Brian's post is interesting, but I'm not sure it is all that accurate.
Perhaps this is accurately what Verant wants to be true, but it is not what
is true. Monks out damage warriors only until the warrior gains some good
weapons around 15th level or so. After that the warrior often out damages
the monk, but the monk takes less damage. The reason for this? The monk
having no offensive items to spend money on is free to spend all his funds
to acquire better defensive items. The two do seem to balance out with the
warrior doing more damage but the monk taking less. Despite not being able
to wear heavy armor our group monk who is 2 levels lower than me has nearly
the same ac I do, and I have only one piece of armor with an AC below banded
and several at plate or higher. He takes way less damage than I do and
until he is 35th level will probably never die again except in very rare
circumstances.
My biggest laugh was at Brian's mention of Bard only items. That's a good
one. Excepting the quest armor, there are what, two bard only items that
you can get without taking on a dragon or going to the planes? A Shawl of
the Wind Spirit and Mistmoore Battle Drums, that's it as far as I know. A
piece of armor equal to cloth and a drum on a 35+ mob. To even mention bard
only items was in my opinion a slap in the face. Considering one is useless
after 3rd level and the other sells for 500pp+ that's a joke. What other
class has so little equipment dedicated to it? There must be one but I
don't know what it would be. Are there even any other items on mobs below
30th that are bard plus a few others? Shimmering Orb, great for looks but
with dual wield is it useful? Anyone know of anything else?
My next point regards weapons. If they are trying to balance the items, why
is it I am still using the same weapons at 21st level I used at 12th level?
There really isn't anything much better than my dragoon dirk and screaming
mace available for bards at my level. The only 1HS weapons available are a
Polished Granite Tomahawk and a Barbed Leather Whip. They don't even begin
to compare to our Shadowknight's Dark Reaver. The primary weapons carried
by every member of our group is better than either the PGT or the BLW. Why?
That's a good question. Since we don't have anybody near my level who is a
melee class (or hybrid other than the SK) its really puzzling. Our mages
carry Glowing Wooden Crooks or better, at 150pp not hard to see why. The
shadowknight has a dark Reaver and I'm using the same primary as the 7th
level ranger, a dragoon dirk. At 25pp who would blame him? A good 1HS
weapon on the other hand cost 400pp+.
Why does this inequity exist? Because in truth their are far more good
piercing weapons per piercing user than 1HS per 1HS user. All the good 1HS
weapons at the mid-levels are either warrior or paladin or ranger only. I
could currently get thru quests at least 6 weapons I cannot use. The quests
are easily doable for a group of my level or close (21st). I can get no
decent weapons via quest that I can use except the Screaming Mace that I did
9 levels ago.
Believe me if anyone can refute this and offer me a solution to where I
might find a better weapon obtainable I'd be glad to hear it. I get really
tired of having my own guild members laugh, "you still using that little
sticker?" I suppose I could buy a PGT, but at the 250pp they go for on E'ci
it hardly seems justifiable. Any suggestions out there? I currently own 4
magical piercing weapons (don't ask), and 2 magical 1HB, but only a combine
Scimitar for 1HS.
Kitasi Ireallyshouldthinkupalastname of E'ci
"materialistically inclined? not usually, but all those guild posts,
sheesh!"
From: Ryan Honeyman <
honeyman@...>
> CONCLUSION
>
> Hopefully this gives you some insight into how tricky designing some items
> can be. It's both an art and a science -- you have to have an intuitive
feel
> for the interactions between everything (race, procs, stat bonuses,
classes,
> skill caps, etc.) and then you have to back up your gut instincts by
running
> simulations so that the numbers do, in fact, add up to what you expect.
Then
> you have to see how it all fits into the world with regards to real world
> usefulness (is that proc really relevant? Do these races really use this?
Is
> there another weapon that's similar and easier to get?) and hope you made
> the right decision.
This guy is like a god. When I read his stuff, I get more
insight, more information, and more chuckles than anything
else Verant releases. I especially enjoyed reading his story
about the GM event he ran a long time ago. I wish there were
more of him running around at Verant. The game would
probably be a lot more interesting.
Harmonic.
Please send submissions for the eqbards newsletter to
lol@...
with the subject submissions.