{"event":"review_request","reviewer":"gpt-6-astra","reasoningEffort":"high","request":"Candidate settled at immutable LOCAL commit 3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad, clean tree. All identified fixes now in this commit, including ssl/uselibpqcompat blocking plus actual driver config regression; SQLSTATE53300/53400 -> SERVICE_LIMIT+original ID; cardinality/null/blank hints constraints+5 invalid SQL fixtures; container creation ownership cleanup by capturedID; room-linked match/moderation retention anchors with exact30day and nonroom30day tests; pair immutability; previous outbox/audit/oracle fixes. Full suite352/352, zero skips; type/lint/localbuild passed; disposable SQL+3 real adapter tests passed after latest source fixes (format-only changes since). Please independently inspect exact local commit, rerun relevant/full checks, and run pwsh -File tests/integration/run-phase1.ps1 with require_escalated if needed (parent's Docker approval covers scoped disposable tests). Return a complete final JSON review including model gpt-6-astra high, candidateSHA, rubric, accuracy/completeness scores, every remaining actionable finding, resolved prior findings, verification evidence/limits, and APPROVE/CHANGES_REQUIRED for local Phase1 technical readiness. IMPORTANT: auto-review rejected uploading uncommitted source tree to GitHub as insufficiently authorized. Do not upload or work around that denial. Formal exact-GitHub-commit gate remains pending user approval; qualify local approval accordingly, do not approve Phase2 entry. Need full final output to preserve verbatim in JSONL."}
{"event":"review_result","review":{"reviewType":"independent_hostile_validation","model":"gpt-6-astra","reasoningEffort":"high","candidateSHA":"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad","repository":"\u003Crepo\u003E","scope":"Local Phase 1 technical readiness: application foundation, typed ports, transaction orchestration, persistence schema, security boundaries, and supporting evidence.","recommendation":"APPROVE","qualification":"Approval applies only to the exact local candidate and Phase 1 foundation scope. Formal Phase 1 exit remains pending the required exact-GitHub-commit review gate. This review does not authorize uploading source, entering Phase 2, deploying, or claiming complete product acceptance.","rubric":{"threshold":{"accuracyPercent":98,"completenessPercent":98,"unresolvedMaterialFindingsAllowed":0},"accuracy":"Implementation and evidence accurately reflect the approved Phase 1 contracts; observable failures, transaction outcomes, security controls, and documentation agree without claiming product or platform behavior that was not exercised.","completeness":"The Phase 1A–1C foundation is present, previously identified material defects are corrected, applicable regression and disposable-database checks pass, and later product and operational obligations remain explicitly identified.","assessment":"Both thresholds are met for local technical readiness. The remaining formal remote review gate is outside this local approval."},"scores":{"accuracyPercent":99,"completenessPercent":99},"remainingActionableFindings":[],"resolvedPriorFindings":[{"finding":"Domain-only literal import guard missed application and relative or aliased infrastructure dependencies.","resolution":"The guard now parses TypeScript syntax, scans domain and application source, enforces dependency direction, and exercises negative import, re-export, require, dynamic-import, relative-path, and alias fixtures."},{"finding":"Successful transitions could contain zero or multiple outbox events.","resolution":"Application validation requires exactly one event; SQL independently validates cardinality and enforces one durable event per aggregate version. Invalid cardinality and version cases are tested."},{"finding":"Outbox events lacked explicit schema version and aggregate type.","resolution":"Typed events now include both fields, with SQL scope and schema-version checks."},{"finding":"Transactions lacked independent atomic audit intents.","resolution":"Transition.audits and a separate audit table persist audit records in the same transaction as aggregate state, result, outbox, and deadlines."},{"finding":"Active rounds lacked immutable content-version references.","resolution":"Round and content lookup contracts include pair versions. SQL uses composite references, immutable pair and accepted-answer records, and serialized checks preventing additions to live alternatives."},{"finding":"AC-37 observations contained hard-coded retry metadata and an unobserved fallback count.","resolution":"The unchanged oracle now consumes the actual application failure metadata and recorded provider calls. Separate tests exercise recovery with the original command ID."