{ "arm": "gpt-6-luna-openrouter-high", "composite": false, "context": { "baseline_scope": "One submission from seeds, no experiments; expected win rate with uniform MAP tie breaking on scored items, equal weight per headline tier.", "exposure": "Rule catalogs are public and include classes used in experiments while this benchmark was developed. Sealed items hide seed pairs, not the rule universe. This benchmark does not establish contamination-free reasoning.", "prior": "T1-T4 share the 3-piece catalog prior because their tier is not revealed; T5 and T6 use their registered tier classes.", "seed_only_map_win": 0.04655555555555555, "tiers": { "T1": { "manifest_classes": 15, "manifest_families": 5, "scored_classes": 15, "scored_families": 5, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T2": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 7, "scored_classes": 30, "scored_families": 7, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T3": { "manifest_classes": 75, "manifest_families": 10, "scored_classes": 75, "scored_families": 10, "seed_only_map_win": 0.17555555555555555 }, "T4": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 5, "scored_classes": 30, "scored_families": 5, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T5": { "manifest_classes": 50, "manifest_families": 17, "scored_classes": 50, "scored_families": 17, "seed_only_map_win": 0.018333333333333333 }, "T6": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 7, "scored_classes": 30, "scored_families": 7, "seed_only_map_win": 0.03888888888888888 } } }, "families": { "T1": { "count=1-1-and": { "ci": [ 0.22277809550351207, 0.9567281317072582 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": 2.0, "estimate": 0.6666666666666666, "items": 6, "n_eff": 6.0, "scored": 6, "se": 0.16666666666666666 }, "count=2-1-and": { "ci": [ 0.2924017738212866, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": 3, "scored": 6, "se": 0.0 }, "count>=2-1-and": { "ci": [ 0.2924017738212866, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": 3, "scored": 6, "se": 0.0 }, "exists-1-and": { "ci": [ 0.2924017738212866, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": 3, "scored": 6, "se": 0.0 }, "forall-1-and": { "ci": [ 0.2924017738212866, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": 3, "scored": 6, "se": 0.0 } }, "T2": { "count=1-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.34914420558717574, 0.9681459737500557 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": 3.0, "estimate": 0.75, "items": 8, "n_eff": 8.0, "scored": 8, "se": 0.14433756729740643 }, "count=1-2-or": { "ci": [ 0.001991559834161668, 0.5601939493197616 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": 3.0, "estimate": 0.125, "items": 8, "n_eff": 7.0, "scored": 8, "se": 0.125 }, "exists-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.3976353643835254, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": 4, "scored": 8, "se": 0.0 }, "exists-2-or": { "ci": [ 0.31115993085344484, 0.9978049237867372 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": 2.0, "estimate": 0.8333333333333334, "items": 6, "n_eff": 4.999999999999999, "scored": 6, "se": 0.16666666666666666 }, "forall-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.4781762498950183, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 10, "n_eff": 5, "scored": 10, "se": 0.0 }, "forall-2-or": { "ci": [ 0.4439045376923586, 0.9747892736731665 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": 4.0, "estimate": 0.8, "items": 10, "n_eff": 10.0, "scored": 10, "se": 0.1224744871391589 }, "outer-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.3475471499400028, 0.9332604888222653 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": 4.0, "estimate": 0.7, "items": 10, "n_eff": 10.0, "scored": 10, "se": 0.1224744871391589 } }, "T3": { "count=1-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.2803803968239795, 0.8075974954449694 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 9, "df": 8.0, "estimate": 0.5555555555555556, "items": 18, "n_eff": 14.545454545454543, "scored": 18, "se": 0.13028932666176193 }, "count=2-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.3976353643835254, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": 4, "scored": 8, "se": 0.0 }, "count=2-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.6637328831200573, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 9, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": 9, "scored": 18, "se": 0.0 }, "count>=2-2-and": { "ci": [ 0.3976353643835254, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": 4, "scored": 8, "se": 0.0 }, "count>=2-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.6637328831200573, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 9, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": 9, "scored": 18, "se": 0.0 }, "exists-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.6165237631507363, 0.984486396184586 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": 7.0, "estimate": 0.875, "items": 16, "n_eff": 16.0, "scored": 16, "se": 0.08183170883849714 }, "exists-3-or": { "ci": [ 0.6165237631507363, 0.984486396184586 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": 7.0, "estimate": 0.875, "items": 16, "n_eff": 16.0, "scored": 16, "se": 0.08183170883849714 }, "forall-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.6305833524471807, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": 8, "scored": 16, "se": 0.0 }, "forall-3-or": { "ci": [ 0.3737119117341051, 0.9099330966314167 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": 7.0, "estimate": 0.6875, "items": 16, "n_eff": 12.419354838709676, "scored": 16, "se": 0.13152607020228782 }, "outer-3-and": { "ci": [ 0.17786205375914355, 0.8221379462408562 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": 7.0, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 