{ "planned_families": [ "DX01", "DX03", "DX04", "DX05", "DX06", "DX07" ], "completed_families": [ "DX01", "DX03", "DX04", "DX05", "DX06", "DX07" ], "families": [ { "family": "DX01", "jobs": 39, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056118, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.298176041666666, "sd": 0.4115024113594466, "median": 11.167901041666667, "min": 11.088213541666667, "max": 12.451598958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 14.6061859375, "sd": 0.1538226960335173, "median": 14.555627604166666, "min": 14.444390625, "max": 14.959239583333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 3.308009895833333, "sd": 0.48001410937792593, "median": 3.4147083333333326, "min": 2.033026041666666, "max": 3.751776041666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.1180677083333332, 3.5471562500000005, 2.033026041666666, 3.6355677083333333, 3.4594010416666663, 3.3940833333333327, 3.3462395833333325, 3.751776041666668, 3.3594479166666673, 3.4353333333333325 ], "df": 9, "t": 21.792788146928444, "p": 4.2530258120064315e-09, "ci95": [ 2.964628487726476, 3.65139130394019 ], "shapiro_p": 0.001161043516983936, "lag1": -0.3193830173106346, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2927914987015328, "p_holm": 2.977118068404502e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.194578645833333, "sd": 0.0734255829676955, "median": 11.159052083333332, "min": 11.123958333333333, "max": 11.301697916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 14.498142708333333, "sd": 0.048991194534600484, "median": 14.484572916666668, "min": 14.449489583333333, "max": 14.573473958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 3.3035640625, "sd": 0.09196054943273199, "median": 3.3177916666666665, "min": 3.154416666666666, "max": 3.441739583333332 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.1692291666666677, 3.441739583333332, 3.2788697916666667, 3.331135416666667, 3.4164062499999996, 3.336562500000001, 3.154416666666666, 3.3102135416666663, 3.3253697916666667, 3.2716979166666675 ], "df": 9, "t": 113.60074399534273, "p": 1.6113936170556708e-15, "ci95": [ 3.2377794483864384, 3.3693486766135616 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5227312383728404, "lag1": -0.35103079425421824, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2951039219086284, "p_holm": 3.86734468093361e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.298176041666666, "sd": 0.4115024113594466, "median": 11.167901041666667, "min": 11.088213541666667, "max": 12.451598958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.825824479166666, "sd": 0.08061953301048333, "median": 12.811372395833335, "min": 12.750739583333333, "max": 13.016182291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.5276484374999997, "sd": 0.4003912226188704, "median": 1.6281796874999994, "min": 0.42203124999999986, "max": 1.8478281249999995 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.5145937499999995, 1.7160312500000003, 0.42203124999999986, 1.6280729166666656, 1.6966770833333324, 1.6282864583333332, 1.8478281249999995, 1.605864583333334, 1.524098958333333, 1.6929999999999996 ], "df": 9, "t": 12.06532075028985, "p": 7.351831515873036e-07, "ci95": [ 1.241225811309553, 1.8140710636904465 ], "shapiro_p": 5.8411342616401945e-05, "lag1": -0.1619270787458483, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1352119520767041, "p_holm": 1.5487041391780728e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.194578645833333, "sd": 0.0734255829676955, "median": 11.159052083333332, "min": 11.123958333333333, "max": 11.301697916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 12.817852083333333, "sd": 0.08160025357105652, "median": 12.801799479166666, "min": 12.743640625, "max": 13.021421875 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.6232734374999997, "sd": 0.12282370298289935, "median": 1.6166380208333333, "min": 1.4844270833333333, "max": 1.8974635416666672 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.5676249999999996, 1.692984375, 1.5007656249999997, 1.6063749999999999, 1.6269010416666667, 1.8974635416666672, 1.5180364583333326, 1.7063489583333329, 1.6318072916666662, 1.4844270833333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 41.79357243825876, "p": 1.2816050041785614e-11, "ci95": [ 1.5354106533542933, 1.7111362216457067 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2570526019098822, "lag1": -0.39303299304133243, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1450053180969155, "p_holm": 1.66608650543213e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.298176041666666, "sd": 0.4115024113594466, "median": 11.167901041666667, "min": 11.088213541666667, "max": 12.451598958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 13.880125, "sd": 0.045149035785273406, "median": 13.853390625, "min": 13.838453125, "max": 13.952354166666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.581948958333333, "sd": 0.42548680709785, "median": 2.6970625000000004, "min": 1.3961145833333326, "max": 2.857953125 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.5754166666666656, 2.857953125, 1.3961145833333326, 2.726265625, 2.690401041666666, 2.824307291666665, 2.670098958333332, 2.7037239583333346, 2.6145468750000003, 2.760661458333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 19.189406990837277, "p": 1.3073996735967491e-08, "ci95": [ 2.277574032476478, 2.8863238841901877 ], "shapiro_p": 2.111049597492386e-05, "lag1": -0.25831724329008665, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.228527945467599, "p_holm": 6.536998367983746e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.194578645833333, "sd": 0.0734255829676955, "median": 11.159052083333332, "min": 11.123958333333333, "max": 11.301697916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 13.878302083333333, "sd": 0.02821537990177612, "median": 13.879796875, "min": 13.840776041666667, "max": 13.924895833333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.6837234375, "sd": 0.07137983847504768, "median": 2.7120208333333338, "min": 2.5603854166666657, "max": 2.7712031249999995 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.5969218749999996, 2.7623645833333335, 2.615796874999999, 2.7144427083333333, 2.7712031249999995, 2.716817708333334, 2.5603854166666657, 2.709598958333334, 2.7240208333333324, 2.665682291666668 ], "df": 9, "t": 118.89461861759797, "p": 1.0697449569132857e-15, "ci95": [ 2.6326613770998044, 2.734785497900196 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3315893178349679, "lag1": -0.3827014521642584, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2397342072806725, "p_holm": 2.6743623922832142e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.298176041666666, "sd": 0.4115024113594466, "median": 11.167901041666667, "min": 11.088213541666667, "max": 12.451598958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.687200520833333, "sd": 0.0938360319711275, "median": 9.675484375, "min": 9.577125, "max": 9.878625 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.6109755208333334, "sd": 0.405110070302071, "median": -1.5189713541666663, "min": -2.7129166666666666, "max": -1.2897291666666675 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.6806770833333342, -1.4008802083333336, -2.7129166666666666, -1.3698958333333344, -1.5892499999999998, -1.5509218750000002, -1.2897291666666675, -1.5987135416666653, -1.4870208333333323, -1.4297500000000003 ], "df": 9, "t": -12.57522899100177, "p": 5.162347130593576e-07, "ci95": [ -1.9007738073021812, -1.3211772343644852 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00024930300588600597, "lag1": -0.3136344803980517, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8574127792935603, "p_holm": 1.5487041391780728e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.194578645833333, "sd": 0.0734255829676955, "median": 11.159052083333332, "min": 11.123958333333333, "max": 11.301697916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 9.66693125, "sd": 0.07521370938676297, "median": 9.686619791666667, "min": 9.567645833333334, "max": 9.784057291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.5276473958333332, "sd": 0.10377384851038889, "median": -1.521473958333333, "min": -1.6891145833333336, "max": -1.3957083333333333 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.5027447916666663, -1.4132708333333337, -1.6810312500000002, -1.5906302083333337, -1.4667447916666667, -1.5563124999999989, -1.6891145833333336, -1.4407135416666659, -1.3957083333333333, -1.5402031249999997 ], "df": 9, "t": -46.55166308084383, "p": 4.876300377426613e-12, "ci95": [ -1.6018827350243934, -1.453412056642273 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4999577827329058, "lag1": -0.10547005224428924, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8635368561726143, "p_holm": 7.31445056613992e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 7.928752083333333, "sd": 0.070399594986732, "median": 7.937007812499999, "min": 7.836411458333333, "max": 8.073947916666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.142191666666666, "sd": 0.0742572426902971, "median": 5.153817708333333, "min": 5.043953125, "max": 5.29640625 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.161052083333333, 5.095677083333333, 5.043953125, 5.160442708333333, 5.059114583333333, 5.203651041666666, 5.29640625, 5.093984375, 5.159671874999999, 5.147963541666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 218.98251594963642, "p": 4.393923017614394e-18, "ci95": [ 5.089071235289824, 5.195312098043511 ], "shapiro_p": 0.47827318238538064, "lag1": -0.0694794632320762, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.845354450565923, "p_holm": 1.6257515165173257e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 7.972954166666667, "sd": 0.3305845066012232, "median": 7.866296875, "min": 7.821338541666667, "max": 8.903822916666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.179153125, "sd": 0.3362221471996662, "median": 5.080361979166667, "min": 4.996703125, "max": 6.127265625 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.0615625, 6.127265625, 5.0265885416666665, 5.11284375, 5.043630208333333, 5.151088541666667, 4.996703125, 5.094520833333334, 5.1111249999999995, 5.0662031249999995 ], "df": 9, "t": 48.71160440258772, "p": 3.2467788371461014e-12, "ci95": [ 4.938634290060435, 5.419671959939567 ], "shapiro_p": 3.4232156581095666e-06, "lag1": -0.20017618820444177, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.8538017016094783, "p_holm": 5.194846139433762e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 7.9398687500000005, "sd": 0.09537957604221887, "median": 7.907591145833333, "min": 7.8590052083333335, "max": 8.104078125 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.153308333333333, "sd": 0.10265100831977403, "median": 5.122916666666667, "min": 5.034531250000001, "max": 5.326781249999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.08784375, 5.034531250000001, 5.067583333333333, 5.315140625000001, 5.326781249999999, 5.083296875, 5.083281250000001, 5.204619791666667, 5.172015625, 5.157989583333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 158.7533535734432, "p": 7.938351288421636e-17, "ci95": [ 5.079876225626931, 5.226740441039736 ], "shapiro_p": 0.12915893822936086, "lag1": 0.24243959610248236, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.8493438371229765, "p_holm": 2.143354847873842e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 7.89966875, "sd": 0.06365912760091604, "median": 7.888830729166667, "min": 7.835671875, "max": 8.041848958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.105867708333333, "sd": 0.0745754662336485, "median": 5.065588541666666, "min": 5.035380208333333, "max": 5.265364583333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.265364583333333, 5.061645833333333, 5.039734375, 5.147729166666666, 5.160901041666667, 5.068505208333333, 5.057083333333334, 5.0626718749999995, 5.035380208333333, 5.159661458333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 216.5078169173075, "p": 4.867069197008246e-18, "ci95": [ 5.052519633547111, 5.1592157831195555 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0398443723644701, "lag1": -0.1383593261737397, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.8275702643762286, "p_holm": 1.703474218952886e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.002408333333333, "sd": 0.04544264941495682, "median": 9.002057291666667, "min": 8.918583333333334, "max": 9.10090625 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.215847916666666, "sd": 0.04777820731194172, "median": 6.219669270833334, "min": 6.141041666666668, "max": 6.318104166666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.203364583333333, 6.154187499999999, 6.225963541666667, 6.231182291666667, 6.221135416666667, 6.318104166666666, 6.141041666666668, 6.216682291666666, 6.228614583333332, 6.2182031250000005 ], "df": 9, "t": 411.4059131089724, "p": 1.507792559420184e-20, "ci95": [ 6.181669446111171, 6.250026387222163 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09613539147433846, "lag1": -0.3297467105608785, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.2306524845071096, "p_holm": 6.332728749564773e-19 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 9.041286458333333, "sd": 0.07198547292080512, "median": 9.031236979166668, "min": 8.965265625, "max": 9.225005208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.247485416666667, "sd": 0.07781097117684761, "median": 6.240481770833334, "min": 6.155255208333333, "max": 6.429744791666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.188781250000001, 6.256973958333333, 6.238838541666667, 6.292942708333333, 6.279031250000001, 6.213973958333334, 6.155255208333333, 6.429744791666668, 6.1771875000000005, 6.242125 ], "df": 9, "t": 253.9010022179386, "p": 1.1604944670276026e-18, "ci95": [ 6.191822801075025, 6.30314803225831 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1729951479089129, "lag1": -0.511077748170806, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.236195535577463, "p_holm": 4.6419778681104106e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.069219270833333, "sd": 0.11396614779901876, "median": 9.036447916666667, "min": 8.908177083333333, "max": 9.210848958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.282658854166667, "sd": 0.11529942335818011, "median": 6.247177083333333, "min": 6.125375, "max": 6.422739583333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.2105781250000005, 6.1990625, 6.252421875, 6.422739583333333, 6.3800052083333325, 6.125375, 6.422296875000001, 6.16053125, 6.241932291666666, 6.411645833333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 172.3123252687177, "p": 3.797390759020518e-17, "ci95": [ 6.200178615412957, 6.365139092920376 ], "shapiro_p": 0.11343196189064486, "lag1": -0.3318768729994323, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.254628615475022, "p_holm": 1.1588119518831623e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 9.013110416666667, "sd": 0.07816496974462064, "median": 9.0165234375, "min": 8.910989583333333, "max": 9.162463541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.219309375, "sd": 0.09376130642340777, "median": 6.218559895833334, "min": 6.059234374999999, "max": 6.385276041666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.2843229166666665, 6.300078125000001, 6.148296875000001, 6.135057291666666, 6.215708333333334, 6.385276041666666, 6.182932291666667, 6.221411458333334, 6.059234374999999, 6.2607760416666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 209.75798917972733, "p": 6.472034859565718e-18, "ci95": [ 6.152236576937184, 6.286382173062816 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9991815294936397, "lag1": -0.10795547287946397, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.226110335791777, "p_holm": 2.200491852252344e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.309420833333334, "sd": 0.08949654743910743, "median": 10.270354166666667, "min": 10.209786458333333, "max": 10.490588541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.522860416666666, "sd": 0.09584225193126741, "median": 7.490994791666667, "min": 7.421369791666667, "max": 7.713755208333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.669114583333333, 7.421369791666667, 7.469619791666666, 7.713755208333333, 7.432489583333333, 7.4876249999999995, 7.488828125000001, 7.493161458333333, 7.537114583333333, 7.515526041666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 248.21384052255326, "p": 1.4229097885466776e-18, "ci95": [ 7.454298999863853, 7.591421833469478 ], "shapiro_p": 0.04516758549442182, "lag1": -0.45685236777720284, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.699693992519153, "p_holm": 5.407057196477375e-17 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 10.294591666666667, "sd": 0.08403846688641109, "median": 10.269411458333334, "min": 10.200989583333333, "max": 10.494364583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.5007906250000005, "sd": 0.09742003765023627, "median": 7.489322916666667, "min": 7.367546875, "max": 7.717296874999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.526770833333333, 7.458661458333333, 7.550614583333334, 7.717296874999999, 7.4945, 7.484145833333333, 7.367546875, 7.433031250000001, 7.414859375000001, 7.560479166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 243.4774528849752, "p": 1.692280591300922e-18, "ci95": [ 7.431100528286982, 7.570480721713019 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4947528664356159, "lag1": 0.21799841092115044, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.6847977050382004, "p_holm": 6.261438187813412e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.1009015625, "sd": 0.0614130485552828, "median": 10.0739765625, "min": 10.040901041666666, "max": 10.2415 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.314341145833334, "sd": 0.0686415095274777, "median": 7.294661458333334, "min": 7.216427083333333, "max": 7.463958333333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.374328125000001, 7.216427083333333, 7.33459375, 7.296677083333333, 7.340484375, 7.26315625, 7.463958333333334, 7.292645833333333, 7.285901041666666, 7.275239583333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 336.9677876192399, "p": 9.087293103472325e-20, "ci95": [ 7.265237967956601, 7.363444323710066 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4594055611149442, "lag1": -0.478726993083267, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.624863649855071, "p_holm": 3.725790172423653e-18 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "after": { "mean": 10.148982291666666, "sd": 0.08313355212637841, "median": 10.11790625, "min": 10.063177083333333, "max": 10.285130208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.35518125, "sd": 0.0938578352553034, "median": 7.312906250000001, "min": 7.225989583333334, "max": 7.489192708333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.429010416666666, 7.329125000000001, 7.489192708333333, 7.453338541666666, 7.295744791666667, 7.285989583333333, 7.296687500000001, 7.282630208333334, 7.225989583333334, 7.464104166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 247.81229281601287, "p": 1.4437927642684745e-18, "ci95": [ 7.288039399370663, 7.422323100629339 ], "shapiro_p": 0.13278585212805105, "lag1": 0.12527320851570778, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.6326789704438656, "p_holm": 5.4864125042202033e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.928752083333333, "sd": 0.070399594986732, "median": 7.937007812499999, "min": 7.836411458333333, "max": 8.073947916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 9.002408333333333, "sd": 0.04544264941495682, "median": 9.002057291666667, "min": 8.918583333333334, "max": 9.10090625 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.0736562500000004, "sd": 0.09269014220846444, "median": 1.0704895833333339, "min": 0.8446354166666676, "max": 1.1820104166666674 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0423125000000004, 1.0585104166666666, 1.1820104166666674, 1.0707395833333342, 1.162020833333334, 1.1144531249999998, 0.8446354166666676, 1.1226979166666666, 1.0689427083333332, 1.0702395833333336 ], "df": 9, "t": 36.62956052477725, "p": 4.1735656322648877e-11, "ci95": [ 1.0073497166557723, 1.1399627833442285 ], "shapiro_p": 0.027752340175621927, "lag1": -0.2466751705337989, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1354130181793531, "p_holm": 6.260348448397332e-10 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.972954166666667, "sd": 0.3305845066012232, "median": 7.866296875, "min": 7.821338541666667, "max": 8.903822916666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.041286458333333, "sd": 0.07198547292080512, "median": 9.031236979166668, "min": 8.965265625, "max": 9.225005208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.068332291666667, "sd": 0.3393751976952879, "median": 1.1672369791666664, "min": 0.12970833333333331, "max": 1.3352239583333336 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.1272187500000008, 0.12970833333333331, 1.212250000000001, 1.1800989583333337, 1.235401041666667, 1.062885416666667, 1.1585520833333334, 1.3352239583333336, 1.066062500000001, 1.1759218749999993 ], "df": 9, "t": 9.954655975205633, "p": 3.7161415068543173e-06, "ci95": [ 0.8255579002801833, 1.3111066830531508 ], "shapiro_p": 5.143829185607511e-05, "lag1": -0.1307855880790377, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1339945356933256, "p_holm": 7.432283013708635e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.928752083333333, "sd": 0.070399594986732, "median": 7.937007812499999, "min": 7.836411458333333, "max": 8.073947916666667 }, "after": { "mean": 10.309420833333334, "sd": 0.08949654743910743, "median": 10.270354166666667, "min": 10.209786458333333, "max": 10.490588541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.38066875, "sd": 0.10351967962301416, "median": 2.375408854166667, "min": 2.192421875000001, "max": 2.5533124999999997 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.5080625000000003, 2.3256927083333343, 2.4256666666666664, 2.5533124999999997, 2.3733750000000002, 2.283973958333333, 2.192421875000001, 2.399177083333333, 2.3774427083333336, 2.367562499999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 72.7237142908652, "p": 8.88721127907384e-14, "ci95": [ 2.3066152322778066, 2.454722267722194 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9120377424043402, "lag1": 0.1453028444025204, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.3002576855700023, "p_holm": 1.9551864813962446e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.972954166666667, "sd": 0.3305845066012232, "median": 7.866296875, "min": 7.821338541666667, "max": 8.903822916666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.294591666666667, "sd": 0.08403846688641109, "median": 10.269411458333334, "min": 10.200989583333333, "max": 10.494364583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.3216375, "sd": 0.36083219819521156, "median": 2.4108567708333335, "min": 1.3313958333333336, "max": 2.604453124999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.465208333333333, 1.3313958333333336, 2.5240260416666676, 2.604453124999999, 2.4508697916666664, 2.333057291666666, 2.3708437500000006, 2.338510416666667, 2.3037343750000012, 2.4942760416666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 20.346472509882, "p": 7.802824048137548e-09, "ci95": [ 2.0635136951244797, 2.5797613048755204 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00011168117623692004, "lag1": -0.2203877258148555, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2911891190477809, "p_holm": 3.901412024068774e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.9398687500000005, "sd": 0.09537957604221887, "median": 7.907591145833333, "min": 7.8590052083333335, "max": 8.104078125 }, "after": { "mean": 9.069219270833333, "sd": 0.11396614779901876, "median": 9.036447916666667, "min": 8.908177083333333, "max": 9.210848958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1293505208333332, "sd": 0.11119057426128741, "median": 1.1151666666666662, "min": 0.9559114583333335, "max": 1.339015625 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.1227343750000003, 1.1645312500000005, 1.1848385416666662, 1.107598958333332, 1.0532239583333336, 1.0420781249999997, 1.339015625, 0.9559114583333335, 1.0699166666666668, 1.2536562499999997 ], "df": 9, "t": 32.118908875661596, "p": 1.3507976601529526e-10, "ci95": [ 1.0498095756566772, 1.2088914660099892 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9516780641606941, "lag1": -0.4187379318734063, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1422379331942147, "p_holm": 1.6209571921835432e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.89966875, "sd": 0.06365912760091604, "median": 7.888830729166667, "min": 7.835671875, "max": 8.041848958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.013110416666667, "sd": 0.07816496974462064, "median": 9.0165234375, "min": 8.910989583333333, "max": 9.162463541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1134416666666667, "sd": 0.10308715164275133, "median": 1.1048385416666666, "min": 0.9873281249999994, "max": 1.316770833333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0189583333333339, 1.2384322916666672, 1.1085625000000006, 0.9873281249999994, 1.0548072916666662, 1.316770833333333, 1.125848958333333, 1.1587395833333334, 1.0238541666666663, 1.1011145833333327 ], "df": 9, "t": 34.155679464330504, "p": 7.799199246616325e-11, "ci95": [ 1.0396975608221792, 1.1871857725111536 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5053902648086082, "lag1": -0.18050620261099684, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.140947893121046, "p_holm": 7.019279321954692e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.9398687500000005, "sd": 0.09537957604221887, "median": 7.907591145833333, "min": 7.8590052083333335, "max": 8.104078125 }, "after": { "mean": 10.1009015625, "sd": 0.0614130485552828, "median": 10.0739765625, "min": 10.040901041666666, "max": 10.2415 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.1610328125, "sd": 0.12445322016820558, "median": 2.1485546874999994, "min": 1.9815364583333324, "max": 2.3806770833333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.2864843750000006, 2.181895833333333, 2.2670104166666665, 1.9815364583333324, 2.013703125000001, 2.1798593749999995, 2.3806770833333335, 2.0880260416666667, 2.1138854166666663, 2.1172499999999994 ], "df": 9, "t": 54.91047782149262, "p": 1.108353854688973e-12, "ci95": [ 2.0720043419823857, 2.250061283017613 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9022956924480307, "lag1": 0.028550956633164617, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2721748785205045, "p_holm": 1.9950369384401516e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.89966875, "sd": 0.06365912760091604, "median": 7.888830729166667, "min": 7.835671875, "max": 8.041848958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 10.148982291666666, "sd": 0.08313355212637841, "median": 10.11790625, "min": 10.063177083333333, "max": 10.285130208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.249313541666667, "sd": 0.08972423068008054, "median": 2.2297812500000003, "min": 2.13484375, "max": 2.4494583333333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.1636458333333337, 2.267479166666668, 2.4494583333333333, 2.3056093749999995, 2.13484375, 2.2174843749999997, 2.239604166666667, 2.2199583333333335, 2.190609375000001, 2.304442708333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 79.27573086570746, "p": 4.093229045750152e-14, "ci95": [ 2.1851286936167664, 2.3134983897165675 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3779905910737792, "lag1": 0.152327630520571, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2847351721762594, "p_holm": 9.41442680522535e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.342317708333333, "sd": 0.10931714042249924, "median": 15.294619791666666, "min": 15.262541666666667, "max": 15.626213541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 17.629436979166666, "sd": 0.042558278231373606, "median": 17.617153645833334, "min": 17.583796875, "max": 17.712671875 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.287119270833333, "sd": 0.13674201571110978, "median": 2.3264140625000005, "min": 1.9643281249999998, "max": 2.4501302083333343 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.4501302083333343, 1.9643281249999998, 2.3193229166666676, 2.216192708333333, 2.204911458333333, 2.3335052083333334, 2.380119791666667, 2.3741927083333323, 2.3634322916666655, 2.2650572916666682 ], "df": 9, "t": 52.89161592861635, "p": 1.5512529125432759e-12, "ci95": [ 2.189299925558042, 2.3849386161086246 ], "shapiro_p": 0.10283486943967574, "lag1": -0.2982819334540928, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1490726052160334, "p_holm": 2.637129951323569e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.355978125, "sd": 0.1471117741124535, "median": 15.302158854166667, "min": 15.276927083333334, "max": 15.762463541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 17.611311458333333, "sd": 0.04299699540222328, "median": 17.598890625, "min": 17.573828125, "max": 17.714854166666665 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.2553333333333327, "sd": 0.16268995146868523, "median": 2.2967317708333326, "min": 1.8335312499999983, "max": 2.4252604166666654 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.3653749999999985, 2.3367135416666667, 2.1820416666666667, 2.2995937499999997, 2.2816041666666678, 2.4252604166666654, 1.8335312499999983, 2.229739583333332, 2.305604166666665, 2.2938697916666655 ], "df": 9, "t": 43.8379270007088, "p": 8.354480579499914e-12, "ci95": [ 2.138951953018176, 2.3717147136484886 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004923092628199086, "lag1": -0.23994240271381384, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.146870053797588, "p_holm": 1.169627281129988e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.342317708333333, "sd": 0.10931714042249924, "median": 15.294619791666666, "min": 15.262541666666667, "max": 15.626213541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 17.089408854166667, "sd": 0.09859494944249254, "median": 17.045588541666667, "min": 16.994333333333334, "max": 17.296020833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.7470911458333331, "sd": 0.1509011824975524, "median": 1.7605755208333331, "min": 1.412354166666665, "max": 1.9559114583333344 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.8021614583333339, 1.412354166666665, 1.70146875, 1.925682291666666, 1.639302083333332, 1.9559114583333344, 1.749083333333333, 1.7581666666666642, 1.7637968750000006, 1.762984375000002 ], "df": 9, "t": 36.61195498475526, "p": 4.1915529244756914e-11, "ci95": [ 1.6391429428145696, 1.855039348852097 ], "shapiro_p": 0.22303363142847515, "lag1": -0.25738677155856443, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1138740038530413, "p_holm": 6.260348448397332e-10 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.355978125, "sd": 0.1471117741124535, "median": 15.302158854166667, "min": 15.276927083333334, "max": 15.762463541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 17.051503125, "sd": 0.015701128815601387, "median": 17.0478046875, "min": 17.031473958333333, "max": 17.070989583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.6955250000000002, "sd": 0.15443613342415138, "median": 1.7415026041666666, "min": 1.2731875000000006, "max": 1.7872604166666672 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.7772812499999997, 1.7872604166666672, 1.6374322916666664, 1.7696874999999999, 1.7293697916666666, 1.752416666666667, 1.2731875000000006, 1.7269010416666664, 1.7711250000000014, 1.7305885416666662 ], "df": 9, "t": 34.71804629445936, "p": 6.739940184233755e-11, "ci95": [ 1.5850480454236262, 1.8060019545763737 ], "shapiro_p": 4.3471379757406956e-05, "lag1": -0.14401150259662104, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1104146532508816, "p_holm": 6.739940184233755e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.342317708333333, "sd": 0.10931714042249924, "median": 15.294619791666666, "min": 15.262541666666667, "max": 15.626213541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 19.018631770833334, "sd": 0.09073001761125883, "median": 18.973846354166668, "min": 18.944947916666667, "max": 19.216473958333335 }, "difference": { "mean": 3.6763140625000004, "sd": 0.16925194852009157, "median": 3.6813515625000015, "min": 3.329270833333334, "max": 3.9539322916666677 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.9539322916666677, 3.329270833333334, 3.756494791666668, 3.5762916666666644, 3.5518229166666675, 3.6779062500000013, 3.6847968750000017, 3.8371354166666656, 3.6702031250000005, 3.7252864583333327 ], "df": 9, "t": 68.68769271643905, "p": 1.4844805980552987e-13, "ci95": [ 3.5552385122771613, 3.7973896127228395 ], "shapiro_p": 0.803587097302662, "lag1": -0.5789738899511306, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.239619210890358, "p_holm": 2.9689611961105974e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.355978125, "sd": 0.1471117741124535, "median": 15.302158854166667, "min": 15.276927083333334, "max": 15.762463541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 19.0578890625, "sd": 0.12495068474178345, "median": 19.02278385416667, "min": 18.940328125, "max": 19.366640625 }, "difference": { "mean": 3.7019109374999997, "sd": 0.18788560970870516, "median": 3.7217317708333333, "min": 3.239651041666667, "max": 3.9725989583333323 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.756333333333332, 3.6604739583333323, 3.9725989583333323, 3.8190781250000008, 3.6703437500000007, 3.703796875, 3.239651041666667, 3.7396666666666665, 3.663401041666667, 3.793765624999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 62.30636968812436, "p": 3.564220785567561e-13, "ci95": [ 3.5675056690623688, 3.8363162059376315 ], "shapiro_p": 0.03087706611464187, "lag1": -0.030143393183261803, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.241072949398982, "p_holm": 7.128441571135122e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.342317708333333, "sd": 0.10931714042249924, "median": 15.294619791666666, "min": 15.262541666666667, "max": 15.626213541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 14.903473437499999, "sd": 0.08042966810026038, "median": 14.86128125, "min": 14.820114583333334, "max": 15.023817708333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.4388442708333338, "sd": 0.12027407416197919, "median": -0.43802343750000006, "min": -0.625109375000001, "max": -0.25918750000000124 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.25918750000000124, -0.625109375000001, -0.4158541666666675, -0.5502239583333335, -0.5608645833333341, -0.4434010416666663, -0.4610572916666662, -0.2625104166666681, -0.43264583333333384, -0.37758854166666644 ], "df": 9, "t": -11.538209241005534, "p": 1.0748546832775214e-06, "ci95": [ -0.5248831603943336, -0.35280538127233413 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6293759195772195, "lag1": -0.2726365020112478, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9713964813416052, "p_holm": 1.5487041391780728e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.355978125, "sd": 0.1471117741124535, "median": 15.302158854166667, "min": 15.276927083333334, "max": 15.762463541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 14.860318229166666, "sd": 0.06454686295009254, "median": 14.8311015625, "min": 14.8004375, "max": 15.000619791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.49565989583333375, "sd": 0.17409320410440557, "median": -0.45521614583333303, "min": -0.9471770833333348, "max": -0.30453645833333276 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.439937500000001, -0.4465520833333336, -0.5785625000000003, -0.3773125000000004, -0.49435416666666754, -0.46388020833333243, -0.9471770833333348, -0.4277968750000003, -0.47648958333333447, -0.30453645833333276 ], "df": 9, "t": -9.003305003767649, "p": 8.51244442090128e-06, "ci95": [ -0.6201986716719807, -0.3711211199946868 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004315961131658061, "lag1": -0.20857793206812963, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9677220238399282, "p_holm": 8.51244442090128e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.333321875, "sd": 0.13196108668802412, "median": 8.29765625, "min": 8.230625, "max": 8.695625 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.5407359375, "sd": 0.12523649849727084, "median": 5.509901041666667, "min": 5.453822916666667, "max": 5.886463541666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.556947916666667, 5.520572916666666, 5.524890625000001, 5.4986927083333335, 5.480109375, 5.466, 5.520630208333333, 5.453822916666667, 5.499229166666668, 5.886463541666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 139.90606321870436, "p": 2.4747155160477044e-16, "ci95": [ 5.451147143420392, 5.630324731579607 ], "shapiro_p": 5.693308767011453e-05, "lag1": -0.0109796706384845, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.984087888969397, "p_holm": 6.4342603417240315e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 8.306931770833334, "sd": 0.08754597906850642, "median": 8.275625000000002, "min": 8.213151041666666, "max": 8.481791666666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.513925520833333, "sd": 0.1058436112058475, "median": 5.497666666666667, "min": 5.346239583333333, "max": 5.704536458333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.45609375, 5.514984374999999, 5.436255208333334, 5.346239583333333, 5.449833333333332, 5.630161458333333, 5.511895833333334, 5.483437500000001, 5.704536458333333, 5.605817708333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 164.73893223892796, "p": 5.690042606945956e-17, "ci95": [ 5.438209562604357, 5.589641479062311 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7887750898712563, "lag1": 0.3003059630048986, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.9741901833672353, "p_holm": 1.707012782083787e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.438593749999999, "sd": 0.09665027458573555, "median": 8.4181015625, "min": 8.32246875, "max": 8.614807291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.6460078125, "sd": 0.09293613441430175, "median": 5.640731770833334, "min": 5.545807291666668, "max": 5.837791666666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.7506875, 5.638322916666667, 5.643140625000001, 5.566906249999999, 5.673661458333333, 5.550963541666666, 5.837791666666666, 5.665536458333333, 5.545807291666668, 5.587260416666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 192.11305147481303, "p": 1.4270060241513024e-17, "ci95": [ 5.579525306932512, 5.7124903180674895 ], "shapiro_p": 0.27819409564326497, "lag1": -0.21896692816476984, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.021784804071047, "p_holm": 4.851820482114428e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 8.453772395833333, "sd": 0.11369062556283405, "median": 8.4308125, "min": 8.347786458333333, "max": 8.744776041666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.660766145833334, "sd": 0.13006880935458678, "median": 5.6524609375, "min": 5.470984375, "max": 5.966255208333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.61871875, 5.683442708333333, 5.5708906250000005, 5.470984375, 5.580661458333333, 5.682276041666666, 5.966255208333333, 5.6322447916666665, 5.729510416666667, 5.672677083333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 137.62649486246676, "p": 2.868853634780277e-16, "ci95": [ 5.567720524810148, 5.753811766856519 ], "shapiro_p": 0.16251985637759625, "lag1": 0.16082556386150323, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.0267645823683114, "p_holm": 7.745904813906747e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.434925, "sd": 0.09333765201002743, "median": 9.403343750000001, "min": 9.322390625, "max": 9.599927083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.6423390625000005, "sd": 0.1108515654453838, "median": 6.613591145833333, "min": 6.457104166666667, "max": 6.8229114583333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.617213541666667, 6.673958333333333, 6.60996875, 6.553520833333334, 6.457104166666667, 6.587729166666667, 6.8229114583333335, 6.721473958333334, 6.78815625, 6.591354166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 189.48690840957568, "p": 1.6151492468902706e-17, "ci95": [ 6.5630406296209856, 6.721637495379014 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8073389843023517, "lag1": 0.3310524499034313, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.378562096623033, "p_holm": 5.329992514737893e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 9.4362234375, "sd": 0.10675322877252413, "median": 9.415067708333334, "min": 9.342786458333334, "max": 9.722770833333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.6432171875, "sd": 0.11824965837085913, "median": 6.637794270833334, "min": 6.507119791666667, "max": 6.946942708333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.578359375000001, 6.639541666666666, 6.5658906250000015, 6.507119791666667, 6.6451875000000005, 6.946942708333333, 6.685380208333333, 6.588161458333333, 6.639234375000001, 6.636354166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 177.6554587396161, "p": 2.885076056218991e-17, "ci95": [ 6.558626477755736, 6.727807897244267 ], "shapiro_p": 0.007286557382683449, "lag1": 0.1786673906119487, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.378518554156476, "p_holm": 8.943735774278872e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.555628645833334, "sd": 0.057474889000398606, "median": 9.546302083333334, "min": 9.473541666666666, "max": 9.66415625 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.763042708333334, "sd": 0.06676090312274006, "median": 6.751630208333333, "min": 6.648645833333333, "max": 6.887307291666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.750385416666667, 6.796182291666666, 6.695895833333333, 6.887307291666666, 6.648645833333333, 6.752875, 6.733348958333332, 6.746359375000001, 6.799765625000001, 6.819661458333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 320.34645834565487, "p": 1.4326354110798408e-19, "ci95": [ 6.715284835235642, 6.810800581431024 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9551212770644196, "lag1": -0.5679114920389193, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.421784990576797, "p_holm": 5.730541644319363e-18 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 9.560730208333334, "sd": 0.057838843826857604, "median": 9.556697916666668, "min": 9.450354166666667, "max": 9.661848958333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.767723958333334, "sd": 0.06905384613537455, "median": 6.768388020833333, "min": 6.659078125, "max": 6.884453125 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.802494791666667, 6.743333333333332, 6.8198750000000015, 6.659078125, 6.761723958333333, 6.775052083333334, 6.821854166666666, 6.884453125, 6.673098958333334, 6.736276041666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 309.9236824791488, "p": 1.9293521162280788e-19, "ci95": [ 6.718325812616557, 6.817122104050108 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8841244503584254, "lag1": -0.20173250228213024, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.4230966036446695, "p_holm": 7.910343676535123e-18 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.8337546875, "sd": 0.19688404963784245, "median": 9.741723958333335, "min": 9.6830625, "max": 10.236505208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.041168750000001, "sd": 0.20560471842815523, "median": 6.953106770833333, "min": 6.853083333333334, "max": 7.4475468750000005 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.4475468750000005, 6.940093749999999, 7.013536458333334, 6.953989583333334, 6.853083333333334, 6.952223958333334, 6.9344375, 7.064776041666667, 7.378098958333334, 6.873901041666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 108.29581543568125, "p": 2.477438401251478e-15, "ci95": [ 6.894087994772265, 7.188249505227734 ], "shapiro_p": 0.007757495701002098, "lag1": -0.1396115633428528, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.5213794338244964, "p_holm": 5.945852163003548e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 9.7327765625, "sd": 0.08247090347952805, "median": 9.700898437500001, "min": 9.649557291666667, "max": 9.9289375 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.9397703125, "sd": 0.08766526715142318, "median": 6.917942708333333, "min": 6.846197916666667, "max": 7.141765625 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.894765625000001, 6.866229166666667, 6.929036458333334, 6.846197916666667, 7.141765625, 6.917416666666666, 6.967979166666666, 6.918468750000001, 7.027390625000001, 6.888453125 ], "df": 9, "t": 250.332672665131, "p": 1.3181288481003455e-18, "ci95": [ 6.877058358229466, 7.002482266770534 ], "shapiro_p": 0.07620950341080882, "lag1": -0.3929846421232345, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.484695590101168, "p_holm": 5.140702507591348e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.467708854166666, "sd": 0.06812950539781465, "median": 9.436471354166667, "min": 9.400333333333334, "max": 9.609052083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.675122916666667, "sd": 0.07844132331688265, "median": 6.639049479166666, "min": 6.5628125, "max": 6.832390625 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.631703125, 6.71228125, 6.622687500000001, 6.64015625, 6.5628125, 6.7370520833333325, 6.637942708333332, 6.738520833333334, 6.832390625, 6.635682291666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 269.1004076127036, "p": 6.877345375199136e-19, "ci95": [ 6.619009374318456, 6.731236459014876 ], "shapiro_p": 0.30152739957829305, "lag1": -0.10920606548405648, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.390301701025688, "p_holm": 2.6821646963276632e-17 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "after": { "mean": 9.454279166666666, "sd": 