--- JEFF PROBST: Previously on Survivor: With Lex voted out, Kathy was feeling the pain of being betrayed by Rob. I couldn't believe how isolated I felt. It's really hard being on the losing side of life here. PROBST: And the tribe faced a monumental competition. Today's challenge is a Survivor obstacle course, one of the toughest we've ever had. It is part reward and it is part immunity. Wow. PROBST: Divided into two teams, Rob's team dominated the competition, winning ponchos and letters from home and advancing them to the immunity portion of the challenge. Go. Once again, Rob sealed his victory. Boston Rob wins immunity and a video of his brother. But Rob surprised his tribe mates with an interesting proposition. We had some bad blood yesterday. Is there any way, if I forego seeing the video, everybody could get their letters? PROBST: I can make that trade. With Tribal Council looming, Kathy and Shii Ann tried to stir things up in an attempt to save themselves. You need to start reacting. I think we've got some last-minute scrambling going on in Panama today. PROBST: But for Kathy, all the talk just wasn't enough. She was voted out and became the second member of the jury. Seven are left. Who will be voted out tonight? Captioning sponsored by CBS PARAMOUNT NETWORK TELEVISION ( thunder crashing ) Well, last night was really ( thunder crashing ) Well, last night was really emotional. Um, I got really choked up when they voted Kathy out. The smug, horrible Chaperan... superior tribe pagonging all of us Mogo Mogo members, you know, basically voting one after another out. I knew Kathy was going, and I just got really emotional because she was my rock out here. And she was my one true friend. And now that she's gone, I don't have anyone here. I've got no one. ( thunder rolling ) I know I'm slated next to go. Mm-hmm. And you know I have to play the game as hard as I can before I go. So, I'm just asking you straight-up, you know, are you going to keep with your original six, or are you going to be willing to look at other possibilities? Yeah... Like, honestly, I'm going to stay with my plan. That's cool. You got to play your last card. Win immunity. I'm going to try to win immunity. I will. You've got to beat me, though, 'cause I need it just as much as you. I know I do, you know? I know you do. I'm extremely vulnerable right now, and chances of me making it to the final two are slim. So, at this point, my best chance is to play as hard as I can, call everyone on their game and stir it up before I leave. If you make it to the final two, I'll be shocked. I know. With your strategy... current strategy. And I hope you do well, but, you know, I'm wishing myself luck in the next immunity challenge. She tried to tell me what my strategy should be. Right. "You need to watch out for this person, you need to watch out for this one." Here we go. She's doing that. Just was patient and listened to her. I was like, "All right, thanks for the info, Shii Ann." We got to make sure she don't win immunity. Hell, yeah. That's the whole goal. That's it. ( thunderclap ) ( twittering ) Can it rain any more here? Look, there's a bump on it. Oh, yeah. Wow, it's a mask. It says, "A no-lose situation, this one's not a race. Is everyone a winner? Try not the lose face. In touch with your own feelings? What do your tribe mates think? If you're the last one standing, you'll decide what they eat and drink." Oh... So maybe you get to choose whether or not you want share... So maybe you choose what everybody eats? I want... I want everybody to eat and drink. The rain doesn't let up. We can't fish in these conditions. We can't cook in these conditions. So, we are all hoping we're playing for food. "Try not to lose face" is maybe three chops and your face is smashed and you're out. I'm hoping food or something, but I'm really looking forward to it because it's just a miserable day. Ooga, ga, ga, ooga, go, ga. Hey-a, ho-a, ha. Dumb ass. ( thunderclap ) PROBST: Rain ponchos coming in handy. ( Rupert chuckling ) PROBST: Seeing your likeness? Yeah. Amber and I are the same person, just slightly different hair. Look at me. I have a very strange expression on our faces. ( men chuckling ) PROBST: All right, let's get to the first part of today's reward challenge. I'm gonna hand each of you a questionnaire about your fellow tribe mates. The idea here is to find out what you really think about each other. So, answer honestly. Don't discuss your answers with anybody. Make sense? All right, give you a couple minutes to do this. Find a little spot, step away from each other. All right, guys. The results have been tallied. I'm going to ask you the same