{ "arm": "qwen3.5-4b-mlx-force16", "composite": false, "context": { "baseline_scope": "One submission from seeds, no experiments; expected win rate with uniform MAP tie breaking on scored items, equal weight per headline tier.", "exposure": "Rule catalogs are public and include classes used in experiments while this benchmark was developed. Sealed items hide seed pairs, not the rule universe. This benchmark does not establish contamination-free reasoning.", "prior": "T1-T4 share the 3-piece catalog prior because their tier is not revealed; T5 and T6 use their registered tier classes.", "seed_only_map_win": 0.03302521008403361, "tiers": { "T1": { "manifest_classes": 15, "manifest_families": 5, "scored_classes": 5, "scored_families": 5, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T2": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 7, "scored_classes": 7, "scored_families": 7, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T3": { "manifest_classes": 75, "manifest_families": 10, "scored_classes": 10, "scored_families": 10, "seed_only_map_win": 0.1 }, "T4": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 5, "scored_classes": 5, "scored_families": 5, "seed_only_map_win": 0.0 }, "T5": { "manifest_classes": 50, "manifest_families": 17, "scored_classes": 17, "scored_families": 17, "seed_only_map_win": 0.029411764705882353 }, "T6": { "manifest_classes": 30, "manifest_families": 7, "scored_classes": 7, "scored_families": 7, "seed_only_map_win": 0.03571428571428571 } } }, "families": { "T1": { "count=1-1-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=2-1-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count>=2-1-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "exists-1-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "forall-1-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T2": { "count=1-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=1-2-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "exists-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "exists-2-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "forall-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 10, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "forall-2-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 10, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "outer-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 10, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T3": { "count=1-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=2-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=2-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count>=2-2-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count>=2-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "exists-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "exists-3-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "forall-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "forall-3-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "outer-3-and": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T4": { "count=1-3-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 14, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=2-2-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count=2-3-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 14, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count>=2-2-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "count>=2-3-or": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T5": { "K01": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K02": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 16, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K03": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K04": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K05": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "K06": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S04": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S05": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 1.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S06": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S07": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S08": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S09": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S11": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "S12": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 20, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "X01": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "X02": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "X04": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 4, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T6": { "C08": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 8, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C09": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 6, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C11": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 14, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C13": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C16": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 18, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C17": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.5, "items": 10, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null }, "C18": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } } }, "files": [ { "composite": false, "configurations": [ { "settings": { "agent": "e02-intervention-v1", "agent_config": { "arm": "force16", "force_experiments": 16, "show_consistent_rules": false }, "agent_source_sha256": "ded59be23e3d236c3c63210803e7e3c1e0c4583663fd9c60c4345b84c275c4b6", "backend": "mlx", "decoding": { "action_allowance": 2048, "action_temperature": 1.0, "min_p": 0.0, "presence_penalty": 1.5, "seed": 0, "temperature": 