16, "n_eff": 9.333333333333334, "scored": 16, "se": 0.16366341767699427 } }, "T4": { "count=1-3-or": { "ci": [ 0.0014126952347834013, 0.3530149605244596 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 7, "df": 6.0, "estimate": 0.07142857142857142, "items": 14, "n_eff": 13.0, "scored": 14, "se": 0.07142857142857144 }, "count=2-2-or": { "ci": [ 0.001991559834161668, 0.5601939493197616 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": 3.0, "estimate": 0.125, "items": 8, "n_eff": 7.0, "scored": 8, "se": 0.125 }, "count=2-3-or": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.4096163972250032 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 7, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 14, "n_eff": 7, "scored": 14, "se": 0.0 }, "count>=2-2-or": { "ci": [ 0.031854026249944226, 0.6508557944128239 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": 3.0, "estimate": 0.25, "items": 8, "n_eff": 8.0, "scored": 8, "se": 0.14433756729740643 }, "count>=2-3-or": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.369416647552819 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": 8, "scored": 16, "se": 0.0 } }, "T5": { "K01": { "ci": [ 0.1319320462682399, 0.9979079843994643 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": 1.0, "estimate": 0.75, "items": 4, "n_eff": 3.0, "scored": 4, "se": 0.25 }, "K02": { "ci": [ 0.14593007769157212, 0.6547524414722261 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 8, "df": 7.0, "estimate": 0.375, "items": 16, "n_eff": 15.0, "scored": 16, "se": 0.125 }, "K03": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K04": { "ci": [ 0.001991559834161668, 0.5601939493197616 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": 3.0, "estimate": 0.125, "items": 8, "n_eff": 7.0, "scored": 8, "se": 0.125 }, "K05": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K06": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.3362671168799426 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 9, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": 9, "scored": 18, "se": 0.0 }, "S04": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S05": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S06": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S07": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S08": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S09": { "ci": [ 0.012579117093425053, 0.9874208829065749 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 4, "n_eff": 2, "scored": 4, "se": 0.0 }, "S11": { "ci": [ 0.1319320462682399, 0.9979079843994643 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": 1.0, "estimate": 0.75, "items": 4, "n_eff": 3.0, "scored": 4, "se": 0.25 }, "S12": { "ci": [ 0.08657146910143443, 0.4910458717079572 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 10, "df": 9.0, "estimate": 0.25, "items": 20, "n_eff": 20.0, "scored": 20, "se": 0.08333333333333334 }, "X01": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.8418861169915808 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": 2, "scored": 4, "se": 0.0 }, "X02": { "ci": [ 0.002092015600535833, 0.8680679537317599 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": 1.0, "estimate": 0.25, "items": 4, "n_eff": 3.0, "scored": 4, "se": 0.25 }, "X04": { "ci": [ 0.1319320462682399, 0.9979079843994643 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": 1.0, "estimate": 0.75, "items": 4, "n_eff": 3.0, "scored": 4, "se": 0.25 } }, "T6": { "C08": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.6023646356164742 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 4, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": 4, "scored": 8, "se": 0.0 }, "C09": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.7075982261787133 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": 3, "scored": 6, "se": 0.0 }, "C11": { "ci": [ 0.0, 0.4096163972250032 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 7, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 14, "n_eff": 7, "scored": 14, "se": 0.0 }, "C13": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C16": { "ci": [ 0.06409204771766652, 0.47637276573648035 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 9, "df": 8.0, "estimate": 0.2222222222222222, "items": 18, "n_eff": 18.0, "scored": 18, "se": 0.08784104611578832 }, "C17": { "ci": [ 0.4439045376923586, 0.9747892736731665 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": 4.0, "estimate": 0.8, "items": 10, "n_eff": 10.0, "scored": 10, "se": 0.1224744871391589 }, "C18": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } } }, "files": [ { "composite": false, "configurations": [ { "settings": { "backend": "openai-chat-completions", "guided": null, "model": "openai/gpt-6-luna", "sampling": { "max_tokens": 65536, "reasoning": { "effort": "high" } } }, "sha256": "1f71454157800f79dd91b01535ac855a63bc8fcf40a920ceec89233994715130" } ], "end": null, "finished": 57, "path": "experiments/E01-dev-baseline/results/runs/gpt-6-luna-openrouter-high.jsonl", "player": "model", "reply_policy": "action-object-v1", "sha256": "eead7cfcfbbfd51fed1679f0dff7b651c276c8d8e6415ef01727b4f06ae70fab", "truncated": false }, { "composite": false, "configurations": [ { "settings": { "backend": "openai-chat-completions", "guided": null, "model": "openai/gpt-6-luna", "sampling": { "max_tokens": 65536, "reasoning": { "effort": "high" } } }, "sha256": "1f71454157800f79dd91b01535ac855a63bc8fcf40a920ceec89233994715130" } ], "end": "complete", "finished": 403, "path": "experiments/E01-dev-baseline/results/runs/gpt-6-luna-openrouter-high.part2.jsonl", "player": "model", "reply_policy": "action-object-v1", "sha256": "7b06d2b3214eaa4049f3ae272d3988e16b63bf609a604a1f5f9f2642ef7df63a", "truncated": false } ], "headline": { "ci": [ 0.4053232072117378, 0.4963652229456103 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard-mover", "classes": 