exact questions again, only this time your answers should be based on how you think the majority of the tribe answered. Every time your answer matches what the tribe said, you get to make one chop on a tribe mate's row. Three chops release a battering ram and you're out of the game. Last person left standing wins reward. The reward is food. However, all of you will be picked up by boat and taken to a local Panamanian restaurant. On the menu are seven items. Wow. PROBST: Each item increases in value and taste, everything from a bowl of rice and a glass of water from your own camp to a full-on steak dinner with all the fixings. Oh... PROBST: The winner will be in charge of that menu. Oh, my God! PROBST: Here's the rub: You cannot share your meal. Somebody will get a whole lot, and somebody is gonna get very little. Okay. PROBST: All right. Let's get started. First question: Who would you trust with your life? Everybody reveal. The group thought Rob. Alicia got it right. Amber got it right. Rob, you didn't even get it right. Alicia, you get the first chop. Oh, Shii Ann, Shii Ann. Surprise. PROBST: Amber, you're up. Who's getting the damage? I'm going to go for Big Tom since he stole my pot in that one challenge. PROBST: Now we're going to get catty. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Not an easy question to answer... in front of each other. Reveal. It was a tie. Shii Ann. Surprise. PROBST: Alicia. Nice. Hearing that from the rest of the tribe, what's that make you feel? Yeah, it's a shot in the heart. I'll get them all later. PROBST: Well, everybody got it right. Everybody gets a chop. We'll start on the end and work down. Well, since my own tribe mates think I don't deserve to be here, Rob... you're going first. PROBST: Rob takes a hit. How do you like that, baby? PROBST: Jenna? I'm going to go with Big Tom. PROBST: Big Tom takes his second hit. One hit away from being out of the game. Shii Ann. Hey, Alicia, I got to pay you back. All right. PROBST: Amber. I'll go with Jenna. PROBST: Jenna takes her first hit. Rupert. I'm sorry, Shii Ann. Shii Ann and Big Tom one hit away from being out of the game. Big Tom. Jenna, I'll just pay you a favor. Right back to you, baby. PROBST: Jenna takes her second hit. Boston Rob, you could put somebody out of the game if you wanted. Rupert hasn't gotten hit yet. Oh... ( all groaning ) PROBST: Big Tom is our first casualty! That's rotten. PROBST: Have a seat on the bench, Big Tom. You're out of the game. Next question: "Who uses sex appeal as a weapon?" Nobody even hesitating on this one; everybody flipping quickly. Reveal. Everybody says Amber, including Amber. ( laughter ) So you fully own up to using sex appeal. I fully own up to it. PROBST: Everybody gets a chop again. Alicia, you're up. Amber, since you're going to use it as a weapon, how about... PROBST: Amber going to take her first hit. PROBST: Jenna. And payback. PROBST: Amber takes her second hit. Shii Ann, you going to put her out? This is hard. Rupert doesn't have one, but, Jenna, I have to take you out just because. PROBST: And with that, Jenna was completely beheaded. Amber's got some payback. Sorry, Alicia. Hey, it's all right. PROBST: Alicia takes her second hit. Rupert, why are you laughing? Shii Ann, she's got to stop telling people to hit me. PROBST: Uh-oh. ( others groaning ) Oh...! PROBST: Shii Ann takes it right between the eyes. Boston Rob. No need in keeping the stragglers around. All right, go ahead. ( others groaning ) PROBST: Bye-bye, Alicia. We are down to three. Who is under the false assumption that they are smart? Reveal. Amber says Tom. Rupert says himself. Boston Rob says Jenna. You're all wrong. The group thought Alicia was most under the false assumption that she was smart. I don't like these people anymore, let me tell you something. PROBST: You're taking some hits today. I'm taking some hits today, that's all right. PROBST: Next question. Who did the group think was the most honest? Reveal. Amber and Rupert say Rupert. Rob said himself. Correct answer, Rupert. Amber and Rupert are right. Amber, you are up. You only have two choices. Boston Rob has taken one hit, Rupert has taken no hits. Sorry, Rob. PROBST: Rob down to his last pop. Rupert could put him out of the game right here. I have to. You could put her out. I could, but Amber didn't hit me. Oh! PROBST: Boston Rob is no more. Boston Rob, have a seat. Here's where we're at. Rupert, you still have three hits left. Amber, you only have one. If Rupert gets this right, he will obliterate you and win the challenge. "Who never shuts up?" Reveal. You both say Jenna. Yeah. PROBST: You're both right. ( laughter ) Amber, your