PhysicsLogic · Paper-first editionLean-extracted article 183

Formal reconstruction · selected galactic anisotropy model · atomic scan · oxygen comparison · nuclear line-width bound · explicit residual scope

Upper Limit for the Anisotropy of Inertial Mass

How two null resonance routes bound one selected model without establishing exact isotropy

Definitions, structures, and assumptions

Structures, classes, and inductive alternatives

  • structureSelected physical indices without any setup, observation, or conclusion.
  • structureProof-free physical selections and object-indexed experimental relations. Neither a protected reference, finite readout, calculated model result, nor evidence support is stored as a proof.
  • structureThe actual branch-specific observed result, separate from its explanation.
  • structureThe same selected experiment together with independent source provenance.
  • inductiveA finite affirmative redshift test is not an anisotropy null bound.
  • structure
  • structure
  • structure
  • inductive
  • inductive
  • inductive
  • structure
  • inductive
  • structure
  • structureA selected claim must depend on exactly these source-map steps.
  • structureA selected claim must retain exactly these epistemic statuses.
  • structureA selected route must name exactly these immediate predecessor routes.
  • structure
  • structure
  • inductive
  • structureEquation (2) on journal p. 342, kept as a scalar readout rather than a named `P2`-dependence label. The paper treats the angular factor as the second Legendre polynomial of the cosine between the acceleration direction and the galactic center. The kinetic-energy and binding-energy-shift values stay paper-local: Lean checks the displayed relation without rebuilding the atomic-structure calculation.
  • inductiveThe protected sidereal nuclear null route is not a gamma-redshift derivation.
  • structurePaper-local objects and proof-free physical relations.
  • structure
  • structure
  • structure
  • structure
  • structure
  • structureThe finite numerical readouts printed on journal p. 343, kept together with the selected paper-local objects to which they refer. The historical frequency units are retained literally: Mc/sec, kc/sec, cycles/sec, gauss, and parts per million.
  • structure
  • structure
  • structureModel support plus the exact extra relations needed for theory transfer.
  • structureAccessible obtained evidence supporting a model in a declared regime.

