft I sighed from my saddened soul.
Whence came this desponding horror on the people4?
Long since have I considered silence as an antidote to mischief.
And how didst thou fear any5 when the chiefs were absent?
Even as thou saidst just now, and to have died were matter of great thanks1.
Yea, for we have fared well. But this in a long time one might say that some things fall out well, but others on the contrary are open to complaint; for who, save the gods, is free from suffering throughout all time for evermore? For were I to tell our hardships, and our bad lodgments, our approaches [to the shore] infrequent and ill-bedded,—and in what part of the day were we not sighing, as not having met with our portion2?—And then again the ills on shore were added, more loathly still: for our beds were hard by the walls of our foes : and from the sky and from the soil the meadow-dews drizzled on us, a deep rankling destruction to our garments making our hair shaggy. And were any one to describe the winter, death to birds, how intolerable the snow of Ida made it, or the sultriness, when ocean, having sunk upon his noon-tide couch unruffled by a breeze, slumbered3 without a ripple.—What need is there to grieve over this? the toil is past—past too with the dead is even the thought about ever hereafter rising. Why need one take exact account of those that fell, and why should the survivor feel sorrowed on account of adverse hap? I deem it good to bid a long farewell to misfortunes. With us, the remnant of the host of the Argives, the advantage preponderates, the suffering counterpoises not: wherefore it is fair for us, flying over sea and land, to make our boast to this light of the sun. "The armament of the Greeks, having at length captured Troy, have fixed these spoils as a glory to the ancient shrine4 of the gods throughout Greece."
Those that hear such tidings must glorify our city and our commanders; and the favour of Jove, which hath brought this to pass, shall be honoured. Thou hast my whole tale.
Long since, in truth, I raised the jocund shout through delight, when the first mighty messenger of fire arrived, telling of the capture and overthrow of Ilion.—And some one chiding me said, “Dost thou, persuaded by beacon-lights, think that Troy has now been sacked? Verily it is like a woman to be much elated in heart." By words like these I was made to seem in error1. Nevertheless I went on sacrificing; and, by a woman's edict, one and another, in different places throughout the city, raised aloud a shout of joy, pouring forth a hallowed song in the dwelling of the gods, while they lulled the fragrant incense-fed flame. And now what need is there for thee to say more to me? From the king himself I shall hear the whole tale. And I will haste to welcome back my revered lord on his return as well as I possibly can : for what day is more delightful for a woman to behold than this, to throw open the gates to a husband returning from warfare, when a god hath kept him safe? Bear thou this message to my husband, that he come with all speed, desired oy the city. And may he coming find a loyal consort in his house, just as he left her, a watch-dog of his home attached to him, a foe to the ill-disposed, and in -all other points alike, not having destroyed one single seal in the course of long time. I know not delight nor slanderous report from another man any more than brass does of dyeing2.
Thus hath she spoken, as beseems2 a clear interpreter. to you that learn. But do thou tell me, Herald! I ask about Menelaus, whether he too returning and preserved will come back along with you, a chieftain beloved by this land3.
I cannot tell pleasant falsehoods, that my friends can enjoy for any length of time.
How then mightest thou, while telling good things, tell true4? But 'tis full plain that these two things are severed.
The man is vanished from the Grecian armament, himself and vessel: I tell no falsehood.
Was it when he was putting to sea from Ilion before your eyes, or did a tempest, a common bane, tear him away rom the host?
Thou hast hit the mark like a capital archer, and hast expressed in brief a long sorrow.
Was a rumour bruited by the rest of the mariners that he survived or had perished?
No one knows, so as to report clearly except the sun that nurtures earth's nature.
Why! How dost thou say that the tempest came upon the naval armament, and ended through the wrath of heaven5?
"care"5
correctly named, avenging at a late season the dishonour of the board, and of Jove, guardian of the hearth, punishing them who loudly honoured the marriage song, which then befell the nuptial party to sing. But the Priam's ancient city, now taught another song, is wailing. I ween, in loud lament calling Paris the ill-wedded, having all the time before led a life of many laments, because, of the hapless blood of her inhabitants.
And yet say not thus against my fancy.
Rest assured that I will not spoil my resolution.
Didst thou pray to the gods, fearing that thou would'st act thus in this point1?
If ever man did, be sure that I have with perfect knowledge uttered this as my final decision.
And what thinkest thou Priam would have done, had he achieved this triumph?
I think in truth he would have stalked upon embroidery.
Do not now stand in awe of the censure of men.
Yet sure at all events the voice of popular clamour has mighty power.
Aye, but he that is not envied is not worthy of admiration.
Truly, 'tis not a woman's duty to be fond of contest.
Yet surely in the blest even to yield is becoming.
And dost thou value the victory in this strife?
Yield thee ; give me the victory cheerfully.
