{ "queries": 300, "corpus": 5183, "methods": { "search": { "hit5": { "mean": 0.8466666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.8033333333333333, 0.8866666666666667 ] }, "ndcg5": { "mean": 0.7354595147832406, "ci95": [ 0.6923827357581637, 0.7757347791939254 ] }, "recall5": { "mean": 0.8334444444444444, "ci95": [ 0.7916083333333334, 0.8733333333333333 ] }, "mrr5": { "mean": 0.7117222222222221, "ci95": [ 0.6651666666666667, 0.7556125 ] } }, "bge": { "hit5": { "mean": 0.8166666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.7733333333333333, 0.86 ] }, "ndcg5": { "mean": 0.7286710381723919, "ci95": [ 0.6843907144728544, 0.7716672352368392 ] }, "recall5": { "mean": 0.8019444444444443, "ci95": [ 0.756775, 0.8447791666666666 ] }, "mrr5": { "mean": 0.7107222222222223, "ci95": [ 0.6636666666666666, 0.7554458333333334 ] }, "latency": { "median_seconds": 0.15375117800431326, "p95_seconds": 0.165911595968646, "total_seconds": 46.23716147628147 } }, "noul": { "hit5": { "mean": 0.8733333333333333, "ci95": [ 0.8333333333333334, 0.91 ] }, "ndcg5": { "mean": 0.7858938343589951, "ci95": [ 0.7450718088290401, 0.8242338591540701 ] }, "recall5": { "mean": 0.8627222222222224, "ci95": [ 0.8233333333333334, 0.8996666666666666 ] }, "mrr5": { "mean": 0.7656111111111111, "ci95": [ 0.7222208333333333, 0.8064458333333333 ] }, "latency": { "median_seconds": 3.30676821351517, "p95_seconds": 3.8272787401074315, "total_seconds": 999.5904360541608, "uncached_queries": 300 } }, "span_noul": { "hit5": { "mean": 0.8566666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.8166666666666667, 0.8933333333333333 ] }, "ndcg5": { "mean": 0.7424108844614891, "ci95": [ 0.7003304187276058, 0.7826866031253356 ] }, "recall5": { "mean": 0.8397222222222221, "ci95": [ 0.7977777777777777, 0.8783333333333333 ] }, "mrr5": { "mean": 0.7181111111111111, "ci95": [ 0.6726666666666667, 0.7607236111111111 ] }, "latency": { "median_seconds": 3.648189618019387, "p95_seconds": 7.037027447586294, "total_seconds": 1234.8959365497867, "uncached_queries": 299 } }, "liquid_noul": { "hit5": { "mean": 0.8733333333333333, "ci95": [ 0.8333333333333334, 0.91 ] }, "ndcg5": { "mean": 0.7866853513322697, "ci95": [ 0.746395721965559, 0.8253056435761149 ] }, "recall5": { "mean": 0.8667222222222222, "ci95": [ 0.8271652777777777, 0.903111111111111 ] }, "mrr5": { "mean": 0.7631111111111111, "ci95": [ 0.7191111111111111, 0.8043347222222221 ] }, "latency": { "median_seconds": 3.873437517991988, "p95_seconds": 5.131768966600065, "total_seconds": 1220.3547977076669, "uncached_queries": 299 } } }, "paired_differences": { "bge-search": { "ndcg5_mean": -0.006788476610848706, "ci95": [ -0.03598557095052707, 0.021731334667334876 ], "wins": 51, "ties": 205, "losses": 44 }, "noul-search": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.050434319575754644, "ci95": [ 0.020671139279733616, 0.080424917096399 ], "wins": 64, "ties": 204, "losses": 32 }, "span_noul-search": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.0069513696782485465, "ci95": [ -0.024642124296899652, 0.03923170928860712 ], "wins": 58, "ties": 198, "losses": 44 }, "liquid_noul-search": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.05122583654902915, "ci95": [ 0.020682850206021675, 0.08246608471139764 ], "wins": 65, "ties": 202, "losses": 33 }, "noul-bge": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.05722279618660335, "ci95": [ 0.027650918279121278, 0.08699017087381551 ], "wins": 61, "ties": 212, "losses": 27 }, "span_noul-bge": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.01373984628909725, "ci95": [ -0.015584535284558982, 0.043588549083423626 ], "wins": 52, "ties": 206, "losses": 42 }, "liquid_noul-bge": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.058014313159877866, "ci95": [ 0.026868546490646246, 0.08841689381351399 ], "wins": 68, "ties": 203, "losses": 29 }, "span_noul-noul": { "ndcg5_mean": -0.04348294989750609, "ci95": [ -0.0634454464159435, -0.0243625341692531 ], "wins": 17, "ties": 229, "losses": 54 }, "liquid_noul-noul": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.0007915169732745146, "ci95": [ -0.014296514483095333, 0.015815691337599302 ], "wins": 25, "ties": 250, "losses": 25 }, "liquid_noul-span_noul": { "ndcg5_mean": 0.04427446687078061, "ci95": [ 0.024506789549654462, 0.0655717747663972 ], "wins": 55, "ties": 227, "losses": 18 } }, "candidate_recall20": 0.925, "candidate_hit20": 0.9266666666666666, "score_diagnostics": { "bge": { "queries_with_any_ties": 165, "queries_with_tied_top_score": 1, "mean_unique_scores_out_of_20": 19.2 }, "noul": { "queries_with_any_ties": 300, "queries_with_tied_top_score": 13, "mean_unique_scores_out_of_20": 9.703333333333333 }, "span_noul": { "queries_with_any_ties": 0, "queries_with_tied_top_score": 0, "mean_unique_scores_out_of_20": 20.0 }, "liquid_noul": { "queries_with_any_ties": 12, "queries_with_tied_top_score": 2, "mean_unique_scores_out_of_20": 19.946666666666665 } }, "noul": { "completed_queries": 300, "calls": 6000, "models": [ "typesafe/jev-1.13-20260917" ], "reported_cost_usd": 0.182449386 }, "span_noul": { "completed_queries": 300, "calls": 6000, "models": [ "respan/span-02-20261015" ], "reported_cost_usd": 0.02927134 }, "liquid_noul": { "completed_queries": 300, "calls": 6000, "models": [ "liquid/d1-ultra-20261015" ], "reported_cost_usd": 0.110930904 }, "top1_hits": { "search": 189, "bge": 191, "noul": 211, "span_noul": 190, "liquid_noul": 209 }, "api_cost_total": 0.32265162999999997, "embedding": { "load_seconds": 0.1600018210010603, "documents": { "seconds": 1662.356543758011, "batch_seconds": [ 1.7338815939729102, 1.272653613006696, 1.129450655018445, 1.2669724529841915, 0.8425601240014657, 1.1460144640295766, 1.2662071640370414, 1.1320833250065334, 1.4915826969663613, 1.2804531800211407, 1.2377863129950128, 1.4319116650149226, 0.8661133809946477, 1.299806728027761, 1.4127186599653214, 1.3931466299691238, 1.4333029270055704, 1.589824328024406, 1.378074268985074, 1.2655430790036917, 1.351368798990734, 1.4213959620101377, 1.2214032470365055, 1.3208643720136024, 1.2172138940077275, 1.0742387240170501, 1.4734987660194747, 1.3246844609966502, 1.4171159039833583, 1.3367645520484075, 1.2715392119716853, 1.5422650800319389, 1.5361911739455536, 1.3469379419693723, 1.4819923579925671, 1.3238463799934834, 1.414442097011488, 1.0399367309873924, 1.2981561940396205, 1.1627014189725742, 1.1421250840066932, 1.2002319649909623, 1.3003952910075895, 0.9259748610202223, 1.2733469249797054, 1.6376378280110657, 1.2633831650018692, 1.270443568995688, 0.9450457390048541, 1.6273764480138198, 1.6173391150077805, 1.3689154040184803, 1.13373674597824, 1.3814109049853869, 0.987956408993341, 1.2127390559762716, 1.3522075960063376, 1.2783900589565746, 1.14603501802776, 1.255265828978736, 1.2838072860031389, 1.3426361770252697, 1.1038817149819806, 1.3386064909864217, 1.2408061369787902, 1.2147394710336812, 1.2086377590312622, 1.3892401150078513, 1.1689550030278042, 1.3249426080146804, 1.228773929993622, 1.24423275195295, 1.4561990259680897, 0.8749485749867745, 1.4010787730221637, 0.8956643690471537, 1.1686003899667412, 1.126453825039789, 0.9716467140242457, 1.4807869180222042, 1.3196974910097197, 1.1023568219970912, 1.664237584976945, 1.2470805670018308, 1.3254161680233665, 1.256247347977478, 1.1677043300005607, 0.9729032189934514, 0.6937805699999444, 1.4170841129962355, 1.318385505990591, 1.2373679640004411, 1.2793888049782254, 1.4536427049897611, 1.3397560800076462, 1.26368995802477, 1.1563233570195735, 1.33827247004956, 1.0009206770337187, 1.6290660899830982, 1.3830884660128504, 0.8993346730130725, 1.7794131489936262, 1.5466256720246747, 1.5017898160149343, 0.9570593790267594, 1.5171866589807905, 1.3404223010293208, 1.3221647670143284, 1.223525581008289, 1.2052239180193283, 1.391881513001863, 0.9152580529917032, 1.0210196319967508, 1.2185638680239208, 1.3875561270397156, 1.0718443249934353, 1.0863663690397516, 1.16024070099229, 1.2471866039559245, 1.120230801985599, 0.6933462710003369, 1.2206014479743317, 1.1696291040279903, 1.1432362389750779, 0.8756972820265219, 1.0869506670278497, 1.2251512630027719, 1.2564106300123967, 1.0824500499875285, 1.213055398024153, 1.1606831820099615, 1.078746034996584, 1.3231353480368853, 1.1506213870015927, 0.8681332679698244, 1.2458825809881091, 1.2193070540088229, 1.2053265679860488, 1.2080084339831956, 0.8379567540250719, 1.3217981409979984, 1.281263843004126, 1.044574111001566, 1.2581277320277877, 1.4006395310279913, 1.164646224991884, 1.2412056069588289, 1.3770376369939186, 1.4907235950231552, 0.8671620229724795, 1.401864777028095, 0.9399532090174034, 1.4491804050048813, 1.3610073600430042, 1.2004761549760588, 1.2675950389821082, 1.3950880320044234, 1.3918549179797992, 1.1561995599768125, 1.4094106039847247, 1.4024163389694877, 1.4550648150034249, 1.1310772570432164, 1.0983005259768106, 1.3837269800133072, 1.2034539430169389, 1.1363536060089245, 1.3918709880090319, 1.5149500080151483, 1.496386591985356, 1.0547195309773088, 1.1737216589972377, 1.4296137660276145, 1.4507903269841336, 1.6298796740011312, 1.2513447570381686, 1.5157852430129424, 1.1361808709916659, 1.186555958003737, 1.1798466609907337, 1.0608460860094056, 1.22554900101386, 0.7974027679883875, 1.0596679159789346, 1.4338379860273562, 1.072732187982183, 1.1323768869624473, 1.2467794920084998, 1.1631626739981584, 1.1344349500141107, 1.1126518090022728, 