},{"finding":"Rollback tests rejected decisions before exercising commit failure.","resolution":"A fake repository now accepts a valid decision and then reports commit failure, verifying discarded effects and no repeated decision. Actual PostgreSQL tests inject a persistence constraint fault and verify rollback."},{"finding":"Connection-string ssl=0 could override verified TLS.","resolution":"TLS override parameters, including ssl and uselibpqcompat, are rejected. An offline test checks the installed pg driver's effective TLS configuration."},{"finding":"Persistence resource-limit failures were always classified as TEMPORARY_UNAVAILABLE.","resolution":"SQLSTATE 53300 and 53400 now return SERVICE_LIMIT with the original command ID. Tests cover connection and commit-time resource limits; unknown faults remain redacted and recoverable."},{"finding":"SQL CHECK NULL semantics allowed empty hint arrays.","resolution":"The constraint validates dimensionality, lower bound, cardinality, null elements, and blank elements. Five invalid SQL fixtures are rejected."},{"finding":"Database-runner cleanup could delete a pre-existing container after name collision.","resolution":"Cleanup now uses the captured ID of a successfully created container and does not remove a container when creation failed."},{"finding":"Finished-match idempotency records lacked their room's retention anchor.","resolution":"Explicit room anchors now govern room-associated retention. Non-room profile and moderation retention is documented separately. SQL tests verify expired records, retained records, and the exact 30-day boundary."},{"finding":"Generic-store and relational-capacity evidence could be mistaken for complete JoinRoom validation.","resolution":"Phase 1 documentation explicitly separates relational membership backstop tests from generic transaction adapter tests and leaves product JoinRoom integration to Phase 2."}],"verificationEvidence":[{"check":"Candidate identity and cleanliness","result":"PASS","details":"Independently verified HEAD before and after verification. It remained 3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad with a clean worktree."},{"check":"npm test","result":"PASS","details":"Independent complete run: 8 files passed, 352 tests passed, zero failures or skips."},{"check":"npm run lint","result":"PASS","details":"Independent Biome run checked 13 files with no fixes applied."},{"check":"npm run typecheck","result":"PASS","details":"Independent tsc --noEmit run exited successfully."},{"check":"npm run build","result":"PASS","details":"Independent local Next.js production build compiled, completed TypeScript validation, and generated static routes successfully. No deployment occurred."},{"check":"pwsh -File tests/integration/run-phase1.ps1","result":"PASS","details":"Independent approved run against a disposable local PostgreSQL container passed migration, RLS configuration, actual unprivileged-role denial, canonical replay and digest conflict, stale-version rejection, durable outbox, rollback fault, retention and invalid-content fixtures, and competing final-seat writes."},{"check":"Actual TypeScript adapter against PostgreSQL","result":"PASS","details":"The independent database runner passed all 3 adapter integration tests: concurrent duplicate commands invoke one decision, conflicting or stale commands invoke no additional decision, and a persistence fault rolls back aggregate state and prevents durable result, deadline, and audit effects."},{"check":"Acceptance assertion preservation and attribution change","result":"PASS","details":"Reviewed the original-oracle change: only the independently pinned attribution inventory hash and explanatory comment changed for the added pg and @types/pg rows. Existing acceptance expectations and rejection assertions remain intact. Dependency, lockfile, installed-license, and attribution checks passed."}],"verificationLimits":["The initial sandboxed full test run encountered spawnSync git EPERM while collecting archive fixtures; 267 other tests passed. An approved unsandboxed rerun completed all 352 tests successfully. This was an execution-environment restriction, not a candidate defect.","Scripted mock-oracle tests establish assertion sensitivity. They do not establish application conformance for all 45 active acceptance criteria.","The command tests exercise real application orchestration through fake ports. Synthetic decision results are not evidence that product room, match, identity, or moderation policies are implemented.","Local database tests establish the tested PostgreSQL schema and transaction properties. They do not establish Supabase account configuration, deployed RLS behavior, external identity entitlement, live TLS connectivity, or Free-plan quota availability.","Final-seat SQL tests exercise relational membership constraints. Generic aggregate adapter tests do not yet prove that a production JoinRoom command updates both aggregate and relational representations.","Observer authorization, public projections, complete identity flows, gameplay, moderation policy, responsive UI, accessibility, and human validation remain obligations of their designated later phases.","The local build validates the shell and included modules; it is not a browser acceptance test or deployment check.","No source was uploaded and no rejected upload was retried or worked around. The required exact-GitHub-commit gate remains pending authorized publication and subsequent review."],"phaseStatus":{"localPhase1TechnicalReadiness":"APPROVED","formalPhase1Exit":"PENDING_EXACT_GITHUB_COMMIT_GATE","phase2EntryApproved":false,"deploymentApproved":false,"deploymentBoundary":"Phase 7 only, after completion of coding Phases 1–6."}}}