There is a sea—and who shall drain it ?—that breeds the drops of abundant purple, worth its weight in silver, constantly renewed, the dye of vestments. To thy house, O king, belongs good store of these by the gods' gifts, and thy dwelling knows not a want [of them]. I would have vowed the trampling of many vestments, had it been enjoined me in the prophetic shrines when I was planning ransoms for this life of thine. For while the root exists, foliage springs in the
To thee she leaves off speaking clear words, and now that thou art within the toils of destiny, yield thee, if thou canst yield; but perchance thou mayest be unyielding.
But if she be not, like a swallow, endowed with an unintelligible barbaric voice, speaking to her mind I am persuading her with my speech.
(to Cassandra.) Follow her; she says what is best for thee of the things that are at present in thy power; yield thee, and leave this thy seat in the ear.
Nay, I have no time to linger here with her outside the door, for the sheep are already standing ready for the sacrifice of the fire of the central hearth, inasmuch as we never hoped to have this joy; and if thou wilt do aught of this my bidding, delay not. But if, not understanding, thou apprehendest not my speech, do thou, instead of voice signify it to me with thy barbaric hand.
The stranger seems to stand in need of a clear interpreter: and her behaviour is as of a wild beast newly taken.
Aye, surely she is raving, and lends an ear to evil thoughts, she that bath come here after leaving a city newly taken; and she knows not how to bear the bit, before that she foams away her bloody mettle:—in truth I'll not submit to be insulted in wasting more [words].
But I, for I pity thee, will not be angry with thee. Come, wretched one, having left this car empty, submitting to this thy doom, hansel the yoke.
Why sayest thou, Woe! for Loxias?—for he is not such [a god] as to have a mourner.
She with ill-omened outcry is again invoking the god not suited to stand by in wailings.
She seems to be upon the point of divining, touching her own ills. Divination remains even in the mind of a slave.
To that of the Atreidae: if thou perceivest not this, I tell it thee, and thou shalt not pronounce this to be a falsehood.
The stranger maiden seems to be keen-scented, like a hound, and to be seeking whose blood she may discover.
Verily we had heard of thy renown as a prophetess; but we seek not for prophets.
I am unskilled in these prophetic bodings—but those I understand, for the whole city bruits them.
Nor yet do I understand thee; for now I am bewildered by oracles obscure with their riddling strain.
What kind of Erinnys is this that thou art summoning to sound her trumpet-blast over the house? thy words cheer me not: and to my heart has run the drop of saffron dye, which also, in the last hour of man, keeps pace with the rays of the setting sun of life. But calamity comes on apace.
I cannot boast of being a sharp judge of weird words, but I liken these to some misfortune. And from weird words what good tidings are sent to mortals? by means of weird-song wordy lore brings evil terror [for us] to learn.
Thou art a maniac possessed; and touching thyself dost wail a strain unmusical, like a dun nightingale insatiate of song, alas! in her wretched soul bewailing Itys, Itys, through her life thick-teeming with woes.
Whence hast thou ungovernable woes, bursting impetuously on thee, with wanderings of speech1, and sent by the gods? and whence is it that thou modellest in song thy horrors with dismal-omened outcry, and at the same time with shrill-sounding lays? whence dost thou ken the ill-boding boundaries of the prophetic path?
What is this but too distinct saying thou hast uttered? a child might understand it. And I am stricken beneath with a murderous pang, while thou plaintively wailest in thy sad sorrowing lot, wonders for me to hear.
These words hast thou uttered in unison with those before them. And some evil-thinking god falling upon thee heavily, makes thee chaunt sufferings, lamentable, deadly. But for the issue I am at a loss.
And how can oath, a pledge honourably pledged1, heal the mischief? But I marvel at thee, that, bred beyond the sea, thou shouldst succeed in speaking to a city of strange tongue, just as if thou hadst been present.
What! was he, a god, smitten with a passion for you
Heretofore I was ashamed to tell this tale2.
Aye, for every one that is very prosperous grows delicate.
But he was an eager suitor, breathing strong love for me.
Did you even meet in wedlock?
Having consented, I deceived him.
Wast thou already possessed of inspired lore?
I was even then predicting all their sufferings to my countrymen.
How then wast thou unscathed by the wrath of Loxias?
I used to win no one's credence in any thing, after I had committed this trespass.
Yet to us at all events thou seemest to utter things worthy of belief.
HO! ho! alas! alas! oh miseries! again the dread task of true prophecy is racking me, troubling me with the preludings of predictions. See ye these infants sitting' here on the palace, like to the phantoms of dreams?—children just as if they had perished by the hands of their friends,—their hands crammed with the meat of their own flesh; and they stand forth holding their bowels along with their entrails, a piteous mess, of which their father tasted3. For this, I tell
I say that thou shalt witness the death of Agamemnon.
