"""保存済みの各探索バッチ・精度・資源比較を図示する。新しい計時は行わない。""" from pathlib import Path import csv import json import hashlib import matplotlib matplotlib.use('Agg') import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np R = Path(__file__).resolve().parent OUT = R / 'figures' OUT.mkdir(exist_ok=True) records = [] summary = json.loads((R / 'comparison-summary.json').read_text()) def save(fig, name, sources, effect, topic, caption): fig.tight_layout() for extension in ('png', 'svg'): fig.savefig(OUT / f'{name}.{extension}', dpi=150) plt.close(fig) records.append(dict(name=name, effect=effect, topic=topic, caption=caption, sources=sources, png_sha256=hashlib.sha256((OUT/f'{name}.png').read_bytes()).hexdigest())) def paired_plot(rows, name, title, effect, sources, topic, caption, historical=False, before_label='Original draft', after_label='Independent candidate', unit='ns / stereo frame'): fig, axes = plt.subplots(1, 2, figsize=(13, max(3.8, .4*len(rows)+1.7)), gridspec_kw={'width_ratios':[1.1, 1]}) y = np.arange(len(rows)) a=np.array([x['before'] for x in rows]);b=np.array([x['after'] for x in rows]) labels=[x['label'] for x in rows] axes[0].barh(y-.16,a,.3,label=before_label,color='#738da8') axes[0].barh(y+.16,b,.3,label=after_label,color='#8e8e8e' if historical else '#319a7c') axes[0].legend(fontsize=9,loc='best');axes[0].set_xlabel('Mean '+unit) for i,x in enumerate(rows): delta=x['delta'];lo,hi=x['ci'] color='#777777' if historical or x.get('holm',1)>=.05 else ('#087755' if delta<0 else '#b24435') axes[1].errorbar(delta,i,xerr=[[max(0,delta-lo)],[max(0,hi-delta)]],fmt='o',capsize=3,color=color) axes[1].axvline(0,color='#777777',lw=1) axes[1].set_xlabel('After - before, '+unit+'\nPointwise 95% CI; lower is faster') for ax in axes: ax.set_yticks(y,labels);ax.invert_yaxis();ax.grid(axis='x',alpha=.18) footer='Historical diagnostic: 2 s cooldown; excluded from decision statistics' if historical else 'Exploratory 10-block comparison; color uses the stated family Holm correction' fig.suptitle(title+'\n'+footer,fontsize=11,color='#8d4e30' if historical else '#202020') save(fig,name,sources,effect,topic,caption) TOPICS={ 'screen-eq-gain-exp2-eq-gain-pade.json':('Gain操作時の指数関数','Gainのexp2と範囲限定Padéを、元draftから独立に比較。'), 'screen-eq-gain-exp2-root-eq-gain-pade-root.json':('Shelfのsqrt(A)キャッシュ','sqrt(A)を保持しAを二乗で得る案。元draftからの値であり、既存キャッシュ案との差は別表の対応を参照。'), 'screen-eq-v2-eq-canonical.json':('積分器の等価式','v2=s2+g*v1、さらにv1を集約した等価式。命令数の削減と速度差を分けて評価。'), 'screen-repeat-reverb-exp-reverb-pade-eq-cache-eq-cache-peak-eq-cache-peak-soa.json':('初期候補の規定準拠再測定','初期5候補の同じbinaryを、10ブロック・200 ms以上と最低1周のburn-in・5秒クールタイムで再比較。'), 'screen-reverb-exp-reverb-pade-eq-cache-eq-cache-peak-eq-cache-peak-soa.json':('初期候補の診断記録','2秒クールタイムの旧診断。採否の根拠から除外し、後の同一binary再測定と分けて保存。'), 'screen-reverb-pade-cache-damping-reverb-ring-f64-damping-reverb-ring-f32-damping.json':('Dampingの指数計算','DampingにもPadéを使った独立候補。f64/f32リングと指数キャッシュの交換条件を比較。'), 'screen-reverb-pade-cache-reverb-pade-f32-reverb-pade-split-f32-eq-pade-scale-param-reverb-param-eq.json':('係数保持・精度・対数換算','Decay係数の保持、f32化、プリワープ倍率保持、追加パラメータ換算。換算処理はns/updateとして音声とは別図。'), 'screen-reverb-pade-projection-reverb-pade-balanced-reverb-pade-projection-f32.json':('出力射影と加算順序','二組の符号和へまとめる射影と帰還の加算順序。