player_type,row_label,column_key,elo,se_elo,appearances,share,p_value_vs_ref,p_text,cell_text,color_position
Null,Null,General,1311.4423726797052,19.578746972118168,48.0,,4.963960665368781e-21,<0.001,1311***,0.3245511306617103
Null,Null,Domination,1366.2868896914174,37.362912159103985,11.0,25.0,0.00035850384716310706,<0.001,1366***,0.3755827894487841
Null,Null,Diplomatic,1135.739625821036,45.498123789554,12.0,27.27272727272727,3.657569006280472e-16,<0.001,1136***,0.16106345469715777
Null,Null,Science,1393.5062016527909,28.132762381848842,21.0,47.72727272727273,0.010800186373814172,0.011,1394*,0.40090978139102496
Vanilla,Vanilla,General,1500.0,4.266028215984963,5202.0,,,,1500,0.5
Vanilla,Vanilla,Domination,1500.2530049727138,3.6135466495711372,1701.0,32.69896193771626,,,1500,0.5002354157560766
Vanilla,Vanilla,Culture,1525.3860798566789,6.071578625104767,414.0,7.958477508650519,,,1525,0.5236212083864424
Vanilla,Vanilla,Diplomatic,1508.2121399077319,4.349545919933817,1016.0,19.530949634755864,,,1508,0.5076412218489149
Vanilla,Vanilla,Science,1466.1487752628755,4.543926398856407,2071.0,39.811610918877356,,,1466,0.46850215400856604
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Every-turn,General,1422.6055868661754,17.417876929751717,48.0,,1.5900575791086228e-05,<0.001,1423***,0.427986141582253
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1444.8728069291067,34.89290565839139,10.0,20.833333333333336,0.11440381891670999,0.114,1445,0.4487053171407783
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1305.7379669169532,39.327282960350935,10.0,20.833333333333336,3.395034845088236e-08,<0.001,1306***,0.31924330219809904
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1449.2492826007,24.74261659176238,21.0,43.75,0.018922245119405667,0.019,1449*,0.45277753484514777
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1610.2865377662574,46.004857843674195,7.0,14.583333333333334,0.0018212791214121306,0.002,1610**,0.6026192821224676
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple-Per-5,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Per-5,General,1382.164967845655,17.8597076740953,48.0,,1.3872846004151964e-10,<0.001,1382***,0.39035700409613894
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple-Per-5,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1477.1578464188535,28.22290227303667,16.0,33.33333333333333,0.41697146121107564,0.417,1477,0.4787458610080189
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple-Per-5,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1340.5652971154332,38.34894928165868,9.0,18.75,1.9344235115131435e-06,<0.001,1341***,0.3516493935996157
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple-Per-5,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1289.8773633347919,30.470855528441064,16.0,33.33333333333333,1.3079930702802225e-12,<0.001,1290***,0.30448534726909415
GPT-OSS-120B-Simple-Per-5,GPT-OSS-120B-Simple | Per-5,Science,1426.7135874207195,42.686303993633366,7.0,14.583333333333334,0.3582803025881728,0.358,1427,0.4318085488896569
Opus-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Opus-5.5-Simple | Per-5,General,1593.840091903046,16.977338725550034,48.0,,8.288893124103267e-08,<0.001,1594***,0.5873162133877707
Opus-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Opus-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1520.6896906029335,34.61335686505728,10.0,22.727272727272727,0.5570450126227204,0.557,1521,0.5192513178853149
Opus-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Opus-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1642.405597617852,25.36976567034218,21.0,47.72727272727273,7.2613346647059365e-06,<0.001,1642***,0.6325053854599834
Opus-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Opus-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Science,1532.5298846602905,28.73424319697752,13.0,29.545454545454547,0.022499992041565463,0.022,1533*,0.5302683671006219
Sonnet-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Sonnet-5.5-Simple | Per-5,General,1495.586997589378,16.63069954826309,48.0,,0.7971547201625393,0.797,1496,0.49589379494038927