Wretch! lull thy ill-omened tongue in silence4.
But the god of healing presides not over this declaration.
No, if indeed it is to be; but never may it be!
Thou prayest indeed,—but murder is their care.
By what man is this sad deed1 prepared?
Verily, thou must have very much overlooked my oracles.
Like enough, for I understand not the device of the accomplisher.
And yet verily I know the Grecian language too well2.
Yes, and the Pythian oracles, and yet they are hard to understand.
Ah me! what a fire is that! and it comes upon me! Woe! woe! Lycaean Apollo, ah me! ah me! this biped lioness, that lay down with a wolf in the absence of the generous lion, will slay me, wretched woman; and as though she were compounding poison she will add my price to her wrath3. She boasts, while she whets the blade for her husband, that she will exact his murder as a punishment for having brought me hither. Why then do I retain these mockeries of myself, my wands and my prophetic wreaths about my neck? —I will destroy you before my own doom. Go fall into destruction—thus will I rid myself of you; enrich some other maiden with calamities in my room. Lo, too, Apollo himself stripping me of my oracular vesture! and having beheld me even in this array, idly laughed to scorn among my friends, by my foes with no changing of the scale! I poor, wretched, dying of starvation, bore to be called vagrant, like a begging gipsy. And now the prophet, having avenged himself on his prophetess. hath brought me to these deadly woes. And, in place of my sire's altar, a butcher's block awaits me, cut down, a hot reeking victim. Yet. verily, we shall not at all events die unhonoured of the gods. For there shall come hereafter another avenger
There is no escape, strangers, nothing is to be gained by time3.
Yet the last has the advantage in time.
This day has arrived; 'tis little I shall gain by flight.
Be sure, thou hast stout resolution in thy undaunted spirit.
Yet to die gloriously is surely a gratification to a mortal.
No one hears these sentiments from the happy4.
Alas, my sire, for thee and for thy noble children!
What is the matter? what terror turns thee away?
Faugh! faugh!
Why criest thou, faugh! unless there be something which thy heart loaths?
The palace reeks with blood-dripping murder.
How sayest thou? this is the smell of victims at the hearth.
'Tis plainly like a fume from the grave.
No Syrian luxury art thou describing in the house.
But I will go to shriek over my own destiny and that of Agamemnon also within the palace. Enough of life. Alas, strangers! Yet do I not vainly quail in terror, like a bird at a bush1. Do ye bear this testimony to me dying, when a woman shall perish for me a woman, and a man shall fall for one that was ill-mated. These boons I claim from you as on the point of death.
Wretched one, I pity thec for thy predicted doom.
Yet once more do I wish to utter a speech, or mine own dirge2. And (looking upon) his light for the last time, I pray the sun, upon my hated murderers, that they may at the same time pay the penalty for a slave, that dies an easy victim, to my avengers their murderers3. Alas for the condition of mortals! them when prosperous a shadow may overturn; but
" Enter here no more."
And to this our sovereign the blessed gods have granted to capture the city of Priam; and he returns to his home honoured by heaven. Yet if now he is to pay the price of the bloodshed of his predecessors, and dying for the dead accomplish to the full the vengeance2 due for the deaths of others, who among mortals that hears this tale would not pray to be born with an innocuous genius3?
"a blow,"
mortally wounded?
But let us in some way or other concert unfailing measures.
But to me it seems best that we should, as quick as possible, burst in and detect the deed by the fresh-dripping sword.
And I agreeing in such an opinion, vote that we do something—and high time it is that we dally not.
We may see that plainly; for they are preluding, as though displaying signs of a tyranny over the city.
Aye, for we are tardy2: but they, trampling to the ground the reputation of delay, are not slumbering in hand.
I know not what plan I have to tell you—'tis the doer's part also to take counsel.
I too am in the same state, since I am unable to raise the dead again by my words.
What! shall we prolong our lives thus submitting to these rulers that disgrace the house?
Nay, 'tis beyond endurance; to die is better; for 'tis a milder doom than tyranny.
Shall we augur as though the king has perished, on proofs drawn from outcries?
We ought to speak of these things, having clear knowledge; for to guess is distinct from clearly knowing.
I am inclined on all accounts to recommend that we clearly learn how Atrides fares3.
We marvel at thy tonguc, how bold thy language is, thou that dost boast in such words over thy husband.
Ye are trying me like a senseless woman; but I say with heart undaunted to you that know,—and 'tis all one
NOW too, thou hast perfectly accomplished by an inexpiable murder the memorable strife-begotten strife which formerly existed in the house, a bane to its master3.
Ah me! for this slave-like couch; smitten down by a death from a treacherous hand, with a two-edged weapon.
Ah me! for this slave-like couch! thou wast smitten down by death from a treacherous hand, with a two-edged weapon.
And who, pronouncing with tears the funeral panegyric4 over the godlike man, shall wail in sincerity of soul?