f32候補も独立に比較。'), 'screen-reverb-pade8-reverb-pade4-reverb-pade-split-reverb-pade-paired-eq-cache-peak-soa-pade-eq-cache-peak-pade.json':('近似式と並列配置','Decay二乗回数、FDNループ分割、EQ tan近似と左右状態配置。元draftからの独立候補。'), 'screen-reverb-ring-f64-reverb-ring-f32.json':('8本の履歴管理の共有','共通の2の冪リングをf64/f32で比較。遅延長と初回到着は同じ。'), 'screen-reverb-ring-pade8-reverb-ring-pade4.json':('共通リング上の二乗回数','共通リングとDamping Padéを組み合わせ、Decayの縮小率を8/4へ変更した候補。'), } all_rows=summary['performance']+summary['historical_diagnostics'] for index,raw in enumerate(sorted({x['raw'] for x in all_rows}),1): topic,caption=TOPICS[raw] for effect in ('reverb','eq'): for kind in ('audio','parameters'): selected=[x for x in all_rows if x['raw']==raw and (x['variant'].startswith(effect) or x['variant']=='param-'+effect) and ((x['mode']=='parameters')==(kind=='parameters'))] if not selected: continue rows=[dict(label=x['variant'].removeprefix(effect+'-')+' / '+x['mode'], before=x['before_mean_ns'],after=x['after_mean_ns'],delta=x['delta_ns'], ci=x['delta_ci95'],holm=x.get('holm_p',1)) for x in selected] paired_plot(rows,f'{effect}-batch-{index:02d}-{kind}',f'{effect.title()} / batch {index:02d}',effect, [raw,'comparison-summary.json','protocol-audit.json'],topic,caption, historical=not selected[0]['protocol_eligible'], unit='ns / update' if kind=='parameters' else 'ns / stereo frame') stage5=json.loads((R/'stage5/comparison-summary.json').read_text()) rows=[dict(label=x['mode'],before=x['before']['mean'],after=x['after']['mean'], delta=x['difference']['mean'],ci=x['difference_ci95'],holm=x['holm_p']) for x in stage5] paired_plot(rows,'reverb-pade-direct','Reverb: direct Pade comparison','reverb', ['stage5/comparison-summary.json','stage5/performance-observations.json'], 'Padé[3/3]/4とPadé[2/2]/8の直接選択', '同じf64共通リングの係数式だけを比較。3比較のHolm補正で追加短縮が明確でなく、精度余裕の大きい3/3を選択。', before_label='Pade[3/3] / 4',after_label='Pade[2/2] / 8') for effect in ('reverb','eq'): values=[] for name,x in summary['error'].items(): if name.startswith(effect): values.append((name,x['relative_rms_db'],x['tail_relative_rms_db'],x['maximum_absolute'])) for stage in ('stage2','stage3','stage4'): for x in json.loads((R/stage/'audio-summary.json').read_text())['regular']: if x['candidate'].startswith(effect): values.append((stage+'/'+x['candidate'],x['worst_relative_rms_db'],x['worst_tail_relative_rms_db'],x['max_absolute'])) fig,axes=plt.subplots(1,2,figsize=(14,max(4,.32*len(values)+1.8))) for i,(name,whole,tail,absolute) in enumerate(values): for v,marker,color,offset in [(whole,'o','#267d67',-.08),(tail,'x','#b16a33',.08)]: if v==-999 and marker=='o': axes[0].text(-335,i,'exact',fontsize=7,va='center') elif v==-999: pass else: axes[0].scatter(v,i+offset,marker=marker,color=color,s=20) if absolute: axes[1].scatter(absolute,i,color='#267d67',s=20) else: axes[1].text(1e-17,i,'exact',fontsize=7,va='center') axes[0].axvline(-80,color='#bd4f3e',ls='--',label='-80 dB criterion') axes[0].scatter([],[],marker='o',color='#267d67',label='Whole interval');axes[0].scatter([],[],marker='x',color='#b16a33',label='Tail interval') axes[0].legend(fontsize=8,loc='lower right');axes[0].set_xlim(-340,-65) axes[0].set_xlabel('Worst error RMS / reference