Sonnet-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Sonnet-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1458.437993454983,43.57845509946949,6.0,13.333333333333334,0.33894484365911626,0.339,1458,0.4613274352282381
Sonnet-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Sonnet-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1536.382684909788,19.12943098059356,32.0,71.11111111111111,0.5837492814565932,0.584,1536,0.5338533159418182
Sonnet-5.5-Simple-Per-5,Sonnet-5.5-Simple | Per-5,Science,1443.9543126519366,46.23072002031731,7.0,15.555555555555555,0.6328081134862515,0.633,1444,0.4478506777145543
GLM-5.1-Simple,GLM-5.1-Simple | Every-turn,General,1482.8755534038896,16.873395924010175,48.0,,0.3251552919343146,0.325,1483,0.48406606597659435
GLM-5.1-Simple,GLM-5.1-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1509.3575643829977,27.916862007566653,16.0,33.33333333333333,0.7463673795085504,0.746,1509,0.5087070150069739
GLM-5.1-Simple,GLM-5.1-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1416.6623704857923,29.0876459592198,15.0,31.25,0.0002532636572901479,<0.001,1417***,0.4224561049086383
GLM-5.1-Simple,GLM-5.1-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1091.7416731796873,74.54608137319573,6.0,12.5,2.4432746786489186e-08,<0.001,1092***,0.12012429379537332
GLM-5.1-Simple,GLM-5.1-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1722.1725884829657,41.55227984155555,11.0,22.916666666666664,9.069900664969423e-10,<0.001,1722***,0.7067268770893256
GLM-5.2-Simple,GLM-5.2-Simple | Every-turn,General,1536.2662695826778,17.06604208761331,48.0,,0.03924398588192814,0.039,1536*,0.533744993951319
GLM-5.2-Simple,GLM-5.2-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1420.4761784583923,31.136365306345965,14.0,31.818181818181817,0.01092486798815749,0.011,1420*,0.4260047722639471
GLM-5.2-Simple,GLM-5.2-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1545.9763707737459,27.07080150155249,16.0,36.36363636363637,0.45798382559767614,0.458,1546,0.542780036974211
GLM-5.2-Simple,GLM-5.2-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1618.4299154618643,29.32971453639626,14.0,31.818181818181817,2.884626026319442e-07,<0.001,1618***,0.6101965221927509
GLM-5.2-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.2-Simple | Per-5,General,1495.0137405919922,17.205748625537307,48.0,,0.7784919207397805,0.778,1495,0.49536039147397454
GLM-5.2-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.2-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1535.1212196366005,29.751094715926897,14.0,29.166666666666668,0.24464805740948536,0.245,1535,0.5326795492847192
GLM-5.2-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.2-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1506.106579943297,26.18492340692328,16.0,33.33333333333333,0.47321782521765154,0.473,1506,0.5056820430008668
GLM-5.2-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.2-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1140.3826550689196,71.39991584022833,5.0,10.416666666666668,2.716163445656887e-07,<0.001,1140***,0.16538369484560866
GLM-5.2-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.2-Simple | Per-5,Science,1554.988717855143,29.99145001080026,13.0,27.083333333333332,0.0034032545907474137,0.003,1555**,0.5511658346106515
GLM-5.3-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Simple | Per-5,General,1633.5713511093545,17.48618931668838,48.0,,1.162198874445934e-13,<0.001,1634***,0.6242853066257352
GLM-5.3-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1596.8854939315488,28.55191228893429,16.0,33.33333333333333,0.0007860383643826408,<0.001,1597***,0.59014989532456
GLM-5.3-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1655.6093252179958,31.152194116508635,12.0,25.0,4.0778451674349555e-05,<0.001,1656***,0.6447911736904479
GLM-5.3-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1565.0456506699236,39.54542182361009,7.0,14.583333333333334,0.15313205130498023,0.153,1565,0.5605235970965314
GLM-5.3-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Simple | Per-5,Science,1660.5231085821183,31.96176915053897,13.0,27.083333333333332,1.7342670653470683e-09,<0.001,1661***,0.6493633447962296
