--- title: "Filament vs a Custom Admin Panel for a Large Laravel SaaS" description: "Filament or a custom Inertia or Livewire admin for a large Laravel SaaS? Trade-offs on speed, customization, design, upgrades, testing, hiring and tenancy." pageClass: blog-page date: 2026-11-21 author: annu-gupta category: frontend tags: [Filament, Admin Panel, Inertia] --- # Filament vs a Custom Inertia or Livewire Admin for a Large Laravel SaaS: The Trade-offs Your SaaS is growing. The admin started as three screens, and now support wants refunds, impersonation, tenant notes and an audit view. You're deciding whether to build the next twenty admin screens in Filament or in the same Inertia or Livewire stack as your customer app. This post is for teams at that point. We compare the two options factor by factor: speed to first screen, how far you can customize, design consistency, upgrades across major versions, testing, hiring and multi-tenancy. If you're still sorting out what Filament and Inertia are, start with [Filament vs Inertia](/blog/filament-vs-inertia.html), which covers the basics and how to run both in one app. A note on bias: we make a starter kit whose admin is custom-built, and we explain that choice in [why we didn't use Filament](/blog/why-no-filament-multi-tenant-saas-kit.html). Here we try to stay neutral, and we say where Filament is the better choice. Versions: Laravel 13, Filament 5, Inertia v3, Livewire 4. ## What "custom admin" means here By a custom admin we mean admin screens built with the same tools as the customer app: - **Custom Inertia admin.** Laravel controllers returning Vue, React or Svelte pages, usually with a component library like shadcn-vue, shadcn/ui or shadcn-svelte. - **Custom Livewire admin.** Plain Livewire components with Blade and a component library such as Flux UI. Filament is built on Livewire too, so the Livewire comparison is closer than it looks. The difference is that Filament gives you a framework for panels (resources, forms, tables, actions), while a custom Livewire admin is just components you write. ## First question: which admin? "Admin" covers two different things in a large SaaS, and the answer can differ for each: 1. **The staff back office.** Your support and operations team. Nobody outside the company sees it. 2. **The customer's admin.** In a B2B product, a customer's admin invites users, sets roles and changes workspace settings. That's part of the product they pay for. Most of the trade-offs below depend on which of the two you're building. ## Speed to first screen **Filament wins, clearly.** You generate a resource for a model and get a table, a create form and an edit form with very little code. Filters, bulk actions and notifications are a few lines each. A custom admin needs a route, a controller, validation, a page and a table component for each screen. The first screen is slow. The tenth is faster, because you copy your own table and form patterns, but it never gets as fast as generating a resource. If you need a working back office this week, this factor alone often decides it. ## Customization ceiling **A custom admin wins, at a cost.** With your own pages there's no framework model to fit into. A multi-step wizard, a drag-and-drop board or a chart that reacts to filters is built the same way as any other screen. Filament is very flexible within its model, and it has themes and a large plugin ecosystem (its site listed 1.3K+ community plugins as of November 2026). But when a screen is far from "table plus form", you're working through extension points rather than writing a page. That's fine for a few screens. It gets tiring when most of your admin is unusual. ## Design consistency with the customer app For the staff back office, this rarely matters. Your team doesn't need the admin to match the marketing site. For the customer's admin it matters a lot. If a customer goes from your app's dashboard to "Manage users" and lands in a different-looking interface, it feels like two products. With a custom admin, both sides share one set of components, so this comes for free. With Filament, you can share brand colors and use a theme, but matching your app exactly takes ongoing effort. ## Upgrade path across major versions Both options need upgrade work. The shape is different. With **Filament**, you follow Filament's major versions in addition to Laravel's and Livewire's. When we checked in November 2026, Filament 5 required PHP 8.2+, Laravel v11.28+ and Tailwind CSS v4.1+ ([installation docs](https://filamentphp.com/docs/5.x/introduction/installation)). Each plugin you use also has to support the new major version before you can upgrade, so check that list before you plan the move. With a **custom admin**, you upgrade Laravel, Inertia or Livewire, and your JavaScript framework, which you were doing for the customer app anyway. shadcn-style components are copied into your repo, so you update them when you choose. You own more code, so there's more code to touch, but there's no extra framework layer in the middle. ## Testing Business logic should live in service classes either way. Then the most important tests, the ones for what an action does, look the same whatever the UI is. Our [Pest testing guide](/blog/laravel-saas-testing-pest.html) shows that style. The UI tests differ: - **Custom Inertia:** HTTP feature tests that hit the route and assert the page component and its props. - **Custom Livewire:** Livewire component tests that set properties and call actions. - **Filament:** panels run on Livewire, so screen tests are Livewire component tests too. None of these is hard. The real risk is logic hidden inside Filament resource closures or Livewire components, where your customer app can't reuse it and only UI tests cover it. ## Hiring and learning curve A Laravel developer who already knows Filament is