Definitions and domain choices

  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe complete selected physical experiment, rather than an implication or label.
  • definitionAn independent source calculation and its branch-specific model conclusion.
  • definitionExact scope, a real resonance, distinct configurations, and a protected reference.
  • definitionThe selected observation exists and has its separately established finite sensitivity.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionImmediate predecessor routes. Claims established by their transitive predecessors are inherited by the dependency closure.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionTemporary reductio-introduction steps discharged by this inference. Discharge removes only those exact origins from the conclusion's epistemic basis; it does not assert the temporary hypotheses globally.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionA source-mapped claim holds when its declared formula evaluates under the given paper-local semantic interpretation.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionEvery claim in the supplied identifier list holds.
  • definitionA source-mapped step is semantically sound when the interpreted premises imply the interpreted conclusion. Physical principles and imported calculations therefore remain explicit hypotheses of paper-specific certificates rather than acquiring truth from their source-map labels. A reductio hypothesis is different: it introduces a temporary assumption into a subargument and therefore is not required to hold globally. Its later uses remain ordinary premise-sensitive steps, and discharging it into a negated conclusion remains an ordinary semantic obligation.
  • definitionEvery step in the supplied identifier list is semantically sound.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe formula declared for a claim identifier, when that claim is present.
  • definition
  • definitionEvery source-mapped step whose justification contributes to the claim through declared premise-to-conclusion steps.
  • definitionAll justification statuses contributed by the exact source-mapped origins of a claim. This records epistemic provenance; it does not assert any paper claim or discharge any physical assumption.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe declared argument step with the requested identifier, when present.
  • definition
  • definitionThe premise list and conclusion attached to a declared step identifier.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe complete Lean-side fidelity certificate. The first conjunct is computed from source-map data; the second is supplied by checked route semantics; the third requires each declared independence boundary to have a countermodel.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionA typed countermodel matrix avoids string-keyed audit rows. Each index selects one proposition-valued separation obligation.
  • definition
  • definitionEvery route actually declared in the source map has a semantic certificate under the paper-local interpretation.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionOne countermodel row retains a weaker proposition while rejecting a stronger upgrade. This is a proposition, not a structure carrying proof fields.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionIndependent dependency and epistemic ledgers must review the same actual source claims, including every public conclusion and the selected paper conclusion. Empty, duplicated, nonexistent, or one-sided entries are invalid.
  • definitionEvery actually declared source route must have exactly one independently reviewed predecessor row. Correct rows for a selected subset are insufficient.
  • definitionThe declared main conclusion must be exposed by at least one public route output, rather than existing only as an unexported source-map claim.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionTwo finite lists describe the same dependency set. Duplicate expected entries are rejected so a ledger cannot pass by repeating a label.
  • definitionEvery paper-level, claim-level, and step-level source reference is present and has a nonempty work and locator. PaperArgument.auditable separately checks that every claim and step carries at least one source.
  • definitionA source reference is usable for review only when both the work and its locator are nonempty.
  • definitionStatic fidelity checks that can be evaluated from a paper's source map alone. They do not assert the truth of any physical premise.
  • definitionEvery declared output of a named source route holds under the semantic interpretation. This is the proof obligation discharged by paper-specific Lean theorems.
  • definition
  • definitionA route is fully certified only when both its individual steps and its declared outputs are semantically checked.
  • definitionEvery source-mapped inference step in a named route is semantically sound.
  • definitionEvery route named in the supplied identifier list is semantically certified.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe source-mapped route with the requested identifier, when present.
  • definition
  • definitionThe public semantic interface inherited from predecessor routes. Descendants receive only declared route outputs, not every internal intermediate claim. Outputs still carrying a temporary reductio origin are excluded.
  • definitionAll direct and inherited route dependencies. The route-order check separately ensures that the declared graph is acyclic and topologically ordered.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionJournal p. 342, equation (2): the anisotropic contribution to the selected binding energy is `(Delta m / m) * T * P_2(cos theta)`.
  • definitionThe selected kinetic energy and cosine lie in the physical scalar domain.
  • definitionThe paper names `P_2` as the order-two Legendre polynomial. This local definition exposes the actual angular dependence rather than allowing an arbitrary value to travel under the `P2` name.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe scalar equation-(2) readout is attached to the exact selected P2 model, chlorine transition, and near-galactic orientation used by the atomic branch. The value maps keep this attachment semantic rather than letting an unrelated real-number tuple satisfy the source formula.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe paper's selected galactic comparison uses two genuinely different orientations of the laboratory field relative to the galactic center. The physical content must not be hidden inside the name of an orientation-indexed prediction relation.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe lithium observation first excludes the selected model's predicted triplet-or-unresolved-broadening signature above the residual line-width allowance. The nuclear structure model is a later, separate conversion of that excluded signature into a bound on the selected P2 anisotropy.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe journal's chlorine numbers are tied to the exact selected orientations, half-sidereal interval, finite error, and finite bound objects used by the atomic branch.
  • definitionThe journal's lithium numbers are tied to the same selected sidereal comparison and to the exact width and bound objects used by the nuclear branch.
  • definitionThe existing oxygen comparison remains a separate branch: its retained `10^-10` number is tied only to the selected oxygen bound object.
  • definitionZero frequency response to the selected anisotropy at every represented orientation. This is not immunity to magnetic-field changes or other shifts; the model and perturbative order belong to the specified regime.
  • definition
  • definitionThe paper's selected atomic P2 model retains its literal equation (2).
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionEarth rotation carries the fixed laboratory field between the two distinct galactic orientations during the selected half-sidereal interval.
  • definitionThe paper reports more than a named comparison: the nuclear line gives a strictly stronger finite sensitivity than the atomic scan. Equality of the two retained bounds therefore cannot satisfy this source claim.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionHughes provenance separately retains its printed P2 law and both finite readouts.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionThe controlled resonance interface selects the bounded P2 model, the actual Li-7 transition, distinct galactic orientations, the protected Atomichron and proton references, observed line width, excess-width sensitivity, and finite nuclear bound. The unconstrained parent model is not silently supported.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionA signed adjacent gap. Positivity is required before interpreting it as a positive resonance frequency in this ordering of the levels.
  • definitionThe allowed magnetic numbers are -j, -j+1, ..., j with 2j integral. The scalar term has been removed; the rank-two diagonal term is retained.
  • definitionJournal p. 343, left column: the chlorine transition is followed for twelve hours while the horizontal south direction moves from within 22 degrees of the galactic center to 104 degrees away. The selected transition is about 9190 Mc/sec in 4730 gauss, with no variation within 30 kc/sec; the chlorine conversion gives the reported order-`10^-10` bound.
  • definitionJournal p. 343, right column: the lithium run uses about 4700 gauss, sees one line of width 4.3 ppm against an expected `5.0 plus-or-minus 1` ppm instrumental width, allows at most 8 cycles/sec of anisotropy broadening, and obtains `Delta m / m <= 10^-20`. The comparison value `3 x 10^-10` is the paper's stated galactic `P_2` estimate at `nu = 0`.
  • definitionJournal p. 343, right column before the lithium discussion: the independent oxygen transition-pair comparison gives the reported order-`10^-10` bound.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionBuild the epistemic dependency basis in paper order. A conclusion inherits the justification origin of its own step and every origin already attached to its premises.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definitionExpand a set of route identifiers by one dependency edge, iterated with enough fuel to traverse any acyclic graph on the declared routes.
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition

Selected instances and coercions

  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance
  • instance

Source mappings and interpretation choices

  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • definition
  • structure
  • definition
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • inductive
  • definition
  • instance
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • recursor
  • definition
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • constructor
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • instance
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • definition
  • definition
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement

Checked statements: parameters, hypotheses, and interpretation

  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementA calculation merely called `P2` can keep a false aligned polynomial value; the source formula blocks that substitution.
  • checked statementFor acceleration aligned with the galactic direction, the exposed polynomial has `P_2(1) = 1`, so equation (2) reduces to the full anisotropic ratio times the selected kinetic energy.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementWith no anisotropic mass term, equation (2) carries no binding-energy shift.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementAccessible obtained null evidence can support the bounded P2 model while the containing Machian theory lacks support. The evidence-layer transfer premise is therefore physically active rather than a truth-value label.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe named P2 prediction, triplet prediction, and half-sidereal rotation can all have zero residual while the selected near/far angles coincide. The source-shaped chlorine and lithium readouts still cannot realize either scan.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe reported lithium bound and selected P2 exclusion retain the full atomic, oxygen, nuclear, and galactic hierarchy, but a finite selected-model test does not establish exact isotropy, other angular laws, or arbitrary preferred-direction coverage.
  • checked statementA named stronger-than relation with the atomic scale still below the quoted galactic estimate cannot make equal atomic and nuclear bounds a strictly stronger nuclear sensitivity.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe source-shaped chlorine and lithium null readouts retain both scan setups, but nonzero structure and conversion residuals block both anisotropy bounds.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementA single source-shaped lithium line can retain the reported width and excess allowance while its triplet/broadening-exclusion residual remains nonzero.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe established chlorine bound retains the actual finite p. 343 readout.
  • checked statementThe established lithium bound retains the actual finite p. 343 readout.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe full published finite anisotropy assessment inhabits the controlled test.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementJournal p. 343: the nuclear route uses the Atomichron as well as the proton resonance; it does not borrow its frequency standard from the atomic scan's successful conclusion. Both insensitivity claims remain explicit selected-model inputs, not derivations of clock or nuclear dynamics.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe independent oxygen comparison retains its own printed finite bound.
  • checked statementThe spin-half gap supplies the proton control only after the physical reference response has been identified with that calculated shift at fixed field. No such identification, nor field stabilization, follows from a name.
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe source-level finite hierarchy is inherited by the scoped conclusion: the lithium ratio is below the chlorine ratio, and the chlorine ratio is below the quoted galactic `P_2` estimate.
  • checked statementThe combined assessment does not discard either finite source-number package when it passes from the separate atomic and nuclear bounds to the scoped model conclusion.
  • checked statementThe finite nuclear limit remains a statement about the selected galactic P2 model. Hughes, Robinson, and Beltran-Lopez explicitly leave other angular laws and preferred directions for later experiments.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementOne fixed P2 response vanishes at an admissible intermediate cosine but not at alignment. An unsplit configuration therefore does not establish isotropy of that same model. These are not the published galactic angles or a calculation of measured line width.
  • checked statementAn anisotropy-insensitive proton transition can still track a changing magnetic field through its ordinary Larmor frequency.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe printed angular readouts really are distinct numerical directions.
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statement
  • checked statementThe paper's two finite scales are not merely named as "stronger": the printed nuclear ratio lies strictly below the printed atomic ratio, which itself lies below the quoted `3 x 10^-10` galactic estimate.