1.0717110609984957, 1.159317959973123, 1.0497924630180933, 1.3736702610040084, 1.2691556549980305, 1.2201975850039162, 1.527685373032, 1.1920958069968037, 1.1557674399809912, 1.131159306038171, 1.1952914300491102, 1.1080860960064456, 1.3550230620312504, 1.0801625630119815, 1.0847089280141518, 1.1030089569976553, 1.0793446080060676, 1.1885730770300142, 1.117174785991665, 1.085019543999806, 1.40453008498298, 1.3360452449996956, 1.2751790839829482, 1.2498169239843264, 1.2069955449551344, 1.075635427958332, 1.2917306790477596, 1.073301268974319, 1.227144500007853, 1.2765522439731285, 1.2236217639874667, 1.213574711990077, 1.274165434006136, 1.1760664720204659, 1.2287037079804577, 1.2709578340291046, 1.200622590025887, 1.2087391670211218, 1.4053969340166077, 1.345012322999537, 1.3908623099559918, 1.2907830289914273, 1.3368872769642621, 1.178303330030758, 0.99351201497484, 1.1282002679654397, 1.258104421023745, 1.2193858489627019, 0.9601331560406834, 1.040837120031938, 1.3318618870107457, 1.205182773002889, 1.2800622759968974, 1.3374585589626804, 0.9599190399749205, 1.6988274090108462, 1.0490034089889377, 1.3685962479794398, 1.4303371799760498, 1.112583859008737, 1.1989383089821786, 1.1602899819845334, 1.0864390089991502, 1.2639868700061925, 1.1179306620033458, 1.3470505290315486, 0.8767566690221429, 1.4244716429966502, 1.285956133971922, 1.0570696400245652, 1.3836149880080484, 1.268414762977045, 1.3981629849877208, 1.3408947889693081, 1.3133015939965844, 1.358673817012459, 1.2236071130027995, 1.3541267240070738, 1.4775914270430803, 1.3766242869896814, 1.185808633978013, 1.1500096800155006, 1.1504599939798936, 0.8839927850058302, 1.2521312999888323, 1.1947510719764978, 1.2736977320164442, 0.7483153840294108, 1.1601035179919563, 1.2631019850377925, 1.454504270979669, 1.0895619899965823, 1.2325749089941382, 1.2822188109857962, 1.1525805040146224, 1.3054131409735419, 1.2574860089807771, 1.1237646090448834, 1.2639796059811488, 1.2912384669762105, 1.094423713046126, 1.2494504710193723, 1.1836771719972603, 1.1827515799668618, 1.3821416310383938, 1.135849687969312, 1.1622004469973035, 1.3864865400246345, 0.8048994740238413, 1.1574553109821863, 1.1217191600007936, 1.3641252829693258, 1.237793962995056, 1.114303098001983, 1.2270897869602777, 1.188050914031919, 1.5527797239483334, 1.2967548370361328, 1.4918940720381215, 1.1154781460063532, 1.3789137579733506, 1.056088479992468, 1.3540004119859077, 1.0407073039677925, 1.25715590902837, 1.4977974919602275, 1.2910101459710859, 1.2253149999887682, 1.3459973929566331, 1.33032336801989, 1.3571146230096929, 0.9786238690139726, 1.3179996649851091, 1.325552606023848, 1.1585883049992844, 1.136409165977966, 1.3728714759927243, 1.204183205962181, 0.8710565700312145, 0.8472913430305198, 1.314789202006068, 0.9825235370080918, 1.0907017790013924, 1.4189291530055925, 0.9886804560082965, 1.239260632020887, 1.0985187019687146, 1.06706671603024, 1.1799533580197021, 1.3522987060132436, 1.3535899360431358, 1.4144712500274181, 1.2153240450425074, 1.300593429012224, 1.392037535959389, 1.42226079601096, 1.2797848979826085, 1.0827408200129867, 1.1662562420242466, 1.1550526999635622, 1.2380854219663888, 1.0499002250144258, 1.2824110920191742, 1.4147756759775802, 1.110862075991463, 1.263680602016393, 1.1456640340038575, 1.2638536149752326, 1.311646001006011, 1.27276893297676, 1.1094015800044872, 1.034079479984939, 1.1780949690146372, 1.3934541849885136, 1.1001469809561968, 1.2237251329934224, 1.0252307649934664, 1.3912912359810434, 1.3126094890176319, 1.1558624080498703, 1.282606762018986, 1.42197948199464, 1.2550377569859847, 1.1697135749855079, 0.9943569470196962, 1.1835285570123233, 1.1680071559967473, 1.0857781930244528, 1.0102466139942408, 1.2876102759619243, 1.327123433991801, 1.3766492729773745, 1.1226768179913051, 1.3932801490300335, 1.2665587030351162, 1.1340734010445885, 0.8813150229980238, 1.2317596720531583, 1.0825051059946418, 1.305061973980628, 1.2891730020055547, 1.617314969014842, 1.0397907510050572, 1.0486344270175323, 1.0069198099663481, 1.2855965389753692, 1.4873652649694122, 1.2115714169922285, 1.5101031659869477, 1.4426608569920063, 1.1467915049870498, 1.380118808010593, 1.5371626520063728, 1.2080158989992924, 1.429197204997763, 1.0810242560110055, 1.4215732370503247, 1.6970517730223946, 1.4791907439939678, 1.1692489340202883, 1.4428951580193825, 1.4987954649841413, 1.3506194389774464, 1.4827982760034502, 1.4850442310562357, 1.1847030380158685, 1.4811911980505101, 1.2093762399745174, 1.0465818890370429, 1.1239559979876503, 0.7200739710242487, 1.6463877719943412, 1.5786762349889614, 1.1947966570151038, 1.6002658230136149, 1.5923954779864289, 0.7137958499952219, 1.088738218008075, 