` + `<h1>` if not supplied). ## Process 1. **Validate target & preflight.** See `skills/seo-firecrawl/references/preflight.md` for the canonical 3-stage preflight (credit balance, Firecrawl availability, Google APIs). Skill-specific notes: - Confirm the URL is fetchable; derive parent domain. If the user supplied a primary keyword, use it; otherwise infer it in step 3. - Estimated SE Ranking cost for this skill: ~10–15 credits typical (URL overview, ranking keywords, page authority, SERP context for top 3–5 keywords). - Firecrawl: optional with WebFetch fallback, ~1 Firecrawl credit if available. When available, step 6 recovers `og:*`, `twitter:*`, canonical, robots meta, JSON-LD types, and hreflang count from raw `<head>` — WebFetch returns markdown only and strips those fields. Without Firecrawl, the affected lines in `PAGE.md` emit `(skipped — Firecrawl not installed)`. Pass `--no-firecrawl` to treat Firecrawl as unavailable even when installed (credit conservation). - Google APIs: tier 1 (GSC available) unlocks step 4b (GSC URL performance + URL Inspection) after the page-authority step. See `skills/seo-google/references/cross-skill-integration.md` § "seo-page" for the full recipe. 2. **URL-level overview** `DATA_getUrlOverviewWorldwide` - Pull keyword count, organic traffic estimate, paid keyword count, paid traffic estimate, top regions. - Note: traffic estimates are directional — they don't replace Google Search Console. 3. **Ranking keywords** `DATA_getDomainKeywords` (use the `url` param for exact match — not `filter_url`) - Pull every keyword the URL ranks for in the target country, with positions. - Sort by traffic-weighted score: `volume × CTR-by-position` (use a standard CTR curve: 1=28%, 2=15%, 3=11%, 4=8%, 5=7%, 6=5%, 7=4%, 8=3%, 9=2%, 10=2%, 11+=1%). - Take the top 3–5 as the URL's "primary keywords" for SERP work in step 5. 4. **Page authority** `DATA_getPageAuthority` + `DATA_getPageAuthorityHistory` - Current PA score and its 12-month trajectory. - Flag any drop > 5 points in the last 90 days. 4b. **GSC URL performance + URL Inspection** *(only if google-api.json is present, tier ≥ 1)* - Replaces the directional traffic estimate from step 2 with first-party Google data for the exact URL. - Pull GSC search analytics for the URL (last 28 days, by query and page): `python3 scripts/gsc_query.py --property "{config.default_property}" --url "{target_url}" --days 28 --json` - Pull URL Inspection (real indexation status, canonical Google sees, last crawl date): `python3 scripts/gsc_inspect.py "{target_url}" --site-url "{config.default_property}" --json` - If the URL's domain isn't a verified GSC property: surface "GSC: {target_domain} not verified — add it in Search Console" and continue with SE Ranking data only. - Surface in `PAGE.md` "## Snapshot": `GSC last 28d: {clicks}/{impressions}/{ctr}% CTR / pos {position}` and `Google sees: {INDEXED|EXCLUDED} · canonical {userCanonical} → {googleCanonical} · last crawled {date}`. - **Feed into the verdict heuristic:** `INDEXED` + impressions > 100 + position 4–10 → harden REFRESH (clear quick-win). `EXCLUDED` (any reason) → harden KILL or CONSOLIDATE. `userCanonical ≠ googleCanonical` → flag as critical issue regardless of verdict. - See `skills/seo-google/references/cross-skill-integration.md` § "seo-page" for the full recipe. 