Axioms and trust boundaries

  • axiom / trust boundary
  • axiom / trust boundary
  • axiom / trust boundary
  • axiom / trust boundary
  • axiom / trust boundary
  • axiom / trust boundary

Constructors, projections, and other meaning dependencies

  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • recursor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor
  • constructor

External mathematical declarations

  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary
  • external type boundary

This edition is derived only from the paper-local semantics, the source map, and the exhaustive coverage proof.

01

One model, three empirical routes, one qualified combination

The selected-model route supplies a distinct near/far galactic orientation pair, the typed p. 342 P2 energy-shift formula, the orientation-dependent atomic signature, and the nuclear triplet-or-broadening signature. The atomic and nuclear experiments each retain the same distinct half-sidereal orientation change, depend on that model, but remain logically independent. Existing oxygen data supplies a third comparison. Only the qualified-combination route compares the distinct bounds, applies the exclusion bridge, and retains the untested scope.

selected model + atomic bound + oxygen comparison + nuclear bound + exclusion bridge + scope qualifications ⇒ scoped anisotropy assessment.EstablishedScopedAnisotropyAssessment(1)
02

The atomic null becomes a bound only through the model calculation

The chlorine route retains the transition, distinct sidereal orientation change, Atomichron reference, proton reference, stabilized magnetic field, scan duration, and finite experimental error. Before the conversion, SelectedAtomicP2EnergyFormulaAt binds the p. 342 scalar readout to the selected P2 model, chlorine transition, and near-galactic orientation. Its SourceFormulaAt exposes both P2(cos theta) = (3 cos(theta)^2 - 1)/2 and the binding-energy-shift equality instead of trusting a name like orientation dependence. PrintedAtomicReadoutAt then binds the selected objects to the paper's 22-degree and 104-degree orientations over twelve hours, about 9190 Mc/sec in 4730 gauss, a 30 kc/sec error, and the reported atomic 10^-10 ratio. The observed absence of variation does not itself contain an anisotropy bound: the conversion also requires the paper's model of chlorine as an outer-shell hole moving in a Coulomb potential.

delta V = (Delta m / m) T P2(cos theta), with P2(x) = (3x^2 - 1)/2.SelectedAtomicP2EnergyFormulaAt(2)
SelectedP2ModelSetup + SelectedAtomicP2EnergyFormulaAt + AtomicScanSetup + AtomicNullObservation + chlorine outer-shell-hole Coulomb model + AtomicBoundCalculation ⇒ EstablishedAtomicBound.atomic_scan_and_model_calculation_establish_bound(2a)
22 deg, 104 deg, 12 h, 9190 Mc/sec, 4730 gauss, 30 kc/sec, 10^-10 ⇒ retained atomic source readout.established_atomic_bound_retains_printed_atomic_readout(2b)

OxygenComparisonAssessment records a separate transition-pair comparison and its model-dependent 10^-10 bound; PrintedOxygenReadoutAt keeps that number in the oxygen route rather than borrowing it from chlorine.