1.1356851950404234, 1.5213679739972576, 1.1050140730221756, 0.9340156549587846, 1.4684828899917193, 1.4134402089985088, 1.4085870180279016, 1.169312268961221, 1.2149710259982385, 1.500350009999238, 1.3456006240448914, 1.3544966760091484, 1.1196639640256763, 1.3681361969793215, 1.5492873269831762, 1.273827989003621, 1.1382371520157903, 0.7518657350447029, 1.0276109949918464, 1.541696641012095, 1.6155695489724167, 1.2376138410181738, 1.273646928020753, 1.1861684290342964, 0.9707501800148748, 1.2923986040404998, 1.5112795570166782, 1.5001976789790206, 1.0805336459889077, 1.1391774519579485, 1.1822871239855886, 1.176891318988055, 1.4862187840044498, 1.4723612859961577, 1.5647503339569084, 1.080312009959016, 1.2738805279950611, 0.8720765130128711, 1.5987405229825526, 0.8789961729780771, 1.3491286559728906, 1.1802676030201837, 1.1933899559662677, 1.29901474196231, 1.232746950990986, 1.1257745740003884, 1.342434794001747, 1.5446880650124513, 1.0952118950081058, 1.2026481530047022, 1.565807762031909, 1.113534145988524, 1.142818592954427, 1.4196884660050273, 1.4364285750198178, 1.489480154006742, 1.404190818022471, 1.4167632210301235, 1.364168995001819, 1.1698989600408822, 1.1200977099942975, 1.1843803519732319, 1.4780597180360928, 1.5107525140047073, 1.3250404900172725, 0.9613810740411282, 1.514650459983386, 1.5834662260022014, 1.562367649981752, 1.3621134820277803, 1.2668086899793707, 1.185492463002447, 1.4143753930111416, 1.4692824460216798, 1.1799142599920742, 1.6122926770476624, 1.5871711280196905, 1.243444323015865, 1.0955706560052931, 1.2005039100185968, 1.3581209999974817, 1.5065891349804588, 1.4699169740197249, 1.6915330910123885, 1.1789257469936274, 1.5679815530311316, 1.6447483280207962, 1.4339078060002066, 1.00707232800778, 1.1148258039611392, 1.3273369169910438, 1.5288549580145627, 1.457662363012787, 1.643112341989763, 1.1508305929601192, 1.3387767880340107, 1.5026579520199448, 0.9451373839983717, 1.1277452299837023, 1.1375828820164315, 1.1319783640210517, 1.510328508040402, 1.3283842779928818, 1.430637774989009, 1.455284269002732, 1.530099206021987, 1.2648397790035233, 1.028342948993668, 1.3795209630043246, 1.5131306269904599, 1.4775947079760954, 1.0506901929620653, 1.600473344034981, 1.2649554490344599, 1.270480549952481, 1.6606168940197676, 1.0760675560450181, 1.4127982960199006, 1.3567874759901315, 1.3173130240174942, 1.18280330800917, 1.547428383026272, 1.471417636028491, 1.0634509400115348, 0.838844443031121, 1.5236031300155446, 1.1297741690068506, 1.160110029974021, 1.4350451469654217, 1.2948635959764943, 1.3150443829945289, 1.1193514179904014, 1.4391626490396447, 1.4534840559936129, 1.572374465991743, 1.3733393379952759, 0.7982262660516426, 1.5764337820000947, 1.4541564609971829, 1.4303179090493359, 1.2477511420147493, 1.760964321962092, 1.0978057219763286, 1.5552591580199078, 1.1259221290238202, 0.7219870570115745, 1.1669936800026335, 1.3260656940401532, 0.9771359769511037, 1.3025844580261037, 1.122128589951899, 1.199322376982309, 1.2300077729742043, 1.0960442090290599, 1.3075385259580798, 1.07570017199032, 1.079700973990839, 1.3091628840193152, 1.3559521600254811, 1.2328159229946323, 1.3695984169607982, 1.413366855995264, 1.1894013739656657, 1.2541194169898517, 1.2046677690232173, 1.0645649050129578, 1.2988829829846509, 1.3392980250064284, 1.4135581649607047, 1.2215513489791192, 0.960139756964054, 1.3023104379535653, 1.363087932986673, 1.1356934210052714, 1.298235961003229, 1.2488155979663134, 1.245869304984808, 1.205789293977432, 1.259226922004018, 1.382263308041729, 1.1214423610363156, 1.1718083880259655, 1.1666239089681767, 0.9924450460239314, 1.192351390956901, 1.4168765749782324, 1.2420060560107231, 1.1654854679945856, 1.1815629790071398, 1.3558368840022013, 1.1257358570001088, 1.2953421070124023, 1.2734559230157174, 1.0883750229841098, 1.176987744984217, 1.089738574984949, 1.443992929009255, 1.1803514779894613, 1.0558644600096159, 1.331806325004436, 1.2325875100214034, 1.3897360910195857, 1.1785599839640781, 1.176121378026437, 1.2675684519927017, 1.236401074042078, 1.188244085002225, 1.030993351014331, 1.1070413420093246, 0.9686441360390745, 1.2653663770179264, 1.4349237350397743, 0.7648206180310808, 1.139853305008728, 1.2636476449551992, 1.3076763399876654, 1.093304954993073, 1.31120745401131, 1.2094499659724534, 1.340485060994979, 1.2125044779968448, 1.5225606830208562, 0.9276602119789459, 1.5612252920400351, 0.893435503996443, 1.4352485159761272, 1.289137029030826, 0.8852256860118359, 1.1741989310248755, 1.310097270004917, 1.1434488960076123, 1.2576646790257655, 1.0346693629981019, 1.3792888940079138, 1.2220791020081379, 1.583691363048274, 1.5676101049757563, 1.363017889962066, 1.1618561660288833, 