Aegisthus! I honour not insolence amidst guilt. And dost thou say, that thou didst wilfully slay this man, and that thou alone didst plot this piteous murder? I declare that thy head shall not escape, be sure of it, curses of stoning, hurled by the populace.
Woman! didst thou, guardian of the house of this man just arrived from battle2, having at the same time defiled his bed, resolve on the destruction of this warrior-chief here?
These words too are the first parents of mourning. Thou hast a tongue quite opposite to that of Orpheus; for he. indeed, led all things along for joy of his voice. whereas thou having angered us by thy silly yelpings3, shalt be dragged away: but when overpowered thou wilt show thyself more tame.
As if thou forsooth shouldst be sovereign of the Argives, thou, that when thou hadst resolved on his destruction, daredst not to do this deed by a stroke of thine own hand4?
Aye! for to plot was plainly a woman's part; and I, an ancient foe, was a suspicious object. However, by means of this man's wealth, I will try to rule the citizens; and the over-fed colt that is unruly, and draws not as I direct, I will yoke in heavy harness1; but famine, that dwells with hated darkness, shall see him softened.
O why didst not thou thyself with thy dastard heart slay this man here? but his wife, a pollution of her country and her country's gods, killed him. Does then Orestes anywhere behold the light, so that, returning hither under the guidance of gracious Fortune, he may become the mastering slayer of these twain?
Come on, comrades dear, this business is not far off.
* * * * * * *
Come on, let each man have his drawn sword in readiness.
I'faith I refuse not to die with hand on hilt.
Thou talkest of dying to those who welcome the omen, and let us take our fortune.
By no means, dearest of men, let us perpetrate any further ills. But to reap even these is in many respects a wretched harvest. And enough of misery assuredly is ours; let us not at all stain ourselves with blood. Repair, old men, forthwith to your appointed2 homes, before you suffer by your deeds: we must take these things and be contented with them since we did them; and if any one has a share of troubles, we at all events shall have enough of these, miserably smitten by the daemon in his fell wrath. Such is a woman's advice, if any one condescends to heed it.
But that these men should thus blossom forth a foolish tongue in my presence, and blurt forth such expressions, tempting their fate, and miss sobriety of judgment, and [insult] the ruler * * * * *
This never can be the conduct of Argives, to fawn on the base.
Yet on some future day I will pursue thee yet.
Not so, if a divine power shall guide Orestes to come hither.
I know that exiles feed themselves on hopes.
Do thy pleasure! batten! while thou pollutest justice, since it is permitted thee.
Rest assured that thou shalt make me a requital for this folly
Brag boldly like the cock beside his partlet.
Make not thou any account of these vain yelpings; I and thou mastering this house, will order things aright.
μη̃χοςfor
μη̃κος,
"pauci hodie probabunt."
όμήυριν
ἀστρω̃ν τ’
αἰθέριοι χοροί;
ἡλίου φω̃ς, ἄστρων χορόν;
ὑπ’
οὐράνιον χορόν ἀστρω̃ν.It is probable, from the allusion to the changes of the weather, that the Pleiades are particularly meant; of which
"existimantur choream ducere stellis."See
εὐτ’
ἂνhas been sought for by Klausen in v. 18; yet I am by no means satisfied on the subject. Sewell, who candidly confesses his doubts, renders it, "And well may I retain," etc.; but that would require
εὖ δ’or
εὖ γ’.I cannot help thinking Aeschylus wrote
εὐνὴν δὲ νυκτίπλαγτον εὐνὴν ὀνείροις,a repetition that might easily escape the copyists. Such repetitions are familiar to every reader of the poets, especially
ἐντέμνειν.
χάρινin apposition with the preceding sentence, and not adverbially.
πρέπει,stands conspicuous. See
He ne'er drinks, But Timon's silver treads upon his lip.
βου̃ςto signify great magnitude, the phrase
μέγας βου̃ςmight merely be used to express a great weight.
ξυτωρὶς τω̃ν στρατηγω̃ν,by a similar metaphor.
ἐκπάτιον,quod sese continere nequit in itinere suo .... itaque quicquid immodicum est et certis rationis finibus destitutum." See also Dindorf. Paley rightly condemns the supposition that
ἐκπατίοιςis an enallage for
ἐκπατίων.
τις.I have construed
ὔπατοςwith
ἀίων,like
v7rarot.... ἐρεσσόμενοι,v. 52.