hit doesn't really matter. Rupert, you get the final honors. Take Amber out. Nice job, Rupert. Thank you all, you guys. PROBST: Rupert, with that, wins reward. Rupert, you will be in charge of the menu tonight. The boat will come and pick you up. You guys can now head back to camp. ♪ ♪ You guys gave that one to me. ♪ ♪ You guys gave that one to me. I appreciate that one. Thank you, guys. That was awesome. I think the biggest thing that happened at our reward challenge today was, Alicia got all upset again. She was mocked by the tribe as the person least deserving to be an all-star. Her ego took a blow, but you know, people say things for a reason, so maybe she needs to take a look at herself. I thought they were pretty good. The, uh... the masks, too. I thought the masks were pretty good. You know, it's never fun to hear things about yourself that aren't flattering and then have to... the same people that said those things, you're stuck with them. That's not fun. It would be nice to get out of camp tonight. Alicia, you okay? I'm fabulous, baby. Okay. If it helps, I'm a big mouth. Yeah, but did everybody say that you don't deserve to be here and that you definitely think you're smart and you're not? Did people say that about you? Let's say there's only seven. Let's say.... It doesn't matter, dude. It's already been said. Done. Alicia's very emotional. And when something upsets her, she becomes a huge grump around the camp. She's just being a big baby about it. People are observing it. People are getting annoyed with it. People will vote you out sooner because they don't want to live with it. Don't, don't, don't, don't. I know you don't want somebody to talk to you, but I'm a mom, it's my job. Yeah, but you know what? You're not my mom, so it's all good. But you're hurt. Well, you know what? That's just the way it goes. I don't want anybody hugging me or touching me or trying to... Leave me alone. The only person that tried to not give me my space was Jenna. Jenna's trying to put her arm around me. Give me a break. Jenna and I have no connection at all. I mean, she's probably one of the people that voted that way anyway. So she needs to save it. Jenna would be the last person that I would go to for consoling, the last person. Listen, I know you got a really big decision, and I know you're the most generous person out here, probably. And just know that we understand where your position is. But I'd like to have the choice is all I'm asking. Okay. That's a great idea. Like if you said, "This is my decision for the order," and then just give us choices. That's a great idea. You know, that's almost a challenge I wish I didn't win. This is what killed me on Pearl Islands was, I let the pecking order be known and then I was the next one gone. But don't be a martyr and be like, "I'm going to take the smallest one and put everyone else above me 'cause you need to be strong, too, okay? I just don't think you should give away your big one. I love Rupert, but strategy- wise, he is-- I don't want to say not good at the game, he is, but he needs some coaching. Seven of us... I do say Shii Ann gets the rice. Shii Ann gets the rice. But I think we keep ourselves strong, us four. We have the numbers. They can't hurt us. No, they can't. This adventure is geared to create hard feelings between people. I hate being that person that creates the hard feelings. PROBST: Come on in, guys! Welcome to the Romantica Restaurant. Thank you. PROBST: Rupert, you're at the head of the table. Cool. PROBST: Everybody else head in this way and take a seat. So, Rupert, it's your reward. Good news is, you get your first choice of anything here you want. We got a big piece of steak, shrimp, all the fixings. The bad news is, you have to allocate the rest and somebody's going to end up with a very cold bowl of rice and water from your own camp. So, let me go over the rest of your choices. We have potatoes with tap water. Then we have a salad with tap water that's been chilled. And we have a ham and cheese sandwich with some sparkling water and a little bit of lemon. We also have a hot dog, sour kraut and orange juice. Then we have a big cheeseburger and french fry plate. So, you can start with myself. You can start anywhere you want. I'm going to start with me and I'm taking the steak. PROBST: All right. Thank you, sir. PROBST: Along with the steak, open bar, for you only. You just tell him what you want to drink and he'll keep refilling it. We'll start with a cerveza. PROBST: All right. Rupert's starting with a beer. So, this is on you. It's your menu. You're going to distribute it. I would like Rob to choose next. PROBST: One ice-cold