03

The single lithium line constrains predicted splitting or broadening

The nuclear route retains lithium-7 spin three-halves, the same distinct sidereal orientation change, both Atomichron and proton reference controls, proton-based magnetic-field stabilization, the single observed line, observed and expected widths, and the finite excess-width limit. The nuclear setup requires its own frequency-reference inputs; it does not borrow them from a successful atomic bound. PrintedNuclearReadoutAt binds these selected objects to about 4700 gauss, a 4.3-ppm observed line, an expected 5.0 plus-or-minus 1 ppm instrumental width, at most 8 cycles/sec residual broadening, the reported 10^-20 ratio, and the quoted 3 x 10^-10 galactic estimate. NuclearLineSignatureCalculation first uses those facts to establish tripletOrBroadeningExcludedAboveAt for the selected model. NuclearBoundCalculation is a later conversion using the paper's idealization of lithium-7 as one p-three-halves proton in a central nuclear potential, not a synonym for the line observation.

The reference controls now assert zero selected frequency shift at every represented orientation, rather than two arbitrary insensitivity predicates. A separate inspectable reconstruction, RankTwoNuclearSpectrum, uses first-order diagonal energies E_m/h = w*m + q*(3*m^2 - j*(j+1)). Its spin-half gap is w; its spin-three-halves gaps are w-6q, w, and w+6q, all positive exactly when 6*|q| < w. This is a stated model, not a formula quoted from the letter or a nuclear matrix-element calculation. The proton control follows only after an explicit identification with that response. Cesium dynamics, field stabilization, and the instrumental conversion of unresolved splitting to line width remain separate. Distinct calculated gaps must not be confused with resolved observed peaks. The frequency-reference review exposes these distinctions and their full Lean dependencies.

SelectedP2ModelSetup + NuclearScanSetup + NuclearLineObservation + NuclearLineSignatureCalculation ⇒ finite exclusion of the predicted triplet-or-broadening signature.single_lithium_line_and_width_limit_exclude_predicted_signature(3a)
finite signature exclusion + single-p-three-halves-proton central-potential model + NuclearBoundCalculation ⇒ EstablishedNuclearBound.nuclear_line_and_model_calculation_establish_bound(3b)
4700 gauss, 4.3 ppm, 5.0 plus-or-minus 1 ppm, 8 cycles/sec, 10^-20 ⇒ retained nuclear source readout.established_nuclear_bound_retains_printed_nuclear_readout(3c)
04

The result is a finite model constraint, not an exact principle

The combined assessment includes the strictly stronger, unequal nuclear bound and selected-model exclusion. A relation merely named boundStrongerThan cannot pass when the retained nuclear and atomic bounds are equal. Separately, scoped_assessment_retains_numeric_sensitivity_hierarchy checks the stored source numbers themselves: the 10^-20 nuclear ratio is below the 10^-10 atomic ratio, which is below the quoted 3 x 10^-10 galactic estimate. The assessment also includes the negations of exact-isotropy establishment, testing of other angular dependences, and testing of arbitrary directions, together with the proposed sensitivity improvement. scoped_assessment_retains_selected_p2_scope_and_open_extensions exposes that boundary directly.

qualified assessment + accessible obtained evidence + assessment-to-support bridge ⇒ support for the bounded selected model.scoped_assessment_realizes_model_support_only_through_bridge(4)

Model support reaches the Machian theory only through model_support_reaches_theory_only_with_explicit_transfer. No local Lorentz invariance or equivalence-principle theorem is asserted.