"her who avengeth late these Metics of our state,"observing-in his note,
"So much political allusion is traceable in the whole of the tetralogy, that perhaps a reference is intended here to some art of injustice meditated against the Metaeci at this moment by the democratical party;τω̃νδεmust be rendered 'these'—'these present in the theatre.' Never was I less inclined to admire the ingenuity of this able scholar than in this instance. To say nothing of the unpoetical change from a pathetic description to a personal allusion—to say nothing of the probable reception of such a remark, if understood-have we any warranty for supposing that it could be understood? Of the music of the choruses we know nothing; but, I believe, any one acquainted with chorus-singing in general, will confess that such a sound as "t6nde metoikôn” would probably stick in the throat of the singer, if he attempted to lay any peculiar stress upon it."
άπύρων ῐερω̃νseem to be set at rest by Bamberger and Dindorf, who understand the sacrifice of Iphigenia to be meant. And if we consider the connexion of the sense, this is clearly required by the context from v. 40, as follows : The AtridAe hover over the heads of those who stole away Helen, like vultures mourning over their lost young. But as some god sends an Erinnys to aid the birds, so Jove sends the AtridAe against Paris, bringing a doubtful contest upon both Greeks and Trojans. But the end of all will be as fate decrees. Nor by any means will Agamemnon avert the unflinching wrath resulting from Iphigentia’s death." The chorus darkly hints at the consequences of Agamemnon's connexion with Menelaus, which are more fully explained hereafter.
περίπεμπταis not destitute of meaning, I have little doubt that Aeschylus wrote
περίπεπτα—“decocta.”
πέλανοςwas a common offering to all the gods, as we learn from Pollux, vi. ii. p. 288, ed. Seber. Sewell observes, " it should be remembered that the oil used in religious rites was of great value."
αἰνει̃ν—to say. Cf. v. 1481,
ἦ μέγαν ὄικοις τοι̃σδε ΔαίμοναMai
ϐαρύμηνιν αὶνει̃ς.Thus
αίνος,a narrative, v. 1483,
κακὸνalvo'
ὰτηρα̃ς τύχας.
εἰ τὸ μάταν ἀπὸ φροντίδος ἄχθος χρὴ βαλεῖν,seems to amount to absolute ridicule of the popular polytheism.
ἐπιθυμεῖνto be referred to the Greeks, not to Artemis:
ὀργὰ
"Assensere omnes, et quae sibi quisque timebat, Unius in miseri exitium conversa tulere."
εὔ γὰρ εἴη,understand
ἀυτοῖ
ς.
προτέλεια,see
ἡ δὲ πρὸ γάμου θυσία, προτέλεια.... προτε-
πατρω̢ουςto the kin of Agamemnon as well, but I am scarcely disposed to accede to that view.
Nec miserae tali prodesse in tempore quibat, Quod patrio princeps donarat nomine regem.
ἀραῖονproleptically, as referring to what would befal the house on account of her death.
ἄγγαροςa Persian word, which Symmons translates by estafette, a Spanish word for a military courier, which has been naturalized in English. The original institution is described by Xenophon, Cyrop. VIII. 6. 9, and by Herodotus, VIII. 98. OLD TRANSLATION.
ὥστε νωτίσαιseems to compel us to take
ὺπερτέληςin the sense expressed.
χατίζεσθαεbeing taken passively.
πάλον.
ώς δ’
εὐδαίμονες,the conjecture of Vossins, and with reason.
ἀμπλύκητος.
ἄτης παναλώτονin apposition with
δουλειας(although Pollux is against this view):
γάγγαμον(which Sewell retains in his version) does not seem to imply more than
στεγανὸν δίκτυονin v. 358.
σκήπτωis everywhere in Aeschylus used intransitively, cf. v. 308—310 : Prom. 749; Sept. c. Th. 429 ; and I do not see why we should not take it in this sense, especially as it is commonly used of the descent of the thunderbolt. We may join
ἠλίθιον σκήψειενthe former word expressing the consequence of the stroke descending either before or beyond its mark (see Linwood, s.
ἄστρον).
ὑπὲρ ἄστρωνcan only be a proverbial phrase, denoting excessive distance, probably derived from the temporary vanishing of objects shot to a great distance. Respecting
ὅπως ἂν—just as that, see Blomfield, and Jelf, Gk. Gr. § 810.
ἔχουσιis a customary enallage, particularly when the speaker proceeds from the general remark to the individual instance (see Blomf. Pers. 606).
ἐγγόνους(rather
ἐκγόνους) to mean "per posteros,” which, though intolerably harsh, is better than supposing that
πέφανταιcan be the plural: but this is only the lesser of two evils. Dindorf says the passage is interpolated, but he does not tell us how. Perhaps we should connect these words with the preceding, and read
—εὐσεβὴς Πέφανται, καὶ γένους κτλ.
ὑπέρφευalso appears corrupt.
προφητ̃αι.See Blomfield.
ἐρω̃ν ἐρω̃σαν ᾤχετ ἐξανάρπασας
Grief fills the room up of my absent child, Lies in his bed, walks up and down with me; Puts on his pretty looks, repeats his words, Remembers me of all his gracious parts, Stuffs out his vacant garments with his form—.