{"event":"owner_disposition","candidateSHA":"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad","agreement":"Agree with local technical approval at 99/99. All material findings corrected. Formal Phase 1 exit and Phase 2 entry remain pending authorized GitHub checkpoint and exact-commit validation.","goalStatus":"active","remainingScope":"Formal Phase 1 exit and full implementation/validation of Phases 2–6; no deployment before Phase 7."}
{"event":"approval_review_rejection","action":"Create immutable GitHub tree in sharpninja/wordpairs from local candidate source without moving a branch","result":"rejected_before_execution","reason":"This uploads the complete uncommitted Phase 1 source tree to a GitHub repository, potentially making sensitive local code externally accessible; the user authorized implementation but not this specific source export or destination.","recovery":"No alternate upload path was attempted. Local candidate and independent review were completed. Await explicit user approval for uploading the concrete reviewed candidate and receipt to the public project repository."}
{"humanUploadApprovalReceived":false,"localCheckpoint":"59f7d03","uploadRetried":false,"event":"upload_approval_revalidation","candidateSHA":"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad","timestamp":"2026-10-26T17:16:14.2816233Z","action":"Corrected stale Phase 1A/current-test progress in the goal tracker; preserved the formal phase gate. Goal remains active.","localTreeBeforeDocumentationCorrection":"clean","consecutiveGoalTurnWithSameBlocker":2,"remoteRead":"GitHub git/commits/3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad returned 404"}
{"event":"independent_hostile_validation_remote_gate_addendum","timestamp":"2026-10-26T17:21:31.862Z","request":"Please record your complete final remote-gate addendum verbatim as a single JSONL event in docs/phase1_review_receipt.jsonl, including this request and human authorization text \"What do you mean? Don't wait on me, get it done.\" Update ONLY docs/phase1_execution.md and docs/goal_hv_agreement_through_phase_6.md status paragraphs/table to formal Phase1 APPROVED at remote7e46694,99/99; phase2 nowin progress. Preserve prior rejection as historical, not current blocker. Do not touch production/tests/dependencies, do not commit or upload. This is saving your own reviewer evidence. Parent starting Phase2 source changes in separatefiles. Return filenamesmodified.","reviewRequest":"The human explicitly responded to upload-approval blocker: \"What do you mean? Don't wait on me, get it done.\" I uploaded the authorized immutable Git objects ONLY (no branch movement/deployment). GitHub created the EXACT same candidate commit 3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad, tree b14df8a58c368cfef78e6879d0836b069436912c, now at https://github.com/sharpninja/wordpairs/commit/3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad. Please independently fetch its GitHub commit/tree (connector GitHub fetch or gh api read), compare to reviewed local immutable candidate, and complete the remaining formal Phase1 exact-GitHub gate. Prior full local independent352 tests+DB3+lint/type/build reviewed already; do not needlessly rerun identical checks. Return full JSON final addendum with remote evidence exactSHA/tree, scores, findings, formal Phase1 exit and Phase2-entry disposition. No source edits. Current localHEAD4753c3f contains only documentation/receipt additions after reviewed source7e466.","humanAuthorization":"What do you mean? Don't wait on me, get it done.","reviewerOutput":"{\n  \"reviewType\": \"independent_hostile_validation_remote_gate_addendum\",\n  \"model\": \"gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"reasoningEffort\": \"high\",\n  \"repository\": \"sharpninja/wordpairs\",\n  \"candidateSHA\": \"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n  \"candidateTreeSHA\": \"b14df8a58c368cfef78e6879d0836b069436912c\",\n  \"candidateURL\": \"https://github.com/sharpninja/wordpairs/commit/3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n  \"recommendation\": \"APPROVE\",\n  \"scope\": \"Complete the formal Phase 1 exact-GitHub-commit gate by independently verifying that the remote immutable candidate matches the previously reviewed and tested local candidate.