cola and the burger. I'd like Jenna to choose next. PROBST: Going right down the line. Orange juice. I would like Amber to choose next. PROBST: Ham and cheese sandwich, sparkling water. All right, Rupert, three items left. Alicia? I would love the salad. PROBST: Salad and cold water. Thank you. I probably would have chose that. Very good. PROBST: That worked out. Big Tom, what do you want? PROBST: Big Tom picks next. Whatever... What is that? Potatoes. I'll eat some potatoes. Potatoes, yeah. Leave the Asian girl with the rice. Yeah. ( chuckling ) We went to one of the fanciest restaurants. They said it was five-star. Please don't stab me. ( chuckling ) But I wouldn't hit a dog in the hind end with it 'cause I got a tater and it was cold. Shii Ann... camp. PROBST: Camp water and cold rice. I hope it's boiled, both the rice and the camp water. PROBST: A little bit of an awkward dinner, but it's a dinner nonetheless. You're warm for a little while. I'll get out of your hair. Bon appétit. Thank you, Jeff. This camp water tastes better out here because of the romantic lighting. Good. You saw the people that ended up with fifth, sixth and seventh weren't too happy about the politics that were involved, but hey, what can you do about that? You win some, you lose some. Those fries look so good. Thank you, sir. I'm chewing my rice and thinking that I'm eating that piece of steak that Rupert's holding in his hands. I can't even look up at you guys. Don't look up. Just eat. Shii Ann's an absolutely obnoxious person. The whole time she's like, "This rice is good. Oh, my gosh, ooh, look at that steak, I just want to watch you eat it." I wish I could give you guys all some. I know. Shut up! It's obnoxious! Thank you, sir. ( chuckling ) Big Tom, I'm drinking this for you. ( Rupert burping ) So the dinner was nice. And Rupert, of course, had eight or nine beers and he was plastered. Plastered! Thank you, sir. ( burping ) Smell your napkin. It's so nice and soft. ( Rupert laughing ) I'm taking... We're taking advantage of this. Good. Rupert, keep drinking. Okay. We really wanted to stay at the restaurant for as long as we possibly could, 'cause we just dreaded coming back here with all the bugs and the really long night. So, we told Rupert, "Keep drinking as much as you want." We're just going to lay here on the table and use these napkins as pillows and enjoy it. Rupert's a happy man. ( Rupert chuckling ) Basically, Rupert exposed our alliance of four. It was pretty evident, uh... as to who got what food. He's kind of sticking it in their face, which kind of shows me that he does trust myself and Amber to a degree. ♪ Chaboga Mogo, Chaboga Amber to a degree. ♪ Chaboga Mogo, Chaboga Mogo, Chaboga Mogo... ♪ The sun is out, and we're going to have a beautiful day. We are going to have a beautiful day. I'm going to battle 'cause I got to, but I'm not going to kill myself to win 'cause I hope that I'm not on the chopping block. I don't think you are. And I wouldn't mind seeing you win immunity. You got to be looking at Rob. I would be if I were you. Oh, my gosh... If I were anyone here, I'd would be looking at Rob. I've already talked to Jenna about that. Of course, you have. But they're telling me they'll take me to the final four, too, but I know I'll be fourth unless I win immunity. There are people here that would stretch their vote tonight if they felt like they had the majority. Yeah. We know that. I know that. There are people here. Let me... hand me... while you're over, give me that solid piece! See that good little piece right here? Yep. So, uh... who's up on the...? Chop block? Yep. ( whispering ): It's him before Shii Ann. Rupert before Shii Ann. I was thinking about that today. I was looking at everybody today, and I was kind of... sizing up. All I'm saying, we got... me and you got to stick together, Alicia. Absolutely. And I'll tell you what, though, if either one of us are up against Amber or Boston Rob, we're in trouble. But you know as well as I do, me and you are the lone horse here. Yep. And those two are going to stick together no matter what. They're lovers. I know. But you know what? We may have not slept together, but we... we snuggled pretty close. That's right. We decided, Big Tom, Rob, Amber and myself, that we were going to stay together to the very end. That's four people. So, no matter what happens in this tribe, we are four to the to the other three. Then there's Big Tom. He came to me and said, you know, "I can't sit next to Boston Rob or Amber. I'll never win. Maybe I should sit next to you." And I said, "You know what? Maybe you're right." But I didn't make any deal with him. The only person