# Reverb / EQ 最適化候補の探索比較 比較基点はReverb `9d68a552eb56928dc6533c0db68ff21ca866c54d`、EQ `5c754c2cc5f7cd92f368cb7aa4f2e5b14032e60d`。各候補は基点から独立に比較した。 ## 計測条件 48 kHz、4秒相当のステレオ音声を生成する区間を計時。設定・入力生成を計時外へ置き、各実行で最低1周と実時間200 msのburn-inを行う。10ブロックごとに全条件・変更前後をseed `2026110710`でシャッフルし、ブロック間は5秒待機する。最初の `screen-reverb-exp-...` の18比較だけは2秒で最低3秒に達していないため、下の採否用統計から除き、末尾の診断記録へ分離した。同じ初期5候補・binaryを10ブロック・200 ms以上のburn-in・5秒クールタイムで再測定し、新しい18比較を採否用統計へ加えた。旧記録を新しい測定で上書きしない。全測定は同じ共通ロックを取得しCPU 10に固定。コンポーネント単体の探索値であり、正式な採否は同一条件の全音源比較で決める。 各行の95%CIはブロック対応差のpointwise区間。Holm補正はこの表の全比較を同族として算出。途中版の選択に使用した探索結果であり、確認試験の有意性とは区別する。 |候補|条件|単位|変更前|変更後|差 %|対応差 [95%CI]|Holm p| |---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| |eq-gain-exp2|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.449|4.872|-42.34|-3.577 [-3.629, -3.526]|7.997e-15| |eq-gain-exp2|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.556|15.749|-42.85|-11.807 [-12.095, -11.519]|6.662e-13| |eq-gain-exp2|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.115|16.054|-42.90|-12.062 [-12.241, -11.882]|1.07e-14| |eq-gain-exp2|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.363|15.480|-45.42|-12.883 [-13.018, -12.747]|5.14e-16| |eq-gain-pade|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.504|4.871|-42.72|-3.633 [-3.697, -3.569]|4.593e-14| |eq-gain-pade|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.323|15.265|-44.13|-12.058 [-12.518, -11.599]|3.003e-11| |eq-gain-pade|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.192|15.079|-46.51|-13.114 [-13.354, -12.873]|6.172e-14| |eq-gain-pade|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.542|14.732|-48.39|-13.811 [-13.993, -13.628]|3.928e-15| |eq-gain-exp2-root|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.488|4.878|-42.53|-3.610 [-3.702, -3.518]|9.941e-13| |eq-gain-exp2-root|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.460|15.678|-42.90|-11.781 [-11.956, -11.606]|1.043e-14| |eq-gain-exp2-root|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.386|16.251|-42.75|-12.135 [-12.529, -11.742]|7.219e-12| |eq-gain-exp2-root|q|ns/stereo-frame|30.250|15.644|-48.28|-14.606 [-18.042, -11.170]|0.0001732| |eq-gain-pade-root|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.505|4.894|-42.46|-3.611 [-3.674, -3.548]|4.319e-14| |eq-gain-pade-root|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.396|15.126|-44.79|-12.270 [-12.430, -12.110]|3.566e-15| |eq-gain-pade-root|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.396|14.929|-47.43|-13.467 [-13.703, -13.230]|4.417e-14| |eq-gain-pade-root|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.823|14.948|-48.14|-13.875 [-14.437, -13.313]|5.103e-11| |eq-canonical|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.515|5.536|-34.98|-2.979 [-3.032, -2.925]|5.218e-14| |eq-canonical|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.369|18.203|-33.49|-9.166 [-9.381, -8.951]|4.845e-13| |eq-canonical|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.255|18.742|-33.67|-9.513 [-10.542, -8.484]|2.327e-07| |eq-canonical|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.495|17.784|-37.59|-10.710 [-10.923, -10.498]|1.217e-13| |eq-v2|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.450|4.932|-41.63|-3.518 [-3.588, -3.448]|1.242e-13| |eq-v2|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.578|16.778|-39.16|-10.800 [-11.086, -10.515]|1.3e-12| |eq-v2|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.253|16.918|-40.12|-11.335 [-11.484, -11.187]|3.607e-15| |eq-v2|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.566|16.530|-42.13|-12.036 [-12.304, -11.769]|3.022e-13| |eq-cache|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.531|8.502|-0.34|-0.029 [-0.087, +0.029]|1| |eq-cache|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.779|21.336|-23.19|-6.443 [-6.626, -6.261]|2.305e-12| |eq-cache|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.438|23.213|-18.37|-5.225 [-5.444, -5.006]|6.813e-11| |eq-cache|q|ns/stereo-frame|29.011|19.320|-33.40|-9.691 [-10.104, -9.278]|7.888e-11| |eq-cache-peak|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.537|8.317|-2.57|-0.220 [-0.259, -0.180]|1.832e-05| |eq-cache-peak|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.725|16.978|-38.76|-10.748 [-10.973, -10.522]|1.874e-13| |eq-cache-peak|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.453|20.975|-26.28|-7.478 [-7.715, -7.241]|6.076e-12| |eq-cache-peak|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.626|12.066|-57.85|-16.560 [-17.595, -15.524]|2.06e-09| |eq-cache-peak-soa|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.531|4.877|-42.84|-3.655 [-3.715, -3.594]|2.564e-14| |eq-cache-peak-soa|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.664|17.809|-35.63|-9.856 [-10.157, -9.554]|4.634e-12| |eq-cache-peak-soa|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.820|19.002|-34.07|-9.818 [-10.295, -9.342]|2.251e-10| |eq-cache-peak-soa|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.747|16.008|-44.32|-12.739 [-12.968, -12.511]|5.192e-14| |reverb-exp|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.828|13.907|+0.58|+0.080 [-0.109, +0.269]|1| |reverb-exp|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.504|31.420|-48.91|-30.084 [-30.434, -29.734]|1.294e-15| |reverb-exp|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.907|9.925|+0.19|+0.018 [-0.130, +0.167]|1| |reverb-pade|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.013|13.733|-2.00|-0.281 [-0.535, -0.027]|0.3937| |reverb-pade|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.400|17.562|-71.40|-43.838 [-44.022, -43.653]|1.452e-19| |reverb-pade|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.985|9.970|-0.15|-0.015 [-0.112, +0.083]|1| |reverb-pade-cache-damping|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.108|13.734|-2.65|-0.374 [-0.659, -0.089]|0.2819| |reverb-pade-cache-damping|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.636|15.633|-74.64|-46.004 [-46.348, -45.659]|2.463e-17| |reverb-pade-cache-damping|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|10.019|9.945|-0.73|-0.073 [-0.138, -0.008]|0.3937| |reverb-ring-f32-damping|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.085|10.170|-27.80|-3.915 [-4.311, -3.520]|1.301e-07| |reverb-ring-f32-damping|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.170|14.788|-76.21|-47.382 [-48.203, -46.562]|3.949e-14| |reverb-ring-f32-damping|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|10.024|5.775|-42.39|-4.249 [-4.445, -4.053]|1.534e-10| |reverb-ring-f64-damping|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.838|10.711|-22.60|-3.127 [-3.425, -2.830]|7.833e-08| |reverb-ring-f64-damping|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.275|13.765|-77.90|-48.509 [-49.493, -47.525]|1.43e-13| |reverb-ring-f64-damping|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.943|6.376|-35.88|-3.568 [-3.734, -3.401]|1.654e-10| |eq-pade-scale|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.493|4.888|-42.45|-3.605 [-3.682, -3.528]|2.265e-13| |eq-pade-scale|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.639|15.969|-42.22|-11.670 [-11.892, -11.448]|8.438e-14| |eq-pade-scale|gain|ns/stereo-frame|28.900|19.188|-33.60|-9.712 [-10.420, -9.003]|7.561e-09| |eq-pade-scale|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.904|15.753|-45.50|-13.152 [-13.468, -12.836]|5.948e-13| |param-eq|parameters|ns/update|28.878|17.534|-39.28|-11.344 [-11.592, -11.096]|2.641e-13| |param-reverb|parameters|ns/update|14.328|6.168|-56.95|-8.160 [-10.683, -5.637]|0.001346| |reverb-pade-cache|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.073|13.801|-1.93|-0.272 [-0.636, +0.092]|1| |reverb-pade-cache|decay|ns/stereo-frame|70.593|15.289|-78.34|-55.304 [-74.572, -36.036]|0.003146| |reverb-pade-cache|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.938|10.174|+2.38|+0.237 [+0.065, +0.408]|0.2338| |reverb-pade-f32|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.124|14.687|+3.98|+0.563 [+0.327, +0.799]|0.01039| |reverb-pade-f32|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.824|18.086|-70.75|-43.738 [-44.269, -43.208]|1.842e-15| |reverb-pade-f32|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.941|10.022|+0.81|+0.081 [+0.027, +0.135]|0.1623| |reverb-pade-split-f32|damping|ns/stereo-frame|15.083|14.500|-3.87|-0.583 [-2.576, +1.410]|1| |reverb-pade-split-f32|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.189|17.346|-72.11|-44.843 [-45.117, -44.569]|4.08e-18| |reverb-pade-split-f32|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.984|9.476|-5.10|-0.509 [-0.646, -0.372]|0.0004926| |reverb-pade-balanced|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.050|15.671|+11.54|+1.621 [+0.300, +2.942]|0.3095| |reverb-pade-balanced|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.899|16.659|-73.09|-45.240 [-46.021, -44.459]|3.881e-14| |reverb-pade-balanced|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.970|9.591|-3.80|-0.379 [-0.487, -0.271]|0.0007604| |reverb-pade-projection|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.948|14.534|+4.20|+0.586 [+0.360, +0.812]|0.006182| |reverb-pade-projection|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.059|16.645|-73.18|-45.414 [-46.321, -44.507]|1.257e-13| |reverb-pade-projection|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.936|9.584|-3.54|-0.352 [-0.495, -0.208]|0.009049| |reverb-pade-projection-f32|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.995|14.028|+0.24|+0.034 [-0.160, +0.228]|1| |reverb-pade-projection-f32|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.552|16.828|-72.66|-44.724 [-44.987, -44.460]|2.94e-18| |reverb-pade-projection-f32|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.989|9.417|-5.73|-0.572 [-0.724, -0.421]|0.0004356| |eq-cache-peak-pade|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.513|8.342|-2.01|-0.171 [-0.283, -0.060]|0.1458| |eq-cache-peak-pade|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.836|14.211|-48.95|-13.624 [-13.964, -13.285]|7.943e-13| |eq-cache-peak-pade|gain|ns/stereo-frame|29.974|21.144|-29.46|-8.830 [-11.451, -6.209]|0.001008| |eq-cache-peak-pade|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.990|11.616|-59.93|-17.374 [-17.841, -16.908]|1.473e-12| |eq-cache-peak-soa-pade|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|8.602|4.865|-43.44|-3.737 [-3.854, -3.619]|5.772e-12| |eq-cache-peak-soa-pade|frequency|ns/stereo-frame|27.828|16.261|-41.57|-11.567 [-12.126, -11.008]|2.234e-10| |eq-cache-peak-soa-pade|gain|ns/stereo-frame|36.903|19.584|-46.93|-17.319 [-36.235, +1.596]|0.6822| |eq-cache-peak-soa-pade|q|ns/stereo-frame|28.738|16.330|-43.18|-12.408 [-13.230, -11.587]|3.341e-09| |reverb-pade-paired|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.034|16.106|+14.76|+2.072 [+0.454, +3.690]|0.3004| |reverb-pade-paired|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.926|17.136|-72.33|-44.790 [-45.439, -44.141]|8.451e-15| |reverb-pade-paired|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.906|9.766|-1.41|-0.140 [-0.251, -0.029]|0.3095| |reverb-pade-split|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.101|14.598|+3.53|+0.497 [+0.100, +0.895]|0.3095| |reverb-pade-split|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.757|17.218|-72.12|-44.539 [-45.161, -43.918]|6.209e-15| |reverb-pade-split|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.950|9.666|-2.86|-0.285 [-0.382, -0.187]|0.00288| |reverb-pade4|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.027|13.738|-2.07|-0.290 [-0.545, -0.035]|0.3937| |reverb-pade4|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.501|16.558|-73.51|-45.944 [-48.201, -43.687]|2.47e-10| |reverb-pade4|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.991|9.950|-0.41|-0.041 [-0.185, +0.104]|1| |reverb-pade8|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.981|13.774|-1.48|-0.207 [-0.513, +0.098]|1| |reverb-pade8|decay|ns/stereo-frame|70.239|17.225|-75.48|-53.013 [-72.099, -33.928]|0.003882| |reverb-pade8|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.849|10.046|+2.00|+0.197 [+0.075, +0.318]|0.1152| |reverb-ring-f32|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.878|10.607|-28.70|-4.271 [-6.339, -2.202]|0.02685| |reverb-ring-f32|decay|ns/stereo-frame|62.077|14.632|-76.43|-47.445 [-48.168, -46.723]|1.283e-14| |reverb-ring-f32|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.915|5.706|-42.45|-4.209 [-4.295, -4.123]|1.442e-13| |reverb-ring-f64|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.037|11.533|-17.84|-2.505 [-2.819, -2.190]|8.48e-07| |reverb-ring-f64|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.927|13.644|-77.97|-48.283 [-48.926, -47.640]|4.094e-15| |reverb-ring-f64|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.924|6.265|-36.87|-3.659 [-3.828, -3.491]|1.513e-10| |reverb-ring-pade4|damping|ns/stereo-frame|13.925|10.742|-22.86|-3.184 [-3.415, -2.953]|7.426e-09| |reverb-ring-pade4|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.683|12.821|-79.21|-48.862 [-49.225, -48.498]|2.347e-17| |reverb-ring-pade4|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.897|6.313|-36.21|-3.584 [-3.699, -3.470]|6.576e-12| |reverb-ring-pade8|damping|ns/stereo-frame|14.067|10.779|-23.37|-3.288 [-3.484, -3.091]|1.404e-09| |reverb-ring-pade8|decay|ns/stereo-frame|61.653|13.356|-78.34|-48.297 [-48.570, -48.023]|2.09e-18| |reverb-ring-pade8|fixed|ns/stereo-frame|9.972|6.322|-36.60|-3.649 [-3.744, -3.555]|1.096e-12| ## 規定未達の初期診断 以下の18比較は10ブロック・200 ms burn-inだが、クールタイムが2秒だった。生値は保持し、採用・棄却の統計的根拠には使用しない。同じ初期5候補の適合した再測定は `screen-repeat-*.json` に保持し、上の採否用統計へ加えた。後続バッチと正式全体比較も統合候補を評価する。 |候補|条件|変更前 ns/frame|変更後 ns/frame| |---|---|---:|---:| |eq-cache|fixed|8.595|8.586| |eq-cache|frequency|27.677|21.339| |eq-cache|gain|28.522|23.558| |eq-cache|q|28.830|19.364| |eq-cache-peak|fixed|8.586|8.327| |eq-cache-peak|frequency|27.772|16.929| |eq-cache-peak|gain|28.545|20.971| |eq-cache-peak|q|28.880|11.819| |eq-cache-peak-soa|fixed|8.624|4.870| |eq-cache-peak-soa|frequency|27.891|17.775| |eq-cache-peak-soa|gain|28.444|19.028| |eq-cache-peak-soa|q|28.946|15.901| |reverb-exp|damping|14.161|13.967| |reverb-exp|decay|62.077|31.668| |reverb-exp|fixed|9.878|9.993| |reverb-pade|damping|14.079|13.829| |reverb-pade|decay|62.425|17.731| |reverb-pade|fixed|9.894|9.919| ## 音声誤差 44.1/48/96/192 kHz、固定・無効・無音・切替・パラメータ急変・連続変化・30秒尾部を比較。通常区間は4秒。相対値は誤差RMS / 参照RMS、tailは入力終了後。`exact` は差が0。 |候補|条件数|最悪RMS比 dB|最悪tail RMS比 dB|最大絶対誤差|非有限出力| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| |eq-cache|44|exact|exact|0|0| |eq-cache-peak|44|exact|exact|0|0| |eq-cache-peak-pade|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-cache-peak-soa|44|exact|exact|0|0| |eq-cache-peak-soa-pade|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-canonical|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-gain-exp2|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-gain-exp2-root|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-gain-pade|44|-159.19|-159.12|4.29843e-08|0| |eq-gain-pade-root|44|-159.19|-159.12|4.29843e-08|0| |eq-pade-scale|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |eq-v2|44|-163.26|-163.26|3.48661e-08|0| |reverb-exp|40|-311.90|-311.06|3.33067e-16|0| |reverb-pade|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-balanced|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-cache|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-cache-damping|40|-170.88|-169.24|1.4687e-09|0| |reverb-pade-f32|40|-135.65|-134.62|1.2941e-07|0| |reverb-pade-paired|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-projection|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-projection-f32|40|-135.96|-134.87|1.07698e-07|0| |reverb-pade-split|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-pade-split-f32|40|-135.65|-134.62|1.2941e-07|0| |reverb-pade4|40|-117.86|-114.99|2.28504e-07|0| |reverb-pade8|40|-154.86|-152.05|3.32198e-09|0| |reverb-ring-eager|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-ring-f32|40|-135.96|-134.87|1.07698e-07|0| |reverb-ring-f32-damping|40|-135.96|-134.87|1.07698e-07|0| |reverb-ring-f64|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-ring-f64-damping|40|-170.88|-169.24|1.4687e-09|0| |reverb-ring-nonempty|40|-191.21|-188.42|5.09556e-11|0| |reverb-ring-pade4|40|-117.86|-114.99|2.28499e-07|0| |reverb-ring-pade8|40|-154.86|-152.05|3.31757e-09|0| FDN内部f32では極小の尾部が丸めとflush-to-zeroの床へ達し、f64の減衰との差が拡大する。225条件の12秒試験では通常の全区間の最悪RMS比は−124.17 dB、tailは−121.83 dBだった。各条件で相対誤差が最大の一秒窓のうち、−80 dBを超えた窓の参照RMSは最大6.95e−42(約−823 dBFS)だった。無音を分母にした誤差率として解釈せず、窓ごとの参照RMSもCSVに保存する。 追加のT60=10秒・120秒尾部27条件では、全3240個の一秒窓も保存した。−80 dBを超えた窓は304個あり、その中で最も大きい参照RMSは3.52e−28(−549.07 dBFS)。全区間では最悪−124.19 dB、tailでは−122.24 dB、最大絶対誤差6.95e−7。`long-tail-windows.csv` と `long-tail-window-summary.json` を参照。 `ring-boundary.json` は最大遅延がリング容量と一致する4境界、Size切替、prepare失敗後の1,597,440フレームを同じ係数の独立リングと比較しビット一致した結果。共通リングは8本のcursorとwarmupを1つずつへ集約し、遅延長を変えずに2の冪maskで参照する。 全raw値は `screen-*.json`、計測前の順序・binary SHAは `screen-*-plan.json`、音声の個別条件は `error-*.json`。各buildディレクトリに計測binaryと対応する固定sourceを保持。