{ "base_difficulty": { "0/32": { "both_solved": 3, "c1_only": 1, "c3_only": 2, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.3148477656683637, "statistic": 194.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.030456852791878174, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.02030456852791878, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.3148477656683637, "statistic": 194.5 }, "n": 197, "neither_solved": 191 }, "1-4/32": { "both_solved": 15, "c1_only": 2, "c3_only": 3, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.3399249687213477, "statistic": 79.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -1.25, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.65, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.1471677513729934, "statistic": 63.5 }, "n": 20, "neither_solved": 0 }, "17-31/32": { "both_solved": 194, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 2.916821984771795e-08, "statistic": 4419.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.788659793814433, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 2.3092783505154637, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.2850706847732297e-14, "statistic": 3398.0 }, "n": 194, "neither_solved": 0 }, "32/32": { "both_solved": 18, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.08679380755074477, "statistic": 26.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.6666666666666666, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.3888888888888889, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.7262257625654784, "statistic": 74.5 }, "n": 18, "neither_solved": 0 }, "5-16/32": { "both_solved": 38, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.000166609925925676, "statistic": 106.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -3.4473684210526314, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.23684210526315788, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.4692211560417394, "statistic": 318.0 }, "n": 38, "neither_solved": 0 } }, "base_difficulty_discordant_heterogeneity": { "categories": [ "0/32", "1-4/32" ], "chi2": 0.03555555555555555, "note": "asymptotic; exploratory where expected cells are small", "p": 0.8504362683123465 }, "datasets": { "minif2f_test": { "both_solved": 116, "c1_only": 3, "c1_only_details": [ { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 1, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "integer", "family": "numbertheory", "name": "numbertheory_notequiv2i2jasqbsqdiv8" }, { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 1, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "real", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_215" }, { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 6, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "complex", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_313" } ], "c3_only": 3, "c3_only_details": [ { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 1, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "real+natural", "family": "amc", "name": "amc12b_2021_p4" }, { "c0_correct": 2, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 2, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "integer", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_170" }, { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 3, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "natural", "family": "mathd_numbertheory", "name": "mathd_numbertheory_234" } ], "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.0064105473055595125, "statistic": 7175.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.4262295081967213, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.9713114754098361, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 2.9959045826481124e-08, "statistic": 4950.5 }, "n": 244, "neither_solved": 122 }, "registered_valid": { "both_solved": 152, "c1_only": 0, "c1_only_details": [], "c3_only": 2, "c3_only_details": [ { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 1, "dataset": "registered_valid", "domain": "real", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_493" }, { "c0_correct": 2, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 3, "dataset": "registered_valid", "domain": "real", "family": "amc", "name": "amc12a_2003_p25" } ], "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 6.558425355433659e-11, "statistic": 3130.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 0.5, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.9461883408071748, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.094170403587444, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 6.544109987082883e-08, "statistic": 5712.0 }, "n": 223, "neither_solved": 69 } }, "families": { "aime": { "both_solved": 6, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.2984131561787374, "statistic": 23.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.7307692307692307, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.38461538461538464, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.04568023356646867, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 26, "neither_solved": 20 }, "algebra": { "both_solved": 21, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.8123573426016422, "statistic": 197.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.08571428571428572, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.5142857142857142, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.22149668365083475, "statistic": 190.5 }, "n": 35, "neither_solved": 14 }, "amc": { "both_solved": 28, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 2, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.16883458083428615, "statistic": 570.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 0.5, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.39285714285714285, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.5952380952380952, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.0035128207192632707, "statistic": 417.0 }, "n": 84, "neither_solved": 54 }, "imo": { "both_solved": 4, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.045586666699166146, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.5897435897435898, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.2564102564102564, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.08333569871414671, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 39, "neither_solved": 35 }, "induction": { "both_solved": 9, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.005517352205783725, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -2.533333333333333, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 2.8, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.005432036468973082, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 15, "neither_solved": 6 }, "mathd_algebra": { "both_solved": 104, "c1_only": 2, "c3_only": 2, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.000360542513549099, "statistic": 2131.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.7164179104477612, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.2462686567164178, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.624545782081655e-05, "statistic": 2270.5 }, "n": 134, "neither_solved": 26 }, "mathd_numbertheory": { "both_solved": 91, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 1, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 4.6554146091483334e-05, "statistic": 1464.