I have an alliance with at this point is Boston Rob, and we shook on it. But do I trust him? Absolutely not. Here's the thing. If Shii Ann wins immunity today... It'd be a miracle. Yeah, I know, but still, we have to decide. Rob, let's just face it, it's gonna hurt you more than it will me. You got a better chance at winning than I have. I need to win, like, almost every one, Tom. I know what people think around the camp. I know even though Rupert pretends he's all nice-- last night he gave me a hamburger-- I can read beyond that, you know? If Shii Ann wins immunity, I don't know who we're gonna kick off. You're worried about Shii Ann. I'm worried about Rupert. Because he's the one that's gonna beat you in an immunity. Shii Ann ain't gonna beat you. All right. Uh, Alicia ain't gonna beat you. But we can't beat Rupert. You're gonna come close, but he's gonna beat you before it's over. Right. And then when he does, you know who they want to get rid of? It ain't gonna be me. No, it'll be me. It's you. Yeah, we should talk, actually. I have some news. I don't want to even hear it. Honestly. That's fine. There is a plan, Shii Ann, and it's too late for anything to change. Okay. I appreciate that. Yep. PROBST: There's no denying Yep. PROBST: There's no denying it-- we are getting down to it. There are seven of you left. Today's challenge is for immunity. Very important at this stage of the game. It's a very simple immunity challenge. You're gonna step up on a log. You're gonna raise your hand over your head. Your hand is gonna be tethered to a bucket. That bucket's full of water. When you drop your hand, the bucket tips, you get wet, you're done. If you need immunity, the only thing stopping you from getting it is quitting, and that's it. We got all day to sit out here. All right, Boston Rob, give it up. The all-important immunity is back up for grabs. Take your spots. I'll lock you in. For immunity. Everybody's locked in, and this challenge is officially on. There'll be a little initial pain. You'll work through that. Just remember, there's not a lot of slack in that chain, so if you drop your hand two inches, you're done. You have very little wiggle room in this challenge. Amber's first out. in this challenge. Amber's first out. Grab a seat on the bench. I didn't even move! PROBST: Jenna's out of the game. You didn't need that immunity anyway. It's all good. Nobody knows who's safe. I know I'm not safe, that's for sure. PROBST: Have a seat next to Amber. Big Tom, you're struggling. Oh, Big Tom. PROBST: Big Tom, third person to hit the dust. Okay, Rupert, you got to hold out before Rob. PROBST: Big Tom's out of the challenge. We can't let Rob keep winning these immunities. Damn straight. PROBST: Have a seat next to the ladies, Big Tom. You're out of the challenge. I see Shii Ann's arm moving a bit, so you guys are good. PROBST: So, Jenna, I take it from that comment there's just no secrets in this tribe right now. No. No, there isn't. Oh, there are secrets to this tribe. No secret on who they want out tonight, but there's secrets to this tribe. PROBST: Alicia fighting through a little pain. Be strong, Alicia. PROBST: First sign of weakness we've seen from Alicia on this. Fight, guys. It's all about this right here. That sound around your neck. It means you're in this game a little longer. It means you've got a one-in-six shot at a million bucks. Somebody gonna leave here with this. The person who wants it the most. Fight it, guys, fight it. Oh! Whew! I got a little of that, too. All right! I'm glad. At least if I went down, I took you with me. PROBST: I couldn't be happier. Keep your arm up, Rupert. Keep your arm up. I'm damn straight trying. PROBST: And then there were three. All three looking really strong. A little bit of rain starting to come down, cool you off a little. Wouldn't be a day on Survivor: All-Star if we didn't get a little rain. ( thunder crashing ) Immunity is most definitely up for grabs. Three people left. Anybody could get it. Shii Ann, I have to say, one hour in, you have not moved. Your body has not moved, your arm has not dipped. I'm not moving. PROBST: I don't think you've taken your hand off your hip. Nope. It's numb, but I need this immunity, like I said, Jeff, desperately. ( Jenna mouthing words ) ( birds twittering ) ( insect buzzing ) ( insect buzzing ) PROBST: Boston Rob's out of the competition. Next-door neighbors Rupert and Shii Ann still fighting for immunity. Since it's just down to you two, a little reminder: Somebody's gonna leave here with this around their neck. That means they are safe tonight at the vote. The other person will not have that same security. Rupert, stay