0.09231573839184838, "median": 9.4248828125, "min": 9.387333333333334, "max": 9.694921875 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.661272916666666, "sd": 0.10853988236741641, "median": 6.646924479166667, "min": 6.501083333333333, "max": 6.917630208333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.6000885416666675, 6.604005208333334, 6.626625000000001, 6.501083333333333, 6.6566979166666655, 6.676260416666667, 6.654338541666666, 6.639510416666667, 6.736489583333334, 6.917630208333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 194.07423403457912, "p": 1.302373113137247e-17, "ci95": [ 6.583628162241892, 6.738917671091441 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09856235015842514, "lag1": 0.5369887545628235, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.3849831759834643, "p_holm": 4.297831273352915e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.333321875, "sd": 0.13196108668802412, "median": 8.29765625, "min": 8.230625, "max": 8.695625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.434925, "sd": 0.09333765201002743, "median": 9.403343750000001, "min": 9.322390625, "max": 9.599927083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.101603125, "sd": 0.17735656448100834, "median": 1.1034036458333327, "min": 0.7048906250000009, "max": 1.30228125 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0602656249999995, 1.1533854166666675, 1.085078124999999, 1.0548281250000002, 0.9769947916666677, 1.1217291666666664, 1.30228125, 1.2676510416666673, 1.2889270833333324, 0.7048906250000009 ], "df": 9, "t": 19.641646548313705, "p": 1.064859842508786e-08, "ci95": [ 0.9747298817792792, 1.228476368220721 ], "shapiro_p": 0.20204297292726842, "lag1": -0.037675705276250075, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1321925567647657, "p_holm": 6.389159055052715e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.306931770833334, "sd": 0.08754597906850642, "median": 8.275625000000002, "min": 8.213151041666666, "max": 8.481791666666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.4362234375, "sd": 0.10675322877252413, "median": 9.415067708333334, "min": 9.342786458333334, "max": 9.722770833333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.129291666666667, "sd": 0.10042256161739617, "median": 1.1270963541666674, "min": 0.9346979166666678, "max": 1.31678125 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.1222656250000007, 1.124557291666667, 1.1296354166666678, 1.1608802083333334, 1.195354166666668, 1.31678125, 1.1734843749999992, 1.1047239583333326, 0.9346979166666678, 1.0305364583333336 ], "df": 9, "t": 35.56107065780814, "p": 5.438725895720663e-11, "ci95": [ 1.057453693698398, 1.201129639634936 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6282752221320013, "lag1": 0.5359730572642389, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1359457014720826, "p_holm": 5.98259848529273e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.333321875, "sd": 0.13196108668802412, "median": 8.29765625, "min": 8.230625, "max": 8.695625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.8337546875, "sd": 0.19688404963784245, "median": 9.741723958333335, "min": 9.6830625, "max": 10.236505208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.5004328125000002, "sd": 0.25895037377066443, "median": 1.4707604166666668, "min": 0.9874375000000004, "max": 1.8905989583333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.8905989583333334, 1.4195208333333333, 1.488645833333333, 1.4552968750000002, 1.3729739583333345, 1.4862239583333334, 1.4138072916666662, 1.610953125, 1.8788697916666663, 0.9874375000000004 ], "df": 9, "t": 18.323144680047882, "p": 1.9627405764202427e-08, "ci95": [ 1.3151908743194705, 1.6856747506805299 ], "shapiro_p": 0.21350252096042976, "lag1": -0.4378067501128127, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1800521850717547, "p_holm": 7.850962305680971e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.306931770833334, "sd": 0.08754597906850642, "median": 8.275625000000002, "min": 8.213151041666666, "max": 8.481791666666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.7327765625, "sd": 0.08247090347952805, "median": 9.700898437500001, "min": 9.649557291666667, "max": 9.9289375 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.4258447916666668, "sd": 0.1237503693322445, "median": 1.4368515625000002, "min": 1.2826354166666665, "max": 1.6919322916666673 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.4386718750000007, 1.3512447916666677, 1.4927812500000002, 1.4999583333333337, 1.6919322916666673, 1.2872552083333328, 1.456083333333332, 1.4350312499999998, 1.3228541666666676, 1.2826354166666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 36.435585250250156, "p": 4.376576083596062e-11, "ci95": [ 1.3373191103484254, 1.5143704729849081 ], "shapiro_p": 0.28398575822991456, "lag1": -0.0639841563046274, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1716451791108944, "p_holm": 5.251891300315274e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.438593749999999, "sd": 0.09665027458573555, "median": 8.4181015625, "min": 8.32246875, "max": 8.614807291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 9.555628645833334, "sd": 0.057474889000398606, "median": 9.546302083333334, "min": 9.473541666666666, "max": 9.66415625 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1170348958333336, "sd": 0.13773068145642348, "median": 1.1193411458333333, "min": 0.8955572916666661, "max": 1.320401041666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.9996979166666673, 1.1578593749999992, 1.0527552083333322, 1.320401041666667, 0.974984375, 1.2019114583333348, 0.8955572916666661, 1.0808229166666674, 1.2539583333333333, 1.2324010416666678 ], "df": 9, "t": 25.646968847967756, "p": 1.0032277194070912e-09, "ci95": [ 1.0185083016894354, 1.2155614899772318 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8841013472961248, "lag1": -0.38454514394046035, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1323721616333686, "p_holm": 9.02904947466382e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.453772395833333, "sd": 0.11369062556283405, "median": 8.4308125, "min": 8.347786458333333, "max": 8.744776041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.560730208333334, "sd": 0.057838843826857604, "median": 9.556697916666668, "min": 9.450354166666667, "max": 9.661848958333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1069578125000001, "sd": 0.1305595091528383, "median": 1.1369192708333333, "min": 0.8555989583333332, "max": 1.2522083333333338 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.1837760416666665, 1.0598906249999995, 1.248984375000001, 1.1880937500000002, 1.1810624999999995, 1.0927760416666672, 0.8555989583333332, 1.2522083333333338, 0.9435885416666672, 1.0635989583333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 26.81158947311736, "p": 6.758658879428473e-10, "ci95": [ 1.013561165987377, 1.2003544590126232 ], "shapiro_p": 0.28589019199551313, "lag1": -0.2886950779501161, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1309424669447683, "p_holm": 5.406927103542778e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.438593749999999, "sd": 0.09665027458573555, "median": 8.4181015625, "min": 8.32246875, "max": 8.614807291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 9.467708854166666, "sd": 0.06812950539781465, "median": 9.436471354166667, "min": 9.400333333333334, "max": 9.609052083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.0291151041666668, "sd": 0.1466634709677314, "median": 1.0607031250000007, "min": 0.8001510416666662, "max": 1.2865833333333327 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8810156249999999, 1.0739583333333336, 0.9795468750000005, 1.0732500000000016, 0.8891510416666666, 1.1860885416666669, 0.8001510416666662, 1.0729843750000008, 1.2865833333333327, 1.0484218750000007 ], "df": 9, "t": 22.18921782073547, "p": 3.625818370562335e-09, "ci95": [ 0.9241983773562721, 1.1340318309770616 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8077900994223023, "lag1": -0.37942935948052287, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1219533887582476, "p_holm": 2.900654696449868e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.453772395833333, "sd": 0.11369062556283405, "median": 8.4308125, "min": 8.347786458333333, "max": 8.744776041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.454279166666666, "sd": 0.09231573839184838, "median": 9.4248828125, "min": 9.387333333333334, "max": 9.694921875 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.0005067708333335, "sd": 0.1389965506994647, "median": 1.007122395833334, "min": 0.6880833333333332, "max": 1.2449531250000003 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.9813697916666673, 0.9205625000000008, 1.0557343750000001, 1.0300989583333333, 1.0760364583333324, 0.9939843750000001, 0.6880833333333332, 1.0072656250000005, 1.0069791666666674, 1.2449531250000003 ], "df": 9, "t": 22.76229298016414, "p": 2.892855237345312e-09, "ci95": [ 0.9010746283843698, 1.0999389132822972 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1281188874516066, "lag1": 0.01877189878501864, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.118350332134144, "p_holm": 1.7357131424071872e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.176827083333334, "sd": 0.06591209077959412, "median": 10.165315104166666, "min": 10.083333333333334, "max": 10.297177083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 16.3664703125, "sd": 0.1853338094337748, "median": 16.28275, "min": 16.234911458333332, "max": 16.851807291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.189643229166666, "sd": 0.2089446472817924, "median": 6.15671875, "min": 5.964734375000001, "max": 6.7150156249999995 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.105098958333334, 6.044744791666666, 6.7150156249999995, 6.138635416666665, 6.3096354166666675, 6.174802083333335, 6.206109374999999, 5.964734375000001, 6.0458333333333325, 6.1918229166666645 ], "df": 9, "t": 93.67730048431758, "p": 9.127257941715543e-15, "ci95": [ 6.040173232768033, 6.339113225565302 ], "shapiro_p": 0.019009106531056225, "lag1": -0.18119441075660592, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6082095311714089, "p_holm": 2.099269326594575e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.136428645833334, "sd": 0.056706053501591976, "median": 10.114304687499999, "min": 10.092192708333334, "max": 10.272052083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 16.37639375, "sd": 0.14803352133047457, "median": 16.309281249999998, "min": 16.259296875, "max": 16.760223958333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.239965104166667, "sd": 0.10860119914748532, "median": 6.188921875000001, "min": 6.162817708333334, "max": 6.488171875000001 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.1971927083333345, 6.167104166666666, 6.199499999999999, 6.165020833333333, 6.180651041666668, 6.178057291666665, 6.488171875000001, 6.315921875000001, 6.162817708333334, 6.345213541666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 181.6969094635767, "p": 2.3564525116036037e-17, "ci95": [ 6.162276486359817, 6.317653721973516 ], "shapiro_p": 0.003065896062578512, "lag1": 0.0730682697942103, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6155979903959228, "p_holm": 7.540648037131532e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.176827083333334, "sd": 0.06591209077959412, "median": 10.165315104166666, "min": 10.083333333333334, "max": 10.297177083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 11.567136979166667, "sd": 0.06342903639499933, "median": 11.5560625, "min": 11.500479166666667, "max": 11.690864583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.390309895833333, "sd": 0.08710139318570308, "median": 1.389736979166666, "min": 1.256421875000001, "max": 1.5540729166666658 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.4266354166666666, 1.3683593750000007, 1.5540729166666658, 1.383848958333333, 1.4774374999999988, 1.395624999999999, 1.3343333333333334, 1.256421875000001, 1.2892187499999999, 1.4171458333333327 ], "df": 9, "t": 50.476183715353365, "p": 2.3595395345913107e-12, "ci95": [ 1.3280013126982742, 1.452618478968392 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9746554174998275, "lag1": 0.1840891802749193, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1366152617558232, "p_holm": 3.775263255346097e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.136428645833334, "sd": 0.056706053501591976, "median": 10.114304687499999, "min": 10.092192708333334, "max": 10.272052083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 11.567452604166666, "sd": 0.04107672895173058, "median": 11.566122395833332, "min": 11.501614583333334, "max": 11.647979166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.4310239583333333, "sd": 0.08771604835152247, "median": 1.458677083333333, "min": 1.2295625000000001, "max": 1.5154895833333342 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.4931354166666662, 1.4617864583333322, 1.4485885416666662, 1.3197291666666668, 1.445244791666667, 1.4774427083333332, 1.2295625000000001, 1.4555677083333336, 1.5154895833333342, 1.4636927083333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 51.59027543589384, "p": 1.9398246237654866e-12, "ci95": [ 1.3682756773806148, 1.4937722392860517 ], "shapiro_p": 0.005365829275342163, "lag1": -0.1521306244059501, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1411763460616444, "p_holm": 3.491684322777876e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.176827083333334, "sd": 0.06591209077959412, "median": 10.165315104166666, "min": 10.083333333333334, "max": 10.297177083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.181490625, "sd": 0.05294486695946394, "median": 12.175393229166666, "min": 12.107588541666667, "max": 12.290130208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.0046635416666665, "sd": 0.09167760062762527, "median": 2.0020755208333334, "min": 1.8768229166666668, "max": 2.206796875 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.0055572916666673, 1.9291510416666675, 2.030843749999999, 2.0363229166666663, 1.9713802083333327, 2.0653749999999995, 1.9257916666666652, 1.8768229166666668, 1.9985937499999995, 2.206796875 ], "df": 9, "t": 69.14778190711394, "p": 1.3980588883545087e-13, "ci95": [ 1.9390813369348747, 2.0702457463984594 ], "shapiro_p": 0.48696268729072845, "lag1": 0.011156027622267538, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1969831584295776, "p_holm": 2.9359236655444685e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.136428645833334, "sd": 0.056706053501591976, "median": 10.114304687499999, "min": 10.092192708333334, "max": 10.272052083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 12.205571354166667, "sd": 0.10469752589411675, "median": 12.176598958333333, "min": 12.101348958333332, "max": 12.422640625 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.069142708333333, "sd": 0.08368483853291299, "median": 2.0711770833333336, "min": 1.963697916666666, "max": 2.238598958333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.238598958333334, 2.0854166666666654, 2.0609374999999996, 1.963697916666666, 2.0015572916666677, 1.9916145833333339, 2.150588541666666, 2.0073906249999993, 2.1102083333333326, 2.0814166666666676 ], "df": 9, "t": 78.18864058259936, "p": 4.634087593667443e-14, "ci95": [ 2.009278181163774, 2.1290072355028924 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5788389663805302, "lag1": 0.050845503098315675, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2041293615956021, "p_holm": 1.0194992706068375e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.176827083333334, "sd": 0.06591209077959412, "median": 10.165315104166666, "min": 10.083333333333334, "max": 10.297177083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.4039046875, "sd": 0.12210744591194181, "median": 8.41653125, "min": 8.253411458333334, "max": 8.61096875 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.7729223958333336, "sd": 0.15376952270714292, "median": -1.7898697916666677, "min": -2.0203749999999996, "max": -1.5006302083333338 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.926567708333332, -1.647588541666666, -1.6748072916666672, -1.8870520833333337, -1.6643750000000015, -1.5006302083333338, -1.7954322916666676, -2.0203749999999996, -1.8280885416666663, -1.7843072916666678 ], "df": 9, "t": -36.46023468664587, "p": 4.3501803809303e-11, "ci95": [ -1.8829224858297011, -1.662922305836966 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9714178159751486, "lag1": 0.06293441501342127, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8257882951812298, "p_holm": 6.260348448397332e-10 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.136428645833334, "sd": 0.056706053501591976, "median": 10.114304687499999, "min": 10.092192708333334, "max": 10.272052083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 8.375098958333334, "sd": 0.060524157949577446, "median": 8.364127604166667, "min": 8.2868125, "max": 8.461510416666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.7613296875, "sd": 0.09424502738699006, "median": -1.766690104166667, "min": -1.9502916666666668, "max": -1.632447916666667 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.660145833333333, -1.767677083333334, -1.7722395833333326, -1.8083802083333342, -1.676963541666666, -1.7337708333333328, -1.9502916666666668, -1.632447916666667, -1.8456770833333334, -1.765703125 ], "df": 9, "t": -59.09928276747979, "p": 5.728734256475786e-13, "ci95": [ -1.8287485186946777, -1.6939108563053222 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7323757340003103, "lag1": -0.5635830273553926, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00\u6570\u5024\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u691c\u51fa\u30fbballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8262376474949084, "p_holm": 1.0884595087303994e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 7.974336979166667, "sd": 0.059181010210893795, "median": 7.970682291666667, "min": 7.894588541666667, "max": 8.093255208333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.168519270833333, "sd": 0.09468697728873458, "median": 5.171697916666667, "min": 4.956671875, "max": 5.315994791666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.126875, 5.226901041666668, 5.198385416666667, 5.166567708333334, 5.315994791666667, 5.176828125, 5.118015625, 4.956671875, 5.241234375000001, 5.157718749999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 172.6139485524646, "p": 3.738103070590846e-17, "ci95": [ 5.10078428772435, 5.2362542539423185 ], "shapiro_p": 0.42115720775104026, "lag1": -0.07241990903108483, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.8420723682378686, "p_holm": 1.1588119518831623e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 8.021575520833334, "sd": 0.30301819540824443, "median": 7.916028645833333, "min": 7.885578125, "max": 8.876791666666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.220578645833333, "sd": 0.3224701400341594, "median": 5.1392109375, "min": 4.884812500000001, "max": 6.099885416666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.108390625, 5.127255208333334, 5.141583333333333, 4.884812500000001, 5.129401041666666, 6.099885416666668, 5.136838541666667, 5.176234375, 5.247302083333334, 5.1540833333333325 ], "df": 9, "t": 51.19518732221856, "p": 2.078347129738902e-12, "ci95": [ 4.98989740419057, 5.4512598874760965 ], "shapiro_p": 7.593076642063725e-05, "lag1": -0.08517020617408035, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.863828800534929, "p_holm": 3.533190120556133e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 7.973168229166666, "sd": 0.05312480602327089, "median": 7.969768229166666, "min": 7.91659375, "max": 8.06240625 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.167350520833333, "sd": 0.07691248784256577, "median": 5.161713541666666, "min": 5.0466927083333335, "max": 5.2849635416666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.0790572916666665, 5.183848958333334, 5.14259375, 5.178421875, 5.20534375, 5.145005208333333, 5.279442708333334, 5.0466927083333335, 5.128135416666666, 5.2849635416666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 212.45700890262057, "p": 5.768688045173519e-18, "ci95": [ 5.11233064149977, 5.222370400166898 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7365962242973486, "lag1": -0.4216361660885542, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.841655823001687, "p_holm": 2.076727696262467e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 7.970438541666667, "sd": 0.09342714346197711, "median": 7.933057291666667, "min": 7.904729166666667, "max": 8.204760416666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.169441666666667, "sd": 0.12636643995154007, "median": 5.149315104166666, "min": 4.925098958333333, "max": 5.427343749999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.151848958333333, 5.137953125, 5.27665625, 4.925098958333333, 5.427343749999999, 5.2048749999999995, 5.128296875, 5.135468749999999, 5.16009375, 5.14678125 ], "df": 9, "t": 129.36353911934643, "p": 5.007357576849818e-16, "ci95": [ 5.079044561164405, 5.259838772168928 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1163184974354981, "lag1": -0.5756866282423654, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.8455720935663904, "p_holm": 1.3019129699809526e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 9.1388578125, "sd": 0.11866129169332201, "median": 9.127921875, "min": 9.01640625, "max": 9.447046875 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.333040104166667, "sd": 0.12420407733365477, "median": 6.309976562499999, "min": 6.190864583333334, "max": 6.6474270833333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.291239583333333, 6.238760416666667, 6.282296875, 6.6474270833333335, 6.36384375, 6.271786458333334, 6.328713541666667, 6.190864583333334, 6.3755781250000005, 6.339890624999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 161.24133500511206, "p": 6.901896499703785e-17, "ci95": [ 6.244189859696322, 6.42189034863701 ], "shapiro_p": 0.018921021044243064, "lag1": -0.031014807762524986, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.257110319518411, "p_holm": 1.9325310199170596e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.061188541666667, "sd": 0.0895375797242164, "median": 9.03528125, "min": 9.002588541666666, "max": 9.301010416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.260191666666667, "sd": 0.12506017036089662, "median": 6.251682291666667, "min": 6.009229166666666, "max": 6.5241041666666675 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.311744791666667, 6.226729166666667, 6.225385416666667, 6.009229166666666, 6.292697916666667, 6.5241041666666675, 6.235645833333334, 6.280359375, 6.26771875, 6.2283020833333325 ], "df": 9, "t": 158.29551646014824, "p": 8.14732961104279e-17, "ci95": [ 6.170729010137132, 6.3496543231962015 ], "shapiro_p": 0.055938850199857296, "lag1": 0.01237837354846065, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.23498702284938, "p_holm": 2.362725587202409e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 9.132416145833334, "sd": 0.09485880544397086, "median": 9.105669270833333, "min": 9.024619791666666, "max": 9.347135416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.3265984375, "sd": 0.1119242243672256, "median": 6.322809895833334, "min": 6.127869791666666, "max": 6.569630208333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.354895833333334, 6.347354166666667, 6.296213541666667, 6.390864583333334, 6.320374999999999, 6.569630208333334, 6.248046874999999, 6.127869791666666, 6.325244791666668, 6.285489583333332 ], "df": 9, "t": 178.75005180398503, "p": 2.72995112058784e-17, "ci95": [ 6.246532670653495, 6.406664204346504 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3436883906587629, "lag1": -0.06227338142415881, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.2548144944377104, "p_holm": 8.735843585881088e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.116916666666667, "sd": 0.10773864608998932, "median": 9.104703125, "min": 8.944802083333334, "max": 9.325953125 }, "difference": { "mean": 6.3159197916666665, "sd": 0.1382773803514499, "median": 6.323046874999999, "min": 6.0673385416666665, "max": 6.548859374999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 6.363208333333333, 6.252723958333334, 6.268770833333333, 6.0673385416666665, 6.167385416666667, 6.396067708333334, 6.349005208333334, 6.297088541666666, 6.44875, 6.548859374999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 144.43932919353574, "p": 1.8575281042437785e-16, "ci95": [ 6.217002112692724, 6.414837470640609 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9988148122875742, "lag1": 0.47912499669632796, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.254882841190841, "p_holm": 5.20107869188258e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 10.3500484375, "sd": 0.07941199951832559, "median": 10.333671875, "min": 10.253286458333333, "max": 10.538354166666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.544230729166666, "sd": 0.11470648301290352, "median": 7.536203125, "min": 7.305640625, "max": 7.76109375 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.480458333333333, 7.5319270833333345, 7.533213541666667, 7.589229166666668, 7.76109375, 7.508838541666667, 7.570026041666666, 7.305640625, 7.539192708333333, 7.6226875 ], "df": 9, "t": 207.9825975949053, "p": 6.986477028085679e-18, "ci95": [ 7.462174654383779, 7.6262868039495535 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3649788271239016, "lag1": -0.028359937952600868, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.6887814938084373, "p_holm": 2.4452669598299874e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.365504166666668, "sd": 0.056903640360397544, "median": 10.361869791666667, "min": 10.273166666666667, "max": 10.447598958333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.564507291666667, "sd": 0.10662801851107108, "median": 7.584614583333332, "min": 7.304229166666666, "max": 7.670692708333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.623494791666667, 7.525177083333334, 7.495963541666667, 7.304229166666666, 7.585583333333332, 7.670692708333334, 7.650223958333334, 7.567994791666665, 7.638067708333335, 7.583645833333332 ], "df": 9, "t": 224.34133872734967, "p": 3.5348369586418804e-18, "ci95": [ 7.488230202254804, 7.64078438107853 ], "shapiro_p": 0.03710870112547234, "lag1": 0.25863279938568007, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.7006482439101855, "p_holm": 1.272541305111077e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "after": { "mean": 10.293652604166667, "sd": 0.11815683163711563, "median": 10.252473958333333, "min": 10.1395, "max": 10.526427083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.487834895833333, "sd": 0.13984307631075246, "median": 7.469958333333334, "min": 7.282552083333333, "max": 7.726807291666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.375333333333334, 7.657187500000001, 7.549208333333334, 7.726807291666667, 7.5773593749999995, 7.361994791666667, 7.489802083333333, 7.282552083333333, 7.450114583333335, 7.4079895833333325 ], "df": 9, "t": 169.32274116671684, "p": 4.445039063018612e-17, "ci95": [ 7.3877971854422535, 7.587872606224413 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9318396399984915, "lag1": 0.15261460345657746, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.6686818867791433, "p_holm": 1.2890613282753975e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.255432291666667, "sd": 0.05147530389115448, "median": 10.243403645833332, "min": 10.191223958333333, "max": 10.344661458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 7.454435416666667, "sd": 0.0602608409245127, "median": 7.4584609375, "min": 7.328031249999999, "max": 7.566885416666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.464859375, 7.414177083333334, 7.566885416666667, 7.328031249999999, 7.4673437499999995, 7.4818437499999995, 7.433473958333333, 7.4520625, 7.45040625, 7.485270833333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 391.1826357820377, "p": 2.373286799090764e-20, "ci95": [ 7.411327407951717, 7.4975434253816164 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3553780858708854, "lag1": -0.6579523323415352, "reference": "limit.instant.max.0.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "question": "\u5373\u6642\u5236\u9650\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u5236\u9650\u306eCPU\u8ffd\u52a0\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u97f3\u97ff\u52b9\u679c\u30fb\u9045\u5ef6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 3.661350850906132, "p_holm": 9.967804556181208e-19 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.974336979166667, "sd": 0.059181010210893795, "median": 7.970682291666667, "min": 7.894588541666667, "max": 8.093255208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.1388578125, "sd": 0.11866129169332201, "median": 9.127921875, "min": 9.01640625, "max": 9.447046875 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.164520833333333, "sd": 0.13188103485932037, "median": 1.149354166666666, "min": 1.0118593749999985, "max": 1.4808593749999996 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.1643645833333327, 1.0118593749999985, 1.0839114583333327, 1.4808593749999996, 1.0478489583333328, 1.0949583333333335, 1.2106979166666667, 1.2341927083333344, 1.1343437499999993, 1.1821718749999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 27.923182586327798, "p": 4.707547483950022e-10, "ci95": [ 1.0701788242801602, 1.2588628423865058 ], "shapiro_p": 0.10557130156605216, "lag1": -0.28518543657076995, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1460335619595332, "p_holm": 5.178302232345025e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.021575520833334, "sd": 0.30301819540824443, "median": 7.916028645833333, "min": 7.885578125, "max": 8.876791666666668 }, "after": { "mean": 9.061188541666667, "sd": 0.0895375797242164, "median": 9.03528125, "min": 9.002588541666666, "max": 9.301010416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.0396130208333334, "sd": 0.22180533113631107, "median": 1.099140625, "min": 0.42421874999999964, "max": 1.2033541666666672 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.2033541666666672, 1.0994739583333333, 1.0838020833333335, 1.124416666666666, 1.1632968750000003, 0.42421874999999964, 1.0988072916666667, 1.1041250000000007, 1.0204166666666659, 1.07421875 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.821758404810584, "p": 1.2514648991118238e-07, "ci95": [ 0.8809430454238629, 1.1982829962428034 ], "shapiro_p": 3.303210150565758e-05, "lag1": -0.1980710514689529, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1296020985071185, "p_holm": 3.754394697335471e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.974336979166667, "sd": 0.059181010210893795, "median": 7.970682291666667, "min": 7.894588541666667, "max": 8.093255208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.3500484375, "sd": 0.07941199951832559, "median": 10.333671875, "min": 10.253286458333333, "max": 10.538354166666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.375711458333333, "sd": 0.06380121362785943, "median": 2.3512760416666665, "min": 2.297958333333332, "max": 2.4649687500000006 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.353583333333333, 2.3050260416666664, 2.3348281249999996, 2.4226614583333337, 2.4450989583333325, 2.332010416666667, 2.452010416666666, 2.34896875, 2.297958333333332, 2.4649687500000006 ], "df": 9, "t": 117.75104021552755, "p": 1.1669041798864318e-15, "ci95": [ 2.330070819555334, 2.421352097111332 ], "shapiro_p": 0.12479153217714878, "lag1": -0.22914423737813525, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2979196219748415, "p_holm": 2.9172604497160793e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.021575520833334, "sd": 0.30301819540824443, "median": 7.916028645833333, "min": 7.885578125, "max": 8.876791666666668 }, "after": { "mean": 10.365504166666668, "sd": 0.056903640360397544, "median": 10.361869791666667, "min": 10.273166666666667, "max": 10.447598958333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.343928645833333, "sd": 0.27666101370269375, "median": 2.4086692708333333, "min": 1.5708072916666662, "max": 2.515104166666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.515104166666667, 2.3979218750000006, 2.3543802083333336, 2.419416666666666, 2.456182291666666, 1.5708072916666662, 2.513385416666667, 2.391760416666666, 2.3907656250000002, 2.4295624999999994 ], "df": 9, "t": 26.791462572000622, "p": 6.803975585157485e-10, "ci95": [ 2.1460172790682663, 2.5418400125983998 ], "shapiro_p": 1.2833402422620003e-05, "lag1": -0.27827176681756877, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.292203026667987, "p_holm": 5.406927103542778e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.973168229166666, "sd": 0.05312480602327089, "median": 7.969768229166666, "min": 7.91659375, "max": 8.06240625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.132416145833334, "sd": 0.09485880544397086, "median": 9.105669270833333, "min": 9.024619791666666, "max": 9.347135416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1592479166666665, "sd": 0.13246349100932053, "median": 1.1585625, "min": 0.9686041666666654, "max": 1.4246250000000007 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.2758385416666673, 1.1635052083333335, 1.1536197916666664, 1.2124427083333336, 1.1150312499999995, 1.4246250000000007, 0.9686041666666654, 1.0811770833333325, 1.197109375000001, 1.0005260416666655 ], "df": 9, "t": 27.674521949703053, "p": 5.097905987791397e-10, "ci95": [ 1.064489243584166, 1.254006589749167 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8631353087033689, "lag1": -0.41500130869442237, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.145393635672457, "p_holm": 5.178302232345025e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.970438541666667, "sd": 0.09342714346197711, "median": 7.933057291666667, "min": 7.904729166666667, "max": 8.204760416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.116916666666667, "sd": 0.10773864608998932, "median": 9.104703125, "min": 8.944802083333334, "max": 9.325953125 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1464781250000002, "sd": 0.17874138951448523, "median": 1.1764062499999999, "min": 0.7400416666666683, "max": 1.402078125 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.2113593749999998, 1.114770833333334, 0.9921145833333327, 1.1422395833333336, 0.7400416666666683, 1.1911927083333333, 1.2207083333333335, 1.1616197916666664, 1.2886562499999998, 1.402078125 ], "df": 9, "t": 20.283394754886483, "p": 8.019598343540505e-09, "ci95": [ 1.0186142376280207, 1.2743420123719797 ], "shapiro_p": 0.24050361784301205, "lag1": 0.1141015667145017, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1438412853956044, "p_holm": 3.901412024068774e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.973168229166666, "sd": 0.05312480602327089, "median": 7.969768229166666, "min": 7.91659375, "max": 8.06240625 }, "after": { "mean": 10.293652604166667, "sd": 0.11815683163711563, "median": 10.252473958333333, "min": 10.1395, "max": 10.526427083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.320484375, "sd": 0.1312145456596554, "median": 2.3091276041666675, "min": 2.123026041666666, "max": 2.548385416666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.296276041666667, 2.473338541666667, 2.406614583333334, 2.548385416666666, 2.3720156249999995, 2.2169895833333335, 2.2103593749999995, 2.2358593749999995, 2.321979166666668, 2.123026041666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 55.92379917136358, "p": 9.405791095715703e-13, "ci95": [ 2.2266191435985627, 2.414349606401438 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9420379379491353, "lag1": 0.4211095531264325, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2910366755477993, "p_holm": 1.7871003081859835e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.970438541666667, "sd": 0.09342714346197711, "median": 7.933057291666667, "min": 7.904729166666667, "max": 8.204760416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.255432291666667, "sd": 0.05147530389115448, "median": 10.243403645833332, "min": 10.191223958333333, "max": 10.344661458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.28499375, "sd": 0.09379712768003208, "median": 2.2977447916666662, "min": 2.040000000000001, "max": 2.4029322916666658 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.3130104166666667, 2.2762239583333335, 2.2902291666666663, 2.4029322916666658, 2.040000000000001, 2.276968749999999, 2.3051770833333327, 2.316593750000001, 2.2903124999999998, 2.3384895833333337 ], "df": 9, "t": 77.03631089747779, "p": 5.295648958554858e-14, "ci95": [ 2.217895326953877, 2.352092173046123 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0020970097799415262, "lag1": -0.3349521552343532, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.compensated.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u5148\u8aad\u307f\u9577\u3067\u5236\u5fa1\u5e73\u6ed1\u5316\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305f\u5834\u5408\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2866835667893117, "p_holm": 1.1120862812965203e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.4531854166666667, "sd": 0.026443183157909753, "median": 0.4420208333333333, "min": 0.439765625, "max": 0.52596875 }, "comp.peaklog.max.bass": { "mean": 11.298176041666666, "sd": 0.4115024113594466, "median": 11.167901041666667, "min": 11.088213541666667, "max": 12.451598958333333 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.bass": { "mean": 14.6061859375, "sd": 0.1538226960335173, "median": 14.555627604166666, "min": 14.444390625, "max": 14.959239583333334 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.bass": { "mean": 12.825824479166666, "sd": 0.08061953301048333, "median": 12.811372395833335, "min": 12.750739583333333, "max": 13.016182291666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.bass": { "mean": 13.880125, "sd": 0.045149035785273406, "median": 13.853390625, "min": 13.838453125, "max": 13.952354166666666 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.bass": { "mean": 9.687200520833333, "sd": 0.0938360319711275, "median": 9.675484375, "min": 9.577125, "max": 9.878625 }, "limit.instant.max.0.bass": { "mean": 2.7865604166666667, "sd": 0.01586326137916533, "median": 2.7774192708333336, "min": 2.776328125, "max": 2.8244739583333334 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 7.928752083333333, "sd": 0.070399594986732, "median": 7.937007812499999, "min": 7.836411458333333, "max": 8.073947916666667 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 7.9398687500000005, "sd": 0.09537957604221887, "median": 7.907591145833333, "min": 7.8590052083333335, "max": 8.104078125 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.002408333333333, "sd": 0.04544264941495682, "median": 9.002057291666667, "min": 8.918583333333334, "max": 9.10090625 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.069219270833333, "sd": 0.11396614779901876, "median": 9.036447916666667, "min": 8.908177083333333, "max": 9.210848958333333 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.bass": { "mean": 10.309420833333334, "sd": 0.08949654743910743, "median": 10.270354166666667, "min": 10.209786458333333, "max": 10.490588541666666 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.bass": { "mean": 10.1009015625, "sd": 0.0614130485552828, "median": 10.0739765625, "min": 10.040901041666666, "max": 10.2415 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.466303125, "sd": 0.04065643658444009, "median": 0.4417317708333333, "min": 0.43918229166666667, "max": 0.5459739583333333 }, "comp.peaklog.max.pad": { "mean": 15.342317708333333, "sd": 0.10931714042249924, "median": 15.294619791666666, "min": 15.262541666666667, "max": 15.626213541666667 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.pad": { "mean": 17.629436979166666, "sd": 0.042558278231373606, "median": 17.617153645833334, "min": 17.583796875, "max": 17.712671875 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.pad": { "mean": 17.089408854166667, "sd": 0.09859494944249254, "median": 17.045588541666667, "min": 16.994333333333334, "max": 17.296020833333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.pad": { "mean": 19.018631770833334, "sd": 0.09073001761125883, "median": 18.973846354166668, "min": 18.944947916666667, "max": 19.216473958333335 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.pad": { "mean": 14.903473437499999, "sd": 0.08042966810026038, "median": 14.86128125, "min": 14.820114583333334, "max": 15.023817708333333 }, "limit.instant.max.0.pad": { "mean": 2.7925859375, "sd": 0.028067628303726725, "median": 2.7773697916666666, "min": 2.7766614583333333, "max": 2.8652864583333333 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 8.333321875, "sd": 0.13196108668802412, "median": 8.29765625, "min": 8.230625, "max": 8.695625 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 8.438593749999999, "sd": 0.09665027458573555, "median": 8.4181015625, "min": 8.32246875, "max": 8.614807291666667 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.434925, "sd": 0.09333765201002743, "median": 9.403343750000001, "min": 9.322390625, "max": 9.599927083333334 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.555628645833334, "sd": 0.057474889000398606, "median": 9.546302083333334, "min": 9.473541666666666, "max": 9.66415625 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.8337546875, "sd": 0.19688404963784245, "median": 9.741723958333335, "min": 9.6830625, "max": 10.236505208333334 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.467708854166666, "sd": 0.06812950539781465, "median": 9.436471354166667, "min": 9.400333333333334, "max": 9.609052083333333 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.4511734375, "sd": 0.030745636186999045, "median": 0.441375, "min": 0.44047916666666664, "max": 0.53865625 }, "comp.peaklog.max.drums": { "mean": 10.176827083333334, "sd": 0.06591209077959412, "median": 10.165315104166666, "min": 10.083333333333334, "max": 10.297177083333333 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.drums": { "mean": 16.3664703125, "sd": 0.1853338094337748, "median": 16.28275, "min": 16.234911458333332, "max": 16.851807291666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.drums": { "mean": 11.567136979166667, "sd": 0.06342903639499933, "median": 11.5560625, "min": 11.500479166666667, "max": 11.690864583333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.drums": { "mean": 12.181490625, "sd": 0.05294486695946394, "median": 12.175393229166666, "min": 12.107588541666667, "max": 12.290130208333334 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.drums": { "mean": 8.4039046875, "sd": 0.12210744591194181, "median": 8.41653125, "min": 8.253411458333334, "max": 8.61096875 }, "limit.instant.max.0.drums": { "mean": 2.8058177083333335, "sd": 0.05599801589168986, "median": 2.7775755208333335, "min": 2.776572916666667, "max": 2.9476458333333335 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 7.974336979166667, "sd": 0.059181010210893795, "median": 7.970682291666667, "min": 7.894588541666667, "max": 8.093255208333334 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 7.973168229166666, "sd": 0.05312480602327089, "median": 7.969768229166666, "min": 7.91659375, "max": 8.06240625 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.1388578125, "sd": 0.11866129169332201, "median": 9.127921875, "min": 9.01640625, "max": 9.447046875 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.132416145833334, "sd": 0.09485880544397086, "median": 9.105669270833333, "min": 9.024619791666666, "max": 9.347135416666667 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.drums": { "mean": 10.3500484375, "sd": 0.07941199951832559, "median": 10.333671875, "min": 10.253286458333333, "max": 10.538354166666666 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.drums": { "mean": 10.293652604166667, "sd": 0.11815683163711563, "median": 10.252473958333333, "min": 10.1395, "max": 10.526427083333333 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.4453213541666667, "sd": 0.009625181015438496, "median": 0.4415598958333333, "min": 0.44059375, "max": 0.471984375 }, "comp.peaklog.max.bass": { "mean": 11.194578645833333, "sd": 0.0734255829676955, "median": 11.159052083333332, "min": 11.123958333333333, "max": 11.301697916666667 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.bass": { "mean": 14.498142708333333, "sd": 0.048991194534600484, "median": 14.484572916666668, "min": 14.449489583333333, "max": 14.573473958333333 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.bass": { "mean": 12.817852083333333, "sd": 0.08160025357105652, "median": 12.801799479166666, "min": 12.743640625, "max": 13.021421875 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.bass": { "mean": 13.878302083333333, "sd": 0.02821537990177612, "median": 13.879796875, "min": 13.840776041666667, "max": 13.924895833333334 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.bass": { "mean": 9.66693125, "sd": 0.07521370938676297, "median": 9.686619791666667, "min": 9.567645833333334, "max": 9.784057291666667 }, "limit.instant.max.0.bass": { "mean": 2.7938010416666668, "sd": 0.027171468151722323, "median": 2.7774479166666666, "min": 2.776484375, "max": 2.8517552083333335 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 7.972954166666667, "sd": 0.3305845066012232, "median": 7.866296875, "min": 7.821338541666667, "max": 8.903822916666666 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 7.89966875, "sd": 0.06365912760091604, "median": 7.888830729166667, "min": 7.835671875, "max": 8.041848958333333 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.041286458333333, "sd": 0.07198547292080512, "median": 9.031236979166668, "min": 8.965265625, "max": 9.225005208333334 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.013110416666667, "sd": 0.07816496974462064, "median": 9.0165234375, "min": 8.910989583333333, "max": 9.162463541666666 