When thou art gone-the light of our life quench’d— Haunting like spectres of departed joy The home where thou wert dearest !
προσδίκοις.See Peile.
ὑπερκότως,with Blomfield.
ὅσσοιςas referring to Jove. But what writer would use
ὅσσοις διόθενto mean "from the eye of Jove?" I have no doubt that the passage is corrupt. Burges reads
βάλλεται δ' ἄκρ' ὄσσης,which has been partly anticipated by Lobeck.
τίς οἶδεν, εἴ τοι θεῖόν ἐστιν ἢ ψύθος;the common reading seems untenable. Symmons, whose taste is finer than his scholarship, agrees with Stanley.
αἰχμά(=edge, point) as closely to English notions as I could.
οὖδαςand
χθονός.
ἦσθ' ἀνάρσιος.See Paley.
κἀπαγώνιοςfor καὶ
ἐπαγώνιος,not
ἀπαγώνιος.An anonymous critic in Scholfield's notes proposes
καὶ παιώνιος,which Paley and Conington have admitted, and supported with good taste. The common reading might easily result from the next line. In confirmation of the conjecture, cf. Soph.,
Œd.Tyr. 150.
δράσαντι παθεῖν.
αὐτόχθον' ὃν,with Dindorf and Conington. Paley scarcely shews his accustomed good taste in this passage.
πῶς δή;with Schutz and Dindorf.
φρενῶν,which Dindorf approves. I myself fancy that we should simply read,
πόθεν τὸ δύσφρον τοῦτ' ἑπῆν στυγος(hateful thing, or grief,)
φράσον.
τινάfor
τινάς.The
ςarose from the termination of the next line. I see no need for altering the punctuation.
ἀρχαῖονis not satisfactory.
Amatores,p, 5, B. cum Schol. Ruhnk. p. 59, Valer. Max. VIlI. 14. extern.
πλαγτὸςmight bear that sense, but for
ἐφαινόμην.Sec Paley.
χαλκὸς,like
σίδηρος,is often used as a generic term, and may well refer to the metals used in the formation of weapons. Compare Much Ado about Nothing, IV. 1:
If I know more of any man alive, Than that, which maiden modesty doth warrant, Let all my sins lack mercy.
ALC.—Mortalis nemo corpus corpore contigit, Quo me impudicam faceret. Sos.—Nae ista, (edepol) Si haec vera loquitur, examussest optuma.
λόγοις,with Blomfield and Dindorf (in Notes).
κἀπαγώνιοςfor καὶ
ἐπαγώνιος,not
ἀπαγώνιος.An anonymous critic in Scholfield's notes proposes
καὶ παιώνιος,which Paley and Conington have admitted, and supported with good taste. The common reading might easily result from the next line. In confirmation of the conjecture, cf. Soph., Œd. Tyr. 150.
πῶς δη̃τ' ἂνadmit of our translating, “would that thou mightest," etc.?
πῶςbelongs to
ἐλθεῖν,to which
δαιμόνων κότωrefers.
τελευτῆσαιfills up the description="tell us from beginning to end."
Sweet Helen, miracle of nature's hand; Hell in thy name, but heaven is in thy looks.
πλατα̃νwith Heath, and
κελσάντων,the old reading. So Paley and Conington.
κη̃δος,meaning either relationship or trouble.
ἄγαισιν(Hermann's reading); but there are some doubts about the metre. Maiden and Conington read
ἄσαισιν.
Hellas:
Revenge and wrong bring forth their kind, The foul cubs like their parents are.See copious illustrations on the notes of Blomfield on
Sept.c. Th. 210; Tollius on Longinus, § 43 ; Lobeck on Soph.
Aj.517 ; and Ruhnken on the following elegant passage of Rutilius Lupus, 11. 2:
"crudelitatis mater est avaritia et pater furor. Haec facinori conjuncta, pal'it odium : inde etiam nascitur exitium.”
σκότον,not because I am persuaded of its correctness, but because it involves less alteration than any other conjectures as yet proposed, none of which seem safe.
οὐκ ἀπ' ἄκρας φρενὸς, οὐδ' ἀφίλωςreally refer to the feelings of the Chorus, and should not rather be said of Agamemnon. The connexion of the sense seems to require this. " Before tho didst bring this expedition to a close, thou seemedst unwise; but now seeing you have succeeded, your labour seems to have been one of no light impulse, but of genuine kindness." The opposition between
οὐδ' εὗ πραπίδων οἴακαand
οὐκ ἀπ' ἄκρας φρενός,seems to confirm this view of the passage.
