{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-plan-initial","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary from available conversation summary","text":"Review the UI implementation plan against UI-DEC-01..08 and the 13 pending records, read-only."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary, not verbatim","findings":["Explicit profile editing must be draft-only until Save; Cancel must issue no preference write.","Separate safe drafts and uncertain intents by profile/session generation plus form/resource; retain exact pending command across navigation, shared lock, no uncertain Cancel, and inert stale completions."],"requiredEvidence":["Cancel mutation count","Delayed navigation/session/denial completions and exact canonical retry"]},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":97},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-plan-revised","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Updated docs/testing/ui/implementation-plan.md with explicit draft-only profile Save/Cancel (no preference write on Cancel), separate draft/intent lifecycles keyed by session generation plus form/resource, shared lock, canonical retention across navigation, no uncertain Cancel, stale completion guards and delayed-completion tests. Please recheck the plan read-only and report approval/confidence. Actual repo \u003Chome\u003E/github/WordGame/.mcpServer/wordpairs."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary, not verbatim","resolved":["Both initial plan findings explicitly incorporated."],"limits":["Plan approval only; implementation and tests not yet approved."]},"verdict":"APPROVE_PLAN","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-autocontinue-plan-initial","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary","text":"Review automatic no-solver continuation through existing stage deadline after a three-second summary delay."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary, not verbatim","findings":["Catalog revision mismatch must not return terminal CONFLICT for a still-valid system deadline, because dispatcher would acknowledge it and strand the summary."],"clarifications":["Three seconds is an automatic delay; manual Continue may advance sooner. Late worker starts a full twenty-second initial stage at actual current time."],"requiredEvidence":["Early/exact/late deadline","Both manual/deadline orders","Duplicate delivery","No ninth round","Actual SQL catalog revision race retaining retryable job"]},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED","scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Incremental source review was explicitly unscored."},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-autocontinue-plan-revised","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Amendment now written at bottom of docs/testing/ui/implementation-plan.md, with all requested catalog retry/timing/actor/ordering/no-ninth regressions. Please confirm plan approval after recheck; implementation of this amendment has not begun yet."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reconstructed summary, not verbatim","resolved":["Retryable TEMPORARY_UNAVAILABLE for system-deadline catalog race, original system actor, chronological timing, replay and terminal-round evidence included."],"limits":["Plan approval, not completed implementation proof."]},"verdict":"APPROVE_PLAN","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-source-first","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Please begin independent hostile source review of UI implementation, read-only, against docs/testing/ui/implementation-plan.md and UI-DEC01..08/new QBrain criteria (docs/testing/ui/requirements.json). Files: src/domain/model.ts,content.ts; src/application/content.ts,matches.ts; src/infrastructure/match-repository.ts,migrations/011_content_review_states.sql; src/web/private-state.ts,private-draft.tsx,use-private-intent.ts,identity-panel.tsx,content-panel.tsx,admin-panel.tsx,game-panel.tsx,play-hub.tsx; internal anchors converted NextLink in app/nav and social/landing. New tests ui-content-workflows,ui-autocontinue,private-state; browser ui-gaps fixture/spec and added2-client nosolver in matches.phase4; SQL additions admin.integration +matches.integration. Prior full unit539pass. First expanded UI14/16passed; last2Chromiumcrashed on oversized fullpage screenshots, now viewport-only; full browser regression running. Full disposableSQL runner actively progressing through2..25service games (lastinspection21players), then remaining suites. Review source now and report defects promptly; final evidence/docs/readback to follow. Do not alter files or run live requirements writes."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"complete substantive findings reconstructed from available summary and retained source-review messages; not a verbatim transcript","findings":[{"id":"UI-HV-001","severity":"P2","problem":"Successful mutation result is lost if response settles while its original consumer is unmounted.","reproduction":"Create private room, navigate away before200, let success settle, return. Ledger has neither pending intent nor room destination; UI can create another room.","requiredCorrection":"Retain scoped settled result until current consumer acknowledges its callback, without repeating write."},{"id":"UI-HV-002","severity":"P2","problem":"Private generation changes only with profile ID, not same-profile session replacement.","reproduction":"Replace verified session with another session for the same profile between reads; private drafts/intents survive.","requiredCorrection":"Non-authenticating server-derived verified session marker and same-profile replacement regression."},{"id":"UI-HV-003","severity":"P2","problem":"GamePanel POST authorization denial does not invalidate pending GET; late former authorized projection restores game hints. SocialPanel has equivalent generation gap; RoomSession POST denial does not clear private state.","requiredCorrection":"Current denial invalidates read/lifecycle ownership and clears private state on all relevant surfaces; deferred GET→POST403→lateGET regressions."},{"id":"UI-HV-004","severity":"evidence gap","problem":"Responsive matrix samples focus/colors but does not trigger accepted score/stage/error live announcements and assert focus preservation.","requiredCorrection":"Actual GamePanel browser DOM live-region and activeElement regression; do not claim physical screen-reader execution."}],"positiveFindings":["No additional domain review-state, forward migration, no-solver timing or catalog-retry defect found."],"independentVerification":{"command":"npm test -- tests/application/ui-content-workflows.test.ts tests/application/ui-autocontinue.test.ts tests/web/private-state.test.ts","testsPassed":7,"filesPassed":3,"exitCode":0,"limits":"Focused tests, not full browser/SQL execution; parent-owned heavy runs not repeated."