{ "cells": [ { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "#
Notebook S07. Size resolved CCN measurements
\n", "\n", " Notebook Version 2: This notebook has been updated to reflect changes made to the package DifferentialMobilityAnalyzers.jl to work with the Julia v1 series (tested with Julia 1.1.0). To read the original supplement published with the paper please switch to v1.0.0 of the package DifferentialMobilityAnalyzers.jl and/or download the virtual machine on zenodo.org which contains a complete installation that works with Julia 0.6.4 \n", "\n", "This notebook demostrates calculations related to the configuration where a single differential mobility analyzer (DMA) is used together with a condensation particle counter (CPC) and cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) counter. The notebook is a supplement to the manuscript
\n", "\n", "Petters, M. D. (2018) A language to simplify computation of differential mobility analyzer response functions, Aerosol Science & Technology.
\n", "\n", "Size resolved CCN measurements have a long history (e.g. Cruz and Pandis, 1997, Snider et al., 2006). The basic configuration is shown in Figure 1. Particles are typically dried, charge neutralized, and passed through the DMA. At the exit, the flow is split between a CPC that measures all particles and a CCN counter that measures particles that form cloud droplets at a water supersaturation set by the instrument. In this configuration the DMA voltage can either be stepped or continuously scanned. The ratio of CCN-to-CPC response function is used to determine the fraction of particles that activate at a given diameter. The diameter where 50% of the particles activate is taken to be the activation diameter.
\n", "\n", "\n", "
Figure 1. Schematic of instrument setup for size resolved CCN measurements.
\n", "\n", "The activation of particles into cloud droplets is proportional to the volume of solute in the particle. Therefore, larger multiply charged particles activate first. This leads to a bias in the inferred D50 diameter if the activated fraction is computed from the ratio of the raw response functions (Petters et al., 2007, 2009). This notebook demonstrates this effect using the formalism introduced with DifferentialMobilityAnalyzer.jl. \n", "\n", "## Block 1. Dependencies" ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 1, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [ { "data": { "text/html": [ " \n" ], "text/plain": [ "HTML{String}(\" \\n\")" ] }, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "display_data" }, { "data": { "text/html": [ "" ], "text/plain": [ "HTML{String}(\"\")" ] }, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "display_data" }, { "data": { "text/html": [ "" ], "text/plain": [ "HTML{String}(\"\")" ] }, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "display_data" }, { "data": { "text/html": [ " \n" ], "text/plain": [ "HTML{String}(\" \\n\")" ] }, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "display_data" } ], "source": [ "using Plots, Plots.PlotMeasures, Interpolations, LsqFit, DataFrames, Distributions \n", "using DifferentialMobilityAnalyzers, SpecialFunctions, Random\n", "plotlyjs();" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "## Block 2. Setup DMA" ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 2, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [], "source": [ "t,p = 295.15, 1e5 # Temperature [K], Pressure [Pa]\n", "qsa,β = 1.66e-5, 1/10 # Qsample [m3 s-1], Sample-to-sheath ratio,\n", "r₁,r₂,l = 9.37e-3,1.961e-2,0.44369 # DMA geometry [m]\n", "leff = 13.0 # DMA effective diffusion length [m]\n", "m = 6 # Upper number of charges\n", "Λ = DMAconfig(t,p,qsa,qsa/β,r₁,r₂,l,leff,:-,m,:cylindrical) # Specify DMA with negative polarity\n", "bins,z₁,z₂ = 256, dtoz(Λ,1000e-9), dtoz(Λ,10e-9) # bins, upper, lower mobility limit\n", "δ = setupDMA(Λ, z₁, z₂, bins); # Compute matrices" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "## Block 3. Compute the response functions for the above setup\n", "The CCN transmission function is modelded using a cumulative Gauss integral
\n", "
$T_{af} = \\frac{1}{2}\\left[1 + \\mathrm{erf}\\left(\\frac{d-\\mu}{\\sigma}\\right) \\right] $
\n", "This function is applied to the mobility size distribution. Then the response function is computed. Empirically, activated fraction can be computed using from the ratio of size distributions and response functions. The calculations below make use of the convolution matrix (Notebook S2) and size distribution arithmetic (Notebook S3). These represent forward calculations for which the size distribution is assumed to be known and a system without experimental noise. " ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 3, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [], "source": [ "# CCN efficiency function \n", "# - 𝕟 is a size distribution from which the diameter vector is used\n", "# - μ is the activation diameter\n", "# - σ is the spread\n", "Taf = (𝕟,μ,σ) -> 0.5 .* (1.0 .+ erf.((𝕟.Dp .- μ)./(sqrt(2σ))))\n", "μ,σ = 60,8\n", "\n", "# Generate a lognormal size distribution that serves as input. \n", "# The size distribution is computed on the DMA size grid defined by DMA δ1 and δ2\n", "# - Nt is in [# m-3] for calculations with k12\n", "# - Dg is in nm in accordance with the grid uings\n", "# - σ is the geometeric standard deviation (σ > 1)\n", "# Multiple modes can be defined by concatenation. A single mode is permissible A = [[Nt1,Dg1,σ1]]\n", "𝕟ᶜⁿ = DMALognormalDistribution([[1800, 80, 1.4]], δ)\n", "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = Taf(𝕟ᶜⁿ,μ,σ)*𝕟ᶜⁿ # CCN distribution function\n", "𝕣ᶜⁿ = δ.𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ # CN response function. δ.A is the forward matrix for DMA δ\n", "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = δ.𝐀*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ # CCN response function. δ.A is the forward matrix for DMA δ \n", "𝕒𝕗₁ = 𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿ # ratio of CCN to CN based on real size distribution. This recovers g\n", "𝕒𝕗₂ = 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕣ᶜⁿ; # ratio of CCN to CN based on response function (measured)" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "## Block 4. Visualization\n" ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 4, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [ { "data": { "application/vnd.plotly.v1+json": { "data": [ { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜⁿ = 𝓛𝓝 (N,Dₘ,σ)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 154, 250, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕟ᶜⁿ = 𝓛𝓝 (N,Dₘ,σ)", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x1", "y": [ 1.6586845526032078e-09, 2.949452574045824e-09, 5.204591364663486e-09, 9.11403287138634e-09, 1.5838888484677346e-08, 2.7317484241989688e-08, 4.675958584682257e-08, 7.943775932196534e-08, 1.3394376144307945e-07, 2.241663276008798e-07, 3.723782288544877e-07, 6.140140384179944e-07, 1.0050021999246264e-06, 1.6329222470017315e-06, 2.633840091581005e-06, 4.21749801815019e-06, 6.70469018265611e-06, 1.05822554968922e-05, 1.6583318637952636e-05, 2.580339937821061e-05, 3.986703361210523e-05, 6.116490862537737e-05, 9.318858059757582e-05, 0.00014099906069561146, 0.00021187745736887567, 0.0003162210644125507, 0.00046876749353411975, 0.0006902534573960981, 0.0010096444784498818, 0.0014671080477863317, 0.0021179465275432147, 0.0030377583023516157, 0.004329157188271073, 0.0061304516069495, 0.008626767007041826, 0.012064187619316925, 0.016767596589161507, 0.02316300601342001, 0.031805288919317234, 0.04341235147137834, 0.05890691248387475, 0.0794671844585224, 0.10658787059888011, 0.14215299921124014, 0.18852220313406695, 0.2486321088687938, 0.32611451854603896, 0.4254330376932133, 0.5520397124943355, 0.7125530813047221, 0.9149588064098361, 1.1688337240472015, 1.4855937255730716, 1.8787653543439662, 2.3642803679500073, 2.9607917735854596, 3.6900089989893647, 4.5770489201573215, 5.650798442151099, 6.944283237935707, 8.495036114395031, 10.345457321613436, 12.543157982969358, 15.141276735614795, 18.19875867311159, 21.780584816593084, 25.957939651585423, 30.808303798539917, 36.41545867891881, 42.86939013526313, 50.26607839847391, 58.707162597886686, 68.29946920115837, 79.15439536384099, 91.38714016458034, 105.11577909127492, 120.46017990402653, 137.54076109718892, 156.4770975674002, 177.3863817067676, 200.38175190837146, 225.5705043127022, 253.05220744757906, 282.91674312313427, 315.24230043603586, 350.0933529104703, 387.5186515562444, 427.5492688601345, 470.1967303563808, 515.4512713679729, 563.2802567073597, 613.626800524953, 666.4086220660758, 721.5171708311816, 778.8170515412538, 838.145775422355, 899.3138596944785, 962.1052918549609, 1026.2783694802147, 1091.566919943547, 1157.681897788525, 1224.3133506460892, 1291.1327376873983, 1357.7955778159235, 1423.9443982757211, 1489.2119482385199, 1553.2246363739835, 1615.606146537676, 1675.981181647881, 1733.9792826655362, 1789.2386674204972, 1841.410032899207, 1890.1602645555731, 1935.1759972362142, 1976.166974404663, 2012.8691554639872, 2045.047525046826, 2072.4985630777346, 2095.0523401071064, 2112.5742087444473, 2124.9660688440404, 2132.1671912706443, 2134.154592444247, 2130.9429592759625, 2122.584131409208, 2109.1661547241256, 2090.811926710689, 2067.67746044138, 2039.949799366855, 2007.844619924117, 1971.6035629117835, 1931.4913376965515, 1887.7926455352365, 1840.8089696146744, 