1.1202004580409266, 1.032792131009046, 1.3521515249740332, 1.3099484500125982, 1.7079393900348805, 1.457919389999006, 1.5271480359951966, 1.2051342580234632, 1.168747137999162, 1.1588416710146703, 1.417417922988534, 1.1711237579584122, 1.028317128017079, 1.5037819350254722, 1.5578347410191782, 1.6546352899749763, 1.1217491499846801, 1.0801012890296988, 1.3481733910157345, 1.5409317929879762, 1.5627672160044312, 1.3991293909493834, 1.21039062802447, 1.0530770730110817, 1.1103094939608127, 1.3921115929842927, 1.1832267600111663, 1.6311843750299886, 1.037622720003128, 1.6545466969837435, 0.7316918749711476, 1.4985169660067186, 1.2156478650285862, 1.1962388459942304, 1.3967818900127895, 1.5897929920465685, 1.6150388139649294, 1.232196055992972, 1.1351614409941249, 1.5935457150335424, 1.0156423779553734, 1.192085144983139, 1.131123382016085, 1.4390153660206124, 1.4778003619867377, 1.194222473015543, 1.1525817299843766, 1.3917666909983382, 1.1312691940111108, 1.6276294859708287, 1.3940281649702229, 1.3598901799996383, 1.154340979992412, 1.1997760910307989, 1.5845040929852985, 0.917862648027949, 1.567873172054533, 0.9627964990213513, 1.5399625590071082, 1.517301268002484, 1.5912097069667652, 1.4730228850385174, 1.4091177399968728, 1.4719254350056872, 1.4545576319796965, 1.1486251819878817, 1.2211065129959024, 1.1115960479946807, 1.4681313809705898, 1.1019399110227823, 1.614896925049834, 1.419101862993557, 1.4163388349697925, 1.474492768989876, 1.6101081640226766, 1.5239211409934796, 1.3731302749947645, 1.5695767090073787, 1.4294463639962487, 1.2371293189935386, 1.64527135505341, 1.363655554014258, 1.39684678503545, 1.27563916699728, 1.1793366589699872, 1.5726864809985273, 1.6290635240147822, 1.0895537169999443, 1.6146115600131452, 1.346157707972452, 1.1038038849947043, 1.2063559530070052, 1.3976087759947404, 0.9697242630063556, 1.2291840949910693, 1.0846258529927582, 1.4422789530362934, 1.3141800030134618, 1.067102432018146, 1.3450528199900873, 1.2344291420304216, 1.649711580015719, 1.1972914640209638, 1.6050976989790797, 1.5552185269771144, 1.6522565169725567, 1.4126066410099156, 1.2094338370370679, 1.6753596459748223, 1.2493022460257635, 1.5509166460251436, 1.4303492829785682, 1.4202845320105553, 1.4413285210030153, 1.240363079996314, 1.2108653120230883, 1.1132182080182247, 1.3569563619676046, 1.4079601960256696, 1.2415165599668398, 1.1879067869740538, 1.3478120429790579, 1.2410881269606762, 1.5504869099822827, 1.0493030460202135, 1.3713935549603775, 1.2101104400353506, 1.6959413940203376, 1.2818056069663726, 1.5828554879990406, 1.0935438239830546, 1.3430922140250914, 1.3750228479621, 1.385008301003836, 1.4882656119880266, 1.6627879310399294, 1.2997821809840389, 1.1844570520333946, 1.249007923004683, 1.5325666129938327, 0.8380553210154176, 1.370483408041764, 1.222017655032687, 1.6575189940049313, 1.2370103480061516, 1.1966205219505355, 1.2769760339870118, 1.563236546004191, 1.0614857499604113, 1.5299795520259067, 1.2771452540182509, 1.0066434770124033, 1.1884842080180533, 1.2022683140239678, 1.1693466029828414, 1.4128418519976549, 1.1114778089686297, 1.401234779972583, 1.1995562149677426, 1.536224826995749, 1.3864794099936262, 1.2555777840316296, 1.6748631530208513, 1.6160897070076317, 1.207716820994392, 1.0993215020280331, 1.3870302449795417, 1.3387693160329945, 1.1617394289933145, 1.2031733129988424, 1.635818762006238, 1.3905025179847144, 0.8085622329963371, 1.1182837970554829, 1.0935631380416453, 1.3618158170138486, 1.3680742669967003, 1.3945625420310535, 1.3719812930212356, 1.2402083860361017, 1.4115699279936962, 1.5037876310525462, 1.3785996019723825, 1.543997014989145, 1.5613700849935412, 1.366791300009936, 1.2667841810034588, 1.515403256053105, 1.426762082031928, 1.1536085730185732, 1.5246434250148013, 1.0176749259699136, 1.4511908919666894, 1.4588430580333807, 1.4300683959736489, 1.502609469986055, 1.205541046045255, 1.6107484580134042, 1.647826349013485, 1.414622729003895, 1.457940927008167, 1.5550696669961326, 1.3425953300320543, 1.3463960440130904, 1.2292884170310572, 1.629792127001565, 1.092295654991176, 1.287468985945452, 1.4208961799740791, 1.1028909689630382, 1.6783196189790033, 1.1299033890245482, 1.5769435960100964, 1.5306440580170602, 1.7173258000402711, 1.0923856160370633, 1.7259438020410016, 1.94042341504246, 1.5029061899986118, 1.3526820570114069, 1.1915677459910512, 1.665765302022919, 1.5126900330069475, 1.7119263079948723, 1.2826126249856316, 1.3944586970028467, 1.3282087849802338, 1.2994573100004345, 1.190128210990224, 1.4871401019627228, 1.5131358779617585, 1.0835934490314685, 1.3243363079964183, 1.148238023975864, 1.5846144740353338, 1.7058550990186632, 1.2886990769766271, 1.4480987319839187, 