--- name: architecture-decision-records description: Write and maintain Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) following best practices for technical decision documentation. Use when documenting significant technical decisions, reviewing past architectural choices, or establishing decision processes. --- # Architecture Decision Records Comprehensive patterns for creating, maintaining, and managing Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) that capture the context and rationale behind significant technical decisions. ## When to Use This Skill - Making significant architectural decisions - Documenting technology choices - Recording design trade-offs - Onboarding new team members - Reviewing historical decisions - Establishing decision-making processes ## Core Concepts ### 1. What is an ADR? An Architecture Decision Record captures: - **Context**: Why we needed to make a decision - **Decision**: What we decided - **Consequences**: What happens as a result ### 2. When to Write an ADR | Write ADR | Skip ADR | | -------------------------- | ---------------------- | | New framework adoption | Minor version upgrades | | Database technology choice | Bug fixes | | API design patterns | Implementation details | | Security architecture | Routine maintenance | | Integration patterns | Configuration changes | ### 3. ADR Lifecycle ``` Proposed → Accepted → Deprecated → Superseded ↓ Rejected ``` Before drafting a standard, lightweight, or Y-statement ADR, read [decision templates](references/decision-templates.md). Before drafting a deprecation ADR or RFC, read [deprecation and RFC templates](references/deprecation-rfc-templates.md). ## ADR Management ### Directory Structure ``` docs/ ├── adr/ │ ├── README.md # Index and guidelines │ ├── template.md # Team's ADR template │ ├── 0001-use-postgresql.md │ ├── 0002-caching-strategy.md │ ├── 0003-mongodb-user-profiles.md # [DEPRECATED] │ └── 0020-deprecate-mongodb.md # Supersedes 0003 ``` ### ADR Index (README.md) ```markdown # Architecture Decision Records This directory contains Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) for [Project Name]. ## Index | ADR | Title | Status | Date | | ------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | | [0001](0001-use-postgresql.md) | Use PostgreSQL as Primary Database | Accepted | 2024-01-10 | | [0002](0002-caching-strategy.md) | Caching Strategy with Redis | Accepted | 2024-01-12 | | [0003](0003-mongodb-user-profiles.md) | MongoDB for User Profiles | Deprecated | 2023-06-15 | | [0020](0020-deprecate-mongodb.md) | Deprecate MongoDB | Accepted | 2024-01-15 | ## Creating a New ADR 1. Copy `template.md` to `NNNN-title-with-dashes.md` 2. Fill in the template 3. Submit PR for review 4. Update this index after approval ## ADR Status - **Proposed**: Under discussion - **Accepted**: Decision made, implementing - **Deprecated**: No longer relevant - **Superseded**: Replaced by another ADR - **Rejected**: Considered but not adopted ``` ### Automation (adr-tools) ```bash # Install adr-tools brew install adr-tools # Initialize ADR directory adr init docs/adr # Create new ADR adr new "Use PostgreSQL as Primary Database" # Supersede an ADR adr new -s 3 "Deprecate MongoDB in Favor of PostgreSQL" # Generate table of contents (to a separate file, so the hand-written # index and guidelines in README.md are not overwritten) adr generate toc > docs/adr/toc.md # Link related ADRs adr link 2 "Complements" 1 "Is complemented by" ``` ## Review Process ```markdown ## ADR Review Checklist ### Before Submission - [ ] Context clearly explains the problem - [ ] All viable options considered - [ ] Pros/cons balanced and honest - [ ] Consequences (positive and negative) documented - [ ] Related ADRs linked ### During Review - [ ] At least 2 senior engineers reviewed - [ ] Affected teams consulted - [ ] Security implications considered - [ ] Cost implications documented - [ ] Reversibility assessed ### After Acceptance - [ ] ADR index updated - [ ] Team notified - [ ] Implementation tickets created - [ ] Related documentation updated ``` ## Best Practices ### Do's - **Write ADRs early** - Before implementation starts - **Keep them short** - 1-2 pages maximum - **Be honest about trade-offs** - Include real cons - **Link related decisions** - Build decision graph - **Update status** - Deprecate when superseded ### Don'ts - **Don't change accepted ADRs** - Write new ones to supersede - **Don't skip context** - Future readers need background - **Don't hide failures** - Rejected decisions are valuable - **Don't be vague** - Specific decisions, specific consequences - **Don't forget implementation** - ADR without action is waste