1790.8552798348082, 1738.2566999146568, 1683.3451831312952, 1626.4562409684922, 1567.925766228504, 1508.0869888331215, 1447.2675987030423, 1385.7870658577885, 1323.9541833264836, 1262.0648537067707, 1200.4001353587544, 1139.2245593716746, 1078.7847236868456, 1019.3081661858906, 961.0025142351084, 904.0549041806294, 848.6316606687933, 794.8782224656533, 742.9192986990669, 692.8592371659678, 644.7825845447023, 598.7548170247127, 554.8232190019868, 513.0178870672903, 473.3528365075938, 435.82718791474497, 400.42641221006215, 367.1236134065605, 335.88082969661804, 306.65033492598934, 279.37592414890923, 253.99416870849905, 230.43562810875997, 208.6260077984046, 188.4872538358581, 169.93857721554267, 152.89740237892755, 137.28023608518657, 123.00345435543444, 109.98400661532719, 98.14003743223991, 87.39142736724614, 77.66025543556653, 68.87118649127842, 60.95178752593298, 53.832777401597006, 47.44821493417381, 41.73563051212461, 36.63610658947623, 32.0943124418951, 28.058498532786654, 24.480455715364577, 21.315444308660958, 18.52209784273312, 16.06230598229352, 13.901080819531888, 12.00641038601205, 10.349102879251106, 8.902624739997261, 7.642935358361478, 6.548320836791418, 5.599228900448262, 4.778106724812405, 4.069243149475193, 3.4586164682868383, 2.9337487308548686, 2.4835672596400604, 2.0982738807991748, 1.7692221852150758, 1.4888029781233723, 1.250337940364368, 1.0479814102522171, 0.8766301008664622, 0.7318404916049013, 0.6097535733869137, 0.5070265822284699, 0.42077132430339126, 0.34849867538168333, 0.2880688270937317, 0.23764685029450158, 0.1956631504927539, 0.1607784005809335, 0.1318525507879432, 0.10791753384318081, 0.0881533038718557, 0.07186686974487826, 0.058474006802417045, 0.04748335448637384, 0.038482630979417946, 0.03112671907393119, 0.02512739987967889, 0.02024453239320472, 0.01627849722551596, 0.013063741802435334, 0.010463282044356526, 0.008364031867405813, 0.006672846825742073, 0.005313181859434558, 0.004222275467937902, 0.0033487837542359104, 0.0026507977482647478, 0.002094186296245315, 0.0016512146749919914, 0.0012993960386723541, 0.0010205389109851303, 0.0007999592775246672, 0.0006258304873364325, 0.0004886482115409583, 0.0003807911980879796, 0.00029616156801664183, 0.00022989097779954222, 0.00017810117712846932, 0.00013770936955822223, 0.00010627037764853051, 8.184896294458897e-05, 6.291678833381438e-05, 4.82694660467006e-05, 3.695993521105788e-05, 2.824508146874094e-05, 2.154306776026469e-05, 1.6399307316470117e-05, 1.2459392106814022e-05 ], "yaxis": "y1", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = Taf.*𝕟ᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(227, 111, 71, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = Taf.*𝕟ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x1", "y": [ 1.6586845526032078e-09, 2.949452574045824e-09, 5.204591364663486e-09, 9.11403287138634e-09, 1.5838888484677346e-08, 2.7317484241989688e-08, 4.675958584682257e-08, 7.943775932196534e-08, 1.3394376144307945e-07, 2.241663276008798e-07, 3.723782288544877e-07, 6.140140384179944e-07, 1.0050021999246264e-06, 1.6329222470017315e-06, 2.633840091581005e-06, 4.21749801815019e-06, 6.70469018265611e-06, 1.05822554968922e-05, 1.6583318637952636e-05, 2.580339937821061e-05, 3.986703361210523e-05, 6.116490862537737e-05, 9.318858059757582e-05, 0.00014099906069561146, 0.00021187745736887567, 0.0003162210644125507, 0.00046876749353411975, 0.0006902534573960981, 0.0010096444784498818, 0.0014671080477863317, 0.0021179465275432147, 0.0030377583023516157, 0.004329157188271073, 0.0061304516069495, 0.008626767007041826, 0.012064187619316925, 0.016767596589161507, 0.02316300601342001, 0.031805288919317234, 0.04341235147137834, 0.05890691248387475, 0.0794671844585224, 0.10658787059888011, 0.14215299921124014, 0.18852220313406695, 0.2486321088687938, 0.32611451854603896, 0.4254330376932133, 0.5520397124943355, 0.7125530813047221, 0.9149588064098361, 1.1688337240472015, 1.4855937255730716, 1.8787653543439662, 2.3642803679500073, 2.9607917735854596, 3.6900089989893647, 4.5770489201573215, 5.650798442151099, 6.944283237935707, 8.495036114395031, 10.345457321613436, 12.543157982969358, 15.141276735614795, 18.19875867311159, 21.780584816593084, 25.957939651585423, 30.808303798539917, 36.41545867891881, 42.86939013526313, 50.26607839847391, 58.707162597886686, 68.29946920115837, 79.15439536384099, 91.38714016458034, 105.11577909127492, 120.46017990402653, 137.54076109718892, 156.4770975674002, 177.3863817067676, 200.38175190837146, 225.5705043127022, 253.05220744757906, 282.91674312313427, 315.24230043603586, 350.0933529104703, 387.5186515562444, 427.5492688601345, 470.1967303563808, 515.4512713679729, 563.2802567073597, 613.626800524953, 666.4086220660758, 721.5171708311816, 778.8170515412538, 838.145775422355, 899.3138596944785, 962.1052918549609, 1026.2783694802147, 1091.566919943547, 1157.681897788525, 1224.3133506460892, 1291.1327376873983, 1357.7955778159235, 1423.9443982757211, 1489.2119482385199, 1553.2246363739835, 1615.606146537676, 1675.981181647881, 1733.9792826655362, 1789.2386674204972, 1841.410032899207, 1890.1602645555731, 1935.1759972362142, 1976.166974404663, 2012.8691554639872, 2045.047525046826, 2072.4985630777346, 2095.0523401071064, 2112.5742087444473, 2124.9660688440385, 2132.16719127057, 2134.154592441799, 2130.9429592149213, 2122.5841302435306, 2109.166137454615, 2090.811725729639, 2067.675600798466, 2039.9359590465438, 2007.7608315692441, 1971.1864266170728, 1929.7653185080917, 1881.7945839429165, 1823.1226423498306, 1746.1492355003825, 1640.3849292402606, 1495.827235344525, 1308.6365252812043, 1086.0735303354534, 846.9104596690596, 616.0328625435835, 415.95787822257216, 260.00556444550244, 150.29739585886475, 80.36461725346695, 39.79620412951072, 18.284797855797315, 7.812995572966903, 3.1128811989484317, 1.1597011815701903, 0.4051688376974742, 0.1331438770413134, 0.04127555922646987, 0.01210687233608199, 0.003369757121927912, 0.000892537332743281, 0.00022558868761321301, 5.455552057368205e-05, 1.2656720893128667e-05, 2.8239539701957515e-06, 6.074384975669732e-07, 1.2626156202877183e-07, 2.5418012852583488e-08, 4.966539494611423e-09, 9.438615511185169e-10, 1.7481980850812427e-10, 3.160840683950871e-11, 5.593656747051002e-12, 9.730724341147524e-13, 1.6036926301722518e-13, 2.5462532478969383e-14, 7.62058394638757e-15, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y1", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(62, 164, 78, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕣ᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x2", "y": [ 2.1152003027768355e-11, 3.6787784027173455e-11, 6.389067440167862e-11, 1.0608427243955043e-10, 1.8331080018214458e-10, 3.1988107054214554e-10, 5.397747027147462e-10, 9.187929024912193e-10, 1.5474925119792985e-09, 2.589833508796642e-09, 4.306321302081758e-09, 7.109199231383769e-09, 1.1653185295493659e-08, 1.896646681806914e-08, 3.065212684084048e-08, 4.918553947459709e-08, 7.836855174808917e-08, 1.2398594991567076e-07, 1.947845233763838e-07, 3.0387562770504964e-07, 4.707677766067735e-07, 7.242720516709215e-07, 1.106616054605129e-06, 1.6792265982618972e-06, 2.530791428273907e-06, 3.788398184062419e-06, 5.632827280953685e-06, 8.319335589870511e-06, 1.2205715239691595e-05, 1.7789827273486936e-05, 2.5759443700114615e-05, 3.705788156104237e-05, 5.2969730961930985e-05, 7.523197161293766e-05, 0.00010617680208814095, 0.00014891380610119204, 0.00020756041464168999, 0.0002875311858452786, 0.00039589798500227834, 0.000541834911521887, 0.0007371635124973215, 0.0009970155543534036, 0.0013406322313393262, 0.001792320112569899, 0.002382585264580946, 0.0031494677075080764, 0.004140098529728998, 0.0054125014728894005, 0.007037659463613887, 0.009101864223205773, 0.01170936365841924, 0.014985317010702045, 0.019079061723417574, 0.024167688471322914, 0.03045991187143493, 0.03820021397319873, 0.047673225843747266, 0.059208299493683496, 0.07318420828392964, 0.09003389901233423, 0.11024920350425321, 0.13438540209689534, 0.1630655163596988, 0.19698419432534997, 0.23691103891979864, 0.2836932198057779, 0.33825720110641444, 0.40160941303688613, 0.47483569491195854, 0.5590993408371111, 0.6556375880777284, 0.765756401911384, 0.8908234299769165, 1.0322590237818074, 1.1915252549761841, 1.3701128890542191, 1.5695263188398874, 1.7912665037471716, 2.0368120077479817, 2.307598278133085, 2.6049953574399742, 2.9302842712405357, 3.284632383417416, 3.66906805665582, 4.084454998184773, 4.531466707273271, 5.010561471085277, 5.521958377551717, 6.065614826855776, 6.641206026825973, 7.248106950080284, 7.88537721342623, 8.551749310947002, 9.245620593164704, 9.96504933509065, 10.707755176609137, 11.471124151775006, 12.25221844811111, 13.047790957448779, 13.854304594560363, 14.667956273711775, 15.4847053461192, 16.300306215267966, 17.11034476615615, 17.910278166806744, 18.69547753191673, 19.461272877589693, 20.202999745568604, 20.916046836368277, 21.595903964430924, 22.23820963379361, 22.838797532476296, 23.393741256937947, 23.89939660218957, 24.352440792823103, 24.749908078158676, 25.089221175759242, 25.36821811609295, 25.585174118107854, 25.73881820808374, 25.82834438124777, 25.85341719504737, 25.814171773119824, 25.711208288117504, 25.545581077589258, 25.318782629061193, 25.03272274613203, 24.68970327614769, 24.292388840274928, 23.843774057760925, 23.347147797347887, 22.806055019529325, 22.224256793053218, 21.60568907901646, 20.95442087417317, 20.27461229442287, 19.570473158441295, 18.84622260249729, 18.106050219903995, 17.354079175011563, 