1.4803491409984417, 1.6172758010216057, 1.4198500670026988, 1.2388116330257617, 1.457392047974281, 1.0900066019967198, 1.769613623037003, 1.5975997599889524, 1.3146033550146967, 1.2932464240002446, 1.4036021659849212, 1.1610431059962139, 1.0951523359981366, 1.4619825850240886, 1.2498010629788041, 1.591311179974582, 1.2349614009726793, 1.165549621975515, 1.529821837961208, 1.3400501099531539, 1.4616265480290167, 1.4406955989543349, 1.3516762549988925, 1.6372140599996783, 1.6351194999879226, 1.567797772004269, 1.3453477040166035, 1.111785231041722, 1.5899485899717547, 1.102475481980946, 1.560816500976216, 1.223005365987774, 1.1508802970056422, 1.2218011500081047, 1.3883962610270828, 1.5617889949935488, 1.407510539982468, 1.4042903369991109, 1.3936930839554407, 1.1552358170156367, 1.2984895799891092, 1.4720711619593203, 1.2720291790319607, 1.3082035760162398, 1.2841297030099668, 1.4203112759860232, 1.3797702369629405, 1.38780870300252, 1.2042144930455834, 1.0599459609948099, 1.0944673290359788, 1.5507401489885524, 1.1399867190048099, 1.3882215859484859, 1.1334854860324413, 1.2054087489959784, 1.1918497640290298, 1.431136469997, 1.5048101189895533, 1.3120725670014508, 1.3245125570101663, 1.1631091109593399, 1.5675487429834902, 1.2939184320275672, 1.6280096140108071, 1.0041322560282424, 1.3429447329835966, 1.4122999969986267, 1.5644192399922758, 1.0729513979749754, 1.1516036220127717, 1.3936386199784465, 1.466781782975886, 1.0851383359986357, 1.4176249380107038, 1.1160421679960564, 1.09629394300282, 1.0372326449723914, 1.0785630049649626, 1.487591776996851, 1.3359921309747733, 1.157494498998858, 1.4212513189995661, 1.5616210350417532, 1.4841864409972914, 1.4843388660228811, 1.2234510449925438, 1.5855801530415192, 1.404576590983197, 1.526264916989021, 1.1906483890488744, 1.1426829400006682, 0.7364782150252722, 1.1812998710083775, 1.1797463900293224, 1.3626504779676907, 1.2097362650092691, 1.5647846439969726, 1.1007151420344599, 1.1518762380001135, 1.1127742670360021, 0.7236765609704889, 1.2090372300008312, 1.0402167809661478, 0.7682933610049076, 1.232092806021683, 0.9217396629974246, 1.1326768869766966, 1.6406075190170668, 1.408969515003264, 1.2076003330294043, 1.2185121839866042, 1.1540403559920378, 1.456167733995244, 1.384180266992189, 0.9353705940302461, 1.5462561429594643, 1.1242821880150586, 1.3809509529964998, 1.6500564980087802, 1.409538795996923, 1.4097223120043054, 1.368560250964947, 1.4446261269622482, 0.8519182889722288, 1.4588393790181726, 1.181160228967201, 0.8382402040297166, 1.43369580199942, 1.1343901960062794, 1.5186668369569816, 1.4101020900416188, 1.3567466809763573, 1.3545033750124276, 1.1641229150118306, 1.4319255909649655, 1.4675708030117676, 1.4426516739767976, 1.772596175025683, 1.5548445210442878, 1.2678724889992736, 1.5578613989637233, 1.3948281740304083, 1.270299914991483, 1.5120369360083714, 1.1807688779663295, 1.6201637369813398, 1.038411178975366, 1.6578389460337348, 1.2993249529972672, 0.9220205440069549, 1.481022299034521, 1.3551868560025468, 1.3465668080025353, 1.3966675610281527, 1.5648204099852592, 1.4291355700115673, 1.22038013295969, 1.4730034369858913, 1.4208789659896865, 1.329288394015748, 1.4030560110113584, 1.5621112529770471, 1.5566413319902495, 1.3414568779990077, 1.2354082869715057, 1.337812221958302, 1.1918795990059152, 1.3777874379884452, 1.4663774049840868, 1.4207405889756046, 1.1508577649947256, 1.2552149189868942, 1.0773539029760286, 1.2115341210155748, 1.77830281999195, 1.6962110190070234, 1.647378916037269, 1.1758757620118558, 1.1025580950081348, 1.3780837410013191, 1.2154188039712608, 1.245915655978024, 1.1986408059601672, 1.2107607129728422, 1.2695618019788526, 1.2952556919772178, 1.262609652010724, 1.4240918750292622, 1.2145361940492876, 1.1363811260089278, 1.1361161920358427, 1.3916498940088786, 1.4117194470018148, 1.5507816989556886, 1.309620090003591, 1.1931995790218934, 1.2405994730070233, 1.2011222320143133, 1.24769644101616, 1.025203766010236, 1.092207234003581, 1.6621575099998154, 1.5320673640235327, 1.264070922974497, 1.4712760950205848, 1.3106359270168468, 1.2707218740251847, 1.422884734987747, 1.35294429899659, 1.2632642989628948, 1.011381950986106, 1.22108838299755, 1.2033354160375893, 1.0397519679972902, 1.402110251947306, 1.6673075830331072, 1.3900039160507731, 1.452344699006062, 1.3786776250344701, 1.1640370780369267, 1.5782517609768547, 1.3405483629903756, 1.19248168397462, 1.1341813260223716, 1.191255691985134, 1.425424563989509, 1.493241508025676, 1.285886769008357, 1.3975958210066892, 1.4444378960179165, 0.9114606810035184, 1.2530330520239659, 1.2916427709860727, 1.2603360710199922, 1.2868762130383402, 1.1847399310208857, 1.3550933069782332, 1.2269970430061221, 