RMS (dB)') axes[1].set_xscale('log');axes[1].set_xlim(1e-18,10**np.ceil(np.log10(max(x[3] for x in values)))) axes[1].set_xlabel('Maximum absolute sample error') labels=[x[0].replace(effect+'-','') for x in values] for ax in axes: ax.set_yticks(range(len(values)),labels,fontsize=8);ax.invert_yaxis();ax.grid(axis='x',alpha=.2) fig.suptitle(effect.title()+': ordinary audio / rapid changes / tail accuracy\nEach row summarizes its recorded conditions; exact means zero observed error',fontsize=11) save(fig,effect+'-accuracy-all',['comparison-summary.json','stage2/audio-summary.json','stage3/audio-summary.json','stage4/audio-summary.json'],effect, '全候補の通常音声・急変・尾部誤差','各候補の記録した条件中の最大値。参照は元draft。丸印は全区間、×印は尾部全区間。極小の1秒窓は別図で基準RMSとともに扱う。exactは観測差0。') memory=json.loads((R/'memory.json').read_text());fig,ax=plt.subplots(figsize=(8,4)) for key,label in [('before_bytes','Original: 8 independent f64 lines'),('ring_f64_bytes','Shared ring f64'),('ring_f32_bytes','Shared ring f32')]: ax.plot([x['rate']/1000 for x in memory],[x[key]/1048576 for x in memory],marker='o',label=label) ax.set_xlabel('Sample rate (kHz)');ax.set_ylabel('Delay history (MiB)');ax.grid(alpha=.2);ax.legend();ax.set_title('Reverb: history memory versus sample rate') save(fig,'reverb-memory',['memory.json'],'reverb','共通リングのメモリ交換条件','共通cursor/validによる短縮と引き換えに、全列の容量を揃える。履歴のbytesのみをMiBへ換算し、State全体の大きさとは区別する。') windows=list(csv.DictReader((R/'long-tail-windows.csv').open())) fig,axes=plt.subplots(1,2,figsize=(11,4.4)) for rate,color in zip(sorted({int(x['rate']) for x in windows}), ['#267d67','#b16a33','#567faf']): rs=[x for x in windows if float(x['rate'])==rate] db=20*np.log10([float(x['reference_rms']) for x in rs]);err=[float(x['error_relative_db']) for x in rs] axes[0].scatter([float(x['second']) for x in rs],db,s=6,alpha=.4,color=color,label=f'{rate/1000:g} kHz') axes[1].scatter(db,err,s=6,alpha=.4,color=color,label=f'{rate/1000:g} kHz') axes[0].set_xlabel('One-second window start (s)');axes[0].set_ylabel('Reference RMS (dBFS)') axes[1].set_xlabel('Reference RMS (dBFS)');axes[1].set_ylabel('Window error RMS / reference RMS (dB)');axes[1].axhline(-80,color='#bd4f3e',ls='--') for ax in axes:ax.grid(alpha=.2);ax.legend(fontsize=8) fig.suptitle('Reverb f32: 27 long tails, T60=10 s, all 3240 one-second windows') save(fig,'reverb-f32-long-tail',['long-tail-windows.csv','long-tail-window-summary.json'],'reverb','f32の極小尾部と相対誤差','全27条件・3240窓を表示。−80 dBを超える304窓で最も大きい参照RMSも−549.07 dBFSだった。通常区間の誤差と極小分母で拡大する比を区別する。') assembly=json.loads((R/'assembly-summary.json').read_text()) for effect in ('reverb','eq'): rows=[x for x in assembly if x['variant'].startswith(effect)] fig,axes=plt.subplots(1,2,figsize=(10,max(3.5,.45*len(rows)+1.7))) labels=[x['variant'].removeprefix(effect+'-') for x in rows];ys=np.arange(len(rows)) axes[0].barh(ys,[x['instructions'] for x in rows],color='#267d67');axes[0].set_xlabel('Instructions in sample function') axes[1].barh(ys,[x['function_bytes'] for x in rows],color='#738da8');axes[1].set_xlabel('Function code size (bytes)') for ax in axes:ax.set_yticks(ys,labels);ax.invert_yaxis();ax.grid(axis='x',alpha=.2) fig.suptitle(effect.title()+': assembly inspection (counts are not execution time)') save(fig,effect+'-assembly',['assembly-summary.json'],effect,'命令数削減と処理時間の違い','命令数とコードサイズを図示。