215, "complete": true, "df": 77.17785923611719, "estimate": 0.44933333333333336, "finished": 430, "items": 430, "missing": [], "n_eff": null, "over_cap": {}, "se": 0.02046501255354462, "unscored_cap": 0.05, "withheld": null }, "kind": "score", "malformed": { "T1": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 1 }, "decisions": 347, "games": 30, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.02631578947368421, "invalid_submissions": 1, "invalid_turns": 1, "malformed_rate": 0.002881844380403458 }, "T2": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 7 }, "decisions": 911, "games": 60, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.07446808510638298, "invalid_submissions": 7, "invalid_turns": 7, "malformed_rate": 0.007683863885839737 }, "T3": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 29 }, "decisions": 2358, "games": 150, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.12340425531914893, "invalid_submissions": 29, "invalid_turns": 29, "malformed_rate": 0.012298558100084818 }, "T4": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 35 }, "decisions": 1391, "games": 60, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.3119266055045872, "invalid_submissions": 34, "invalid_turns": 35, "malformed_rate": 0.02516175413371675 }, "T5": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 29 }, "decisions": 2019, "games": 100, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.16292134831460675, "invalid_submissions": 29, "invalid_turns": 29, "malformed_rate": 0.014363546310054482 }, "T6": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 28 }, "decisions": 1416, "games": 60, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.2621359223300971, "invalid_submissions": 27, "invalid_turns": 28, "malformed_rate": 0.01977401129943503 }, "all": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 129 }, "decisions": 8442, "games": 460, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.16776750330250992, "invalid_submissions": 127, "invalid_turns": 129, "malformed_rate": 0.015280739161336177 }, "headline": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 128 }, "decisions": 8095, "games": 430, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.17524339360222532, "invalid_submissions": 126, "invalid_turns": 128, "malformed_rate": 0.015812229771463866 } }, "manifest_sha256": "6b98d1a59d5f7d3b09b12f9840c83405e6ea2925d71911a10ab572e39facc278", "player": "model", "schema": "zendo-bench-v1-score", "split": "dev", "templates": {}, "tiers": { "T1": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.7776772007145272, 0.9920083411190723 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 15, "df": 13.999999999999998, "estimate": 0.9333333333333333, "finished": 30, "items": 30, "n_eff": 29.568802067889923, "scored": 30, "se": 0.0454256762579498, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 28 }, "T2": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.6072540300990839, 0.8616707474463017 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 30, "df": 20.440604751619865, "estimate": 0.75, "finished": 60, "items": 60, "n_eff": 49.91501311776149, "scored": 60, "se": 0.06009252125773315, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 45 }, "T3": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.7616485943073072, 0.8905761490410979 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 75, "df": 28.898278983756338, "estimate": 0.8333333333333334, "finished": 150, "items": 150, "n_eff": 141.93003737400406, "scored": 150, "se": 0.029973533298773745, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 125 }, "T4": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.016464501139950884, 0.17053709960580893 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 30, "df": 12.00708800945068, "estimate": 0.06666666666666667, "finished": 60, "items": 60, "n_eff": 52.868326024752804, "scored": 60, "se": 0.029546842014263944, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 4 }, "T5": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.23830008748508358, 0.432287721587438 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 50, "df": 35.96907975734802, "estimate": 0.33, "finished": 100, "items": 100, "n_eff": 97.98741179127332, "scored": 100, "se": 0.04508129581459735, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 33 }, "T6": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.1572224575006682, 0.4019479491881309 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 30, "df": 16.200836820083683, "estimate": 0.26666666666666666, "finished": 60, "items": 60, "n_eff": 55.84733919932777, "scored": 60, "se": 0.055277079839256664, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 0, "unscored": 0, "wins": 16 } }, "verified": true, "w0": { "bands": [ "w0=0", "0=0.5" ], "pooled": { "0=0.5": { "ci": [ 0.4385128267500198, 0.966881620049437 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard-mover", "classes": 21, "df": 2.1422143587084177, "estimate": 0.7569444444444444, "n_eff": null, "se": 0.11304736525069241 } }, "tiers": { "T1": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T2": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T3": { "0=0.5": { "ci": [ 0.6313268427037997, 0.9995731629691025 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 16, "df": 6.0, "estimate": 0.9375, "items": 27, "n_eff": 11.381636828152933, "scored": 27, "se": 0.0625 } }, "T4": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T5": { "0=0.5": { "ci": [ 0.158113883008419, 1.0 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 2, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": 2, "scored": 2, "se": 0.0 } }, "T6": { "0=0.5": { "ci": [ 0.0015592835712882093, 0.9600784822958319 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": 2.0, "estimate": 0.3333333333333333, "items": 3, "n_eff": 2.0, "scored": 3, "se": 0.33333333333333337 } } } } }