}},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED","scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Incremental source review was explicitly unscored."},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-discovery-plan","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Remaining fixes being applied + tests. Also source inspection reveals UI-DEC08 discovery links currently indistinguishable from direct invites: landing board simply links /rooms/id, and late seat loss stays on full room instead of returning fresh browsing. Proposed small amendment: discovery-only ?from=discovery marker passed by server room page; if authoritative view/join loses availability and visitor has no current membership, replace to /?seatLost=1#community, reload board first page and safe seat-lost status. Direct room/code/invite links omit marker and retain observer path. No membership changes on navigation. Add browser discovery-seat-loss vs direct-full observer regression and invalid-code correction/rate-window case (existing service authority unchanged). Please review amendment; continuing unrelated denial/result/session fixes."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reviewer message verbatim","text":"Amendment APPROVE as a design, accuracy 99/completeness 99, with these implementation constraints: (1) treat from=discovery solely as UX provenance, never authority; direct invitation/code behavior stays unchanged; (2) redirect only from an owned current-generation authoritative no-membership/unavailable result—do not redirect from an old preview while a join is in flight or its outcome is uncertain; first resolve/replay that canonical join so a successful last-seat winner is not sent away; (3) force the returned board to first-page fresh=1, not just a normal cached refresh, and keep unavailable/retry honest if refresh fails; (4) a current member must never be bounced merely because the room becomes full/countdown. Regressions should include both join race loser and winner/accepted-response-lost, plus direct-full observer and invalid-code/rate recovery. This closes an existing UI-DEC-08 obligation rather than adding a new admission policy."},"verdict":"APPROVE_PLAN","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-source-rereview","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"All findings repaired. Full browser run55/55 pass docs/evidence/ui-gaps/browser-final.log; full unit542/542 pass unit.log; disposableSQL68/68 pass postgres.log incl2..25service games +catalog race. Newtests prove settled private-room destination acrossnavigation, same-profile replacement session generation, game/social/room lateGET403 denial, actual stage/score/error live region+focus, native profile Cancel/Escape no-write/focus, discovery winner/loser/canonical503/full directobserver/code. Source/notes: purpose-separated verified sessionGeneration API +privateIdentityRevision keyedcomponents; ledger retained settled results acknowledged after callback; admin saved-form callback handles unmount/remount; Game/Social/Room denial incrementsreadgen. New discoveredseat correction follows your UX-only/currentmember/uncertainwinner/fresh=1 safeguards andtests pass. Strengthening just code-window fixture to assert blocked until controlled60s interval; focused4seat rerun next. Please re-review final source now; docs/QBrain/export/productionbuild and SHA manifest in progress, final approval after those receipts. No code edits by reviewer."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"provenance":"reviewer findings messages verbatim","findings":[{"id":"UI-HV-005","severity":"P2","text":"Re-review found one remaining lifecycle defect introduced by the denial repair: GamePanel refresh/send and SocialPanel refresh call deny() immediately on 401/403/404 before checking their captured generation/lifecycle. If the component unmounts or session changes while that request is pending, its late denial still runs; GamePanel deny() calls global invalidatePrivateState(), deleting the new session’s drafts/intents. Room command already checks epoch before denial, which is the correct pattern. Guard ownership before processing denial (still drain every body), and add old-session/unmounted GET or POST → new-session draft → old403 regression. Current prior regression only covers late200 after a current denial, so misses the reverse ordering."},{"id":"UI-HV-006","severity":"P2","text":"Discovery race follow-up: redirect evaluation runs before the monotonic setRoom guard, and a successful join does not invalidate an older in-flight preview. Concrete ordering: preview GET snapshots a temporarily full outsider view and stalls; racer leaves; Alice joins successfully (canonical200); send clears pending and refresh coalesces behind that old GET; old no-role/full snapshot returns after command finishes and triggers seatLost despite Alice now being a member. Retire pre-command reads after a successful membership mutation or gate redirects on a fresh post-resolution read/version. Current winner test returns a current member projection on refresh, so does not cover this stale-preview ordering."}],"priorCorrections":"Retained settled result and purpose-separated session marker source address UI-HV-001/002. Current-denial invalidation addresses the original UI-HV-003 direction but introduces UI-HV-005. Parent reports UI-HV-004 regression passing; final evidence mapping remains pending.","evidenceLimits":"Parent reports55 browser/542 unit/68 SQL pass. These are implementer-run counts, not independent reruns. Two remaining races prevent final approval."},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED","scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Incremental source review was explicitly unscored."},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-receipt-preservation-and-contest","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"User now asks contest compliance and explicitly keep all HV receipts for the submission. Preserve ALL your review rounds from this UI implementation in a new append-only docs/evidence/ui-gaps/hostile-validation.jsonl: complete available request, rubric, report/findings, corrections, scores or explicitly unscored, candidate source hashes/commit and evidence limits. Include rejected/superseded rounds, no invented verbatim/history; label reconstructed summaries if needed. Do not alter implementation. I will fix latest two races. Also independently inspect official contest rules PDF https://go.joinhandshake.com/rs/390-ZTF-353/images/%5BAI_Skills_Studio_Challenge%5D_Contest_Official_Rules.pdf?version=0 and public brief https://joinhandshake.com/learn/create-a-multiplayer-game-8d7d59b5/ for overlooked blockers. Critical deadline conflict: public October31 vs binding PDF October30 2026 23:59PT. Full mission behind auth/security, Code of Conduct referenced but not linked in PDF. Keep rule paraphrase compact (<200 words total derived PDF) and link original; can inspect local saved PDF once I download. Report actual compliance gaps, don’t assert entrant age/location/employment. Await code repairs before final approval."