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,General,1470.6517735525645,16.93092242119532,48.0,,0.0927874305785222,0.093,1471,0.4726920983231292
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1445.3941783883665,29.6270620833248,14.0,29.166666666666668,0.06605872663332432,0.066,1445,0.44919044221544324
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1489.0560996028644,22.585734622242896,24.0,50.0,0.12033072357818456,0.120,1489,0.4898169330081423
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1474.4638328136803,45.137364192210526,5.0,10.416666666666668,0.45673572308650956,0.457,1474,0.4762391385395254
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1476.8754315958897,46.413780190391925,5.0,10.416666666666668,0.8180842567698304,0.818,1477,0.47848308001062545
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Per-5,General,1435.1617305611612,17.6360249019895,48.0,,0.0003523630548291875,<0.001,1435***,0.4396693667365041
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1446.5435500627973,29.84752035490578,15.0,34.090909090909086,0.07403178139803164,0.074,1447,0.4502599081585302
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1385.6783171379602,24.995799287840363,23.0,52.27272727272727,5.594005651741179e-08,<0.001,1386***,0.39362610102786033
GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple-Per-5,GLM-5.3-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Science,1666.8530151225405,49.38744336580314,6.0,13.636363636363635,5.1927040067405874e-05,<0.001,1667***,0.6552531884547289
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Every-turn,General,1472.954157055086,16.847771724207593,48.0,,0.11966201288482728,0.120,1473,0.47483441729500697
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1479.9750682551776,28.869437831274233,15.0,32.608695652173914,0.4858259444041543,0.486,1480,0.4813672261200151
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1507.4814151705018,21.531422156821286,26.0,56.52173913043478,0.42350925429322406,0.424,1507,0.5069612979934521
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1417.8321010420023,47.81181153927374,5.0,10.869565217391305,0.314402926904233,0.314,1418,0.4235445143590228
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Per-5,General,1446.479384499777,17.31466979789713,48.0,,0.0026882758639709967,0.003,1446**,0.4502002034643084
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1450.53969905706,27.886321126894764,15.0,32.608695652173914,0.07707230765897108,0.077,1451,0.4539782399635851
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1434.4907953672537,23.576222879092867,25.0,54.347826086956516,0.0001887928837871359,<0.001,1434***,0.43904507578183277
MiniMax-M2.7-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M2.7-Simple | Per-5,Science,1530.8527561105334,42.23092780593966,6.0,13.043478260869565,0.12767013113530815,0.128,1531,0.528707834588776
MiniMax-M3-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M3-Simple | Per-5,General,1446.9235734664508,17.632380592315677,48.0,,0.0034362230638829414,0.003,1447**,0.45061351186812626
MiniMax-M3-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M3-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1436.7837635140113,27.49079422951206,17.0,40.476190476190474,0.022076165255795498,0.022,1437*,0.4411786339650505
MiniMax-M3-Simple-Per-5,MiniMax-M3-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1467.1948256515286,23.37490239054474,25.0,59.523809523809526,0.015973578689211385,0.016,1467*,0.4694754816886409
Kimi-K2.7-Simple,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Every-turn,General,1574.3869024659296,17.061605073114695,48.0,,2.3401531876637695e-05,<0.001,1574***,0.5692154335876088
Kimi-K2.7-Simple,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1598.3341294397276,37.140371260355735,9.0,18.75,0.0085784750489581,0.009,1598**,0.591497819911888
Kimi-K2.7-Simple,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1755.3555840322765,50.426252290618585,7.0,14.583333333333334,5.959844045098073e-06,<0.001,1755***,0.7376029500073128
Kimi-K2.7-Simple,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1473.0338340668916,41.223350349722885,6.0,12.5,0.39607723175013354,0.396,1473,0.47490855506303165