5. **SERP context** `DATA_getSerpResults` and `DATA_getAiOverview` - For each of the 3–5 primary keywords: - Top 10 organic results (URL, title, snippet). - SERP features present (PAA, image carousel, video, shopping, etc.). - AIO presence and citations — is this URL cited in the AIO? 6. **HTML sense-check** `WebFetch` (always) + `mcp__firecrawl-mcp__firecrawl_scrape` (when available) - **WebFetch first** (free, instant): extract `<title>`, meta description, all `<h1..h6>`, lang, word count, internal-link count, image count. WebFetch returns markdown so anything in `<head>` beyond `<title>` is lost — the next bullet recovers it. - **Firecrawl second** (1 Firecrawl credit; pass `formats: ["rawHtml"]`) — recovers what WebFetch can't see. Pin the format to `rawHtml`; the default `html` is post-processed and silently strips canonical, hreflang, and `<script type="application/ld+json">` blocks on many sites. If those head fields come back zero on a site that obviously has them (any major SaaS homepage), you forgot the `rawHtml` flag — re-run. - From `metadata`: `og:title`, `og:description`, `og:image`, `twitter:card`, `viewport`, robots meta, canonical URL. - From the returned `rawHtml`: every `<script type="application/ld+json">` block. Parse each as JSON, list detected `@type`s (Article, BreadcrumbList, Organization, Product, etc.). Note any block that fails to parse. - hreflang: count `<link rel="alternate" hreflang="…">` occurrences in `rawHtml`. - **If Firecrawl unavailable:** the WebFetch portion still runs; populate Page basics' OG / Twitter / canonical / robots / JSON-LD / hreflang lines as `(skipped — Firecrawl not installed)`. Don't infer from markdown. - **Sense-check:** does the page actually talk about its top-ranking keyword in title and H1? If a page ranks for keywords it doesn't address textually, that's a strong consolidation signal. 7. **Domain context** `DATA_getDomainOverviewWorldwide` (parent domain) - Light-weight: parent DA, total keywords, total traffic. Used to contextualise the page's PA against its domain. 8. **Cannibalization check** `DATA_getDomainPages` - Pull the parent domain's pages ranked by organic traffic. Cap at the top 50 — that's where the cannibalization risk concentrates. - For the candidate URL's top-3 traffic-weighted keywords (from step 3), scan the peer-page list: does any other URL on the same domain rank in the top 20 for any of those keywords? - **Cannibalization signal:** any peer URL ranking ≤ 20 for the candidate's top-3 keywords. Record peer URL, keyword, peer position vs candidate position, peer traffic. - **Cheaper than the old approach.** Previous versions cross-checked via `DATA_getDomainKeywords` on the parent domain — that endpoint can return tens of thousands of rows on large sites and is unnecessarily heavy for this question. `DATA_getDomainPages` ranked by traffic surfaces the high-impact peers directly. - If no peer URL competes, this signal is "no cannibalization detected" — pass through to step 9. 9. **Synthesise verdict** - Apply the verdict heuristic (see Tips) to produce KEEP / REFRESH / CONSOLIDATE / KILL. - For REFRESH, identify the top 3 specific changes (e.g., "add an H2 on 'alternatives' which 7 of 10 SERP winners use"). - Write `PAGE.md` (output spec below). ## Output format Create a folder `seo-page-{target-slug}-{YYYYMMDD}/` with: ``` seo-page-{target-slug}-{YYYYMMDD}/ ├── PAGE.md (synthesised verdict + plan — primary deliverable) ├── keywords.csv (full keyword list with positions — load-bearing CSV the auditor walks through row-by-row) ├── 04-serp-context.md (top 10 + AIO for top 3–5 keywords — load-bearing reference for SERP-driven REFRESH discussions) └── evidence/ ├── 01-url-overview.md (raw DATA_getUrlOverviewWorldwide) ├── 02-keywords.md (raw DATA_getDomainKeywords filtered) ├── 03-authority.md (PA + history) ├── 05-page-snapshot.md (HTML extracts) └── 06-cannibalization.md (peer pages on the same domain competing for the top-3 keywords) ``` Top-level: `PAGE.md` + `keywords.csv` + `04-serp-context.md`. The other step files preserve raw API/HTML extracts in `evidence/` for reproducibility — auditors lean on the CSV and SERP context, not the per-call dumps. `PAGE.md` follows this shape: ```markdown # Page Intelligence: {URL} > Snapshot dated {YYYY-MM-DD} · Country: {country} · Primary keyword: {keyword} ## Snapshot - Ranking keywords: {n} - Estimated monthly organic traffic: {n} - Page authority: {PA} ({↑/↓ trajectory over 90 days}) - Primary topic: {topic} - AIO citations: {n} of {checked} primary-keyword AIOs cite this URL - GSC last 28d: {clicks} clicks / {impressions} impressions / {ctr}% CTR / avg position {n} *(or `not configured` / `property not verified`)* - Google sees: {INDEXED|EXCLUDED|...