{
  "reviewer": {
    "model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "reasoningEffort": "high",
    "role": "Independent hostile validator"
  },
  "scope": "Administration and ACL extension after the completed Phase 0–6 baseline",
  "verdict": "APPROVE",
  "accuracyScore": 99,
  "completenessScore": 99,
  "scoreScale": 100,
  "unresolvedFindings": [],
  "rubric": {
    "accuracy": "Authorization, concurrency, retry semantics, catalog integrity, privacy and UI behavior agree with the reviewed design and observed evidence.",
    "completeness": "Requested administration pages, word/hint management, role assignment, private environment bootstrap, documentation and relevant verification are present.",
    "approvalThreshold": "At least 98 in both categories, with no unresolved material finding.",
    "qualification": "Scores express review judgment, not statistical guarantees."
  },
  "snapshot": {
    "repository": "\u003Crepo\u003E",
    "baseCommit": "435be05abac5310172cfb9a9290c9d7ea0d1cbde",
    "type": "Local working-tree snapshot",
    "manifest": "\u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs-local/admin-source-manifest.json",
    "fileCount": 189,
    "snapshotSha256": "5c9bcee1f2133751fe786416eed769c14c77a171a3050a15437726ef4493f7df",
    "algorithm": "SHA256 over UTF-8 lines in listed files-array order: file SHA256, two spaces, relative path, LF.",
    "independentVerification": "All 189 listed file hashes match current files. Recomputed snapshot digest matches the recorded digest."
  },
  "assessment": {
    "authorization": "Permissions are derived from authenticated profiles and trusted server configuration. Administrative SQL independently authorizes directory reads and mutations. Browser database roles cannot execute the privileged ACL functions.",
    "bootstrap": "WORDPAIRS_ADMIN_PROFILE_IDS is private server configuration containing explicit profile IDs. There is no first-user assignment, default administrator credential or browser-controlled bootstrap.",
    "concurrency": "Exclusive ACL locking serializes role changes and final-administrator checks. Content operations acquire the corresponding shared lock before loading authoritative roles. The repaired integration test verifies an actual writer waiting behind revocation.",
    "retries": "ACL authorization precedes canonical replay, so revoked administrators cannot recover authority through historical commands. Replayed successful grants do not reapply removed roles. Existing content replay remains mutation-free.",
    "catalog": "Editorial changes append the next immutable pair version without moving IDs between categories. Community activation requires previously unused IDs at version zero. Historical round lookups remain available; future selection uses the highest version and never falls back after exclusion. Both publication paths enforce the 4096-version ceiling.",
    "interface": "Administration pages provide moderation, word/hint editing and user-role management. Identity binding, uncertain-write retries and stale-response invalidation protect private UI state. Reviewed phone captures show readable forms and controls without visible clipping."
  },
  "resolvedFindings": [
    {
      "id": "ADMIN-DESIGN-001",
      "issue": "Publishing beyond 4096 historical versions could make catalog reads unavailable.",
      "resolution": "Both editorial saves and community activation reject projected overflow before mutation. Pure and PostgreSQL evidence cover rejection and preserved state/history.",
      "status": "RESOLVED"
    },
    {
      "id": "ADMIN-DESIGN-002",
      "issue": "Newest-selectable wording could imply fallback to an older excluded pair version.",
      "resolution": "Design explicitly specifies highest-version selection followed by selectability filtering.",
      "status": "RESOLVED"
    },
    {
      "id": "ADMIN-IMPLEMENTATION-001",
      "issue": "A delayed authorized GET could repopulate privileged data after mutation denial.",
      "resolution": "Both private UI owners increment their request generation before clearing data. Browser regressions exercise delayed GET, POST 403 and late GET completion for users and moderation.",
      "status": "RESOLVED"
    },
    {
      "id": "ADMIN-IMPLEMENTATION-002",
      "issue": "Community activation bypassed pair identity and version invariants.",
      "originalEvidence": "Independent execution of the actual domain source accepted heroes-01, originally category heroes/version 0, in hv-weather/version 99.",
      "resolution": "Activation now requires unused IDs at version zero. Regression assertions separately reject reused IDs at version zero, cross-category reuse and skipped versions.",
      "status": "RESOLVED"
    },
    {
      "id": "ADMIN-EVIDENCE-001",
      "issue": "Manifest algorithm description incorrectly claimed ordinal sorting.",
      "resolution": "Description now specifies listed-files order. Every file hash and the aggregate digest independently reproduce.",
      "status": "RESOLVED"
    }
  ],
  "independentChecks": [
    "Read-only examination of domain/application policies, repository adapters, migration 010, runtime configuration, API handlers, administration UI and linked design documents.",
    "Executed 18 focused tests across five files covering access policy, catalog administration, admin transport and existing content behavior; all passed on the final snapshot.",
    "Inspected delayed-response browser regressions and PostgreSQL authorization, concurrency, rollback, history, capacity and actual-route composition tests.",
    "Inspected both phone screenshots independently.",
    "Read saved production build, final unit, PostgreSQL rerun and production-browser completion logs.",
    "Verified all 189 manifest hashes and reproduced the snapshot digest."
  ],
  "implementerRunEvidence": {
    "finalDefaultSuite": {
      "result": "502/502 tests passed across 42 files",
      "logReviewed": "\u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs-local/admin-unit-completion.log"
    },
    "finalPostgreSQLSuite": {
      "result": "66/66 tests passed across 10 files; migration and SQL checks passed",
      "durationSeconds": 377.85,
      "logReviewed": "\u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs-local/admin-postgres-rerun-completion.log"
    },
    "focusedAdministrationPostgreSQL": {
      "result": "8/8 passed, reported by implementer",
      "scope": "Includes actual Request handlers, trusted environment bootstrap and real database persistence; test database TLS factory seam substituted."
    },
    "fullBrowserSuite": {
      "result": "31/31 journeys passed, reported by implementer"
    },
    "productionAdministrationBrowser": {
      "result": "5/5 journeys passed",
      "logReviewed": "\u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs-local/admin-production-browser-completion.log"
    },
    "productionBuild": {
      "result": "Passed, exit 0",
      "logReviewed": "\u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs-local/admin-build-completion.log"
    },
    "typecheckAndLint": "Passed, reported by implementer"
  },
  "evidenceQualifications": [
    "The reviewer independently ran the focused 18-test suite, not the full database or browser suites.",
    "Administration browser tests use disclosed HTTP fixtures. The catalog journey exercises the actual content service/domain with an in-memory transaction port; those tests alone do not prove database authorization.",
    "Separate real PostgreSQL and actual route-handler tests supply persistence and server-authorization evidence.",
    "Phone inspection was agent visual review and browser automation; no personal human sign-off or human testing is claimed.",
    "The first full PostgreSQL run passed 65/66 and timed out at 60 seconds in the 25-player fixture. Its failure log is preserved. Increasing only that fixture's wall-clock budget to 120 seconds retained all eight-round assertions; the subsequent complete run passed.",
    "Approval binds to the verified local snapshot, not an independently verified new remote commit."
  ],
  "disposition": "The reviewed administration/ACL extension is technically ready and approved. No unresolved material correctness, security, completeness or usability finding remains.",
  "scopeLimits": [
    "This extension does not reopen historical Phase 0–6 approvals.",
    "This report does not authorize or claim external deployment, branch movement, PR publication or Phase 7 completion.",
    "The reviewer made no implementation, test, configuration or documentation changes and preserved the preceding multiplayer work."
  ]
}