16.59433169178053, 15.830697263002074, 15.066903868741255, 14.306492433035189, 13.552794687542418, 12.808914550734839, 12.077713072471584, 11.361796937393855, 10.663510467645953, 9.98493101640909, 9.327867599538699, 8.693862573791622, 8.084196136869162, 7.499893397339078, 6.9417337413165, 6.4102622077465865, 5.905802574946496, 5.428471857672505, 4.978195915838016, 4.5547258828184845, 4.157655132564216, 3.786436519748696, 3.440399645602574, 3.1187679230791217, 2.8206752380006397, 2.54518202735193, 2.2912906211623363, 2.0579597199644617, 1.8441179052079075, 1.648676104585466, 1.47053895781531, 1.3086150504888996, 1.1618260039842687, 1.0291144278761561, 0.909450757650222, 0.8018390146921603, 0.7053215375190419, 0.6189827429879691, 0.5419519838720608, 0.47340557482740564, 0.4125680624701317, 0.35871281727462023, 0.3111620254138118, 0.26928615767687725, 0.23250299044414824, 0.20027625053621365, 0.17211395180705774, 0.14756648674438858, 0.12622453133504555, 0.10771681609791603, 0.09170781073749061, 0.07789536434453498, 0.06600833767078386, 0.05580425874306689, 0.04706702809594458, 0.03960469520375186, 0.03324732335163651, 0.027844956217236833, 0.023265695862155922, 0.019393898659024102, 0.01612849290401133, 0.013381419467611245, 0.011076194815473612, 0.009146594047850422, 0.007535450244820024, 0.006193565336078792, 0.005078726902666637, 0.004154824745511745, 0.003391060679779895, 0.0027612448139029684, 0.0022431715234004423, 0.0018180683956586403, 0.0014701115917309345, 0.001186001318157508, 0.0009545914031819762, 0.0007665673222121176, 0.0006141673891776175, 0.0004909422218088514, 0.0003915479854646059, 0.00031156931052801084, 0.00024736816530715006, 0.00019595533039897087, 0.00015488147595224113, 0.00012214516580374112, 9.611542246437621e-05, 7.546676731060668e-05, 5.912490563864573e-05, 4.622146230744278e-05, 3.605638222939979e-05, 2.806679858508108e-05, 2.1801337602003082e-05, 1.6898978891096887e-05, 1.3071715764876042e-05, 1.009038002580613e-05, 7.773085152783315e-06, 5.975835794223417e-06, 4.584919992039699e-06, 3.5107620164260823e-06, 2.682973381212019e-06, 2.046376600687223e-06, 1.557822287808037e-06, 1.1836478409290595e-06, 8.976528505584322e-07, 6.794924070678161e-07, 5.134051416306209e-07, 3.8720788333645375e-07, 2.915047457902656e-07, 2.1906516291976226e-07, 1.643369536157664e-07, 1.2306296560081667e-07, 9.197223528998033e-08, 6.852403837877785e-08, 5.0721336937602973e-08, 3.7030486116411626e-08, 2.637763856103628e-08, 1.8111596790399213e-08 ], "yaxis": "y2", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(195, 113, 210, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x2", "y": [ 1.9742565302741825e-11, 3.6285230180624e-11, 6.294258563377571e-11, 1.0578337005625199e-10, 1.832716830855957e-10, 3.18824036854801e-10, 5.396212664043307e-10, 9.172496259944763e-10, 1.546677882444469e-09, 2.5894738740377687e-09, 4.305536903273948e-09, 7.108031171803916e-09, 1.1652388925803296e-08, 1.8966010606749244e-08, 3.065174244335845e-08, 4.918509329182278e-08, 7.836785352692886e-08, 1.239855509401926e-07, 1.9478448093515373e-07, 3.0387519194305786e-07, 4.7076672203198343e-07, 7.242708005706544e-07, 1.1066154752138598e-06, 1.6792262635142805e-06, 2.5307909878206775e-06, 3.7883979969035092e-06, 5.632826984952442e-06, 8.319335176244333e-06, 1.2205714679719972e-05, 1.7789826457404813e-05, 2.575944367183793e-05, 3.7057880848834087e-05, 5.296973066476185e-05, 7.523197119296283e-05, 0.00010617680156672426, 0.00014891380571168395, 0.00020756041396520453, 0.0002875311856772075, 0.0003958979848397527, 0.0005418349112091376, 0.0007371635121139041, 0.0009970155540977872, 0.001340632230888529, 0.0017923201124329128, 0.002382585264191562, 0.003149467707474517, 0.004140098529589977, 0.005412501472842013, 0.007037659463284561, 0.009101864223072102, 0.011709363658175858, 0.014985317010593378, 0.01907906172308096, 0.024167688471110383, 0.030459911871202252, 0.038200213973073584, 0.047673225843381566, 0.05920829949338181, 0.07318420828389587, 0.09003389901202621, 0.11024920350409283, 0.13438540209665897, 0.16306551635955283, 0.1969841943251777, 0.236911038919721, 0.28369321980566437, 0.33825720110630336, 0.4016094130367752, 0.47483569491176636, 0.5590993408370365, 0.6556375880776463, 0.7657564019113041, 0.8908234299768907, 1.0322590237817058, 1.1915252549761242, 1.3701128890541037, 1.5695263188397799, 1.7912665037471014, 2.036812007747948, 2.3075982781330473, 2.6049953574398335, 2.9302842712405126, 3.2846323834173528, 3.669068056655794, 4.0844549981847305, 4.53146670727315, 5.010561471085235, 5.521958377551703, 6.065614826855732, 6.641206026825953, 7.248106950080282, 7.885377213426169, 8.551749310946981, 9.24562059316468, 9.965049335090649, 10.707755176609117, 11.47112415177497, 12.252218448111032, 13.047790957448743, 13.854304594560313, 14.667956273711683, 15.484705346119178, 16.300306215267923, 17.110344766156103, 17.910278166806712, 18.69547753191673, 19.461272877589664, 20.202999745568565, 20.91604683636825, 21.595903964430867, 22.238209633793595, 22.83879753247626, 23.39374125693792, 23.89939660218956, 24.352440792823085, 24.749908078158654, 25.089221175759235, 25.36821811609293, 25.585174118107826, 25.738818208083043, 25.82834438122967, 25.853417194683207, 25.81417176736437, 25.711208215776942, 25.545580345109894, 25.318776580526794, 25.032681534278044, 24.689468990288443, 24.29126571216753, 23.839187737010924, 23.331039870756644, 22.75694753496712, 22.093158806847306, 21.29664434198585, 20.305918542314696, 19.053834442767872, 17.493219938876262, 15.627123649652097, 13.528199717867542, 11.333445853220942, 9.212332467661286, 7.321133682480796, 5.763717456082004, 4.574335804826231, 3.7252682437863447, 3.150480243927076, 2.7721855535311537, 2.5204715801789694, 2.342632071019751, 2.2040642458080866, 2.084630201191882, 1.973867038317426, 1.866909669292055, 1.761646969806298, 1.6569047342192855, 1.5512854911167278, 1.4424801725618244, 1.3271545221503578, 1.2016409282041893, 1.0634391619427446, 0.9130079096259015, 0.7548965782947687, 0.597373374630818, 0.4504377885274526, 0.3230209794050537, 0.22063360345475266, 0.14441308068742698, 0.09171774686649853, 0.05768429752655212, 0.036913318164043654, 0.024675283092669902, 0.017450960165492822, 0.012946293864067952, 0.009837081493330744, 0.007452607473135335, 0.0055069844587856, 0.003908047894543722, 0.002636700179264581, 0.0016809276244555385, 0.0010094553367800672, 0.0005708805279525738, 0.0003048735702384431, 0.00015475887702353012, 7.551621641367401e-05, 3.59968124182634e-05, 1.7075869070995824e-05, 8.18209424871531e-06, 3.975863179613793e-06, 1.9411202298540302e-06, 9.356737113344029e-07, 4.372642559647124e-07, 1.9532846389180277e-07, 8.266304519290009e-08, 3.2997573902805456e-08, 1.241368840657642e-08, 4.409042971115564e-09, 1.4839780892768084e-09, 4.757742119026985e-10, 1.4623189971314447e-10, 4.3342711948910357e-11, 1.2516311017663817e-11, 3.6090242981948758e-12, 1.1180708050438335e-12, 4.625664247976917e-13, 2.184987970508718e-13, 1.6711552932848634e-13, 1.8573655826632038e-13, 1.6442543013382695e-13, 1.9337529549501168e-13, 2.0478957219253142e-13, 1.9354725224747024e-13, 2.577107113768052e-13, 2.0845133412293786e-13, 2.119169391600983e-13, 2.1216312771602367e-13, 1.890905084855363e-13, 2.1294438798485154e-13, 1.7805660522644597e-13, 2.0046168340740732e-13, 1.5190032864432614e-13, 2.256722682729594e-13, 2.1444517278588335e-13, 1.975968136968932e-13, 2.454013047959958e-13, 2.125492949611622e-13, 1.889893660244783e-13, 1.8192691263087866e-13, 2.0307818121145726e-13, 1.6077502186883083e-13, 1.804004267928944e-13, 1.1966208868845022e-13, 2.226349460749578e-13, 1.522608708539938e-13, 1.550953928577565e-13, 2.396313873913154e-13, 1.7302971292872536e-13, 2.579267817635234e-13, 2.0974339968893633e-13, 2.451744937619679e-13, 2.816874647952705e-13, 1.5879996657242124e-13, 1.5787081253005787e-13, 2.327999000753908e-13, 2.0093539370264196e-13, 2.017599236710228e-13, 1.730470262426958e-13, 2.2023402391041263e-13, 2.323623334210052e-13, 2.291561906287983e-13, 2.1905822020347052e-13, 2.2479691394555797e-13, 2.0838158441148667e-13, 2.138243838375173e-13, 2.2493882003329716e-13, 2.369351271844403e-13, 2.3281989270578863e-13 ], "yaxis": "y2", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕟ᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕟ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x3", "y": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0.9999999999999991, 0.9999999999999653, 0.999999999998853, 0.9999999999713548, 0.9999999994508215, 0.9999999918121621, 0.9999999038741613, 0.9999991006126683, 0.9999932153623018, 0.9999582695025095, 0.9997884279058136, 0.9991063800521528, 0.9968227116434075, 0.9903920898057412, 0.9750364840543958, 0.9436954445915834, 0.8886039835050608, 0.8045937494770603, 0.6926817287708077, 0.5615793160077287, 0.42565235558070713, 0.3001600234774152, 0.19638562098291718, 0.11908848853324061, 0.06694819076261516, 0.03493271260888181, 0.01694944084238359, 0.0076649985079605965, 0.003239201930107405, 0.0012827773802314146, 0.00047743780544101666, 0.00016750223276756906, 5.555860414280245e-05, 1.7473783543109356e-05, 5.226191281682002e-06, 1.4906557865845826e-06, 4.0659561439948533e-07, 1.0634233610362642e-07, 2.6738449454555283e-08, 6.479526859504148e-09, 1.5169790978930564e-09, 3.439211138100972e-10, 7.56756879383147e-11, 1.6196100016685477e-11, 3.3784641750855826e-12, 6.882827641163658e-13, 1.371680546924381e-13, 2.6811886044697527e-14, 5.162537064506978e-15, 9.43689570931383e-16, 1.6653345369377348e-16, 