} · canonical {userCanonical} {→ googleCanonical if differ} · last crawled {YYYY-MM-DD} ## Page basics - `<title>`: {value} - meta description: {value | absent} - `og:title`: {value | absent | skipped — Firecrawl required} - `og:description`: {value | absent | skipped} - `og:image`: {url | absent | skipped} - `twitter:card`: {summary | summary_large_image | absent | skipped} - `<link rel="canonical">`: {URL | self-referential | absent | skipped} - meta robots: {index,follow | noindex,nofollow | absent | skipped} - JSON-LD types detected: {Article, BreadcrumbList, Organization | none | skipped} - hreflang variants: {n | skipped} ## What this page wins - {keyword} — position {n}, ~{volume} monthly searches, ~{traffic} monthly clicks. - ... (top 3–5) ## Almost-wins (page-2 refresh opportunities) - {keyword} — position {n}, ~{volume} monthly searches. The top 3 SERP winners all do {pattern} that this page doesn't. - ... (top 3 examples) ## What this page misses - {keyword} — competitors {comp1}, {comp2} rank in top 5; this page is absent. - ... ## Same-domain cannibalization - {peer URL} — ranks position {n} for "{keyword}" (candidate ranks position {m}). Peer estimated traffic: {n}/mo. - ... (only list rows where a peer URL ranks ≤ 20 for one of the candidate's top-3 keywords; if none, write "No same-domain cannibalization detected on top-3 keywords.") ## AI Search angle - {n} of {checked} AIO queries on the URL's keywords cite this page. - The AIOs that DON'T cite this page tend to cite {pattern} (e.g., comparison tables, step-by-step how-tos). - Recommended GEO move: {one specific change}. ## Verdict: {KEEP | REFRESH | CONSOLIDATE | KILL} Reasoning: {1–2 sentences anchored in objective signals from above}. ### If REFRESH — top 3 changes 1. {Specific change} 2. {Specific change} 3. {Specific change} ## Raw data - keywords.csv — full enriched ranking-keyword list - 04-serp-context.md — per-keyword SERP top-10 with AIO - evidence/05-page-snapshot.md — HTML extracts ``` `keywords.csv` columns: `keyword,volume,kd,position,intent,traffic_estimate,url` ## Tips - Respect SE Ranking Data API rate limit: 10 requests per second. The 3–5 SERP queries in step 5 should be paced sequentially. - Call `DATA_getCreditBalance` before running. ~10–15 credits is typical for one URL. - Verdict heuristic: - **KEEP**: PA stable or up; traffic stable or up; top 3 keywords held in their positions; AIO citations present where AIO appears. - **REFRESH**: any of (PA dropped >5 in 90 days; traffic dropped >20%; a top-3 keyword fell to position 11+; AIO citations missing while competitors get cited). **Hardens** when GSC data (step 4b) shows `INDEXED` + impressions > 100 + average position 4–10 (clear quick-win territory). - **CONSOLIDATE**: cannibalization detected (step 8) — a peer URL on the same domain ranks ≤ 20 for one or more of the candidate's top-3 keywords. CONSOLIDATE harden when the peer outranks the candidate AND captures higher traffic; otherwise CONSOLIDATE recommendation is "merge into the candidate" rather than "kill the candidate." - **KILL**: PA <10 AND traffic <50/mo AND no top-10 keyword AND no internal links pointing to it. **Hardens** when JSON-LD schema is also absent (Firecrawl detected zero blocks) — the page has no signals for any crawler, organic or AI. **Also hardens** when URL Inspection (step 4b) returns `EXCLUDED` for any reason. - **GSC canonical mismatch (any verdict):** if step 4b detects `userCanonical ≠ googleCanonical`, flag this as a critical issue in `PAGE.md` regardless of the verdict — it points at indexing instability that the verdict on its own can't resolve. - Don't invent reasons. Anchor every claim in `PAGE.md` to a number from the raw data files. - When between KEEP and REFRESH, default to REFRESH — small refreshes compound. - The `keywords.csv` is the auditable trail. If a stakeholder questions the verdict, walk them through the CSV row by row. - For pages with very low data (new pages, <5 ranking keywords), the verdict is unreliable. Flag as "insufficient data — re-run after 60 days" rather than forcing a verdict. - **`DATA_getPageAuthorityHistory` all-zeros caveat:** if the endpoint returns `inlink_rank: 0` (or equivalent) for every date in the history window, treat as "insufficient history" — don't claim a drop or recommend REFRESH based on it. Often happens for very high-authority pages where the metric is saturated, or for URLs that haven't accumulated enough longitudinal data. Cross-check with `DATA_getPageAuthority` (current value) — if current PA is meaningful but history is flat-zero, flag the gap explicitly in `PAGE.md` rather than synthesising a trajectory.

--- name: seo-page description: URL-level SEO intelligence — which keywords this page ranks for, traffic captured, position history, SERP context, and AI Search citation status. Produces a keep / refresh / consolidate / kill verdict for one page. Distinct from `seo-technical-audit` (which checks technical health, not keyword/traffic performance) and from `seo-content-brief` (which produces a NEW article from a topic). Use when the user asks "analyze this page", "page SEO performance", "what does this URL rank for", "page traffic", "should I refresh this page", or provides a single URL for analysis. --- > Example output: [examples/seo-page-notion-keyboard-shortcuts-20260514/PAGE.md](../../examples/seo-page-notion-keyboard-shortcuts-20260514/PAGE.md) # Page Intelligence Show what a single URL ranks for, what traffic it captures, where its weak and strong points are, and what to do about it. The deliverable is an opinionated verdict — **KEEP**, **REFRESH**, **CONSOLIDATE**, or **KILL** — anchored in objective signals from SE Ranking's URL-level data. ## Prerequisites - SE Ranking MCP server connected. - Claude's `WebFetch` tool available (for the page-level HTML sense-check). - User provides: (a) a target URL, optionally (b) target market country (default: `us`), (c) primary topical keyword (auto-inferred from `` + `<h1>` if not supplied). ## Process 1. **Validate target & preflight.** See `skills/seo-firecrawl/references/preflight.md` for the canonical 3-stage preflight (credit balance, Firecrawl availability, Google APIs). Skill-specific notes: - Confirm the URL is fetchable; derive parent domain. If the user supplied a primary keyword, use it; otherwise infer it in step 3. - Estimated SE Ranking cost for this skill: ~10–15 credits typical (URL overview, ranking keywords, page authority, SERP context for top 3–5 keywords). - Firecrawl: optional with WebFetch fallback, ~1 Firecrawl credit if available. When available, step 6 recovers `og:*`, `twitter:*`, canonical, robots meta, JSON-LD types, and hreflang count from raw `<head>` — WebFetch returns markdown only and strips those fields. Without Firecrawl, the affected lines in `PAGE.md` emit `(skipped — Firecrawl not installed)`. Pass `--no-firecrawl` to treat Firecrawl as unavailable even when installed (credit conservation). - Google APIs: tier 1 (GSC available) unlocks step 4b (GSC URL performance + URL Inspection) after the page-authority step. See `skills/seo-google/references/cross-skill-integration.md` § "seo-page" for the full recipe. 