ἐφραξάμεσθα(the common reading will hardly bear the sense assigned it); but Conington prefers Tyrwhitt's emendation,
χἀρπαγάς.I think the mention of the Trojan horse, which was literally a snare, confirms the common reading, if we admit Paley's correction of the verb. The sense of
ὑπερκόπους(which I read with Heath and Dindorf,) as applied to the Trojan horse, may be illustrated from Tryphiodorus, 321—
"Illa subit, mediaeque minans illabitur urbi."
"You and your coach-fellow Nym,”—from the Merry Wives of Windsor, II. 2.
"Most potent, grave, and reverend signors!"
λέγω,instead of after
χθονός.This, on the whole, seems the simplest way of treating the passage, although I confess that Symmons' remarks shew considerable taste. See Boyes, p. 24.
ἐμοῦwith
λελημμένης. ἔνωθενmay either be taken with
ἔλυσαν,or with
ἐμῆς δέρης,which I prefer, supplying some word, as in Virgil’s
“trabe nectit ab alta,”which Conington aptly compares. Perhaps
κρεμαστη̃ςmay be understood, as in Soph. Antig. 1221. We may compare the
" ad exitium sublimatus”of Apul. Met. I. p. 109, ed. Elm. Clytaemnestra appears to have contrived her suicide with the same regard to her own safety that distinguished Mr. Mantalini’s similar attempts.
"Quando ego non timui graviora pericula veris ?”—Ovid, Heroid.
Faithful-as dog, the lonely shepherd's pride. True-as the helm, the bark's protecting guide, Firm-as the shaft that props the towering dome, Sweet-as to shipwreck'd seamen land and home, Lovely-as child, a parent's sole delight, Radiant—as morn that breaks a stormy night, Grateful-as streams, that in some deep recess With rills unhop'd the panting traveller bless, Is he that links with mine his chain of life, Names himself lord, and deigns to call me wife.
ἄελπτονwith
δω̃μα.Clytaemnestra, as in v. 913. seems darkly to hint at her deadly purpose.
εἰand
ἂν,and think that Butler and Dindorf have settled the question of reading
πράσσοιμεν.Paley appears to give
πράσσοιμιan active sense.
ξυνεμβολαι̃ς ψαμμίας ἀκτα̃ς παρήβησεν,with Wellauer ; but I cannot conceive whence Conington, and some other translators, have got the notion that it was at their departure from Greece, not on their arriva at Troy, that the army suffered thus. The stoppages at Aulis, and under the walls of Troy, are evidently meant. In other respects, Conington's view is confirmed by the tragedians, and by Dion. Chrysost. Or. II. p. 80, and Apuleius de Deo Socr. § 19. I remember a similar passage in Dictys Cretensis, but have not the book at hand.
And nothing is at a like goodness still; For goodness, growing to a pleurisy, Dies in his own too much.
μοι̃ραto mean “the superior fate in the hands of heaven,”
μοι̃ρανfor the fateful bodings of the Chorus! own mind (so Conington). I am not quite satisfied, and could better understand these verses in the mouth of Cassandra, than of the Chorus.
Agam.III. 2, v. 1.
ἀγυιάτηςsee Blomfield, and Mitchell on Aristoph. Vesp. 875.
ματαίους.
"Aye, but the oracle no more shall peer Out from his veil, as 'twere a new wed bride: No; clear I see him rushing”
Lady of the Lake,III. 7.
" Late had he beard, in prophet's dream, The fatal ben-shie's boding scream; Sounds, too, had come in midnight blast, Of charging steeds, careering fast Along Benharrow's shingly side, Where mortal horseman ne'er might ride; * * * * All augured ill to Alpine's line. He girt his loins, and came to show The signals of impending woe."
πη̃γμα-παιώνιος.to giving, with Conington, a sense to
γενναίως,that it cannot bear.
"Why, there the) are both, baked in that pye; Whereof their mother daintily bath fed, Eating the flesh that she herself hath bred."And the ditty of the Scotch Itys:
" Pippety pew, my mammie me slew, And daddy me ate, my sister Kate Gathered a' my baines”Seneca, Agam. I. 1, 27:
“A fratre vincar liberibus plenus tribus In me sepultis: viscera exedi mea."
ἄρη.
" Oh! but remember this another day, When he shall split thy very heart with sorrow; And say, poor Margaret was a prophetess."
δἴφημον σοίμησον.
ἄγος.
έπίστασαι.
ἄξεινwith the vulgate.
Aj., 833, sqq., for a similar prayer.
χρόνῳ πλέονwith Pauw. I cannot agree with Conington, in considering the common reading equivalent to the same tense.
" The bird that hath been limed in a bush, With trembling wings misdoubteth every twig."
" Once, once again; One word, one dirge, fain would I speak, my own."But I wish "above myself" did not follow. The redundancy in
ἐμὸν τὸν αὐτη̃ςhere seems disagreeable, and I would read
ἐγὼ τὸν αὐτη̃ς.The stress is upon the fact that Cassandra, like the fabled swan, sings her own dirge.