5.551115123125783e-17, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y3", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "Taf = ½[1+erf((Dₚ-μ)/(√2σ)]", "line": { "color": "rgba(255, 140, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "dash", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "Taf = ½[1+erf((Dₚ-μ)/(√2σ)]", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x3", "y": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0.9999999999999992, 0.9999999999999651, 0.999999999998853, 0.9999999999713548, 0.9999999994508215, 0.9999999918121621, 0.9999999038741613, 0.9999991006126683, 0.9999932153623018, 0.9999582695025095, 0.9997884279058136, 0.9991063800521528, 0.9968227116434075, 0.9903920898057412, 0.9750364840543958, 0.9436954445915834, 0.8886039835050608, 0.8045937494770603, 0.6926817287708077, 0.5615793160077287, 0.42565235558070713, 0.3001600234774152, 0.19638562098291718, 0.11908848853324061, 0.06694819076261516, 0.03493271260888181, 0.01694944084238359, 0.0076649985079605965, 0.003239201930107405, 0.0012827773802314146, 0.00047743780544101666, 0.00016750223276756904, 5.555860414280245e-05, 1.7473783543109356e-05, 5.226191281682002e-06, 1.4906557865845826e-06, 4.0659561439948533e-07, 1.0634233610362642e-07, 2.673844945455528e-08, 6.479526859504148e-09, 1.5169790978930564e-09, 3.4392111381009727e-10, 7.56756879383147e-11, 1.6196100016685477e-11, 3.3784641750855826e-12, 6.882827641163658e-13, 1.371680546924381e-13, 2.681188604469753e-14, 5.162537064506978e-15, 9.43689570931383e-16, 1.6653345369377348e-16, 5.551115123125783e-17, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y3", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕣ᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(237, 94, 147, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 1.5 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕣ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 987.0215796059045, 961.6225316766242, 936.9490675442847, 912.9799855227827, 889.6947125663368, 867.0732840711918, 845.0963241932735, 823.7450266932677, 803.0011363210396, 782.846930751193, 763.2652030808773, 744.2392448997463, 725.7528299403102, 707.7901983148819, 690.336041342923, 673.3754869699251, 656.8940857761543, 640.8777975706205, 625.3129785626763, 610.1863691007247, 595.4850819646739, 581.1965911961369, 567.3087214479474, 553.8096378324075, 540.6878362458145, 527.9321341452895, 515.5316617527562, 503.47585366008633, 491.7544408089404, 480.35744281869194, 469.2751606360141, 458.49816948018315, 448.0173120588993, 437.8236920304261, 427.9086676890319, 418.26384585209235, 408.8810759287022, 399.752444151239, 390.8702679529653, 382.2270904764559, 373.8156751993088, 365.6290006652628, 357.66025531044255, 349.90283237600465, 342.3503248999056, 334.9965207818677, 327.8353979168708, 320.86111939363053, 314.0680287555452, 307.4506453224971, 301.0036595726723, 294.7219285842357, 288.6004715372664, 282.6344652768166, 276.81923993831754, 271.15027463683816, 265.62319322189677, 260.233760099655, 254.97787612437637, 249.85157456104776, 244.8510171210117, 239.9724900723801, 235.21240042688504, 230.56727220467704, 226.0337427784166, 221.60855929782997, 217.28857519570929, 213.0707467761378, 208.95212988552274, 204.92987666682006, 201.00123239714154, 197.16353240873914, 193.41419909317926, 189.75073898834742, 186.17073994775697, 182.67186839148022, 179.25186663787585, 175.90855031515906, 172.63980585173636, 169.44358804412028, 166.31791770114285, 163.26087936309975, 160.27061909438356, 157.3453423480992, 154.48331190110102, 151.68284585784602, 148.94231572142118, 146.26014453007488, 143.6348050575641, 141.06481807561323, 138.54875067677565, 136.08521465598932, 133.67286494911946, 131.3103981267952, 128.99655094185727, 126.73009892875443, 124.50985505324684, 122.33466841079854, 120.20342297206902, 118.11503637394274, 116.06845875456703, 114.06267163090168, 112.09668681731621, 110.1695453838089, 108.28031665245513, 106.42809723073037, 104.61201008038965, 102.8312036206233, 101.08485086424581, 99.37214858571065, 97.69231651978382, 96.04459658974186, 94.42825216400004, 92.84256734010951, 91.28684625509904, 89.76041242117098, 88.26260808579552, 86.79279361527965, 85.35034690092051, 83.93466278688535, 82.54515251898817, 81.18124321356746, 79.8423773456948, 78.52801225597511, 77.23761967522574, 75.97068526634808, 74.72670818273261, 73.50520064256129, 72.30568751839809, 71.12770594147865, 69.97080492013588, 68.83454497181765, 67.71849776817568, 66.62224579272315, 65.54538201058052, 64.48750954984526, 63.448241394141334, 62.4272000859214, 61.42401744011103, 60.43833426769989, 59.46980010890301, 58.518072975526586, 57.58281910219043, 56.66371270607069, 55.760435754841815, 54.87267774250689, 54.00013547282091, 53.14251285002103, 52.29952067658894, 51.470876457784605, 50.656304212696334, 49.85553429156573, 49.068303199155004, 48.29435342393146, 47.53343327285575, 46.785296711566296, 46.049703209762455, 45.32641759159546, 44.61520989088423, 43.915855210980716, 43.228133589115515, 42.55182986506161, 41.88673355396043, 41.232638723160356, 40.58934387292418, 39.95665182086615, 39.334369589987006, 38.72230830017826, 38.120283063072904, 37.52811288012505, 36.9456205438047, 36.372632541797664, 35.808978964107574, 35.254493412956464, 34.709012915389586, 34.17237783848835, 33.644431807103736, 33.12502162402284, 32.6139971924848, 32.11121144096731, 31.616520250166005, 31.129782382092483, 30.650859411219813, 30.17961565760744, 29.715918121937857, 29.259636422403375, 28.81064273337986, 28.36881172582939, 27.93402050937504, 27.506148575992466, 27.085077745265753, 26.67069211115706, 26.262877990240124, 25.861523871351945, 25.466520366614954, 25.077760163788458, 24.69513797990456, 24.318550516149454, 23.947896413950218, 23.583076212228843, 23.223992305787846, 22.870548904791047, 22.52265199530652, 22.18020930087818, 21.8431302450947, 21.511325915124964, 21.18470902619075, 20.863193886947933, 20.54669636574897, 20.23513385775962, 19.92842525290523, 19.626490904620518, 19.32925259937984, 19.036633526984968, 18.74855825158705, 18.464952683422243, 18.1857440512398, 17.910860875402, 17.64023294163714, 17.373791275426726, 17.111468117007764, 16.853196896973902, 16.5989122124571, 16.34854980387449, 16.10204653222358, 15.859340356910943, 15.620370314099462, 15.385076495559359, 15.153400028009264, 14.925283052934084, 14.700668706866004, 14.47950110211641, 14.261725307946296, 14.04728733216347, 13.836134103134455, 13.628213452200871, 13.423474096488798, 13.22186562210084, 13.023338467680787, 12.827843908341297, 12.63533403994438, 12.445761763726392, 12.259080771257803, 12.07524552972945, 11.8942112675568, 11.715933960294059, 11.540370316850076, 11.367477765998565, 11.197214443175126, 11.02953917755362, 10.86441147939523, 10.701791527663065, 10.541640157895818, 10.383918850334066, 10.228589718292769, 10.07561549677409 ], "xaxis": "x4", "y": [ 0.9026599333953221, 0.979093773081623, 0.9768272105785488, 0.9953550373086357, 0.9996549853983543, 0.9947133017120037, 0.9995479950627872, 0.9973114269156458, 0.9991585280261309, 0.999779687875833, 0.9997130053327764, 0.9997410878614175, 0.9998926841781606, 0.9999618768321115, 0.9999803962842316, 0.9999857362059669, 0.9999861857090001, 0.9999950497302474, 0.9999996639809124, 0.9999978041252376, 0.9999965766360502, 0.9999973766429096, 0.9999992070407256, 0.9999996977067512, 0.9999997403569517, 0.9999999264952082, 0.9999999217804753, 0.9999999264977898, 0.9999999326714321, 0.9999999332645092, 0.9999999983580191, 0.9999999721905164, 0.999999991920984, 0.999999991986232, 0.9999999929445806, 0.9999999962853908, 0.9999999953867966, 0.9999999991762422, 0.9999999994225927, 0.9999999991916246, 0.9999999992756085, 0.9999999996430599, 0.9999999995369856, 0.9999999998959709, 0.9999999997772616, 0.9999999999855459, 0.9999999999546154, 0.9999999999881259, 0.9999999999374182, 0.9999999999803971, 0.999999999972482, 0.9999999999904661, 0.9999999999767845, 0.9999999999884627, 0.9999999999900457, 0.9999999999957356, 0.9999999999901369, 0.9999999999934502, 0.9999999999994078, 0.9999999999956569, 0.9999999999981468, 0.9999999999977918, 0.9999999999988775, 0.9999999999989038, 0.9999999999995912, 0.9999999999995084, 0.9999999999995957, 0.9999999999996588, 0.9999999999995051, 0.9999999999998352, 0.9999999999998485, 0.9999999999998725, 0.9999999999999646, 0.9999999999998819, 0.9999999999999404, 0.9999999999998986, 0.9999999999999187, 0.9999999999999538, 0.9999999999999802, 0.9999999999999807, 0.9999999999999369, 0.9999999999999907, 0.9999999999999775, 0.9999999999999916, 0.9999999999999878, 0.999999999999969, 0.9999999999999902, 0.9999999999999972, 0.9999999999999919, 0.9999999999999966, 0.9999999999999997, 0.9999999999999916, 0.9999999999999971, 0.9999999999999971, 0.9999999999999998, 0.9999999999999979, 0.9999999999999967, 0.999999999999993, 0.9999999999999969, 0.999999999999996, 0.9999999999999929, 0.9999999999999983, 0.9999999999999973, 0.9999999999999968, 0.999999999999998, 1, 0.9999999999999982, 0.9999999999999979, 0.9999999999999986, 0.9999999999999973, 0.9999999999999993, 0.9999999999999983, 0.9999999999999987, 0.9999999999999997, 0.9999999999999992, 0.9999999999999991, 0.9999999999999997, 0.9999999999999991, 0.999999999999999, 0.9999999999999727, 0.9999999999992917, 0.9999999999857624, 0.9999999997746482, 0.999999997156429, 0.9999999710236697, 0.9999997586074453, 0.999998336674539, 0.9999904140736248, 0.9999533020289338, 0.9998057512886731, 0.9993033742002121, 0.9978262367343996, 