A

Complete semantic ledger

Primary theorems: zero_anisotropy_ratio_forces_zero_binding_energy_shift; parallel_acceleration_uses_full_p2_shift; selected_atomic_p2_formula_retains_equation_two; atomic_source_numbers_make_reported_angles_distinct; source_numbers_make_nuclear_bound_strictly_below_atomic_and_estimate; atomic_scan_and_model_calculation_establish_bound; established_atomic_bound_retains_printed_atomic_readout; oxygen_comparison_retains_printed_oxygen_readout; single_lithium_line_and_width_limit_exclude_predicted_signature; nuclear_line_and_model_calculation_establish_bound; established_nuclear_bound_retains_printed_nuclear_readout; excluded_signature_and_model_calculation_establish_bound; independent_bounds_establish_scoped_anisotropy_assessment; selected_p2_model_requires_distinct_galactic_orientations; atomic_scan_requires_distinct_sidereal_orientation_change; nuclear_scan_requires_distinct_sidereal_orientation_change; scoped_assessment_retains_strict_nuclear_sensitivity_improvement; scoped_assessment_retains_printed_finite_readouts; scoped_assessment_retains_numeric_sensitivity_hierarchy; scoped_assessment_retains_selected_p2_scope_and_open_extensions; scoped_assessment_realizes_model_support_only_through_bridge; model_support_reaches_theory_only_with_explicit_transfer.

Countermodels: named_p2_energy_calculation_does_not_supply_equation_two; collapsed_orientation_pair_does_not_realize_selected_model_or_scans; named_strength_relation_without_distinct_bounds_is_not_strict_improvement; null_signals_without_structure_models_do_not_supply_anisotropy_bounds; single_lithium_line_without_signature_calculation_does_not_supply_exclusion; finite_nuclear_p2_bound_does_not_establish_unrestricted_isotropy.

Coverage theorems: every_source_claim_has_semantics; selected_model_route_is_semantically_realized; atomic_bound_route_is_semantically_realized; oxygen_comparison_route_is_semantically_realized; nuclear_bound_route_is_semantically_realized; scoped_assessment_route_is_semantically_realized; evidence_support_route_is_semantically_realized; all_routes_are_semantically_realizable; route_semantic_realization_is_exhaustive.

Source-map audits: argument_wellFormed; argument_auditable; routes_wellFormed; routes_have_exact_predecessor_graph; source_contracts_are_independent_hypotheses; interpretive_contracts_are_independent_hypotheses; result_steps_apply_exact_semantic_inputs; printed_readouts_are_retained_from_reported_bounds; dependent_routes_consume_certified_predecessor_outputs; model_calculations_retain_controlled_approximation_status; scope_retains_open_obligation_status.

Atoms: selectedP2ModelSetup, atomicP2EnergyFormula, atomicScanSetup, atomicNullObservation, atomicBoundCalculation, establishedAtomicBound, printedAtomicReadout, oxygenComparisonAssessment, printedOxygenReadout, nuclearScanSetup, nuclearLineObservation, nuclearLineSignatureCalculation, excludedTripletOrBroadening, nuclearBoundCalculation, establishedNuclearBound, printedNuclearReadout, nuclearBoundStronger, selectedModelExclusionBridge, boundedSelectedModelRelation, scopeQualifications, scopedAnisotropyAssessment, assessmentSupportBridge, boundedModelSupport.

Claims: modelSetup, atomicEnergyFormula, atomicSetup, atomicNull, atomicCalculation, atomicBound, atomicReadout, oxygenAssessment, oxygenReadout, nuclearSetup, nuclearObservation, nuclearSignatureCalculation, signatureExclusion, nuclearCalculation, nuclearBound, nuclearReadout, strongerBound, exclusionBridge, boundedModelRelation, scope, scopedAssessment, supportBridge, modelSupport.

Steps: stateModelSetup, stateAtomicP2EnergyFormula, stateAtomicSetup, recordAtomicNull, supplyAtomicCalculation, deriveAtomicBound, retainPrintedAtomicReadout, recordOxygenComparison, retainPrintedOxygenReadout, stateNuclearSetup, recordNuclearLine, supplyNuclearSignatureCalculation, deriveSignatureExclusion, supplyNuclearCalculation, deriveNuclearBound, retainPrintedNuclearReadout, compareBounds, stateExclusionBridge, identifyBoundedModel, retainScope, deriveScopedAssessment, stateSupportBridge, deriveModelSupport.