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.bass": { "mean": 10.294591666666667, "sd": 0.08403846688641109, "median": 10.269411458333334, "min": 10.200989583333333, "max": 10.494364583333333 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.bass": { "mean": 10.148982291666666, "sd": 0.08313355212637841, "median": 10.11790625, "min": 10.063177083333333, "max": 10.285130208333333 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4510958333333333, "sd": 0.031220398422074965, "median": 0.4413697916666667, "min": 0.44004166666666666, "max": 0.5399270833333333 }, "comp.peaklog.max.pad": { "mean": 15.355978125, "sd": 0.1471117741124535, "median": 15.302158854166667, "min": 15.276927083333334, "max": 15.762463541666667 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.pad": { "mean": 17.611311458333333, "sd": 0.04299699540222328, "median": 17.598890625, "min": 17.573828125, "max": 17.714854166666665 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.pad": { "mean": 17.051503125, "sd": 0.015701128815601387, "median": 17.0478046875, "min": 17.031473958333333, "max": 17.070989583333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.pad": { "mean": 19.0578890625, "sd": 0.12495068474178345, "median": 19.02278385416667, "min": 18.940328125, "max": 19.366640625 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.pad": { "mean": 14.860318229166666, "sd": 0.06454686295009254, "median": 14.8311015625, "min": 14.8004375, "max": 15.000619791666667 }, "limit.instant.max.0.pad": { "mean": 2.79300625, "sd": 0.03919461568663865, "median": 2.7779583333333333, "min": 2.775828125, "max": 2.9034375 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 8.306931770833334, "sd": 0.08754597906850642, "median": 8.275625000000002, "min": 8.213151041666666, "max": 8.481791666666666 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 8.453772395833333, "sd": 0.11369062556283405, "median": 8.4308125, "min": 8.347786458333333, "max": 8.744776041666666 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.4362234375, "sd": 0.10675322877252413, "median": 9.415067708333334, "min": 9.342786458333334, "max": 9.722770833333334 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.560730208333334, "sd": 0.057838843826857604, "median": 9.556697916666668, "min": 9.450354166666667, "max": 9.661848958333334 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.7327765625, "sd": 0.08247090347952805, "median": 9.700898437500001, "min": 9.649557291666667, "max": 9.9289375 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.454279166666666, "sd": 0.09231573839184838, "median": 9.4248828125, "min": 9.387333333333334, "max": 9.694921875 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.4466265625, "sd": 0.013418054281910176, "median": 0.4413489583333333, "min": 0.43963541666666667, "max": 0.483890625 }, "comp.peaklog.max.drums": { "mean": 10.136428645833334, "sd": 0.056706053501591976, "median": 10.114304687499999, "min": 10.092192708333334, "max": 10.272052083333334 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.drums": { "mean": 16.37639375, "sd": 0.14803352133047457, "median": 16.309281249999998, "min": 16.259296875, "max": 16.760223958333334 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.drums": { "mean": 11.567452604166666, "sd": 0.04107672895173058, "median": 11.566122395833332, "min": 11.501614583333334, "max": 11.647979166666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.drums": { "mean": 12.205571354166667, "sd": 0.10469752589411675, "median": 12.176598958333333, "min": 12.101348958333332, "max": 12.422640625 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.drums": { "mean": 8.375098958333334, "sd": 0.060524157949577446, "median": 8.364127604166667, "min": 8.2868125, "max": 8.461510416666666 }, "limit.instant.max.0.drums": { "mean": 2.800996875, "sd": 0.07576625866736356, "median": 2.777080729166667, "min": 2.7764322916666666, "max": 3.0166302083333334 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 8.021575520833334, "sd": 0.30301819540824443, "median": 7.916028645833333, "min": 7.885578125, "max": 8.876791666666668 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 7.970438541666667, "sd": 0.09342714346197711, "median": 7.933057291666667, "min": 7.904729166666667, "max": 8.204760416666666 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.061188541666667, "sd": 0.0895375797242164, "median": 9.03528125, "min": 9.002588541666666, "max": 9.301010416666667 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.116916666666667, "sd": 0.10773864608998932, "median": 9.104703125, "min": 8.944802083333334, "max": 9.325953125 }, "limit.compensated.max.1.drums": { "mean": 10.365504166666668, "sd": 0.056903640360397544, "median": 10.361869791666667, "min": 10.273166666666667, "max": 10.447598958333334 }, "limit.compensated.max.5.drums": { "mean": 10.255432291666667, "sd": 0.05147530389115448, "median": 10.243403645833332, "min": 10.191223958333333, "max": 10.344661458333333 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "ae0a39c0b25cdb89fdd241f9facbe183dc60e1752fa3ba6b64c83f62e73594a0" }, { "family": "DX03", "jobs": 27, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056119, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 13.645876041666666, "sd": 0.07343826605195428, "median": 13.667942708333333, "min": 13.524916666666666, "max": 13.757369791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.9273723958333338, "sd": 0.07950594420106592, "median": 2.9266796875, "min": 2.7847239583333323, "max": 3.0271197916666672 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.0271197916666672, 2.826437500000001, 2.914755208333334, 2.954760416666666, 2.90325, 2.9942343750000013, 2.9036927083333346, 2.938604166666666, 3.0261458333333344, 2.7847239583333323 ], "df": 9, "t": 116.43361289976639, "p": 1.2911787674471428e-15, "ci95": [ 2.8704972695833826, 2.984247522083284 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5750820355722628, "lag1": -0.6221620850813464, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2731139058735412, "p_holm": 2.8405932883837142e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "after": { "mean": 13.578968229166666, "sd": 0.0856269780402694, "median": 13.540924479166666, "min": 13.482078125, "max": 13.731182291666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.800636458333333, "sd": 0.13378775742638718, "median": 2.802429687499999, "min": 2.6201510416666665, "max": 2.9942812500000002 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.7917968749999993, 2.6201510416666665, 2.9517708333333346, 2.94253125, 2.6555260416666666, 2.9942812500000002, 2.813062499999999, 2.702343749999999, 2.681166666666666, 2.853734375 ], "df": 9, "t": 66.19731339254685, "p": 2.0685323225351758e-13, "ci95": [ 2.7049304621240386, 2.8963424545426273 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4721513764171903, "lag1": -0.29026928542124353, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.259839511148839, "p_holm": 4.343917877323869e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.620780208333333, "sd": 0.06960601871039444, "median": 12.593950520833333, "min": 12.56653125, "max": 12.786401041666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.9022765625000002, "sd": 0.07528009148064176, "median": 1.867059895833334, "min": 1.8445833333333326, "max": 2.0726927083333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.996546875, 1.867979166666668, 1.923375, 1.8805833333333322, 1.8661406249999999, 1.8606510416666673, 2.0726927083333333, 1.8445833333333326, 1.8459895833333348, 1.8642239583333335 ], "df": 9, "t": 79.90859945491084, "p": 3.8108929873380723e-14, "ci95": [ 1.8484244291772198, 1.9561286958227806 ], "shapiro_p": 0.003841669605638742, "lag1": -0.29428052501020213, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1774759449038843, "p_holm": 7.621785974676145e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "after": { "mean": 12.640797916666667, "sd": 0.1218696608665506, "median": 12.594192708333333, "min": 12.568932291666666, "max": 12.966510416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.8624661458333334, "sd": 0.18916222822248188, "median": 1.8386276041666667, "min": 1.6310156249999999, "max": 2.2955000000000005 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.8340781249999996, 1.7187916666666663, 2.0064479166666676, 2.2955000000000005, 1.6871875000000003, 1.8431770833333339, 1.910124999999999, 1.798895833333333, 1.6310156249999999, 1.8994427083333338 ], "df": 9, "t": 31.135365348211057, "p": 1.7830588886004306e-10, "ci95": [ 1.7271476395255823, 1.997784652141085 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2507978390269364, "lag1": -0.07622868800194245, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1727972552184054, "p_holm": 2.496282444040603e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 13.706509895833333, "sd": 0.05218528536886792, "median": 13.6938125, "min": 13.653135416666666, "max": 13.828291666666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.98800625, "sd": 0.06980337017507832, "median": 2.9637942708333327, "min": 2.9006822916666675, "max": 3.1297395833333344 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.0788229166666667, 3.1297395833333344, 2.962880208333333, 2.9647083333333324, 2.9006822916666675, 2.998963541666667, 2.962171875000001, 2.9313906250000006, 3.010020833333334, 2.9406822916666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 135.3646018683495, "p": 3.3300626758345827e-16, "ci95": [ 2.9380719270852316, 3.0379405729147697 ], "shapiro_p": 0.25710686961135953, "lag1": 0.27303546641306714, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.278770838610625, "p_holm": 7.992150422002999e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "after": { "mean": 13.763036458333334, "sd": 0.11145753661233082, "median": 13.738588541666665, "min": 13.655255208333333, "max": 14.0434375 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.9847046875, "sd": 0.15457281339869375, "median": 2.9839765624999997, "min": 2.7035312499999993, "max": 3.2637031249999993 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.9692187499999996, 2.8813385416666666, 3.001270833333333, 3.157729166666668, 2.873432291666667, 3.0438229166666666, 2.9542656249999997, 3.2637031249999993, 2.7035312499999993, 2.9987343749999997 ], "df": 9, "t": 61.06161069305383, "p": 4.2724115059247964e-13, "ci95": [ 2.8741299579599295, 3.09527941704007 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8899660138418015, "lag1": -0.5388273776006034, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2769171288247734, "p_holm": 8.544823011849593e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.225908854166667, "sd": 0.10249603631023918, "median": 9.220723958333334, "min": 9.095713541666667, "max": 9.398682291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.4925947916666664, "sd": 0.11837159015676138, "median": -1.5120494791666665, "min": -1.6444791666666667, "max": -1.2897447916666671 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.3073645833333334, -1.5369687499999998, -1.4879479166666663, -1.2897447916666671, -1.4838958333333334, -1.5361510416666668, -1.5576197916666654, -1.455088541666667, -1.6266874999999992, -1.6444791666666667 ], "df": 9, "t": -39.874425604322845, "p": 1.9525046559410932e-11, "ci95": [ -1.5772727261560349, -1.407916857177298 ], "shapiro_p": 0.28969749336412887, "lag1": 0.1357058056105884, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.860745973413286, "p_holm": 3.5145083806939677e-10 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.176920833333334, "sd": 0.12467306954345286, "median": 9.103674479166667, "min": 9.090854166666666, "max": 9.430083333333334 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.6014109374999999, "sd": 0.16010101176758146, "median": -1.589744791666667, "min": -1.910708333333334, "max": -1.3496510416666663 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.4089687499999997, -1.7779791666666664, -1.5778020833333333, -1.5740260416666665, -1.6088749999999994, -1.6343645833333333, -1.6016875000000006, -1.3496510416666663, -1.910708333333334, -1.5700468749999992 ], "df": 9, "t": -31.630693500907473, "p": 1.5487486231434893e-10, "ci95": [ -1.7159403019208297, -1.4868815730791696 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4139219420869782, "lag1": -0.6028464385952093, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8514231170881665, "p_holm": 2.323122934715234e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 11.403043229166666, "sd": 0.04755508235961403, "median": 11.406830729166668, "min": 11.344208333333333, "max": 11.484984375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6845395833333334, "sd": 0.07017672492610498, "median": 0.6685677083333337, "min": 0.6053072916666657, "max": 0.8366197916666671 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8366197916666671, 0.6689687500000012, 0.6162708333333331, 0.7169322916666658, 0.648182291666668, 0.6396562499999998, 0.7576875000000012, 0.6053072916666657, 0.6876041666666666, 0.6681666666666661 ], "df": 9, "t": 30.846469882363014, "p": 1.9377359077131566e-10, "ci95": [ 0.6343381785190405, 0.7347409881476263 ], "shapiro_p": 0.27076547708795207, "lag1": -0.4245669453955287, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0638652190596993, "p_holm": 2.906603861569735e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "after": { "mean": 11.4226828125, "sd": 0.06019293521510227, "median": 11.417197916666666, "min": 11.340208333333333, "max": 11.519192708333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6443510416666669, "sd": 0.10280674643362932, "median": 0.626026041666667, "min": 0.46798958333333296, "max": 0.8182031250000001 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.587427083333333, 0.6135312499999994, 0.668354166666667, 0.7466822916666676, 0.5711354166666673, 0.6385208333333345, 0.8182031250000001, 0.5876041666666669, 0.46798958333333296, 0.7440625000000001 ], "df": 9, "t": 19.81987539780946, "p": 9.83355888769613e-09, "ci95": [ 0.5708075256249951, 0.7178945577083387 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8536167832687862, "lag1": -0.2441884385081645, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0597820753124627, "p_holm": 8.850202998926518e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.1733359375, "sd": 0.07122243886548672, "median": 11.153380208333335, "min": 11.10228125, "max": 11.339354166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.0561875, "sd": 0.05185747864564419, "median": 12.06190625, "min": 11.987588541666666, "max": 12.13978125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.8828515625, "sd": 0.05832125925234999, "median": 0.886283854166666, "min": 0.7721822916666667, "max": 0.9908750000000008 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8614843749999999, 0.8853072916666651, 0.8366458333333338, 0.887911458333333, 0.8999114583333334, 0.9416250000000002, 0.9908750000000008, 0.7721822916666667, 0.8653124999999999, 0.8872604166666669 ], "df": 9, "t": 47.86971010448483, "p": 3.7962886422160905e-12, "ci95": [ 0.8411310469289259, 0.924572078071074 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7422354078836482, "lag1": -0.1002585739266192, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.079014142905788, "p_holm": 7.212948420210572e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.17748125, "sd": 0.08010292200003473, "median": 11.141942708333332, "min": 11.109453125, "max": 11.352692708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.043550520833334, "sd": 0.054697547415317196, "median": 12.029747395833333, "min": 11.9908125, "max": 12.148302083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.8660692708333337, "sd": 0.11548483546040994, "median": 0.8704401041666667, "min": 0.6405520833333345, "max": 1.0293333333333337 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0036562500000006, 0.9085260416666667, 0.6405520833333345, 1.0293333333333337, 0.9283229166666676, 0.8503333333333334, 0.8905468750000001, 0.8412187500000012, 0.7453229166666677, 0.8228802083333324 ], "df": 9, "t": 23.715247949185997, "p": 2.0110034015620206e-09, "ci95": [ 0.7834563962518436, 0.9486821454148239 ], "shapiro_p": 0.851365778684465, "lag1": -0.2173332461009417, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0774834018024708, "p_holm": 2.6143044220306267e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.1733359375, "sd": 0.07122243886548672, "median": 11.153380208333335, "min": 11.10228125, "max": 11.339354166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.45483229166666683, "sd": 0.07104222384923227, "median": -0.43840104166666727, "min": -0.6004531249999996, "max": -0.3483281250000001 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5090052083333347, -0.40372916666666825, -0.4895677083333325, -0.49569270833333334, -0.3483281250000001, -0.4416041666666679, -0.43519791666666663, -0.6004531249999996, -0.40041666666666664, -0.42432812499999883 ], "df": 9, "t": -20.24579070206334, "p": 8.152001752493065e-09, "ci95": [ -0.505652837112729, -0.40401174622060465 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7357017519000768, "lag1": -0.3408848573544636, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9592930621426896, "p_holm": 6.521601401994452e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.17748125, "sd": 0.08010292200003473, "median": 11.141942708333332, "min": 11.109453125, "max": 11.352692708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3991494791666666, "sd": 0.12762742538997238, "median": -0.40615885416666586, "min": -0.6494739583333331, "max": -0.22770833333333407 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.3790156249999992, -0.24815104166666657, -0.6494739583333331, -0.4479583333333341, -0.22770833333333407, -0.4396302083333339, -0.43330208333333253, -0.369859374999999, -0.2857447916666658, -0.5106510416666676 ], "df": 9, "t": -9.889892216973031, "p": 3.923371732571953e-06, "ci95": [ -0.4904486393106391, -0.3078503190226941 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7079950534818327, "lag1": -0.3340822253276171, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9642898547321055, "p_holm": 1.5693486930287812e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.0561875, "sd": 0.05185747864564419, "median": 12.06190625, "min": 11.987588541666666, "max": 12.13978125 }, "after": { "mean": 11.403043229166666, "sd": 0.04755508235961403, "median": 11.406830729166668, "min": 11.344208333333333, "max": 11.484984375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6531442708333334, "sd": 0.073573657230389, "median": -0.655046875, "min": -0.7673281250000006, "max": -0.5338697916666675 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5338697916666675, -0.6200677083333321, -0.7099427083333332, -0.6666718750000005, -0.6000572916666655, -0.7435729166666682, -0.6683854166666663, -0.7673281250000006, -0.578125, -0.6434218749999996 ], "df": 9, "t": -28.072867576169763, "p": 4.488628178471457e-10, "ci95": [ -0.7057756946306106, -0.6005128470360561 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9772685221625518, "lag1": -0.18827796473042227, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9458249740364992, "p_holm": 5.835216632012894e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.043550520833334, "sd": 0.054697547415317196, "median": 12.029747395833333, "min": 11.9908125, "max": 12.148302083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 11.4226828125, "sd": 0.06019293521510227, "median": 11.417197916666666, "min": 11.340208333333333, "max": 11.519192708333334 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6208677083333335, "sd": 0.08713281502779657, "median": -0.6055703125000003, "min": -0.7952447916666667, "max": -0.5056458333333325 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.7952447916666667, -0.5431458333333339, -0.6216718750000005, -0.7306093750000002, -0.5848958333333343, -0.6514427083333327, -0.5056458333333325, -0.6234739583333333, -0.5630781250000005, -0.58946875 ], "df": 9, "t": -22.5329123517483, "p": 3.1644195029194984e-09, "ci95": [ -0.6831987693001322, -0.5585366473665347 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5008313816585139, "lag1": -0.4176119334220575, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9484481169187329, "p_holm": 3.480861453211448e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 17.66693385416667, "sd": 0.047380651125159864, "median": 17.664322916666666, "min": 17.608395833333333, "max": 17.748682291666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.7745588541666666, "sd": 0.06879022453883404, "median": 2.782661458333334, "min": 2.6665937499999988, "max": 2.8652604166666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.737124999999999, 2.8421770833333344, 2.8297083333333344, 2.7227708333333336, 2.6864374999999985, 2.6665937499999988, 2.779760416666667, 2.785562500000001, 2.8301927083333336, 2.8652604166666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 127.54610906089559, "p": 5.687000445256477e-16, "ci95": [ 2.7253492919795383, 2.823768416353794 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5276676553967495, "lag1": 0.4845450885157552, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1863073454816084, "p_holm": 1.3080101024089897e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "after": { "mean": 17.684805729166666, "sd": 0.08908599893892949, "median": 17.652421875, "min": 17.633598958333334, "max": 17.931140625 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.7894916666666667, "sd": 0.11960889559852264, "median": 2.7758802083333327, "min": 2.5881041666666675, "max": 3.072770833333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.7785208333333333, 3.072770833333335, 2.714359375000001, 2.769020833333334, 2.8166666666666664, 2.7725833333333316, 2.8026406250000004, 2.773239583333332, 2.5881041666666675, 2.8070104166666674 ], "df": 9, "t": 73.74992584443541, "p": 7.835723394036874e-14, "ci95": [ 2.7039286171847396, 2.8750547161485946 ], "shapiro_p": 0.021504455174191483, "lag1": -0.19093446259907304, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.187273101793094, "p_holm": 1.7238591466881124e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 16.997846354166665, "sd": 0.5092048535537815, "median": 16.832864583333333, "min": 16.785171875, "max": 18.443182291666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.1054713541666663, "sd": 0.514434085244556, "median": 1.9488880208333335, "min": 1.8649374999999981, "max": 3.55521875 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.8697499999999998, 1.9206927083333323, 1.9482916666666679, 3.55521875, 1.8649374999999981, 1.8664374999999982, 1.9647812499999997, 2.0883072916666663, 1.949484374999999, 2.0268125 ], "df": 9, "t": 12.94254253047898, "p": 4.033474441359048e-07, "ci95": [ 1.7374673786202712, 2.4734753297130605 ], "shapiro_p": 2.8838517665807976e-06, "lag1": -0.1693668066874218, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1413791523626464, "p_holm": 1.6133897765436192e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "after": { "mean": 16.87724375, "sd": 0.06961657607010628, "median": 16.85709375, "min": 16.804515625, "max": 17.025458333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.9819296875000005, "sd": 0.11470585119862826, "median": 1.9646015625000004, "min": 1.7547916666666659, "max": 2.149828124999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.93953125, 1.9461458333333344, 1.9163385416666685, 1.9117447916666688, 2.0759010416666683, 2.042364583333333, 1.9830572916666664, 2.149828124999999, 1.7547916666666659, 2.0995937500000004 ], "df": 9, "t": 54.638991030657195, "p": 1.1587739607834663e-12, "ci95": [ 1.8998740646898182, 2.0639853103101826 ], "shapiro_p": 0.758226736856894, "lag1": -0.5158651684526614, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.1330572607723426, "p_holm": 2.201670525488586e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 18.98103645833333, "sd": 0.4986223952341408, "median": 18.779364583333333, "min": 18.706296875, "max": 20.348703125 }, "difference": { "mean": 4.088661458333333, "sd": 0.5083136567656964, "median": 3.896841145833333, "min": 3.766442708333333, "max": 5.460739583333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.766442708333333, 3.872447916666667, 3.837031250000001, 5.460739583333334, 3.788104166666665, 3.8237864583333323, 3.921234374999999, 4.0946302083333315, 4.283369791666667, 4.038828125 ], "df": 9, "t": 25.43603268884573, "p": 1.0796428832700427e-09, "ci95": [ 3.7250357735667894, 4.452287143099875 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00016550543711616825, "lag1": -0.22992485270858048, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.274547307486773, "p_holm": 1.2955714599240511e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "after": { "mean": 18.760321875, "sd": 0.03454958478527483, "median": 18.749354166666667, "min": 18.713145833333332, "max": 18.813776041666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 3.8650078125000005, "sd": 0.0903186611236929, "median": 3.8767708333333335, "min": 3.6477187499999992, "max": 3.964432291666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 3.859177083333334, 3.9546718750000007, 3.8178541666666668, 3.8314947916666693, 3.964432291666668, 3.922270833333334, 3.8989166666666666, 3.8669843750000013, 3.6477187499999992, 3.8865572916666657 ], "df": 9, "t": 135.3233950745402, "p": 3.339195933216027e-16, "ci95": [ 3.800397734527143, 3.929617890472859 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0846710784868161, "lag1": -0.05330123679417304, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.259478101386961, "p_holm": 8.014070239718465e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 14.386897916666667, "sd": 0.09057568898436395, "median": 14.373888020833334, "min": 14.267395833333333, "max": 14.593015625 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.5054770833333336, "sd": 0.07243001088401785, "median": -0.5123437500000003, "min": -0.6045104166666668, "max": -0.3710885416666674 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.507822916666667, -0.5673750000000002, -0.4912864583333345, -0.556984374999999, -0.3710885416666674, -0.5574843750000014, -0.6045104166666668, -0.4673541666666665, -0.5168645833333336, -0.4139999999999997 ], "df": 9, "t": -22.069013504798207, "p": 3.804427169852767e-09, "ci95": [ -0.5572903918187462, -0.45366377484792103 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7040445202393996, "lag1": -0.3652259552588594, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9660579938838948, "p_holm": 3.42398445286749e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "after": { "mean": 14.37016875, "sd": 0.09735108115364895, "median": 14.329716145833334, "min": 14.311369791666667, "max": 14.622 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.5251453125, "sd": 0.1141006745915123, "median": -0.535046874999999, "min": -0.6681979166666672, "max": -0.2447395833333328 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.2447395833333328, -0.518760416666666, -0.6110468749999995, -0.59021875, -0.5379739583333318, -0.5321197916666662, -0.5291875000000008, -0.5630468750000013, -0.6681979166666672, -0.45616145833333377 ], "df": 9, "t": -14.554298613975282, "p": 1.4655534131944654e-07, "ci95": [ -0.6067680180449498, -0.4435226069550501 ], "shapiro_p": 0.04335712767275615, "lag1": 0.023235160197675717, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9647442604904793, "p_holm": 8.050977690733434e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 15.4443546875, "sd": 0.11020037580038303, "median": 15.3967109375, "min": 15.373536458333334, "max": 15.692244791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5519796874999999, "sd": 0.12164644396009718, "median": 0.5394192708333332, "min": 0.4129218750000003, "max": 0.8173750000000002 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.4454739583333325, 0.534286458333332, 0.6837499999999999, 0.49443229166666747, 0.4129218750000003, 0.45285416666666656, 0.5478333333333332, 0.5863177083333326, 0.8173750000000002, 0.5445520833333344 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.349067492844602, "p": 1.6573870781693903e-07, "ci95": [ 0.46495906372637097, 0.6390003112736289 ], "shapiro_p": 0.21315194455651626, "lag1": 0.16637992383803996, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.037064584225149, "p_holm": 9.944322469016342e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "after": { "mean": 15.411165104166667, "sd": 0.05313716931527282, "median": 15.394059895833333, "min": 15.357520833333334, "max": 15.541177083333332 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5158510416666667, "sd": 0.11094680354072728, "median": 0.5158593750000007, "min": 0.2600052083333324, "max": 0.6744374999999998 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6744374999999998, 0.5164166666666663, 0.4289166666666677, 0.515302083333335, 0.5757656250000007, 0.515140624999999, 0.5866249999999997, 0.5072447916666665, 0.2600052083333324, 0.5786562499999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.703120531438021, "p": 1.341829615122239e-07, "ci95": [ 0.4364844795584369, 0.5952176037748966 ], "shapiro_p": 0.13466147239442178, "lag1": -0.16637537172925887, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0346317667087905, "p_holm": 8.050977690733434e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.352338020833333, "sd": 0.07956329245379688, "median": 15.31503125, "min": 15.261515625, "max": 15.486395833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 16.129286458333333, "sd": 0.08514076924213855, "median": 16.087776041666665, "min": 16.064380208333333, "max": 16.329494791666665 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7769484374999995, "sd": 0.10697135524653165, "median": 0.7998880208333325, "min": 0.5978385416666683, "max": 0.9148958333333326 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5978385416666683, 0.7919322916666651, 0.8172499999999996, 0.7713072916666643, 0.8897864583333313, 0.80784375, 0.8593020833333345, 0.9148958333333326, 0.6279218750000002, 0.69140625 ], "df": 9, "t": 22.968080392611824, "p": 2.6710980968410583e-09, "ci95": [ 0.7004257397833519, 0.8534711352166472 ], "shapiro_p": 0.49910885962858087, "lag1": 0.061747850249676224, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.050607825104272, "p_holm": 2.938207906525164e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.346647395833333, "sd": 0.09155634367767163, "median": 15.315190104166668, "min": 15.256994791666667, "max": 15.534979166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 16.080932291666667, "sd": 0.04303848893102112, "median": 16.068755208333336, "min": 16.022151041666667, "max": 16.14840625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7342848958333337, "sd": 0.10983880585615576, "median": 0.7774609375000008, "min": 0.5152343750000021, "max": 0.8662083333333346 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6568437500000002, 0.7037552083333338, 0.806750000000001, 0.8022864583333309, 0.8236406249999995, 0.8662083333333346, 0.7803958333333352, 0.5152343750000021, 0.7745260416666664, 0.6132083333333327 ], "df": 9, "t": 21.140185421659723, "p": 5.56497451929763e-09, "ci95": [ 0.6557109475205616, 0.8128588441461058 ], "shapiro_p": 0.31058115868439723, "lag1": 0.04328132091471959, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0478465997747948, "p_holm": 5.56497451929763e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.352338020833333, "sd": 0.07956329245379688, "median": 15.31503125, "min": 15.261515625, "max": 15.486395833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.45996302083333324, "sd": 0.08288629327959417, "median": -0.45657291666666655, "min": -0.5630520833333339, "max": -0.3269635416666663 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5465416666666663, -0.44277604166666684, -0.34254166666666563, -0.43204687500000105, -0.4756041666666668, -0.3269635416666663, -0.43814583333333346, -0.47036979166666626, -0.5615885416666657, -0.5630520833333339 ], "df": 9, "t": -17.548508055226357, "p": 2.8676041364121304e-08, "ci95": [ -0.5192563031412009, -0.40066973852546567 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3112584470139298, "lag1": 0.2804397222684265, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9700395457545843, "p_holm": 2.0073228954884912e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.346647395833333, "sd": 0.09155634367767163, "median": 15.315190104166668, "min": 15.256994791666667, "max": 15.534979166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.45133333333333353, "sd": 0.14655841197920152, "median": -0.4539713541666668, "min": -0.6593489583333323, "max": -0.14828645833333276 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5376927083333332, -0.4600260416666675, -0.3283906250000008, -0.42288541666666823, -0.4492916666666673, -0.414791666666666, -0.45865104166666626, -0.6593489583333323, -0.14828645833333276, -0.6339687500000011 ], "df": 9, "t": -9.738378698398238, "p": 4.4597367848350376e-06, "ci95": [ -0.5561749054707491, -0.34649176119591796 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4925489903647529, "lag1": -0.6797003936497703, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9705907536876183, "p_holm": 1.5693486930287812e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.129286458333333, "sd": 0.08514076924213855, "median": 16.087776041666665, "min": 16.064380208333333, "max": 16.329494791666665 }, "after": { "mean": 15.4443546875, "sd": 0.11020037580038303, "median": 15.3967109375, "min": 15.373536458333334, "max": 15.692244791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6849317708333329, "sd": 0.1605129171671555, "median": -0.704671874999999, "min": -0.9524687499999978, "max": -0.3721354166666657 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.6989062500000021, -0.700421875, -0.47604166666666536, -0.7089218749999979, -0.9524687499999978, -0.6819531249999997, -0.7496145833333347, -0.7989479166666662, -0.3721354166666657, -0.7099062499999995 ], "df": 9, "t": -13.493894920557938, "p": 2.8176785275612604e-07, "ci95": [ -0.7997557946263548, -0.570107747040311 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1892478544744698, "lag1": -0.1674046950266245, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9575348994760114, "p_holm": 1.4088392637806302e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.080932291666667, "sd": 0.04303848893102112, "median": 16.068755208333336, "min": 16.022151041666667, "max": 16.14840625 }, "after": { "mean": 15.411165104166667, "sd": 0.05313716931527282, "median": 15.394059895833333, "min": 15.357520833333334, "max": 15.541177083333332 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6697671875000004, "sd": 0.06340431302192694, "median": -0.6679296875000009, "min": -0.7658593750000016, "max": -0.5200989583333335 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5200989583333335, -0.647364583333335, -0.7062239583333341, -0.7098697916666641, -0.697166666666666, -0.7658593750000016, -0.6524218750000017, -0.667338541666668, -0.6628072916666667, -0.6685208333333339 ], "df": 9, "t": -33.40450694281, "p": 9.513760941523522e-11, "ci95": [ -0.7151239006885616, -0.6244104743114393 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09836557865736786, "lag1": 0.3023059998406789, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9583502265072603, "p_holm": 1.5222017506437636e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 15.641534374999999, "sd": 0.08835802794557227, "median": 15.631075520833333, "min": 15.534098958333333, "max": 15.812427083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.623395833333333, "sd": 0.20025784315701797, "median": 5.6612552083333325, "min": 5.095739583333334, "max": 5.817994791666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.760109374999999, 5.564416666666666, 5.686057291666666, 5.600562499999999, 5.095739583333334, 5.6592031249999994, 5.745140625000001, 5.641427083333333, 5.817994791666667, 5.663307291666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 88.79921374210983, "p": 1.476257348547776e-14, "ci95": [ 5.48014000225617, 5.766651664410497 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0024054277769328834, "lag1": -0.008044059561668423, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.5613214281220946, "p_holm": 3.1001404319503297e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "after": { "mean": 15.609188020833335, "sd": 0.15381458636143447, "median": 15.556809895833332, "min": 15.5116875, "max": 16.032828125 }, "difference": { "mean": 5.6086937500000005, "sd": 0.20956334614606661, "median": 5.607252604166668, "min": 5.293421875, "max": 6.100708333333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 5.620697916666668, 5.293421875, 6.100708333333335, 5.524921875, 5.4123906250000005, 5.686604166666667, 5.638697916666667, 5.593807291666668, 5.628895833333333, 5.586791666666668 ], "df": 9, "t": 84.63429924424271, "p": 2.2736430419325724e-14, "ci95": [ 5.4587811630960905, 5.75860633690391 ], "shapiro_p": 0.08248890977956991, "lag1": -0.5008610353046605, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.5608416542328196, "p_holm": 5.229378996444917e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 11.483946354166667, "sd": 0.07204422125389875, "median": 11.453903645833332, "min": 11.4168125, "max": 11.626916666666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.4658078124999998, "sd": 0.20588938023576672, "median": 1.5344817708333336, "min": 0.9499843749999997, "max": 1.6457656249999992 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.565171874999999, 1.5228593749999995, 1.5789010416666667, 1.6457656249999992, 0.9499843749999997, 1.5156979166666655, 1.5337031250000006, 1.5430416666666673, 1.5352604166666666, 1.2676927083333336 ], "df": 9, "t": 22.513503582657325, "p": 3.188664581460172e-09, "ci95": [ 1.3185234224823241, 1.6130922025176755 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0007533429721115197, "lag1": -0.23644386679254942, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.146315386476592, "p_holm": 3.188664581460172e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "after": { "mean": 11.561952083333333, "sd": 0.2265871468580834, "median": 11.481380208333334, "min": 11.422604166666666, "max": 12.153802083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.5614578125, "sd": 0.2754138136081573, "median": 1.5017682291666672, "min": 1.1909166666666664, "max": 2.221682291666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.5847395833333344, 1.1909166666666664, 2.221682291666667, 1.4358385416666657, 1.4097291666666667, 1.7890156249999993, 1.5094114583333322, 1.4947343750000002, 1.5088020833333342, 1.469708333333335 ], "df": 9, "t": 17.92852396571981, "p": 2.3762835904976985e-08, "ci95": [ 1.3644386389356873, 1.7584769860643128 ], "shapiro_p": 0.035038897599327726, "lag1": -0.518620196036563, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.156138063800909, "p_holm": 1.9010268723981588e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.190952083333332, "sd": 0.12988171098402768, "median": 12.127046875000001, "min": 12.098234375, "max": 12.509802083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.1728135416666667, "sd": 0.23808628483812128, "median": 2.2087838541666667, "min": 1.6937864583333333, "max": 2.617130208333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.1239166666666662, 2.201437499999999, 2.342822916666666, 2.1204374999999995, 1.6937864583333333, 2.2217812499999994, 2.2221302083333345, 2.617130208333334, 2.2161302083333343, 1.968562499999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 28.85945205619704, "p": 3.5089809705150743e-10, "ci95": [ 2.002496873590817, 2.343130209742515 ], "shapiro_p": 0.40814115517950167, "lag1": 0.06144516415956165, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2168879510529493, "p_holm": 4.912573358721104e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "after": { "mean": 12.169078645833334, "sd": 0.0888594381567303, "median": 12.125752604166667, "min": 12.099130208333333, "max": 12.368416666666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.168584375, "sd": 0.16037276556643404, "median": 2.181236979166667, "min": 1.8799374999999987, "max": 2.4359479166666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 2.226020833333335, 1.8799374999999987, 2.187744791666667, 2.140072916666666, 1.9596718749999997, 2.4359479166666667, 2.246932291666665, 2.1235572916666676, 2.1747291666666673, 2.311229166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 42.7607885854655, "p": 1.0440846793064216e-11, "ci95": [ 2.053860609622437, 2.283308140377563 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8208105695052819, "lag1": -0.25418431474971925, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.2168477193497051, "p_holm": 1.7760801436554603e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.148755208333334, "sd": 0.11506651745694783, "median": 8.119744791666665, "min": 8.023354166666667, "max": 8.392697916666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.8693833333333336, "sd": 0.15725517440231337, "median": -1.837231770833334, "min": -2.2672968749999995, "max": -1.6777083333333334 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.8581145833333341, -1.8287395833333342, -1.845723958333334, -1.9577968749999997, -2.2672968749999995, -1.8267968750000012, -1.6777083333333334, -1.856859374999999, -1.8183749999999996, -1.756421875000001 ], "df": 9, "t": -37.591825997199976, "p": 3.309407729316537e-11, "ci95": [ -1.98187690834165, -1.7568897583250176 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00894844587420999, "lag1": 0.15971885956655318, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8134001316154355, "p_holm": 5.625993139838114e-10 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "after": { "mean": 8.14395, "sd": 0.08465194486760944, "median": 8.115278645833333, "min": 8.057375, "max": 8.291911458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.8565442708333335, "sd": 0.1364332375329965, "median": -1.8588567708333334, "min": -2.0905572916666664, "max": -1.6287239583333335 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.6287239583333335, -2.023697916666668, -1.8200312499999995, -1.8845781250000009, -2.0905572916666664, -1.8634218750000002, -1.683338541666668, -1.8776770833333334, -1.8542916666666667, -1.8391249999999992 ], "df": 9, "t": -43.03136522249543, "p": 9.867111909197002e-12, "ci95": [ -1.9541427295064986, -1.7589458121601684 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5033197998566348, "lag1": -0.3124081682107574, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8143547488199673, "p_holm": 1.7760801436554603e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 10.718116666666667, "sd": 0.0208549894965691, "median": 10.712140625, "min": 10.695322916666667, "max": 10.753307291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.699978125, "sd": 0.20361331529711102, "median": 0.7607838541666663, "min": 0.1744427083333342, "max": 0.8442395833333318 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.7210937499999996, 0.7247135416666666, 0.7938333333333336, 0.7277343749999989, 0.1744427083333342, 0.8442395833333318, 0.812156250000001, 0.8329427083333343, 0.8160989583333329, 0.5525260416666669 ], "df": 9, "t": 10.871220205142723, "p": 1.7778914717183892e-06, "ci95": [ 0.5543219337546292, 0.8456343162453708 ], "shapiro_p": 0.000829149534739886, "lag1": -0.15304882324392882, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0698710765566581, "p_holm": 3.5557829434367784e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "after": { "mean": 10.738761979166666, "sd": 0.06320728926664698, "median": 10.7206484375, "min": 10.669, "max": 10.86896875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7382677083333334, "sd": 0.139269163743663, "median": 0.7635390625000005, "min": 0.48066666666666613, "max": 0.9368489583333339 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8418749999999999, 0.48066666666666613, 0.9368489583333339, 0.7510208333333335, 0.5210677083333337, 0.768770833333333, 0.7200729166666662, 0.8232916666666661, 0.7807552083333338, 0.758307291666668 ], "df": 9, "t": 16.763276367360493, "p": 4.281720727568111e-08, "ci95": [ 0.6386405502605448, 0.8378948664061221 ], "shapiro_p": 0.15603351495875556, "lag1": -0.49070795443829707, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "question": "1kHz\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306e\u6e1b\u8870\u91cf6dB\u3078threshold\u3092\u6821\u6b63\u3057\u305f\u691c\u51fa/ballistics\u65b9\u5f0f\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u305d\u306e\u4ed6\u306e\u5165\u529b\u3067\u52b9\u679c\u304c\u7b49\u4fa1\u3068\u3044\u3046\u610f\u5473\u3067\u306f\u306a\u3044\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0738231219717318, "p_holm": 2.9972045092976777e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.172552604166667, "sd": 0.02752807203149078, "median": 10.17425, "min": 10.128223958333333, "max": 10.225380208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 11.078203645833334, "sd": 0.10492803323643436, "median": 11.050018229166668, "min": 10.987895833333333, "max": 11.36971875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.9056510416666663, "sd": 0.08756482190939652, "median": 0.8800364583333335, "min": 0.8369322916666668, "max": 1.1443385416666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.897567708333332, 0.87221875, 1.1443385416666665, 0.8703854166666662, 0.8369322916666668, 0.887854166666667, 0.9154999999999998, 0.8585833333333319, 0.9142239583333343, 0.8589062499999986 ], "df": 9, "t": 32.706285406872915, "p": 1.1489561452580724e-10, "ci95": [ 0.8430109415936882, 0.9682911417396445 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0001889957532898993, "lag1": -0.2061433125806118, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.089028887527769, "p_holm": 1.838329832412916e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.144352083333334, "sd": 0.051930830737027416, "median": 10.146911458333333, "min": 10.063557291666667, "max": 10.245265625 }, "after": { "mean": 11.072918229166667, "sd": 0.10041223228314267, "median": 11.040958333333332, "min": 10.994151041666667, "max": 11.307421875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.928566145833333, "sd": 0.12647157816287358, "median": 0.8988515625, "min": 0.8088958333333327, "max": 1.1732083333333332 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8175468749999997, 0.9529791666666654, 0.9081979166666656, 1.1732083333333332, 0.8088958333333327, 0.8315989583333341, 0.8988958333333343, 0.8988072916666656, 0.8641562499999988, 1.1313750000000002 ], "df": 9, "t": 23.217738100617723, "p": 2.4270051797154643e-09, "ci95": [ 0.8380938289855127, 1.0190384626811533 ], "shapiro_p": 0.025701681914073283, "lag1": -0.27178384864717886, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "question": "\u540c\u4e00controls\u306esmooth branching / smooth decoupled\u306eCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002release\u5f62\u72b6\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0915352836933687, "p_holm": 2.912406215658557e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.172552604166667, "sd": 0.02752807203149078, "median": 10.17425, "min": 10.128223958333333, "max": 10.225380208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.15441406250000006, "sd": 0.1970493363032728, "median": -0.22045312500000058, "min": -0.2870625000000011, "max": 0.36991666666666667 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.18601041666666696, -0.1933541666666656, -0.26590625000000045, -0.19748437500000016, 0.36991666666666667, -0.2562187499999986, -0.243421875000001, -0.2870625000000011, -0.24611979166666664, -0.03847916666666684 ], "df": 9, "t": -2.478060314337044, "p": 0.03510297629837741, "ci95": [ -0.29537466604148227, -0.01345345895851785 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00019609933621960747, "lag1": -0.125322539881827, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9848205196366592, "p_holm": 0.03510297629837741 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.144352083333334, "sd": 0.051930830737027416, "median": 10.146911458333333, "min": 10.063557291666667, "max": 10.245265625 }, "after": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.1438578125000003, "sd": 0.1224377742869825, "median": -0.16620572916666632, "min": -0.28324479166666805, "max": 0.16433333333333344 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.28324479166666805, 0.16433333333333344, -0.17942187500000095, -0.1474479166666658, -0.09733333333333327, -0.23731249999999982, -0.17439583333333175, -0.15801562500000088, -0.21977604166666787, -0.10596354166666799 ], "df": 9, "t": -3.7155065040888196, "p": 0.004803887376533528, "ci95": [ -0.2314445198878707, -0.05627110511212988 ], "shapiro_p": 0.022686115256060884, "lag1": -0.4574819894920262, "reference": "comp.peaklog.