1.0, "thinking": true, "thinking_budget": 63487, "top_k": 20, "top_p": 0.95 }, "local_model": { "model": "Qwen/Qwen3.5-4B", "model_sha256": "76eef3317d2e81bba118981981c38e0ccbd267fdcda9689e531a20ebdc3703a2", "revision": "851bf6e806efd8d0a36b00ddf55e13ccb7b8cd0a", "tokenizer_sha256": "2cc0b586a258eb03d2369016d2dbd0422d7eb86ee8a2cfcfb6fe037a11dcc543" }, "model": "Qwen/Qwen3.5-4B", "model_sha256": "76eef3317d2e81bba118981981c38e0ccbd267fdcda9689e531a20ebdc3703a2", "revision": "851bf6e806efd8d0a36b00ddf55e13ccb7b8cd0a", "settings": { "compile_threads": 8, "completion_batch_size": 36, "prefill_batch_size": 1 }, "tokenizer_sha256": "2cc0b586a258eb03d2369016d2dbd0422d7eb86ee8a2cfcfb6fe037a11dcc543" }, "sha256": "2eb1dd2da92ecf1b92ed258db2f0249cb4d59b6b11f04ce343517324f78da8a9" } ], "end": "complete", "finished": 102, "path": "experiments/E02-small-model-interventions/results/runs/qwen3.5-4b-mlx-force16.jsonl", "player": "agent-tools", "reply_policy": "action-object-v1", "sha256": "43af03bdd5efb6cf826ddc59fb424d17d370ae4c8d8377c38a83d6af459443f4", "truncated": false } ], "headline": { "ci": [ 0.1143177161395354, 0.3477567196985253 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard-mover", "classes": 46, "complete": false, "df": 21.644026812109338, "estimate": 0.19100840336134456, "finished": 92, "items": 430, "missing": [], "n_eff": null, "over_cap": {}, "se": 0.046224140219628236, "unscored_cap": 0.05, "withheld": null }, "kind": "score", "malformed": { "T1": { "by_kind": {}, "decisions": 179, "games": 10, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 0, "malformed_rate": 0.0 }, "T2": { "by_kind": {}, "decisions": 251, "games": 14, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 0, "malformed_rate": 0.0 }, "T3": { "by_kind": {}, "decisions": 362, "games": 20, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 0, "malformed_rate": 0.0 }, "T4": { "by_kind": {}, "decisions": 182, "games": 10, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 0, "malformed_rate": 0.0 }, "T5": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 1 }, "decisions": 618, "games": 34, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 1, "malformed_rate": 0.0016181229773462784 }, "T6": { "by_kind": {}, "decisions": 256, "games": 14, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 0, "malformed_rate": 0.0 }, "all": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 1 }, "decisions": 1848, "games": 102, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 1, "malformed_rate": 0.0005411255411255411 }, "headline": { "by_kind": { "schema_error": 1 }, "decisions": 1669, "games": 92, "invalid_submission_rate": 0.0, "invalid_submissions": 0, "invalid_turns": 1, "malformed_rate": 0.0005991611743559018 } }, "manifest_sha256": "6b98d1a59d5f7d3b09b12f9840c83405e6ea2925d71911a10ab572e39facc278", "player": "agent-tools", "schema": "zendo-bench-v1-score", "split": "dev", "templates": {}, "tiers": { "T1": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.3475471499400028, 0.9332604888222653 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": 4.0, "estimate": 0.7, "finished": 10, "items": 30, "n_eff": 10.0, "scored": 10, "se": 0.1224744871391589, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 20, "unscored": 0, "wins": 7 }, "T2": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.10751149065767968, 0.6828243640218772 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 7, "df": 6.0, "estimate": 0.35714285714285715, "finished": 14, "items": 60, "n_eff": 11.25, "scored": 14, "se": 0.14285714285714285, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 46, "unscored": 0, "wins": 5 }, "T3": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.09368762332302213, 0.6944364338287459 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 10, "df": 9.0, "estimate": 0.35, "finished": 20, "items": 150, "n_eff": 10.11111111111111, "scored": 20, "se": 0.15, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 130, "unscored": 0, "wins": 7 }, "T4": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.0, 0.5218237501049814 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 5, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "finished": 10, "items": 60, "n_eff": 5, "scored": 10, "se": 0.0, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 50, "unscored": 0, "wins": 0 }, "T5": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.05763262639821003, 0.37129113462140173 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 17, "df": 16.0, "estimate": 0.17647058823529413, "finished": 34, "items": 100, "n_eff": 26.880000000000003, "scored": 34, "se": 0.07352941176470588, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 66, "unscored": 0, "wins": 6 }, "T6": { "abandoned": 0, "ci": [ 0.0014126952347834013, 0.3530149605244596 ], "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 7, "df": 6.0, "estimate": 0.07142857142857142, "finished": 14, "items": 60, "n_eff": 13.0, "scored": 14, "se": 0.07142857142857144, "timing_unverifiable": 0, "unfinished": 46, "unscored": 0, "wins": 1 } }, "verified": true, "w0": { "bands": [ "w0=0", "0=0.5" ], "pooled": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 3, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "n_eff": null, "se": null } }, "tiers": { "T1": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T2": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T3": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 27, "n_eff": null, "scored": 2, "se": null } }, "T4": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 0, "df": null, "estimate": null, "items": 0, "n_eff": null, "scored": 0, "se": null } }, "T5": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 2, "n_eff": null, "scored": 1, "se": null } }, "T6": { "0=0.5": { "ci": null, "ci_method": "korn-graubard", "classes": 1, "df": null, "estimate": 0.0, "items": 3, "n_eff": null, "scored": 1, "se": null } } } } }