Kimi-K2.7-Simple,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1552.5054834220568,21.67254109901173,26.0,54.166666666666664,9.626400266035139e-05,<0.001,1553***,0.5488552376871613
Kimi-K2.7-Simple-Per-5,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Per-5,General,1517.3054356189307,17.0681506758728,48.0,,0.32529092359031986,0.325,1517,0.5161023404669304
Kimi-K2.7-Simple-Per-5,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1477.1256054546375,31.27551248426806,13.0,27.083333333333332,0.46259152766425904,0.463,1477,0.4787158614752582
Kimi-K2.7-Simple-Per-5,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1547.4222924873668,36.31742818958945,10.0,20.833333333333336,0.5495322479530234,0.550,1547,0.544125436433314
Kimi-K2.7-Simple-Per-5,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1391.0538516803724,37.93955985383872,9.0,18.75,0.002155478549727408,0.002,1391**,0.398627921802541
Kimi-K2.7-Simple-Per-5,Kimi-K2.7-Simple | Per-5,Science,1583.2267392959873,27.08325587670191,16.0,33.33333333333333,2.0142629504286478e-05,<0.001,1583***,0.5774407140973922
Kimi-K2.6-Simple,Kimi-K2.6-Simple | Every-turn,General,1503.735025705717,16.723167940207304,48.0,,0.8286651657119057,0.829,1504,0.5034753621284401
Kimi-K2.6-Simple,Kimi-K2.6-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1417.4340644541471,37.7566679304126,9.0,18.75,0.02899794753705454,0.029,1417*,0.4231741497639283
Kimi-K2.6-Simple,Kimi-K2.6-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1592.6653533129477,39.81785721025524,8.0,16.666666666666664,0.09484650732541414,0.095,1593,0.5862231440681684
Kimi-K2.6-Simple,Kimi-K2.6-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1626.7254912332264,40.84245038732351,7.0,14.583333333333334,0.003909118257826406,0.004,1627**,0.6179153793415167
Kimi-K2.6-Simple,Kimi-K2.6-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1476.613164420809,22.574790866300123,24.0,50.0,0.6495201215295819,0.650,1477,0.47823904597187344
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,General,1430.657959657676,17.245140856531727,48.0,,9.488856078922607e-05,<0.001,1431***,0.4354787035212053
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1398.3766306517275,30.63812384651707,14.0,29.166666666666668,0.0009590850783088242,<0.001,1398***,0.4054416121803694
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1413.8171800353746,31.470502738741992,12.0,25.0,0.0004995506472436051,<0.001,1414***,0.4198087155949727
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,962.642227244196,110.82368600097695,5.0,10.416666666666668,8.695340088054354e-07,<0.001,963***,0.0
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1553.1458850894755,26.715160957944704,17.0,35.41666666666667,0.0013256746576173802,0.001,1553**,0.5494511178436299
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Per-5,General,1478.6244258882505,16.913624251124197,48.0,,0.22041331372729522,0.220,1479,0.48011048207032875
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1379.8779850132828,31.097743618830233,14.0,29.166666666666668,0.00012055780171831399,<0.001,1380***,0.3882290151208948
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1519.0156605143889,26.081251236053625,16.0,33.33333333333333,0.8119650242065126,0.812,1519,0.51769366842585
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1625.958912994478,47.319767418643046,6.0,12.5,0.013216731299443613,0.013,1626*,0.6172020945640239
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Science,1502.3680831859722,32.069308516454356,12.0,25.0,0.2634653811416968,0.263,1502,0.5022034511325923
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple | Per-5,General,1495.7108574106826,16.697030764402044,48.0,,0.8034493084760894,0.803,1496,0.49600904387469746
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1453.1331342132687,33.166314406694845,11.0,22.916666666666664,0.1578449663002005,0.158,1453,0.4563913763204935
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1462.248296007822,24.481655872695676,18.0,37.5,0.012309271687941405,0.012,1462*,0.46487284086487596
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1431.4971683338476,37.79889373609606,8.0,16.666666666666664,0.04377373214531617,0.044,1431*,0.4362595693788516