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"preservation":"All available UI implementation review rounds preserved above. Historical reconstructed summaries explicitly labeled; unavailable raw transcripts/hashes not invented. Current preservation-time snapshot attached separately below. Append further reviews; do not rewrite these events.","contestSources":{"officialRules":"https://go.joinhandshake.com/rs/390-ZTF-353/images/%5BAI_Skills_Studio_Challenge%5D_Contest_Official_Rules.pdf?version=0","publicBrief":"https://joinhandshake.com/learn/create-a-multiplayer-game-8d7d59b5/","mission":"https://app.joinhandshake.com/learn/create-a-multiplayer-game-8d7d59b5"},"officialRulesParaphrase":"The PDF deadline is October30,2026 23:59PT, earlier than public copy. Mission entry needs title, cover, description and URL. Automated/script/macro entry is prohibited. Entrant eligibility, account/email, location and excluded affiliations remain unverified. The incorporated Code of Conduct was not available in inspected sources. Entrant publicity/project promotional licenses and applicable terms need awareness.","publicBriefAssessment":"Reusable public room-code multiplayer, with no required login/install, and ChatGPT Work are explicit brief requirements. Optional account/PWA features are compatible. An expired temporary endpoint does not establish a reusable public deliverable. Codex evidence alone does not establish Work-mode provenance.","accessLimits":"Official seven-page PDF and public brief independently read via web tools. Mission redirects to login. Search did not locate an authoritative Challenge Code of Conduct; unrelated third-party results not treated as rules. No eligibility claim, legal certification, submission or external publication performed.","outstanding":"Final UI approval awaits UI-HV-005/006 corrections and current evidence. Prior real live2..25 UI matrix remains separate and incomplete; service SQL games do not substitute."},"verdict":"NOT_READY_FOR_FINAL_APPROVAL","scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Incremental source review was explicitly unscored."},"historicalCandidate":{"commit":null,"sourceHashes":null,"qualification":"No contemporaneous immutable snapshot or complete hash inventory was captured for this historical round; do not substitute current hashes."},"preservationSnapshot":{"baseCommit":"435be05abac5310172cfb9a9290c9d7ea0d1cbde","immutableCandidate":false,"capturedAt":"2026-10-28T00:51:41.188367+00:00","qualification":"Dirty working tree; implementer actively repairing source. These hashes identify preservation-time bytes only, not historical reviewed bytes or a final approved snapshot.","files":{"docs/testing/ui/implementation-plan.md":"14af53c84737cf59357f4f19a4b043e6e58a30286056a6db6204934e37cffee5","docs/testing/ui/decisions.md":"da93060bd2dd8249262d191218027a3911f95b31c2f6196fbc6ed5039282b2d6","docs/testing/ui/requirements.json":"285ce5a7c711d2551c02fc8ed617151859be2412c01993f593971b9b07097398","src/domain/model.ts":"203f1b0dd77a9362638f271706cbe4936363c3cf751831434cef2fe44b54b271","src/domain/content.ts":"96415d3568de91769d2c86ba5974b4d1564b1544b068316ec2905e1bba3f9670","src/application/content.ts":"dce7440f073cb81ec247444756913f59e62512f8980b6b6a5328b1c7aa20417a","src/application/matches.ts":"9e059792d487d23510a375d123a913eccb78b39b4a31b3ae01ada178f8e68593","src/infrastructure/match-repository.ts":"ff656dd160a8df1d3a5b21c44b0735c6a4730ae712cdf3b1a4d9fcbca03cb86b","src/infrastructure/migrations/011_content_review_states.sql":"2f4188a6835986c48268346ddd4f2d25e493d8e8dd236dd49caaff9e6beb56dd","src/web/private-state.ts":"98aa2bc4acee7b412920375e5700d41fbc2705554879cdd5637134ff704ddf3e","src/web/private-draft.tsx":"121af0f201f4101f219d87b98327477f479315b072c615fdee086055d93fbdb3","src/web/use-private-intent.ts":"d9d0311eebbf05571d5b92fa832660dc17c08b0992d969b65f6cea99c1561564","src/web/identity-panel.tsx":"41ed20847807dfac3e604868a7f2810c546b461edbfa3539a3f458eec4810ea0","src/web/content-panel.tsx":"88d79fdbf2af9581237c1d29243d40b40484d6ec959d0e07a248fd28b14de2ec","src/web/admin-panel.tsx":"78bb68f1ae0833be81ad644f741d4fb1422f24826d402df1c4ab5c6e68542006","src/web/game-panel.tsx":"c84a34147ec70bdd023357e8b38966affdbdd701b867f50314b4be78bcc787c1","src/web/social-panel.tsx":"d9a30dbfd47b7d4469748c2d09f713cc1111e393d1d913e22f6d7efe6b9d28ff","src/web/room-screen.tsx":"8dace28df0a6f90926ed6d836490e1c759fb7fce466f5c061b16fc3ca1bd946b","src/web/play-hub.tsx":"8179e5b1d124aa96e0a1d2fc4a0089ab2af9ac3a1bd53ff230bc0e8bb3a5c14f","src/web/landing-board.tsx":"91470ef3a53edaf4c901f6f4bd4531a2728867bade591c51935531a1c8d112e4","src/web/server-http.ts":"0225e33fe6d6066cffb0602b88931df9291e60fa6724270edfcea985bacdcc4e","src/app/api/session/route.ts":"5f49ee6ba6f0a94a740fb164c325457eeabbe490e7dd663298c4a77b1a5e7a0e","tests/application/ui-content-workflows.test.ts":"9539675402d61672ced63e20160a2388e6012aca0a515ffc7a962363810fc55d","tests/application/ui-autocontinue.test.ts":"f7ea6496215b2007b8c35fb10fb23cd37c1dade47b2d85ce6646d3281c8cd8d5","tests/web/private-state.test.ts":"5b980feed15fd91c29cf79948aec903cbe4913557bec2c00c51efc3080d0ffca","tests/browser/ui-gaps.phase6.spec.ts":"6d1fa99b434eab05597b06705301d0b6ee9096764028b34f254e8743c545eaad","tests/browser/seat-recovery.phase6.spec.ts":"a7b967d3e944ae89ae11cb023e31300a4f1ef321abae2a6e77eb21915e11d130","tests/integration/admin.integration.ts":"1b8509d8ae143796a947f5579870af1cf422744d0af8365c1b0c136d8b3d4657","tests/integration/matches.integration.ts":"3da3d7be48db0608779f03d2e292d80c831e22fad51deda4a47121e57c72c778"}}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-source-rereview-races-repaired","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T00:58:25.896971+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Both races fixed: GamePanel GET/POST and SocialPanel GET check captured ownership before deny (still drain stale bodies); RoomSession retires pre-command read generation on resolved success/terminal<500 before pending clear and authoritative refresh. New tests ui-gaps.phase6.spec.ts obsolete game-read/game-write/social-read and seat-recovery pre-join full preview. First isolated prejoin passed; obsolete tests initially failed due wrong accessible link then missing route-completion synchronization, both harness fixes retained logs. Full59 browser suite now running docs/evidence/ui-gaps/browser-verified.log output/browser-artifacts, full542unit lane unit-final.log. Prior10files68SQL pass unchanged domain. Please re-review source + test strength now, append complete request/report/disposition to existing hostile-validation.jsonl. Current contest docs docs/submission/README.md/rules-receipt.json/requirements-receipt.json; QBrain two new TR/TEST, 10false criteria and3mappingunions verified. Check factual scope (200word compactPDF register), public deadline/image conflicts, no automatedentry, pendingmission/conduct/elig/Work/finalURL. Build/docs sync forthcoming; don’t finalapprove before their evidence, send any defects promptly. Refresh HV index after every final append and preserve all rejections."