2. **URL-level overview** `DATA_getUrlOverviewWorldwide` - Pull keyword count, organic traffic estimate, paid keyword count, paid traffic estimate, top regions. - Note: traffic estimates are directional — they don't replace Google Search Console. 3. **Ranking keywords** `DATA_getDomainKeywords` (use the `url` param for exact match — not `filter_url`) - Pull every keyword the URL ranks for in the target country, with positions. - Sort by traffic-weighted score: `volume × CTR-by-position` (use a standard CTR curve: 1=28%, 2=15%, 3=11%, 4=8%, 5=7%, 6=5%, 7=4%, 8=3%, 9=2%, 10=2%, 11+=1%). - Take the top 3–5 as the URL's "primary keywords" for SERP work in step 5. 4. **Page authority** `DATA_getPageAuthority` + `DATA_getPageAuthorityHistory` - Current PA score and its 12-month trajectory. - Flag any drop > 5 points in the last 90 days. 4b. **GSC URL performance + URL Inspection** *(only if google-api.json is present, tier ≥ 1)* - Replaces the directional traffic estimate from step 2 with first-party Google data for the exact URL. - Pull GSC search analytics for the URL (last 28 days, by query and page): `python3 scripts/gsc_query.py --property "{config.default_property}" --url "{target_url}" --days 28 --json` - Pull URL Inspection (real indexation status, canonical Google sees, last crawl date): `python3 scripts/gsc_inspect.py "{target_url}" --site-url "{config.default_property}" --json` - If the URL's domain isn't a verified GSC property: surface "GSC: {target_domain} not verified — add it in Search Console" and continue with SE Ranking data only. - Surface in `PAGE.md` "## Snapshot": `GSC last 28d: {clicks}/{impressions}/{ctr}% CTR / pos {position}` and `Google sees: {INDEXED|EXCLUDED} · canonical {userCanonical} → {googleCanonical} · last crawled {date}`. - **Feed into the verdict heuristic:** `INDEXED` + impressions > 100 + position 4–10 → harden REFRESH (clear quick-win). `EXCLUDED` (any reason) → harden KILL or CONSOLIDATE. `userCanonical ≠ googleCanonical` → flag as critical issue regardless of verdict. - See `skills/seo-google/references/cross-skill-integration.md` § "seo-page" for the full recipe. 5. **SERP context** `DATA_getSerpResults` and `DATA_getAiOverview` - For each of the 3–5 primary keywords: - Top 10 organic results (URL, title, snippet). - SERP features present (PAA, image carousel, video, shopping, etc.). - AIO presence and citations — is this URL cited in the AIO? 6. **HTML sense-check** `WebFetch` (always) + `mcp__firecrawl-mcp__firecrawl_scrape` (when available) - **WebFetch first** (free, instant): extract `<title>`, meta description, all `<h1..h6>`, lang, word count, internal-link count, image count. WebFetch returns markdown so anything in `<head>` beyond `<title>` is lost — the next bullet recovers it. - **Firecrawl second** (1 Firecrawl credit; pass `formats: ["rawHtml"]`) — recovers what WebFetch can't see. Pin the format to `rawHtml`; the default `html` is post-processed and silently strips canonical, hreflang, and `<script type="application/ld+json">` blocks on many sites. If those head fields come back zero on a site that obviously has them (any major SaaS homepage), you forgot the `rawHtml` flag — re-run. - From `metadata`: `og:title`, `og:description`, `og:image`, `twitter:card`, `viewport`, robots meta, canonical URL. - From the returned `rawHtml`: every `<script type="application/ld+json">` block. Parse each as JSON, list detected `@type`s (Article, BreadcrumbList, Organization, Product, etc.). Note any block that fails to parse. - hreflang: count `<link rel="alternate" hreflang="…">` occurrences in `rawHtml`. - **If Firecrawl unavailable:** the WebFetch portion still runs; populate Page basics' OG / Twitter / canonical / robots / JSON-LD / hreflang lines as `(skipped — Firecrawl not installed)`. Don't infer from markdown. - **Sense-check:** does the page actually talk about its top-ranking keyword in title and H1? If a page ranks for keywords it doesn't address textually, that's a strong consolidation signal. 