productive in a panel on day one. One who doesn't has to learn its resources, forms, tables and actions. That's a reasonable amount to learn, and it's well documented. A custom Inertia admin needs frontend skills in Vue, React or Svelte. A custom Livewire admin needs Livewire and Blade. If your customer app is already built that way, your team already has those skills. The awkward case is mixing: an Inertia app with a Filament admin means new hires need both a JavaScript framework and Filament to work across the product. That's common and workable, but it's worth counting. ## Multi-tenancy fit Filament has tenancy built in. Its [tenancy docs](https://filamentphp.com/docs/5.x/users/tenancy) (checked November 2026) describe users who belong to many tenants, a tenant switcher and `canAccessTenant()` checks, with examples that scope records by a tenant foreign key like `team_id`. Multi-database tenancy isn't mentioned. If your SaaS is team-based on a shared database, that's a good match. If you use a database per tenant with a package like stancl/tenancy, Filament can still work, but you wire it up yourself. Our [Filament vs Inertia](/blog/filament-vs-inertia.html) post covers the middleware details. Some kits do this work for you: SaaSykit Tenancy, for example, ships a plugin that integrates Tenancy for Laravel with Filament for its multi-database mode ([their docs](https://saasykit.com/docs/multi-tenancy/multi-database-tenancy), November 2026). A custom admin has no tenancy of its own. It uses whatever your backend does, which is simpler when your tenancy is unusual. For the bigger picture, see [single vs multi-database tenancy](/blog/single-vs-multi-database-tenancy-laravel.html). ## What about performance? We haven't found a sourced benchmark comparing Filament with a custom admin, so we won't guess. In practice, admin screens are usually slow because of queries, not the UI layer: missing indexes, N+1 queries on big tables, unbounded counts. Measure your own heaviest screens, and see our [N+1 queries guide](/blog/laravel-n-plus-one-queries.html) for the usual fixes. ## Decision table | Factor | Filament | Custom Inertia admin | Custom Livewire admin | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Speed to first screen | Fastest | Slowest | In between | | Customization ceiling | High within its model | No framework limit | No framework limit | | Matches the customer app | Needs a custom theme | Yes, if the app is Inertia | Yes, if the app is Livewire | | Upgrade work | Laravel, Livewire, Filament and plugins | Laravel, Inertia, JS framework | Laravel, Livewire | | UI tests | Livewire tests | HTTP feature tests | Livewire tests | | Skills needed | Laravel and Filament | Laravel and Vue, React or Svelte | Laravel, Livewire and Blade | | Built-in tenancy | Team-style, scoped by foreign key | None; uses your backend | None; uses your backend | | Plugin ecosystem | Large | Laravel and JS packages | Laravel packages | ## When Filament wins - The admin is a staff back office, and nobody outside your company sees it. - It's CRUD-heavy: many models, tables, filters and bulk actions. - You need it working soon, and your team knows Filament or is happy to learn it. - Your tenancy is team-based on a shared database. - It's an internal tool or an admin-only app, where the panel is the product. ## When a custom admin wins - Your customers use the admin, and it has to look like the rest of your product. - Many screens are unusual: wizards, builders, live dashboards. - You want one stack and one set of conventions across the codebase. - You use a database per tenant, or another tenancy setup Filament doesn't model. - You'd rather upgrade fewer layers, even if you own more code. ## The mixed setup Many teams end up with both: a custom admin for everything customers see, and Filament for staff tooling on its own path or domain. That's a sensible split, as long as both sides call the same service classes. If you go this way, decide where each new screen belongs up front, or you'll have the same feature half-built in both. For the wider picture, see [Best Laravel SaaS starter kits in 2026, compared](/blog/best-laravel-saas-starter-kits.html). ## Frequently asked questions ### Is Filament good for a large SaaS? Yes, for the staff back office and for team-based products where a panel-style UI fits. It's less of a fit when customers use the admin and it must match a custom product UI, or when your tenancy is database-per-tenant. ### Is a custom admin panel worth the extra work? It is when the admin is part of what customers pay for, or when most screens don't fit a table-and-form model. For a purely internal back office, it usually isn't. ### Can I start with Filament and move to a custom admin later? You can, and it's easier if your business logic lives in services rather than inside Filament resources. Then moving a screen means rebuilding the UI, not the logic. ### Is Filament faster than Inertia? We don't have a sourced benchmark either way. Query design usually matters more than the UI layer, so measure your own screens. ## Where SaaS Laravel fits SaaS Laravel takes the custom-admin route in all four kits. The central admin (tenants, domains, admin users, roles, menus, tenant maintenance) and each tenant's admin (users, roles, menus, layout settings) are built in the kit's own stack: [Vue](/kits/vue.html), [React](/kits/react.html), [Svelte](/kits/svelte.html) or [Livewire](/kits/livewire.html), on a database-per-tenant backend. The [architecture docs](/docs/core/architecture.html) show the controller, service and page pattern every screen follows. It's not the right choice if you want a Filament admin ready on day one, or if your product is an internal tool where Filament alone would be quicker. Billing isn't included either. Prices are on the [pricing page](/pricing.html).