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9858189255145873, "p_holm": 0.004803887376533528 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.078203645833334, "sd": 0.10492803323643436, "median": 11.050018229166668, "min": 10.987895833333333, "max": 11.36971875 }, "after": { "mean": 10.718116666666667, "sd": 0.0208549894965691, "median": 10.712140625, "min": 10.695322916666667, "max": 10.753307291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.36008697916666643, "sd": 0.09283793833728178, "median": -0.34255208333333353, "min": -0.6164114583333333, "max": -0.29257291666666596 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.3624843749999993, -0.3408593749999991, -0.6164114583333333, -0.34013541666666747, -0.29257291666666596, -0.29983333333333384, -0.34676562499999974, -0.31270312499999875, -0.344244791666668, -0.34485937499999864 ], "df": 9, "t": -12.265406043371705, "p": 6.389420806985779e-07, "ci95": [ -0.4264992394923197, -0.29367471884101315 ], "shapiro_p": 4.526025658618052e-05, "lag1": -0.02897628029742532, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9674959054122371, "p_holm": 1.916826242095734e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.072918229166667, "sd": 0.10041223228314267, "median": 11.040958333333332, "min": 10.994151041666667, "max": 11.307421875 }, "after": { "mean": 10.738761979166666, "sd": 0.06320728926664698, "median": 10.7206484375, "min": 10.669, "max": 10.86896875 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3341562499999998, "sd": 0.12093281951238075, "median": -0.30557812499999937, "min": -0.5696354166666655, "max": -0.15077083333333263 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.2589166666666678, -0.3079791666666658, -0.15077083333333263, -0.5696354166666655, -0.38516145833333226, -0.30014062500000094, -0.3532187499999999, -0.2335312500000004, -0.30317708333333293, -0.47903125000000024 ], "df": 9, "t": -8.737866599334998, "p": 1.0866483583134747e-05, "ci95": [ -0.42066637759668535, -0.2476461224033143 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7467062171991921, "lag1": -0.24774556949453272, "reference": "comp.decoupled.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums", "question": "\u57fa\u6e96\u97f3\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308bthreshold\u6821\u6b63\u304c\u540c\u3058\u65b9\u5f0f\u306e\u5b9f\u884c\u8cbb\u7528\u3078\u4e0e\u3048\u308b\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9698222055754178, "p_holm": 2.1732967166269494e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.4685197916666667, "sd": 0.04966654242970107, "median": 0.4459088541666667, "min": 0.4404635416666667, "max": 0.6015260416666667 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 10.718503645833334, "sd": 0.03445009089741267, "median": 10.722466145833334, "min": 10.648364583333333, "max": 10.760119791666666 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 13.645876041666666, "sd": 0.07343826605195428, "median": 13.667942708333333, "min": 13.524916666666666, "max": 13.757369791666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 12.620780208333333, "sd": 0.06960601871039444, "median": 12.593950520833333, "min": 12.56653125, "max": 12.786401041666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 13.706509895833333, "sd": 0.05218528536886792, "median": 13.6938125, "min": 13.653135416666666, "max": 13.828291666666667 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 9.225908854166667, "sd": 0.10249603631023918, "median": 9.220723958333334, "min": 9.095713541666667, "max": 9.398682291666667 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 11.403043229166666, "sd": 0.04755508235961403, "median": 11.406830729166668, "min": 11.344208333333333, "max": 11.484984375 }, "comp.peaklog.max.bass": { "mean": 11.1733359375, "sd": 0.07122243886548672, "median": 11.153380208333335, "min": 11.10228125, "max": 11.339354166666666 }, "comp.decoupled.max.bass": { "mean": 12.0561875, "sd": 0.05185747864564419, "median": 12.06190625, "min": 11.987588541666666, "max": 12.13978125 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4439125, "sd": 0.0038069696847941132, "median": 0.4424401041666667, "min": 0.439578125, "max": 0.4496875 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 14.892375, "sd": 0.04700028255328632, "median": 14.881416666666667, "min": 14.828984375, "max": 14.964104166666667 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 17.66693385416667, "sd": 0.047380651125159864, "median": 17.664322916666666, "min": 17.608395833333333, "max": 17.748682291666668 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 16.997846354166665, "sd": 0.5092048535537815, "median": 16.832864583333333, "min": 16.785171875, "max": 18.443182291666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 18.98103645833333, "sd": 0.4986223952341408, "median": 18.779364583333333, "min": 18.706296875, "max": 20.348703125 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 14.386897916666667, "sd": 0.09057568898436395, "median": 14.373888020833334, "min": 14.267395833333333, "max": 14.593015625 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 15.4443546875, "sd": 0.11020037580038303, "median": 15.3967109375, "min": 15.373536458333334, "max": 15.692244791666667 }, "comp.peaklog.max.pad": { "mean": 15.352338020833333, "sd": 0.07956329245379688, "median": 15.31503125, "min": 15.261515625, "max": 15.486395833333333 }, "comp.decoupled.max.pad": { "mean": 16.129286458333333, "sd": 0.08514076924213855, "median": 16.087776041666665, "min": 16.064380208333333, "max": 16.329494791666665 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.4446583333333333, "sd": 0.0030479913474053726, "median": 0.44432031250000004, "min": 0.440234375, "max": 0.44873958333333336 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 10.018138541666668, "sd": 0.1932085672295786, "median": 9.9703125, "min": 9.882104166666666, "max": 10.520880208333333 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 15.641534374999999, "sd": 0.08835802794557227, "median": 15.631075520833333, "min": 15.534098958333333, "max": 15.812427083333333 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 11.483946354166667, "sd": 0.07204422125389875, "median": 11.453903645833332, "min": 11.4168125, "max": 11.626916666666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 12.190952083333332, "sd": 0.12988171098402768, "median": 12.127046875000001, "min": 12.098234375, "max": 12.509802083333334 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 8.148755208333334, "sd": 0.11506651745694783, "median": 8.119744791666665, "min": 8.023354166666667, "max": 8.392697916666666 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 10.718116666666667, "sd": 0.0208549894965691, "median": 10.712140625, "min": 10.695322916666667, "max": 10.753307291666667 }, "comp.peaklog.max.drums": { "mean": 10.172552604166667, "sd": 0.02752807203149078, "median": 10.17425, "min": 10.128223958333333, "max": 10.225380208333334 }, "comp.decoupled.max.drums": { "mean": 11.078203645833334, "sd": 0.10492803323643436, "median": 11.050018229166668, "min": 10.987895833333333, "max": 11.36971875 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.45473020833333333, "sd": 0.03265676287328372, "median": 0.4414661458333333, "min": 0.43921354166666665, "max": 0.545609375 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 10.778331770833333, "sd": 0.10960012573251487, "median": 10.744841145833334, "min": 10.671010416666666, "max": 11.0015625 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 13.578968229166666, "sd": 0.0856269780402694, "median": 13.540924479166666, "min": 13.482078125, "max": 13.731182291666666 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 12.640797916666667, "sd": 0.1218696608665506, "median": 12.594192708333333, "min": 12.568932291666666, "max": 12.966510416666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 13.763036458333334, "sd": 0.11145753661233082, "median": 13.738588541666665, "min": 13.655255208333333, "max": 14.0434375 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 9.176920833333334, "sd": 0.12467306954345286, "median": 9.103674479166667, "min": 9.090854166666666, "max": 9.430083333333334 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.bass": { "mean": 11.4226828125, "sd": 0.06019293521510227, "median": 11.417197916666666, "min": 11.340208333333333, "max": 11.519192708333334 }, "comp.peaklog.max.bass": { "mean": 11.17748125, "sd": 0.08010292200003473, "median": 11.141942708333332, "min": 11.109453125, "max": 11.352692708333333 }, "comp.decoupled.max.bass": { "mean": 12.043550520833334, "sd": 0.054697547415317196, "median": 12.029747395833333, "min": 11.9908125, "max": 12.148302083333334 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4523453125, "sd": 0.030729423163752167, "median": 0.44109374999999995, "min": 0.43978645833333335, "max": 0.5385572916666667 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 14.895314062499999, "sd": 0.08258193371875548, "median": 14.867072916666666, "min": 14.826588541666666, "max": 15.114453125 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 17.684805729166666, "sd": 0.08908599893892949, "median": 17.652421875, "min": 17.633598958333334, "max": 17.931140625 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 16.87724375, "sd": 0.06961657607010628, "median": 16.85709375, "min": 16.804515625, "max": 17.025458333333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 18.760321875, "sd": 0.03454958478527483, "median": 18.749354166666667, "min": 18.713145833333332, "max": 18.813776041666667 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 14.37016875, "sd": 0.09735108115364895, "median": 14.329716145833334, "min": 14.311369791666667, "max": 14.622 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.pad": { "mean": 15.411165104166667, "sd": 0.05313716931527282, "median": 15.394059895833333, "min": 15.357520833333334, "max": 15.541177083333332 }, "comp.peaklog.max.pad": { "mean": 15.346647395833333, "sd": 0.09155634367767163, "median": 15.315190104166668, "min": 15.256994791666667, "max": 15.534979166666666 }, "comp.decoupled.max.pad": { "mean": 16.080932291666667, "sd": 0.04303848893102112, "median": 16.068755208333336, "min": 16.022151041666667, "max": 16.14840625 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.46408333333333335, "sd": 0.04742983384384623, "median": 0.44193489583333334, "min": 0.4395104166666667, "max": 0.5675260416666666 }, "comp.peaklog.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 10.000494270833332, "sd": 0.11091641825124786, "median": 9.966421875, "min": 9.893359375, "max": 10.244729166666668 }, "comp.peaklinear.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 15.609188020833335, "sd": 0.15381458636143447, "median": 15.556809895833332, "min": 15.5116875, "max": 16.032828125 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 11.561952083333333, "sd": 0.2265871468580834, "median": 11.481380208333334, "min": 11.422604166666666, "max": 12.153802083333334 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 12.169078645833334, "sd": 0.0888594381567303, "median": 12.125752604166667, "min": 12.099130208333333, "max": 12.368416666666667 }, "comp.gainlinear.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 8.14395, "sd": 0.08465194486760944, "median": 8.115278645833333, "min": 8.057375, "max": 8.291911458333333 }, "comp.decoupled.max.matched.drums": { "mean": 10.738761979166666, "sd": 0.06320728926664698, "median": 10.7206484375, "min": 10.669, "max": 10.86896875 }, "comp.peaklog.max.drums": { "mean": 10.144352083333334, "sd": 0.051930830737027416, "median": 10.146911458333333, "min": 10.063557291666667, "max": 10.245265625 }, "comp.decoupled.max.drums": { "mean": 11.072918229166667, "sd": 0.10041223228314267, "median": 11.040958333333332, "min": 10.994151041666667, "max": 11.307421875 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "a1ae91141964b2689064f4e7f6dd3e3bc3fa1bcee194115c3647521c7826e0c1" }, { "family": "DX04", "jobs": 27, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056120, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.937136458333333, "sd": 0.09594071969378155, "median": 12.911973958333334, "min": 12.831984375, "max": 13.104901041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 13.052088541666667, "sd": 0.09280563713871164, "median": 13.006158854166667, "min": 12.961541666666667, "max": 13.25128125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1149520833333332, "sd": 0.10825639391908204, "median": 0.12210156249999926, "min": -0.06020833333333364, "max": 0.3034114583333327 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.12955729166666785, 0.12949479166666578, 0.10339583333333202, 0.24676041666666748, 0.3034114583333327, 0.15130208333333428, 0.11470833333333275, 0.02699479166666663, 0.004104166666666131, -0.06020833333333364 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.3578654521461813, "p": 0.008417658046851332, "ci95": [ 0.03751012432783721, 0.1923940423388292 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8317176761231485, "lag1": 0.688499019286752, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.008885434864474, "p_holm": 0.025252974140553996 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.84641875, "sd": 0.03868257853963355, "median": 12.83375, "min": 12.813026041666667, "max": 12.92625 }, "after": { "mean": 13.017716666666667, "sd": 0.10436851806312546, "median": 12.994994791666667, "min": 12.929911458333333, "max": 13.283848958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.17129791666666633, "sd": 0.10944281269163064, "median": 0.13338281249999984, "min": 0.07524479166666609, "max": 0.4372656250000002 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.4372656250000002, 0.2499374999999997, 0.13534895833333316, 0.10444270833333391, 0.13141666666666652, 0.19153124999999882, 0.07524479166666609, 0.09883854166666595, 0.08447916666666622, 0.20447395833333282 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.949539963256153, "p": 0.0007918009427389908, "ci95": [ 0.09300724479885443, 0.24958858853447824 ], "shapiro_p": 0.019548604533676586, "lag1": 0.5341416919643965, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.013334293393376, "p_holm": 0.002650806939678813 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.937136458333333, "sd": 0.09594071969378155, "median": 12.911973958333334, "min": 12.831984375, "max": 13.104901041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.421566145833333, "sd": 0.05829707180701011, "median": 12.396322916666666, "min": 12.367369791666667, "max": 12.549109375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.5155703124999998, "sd": 0.13561883529314023, "median": -0.5130833333333324, "min": -0.715958333333333, "max": -0.2828749999999989 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.2828749999999989, -0.40927083333333414, -0.46584895833333384, -0.5494791666666661, -0.5477291666666666, -0.4784374999999983, -0.4053281250000005, -0.598473958333333, -0.715958333333333, -0.7023020833333344 ], "df": 9, "t": -12.021755517518782, "p": 7.581982471551925e-07, "ci95": [ -0.6125861829066458, -0.41855444209335385 ], "shapiro_p": 0.845647344041481, "lag1": 0.7098300423255692, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.960148034755566, "p_holm": 5.307387730086348e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.84641875, "sd": 0.03868257853963355, "median": 12.83375, "min": 12.813026041666667, "max": 12.92625 }, "after": { "mean": 12.4221328125, "sd": 0.06790145736037811, "median": 12.400270833333334, "min": 12.366588541666667, "max": 12.602526041666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.4242859375000004, "sd": 0.08697851239808513, "median": -0.42416145833333374, "min": -0.5310416666666669, "max": -0.21508333333333418 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.38821354166666744, -0.42381770833333476, -0.4245052083333327, -0.516385416666667, -0.21508333333333418, -0.4053593750000015, -0.4736822916666661, -0.44267187500000027, -0.5310416666666669, -0.4220989583333328 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.42576326827805, "p": 8.844550396896216e-08, "ci95": [ -0.4865066170150256, -0.36206525798497513 ], "shapiro_p": 0.058797917361536015, "lag1": -0.20156672968355732, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.966972434438197, "p_holm": 7.075640317516972e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.937136458333333, "sd": 0.09594071969378155, "median": 12.911973958333334, "min": 12.831984375, "max": 13.104901041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 21.798081770833335, "sd": 0.14584483589826222, "median": 21.754723958333333, "min": 21.714604166666668, "max": 22.2026875 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.8609453125, "sd": 0.20191943997480774, "median": 8.842749999999999, "min": 8.609703125000001, "max": 9.322348958333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 8.987458333333334, 8.865255208333332, 8.840145833333333, 8.845354166666667, 8.820369791666666, 8.935317708333335, 9.322348958333333, 8.761734375, 8.609703125000001, 8.621765625 ], "df": 9, "t": 138.77202419533478, "p": 2.662707117928716e-16, "ci95": [ 8.71650084666429, 9.005389778335706 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1781817942480008, "lag1": 0.23140500780058282, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6849232317397649, "p_holm": 3.803215044365514e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.84641875, "sd": 0.03868257853963355, "median": 12.83375, "min": 12.813026041666667, "max": 12.92625 }, "after": { "mean": 21.84150208333333, "sd": 0.1160837682482931, "median": 21.812359375, "min": 21.710171875, "max": 22.014697916666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.995083333333334, "sd": 0.12075531709763193, "median": 8.989955729166667, "min": 8.830723958333332, "max": 9.15925 }, "differences_ns": [ 8.863588541666667, 9.14, 9.050958333333334, 9.088447916666667, 9.15925, 8.928953124999998, 8.894520833333333, 8.917677083333334, 8.830723958333332, 9.076713541666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 235.5585804420925, "p": 2.27872715802895e-18, "ci95": [ 8.908700183314865, 9.081466483351802 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2745060157601371, "lag1": 0.11599479102948863, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.7002016288261919, "p_holm": 3.873836168649215e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.094398958333333, "sd": 0.057655418804022474, "median": 14.074645833333333, "min": 14.029109375, "max": 14.176140625 }, "after": { "mean": 15.265384375, "sd": 0.1260270653129962, "median": 15.2334375, "min": 15.175171875, "max": 15.607557291666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1709854166666664, "sd": 0.15544914388750675, "median": 1.1453619791666672, "min": 1.0223541666666662, "max": 1.5692447916666659 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.219083333333332, 1.0524947916666658, 1.5692447916666659, 1.0223541666666662, 1.2021145833333335, 1.1888750000000012, 1.1108906249999997, 1.1288906250000004, 1.161833333333334, 1.0540729166666658 ], "df": 9, "t": 23.821173477723892, "p": 1.9330444899799038e-09, "ci95": [ 1.0597837980595108, 1.282187035273822 ], "shapiro_p": 0.007705408029130184, "lag1": -0.5401204057877815, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0830816142020956, "p_holm": 2.3196533879758845e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.129022395833333, "sd": 0.06440177474412756, "median": 14.108244791666667, "min": 14.050625, "max": 14.251609375 }, "after": { "mean": 15.278684895833333, "sd": 0.09687939102484995, "median": 15.2444453125, "min": 15.189661458333333, "max": 15.509364583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.1496625, "sd": 0.13527089567342443, "median": 1.1201302083333333, "min": 0.962515625, "max": 1.4017760416666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0809218749999996, 0.962515625, 1.1049114583333335, 1.4017760416666665, 1.2909895833333334, 1.1765572916666667, 0.9890937500000003, 1.1025416666666672, 1.2519687499999996, 1.1353489583333332 ], "df": 9, "t": 26.876084632871816, "p": 6.615686360104904e-10, "ci95": [ 1.0528955306031786, 1.2464294693968214 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8227863117020676, "lag1": 0.2855753340232822, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0813688638740524, "p_holm": 7.938823632125884e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.094398958333333, "sd": 0.057655418804022474, "median": 14.074645833333333, "min": 14.029109375, "max": 14.176140625 }, "after": { "mean": 13.767710416666667, "sd": 0.07054380571864567, "median": 13.743270833333334, "min": 13.700151041666667, "max": 13.939338541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3266885416666666, "sd": 0.09536054875079987, "median": -0.31168489583333336, "min": -0.45266666666666744, "max": -0.11074999999999946 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.29935416666666725, -0.3795364583333338, -0.2930781249999992, -0.45266666666666744, -0.3029062499999995, -0.31678645833333263, -0.37039062499999886, -0.11074999999999946, -0.3065833333333341, -0.4348333333333336 ], "df": 9, "t": -10.833409524993124, "p": 1.8308113930094561e-06, "ci95": [ -0.39490536877270355, -0.2584717145606297 ], "shapiro_p": 0.13769046697171533, "lag1": -0.2355232584994834, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9768213924813366, "p_holm": 1.0984868358056737e-05 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.129022395833333, "sd": 0.06440177474412756, "median": 14.108244791666667, "min": 14.050625, "max": 14.251609375 }, "after": { "mean": 13.754708854166667, "sd": 0.06677717631304203, "median": 13.732114583333333, "min": 13.6875, "max": 13.881734375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3743135416666668, "sd": 0.074869255122876, "median": -0.3699999999999992, "min": -0.5396458333333332, "max": -0.23934895833333414 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.3483697916666664, -0.5396458333333332, -0.4118697916666676, -0.3747656250000002, -0.3265937500000007, -0.23934895833333414, -0.3698749999999986, -0.3701249999999998, -0.39547395833333354, -0.3670677083333338 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.810005706191895, "p": 7.138727658752252e-08, "ci95": [ -0.4278717803636957, -0.3207553029696379 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1518693930491915, "lag1": 0.1740576131657793, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9735074705680238, "p_holm": 6.424854892877028e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.094398958333333, "sd": 0.057655418804022474, "median": 14.074645833333333, "min": 14.029109375, "max": 14.176140625 }, "after": { "mean": 24.1525421875, "sd": 0.04636292854730346, "median": 24.15341145833333, "min": 24.095114583333334, "max": 24.252770833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 10.058143229166665, "sd": 0.08360999608667613, "median": 10.037421875, "min": 9.953010416666665, "max": 10.214458333333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 10.103505208333331, 9.953010416666665, 10.214458333333333, 10.011447916666665, 10.144458333333334, 10.110645833333335, 9.996369791666668, 10.059859375, 10.014984375, 9.972692708333332 ], "df": 9, "t": 380.4167339440435, "p": 3.0508708956824887e-20, "ci95": [ 9.99833224105788, 10.11795421727545 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6338418299867076, "lag1": -0.47370550492257263, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.7136269704654399, "p_holm": 5.49156761222848e-19 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 14.129022395833333, "sd": 0.06440177474412756, "median": 14.108244791666667, "min": 14.050625, "max": 14.251609375 }, "after": { "mean": 24.2545296875, "sd": 0.13956569408675157, "median": 24.244838541666667, "min": 24.087489583333333, "max": 24.51273958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 10.125507291666667, "sd": 0.10906364856327712, "median": 10.085135416666667, "min": 9.992057291666665, "max": 10.309119791666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 10.1588125, 10.285593749999999, 9.992057291666665, 10.197739583333332, 10.071114583333333, 10.309119791666667, 10.086369791666668, 10.083901041666667, 10.05796875, 10.012395833333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 293.5869643837579, "p": 3.140902188370458e-19, "ci95": [ 10.047487857476568, 10.203526725856765 ], "shapiro_p": 0.30097244324949257, "lag1": -0.3458231332017008, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.bass", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.bass", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.7166459934731713, "p_holm": 5.653623939066825e-18 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.8300796875, "sd": 0.257096063374705, "median": 16.753002604166667, "min": 16.67385416666667, "max": 17.535479166666665 }, "after": { "mean": 16.795805729166666, "sd": 0.08606097765152813, "median": 16.760903645833334, "min": 16.715484375, "max": 16.958546875 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.034273958333332646, "sd": 0.2171937384501274, "median": 0.00912239583333374, "min": -0.6006666666666653, "max": 0.18978645833333374 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.18978645833333374, 0.04208854166666853, -0.6006666666666653, 0.08303645833333206, -0.02832812499999804, 0.12325520833333314, 0.01709895833333519, -0.09030729166666518, -0.07984895833333283, 0.0011458333333322912 ], "df": 9, "t": -0.49901886461578204, "p": 0.6297354231182192, "ci95": [ -0.18964499906721755, 0.12109708240055227 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004694094861469564, "lag1": -0.2168897058549891, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9979635296463397, "p_holm": 0.6297354231182192 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.686306770833333, "sd": 0.024066797487062096, "median": 16.694552083333335, "min": 16.630614583333333, "max": 16.709260416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 16.774794270833333, "sd": 0.1409337039915502, "median": 16.715229166666667, "min": 16.676296875, "max": 17.141671875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.0884875000000001, "sd": 0.13600498730969224, "median": 0.03853125000000013, "min": -0.028677083333334963, "max": 0.43241145833333405 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.43241145833333405, -0.009218749999998721, 0.13315624999999898, 0.0004739583333339681, -0.028677083333334963, 0.04712499999999764, 0.08612499999999912, 0.026432291666669272, 0.029937500000002615, 0.167109374999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.0574395835718633, "p": 0.06976872034090967, "ci95": [ -0.008804606918440858, 0.18577960691844103 ], "shapiro_p": 0.007029141844819129, "lag1": -0.40739795025961767, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0053030009105832, "p_holm": 0.06976872034090967 }, "direction_changed": true, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.8300796875, "sd": 0.257096063374705, "median": 16.753002604166667, "min": 16.67385416666667, "max": 17.535479166666665 }, "after": { "mean": 16.169863541666665, "sd": 0.169422361625266, "median": 16.106846354166667, "min": 16.068770833333332, "max": 16.627765625 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6602161458333334, "sd": 0.3148496333201983, "median": -0.615471354166667, "min": -1.437624999999997, "max": -0.1654791666666675 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.5139999999999993, -0.5948489583333334, -1.437624999999997, -0.5987187500000033, -0.1654791666666675, -0.6151302083333334, -0.622078124999998, -0.6949010416666681, -0.7435677083333339, -0.6158125000000005 ], "df": 9, "t": -6.631059870817651, "p": 9.579520528050115e-05, "ci95": [ -0.8854460053712688, -0.43498628629539804 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0065451440382036504, "lag1": -0.04262375652495032, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9607716565760714, "p_holm": 0.0003831808211220046 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.686306770833333, "sd": 0.024066797487062096, "median": 16.694552083333335, "min": 16.630614583333333, "max": 16.709260416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 16.0921484375, "sd": 0.06900902991487515, "median": 16.073541666666667, "min": 16.031723958333334, "max": 16.277817708333334 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.5941583333333327, "sd": 0.07070102960113654, "median": -0.6194895833333316, "min": -0.6607916666666647, "max": -0.42715624999999946 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.6394114583333312, -0.6345208333333332, -0.6543437499999989, -0.6229270833333302, -0.42715624999999946, -0.5810729166666668, -0.5379010416666681, -0.616052083333333, -0.6607916666666647, -0.5674062500000012 ], "df": 9, "t": -26.575194657033276, "p": 7.312786474472945e-10, "ci95": [ -0.6447348031177421, -0.5435818635489232 ], "shapiro_p": 0.04653707250981224, "lag1": 0.0617621405898826, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9643924601475093, "p_holm": 8.04406512192024e-09 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.8300796875, "sd": 0.257096063374705, "median": 16.753002604166667, "min": 16.67385416666667, "max": 17.535479166666665 }, "after": { "mean": 28.4627375, "sd": 0.07389232122647481, "median": 28.446276041666668, "min": 28.374838541666666, "max": 28.591119791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 11.6326578125, "sd": 0.2138229744475179, "median": 11.708078125, "min": 11.055640625000002, "max": 11.78065625 }, "differences_ns": [ 11.696020833333336, 11.739208333333334, 11.055640625000002, 11.732651041666664, 11.78065625, 11.702864583333334, 11.748901041666667, 11.562999999999999, 11.59434375, 11.713291666666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 172.0380797428334, "p": 3.852204918110927e-17, "ci95": [ 11.479698071073779, 11.78561755392622 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00016529217063739485, "lag1": -0.21734437150769523, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6911825748002716, "p_holm": 6.548748360788576e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.686306770833333, "sd": 0.024066797487062096, "median": 16.694552083333335, "min": 16.630614583333333, "max": 16.709260416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 28.52326927083333, "sd": 0.33072139360989905, "median": 28.410794270833335, "min": 28.358979166666668, "max": 29.443729166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 11.8369625, "sd": 0.34107330865897595, "median": 11.709966145833334, "min": 11.650375, "max": 12.781838541666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 11.650375, 11.672807291666668, 11.667645833333331, 11.747125, 11.850942708333335, 12.781838541666666, 11.840505208333333, 11.671692708333335, 11.670416666666668, 11.816276041666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 109.74696972089131, "p": 2.1979150330698874e-15, "ci95": [ 11.592973353208539, 12.080951646791465 ], "shapiro_p": 1.920919217549167e-05, "lag1": 0.11574071273204753, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.7093818100414109, "p_holm": 2.857289542990854e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.229452604166667, "sd": 0.16422692901881922, "median": 19.154856770833334, "min": 19.093901041666665, "max": 19.643796875 }, "after": { "mean": 20.174896875, "sd": 0.09491510109256959, "median": 20.16238020833333, "min": 20.097432291666667, "max": 20.414421875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.9454442708333335, "sd": 0.21100106058343515, "median": 0.9942317708333341, "min": 0.49436979166666717, "max": 1.2735572916666662 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.050822916666668, 0.7724479166666676, 0.9821302083333343, 0.8033645833333338, 0.9712552083333321, 0.49436979166666717, 1.0309687499999995, 1.0691927083333326, 1.2735572916666662, 1.006333333333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.169394638697598, "p": 1.8483160864346915e-07, "ci95": [ 0.7945032049778386, 1.0963853366888285 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3286183648489688, "lag1": -0.03369716712585332, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0491664682450959, "p_holm": 1.4786528691477532e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.194384375, "sd": 0.09308758766679617, "median": 19.16726302083333, "min": 19.133322916666668, "max": 19.44334375 }, "after": { "mean": 20.178967708333335, "sd": 0.12017875299001644, "median": 20.128893229166668, "min": 20.089348958333332, "max": 20.453213541666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.9845833333333335, "sd": 0.15979903680142782, "median": 0.9490364583333317, "min": 0.7447291666666658, "max": 1.319749999999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.9516041666666659, 0.7447291666666658, 0.9855468750000007, 0.9390989583333322, 0.9464687499999975, 0.8965833333333322, 0.9124687500000022, 1.319749999999999, 1.1890833333333362, 0.9605000000000032 ], "df": 9, "t": 19.484009052214123, "p": 1.1432216892469702e-08, "ci95": [ 0.8702699887899716, 1.0988966778766953 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0766703461757974, "lag1": 0.2552565101762068, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.051295384842648, "p_holm": 1.1432216892469702e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.229452604166667, "sd": 0.16422692901881922, "median": 19.154856770833334, "min": 19.093901041666665, "max": 19.643796875 }, "after": { "mean": 18.452440104166666, "sd": 0.08807373520691125, "median": 18.4337578125, "min": 18.345494791666667, "max": 18.60471875 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7770124999999993, "sd": 0.14880872647264903, "median": -0.774630208333333, "min": -1.0584479166666654, "max": -0.5361458333333324 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.80859375, -0.8328750000000014, -0.7406666666666659, -0.9099270833333328, -0.8546249999999986, -1.0584479166666654, -0.7155364583333323, -0.6468333333333334, -0.5361458333333324, -0.6664739583333308 ], "df": 9, "t": -16.511997170227783, "p": 4.886086845583775e-08, "ci95": [ -0.8834638501509084, -0.6705611498490902 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9930729536607752, "lag1": 0.3968241126075081, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9595925835230673, "p_holm": 4.886086845583775e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.194384375, "sd": 0.09308758766679617, "median": 19.16726302083333, "min": 19.133322916666668, "max": 19.44334375 }, "after": { "mean": 18.54957604166667, "sd": 0.22211621668955975, "median": 18.499447916666668, "min": 18.386598958333334, "max": 19.141604166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.6448083333333333, "sd": 0.25758639479300083, "median": -0.7221484374999996, "min": -0.9230312500000011, "max": 0.008281249999999574 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.6598385416666694, -0.9230312500000011, 0.008281249999999574, -0.7773177083333351, -0.7044999999999995, -0.8112239583333327, -0.7397968749999997, -0.5373020833333335, -0.760088541666665, -0.5432656249999965 ], "df": 9, "t": -7.916035275189973, "p": 2.407921056010344e-05, "ci95": [ -0.8290745397325925, -0.4605421269340741 ], "shapiro_p": 0.012047443463932838, "lag1": -0.44742831986292864, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9664064071691109, "p_holm": 0.00012039605280051719 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.229452604166667, "sd": 0.16422692901881922, "median": 19.154856770833334, "min": 19.093901041666665, "max": 19.643796875 }, "after": { "mean": 31.924933854166667, "sd": 0.1893967374809157, "median": 31.875486979166666, "min": 31.6700625, "max": 32.24609375 }, "difference": { "mean": 12.69548125, "sd": 0.2877289793473692, "median": 12.6766484375, "min": 12.175145833333335, "max": 13.092005208333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 13.092005208333333, 12.423593749999998, 12.903234375, 12.637963541666668, 12.566328124999998, 12.175145833333335, 12.865869791666668, 13.046140625, 12.529197916666668, 12.715333333333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 139.52934748881634, "p": 2.535476696243676e-16, "ci95": [ 12.48965233757597, 12.901310162424034 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9058791777945178, "lag1": -0.2961513014547568, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6602102260180367, "p_holm": 3.803215044365514e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 19.194384375, "sd": 0.09308758766679617, "median": 19.16726302083333, "min": 19.133322916666668, "max": 19.44334375 }, "after": { "mean": 31.91616875, "sd": 0.28018561015103116, "median": 31.798463541666667, "min": 31.71259375, "max": 32.629838541666665 }, "difference": { "mean": 12.721784374999999, "sd": 0.2924998402711384, "median": 12.654919270833334, "min": 12.336005208333333, "max": 13.426260416666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 12.817395833333332, 12.336005208333333, 12.684255208333333, 12.913046874999996, 12.699390625, 13.426260416666665, 12.553432291666667, 12.590078124999998, 12.625583333333335, 12.572395833333335 ], "df": 9, "t": 137.53790254808288, "p": 2.885520562181161e-16, "ci95": [ 12.512542594266723, 12.931026155733274 ], "shapiro_p": 0.06932339499148713, "lag1": -0.1560707842227384, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.pad", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.pad", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.662786788388466, "p_holm": 4.616832899489858e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.71420625, "sd": 0.06697908270507663, "median": 11.691276041666667, "min": 11.664838541666667, "max": 11.892979166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 11.799391145833333, "sd": 0.060136974998915196, "median": 11.776565104166666, "min": 11.734864583333334, "max": 11.940322916666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.08518489583333314, "sd": 0.10793916216168224, "median": 0.1047890624999992, "min": -0.15811458333333306, "max": 0.25295833333333206 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.08834374999999994, 0.25295833333333206, 0.10415624999999906, 0.12387499999999996, 0.10542187499999933, 0.024713541666667282, -0.15811458333333306, 0.16614583333333321, 0.023755208333332334, 0.12059375000000117 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.495649286901242, "p": 0.03410441834983686, "ci95": [ 0.007969870756286287, 0.16239992091037997 ], "shapiro_p": 0.24456822188800348, "lag1": -0.07815410976908395, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0072719306810338, "p_holm": 0.06820883669967372 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.717741666666667, "sd": 0.05251874390971068, "median": 11.717447916666668, "min": 11.659557291666667, "max": 11.839427083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 11.8125765625, "sd": 0.09277653663358366, "median": 11.775749999999999, "min": 11.75125, "max": 12.06296875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.09483489583333267, "sd": 0.0960738604846021, "median": 0.08329687499999938, "min": -0.06891666666666652, "max": 0.32301041666666563 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.05233854166666596, 0.0642656249999991, 0.11219270833333184, 0.11508854166666715, 0.106562499999999, 0.32301041666666563, 0.08695833333333347, 0.07721354166666572, 0.07963541666666529, -0.06891666666666652 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.1214970543023792, "p": 0.012288936731888783, "ci95": [ 0.0261077962524104, 0.16356199541425492 ], "shapiro_p": 0.020093520727241874, "lag1": 0.06632242471367646, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.after.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0080932741590565, "p_holm": 0.024577873463777565 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.71420625, "sd": 0.06697908270507663, "median": 11.691276041666667, "min": 11.664838541666667, "max": 11.892979166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 11.3086546875, "sd": 0.08217782745277297, "median": 11.276059895833335, "min": 11.224880208333333, "max": 11.488359375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.4055515625, "sd": 0.08261122408558884, "median": -0.40548437499999945, "min": -0.5061874999999993, "max": -0.2401250000000008 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.4127864583333327, -0.3763385416666676, -0.3932500000000001, -0.45285416666666656, -0.3981822916666662, -0.48922916666666616, -0.5061874999999993, -0.31180729166666765, -0.2401250000000008, -0.47475520833333285 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.524121090512333, "p": 8.368565291651133e-08, "ci95": [ -0.4646480721603161, -0.3464550528396839 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5294793243617302, "lag1": 0.027131121225395113, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9653795098152724, "p_holm": 7.53170876248602e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.717741666666667, "sd": 0.05251874390971068, "median": 11.717447916666668, "min": 11.659557291666667, "max": 11.839427083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 11.364905208333333, "sd": 0.0833473650585365, "median": 11.371973958333333, "min": 11.256255208333334, "max": 11.490932291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3528364583333339, "sd": 0.091218170772388, "median": -0.3511510416666672, "min": -0.4699791666666666, "max": -0.23177604166666654 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.23177604166666654, -0.3063333333333347, -0.4383541666666666, -0.41755729166666633, -0.3214635416666667, -0.45712500000000134, -0.2575833333333346, -0.4699791666666666, -0.24735416666666765, -0.38083854166666775 ], "df": 9, "t": -12.231848549830586, "p": 6.540615381405064e-07, "ci95": [ -0.4180900067453731, -0.28758290992129465 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2537139800005218, "lag1": -0.5183776052732034, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.energy.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9698886979786349, "p_holm": 3.924369228843038e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.71420625, "sd": 0.06697908270507663, "median": 11.691276041666667, "min": 11.664838541666667, "max": 11.892979166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 19.7416265625, "sd": 0.2061402001511516, "median": 19.665380208333332, "min": 19.587640625, "max": 20.265286458333332 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.0274203125, "sd": 0.15578226471233128, "median": 7.984179687499999, "min": 7.885546874999999, "max": 8.372307291666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 8.043989583333333, 7.900276041666665, 7.959552083333332, 7.952343750000001, 8.015598958333333, 7.911536458333334, 8.372307291666665, 8.008807291666667, 7.885546874999999, 8.224244791666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 162.9513601556418, "p": 6.276923518817061e-17, "ci95": [ 7.915980393610284, 8.138860231389717 ], "shapiro_p": 0.027538426256182268, "lag1": -0.29736500238983665, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6852722362217243, "p_holm": 1.0043077630107298e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.717741666666667, "sd": 0.05251874390971068, "median": 11.717447916666668, "min": 11.659557291666667, "max": 11.839427083333334 }, "after": { "mean": 19.7231515625, "sd": 0.1840240884137851, "median": 19.65678125, "min": 19.614588541666667, "max": 20.21036979166667 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.005409895833333, "sd": 0.21361066068758652, "median": 7.942190104166665, "min": 7.785541666666667, "max": 8.550812500000001 }, "differences_ns": [ 7.936166666666665, 7.902401041666666, 8.149651041666667, 7.928979166666668, 8.550812500000001, 7.950401041666666, 8.023703125, 7.878229166666667, 7.948213541666664, 7.785541666666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 118.51154241364958, "p": 1.1012523721411674e-15, "ci95": [ 7.852602034521512, 8.158217757145154 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004306700682266884, "lag1": -0.1987816348153921, "reference": "comp.rmsiir.