1.054175072000362, 1.3319308889913373, 1.502097301010508, 1.1399777159676887, 1.349698781967163, 1.1176804559654556, 1.2781862430274487, 1.4030000119819306, 1.4327701369766146, 1.0845529119833373, 1.2664848559652455, 1.2147324630059302, 1.2098999180016108, 1.2335705550503917, 1.326526433986146, 1.089479350950569, 1.3127993160160258, 1.4769209339865483, 1.2915439700009301, 1.379629516042769, 1.2201683140010573, 1.3891059330198914, 1.1754854819737375, 1.3874774599680677, 1.1102031450136565, 1.1400538199814036, 1.3000422869808972, 1.1004296930041164, 1.0828447390231304, 1.141910790989641, 1.4028794009936973, 1.4320934930001386, 1.0318340150406584, 1.3341858459752984, 1.264963074005209, 1.2411404919694178, 1.1051340439589694, 1.2590974100166932, 1.0887894550105557, 1.2861220890190452, 1.4483734410023317, 1.3755724739748985, 1.2740201949491166, 1.4171548289596103, 1.3194600669667125, 1.4268993270234205, 1.148046937014442, 1.2462753559811972, 0.8791561729740351, 0.9392623559688218, 1.1843697259901091, 1.219869695021771, 1.3349246080033481, 1.4567535429960117, 1.2471809220151044, 0.8112377609941177, 1.3843755839625373, 1.2829717290005647, 1.1766253919922747, 0.8068122749682516, 1.4004723070538603, 1.5861975189764053, 1.2092298609786667, 1.1087849420146085, 1.1030823439941742, 1.4081530870171264, 1.2798301029833965, 0.9063527039834298, 1.3998240230139345, 1.3527627369621769, 1.1397113670245744, 1.2269405709812418, 1.4535570049774833, 1.2595958840101957, 1.2286974120070226, 1.38239489501575, 1.0640972420223989, 1.1472620770218782, 1.4416608850006014, 1.4144402879755944, 1.1579478179919533, 1.2503645130200312, 1.2081815209821798, 1.083318685006816, 1.4068033419898711, 1.4431555420160294, 1.403556761040818, 1.239894120953977, 1.2561703629908152, 1.1875205009710044, 1.1269583179964684, 1.058857159980107, 1.4262158389901742, 1.1172090169857256, 1.4437939210329205, 1.2417258020141162, 1.2855319960508496, 1.0860312400036491, 1.060368602978997, 0.6470284900278784, 1.421595598978456, 1.18844627100043, 1.342589418985881, 1.4299859579768963, 1.4062562190229073, 0.687237792997621, 1.1035864619771019, 1.3429600999807008, 1.0218375729746185, 1.2453565199975856, 1.4651122969808057, 1.2039308499661274, 1.1070243470021524, 1.1943636739742942, 1.1433576349518262, 1.3843753760447726, 0.7558483460452408, 1.2435549449874088, 1.2104152659885585, 1.2286939049954526, 1.115101298026275, 1.114164853002876, 1.1373742939904332, 1.3998810580233112, 1.092175589990802, 1.391261514974758, 1.4322336940094829, 1.491864476003684, 1.384875978983473, 0.8539535040035844, 0.963160687009804, 0.8318655140465125, 1.343175905989483, 1.1362140779965557, 1.2319443710148335, 0.9349572549690492, 1.081257599988021, 1.2013630300061777, 0.8483850779593922, 1.4263842409709468, 1.0239064309862442, 1.4985007549985312, 1.026515859994106, 0.7684878900181502, 0.7488915929570794, 0.627286286035087, 0.9527339600026608, 1.5775157010066323, 1.563161445024889, 1.0703850230202079 ] }, "queries": { "seconds": 8.119335422990844, "batch_seconds": [ 0.08559314697049558, 0.10875023895641789, 0.10844587703468278, 0.10548240400385112, 0.12079262203769758, 0.10798839497147128, 0.09480502700898796, 0.088469980051741, 0.13052032398991287, 0.11764265701640397, 0.12657835701247677, 0.11428384302416816, 0.09117760101798922, 0.10671235003974289, 0.11132646002806723, 0.13232374301878735, 0.12324725202051923, 0.09790757100563496, 0.11362719000317156, 0.07386650500120595, 0.13048588403034955, 0.12378914497094229, 0.11760133702773601, 0.08050455403281376, 0.13238128303783014, 0.11724867601878941, 0.09091264003654942, 0.11522980604786426, 0.10075396299362183, 0.08788670698413625, 0.08574566803872585, 0.07405704603297636, 0.12637180596357211, 0.11042654496850446, 0.14089310000417754, 0.10678662895224988, 0.0906800189986825, 0.11702885397244245, 0.09733499796129763, 0.10992882400751114, 0.1096320420037955, 0.10455763997742906, 0.12988975102780387, 0.09122417104663327, 0.11124652897706255, 0.12836389400763437, 0.1684626010246575, 0.08661391999339685, 0.08238790195900947, 0.12660291697829962, 0.09953060699626803, 0.11377946997527033, 0.13350878696655855, 0.10210911801550537, 0.12697358801960945, 0.08051182399503887, 0.14162317296722904, 0.08097680599894375, 0.09570078097749501, 0.0952411680482328, 0.08575624699005857, 0.1135218589915894, 0.1292750479769893, 0.10267822101013735, 0.09662947501055896, 0.12452141696121544, 0.12495601898990571, 0.09557305002817884, 0.08229269098956138, 0.09367561101680622, 0.1212071519694291, 0.08429791999515146, 0.09642061300110072, 0.11113030801061541, 0.09390648297267035 ] }, "search_seconds": 0.10133320500608534, "peak_rss_mib": 2077.71484375, "stage_wall_seconds_approx": 