7. **Domain context** `DATA_getDomainOverviewWorldwide` (parent domain) - Light-weight: parent DA, total keywords, total traffic. Used to contextualise the page's PA against its domain. 8. **Cannibalization check** `DATA_getDomainPages` - Pull the parent domain's pages ranked by organic traffic. Cap at the top 50 — that's where the cannibalization risk concentrates. - For the candidate URL's top-3 traffic-weighted keywords (from step 3), scan the peer-page list: does any other URL on the same domain rank in the top 20 for any of those keywords? - **Cannibalization signal:** any peer URL ranking ≤ 20 for the candidate's top-3 keywords. Record peer URL, keyword, peer position vs candidate position, peer traffic. - **Cheaper than the old approach.** Previous versions cross-checked via `DATA_getDomainKeywords` on the parent domain — that endpoint can return tens of thousands of rows on large sites and is unnecessarily heavy for this question. `DATA_getDomainPages` ranked by traffic surfaces the high-impact peers directly. - If no peer URL competes, this signal is "no cannibalization detected" — pass through to step 9. 9. **Synthesise verdict** - Apply the verdict heuristic (see Tips) to produce KEEP / REFRESH / CONSOLIDATE / KILL. - For REFRESH, identify the top 3 specific changes (e.g., "add an H2 on 'alternatives' which 7 of 10 SERP winners use"). - Write `PAGE.md` (output spec below). ## Output format Create a folder `seo-page-{target-slug}-{YYYYMMDD}/` with: ``` seo-page-{target-slug}-{YYYYMMDD}/ ├── PAGE.md (synthesised verdict + plan — primary deliverable) ├── keywords.csv (full keyword list with positions — load-bearing CSV the auditor walks through row-by-row) ├── 04-serp-context.md (top 10 + AIO for top 3–5 keywords — load-bearing reference for SERP-driven REFRESH discussions) └── evidence/ ├── 01-url-overview.md (raw DATA_getUrlOverviewWorldwide) ├── 02-keywords.md (raw DATA_getDomainKeywords filtered) ├── 03-authority.md (PA + history) ├── 05-page-snapshot.md (HTML extracts) └── 06-cannibalization.md (peer pages on the same domain competing for the top-3 keywords) ``` Top-level: `PAGE.md` + `keywords.csv` + `04-serp-context.md`. The other step files preserve raw API/HTML extracts in `evidence/` for reproducibility — auditors lean on the CSV and SERP context, not the per-call dumps. `PAGE.md` follows this shape: ```markdown # Page Intelligence: {URL} > Snapshot dated {YYYY-MM-DD} · Country: {country} · Primary keyword: {keyword} ## Snapshot - Ranking keywords: {n} - Estimated monthly organic traffic: {n} - Page authority: {PA} ({↑/↓ trajectory over 90 days}) - Primary topic: {topic} - AIO citations: {n} of {checked} primary-keyword AIOs cite this URL - GSC last 28d: {clicks} clicks / {impressions} impressions / {ctr}% CTR / avg position {n} *(or `not configured` / `property not verified`)* - Google sees: {INDEXED|EXCLUDED|...} · canonical {userCanonical} {→ googleCanonical if differ} · last crawled {YYYY-MM-DD} ## Page basics - `<title>`: {value} - meta description: {value | absent} - `og:title`: {value | absent | skipped — Firecrawl required} - `og:description`: {value | absent | skipped} - `og:image`: {url | absent | skipped} - `twitter:card`: {summary | summary_large_image | absent | skipped} - `<link rel="canonical">`: {URL | self-referential | absent | skipped} - meta robots: {index,follow | noindex,nofollow | absent | skipped} - JSON-LD types detected: {Article, BreadcrumbList, Organization | none | skipped} - hreflang variants: {n | skipped} ## What this page wins - {keyword} — position {n}, ~{volume} monthly searches, ~{traffic} monthly clicks. - ... (top 3–5) ## Almost-wins (page-2 refresh opportunities) - {keyword} — position {n}, ~{volume} monthly searches. The top 3 SERP winners all do {pattern} that this page doesn't. - ... (top 3 examples) ## What this page misses - {keyword} — competitors {comp1}, {comp2} rank in top 5; this page is absent. - ... ## Same-domain cannibalization - {peer URL} — ranks position {n} for "{keyword}" (candidate ranks position {m}). Peer estimated traffic: {n}/mo. - ... (only list rows where a peer URL ranks ≤ 20 for one of the candidate's top-3 keywords; if none, write "No same-domain cannibalization detected on top-3 keywords.") ## AI Search angle - {n} of {checked} AIO queries on the URL's keywords cite this page. - The AIOs that DON'T cite this page tend to cite {pattern} (e.g., comparison tables, step-by-step how-tos). - Recommended GEO move: {one specific change}. ## Verdict: {KEEP | REFRESH | CONSOLIDATE | KILL} Reasoning: {1–2 sentences anchored in objective signals from above}. ### If REFRESH — top 3 changes 1. {Specific change} 2. {Specific change} 3. {Specific change} ## Raw data - keywords.csv — full enriched ranking-keyword list - 04-serp-context.md — per-keyword SERP top-10 with AIO - evidence/05-page-snapshot.md — HTML extracts ``` `keywords.csv` columns: `keyword,volume,kd,position,intent,traffic_estimate,url` ## Tips - Respect SE Ranking Data API rate limit: 10 requests per second. The 3–5 SERP queries in step 5 should be paced sequentially. - Call `DATA_getCreditBalance` before running. ~10–15 credits is typical for one URL. - Verdict heuristic: - **KEEP**: PA stable or up; traffic stable or up; top 3 keywords held in their positions; AIO citations present where AIO appears. - **REFRESH**: any of (PA dropped >5 in 90 days; traffic dropped >20%; a top-3 keyword fell to position 11+; AIO citations missing while competitors get cited). **Hardens** when GSC data (step 4b) shows `INDEXED` + impressions > 100 + average position 4–10 (clear quick-win territory). - **CONSOLIDATE**: cannibalization detected (step 8) — a peer URL on the same domain ranks ≤ 20 for one or more of the candidate's top-3 keywords. CONSOLIDATE harden when the peer outranks the candidate AND captures higher traffic; otherwise CONSOLIDATE recommendation is "merge into the candidate" rather than "kill the candidate." - **KILL**: PA <10 AND traffic <50/mo AND no top-10 keyword AND no internal links pointing to it. **Hardens** when JSON-LD schema is also absent (Firecrawl detected zero blocks) — the page has no signals for any crawler, organic or AI. **Also hardens** when URL Inspection (step 4b) returns `EXCLUDED` for any reason. - **GSC canonical mismatch (any verdict):** if step 4b detects `userCanonical ≠ googleCanonical`, flag this as a critical issue in `PAGE.md` regardless of the verdict — it points at indexing instability that the verdict on its own can't resolve. - Don't invent reasons. Anchor every claim in `PAGE.md` to a number from the raw data files. - When between KEEP and REFRESH, default to REFRESH — small refreshes compound. - The `keywords.csv` is the auditable trail. If a stakeholder questions the verdict, walk them through the CSV row by row. - For pages with very low data (new pages, <5 ranking keywords), the verdict is unreliable. Flag as "insufficient data — re-run after 60 days" rather than forcing a verdict. - **`DATA_getPageAuthorityHistory` all-zeros caveat:** if the endpoint returns `inlink_rank: 0` (or equivalent) for every date in the history window, treat as "insufficient history" — don't claim a drop or recommend REFRESH based on it. Often happens for very high-authority pages where the metric is saturated, or for URLs that haven't accumulated enough longitudinal data. Cross-check with `DATA_getPageAuthority` (current value) — if current PA is meaningful but history is flat-zero, flag the gap explicitly in `PAGE.md` rather than synthesising a trajectory.