ὁμου̃.Klausen's Latin, which people carefully avoid translating, is as follows:
" Precibus, quibus solem in ultima luce (?) invoco, imprecor ((i.e., I invoke upon my avengers that they suffer the same at the hands of my slayers!) I can only express my conviction that these interpretations may fairly be met aside in favour of the following readings:ἐπεύχομαι standing for two verbs with their datives of a different signification!) ultoribus meis ut occisoribus invisis meis idem solvant."
τὸν....ἡλίουis due to Jacobs. and is approved by Dindorf,
ἐχθροὺς....τοὺς ἐμοὺςis Wellaner's conjecture, as also
ἐμου̃for
όμου̃.For the transposition of the half lines, I am myself answerable, as well as for
κατεύχομαιin lieu of
ἐπεύχομαι.Compare Choeph. 88,
πω̃ς κατεύξωμαι πατρί;139,
κατεύχομαί σοι.Eum. 922,
ᾇτ' ἐγὼ κατεύχομαι .. ἐξαμβρόσαι φαιδρὸν ἁλίου σέλας,which last passage is almost conclusive; the same verb occurs, but in a somewhat different sense, also in Sept. c. Th. 633, and above, vs. 1250. In further support of the genitive in this simple form cf. Soph., Aj. 856, at
δ’,
ῴ φαεννη̃ς ἡμέρας ... σέλας.Aesch., Prom. 91,
καὶ τὸν πανόπτην κυκλον ἡλίου καλω̃.Orph., Hymn. VII. 1.
δακτυλοδεικτω̃ν,I should prefer following all the other editors in reading
δακτυλοδεικτὸνwith Casaubon. Dindorf's note is brief, but important. For the syntax in vs. 1334, cf. Sept. c. Th. 434,
χρυσοĩς δὲ φωνεĩ γράμμασιν, πρήσω πόλιν.
ἅγαν,or read
ὰντεπικραίνειwith Bamberger. So Dindorf and Conington.
χρονίζομεν,"we are slow," it will convey a pleasing criticism as well as an undoubted truth! at least, no reader of poetry will challenge the assertion.
ὁρμαίνει,I take with Conington to signify the physical tumult attending a violent death, the catching of breath, and the gurgling of blood." The notion is well expressed by Apuleius,
Met.I. p. 108,
"cum ille impetu teli praesecata gula, vocem, immo stridorem incertum, per vulnus effunderet, et spiritum rebulliret."
διοσδό-ῳ;so also Dindorf in his notes.
πρεπόντως,with Blomfield.
ῥυτοῖς πόροις.
όμοίων,following Paley and Conington in their interpretation.
τύχᾳfor the death of Agamemnon.
An Angelo for a Claudiodeath for death.
δι' αἷμ’), as explained by Linwood, s.v.
ἐπανθίζειν.He understands ἱptv with
τελείανand
πολύμναστον,and takes
τελείαν ἐπηνθίσωas equivalent to
ἐπηνθίσω ὥστε τελείαν εἷναι.I however prefer reading
ἀπηνθίσωwith Casaubon. If we do not retain
διὰ,we must consider
αῑμ' ἄνιπτονas an epexegesis to
τελ. πολ. ἀπηνθίσω,an explanation that, as far as I remember, has not occurred to any of the commentators. Symmons is probably right in considering
ἐρίδματοςas formed with the Homeric
ἐρι,not from
ἔρις.
ἰσόψυχονappears to me to signify "too strong for my spirit to sustain.”
ἐπιτύμβιον αινον.
θέσμιον γάρ.
λάκτιτμα δείπνουmeans that Thyestes spurned the banquet with his feet. Although I grant that this clever scholar has shown much taste in his note, still I cannot suppose that
τιθεὶς ἀρᾷwould have then been used. The words can only mean putting under a curse the trampling of the board." Linwood prefers joining
τιθεὶς λάκτισμα=
λακτίζων.In support of the proverbial sense I have preferred, compare v. 384,
λακτίσαντι μέγαν δίκας βωμόν.Choeph. 641, TO
μὴ θέμις γὰρoil
λὰξ πέδον πατούμενον.Eum. 540,
μηδέ νιν κέρδος ἰδὼν ἀθεῳ ποῦ
ὶ λὰξ ἀτίσῃς.Lycophrou (quoted by Schutz). 137,
λάξας τρο πεζαν.
τούσδ' ἤκοντας.
νηπίοιςfor
ἠπίοις.Cf. v. 1672,
ματαίων τω̃νδ' ὑλαγμάτων.
ζεύγλαιςfrom
ζεύξω.
παθεῖν ἔρξαντας' αἴρειν χρη̃νand
μαθεῖνfor
παθεῖν.
πένοιτοfor
γένοιτοis ingenious, but the whole passage seems desperate.