Scaling 'Wildfire': William Sigerson (Chapter 29) VS Elysius Blight (Chapter 29) The two main characters of u/ConversationSea1684's new novel 'Wildfire' go head to head. Amazing novel so far, world-building is great and the characters (especially Sigerson) surpassed my expectations. I would highly recommend checking it out if you haven't already, easily accessible through the pinned fan novels section for the sub. I've tried to put some justifications next to my takes from what I can remember, so if you want me to try and explain my thoughts, or perhaps the author thinks I've misunderstood something, please let me know. \[The Elusive Detective VS The Harbinger of The Wildfire\] General Intelligence: CPI) Sigerson (Eden memorisation + Bowers gamble) VSI) Sigerson (Crime scene visualisation) VCI) Sigerson >= (Letter decoding) FRI) Sigerson (Towns Murder Reasoning) LA) CGEW (Blight: Academic Narrative, highest national score multiple times/Sigerson: Eden learning, gambling learning) Overall) Sigerson Theory of Mind: Cognitive) Sigerson (Crime scene recreations, Percy Enforcer concealment reasoning, Brook prescription reasoning) Emotional) Blight (Fake Journalist reading, Knightley reading, Evelyn reading) Reactive) CGEW (Blight: Towns blackmailing, Sigerson Crowne Hotel escape/Sigerson: Mayor framing to catch Brook, Bowers pressuring) Overall) CGEW EQ: EU) Blight (Same as emotional TOM) EP) CGEW (Blight: Police Journalist daughter conflict, Evelyn pride, Knightley patriotism reading/Sigerson: Percy Enforcer, Turner, Bowers, Elena, Harvey readings) EE) Blight (Justice pursuit after Charlie's death, Mr Stone Mansion burning) EM) Sigerson >= (Home raid, criminal status, theatre bomb threat, Thomas saving, Bowers cheating + threat of debt) Overall) Blight SQ: Social Understanding) Blight >= (Rebellion incitement, crime proxy gathering) Social Skills) Blight (Self-explanatory) Social Integration) Sigerson >= (Eden integration, gambling integration) Social Engineering) Blight >= (Theatre child suicide bombing, Crowne assassination attempt, fake journalist pressuring) Leadership) Sigerson >= (Investigation leading, Turner and Harvey leadership) Charisma) Blight (Self-explanatory) Persuasion) Blight >= (Fake Journalist suicide persuasion, Rook representative persuasion, Knightley train murder persuasion) Negotiation) CGEW (Blight: Wensworth company contract, lookout negotiation, landlord 60 sovereign negotiation/Sigerson: Bowers bet raising negotiation, Percy negotiation, Turner and Harvey negotiation) Overall) Blight AC: Stress Tolerance) Sigerson (same as EM) Pain Tolerance) Sigerson >= (Freezing river endurance) Cognitive Discipline) Sigerson >= (Brook arrest planning) Composure) Blight >= (Interrogation composure, Charlie death composure) Perseverance) CGEW (Blight: Mr Stone takedown pursuit, rebellion incitement/Sigerson: Blight takedown pursuit, Enforcer evasion) Overall) Sigerson Thinking: Convergent) Sigerson (Forced boiler explosion thinking, Towns Murder thinking, Blight as mastermind) Divergent) Sigerson >= (Theatre bombing prevention, Harvey and Dexter hiring, Elena seduction for info gathering) Linear) Sigerson (Barn murders thinking, Towns Murder thinking, Grock tracking thinking) Lateral) Sigerson (Brook glasses trap, seeing through locked room Towns Murder) Critical) Sigerson (Bowers cheating identification, boiler coin bending, Whist game cheating identification) Applicative) Sigerson >= (Footsteps stride profiling, dust displacement profiling, hotel room setup) Holistic) Blight (Revalty and Ecclesia war initiation, rebellion planning) Metacognition) Sigerson >= (Simply more thoughts shown atp) Overall) Sigerson Reasoning: Deductive) Sigerson (Letter decoding, blood splatter deductions; neither really have too many deductive feats) Inductive) Sigerson (Barn murders reasoning, forced boiler explosion, Whist cheating, Bowers cheating etc) Abductive) Sigerson (Airgun reasoning, accidental crate drop reasoning) Abstract) Sigerson (Blight wider conspiracy and mastermind) Overall) Sigerson Manipulation: Direct) Blight Indirect) Blight (Rebellion incitement, proxy murders, Brook location trap) Emotional) Blight Individual) Blight (Custodian train murders manipulation) Mass) Blight (Charity donations to protect image, coal monopoly through Wensworth contract, Revalty Vs Ecclesia war, Enforcer distrust) Logical) Blight >= (Towns locked room murder,) Overall) Blight Deception: Misdirection) Sigerson >= (Hotel room setup, Mayor framing) Concealment) Blight (Towns assassination, proxy crimes, Mr Stone wallet theft disguise) Fabrication) Blight (Fake Journalist suicide fabrication, boiler explosion fabrication) Bluffing) Blight Acting Skills) Blight Overall) Blight Strategy: Effectiveness) Blight (Mr Stone wallet theft, Mr Stone mansion infiltration, Wensworth contract) Efficiency) Sigerson (Intentional exposure strategy, Hotel room setup, bet raising strategy) Alignment) CGEW (Blight: Home raid trap/Sigerson: Brook arrest trap) Complexity) Blight (Brook location trap) Resilience) Blight (Sigerson elimination) Shielding) Blight (Proxy murders) Overall) Blight Planning: Aim) Blight Contingencies) Sigerson >= (Brook Arrest) Coverage) Blight (Revalty VS Ecclesia war, Ecclesia politician assassination framing) Versatility) Blight Intricacy) Blight (Brook location trap) Invincibility) Blight Overall) Blight Insight: Observation) Sigerson (Coin bending observation, door fibres, Eden Observation) Perception) Sigerson (Forced boiler explosion, intentional fireplace message identification, Blight-Rook coded letters) Pattern Recognition) Sigerson (Bowers cheating fingerprints, Theatre bomb threat identification) Analysis) Sigerson Intuition) Sigerson (Suspicion of Blight being mastermind since Boiler incident) Cold Reading) Sigerson >= (Harvey reading, Percy reading) Overall) Sigerson Foresight: Anticipation) Blight >= Prediction) Blight (Prediction of Sigerson solving barn case, Eden travel prediction, Crowne Hotel prediction) Trap Setting) Blight >= Overall) Blight Field Skills: Information Gathering) Sigerson (Crime scenes, Cooper interrogation, Turner connections) Information Control) Sigerson >= Overall) Sigerson Adaptability: Mental Flexibility) Sigerson Situational Awareness) Sigerson >= (Grock awareness, Blight involvement, Enforcer movements, Evelyn mental state, Harvey cunning) Strategic Adaptation) Sigerson Trap Evasion) Sigerson (Grock hotel evasion, Crowne assassin identification, Eden + Alms travel methods) Overall) Sigerson Overall Tactics) Blight Overall Countering) Blight >= Overall Counteraction) Sigerson Feat Framework: MAC) Sigerson (same as situational awareness) OC) Sigerson (Self-explanatory) Scenario Width) Sigerson Novelty) CGEW Overall) Sigerson Overall Outcome) Sigerson High – Very High Diff Maybe a little bit unfair since I think Blight is due to recieve some pretty significant feats in the upcoming chapters, but while the opportunity is fresh I thought I would be nice to start up some discussion. Once again, massive W for ConversationSea 🙏🌹