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmsiir.independent.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.6831870955652006, "p_holm": 1.5417533209976343e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.488990625, "sd": 0.10070797546778595, "median": 12.474346354166666, "min": 12.354109375, "max": 12.634317708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 13.4851484375, "sd": 0.13572469838873338, "median": 13.4677421875, "min": 13.336296875, "max": 13.80275 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.9961578125000001, "sd": 0.17815992691217591, "median": 1.0089921875000005, "min": 0.7336197916666656, "max": 1.3418385416666663 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.3418385416666663, 0.9151041666666675, 0.9147656250000011, 1.0748229166666654, 1.1220572916666658, 0.7658906250000008, 1.0433958333333333, 0.7336197916666656, 1.0754947916666673, 0.9745885416666678 ], "df": 9, "t": 17.681459860633026, "p": 2.6839487298801234e-08, "ci95": [ 0.8687098784161462, 1.123605746583854 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7542989056682916, "lag1": -0.44013676620665265, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.079762876153172, "p_holm": 2.952343602868136e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.440731770833333, "sd": 0.15527510047201323, "median": 12.3981796875, "min": 12.328447916666667, "max": 12.862739583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 13.497103125, "sd": 0.1756372963848104, "median": 13.428921875, "min": 13.366942708333333, "max": 13.959630208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.0563713541666666, "sd": 0.2572287384744313, "median": 1.0271640624999998, "min": 0.543432291666667, "max": 1.5681927083333331 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.0324062499999993, 0.951161458333333, 1.0688385416666666, 1.1439010416666662, 1.0219218750000003, 0.984010416666667, 0.543432291666667, 1.5681927083333331, 0.9923541666666669, 1.257494791666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 12.986649757469152, "p": 3.917386543061436e-07, "ci95": [ 0.8723609996848601, 1.240381708648473 ], "shapiro_p": 0.22872135745131827, "lag1": -0.4696014335336668, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.after.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0849123165442147, "p_holm": 2.742170580143005e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.488990625, "sd": 0.10070797546778595, "median": 12.474346354166666, "min": 12.354109375, "max": 12.634317708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.1271671875, "sd": 0.05981022225313019, "median": 12.106822916666667, "min": 12.057557291666667, "max": 12.257036458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.3618234374999997, "sd": 0.11653062293868226, "median": -0.3180598958333327, "min": -0.5644114583333337, "max": -0.22168749999999982 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.27780729166666696, -0.44332812499999896, -0.4115364583333321, -0.22168749999999982, -0.26089583333333266, -0.31336979166666623, -0.2824895833333336, -0.5644114583333337, -0.3227499999999992, -0.5199583333333333 ], "df": 9, "t": -9.81875960565012, "p": 4.165771903911196e-06, "ci95": [ -0.4451844233762496, -0.2784624516237498 ], "shapiro_p": 0.28329349573463625, "lag1": -0.1498713455037334, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9710286084468895, "p_holm": 2.082885951955598e-05 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.440731770833333, "sd": 0.15527510047201323, "median": 12.3981796875, "min": 12.328447916666667, "max": 12.862739583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.147016666666666, "sd": 0.07462141035126907, "median": 12.124950520833334, "min": 12.057791666666667, "max": 12.300770833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.29371510416666685, "sd": 0.1828310295665359, "median": -0.27383593750000035, "min": -0.741703124999999, "max": -0.02767708333333374 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.2127708333333338, -0.31380729166666654, -0.2751041666666669, -0.3100625000000008, -0.27256770833333377, -0.36301041666666656, -0.741703124999999, -0.24638541666666747, -0.1740624999999998, -0.02767708333333374 ], "df": 9, "t": -5.080148126728493, "p": 0.0006627017349197032, "ci95": [ -0.4245045437928151, -0.1629256645405186 ], "shapiro_p": 0.03907185639332651, "lag1": 0.15985344484360559, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.energy.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9763908498650162, "p_holm": 0.002650806939678813 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.488990625, "sd": 0.10070797546778595, "median": 12.474346354166666, "min": 12.354109375, "max": 12.634317708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 21.293529166666666, "sd": 0.15010017310016294, "median": 21.247278645833333, "min": 21.22163541666667, "max": 21.716161458333332 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.804538541666666, "sd": 0.2132690527139037, "median": 8.759315104166667, "min": 8.629874999999998, "max": 9.362052083333332 }, "differences_ns": [ 8.782651041666666, 8.670437500000002, 8.735979166666668, 8.861833333333333, 9.362052083333332, 8.667770833333334, 8.862729166666666, 8.629874999999998, 8.807093750000002, 8.664963541666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 130.5505659827449, "p": 4.61236914513886e-16, "ci95": [ 8.651975051977955, 8.957102031355381 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0018513426117535128, "lag1": -0.13907986393322266, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.7049839979895627, "p_holm": 5.996079888680518e-15 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.440731770833333, "sd": 0.15527510047201323, "median": 12.3981796875, "min": 12.328447916666667, "max": 12.862739583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 21.342614583333333, "sd": 0.15272758982710408, "median": 21.297635416666665, "min": 21.194614583333333, "max": 21.735942708333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 8.9018828125, "sd": 0.22762249537197712, "median": 8.891937500000001, "min": 8.427734375, "max": 9.315140625 }, "differences_ns": [ 8.974229166666666, 8.814666666666668, 8.923838541666667, 8.846536458333334, 8.860036458333333, 9.315140625, 8.427734375, 8.803177083333333, 8.950401041666666, 9.103067708333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 123.67066403258144, "p": 7.506291508245775e-16, "ci95": [ 8.73905148848138, 9.064714136518617 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4141840052146103, "lag1": -0.3864125427952108, "reference": "comp.rmswindow.max.drums", "candidate": "comp.rmswindow.independent.drums", "question": "RMS\u691c\u51fa\u306estereo link\u4f4d\u7f6e/\u65b9\u6cd5\u3092\u5909\u3048\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u5de6\u53f3\u50cf\u3068\u5727\u7e2e\u91cf\u306f\u5225\u306b\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.715543343951038, "p_holm": 1.1259437262368662e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.46330364583333333, "sd": 0.03702069663997697, "median": 0.44427083333333334, "min": 0.44113541666666667, "max": 0.5408020833333333 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.bass": { "mean": 12.937136458333333, "sd": 0.09594071969378155, "median": 12.911973958333334, "min": 12.831984375, "max": 13.104901041666666 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.bass": { "mean": 13.052088541666667, "sd": 0.09280563713871164, "median": 13.006158854166667, "min": 12.961541666666667, "max": 13.25128125 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.bass": { "mean": 12.421566145833333, "sd": 0.05829707180701011, "median": 12.396322916666666, "min": 12.367369791666667, "max": 12.549109375 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.bass": { "mean": 21.798081770833335, "sd": 0.14584483589826222, "median": 21.754723958333333, "min": 21.714604166666668, "max": 22.2026875 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.bass": { "mean": 14.094398958333333, "sd": 0.057655418804022474, "median": 14.074645833333333, "min": 14.029109375, "max": 14.176140625 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.bass": { "mean": 15.265384375, "sd": 0.1260270653129962, "median": 15.2334375, "min": 15.175171875, "max": 15.607557291666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.bass": { "mean": 13.767710416666667, "sd": 0.07054380571864567, "median": 13.743270833333334, "min": 13.700151041666667, "max": 13.939338541666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.bass": { "mean": 24.1525421875, "sd": 0.04636292854730346, "median": 24.15341145833333, "min": 24.095114583333334, "max": 24.252770833333333 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4560375, "sd": 0.030713562697048443, "median": 0.4443828125, "min": 0.4406979166666667, "max": 0.541375 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.pad": { "mean": 16.8300796875, "sd": 0.257096063374705, "median": 16.753002604166667, "min": 16.67385416666667, "max": 17.535479166666665 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.pad": { "mean": 16.795805729166666, "sd": 0.08606097765152813, "median": 16.760903645833334, "min": 16.715484375, "max": 16.958546875 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.pad": { "mean": 16.169863541666665, "sd": 0.169422361625266, "median": 16.106846354166667, "min": 16.068770833333332, "max": 16.627765625 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.pad": { "mean": 28.4627375, "sd": 0.07389232122647481, "median": 28.446276041666668, "min": 28.374838541666666, "max": 28.591119791666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.pad": { "mean": 19.229452604166667, "sd": 0.16422692901881922, "median": 19.154856770833334, "min": 19.093901041666665, "max": 19.643796875 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.pad": { "mean": 20.174896875, "sd": 0.09491510109256959, "median": 20.16238020833333, "min": 20.097432291666667, "max": 20.414421875 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.pad": { "mean": 18.452440104166666, "sd": 0.08807373520691125, "median": 18.4337578125, "min": 18.345494791666667, "max": 18.60471875 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.pad": { "mean": 31.924933854166667, "sd": 0.1893967374809157, "median": 31.875486979166666, "min": 31.6700625, "max": 32.24609375 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.47027135416666666, "sd": 0.04814423845672931, "median": 0.44709895833333335, "min": 0.441, "max": 0.5741822916666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.drums": { "mean": 11.71420625, "sd": 0.06697908270507663, "median": 11.691276041666667, "min": 11.664838541666667, "max": 11.892979166666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.drums": { "mean": 11.799391145833333, "sd": 0.060136974998915196, "median": 11.776565104166666, "min": 11.734864583333334, "max": 11.940322916666666 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.drums": { "mean": 11.3086546875, "sd": 0.08217782745277297, "median": 11.276059895833335, "min": 11.224880208333333, "max": 11.488359375 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.drums": { "mean": 19.7416265625, "sd": 0.2061402001511516, "median": 19.665380208333332, "min": 19.587640625, "max": 20.265286458333332 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.drums": { "mean": 12.488990625, "sd": 0.10070797546778595, "median": 12.474346354166666, "min": 12.354109375, "max": 12.634317708333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.drums": { "mean": 13.4851484375, "sd": 0.13572469838873338, "median": 13.4677421875, "min": 13.336296875, "max": 13.80275 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.drums": { "mean": 12.1271671875, "sd": 0.05981022225313019, "median": 12.106822916666667, "min": 12.057557291666667, "max": 12.257036458333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.drums": { "mean": 21.293529166666666, "sd": 0.15010017310016294, "median": 21.247278645833333, "min": 21.22163541666667, "max": 21.716161458333332 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.45166927083333336, "sd": 0.031478737926071726, "median": 0.44131770833333334, "min": 0.44014583333333335, "max": 0.5410729166666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.bass": { "mean": 12.84641875, "sd": 0.03868257853963355, "median": 12.83375, "min": 12.813026041666667, "max": 12.92625 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.bass": { "mean": 13.017716666666667, "sd": 0.10436851806312546, "median": 12.994994791666667, "min": 12.929911458333333, "max": 13.283848958333333 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.bass": { "mean": 12.4221328125, "sd": 0.06790145736037811, "median": 12.400270833333334, "min": 12.366588541666667, "max": 12.602526041666666 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.bass": { "mean": 21.84150208333333, "sd": 0.1160837682482931, "median": 21.812359375, "min": 21.710171875, "max": 22.014697916666666 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.bass": { "mean": 14.129022395833333, "sd": 0.06440177474412756, "median": 14.108244791666667, "min": 14.050625, "max": 14.251609375 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.bass": { "mean": 15.278684895833333, "sd": 0.09687939102484995, "median": 15.2444453125, "min": 15.189661458333333, "max": 15.509364583333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.bass": { "mean": 13.754708854166667, "sd": 0.06677717631304203, "median": 13.732114583333333, "min": 13.6875, "max": 13.881734375 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.bass": { "mean": 24.2545296875, "sd": 0.13956569408675157, "median": 24.244838541666667, "min": 24.087489583333333, "max": 24.51273958333333 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.44338958333333334, "sd": 0.004472966073188815, "median": 0.44184375, "min": 0.43988020833333336, "max": 0.4547760416666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.pad": { "mean": 16.686306770833333, "sd": 0.024066797487062096, "median": 16.694552083333335, "min": 16.630614583333333, "max": 16.709260416666666 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.pad": { "mean": 16.774794270833333, "sd": 0.1409337039915502, "median": 16.715229166666667, "min": 16.676296875, "max": 17.141671875 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.pad": { "mean": 16.0921484375, "sd": 0.06900902991487515, "median": 16.073541666666667, "min": 16.031723958333334, "max": 16.277817708333334 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.pad": { "mean": 28.52326927083333, "sd": 0.33072139360989905, "median": 28.410794270833335, "min": 28.358979166666668, "max": 29.443729166666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.pad": { "mean": 19.194384375, "sd": 0.09308758766679617, "median": 19.16726302083333, "min": 19.133322916666668, "max": 19.44334375 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.pad": { "mean": 20.178967708333335, "sd": 0.12017875299001644, "median": 20.128893229166668, "min": 20.089348958333332, "max": 20.453213541666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.pad": { "mean": 18.54957604166667, "sd": 0.22211621668955975, "median": 18.499447916666668, "min": 18.386598958333334, "max": 19.141604166666667 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.pad": { "mean": 31.91616875, "sd": 0.28018561015103116, "median": 31.798463541666667, "min": 31.71259375, "max": 32.629838541666665 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.46563125, "sd": 0.03947833821079358, "median": 0.44220052083333333, "min": 0.4395, "max": 0.5431041666666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.max.drums": { "mean": 11.717741666666667, "sd": 0.05251874390971068, "median": 11.717447916666668, "min": 11.659557291666667, "max": 11.839427083333334 }, "comp.rmsiir.after.drums": { "mean": 11.8125765625, "sd": 0.09277653663358366, "median": 11.775749999999999, "min": 11.75125, "max": 12.06296875 }, "comp.rmsiir.energy.drums": { "mean": 11.364905208333333, "sd": 0.0833473650585365, "median": 11.371973958333333, "min": 11.256255208333334, "max": 11.490932291666667 }, "comp.rmsiir.independent.drums": { "mean": 19.7231515625, "sd": 0.1840240884137851, "median": 19.65678125, "min": 19.614588541666667, "max": 20.21036979166667 }, "comp.rmswindow.max.drums": { "mean": 12.440731770833333, "sd": 0.15527510047201323, "median": 12.3981796875, "min": 12.328447916666667, "max": 12.862739583333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.after.drums": { "mean": 13.497103125, "sd": 0.1756372963848104, "median": 13.428921875, "min": 13.366942708333333, "max": 13.959630208333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.energy.drums": { "mean": 12.147016666666666, "sd": 0.07462141035126907, "median": 12.124950520833334, "min": 12.057791666666667, "max": 12.300770833333333 }, "comp.rmswindow.independent.drums": { "mean": 21.342614583333333, "sd": 0.15272758982710408, "median": 21.297635416666665, "min": 21.194614583333333, "max": 21.735942708333333 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "a57836484519c833efd3660572e3619c7676094e38078c2acd8106082979b444" }, { "family": "DX05", "jobs": 27, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056121, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.109610416666667, "sd": 0.03267192733514207, "median": 9.119497395833333, "min": 9.068421875, "max": 9.152161458333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.3343578125, "sd": 0.06706412099123694, "median": 9.3092890625, "min": 9.266385416666667, "max": 9.483515625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2247473958333334, "sd": 0.08162913295386756, "median": 0.19331250000000022, "min": 0.14711458333333383, "max": 0.36326562500000037 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.14764062500000108, 0.24537499999999923, 0.3328020833333323, 0.15944791666666625, 0.36326562500000037, 0.21297916666666694, 0.14711458333333383, 0.30178124999999945, 0.16342187500000094, 0.1736458333333335 ], "df": 9, "t": 8.70661788636696, "p": 1.1187769610169689e-05, "ci95": [ 0.16635343184638665, 0.2831413598202801 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0758593850134212, "lag1": -0.4383021239983183, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0246714607489846, "p_holm": 0.00014702701063119662 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.1883875, "sd": 0.1597088631037635, "median": 9.121119791666667, "min": 9.08271875, "max": 9.584333333333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.355320833333334, "sd": 0.19792235716417272, "median": 9.29265625, "min": 9.23125, "max": 9.909489583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1669333333333336, "sd": 0.27315819058923646, "median": 0.15036458333333336, "min": -0.23501041666666644, "max": 0.8267708333333328 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.15785416666666663, 0.14823437499999947, 0.23911458333333435, 0.139026041666666, 0.25414062500000156, -0.013723958333333286, 0.0004322916666676946, 0.15249479166666724, -0.23501041666666644, 0.8267708333333328 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.9325415415833527, "p": 0.08532407414231187, "ci95": [ -0.028472264727127744, 0.3623389313937949 ], "shapiro_p": 0.04375047049518806, "lag1": -0.6974401570439727, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.01816785952196, "p_holm": 0.17064814828462374 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.806216145833334, "sd": 0.09597074561350244, "median": 9.799380208333334, "min": 9.6379375, "max": 9.99340625 }, "after": { "mean": 11.47575, "sd": 4.469387444598089, "median": 10.059515625, "min": 9.812661458333332, "max": 24.1825 }, "difference": { "mean": 1.6695338541666667, "sd": 4.446735259236537, "median": 0.3040234374999997, "min": 0.01493750000000027, "max": 14.308765625000001 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.03786979166666704, 0.08870833333333294, 0.09410416666666599, 0.3915520833333339, 0.2740468749999998, 14.308765625000001, 0.01493750000000027, 0.33399999999999963, 0.38516666666666666, 0.7661874999999991 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.1872821974188112, "p": 0.26550681222360384, "ci95": [ -1.5114689225514442, 4.850536630884777 ], "shapiro_p": 3.266276629048877e-07, "lag1": -0.14067570588804237, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.1702526060345968, "p_holm": 0.45478244963386094 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.7637203125, "sd": 0.07872246243992029, "median": 9.770182291666666, "min": 9.649885416666667, "max": 9.865526041666667 }, "after": { "mean": 9.908671875, "sd": 0.084995514573351, "median": 9.887075520833335, "min": 9.801119791666666, "max": 10.026635416666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.14495156250000002, "sd": 0.09400949153932074, "median": 0.16446354166666666, "min": -0.0008072916666677088, "max": 0.28298437499999984 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.16781770833333454, 0.1512343749999996, 0.28298437499999984, 0.22653645833333336, 0.16110937499999878, 0.05457812500000081, 0.21477083333333447, -0.0008072916666677088, 0.01240624999999973, 0.17888541666666669 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.875859664750216, "p": 0.0008763841709101417, "ci95": [ 0.07770122350055615, 0.2122019014994439 ], "shapiro_p": 0.40135160606047326, "lag1": 0.13203776070385662, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0148459355512698, "p_holm": 0.007011073367281134 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.3343578125, "sd": 0.06706412099123694, "median": 9.3092890625, "min": 9.266385416666667, "max": 9.483515625 }, "after": { "mean": 11.47575, "sd": 4.469387444598089, "median": 10.059515625, "min": 9.812661458333332, "max": 24.1825 }, "difference": { "mean": 2.1413921875, "sd": 4.486679306532969, "median": 0.7173072916666667, "min": 0.4696562499999999, "max": 14.895921875 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6045781249999997, 0.49031770833333255, 0.4696562499999999, 0.7178802083333338, 0.6060260416666665, 14.895921875, 0.7167343749999997, 0.8294531250000006, 0.8703124999999989, 1.2130416666666672 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.5092847546135595, "p": 0.16550409202177727, "ci95": [ -1.0681848393040325, 5.350969214304033 ], "shapiro_p": 3.0954176255761004e-07, "lag1": -0.13007420367092262, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.2294096959334875, "p_holm": 0.45478244963386094 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.355320833333334, "sd": 0.19792235716417272, "median": 9.29265625, "min": 9.23125, "max": 9.909489583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.908671875, "sd": 0.084995514573351, "median": 9.887075520833335, "min": 9.801119791666666, "max": 10.026635416666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5533510416666665, "sd": 0.23649995070669397, "median": 0.6078723958333336, "min": -0.07211979166666538, "max": 0.7532864583333332 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6308020833333341, 0.521869791666667, 0.6626874999999988, 0.729265625, 0.6895781249999988, 0.5849427083333332, 0.7532864583333332, 0.5113697916666666, 0.521828124999999, -0.07211979166666538 ], "df": 9, "t": 7.398942926053952, "p": 4.1080103850979194e-05, "ci95": [ 0.3841691686669112, 0.7225329146664218 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0013735076204486054, "lag1": 0.3570790980617747, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0591482699016646, "p_holm": 0.0006162015577646879 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.171701041666667, "sd": 0.08440893390554678, "median": 9.129835937500001, "min": 9.103958333333333, "max": 9.370515625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.3493890625, "sd": 0.042030207893737126, "median": 9.358140625, "min": 9.283020833333333, "max": 9.400567708333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1776880208333333, "sd": 0.09329145154094144, "median": 0.1917630208333332, "min": 0.015369791666667965, "max": 0.29184895833333435 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2028854166666676, 0.29184895833333435, 0.09878645833333266, 0.082760416666666, 0.015369791666667965, 0.18064062499999878, 0.24584375000000058, 0.2753281249999997, 0.1265260416666667, 0.2568906249999987 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.023047658489815, "p": 0.00019686259801422374, "ci95": [ 0.11095133670549322, 0.24442470496117336 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5571264334862802, "lag1": 0.18642459405032158, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0193735077087775, "p_holm": 0.0018716702084273066 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.209346875, "sd": 0.0928561974374173, "median": 9.191546875, "min": 9.106401041666667, "max": 9.37709375 }, "after": { "mean": 9.362328125, "sd": 0.0956067013464614, "median": 9.334333333333333, "min": 9.283890625, "max": 9.615494791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.15298125, "sd": 0.1583407812118901, "median": 0.13506250000000009, "min": -0.0612187500000001, "max": 0.5090937499999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.12904166666666583, 0.5090937499999999, -0.03392187499999899, 0.10892187500000006, 0.1702187499999983, 0.1647447916666671, 0.27280729166666795, -0.0612187500000001, 0.1293437500000003, 0.14078124999999986 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.055240637295193, "p": 0.013676478284935614, "ci95": [ 0.03971107866328433, 0.2662514213367157 ], "shapiro_p": 0.13708537070364396, "lag1": -0.38333219524824186, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0166115200216084, "p_holm": 0.0759914826397782 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.8006953125, "sd": 0.11578578348725284, "median": 9.793427083333334, "min": 9.602890625, "max": 10.026104166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.003122395833334, "sd": 0.14840018269244343, "median": 10.0051875, "min": 9.815322916666666, "max": 10.250973958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.20242708333333273, "sd": 0.19525545338191233, "median": 0.17884114583333233, "min": -0.21078125000000014, "max": 0.48292187499999883 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.25869270833333324, 0.15474479166666555, 0.3432604166666664, 0.42280729166666653, 0.11491666666666589, 0.10568229166666576, 0.2029374999999991, -0.21078125000000014, 0.48292187499999883, 0.14908854166666607 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.278426452888716, "p": 0.009553247371875228, "ci95": [ 0.06274974632814856, 0.3421044203385169 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5071707275596222, "lag1": -0.3530826839285185, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0206543593978636, "p_holm": 0.05731948423125137 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.7849296875, "sd": 0.07682773016346588, "median": 9.819135416666667, "min": 9.661901041666667, "max": 9.864234375 }, "after": { "mean": 10.005965104166666, "sd": 0.09967917502833369, "median": 10.012473958333334, "min": 9.858588541666666, "max": 10.1610625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2210354166666665, "sd": 0.13399328865942434, "median": 0.22096354166666732, "min": 0.021401041666665677, "max": 0.49864062500000017 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.045921874999999446, 0.49864062500000017, 0.23544791666666676, 0.30954166666666616, 0.021401041666665677, 0.21907291666666673, 0.2228541666666679, 0.17758333333333276, 0.19899999999999984, 0.2808906249999996 ], "df": 9, "t": 5.216495297817642, "p": 0.0005517708422444304, "ci95": [ 0.12518239227042657, 0.3168884410629065 ], "shapiro_p": 0.43103030836521133, "lag1": -0.4224756774049381, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0225893719961048, "p_holm": 0.0049659375801998735 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.3493890625, "sd": 0.042030207893737126, "median": 9.358140625, "min": 9.283020833333333, "max": 9.400567708333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.003122395833334, "sd": 0.14840018269244343, "median": 10.0051875, "min": 9.815322916666666, "max": 10.250973958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6537333333333329, "sd": 0.17641012180137985, "median": 0.6982968749999996, "min": 0.4290677083333332, "max": 0.9152916666666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.740114583333332, 0.4610468749999992, 0.9152916666666666, 0.7288489583333337, 0.49074999999999847, 0.6790937499999998, 0.7174999999999994, 0.4290677083333332, 0.8844947916666666, 0.49112500000000026 ], "df": 9, "t": 11.718637766346337, "p": 9.422049855239847e-07, "ci95": [ 0.5275371344195897, 0.7799295322470762 ], "shapiro_p": 0.22644385012263363, "lag1": -0.6293682766937396, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.069922572369507, "p_holm": 1.5075279768383755e-05 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.362328125, "sd": 0.0956067013464614, "median": 9.334333333333333, "min": 9.283890625, "max": 9.615494791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.005965104166666, "sd": 0.09967917502833369, "median": 10.012473958333334, "min": 9.858588541666666, "max": 10.1610625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6436369791666667, "sd": 0.10157672564931701, "median": 0.67484375, "min": 0.5044062500000006, "max": 0.839083333333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5729895833333334, 0.5455677083333335, 0.6766458333333336, 0.839083333333333, 0.5412708333333338, 0.5044062500000006, 0.6731302083333333, 0.7009270833333332, 0.6765572916666667, 0.7057916666666664 ], "df": 9, "t": 20.037649643323544, "p": 8.930149581221368e-09, "ci95": [ 0.5709733669875403, 0.7163005913457932 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3575436267786133, "lag1": 0.07268009154451764, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.bass", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0687475348624, "p_holm": 1.585091497496752e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.418309375, "sd": 0.11323551679546971, "median": 9.361036458333334, "min": 9.343744791666667, "max": 9.712890625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.67423125, "sd": 0.2255951885004563, "median": 9.589283854166666, "min": 9.546, "max": 10.284635416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.25592187499999974, "sd": 0.2709419022952474, "median": 0.22528645833333272, "min": -0.16689062500000063, "max": 0.9233229166666668 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.16689062500000063, 0.3246354166666663, 0.9233229166666668, 0.2881666666666671, 0.20351562499999964, 0.2193697916666668, 0.10800520833333316, 0.23173437500000027, 0.1961562499999996, 0.23120312499999862 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.986972562032903, "p": 0.015275762606890614, "ci95": [ 0.06210171407626544, 0.4497420359237341 ], "shapiro_p": 0.009661036073661637, "lag1": 0.0892718201037199, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.027172804036287, "p_holm": 0.07637881303445307 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.476719791666667, "sd": 0.14467813092115983, "median": 9.423958333333333, "min": 9.344416666666667, "max": 9.78196875 }, "after": { "mean": 9.749827604166667, "sd": 0.2831742569146927, "median": 9.609682291666667, "min": 9.534458333333333, "max": 10.247229166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2731078124999998, "sd": 0.3554972490699724, "median": 0.19042187500000018, "min": -0.2392656250000016, "max": 0.7869166666666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6096666666666657, 0.11048958333333303, -0.163203124999999, 0.18842187499999952, 0.7829583333333332, 0.19004166666666578, 0.2742500000000003, -0.2392656250000016, 0.1908020833333346, 0.7869166666666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.429393579122221, "p": 0.038020352355372725, "ci95": [ 0.01880040032422159, 0.5274152246757781 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2833818725342816, "lag1": -0.05667600579869255, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0288188126803282, "p_holm": 0.1520814094214909 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.170071875, "sd": 0.13150946937227584, "median": 10.145763020833332, "min": 10.064354166666666, "max": 10.523916666666667 }, "after": { "mean": 10.4127328125, "sd": 0.052653901306399215, "median": 10.407528645833334, "min": 10.337177083333334, "max": 10.522546875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.24266093750000034, "sd": 0.1280041453655705, "median": 0.29287499999999955, "min": -0.09843749999999929, "max": 0.3219791666666669 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.31893750000000054, 0.1898333333333344, 0.3219791666666669, 0.3162031249999995, 0.31168750000000145, 0.27883854166666566, -0.09843749999999929, 0.30691145833333344, 0.25759374999999984, 0.22306250000000105 ], "df": 9, "t": 5.994815710539988, "p": 0.00020379126147015915, "ci95": [ 0.15109228811986664, 0.33422958688013404 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0002708130955657876, "lag1": -0.19609851757411054, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0238602972016853, "p_holm": 0.0018716702084273066 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.141339583333334, "sd": 0.05836238171824684, "median": 10.127075520833333, "min": 10.065572916666667, "max": 10.264203125 }, "after": { "mean": 10.337347916666666, "sd": 0.08379988170547906, "median": 10.328106770833333, "min": 10.218161458333332, "max": 10.526333333333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.19600833333333298, "sd": 0.10093731047883833, "median": 0.19055729166666602, "min": 0.016677083333332732, "max": 0.35189583333333374 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.08192708333333343, 0.3028333333333322, 0.15977604166666737, 0.15258854166666502, 0.19711979166666538, 0.24910416666666713, 0.18399479166666666, 0.2641666666666662, 0.016677083333332732, 0.35189583333333374 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.140769659567904, "p": 0.00017061171522741843, "ci95": [ 0.12380213121219083, 0.26821453545447516 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9834895792335406, "lag1": -0.7658075917098766, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0193276570341319, "p_holm": 0.0018767288675016027 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.67423125, "sd": 0.2255951885004563, "median": 9.589283854166666, "min": 9.546, "max": 10.284635416666667 }, "after": { "mean": 10.4127328125, "sd": 0.052653901306399215, "median": 10.407528645833334, "min": 10.337177083333334, "max": 10.522546875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7385015625000003, "sd": 0.19962143220195602, "median": 0.8087317708333339, "min": 0.2379114583333326, "max": 0.8807916666666653 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8451145833333342, 0.5522395833333338, 0.2379114583333326, 0.7896666666666672, 0.7433281250000014, 0.8807916666666653, 0.8599010416666673, 0.8585989583333333, 0.8148437499999996, 0.8026197916666682 ], "df": 9, "t": 11.698879059892395, "p": 9.558100215900627e-07, "ci95": [ 0.5957009923945762, 0.8813021326054244 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0009525813896094482, "lag1": 0.26816303087737814, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0763369763876587, "p_holm": 1.5075279768383755e-05 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.749827604166667, "sd": 0.2831742569146927, "median": 9.609682291666667, "min": 9.534458333333333, "max": 10.247229166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 10.337347916666666, "sd": 0.08379988170547906, "median": 10.328106770833333, "min": 10.218161458333332, "max": 10.526333333333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5875203124999997, "sd": 0.27104794981536967, "median": 0.658182291666666, "min": 0.0787916666666657, "max": 0.843354166666666 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.26402083333333337, 0.843354166666666, 0.7930468749999999, 0.5794791666666654, 0.0787916666666657, 0.8326250000000002, 0.6161666666666665, 0.8249739583333344, 0.7001979166666654, 0.34254687500000003 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.8545154478366115, "p": 7.435618375025045e-05, "ci95": [ 0.3936242897503849, 0.7814163352496145 ], "shapiro_p": 0.10148479934202403, "lag1": -0.2604862713455085, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0602595590766053, "p_holm": 0.0010409865725035062 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.603706770833334, "sd": 0.14215718380280437, "median": 9.561557291666666, "min": 9.459640625, "max": 9.88621875 }, "after": { "mean": 9.710047916666667, "sd": 0.0436292712405277, "median": 9.692377604166666, "min": 9.660078125, "max": 9.780890625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.10634114583333343, "sd": 0.12893742695488333, "median": 0.13529687499999987, "min": -0.10532812499999977, "max": 0.2866770833333341 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.08250520833333219, 0.2298645833333346, -0.043770833333333314, 0.2004374999999996, 0.11714062499999933, 0.1534531250000004, -0.02948437499999912, 0.17191666666666627, 0.2866770833333341, -0.10532812499999977 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.6080885726308645, "p": 0.028359514813639717, "ci95": [ 0.014104867023069498, 0.19857742464359734 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6457441322544809, "lag1": -0.6255774198081547, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0110729271906025, "p_holm": 0.11343805925455887 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.5122, "sd": 0.052781772121327515, "median": 9.496520833333333, "min": 9.449770833333334, "max": 9.611598958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 9.716519791666666, "sd": 0.0651734154769009, "median": 9.7020546875, "min": 9.646390625, "max": 9.866078125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.20431979166666636, "sd": 0.09589133875705753, "median": 0.18315104166666618, "min": 0.08905729166666632, "max": 0.4012864583333329 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.11346874999999912, 0.1858541666666671, 0.4012864583333329, 0.33151562499999976, 0.15131249999999952, 0.08905729166666632, 0.18044791666666526, 0.22690104166666636, 0.15946875000000027, 0.20388541666666704 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.738000752650903, "p": 8.479446572397421e-05, "ci95": [ 0.1357232602640328, 0.2729163230692999 ], "shapiro_p": 0.21270985468543724, "lag1": 0.30339889604199455, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0214797619548228, "p_holm": 0.0011023280544116647 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.266802083333333, "sd": 0.07480861439766129, "median": 10.284835937499999, "min": 10.136473958333333, "max": 10.392322916666666 }, "after": { "mean": 10.628327604166667, "sd": 0.11372652755130527, "median": 10.628841145833334, "min": 10.505234375, "max": 10.848828125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.3615255208333338, "sd": 0.13029049098902387, "median": 0.38724479166666637, "min": 0.11411458333333435, "max": 0.5569843750000008 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.3682187500000005, 0.40706770833333294, 0.11411458333333435, 0.5569843750000008, 0.3897499999999994, 0.47969270833333333, 0.3997864583333346, 0.33751041666666737, 0.17739062500000102, 0.38473958333333336 ], "df": 9, "t": 8.774578017426462, "p": 1.0501929330799759e-05, "ci95": [ 0.2683213183220269, 0.4547297233446407 ], "shapiro_p": 0.26940961774175626, "lag1": -0.30656031116095733, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0352130602985148, "p_holm": 0.00014702701063119662 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 10.332994791666668, "sd": 0.08463212518528487, "median": 10.29984375, "min": 10.2455, "max": 10.46325 }, "after": { "mean": 10.5057296875, "sd": 0.07505908851192664, "median": 10.530182291666666, "min": 10.401234375, "max": 10.609171875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.172734895833333, "sd": 0.08514616606430325, "median": 0.1483749999999997, "min": 0.09072395833333324, "max": 0.36367187499999964 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.09424479166666622, 0.17928125000000072, 0.1511822916666663, 0.09072395833333324, 0.1455677083333331, 0.36367187499999964, 0.1454947916666658, 0.152333333333333, 0.12581250000000033, 0.2790364583333318 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.415270674815097, "p": 0.0001230462852068279, "ci95": [ 0.11182499792230863, 0.2336447937443574 ], "shapiro_p": 0.01923640316237854, "lag1": -0.17297065635856582, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0167168279202696, "p_holm": 0.001476555422481935 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.710047916666667, "sd": 0.0436292712405277, "median": 9.692377604166666, "min": 9.660078125, "max": 9.780890625 }, "after": { "mean": 10.628327604166667, "sd": 0.11372652755130527, "median": 10.628841145833334, "min": 10.505234375, "max": 10.848828125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.9182796875000001, "sd": 0.12972474899325234, "median": 0.8751119791666673, "min": 0.7523645833333337, "max": 1.1887500000000006 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.8092187500000012, 1.033114583333333, 0.8301145833333337, 1.1887500000000006, 0.8518541666666657, 0.9698958333333323, 0.9972604166666663, 0.8541510416666682, 0.7523645833333337, 0.8960729166666663 ], "df": 9, "t": 22.384744346036047, "p": 3.354823603083296e-09, "ci95": [ 0.825480192432366, 1.0110791825676342 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4835303172324507, "lag1": -0.37956104812838487, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0945700469638087, "p_holm": 6.038682485549933e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.716519791666666, "sd": 0.0651734154769009, "median": 9.7020546875, "min": 9.646390625, "max": 9.866078125 }, "after": { "mean": 10.5057296875, "sd": 0.07505908851192664, "median": 10.530182291666666, "min": 10.401234375, "max": 10.609171875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7892098958333331, "sd": 0.1243531578103659, "median": 0.7996093749999993, "min": 0.5437031250000004, "max": 0.9551354166666659 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.676166666666667, 0.772677083333333, 0.5437031250000004, 0.7611875000000001, 0.7165416666666662, 0.9551354166666659, 0.838265625, 0.8592083333333331, 0.9426718750000003, 0.8265416666666656 ], "df": 9, "t": 20.069460773834283, "p": 8.806063874981956e-09, "ci95": [ 0.7002530056144279, 0.8781667860522383 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8095029453262172, "lag1": 0.23866115305495667, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.pad", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0812235154926764, "p_holm": 1.585091497496752e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.2305671875, "sd": 0.09369365511824176, "median": 9.203479166666666, "min": 9.15040625, "max": 9.433614583333334 }, "after": { "mean": 9.413994270833333, "sd": 0.048214005774550546, "median": 9.4072578125, "min": 9.344380208333334, "max": 9.497390625 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1834270833333333, "sd": 0.08979944905503781, "median": 0.17033854166666806, "min": 0.03247395833333222, "max": 0.3290260416666655 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.19383854166666836, 0.10654166666666676, 0.2511354166666653, 0.03247395833333222, 0.14683854166666777, 0.3290260416666655, 0.23567187499999953, 0.1369479166666654, 0.27555208333333425, 0.12624479166666802 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.459364439300004, "p": 0.00011685590243503414, "ci95": [ 0.11918842729945113, 0.24766573936721548 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9577702029155599, "lag1": -0.2877366581906727, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0198717023133452, "p_holm": 0.0012854149267853756 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.322970833333333, "sd": 0.31040364218302613, "median": 9.179684895833333, "min": 9.125453125, "max": 10.11190625 }, "after": { "mean": 9.489838541666666, "sd": 0.19913703654307444, "median": 9.376260416666668, "min": 9.319463541666666, "max": 9.84903125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1668677083333332, "sd": 0.4240088837793652, "median": 0.18880729166666743, "min": -0.7648020833333344, "max": 0.7033541666666654 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.4278750000000002, 0.6699947916666655, 0.19510937500000125, 0.1508281250000003, 0.0013802083333338544, -0.1555781249999999, -0.7648020833333344, 0.1825052083333336, 0.7033541666666654, 0.25801041666666613 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.2445070055196625, "p": 0.24474515254390347, "ci95": [ -0.13644997487114868, 0.4701853915378151 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3432290005123798, "lag1": 0.34380688915929364, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0178985552262714, "p_holm": 0.24474515254390347 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.833460416666666, "sd": 0.07736367343776726, "median": 9.850807291666666, "min": 9.730833333333333, "max": 9.974447916666668 }, "after": { "mean": 10.025627604166667, "sd": 0.1385285579344194, "median": 9.991338541666666, "min": 9.860802083333333, "max": 10.323932291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.19216718749999995, "sd": 0.14737586978014214, "median": 0.1832291666666661, "min": -0.014791666666667425, "max": 0.4817499999999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.12996874999999974, 0.2742447916666677, -0.014791666666667425, 0.20426562499999967, -0.000166666666665094, 0.13868229166666524, 0.319088541666666, 0.4817499999999999, 0.22643750000000118, 0.16219270833333255 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.123375183163937, "p": 0.002584895077147167, "ci95": [ 0.08674084127934188, 0.297593533720658 ], "shapiro_p": 0.79048414786055, "lag1": 0.11419858402787224, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0195421732897096, "p_holm": 0.018094265540030168 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.885977604166666, "sd": 0.11881364116742613, "median": 9.865828125, "min": 9.724635416666667, "max": 10.116145833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 10.045611458333333, "sd": 0.19140958385859536, "median": 10.0552421875, "min": 9.839432291666666, "max": 10.480682291666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.1596338541666668, "sd": 0.21281696111366868, "median": 0.09629166666666666, "min": -0.039572916666667624, "max": 0.6173802083333335 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.014244791666666146, 0.23482812499999994, -0.039572916666667624, -0.01268229166666579, -0.019984374999999943, 0.3416770833333338, 0.11505729166666612, 0.6173802083333335, 0.29635416666666714, 0.07752604166666721 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.372022268320065, "p": 0.041770298467272635, "ci95": [ 0.007393771326313525, 0.3118739370070201 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09130039059265453, "lag1": 0.0666317252958283, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0161475031158664, "p_holm": 0.1520814094214909 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.413994270833333, "sd": 0.048214005774550546, "median": 9.4072578125, "min": 9.344380208333334, "max": 9.497390625 }, "after": { "mean": 10.025627604166667, "sd": 0.1385285579344194, "median": 9.991338541666666, "min": 9.860802083333333, "max": 10.323932291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6116333333333334, "sd": 0.13165651985083143, "median": 0.5717213541666668, "min": 0.46956249999999855, "max": 0.9121927083333343 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.46956249999999855, 0.6846666666666668, 0.5568802083333342, 0.5123541666666664, 0.5298906250000002, 0.5068437499999998, 0.6766562500000006, 0.9121927083333343, 0.6807239583333331, 0.5865624999999994 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.690912598979088, "p": 1.3515307372327854e-07, "ci95": [ 0.5174519326419772, 0.7058147340246895 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09193409945016448, "lag1": 0.27154013139129446, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0649706506863204, "p_holm": 2.297602253295735e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.489838541666666, "sd": 0.19913703654307444, "median": 9.376260416666668, "min": 9.319463541666666, "max": 9.84903125 }, "after": { "mean": 10.045611458333333, "sd": 0.19140958385859536, "median": 10.0552421875, "min": 9.839432291666666, "max": 10.480682291666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5557729166666668, "sd": 0.3014309007317324, "median": 0.5286328124999997, "min": 0.1951406250000005, "max": 1.135921875000001 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2261354166666667, 0.31099999999999994, 0.5274583333333318, 0.7457447916666666, 0.3373802083333324, 0.7468489583333344, 0.8022916666666671, 1.135921875000001, 0.1951406250000005, 0.5298072916666676 ], "df": 9, "t": 5.830551128750303, "p": 0.00024974556199094277, "ci95": [ 0.3401422401552642, 0.7714035931780695 ], "shapiro_p": 0.46642533816286375, "lag1": -0.015459508996991844, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.1.