速度は対応する計時図で判断し、この図だけから高速化を断定しない。') domain=json.loads((R/'stage2/coefficient-domain.json').read_text()) other=json.loads((R/'stage3/coefficient-domain.json').read_text()) names=['Taylor5 / 16','Taylor4 / 32','Pade[3/3] / 4','Pade[2/2] / 8','Pade[2/2] / 16'] items=[domain['taylor5'],domain['taylor4'],domain['pade4'],*other] fig,axes=plt.subplots(1,2,figsize=(11,4)) for key,ax,label in [('max_absolute_error',axes[0],'Maximum absolute gain error'),('max_relative_error',axes[1],'Maximum relative gain error')]: ax.barh(names,[x[key] for x in items],color='#267d67');ax.set_xscale('log');ax.set_xlabel(label);ax.invert_yaxis();ax.grid(axis='x',alpha=.2) fig.suptitle('Decay coefficient: 1,000,001 points over exponent [-11.28, 0]\nEvery recorded candidate remains finite and in (0, 1]') save(fig,'reverb-coefficient-error',['stage2/coefficient-domain.json','stage3/coefficient-domain.json'],'reverb', '強減衰での係数絶対誤差と相対誤差','各式の同じ指数域100万区間を走査した保存値。強減衰では係数自体が小さいため、係数の相対誤差だけで音声誤差を判断せず、絶対差と音声比較を併用する。') grids=[('f32','grid-f32.csv'),('Pade[3/3]/16','grid-pade16.csv'),('Taylor5/16','stage2/grid-reverb-ring-taylor5.csv'), ('Taylor4/32','stage2/grid-reverb-ring-taylor4.csv'),('Pade[3/3]/4','stage2/grid-reverb-ring-decay4.csv'), ('Pade[2/2]/8','stage3/grid-reverb-ring-pade22-8.csv'),('Pade[2/2]/16','stage3/grid-reverb-ring-pade22-16.csv')] fig,axes=plt.subplots(1,2,figsize=(12,5)) for label,path in grids: rows=list(csv.DictReader((R/path).open()));times=sorted({float(x['decay']) for x in rows}) relative=[max(float(x['relative_db']) for x in rows if float(x['decay'])==t) for t in times] absolute=[max(float(x['max_absolute']) for x in rows if float(x['decay'])==t) for t in times] axes[0].plot(times,relative,marker='o',ms=3,label=label);axes[1].plot(times,absolute,marker='o',ms=3,label=label) axes[0].set_ylabel('Worst whole-interval error RMS ratio (dB)');axes[0].axhline(-80,color='#bd4f3e',ls='--');axes[0].legend(fontsize=7) axes[1].set_yscale('log');axes[1].set_ylabel('Maximum absolute sample error') for ax in axes:ax.set_xscale('log');ax.set_xlabel('T60 setting (s)');ax.grid(alpha=.2) fig.suptitle('Reverb: 225 settings per candidate\nAt each T60, show the worst over recorded sample rates, Damping and Size') save(fig,'reverb-grid-accuracy',[p for _,p in grids],'reverb','225設定での帰還誤差の拡大','各T60で、記録したFs・Damping・Sizeのうち最大となる誤差を表示。図の最大値だけでなく全225条件のCSVを保存している。') parameters=json.loads((R/'parameter-error.json').read_text()) fig,ax=plt.subplots(figsize=(6.5,3.5)) ax.barh(['Reverb','EQ'],[parameters['result'][x]['max_relative'] for x in ['reverb','eq']],color='#267d67') ax.set_xlabel('Maximum relative error of extra parameter conversion');ax.ticklabel_format(axis='x',style='sci',scilimits=(0,0));ax.grid(axis='x',alpha=.2) ax.set_title('Equivalent pow -> exp2 conversion\n100,001 normalized points per extra parameter') save(fig,'parameter-conversion-error',['parameter-error.json'],'both','対数軸の等価換算','追加パラメータを正規化値100001点で比較した最大相対差。音声RMS誤差や処理時間とは単位を分けて示す。') (OUT/'manifest.json').write_text(json.dumps(records,indent=2,ensure_ascii=False)+'\n') print('generated',len(records),'figures')