1673.82, "stage_wall_measurement": "Embedding log creation to final stats write, from filesystem timestamps; includes process startup, loading, document/query embedding and search." }, "bge_runtime": { "load_seconds": 0.8915864310110919, "peak_rss_mib": 4315.421875, "candidate_sha256": "03d8af4abfdc7c5dc0e12438ffc1eaeb6f4e055c54b2ddbbb06d48cbc519ec88", "device": "cuda", "gpu_name": "NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Ti", "peak_cuda_allocated_mib": 1155.669921875, "peak_cuda_reserved_mib": 1200.0, "stage_wall_seconds": 51.449888900038786, "torch_version": "2.13.0+cu130", "transformers_version": "5.16.1" }, "cpu_partial": { "status": "interrupted_by_user_to_switch_to_gpu", "completed_queries": 99, "completed_pairs": 1980, "completed_query_seconds": 446.4231961859041, "median_query_seconds": 4.522543830971699, "stopped_utc": "2026-10-12T08:14:12Z", "note": "Sum of completed query timings excludes load, warmup, checkpoint writes and the interrupted query. Exact CPU process wall elapsed was not instrumented.", "embedding_document_seconds": 1662.356543758011, "embedding_query_seconds": 8.119335422990844, "embedding_search_seconds": 0.10133320500608534, "elapsed_wall_seconds_approx": 454.144, "wall_time_measurement": "Log creation to final interrupt traceback write; includes process startup, load, warmup, completed queries, checkpoint writes and interrupted query. Approximate, from filesystem timestamps.", "candidate_sha256": "03d8af4abfdc7c5dc0e12438ffc1eaeb6f4e055c54b2ddbbb06d48cbc519ec88", "device": "cpu", "torch_version": "2.14.1+cpu", "transformers_version": "5.19.0", "python_version": "3.12.3", "full_300_query_seconds_estimate": 1352.7975641997093, "estimate_method": "Mean measured scoring time over 99 completed claims multiplied by 300. Assumes similar claim/passages workload; excludes model loading, warmup and checkpoint overhead." }, "cpu_full_run_estimate": { "queries": 300, "estimated_scoring_seconds": 1352.7975641997093, "measured_sample_queries": 99, "method": "Mean measured CPU query time multiplied by full query count; excludes setup and checkpoint overhead; assumes similar workload." }, "cpu_comparison": { "matched_queries": 99, "cpu_query_seconds": 446.4231961859041, "current_query_seconds": 15.277122299885377, "observed_time_ratio": 29.22168111393947, "same_top5_order_queries": 86, "current_minus_cpu_ndcg5": 0.0, "note": "Same candidates, BF16 and batch size; Python, Torch and Transformers versions differ. CPU run is partial, not a full 300-query result." }, "protocol": { "dataset": "BEIR SciFact test", "queries": 300, "corpus": 5183, "candidate_k": 20, "report_k": 5, "seed": 42, "threads": 6, "dtype": "bfloat16", "batch_size": 4, "document_token_cap_each_tokenizer": 400, "max_length": 512, "shared_trimming": true, "trimmed_documents": 2001, "prompt_tuned_on_test": false, "dataset_sha256": "509b858780259f9811bdd064af699d6ac781c479d112d16981c7fe226cba6947", "model_manifest_sha256": "afacff42474dde11094a5332e9e154f461c131fea06c579dfa5251cc342f235d", "cpu": "x86_64", "platform": "Linux-6.8.0-139-generic-x86_64-with-glibc2.39", "created_utc": "2026-10-12T07:37:43Z", "embedding_device": "cpu", "bge_device": "cuda", "amendment": "User requested stopping CPU BGE after 99 completed claims and restarting all 300 claims on GPU. CPU partial results and timings retained separately." }, "timing_note": "BGE local-device time versus remote API time including network. API concurrency 4; BGE batch size 4. Shared embedding and partly cached API queries excluded.", "api_timing_comparison": { "noul": { "call_median_seconds": 0.5852144889940973, "call_p95_seconds": 0.7319137562211836, "input_tokens": 4344033, "mean_input_tokens": 724.0055, "query_timing": { "median_seconds": 3.30676821351517, "p95_seconds": 3.8272787401074315, "total_seconds": 999.5904360541608, "uncached_queries": 300 } }, "span_noul": { "call_median_seconds": 0.6042799360002391, "call_p95_seconds": 1.7464174509950687, "input_tokens": 2927134, "mean_input_tokens": 487.85566666666665, "query_timing": { "median_seconds": 3.648189618019387, "p95_seconds": 7.037027447586294, "total_seconds": 1234.8959365497867, "uncached_queries": 299 } }, "liquid_noul": { "call_median_seconds": 0.7149257620039862, "call_p95_seconds": 0.9591134348404012, "input_tokens": 2641212, "mean_input_tokens": 440.202, "query_timing": { "median_seconds": 3.873437517991988, "p95_seconds": 5.131768966600065, "total_seconds": 1220.3547977076669, "uncached_queries": 299 } }, "note": "Same 4-call concurrency, saved passages, HTTP-session reuse and client code pattern; different run times and prompt lengths. Observed client wall time, not isolated model inference speed." } }