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0585650550561483, "p_holm": 0.0024974556199094276 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.235186458333333, "sd": 0.07672082822925007, "median": 9.219559895833333, "min": 9.141921875, "max": 9.363994791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.456311979166667, "sd": 0.10786868778880297, "median": 9.420789062499999, "min": 9.367307291666666, "max": 9.738270833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.22112552083333323, "sd": 0.11530534359824555, "median": 0.234622395833334, "min": 0.0420520833333331, "max": 0.44557291666666643 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.0420520833333331, 0.2765468749999993, 0.2878958333333319, 0.44557291666666643, 0.07578125000000036, 0.2268645833333327, 0.2307187500000012, 0.2385260416666668, 0.1361093750000002, 0.25118750000000034 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.0644222791682205, "p": 0.00018716702084273066, "ci95": [ 0.1386410469950079, 0.30360999467165856 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5108363057524078, "lag1": -0.27950496887624615, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.023943806855551, "p_holm": 0.0018716702084273066 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.267546875, "sd": 0.10643782619288226, "median": 9.233776041666667, "min": 9.179484375, "max": 9.519213541666666 }, "after": { "mean": 9.419466666666667, "sd": 0.0808559980097885, "median": 9.416880208333332, "min": 9.328833333333334, "max": 9.54278125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.15191979166666644, "sd": 0.1495847765432863, "median": 0.19291145833333267, "min": -0.19038020833333213, "max": 0.3328281249999989 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.23413541666666582, 0.22634895833333246, 0.1382343749999997, 0.042859374999999034, 0.3328281249999989, -0.19038020833333213, 0.07023437500000007, 0.2575833333333346, 0.1594739583333329, 0.24788020833333313 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.2116407459813496, "p": 0.010630914566678579, "ci95": [ 0.04491328873834788, 0.258926294594985 ], "shapiro_p": 0.16940958845074217, "lag1": -0.28615120704486857, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0163926650402473, "p_holm": 0.07441640196675005 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.944755729166667, "sd": 0.35303428077026766, "median": 9.87365625, "min": 9.680041666666666, "max": 10.918286458333334 }, "after": { "mean": 10.161225, "sd": 0.2663157893826032, "median": 10.073619791666665, "min": 9.878072916666667, "max": 10.746052083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2164692708333332, "sd": 0.4368888513685136, "median": 0.30848958333333254, "min": -0.8416093750000009, "max": 0.8015781250000007 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.53515625, 0.32503645833333294, -0.8416093750000009, 0.008510416666666742, 0.8015781250000007, 0.029296875, 0.3799427083333349, 0.24147916666666625, 0.3933593749999993, 0.29194270833333213 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.566842314984562, "p": 0.15159414987795364, "ci95": [ -0.09606218613472425, 0.5290007278013906 ], "shapiro_p": 0.06766611563887787, "lag1": -0.06204817965266445, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0217671782725097, "p_holm": 0.45478244963386094 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.911451041666666, "sd": 0.12690755197452774, "median": 9.8939765625, "min": 9.747109375, "max": 10.18590625 }, "after": { "mean": 10.104549479166666, "sd": 0.19580376899649685, "median": 10.102729166666666, "min": 9.917041666666666, "max": 10.549994791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.19309843749999994, "sd": 0.1968003823244173, "median": 0.16019270833333277, "min": -0.10146354166666782, "max": 0.6230833333333337 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.07310416666666697, 0.3057812500000008, 0.3367708333333326, 0.19428645833333213, 0.11830729166666742, 0.6230833333333337, -0.10146354166666782, 0.05507291666666703, 0.1260989583333334, 0.19994270833333339 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.102793134380553, "p": 0.012665247106629699, "ci95": [ 0.05231592490656092, 0.333880950093439 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5020889084600446, "lag1": -0.3129016951461628, "reference": "limit.triangle.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u540c\u3058lookahead/release\u8a2d\u5b9a\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u3068\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u5305\u7d61\u306e\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\uff08\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\uff09", "mean_ratio": 1.0194823580006838, "p_holm": 0.0759914826397782 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.456311979166667, "sd": 0.10786868778880297, "median": 9.420789062499999, "min": 9.367307291666666, "max": 9.738270833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 10.161225, "sd": 0.2663157893826032, "median": 10.073619791666665, "min": 9.878072916666667, "max": 10.746052083333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.7049130208333336, "sd": 0.32601635893498004, "median": 0.676421875, "min": 0.13980208333333444, "max": 1.3369062500000002 }, "differences_ns": [ 1.071802083333333, 0.7459062500000009, 0.6295364583333338, 0.13980208333333444, 1.3369062500000002, 0.4746145833333344, 0.6753906250000004, 0.5167656249999997, 0.7809531249999999, 0.6774531249999995 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.8374811172823104, "p": 7.57904945318438e-05, "ci95": [ 0.47169496700978464, 0.9381310746568826 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6913898936283494, "lag1": -0.5136077545905817, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.074544179843721, "p_holm": 0.0009094859343821255 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.419466666666667, "sd": 0.0808559980097885, "median": 9.416880208333332, "min": 9.328833333333334, "max": 9.54278125 }, "after": { "mean": 10.104549479166666, "sd": 0.19580376899649685, "median": 10.102729166666666, "min": 9.917041666666666, "max": 10.549994791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.6850828124999999, "sd": 0.21925968697545298, "median": 0.6756119791666668, "min": 0.399307291666668, "max": 1.2211614583333326 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5082708333333343, 0.6530260416666671, 0.7464843749999996, 0.7136927083333333, 0.399307291666668, 1.2211614583333326, 0.5681354166666654, 0.6981979166666665, 0.5921666666666656, 0.750385416666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 9.880621938389487, "p": 3.9540628666970155e-06, "ci95": [ 0.5282338812211435, 0.8419317437788564 ], "shapiro_p": 0.056670070222013695, "lag1": -0.5480199758245332, "reference": "limit.invbox.max.5.drums", "candidate": "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums", "question": "\u9006\u632f\u5e45\u306eFIR\u30921\u6bb5Box\u304b\u30892\u6bb5Triangle\u3078\u5909\u3048\u308b\u8cbb\u7528", "mean_ratio": 1.0727305310102482, "p_holm": 6.326500586715225e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.44216041666666667, "sd": 0.002773131748274334, "median": 0.441171875, "min": 0.43990104166666666, "max": 0.44809375 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.109610416666667, "sd": 0.03267192733514207, "median": 9.119497395833333, "min": 9.068421875, "max": 9.152161458333333 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.806216145833334, "sd": 0.09597074561350244, "median": 9.799380208333334, "min": 9.6379375, "max": 9.99340625 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.3343578125, "sd": 0.06706412099123694, "median": 9.3092890625, "min": 9.266385416666667, "max": 9.483515625 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 11.47575, "sd": 4.469387444598089, "median": 10.059515625, "min": 9.812661458333332, "max": 24.1825 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.171701041666667, "sd": 0.08440893390554678, "median": 9.129835937500001, "min": 9.103958333333333, "max": 9.370515625 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.8006953125, "sd": 0.11578578348725284, "median": 9.793427083333334, "min": 9.602890625, "max": 10.026104166666666 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.3493890625, "sd": 0.042030207893737126, "median": 9.358140625, "min": 9.283020833333333, "max": 9.400567708333334 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 10.003122395833334, "sd": 0.14840018269244343, "median": 10.0051875, "min": 9.815322916666666, "max": 10.250973958333333 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.45350572916666665, "sd": 0.032711585841212455, "median": 0.44170572916666667, "min": 0.44003125, "max": 0.5456458333333334 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.418309375, "sd": 0.11323551679546971, "median": 9.361036458333334, "min": 9.343744791666667, "max": 9.712890625 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 10.170071875, "sd": 0.13150946937227584, "median": 10.145763020833332, "min": 10.064354166666666, "max": 10.523916666666667 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.67423125, "sd": 0.2255951885004563, "median": 9.589283854166666, "min": 9.546, "max": 10.284635416666667 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 10.4127328125, "sd": 0.052653901306399215, "median": 10.407528645833334, "min": 10.337177083333334, "max": 10.522546875 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.603706770833334, "sd": 0.14215718380280437, "median": 9.561557291666666, "min": 9.459640625, "max": 9.88621875 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 10.266802083333333, "sd": 0.07480861439766129, "median": 10.284835937499999, "min": 10.136473958333333, "max": 10.392322916666666 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.710047916666667, "sd": 0.0436292712405277, "median": 9.692377604166666, "min": 9.660078125, "max": 9.780890625 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 10.628327604166667, "sd": 0.11372652755130527, "median": 10.628841145833334, "min": 10.505234375, "max": 10.848828125 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.4652942708333333, "sd": 0.04212809233441481, "median": 0.441484375, "min": 0.4412083333333333, "max": 0.54365625 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.2305671875, "sd": 0.09369365511824176, "median": 9.203479166666666, "min": 9.15040625, "max": 9.433614583333334 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.833460416666666, "sd": 0.07736367343776726, "median": 9.850807291666666, "min": 9.730833333333333, "max": 9.974447916666668 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.413994270833333, "sd": 0.048214005774550546, "median": 9.4072578125, "min": 9.344380208333334, "max": 9.497390625 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 10.025627604166667, "sd": 0.1385285579344194, "median": 9.991338541666666, "min": 9.860802083333333, "max": 10.323932291666667 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.235186458333333, "sd": 0.07672082822925007, "median": 9.219559895833333, "min": 9.141921875, "max": 9.363994791666666 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.944755729166667, "sd": 0.35303428077026766, "median": 9.87365625, "min": 9.680041666666666, "max": 10.918286458333334 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.456311979166667, "sd": 0.10786868778880297, "median": 9.420789062499999, "min": 9.367307291666666, "max": 9.738270833333333 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 10.161225, "sd": 0.2663157893826032, "median": 10.073619791666665, "min": 9.878072916666667, "max": 10.746052083333334 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.44476822916666664, "sd": 0.008138715664781781, "median": 0.4416510416666667, "min": 0.43928125, "max": 0.46674479166666666 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.1883875, "sd": 0.1597088631037635, "median": 9.121119791666667, "min": 9.08271875, "max": 9.584333333333333 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.7637203125, "sd": 0.07872246243992029, "median": 9.770182291666666, "min": 9.649885416666667, "max": 9.865526041666667 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.355320833333334, "sd": 0.19792235716417272, "median": 9.29265625, "min": 9.23125, "max": 9.909489583333333 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.908671875, "sd": 0.084995514573351, "median": 9.887075520833335, "min": 9.801119791666666, "max": 10.026635416666666 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.209346875, "sd": 0.0928561974374173, "median": 9.191546875, "min": 9.106401041666667, "max": 9.37709375 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.7849296875, "sd": 0.07682773016346588, "median": 9.819135416666667, "min": 9.661901041666667, "max": 9.864234375 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.362328125, "sd": 0.0956067013464614, "median": 9.334333333333333, "min": 9.283890625, "max": 9.615494791666666 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.bass": { "mean": 10.005965104166666, "sd": 0.09967917502833369, "median": 10.012473958333334, "min": 9.858588541666666, "max": 10.1610625 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4510619791666667, "sd": 0.03123775381673821, "median": 0.441265625, "min": 0.4403489583333333, "max": 0.5399583333333333 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.476719791666667, "sd": 0.14467813092115983, "median": 9.423958333333333, "min": 9.344416666666667, "max": 9.78196875 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 10.141339583333334, "sd": 0.05836238171824684, "median": 10.127075520833333, "min": 10.065572916666667, "max": 10.264203125 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.749827604166667, "sd": 0.2831742569146927, "median": 9.609682291666667, "min": 9.534458333333333, "max": 10.247229166666667 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.pad": { "mean": 10.337347916666666, "sd": 0.08379988170547906, "median": 10.328106770833333, "min": 10.218161458333332, "max": 10.526333333333334 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.5122, "sd": 0.052781772121327515, "median": 9.496520833333333, "min": 9.449770833333334, "max": 9.611598958333333 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 10.332994791666668, "sd": 0.08463212518528487, "median": 10.29984375, "min": 10.2455, "max": 10.46325 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.716519791666666, "sd": 0.0651734154769009, "median": 9.7020546875, "min": 9.646390625, "max": 9.866078125 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.pad": { "mean": 10.5057296875, "sd": 0.07505908851192664, "median": 10.530182291666666, "min": 10.401234375, "max": 10.609171875 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.45491927083333333, "sd": 0.0429466777098548, "median": 0.4409296875, "min": 0.4395, "max": 0.57703125 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.322970833333333, "sd": 0.31040364218302613, "median": 9.179684895833333, "min": 9.125453125, "max": 10.11190625 }, "limit.triangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.885977604166666, "sd": 0.11881364116742613, "median": 9.865828125, "min": 9.724635416666667, "max": 10.116145833333333 }, "limit.invbox.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.489838541666666, "sd": 0.19913703654307444, "median": 9.376260416666668, "min": 9.319463541666666, "max": 9.84903125 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.1.drums": { "mean": 10.045611458333333, "sd": 0.19140958385859536, "median": 10.0552421875, "min": 9.839432291666666, "max": 10.480682291666668 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.267546875, "sd": 0.10643782619288226, "median": 9.233776041666667, "min": 9.179484375, "max": 9.519213541666666 }, "limit.triangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.911451041666666, "sd": 0.12690755197452774, "median": 9.8939765625, "min": 9.747109375, "max": 10.18590625 }, "limit.invbox.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.419466666666667, "sd": 0.0808559980097885, "median": 9.416880208333332, "min": 9.328833333333334, "max": 9.54278125 }, "limit.invtriangle.max.5.drums": { "mean": 10.104549479166666, "sd": 0.19580376899649685, "median": 10.102729166666666, "min": 9.917041666666666, "max": 10.549994791666666 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "f03adb17d062e29ed96ebf7ae4ae4cca6551b3b42ea3f4558ba4872928353f8f" }, { "family": "DX06", "jobs": 36, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056122, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.011853125000002, "sd": 0.1938762735481751, "median": 15.915083333333333, "min": 15.849786458333334, "max": 16.415078125 }, "after": { "mean": 11.827659895833333, "sd": 0.03716554038725559, "median": 11.8163359375, "min": 11.773265625, "max": 11.888088541666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.184193229166667, "sd": 0.1771046959379293, "median": -4.1121015625, "min": -4.542838541666667, "max": -4.021114583333333 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.542838541666667, -4.314708333333336, -4.142973958333332, -4.076520833333333, -4.1241875, -4.021114583333333, -4.0263229166666665, -4.4099375, -4.0833125, -4.100015625000001 ], "df": 9, "t": -74.71050219390499, "p": 6.975470033266072e-14, "ci95": [ -4.310886296485699, -4.057500161847634 ], "shapiro_p": 0.03616979806593561, "lag1": 0.21114483738728393, "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7386815132201215, "p_holm": 2.5809239123084464e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.918316666666668, "sd": 0.1225358844813587, "median": 15.8769921875, "min": 15.83884375, "max": 16.244369791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 11.810220833333334, "sd": 0.054101103494788104, "median": 11.7880546875, "min": 11.755989583333333, "max": 11.916390625 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.1080958333333335, "sd": 0.13097513634803729, "median": -4.075041666666667, "min": -4.44478125, "max": -3.963630208333333 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.44478125, -4.054203125000001, -4.0518229166666675, -4.095880208333334, -4.125984375, -4.024859375, -4.054088541666667, -3.963630208333333, -4.097135416666665, -4.168572916666667 ], "df": 9, "t": -99.18630391848016, "p": 5.459851926457266e-15, "ci95": [ -4.201789801630352, -4.014401865036317 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0074397605396015155, "lag1": -0.07917252088026959, "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7419264913898979, "p_holm": 1.9655466935246158e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.088649999999998, "sd": 0.1703836035210358, "median": 16.014294270833332, "min": 15.977453125, "max": 16.45634375 }, "after": { "mean": 12.004072916666667, "sd": 0.03249333689784059, "median": 12.007390625, "min": 11.956817708333332, "max": 12.059296875 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.084577083333333, "sd": 0.1804330334793314, "median": -4.030968749999999, "min": -4.492916666666666, "max": -3.94665625 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.04746875, -4.492916666666666, -3.9749218749999997, -4.033979166666665, -3.9650052083333325, -4.027958333333332, -3.94665625, -4.331104166666664, -4.049760416666665, -3.975999999999999 ], "df": 9, "t": -71.58648620370452, "p": 1.0239385705514323e-13, "ci95": [ -4.213651099898009, -3.9555030667686566 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0014851091665921568, "lag1": -0.2555875085998033, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7461205829368324, "p_holm": 3.686178853985156e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.087677604166668, "sd": 0.11718335683133728, "median": 16.036484375, "min": 15.953708333333333, "max": 16.278395833333335 }, "after": { "mean": 11.9930609375, "sd": 0.0763279582221885, "median": 11.9755859375, "min": 11.942890625, "max": 12.200901041666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.094616666666667, "sd": 0.16274893896937642, "median": -4.0748958333333345, "min": -4.333390625000002, "max": -3.8129270833333333 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.308901041666667, -4.081703125000001, -4.238411458333331, -4.068088541666668, -3.8129270833333333, -4.333390625000002, -4.007958333333333, -3.9365000000000006, -4.107145833333332, -4.051140625 ], "df": 9, "t": -79.56005669806258, "p": 3.9636081276169e-14, "ci95": [ -4.211040244097808, -3.9781930892355253 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7648411102947144, "lag1": -0.3645602041225925, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7454811833371043, "p_holm": 1.387262844665915e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.208277083333332, "sd": 0.044048184115483835, "median": 16.196463541666667, "min": 16.162484375, "max": 16.320317708333334 }, "after": { "mean": 12.073764583333332, "sd": 0.043122332554715925, "median": 12.060473958333333, "min": 12.02909375, "max": 12.144458333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.1345125000000005, "sd": 0.061048874963487584, "median": -4.1298671875, "min": -4.2664010416666684, "max": -4.043968750000001 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.086562499999998, -4.122286458333333, -4.160739583333333, -4.043968750000001, -4.133390624999999, -4.142119791666667, -4.2664010416666684, -4.179984375, -4.0833281249999995, -4.126343750000002 ], "df": 9, "t": -214.1640861073454, "p": 5.367875635550801e-18, "ci95": [ -4.178184234306871, -4.09084076569313 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6084433987117663, "lag1": 0.09413639174006667, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.744913510625294, "p_holm": 2.0934714978648122e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.170590104166667, "sd": 0.01616228758532767, "median": 16.17067708333333, "min": 16.136875, "max": 16.18978125 }, "after": { "mean": 12.045231770833334, "sd": 0.060340321048168756, "median": 12.026549479166668, "min": 12.003052083333333, "max": 12.206901041666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -4.125358333333333, "sd": 0.05465526473896505, "median": -4.134531249999998, "min": -4.1759322916666655, "max": -3.9828802083333326 }, "differences_ns": [ -4.131416666666665, -4.167338541666666, -4.115067708333333, -4.1759322916666655, -3.9828802083333326, -4.137645833333332, -4.151145833333334, -4.158380208333334, -4.122895833333333, -4.110880208333333 ], "df": 9, "t": -238.687499914148, "p": 2.023592721830493e-18, "ci95": [ -4.164456354412007, -4.086260312254659 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00394020323456583, "lag1": -0.31860588713246474, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7448851089070426, "p_holm": 8.094370887321972e-17 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.011853125000002, "sd": 0.1938762735481751, "median": 15.915083333333333, "min": 15.849786458333334, "max": 16.415078125 }, "after": { "mean": 16.088649999999998, "sd": 0.1703836035210358, "median": 16.014294270833332, "min": 15.977453125, "max": 16.45634375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.0767968749999989, "sd": 0.19036437037658427, "median": 0.09859375000000004, "min": -0.4107916666666682, "max": 0.3265052083333302 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.4107916666666682, 0.3265052083333302, 0.022437500000000554, 0.19094270833333127, 0.10831249999999848, 0.0896614583333335, 0.10752604166666657, 0.08455208333333175, 0.1654531249999991, 0.0833697916666658 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.2757273942745755, "p": 0.23399247145329807, "ci95": [ -0.05938159199964807, 0.21297534199964588 ], "shapiro_p": 0.005509176531907856, "lag1": -0.9514209286660488, "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0047962515269446, "p_holm": 0.6002571024684564 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 15.918316666666668, "sd": 0.1225358844813587, "median": 15.8769921875, "min": 15.83884375, "max": 16.244369791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 16.087677604166668, "sd": 0.11718335683133728, "median": 16.036484375, "min": 15.953708333333333, "max": 16.278395833333335 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.16936093749999975, "sd": 0.10544577233269264, "median": 0.15648177083333348, "min": 0.03363541666666592, "max": 0.3424583333333313 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.03363541666666592, 0.1838958333333327, 0.3424583333333313, 0.1645625000000006, 0.13185416666666683, 0.33714583333333437, 0.14840104166666634, 0.08704687500000041, 0.20954166666666652, 0.05506770833333263 ], "df": 9, "t": 5.079068580119586, "p": 0.0006636706986097542, "ci95": [ 0.09392957605639762, 0.24479229894360188 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3492419724790281, "lag1": -0.21588053719459013, "reference": "f64.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0106393748187361, "p_holm": 0.007964048383317051 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.088649999999998, "sd": 0.1703836035210358, "median": 16.014294270833332, "min": 15.977453125, "max": 16.45634375 }, "after": { "mean": 16.208277083333332, "sd": 0.044048184115483835, "median": 16.196463541666667, "min": 16.162484375, "max": 16.320317708333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.11962708333333402, "sd": 0.18310935091326935, "median": 0.1747578125000011, "min": -0.27186458333333263, "max": 0.34286458333333414 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.19654687499999923, -0.27186458333333263, 0.23654166666666576, 0.14769791666666876, 0.1381822916666664, 0.17589062500000097, 0.34286458333333414, -0.13776041666666572, 0.17362500000000125, 0.19454687500000212 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.0659461206614402, "p": 0.06881439833724277, "ci95": [ -0.011361455390279052, 0.2506156220569471 ], "shapiro_p": 0.01877892772299108, "lag1": -0.42805782579061474, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0074354954165412, "p_holm": 0.37816524513110794 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.087677604166668, "sd": 0.11718335683133728, "median": 16.036484375, "min": 15.953708333333333, "max": 16.278395833333335 }, "after": { "mean": 16.170590104166667, "sd": 0.01616228758532767, "median": 16.17067708333333, "min": 16.136875, "max": 16.18978125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.08291249999999976, "sd": 0.11925042555473206, "median": 0.13740364583333253, "min": -0.12245833333333422, "max": 0.21194270833333384 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.12245833333333422, 0.14320312499999943, -0.010338541666666146, 0.13674479166666487, 0.1759531249999995, -0.0895572916666687, 0.19100520833333512, 0.21194270833333384, 0.0545677083333338, 0.1380625000000002 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.1986701119013805, "p": 0.05546071818222825, "ci95": [ -0.002394115460518459, 0.168219115460518 ], "shapiro_p": 0.12030712194610932, "lag1": -0.42490066703772866, "reference": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0051537892566, "p_holm": 0.14838243084274755 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.827659895833333, "sd": 0.03716554038725559, "median": 11.8163359375, "min": 11.773265625, "max": 11.888088541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 12.004072916666667, "sd": 0.03249333689784059, "median": 12.007390625, "min": 11.956817708333332, "max": 12.059296875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.17641302083333327, "sd": 0.05915238578845453, "median": 0.188841145833333, "min": 0.08281770833333368, "max": 0.2674947916666657 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.0845781249999984, 0.14829687499999977, 0.1904895833333331, 0.23348437499999974, 0.2674947916666657, 0.08281770833333368, 0.1871927083333329, 0.16338541666666728, 0.19900520833333424, 0.20738541666666777 ], "df": 9, "t": 9.431013598321409, "p": 5.814045208572018e-06, "ci95": [ 0.13409795315492132, 0.21872808851174522 ], "shapiro_p": 0.560096855283089, "lag1": -0.02948613698756376, "reference": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.014915293674912, "p_holm": 0.00011046685896286833 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.810220833333334, "sd": 0.054101103494788104, "median": 11.7880546875, "min": 11.755989583333333, "max": 11.916390625 }, "after": { "mean": 11.9930609375, "sd": 0.0763279582221885, "median": 11.9755859375, "min": 11.942890625, "max": 12.200901041666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.18284010416666643, "sd": 0.105091741784604, "median": 0.1710078124999992, "min": 0.028614583333332888, "max": 0.44491145833333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.16951562499999895, 0.15639583333333285, 0.15586979166666737, 0.19235416666666616, 0.44491145833333334, 0.028614583333332888, 0.1945312500000007, 0.11417708333333287, 0.19953124999999972, 0.17249999999999943 ], "df": 9, "t": 5.501775562671414, "p": 0.0003793135982135664, "ci95": [ 0.10766200092056409, 0.25801820741276876 ], "shapiro_p": 0.010147926619858309, "lag1": -0.4136977601547872, "reference": "f32.full.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.015481514422712, "p_holm": 0.004931076776776363 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.004072916666667, "sd": 0.03249333689784059, "median": 12.007390625, "min": 11.956817708333332, "max": 12.059296875 }, "after": { "mean": 12.073764583333332, "sd": 0.043122332554715925, "median": 12.060473958333333, "min": 12.02909375, "max": 12.144458333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.0696916666666663, "sd": 0.06193099555829135, "median": 0.05622656249999913, "min": -0.030203124999999886, "max": 0.15745312500000175 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.15745312500000175, 0.09876562500000041, 0.05072395833333232, 0.13770833333333243, -0.030203124999999886, 0.06172916666666595, 0.02311979166666589, 0.013359374999998508, 0.14005729166666647, 0.04420312499999923 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.5585476805789047, "p": 0.006133213298307103, "ci95": [ 0.02538890130040402, 0.11399443203292858 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6629498489623051, "lag1": -0.26344697735435274, "reference": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0058056683885936, "p_holm": 0.06746534628137814 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 11.9930609375, "sd": 0.0763279582221885, "median": 11.9755859375, "min": 11.942890625, "max": 12.200901041666667 }, "after": { "mean": 12.045231770833334, "sd": 0.060340321048168756, "median": 12.026549479166668, "min": 12.003052083333333, "max": 12.206901041666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.05217083333333381, "sd": 0.03953586440093837, "median": 0.05142187500000084, "min": -0.009937499999999488, "max": 0.11300520833333216 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.055026041666668135, 0.05756770833333391, 0.11300520833333216, 0.028901041666667737, 0.006000000000000227, 0.10618750000000077, 0.04781770833333354, -0.009937499999999488, 0.0388177083333332, 0.07832291666666791 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.172886144319476, "p": 0.002401306532943584, "ci95": [ 0.02388857970060279, 0.08045308696606483 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8689365089920724, "lag1": -0.14508074319199557, "reference": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0043500849036968, "p_holm": 0.02401306532943584 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.284536458333335, "sd": 0.11962279988273256, "median": 16.3154296875, "min": 16.099380208333333, "max": 16.451010416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.486046875, "sd": 0.12331928819141265, "median": 12.4518359375, "min": 12.34121875, "max": 12.715666666666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.7984895833333336, "sd": 0.17735931467905497, "median": -3.7963567708333334, "min": -4.018479166666667, "max": -3.4502291666666665 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.849656249999999, -3.6294062500000006, -3.9866770833333334, -3.7362812499999993, -3.7188437499999996, -3.904536458333334, -4.018479166666667, -3.4502291666666665, -3.743057291666668, -3.947729166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": -67.72623571247833, "p": 1.6849061512096453e-13, "ci95": [ -3.9253647939272196, -3.671614372739447 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6226421480774089, "lag1": -0.36709605776163506, "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7667425417326188, "p_holm": 5.8971715292337584e-12 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.12330625, "sd": 0.06456789801174798, "median": 16.10280989583333, "min": 16.054020833333333, "max": 16.245505208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 12.423641666666667, "sd": 0.0975172264689102, "median": 12.411249999999999, "min": 12.314703125, "max": 12.668713541666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.699664583333333, "sd": 0.09155992641776689, "median": -3.675494791666666, "min": -3.853338541666666, "max": -3.576791666666667 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.7328124999999996, -3.6168385416666684, -3.637567708333334, -3.716166666666666, -3.848572916666667, -3.663567708333332, -3.676765625, -3.576791666666667, -3.6742239583333323, -3.853338541666666 ], "df": 9, "t": -127.77824447575063, "p": 5.594734794815819e-16, "ci95": [ -3.7651626090064485, -3.6341665576602176 ], "shapiro_p": 0.27349533183629426, "lag1": 0.01234031238868443, "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7705393344287973, "p_holm": 2.1259992220300112e-14 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.3874765625, "sd": 0.038974397578800994, "median": 16.379984375, "min": 16.328411458333335, "max": 16.456854166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.605982291666667, "sd": 0.0507812271604889, "median": 12.59571875, "min": 12.548026041666667, "max": 12.70296875 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.7814942708333334, "sd": 0.05088403945464173, "median": -3.7820911458333333, "min": -3.883619791666666, "max": -3.6997760416666665 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.745421874999998, -3.8089427083333334, -3.767911458333332, -3.6997760416666665, -3.7657187500000013, -3.734750000000002, -3.7962708333333346, -3.812453125000001, -3.800078124999999, -3.883619791666666 ], "df": 9, "t": -235.00757767807528, "p": 2.3272580280341706e-18, "ci95": [ -3.817894519860895, -3.7450940218057718 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8478451502226099, "lag1": 0.27640933401395024, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7692448708371213, "p_holm": 9.309032112136683e-17 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.370281249999998, "sd": 0.04514271511561135, "median": 16.35657552083333, "min": 16.310317708333333, "max": 16.440994791666668 }, "after": { "mean": 12.620186458333333, "sd": 0.09098050779300751, "median": 12.596752604166667, "min": 12.516776041666667, "max": 12.783375 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.7500947916666663, "sd": 0.1181117198610609, "median": -3.780265625, "min": -3.9005468750000016, "max": -3.5500208333333347 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.7792031250000004, -3.573244791666667, -3.857567708333331, -3.8158072916666654, -3.675156249999999, -3.9005468750000016, -3.5500208333333347, -3.781328125, -3.7292604166666656, -3.8388124999999995 ], "df": 9, "t": -100.40359243901686, "p": 4.8926268643002454e-15, "ci95": [ -3.834586826145349, -3.6656027571879837 ], "shapiro_p": 0.383016338704688, "lag1": -0.6003278046294362, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7709205642592936, "p_holm": 1.8102719397910907e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.491589583333333, "sd": 0.105834666644598, "median": 16.4428046875, "min": 16.359786458333332, "max": 16.678744791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 12.719147395833334, "sd": 0.026991395217039884, "median": 12.727268229166667, "min": 12.675145833333334, "max": 12.749911458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.7724421875000007, "sd": 0.12443996262608752, "median": -3.737630208333335, "min": -4.003598958333333, "max": -3.609874999999999 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.742979166666668, -3.6903281250000006, -4.003598958333333, -3.6710312500000004, -3.9289166666666677, -3.6952291666666675, -3.780322916666668, -3.609874999999999, -3.8698593750000008, -3.7322812500000015 ], "df": 9, "t": -95.8655837084532, "p": 7.415958563605748e-15, "ci95": [ -3.8614611741433036, -3.683423200856697 ], "shapiro_p": 0.451207234533015, "lag1": -0.650227614784691, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7712505414691807, "p_holm": 2.818064254170184e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.465239583333332, "sd": 0.06288359933631296, "median": 16.448611979166664, "min": 16.407666666666668, "max": 16.586755208333333 }, "after": { "mean": 12.717930729166667, "sd": 0.0460214758268416, "median": 12.714559895833332, "min": 12.675630208333333, "max": 12.840208333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -3.7473088541666666, "sd": 0.06498757170855476, "median": -3.7256276041666663, "min": -3.911125, "max": -3.690932291666668 }, "differences_ns": [ -3.7280625, -3.7088906250000004, -3.70296875, -3.7578437499999993, -3.7667083333333338, -3.7807447916666668, -3.7026197916666668, -3.7231927083333325, -3.690932291666668, -3.911125 ], "df": 9, "t": -182.3430351948743, "p": 2.2823769058178992e-17, "ci95": [ -3.7937981623906456, -3.7008195459426885 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0076928094564469324, "lag1": -0.29132986632174124, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.7724109123829686, "p_holm": 8.901269932689807e-16 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.284536458333335, "sd": 0.11962279988273256, "median": 16.3154296875, "min": 16.099380208333333, "max": 16.451010416666666 }, "after": { "mean": 16.3874765625, "sd": 0.038974397578800994, "median": 16.379984375, "min": 16.328411458333335, "max": 16.456854166666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.10294010416666666, "sd": 0.1267304189943679, "median": 0.0792812499999993, "min": -0.07135937500000011, "max": 0.3033645833333338 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.07135937500000011, 0.26514583333333164, 0.07852604166666666, 0.3033645833333338, 0.05507812500000142, 0.005968750000000966, -0.04730729166666592, 0.194583333333334, 0.16536458333333215, 0.08003645833333195 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.568642906137024, "p": 0.030255078834288893, "ci95": [ 0.012282623742489687, 0.19359758459084364 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7437941716866797, "lag1": -0.2963709113791025, "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0063213407658276, "p_holm": 0.25610275302982144 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.12330625, "sd": 0.06456789801174798, "median": 16.10280989583333, "min": 16.054020833333333, "max": 16.245505208333334 }, "after": { "mean": 16.370281249999998, "sd": 0.04514271511561135, "median": 16.35657552083333, "min": 16.310317708333333, "max": 16.440994791666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.24697499999999978, "sd": 0.08771882696116781, "median": 0.2632656250000007, "min": 0.11102604166666552, "max": 0.3599270833333321 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2272447916666671, 0.2987499999999983, 0.312713541666664, 0.3599270833333321, 0.14704166666666652, 0.34343229166666944, 0.2617447916666684, 0.11102604166666552, 0.26478645833333303, 0.14308333333333323 ], "df": 9, "t": 8.903488021628775, "p": 9.324498238537597e-06, "ci95": [ 0.18422473134968265, 0.3097252686503169 ], "shapiro_p": 0.40220650205115915, "lag1": -0.2581126589717121, "reference": "f64.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0153178880417284, "p_holm": 0.00014919197181660155 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.3874765625, "sd": 0.038974397578800994, "median": 16.379984375, "min": 16.328411458333335, "max": 16.456854166666666 }, "after": { "mean": 16.491589583333333, "sd": 0.105834666644598, "median": 16.4428046875, "min": 16.359786458333332, "max": 16.678744791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.10411302083333354, "sd": 0.10206722021388609, "median": 0.08877343750000044, "min": -0.018791666666665208, "max": 0.27232291666666697 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.08169270833333542, 0.040213541666666686, 0.27232291666666697, 0.015192708333334082, 0.2524218749999996, 0.09585416666666546, 0.16441145833333337, -0.0006927083333359008, 0.1385052083333349, -0.018791666666665208 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.2256612771854827, "p": 0.01039465301782939, "ci95": [ 0.0310985299801015, 0.1771275116865656 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4245150224530917, "lag1": -0.6333006896311661, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0063532063912497, "p_holm": 0.10394653017829389 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 16.370281249999998, "sd": 0.04514271511561135, "median": 16.35657552083333, "min": 16.310317708333333, "max": 16.440994791666668 }, "after": { "mean": 16.465239583333332, "sd": 0.06288359933631296, "median": 16.448611979166664, "min": 16.407666666666668, "max": 16.586755208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.09495833333333366, "sd": 0.0808186805847641, "median": 0.08159374999999969, "min": 0.008328125000002018, "max": 0.23116666666666674 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2185052083333332, 0.06867708333333411, 0.008328125000002018, 0.012072916666667766, 0.14678645833333448, 0.03410416666666549, 0.09956770833333195, 0.09451041666666526, 0.03586458333333553, 0.23116666666666674 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.715534749814177, "p": 0.00480367752759145, "ci95": [ 0.03714413204558537, 0.15277253462108195 ], "shapiro_p": 0.17075504871931452, "lag1": -0.2856761220797825, "reference": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0058006537507311, "p_holm": 0.03581612357828316 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.486046875, "sd": 0.12331928819141265, "median": 12.4518359375, "min": 12.34121875, "max": 12.715666666666667 }, "after": { "mean": 12.605982291666667, "sd": 0.0507812271604889, "median": 12.59571875, "min": 12.548026041666667, "max": 12.70296875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.11993541666666677, "sd": 0.14553572560019154, "median": 0.12624479166666713, "min": -0.16764062500000065, "max": 0.33986979166666664 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.032875000000000654, 0.08560937499999888, 0.29729166666666806, 0.33986979166666664, 0.008203124999999645, 0.17575520833333336, 0.17490104166666676, -0.16764062500000065, 0.1083437500000013, 0.14414583333333297 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.6060205301748085, "p": 0.028455861447757937, "ci95": [ 0.015825430293118087, 0.22404540304021545 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8594660249779427, "lag1": -0.02340779343571572, "reference": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.009605555534699, "p_holm": 0.25610275302982144 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.423641666666667, "sd": 0.0975172264689102, "median": 12.411249999999999, "min": 12.314703125, "max": 12.668713541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 12.620186458333333, "sd": 0.09098050779300751, "median": 12.596752604166667, "min": 12.516776041666667, "max": 12.783375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.19654479166666655, "sd": 0.1423937053261231, "median": 0.195302083333333, "min": -0.0935104166666676, "max": 0.3884895833333335 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.18085416666666632, 0.3423437499999995, 0.0927135416666669, 0.26028645833333286, 0.3204583333333346, 0.10645312499999982, 0.3884895833333335, -0.0935104166666676, 0.20974999999999966, 0.15760937499999983 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.364864320978689, "p": 0.0018105839893347623, "ci95": [ 0.09468247119487255, 0.29840711213846055 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7721444588392016, "lag1": -0.5767890388924979, "reference": "f32.full.