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":98,"completeness":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"report":{"resolvedFindings":[{"id":"UI-HV-005","evidence":"GamePanel refresh/send and SocialPanel refresh now check captured read generation or lifecycle before status denial; stale bodies are drained without mutating current state. Browser cases hold obsolete GET/POST through navigation to another profile draft, release403, then check draft remains after Back."},{"id":"UI-HV-006","evidence":"RoomSession advances read sequence and clears read ownership/coalescing upon resolved success or terminal response before clearing pending intent and fetching authoritative state. A pre-command preview cannot trigger redirect afterward."}],"unresolvedMaterialSourceFindings":[],"testStrengthRecommendation":"Tag or otherwise uniquely identify the held stale GET in pre-join regression. Its generic response predicate can match the newer authorized GET; final assertions should explicitly follow stale response processing. This is an evidence refinement, not an additional observed source defect.","independentChecks":["Read repaired source and new obsolete game-read/game-write/social-read and stale-full-preview browser tests.","Verified retained official PDF SHA256 and byte count against rules receipt.","Parsed saved QBrain receipt: two distinct records, ten unsatisfied criteria, three mappings. No live QBrain query or mutation.","Read official Handshake submission guide independently: confirms optional preview image in generic guide; also requires desktop submission and Build completion and distinguishes profile-only versus Showcase. Check actual mission/form before asserting contest entry.","Read unit-final.log: implementer run542/542 in53files passed. Browser-verified.log still in progress when inspected; no59-pass claim."],"contestAssessment":"Readiness docs preserve unresolved mission/conduct/entrant/Work/final-public-URL conditions and do not claim entry. Earlier deadline and required-cover conflict policy is accurately disclosed. Suggested desktop/Build/Showcase form checks sent to implementer.","limits":["No browser/build/SQL rerun by reviewer during implementer-owned lanes.","Browser tests use disclosed HTTP/domain fixture boundaries; real live2..25UI remains separate.","Final build, final complete browser results, documentation/readback synchronization and frozen source/evidence manifest remain pending.","No physical screen-reader, native installation, entrant eligibility or contest entry certification."]},"scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Incremental repaired-source review; final exact-snapshot/evidence review pending."},"verdict":"SOURCE_FINDINGS_RESOLVED_FINAL_EVIDENCE_PENDING","candidate":{"baseCommit":"435be05abac5310172cfb9a9290c9d7ea0d1cbde","immutable":false,"files":{"src/web/game-panel.tsx":"c84a34147ec70bdd023357e8b38966affdbdd701b867f50314b4be78bcc787c1","src/web/social-panel.tsx":"d9a30dbfd47b7d4469748c2d09f713cc1111e393d1d913e22f6d7efe6b9d28ff","src/web/room-screen.tsx":"8dace28df0a6f90926ed6d836490e1c759fb7fce466f5c061b16fc3ca1bd946b","tests/browser/ui-gaps.phase6.spec.ts":"dd5ba4471c3bc9a10a3d606f3a8dd6ba34a01ae9554a87f1503a1693b2bfc116","tests/browser/seat-recovery.phase6.spec.ts":"3798552af834b9827231648caee3464fec192d1d560689f4b54d6464021ee566","docs/submission/README.md":"9a66ab9263fa66219ec4612d715a2c64b2e8198a0e04e46ec3895c9895e33a60","docs/submission/rules-receipt.json":"6146f1b6a134462501112ea3ae484dd097559cfd97c8e120a874b4048f21f616","docs/submission/requirements-receipt.json":"eccd6c5caea5b5b4f30daabcbe0d81acda142dac8e8ca355091d32f84edc01a4"},"qualification":"Read-time dirty source/doc hashes, not final frozen candidate."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-final-evidence-room-error-finding","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T01:08:39.997572+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Final implementation evidence ready for review: source manifest docs/testing/ui/implementation-manifest.json (234files SHA256 fbf9b3b43ae80758aadcc6e2805bd92fceb7b6a33b9b7f78a17ffa23eb7b1526); implementation-receipt.json. 542unit/53files,59fullbrowser, final5seat cases after tagged-stale response refinement,68realSQL/10files, lint/type/build all PASS. Raw logs retained docs/evidence/ui-gaps including failures and19viewportPNGs. QBrain final readback docs/testing/ui/requirements.json and receipt:163records (30FR41TR92TEST),415ACentries,58exactfullcase notes,293inventory;13gaprecords/49AC nowcompleted/satisfied within scope, original148baseline fields/evidence preserved; LIVE07 false/TESTROOMSYNC139 in_progress, contest10false. Updated9cases/index/gaps/coverage/decisions/persistence/sources; archive/design-20261027 preserves oldreceipts. Validation441passed. Export running; wiki push newly explicitly authorized https://github.com/sharpninja/wordpairs.wiki.git, not apprepo commit. Inspect sources/evidence/docs and scoring final implementation accuracy/completeness threshold99/99; append complete actual request/rubric/report/scores/disposition and refresh HV index. Do not certify contest submission/readiness or real liveUI. Contest latest user attests eligibility; says no other conductlink; provided officialPDFsame; Handshake TOS inspected, current OpenAI usage page futureeffectiveNov20 correctlyusesOct29,2025revision. Rule originals retained; directOpenAIHTML downloadsfailed transparently. Need final wiki/export linkage audit after export generated; send findings now, hold final until any material issue resolved. No source edits by reviewer."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correct authority, state transitions, retry identity, asynchronous ownership, privacy and truthful evidence.","completeness":"Coverage of UI-DEC-01..08 and associated accepted criteria, including SQL and browser boundaries.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scope":"UI extension only; prior live 2..25 UI execution remains separate and incomplete."},"candidate":{"baseCommit":"435be05abac5310172cfb9a9290c9d7ea0d1cbde","immutableCommit":false,"manifest":"docs/testing/ui/implementation-manifest.json","manifestFileSha256":"fbf9b3b43ae80758aadcc6e2805bd92fceb7b6a33b9b7f78a17ffa23eb7b1526","filesVerified":234,"mismatches":0,"lineDigest":"6c6ebfff9afeda22506e1a1d68983b69b73168c0d90b57ce81d7aa29a8f5808d"},"report":{"findings":[{"id":"UI-HV-007","severity":"P2","files":["src/web/room-screen.tsx"],"problem":"RoomSession refresh and command render caught problem.message directly. response.json() can throw a SyntaxError containing malformed server body text, which then appears in the alert; raw network exception text also renders verbatim.","contract":"UI-FEEDBACK-04 and implementation.md statement that no raw server/network exception is rendered.","requiredCorrection":"Use controlled explanation strings, preserve intentional status-specific feedback, and exercise malformed room GET/POST sentinel bodies in browser or actual component tests."