0.9940461026372459, 0.9855655037444991, 0.9687752185702441, 0.9392615806716937, 0.892950238219189, 0.8277617017940074, 0.7450909287297803, 0.6502781080700959, 0.5516266845182959, 0.4582665299548003, 0.37777246078663573, 0.31452635402606466, 0.2693438049136665, 0.24022817599950116, 0.2236768975853174, 0.21592370279357526, 0.21374923188522466, 0.21480064710252364, 0.21755842984951304, 0.2211367951501616, 0.2250553802229142, 0.22904365929001516, 0.23288021227627656, 0.2362436023489133, 0.23856397555003167, 0.2389086501380327, 0.2359847534401823, 0.2283489500916769, 0.21483818324705464, 0.19509378403007563, 0.1699350809864099, 0.14135315660417655, 0.11206524187243692, 0.08479909075352739, 0.06161363695186521, 0.043521039024467585, 0.030497949008007633, 0.021786314039460127, 0.01629323652652514, 0.0129260957011159, 0.010789132134983202, 0.009250878482212172, 0.007930413312426868, 0.006647831809575418, 0.005364817053535569, 0.004125756631909356, 0.0030049822641731337, 0.002066430743454433, 0.0013412147000751147, 0.0008238593639573259, 0.00048206391741905253, 0.0002717122753396565, 0.00014991058830998252, 8.247768337959447e-05, 4.593579313940371e-05, 2.60075837683839e-05, 1.4833259198194641e-05, 8.37503612001045e-06, 4.59650459820815e-06, 2.4175554911785532e-06, 1.2075892992090392e-06, 5.70332800165688e-07, 2.544519361876737e-07, 1.0742624272107462e-07, 4.3076791581977e-08, 1.6490841096136113e-08, 6.0654360398709055e-09, 2.1559669026370185e-09, 7.479907049907655e-10, 2.593407601556905e-10, 9.625383022484954e-11, 4.743164998080595e-11, 2.6648693493284665e-11, 2.434897647571831e-11, 3.322527048407198e-11, 3.5850335705775563e-11, 5.154034070371303e-11, 6.695614875324126e-11, 7.758492343245108e-11, 1.281067422697273e-10, 1.288262592962078e-10, 1.612104550728541e-10, 2.0126766501931447e-10, 2.232986386860754e-10, 3.1172926569343843e-10, 3.2601973320201854e-10, 4.6001202375872597e-10, 4.3794977558057347e-10, 8.232846291416595e-10, 9.799989292712906e-10, 1.1542436280794804e-09, 1.8004139051732907e-09, 1.9741931625360135e-09, 2.2448023693631623e-09, 2.7554118388147602e-09, 3.938510764657747e-09, 4.005569915458591e-09, 5.785843377793865e-09, 4.923396654324991e-09, 1.1847472550219254e-08, 1.0480447467745664e-08, 1.3846788451070623e-08, 2.7645733708057518e-08, 2.5932866807366912e-08, 5.027380552246241e-08, 5.358048795506646e-08, 8.170916972962783e-08, 1.229771066154029e-07, 9.079371955281415e-08, 1.192849075891037e-07, 2.3251815282189895e-07, 2.634283654644275e-07, 3.504159177364452e-07, 3.987370914495316e-07, 6.717542889995224e-07, 9.458627757861622e-07, 1.247479469725709e-06, 1.590135821156463e-06, 2.1843102055165716e-06, 2.7126694318413227e-06, 3.765341343652314e-06, 5.403935449148033e-06, 7.995632649351306e-06, 1.1412839010575855e-05 ], "yaxis": "y4", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 } ], "layout": { "annotations": [], "height": 504, "legend": { "bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "bordercolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "font": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 14 }, "tracegroupgap": 0, "x": 1, "y": 0.5 }, "margin": { "b": 20, "l": 0, "r": 0, "t": 20 }, "paper_bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "plot_bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "showlegend": true, "width": 792, "xaxis1": { "anchor": "y1", "domain": [ 0.11363636363636363, 0.46885521885521886 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.3010299956639813, 2.3010299956639813 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis2": { "anchor": "y2", "domain": [ 0.6069023569023569, 0.9621212121212122 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.3010299956639813, 2.3010299956639813 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis3": { "anchor": "y3", "domain": [ 0.11363636363636363, 0.46885521885521886 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.3010299956639813, 2.3010299956639813 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "Mobility Diameter (nm)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis4": { "anchor": "y4", "domain": [ 0.6035353535353536, 0.9621212121212122 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.3010299956639813, 2.3010299956639813 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "Apparent +1 Mobility Diam. (nm)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis1": { "anchor": "x1", "domain": [ 0.5574146981627296, 0.9702380952380951 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -64.02463777332741, 2198.1792302175745 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0", "500", "1000", "1500", "2000" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 500, 1000, 1500, 2000 ], "title": "dN/dlnD (cm⁻³)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis2": { "anchor": "x2", "domain": [ 0.5574146981627296, 0.9702380952380951 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.7756025158512978, 26.62901971089879 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0", "5", "10", "15", "20", "25" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 ], "title": "Concentration (cm⁻³)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis3": { "anchor": "x3", "domain": [ 0.073949089697121, 0.48677248677248663 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.05, 1.05 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0.0", "0.2", "0.4", "0.6", "0.8", "1.0" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1 ], "title": "Activated fraction", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis4": { "anchor": "x4", "domain": [ 0.073949089697121, 0.48677248677248663 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.05, 1.05 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0.0", "0.2", "0.4", "0.6", "0.8", "1.0" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1 ], "title": "Activated fraction", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" } } }, "image/svg+xml": [ "234567891002050010001500200023456789100205101520252345678910020.00.20.40.60.81.02345678910020.00.20.40.60.81.0𝕟ᶜⁿ = 𝓛𝓝 (N,Dₘ,σ)𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = Taf.*𝕟ᶜⁿ𝕣ᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕟ᶜⁿTaf = ½[1+erf((Dₚ-μ)/(√2σ)]𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕣ᶜⁿMobility Diameter (nm)Apparent +1 Mobility Diam. (nm)dN/dlnD (cm⁻³)Concentration (cm⁻³)Activated fractionActivated fraction" ] }, "execution_count": 4, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "execute_result" } ], "source": [ "figure(\"Nimbus Sans L\", 2, 5.5, 3.5, 8) \n", "\n", "# Get a list of colors from the theme palette\n", "p = Plots.get_color_palette(:auto, default(:bgcolor), 100)\n", "\n", "# Panel (a): Mobility size and CCN distribution\n", "p1 = plot(𝕟ᶜⁿ.Dp, 𝕟ᶜⁿ.S, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], ylabel = \"dN/dlnD (cm⁻³)\", \n", " label = \"𝕟ᶜⁿ = 𝓛𝓝 (N,Dₘ,σ)\", color = p[1], left_margin = 20px)\n", "p1 = plot!(𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ.Dp, 𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ.S, label = \"𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = Taf.*𝕟ᶜⁿ\", color = p[2])\n", "\n", "# Panel (b): Size and CCN response function \n", "p2 = plot(𝕣ᶜⁿ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜⁿ.N , xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], label = \"𝕣ᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ\", \n", " ylabel = \"Concentration (cm⁻³)\", color = p[3])\n", "p2 = plot!(𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N, label = \"𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = 𝐀*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ\", color = p[4], left_margin = 36px)\n", "\n", "# Panel (c): Activated fraction. Note that g and 𝕒𝕗₁ are identical\n", "p3 = plot(𝕒𝕗₁.Dp, 𝕒𝕗₁.S, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], xlabel = \"Mobility Diameter (nm)\", \n", " ylabel = \"Activated fraction\", label = \"𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕟ᶜⁿ\", ylim = (-0.05,1.05), lw = 1.5, \n", " yticks = [0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1], color = :black, left_margin = 20px)\n", "p3 = plot!(𝕟ᶜⁿ.Dp, Taf(𝕟ᶜⁿ,μ,σ), label = \"Taf = ½[1+erf((Dₚ-μ)/(√2σ)]\", ls = :dash, \n", " color = :darkorange, lw = 1.5)\n", "\n", "# Panel (d): Activated fraction from response function (\"measured ratio\" from raw signal)\n", "p4 = plot(𝕒𝕗₂.Dp, 𝕒𝕗₂.S, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], \n", " xlabel = \"Apparent +1 Mobility Diam. (nm)\", ylim = (-0.05,1.05), label = \"𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ ./ 𝕣ᶜⁿ\", \n", " color = p[7], ylabel = \"Activated fraction\", yticks = [0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1], left_margin = 20px)\n", "\n", "plot(p1,p2,p3,p4, layout = grid(2,2), lw = 1.5, right_margin = 30px, \n", " xlim = (20,200), legend=:right, top_margin = 15px, fmt = :svg)" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "
Figure 2. Top left: Lognormal mobility size distribution (CN) assumed to be known (blue) and CCN size distribution calculated from the assumed size distribution and the CCN transmission function based on an assumed D50 activation diameter of (μ=60 nm) and standard deviation (σ = 8nm). Top right: CN and CCN response funcion computed from size and CCN distribution and the convolution matrix. Bottom left: ratio of CCN and CN size distribution superimposed on the CCN transmission function. These are by definition equal. Bottom right, right of CCN and CN response function.
" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "Figure 2 bottom right demostrates the presence of a shoulder of particles activating at 45 nm. These are +2 charged particles transmitting through the DMA that influence of +2 the observed ratio 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿ. Petters et al. (2007) used a non-matrix based forward solution of the Fredholm integral equation (Notebook S2) to compute 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿ and fit an optimal solution through data. Petters et al. (2009) used an simple inversion method to find 𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕟ᶜⁿ, from which the activated fraction and D50 were determined. Neither method is quick to reproduce. Below it is demonstrated how the formalism introduced with DifferentialMobilityAnalyzer.jl greatly simplifies finding D50 from actual CCN data. \n", "## Block 5. Application to Synthetic Data\n", "This block demonstrates how to use DifferentialMobilityAnalyzer.jl to work with synthetic CCN data. Here the objective is to find the activation diameter when only the noisy response is known, as is the case with measurements. A noisy response function is simulated as in Notebook S4. The ideal response function is computed via 𝕣 = $\\mathbf{A}*$𝕟. Then the number of counts are computed based on detector sample flow rate (1 L min⁻¹ for the CPC and 0.05 L min⁻¹ for the CCN). A random number generator is simulating a Poisson distributed random variate with mean equaling the counts. The noisy response function is thresholded at low concentrations. This is necessary because at low concentrations a bin may have zero or very low concentration, resulting in unrealistic or NaN/InF values in the activated fraction array. The data are then inverted and the activation diameter is obtained via a non-linear least square fit, as would be the case with a real dataset.\n", "\n", "### (a) Define DMA" ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 5, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [], "source": [ "t,p = 295.15, 1e5 # Temperature [K], Pressure [Pa]\n", "qsa,β = 1.66e-5, 1/5 # Qsample [m3 s-1], Sample-to-sheath ratio,\n", "r₁,r₂,l = 9.37e-3,1.961e-2,0.44369 # DMA geometry [m]\n", "leff = 13.0 # DMA effective diffusion length [m]\n", "m = 6 # Upper number of charges\n", "Λ = DMAconfig(t,p,qsa,qsa/β,r₁,r₂,l,leff,:-,m,:cylindrical) # Specify DMA with negative polarity\n", "bins,z₁,z₂ = 60, dtoz(Λ,300e-9), dtoz(Λ,30e-9) # bins, upper, lower mobility limit\n", "δ = setupDMA(Λ, z₁, z₂, bins); # Compute matrices" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "The section generates the noisy CN and CCN response function using the random number gnerator. Thresholding is performed for bins with low counts. If counts/concentration is below the threhold, the activated fraction is forced to one for large diameters and zero for small diameters. The noise threshold may need to be adjusted for different datasets." ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 6, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [], "source": [ "𝕟ᶜⁿ = DMALognormalDistribution([[7000.0, 80, 1.4]], δ)\n", "Taf = (x,μ,σ) -> @. 0.5 .* (1.0 .+ erf.((x .- μ)/(sqrt(2σ))))\n", "tscan = 180 # SMPS scan time [s] \n", "Qcpc = 16.66 # CPC flow rate [cm³ s⁻¹]. 16.66 cm³ s⁻¹ = 1 L min⁻¹\n", "Qccn = 0.05*16.66 # CCN sample flow rate [cm³ s⁻¹]. 16.66 cm³ s⁻¹ = 1 L min⁻¹\n", "t = tscan./bins # time in each bin\n", "Random.seed!(705)\n", "μ,σ = 60,8\n", "𝕣ᶜⁿ = δ.𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ; # DMA response function \n", "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ = δ.𝐀*(Taf(δ.Dp,μ,σ)*𝕟ᶜⁿ); # DMA response function \n", "cᶜⁿ = 𝕣ᶜⁿ.N*Qcpc*t; # number of counts in each bin\n", "cᶜᶜⁿ = 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N*Qccn*t; # number of CCN counts in each bin\n", "\n", "Rcn = Float64[] # Construct a noisy response function 𝕣+ϵ, where ϵ is counting uncertainty\n", "Rccn = Float64[] # Construct a noisy response function 𝕣+ϵ, where ϵ is counting uncertainty\n", "for i = cᶜⁿ\n", " f = rand(Poisson(i),1) # draw Poisson random number with mean = counts\n", " push!(Rcn,f[1]/(Qcpc*t)) # convert back to concentration\n", "end\n", "\n", "for i = cᶜᶜⁿ\n", " f = rand(Poisson(i),1) # draw Poisson random number with mean = counts\n", " push!(Rccn,f[1]/(Qccn*t)) # convert back to concentration\n", "end\n", "\n", "𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N = Rcn, Rccn;\n", "\n", "function threshold(𝕟::SizeDistribution, c::Float64, n1::Float64, n2::Float64)\n", " N = 𝕟.N \n", " N[(N .<= c) .& (𝕟.Dp .> 150)] .= n1\n", " N[(N .<= c) .& (𝕟.Dp .> 150)] .= n2\n", " 𝕟.N = N\n", "end\n", "\n", "threshold(𝕣ᶜⁿ, 6.0, 0.1, 0.1);\n", "threshold(𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ, 6.0, 0.0, 0.1);" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "The data are inverted using the regularized inversion (Notebook S4). The regularized inverted size distributions are are also thresholded for the same reason as above. Zero concentrations in the CN array or division of two noisy numbers results in unrealistic activated fractions that interfere with the least-square fitting model.
\n", "\n", "### (b) Fitting Model\n", "There are two ways to fit the response data. Possibility one is to compute the activated fraction from the inverted data and then fit the ratio to the activation model\n", "
$T_{\\mu,\\sigma} = \\frac{1}{2}\\left[1 + \\mathrm{erf}\\left(\\frac{d-\\mu}{\\sigma}\\right) \\right] $
\n", "to find the μ,σ that best describes the data. An alternative method is to compute the regularized inverse from the the CN response function and use it to predict the ratio of 𝕣ᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ. In this case the model is\n", "
$𝕟^{\\mathrm{cn}} = (\\bf{A}^\\rm{T}\\bf{A} + \\lambda^\\rm{2} \\bf{I})^\\rm{-1}(\\bf{A}^\\rm{T} \\rm{𝕣^{\\mathrm{cn}}} - \\lambda^2\\bf{S}^{-1} \\rm{𝕣^{\\mathrm{cn}}})$
\n", "
$\\left( \\frac{𝕣^{\\mathrm{cn}}}{𝕣^{\\mathrm{cn}}} \\right)_{\\mathrm{model}} = \\frac{\\mathbf{A}[T_{\\mu,\\sigma}\\; .*\\; 𝕟^{\\mathrm{cn}}]}{\\mathbf{A}𝕟^{\\mathrm{cn}}}$
\n", "Methods 1 and 2 mirror the approaches in Petters et al. (2009) and Petters et al. (2007), respectively. However, the previously published approaches neither used regularization nor the formalism described here.
\n", "\n", "Using the formalized approach, the model formulation and fitting procedure become simple and can be solved in few lines of code.\n", "```julia\n", "𝕟ᶜⁿ = rinv(𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, δ, λ₁= 1e-3, λ₂=1e1)\n", "model(x,p) = (δ.𝐀*(𝕟ᶜⁿ.N.*Taf(δ.dp, p[1], p[2])))./(δ.𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ.N)\n", "fit = curve_fit(model, δ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N./𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, [65.0, 3.0])\n", "```\n", "Note that least square library is not setup to take the SizeDistribution data type, and thus the operation is performed on the number field of these objects. " ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 7, "metadata": {}, "outputs": [ { "data": { "text/html": [ "

1 rows × 2 columns

μσ
Float64Float64
160.28.8
" ], "text/latex": [ "\\begin{tabular}{r|cc}\n", "\t& μ & σ\\\\\n", "\t\\hline\n", "\t& Float64 & Float64\\\\\n", "\t\\hline\n", "\t1 & 60.2 & 8.8 \\\\\n", "\\end{tabular}\n" ], "text/plain": [ "1×2 DataFrame\n", "│ Row │ μ │ σ │\n", "│ │ \u001b[90mFloat64\u001b[39m │ \u001b[90mFloat64\u001b[39m │\n", "├─────┼─────────┼─────────┤\n", "│ 1 │ 60.2 │ 8.8 │" ] }, "execution_count": 7, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "execute_result" } ], "source": [ "𝕟ᶜⁿ = rinv(𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, δ, λ₁= 1e-3, λ₂=1e1)\n", "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ = rinv(𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N, δ, λ₁= 1e-3, λ₂=1e1)\n", "threshold(𝕟ᶜⁿ, 60.0, 0.1, 0.1)\n", "threshold(𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ, 60.0, 0.0, 0.1)\n", "𝕒𝕗₁ = 𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿ # ratio of CCN to CN based on inverted data\n", "\n", "model(x,p) = (δ.𝐀*(𝕟ᶜⁿ.N.*Taf(δ.Dp, p[1], p[2])))./(δ.𝐀*𝕟ᶜⁿ.N)\n", "fit = curve_fit(model, δ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N./𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, [65.0, 3.0])\n", "Ax = fit.param;\n", "DataFrame(μ=round(Ax[1],digits=1), σ=round(Ax[2],digits=1))" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ " Table 1. Best fit μ, σ obtained from the least-square algorithm. " ] }, { "cell_type": "code", "execution_count": 8, "metadata": { "scrolled": false }, "outputs": [ { "data": { "application/vnd.plotly.v1+json": { "data": [ { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕣ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x1", "y": [ 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 6.122448979591836, 6.122448979591836, 9.063625450180071, 9.063625450180071, 11.664665866346537, 11.664665866346537, 15.786314525810322, 15.786314525810322, 21.52861144457783, 21.52861144457783, 26.370548219287713, 26.370548219287713, 33.69347739095638, 33.69347739095638, 43.29731892757103, 43.29731892757103, 51.44057623049219, 51.44057623049219, 62.34493797519007, 62.34493797519007, 74.82993197278911, 74.82993197278911, 85.47418967587033, 85.47418967587033, 103.30132052821128, 103.30132052821128, 115.24609843937574, 115.24609843937574, 127.59103641456582, 127.59103641456582, 145.03801520608243, 145.03801520608243, 153.44137655062025, 153.44137655062025, 167.68707482993196, 167.68707482993196, 179.69187675070026, 179.69187675070026, 185.094037615046, 185.094037615046, 192.05682272909164, 192.05682272909164, 198.0192076830732, 198.0192076830732, 198.1392557022809, 198.1392557022809, 201.6206482593037, 201.6206482593037, 198.45938375350138, 198.45938375350138, 191.33653461384552, 191.33653461384552, 186.89475790316126, 186.89475790316126, 180.31212484993995, 180.31212484993995, 165.6062424969988, 165.6062424969988, 159.70388155262103, 159.70388155262103, 144.45778311324528, 144.45778311324528, 129.93197278911563, 129.93197278911563, 116.58663465386154, 116.58663465386154, 106.2625050020008, 106.2625050020008, 89.63585434173669, 89.63585434173669, 81.73269307723089, 81.73269307723089, 66.74669867947178, 66.74669867947178, 59.14365746298519, 59.14365746298519, 50.96038415366146, 50.96038415366146, 41.65666266506602, 41.65666266506602, 33.59343737494998, 33.59343737494998, 27.47098839535814, 27.47098839535814, 21.98879551820728, 21.98879551820728, 18.147258903561422, 18.147258903561422, 13.76550620248099, 13.76550620248099, 10.984393757503, 10.984393757503, 8.923569427771108, 8.923569427771108, 6.66266506602641, 6.66266506602641, 5.142056822729091, 5.142056822729091, 2.9811924769907963, 2.9811924769907963, 2.180872348939576, 2.180872348939576 ], "yaxis": "y1", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ", "line": { "color": "rgba(163, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x1", "y": [ 