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0158202238071632, "p_holm": 0.019916423882682385 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.605982291666667, "sd": 0.0507812271604889, "median": 12.59571875, "min": 12.548026041666667, "max": 12.70296875 }, "after": { "mean": 12.719147395833334, "sd": 0.026991395217039884, "median": 12.727268229166667, "min": 12.675145833333334, "max": 12.749911458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.11316510416666628, "sd": 0.057135879735897406, "median": 0.11088541666666618, "min": 0.03663541666666603, "max": 0.20188541666666637 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.08413541666666546, 0.15882812499999943, 0.03663541666666603, 0.043937500000000185, 0.08922395833333319, 0.1353749999999998, 0.1803593750000001, 0.20188541666666637, 0.068723958333333, 0.13254687499999918 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.263305692868152, "p": 0.0001472773128596448, "ci95": [ 0.07229255801888271, 0.15403765031444985 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6630955629191871, "lag1": 0.15035869788704886, "reference": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.008977095282886, "p_holm": 0.0022091596928946722 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 12.620186458333333, "sd": 0.09098050779300751, "median": 12.596752604166667, "min": 12.516776041666667, "max": 12.783375 }, "after": { "mean": 12.717930729166667, "sd": 0.0460214758268416, "median": 12.714559895833332, "min": 12.675630208333333, "max": 12.840208333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.09774427083333333, "sd": 0.10365264760571083, "median": 0.11341927083333303, "min": -0.06696874999999913, "max": 0.2696458333333336 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2696458333333336, -0.06696874999999913, 0.16292708333333294, 0.07003645833333394, 0.0552343749999995, 0.15390625000000036, -0.053031250000000085, 0.1526458333333327, 0.07419270833333336, 0.15885416666666607 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.9820224683645016, "p": 0.015398955735616055, "ci95": [ 0.023595633546444394, 0.17189290812022226 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4443566050473591, "lag1": -0.8157398389972629, "reference": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.00774507343105, "p_holm": 0.08225304158505654 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.598983854166667, "sd": 0.11651279844525927, "median": 8.563473958333333, "min": 8.49015625, "max": 8.874416666666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.076471354166666, "sd": 0.06538939289801589, "median": 7.057377604166667, "min": 7.033609375, "max": 7.257333333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.5225125000000002, "sd": 0.13594978892055126, "median": -1.459354166666667, "min": -1.8357864583333336, "max": -1.3630104166666666 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.5623645833333333, -1.6409062499999996, -1.3630104166666666, -1.455708333333333, -1.4409166666666673, -1.5644427083333339, -1.44328125, -1.8357864583333336, -1.4625156250000009, -1.456192708333333 ], "df": 9, "t": -35.41459905385182, "p": 5.643201859038473e-11, "ci95": [ -1.6197651203695707, -1.4252598796304297 ], "shapiro_p": 0.060522295019774526, "lag1": -0.27082680813982046, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8229427423262038, "p_holm": 1.862256613482696e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.742018229166668, "sd": 0.11601895656432538, "median": 8.754432291666667, "min": 8.598182291666667, "max": 8.889020833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.095855729166667, "sd": 0.06829621432000577, "median": 7.093010416666667, "min": 7.002677083333333, "max": 7.2124322916666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.6461625000000002, "sd": 0.12191592832275942, "median": -1.6243385416666674, "min": -1.8353489583333333, "max": -1.412937499999999 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.561838541666666, -1.6274843750000008, -1.7305104166666672, -1.412937499999999, -1.8353489583333333, -1.7436302083333342, -1.621192708333334, -1.7545885416666662, -1.5955052083333339, -1.578588541666667 ], "df": 9, "t": -42.69846418242904, "p": 1.0578189999864122e-11, "ci95": [ -1.7333759012735108, -1.5589490987264896 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7612366685635266, "lag1": -0.417984737720592, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8116953709261573, "p_holm": 3.1734569999592367e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.493465104166667, "sd": 0.1250853673111567, "median": 8.482653645833334, "min": 8.340166666666667, "max": 8.720432291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.1973171875, "sd": 0.07382289133051277, "median": 7.196026041666666, "min": 7.082885416666667, "max": 7.315260416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.2961479166666667, "sd": 0.14900467663255373, "median": -1.323645833333333, "min": -1.5354635416666662, "max": -1.0913854166666672 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.3227604166666662, -1.0971979166666666, -1.1653281249999994, -1.5354635416666662, -1.3452968750000007, -1.3636510416666674, -1.3245312499999997, -1.4758437500000001, -1.0913854166666672, -1.2400208333333333 ], "df": 9, "t": -27.507724547843537, "p": 5.379847127557305e-10, "ci95": [ -1.40273944111769, -1.1895563922156436 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6249498484975806, "lag1": -0.06887783683505284, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8473946851172897, "p_holm": 1.6139541382671916e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.49260625, "sd": 0.07568233291388068, "median": 8.508723958333334, "min": 8.361354166666667, "max": 8.58840625 }, "after": { "mean": 7.170591145833333, "sd": 0.07370901120726345, "median": 7.1768020833333335, "min": 7.071052083333333, "max": 7.334302083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.3220151041666668, "sd": 0.07772329877002233, "median": -1.3303567708333337, "min": -1.405036458333333, "max": -1.1637447916666668 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.1637447916666668, -1.3948437500000006, -1.3871666666666664, -1.3828697916666668, -1.3552395833333337, -1.3054739583333337, -1.254104166666667, -1.2689999999999992, -1.405036458333333, -1.3026718750000006 ], "df": 9, "t": -53.78797473176551, "p": 1.3340918417641442e-12, "ci95": [ -1.3776150026966236, -1.26641520563671 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2527110631963907, "lag1": -0.07845349775709873, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8443334042283349, "p_holm": 4.2690938936452614e-11 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.644773958333333, "sd": 0.2059464143204972, "median": 8.589638020833334, "min": 8.485776041666666, "max": 9.174770833333334 }, "after": { "mean": 7.408082291666667, "sd": 0.0919293757189778, "median": 7.3926015625, "min": 7.281822916666667, "max": 7.580869791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.2366916666666665, "sd": 0.24870601942637027, "median": -1.1500416666666666, "min": -1.8812552083333332, "max": -0.9798645833333328 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.1593437499999997, -1.12928125, -0.9798645833333328, -1.3318958333333333, -1.0936875000000006, -1.8812552083333332, -1.196791666666667, -1.1407395833333336, -1.3199010416666654, -1.1341562500000002 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.724438190263367, "p": 7.48443039362279e-08, "ci95": [ -1.4146052352197949, -1.0587780981135382 ], "shapiro_p": 0.003267364944241096, "lag1": -0.24407032593117203, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8569434351172909, "p_holm": 1.7962632944694698e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.616283854166667, "sd": 0.07933587573074023, "median": 8.598984375, "min": 8.488697916666666, "max": 8.78109375 }, "after": { "mean": 7.379688541666667, "sd": 0.0269064998966758, "median": 7.379830729166667, "min": 7.341208333333333, "max": 7.425838541666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.2365953124999998, "sd": 0.08645698630455859, "median": -1.2306744791666668, "min": -1.3826093750000004, "max": -1.096994791666666 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.2191406249999996, -1.096994791666666, -1.2665364583333334, -1.231781250000001, -1.181760416666667, -1.2295677083333327, -1.1508697916666657, -1.3826093750000004, -1.2489218749999997, -1.3577708333333325 ], "df": 9, "t": -45.23009531713807, "p": 6.312829793117185e-12, "ci95": [ -1.298442914722377, -1.174747710277623 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7608364715443852, "lag1": -0.16478789220310633, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8564815953803556, "p_holm": 1.9569772358663273e-10 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.598983854166667, "sd": 0.11651279844525927, "median": 8.563473958333333, "min": 8.49015625, "max": 8.874416666666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.493465104166667, "sd": 0.1250853673111567, "median": 8.482653645833334, "min": 8.340166666666667, "max": 8.720432291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.10551875000000006, "sd": 0.15738874913203582, "median": -0.13290364583333325, "min": -0.2961510416666666, "max": 0.2093541666666674 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.10133854166666723, -0.2961510416666666, -0.2589739583333337, 0.2093541666666674, 0.02464062499999997, -0.15151562500000004, 0.04745833333333316, -0.22564062500000048, -0.11429166666666646, -0.18872916666666661 ], "df": 9, "t": -2.1200980863883956, "p": 0.06302754085518465, "ci95": [ -0.21810787861368636, 0.007070378613686215 ], "shapiro_p": 0.504467955914438, "lag1": -0.03860019849721972, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9877289280001531, "p_holm": 0.37816524513110794 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.742018229166668, "sd": 0.11601895656432538, "median": 8.754432291666667, "min": 8.598182291666667, "max": 8.889020833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.49260625, "sd": 0.07568233291388068, "median": 8.508723958333334, "min": 8.361354166666667, "max": 8.58840625 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.24941197916666677, "sd": 0.12612352473305838, "median": -0.2553046874999998, "min": -0.48122916666666704, "max": -0.09536458333333364 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.2385833333333327, -0.2720260416666669, -0.3178125000000005, -0.11465624999999946, -0.34133333333333304, -0.34903645833333385, -0.09536458333333364, -0.48122916666666704, -0.12209375000000122, -0.1619843749999994 ], "df": 9, "t": -6.253471995541224, "p": 0.00014901537757519237, "ci95": [ -0.339635313589822, -0.15918864474351152 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5032539273504323, "lag1": -0.5813908364667737, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.971469748446127, "p_holm": 0.002086215286052693 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.493465104166667, "sd": 0.1250853673111567, "median": 8.482653645833334, "min": 8.340166666666667, "max": 8.720432291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.644773958333333, "sd": 0.2059464143204972, "median": 8.589638020833334, "min": 8.485776041666666, "max": 9.174770833333334 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.15130885416666667, "sd": 0.2338471475820378, "median": 0.14628385416666667, "min": -0.10871874999999953, "max": 0.7282343749999995 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.22144270833333302, 0.20676562500000095, 0.12440624999999983, -0.0008697916666662309, -0.061348958333333314, 0.7282343749999995, 0.039937500000000625, -0.10871874999999953, 0.19507812499999844, 0.1681614583333335 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.0461254895104743, "p": 0.07105772641370889, "ci95": [ -0.015975317797685296, 0.31859302613101864 ], "shapiro_p": 0.03199488754339292, "lag1": -0.2655064687063889, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.017814737837969, "p_holm": 0.37816524513110794 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.49260625, "sd": 0.07568233291388068, "median": 8.508723958333334, "min": 8.361354166666667, "max": 8.58840625 }, "after": { "mean": 8.616283854166667, "sd": 0.07933587573074023, "median": 8.598984375, "min": 8.488697916666666, "max": 8.78109375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.12367760416666637, "sd": 0.13754041319263374, "median": 0.11527343749999996, "min": -0.07919270833333414, "max": 0.41189583333333424 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.22841666666666605, -0.07919270833333414, 0.1004635416666666, 0.1263541666666672, 0.0193489583333335, 0.10419270833333272, -0.011697916666667751, 0.41189583333333424, 0.1472187500000004, 0.18977604166666495 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.8435491477812644, "p": 0.019291128859293127, "ci95": [ 0.025287119739257097, 0.22206808859407565 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7646311870357829, "lag1": -0.26999130210524724, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0145629740183313, "p_holm": 0.08225304158505654 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.076471354166666, "sd": 0.06538939289801589, "median": 7.057377604166667, "min": 7.033609375, "max": 7.257333333333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.1973171875, "sd": 0.07382289133051277, "median": 7.196026041666666, "min": 7.082885416666667, "max": 7.315260416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.12084583333333336, "sd": 0.09671808647357119, "median": 0.13195052083333358, "min": -0.06129166666666652, "max": 0.2568385416666672 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.13826562499999984, 0.2475572916666664, -0.06129166666666652, 0.12959895833333412, 0.12026041666666654, 0.04927604166666644, 0.1662083333333335, 0.13430208333333304, 0.2568385416666672, 0.027442708333333066 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.9511542567465456, "p": 0.003348847324663228, "ci95": [ 0.051657882242196265, 0.19003378442447044 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6355465451288742, "lag1": -0.4524112684236195, "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.017077131706635, "p_holm": 0.04018616789595873 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.095855729166667, "sd": 0.06829621432000577, "median": 7.093010416666667, "min": 7.002677083333333, "max": 7.2124322916666666 }, "after": { "mean": 7.170591145833333, "sd": 0.07370901120726345, "median": 7.1768020833333335, "min": 7.071052083333333, "max": 7.334302083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.07473541666666658, "sd": 0.10416747921558095, "median": 0.07874739583333312, "min": -0.08458854166666718, "max": 0.2717239583333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.15951041666666654, -0.03938541666666673, 0.025531250000000227, -0.08458854166666718, 0.13877604166666657, 0.08911979166666661, 0.2717239583333333, 0.004359374999999943, 0.06837499999999963, 0.11393229166666696 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.2687900324367782, "p": 0.049460810280915854, "ci95": [ 0.00021849103224508282, 0.14925234230108808 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9899053047087133, "lag1": -0.1800656295295591, "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0105322627064521, "p_holm": 0.14838243084274755 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.1973171875, "sd": 0.07382289133051277, "median": 7.196026041666666, "min": 7.082885416666667, "max": 7.315260416666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.408082291666667, "sd": 0.0919293757189778, "median": 7.3926015625, "min": 7.281822916666667, "max": 7.580869791666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2107651041666668, "sd": 0.10936965519486001, "median": 0.20666406250000025, "min": -0.03343749999999979, "max": 0.38485937499999956 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.38485937499999956, 0.1746822916666675, 0.3098697916666664, 0.2026979166666667, 0.19026041666666682, 0.2106302083333338, 0.16767708333333342, 0.226385416666667, -0.03343749999999979, 0.27402604166666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.093991786495409, "p": 0.00018055642992939768, "ci95": [ 0.1325267660193933, 0.28900344231394026 ], "shapiro_p": 0.273578060824598, "lag1": -0.36213082455797474, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0292838426702542, "p_holm": 0.0025277900190115673 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.170591145833333, "sd": 0.07370901120726345, "median": 7.1768020833333335, "min": 7.071052083333333, "max": 7.334302083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.379688541666667, "sd": 0.0269064998966758, "median": 7.379830729166667, "min": 7.341208333333333, "max": 7.425838541666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.20909739583333337, "sd": 0.06952820417668235, "median": 0.20574218750000028, "min": 0.09153645833333357, "max": 0.3033333333333337 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.17302083333333318, 0.21865625000000044, 0.22109374999999964, 0.27744270833333307, 0.19282812500000013, 0.18009895833333367, 0.09153645833333357, 0.2982864583333331, 0.3033333333333337, 0.13467708333333306 ], "df": 9, "t": 9.510155360303255, "p": 5.426588028065856e-06, "ci95": [ 0.15935991481580525, 0.2588348768508615 ], "shapiro_p": 0.721958164173645, "lag1": -0.1522049159617123, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0291604125211957, "p_holm": 9.225199647711955e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.842121354166666, "sd": 0.07633390105985105, "median": 8.822937499999998, "min": 8.752572916666667, "max": 9.0155 }, "after": { "mean": 7.3681078125, "sd": 0.03227404920498432, "median": 7.363539062499999, "min": 7.317354166666667, "max": 7.437510416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.4740135416666664, "sd": 0.08615045130010077, "median": -1.476739583333333, "min": -1.635791666666666, "max": -1.3150624999999998 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.3150624999999998, -1.501291666666666, -1.5409375, -1.488348958333333, -1.4336093749999987, -1.635791666666666, -1.465130208333333, -1.390140625, -1.463145833333333, -1.5066770833333338 ], "df": 9, "t": -54.10581167312722, "p": 1.2653822988317137e-12, "ci95": [ -1.5356418619566825, -1.4123852213766495 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9141993805894131, "lag1": -0.16318105863780166, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8332963909195763, "p_holm": 4.3022998160278266e-11 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.9106953125, "sd": 0.058494698131563744, "median": 8.898432291666666, "min": 8.831848958333333, "max": 9.029223958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.409509375, "sd": 0.04706195503164368, "median": 7.406591145833334, "min": 7.353177083333334, "max": 7.51915625 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.5011859375, "sd": 0.07064614342167154, "median": -1.4931822916666668, "min": -1.5988229166666663, "max": -1.4054583333333337 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.497947916666667, -1.5817968750000002, -1.4112656250000004, -1.452088541666667, -1.5988229166666663, -1.591234374999999, -1.5122968750000005, -1.4884166666666667, -1.4054583333333337, -1.4725312499999994 ], "df": 9, "t": -67.19640342687023, "p": 1.8080848764412764e-13, "ci95": [ -1.5517231440768868, -1.4506487309231133 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3512563495108675, "lag1": 0.12861400531952283, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8315298767544971, "p_holm": 5.9666800922562124e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.869277604166667, "sd": 0.17951852674823043, "median": 8.889442708333334, "min": 8.616630208333333, "max": 9.232729166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.458553125, "sd": 0.11527032114333358, "median": 7.4161328125, "min": 7.402072916666667, "max": 7.779239583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.4107244791666669, "sd": 0.181706108200817, "median": -1.4227760416666664, "min": -1.8018281250000001, "max": -1.1871302083333326 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.406713541666666, -1.4837083333333343, -1.4965729166666666, -1.4388385416666667, -1.5010312500000005, -1.2449427083333342, -1.8018281250000001, -1.2130260416666667, -1.1871302083333326, -1.3334531250000001 ], "df": 9, "t": -24.551197256347187, "p": 1.4787076165479845e-09, "ci95": [ -1.5407091985251742, -1.2807397598081596 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3077737242572734, "lag1": -0.2884768067337139, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8409425725378211, "p_holm": 3.992510564679558e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.767674479166667, "sd": 0.10775017799851626, "median": 8.748028645833333, "min": 8.618588541666666, "max": 9.027484375 }, "after": { "mean": 7.468019791666666, "sd": 0.08997286906734638, "median": 7.439890625, "min": 7.382192708333333, "max": 7.6474375 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.2996546875, "sd": 0.05444497729120723, "median": -1.2929453125, "min": -1.3800468750000006, "max": -1.2259427083333332 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.3800468750000006, -1.2437812500000005, -1.2807916666666666, -1.2259427083333332, -1.3626927083333324, -1.2778697916666664, -1.3344062500000007, -1.3455364583333331, -1.2403802083333328, -1.3050989583333337 ], "df": 9, "t": -75.48665071953482, "p": 6.35675516873035e-14, "ci95": [ -1.338602278000681, -1.2607070969993188 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5553418402903094, "lag1": -0.4528136953963765, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8517674566285304, "p_holm": 2.161296757368319e-12 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.961546354166666, "sd": 0.19424461350048053, "median": 8.916244791666667, "min": 8.719036458333333, "max": 9.252619791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.747902604166667, "sd": 0.13179104709387376, "median": 7.717651041666667, "min": 7.624020833333334, "max": 8.027354166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.21364375, "sd": 0.24507872726311017, "median": -1.1542109375000007, "min": -1.582703125000001, "max": -0.942499999999999 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.942499999999999, -0.9728645833333331, -1.0359895833333335, -1.4476927083333333, -0.9536510416666664, -1.4440937499999995, -1.582703125000001, -1.111791666666667, -1.4485208333333324, -1.1966302083333344 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.659778230803894, "p": 7.757968106779863e-08, "ci95": [ -1.3889625100541667, -1.038324989945833 ], "shapiro_p": 0.09727827332417967, "lag1": -0.07080830086165653, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8645720613345133, "p_holm": 1.7962632944694698e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.92633125, "sd": 0.15065569762764247, "median": 8.8865703125, "min": 8.743890625, "max": 9.202208333333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.73716875, "sd": 0.17887557828488385, "median": 7.667927083333334, "min": 7.568807291666666, "max": 8.174807291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.1891625, "sd": 0.19627187036873628, "median": -1.1889453124999996, "min": -1.5855572916666665, "max": -0.8741458333333334 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.5855572916666665, -1.1857447916666661, -1.192145833333333, -1.3104531249999996, -0.9697447916666668, -0.8741458333333334, -1.3218177083333336, -1.158302083333334, -1.0952135416666664, -1.1985000000000001 ], "df": 9, "t": -19.159454694119912, "p": 1.3255050478347745e-08, "ci95": [ -1.3295669379160542, -1.0487580620839452 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7231141381459066, "lag1": -0.011331897769789349, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058f32\u91cf\u5b50\u5316\u6e08\u307f\u5165\u529b\u306b\u5bfe\u3059\u308b\u5185\u90e8\u6f14\u7b97/\u5c65\u6b74/\u8ee2\u9001\u306e\u6570\u5024\u578b\u5dee\u3002\u8aa4\u5dee\u306f\u5225\u9014\u8a55\u4fa1\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8667803751961367, "p_holm": 3.3137626195869363e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.842121354166666, "sd": 0.07633390105985105, "median": 8.822937499999998, "min": 8.752572916666667, "max": 9.0155 }, "after": { "mean": 8.869277604166667, "sd": 0.17951852674823043, "median": 8.889442708333334, "min": 8.616630208333333, "max": 9.232729166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.027156250000000527, "sd": 0.1663629428736285, "median": 0.005135416666667503, "min": -0.1544895833333335, "max": 0.4093072916666678 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.1255468749999995, 0.08664062500000114, 0.0015885416666669983, -0.02414062499999936, 0.08065104166666792, 0.008682291666668007, 0.4093072916666678, -0.14229687499999955, -0.1544895833333335, -0.11992708333333368 ], "df": 9, "t": 0.5161942991966756, "p": 0.6181607146929968, "ci95": [ -0.09185263008225278, 0.14616513008225382 ], "shapiro_p": 0.14146638452767368, "lag1": -0.046632809548917915, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0030712369704362, "p_holm": 0.6181607146929968 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.9106953125, "sd": 0.058494698131563744, "median": 8.898432291666666, "min": 8.831848958333333, "max": 9.029223958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.767674479166667, "sd": 0.10775017799851626, "median": 8.748028645833333, "min": 8.618588541666666, "max": 9.027484375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.14302083333333346, "sd": 0.11681907316459385, "median": -0.13905208333333352, "min": -0.2841093749999999, "max": 0.12473958333333357 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.12473958333333357, -0.1818229166666665, -0.10263020833333414, -0.2418854166666673, -0.2841093749999999, -0.2625729166666666, -0.1488750000000003, -0.12922916666666673, -0.0875885416666673, -0.11623437499999945 ], "df": 9, "t": -3.871556021947128, "p": 0.003779781500992377, "ci95": [ -0.22658816407071802, -0.05945350259594889 ], "shapiro_p": 0.17430234495067876, "lag1": 0.23339761401127535, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9839495316226667, "p_holm": 0.03401803350893139 }, "direction_changed": true, "significance_changed": true }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.869277604166667, "sd": 0.17951852674823043, "median": 8.889442708333334, "min": 8.616630208333333, "max": 9.232729166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.961546354166666, "sd": 0.19424461350048053, "median": 8.916244791666667, "min": 8.719036458333333, "max": 9.252619791666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.09226874999999986, "sd": 0.21101547795935804, "median": 0.06328906249999999, "min": -0.18406770833333397, "max": 0.5806354166666665 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.0917343749999997, -0.042651041666667666, -0.07054687499999979, 0.27144791666666634, -0.18406770833333397, 0.04393229166666579, 0.019890625000000384, 0.12966666666666704, 0.5806354166666665, 0.0826458333333342 ], "df": 9, "t": 1.3827393595879158, "p": 0.2000857008228188, "ci95": [ -0.05868262942492751, 0.2432201294249272 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1877621953691112, "lag1": -0.07221208512620078, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0104031866086425, "p_holm": 0.6002571024684564 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.767674479166667, "sd": 0.10775017799851626, "median": 8.748028645833333, "min": 8.618588541666666, "max": 9.027484375 }, "after": { "mean": 8.92633125, "sd": 0.15065569762764247, "median": 8.8865703125, "min": 8.743890625, "max": 9.202208333333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.15865677083333338, "sd": 0.1642937179377893, "median": 0.13932812499999958, "min": -0.0012239583333322201, "max": 0.4990052083333332 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.17472395833333287, 0.004364583333332561, 0.013828124999999858, 0.4990052083333332, -0.0012239583333322201, 0.3640885416666677, 0.17402604166666613, 0.05919791666666718, 0.19392708333333353, 0.10463020833333303 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.0537793431072147, "p": 0.01370884026417609, "ci95": [ 0.04112812509893933, 0.27618541656772744 ], "shapiro_p": 0.11255728682445632, "lag1": -0.4991383866021423, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0180956502445804, "p_holm": 0.08225304158505654 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.3681078125, "sd": 0.03227404920498432, "median": 7.363539062499999, "min": 7.317354166666667, "max": 7.437510416666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.458553125, "sd": 0.11527032114333358, "median": 7.4161328125, "min": 7.402072916666667, "max": 7.779239583333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.09044531250000007, "sd": 0.11394788863479324, "median": 0.04962500000000025, "min": 0.013229166666666181, "max": 0.3995312499999999 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.033895833333333236, 0.10422395833333287, 0.04595312500000048, 0.025369791666666863, 0.013229166666666181, 0.3995312499999999, 0.07260937500000075, 0.03481770833333364, 0.1215260416666668, 0.05329687500000002 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.5100350222581116, "p": 0.033308841540116686, "ci95": [ 0.008931903444324499, 0.17195872155567565 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00016206604647277326, "lag1": -0.21849507619223377, "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.012275242816963, "p_holm": 0.25610275302982144 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.409509375, "sd": 0.04706195503164368, "median": 7.406591145833334, "min": 7.353177083333334, "max": 7.51915625 }, "after": { "mean": 7.468019791666666, "sd": 0.08997286906734638, "median": 7.439890625, "min": 7.382192708333333, "max": 7.6474375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.058510416666666565, "sd": 0.08471840205128207, "median": 0.039903645833332835, "min": -0.04797916666666602, "max": 0.24264062499999994 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.24264062499999994, 0.1561927083333332, 0.027843749999999723, -0.015739583333333584, -0.04797916666666602, 0.050791666666666124, 0.029015624999999545, 0.013651041666666863, 0.07748958333333356, 0.05119791666666629 ], "df": 9, "t": 2.1840140870473754, "p": 0.05680172651131761, "ci95": [ -0.002093477303517381, 0.11911431063685052 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2033054242124182, "lag1": 0.6406967934038755, "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b/\u7cfb\u5217\u5e45\u3067\u51fa\u529b\u9818\u57df\u306e\u307f\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002\u5168\u97f3\u58f0/\u6700\u7d42\u72b6\u614b\u4e00\u81f4\u3092\u5225\u691c\u8a3c\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0078966654477939, "p_holm": 0.14838243084274755 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.458553125, "sd": 0.11527032114333358, "median": 7.4161328125, "min": 7.402072916666667, "max": 7.779239583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.747902604166667, "sd": 0.13179104709387376, "median": 7.717651041666667, "min": 7.624020833333334, "max": 8.027354166666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2893494791666667, "sd": 0.19112287085889976, "median": 0.29091927083333324, "min": -0.15521874999999952, "max": 0.5559479166666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5559479166666668, 0.4681927083333335, 0.39003645833333334, 0.26259374999999974, 0.36331250000000015, -0.15521874999999952, 0.2390156249999995, 0.2309010416666668, 0.31924479166666675, 0.21946874999999988 ], "df": 9, "t": 4.787513863924874, "p": 0.0009908259853037898, "ci95": [ 0.15262841360881324, 0.42607054472452016 ], "shapiro_p": 0.17784459519326384, "lag1": 0.18186974143849108, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0387943176534882, "p_holm": 0.012880737808949268 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.468019791666666, "sd": 0.08997286906734638, "median": 7.439890625, "min": 7.382192708333333, "max": 7.6474375 }, "after": { "mean": 7.73716875, "sd": 0.17887557828488385, "median": 7.667927083333334, "min": 7.568807291666666, "max": 8.174807291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.2691489583333334, "sd": 0.22629303192272315, "median": 0.22883072916666647, "min": -0.030786458333333044, "max": 0.7678125000000007 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.030786458333333044, 0.062401041666666934, 0.10247395833333339, 0.4144947916666668, 0.3917239583333334, 0.7678125000000007, 0.18661458333333325, 0.24643229166666636, 0.33909374999999997, 0.21122916666666658 ], "df": 9, "t": 3.7611575175931207, "p": 0.004477015447285395, "ci95": [ 0.10726867517437333, 0.4310292414922935 ], "shapiro_p": 0.48947134557039457, "lag1": 0.2568529079024692, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "\u540c\u3058\u578b\u3068\u51fa\u529b\u518d\u5229\u7528\u3067call\u5358\u4f4d\u3092256\u304b\u308932frame\u3078\u77ed\u304f\u3059\u308b\u8cbb\u7528\u5dee\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0360402042096446, "p_holm": 0.03581612357828316 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.076471354166666, "sd": 0.06538939289801589, "median": 7.057377604166667, "min": 7.033609375, "max": 7.257333333333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.6343921875, "sd": 0.035843321397634804, "median": 7.6292369791666665, "min": 7.574052083333333, "max": 7.684703125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5579208333333334, "sd": 0.06649481597611602, "median": 0.564502604166667, "min": 0.41646874999999994, "max": 0.6417604166666662 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6269583333333335, 0.5779791666666672, 0.41646874999999994, 0.5451822916666673, 0.48703645833333287, 0.6417604166666662, 0.5985208333333336, 0.5834947916666664, 0.5510260416666668, 0.55078125 ], "df": 9, "t": 26.532904279729674, "p": 7.417141004443667e-10, "ci95": [ 0.5103533075135703, 0.6054883591530965 ], "shapiro_p": 0.39668054118839396, "lag1": -0.008662194078118114, "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0788416719873848, "p_holm": 2.1509708912886634e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.095855729166667, "sd": 0.06829621432000577, "median": 7.093010416666667, "min": 7.002677083333333, "max": 7.2124322916666666 }, "after": { "mean": 7.685716145833333, "sd": 0.09042819741109609, "median": 7.677731770833333, "min": 7.563958333333333, "max": 7.839177083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5898604166666666, "sd": 0.13418164798388527, "median": 0.6250520833333333, "min": 0.3810989583333333, "max": 0.7855052083333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.651140625, 0.3810989583333333, 0.6902552083333333, 0.43160416666666634, 0.7855052083333334, 0.5141197916666673, 0.7137656249999997, 0.5989635416666665, 0.6635468749999998, 0.46860416666666627 ], "df": 9, "t": 13.901322917621549, "p": 2.1800433969095912e-07, "ci95": [ 0.4938726481268695, 0.6858481852064636 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6934631045168292, "lag1": -0.7326311541172253, "reference": "f32.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.083127453429206, "p_holm": 4.360086793819182e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.598983854166667, "sd": 0.11651279844525927, "median": 8.563473958333333, "min": 8.49015625, "max": 8.874416666666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.6343921875, "sd": 0.035843321397634804, "median": 7.6292369791666665, "min": 7.574052083333333, "max": 7.684703125 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.9645916666666667, "sd": 0.11503362545382187, "median": -0.9290442708333337, "min": -1.2522916666666672, "max": -0.8447604166666665 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.9354062499999998, -1.0629270833333324, -0.9465416666666666, -0.9105260416666656, -0.9538802083333344, -0.9226822916666677, -0.8447604166666665, -1.2522916666666672, -0.9114895833333341, -0.905411458333333 ], "df": 9, "t": -26.516652558334552, "p": 7.457682003454157e-10, "ci95": [ -1.046881765053901, -0.8823015682794325 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004031743660264592, "lag1": -0.38075391675206005, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8878249240810854, "p_holm": 2.1509708912886634e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.742018229166668, "sd": 0.11601895656432538, "median": 8.754432291666667, "min": 8.598182291666667, "max": 8.889020833333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.685716145833333, "sd": 0.09042819741109609, "median": 7.677731770833333, "min": 7.563958333333333, "max": 7.839177083333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -1.0563020833333336, "sd": 0.1263262370232155, "median": -1.045049479166667, "min": -1.2463854166666675, "max": -0.9074270833333342 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.910697916666666, -1.2463854166666675, -1.0402552083333338, -0.9813333333333327, -1.04984375, -1.2295104166666668, -0.9074270833333342, -1.1556249999999997, -0.9319583333333341, -1.1099843750000007 ], "df": 9, "t": -26.44201679102065, "p": 7.647051267331375e-10, "ci95": [ -1.146670429393178, -0.9659337372734894 ], "shapiro_p": 0.35551330250477375, "lag1": -0.6845601623095046, "reference": "f64.full.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8791695400715235, "p_holm": 2.217644867526099e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.1973171875, "sd": 0.07382289133051277, "median": 7.196026041666666, "min": 7.082885416666667, "max": 7.315260416666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.764505729166666, "sd": 0.06746842090781492, "median": 7.766013020833333, "min": 7.65353125, "max": 7.85753125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5671885416666667, "sd": 0.11859831490588157, "median": 0.5865807291666663, "min": 0.36665625000000013, "max": 0.7562864583333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.4575208333333336, 0.36665625000000013, 0.5319114583333331, 0.5926666666666662, 0.6502552083333333, 0.7562864583333333, 0.5804947916666663, 0.6469062500000007, 0.43913020833333327, 0.6500572916666663 ], "df": 9, "t": 15.123382282786825, "p": 1.0506082131206837e-07, "ci95": [ 0.48234841806226064, 0.6520286652710726 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8022120726091675, "lag1": 0.2564030922758881, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0788055503030678, "p_holm": 2.311338068865504e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.170591145833333, "sd": 0.07370901120726345, "median": 7.1768020833333335, "min": 7.071052083333333, "max": 7.334302083333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.737311458333333, "sd": 0.07336763109036115, "median": 7.720997395833333, "min": 7.643005208333333, "max": 7.87921875 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5667203125000001, "sd": 0.1024600100674091, "median": 0.5620026041666666, "min": 0.3482604166666672, "max": 0.7045572916666663 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5158489583333337, 0.5554895833333333, 0.7045572916666663, 0.5157083333333334, 0.5673177083333334, 0.6986614583333335, 0.3482604166666672, 0.5619895833333333, 0.6373541666666673, 0.5620156249999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 17.490989729586612, "p": 2.951338880466286e-08, "ci95": [ 0.4934248367124552, 0.640015788287545 ], "shapiro_p": 0.23645921213313076, "lag1": -0.39177057403297705, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0790339737650931, "p_holm": 6.788079425072458e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.493465104166667, "sd": 0.1250853673111567, "median": 8.482653645833334, "min": 8.340166666666667, "max": 8.720432291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.764505729166666, "sd": 0.06746842090781492, "median": 7.766013020833333, "min": 7.65353125, "max": 7.85753125 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7289593750000001, "sd": 0.11775289731734816, "median": -0.7127916666666669, "min": -0.942796875, "max": -0.5899635416666671 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.8652395833333326, -0.7305416666666664, -0.6334166666666663, -0.942796875, -0.6950416666666674, -0.6073645833333341, -0.7440364583333334, -0.8289374999999994, -0.652255208333334, -0.5899635416666671 ], "df": 9, "t": -19.5763501302247, "p": 1.0965722579876186e-08, "ci95": [ -0.8131947232940197, -0.6447240267059805 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5149267902520078, "lag1": -0.18048255141822028, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9141740896018525, "p_holm": 2.851087870767808e-07 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.49260625, "sd": 0.07568233291388068, "median": 8.508723958333334, "min": 8.361354166666667, "max": 8.58840625 }, "after": { "mean": 7.737311458333333, "sd": 0.07336763109036115, "median": 7.720997395833333, "min": 7.643005208333333, "max": 7.87921875 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7552947916666667, "sd": 0.09711016651880382, "median": -0.7541692708333332, "min": -0.9058437499999998, "max": -0.6068125000000002 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.6478958333333331, -0.8393541666666673, -0.6826093750000002, -0.8671614583333334, -0.7879218750000003, -0.6068125000000002, -0.9058437499999998, -0.707010416666666, -0.7676822916666657, -0.7406562500000007 ], "df": 9, "t": -24.59528113430374, "p": 1.4553381202974063e-09, "ci95": [ -0.8247632199258542, -0.6858263634074792 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9616071655454895, "lag1": -0.7048047231248271, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9110644283471088, "p_holm": 4.0749467368327377e-08 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.408082291666667, "sd": 0.0919293757189778, "median": 7.3926015625, "min": 7.281822916666667, "max": 7.580869791666666 }, "after": { "mean": 7.954792708333334, "sd": 0.17228256915877244, "median": 7.895361979166667, "min": 7.819458333333333, "max": 8.418791666666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5467104166666665, "sd": 0.21198867885200787, "median": 0.48895833333333316, "min": 0.3094687500000006, "max": 1.0311250000000003 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.3094687500000006, 0.4211354166666661, 0.3460052083333336, 1.0311250000000003, 0.4219218749999998, 0.669723958333333, 0.508354166666666, 0.4695625000000003, 0.6498385416666661, 0.6399687499999995 ], "df": 9, "t": 8.155388988547259, "p": 1.897517504796324e-05, "ci95": [ 0.39506285126228535, 0.6983579820710477 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1441756104391802, "lag1": -0.31482888416824195, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0737991824526112, "p_holm": 0.00032257797581537506 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.379688541666667, "sd": 0.0269064998966758, "median": 7.379830729166667, "min": 7.341208333333333, "max": 7.425838541666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.955436458333334, "sd": 0.12185688559391077, "median": 7.910182291666667, "min": 7.843442708333333, "max": 8.199109375 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5757479166666668, "sd": 0.12906751501238395, "median": 0.5395026041666671, "min": 0.4176041666666661, "max": 0.8551458333333342 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6048333333333336, 0.49898958333333265, 0.5100520833333331, 0.7287291666666675, 0.47976562499999975, 0.5237187500000005, 0.4176041666666661, 0.5833541666666671, 0.5552864583333337, 0.8551458333333342 ], "df": 9, "t": 14.106375059508922, "p": 1.920950563848627e-07, "ci95": [ 0.4834185784660855, 0.6680772548672481 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1827454533108056, "lag1": -0.17191012838061046, "reference": "f32.