}],"independentVerification":["All234 source manifest entries match current SHA256 and byte counts; manifest file digest matches request.","All logs listed in implementation receipt match SHA256 and byte counts.","Read implementer logs confirming542unit/53files,59browser,68SQL/10files and successful production build; did not rerun these lanes.","Saved QBrain readback independently has163records:30FR41TR92TEST and415criterion entries. Exactly13 prior records changed status/criteria; original148 substantive body/condition/status/priority/criteria remain unchanged.","All58 full local case texts are contained exactly in corresponding TEST notes. LIVE07 remains unsatisfied and both room-sync records in_progress.","Visually inspected320px editor,200%-text content, and full320px game captures: legible reflow and focus; partial viewport captures do not certify off-screen content."],"resolvedPriorFindings":["UI-HV-001","UI-HV-002","UI-HV-003","UI-HV-004","UI-HV-005","UI-HV-006"],"pending":["UI-HV-007 repair and matching evidence","Final exact manifest after any implementation change","Export/wiki linkage audit after export completes"],"limits":["Saved readback only; no independent live QBrain mutation/query.","HTTP browser fixtures and SQL service2..25 games do not complete real live private-push2..25 UI obligation.","No contest submission/readiness certification, physical screen-reader/device claim or new entrant-fact inference."]},"scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Final gate held for material UI-HV-007 and incomplete export linkage; no approval score assigned."},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED"}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"ui-implementation-final-approval","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T01:15:37.391311+00:00","reviewer":{"agent":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","role":"Independent hostile source/evidence reviewer"},"request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"UI-HV-007 fixed: RoomSession GET drains text, checks ownership/status before JSON parsing and uses controlled explanation; command catch uses controlled text only and epochguard. Added malformed200GET/POST private-sentinel absence and explicit refresh-recovery browser tests. FINAL61/61 browser passed docs/evidence/ui-gaps/browser-safe-errors-final.log with19PNGs final-browser-artifacts; FINAL542unit passed unit-safe-errors-final.log; lint/types/build-safe-errors-final.log all PASS. Domain/SQL unchanged68pass. New234-file manifest SHA2562728c24a17214fa06d1e4de9af4742f1a466ba736e922e88bb6a6c932784b0f8; exact two-file delta from prior preserved in archive/pre-safe-errors-20261028/{implementation-manifest,implementation-receipt,validation}. Old ZIP/receipt preserved docs/requirements/archive/ui-first-implementation-export-receipt-20261028.json and requirements-wiki-ui-first-implementation-20261028.zip. QBrain13notes updated to final61/542logs;58case exactreadback checked incl revisedfeedback case. Final canonicalexport running ui-implementation-wiki-final.yaml (rootwilldecode/verify). Please final independent implementation source/evidence review now, append full request/rubric/report/scores/disposition; threshold99/99, no contest/liveUI certification. Refresh HV index for allchangedreceipts and add pre-safe-error archived candidate artifacts. Wiki preparation helper /tmp/prepare-wordpairs-wiki.py currently stops on stale HV index hash, intentional; exportpublishingafterfinalreview. Sourcefiles will remain unchanged now. Audit wiki link transforms/receipt after rootprepares stage. Need any material issue immediately; ifsource/evidence approved score it separately from remaining publication check."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Correctness/security of review-state authority, audit and atomicity, session-bound drafts and canonical intents, async ownership, private denial handling, no-solver timing, discovery recovery, safe errors, and truthful evidence boundaries.","completeness":"UI-DEC-01..08 and49 scoped gap criteria covered by domain/application, actual browser UI with disclosed ports, real PostgreSQL, compile/lint/build and synchronized saved requirements/cases.","threshold":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scoreMeaning":"Qualitative independent review judgment on this scope and evidence, not a statistical guarantee or universal correctness certification."},"candidate":{"baseCommit":"435be05abac5310172cfb9a9290c9d7ea0d1cbde","kind":"Frozen local working-tree manifest; not an immutable new Git commit or deployed release","manifest":"docs/testing/ui/implementation-manifest.json","manifestFileSha256":"2728c24a17214fa06d1e4de9af4742f1a466ba736e922e88bb6a6c932784b0f8","sourceFiles":234,"independentHashMismatches":0,"implementationReceipt":"docs/testing/ui/implementation-receipt.json","implementationReceiptSha256":"d8784be25a4ac84f582e9b612954df84d7455e2756f432d652ec1b10ccaf6c4a","priorCandidateArchive":"docs/testing/ui/archive/pre-safe-errors-20261028","deltaFromPriorCandidate":["src/web/room-screen.tsx","tests/browser/ui-gaps.phase6.spec.ts"],"documentationReadbackSha256":"739e3e52a985bb8955d44afc969e391e3695a40f3d57a89e50bb4a6c39cbc49d"},"report":{"verdict":"APPROVE_IMPLEMENTATION","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99},"unresolvedMaterialFindings":[],"resolvedFindings":[{"id":"UI-HV-001","resolution":"Scoped ledger retains successful results and draft identity across navigation; a current mounted consumer handles destination/form completion and explicitly acknowledges the same result. Duplicate writes remain blocked until consumption. Delayed successful private-room creation is covered."},{"id":"UI-HV-002","resolution":"Verified sessions expose a purpose-separated non-authenticating SHA256 marker; same-profile replacement changes private identity revision and invalidates drafts/intents/component state. Marker is not cookie or credential-store digest. API and browser/ledger tests cover separation and replacement."},{"id":"UI-HV-003","resolution":"Game, social and room denial handling retires older read ownership and clears relevant private projection; current denial followed by late successful GET cannot restore protected content."},{"id":"UI-HV-004","resolution":"Browser test triggers accepted stage/score/error DOM announcements and checks focus remains; responsive matrix and captures retain explicit equivalent-zoom/headless/partial-viewport limitations."