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple-Per-5,DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-Simple | Per-5,Science,1636.5341550769756,34.97613677198225,11.0,22.916666666666664,1.3593220673195552e-06,<0.001,1637***,0.6270421328203453
Qwen-3.5-Simple,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Every-turn,General,1459.4917161172089,16.67566014270689,48.0,,0.018602775645683304,0.019,1459*,0.46230790179599796
Qwen-3.5-Simple,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1434.7349999019493,30.176253096179877,15.0,31.25,0.0311011483600904,0.031,1435*,0.4392723029171576
Qwen-3.5-Simple,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1431.0777927372842,24.596682069450566,19.0,39.58333333333333,0.00019729533388298677,<0.001,1431***,0.4358693492891591
Qwen-3.5-Simple,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1505.77070841018,34.60752279661565,8.0,16.666666666666664,0.9441971563290452,0.944,1506,0.5053695216695065
Qwen-3.5-Simple,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1573.1266043631492,42.42896255879992,6.0,12.5,0.012175936720013176,0.012,1573*,0.5680427529577959
Qwen-3.5-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Per-5,General,1423.4648687753063,17.245439673896943,48.0,,1.6463578629213074e-05,<0.001,1423***,0.4287856851570339
Qwen-3.5-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1467.112118825933,26.77300518684866,17.0,35.41666666666667,0.2199263499109061,0.220,1467,0.46939852474320454
Qwen-3.5-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1415.0097694825924,26.19001031470881,20.0,41.66666666666667,4.033333854641089e-05,<0.001,1415***,0.42091839475816945
Qwen-3.5-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1248.7497403809584,53.73266638438275,5.0,10.416666666666668,1.4866522837514854e-06,<0.001,1249***,0.2662169672074146
Qwen-3.5-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.5-Simple | Per-5,Science,1530.9367021108628,44.74658220062751,6.0,12.5,0.14973237020534225,0.150,1531,0.5287859445599958
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Every-turn,General,1387.3838783513258,18.211520761327204,48.0,,1.735547243270003e-09,<0.001,1387***,0.395213089529598
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1395.2392580510875,28.335297486800815,17.0,37.77777777777778,0.00023660756995279932,<0.001,1395***,0.4025223535786466
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1415.7707602297542,23.57448851539836,22.0,48.888888888888886,6.7063223453797305e-06,<0.001,1416***,0.4216264804933576
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1356.4354712191112,52.88327712229747,6.0,13.333333333333334,0.03873273039617915,0.039,1356*,0.36641625369571973
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Per-5,General,1343.6304716265804,18.236037808586033,48.0,,6.864706298757326e-17,<0.001,1344***,0.35450147341175625
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1422.717754334056,27.602602988480285,17.0,38.63636363636363,0.005349178533724824,0.005,1423**,0.4280905110299168
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1321.6168011638508,27.123306710722243,20.0,45.45454545454545,2.279928788039858e-13,<0.001,1322***,0.33401822037362305
Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.6-27B-Simple | Per-5,Science,1317.9024259658338,42.117679144073215,7.0,15.909090909090908,0.00046612185511624437,<0.001,1318***,0.3305620731042088
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Every-turn,General,1517.1995263106485,16.61993098445567,48.0,,0.31616051459774286,0.316,1517,0.5160037941039187
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1443.2168264356374,43.08816075736167,6.0,12.5,0.1871429383644252,0.187,1443,0.4471644624463569
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1619.5472491259302,28.18457976199007,19.0,39.58333333333333,0.0010909605027893195,0.001,1620**,0.6112361774473272
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1552.7123867391845,28.930352376209648,13.0,27.083333333333332,0.1282371693316009,0.128,1553,0.5490477568314053