Routes: selectedModel, atomicBound, oxygenComparison, nuclearBound, scopedAssessment, evidenceSupport. Kinds: modelSignature, atomicNullConstraint, existingDataConstraint, nuclearLineConstraint, qualifiedCombination, epistemicSupport.

Current checked semantic identifiers

These complete lists follow current Lean declaration order. Historical and selected explanatory lists elsewhere retain their separate scope.

Primary semantic theorems (43)

spin_half_reference_gap_is_unchanged, spin_three_halves_has_three_explicit_gaps, all_three_gaps_are_positive_iff, a_single_gap_value_iff_zero_rank_two_response, nonzero_rank_two_response_separates_all_three_gaps, one_unsplit_configuration_does_not_supply_global_isotropy, rank_two_insensitivity_does_not_stabilize_the_larmor_frequency, zero_anisotropy_ratio_forces_zero_binding_energy_shift, parallel_acceleration_uses_full_p2_shift, named_p2_energy_calculation_does_not_supply_equation_two, atomic_source_numbers_make_reported_angles_distinct, source_numbers_make_nuclear_bound_strictly_below_atomic_and_estimate, rank_two_spin_half_response_supplies_proton_reference_control, selected_atomic_p2_formula_retains_equation_two, atomic_scan_and_model_calculation_establish_bound, established_atomic_bound_retains_printed_atomic_readout, oxygen_comparison_retains_printed_oxygen_readout, nuclear_scan_requires_both_frequency_reference_controls, single_lithium_line_and_width_limit_exclude_predicted_signature, nuclear_line_and_model_calculation_establish_bound, established_nuclear_bound_retains_printed_nuclear_readout, excluded_signature_and_model_calculation_establish_bound, independent_bounds_establish_scoped_anisotropy_assessment, selected_p2_model_requires_distinct_galactic_orientations, atomic_scan_requires_distinct_sidereal_orientation_change, nuclear_scan_requires_distinct_sidereal_orientation_change, scoped_assessment_retains_strict_nuclear_sensitivity_improvement, scoped_assessment_retains_printed_finite_readouts, scoped_assessment_retains_numeric_sensitivity_hierarchy, scoped_assessment_retains_selected_p2_scope_and_open_extensions, scoped_assessment_realizes_model_support_only_through_bridge, model_support_reaches_theory_only_with_explicit_transfer, hughes_scoped_anisotropy_assessment_realizes_nonvacuous_resonance_test, hughes_sidereal_p2_inputs_realize_source_structural_resonance_explanation, source_structural_hughes_resonance_retains_p2_formula_and_readouts, hughes_resonance_test_preserves_finite_bound_and_open_anisotropy_scope, hughes_resonance_and_explicit_bridge_establish_bounded_model_support, collapsed_orientation_pair_does_not_realize_selected_model_or_scans, named_strength_relation_without_distinct_bounds_is_not_strict_improvement, null_signals_without_structure_models_do_not_supply_anisotropy_bounds, single_lithium_line_without_signature_calculation_does_not_supply_exclusion, finite_nuclear_p2_bound_does_not_establish_unrestricted_isotropy, bounded_model_support_does_not_supply_machian_theory_support_without_transfer

Coverage theorems (9)

every_source_claim_has_semantics, selected_model_route_is_semantically_realized, atomic_bound_route_is_semantically_realized, oxygen_comparison_route_is_semantically_realized, nuclear_bound_route_is_semantically_realized, scoped_assessment_route_is_semantically_realized, evidence_support_route_is_semantically_realized, all_routes_are_semantically_realizable, route_semantic_realization_is_exhaustive

Source-map audit theorems (11)

argument_wellFormed, argument_auditable, routes_wellFormed, routes_have_exact_predecessor_graph, source_contracts_are_independent_hypotheses, interpretive_contracts_are_independent_hypotheses, result_steps_apply_exact_semantic_inputs, printed_readouts_are_retained_from_reported_bounds, dependent_routes_consume_certified_predecessor_outputs, model_calculations_retain_controlled_approximation_status, scope_retains_open_obligation_status