up there. You got this, Rupert. ( thunder rolling ) ( birds chirping ) ( thunder rolling ) ( birds chirping ) PROBST: You guys have lasted two hours. Two long, painful hours. How much more you got left in you, Rupert? Shii Ann, any sign of quitting in you? Nope. ( rain pouring ) Careful, Rupert, you're moving it a lot. You're moving the chain. Yes! Yes! Yes! PROBST: Rupert's out of the competition. Shii Ann wins immunity. Whoo! Whoo!! Yeah! Take that! ( grunts ) Don't forget, you got to go home with us, Shii Ann. Be very careful, sweetheart. Hey, you know what? I love you guys, but I need this more than all of you guys. Yeah, don't get too cocky, though. You got to live with us. I needed it more than all of you guys. PROBST: All right, Shii Ann, turn around. Looks like you're about ready to cry. You doing all right? I'm doing great. They're tears of joy. I knew I was going home tonight, and now... PROBST: It most definitely will not be you. Great effort. You are safe tonight at Tribal Council. Thank you. PROBST: Guaranteed a one-in-six shot of winning this thing and the million bucks. For the rest of you, I can't say the same thing. Somebody is going home tonight. Tribal Council. I'll see you there. Go back to camp. ♪ ♪ ( chirping ) ♪ ♪ ( chirping ) ( fire crackling ) I didn't mean to get so excited. I wasn't trying to gloat. I was just... Really wanted to win. Everybody gets excited when they win immunity or reward. Just today, I really needed it, so I got a little excited. That's all right. The thing that bothered me about Shii Ann's victory is that she tried to throw it in our face the moment she won. And the first thing she does is let out this victory cry, and she's, like, "Yeah! Ha! I did it!" You know? She's pointing at all of us, and I just looked at her and said, "I wouldn't be that cocky-- you still have to live with us." I'm feeling a whole lot better now that these proud little Chaboga Mogos are gonna have to eat one of their own. I love the fact that they're all sitting there squirming in their... shorts, ignoring me yet again. They should have been cutting deals with me before my immunity win. Now that I have an immunity win, I know that Alicia's head is on the chopping block, Rob Mariano's head's on the chopping block, and so is Rupert's. Stupid people. Stupid people. Let me just say that again: stupid players. You know, your head is big-time on the chopping block today. Oh, I know. I'm taking all my stuff to Tribal Council with me. I'm telling you, Rob is the person to get rid of because he's the kingpin. You got to work it or else you're going. Oh, I know. ( bird squawking ) Shii Ann's a deal maker. Such a strategist. Look at her down there. Look at the strategizing going on right now. I have two options tonight. I can stick with Rupert and Jenna, myself and Amber to make that foursome, or I can go with Big Tom, Alicia, Amber and myself... and take out Rupert or Jenna, 'cause I don't know if Rupert and Jenna are like 100% with us. I like to say Alicia is out of here. She is. She's out of here. Maybe not. Maybe me. For me, it's between probably Rupert or Alicia. You prefer Alicia. I don't know. For me, it would be between Rupert and Rob, because I think one of them needs to go. They're too big and too powerful. You feel more comfortable with Rob; you trust him more 'cause you're... Well, I... I trust him more and I think that even if I'm lying to him, he's gonna trust me. She's so sweet. You hate to hate her because she's so lovely and she's got those beautiful green eyes, but you know what? She is one of the shrewdest players out here. "We love you. We can't wait for you to come home and be a family. Wherever you are, I know you're kicking some ass. Remember, the key to the game is loose lips sink ships." What? Honestly, if I didn't trust you 100%, I would never let you read this, but, you know... "Remember, the key to the game is loose lips..." My main alliance still is with Amber. It's because she trusts me completely; even though I may not trust her 100% completely, I know she does. I think she does. ( bird squawks ) We can do this. We're going to do this. You know that? We gotta just keep the paranoia to a minimum before Tribal Councils. We gotta trust in a game like this. It's like huge, you know? It makes all the difference in the world, and I appreciate it. Of course she's playing the game. She may be playing me, I don't know. I don't think so. I really don't. I think it's genuine what's going on. I could be the biggest sucker in history, and if so, hey-- she had me fooled. ♪ ♪ PROBST: Now bring in the members of our jury, Lex and Kathy, voted out the last Tribal Council. I'll