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.8695652173913043, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.4869565217391305, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 2.667523848253906e-06, "statistic": 1466.0 }, "n": 115, "neither_solved": 23 }, "numbertheory": { "both_solved": 5, "c1_only": 1, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.04616783818364573, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.6, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.8666666666666667, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.5158302762686726, "statistic": 23.0 }, "n": 15, "neither_solved": 9 }, "other": { "both_solved": 0, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 4, "neither_solved": 4 } }, "families_discordant_heterogeneity": { "categories": [ "amc", "mathd_algebra", "mathd_numbertheory", "numbertheory" ], "chi2": 3.7333333333333334, "note": "asymptotic; exploratory where expected cells are small", "p": 0.29173639254975553 }, "numeric_domains": { "complex": { "both_solved": 12, "c1_only": 1, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.14797298840460651, "statistic": 28.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.7222222222222222, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.8888888888888888, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.6747859937730194, "statistic": 68.5 }, "n": 18, "neither_solved": 5 }, "complex+integer": { "both_solved": 0, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 1, "neither_solved": 1 }, "complex+real": { "both_solved": 0, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 1, "neither_solved": 1 }, "integer": { "both_solved": 12, "c1_only": 1, "c3_only": 1, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.06514212911102778, "statistic": 38.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.8260869565217391, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.3478260869565217, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.015100220860978746, "statistic": 30.0 }, "n": 23, "neither_solved": 9 }, "integer+natural": { "both_solved": 6, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.08999090925403289, "statistic": 9.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -1.3846153846153846, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.3076923076923077, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.1579763800330063, "statistic": 10.0 }, "n": 13, "neither_solved": 7 }, "natural": { "both_solved": 59, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 1, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 6.482967133523949e-05, "statistic": 1131.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.9291338582677166, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.9212598425196851, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 2.5537011708122156e-05, "statistic": 1141.0 }, "n": 127, "neither_solved": 67 }, "other": { "both_solved": 57, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.007683428479082693, "statistic": 576.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.6029411764705882, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.4264705882352942, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.0005026286791012152, "statistic": 548.5 }, "n": 68, "neither_solved": 11 }, "real": { "both_solved": 114, "c1_only": 1, "c3_only": 2, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.0011095473017876318, "statistic": 3382.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.4883720930232558, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.2965116279069768, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 5.00381049187644e-07, "statistic": 3229.5 }, "n": 172, "neither_solved": 55 }, "real+integer": { "both_solved": 2, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.31731050786291415, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.16666666666666666, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.3333333333333333, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.31731050786291415, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 6, "neither_solved": 4 }, "real+integer+natural": { "both_solved": 0, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 0, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.0, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 1.0, "statistic": 0.0 }, "n": 2, "neither_solved": 2 }, "real+natural": { "both_solved": 6, "c1_only": 0, "c3_only": 1, "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.21268251829406037, "statistic": 61.0 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 1.0, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.6388888888888888, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 0.2777777777777778, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 0.11084150979566823, "statistic": 35.0 }, "n": 36, "neither_solved": 29 } }, "numeric_domains_discordant_heterogeneity": { "categories": [ "complex", "integer", "natural", "real", "real+natural" ], "chi2": 3.022222222222222, "note": "asymptotic; exploratory where expected cells are small", "p": 0.5541134763965901 }, "overall": { "both_solved": 268, "c1_only": 3, "c1_only_details": [ { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 1, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "integer", "family": "numbertheory", "name": "numbertheory_notequiv2i2jasqbsqdiv8" }, { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 1, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "real", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_215" }, { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 6, "c3_correct": 0, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "complex", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_313" } ], "c3_only": 5, "c3_only_details": [ { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 1, "dataset": "registered_valid", "domain": "real", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_493" }, { "c0_correct": 2, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 3, "dataset": "registered_valid", "domain": "real", "family": "amc", "name": "amc12a_2003_p25" }, { "c0_correct": 1, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 1, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "real+natural", "family": "amc", "name": "amc12b_2021_p4" }, { "c0_correct": 2, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 2, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "integer", "family": "mathd_algebra", "name": "mathd_algebra_170" }, { "c0_correct": 0, "c1_correct": 0, "c3_correct": 3, "dataset": "minif2f_test", "domain": "natural", "family": "mathd_numbertheory", "name": "mathd_numbertheory_234" } ], "correct_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 8.579240250439364e-11, "statistic": 20358.5 }, "mcnemar_exact_p": 0.7265625, "mean_correct_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": -0.6745182012847966, "mean_mode_count_delta_c3_minus_c1": 1.0299785867237687, "mode_count_wilcoxon": { "p": 7.94050299945234e-15, "statistic": 21604.5 }, "n": 467, "neither_solved": 191 } }