{ "verdict": { "thin001_domain_resolved_init": "supported", "hypotheses": { "H1": false, "H2": true, "H3": true, "H4": false }, "headline": "At 1.5B time-zero, init-quality spread S=random\u2212focus is 4.97 bits/byte on formal vs 2.53 on prose (ratio 1.96); FOCUS\u2265FVT\u2265random ranking holds 9/9 domains." }, "gates": { "G1_scorer_repro": { "passed": true, "detail": { "pl": { "e7": 1.2043, "e5": 1.2043, "d": -4e-05 }, "en": { "e7": 0.8294, "e5": 0.8294, "d": 0.0 }, "sci_arxiv": { "e7": 0.6935, "e5": 0.6935, "d": -3e-05 }, "sci_latex": { "e7": 0.6436, "e5": 0.6436, "d": 4e-05 }, "sci_python": { "e7": 0.3417, "e5": 0.3417, "d": 4e-05 }, "sci_gsm8k": { "e7": 0.0524, "e5": 0.0524, "d": -4e-05 }, "pl_wiki_sci": { "e7": 1.093, "e5": 1.093, "d": -5e-05 }, "pl_pes": { "e7": 1.4071, "e5": 1.4071, "d": -3e-05 }, "pl_informal": { "e7": 1.6948, "e5": 1.6948, "d": 1e-05 } } }, "G4_overlap_equal": { "passed": true, "n_overlap": 5972 } }, "per_domain": { "sci_latex": { "cls": "FORMAL", "base": 0.6436, "focus": 2.6454, "fvt": 2.7363, "random": 7.1187, "delta_random": 6.4751, "delta_fvt": 2.0927, "delta_focus": 2.0018, "S": 4.4733, "S_ci": [ 4.3617, 4.5874 ], "G": 0.0909, "G_ci": [ 0.082, 0.1 ], "rank_ok": true }, "sci_python": { "cls": "FORMAL", "base": 0.3417, "focus": 1.9744, "fvt": 2.0459, "random": 5.5805, "delta_random": 5.2388, "delta_fvt": 1.7041, "delta_focus": 1.6327, "S": 3.6061, "S_ci": [ 3.5234, 3.6984 ], "G": 0.0715, "G_ci": [ 0.0563, 0.0861 ], "rank_ok": true }, "math_clean": { "cls": "FORMAL", "base": 1.5651, "focus": 3.5211, "fvt": 3.8017, "random": 10.3653, "delta_random": 8.8003, "delta_fvt": 2.2366, "delta_focus": 1.956, "S": 6.8443, "S_ci": [ 6.6981, 6.9945 ], "G": 0.2806, "G_ci": [ 0.2647, 0.2964 ], "rank_ok": true }, "sci_arxiv": { "cls": "SCI_PROSE", "base": 0.6935, "focus": 3.0633, "fvt": 3.1806, "random": 6.465, "delta_random": 5.7715, "delta_fvt": 2.4871, "delta_focus": 2.3698, "S": 3.4017, "S_ci": [ 3.3576, 3.4463 ], "G": 0.1173, "G_ci": [ 0.1061, 0.1277 ], "rank_ok": true }, "pl_wiki_sci": { "cls": "SCI_PROSE", "base": 1.093, "focus": 3.3444, "fvt": 3.6284, "random": 5.4243, "delta_random": 4.3314, "delta_fvt": 2.5355, "delta_focus": 2.2515, "S": 2.0799, "S_ci": [ 2.0399, 2.1198 ], "G": 0.284, "G_ci": [ 0.2732, 0.2948 ], "rank_ok": true }, "pl_pes": { "cls": "SCI_PROSE", "base": 1.4071, "focus": 3.5075, "fvt": 3.8365, "random": 5.9227, "delta_random": 4.5157, "delta_fvt": 2.4294, "delta_focus": 2.1004, "S": 2.4153, "S_ci": [ 2.3295, 2.5103 ], "G": 0.329, "G_ci": [ 0.303, 0.3535 ], "rank_ok": true }, "pl": { "cls": "GEN_PROSE", "base": 1.2043, "focus": 3.4921, "fvt": 3.8115, "random": 5.4783, "delta_random": 4.2741, "delta_fvt": 2.6073, "delta_focus": 2.2878, "S": 1.9862, "S_ci": [ 1.9268, 2.0638 ], "G": 0.3194, "G_ci": [ 0.3074, 0.3338 ], "rank_ok": true }, "en": { "cls": "GEN_PROSE", "base": 0.8294, "focus": 3.115, "fvt": 3.2515, "random": 6.6051, "delta_random": 5.7757, "delta_fvt": 2.4221, "delta_focus": 2.2856, "S": 3.4901, "S_ci": [ 3.418, 3.5621 ], "G": 0.1365, "G_ci": [ 0.1212, 0.1499 ], "rank_ok": true }, "pl_informal": { "cls": "GEN_PROSE", "base": 1.6948, "focus": 3.803, "fvt": 4.2521, "random": 5.6395, "delta_random": 3.9446, "delta_fvt": 2.5573, "delta_focus": 2.1081, "S": 1.8365, "S_ci": [ 1.7701, 1.9129 ], "G": 0.4492, "G_ci": [ 0.4087, 0.4784 ], "rank_ok": true } }, "H1_formal_damage": { "passed": false, "bin": ">1.15", "detail": { "random": { "mean_formal": 6.8381, "mean_prose": 4.7688, "ratio": 1.434 }, "fvt": { "mean_formal": 2.0111, "mean_prose": 2.5065, "ratio": 0.802 } } }, "H2_ranking": { "passed": true, "bin": ">=7/9", "n_holds": 9 }, "H3_spread_formal": { "passed": true, "bin": ">1.25", "mean_formal_S": 4.9746, "mean_prose_S": 2.535, "ratio": 1.962 }, "H4_focus_gt_fvt": { "passed": false, "mean_formal_G": 0.1477, "mean_prose_G": 0.2726 } }