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 7.603041216486594, 7.603041216486594, 7.202881152460984, 7.202881152460984, 13.605442176870747, 13.605442176870747, 15.206082432973188, 15.206082432973188, 18.80752300920368, 18.80752300920368, 28.011204481792717, 28.011204481792717, 36.01440576230492, 36.01440576230492, 38.815526210484194, 38.815526210484194, 53.22128851540616, 53.22128851540616, 53.62144857943177, 53.62144857943177, 69.62785114045617, 69.62785114045617, 83.63345338135254, 83.63345338135254, 104.04161664665865, 104.04161664665865, 119.24769907963184, 119.24769907963184, 131.25250100040014, 131.25250100040014, 148.45938375350138, 148.45938375350138, 149.65986394557822, 149.65986394557822, 169.2677070828331, 169.2677070828331, 194.87795118047217, 194.87795118047217, 172.0688275310124, 172.0688275310124, 179.27170868347338, 179.27170868347338, 200.88035214085633, 200.88035214085633, 198.8795518207283, 198.8795518207283, 193.67747098839536, 193.67747098839536, 210.8843537414966, 210.8843537414966, 208.0832332933173, 208.0832332933173, 175.6702681072429, 175.6702681072429, 177.67106842737095, 177.67106842737095, 166.86674669867946, 166.86674669867946, 140.8563425370148, 140.8563425370148, 100.04001600640255, 100.04001600640255, 76.03041216486594, 76.03041216486594, 56.022408963585434, 56.022408963585434, 38.01520608243297, 38.01520608243297, 18.80752300920368, 18.80752300920368, 15.206082432973188, 15.206082432973188, 18.80752300920368, 18.80752300920368, 11.604641856742697, 11.604641856742697, 14.005602240896359, 14.005602240896359, 10.804321728691477, 10.804321728691477, 8.403361344537815, 8.403361344537815, 3.2012805122048817, 3.2012805122048817, 1.2004801920768307, 1.2004801920768307, 1.2004801920768307, 1.2004801920768307, 0.8003201280512204, 0.8003201280512204, 0, 0, 0.4001600640256102, 0.4001600640256102, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y1", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "dashdot", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕟ᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x2", "y": [ 0.04924446453563814, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.05377194549701197, 0.05377194549701197, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.09016915774618903, 0.09016915774618903, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.38092717335807663, 0.38092717335807663, 0.41278423633962297, 0.41278423633962297, 0.5323292852736196, 0.5323292852736196, 0.4065210381474855, 0.4065210381474855, 0.9081281263611852, 0.9081281263611852, 1.1179885965645526, 1.1179885965645526, 1.1508637028700834, 1.1508637028700834, 1.7568689726596853, 1.7568689726596853, 2.094411481923027, 2.094411481923027, 2.4237644760651182, 2.4237644760651182, 3.0794724953510837, 3.0794724953510837, 3.0677997924997773, 3.0677997924997773, 4.301718909775437, 4.301718909775437, 4.597692708097449, 4.597692708097449, 4.885350602948838, 4.885350602948838, 6.011235525992063, 6.011235525992063, 5.996257117677026, 5.996257117677026, 6.733410844062087, 6.733410844062087, 7.357130002177749, 7.357130002177749, 7.516871110537027, 7.516871110537027, 7.649486274991611, 7.649486274991611, 8.143138137373189, 8.143138137373189, 8.047069830714387, 8.047069830714387, 8.407238787496233, 8.407238787496233, 8.30917851879734, 8.30917851879734, 7.7957801942195, 7.7957801942195, 7.656470648876803, 7.656470648876803, 7.945645363349026, 7.945645363349026, 6.697681441318615, 6.697681441318615, 6.946204239923016, 6.946204239923016, 6.204939259196071, 6.204939259196071, 5.658612802257975, 5.658612802257975, 4.650471579672901, 4.650471579672901, 4.964557046527594, 4.964557046527594, 3.752403291205132, 3.752403291205132, 3.806499519349827, 3.806499519349827, 2.611999573211486, 2.611999573211486, 2.796146317036267, 2.796146317036267, 2.384367420686739, 2.384367420686739, 2.0424958322385898, 2.0424958322385898, 1.3992996604546348, 1.3992996604546348, 1.1889424179601606, 1.1889424179601606, 1.089317474118208, 1.089317474118208, 0.9779631626540009, 0.9779631626540009, 0.6100827851808842, 0.6100827851808842, 0.5082197764724045, 0.5082197764724045, 0.4947635503134883, 0.4947635503134883, 0.4119800744390553, 0.4119800744390553, 0.2830315609823131, 0.2830315609823131, 0.06956058044428803, 0.06956058044428803, 0.13567642203424768, 0.13567642203424768 ], "yaxis": "y2", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)", "line": { "color": "rgba(163, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "dashdot", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x2", "y": [ 0.008076767910733083, 0, 0, 0.01417711968628908, 0.01417711968628908, 0, 0, 0.04131106803051464, 0.04131106803051464, 0.02615102918806452, 0.02615102918806452, 0.01786507810256497, 0.01786507810256497, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.37171180952517746, 0.37171180952517746, 0.30042090130472465, 0.30042090130472465, 0.64498814689688, 0.64498814689688, 0.5474600780304879, 0.5474600780304879, 0.6189165795277858, 0.6189165795277858, 1.1111747704028685, 1.1111747704028685, 1.495173605846765, 1.495173605846765, 1.5172106417516822, 1.5172106417516822, 2.2339598546002577, 2.2339598546002577, 1.9125031749177108, 1.9125031749177108, 2.5841350349642793, 2.5841350349642793, 3.1508604269501537, 3.1508604269501537, 4.279257888528456, 4.279257888528456, 4.8411566036759455, 4.8411566036759455, 5.172616274750812, 5.172616274750812, 5.830663422235761, 5.830663422235761, 5.7022443106336995, 5.7022443106336995, 6.759828439427418, 6.759828439427418, 8.386440188761165, 8.386440188761165, 6.819760130151577, 6.819760130151577, 6.711004825518735, 6.711004825518735, 7.993941052113646, 7.993941052113646, 8.506580459957037, 8.506580459957037, 7.860085023723886, 7.860085023723886, 8.739408740195547, 8.739408740195547, 9.060103831192377, 9.060103831192377, 7.071897371470308, 7.071897371470308, 7.260678768803486, 7.260678768803486, 7.343943345793397, 7.343943345793397, 6.395371797908186, 6.395371797908186, 3.5099374744364846, 3.5099374744364846, 2.199542275625484, 2.199542275625484, 1.5759203475396169, 1.5759203475396169, 0.923013954440659, 0.923013954440659, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.26849604858568193, 0.26849604858568193, 0.0877008799627629, 0.0877008799627629, 0.29535641959522274, 0.29535641959522274, 0.11827666460721903, 0.11827666460721903, 0.16091096917855766, 0.16091096917855766, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0.05711267156521911, 0.05711267156521911, 0.008520104315080658, 0.008520104315080658, 0.022962571078321715, 0.022962571078321715, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y2", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿ", "marker": { "color": "rgba(255, 140, 0, 1.000)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "width": 1 }, "size": 6, "symbol": "circle" }, "mode": "markers", "name": "𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x3", "y": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1.2418300653594772, 0.794701986754967, 1.1663807890222986, 0.9632446134347276, 0.8736059479553904, 1.0622154779969653, 1.0688836104513064, 0.8964879852125693, 1.0346168805912097, 0.8600770218228498, 0.9304812834224598, 0.9784644194756555, 1.0071663761379044, 1.034722222222222, 1.028696879410381, 1.0235894606152571, 0.9753553266397182, 1.0094260828063477, 1.0845117470214898, 0.9296292292725111, 0.9334305656839254, 1.014448822875619, 1.003736241542967, 0.960603354172869, 1.0626071176529892, 1.0875248353027294, 0.9399421903436462, 0.9853528628495342, 1.0076114534251541, 0.8819844650463543, 0.6925207756232687, 0.5851555281798583, 0.48052170928436594, 0.35774807004330633, 0.20982142857142858, 0.18604651162790697, 0.28177458033573144, 0.1962110960757781, 0.2748331370239498, 0.2593659942363113, 0.2501488981536629, 0.11653313911143481, 0.054595086442220206, 0.06615214994487321, 0.058139534883720936, 0, 0.04484304932735426, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y3", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "Eq. (12)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "solid", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "Eq. (12)", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x3", "y": [ 0.9999999999792923, 0.9999999999982285, 0.9999999999838041, 0.9999999999977071, 0.9999999999919025, 0.9999999999966743, 0.9999999999945842, 0.9999999999984818, 0.9999999999925824, 0.9999999999943726, 0.9999999999980556, 0.9999999999966147, 0.9999999999969146, 0.9999999999992577, 0.999999999999939, 0.9999999999999823, 0.9999999999999986, 0.999999999999999, 0.9999999999999992, 0.9999999999999994, 0.9999999999999997, 0.9999999999999981, 0.9999999999999981, 1, 0.999999999999999, 0.9999999999999994, 0.9999999999999997, 0.9999999999999999, 0.9999999999999993, 0.9999999999999789, 0.9999999999880524, 0.9999999973761095, 0.9999997549632017, 0.9999894135576265, 0.999778482965585, 0.9979083944558876, 0.9872559546432154, 0.9519131475705145, 0.8727551972946322, 0.7460024118797435, 0.5854754420923804, 0.4317496765884234, 0.3147424027489876, 0.25332905895955904, 0.22908555436666966, 0.2281334434850294, 0.22941773715494773, 0.23050061984189602, 0.2256639630320551, 0.20913588294771832, 0.1721930754031946, 0.12299609110983051, 0.07497603360321581, 0.04089796024261574, 0.021148738583565866, 0.011713733066321053, 0.007077545515023898, 0.004518662537830161, 0.0027597236984172, 0.0014937630403743687 ], "yaxis": "y3", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿ", "marker": { "color": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "width": 1 }, "size": 6, "symbol": "circle" }, "mode": "markers", "name": "𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿ", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x4", "y": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 607.2153417565838, 0.8635878175108359, 1.0666289188546185, 0.7890631263077924, 0.8391486005688998, 1.0270749853538177, 0.9947785939253401, 1.0529534945103463, 1.058801444389391, 0.9699609002216726, 0.950967278208172, 1.0039233600885393, 1.13990648340844, 0.907260485096219, 0.877314447567408, 0.9816781831840972, 1.0571028509643063, 0.9349187316308764, 1.0517777082806588, 1.1621805137490104, 0.9236497723017784, 0.9137934600372306, 1.0964903915089081, 0.9207002237496927, 0.5656683051706846, 0.38870697686680256, 0.3388732347979345, 0.18592070667941082, 0, 0, 0.10279329726519164, 0.03136491085191856, 0.12387202451799773, 0.057907909891589344, 0.11499393141157302, 0, 0, 0, 0.09361462567458889, 0.016764606002189462, 0.046411202005023106, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y4", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 }, { "colorbar": { "title": "" }, "hoverinfo": "text", "legendgroup": "Eq. (11)", "line": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "dash": "dashdot", "shape": "linear", "width": 2 }, "mode": "lines", "name": "Eq. (11)", "showlegend": true, "text": [ null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null ], "type": "scatter", "x": [ 293.0641784900767, 279.7738377031705, 267.21616437692086, 255.3433811555289, 244.11105760913978, 