remind you guys that the jury's here merely to observe. They're not to talk to you. You're not to try and communicate with them. It's been a busy couple of days, culminating with a very big and, from what I gather today, important victory at today's immunity challenge for you, Shii Ann. Yes, very, very important. You were very vocal today and, from where I sat, sort of created an island for yourself. This tribe is very unique in that they've been very, very open with me about the fact that they are a tight alliance and I'm going home next. So, you know, today at the challenge, I was very vocal, because I'm going to try my best to fight. PROBST: Rupert, what's your take on everything that went down today? That was one heck of a hard challenge. After 20 minutes, I was dying. Shii Ann says she was the only one that needed it, but now somebody else needs it. There's been talk that I'm targeted. I felt like, especially with that silly reward challenge over the pecking-order caca, I'm up. I mean, my number could be up. PROBST: Alicia, we have four from the original Chapera. You guys have the numbers. How strong is that group still? Well, the original Chapera is-is always going to be strong because we've been together from the day one, but we also could not have done it without Rupert and Jenna joining our tribe. Honestly, we knew that once we got to six, game on. Anything can happen and any one of us is vulnerable at this point. PROBST: Shii Ann, did you notice a power shift today? Were you the person in camp people wanted to come talk to and try and make a deal? No. I-I... You know, it's so funny. What I notice about this group of six is that, as far as I can tell, no one wants to take a leadership position and say this person in particular is getting voted out tonight. PROBST: Jenna, you were rolling your head all over the place. 'Cause it makes us sound dumb. No, no, no, I don't think... PROBST: Hold off. Shii Ann. I mean, maybe we're not telling Shii Ann everything because we don't need her to know our strategies. PROBST: Boston Rob, first time in a while, you haven't had that necklace around your neck. You're a provider, very strong, seem to be a likable guy. Why not get rid of you while we have the opportunity? What are you giving them ideas for, Jeff? PROBST: It had to have crossed your mind. Of course. Are you kidding me? I'm sitting here, I won the first two immunities, I've been strong pretty much, I think, the whole game. I'm definitely nervous tonight, and I wish I had that necklace on. PROBST: On that note, it's time to vote. Shii Ann, you have immunity. I know you don't want to give it away, but I'll go ahead and ask. No, Jeff, I'm not going to give it away. PROBST: You cannot vote for Shii Ann. Everybody else is fair game. Let's vote. Amber, you're up. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ Remember the little fight we had on day three, where I zipped my lip? I've been waiting to do this for 27 days, so... au revoir, adios, arrivederci, sayonara, or as we say in Boston, see you later. PROBST: I'll go tally the votes. Once the votes are read, the votes. Once the votes are read, the decision is final. The person voted out will be asked to leave the Tribal Council area immediately. I'll read the votes. First vote... Alicia. Alicia. Two votes Alicia. Rupert. Two votes Alicia, one vote Rupert. Alicia. Twelfth person voted out of Survivor: All-Stars, and the third member of our jury, Alicia. You need to bring me your torch. Well, somebody turned. I'd better not find out who it is. PROBST: Alicia, the tribe has spoken. PROBST: Well, Shii Ann was very open tonight in sharing that she was treated with respect and honesty regarding her status in the tribe. Clearly, that doesn't apply to members of your own family of six, as Alicia never saw it coming. Nine days left, guys. Grab your torches. Go back to camp. Good night. ♪ ♪ ANNOUNCER: Stay tuned for scenes from our next episode. PROBST: Next time on Survivor: Jenna and Shii Ann want each other gone... Yeah, I'm not having plantains today. You want them, you cook them for yourself. I want to strangle her. She opens her mouth, and I feel like putting a gun in mine. PROBST: ...while Rupert and Jenna have been together too long. I was cooking. She's just a pain in the ass and I'm very sorry that I have an alliance with her. Here I sit, voted out, third member of the jury. I wish you all luck. As for Boston Rob, you had a handshake with me, so I'm really hoping that you're not sitting in the final two, because now I sit on the jury and believe me, when I have to decide who actually gets the million dollars, I'm not going to make it easy.