},{"id":"UI-HV-005","resolution":"Game GET/POST and social GET verify captured generation/lifecycle before processing denial; obsolete requests drain bodies without clearing a replacement session’s private state. Navigation and replacement-draft regressions cover this ordering."},{"id":"UI-HV-006","resolution":"Resolved room commands retire pre-command reads before pending intent clearing and authoritative refresh. Tagged stale-full-preview regression waits for the exact delayed response and keeps the successful member in room. Discovery losers use a fresh first-page board; uncertain winners retain canonical retry and direct links retain observation."},{"id":"UI-HV-007","resolution":"Room read/command catch paths use controlled explanation strings. Reads drain text and check ownership/status before parse. Malformed200 GET/POST browser cases assert sentinel/parser/network text absent, safe messages shown, and explicit refresh restores normal UI."}],"assessment":{"contentWorkflow":"Independent reasoned suggestion-change requests, proposer-only exact-three-pair resubmission, held nominations and threshold-checked reasoned resume preserve one-open, nonplayable and appeal invariants. Existing atomic SQL projection/audit mechanisms and forward status/index migration remain intact.","lifecycle":"Tab memory is distinct from durable browser storage. Profile editing uses draft Save/Cancel/Escape with no Cancel mutation and focus restoration. Session/resource scopes, shared pending locks, canonical payload retention, result acknowledgment and stale completion guards address navigation/account races.","automaticContinuation":"Summary stage deadline uses authoritative endedAt plus3000ms. Early/exact/late execution, manual race order, replay and terminal eighth round are tested; actual next-round time grants full initial stage. Catalog revision mismatch on system deadline is retryable and does not acknowledge a still-valid job.","privacyAndFeedback":"Controlled errors and current-request ownership prevent stale private data or obsolete denials affecting another session; status-specific room recovery remains available.","scopeAlignment":"No new membership authority is introduced by discovery query provenance. Accessibility checks are explicit layout/DOM/browser evidence; no formal compliance, physical-device or live-provider result is inferred."},"independentVerification":[{"check":"Source manifest","result":"All234 entries match current SHA256 and byte counts. Manifest digest matches2728c24a17214fa06d1e4de9af4742f1a466ba736e922e88bb6a6c932784b0f8. Exactly two changed paths versus preserved pre-safe-error manifest; no domain/SQL delta."},{"check":"Evidence integrity","result":"All27 recorded log hashes and byte counts match. Final screenshot directory contains19PNGs. Reviewed final unit/browser/build summaries plus prior realSQL summary."},{"check":"Focused execution","command":"npm test -- tests/application/ui-content-workflows.test.ts tests/application/ui-autocontinue.test.ts tests/web/private-state.test.ts","result":"9passed across3files, exit0; independently run after repair."},{"check":"Saved requirements synchronization","result":"163records:30FR41TR92TEST;415criteria. Exactly13 prior gap records change status/criteria,49 scoped entries satisfied. Original148 substantive bodies/conditions/statuses/priorities/criteria preserved. All58 local case texts match saved TEST notes and case hashes; no prior mapping link lost."},{"check":"Open obligations","result":"Room-sync LIVE07 remains false and TEST-ROOMSYNC-139/TR-ROOM-SYNCRECOVERY-038 in_progress. Contest criteria remain outside implementation approval."},{"check":"Visual inspection","result":"Final320px editor and200%-text content captures independently viewed; earlier current-scope full320px game capture inspected. Reflow/focus legible in visible regions. Remaining off-screen/browser/native behavior is covered only to stated measured/asserted limits."}],"implementerRunEvidenceReviewed":{"unit":{"passed":542,"files":53,"log":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/unit-safe-errors-final.log"},"browser":{"passed":61,"log":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/browser-safe-errors-final.log","boundary":"Actual React/browser interactions with disclosed HTTP/time/persistence fixtures and real domain/application services; not live transport proof."},"database":{"passed":68,"files":10,"log":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/postgres.log","boundary":"Actual disposable PostgreSQL with SQL/migration/atomicity/race checks and2..25 service games. Latest two-file UI repair does not alter this lane’s domain/SQL source."},"lint":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/lint-safe-errors.log","typecheck":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/typecheck-safe-errors.log","productionBuild":"docs/evidence/ui-gaps/build-safe-errors-final.log"},"evidenceLimits":["Reviewer independently ran9focused tests, not all542unit/61browser/68SQL tests; larger results are inspected implementer-run logs with verified hashes.","Saved QBrain readback was inspected; no independent live server query or mutation performed.","Browser fixture evidence does not complete the outstanding real private-push2..25UI matrix.","No physical screen-reader, native phone installation, real OIDC entitlement/provider or formal WCAG certification.","Public contest readiness, eligibility/legal acceptance, authenticated mission/conduct review, Work provenance, durable final URL and manual entry are separate.","Wiki export/stage/publication linkage remains pending a separate audit. Approval does not authorize application commit/push/deployment or contest submission."],"disposition":"Approve the UI implementation and synchronized scoped requirement evidence at99/99 for the exact234-file manifest. No unresolved material implementation finding. Preserve every rejected/superseded round. Complete and audit export/wiki publication separately; do not claim contest or real liveUI completion."