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1424.664060487165,33.80505983024815,10.0,20.833333333333336,0.2238947681653014,0.224,1425,0.4299015075873197
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Per-5,General,1454.7151213599607,16.769102374547998,48.0,,0.008867144331026953,0.009,1455**,0.4578633817765408
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1464.969971440631,47.82941183825356,5.0,10.416666666666668,0.461981150091868,0.462,1465,0.46740530207675257
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1469.682413640673,28.224330130014984,15.0,31.25,0.05367310784342168,0.054,1470,0.4717901295036218
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1246.5053480703787,38.72262523430423,11.0,22.916666666666664,1.8644641197342237e-11,<0.001,1247***,0.26412860780854563
Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-27B-Simple | Per-5,Science,1548.1707024801492,26.13650898879194,17.0,35.41666666666667,0.001989232777886272,0.002,1548**,0.5448218160436286
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Every-turn,General,1449.1996393859731,16.557027196351896,48.0,,0.0029667067999981514,0.003,1449**,0.4527313428877184
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1513.4350187308592,32.671827368097944,10.0,22.727272727272727,0.6884039497333063,0.688,1513,0.5125009997175239
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1438.7575374857433,23.475996904780356,20.0,45.45454545454545,0.00035353290305932213,<0.001,1439***,0.4430151887445689
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1404.779090140105,28.407549031862487,14.0,31.818181818181817,0.03290727402041702,0.033,1405*,0.4113989648167171
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Per-5,General,1494.8291301489683,15.995001812485459,52.0,,0.7547658842866515,0.755,1495,0.4951886153758293
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1557.7750702993626,31.625488421130463,12.0,24.489795918367346,0.07074770802899519,0.071,1558,0.5537584764086196
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1453.3413330459462,20.670074779232785,27.0,55.10204081632652,0.0008252760205387596,<0.001,1453***,0.45658510091445415
Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple-Per-5,Qwen-3.8-Flash-Next-Simple | Per-5,Science,1623.1908229969272,35.757105256685215,10.0,20.408163265306122,1.3193340159121047e-05,<0.001,1623***,0.6146264455849881
Gemma-4-Simple,Gemma-4-Simple | Every-turn,General,1376.8185705068076,17.947361879818644,48.0,,2.4315376900838968e-11,<0.001,1377***,0.38538229487082276
Gemma-4-Simple,Gemma-4-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1367.9383715311274,26.17423162251813,20.0,44.44444444444444,5.509819869343894e-07,<0.001,1368***,0.37711945824138426
Gemma-4-Simple,Gemma-4-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1341.9933347300844,30.952471550798276,14.0,31.11111111111111,6.093331762651469e-09,<0.001,1342***,0.3529781522842883
Gemma-4-Simple,Gemma-4-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1471.3756448455072,34.128135163126764,11.0,24.444444444444443,0.8793331943903218,0.879,1471,0.4733656451941742
Gemma-4-Simple-Per-5,Gemma-4-Simple | Per-5,General,1458.3299320793544,17.211339075892557,48.0,,0.01877479807922445,0.019,1458*,0.46122688641224696
Gemma-4-Simple-Per-5,Gemma-4-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1525.6667249434267,26.746883381398344,18.0,39.130434782608695,0.34639649678321205,0.346,1526,0.5238823426818566
Gemma-4-Simple-Per-5,Gemma-4-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1353.0931957572366,27.591792894168574,17.0,36.95652173913043,1.0710307721555666e-09,<0.001,1353***,0.36330633733149376
Gemma-4-Simple-Per-5,Gemma-4-Simple | Per-5,Science,1553.0700470189795,33.29318739038455,11.0,23.91304347826087,0.009687151499054367,0.010,1553**,0.5493805521289971
GPT-6-Luna-Simple,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Every-turn,General,1484.4652346461553,16.315644080843438,50.0,,0.35696090612458364,0.357,1484,0.4855452306252353
GPT-6-Luna-Simple,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1384.9126587641026,42.32763698621775,7.0,15.909090909090908,0.001019491281288843,0.001,1385**,0.3929136721651205