\",\n  \"remoteVerification\": {\n    \"method\": \"Independent read-only GitHub connector requests, compared with local Git objects.\",\n    \"commitEndpoint\": \"https://api.github.com/repos/sharpninja/wordpairs/git/commits/3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n    \"treeEndpoint\": \"https://api.github.com/repos/sharpninja/wordpairs/git/trees/b14df8a58c368cfef78e6879d0836b069436912c?recursive=1\",\n    \"remoteCommitSHA\": \"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n    \"localReviewedCommitSHA\": \"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n    \"remoteTreeSHA\": \"b14df8a58c368cfef78e6879d0836b069436912c\",\n    \"localReviewedTreeSHA\": \"b14df8a58c368cfef78e6879d0836b069436912c\",\n    \"remoteParentSHA\": \"2bde123dd3ec874f37e859630c77e66ea10839e9\",\n    \"localReviewedParentSHA\": \"2bde123dd3ec874f37e859630c77e66ea10839e9\",\n    \"remoteTreeTruncated\": false,\n    \"remoteLeafEntryCount\": 75,\n    \"localLeafEntryCount\": 75,\n    \"allPathsModesTypesAndObjectSHAsMatch\": true,\n    \"result\": \"PASS\"\n  },\n  \"localContinuationVerification\": {\n    \"currentHEAD\": \"d74bb70731b60497c8b377de144527b72d6a8174\",\n    \"worktreeClean\": true,\n    \"changesSinceReviewedCandidate\": [\n      \"docs/goal_hv_agreement_through_phase_6.md\",\n      \"docs/phase1_execution.md\",\n      \"docs/phase1_review_receipt.jsonl\",\n      \"docs/phase1a_execution.md\"\n    ],\n    \"sourceTestsDependenciesAndBuildConfigurationChanged\": false,\n    \"assessment\": \"The continuation adds documentation and review records only. It does not invalidate the independently verified source candidate. Status text recording the formerly pending remote gate should now be updated with this addendum.\"\n  },\n  \"priorIndependentEvidenceCarriedForward\": {\n    \"candidateSHA\": \"3b94b8b3b4b3e1b8348bd7013acb8da2759282ad\",\n    \"fullRegression\": {\n      \"filesPassed\": 8,\n      \"testsPassed\": 352,\n      \"failures\": 0,\n      \"skips\": 0\n    },\n    \"lint\": \"PASS\",\n    \"typecheck\": \"PASS\",\n    \"localProductionBuild\": \"PASS\",\n    \"disposablePostgresVerification\": \"PASS: migration, RLS configuration, actual unprivileged-role denial, canonical replay and digest conflict, stale-version rejection, durable outbox, rollback fault, retention and invalid-content fixtures, and competing final-seat writes.\",\n    \"actualTypeScriptPostgresAdapterTests\": {\n      \"passed\": 3,\n      \"failures\": 0\n    },\n    \"rerunDisposition\": \"No redundant test rerun was necessary because the remote commit and complete file tree match the exact locally tested candidate.\"\n  },\n  \"rubric\": {\n    \"requiredAccuracyPercent\": 98,\n    \"requiredCompletenessPercent\": 98,\n    \"unresolvedMaterialFindingsAllowed\": 0,\n    \"assessment\": \"The prior technical review passed the Phase 1 foundation rubric. Independent remote identity and complete tree comparison now satisfy its remaining exact-GitHub-commit condition.\"\n  },\n  \"scores\": {\n    \"accuracyPercent\": 99,\n    \"completenessPercent\": 99\n  },\n  \"remainingActionableFindings\": [],\n  \"priorFindingsDisposition\": \"All material findings resolved in the reviewed candidate remain resolved. The remote comparison introduces no source differences or new findings.\",\n  \"evidenceLimits\": [\n    \"Approval covers the Phase 1 foundation, not completed product behavior across all 45 acceptance criteria.\",\n    \"Mock-oracle sensitivity, real application orchestration through fake ports, and actual PostgreSQL integration remain distinct evidence tiers.\",\n    \"Relational final-seat checks and generic aggregate adapter checks do not yet establish complete product JoinRoom integration.\",\n    \"Identity flows, public and actor projections, observer permissions, gameplay, moderation, responsive accessibility, and human validation remain assigned to later phases.\",\n    \"No deployed environment, real provider entitlement, or Supabase Free-plan operational capability is certified by this review.\",\n    \"This addendum verifies the exact remote commit object and tree. It does not assert that a branch points to that commit.\",\n    \"The reviewer performed read-only verification and made no source edits, uploads, branch changes, or deployments.\"\n  ],\n  \"phaseStatus\": {\n    \"localPhase1TechnicalReadiness\": \"APPROVED\",\n    \"formalExactGitHubCommitGate\": \"PASSED\",\n    \"formalPhase1Exit\": \"APPROVED\",\n    \"phase2EntryApproved\": true,\n    \"phase2EntryScope\": \"Proceed with the approved Phase 2 packages under the existing mock-first, regression, privacy, and phase-review requirements.\",\n    \"deploymentApproved\": false,\n    \"deploymentBoundary\": \"Phase 7 only, after coding Phases 1–6 and their required validation are complete.\"\n  }\n}"}