}}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"wiki-163-stage-audit-superseded","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T01:20:29.165185+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Wiki stage ready for separate publication audit. Checkout /tmp/wordpairs-wiki-publish-20261028, target https://github.com/sharpninja/wordpairs.wiki.git originalHEAD00a54b316239cddea5916b4c6436990bb6ef2810. Canonical supported ZIP SHA143442295bfe2282b64f1e583c13a06a9394b4a723169be5020ebfe10ecbdb76,1128285bytes,211entries,103pages/platform; all163IDs verified both. docs/submission/wiki-publication.json inventories103transformedMDpages +163public supportingassets and833link rewrites, zero unresolved source links. Canonical ZIP remains exact; published copy only rewrites links to wiki pages/raw assets/official policy sources.4historical Phase6 /tmp captures copied byte-identically into docs/evidence/phase6/historical-captures, no current/human test claim; LICENSE/package.json/wiki.yaml published as explicit nonsecret support. No raw policyHTML/PDF published; links point originals. Only prior wiki fileHome.md intentionally replaced by generatedHome; no unrelated removals. .mcp-requirements-manifest.json copied exact. Root updated implementation-receipt status+HV pointer (same source hash), implementation.md adds99/99 and hv-evidence prose corrects initial status, then regenerated export. ExistingHVindex40files hashes refreshed by root to current receipts; please audit stage/transformscope/sourceprivacy/canonicalcontent, append full publication review request/report, refresh index. Do not edit MDprose now (would require reexport) unless material issue; append log/index only. Rootwillrerunpreparehelper tocopy newlog/index thenverifyandpush. Need independent publication recommendation, not actual push or contest readiness approval."},"supersedingInstruction":{"provenance":"available parent message verbatim","text":"Before final publication audit, I’m persisting the operator’s new recurring wiki-publication rule as separate TR-DOCS-WIKIPUBLISH-042 / TEST-WIKIPUBLISH-148 with native crosscutting mapping unions. This changes final scope counts to165records/421criteria but leaves all original148 and approved UI source/evidence untouched. Need regenerate export/docs counts once before push; hold stage audit until I provide final165 snapshot. I’ll initially keep publication criterion false, push/readback, then persist true with exact first wiki commit evidence and export/push refreshed authoritative state. Your existing implementation approval remains same234-source scope."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Canonical export unchanged; publication changes only declared links/approved support; truthful source/evidence and privacy boundaries.","completeness":"All configured pages/requirement IDs and public supporting targets present, originals/HV history preserved, intended remote and unrelated wiki content protected.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0}},"candidate":{"wikiBaseCommit":"00a54b316239cddea5916b4c6436990bb6ef2810","canonicalZipSha256":"143442295bfe2282b64f1e583c13a06a9394b4a723169be5020ebfe10ecbdb76","canonicalBytes":1128285,"canonicalEntries":211,"publicationReceiptSha256":"fe44fcbbc9f835885abcf3c341ecd0525d8794bf116d444ab1f1e6e4238c42a3","state":"163-record stage superseded before final approval; not pushed by reviewer"},"report":{"unresolvedMaterialFindings":[],"independentChecks":["Verified ZIP SHA256/bytes/entry count and103configured Markdown pages per platform; GitHub also includes generated Sidebar/Footer auxiliaries. All163 requirement IDs appear on both platforms.","Compared103staged page bytes with canonical GitHub pages: exact hashes match receipt and all content outside Markdown link destinations unchanged.","All163supporting assets match repository source bytes/hash/size. All833recorded link rewrites point to present wiki pages or raw assets/official URLs; no unresolved local/relative destinations.","No unexplained staged files or missing inventoried files. Original wiki HEAD and origin match request; only pre-existing tracked page isHome.md.","Exported requirements metadata matches staged metadata byte-for-byte. Four historical capture copies match original/tmp bytes.","Heuristic scans found no private keys, GitHub tokens, credential-bearing PostgreSQL URLs, Bearer headers or JWT patterns in staged text. No raw policyHTML/PDF or key/env files staged. This is not an absolute secret-free proof.","All40existing HV-index artifact hashes and234implementation source hashes match at inspection."],"limits":["Final publication recommendation withheld because165-record/421-criterion authoritative snapshot/export is being prepared.","No wiki push, application deployment or contest submission performed.","This stage does not publish dirty application source; manifest identifies local reviewed source. Historical receipt evidence does not imply current hosted/device/liveUI completion."]},"scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Superseded preliminary publication stage; final165-record audit pending."},"verdict":"SUPERSEDED_PUBLICATION_AUDIT_PENDING"}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"wiki-165-metadata-correction","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T01:25:00.597724+00:00","reviewer":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high","request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Final165 pending-publication stage ready: ZIP SHA b6a44c6cc43dddcb473af18d504c64026ef75599f78c04863e4913afe1d0505c,1133253bytes/211entries,103pages each platform,165IDs/421criteria. NewTR-DOCS-WIKIPUBLISH042/TESTWIKIPUBLISH148 have6false entries until actual push; all30FR mappings unioned without removed links. Repo docs/requirements.json,receipt/gaps/persistence/index synchronized and446checks pass. Same /tmp/wordpairs-wiki-publish-20261028 stage;103pages+Sidebar/Footer+manifest+EvidenceIndex,163assets,835linktransforms allresolved. Metadata docs/submission/wiki-publication.json. Approved234-source manifest unchanged. Audit this165stage now; append recommendation/fullreport andrefreshindex. I will rerunpreparehelper tocopy your finalreview/index then firstpush/readback. Then mark6publication criteria true with exact firstcommit evidence, regenerate authoritative export and finalpush (only evidence/status delta); no repeated UI source review needed. Do not edit MDprose because canonicalexport nowfrozen forfirstpush. Need any source/data privacy violation or exportsemantic discrepancy raised immediately."},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Canonical export unchanged; publication changes only declared links/approved support; truthful source/evidence and privacy boundaries.","completeness":"All configured pages/requirement IDs and public supporting targets present, originals/HV history preserved, intended remote and unrelated wiki content protected.","approvalThreshold":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0}},"candidate":{"canonicalZipSha256":"b6a44c6cc43dddcb473af18d504c64026ef75599f78c04863e4913afe1d0505c","bytes":1133253,"entries":211,"wikiBaseCommit":"00a54b316239cddea5916b4c6436990bb6ef2810"},"report":{"findings":[{"id":"WIKI-HV-001","severity":"P2 provenance correction","problem":"Staged .mcp-requirements-manifest.json still belongs to preceding163-record export (generated01:16:21), while current canonical ZIP metadata generated01:22:58.","requiredCorrection":"Copy and hash canonical metadata from current ZIP on each preparation, alongside Sidebar/Footer."}],"independentChecks":["Canonical ZIP hash/size/entry count match. Both platforms include all165requirement IDs; current saved readback has421criteria.","All103configured staged pages match canonical content except declared Markdown destinations; all163assets match repository bytes.835rewrites have existing local page/raw-asset targets.","No unexplained stage files; Sidebar and Footer match current ZIP exactly.","All30FR mappings include new publication TR/TEST with no prior links removed; six publication criteria and ten contest criteria remain false/in_progress.","Heuristic credential/private-key/JWT scans have no flags. No source/privacy violation found.","Approved234-source manifest remains byte-exact."],"limits":["No push or contest entry performed.","Final recommendation awaits metadata correction and evidence recopy."]},"scores":{"accuracy":null,"completeness":null,"reason":"Publication gate held for exact metadata provenance repair."},"verdict":"CHANGES_REQUIRED"}