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0780179154466913, "p_holm": 4.033996184082117e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.644773958333333, "sd": 0.2059464143204972, "median": 8.589638020833334, "min": 8.485776041666666, "max": 9.174770833333334 }, "after": { "mean": 7.954792708333334, "sd": 0.17228256915877244, "median": 7.895361979166667, "min": 7.819458333333333, "max": 8.418791666666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.68998125, "sd": 0.23380060763036425, "median": -0.671471354166667, "min": -1.2115312500000002, "max": -0.300770833333333 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.849874999999999, -0.7081458333333339, -0.6338593749999992, -0.300770833333333, -0.6717656250000008, -1.2115312500000002, -0.6884375000000009, -0.6711770833333333, -0.6700624999999993, -0.49418750000000067 ], "df": 9, "t": -9.332363653475308, "p": 6.340269629270081e-06, "ci95": [ -0.8572321292885188, -0.5227303707114812 ], "shapiro_p": 0.12826958553393147, "lag1": 0.06199359570700435, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9201851600370793, "p_holm": 0.00011412485332686145 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.616283854166667, "sd": 0.07933587573074023, "median": 8.598984375, "min": 8.488697916666666, "max": 8.78109375 }, "after": { "mean": 7.955436458333334, "sd": 0.12185688559391077, "median": 7.910182291666667, "min": 7.843442708333333, "max": 8.199109375 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.660847395833333, "sd": 0.10240967098326888, "median": -0.6978151041666667, "min": -0.7992552083333333, "max": -0.5026249999999983 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.6143072916666661, -0.5980052083333334, -0.7564843750000003, -0.5030520833333334, -0.7019947916666673, -0.7058489583333323, -0.7332656249999996, -0.7992552083333333, -0.6936354166666661, -0.5026249999999983 ], "df": 9, "t": -20.406109467587452, "p": 7.603836254774734e-09, "ci95": [ -0.7341068612093979, -0.587587930457268 ], "shapiro_p": 0.3286181680939798, "lag1": -0.14061016667397266, "reference": "f64.reuse.box.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.box.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9233025040703875, "p_holm": 1.976997426241431e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.3681078125, "sd": 0.03227404920498432, "median": 7.363539062499999, "min": 7.317354166666667, "max": 7.437510416666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.8541078125, "sd": 0.047248596153806444, "median": 7.851161458333333, "min": 7.79965625, "max": 7.964541666666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.48600000000000004, "sd": 0.0547797245404468, "median": 0.4828567708333331, "min": 0.4205364583333333, "max": 0.5957552083333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.42899479166666676, 0.5352187499999994, 0.441416666666667, 0.50315625, 0.4205364583333333, 0.46255729166666626, 0.4536145833333336, 0.5957552083333333, 0.5132760416666668, 0.5054739583333339 ], "df": 9, "t": 28.055397425503326, "p": 4.513586846853571e-10, "ci95": [ 0.4468129457428207, 0.5251870542571794 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4938946179190969, "lag1": -0.18044883352698546, "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.065959946891046, "p_holm": 1.399211922524607e-08 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.409509375, "sd": 0.04706195503164368, "median": 7.406591145833334, "min": 7.353177083333334, "max": 7.51915625 }, "after": { "mean": 7.9414114583333335, "sd": 0.1217148827269207, "median": 7.941057291666667, "min": 7.820291666666667, "max": 8.180328125 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5319020833333334, "sd": 0.13964943056119775, "median": 0.552161458333333, "min": 0.3020208333333336, "max": 0.7970885416666675 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6028489583333334, 0.7970885416666675, 0.3020208333333336, 0.6369843750000008, 0.39932812500000026, 0.5695937499999992, 0.46712499999999935, 0.4285364583333333, 0.5807656249999997, 0.5347291666666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 12.04460389679081, "p": 7.46029947351802e-07, "ci95": [ 0.4320028987665098, 0.631801267900157 ], "shapiro_p": 0.9697258282900028, "lag1": -0.4974836462531333, "reference": "f32.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0717864107342916, "p_holm": 1.3428539052332437e-05 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.842121354166666, "sd": 0.07633390105985105, "median": 8.822937499999998, "min": 8.752572916666667, "max": 9.0155 }, "after": { "mean": 7.8541078125, "sd": 0.047248596153806444, "median": 7.851161458333333, "min": 7.79965625, "max": 7.964541666666666 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.9880135416666663, "sd": 0.10430937744976874, "median": -0.9931979166666665, "min": -1.1732343749999998, "max": -0.7943854166666666 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.886067708333333, -0.9660729166666666, -1.099520833333333, -0.985192708333333, -1.0130729166666654, -1.1732343749999998, -1.0115156249999995, -0.7943854166666666, -0.9498697916666661, -1.001203125 ], "df": 9, "t": -29.95294600680474, "p": 2.5187208764179884e-10, "ci95": [ -1.062631975182859, -0.9133951081504735 ], "shapiro_p": 0.8368239632836552, "lag1": 0.11842754564440246, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8882605766091317, "p_holm": 8.059906804537563e-09 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.9106953125, "sd": 0.058494698131563744, "median": 8.898432291666666, "min": 8.831848958333333, "max": 9.029223958333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.9414114583333335, "sd": 0.1217148827269207, "median": 7.941057291666667, "min": 7.820291666666667, "max": 8.180328125 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.9692838541666666, "sd": 0.13925781899587458, "median": -0.9797213541666663, "min": -1.199494791666666, "max": -0.7847083333333327 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.8950989583333335, -0.7847083333333327, -1.1092447916666668, -0.8151041666666661, -1.199494791666666, -1.0216406249999999, -1.0451718750000012, -1.0598802083333334, -0.824692708333334, -0.9378020833333327 ], "df": 9, "t": -22.010575064973246, "p": 3.8947682528448495e-09, "ci95": [ -1.0689028966957783, -0.8696648116375548 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6540674433607032, "lag1": -0.3225066752318354, "reference": "f64.full.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.full.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8912224220250302, "p_holm": 1.0515874282681093e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.458553125, "sd": 0.11527032114333358, "median": 7.4161328125, "min": 7.402072916666667, "max": 7.779239583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 7.94745625, "sd": 0.05299821410938974, "median": 7.933880208333333, "min": 7.886651041666667, "max": 8.065942708333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.4889031249999999, "sd": 0.1411450832843606, "median": 0.5264401041666664, "min": 0.10741145833333388, "max": 0.5945364583333328 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.5945364583333328, 0.4811302083333331, 0.5334583333333329, 0.5791979166666668, 0.5740052083333333, 0.10741145833333388, 0.5383593749999998, 0.5094947916666666, 0.4520156249999996, 0.5194218749999999 ], "df": 9, "t": 10.953604576216335, "p": 1.668335424966774e-06, "ci95": [ 0.38793401492872787, 0.5898722350712718 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00033345361252798064, "lag1": -0.2436008596295141, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0655493252922295, "p_holm": 3.336670849933548e-05 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.468019791666666, "sd": 0.08997286906734638, "median": 7.439890625, "min": 7.382192708333333, "max": 7.6474375 }, "after": { "mean": 8.000278125, "sd": 0.07806620836479038, "median": 7.977236979166666, "min": 7.9301875, "max": 8.169895833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.5322583333333333, "sd": 0.13307924282817604, "median": 0.5208489583333327, "min": 0.2868593750000006, "max": 0.7772500000000004 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.2868593750000006, 0.4544635416666667, 0.5009062500000008, 0.7772500000000004, 0.5781562499999993, 0.5385, 0.6873489583333328, 0.5259270833333325, 0.5157708333333328, 0.4574010416666665 ], "df": 9, "t": 12.64771726355278, "p": 4.914458423003859e-07, "ci95": [ 0.4370591779348505, 0.6274574887318161 ], "shapiro_p": 0.6532159490150241, "lag1": 0.20723058250672585, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0712716822104922, "p_holm": 9.337471003707332e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.869277604166667, "sd": 0.17951852674823043, "median": 8.889442708333334, "min": 8.616630208333333, "max": 9.232729166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 7.94745625, "sd": 0.05299821410938974, "median": 7.933880208333333, "min": 7.886651041666667, "max": 8.065942708333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.9218213541666669, "sd": 0.1768629668658055, "median": -0.8933333333333335, "min": -1.2634687500000004, "max": -0.7035312500000002 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.8121770833333333, -1.0025781250000012, -0.9631145833333337, -0.8596406249999999, -0.9270260416666671, -1.1375312500000003, -1.2634687500000004, -0.7035312500000002, -0.735114583333333, -0.8140312500000002 ], "df": 9, "t": -16.481998049705947, "p": 4.964345141946281e-08, "ci95": [ -1.0483414989245816, -0.7953012094087519 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5953166433934169, "lag1": 0.1915054426581723, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.8960657907771871, "p_holm": 1.2410862854865702e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.767674479166667, "sd": 0.10775017799851626, "median": 8.748028645833333, "min": 8.618588541666666, "max": 9.027484375 }, "after": { "mean": 8.000278125, "sd": 0.07806620836479038, "median": 7.977236979166666, "min": 7.9301875, "max": 8.169895833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7673963541666667, "sd": 0.16155990785394142, "median": -0.7822109374999995, "min": -1.0931875, "max": -0.44869270833333275 }, "differences_ns": [ -1.0931875, -0.7893177083333338, -0.7798854166666658, -0.44869270833333275, -0.7845364583333332, -0.7393697916666664, -0.6470572916666679, -0.8196093750000006, -0.724609375, -0.8476979166666672 ], "df": 9, "t": -15.02056035752257, "p": 1.1147606352156571e-07, "ci95": [ -0.8829693499779679, -0.6518233583553655 ], "shapiro_p": 0.2833969696816743, "lag1": -0.08574081715503094, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b256", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9124743561145983, "p_holm": 2.452473397474446e-06 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.747902604166667, "sd": 0.13179104709387376, "median": 7.717651041666667, "min": 7.624020833333334, "max": 8.027354166666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.168940104166666, "sd": 0.0764845413697448, "median": 8.166184895833332, "min": 8.055734375, "max": 8.302510416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.42103749999999973, "sd": 0.17089312296718911, "median": 0.45425000000000004, "min": 0.0283802083333331, "max": 0.6723541666666675 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.0283802083333331, 0.30305729166666673, 0.37965624999999914, 0.4789322916666663, 0.3902499999999991, 0.546578124999999, 0.49185416666666715, 0.4295677083333338, 0.4897447916666655, 0.6723541666666675 ], "df": 9, "t": 7.791053596690223, "p": 2.73294270528639e-05, "ci95": [ 0.298787924302527, 0.5432870756974725 ], "shapiro_p": 0.25055407745714653, "lag1": 0.6135601080414061, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0543421260579053, "p_holm": 0.0004372708328458224 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 7.73716875, "sd": 0.17887557828488385, "median": 7.667927083333334, "min": 7.568807291666666, "max": 8.174807291666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.1544796875, "sd": 0.08100206418993901, "median": 8.1172265625, "min": 8.070302083333333, "max": 8.303005208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 0.41731093749999976, "sd": 0.2020665100900295, "median": 0.422807291666667, "min": -0.04735937500000098, "max": 0.6535312500000003 }, "differences_ns": [ 0.6489583333333337, 0.5036406249999992, 0.6535312500000003, 0.390447916666667, 0.30165624999999885, -0.04735937500000098, 0.5328229166666665, 0.45516666666666694, 0.3479583333333327, 0.3862864583333332 ], "df": 9, "t": 6.5307856032759135, "p": 0.00010753743196408334, "ci95": [ 0.2727612640417061, 0.5618606109582934 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1853588743082576, "lag1": 0.12480263514200418, "reference": "f32.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 1.0539358712448916, "p_holm": 0.00161306147946125 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.961546354166666, "sd": 0.19424461350048053, "median": 8.916244791666667, "min": 8.719036458333333, "max": 9.252619791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 8.168940104166666, "sd": 0.0764845413697448, "median": 8.166184895833332, "min": 8.055734375, "max": 8.302510416666667 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7926062500000002, "sd": 0.1954292118137676, "median": -0.7898697916666668, "min": -1.0908489583333338, "max": -0.524276041666667 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.9141197916666659, -0.6698072916666664, -0.6563333333333343, -0.968760416666667, -0.5634010416666673, -0.8975156250000005, -1.0908489583333338, -0.6822239583333332, -0.9587760416666669, -0.524276041666667 ], "df": 9, "t": -12.825314160675852, "p": 4.360934129040817e-07, "ci95": [ -0.9324078862993826, -0.6528046137006177 ], "shapiro_p": 0.34387012971128006, "lag1": -0.5022016006752041, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9115547452776965, "p_holm": 9.157961670985715e-06 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 8.92633125, "sd": 0.15065569762764247, "median": 8.8865703125, "min": 8.743890625, "max": 9.202208333333333 }, "after": { "mean": 8.1544796875, "sd": 0.08100206418993901, "median": 8.1172265625, "min": 8.070302083333333, "max": 8.303005208333333 }, "difference": { "mean": -0.7718515625000002, "sd": 0.1299393610393751, "median": -0.7681250000000004, "min": -0.9365989583333327, "max": -0.5386145833333327 }, "differences_ns": [ -0.9365989583333327, -0.682104166666667, -0.5386145833333327, -0.9200052083333325, -0.668088541666668, -0.9215052083333344, -0.7889947916666671, -0.703135416666667, -0.7472552083333337, -0.8122135416666669 ], "df": 9, "t": -18.78421544892912, "p": 1.5775267935111102e-08, "ci95": [ -0.8648045817769326, -0.6788985432230678 ], "shapiro_p": 0.5427805618858899, "lag1": -0.4286169728036563, "reference": "f64.reuse.invbox.b32", "candidate": "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32", "question": "Limiter\u79fb\u52d5\u548c\u3060\u3051f64\u306b\u4fdd\u3064\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u9577\u6642\u9593\u6570\u5024\u5b89\u5b9a\u6027\u306f\u5225\u9014\u78ba\u8a8d\u3002", "mean_ratio": 0.9135309299103145, "p_holm": 3.7860643044266645e-07 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "f64.full.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.4413239583333333, "sd": 0.0030676889776475483, "median": 0.4400026041666667, "min": 0.43913541666666667, "max": 0.447828125 }, "f64.full.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 16.011853125000002, "sd": 0.1938762735481751, "median": 15.915083333333333, "min": 15.849786458333334, "max": 16.415078125 }, "f64.full.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 16.284536458333335, "sd": 0.11962279988273256, "median": 16.3154296875, "min": 16.099380208333333, "max": 16.451010416666666 }, "f64.full.box.b256": { "mean": 8.598983854166667, "sd": 0.11651279844525927, "median": 8.563473958333333, "min": 8.49015625, "max": 8.874416666666667 }, "f64.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 8.842121354166666, "sd": 0.07633390105985105, "median": 8.822937499999998, "min": 8.752572916666667, "max": 9.0155 }, "f64.reuse.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.23454583333333334, "sd": 0.004332577753081521, "median": 0.2326666666666667, "min": 0.23169791666666667, "max": 0.24305729166666667 }, "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 16.088649999999998, "sd": 0.1703836035210358, "median": 16.014294270833332, "min": 15.977453125, "max": 16.45634375 }, "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 16.3874765625, "sd": 0.038974397578800994, "median": 16.379984375, "min": 16.328411458333335, "max": 16.456854166666666 }, "f64.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 8.493465104166667, "sd": 0.1250853673111567, "median": 8.482653645833334, "min": 8.340166666666667, "max": 8.720432291666667 }, "f64.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 8.869277604166667, "sd": 0.17951852674823043, "median": 8.889442708333334, "min": 8.616630208333333, "max": 9.232729166666667 }, "f64.reuse.bypass.b32": { "mean": 0.20507239583333334, "sd": 0.017513375938675756, "median": 0.20325260416666668, "min": 0.19164583333333332, "max": 0.25097395833333336 }, "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32": { "mean": 16.208277083333332, "sd": 0.044048184115483835, "median": 16.196463541666667, "min": 16.162484375, "max": 16.320317708333334 }, "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32": { "mean": 16.491589583333333, "sd": 0.105834666644598, "median": 16.4428046875, "min": 16.359786458333332, "max": 16.678744791666666 }, "f64.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 8.644773958333333, "sd": 0.2059464143204972, "median": 8.589638020833334, "min": 8.485776041666666, "max": 9.174770833333334 }, "f64.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 8.961546354166666, "sd": 0.19424461350048053, "median": 8.916244791666667, "min": 8.719036458333333, "max": 9.252619791666667 }, "f32.full.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.21994010416666668, "sd": 0.002584631881761272, "median": 0.21968489583333334, "min": 0.21718229166666667, "max": 0.22577604166666668 }, "f32.full.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 11.827659895833333, "sd": 0.03716554038725559, "median": 11.8163359375, "min": 11.773265625, "max": 11.888088541666667 }, "f32.full.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 12.486046875, "sd": 0.12331928819141265, "median": 12.4518359375, "min": 12.34121875, "max": 12.715666666666667 }, "f32.full.box.b256": { "mean": 7.076471354166666, "sd": 0.06538939289801589, "median": 7.057377604166667, "min": 7.033609375, "max": 7.257333333333333 }, "f32.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.3681078125, "sd": 0.03227404920498432, "median": 7.363539062499999, "min": 7.317354166666667, "max": 7.437510416666667 }, "f32.reuse.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.08781614583333333, "sd": 0.0018566213626789157, "median": 0.08741666666666667, "min": 0.08574479166666667, "max": 0.09157291666666667 }, "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 12.004072916666667, "sd": 0.03249333689784059, "median": 12.007390625, "min": 11.956817708333332, "max": 12.059296875 }, "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 12.605982291666667, "sd": 0.0507812271604889, "median": 12.59571875, "min": 12.548026041666667, "max": 12.70296875 }, "f32.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 7.1973171875, "sd": 0.07382289133051277, "median": 7.196026041666666, "min": 7.082885416666667, "max": 7.315260416666667 }, "f32.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.458553125, "sd": 0.11527032114333358, "median": 7.4161328125, "min": 7.402072916666667, "max": 7.779239583333333 }, "f32.reuse.bypass.b32": { "mean": 0.09213489583333333, "sd": 0.002420765812809413, "median": 0.09115364583333332, "min": 0.08928645833333333, "max": 0.09655208333333333 }, "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32": { "mean": 12.073764583333332, "sd": 0.043122332554715925, "median": 12.060473958333333, "min": 12.02909375, "max": 12.144458333333333 }, "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32": { "mean": 12.719147395833334, "sd": 0.026991395217039884, "median": 12.727268229166667, "min": 12.675145833333334, "max": 12.749911458333333 }, "f32.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 7.408082291666667, "sd": 0.0919293757189778, "median": 7.3926015625, "min": 7.281822916666667, "max": 7.580869791666666 }, "f32.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 7.747902604166667, "sd": 0.13179104709387376, "median": 7.717651041666667, "min": 7.624020833333334, "max": 8.027354166666667 }, "mixed.full.box.b256": { "mean": 7.6343921875, "sd": 0.035843321397634804, "median": 7.6292369791666665, "min": 7.574052083333333, "max": 7.684703125 }, "mixed.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 7.764505729166666, "sd": 0.06746842090781492, "median": 7.766013020833333, "min": 7.65353125, "max": 7.85753125 }, "mixed.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 7.954792708333334, "sd": 0.17228256915877244, "median": 7.895361979166667, "min": 7.819458333333333, "max": 8.418791666666667 }, "mixed.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.8541078125, "sd": 0.047248596153806444, "median": 7.851161458333333, "min": 7.79965625, "max": 7.964541666666666 }, "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.94745625, "sd": 0.05299821410938974, "median": 7.933880208333333, "min": 7.886651041666667, "max": 8.065942708333333 }, "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 8.168940104166666, "sd": 0.0764845413697448, "median": 8.166184895833332, "min": 8.055734375, "max": 8.302510416666667 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "f64.full.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.4530692708333333, "sd": 0.030637774193396604, "median": 0.43981770833333333, "min": 0.43893229166666664, "max": 0.5361822916666666 }, "f64.full.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 15.918316666666668, "sd": 0.1225358844813587, "median": 15.8769921875, "min": 15.83884375, "max": 16.244369791666667 }, "f64.full.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 16.12330625, "sd": 0.06456789801174798, "median": 16.10280989583333, "min": 16.054020833333333, "max": 16.245505208333334 }, "f64.full.box.b256": { "mean": 8.742018229166668, "sd": 0.11601895656432538, "median": 8.754432291666667, "min": 8.598182291666667, "max": 8.889020833333333 }, "f64.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 8.9106953125, "sd": 0.058494698131563744, "median": 8.898432291666666, "min": 8.831848958333333, "max": 9.029223958333333 }, "f64.reuse.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.2334609375, "sd": 0.0030382532236377558, "median": 0.23257552083333333, "min": 0.23186979166666666, "max": 0.24202604166666666 }, "f64.reuse.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 16.087677604166668, "sd": 0.11718335683133728, "median": 16.036484375, "min": 15.953708333333333, "max": 16.278395833333335 }, "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 16.370281249999998, "sd": 0.04514271511561135, "median": 16.35657552083333, "min": 16.310317708333333, "max": 16.440994791666668 }, "f64.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 8.49260625, "sd": 0.07568233291388068, "median": 8.508723958333334, "min": 8.361354166666667, "max": 8.58840625 }, "f64.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 8.767674479166667, "sd": 0.10775017799851626, "median": 8.748028645833333, "min": 8.618588541666666, "max": 9.027484375 }, "f64.reuse.bypass.b32": { "mean": 0.20076354166666666, "sd": 0.013679849680393551, "median": 0.19381510416666667, "min": 0.19174479166666666, "max": 0.23578645833333334 }, "f64.reuse.decoupled.b32": { "mean": 16.170590104166667, "sd": 0.01616228758532767, "median": 16.17067708333333, "min": 16.136875, "max": 16.18978125 }, "f64.reuse.rmsafter.b32": { "mean": 16.465239583333332, "sd": 0.06288359933631296, "median": 16.448611979166664, "min": 16.407666666666668, "max": 16.586755208333333 }, "f64.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 8.616283854166667, "sd": 0.07933587573074023, "median": 8.598984375, "min": 8.488697916666666, "max": 8.78109375 }, "f64.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 8.92633125, "sd": 0.15065569762764247, "median": 8.8865703125, "min": 8.743890625, "max": 9.202208333333333 }, "f32.full.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.22419895833333334, "sd": 0.01562117445452596, "median": 0.21996354166666665, "min": 0.21704166666666666, "max": 0.2684739583333333 }, "f32.full.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 11.810220833333334, "sd": 0.054101103494788104, "median": 11.7880546875, "min": 11.755989583333333, "max": 11.916390625 }, "f32.full.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 12.423641666666667, "sd": 0.0975172264689102, "median": 12.411249999999999, "min": 12.314703125, "max": 12.668713541666667 }, "f32.full.box.b256": { "mean": 7.095855729166667, "sd": 0.06829621432000577, "median": 7.093010416666667, "min": 7.002677083333333, "max": 7.2124322916666666 }, "f32.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.409509375, "sd": 0.04706195503164368, "median": 7.406591145833334, "min": 7.353177083333334, "max": 7.51915625 }, "f32.reuse.bypass.b256": { "mean": 0.08791197916666667, "sd": 0.00170449944186517, "median": 0.08728645833333333, "min": 0.08610416666666666, "max": 0.09160416666666667 }, "f32.reuse.decoupled.b256": { "mean": 11.9930609375, "sd": 0.0763279582221885, "median": 11.9755859375, "min": 11.942890625, "max": 12.200901041666667 }, "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b256": { "mean": 12.620186458333333, "sd": 0.09098050779300751, "median": 12.596752604166667, "min": 12.516776041666667, "max": 12.783375 }, "f32.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 7.170591145833333, "sd": 0.07370901120726345, "median": 7.1768020833333335, "min": 7.071052083333333, "max": 7.334302083333333 }, "f32.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.468019791666666, "sd": 0.08997286906734638, "median": 7.439890625, "min": 7.382192708333333, "max": 7.6474375 }, "f32.reuse.bypass.b32": { "mean": 0.0941859375, "sd": 0.005301115166872167, "median": 0.09178645833333333, "min": 0.09036458333333333, "max": 0.106921875 }, "f32.reuse.decoupled.b32": { "mean": 12.045231770833334, "sd": 0.060340321048168756, "median": 12.026549479166668, "min": 12.003052083333333, "max": 12.206901041666667 }, "f32.reuse.rmsafter.b32": { "mean": 12.717930729166667, "sd": 0.0460214758268416, "median": 12.714559895833332, "min": 12.675630208333333, "max": 12.840208333333333 }, "f32.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 7.379688541666667, "sd": 0.0269064998966758, "median": 7.379830729166667, "min": 7.341208333333333, "max": 7.425838541666667 }, "f32.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 7.73716875, "sd": 0.17887557828488385, "median": 7.667927083333334, "min": 7.568807291666666, "max": 8.174807291666667 }, "mixed.full.box.b256": { "mean": 7.685716145833333, "sd": 0.09042819741109609, "median": 7.677731770833333, "min": 7.563958333333333, "max": 7.839177083333333 }, "mixed.reuse.box.b256": { "mean": 7.737311458333333, "sd": 0.07336763109036115, "median": 7.720997395833333, "min": 7.643005208333333, "max": 7.87921875 }, "mixed.reuse.box.b32": { "mean": 7.955436458333334, "sd": 0.12185688559391077, "median": 7.910182291666667, "min": 7.843442708333333, "max": 8.199109375 }, "mixed.full.invbox.b256": { "mean": 7.9414114583333335, "sd": 0.1217148827269207, "median": 7.941057291666667, "min": 7.820291666666667, "max": 8.180328125 }, "mixed.reuse.invbox.b256": { "mean": 8.000278125, "sd": 0.07806620836479038, "median": 7.977236979166666, "min": 7.9301875, "max": 8.169895833333333 }, "mixed.reuse.invbox.b32": { "mean": 8.1544796875, "sd": 0.08100206418993901, "median": 8.1172265625, "min": 8.070302083333333, "max": 8.303005208333333 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "9b7865e9686b7172c33579157efdcb87edfc988e3236d8288e7b9d2e0da24501" }, { "family": "DX07", "jobs": 15, "blocks": 10, "seed": 202611056123, "comparisons": [ { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.2096734375, "sd": 0.1119637081020726, "median": 9.171127604166667, "min": 9.0755, "max": 9.438682291666666 }, "after": { "mean": 24.310781249999998, "sd": 0.7234952543491093, "median": 23.9545, "min": 23.7593125, "max": 25.751760416666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 15.1011078125, "sd": 0.763261790325762, "median": 14.765200520833334, "min": 14.470854166666667, "max": 16.628265624999997 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.4845, 14.759291666666668, 14.734848958333332, 16.343708333333332, 14.771109375, 14.977932291666667, 14.647359375, 16.628265624999997, 15.193208333333331, 14.470854166666667 ], "df": 9, "t": 62.56555284770831, "p": 3.4337844261051257e-13, "ci95": [ 14.55510321972693, 15.647112405273067 ], "shapiro_p": 0.004774582843876868, "lag1": -0.22576289899748594, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.bass", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.639700681569362, "p_holm": 6.867568852210251e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.134604166666666, "sd": 0.03606487483020194, "median": 9.1333984375, "min": 9.081578125, "max": 9.184463541666666 }, "after": { "mean": 24.089761458333335, "sd": 0.7232163889035389, "median": 23.80494010416667, "min": 23.604510416666667, "max": 25.984270833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.955157291666668, "sd": 0.7219924688966433, "median": 14.671541666666666, "min": 14.520328125, "max": 16.868322916666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.579869791666667, 16.868322916666667, 14.790234374999999, 14.633895833333334, 14.55078125, 14.709187499999999, 14.540901041666668, 15.372760416666667, 14.985291666666669, 14.520328125 ], "df": 9, "t": 65.50256664036182, "p": 2.2741707702739987e-13, "ci95": [ 14.43867499298264, 15.47163959035069 ], "shapiro_p": 0.000204022763383988, "lag1": -0.1865323721274031, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.bass", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.63719817726092, "p_holm": 6.822512310821996e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.bass", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.222421875, "sd": 0.10823535380155688, "median": 9.217614583333333, "min": 9.0994375, "max": 9.370901041666666 }, "after": { "mean": 23.692331770833334, "sd": 0.20122896886316902, "median": 23.6188125, "min": 23.526557291666666, "max": 24.137557291666667 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.469909895833334, "sd": 0.24651135012326544, "median": 14.412658854166667, "min": 14.176536458333334, "max": 15.03146875 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.432833333333333, 14.302338541666668, 14.176536458333334, 14.445583333333332, 14.378453125000002, 14.272291666666668, 15.03146875, 14.392484375, 14.698656249999999, 14.568453125 ], "df": 9, "t": 185.62176867459598, "p": 1.944225598983909e-17, "ci95": [ 14.293566299122503, 14.646253492544165 ], "shapiro_p": 0.1692992933413459, "lag1": -0.1228105489991821, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.bass", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.568992406979141, "p_holm": 1.1665353593903454e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.23751875, "sd": 0.15317150701925003, "median": 9.152143229166667, "min": 9.11046875, "max": 9.558765625 }, "after": { "mean": 23.919199479166668, "sd": 0.7631658115373507, "median": 23.697182291666664, "min": 23.513916666666667, "max": 26.082911458333335 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.681680729166667, "sd": 0.8180756867690849, "median": 14.522085937500002, "min": 14.107114583333333, "max": 16.95479166666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.107114583333333, 14.546802083333334, 14.1416875, 14.497369791666667, 16.95479166666667, 14.547973958333332, 14.581723958333333, 14.494661458333333, 14.346197916666666, 14.598484374999998 ], "df": 9, "t": 56.7521462065811, "p": 8.242756553078737e-13, "ci95": [ 14.096464637029708, 15.266896821303625 ], "shapiro_p": 2.06222642061128e-05, "lag1": -0.060966767398557026, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.bass", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.bass", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.5893532805188264, "p_holm": 8.242756553078737e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.458802083333333, "sd": 0.07407259492428732, "median": 9.446239583333334, "min": 9.36459375, "max": 9.558567708333333 }, "after": { "mean": 24.19325625, "sd": 0.7430233601126416, "median": 23.893440104166665, "min": 23.657088541666667, "max": 25.588395833333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.734454166666666, "sd": 0.7831348924447303, "median": 14.451856770833334, "min": 14.1405625, "max": 16.189630208333334 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.160109375, 16.152213541666665, 14.551291666666668, 14.352421875, 14.305499999999999, 14.634359375, 14.702812499999999, 14.155640625, 16.189630208333334, 14.1405625 ], "df": 9, "t": 59.49733014777309, "p": 5.393642609763737e-13, "ci95": [ 14.174233213049733, 15.294675120283598 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0016544592186107383, "lag1": -0.49024433419362445, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.pad", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.557750552010088, "p_holm": 6.867568852210251e-13 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.51409375, "sd": 0.13009622947314364, "median": 9.504080729166667, "min": 9.3694375, "max": 9.722578125 }, "after": { "mean": 24.059747916666666, "sd": 0.5992412317931162, "median": 23.796489583333333, "min": 23.535859375, "max": 25.242739583333332 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.545654166666667, "sd": 0.65557763326741, "median": 14.302375, "min": 13.921796875, "max": 15.755624999999998 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.915822916666666, 15.755624999999998, 14.309843749999999, 13.921796875, 14.29490625, 15.590838541666665, 14.225718749999999, 14.012677083333335, 14.039510416666667, 14.389802083333333 ], "df": 9, "t": 70.16315824341552, "p": 1.2264320637281724e-13, "ci95": [ 14.076682179308923, 15.014626154024414 ], "shapiro_p": 0.024633010204582657, "lag1": 0.1046132340405604, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.pad", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.52885335680728, "p_holm": 4.90572825491269e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.pad", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.577711458333333, "sd": 0.06528168054970337, "median": 9.5872578125, "min": 9.476510416666667, "max": 9.66575 }, "after": { "mean": 23.744370833333335, "sd": 0.2711880064464027, "median": 23.689036458333334, "min": 23.489317708333335, "max": 24.358588541666666 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.166659375, "sd": 0.28793838712867503, "median": 14.069624999999998, "min": 13.893723958333334, "max": 14.83134375 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.15796875, 14.83134375, 13.893723958333334, 14.089166666666666, 14.050083333333333, 14.481244791666667, 14.045244791666669, 13.899395833333333, 14.013109374999999, 14.205312499999998 ], "df": 9, "t": 155.585057301712, "p": 9.516986146176012e-17, "ci95": [ 13.960680661273448, 14.372638088726552 ], "shapiro_p": 0.031506124187177964, "lag1": -0.22042860005228684, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.pad", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.4791278100859824, "p_holm": 4.758493073088006e-16 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.594109895833334, "sd": 0.08043080162854349, "median": 9.584046875, "min": 9.479427083333333, "max": 9.739869791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 23.632238020833334, "sd": 0.13805157423317005, "median": 23.625591145833333, "min": 23.4355, "max": 23.875973958333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.038128125, "sd": 0.1311309885639073, "median": 14.056046875, "min": 13.814385416666667, "max": 14.211677083333331 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.211677083333331, 14.063828124999999, 13.814385416666667, 14.119578125000002, 14.048265625, 14.136104166666666, 13.887817708333333, 13.961609375, 13.952333333333332, 14.185682291666666 ], "df": 9, "t": 338.53522684787833, "p": 8.71558447158765e-20, "ci95": [ 13.944322666744045, 14.131933583255949 ], "shapiro_p": 0.7794843607130488, "lag1": -0.23727733642048165, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.pad", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.pad", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.463202764760562, "p_holm": 5.22935068295259e-19 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.269116666666667, "sd": 0.10154593051566395, "median": 9.269934895833334, "min": 9.145567708333333, "max": 9.401375 }, "after": { "mean": 24.234983333333332, "sd": 0.5811634770806717, "median": 24.03106770833333, "min": 23.834473958333334, "max": 25.800630208333335 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.965866666666667, "sd": 0.551530026783596, "median": 14.817455729166667, "min": 14.553083333333335, "max": 16.456494791666668 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.910479166666669, 14.553083333333335, 14.680463541666667, 14.994286458333335, 14.742473958333333, 14.738598958333332, 14.59628125, 15.094067708333334, 14.892437500000002, 16.456494791666668 ], "df": 9, "t": 85.80897417508696, "p": 2.008658656777158e-14, "ci95": [ 14.571325853156836, 15.360407480176498 ], "shapiro_p": 0.00034071454519161006, "lag1": 0.12119241839324006, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.drums", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.61459470247974, "p_holm": 6.025975970331473e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.234178125, "sd": 0.09218288666135123, "median": 9.222703125, "min": 9.137739583333333, "max": 9.437744791666667 }, "after": { "mean": 24.201913020833334, "sd": 0.7245625291026189, "median": 24.0039765625, "min": 23.792901041666667, "max": 26.225286458333333 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.967734895833333, "sd": 0.7637521497504102, "median": 14.788023437500001, "min": 14.385005208333332, "max": 17.087546875 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.604708333333335, 14.675557291666667, 15.016197916666668, 14.789468750000001, 14.385005208333332, 17.087546875, 14.786578125, 14.834447916666665, 14.846520833333331, 14.651317708333334 ], "df": 9, "t": 61.97315935527553, "p": 3.7400687589151557e-13, "ci95": [ 14.421379521059434, 15.514090270607229 ], "shapiro_p": 3.337077438320694e-05, "lag1": -0.26679468037148835, "reference": "limit.box.max.1.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.1.drums", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.6209060181880925, "p_holm": 7.480137517830311e-13 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false }, { "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.drums", "exploration": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.355619791666667, "sd": 0.18673945546775866, "median": 9.265143229166668, "min": 9.191958333333334, "max": 9.693864583333333 }, "after": { "mean": 24.081995833333334, "sd": 0.5220654961138403, "median": 23.947572916666665, "min": 23.811802083333333, "max": 25.551177083333332 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.726376041666667, "sd": 0.5055286880440343, "median": 14.631533854166666, "min": 14.192494791666668, "max": 16.046958333333333 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.58640625, 14.802906250000001, 14.748197916666667, 14.793192708333333, 14.598291666666666, 16.046958333333333, 14.664776041666666, 14.299291666666665, 14.531244791666667, 14.192494791666668 ], "df": 9, "t": 92.11918348686265, "p": 1.0612966966310566e-14, "ci95": [ 14.364742603508075, 15.088009479825255 ], "shapiro_p": 0.0030305414223050727, "lag1": -0.0287511374474578, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.drums", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.574067391535502, "p_holm": 4.2451867865242264e-14 }, "confirmation": { "blocks": 10, "before": { "mean": 9.298641666666667, "sd": 0.12508331101506975, "median": 9.2583984375, "min": 9.142166666666666, "max": 9.535666666666666 }, "after": { "mean": 24.078383333333335, "sd": 0.30018383225561324, "median": 23.984932291666667, "min": 23.729572916666665, "max": 24.509229166666668 }, "difference": { "mean": 14.779741666666666, "sd": 0.3431143085126514, "median": 14.686606770833334, "min": 14.227671875, "max": 15.264729166666667 }, "differences_ns": [ 14.698619791666667, 15.050890625000001, 15.264729166666667, 14.674593750000001, 14.650380208333335, 14.357817708333332, 15.109203124999999, 15.110098958333333, 14.653411458333334, 14.227671875 ], "df": 9, "t": 136.21596574669354, "p": 3.1474377144766337e-16, "ci95": [ 14.534292476534793, 15.02519085679854 ], "shapiro_p": 0.4105125586680475, "lag1": 0.13727541177643565, "reference": "limit.box.max.5.drums", "candidate": "tp.itu.max.5.drums", "question": "Box limiter\u3092\u5171\u901a\u306b\u4fdd\u3061\u30014\u500d\u88dc\u9593sidechain\u30686 sample\u6574\u5408\u9045\u5ef6\u3092\u8ffd\u52a0\u3057\u305fCPU\u8cbb\u7528\u3002\u51fa\u529b\u7279\u6027\u306f\u7570\u306a\u308b\u3002", "mean_ratio": 2.589451685147562, "p_holm": 1.5737188572383168e-15 }, "direction_changed": false, "significance_changed": false } ], "exploration_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.465478125, "sd": 0.04668927350852918, "median": 0.4419895833333333, "min": 0.4399166666666667, "max": 0.5579947916666667 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.2096734375, "sd": 0.1119637081020726, "median": 9.171127604166667, "min": 9.0755, "max": 9.438682291666666 }, "tp.itu.max.1.bass": { "mean": 24.310781249999998, "sd": 0.7234952543491093, "median": 23.9545, "min": 23.7593125, "max": 25.751760416666666 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.222421875, "sd": 0.10823535380155688, "median": 9.217614583333333, "min": 9.0994375, "max": 9.370901041666666 }, "tp.itu.max.5.bass": { "mean": 23.692331770833334, "sd": 0.20122896886316902, "median": 23.6188125, "min": 23.526557291666666, "max": 24.137557291666667 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.443065625, "sd": 0.0064507241240450664, "median": 0.4412786458333333, "min": 0.4392916666666667, "max": 0.461203125 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.458802083333333, "sd": 0.07407259492428732, "median": 9.446239583333334, "min": 9.36459375, "max": 9.558567708333333 }, "tp.itu.max.1.pad": { "mean": 24.19325625, "sd": 0.7430233601126416, "median": 23.893440104166665, "min": 23.657088541666667, "max": 25.588395833333333 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.577711458333333, "sd": 0.06528168054970337, "median": 9.5872578125, "min": 9.476510416666667, "max": 9.66575 }, "tp.itu.max.5.pad": { "mean": 23.744370833333335, "sd": 0.2711880064464027, "median": 23.689036458333334, "min": 23.489317708333335, "max": 24.358588541666666 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.44333125, "sd": 0.005381330722175981, "median": 0.441140625, "min": 0.440234375, "max": 0.4571458333333333 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.269116666666667, "sd": 0.10154593051566395, "median": 9.269934895833334, "min": 9.145567708333333, "max": 9.401375 }, "tp.itu.max.1.drums": { "mean": 24.234983333333332, "sd": 0.5811634770806717, "median": 24.03106770833333, "min": 23.834473958333334, "max": 25.800630208333335 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.355619791666667, "sd": 0.18673945546775866, "median": 9.265143229166668, "min": 9.191958333333334, "max": 9.693864583333333 }, "tp.itu.max.5.drums": { "mean": 24.081995833333334, "sd": 0.5220654961138403, "median": 23.947572916666665, "min": 23.811802083333333, "max": 25.551177083333332 } }, "confirmation_summaries": { "bypass.bass": { "mean": 0.46167552083333335, "sd": 0.0496091851696329, "median": 0.44154947916666665, "min": 0.43925, "max": 0.5988854166666666 }, "limit.box.max.1.bass": { "mean": 9.134604166666666, "sd": 0.03606487483020194, "median": 9.1333984375, "min": 9.081578125, "max": 9.184463541666666 }, "tp.itu.max.1.bass": { "mean": 24.089761458333335, "sd": 0.7232163889035389, "median": 23.80494010416667, "min": 23.604510416666667, "max": 25.984270833333333 }, "limit.box.max.5.bass": { "mean": 9.23751875, "sd": 0.15317150701925003, "median": 9.152143229166667, "min": 9.11046875, "max": 9.558765625 }, "tp.itu.max.5.bass": { "mean": 23.919199479166668, "sd": 0.7631658115373507, "median": 23.697182291666664, "min": 23.513916666666667, "max": 26.082911458333335 }, "bypass.pad": { "mean": 0.4415385416666667, "sd": 0.0020809277199220866, "median": 0.4412369791666667, "min": 0.4395364583333333, "max": 0.44703645833333333 }, "limit.box.max.1.pad": { "mean": 9.51409375, "sd": 0.13009622947314364, "median": 9.504080729166667, "min": 9.3694375, "max": 9.722578125 }, "tp.itu.max.1.pad": { "mean": 24.059747916666666, "sd": 0.5992412317931162, "median": 23.796489583333333, "min": 23.535859375, "max": 25.242739583333332 }, "limit.box.max.5.pad": { "mean": 9.594109895833334, "sd": 0.08043080162854349, "median": 9.584046875, "min": 9.479427083333333, "max": 9.739869791666667 }, "tp.itu.max.5.pad": { "mean": 23.632238020833334, "sd": 0.13805157423317005, "median": 23.625591145833333, "min": 23.4355, "max": 23.875973958333333 }, "bypass.drums": { "mean": 0.4558932291666667, "sd": 0.032234133451778356, "median": 0.44377083333333334, "min": 0.44015625, "max": 0.545203125 }, "limit.box.max.1.drums": { "mean": 9.234178125, "sd": 0.09218288666135123, "median": 9.222703125, "min": 9.137739583333333, "max": 9.437744791666667 }, "tp.itu.max.1.drums": { "mean": 24.201913020833334, "sd": 0.7245625291026189, "median": 24.0039765625, "min": 23.792901041666667, "max": 26.225286458333333 }, "limit.box.max.5.drums": { "mean": 9.298641666666667, "sd": 0.12508331101506975, "median": 9.2583984375, "min": 9.142166666666666, "max": 9.535666666666666 }, "tp.itu.max.5.drums": { "mean": 24.078383333333335, "sd": 0.30018383225561324, "median": 23.984932291666667, "min": 23.729572916666665, "max": 24.509229166666668 } }, "confirmation_sha256": "6f45b80ae851d93a3b8721c8f4019cb20a9cfb894370abb4a26eec05899bf32a" } ], "interpretation": "Each experiment uses its own randomized blocks and within-family Holm correction. Across-experiment mean ratios are displayed descriptively, not treated as paired timings or pooled observations." }