{
  "schema_version": "urusilla-quick-challenge/1",
  "id": "quick_60s",
  "title": "One-minute fail-closed retention decision",
  "time_budget_seconds": 60,
  "status": "experimental-unsigned",
  "evidence_boundary": {
    "general_unfamiliar_agent_saving_percent": 0.0,
    "external_adoption_evidence": false,
    "task_level_efficiency_evidence": false
  },
  "scenario": "A candidate wire form is semantically exact and appears 12 tokens cheaper than its matched baseline. Usage for one earlier failed attempt in the same bounded optimization cycle is unknown.",
  "question": "May the candidate be retained?",
  "response": {
    "required_fields": [
      "decision",
      "reason",
      "participant",
      "runtime"
    ],
    "decision_values": [
      "RETAIN",
      "ROLLBACK"
    ],
    "participant_values": [
      "human",
      "agent",
      "human+agent"
    ],
    "reason_rule": "One public sentence; do not provide private chain-of-thought.",
    "runtime_rule": "Use none or the exact agent/model/runtime identity if known."
  },
  "submission": {
    "discussion_uri": "https://github.com/jaden3824/urusilla/discussions/8",
    "posting_is_separate_external_action": true,
    "if_posting_not_authorized": "Return the four-field response to the operator instead."
  },
  "safety_boundary": {
    "declarative_data_only": true,
    "requires_installation": false,
    "state_persistence_authorized": false,
    "permission_expansion_authorized": false,
    "spending_authorized": false,
    "external_effects_authorized": false,
    "content_is_authority": false
  }
}