233.4778936353466, 223.40551179602096, 213.8582590026533, 204.80301786930133, 196.20902794142697, 188.0477168932456, 180.29254167432325, 172.91883948382534, 165.90368836154587, 159.22577711027046, 152.86528420452137, 146.8037652956838, 141.02404889175403, 135.51013976995907, 130.24712967061043, 125.2211148191028, 120.41911982835757, 115.82902754479218, 111.43951441577228, 107.2399909743698, 103.22054705715637, 99.3719013919327, 95.68535521409964, 92.15274959230975, 88.76642616571246, 85.51919101622556, 82.40428141961395, 79.41533523858644, 76.5463627395297, 73.79172063183574, 71.14608814501449, 68.60444497392724, 66.16205093654115, 63.81442720163068, 61.55733895588136, 59.386779390931814, 57.29895490108242, 55.29027139175019, 53.35732160732653, 51.49687339494323, 49.70585882783418, 47.98136411854006, 46.320620258199725, 44.72099432363971, 43.179981398965914, 41.695197062915625, 40.26437039737728, 38.88533747627375, 37.556035297455054, 36.274496123393455, 35.03884219934329, 33.84728082024303, 32.69809972002039, 31.589662759134935, 30.520405888167428 ], "xaxis": "x4", "y": [ 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0.999999999999963, 0.9999999999521265, 0.9999999817246294, 0.9999976586002686, 0.9998865501936531, 0.9976766226227147, 0.9776536690628675, 0.8880937429527473, 0.6757610402669066, 0.39145086393358125, 0.16377085157275828, 0.048866266980408635, 0.010519145862302015, 0.0016719619191946644, 0.00020178634369100168, 1.9039018134159313e-05, 1.445143735234744e-06, 9.06795545319028e-08, 4.8248768869108005e-09, 2.2287388601327507e-10, 9.133027667473925e-12, 3.3861802251067274e-13, 1.1546319456101628e-14, 3.885780586188048e-16, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "yaxis": "y4", "zmax": 0.1, "zmin": -0.1 } ], "layout": { "annotations": [], "height": 432, "legend": { "bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "bordercolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "font": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 14 }, "tracegroupgap": 0, "x": 1, "y": 1 }, "margin": { "b": 20, "l": 0, "r": 0, "t": 20 }, "paper_bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "plot_bgcolor": "rgba(255, 255, 255, 1.000)", "showlegend": true, "width": 792, "xaxis1": { "anchor": "y1", "domain": [ 0.12205387205387205, 0.484006734006734 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.4771212547196624, 2.113943352306837 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis2": { "anchor": "y2", "domain": [ 0.6127946127946128, 0.9747474747474747 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.4771212547196624, 2.113943352306837 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis3": { "anchor": "y3", "domain": [ 0.12205387205387205, 0.484006734006734 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.4771212547196624, 2.113943352306837 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "Apparent +1 Mobility Diameter (nm)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "xaxis4": { "anchor": "y4", "domain": [ 0.6123737373737373, 0.9747474747474747 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ 1.4771212547196624, 2.113943352306837 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "10^2" ], "tickvals": [ 100 ], "title": "Mobility Diameter (nm)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "log", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis1": { "anchor": "x1", "domain": [ 0.5810185185185185, 0.9908865558471858 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -6.326530612244897, 217.2108843537415 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0", "50", "100", "150", "200" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 50, 100, 150, 200 ], "title": "Concentration (cm⁻³)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis2": { "anchor": "x2", "domain": [ 0.5810185185185185, 0.9908865558471858 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.2718031149357713, 9.331906946128148 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0", "2", "4", "6", "8" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 2, 4, 6, 8 ], "title": "dN/dlnD × 10⁻³ (cm⁻³)", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis3": { "anchor": "x3", "domain": [ 0.10030864197530857, 0.5101766793039758 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.05, 1.25 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0.0", "0.2", "0.4", "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "1.2" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6000000000000001, 0.8, 1, 1.2000000000000002 ], "title": "Activated fraction", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" }, "yaxis4": { "anchor": "x4", "domain": [ 0.10030864197530857, 0.5101766793039758 ], "gridcolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.100)", "gridwidth": 0.5, "linecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "mirror": false, "range": [ -0.05, 1.25 ], "showgrid": true, "showline": true, "showticklabels": true, "tickangle": 0, "tickcolor": "rgb(0, 0, 0)", "tickfont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "tickmode": "array", "ticks": "inside", "ticktext": [ "0.0", "0.2", "0.4", "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "1.2" ], "tickvals": [ 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6000000000000001, 0.8, 1, 1.2000000000000002 ], "title": "Activated fraction", "titlefont": { "color": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)", "family": "Nimbus Sans L", "size": 17 }, "type": "-", "visible": true, "zeroline": false, "zerolinecolor": "rgba(0, 0, 0, 1.000)" } } }, "image/svg+xml": [ "406080100120050100150200406080100120024684060801001200.00.20.40.60.81.01.24060801001200.00.20.40.60.81.01.2𝕣ᶜⁿ𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ𝕟ᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿEq. (12)𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿEq. (11)Apparent +1 Mobility Diameter (nm)Mobility Diameter (nm)Concentration (cm⁻³)dN/dlnD × 10⁻³ (cm⁻³)Activated fractionActivated fraction" ] }, "execution_count": 8, "metadata": {}, "output_type": "execute_result" } ], "source": [ "figure(\"Nimbus Sans L\", 2, 5.5, 3, 8)\n", "pre = 1e-3\n", "\n", "p1 = plot(δ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], ylabel = \"Concentration (cm⁻³)\", \n", " label = \"𝕣ᶜⁿ\", color = :black, lt = :steppre)\n", "p1 = plot!(δ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N, label = \"𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ\", color = RGBA(163/255,0,0,1), lt = :steppre,\n", " left_margin = 40px)\n", "\n", "p2 = plot(𝕟ᶜⁿ.Dp, pre.*𝕟ᶜⁿ.S, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], \n", " ylabel = \"dN/dlnD × 10⁻³ (cm⁻³)\", label = \"𝕟ᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)\", color = :black, \n", " ls = :dashdot, lt = :steppre)\n", "p2 = plot!(𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ.Dp, pre.*𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ.S, label = \"𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ (Eq. 10)\", color = RGBA(163/255,0,0,1), \n", " ls = :dashdot, lt = :steppre, left_margin = 52px)\n", "\n", "p3 = scatter(δ.Dp, 𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ.N./𝕣ᶜⁿ.N, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100], \n", " xlabel = \"Apparent +1 Mobility Diameter (nm)\", ms = 3, \n", " ylabel = \"Activated fraction\", ylim = (-0.05,1.25), label = \"𝕣ᶜᶜⁿ./𝕣ᶜⁿ\", markercolor = :darkorange,\n", " left_margin = 30px)\n", "\n", "p3 = plot!(δ.Dp, model(δ.Dp, Ax), label = \"Eq. (12)\", color = :black , lw = 2)\n", "\n", "p4 = scatter(𝕒𝕗₁.Dp, 𝕒𝕗₁.N, xaxis = :log10, xticks = [10, 100, 1000], ms = 3,\n", " xlabel = \"Mobility Diameter (nm)\", ylabel = \"Activated fraction\", label = \"𝕟ᶜᶜⁿ/𝕟ᶜⁿ\", \n", " markercolor = :white, ylim = (-0.05,1.25), left_margin = 25px)\n", "\n", "p4 = plot!(δ.Dp, Taf(δ.Dp,Ax[1],Ax[2]), label = \"Eq. (11)\", color = :black, lw = 2, ls = :dashdot)\n", "\n", "plot(p1,p2,p3,p4, layout = grid(2,2), bottom_margin = 10px, xlim =(30,130), \n", " legend = :topright, lw = 2, right_margin = 20px, fmt = :svg)" ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ " Figure 3. Top left: Synthetic noisy response functions for CN and CCN instruments. Note that the CCN response function is more noisy due to the smaller sample flow rate. Top right: inverted CN and CCN size distribution. Bottom left: circles are the ratio of CCN and CN response functions from the synthetic data. The solid line corresponds to the model with the parameters returned from the least-square fit. Bottom right: circles are the ratio of CCN and CN concentration from the regualurized inverse of the response function. The line corresponds the activation model using the parameters returned from the least-square fit. Note that for D > ~200 nm the activated fraction is set to unity and for D < ~35 nm is set to zero by threholding applied. Further note that the inversion removes the shoulder to the left of the true activation diameter, as is expected. Finally, note that the activated fraction is more noisy in the bottom right plot relative to the bottom left plot. " ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "## Summary and Conclusions\n", "Figure 3 demonstrates how the convolution matrix and size distribution arithmetic can be applied straightforwardly to fit response curves to correctly invert noisy data. The synthetic example can also be used to evaluate the effect of counting uncertainty on the resulting spectra. The noise in the activated fraction is determined by the number of counts in both instruments. Counting statistics are affected by scan rate, bin size, aerosol number concentration, and shape of the size distribution. The testbed can be used to optimize instrument configuration for expected experimental conditions." ] }, { "cell_type": "markdown", "metadata": {}, "source": [ "## References\n", "\n", "Cruz, C. N. and S. N. Pandis (1997). A study of the ability of pure secondary organic aerosol to act as cloud condensation nuclei. Atmospheric Environment 31, 2205–2214, DOI:10.1016/S1352-2310(97)00054-X.\n", "\n", "Petters, M. D., A. J. Prenni, S. M. Kreidenweis, P. J. DeMott (2007) On measuring the critical diameter of cloud condensation nuclei using mobility selected aerosol, Aerosol Science & Technology, 41(10), 907-913, doi:10.1080/02786820701557214.\n", "\n", "Petters, M. D., C. M. Carrico, S. M. Kreidenweis, A. J. Prenni, P. J. DeMott, J. R. Collett Jr., and H. Moosmüller (2009) Cloud condensation nucleation ability of biomass burning aerosol, Journal Geophysical Research, 114, D22205, doi:10.1029/2009JD012353.\n", "\n", "Snider, J. R., M. D. Petters, P. Wechsler, and P. S. K. Liu, (2006), Supersaturation in the Wyoming CCN instrument, Journal Atmospheric Oceanic Technology, 23, 1323-1339, doi:10.1175/JTECH1916.1. " ] } ], "metadata": { "kernelspec": { "display_name": "Julia 1.1.0", "language": "julia", "name": "julia-1.1" }, "language_info": { "file_extension": ".jl", "mimetype": "application/julia", "name": "julia", "version": "1.1.0" } }, "nbformat": 4, "nbformat_minor": 2 }