GPT-6-Luna-Simple,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1506.1292900628969,17.821292696039578,37.0,84.0909090909091,0.02971540930108297,0.030,1506*,0.5057031742850422
GPT-6-Luna-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Per-5,General,1509.6014244590933,17.25178817496783,48.0,,0.5890084361973708,0.589,1510,0.5089339216308839
GPT-6-Luna-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1552.6823204797558,50.554592425540996,5.0,10.869565217391305,0.30092866302912047,0.301,1553,0.5490197808152826
GPT-6-Luna-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1540.8520113462446,46.155623145695415,5.0,10.869565217391305,0.7397229986718059,0.740,1541,0.5380119293117672
GPT-6-Luna-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6-Luna-Simple | Per-5,Science,1515.8706845506792,19.088899242451607,36.0,78.26086956521739,0.01127837217003047,0.011,1516*,0.5147673350562024
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Every-turn,General,1545.3496433279254,16.6624958272539,48.0,,0.008373728416253369,0.008,1545**,0.5421968803906498
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1767.89762593631,67.60789097287106,5.0,10.416666666666668,7.713378941056926e-05,<0.001,1768***,0.7492730537444492
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1515.1373163075175,29.24554560602453,14.0,29.166666666666668,0.7315066374026121,0.732,1515,0.514084951474589
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1372.811730816049,39.286453552819,8.0,16.666666666666664,0.0006135321900958584,<0.001,1373***,0.38165401559963086
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1594.1971105518041,23.887644799542283,21.0,43.75,1.3941613518881338e-07,<0.001,1594***,0.5876484116613039
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Per-5,General,1599.3107451428589,17.211817294782826,48.0,,2.1378780353110882e-08,<0.001,1599***,0.5924065400911113
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1607.6391928328492,30.12169405131077,13.0,29.545454545454547,0.007431681893890527,0.007,1608**,0.6001559838623238
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Per-5,Diplomatic,1507.0203389954722,37.47703990134933,8.0,18.181818181818183,0.9747999796465924,0.975,1507,0.506532276400757
GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple-Per-5,GPT-6.1-Sol-Simple | Per-5,Science,1664.5757782103387,23.714845510382883,23.0,52.27272727272727,2.074142804610144e-16,<0.001,1665***,0.6531342678513076
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Every-turn,General,1438.76556821367,17.337425312086857,48.0,,0.0006044176537525397,<0.001,1439***,0.44302266116642053
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Every-turn,Domination,1404.8143290590067,31.237878085239736,13.0,27.083333333333332,0.0024054849494885063,0.002,1405**,0.4114317538826694
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Every-turn,Culture,1404.2582599925638,24.828030987942576,21.0,43.75,2.1474703868597005e-06,<0.001,1404***,0.410914343421115
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Every-turn,Diplomatic,1491.7203609170763,47.87554324843771,5.0,10.416666666666668,0.7315540666564959,0.732,1492,0.4922959716015066
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Every-turn,Science,1545.9496293175723,36.754838724988154,9.0,18.75,0.031180476841288655,0.031,1546*,0.5427551546169349
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple-Per-5,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Per-5,General,1433.9399325743564,16.827587758241304,48.0,,0.0001416200075540479,<0.001,1434***,0.4385325096472887
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple-Per-5,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Per-5,Domination,1368.4908637414524,29.42649819359532,15.0,33.33333333333333,8.81841957390207e-06,<0.001,1368***,0.37763354051425396
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple-Per-5,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Per-5,Culture,1526.6740026769687,28.490983368678677,15.0,33.33333333333333,0.9647355699902811,0.965,1527,0.5248195932294538
Nemotron-3-Super-Simple-Per-5,Nemotron-3-Super-Simple | Per-5,Science,1428.76470037524,28.207930743333254,15.0,33.33333333333333,0.19072542307718543,0.191,1429,0.43371706595083337