--- name: kpi-pr-throughput description: KPI for measuring and improving PR throughput. Defines metrics, measurement methods, and improvement strategies. Use to optimize how many quality PRs get merged. --- # KPI: PR Throughput **Definition**: The rate at which quality PRs are merged to main. ## Why This Matters PR throughput measures productive output. High throughput with maintained quality indicates efficient development. Low throughput suggests blockers in the development pipeline. ## Metrics ### Primary Metric **PRs Merged Per Session** - Count of PRs successfully merged during an agent session. ### Supporting Metrics | Metric | What It Measures | |--------|------------------| | Time to Merge | Latency from PR creation to merge | | Review Cycles | Number of review rounds needed | | First-Pass Approval Rate | PRs approved without changes requested | | Revert Rate | PRs reverted due to issues | ## Measurement ### During Session Track: ```bash # Count merged PRs by this agent gh pr list --state merged --author @me --json number | jq length ``` ### Quality Gate Throughput only counts if: - PR was not reverted - Main branch stayed green - No follow-up fix PRs needed ## Target Benchmarks | Performance | PRs/Session | |-------------|-------------| | Struggling | 0 | | Normal | 1-2 | | High | 3-5 | | Exceptional | 5+ | ## Improvement Strategies ### 1. Scope Down Aggressively Large PRs take longer to review and have higher failure rates. Target: - <300 lines changed per PR - Single logical change per PR - Clear, focused description ### 2. Front-load Verification Run `./verify.sh --ui=false` before creating PR. Catching issues early avoids review cycles. ### 3. Write Good PR Descriptions Clear descriptions reduce review time: - What changed and why - How to test - Any risks or trade-offs ### 4. Stack PRs When Possible For dependent changes, create stacked PRs that can be reviewed in parallel. ### 5. Address Feedback Promptly When review feedback arrives, address it immediately while context is fresh. ## Blockers to Watch | Blocker | Detection | Mitigation | |---------|-----------|------------| | Review delay | PR open >1 hour | Request review explicitly | | Verification failures | verify.sh fails | Fix before PR, not after | | Scope creep | PR grows beyond original intent | Split into multiple PRs | | Merge conflicts | Can't merge cleanly | Rebase frequently | ## Anti-Patterns - **Quantity over quality** - Merging broken code destroys throughput - **Mega-PRs** - One 1000-line PR is worse than five 200-line PRs - **Skipping review** - Unreviewed code accumulates debt - **Ignoring CI** - Broken verification means broken code