Semantic atoms (23)

selectedP2ModelSetup, atomicP2EnergyFormula, atomicScanSetup, atomicNullObservation, atomicBoundCalculation, establishedAtomicBound, printedAtomicReadout, oxygenComparisonAssessment, printedOxygenReadout, nuclearScanSetup, nuclearLineObservation, nuclearLineSignatureCalculation, excludedTripletOrBroadening, nuclearBoundCalculation, establishedNuclearBound, printedNuclearReadout, nuclearBoundStronger, selectedModelExclusionBridge, boundedSelectedModelRelation, scopeQualifications, scopedAnisotropyAssessment, assessmentSupportBridge, boundedModelSupport

Claim identifiers (23)

modelSetup, atomicEnergyFormula, atomicSetup, atomicNull, atomicCalculation, atomicBound, atomicReadout, oxygenAssessment, oxygenReadout, nuclearSetup, nuclearObservation, nuclearSignatureCalculation, signatureExclusion, nuclearCalculation, nuclearBound, nuclearReadout, strongerBound, exclusionBridge, boundedModelRelation, scope, scopedAssessment, supportBridge, modelSupport

Step identifiers (23)

stateModelSetup, stateAtomicP2EnergyFormula, stateAtomicSetup, recordAtomicNull, supplyAtomicCalculation, deriveAtomicBound, retainPrintedAtomicReadout, recordOxygenComparison, retainPrintedOxygenReadout, stateNuclearSetup, recordNuclearLine, supplyNuclearSignatureCalculation, deriveSignatureExclusion, supplyNuclearCalculation, deriveNuclearBound, retainPrintedNuclearReadout, compareBounds, stateExclusionBridge, identifyBoundedModel, retainScope, deriveScopedAssessment, stateSupportBridge, deriveModelSupport

Route identifiers (6)

selectedModel, atomicBound, oxygenComparison, nuclearBound, scopedAssessment, evidenceSupport

Route kinds (6)

modelSignature, atomicNullConstraint, existingDataConstraint, nuclearLineConstraint, qualifiedCombination, epistemicSupport

R

Checked source-route details

This ledger is generated from the elaborated Lean route records. It lists direct predecessors, ordered inference steps, and exported claims. The independent fidelity audit checks every field; this ledger does not replace the physical semantics or certify every explanatory diagram.

selectedModel

Logical kind: modelSignature.

Required predecessor routes: none.

Ordered inference steps: stateModelSetup, stateAtomicP2EnergyFormula.

Exported conclusions: modelSetup, atomicEnergyFormula.

atomicBound

Logical kind: atomicNullConstraint.

Required predecessor routes: selectedModel.

Ordered inference steps: stateAtomicSetup, recordAtomicNull, supplyAtomicCalculation, deriveAtomicBound, retainPrintedAtomicReadout.

Exported conclusions: atomicBound, atomicReadout.

oxygenComparison

Logical kind: existingDataConstraint.

Required predecessor routes: selectedModel.

Ordered inference steps: recordOxygenComparison, retainPrintedOxygenReadout.

Exported conclusions: oxygenAssessment, oxygenReadout.

nuclearBound

Logical kind: nuclearLineConstraint.

Required predecessor routes: selectedModel.

Ordered inference steps: stateNuclearSetup, recordNuclearLine, supplyNuclearSignatureCalculation, deriveSignatureExclusion, supplyNuclearCalculation, deriveNuclearBound, retainPrintedNuclearReadout.

Exported conclusions: nuclearBound, nuclearReadout.

scopedAssessment

Logical kind: qualifiedCombination.

Required predecessor routes: atomicBound, oxygenComparison, nuclearBound.

Ordered inference steps: compareBounds, stateExclusionBridge, identifyBoundedModel, retainScope, deriveScopedAssessment.

Exported conclusions: scope, scopedAssessment.

evidenceSupport

Logical kind: epistemicSupport.

Required predecessor routes: scopedAssessment.

Ordered inference steps: stateSupportBridge, deriveModelSupport.

Exported conclusions: modelSupport.