{"schemaVersion":1,"eventId":"wiki-165-publication-recommendation","recordedAt":"2026-10-28T01:26:01.962459+00:00","reviewer":{"agent":"/root/phase1_hv","requestedModel":"gpt-6-astra","requestedReasoningEffort":"high"},"request":{"provenance":"available parent request verbatim","text":"Fixed helper to copy CURRENT ZIP .mcp-requirements-manifest.json on every run, alongside Sidebar/Footer, and inventory all3 exact hashes/bytes in docs/submission/wiki-publication.json exportMetadata. Reranprepare now. No pages/assets/source changes beyond metadata repair. Stage270files no deletions. Git diff --check flags only pre-existing intentionalMarkdown two-space hardbreaks and untouched raw log whitespace; publication receipt records preservation policy, no content normalization. Please finish recommendation and append fullactualreport/index; rootthenrerunshelper+stages+commits/pushes, with remoteproof.","precedingFullScopeRequestEvent":"wiki-165-metadata-correction"},"rubric":{"accuracy":"Publication preserves canonical semantic content, exact metadata/evidence bytes and truthful scope; public assets exclude private runtime secrets.","completeness":"All165requirements/421criteria,103configured pages, generated navigation/metadata, supporting evidence and original review outcomes retained; links resolve and declared target/previous wiki scope respected.","threshold":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99,"unresolvedMaterialFindings":0},"scoreMeaning":"Judgment on inspected publication preparation, not proof of remote push or contest eligibility."},"candidate":{"wikiRemote":"https://github.com/sharpninja/wordpairs.wiki.git","originalWikiHead":"00a54b316239cddea5916b4c6436990bb6ef2810","canonicalZipSha256":"b6a44c6cc43dddcb473af18d504c64026ef75599f78c04863e4913afe1d0505c","canonicalBytes":1133253,"canonicalEntries":211,"publicationReceiptSha256":"100771bac0426cccbbcf32e6fe998d1648057d6d25116594be97dd2830a4d2c0","configuredPages":103,"supportingAssets":163,"rewrittenLinks":835,"stagedFiles":270,"exportMetadata":[{"path":"_Sidebar.md","sha256":"a1f75e3c1ae47d72f984d0a3a634aaf1a70b5f2e35ba37ff63c58455fd5d543e","bytes":6575},{"path":"_Footer.md","sha256":"e17666c5c6206edfb1f6bb1dd058b5bd6215d38142dfa36883c4ccefbb3e3bfe","bytes":45},{"path":".mcp-requirements-manifest.json","sha256":"d7ac702caeea2414131a7c15e5eac5ff1f6d763bc9fc8c071691c4d1b621f050","bytes":4126}],"approvedApplicationManifest":"2728c24a17214fa06d1e4de9af4742f1a466ba736e922e88bb6a6c932784b0f8"},"report":{"verdict":"APPROVE_PUBLICATION_RECOMMENDATION","scores":{"accuracy":99,"completeness":99},"unresolvedMaterialFindings":[],"resolvedFindings":[{"id":"WIKI-HV-001","resolution":"Current ZIP requirements metadata is copied on every helper run and exactly matches current canonical bytes. Sidebar/Footer likewise exact; all three now explicitly hash/size inventoried."}],"independentVerification":["Canonical archive hash/1133253bytes/211entries verified. Both platforms contain103configured pages and all165requirement IDs; GitHub also has Sidebar/Footer.","All103staged configured pages match canonical content except recorded Markdown link destinations; no semantic requirement/prose rewrite detected.","All163supporting assets match their recorded hashes and repository source bytes at stage preparation. Current review-log/index append requires expected recopy before commit, detailed below.","All835rewritten destinations resolve to present wiki/raw-asset targets or official policy URLs. Generated navigation links resolve. No unexplained staged files, missing inventoried files or unrelated deletions.","All270stage files accounted for:103configured pages,163assets, Sidebar/Footer/requirements metadata and EvidenceIndex. Original remote/base commit verified; only prior trackedHome.md is intentionally replaced.","Four historical image copies verified byte-identical to original/tmp captures; historical provenance retained.","Heuristic staged-text scan found no private-key/GitHub-token/credential-URL/Bearer/JWT patterns. No raw policyHTML/PDF or key/env artifacts staged. Private runtime/browser/core/session files are outside enumerated publication inventory.","Saved authoritative requirements readback has165records/421criteria; publication six criteria and contest ten criteria remain false/in_progress. All30FR mappings include publication TR/TEST, with no prior mapping links removed.","Approved234application source files remain exact; no implementation re-review or new deployment is represented."],"publicationPreflight":["Rerun preparation after this append and HV-index refresh; recopy the current hostile-validation.jsonl and hv-index.json. These are the only expected stale supporting assets from review activity. Verify every final page/asset/metadata hash against newly prepared receipt before commit.","Commit/push only the explicitly authorized wiki remote, preserving originals and canonical archive. Retain exact resulting commit/tree and read back remote files before marking publication criteria satisfied.","Any later regenerated export with satisfied publication status is a separate evidence/status delta; compare it explicitly and retain the first publication commit. Do not claim remote publication from this recommendation alone."],"evidenceLimits":["Reviewer did not push or change wiki/application source.","No absolute secret-free guarantee from heuristic scanning; deliberately enumerated assets and byte comparisons bound inspected scope.","Current local source is manifest-bound, not published by this wiki update.","No contest entry/readiness certification, legal agreement acceptance, hosted game release, physical-device or outstanding live2..25UI completion.","Canonical hard-break whitespace and raw evidence-log bytes are preserved intentionally; whitespace warnings alone do not justify altering evidence."],"disposition":"Recommend publication of the inspected165-record wiki package at99/99, after the deterministic final recopy/hash preflight. No unresolved material publication finding. Actual push/readback and later authoritative status synchronization remain implementer actions under user authorization."}}